YouTube2Text

My Daughter-in-Law Said I Wasn't the Right Vibe for Christmas Eve, So I Canceled the...| Steel St... — Transcript

by Steel Stories · 4,286 words · 650 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I am Darlene Hughes. I am 67 years old
  2. 0:03and for 6 years I paid $3,800
  3. 0:06every month toward my son's mortgage
  4. 0:08without telling a soul. On Christmas Eve
  5. 0:10I stood on the porch of that house
  6. 0:12holding a box of gifts while my
  7. 0:14daughter-in-law pulled the door shut in
  8. 0:16my face and told me I would bring down
  9. 0:18the room.
  10. 0:20It was 9° out, the kind of cold that
  11. 0:22gets into your teeth.
  12. 0:24I had parked my Buick at the far end of
  13. 0:26the cul-de-sac because the driveway and
  14. 0:28both sides of the street were full of
  15. 0:30Audis and Range Rovers and I remember
  16. 0:31thinking, well, somebody's doing well.
  17. 0:34Then I walked up the path past the river
  18. 0:36rock planters and the heated front steps
  19. 0:38and the boxwoods and I realized I had
  20. 0:41written the checks for most of it.
  21. 0:43Before we get into it, tell me where
  22. 0:45you're tuning in from. It means a lot to
  23. 0:47know who's keeping me company.
  24. 0:49My son Shawn and his wife Wendy bought
  25. 0:51that house in Dublin, Ohio 6 years ago.
  26. 0:54Four bedrooms, a three-car garage, a
  27. 0:56kitchen with two dishwashers, which
  28. 0:58tells you what kind of people live
  29. 1:00there. Shawn was a financial advisor at
  30. 1:02Reed Partners then and is still, as far
  31. 1:04as I know, drawing a salary there as of
  32. 1:06that night. He did not qualify for the
  33. 1:09loan on his own. The bank looked at his
  34. 1:11income, his car payments, and the credit
  35. 1:13card balances he thought I didn't know
  36. 1:14about and they said no.
  37. 1:17So I said yes. I put down $140,000
  38. 1:20from the sale of my late husband Ralph's
  39. 1:22machine shop and I set up an automatic
  40. 1:24transfer on the first of every month.
  41. 1:27Ralph would have wanted our boy to have
  42. 1:28a good start, I told myself. I thought
  43. 1:31it was a gift. I did not know it was a
  44. 1:33subscription.
  45. 1:34I spent 34 years as a claims
  46. 1:36investigator for an insurance company,
  47. 1:39the kind of person they send when a fire
  48. 1:40looks too convenient or a back injury is
  49. 1:43too well-timed.
  50. 1:45I know how people lie. I know what they
  51. 1:47do with their hands when they do it and
  52. 1:49for 6 years I did not apply a single
  53. 1:50minute of that skill to my own family
  54. 1:53because it was my family.
  55. 1:55That night I carried a heavy shopping
  56. 1:56box up those steps, cashmere scarves, a
  57. 2:00bottle of the bourbon Shawn likes, a
  58. 2:01leather wallet for him with his initials
  59. 2:03stamped inside, and a set of crystal
  60. 2:05wine glasses Wendy had pointed at in a
  61. 2:08catalog back in October and said,
  62. 2:10"Offhand, those are so us." I had
  63. 2:12wrapped everything in the heavy gold
  64. 2:14paper with a cloth ribbon. Shawn had
  65. 2:16called me in November and said, "Mom,
  66. 2:18you're coming Christmas Eve, right?
  67. 2:207:00, bring your appetite." I had it in
  68. 2:22my calendar. I had a pie in the car.
  69. 2:25Through the front window, I could see
  70. 2:27candlelight and a glittering tree and a
  71. 2:29man laughing with his head thrown back.
  72. 2:32Jazz came through the glass, low and
  73. 2:33polished. I rang the bell with my elbow.
  74. 2:37Wendy opened it, wearing a green satin
  75. 2:39dress and holding a champagne flute.
