My Ex's Sister Showed Up at My Door With Pizza… "She Doesn't Know I'm Here. Let's Keep It That Way." — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00My name is Daniel Cross. I'm 34. I
- 0:03restore furniture out of a garage that
- 0:04used to be a two-car garage and is now,
- 0:06structurally speaking, just sawdust with
- 0:09a door.
- 0:10I like things that take a long time to
- 0:12fix right.
- 0:13I am not, generally speaking, a man who
- 0:16gets surprised at his own front door.
- 0:19Her name was Rima. She was 29. She
- 0:22worked the overnight pharmacy counter
- 0:23three blocks from me, and she had a
- 0:25laugh that came out sideways, like it
- 0:27had snuck past security. I knew her
- 0:29because she was Natalie's younger
- 0:31sister. Natalie, who I dated for a year
- 0:33and a half. Natalie, who I had not
- 0:35spoken to in 8 months.
- 0:37Rima and I had met at exactly one
- 0:39Thanksgiving. Where she told me my tie
- 0:42looked like it had given up. And I told
- 0:44her the stuffing tasted like regret. And
- 0:46that was it. That was the whole
- 0:48relationship. A joke about a tie. A joke
- 0:50about stuffing.
- 0:52So, when she showed up at my door on a
- 0:54Tuesday night holding a pizza box and
- 0:55said, "She doesn't know I'm here. Let's
- 0:57keep it that way." I did not have a
- 0:59framework for that sentence.
- 1:01I had sawdust on my hands and absolutely
- 1:04no idea what to do with my face.
- 1:06"Okay." I said. Which was not a
- 1:08sentence.
- 1:10It was a sound a man makes when his
- 1:11brain has left the building.
- 1:14She held the box out like a peace
- 1:15treaty.
- 1:16"Olives. I remembered you hate them.
- 1:19I got them anyway.
- 1:21On my behalf because I'm not here to
- 1:22make this easy for you."
- 1:25The porch light buzzed.
- 1:26Somewhere down the street a dog was
- 1:28losing an argument with a car alarm.
- 1:31I stepped back and let her in.
- 1:33And that was the first mistake, if it
- 1:35was a mistake at all. And 11 weeks later
- 1:37I still hadn't decided.
- 1:39I should back up. Because none of this
- 1:41makes sense without the 8 months before
- 1:43it.
- 1:45After Natalie and I ended, quietly. The
- 1:48kind of ending that doesn't have a
- 1:49villain in it. Just two people who
- 1:51wanted different mornings.
- 1:53Her family did the thing families do.
- 1:56They picked a side without announcing
- 1:58it.
- 1:59Rima hadn't.
- 2:00Rima had texted me once
- 2:03a month after.
- 2:05Just a photo of a dog wearing sunglasses
- 2:07with no caption.
- 2:09And I'd send back a photo of a chair I
- 2:11was refinishing.
- 2:13Also no caption.
- 2:15And that had somehow become a thing.
- 2:17Not a relationship.
- 2:19A rhythm.
- 2:21A joke that kept extending its own
- 2:23punchline.
- 2:25I told myself it was nothing.
- 2:27I am extremely good at telling myself
- 2:29things.
- 2:31The pizza thing started small.
- 2:33She'd text me when she got off her
- 2:35overnight shift, half delirious, craving
- 2:37something specific. And twice she'd
- 2:40shown up instead of texted because
- 2:42apparently I lived annoyingly on the way
- 2:45to nowhere she needed to be.
- 2:47We'd sit on my porch steps at midnight
- 2:49and she'd write something on the inside
- 2:51of the lid before she left.
- 2:53A word. A doodle.
- 2:55Once just the number seven with no
- 2:57explanation I was ever given.
- 3:00I kept every one of those lids in a box
- 3:02in my garage like a man collecting
- 3:03evidence against himself.
- 3:06That night, box six, she wrote
- 3:09"Witness."
- 3:10"Witness to what?"
- 3:12I said.
- 3:13"To me not telling my sister things."
- 3:16She picked an olive off her slice and
- 3:17set it with great ceremony on a napkin
- 3:20like it had personally wronged her.
