My Daughter-in-Law Told Me I Don't Deserve My Pie On Thanksgiving: "This House Doesn't Run On — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Nobody warns you that the cruelest
- 0:02sentence of your life can be spoken over
- 0:04a slice of pecan pie in a dining room
- 0:08you helped furnish while your own son
- 0:10studies the tablecloth.
- 0:13I'm Janet Brooks. I'm 66, a widow for 5
- 0:17years, and until that Thursday, I
- 0:20believed I was the glue in my son's
- 0:22family. I'd been at their house since
- 0:248:00 that morning. I peeled the
- 0:26potatoes, brined the turkey the night
- 0:29before, and basted it in the double oven
- 0:32I paid for when their old one died. The
- 0:34table we sat around came from my pocket,
- 0:36too. My son, Matthew, was on his third
- 0:40glass of a wine that cost more than my
- 0:42weekly groceries, and I knew whose visa
- 0:45it had gone on. I always wonder who's on
- 0:49the other end of these stories.
- 0:51Tell me in the comments where you're
- 0:53listening from.
- 0:55I was halfway through my second slice
- 0:57when my daughter-in-law, Tracy, set her
- 1:00fork down and gave me a smile with no
- 1:03warmth in it.
- 1:04"Janet, maybe that's enough pie. Some of
- 1:07us have been working all day."
- 1:10I laughed a little because I thought it
- 1:12was a joke. "I've been up since 5:00,
- 1:15Tracy. I think I've earned a piece of
- 1:17pie."
- 1:18She didn't laugh. She leaned back and
- 1:21crossed her arms, and I watched her pick
- 1:24the words she wanted.
- 1:26"You walk in here like you pay the
- 1:28mortgage. You helped out a little, and
- 1:31suddenly you think you run the place.
- 1:33This house doesn't run on your widow's
- 1:35pension, Janet.
- 1:37Matthew is the one carrying this family.
- 1:40Honestly, you don't deserve that pie."
- 1:43The room went still. My grandson, Wyatt,
- 1:46who is nine, stopped with a roll halfway
- 1:49to his mouth. Six-year-old Ellie looked
- 1:52from her mother to me, trying to work
- 1:54out what had just happened. Tracy's
- 1:57mother, Karen, was at the far end of the
- 1:59table.
- 2:01She'd moved into their basement in
- 2:03September after selling her condo.
- 2:06She dabbed her lips with a napkin and
- 2:08said,
- 2:09"Well, honey, she's not wrong about the
- 2:11stress he's under."
- 2:13I turned to my son.
- 2:15I waited for the boy I raised, the one I
- 2:17drove to Little League, and the one who
- 2:19cried at his father's funeral with his
- 2:22face pressed into my shoulder.
- 2:24I waited for him to say, "Tracy, that's
- 2:27enough.
- 2:28That's my mother."
- 2:29Matthew picked up his fork, cut into his
- 2:32own pie, and ate a bite. He didn't look
- 2:35at me.
- 2:36I didn't cry. I didn't raise my voice. I
- 2:39slid my plate away, folded my napkin,
- 2:42and stood up. I wiped a smear of
- 2:44cranberry off Ellie's chin, and kissed
- 2:46the top of Wyatt's head. He whispered,
- 2:49"Grandma, you can have mine." And I told
- 2:52him to keep it, sweetheart. Then I went
- 2:54to the hall closet for my coat.
- 2:57Tracy followed me to the door.
- 2:59"Don't be dramatic, Janet. I just want
- 3:02you to respect that this is our home,
- 3:04and we're the providers here."
- 3:07"Good night, Tracy." I said, and I
- 3:09walked out to my car.
- 3:11My husband, Leonard, taught high school
- 3:13shop for 34 years, and he used to say,
- 3:17"I'd spend my last dime fixing
- 3:20everyone's fence while my own roof
- 3:22leaked." I thought about that on the
- 3:24dark drive back to my little ranch house
- 3:27across town. I thought about her line,
- 3:31"This house doesn't run on your widow's
- 3:32pension."