  76. 2:42There was a half second where her face
  77. 2:43did something honest. Shock, then
  78. 2:46annoyance, the look you give a delivery
  79. 2:48you didn't order. Then she stepped out
  80. 2:50onto the porch and pulled the door shut
  81. 2:52behind her until only a sliver of yellow
  82. 2:54light fell across the boards.
  83. 2:57"Darleen," she said. She has never once
  84. 2:59called me Mom, and for 6 years I let
  85. 3:01that go. What are you doing here?"
  86. 3:03"It's Christmas Eve," I said. "Shawn
  87. 3:05invited me. I brought gifts."
  88. 3:07She exhaled and her breath hung in the
  89. 3:09cold. "We're hosting tonight. Shawn's
  90. 3:12managing partner is here. Two couples
  91. 3:14who are thinking about moving their
  92. 3:16portfolios to him. It's a business
  93. 3:18dinner."
  94. 3:19"Shawn said 7:00."
  95. 3:21"Shawn forgot to tell you we changed
  96. 3:23things." She sipped her champagne and
  97. 3:25let her eyes travel down my good wool
  98. 3:27coat, my winter boots, the scarf I'd
  99. 3:30knitted myself. Look, I'll be honest
  100. 3:32because I think you'd prefer it. You're
  101. 3:34not really the vibe tonight. These are
  102. 3:36polished people. You'd be telling
  103. 3:38stories about claims adjusters and fire
  104. 3:40investigations, and you'd ask if anyone
  105. 3:42wanted more pie. It would be awkward,
  106. 3:44for Shawn mostly."
  107. 3:46I want to be exact about this. I did not
  108. 3:49feel anger yet. What I felt was
  109. 3:51something closer to the sensation of
  110. 3:52putting your foot on a stair that isn't
  111. 3:54there.
  112. 3:55"You don't want me at my son's Christmas
  113. 3:57Eve table," I said, "because I'm not the
  114. 3:59right vibe."
  115. 4:01"Don't take it personally." She smiled,
  116. 4:03the thin, patient smile you give a
  117. 4:05child. "It's business. We'll do lunch in
  118. 4:07January. Just leave the box by the door
  119. 4:10and I'll have the caterer bring it in."
  120. 4:12That was when I looked past her through
  121. 4:14the gap.
  122. 4:15Sean stood in the hall, maybe 15 ft
  123. 4:17away, a glass of scotch in his hand, his
  124. 4:20good navy suit, the one I'd paid to have
  125. 4:22tailored. He was looking straight at me.
  126. 4:24He had heard every word. I know he had
  127. 4:27because the foyer has a vaulted ceiling
  128. 4:29and Wendy doesn't whisper well.
  129. 4:31I waited. People who haven't been in
  130. 4:33that spot will tell you what they would
  131. 4:35have done and they're wrong because you
  132. 4:37don't think about anything. You just
  133. 4:39wait for your child to be your child.
  134. 4:42I waited for him to put the glass down.
  135. 4:44I waited for the door to open. I waited
  136. 4:46through 40 years of nights I'd sat up
  137. 4:48with him, the fevers, the Little League,
  138. 4:51the time I drove 4 hours to bring him a
  139. 4:53forgotten calculator for his final exam.
  140. 4:56Sean looked at me for what felt like a
  141. 4:58full minute and was probably 3 seconds.
  142. 5:01Then he turned, walked into the kitchen,
  143. 5:03and became part of the party.
  144. 5:05Something in me closed, not a slam, more
  145. 5:08like a drawer sliding shut on a
  146. 5:09well-made cabinet.
  147. 5:11I bent down. I did not put the box on
  148. 5:13the mat. I took it back into my arms and
  149. 5:15straightened up. "You're right, Wendy,"
  150. 5:17I said, "it is just business. Have a
  151. 5:19lovely night."
  152. 5:20The smile on her face wavered for the
  153. 5:22first time.
  154. 5:23She had expected to leave me with the
  155. 5:25box. A woman who walks away with the
  156. 5:27gifts is a woman who isn't finished.