- 3:22"She doesn't need to know every time I
- 3:24eat pizza with a man she used to date."
- 3:27"We're not.
- 3:28This isn't a thing we're doing."
- 3:30"I know."
- 3:32She said it too fast.
- 3:34Too certainly. The way people confirm
- 3:36things they're actively trying to
- 3:37convince themselves of.
- 3:40"I'm just saying she doesn't need a
- 3:41weekly report."
- 3:43I let that sit.
- 3:44I am good at letting things sit.
- 3:47It's practically my job description.
- 3:49Here's the part I didn't tell anyone.
- 3:51Not even myself in a straightforward
- 3:53way.
- 3:54I started rearranging my evenings around
- 3:56the possibility of her shift ending
- 3:58early.
- 3:59I told myself it was about the pizza.
- 4:02A can like pizza.
- 4:04A man cannot, however, explain why he
- 4:06started keeping two plates clean at all
- 4:08times.
- 4:09Just in case.
- 4:11The evidence piled up the way it always
- 4:13does, sideways in pieces too small to
- 4:15look directly at.
- 4:17There was the night she mentioned almost
- 4:19as an aside that she told her coworker
- 4:21about
- 4:22this guy who fixes chairs
- 4:24and then got oddly interested in the
- 4:26pizza box lid for several seconds.
- 4:29There was the night her phone lit up on
- 4:30my porch step and I saw, before she
- 4:32flipped it over, that she had my name
- 4:34saved as D, the chair guy. Don't ask.
- 4:38There was the night I drove 40 minutes
- 4:39to a 24-hour pharmacy two towns over
- 4:42because mine ran out of the specific
- 4:44allergy medication she took and told
- 4:46myself it was because I happened to be
- 4:47out that way.
- 4:4911:00 p.m. for no reason.
- 4:52Going nowhere.
- 4:54She noticed things, too.
- 4:56I caught her noticing.
- 4:58You kept the lids?
- 4:59She said one night, nodding toward the
- 5:01garage where the box was visible through
- 5:03the open door stacked higher than either
- 5:05of us had acknowledged out loud.
- 5:08I'm environmentally conscious.
- 5:11You're really not.
- 5:13A dry wet valve of her own, apparently.
- 5:15Must run in the family.
- 5:17You're doing the thing where you collect
- 5:18evidence and call it tidying.
- 5:20That's not I started
- 5:22and stopped because she wasn't wrong.
- 5:25And we both knew it.
- 5:27And neither of us said anything else for
- 5:29almost a full minute, which for two
- 5:31people who never shut up was its own
- 5:33kind of confession.
- 5:35The night everything cracked open
- 5:37started with an accident, the way these
- 5:38things usually do.
- 5:40Her car wouldn't start outside my place,
- 5:4211:30 on a Thursday, rain coming down
- 5:45sideways and I drove her home instead
- 5:47because that's what you do. That's just
- 5:49what a decent person does.
- 5:52And the drive took 18 minutes and we
- 5:54spent 11 of them in total silence, which
- 5:56had never once happened before between
- 5:58us.
- 5:59You're quiet, I said, somewhere around
- 6:01minute 12 because the quiet had started
- 6:04to feel like its own kind of noise.
- 6:07I'm thinking about how to say something
- 6:09without saying it. She was looking out
- 6:11the window, not at me.
- 6:13Her fingers were tight around the strap
- 6:14of her bag.
- 6:16Which is in itself
- 6:18a problem.
- 6:20Say it badly then. I'm not picky.
- 6:23She laughed, but it came out wrong.
- 6:25Too soft, too careful, like it had been
- 6:27filed down on purpose.
- 6:30If I tell you something
- 6:32you have to promise it doesn't become a
- 6:33thing where you treat me different.
- 6:36I don't even know what the thing is yet.
- 6:39I know, that's the deal.
- 6:41I pulled up outside her building.
- 6:43The rain hadn't let up. I put the car in
- 6:45park and did not say anything because I
- 6:47had learned by then that with Rima the
- 6:49best move was often no move at all.
- 6:52Give her the whole room and let her
- 6:53decide what to do with it.