- 3:34She was right about that. It didn't run
- 3:36on my pension. It ran on Leonard's life
- 3:39insurance, my savings, and my back.
- 3:42Four years ago, Matthew and Tracy
- 3:45couldn't qualify for the house they
- 3:47wanted. I gave them $60,000
- 3:50toward the down payment, the bulk of
- 3:52what Leonard left me.
- 3:54Matthew signed a promissory note at my
- 3:58kitchen table with interest and a
- 4:00repayment clause because Leonard would
- 4:03have insisted on paper. Tracy rolled her
- 4:06eyes through the whole thing. After
- 4:08that, I never stopped. I paid their
- 4:11family cell phone plan, $212
- 4:14a month. I paid the bi-weekly cleaning
- 4:17service Tracy hired, though she told her
- 4:19friends she and Matthew had just been
- 4:21blessed.
- 4:23I put my Visa in her hand as an
- 4:25authorized user for emergencies.
- 4:28Somewhere along the way, emergencies
- 4:30turned into Whole Foods orders,
- 4:33Matthew's golf trips, and a boat slip at
- 4:36the lake for the bass boat he bought on
- 4:38a payment plan. I let Matthew drive
- 4:41Leonard's old Ford pickup because the
- 4:44truck was paid off, and I kept it titled
- 4:47and insured in my name. And every school
- 4:49day, I picked up Wyatt and Ellie at 2:45
- 4:53and kept them until 6:30. And two
- 4:56mornings a week, I got them on the bus
- 4:58free for 3 years.
- 5:01I pulled into my driveway. The porch
- 5:03light was on the way Leonard always left
- 5:05it. I didn't pour wine. I didn't cry
- 5:09into a pillow. I made a cup of
- 5:11chamomile, sat at my kitchen table, and
- 5:14opened my laptop. If my daughter-in-law
- 5:17wanted to be the provider, it would have
- 5:19been selfish of me to keep holding up
- 5:22her floor.
- 5:24I woke at 6:00 on Friday feeling rested,
- 5:26which surprised me.
- 5:28For the first time in years, I had no
- 5:30urge to hurry over there and make
- 5:33pancakes while two grown adults slept
- 5:35in. I made my own breakfast and logged
- 5:38into my accounts.
- 5:40The Visa came first. Tracy's name came
- 5:43off as an authorized user, and the card
- 5:46number she'd saved in every online store
- 5:48went dead with it. Took less than a
- 5:50minute. Next, I opened the wireless
- 5:53carrier's website.
- 5:54Four lines were on my plan.
- 5:57I kept my own and canceled the other
- 5:59three, effective at the end of the day.
- 6:02Then, I called the cleaning service, who
- 6:05were very polite about it and ended the
- 6:08contract.
- 6:09I didn't feel angry doing any of it, and
- 6:12that was the strange part.
- 6:14I felt like a bookkeeper. I wasn't
- 6:17punishing anyone. I was lining the books
- 6:20up with what Tracy had announced at the
- 6:21table, one entry at a time.
- 6:24At 9:30 on Saturday morning, I took a
- 6:27Ryker ride share to a spot a block from
- 6:29their house. They lived in a neat
- 6:31subdivision with a basketball hoop at
- 6:34every other curb, and nobody outside on
- 6:37a cold morning.
- 6:39Leonard's blue Ford sat in the driveway
- 6:41beside Matthew's leased SUV. The truck
- 6:44was mine. I owned it free and clear, and
- 6:47I'd paid the premium every 6 months.
- 6:50I had a spare key on my ring. I didn't
- 6:52knock. I unlocked the truck, climbed in,
- 6:56and turned the engine over.
- 6:58The gas light was on, which was typical,
- 7:01but it was enough to get me across town.
- 7:04Nobody came to the window. They were
- 7:06sleeping off the turkey and the wine.
- 7:09I drove the Ford home and parked it in
- 7:11my garage next to Leonard's workbench.
- 7:14I sat there a while with my hand on the
- 7:17steering wheel and let myself feel it.
- 7:20The 9 years of Saturdays we'd spent
- 7:22fishing out of that truck.
- 7:24Then, I climbed out and went inside.
