My Daughter-in-Law Said I Was "Living Too Large" So I Canceled 16 Payments And Watched Her — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00My son told me I was living too large,
- 0:03and I looked him dead in the eye and
- 0:04said, he might be right.
- 0:07My name is Joyce Matthews. I'm 63 years
- 0:10old, and I've lived in the same
- 0:12four-bedroom brick colonial outside
- 0:15Columbus, Ohio
- 0:16for 31 years. My husband Roy and I
- 0:20bought it when Shane was five. We
- 0:22painted every room ourselves, and Roy
- 0:25planted the maple in the front yard the
- 0:27summer Shane learned to ride a bike.
- 0:30Roy passed four years ago this November.
- 0:33The house has been quiet since, but it's
- 0:35a quiet I chose to keep.
- 0:37Before I tell you the rest, drop the
- 0:40name of your town in the comments.
- 0:43Every other Sunday, my son Shane and his
- 0:46wife Haley came for dinner with the
- 0:48kids. Hudson is nine and Ruby is six.
- 0:52Lately, Haley's mother, Gail, had
- 0:55started tagging along, and I noticed all
- 0:57three adults had gotten into a habit of
- 1:00looking around my dining room the way
- 1:02people look at a car they're thinking of
- 1:04buying.
- 1:06That Sunday, it came out over pot roast.
- 1:09Joyce, Haley said, setting down her
- 1:11fork, we've been talking, and this house
- 1:14is just so much for one person.
- 1:17Honestly, you're living too large.
- 1:19Gail nodded into her wine glass like
- 1:22she'd rehearsed it.
- 1:24Mom, Shane said, not quite meeting my
- 1:27eyes, if you sold and moved into one of
- 1:30those nice 55 plus condos, you'd free up
- 1:33a ton of equity.
- 1:35It could really help the family.
- 1:37We're stretched thin, and we've got our
- 1:39eye on a house in Dublin with a real
- 1:41yard for the kids.
- 1:43The family, I said.
- 1:46Things are tight, Haley said, and she
- 1:48said it the way you'd say it from the
- 1:50deck of a boat.
- 1:52Her new manicure caught the chandelier
- 1:54light.
- 1:55It's just the logical thing. You don't
- 1:58need all this space, and do.
- 2:00Nobody asked what I wanted. Nobody asked
- 2:03how I was doing without Roy. They had
- 2:05already moved me into a condo and spent
- 2:08the money.
- 2:10I see, I said, and I dabbed my mouth
- 2:13with my napkin. Maybe I ought to take a
- 2:15close look at my finances tonight.
- 2:18Shane and Haley traded a look. Gale
- 2:21actually smiled. They thought I just
- 2:23said yes and I let them think it. They
- 2:26had no idea what I was about to close.
- 2:29After the taillights disappeared down
- 2:31the street, I stood in my kitchen with
- 2:34the dishes still on the table.
- 2:37I wasn't angry. What I felt was colder
- 2:40and cleaner than anger, like opening a
- 2:42window in January. I went into Roy's old
- 2:45study, switched on the green banker's
- 2:48lamp and logged into my bank account.
- 2:51For three years, I'd been helping out.
- 2:54That was the word I'd used with myself
- 2:56and with my sister and with the priest.
- 3:00A little help while Shane got
- 3:01established. A little help while Haley
- 3:04figured out her business.
- 3:06I pulled up the statements and started a
- 3:08list on a yellow legal pad, the way Roy
- 3:11used to.
- 3:13Shane's truck payment which I co-signed,
- 3:15truck insurance, Haley's SUV lease, SUV
- 3:19insurance, both of their cell phones
- 3:22plus the kids' tablets, internet and
- 3:24cable, a streaming bundle,
- 3:26Haley's gym and the boutique Pilates
- 3:28studio, Hudson's travel baseball fees,
- 3:31Ruby's dance tuition, a meal kit
- 3:34subscription because Haley found grocery
- 3:36stores draining, a lawn service for
- 3:39their house, the minimum payments on two
- 3:42credit cards that I had added them to as
- 3:45authorized users, and Gale's car
- 3:48insurance which somehow had ended up on
- 3:50my card too.
- 3:52I counted twice, then a third time.
- 3:5516 recurring payments. The monthly total
- 3:58came to $1,980.