- 6:56I didn't come over with pizza because I
- 6:57wanted pizza, she said finally, to the
- 7:00windshield instead of to me.
- 7:02I came over because my shift ends at
- 7:0411:00 and the first thing I think about
- 7:06every single night around hour six is
- 7:09whether your porch lights on.
- 7:12That landed.
- 7:13I felt it land somewhere behind my
- 7:15sternum, slow and specific.
- 7:17Like a key turning in a lock I hadn't
- 7:19known was locked.
- 7:21You don't have to say anything else.
- 7:23I told her.
- 7:25My voice came out lower than I meant it
- 7:27to.
- 7:28We can sit here. We can pretend the
- 7:30windshield wipers are very interesting.
- 7:32Whatever you need.
- 7:34I don't want the exit. She turned
- 7:36finally and looked at me and there
- 7:37wasn't anything guarded left in it.
- 7:40I've had the exit for eight months. I'm
- 7:42tired of taking it.
- 7:44So I said the only honest thing I had,
- 7:46which had apparently been sitting in me
- 7:48fully formed for longer than I wanted to
- 7:50admit.
- 7:52Every night you didn't show up I
- 7:53noticed. Every night you did I noticed
- 7:55more.
- 7:56I don't know what to call that except
- 7:57the thing you're describing.
- 8:00Neither of us moved for a second. Then
- 8:01she did.
- 8:03Just a hand finding mine on the console.
- 8:06Nothing dramatic. Just a fact being
- 8:08stated with fingers instead of words.
- 8:11I turned my hand over to meet hers
- 8:12halfway, and that was the whole kiss.
- 8:15Really, before the actual kiss happened.
- 8:18That turn, that choosing.
- 8:20The kiss itself was quiet and a little
- 8:22clumsy because the gear shift was in the
- 8:24way, and right in the middle of it her
- 8:26phone buzzed on the seat between us.
- 8:28Loud enough that we both jumped back
- 8:30like teenagers.
- 8:32"That's probably her."
- 8:34Rima said breathless, glancing at the
- 8:36screen where Natalie sat in bold letters
- 8:38like an accusation.
- 8:40"You should probably eventually tell
- 8:41your sister I exist in your life outside
- 8:43of pizza."
- 8:44"Eventually." She said.
- 8:46Is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
- 8:493 months after that.
- 8:51Eventually arrived in the form of a very
- 8:53awkward family dinner.
- 8:55Where Natalie looked at the two of us
- 8:57holding hands across her mother's table
- 8:59and said flatly.
- 9:01"I genuinely thought you were kidding."
- 9:03Which is, as far as I can tell, as close
- 9:06to a blessing as that particular family
- 9:07gets.
- 9:09A year after that, Rima still wrote on
- 9:11pizza box lids.
- 9:13Except now they lived on my refrigerator
- 9:15instead of in a secret box in the
- 9:16garage, because apparently secrets
- 9:18stopped being secrets once they've been
- 9:20fully confessed to.
- 9:22The most recent one says, "Witness
- 9:24number 112."
- 9:26Because she started numbering them
- 9:27retroactively.
- 9:29Which I maintain is cheating. And which
- 9:32she maintains is archival integrity.
- 9:35Nothing about us had changed from that
- 9:37first Tuesday night, really.
- 9:39Except everything had. She still shows
- 9:41up some nights without texting first.
- 9:44Annoyingly, on the way to nowhere she
- 9:46needs to be.
- 9:48I still keep two plates clean.
- 9:50Just in case.
- 9:51Except now it isn't a secret I'm keeping
- 9:53from myself.
- 9:55What would you have done if the person
- 9:56showing up at your door was someone you
- 9:58were never supposed to want in the first
- 10:00place?
- 10:01And have you ever kept something good a
- 10:03secret for longer than you needed to?
- 10:05Just because you were scared of what it
- 10:06meant once it had a name?
- 10:09Tell me your story in the comments. If
- 10:11you liked this one, leave a like,
- 10:13subscribe, and I'll see you in the next
- 10:16one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Ex's Sister Showed Up at My Door With Pizza… "She Doesn't Know I'm Here. Let's Keep It That Way." by Written In Feelings, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,779 words across 306 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.