- 7:27I wasn't going to keep a truck as a
- 7:29monument. A truck is a tool, and I had
- 7:32people who needed tools.
- 7:34My phone stayed quiet until afternoon.
- 7:37First came a call from Tracy that I let
- 7:39ring out, then a text. Janet, my phone
- 7:43says no service. Matthew's, too. What
- 7:45did you do?
- 7:47I typed back, I canceled the lines on my
- 7:50plan. It's my account. You'll need to
- 7:52set up your own.
- 7:54Her call came in under 30 seconds, and
- 7:56this time I answered. Are you insane?
- 8:00Her voice was shrill. The kids' school
- 8:03can't reach us. We have no cards, no
- 8:06phones. Matthew went to take the truck
- 8:08to Home Depot and it's gone. Somebody
- 8:10stole it.
- 8:12Nobody stole it, Tracy. I took it. It's
- 8:15in my name.
- 8:16You can't just take his truck.
- 8:19His truck? I let it sit. Matthew was
- 8:22borrowing it. You said yourself that I
- 8:24don't run your household. I'm just
- 8:27returning the favor.
- 8:29This is about a piece of pie?
- 8:31She almost laughed, but it came out
- 8:33cracked.
- 8:34No, dear. It was never about the pie.
- 8:37You told me the truth and I believed
- 8:40you.
- 8:40I hung up. I went out to the garden and
- 8:43cut back my rose bushes for the winter
- 8:46and the cold air felt good on my face.
- 8:49Less than an hour later, Matthew's SUV
- 8:52tore into my driveway and bounced over
- 8:55the curb. I watched from the front
- 8:57window as the two of them came up the
- 8:59walk. Matthew's face was red. Tracy's
- 9:02was pale and pinched. Karen was in the
- 9:05backseat with her purse in her lap and
- 9:07her lips in a line.
- 9:09I opened the front door and left the
- 9:12storm door locked between us.
- 9:15"Mom," Matthew said, "open the door. We
- 9:18need to talk about this."
- 9:20We can talk right here.
- 9:22This is ridiculous.
- 9:24Tracy said, rattling the handle.
- 9:27We don't have the money for new phone
- 9:28plans right now.
- 9:30Matthew's commissions are down this
- 9:32quarter.
- 9:33That sounds like a problem for the
- 9:35providers, I said.
- 9:37I'm just a guest who eats too much pie.
- 9:40I wouldn't presume to get involved.
- 9:43"Mom." Matthew's voice cracked on the
- 9:45word. You're being cruel. We have kids.
- 9:48I know you do, honey. I'm the one who
- 9:51knows when Ellie's got a loose tooth and
- 9:54what Wyatt's afraid of. I'm just not
- 9:57your paycheck anymore.
- 9:59"You're abandoning us," Tracy said and
- 10:01her eyes finally filled up. Over one
- 10:04comment.
- 10:05Over three years of comments, Tracy.
- 10:08That one was just the first time you
- 10:10said it with a smile at a table with the
- 10:13whole family watching and nobody said a
- 10:15word. I looked at my son. Nobody.
- 10:19He looked at his shoes.
- 10:21"There's one more thing." I said.
- 10:24"Starting Monday, I won't be picking up
- 10:27Wyatt and Ellie. You'll want to make
- 10:29other arrangements."
- 10:31"You wouldn't." Tracy whispered.
- 10:33I closed the wooden door and slid the
- 10:36deadbolt.
- 10:37Sunday I spent in peace. I read on the
- 10:40back patio under a blanket and baked a
- 10:42loaf of sourdough that made the whole
- 10:45house smell like a bakery.
- 10:47The little light on my phone kept
- 10:49blinking and I let it.
- 10:51That evening I sent one text to both of
- 10:53them. I won't be doing school pickup
- 10:56anymore. Please arrange alternate care
- 10:59starting tomorrow.
- 11:01I knew what Tracy would think. For
- 11:03years, every boundary I set was drawn in
- 11:06pencil. I'd threaten to pull back. She'd
- 11:09say she was overwhelmed and I'd show up
- 11:12at the door with a casserole and an
- 11:14apology. She'd count on me being at that
- 11:17curb at 2:45 on Monday like always.