  157. 5:30I walked back down that driveway past
  158. 5:32the Audis with my spine straight. In the
  159. 5:34car, I set the box on the passenger seat
  160. 5:36and turned the heater up and my hands
  161. 5:38didn't shake.
  162. 5:40I drove the 18 miles home to the small
  163. 5:42brick ranch Ralph and I paid off in
  164. 5:441998, the one with my name alone on the
  165. 5:46deed, and a crooked mailbox he always
  166. 5:48meant to fix.
  167. 5:50I put the pie in the refrigerator. I
  168. 5:52hung up my coat and then I went into the
  169. 5:54spare bedroom where I keep the desk and
  170. 5:56turned on the lamp.
  171. 5:58Some people drink when they get hurt. I
  172. 6:00audit.
  173. 6:01The first thing on the screen was the
  174. 6:02standing transfer, $3,800
  175. 6:05on the first of every month to the
  176. 6:07servicer on that house.
  177. 6:09Set up a December of 2018, 73 payments,
  178. 6:12no break, not once. Next to it, the
  179. 6:15second line I had given him 2 years
  180. 6:17back, $600 a month for the kids fund,
  181. 6:20except there were no kids and no fund. I
  182. 6:22thought about that.
  183. 6:24Then I clicked cancel on both and
  184. 6:26watched the confirmation banner roll
  185. 6:28across the screen.
  186. 6:29The credit card was next. A few years
  187. 6:31ago, Shawn had told me it would be
  188. 6:33easier if he were an authorized user on
  189. 6:35my card for emergencies. I had agreed.
  190. 6:38That evening, I scrolled the last
  191. 6:40billing cycle and saw $11,000 in
  192. 6:42charges, including a catering company, a
  193. 6:44wine merchant, and a florist, all dated
  194. 6:47within the last week. He had thrown his
  195. 6:49Christmas party on my credit. I called
  196. 6:51the number on the back, told them the
  197. 6:53card was compromised, and had his access
  198. 6:55terminated before the hold music
  199. 6:57finished its first loop.
  200. 7:00Then there was the money market account,
  201. 7:01$35,000,
  202. 7:03set up as Shawn's cushion, which he'd
  203. 7:05had signing access to since his father
  204. 7:07died. I moved it to a new account in my
  205. 7:09name alone. By 10:30, it was done.
  206. 7:13I did not cry. I made a cup of tea and
  207. 7:15opened the box of gifts on the kitchen
  208. 7:17table and sat for a while. The wallet
  209. 7:19was beautiful. I thought about the
  210. 7:21engraving, SRH, Shawn Ralph Hughes, and
  211. 7:23I put it in the drawer where Ralph's
  212. 7:25watch is. The scarves I decided I would
  213. 7:27give away. The crystal glasses I wrapped
  214. 7:30up again and set by the door for the
  215. 7:32women's shelter on Maple Street because
  216. 7:34somebody ought to drink out of them.
  217. 7:37I slept better than I had in 6 years.
  218. 7:39On the 26th, I slept until 8:00. I found
  219. 7:42the phone on the counter, face down,
  220. 7:44buzzing across the laminate like an
  221. 7:46insect. When I turned it over, the
  222. 7:47screen said 20 missed calls, 12 from
  223. 7:50Shawn, six from Wendy, two from a number
  224. 7:53I didn't recognize.
  225. 7:54There were also text messages, a whole
  226. 7:56stack of them, getting shorter and more
  227. 7:58frantic as they went. Why is my card
  228. 8:00declined? The auto payment got canceled.
  229. 8:02Call me. Mom, this is serious. Mom, pick
  230. 8:05up.
  231. 8:06I made coffee and watched the snow fall
  232. 8:08on the neighbor's roof. I did not call
  233. 8:10back.
  234. 8:11They were at my door by 10:00.
  235. 8:14Both of them in the driveway, doors of
  236. 8:15their leased Lexus still open. Wendy had
  237. 8:18her sunglasses pushed up on top of her
  238. 8:20head and a face the color of raw ham.
  239. 8:22Sean hadn't shaved. I opened the door,
  240. 8:24but I kept the storm door latched
  241. 8:26between us.