- 4:02I sat there with the pen in my hand.
- 4:05Three years at nearly 2,000 a month.
- 4:08I had been quietly financing the exact
- 4:10people who just told me I took up too
- 4:13much room.
- 4:14I'd mistaken rescuing for loving, and
- 4:17over time, my help had hardened into
- 4:20their expectation until they didn't even
- 4:22notice it was mine.
- 4:25I opened the first account and clicked
- 4:27remove payment method, confirm, then the
- 4:29phone carrier, cancel autopay, confirm.
- 4:33Haley's Pilates studio wanted a reason
- 4:36for cancellation, and I typed not my
- 4:39studio.
- 4:41I called the credit card company's
- 4:4224-hour line and removed both authorized
- 4:46users and closed their cards to new
- 4:48charges. I canceled the policies and
- 4:51subscriptions still billed in my name,
- 4:53deleted my bank routing from the truck
- 4:56loan, and asked the SUV leasing company
- 4:59to take my card off file. I spent an
- 5:02hour and 10 minutes going down that list
- 5:05line by line, crossing each one off the
- 5:08legal pad.
- 5:09When the last line was crossed off, I
- 5:11closed the laptop. My chest felt light.
- 5:15Roy used to say a clear conscience is
- 5:17the best mattress in the world. I slept
- 5:20like I was 25.
- 5:22The first call came at 6:52 the next
- 5:25morning.
- 5:26I was on the back patio with black
- 5:28coffee, watching a cardinal fight, his
- 5:31own reflection in the window.
- 5:33Mom. Shane's voice was tight. My card
- 5:37got declined at the gas station. I'm
- 5:39standing at the pump and there's a line
- 5:41behind me.
- 5:43That card was mine, Shane. I removed you
- 5:46from it.
- 5:47You what? Why? I need to get to work.
- 5:50Then I'd stop at the bank on your way
- 5:52and take care of it.
- 5:54You have your own debit card.
- 5:57Is this about last night? Mom, we were
- 5:59just talking.
- 6:01I told you I was going to look at my
- 6:03finances. I did. Have a good day.
- 6:06I hung up before he could build a second
- 6:09sentence.
- 6:10By nine, my phone looked like a slot
- 6:12machine. Haley texted, the lease company
- 6:16just emailed that the auto draft failed
- 6:19and our account is flagged. What did you
- 6:21do? Then the cable and cell providers
- 6:25just sent cancellation notices. The
- 6:28tablets and internet are cutting off
- 6:29today. Joyce, answer me. Then Gail, who
- 6:33had never once texted me in her life.
- 6:36This is cruel and you should be ashamed.
- 6:39I turned the phone face down on the
- 6:41patio table and poured a second cup.
- 6:44I'd cut off the money,
- 6:46but I knew they'd soon come to the house
- 6:49to push me back into the old
- 6:51arrangement. And Roy had taught me that
- 6:53you don't discuss a boundary with
- 6:55someone holding a key to it.
- 6:58Shane had carried a key to my front door
- 7:00since he was 12 and he'd never given it
- 7:03back.
- 7:04Over the years, he and Haley had come to
- 7:07treat my house like a warehouse. They'd
- 7:10let themselves in for the good ladder,
- 7:12the leaf blower, a casserole dish, a bag
- 7:15of my coffee. Sometimes I'd come home
- 7:17from church and find a stranger's flyer
- 7:20on my counter
- 7:22or Haley's laundry basket in my hallway.
- 7:25I called a locksmith.
- 7:27Can you come this morning? I'll pay the
- 7:29rush fee.
- 7:30By 11:30, the old brass cylinders were
- 7:33in a paper bag and three new deadbolts
- 7:36sat in my doors, turning with a clean,
- 7:39heavy click.
- 7:41I tipped him well and locked the door
- 7:43behind him.
- 7:44At 1:40 that afternoon, a truck door
- 7:47slammed in my driveway. I was in the
- 7:50kitchen with a crossword when I heard
- 7:52boots on the porch and the scrape of a
- 7:55key that no longer fit.
- 7:57What the Shane muttered. He rattled the
- 8:00knob. He knocked hard.
- 8:02I walked to the door and spoke through
- 8:04it.
- 8:05Hello, Shane.
- 8:07Mom, the lock's stuck.