- 11:21Monday at 6:00, my body woke me anyway
- 11:24with that old hurry in it. I lay there
- 11:27until it faded. Then I got up, packed an
- 11:29overnight bag and drove 40 minutes to a
- 11:32bed and breakfast in a river town I'd
- 11:35always meant to visit. I'd booked it
- 11:37Friday night and I paid for it with a
- 11:40check Ralph Hicks from down the street
- 11:43gave me for Leonard's old fishing boat
- 11:46trailer. I'd called Ralph on a whim and
- 11:49he'd been asking about it for years.
- 11:52My phone began to buzz at 7:40. Tracy.
- 11:56At 8:05, Matthew. By the time I parked
- 11:59outside a cafe across from the river,
- 12:01there were 14 missed calls and a string
- 12:04of messages. The longest was from Tracy.
- 12:08"Janet, where are you?
- 12:10I have a 9:00 and the kids are standing
- 12:12in the kitchen. Wyatt is crying because
- 12:15he thinks you're mad at him. Matthew has
- 12:18to take them to school and he'll be late
- 12:20for his sales call. My mother says this
- 12:23is cruel to the children. Please call
- 12:26me.
- 12:27I read it twice. The crack in my chest
- 12:30was for Wyatt, not for her. I typed one
- 12:32line. Tell Wyatt I love him and I'm not
- 12:35mad at him. This isn't about the kids.
- 12:38I'll call him tonight. Then I put the
- 12:40phone on do not disturb, went inside,
- 12:43and ordered a croissant and a
- 12:45cappuccino. I drank it while it was hot.
- 12:49I couldn't remember the last time I'd
- 12:51done that.
- 12:52I spent two days doing nothing useful. I
- 12:55got a massage and learned I'd been
- 12:58carrying my shoulders around my ears for
- 13:00years. I walked through antique stores
- 13:03and ran my fingers over old oak tables.
- 13:06Nobody needed anything from me. I did
- 13:09call Wyatt Monday night from the quiet
- 13:11of my room and told him grandma loved
- 13:14him and he'd done nothing wrong and that
- 13:17sometimes grown-ups have to take a
- 13:18time-out, too. He said, "Okay." in his
- 13:21serious little voice and then, "Mom's
- 13:24mad at everybody." I told him I knew.
- 13:28When I checked out on Wednesday, I
- 13:30stopped at a park with a duck pond and
- 13:32turned my notifications back on. There
- 13:35were three voicemails from Tracy and I
- 13:38played them on a bench in the sun.
- 13:41The first, from Monday, she was furious.
- 13:44"Janet, this is unacceptable. Matthew
- 13:47missed his call. You're being petty.
- 13:49Turn the phones back on right now."
- 13:52The second, Tuesday, the edge had
- 13:55cracked. "Janet, please. We have to buy
- 13:58new phones outright because Matthew's
- 14:00credit is shot from the boat.
- 14:02The deposit on a new plan is $500.
- 14:06We don't have it. Why are you doing
- 14:08this?"
- 14:09The third, that morning, she sounded
- 14:11hollow.
- 14:13"I don't know what to do.
- 14:15The cleaning lady's gone, the house is a
- 14:17mess, my mother is yelling at me, and
- 14:20the card at the grocery store got
- 14:21declined. Matthew and I haven't stopped
- 14:24fighting. Please call me. We need you.
- 14:28I watched the ducks put their heads
- 14:30under the water and come up shaking.
- 14:32For years, I'd mistaken being needed for
- 14:35being loved. I thought if I made myself
- 14:38useful enough, if I paid and drove and
- 14:41cooked and bought the oven, they would
- 14:43eventually see me.
- 14:45But being needed is not the same as
- 14:47being valued. If you make yourself an
- 14:50endless supply, people stop thinking of
- 14:53you as a person.
- 14:55I deleted the voicemails. A younger me
- 14:58would have been in the car with my
- 15:00checkbook before the third message
- 15:02ended. This time, I stayed on that
- 15:05bench, and I let my daughter-in-law feel
- 15:08the weight of her own life.