  242. 8:27"Our card got declined at brunch," Wendy
  243. 8:29said, "in front of Sean's partner. Do
  244. 8:32you have any idea how humiliating that
  245. 8:34was?"
  246. 8:35"I have some idea," I said.
  247. 8:37"And the mortgage transfer got
  248. 8:38canceled," Sean said, his voice was
  249. 8:40cracking. "The servicer's portal flagged
  250. 8:43it. Mom, you have to fix this.
  251. 8:45Whatever's going on with the bank, call
  252. 8:47them and fix it."
  253. 8:49"There's nothing wrong with the bank. I
  254. 8:50canceled it."
  255. 8:52They looked at me the way people look at
  256. 8:54a dog that has just spoken. Then Sean
  257. 8:56started to say it was a
  258. 8:57misunderstanding, and Wendy started to
  259. 8:59say I couldn't do that, and I said, in
  260. 9:02the voice I used to use on claimants who
  261. 9:04thought they could argue a denial, "On
  262. 9:06Christmas Eve, your wife told me I
  263. 9:08wasn't the right vibe for the party I
  264. 9:10helped pay for. You stood in the hall
  265. 9:12and watched. I've simply taken her at
  266. 9:14her word. The money isn't the right vibe
  267. 9:16for you, either."
  268. 9:18"You are being vindictive," Wendy said.
  269. 9:21"I'm being consistent."
  270. 9:23Sean changed tactics. He always does.
  271. 9:25His eyes filled. "Mom, we're underwater.
  272. 9:28You know how things are. If we miss two
  273. 9:30payments, the bank starts the clock. We
  274. 9:32could lose the house. You can't just do
  275. 9:34that to your family."
  276. 9:36"I watched my family close the door," I
  277. 9:37said. "I just stopped paying for it."
  278. 9:40That was when Wendy leaned in so close
  279. 9:42that her breath fogged the glass. "You
  280. 9:45have until Friday," she said quietly.
  281. 9:47"You put it all back, the transfers and
  282. 9:49the cards and the account, or you will
  283. 9:51regret it. You have no idea what we can
  284. 9:53do."
  285. 9:54"I think I have some idea," I said, and
  286. 9:56closed the door.
  287. 9:57I stood in my hallway until their car
  288. 9:59was gone. My legs shook then, not from
  289. 10:02fear, from the effort of staying still.
  290. 10:04I'll tell you what a good investigator
  291. 10:06knows. When somebody says, "You have no
  292. 10:09idea what we can do." They've already
  293. 10:11done something.
  294. 10:12Four days later, on the 30th, I was
  295. 10:14shoveling the walk when my phone rang.
  296. 10:17"Probate Court, Franklin County." the
  297. 10:19woman said. She was calling to confirm
  298. 10:21that I had received service of the
  299. 10:23petition.
  300. 10:24"What petition?"
  301. 10:26There was a pause. She sounded young.
  302. 10:28"The petition for guardianship, ma'am."
  303. 10:31"Filed December 27th by Shawn R. Hughes,
  304. 10:33alleging that Darlene Hughes is
  305. 10:35incapacitated. There's a hearing on
  306. 10:37January 9th. I'm sorry, I thought you'd
  307. 10:39been served. Did someone not come by?"
  308. 10:42I thanked her and hung up. Then I leaned
  309. 10:45the shovel against the fence and stood
  310. 10:46in the snow with my face going numb.
  311. 10:49The text arrived while I was standing
  312. 10:51there. Shawn, of course.
  313. 10:53"Mom, it didn't have to come to this. We
  314. 10:55have a letter from a doctor. If you
  315. 10:57restore the accounts and sign the house
  316. 10:59over to us for safekeeping, we'll
  317. 11:00withdraw it. Otherwise, the judge
  318. 11:02decides who manages your money. We just
  319. 11:05want you protected."
  320. 11:06"Protected." I read it three times.