- 8:09It isn' stuck. It's new.
- 8:12You changed the locks? Haley's voice
- 8:14came up from behind him, high and
- 8:16furious.
- 8:18Joyce, open this door right now.
- 8:20I turned the deadbolt and opened it as
- 8:23far as the safety chain allowed, which
- 8:25was 4 in.
- 8:27I looked at their flushed faces.
- 8:30Gail was in the passenger seat of the
- 8:32truck,
- 8:33glaring through the windshield.
- 8:35This is my house, I said evenly.
- 8:38You told me last night I had too much of
- 8:40it. I'm taking responsibility for it.
- 8:44You shut off my insurance, Shane said,
- 8:46loud enough for Mrs. Pruitt next door to
- 8:48hear.
- 8:49If I get pulled over, I'm toast.
- 8:52Then drive carefully to your agent's
- 8:55office and pay the premium.
- 8:58You can't just lock us out, Haley
- 9:00snapped.
- 9:01My inventory is in your spare room.
- 9:04I know where it is, I said, and we'll
- 9:06take care of that.
- 9:08I closed the door and went back to my
- 9:10crossword. I didn't solve a single clue,
- 9:14but my hands didn't shake either.
- 9:16Haley had spent the last four years on
- 9:19one business idea after another.
- 9:21First, it was a jewelry party company,
- 9:24then it was essential oils.
- 9:26This year, it was a wellness candle
- 9:28brand, which meant a lot of inventory
- 9:31and very few buyers because their house
- 9:34was too cluttered to stage photos. 12
- 9:38plastic bins of soy, wax, and glass jars
- 9:41had migrated into my spare bedroom.
- 9:44Roy's old sewing cabinet had been shoved
- 9:46into the corner to make room.
- 9:49Shane was no better.
- 9:50My garage held his old drum kit, a kayak
- 9:53he'd used once, two sets of golf clubs,
- 9:57and a pile of boxes labeled college
- 9:59stuff that had been collecting dust
- 10:01since 2012.
- 10:03They wanted me to downsize.
- 10:05I decided to start with their
- 10:07belongings.
- 10:08I did it myself over
- 10:11hours, with my bad knee complaining on
- 10:13every stair. I rolled the kayak to the
- 10:16end of the driveway and set it on the
- 10:18grass. I carried out the golf clubs and
- 10:21the boxes.
- 10:22Then I went upstairs and carried down 12
- 10:25bins of candles, one at a time, stopping
- 10:28on the landing to catch my breath. I
- 10:30didn't break anything. I didn't throw
- 10:33anything away. Roy would have been proud
- 10:36of how carefully I handled everything
- 10:39that wasn't mine.
- 10:41I stacked it all by the retaining wall
- 10:43and covered it with the blue tarp from
- 10:45the shed, anchoring the corners with
- 10:48bricks from Roy's old flower border, dry
- 10:51and tidy and no longer under my roof.
- 10:55I sent one text to Shane and Haley both.
- 10:58Your belongings are under a tarp at the
- 11:01end of the driveway.
- 11:02Please pick them up before the rain on
- 11:05Thursday.
- 11:06Haley arrived in 20 minutes in her
- 11:08mother's sedan.
- 11:10She jumped out and stared at the tarp
- 11:13like it was a crime scene.
- 11:15You put my business out on the curb, she
- 11:18shrieked,
- 11:19marching toward my doorbell camera.
- 11:21Those candles are temperature sensitive.
- 11:24I pressed the intercom button.
- 11:27Then I put them in a climate-controlled
- 11:29car, Haley.
- 11:31This is insane. You're having a tantrum
- 11:34because we gave you honest advice.
- 11:37I took your advice, I said into the
- 11:39speaker. I'm making room. Drive safe.
- 11:43I shut off the mic and watched her from
- 11:45the window, sweating through her blouse
- 11:48as she hauled bins to the trunk.
- 11:51Gail sat in the passenger seat the whole
- 11:53time with her arms crossed, not lifting
- 11:56a finger.
- 11:58The next day was quiet. I didn't call.
- 12:01Neither did they.
- 12:03I knew they were scrambling because
- 12:05without my money, they had to look at
- 12:07how they actually lived, perhaps for the
- 12:09first time.
- 12:11On Wednesday afternoon, I was pruning
- 12:13roses along the front walk when Shane's
- 12:16truck pulled up to the curb.