- 15:10On Thursday morning, there was a knock
- 15:12at my door. Not the two of them, Karen.
- 15:16She stood on my porch in her good wool
- 15:18coat, carrying a store-bought apple pie
- 15:21in a plastic clamshell.
- 15:23I'd have laughed if she weren't so
- 15:25serious.
- 15:26"Janet," she said, "we need to talk like
- 15:28adults.
- 15:30We can do that.
- 15:32A grandmother helps. That's what family
- 15:34is. You can't punish children for a
- 15:38disagreement between adults.
- 15:40I'm not punishing the children, Karen.
- 15:43I'm seeing them Saturday. I'm just not
- 15:45funding the adults." I took the pie from
- 15:48her gently.
- 15:49"You sat at that table and said Tracy
- 15:52wasn't wrong. You live in my mom's
- 15:54basement. You eat the groceries I paid
- 15:57for on that Visa. When was the last time
- 16:00you handed Matthew a dollar for rent?"
- 16:03She opened her mouth, and nothing came
- 16:05out.
- 16:07"Pay your daughter board, Karen, or find
- 16:09your own place. That's what grownups
- 16:11do."
- 16:12I held the pie out. "Take this back. I'm
- 16:15not hungry for it."
- 16:17She left with her pie and her pride in a
- 16:20very small bundle.
- 16:22It took 9 days for the two of them to
- 16:24come on their own, and they came on a
- 16:26Saturday afternoon after Wyatt and Ellie
- 16:30had already had their weekly ice cream
- 16:32with me, and I dropped them off at the
- 16:35curb. I had a folder ready. I'd been
- 16:38writing it for a week.
- 16:40They sat at my kitchen table.
- 16:42I didn't offer coffee.
- 16:44Tracy looked worn.
- 16:46Her roots were showing, and the fresh
- 16:48polish had chipped off two nails.
- 16:50Matthew looked as if he hadn't slept.
- 16:53"Mom," he said, "we're sorry. What Tracy
- 16:56said was out of line. I should have said
- 16:58something. I froze."
- 17:01"You didn't freeze, Matthew. You ate
- 17:03your pie."
- 17:05He winced. I'd earned that sentence, so
- 17:07I let it stand.
- 17:09"I'm sorry, Janet," Tracy said with her
- 17:11eyes on my table. "I was stressed. I
- 17:14said things."
- 17:15"You meant them," I said without heat.
- 17:19"That's the part that matters. But, I'm
- 17:21not here to fight. I'm here to put
- 17:23things in writing, since you two love
- 17:26numbers."
- 17:27I opened the folder. On top was a single
- 17:30page I had typed up on Leonard's old
- 17:32Dell, an itemized ledger of everything
- 17:36I'd paid in the last 3 years, the phone
- 17:38lines, the cleaning service, the
- 17:41groceries and gas on the Visa, the truck
- 17:43insurance, the after-school care, which
- 17:46I'd priced at the going rate for the
- 17:48area, $18 an hour, and which came to
- 17:52over $36,000
- 17:55by itself. I'd left that number off the
- 17:58total.
- 17:59A grandmother shouldn't bill for love.
- 18:01Without the child care, it still came to
- 18:0441,860.
- 18:08Tracy read it, then read it again, and
- 18:11her hand covered her mouth.
- 18:14"That's not a gift anymore," I said.
- 18:16"That's what you took for granted, and
- 18:18under it is the note."
- 18:21I laid the promissory note on the table
- 18:23with Matthew's signature on it, the one
- 18:26from my kitchen table four years ago.
- 18:29$60,000,
- 18:31interest whist at 4%, repayable on
- 18:34written demand after 24 months.
- 18:37"I'm not calling it all due tomorrow," I
- 18:40said. "I'm not heartless, but I am going
- 18:43to be repaid the way any lender would
- 18:45be.
- 18:46$500 a month starting January 1st by
- 18:49automatic transfer.