  321. 11:09Under the cold, something very old and
  322. 11:11very steady woke up in me. The thing
  323. 11:13that had gotten up at 4:00 a.m. for 34
  324. 11:15years to stand in the ashes of other
  325. 11:17people's lies and find the match.
  326. 11:19I did not panic, and I want that on the
  327. 11:21record, because people assume an old
  328. 11:23woman gets a letter like that and falls
  329. 11:25apart. I had a spare key to a safe
  330. 11:27deposit box, a lawyer I trusted, and 10
  331. 11:29days.
  332. 11:31My lawyer was Glenn Daniels, who had
  333. 11:33handled Ralph's estate, and who had been
  334. 11:35practicing probate law since before
  335. 11:37Shawn learned to drive. I called him
  336. 11:39from the kitchen. He listened without
  337. 11:41interrupting, and when I finished, he
  338. 11:42said, "Darlene, I want you to do three
  339. 11:45things. Don't answer another text. Don't
  340. 11:48delete anything, and come see me in an
  341. 11:50hour."
  342. 11:51By 2:00, I was sitting in his conference
  343. 11:53room with the petition in front of me.
  344. 11:55It was nine pages long. It claimed I had
  345. 11:58been forgetful, confused about money,
  346. 12:00that I'd made irrational financial
  347. 12:02decisions, and abruptly terminated
  348. 12:04support to dependents.
  349. 12:06It attached a letter from a physician
  350. 12:08named Dr. Craig Patterson, who stated
  351. 12:10that on December 23rd, he had observed
  352. 12:12me and found me suffering from moderate
  353. 12:15to severe cognitive impairment with
  354. 12:17impaired judgment.
  355. 12:19"December 23rd," I said, "I've never met
  356. 12:21a Dr. Craig Patterson. I was at the
  357. 12:23grocery store on the 23rd."
  358. 12:26Glenn smiled for the first time all
  359. 12:27afternoon.
  360. 12:29"I thought you might say something like
  361. 12:30that."
  362. 12:31Now, here is the part the comment
  363. 12:33section on a story like this always gets
  364. 12:35wrong. People think you win by acting. I
  365. 12:38did not act. I did not pretend to be
  366. 12:39anything. I walked into that hospital's
  367. 12:42geriatric clinic 2 days later on my own
  368. 12:45and asked for a full cognitive
  369. 12:46assessment with a neurologist who had
  370. 12:48never heard of Sean Hughes. 3 hours,
  371. 12:51clock drawings, memory recall, a number
  372. 12:53sequence I could do in my sleep, and a
  373. 12:55lot of questions about my finances that
  374. 12:57I answered better than the young
  375. 12:58resident asking them.
  376. 13:00At the end, the neurologist, a tired and
  377. 13:02kindly man named Dr. Simpson, signed his
  378. 13:05report and said, "Mrs. Hughes, I'd be
  379. 13:07happy to testify to this in court. I
  380. 13:09wish half my patients were as sharp."
  381. 13:12The second thing I did was call Janet
  382. 13:14Murray.
  383. 13:15Janet and I started at the insurance
  384. 13:17company together in 1987.
  385. 13:19She went on to the state attorney
  386. 13:21general's office, financial crimes,
  387. 13:23and she's been a detective with the
  388. 13:25county's elder fraud unit for the last 9
  389. 13:27years.
  390. 13:28We have had Thanksgiving dinner together
  391. 13:30more times than I have had it with my
  392. 13:32own son. I told her everything over the
  393. 13:34phone and then I said, "I don't want him
  394. 13:37stopped. I want him caught."
  395. 13:39She didn't answer right away.
  396. 13:41"Darlene, they're going to come to you,"
  397. 13:43she said at last. "People like this
  398. 13:45never stop at a petition. They'll try to
  399. 13:48close it quick before the hearing
  400. 13:49because they know a judge isn't going to
  401. 13:51buy a letter from a doctor who never saw
  402. 13:53you. They'll need your signature on
  403. 13:55something. A deed, a power of attorney,
  404. 13:57an admission to a facility.
  405. 14:00Then I'll invite them over."
  406. 14:02"Not as a trap. You can't solicit a
  407. 14:04crime."