- 12:19He climbed out slowly and came up the
- 12:21driveway with his hands in his pockets.
- 12:25He looked like he hadn't slept.
- 12:27Mom.
- 12:29I snipped a spent bloom. Hello, Shane.
- 12:32Haley's furious. She missed a vendor
- 12:35deadline because the internet was off.
- 12:38My phone got cut for two days until I
- 12:40paid the reconnection fee. I had to put
- 12:43it on a card with 24% interest.
- 12:47That sounds stressful.
- 12:49It is and it's unnecessary. You have the
- 12:53money, mom. You're just being
- 12:54vindictive.
- 12:56I set the shears in my basket and turned
- 12:58to face him.
- 13:00I'm being clear. I'm no longer paying
- 13:02for a lifestyle you can't afford.
- 13:05You're 36 years old, Shane. You have two
- 13:08children.
- 13:09It's time you acted like their father
- 13:11instead of my dependent.
- 13:13His face went red. He looked down at the
- 13:16walkway and I watched him decide to play
- 13:19the card I'd been waiting for.
- 13:21Haley says if you're going to treat us
- 13:24like this, she's not comfortable with
- 13:26the kids coming over.
- 13:28It landed exactly where it was aimed. I
- 13:31loved those two children more than I
- 13:33could say.
- 13:35Hudson, who liked to help me roll out
- 13:37pie dough.
- 13:38Ruby, who still fell asleep on my chest
- 13:40during movies.
- 13:42They knew precisely where I was soft.
- 13:45My throat tightened, but I kept my spine
- 13:48straight.
- 13:49I would not let them use a nine-year-old
- 13:52and a six-year-old as a bargaining chip
- 13:54for my checking account.
- 13:56I see, I said, keeping my voice flat.
- 14:00Then you and Haley will have to explain
- 14:03to your children why they can't see
- 14:04their grandmother because I stopped
- 14:06paying for the cable.
- 14:09That's a reflection on the two of you,
- 14:10Shane.
- 14:11Not on me.
- 14:13We just think it's best, he mumbled,
- 14:15until you fix this.
- 14:18Good afternoon, Shane.
- 14:20I went inside, locked the door, and
- 14:22leaned against it. Then I let myself cry
- 14:26for a few minutes, quietly, with my hand
- 14:28over my mouth.
- 14:30I prepared myself for a long winter
- 14:32without them. What I didn't count on was
- 14:35a nine-year-old with a stubborn streak.
- 14:38That night my phone buzzed with a text
- 14:40from Shane's number,
- 14:42but it wasn't Shane.
- 14:44Hi Grandma, it's Hudson. I'm using Dad's
- 14:46phone while he's in the shower. Mom is
- 14:49yelling about candles and Dad keeps
- 14:51saying he's stressed. Can I still come
- 14:54Sunday?
- 14:55I want to make the pie with you.
- 14:57I wiped my eyes and typed back. Always,
- 15:00sweetheart. Ask your dad. If he says no,
- 15:03I will still love you exactly the same.
- 15:06Sunday afternoon, I baked anyway, a
- 15:09peach pie out of habit, not knowing if
- 15:12anyone would come. At 5:55,
- 15:16a minivan I didn't recognize pulled into
- 15:18the driveway. A woman stepped out of the
- 15:20driver's seat and opened the back door.
- 15:23I recognized her after a second, Rita
- 15:26Reyes, Hudson's best friend's mother,
- 15:29from the baseball team.
- 15:31Hudson hopped out with his backpack, and
- 15:33behind him came Ruby, clutching a
- 15:35stuffed rabbit. Rita
- 15:38walked them up the path herself.
- 15:40Joyce, I hope this is all right, she
- 15:43said quietly. Hudson called me and asked
- 15:46if I'd bring them. He said he had a plan
- 15:49and he didn't want to cause a fight.
- 15:51I'll pick them up at 8:00.
- 15:54Does Shane know?
- 15:56Shane's working a double. Haley's at her
- 15:58mother's. Rita hesitated. Hudson's a
- 16:01smart kid. He heard a lot he wasn't
- 16:04supposed to.
- 16:05The children came in and I felt
- 16:07something loosen in my chest.
- 16:10I hadn't known was clenched.