- 18:51Sign the schedule or I'll let my
- 18:53attorney handle the rest." Matthew's jaw
- 18:56worked. "Mom, we can't afford 500 a
- 19:00month on top of everything."
- 19:02"Then sell the boat." He closed his
- 19:05eyes.
- 19:07"The boat costs 640 a month," I said,
- 19:11"and you take it out twice a year.
- 19:14You have a mother who handed you the
- 19:16down payment for your house so you could
- 19:18stay close to your kids. Pay her before
- 19:21you pay the lake." Tracy burst out,
- 19:24"You're doing this to humiliate us."
- 19:27"No, Tracy. You humiliated me at your
- 19:30table in front of my grandchildren. This
- 19:32is bookkeeping."
- 19:34The silence was long. Then Matthew
- 19:37pulled the schedule across the table and
- 19:39picked up my pen. I watched him sign it
- 19:42with a slow, unsteady hand, and Tracy
- 19:45signed under him without a word. She had
- 19:48fought to keep the pen out of her hand
- 19:50for four years, and she signed.
- 19:53Matthew listed the boat that week. It
- 19:56sold within 10 days for less than he
- 19:59owed, and he had to cover the difference
- 20:01out of his savings. Tracy took a job at
- 20:04a dental office downtown answering
- 20:06phones, 40 hours, and Karen, I heard
- 20:10later, started paying 200 a month toward
- 20:13the groceries or she'd be looking at
- 20:16apartments. Tracy gave up the cleaning
- 20:18service, the Whole Foods runs, and her
- 20:21seat as queen of the household. She got
- 20:24a 3-year-old Corolla with a bad door
- 20:27because she needed something to drive.
- 20:30The truck I sold to Ralph's grandson,
- 20:33who needed it for his landscaping
- 20:35business.
- 20:36I put the money in a college fund for
- 20:38Wyatt and Ellie in their name with me as
- 20:41custodian and nobody else.
- 20:44Tracy found out when she asked about it.
- 20:46She went quiet and for the first time
- 20:49since Thanksgiving, she looked at me
- 20:51with something besides anger.
- 20:54That was 3 weeks ago.
- 20:57My life is quieter now.
- 20:59I joined a book club that meets at the
- 21:01library on Wednesdays. I volunteer there
- 21:04two mornings a week shelving large print
- 21:07mysteries and arguing about the endings.
- 21:11I turned the spare room into an art
- 21:12studio with a north window and a
- 21:15drafting table I paid for in cash. I
- 21:18painted a watercolor of Leonard's
- 21:20workbench. It's not good. I hung it over
- 21:23my sofa.
- 21:24I still see my grandchildren and that
- 21:27boundary I made clear from the start.
- 21:29Saturday afternoons I pick them up for
- 21:32ice cream or the park and I'm their
- 21:34grandmother. I'm not their nanny. I'm
- 21:37not their bank. When I drop them back, I
- 21:40stay in the driveway. I kiss them, wave
- 21:43at the house and drive home. Last week
- 21:46Tracy came out to the porch and stood
- 21:48there with her arms wrapped around
- 21:50herself. She lifted a hand, I lifted
- 21:54mine. It wasn't forgiveness yet, but it
- 21:56wasn't contempt either.
- 21:59What I learned is that you can't pay
- 22:00someone into loving you and you can't
- 22:03buy respect with a casserole and a
- 22:05check.
- 22:06Real strength wasn't the speech I never
- 22:09gave. It was the quiet shutting off of
- 22:11one tap after another until the people
- 22:14leaning on me had to stand on their own
- 22:17legs and the dignity I walked out with
- 22:20that night in my coat.
- 22:22On Christmas Eve I baked my own pecan
- 22:24pie, set the table for one, and cut
- 22:27myself a generous slice. I ate every
- 22:29last bite.
- 22:31Closing the wallet can feel harder than
- 22:33closing a door.
- 22:35Would you ever cut off a grown son or
- 22:37daughter financially?
- 22:39Even if it meant hard feelings?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Daughter-in-Law Told Me I Don't Deserve My Pie On Thanksgiving: "This House Doesn't Run On by Blood And Boundaries, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,534 words across 544 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.