  408. 14:05"I won't solicit anything. I'll say I
  409. 14:07want to talk. What they do when they
  410. 14:09walk into my kitchen is theirs."
  411. 14:11She thought about it. Ohio's a one-party
  412. 14:14consent state. If you're in the
  413. 14:16conversation, you can record it. Glenn
  414. 14:18can sit in the next room. I'll be down
  415. 14:20the block with a team in case anything
  416. 14:22goes wrong. And Darlene, don't coach
  417. 14:24them. Don't suggest a thing.
  418. 14:26So, that's what I did. I texted Shawn
  419. 14:28that night. I'm frightened, I wrote. I
  420. 14:31don't want to go to court. Can you and
  421. 14:33Wendy come Thursday afternoon so we can
  422. 14:34talk it through just us? I'll make
  423. 14:36coffee.
  424. 14:37He answered in under a minute. Of
  425. 14:39course, Mom. We love you. We'll be there
  426. 14:41at 2:00.
  427. 14:42Thursday dawned gray and bitter. I put
  428. 14:45on my plain navy slacks and my gray
  429. 14:46cardigan and pinned up my hair the way I
  430. 14:49always do.
  431. 14:50I set out a plate of the shortbread I'd
  432. 14:51baked the day before, a blue pot of
  433. 14:53coffee, four cups. Glenn arrived at noon
  434. 14:56quietly through the back door with a
  435. 14:58thermos and a legal pad. A technician
  436. 15:00from Janet's office installed two small
  437. 15:02recorders, one in the kitchen's wall
  438. 15:04clock, one in the bookshelf, and then
  439. 15:06left as quietly as he'd come.
  440. 15:08I was surprised how ordinary it all
  441. 15:10felt, like waiting for a furnace
  442. 15:12repairman.
  443. 15:13At 2:05, a gray Lexus pulled into the
  444. 15:16drive. Wendy got out first in white wool
  445. 15:18with a leather folder under her arm.
  446. 15:20Shawn followed. And behind them came a
  447. 15:22third person, a slim man in his 50s with
  448. 15:25a silver tie and a medical bag who
  449. 15:27looked at my house and my lawn and my
  450. 15:29crooked mailbox the way a buyer looks at
  451. 15:31a used car.
  452. 15:32"This is Dr. Patterson," Wendy said
  453. 15:34brightly when I opened the door. "He's a
  454. 15:36friend of the family. He's here just to
  455. 15:38chat."
  456. 15:40"Of course," I said. "Come in."
  457. 15:42I led them to the kitchen table. I
  458. 15:44poured the coffee. The doctor sat across
  459. 15:47from me and began in a gentle voice
  460. 15:48asking me what day it was. I told him
  461. 15:51the month, the year, the name of the
  462. 15:52governor, the weather. He asked me to
  463. 15:54count backward from 100 by sevens, and I
  464. 15:57did. And I did it at a pace that I could
  465. 15:59see made him uneasy.
  466. 16:01"You're very sharp today," he said.
  467. 16:03"I'm sharp most days, Doctor."
  468. 16:06Wendy interrupted. "Doctor, she's
  469. 16:08compensating. That's the thing with
  470. 16:10early dementia. They can fool you for 20
  471. 16:12minutes." She slid the leather folder
  472. 16:14across the table.
  473. 16:16"Shawn and I think it would be easiest
  474. 16:18if you just sign these and nobody has to
  475. 16:20go to court. It's a power of attorney
  476. 16:22and a deed transferred to a family trust
  477. 16:25for the house. Nothing changes
  478. 16:27day-to-day. You just have the right
  479. 16:28people looking after things.
  480. 16:30And if I don't sign?
  481. 16:32Then the doctor's letter goes to the
  482. 16:34judge on Monday, Sean said, not looking
  483. 16:36at me. And I'm sorry, Mom, but it's
  484. 16:38going to be a lot worse.
  485. 16:40And after the house is in the trust, I
  486. 16:42asked mildly.