- 16:12We rolled out dough, though we ended up
- 16:15using the one I'd already made.
- 16:17Ruby stuck her fingers in the peaches.
- 16:20Hudson, who had always been serious,
- 16:23waited until we were pressing the
- 16:24lattice before he said anything.
- 16:27Grandma, mom says you're being mean
- 16:30about the money.
- 16:31I kept my hands moving. What do you
- 16:34think?
- 16:35I think mom has too many things.
- 16:38He crimped the crust with a fork.
- 16:41I heard dad say they might not make the
- 16:43SUV payment, and mom said you should
- 16:45just cover it. And dad said it wasn't
- 16:48fair to keep asking you. And then mom
- 16:50said a word I'm not allowed to say.
- 16:53Hudson,
- 16:55I'm just telling you what happened.
- 16:57He looked up at me with Roy's eyes,
- 16:59honest as a clean window.
- 17:02You've never been mean to me. I don't
- 17:04want to stop coming here, even if mom is
- 17:06mad.
- 17:08I put my arm around his shoulders and
- 17:10kissed the top of his head. And I didn't
- 17:13trust myself to speak for a moment.
- 17:16At 7:15, the doorbell rang hard.
- 17:20On the camera, I saw Shane alone on the
- 17:22porch, still in his work boots,
- 17:25shoulders hunched, looking like a man
- 17:27who'd been wrung out. I told the kids to
- 17:30eat their pie and went out, pulling the
- 17:32door shut behind me.
- 17:34Rita told you, I said.
- 17:37Hudson left a note on the fridge. He
- 17:39rubbed his face. Mom, I need help.
- 17:42I crossed my arms against the evening
- 17:44chill.
- 17:45They're going to repossess the SUV
- 17:48Tuesday, and the electric company says
- 17:51they'll shut us off Friday.
- 17:53We're three months behind on the
- 17:55electric bill.
- 17:56His voice dropped. Haley put the utility
- 17:59money into a branding package for the
- 18:01candles.
- 18:03She said it would pay for itself.
- 18:05You both have jobs, Shane.
- 18:08It's a cash flow thing. I just need a
- 18:10loan, 1,500, and I'll pay you back on
- 18:13the first.
- 18:15I reached into my cardigan pocket.
- 18:18I had been carrying that folded page for
- 18:20a week.
- 18:21What's this?
- 18:23A ledger,
- 18:2416 payments, the monthly cost beside
- 18:27each one, and at the bottom,
- 18:30what I've spent covering your cash flow
- 18:32over the last 36 months.
- 18:34He read it under the porch light, and I
- 18:37watched the color leave his face as he
- 18:40reached the bottom line.
- 18:42$71,280.
- 18:46I didn't know, he whispered.
- 18:48I know you didn't. You never had to. I
- 18:52said it gently, but I didn't soften it.
- 18:55You sat at the table my husband and I
- 18:57paid for, and you saw a down payment.
- 19:00You told me I was living too large while
- 19:02I was financing every inch of your
- 19:04lifestyle.
- 19:06Mom, please, just the electric bill.
- 19:09No.
- 19:10The words sat there between us on the
- 19:13porch.
- 19:14You're going to let your grandkids sit
- 19:17in the dark?
- 19:18They're in my house eating pie with the
- 19:21lights on, I said. You have a kayak, a
- 19:24drum kit, and a wife with a closet full
- 19:26of retail. You'll figure it out. You
- 19:29have to.
- 19:30I turned for the door.
- 19:32Mom.
- 19:33His voice cracked on it. Haley's mother
- 19:36is telling her to leave. She says I'm
- 19:38not providing.
- 19:39I looked back. That sounds like a
- 19:42conversation for the three of you. The
- 19:44bank of mom is closed, Shane,
- 19:47permanently. But your children are
- 19:49welcome here whenever you decide to let
- 19:52them come.
- 19:53I locked the deadbolt, and the sound
- 19:56carried through the whole house.
- 19:59The repossession happened on Tuesday,
- 20:01and I didn't have to hear about it from
- 20:03anyone
- 20:04because Haley
- 20:06brought it to my door herself.
- 20:09At 7:20 that morning, the doorbell
- 20:11camera lit up.
- 20:13Haley stood on my porch in her bathrobe
- 20:16and a pair of rain boots, mascara down
- 20:18her cheeks with Gail behind her, holding
- 20:21a purse like a shield.
- 20:24Gail Sedan was still idling at the curb,
- 20:27and across the street, I could see my
- 20:29neighbor's blinds twitching from my own
- 20:31window.
- 20:32I opened the door to the length of the
- 20:34chain.
- 20:36They took the Tahoe, Haley said,
- 20:38with Ruby's booster seat still in it.
- 20:41Do you understand what you've done?
- 20:44I understand what I stopped doing, I
- 20:46said.
- 20:47You could fix this with one phone call.
- 20:50Her voice cracked and climbed.
- 20:53One call, Joyce. It's a car payment.
- 20:56You have Roy's life insurance sitting in
- 20:58an account doing nothing.
- 21:00I hadn't told her about Roy's life
- 21:02insurance.
- 21:04I had never once discussed it at that
- 21:06table. I looked past her at Gail, who
- 21:09suddenly became very interested in the
- 21:11maple tree.
- 21:13Gail, I said, did you tell her what's in
- 21:15my accounts?
- 21:17I only said a woman your age ought to be
- 21:19sensible, Gail snapped.
- 21:21Family helps family. Haley needs a
- 21:24vehicle to run her business.
- 21:26Your car insurance was my card for three
- 21:28years,
- 21:30I said. I never once heard her thank
- 21:32you.
- 21:33I heard that I should be ashamed.
- 21:35Gail's mouth tightened. That was a
- 21:38courtesy between relatives.
- 21:41It was a gift, and it's over.
- 21:43Haley turned on her mother then, the way
- 21:46a person does when the real culprit
- 21:48finally steps into the light. Mom, you
- 21:51told me she'd cave. You said if we
- 21:54pushed about the house, she'd sell in a
- 21:56month. You said she'd never really cut
- 21:59us off.
- 22:00Don't you put this on me,
- 22:02Gail said. And just like that, they were
- 22:05fighting on my porch in full view of
- 22:08Mrs. Pruitt, who had come out in her
- 22:10slippers to get her newspaper and had no
- 22:12intention of going back inside.
- 22:15Gail told Haley that she'd married a man
- 22:17with no backbone. Haley told Gail that
- 22:21she was the one who'd said they deserved
- 22:23Dublin.
- 22:25Gail said she refused to dragged down by
- 22:27a household that couldn't keep its
- 22:29lights on, and she marched down my walk,
- 22:33got into her sedan and drove off without
- 22:35her daughter.
- 22:37Haley stood there in her bathrobe with
- 22:39her arms hanging.
- 22:41Nobody to shout at but me.
- 22:43I'm not going to bail you out, Haley, I
- 22:46said quietly. I'll tell you what I will
- 22:48do. I'll love your children.
- 22:51I'll feed them pie.
- 22:53And when you can speak to me without a
- 22:55price attached, I'll listen.
- 22:57She didn't answer. She walked down to
- 23:00the corner in rain boots and a robe,
- 23:03pulling out her phone to call for a
- 23:04ride.
- 23:06The house in Dublin never happened, of
- 23:08course.
- 23:09The one they were living in was a
- 23:11stretch even with my money, and without
- 23:14it, they listed it within the month.
- 23:17There was a sign in the yard by
- 23:19Halloween.
- 23:20They sold it for barely enough to clear
- 23:22the mortgage and moved into a
- 23:24two-bedroom rental near Shane's work.
- 23:27Haley took a job at the front desk of a
- 23:30dental office.
- 23:31Shane sold the golf clubs, the drum kit,
- 23:34and the kayak. He also sold the truck
- 23:37and refinanced what was left, so my name
- 23:40came off that loan for good. The candles
- 23:42went into a clearance bin, and Haley
- 23:45sold the last of them herself at a table
- 23:48outside a craft fair for a dollar a jar.
- 23:52I didn't gloat. It's hard to enjoy
- 23:54watching your child learn at 36 what he
- 23:57should have learned at 22.
- 24:00But I didn't rescue them, and that was
- 24:02the hardest part.
- 24:04Meanwhile, my house got bigger in the
- 24:06best way.
- 24:08I had a contractor repaint the spare
- 24:10room a soft sage green, moved Roy's
- 24:14sewing cabinet back to where it belonged
- 24:16and turned it into a reading room with
- 24:18two armchairs and a view of the maple.