  487. 16:44We'll sell, Wendy said. She was relaxed
  488. 16:46now, her shoulders down, her voice
  489. 16:49slipping into the casual tone of someone
  490. 16:51discussing a vacation. Honestly, it's a
  491. 16:53fair house, but it's got value. The lot
  492. 16:55alone is worth 350. You'll go to a place
  493. 16:58we've picked out in Westerville. It's
  494. 16:59very nice. They have a memory care wing
  495. 17:02and once you're settled the doctor signs
  496. 17:04the admission form.
  497. 17:05We've already put down a deposit. Sean
  498. 17:08used your old card number, so it's
  499. 17:10technically your money.
  500. 17:12I want you to picture it. A kitchen that
  501. 17:14smells of coffee and shortbread. Ralph's
  502. 17:16clock on the wall. A woman in a gray
  503. 17:18cardigan at the end of the table, hands
  504. 17:20folded.
  505. 17:21I see, I said. And Dr. Patterson, what
  506. 17:24were you paid to write that letter dated
  507. 17:26the 23rd?
  508. 17:27The doctor's face did something
  509. 17:29complicated. I'm sorry.
  510. 17:31You wrote that you evaluated me on
  511. 17:32December 23rd. I've never seen you until
  512. 17:35today. How much?
  513. 17:37He opened his mouth, closed it and
  514. 17:39looked at Wendy. Wendy laughed, a high
  515. 17:41thin sound. Doctor, you see? She's
  516. 17:44inventing things. You see what we mean.
  517. 17:464,000, Sean said quietly.
  518. 17:49Everybody turned to look at him. He had
  519. 17:51gone the color of paper. I think it was
  520. 17:53the first honest thing he'd said in 6
  521. 17:55years and he'd said it to himself more
  522. 17:57than to us.
  523. 17:58Sean, Wendy hissed.
  524. 18:00It's $4,000, Mom, and a promise of more.
  525. 18:04It was only supposed to be a letter. It
  526. 18:05was only supposed to scare you.
  527. 18:08That's enough, the doctor said standing.
  528. 18:10And he had the sense to look at the
  529. 18:12walls then. His eyes landed on the
  530. 18:14clock. I watched him do the math and I
  531. 18:16watched him decide it was too late to
  532. 18:18run. He started anyway. He got as far as
  533. 18:21the hall before Janet Murray stepped
  534. 18:22through my front door with two uniform
  535. 18:24deputies and said in the calm voice of a
  536. 18:27woman announcing a train,
  537. 18:29"Dr. Patterson, I'm Detective Murray
  538. 18:31with the Franklin County Sheriff's
  539. 18:32Office. I'd like you to stay right
  540. 18:34there."
  541. 18:35Glenn walked in from the den with his
  542. 18:37legal pad.
  543. 18:38"Sean Hughes and Wendy Hughes," Janet
  544. 18:41said, "you're being placed under arrest
  545. 18:43for attempted theft by deception,
  546. 18:45forgery, attempted unlawful restraint of
  547. 18:47an elderly person and conspiracy. You
  548. 18:50have the right to remain silent."
  549. 18:52Wendy screamed. That's the only word for
  550. 18:54it. She called me a liar, a controlling
  551. 18:57bitter old woman, a monster who'd set
  552. 18:59them up. She said I'd lured them. She
  553. 19:01invited us, she kept saying. She invited
  554. 19:03us. Janet told her gently that being
  555. 19:06invited to a kitchen is not the same as
  556. 19:08being asked to commit a felony in it and
  557. 19:10that the recording would speak for
  558. 19:11itself.
  559. 19:13Sean didn't scream. He stood in my
  560. 19:15kitchen with his hands behind his back
  561. 19:17and tears running down his face and he
  562. 19:18said, "Mom, Mom, please, I'm your son."
  563. 19:22I looked at him for a long moment. I
  564. 19:24wanted to feel something large, rage or
  565. 19:26the old ache, one or the other. What I
  566. 19:28felt was quiet and sad and clear, like a
  567. 19:31house after the movers have gone.