- 24:21I joined a garden club at church. I
- 24:24stopped flinching when my phone rang. I
- 24:27learned that the quiet in my house
- 24:28wasn't loneliness.
- 24:30Most days it was just peace.
- 24:338 weeks after the night, I canceled
- 24:35everything. I was kneeling in the front
- 24:38bed planting tulip bulbs when a shadow
- 24:41fell across the dirt. Shane stood on the
- 24:44sidewalk in a plain gray jacket holding
- 24:46two paper cups of coffee. He looked
- 24:49thinner and oddly steadier.
- 24:52Black no sugar, he said.
- 24:55Right. I took it. Thank you.
- 24:58I bought an old Honda with cash. We're
- 25:00in the rental and Haley's working.
- 25:03We canceled Christmas in Florida and she
- 25:06cried about it for a day.
- 25:08He swallowed, but it's the first time in
- 25:10years I've known what we have
- 25:13down to the dollar.
- 25:15Then he reached into his jacket and held
- 25:17out an envelope. Inside were three $50
- 25:21bills and a sheet of paper in his
- 25:23handwriting.
- 25:25It's not alone, he said. It's what I
- 25:28owe. 71,280.
- 25:31I wrote it out at 150 a month. It'll
- 25:34take me 40 years. I'm going to start
- 25:37anyway.
- 25:38I could have refused it.
- 25:40Roy would have said the money wasn't the
- 25:42point, but I understood that for Shane
- 25:45the money was exactly the point.
- 25:47So I folded the page, slipped it into my
- 25:50cardigan pocket and said,
- 25:52Thank you.
- 25:54I'm sorry, mom. I treated you like an
- 25:56ATM with a pulse. I said you were living
- 26:00too large when you'd been holding up my
- 26:02whole life. I never once asked how you
- 26:04were doing without dad.
- 26:07I didn't rush to comfort him. He needed
- 26:09to hold it for a while the way I'd held
- 26:12it.
- 26:13It hurt, Shane, I said, hearing my own
- 26:16son decide that my home was something to
- 26:18be liquidated for his convenience. But
- 26:21I'm asking you now.
- 26:23Sunday dinner is at 6:00. Haley is
- 26:26welcome if she can be kind. The minute
- 26:28my money, my house, or my choices come
- 26:31up at that table. Dinner is over and you
- 26:33walk yourselves out.
- 26:35Understood, he said, completely.
- 26:39Haley came the following Sunday.
- 26:41She stood in my doorway holding a
- 26:43store-bought pie and said,
- 26:45Joyce, I'm sorry.
- 26:48Her voice was small and a little stiff,
- 26:50but she said it without a single excuse.
- 26:52It wasn't warm yet, but it was a start.
- 26:55I took the pie and said, Come in, Haley.
- 26:57The roast is almost ready.
- 26:59Gail did not come and nobody asked after
- 27:02her.
- 27:03That evening, after the dishes were done
- 27:06and the children had been driven home,
- 27:08I sat at Roy's desk with the green lamp
- 27:11on.
- 27:12I wasn't looking at a single bill. I
- 27:14opened a travel site and picked out a
- 27:17two-week trip to the Scottish Highlands,
- 27:20the one Roy and I had always promised
- 27:22ourselves and kept putting off for
- 27:25something more practical.
- 27:27I chose the good tour with the private
- 27:29rooms and the castle stay and I clicked
- 27:32Book Now.
- 27:34You don't have to burn yourself down to
- 27:35keep other people warm.
- 27:37You're allowed to keep your home, your
- 27:40peace, and your own monies.
- 27:42And sometimes the most loving thing
- 27:45you can do for someone is to lock the
- 27:48door and let them learn to stand.
- 27:50My name is Joyce Matthews. I'm 63 years
- 27:54old and I am finally living exactly as
- 27:56large as I choose.
- 27:58Helping our children is something most
- 28:01parents do out of love and it can be
- 28:03hard to see where helping ends.
- 28:07Have you ever helped your grown children
- 28:09with money and started to feel more like
- 28:12a bank than a parent?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Daughter-in-Law Said I Was "Living Too Large" So I Canceled 16 Payments And Watched Her by Core Tales, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,313 words across 701 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.