  568. 19:33"You were my son on Christmas Eve, too,"
  569. 19:35I said. "You watched me stand in the
  570. 19:37cold."
  571. 19:38They took them out through the front
  572. 19:39door and down the walk past the crooked
  573. 19:41mailbox and the whole street watched
  574. 19:44from behind its curtains.
  575. 19:46I stood on my porch in my cardigan with
  576. 19:48the deputy's patrol car idling at the
  577. 19:50curb and I did not look away.
  578. 19:52It's been 8 months. People ask if I
  579. 19:55regret it. I tell them what I told the
  580. 19:57judge at sentencing, which is that I
  581. 19:58regret 6 years of not looking at my own
  582. 20:01ledger.
  583. 20:02The Franklin County prosecutor had the
  584. 20:04recordings, the bank records, the false
  585. 20:06letter, the deposit for the care
  586. 20:08facility, and Sean's own statement,
  587. 20:10which he gave without a lawyer present
  588. 20:12and which he has since come to regret.
  589. 20:14Dr. Patterson took a plea. He
  590. 20:16surrendered his medical license in March
  591. 20:19and was sentenced to 18 months for his
  592. 20:21part in the scheme.
  593. 20:23Three other families have since come
  594. 20:24forward with similar letters, and one of
  595. 20:27those cases is still open.
  596. 20:29Sean pleaded guilty to attempted theft
  597. 20:31and forgery. He got 24 months in a state
  598. 20:34facility in Marion. Wendy, who went to
  599. 20:36trial and lost, got 3 years. The judge
  600. 20:39said her recorded words on the day of
  601. 20:41arrest, particularly the comment about
  602. 20:43the lot alone worth 350, showed what he
  603. 20:46called a calculated indifference to the
  604. 20:48life of a woman who had given them
  605. 20:50everything.
  606. 20:51They lost the house in April. The bank
  607. 20:53was patient for exactly as long as its
  608. 20:55policy required, and then it was not.
  609. 20:58Reed Partners terminated Sean the day of
  610. 21:00his arrest. I'm told the Lexus went back
  611. 21:02to the dealer on a flatbed. The caterer,
  612. 21:05the wine merchant, and the florist are
  613. 21:07still waiting on payments the card never
  614. 21:09covered.
  615. 21:10I did not sit in the courtroom and
  616. 21:12gloat.
  617. 21:13I sat in the second row with my purse on
  618. 21:15my lap, and when they brought Sean in
  619. 21:17wearing the county's orange, I let
  620. 21:18myself look at him just once.
  621. 21:21He looked older. He looked a little like
  622. 21:23Ralph.
  623. 21:24Spring came. I fixed the mailbox myself
  624. 21:27with a level and a bag of concrete.
  625. 21:29Janet helped. I took a trip I'd been
  626. 21:31putting off for 20 years, a week in
  627. 21:33Savannah alone, where I walked the
  628. 21:35squares in the morning and ate shrimp
  629. 21:37and grits at a counter, and nobody asked
  630. 21:39me for anything.
  631. 21:40The women at the shelter on Maple Street
  632. 21:42use the crystal wine glasses for their
  633. 21:44holiday dinner now. I like to think of
  634. 21:46that.
  635. 21:47The $3,800
  636. 21:49I used to send on the first of the month
  637. 21:51goes into an account that's all mine,
  638. 21:53and it's growing.
  639. 21:55Last week, I bought a ticket to Ireland
  640. 21:57for September.
  641. 21:58I still bake a pie on Christmas Eve.
  642. 22:01This year, I'll take it to Janet's
  643. 22:02house, where there will be a table and a
  644. 22:04fire and a place set for me.
  645. 22:06Giving to the people we love is one of
  646. 22:08life's quiet joys, but it hurts when
  647. 22:11that giving is met with a closed door.
  648. 22:13Have you ever helped pay for a family
  649. 22:15celebration and still been shut out of
  650. 22:17it?

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of My Daughter-in-Law Said I Wasn't the Right Vibe for Christmas Eve, So I Canceled the...| Steel St... by Steel Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,286 words across 650 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.