YouTube2Text

My Daughter-in-Law Demanded I Sign Away My Grandkids' Trust - So I Called My Lawyer and Froze Eve... — Transcript

by Silent Mother Stories · 4,616 words · 648 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I was standing at my kitchen sink
  2. 0:02rinsing a casserole dish when my
  3. 0:04daughter-in-law walked in without
  4. 0:06knocking, set her purse on my counter
  5. 0:08like she lived there, and said, "I need
  6. 0:10you to sign something." I turned off the
  7. 0:12tap. The look on her face told me it
  8. 0:15wasn't a request. She laid a document on
  9. 0:17the table, four pages stapled at the
  10. 0:19corner with the letterhead of a real
  11. 0:21estate brokerage in Burlington. It was a
  12. 0:23consent and release of funds. My name
  13. 0:26was typed at the top, Joyce Robinson,
  14. 0:28and under it was a line waiting for my
  15. 0:30signature. I dried my hands on the dish
  16. 0:33towel. I read the first paragraph
  17. 0:34standing up. Then I told her I'd look it
  18. 0:37over and let her know. Kimberly said it
  19. 0:39was just a formality and that the offer
  20. 0:41closed Friday. I said Friday was fine,
  21. 0:43and I asked if she wanted tea. She said
  22. 0:46no. She was in a hurry. When her car
  23. 0:48left the driveway, I took my phone out
  24. 0:50to the back porch and called the one man
  25. 0:52who had helped me set up my
  26. 0:53grandchildren's trusts. 3 months
  27. 0:55earlier. Gregory, I said quietly, I need
  28. 0:59you to do something this afternoon. 3
  29. 1:02days later, my daughter-in-law walked
  30. 1:03into our family's bank branch on Gordon
  31. 1:05Street and asked to access money held in
  32. 1:07trust for my grandchildren. The teller
  33. 1:10looked at her screen, looked at
  34. 1:11Kimberly, and said the accounts could
  35. 1:13not be accessed. Kimberly asked for a
  36. 1:16manager. The manager said the same
  37. 1:18thing, more slowly. I wasn't there. I
  38. 1:20didn't need to be. Before I go any
  39. 1:23further, tell me the town you're
  40. 1:24listening from. It means a lot to me. My
  41. 1:27name is Joyce Robinson. I'm 68 years old
  42. 1:30and I live in GE, Ontario, in the same
  43. 1:33brick house where I raised two children.
  44. 1:35I grew up in Sudbury, the daughter of a
  45. 1:37nurse and a man who drove a bus for the
  46. 1:39city for 31 years and never missed a
  47. 1:41shift. I became a nurse myself and then
  48. 1:44a nurse manager at the General Hospital
  49. 1:46and I stayed there for 34 years. I
  50. 1:49married Roy when I was 25. He was an
  51. 1:52engineer with Ontario Hydro and later
  52. 1:54with the successor companies, and he was
  53. 1:56the sort of man who labeled the jars in
  54. 1:58his workshop. Between his pension and
  55. 2:00mine and the RSPS we filled year after
  56. 2:03year without fanfare and the TFSAs and
  57. 2:05the house that was paid off long before
  58. 2:07we retired, we built something solid.
  59. 2:10When Roy died, I had a little over $2
  60. 2:12million. All of it left to me with no
  61. 2:14conditions. He trusted me to know what
  62. 2:16to do with it. The first year after he
  63. 2:19died, I only survived. I kept his
  64. 2:21reading glasses on the kitchen table for
  65. 2:238 months. I think I couldn't stand the
  66. 2:26way the table looked without them. My
  67. 2:28son David was 30. He drove in from
  68. 2:30Burlington every second Saturday that
  69. 2:32first year. He helped me clear out
  70. 2:34Royy's workshop and sat beside me at the
  71. 2:36lawyer's office when the paperwork felt
  72. 2:38like drowning. I thought I knew my son.
  73. 2:41I thought I knew exactly who he was. His
  74. 2:44wife, Kimberly, was polite at the
  75. 2:45funeral. She wore a plain navy dress and
  76. 2:48kept topping up people's coffee in the
  77. 2:50church hall. She told me twice that
  78. 2:52David was lucky to have had a father
  79. 2:54like Roy. I thanked her both times and
  80. 2:56meant it both times. My daughter Shannon
  81. 2:59lives in Calgary. She flew in for the
  82. 3:01funeral and stayed 2 weeks. On her last
  83. 3:04night, she sat across from me at the
  84. 3:06kitchen table and said something I
  85. 3:07didn't fully hear at the time. Mom, I'm
  86. 3:10a little worried about Kimberly. I
  87. 3:12looked up. She's been asking David a lot
  88. 3:14of questions about the estate. I told
  89. 3:16her she was imagining things. David was
  90. 3:18my son. I would have known. What I
  91. 3:21didn't know then was that Kimberly had
  92. 3:23already looked up what Royy's accounts
  93. 3:24were worth. David told me that himself
  94. 3:27much later at a different kitchen table.
  95. 3:306 months after the funeral, David and
  96. 3:32Kimberly came for supper. I made a
  97. 3:34roast. I bought the red wine David
  98. 3:37liked. Halfway through the meal, David
  99. 3:39said Kimberly had been offered a
  100. 3:41position at a marketing firm in
  101. 3:43Hamilton, but they wanted to buy in a
  102. 3:45better school catchment before they
  103. 3:47started a family. His voice had a
  104. 3:48careful sound like someone reading from
  105. 3:50a card. I asked what they were looking
  106. 3:52at. He said around 700,000
  107. 3:56in Burlington. That wasn't a surprise.
  108. 3:58Then he said, "We were hoping you might
  109. 4:00help with the down payment. 85,000."
  110. 4:03I looked at him. Kimberly smiled and
  111. 4:06said, "We'd pay you back, Joyce. just a
  112. 4:08loan between family. I said yes. I told
  113. 4:11myself it was an investment in their
  114. 4:12future. I told myself Roy would have
  115. 4:15done the same. I sent the money by bank
  116. 4:17transfer within the week. They never
  117. 4:19paid back a dollar and I never asked.
  118. 4:22That was my first mistake. 2 years
  119. 4:24later, my grandson Asher was born. I
  120. 4:27drove to the hospital in the middle of
  121. 4:28the night on the 403 with the wipers
  122. 4:31going. When the nurse put him in my
  123. 4:33arms, I couldn't speak for almost a
  124. 4:35minute. He had David's dark eyes and a
  125. 4:37tiny crease between his brows. That was
  126. 4:39Royy's. Exactly. I thought you are why
  127. 4:41all of it matters. Every long shift,
  128. 4:44every sacrifice, every check to the RSP.
  129. 4:46You are the point. The requests came in
  130. 4:49waves after that. When Kimberly decided
  131. 4:51not to go back to work full-time after
  132. 4:53Asher, she said, "It'll be tight,
  133. 4:55though. You understand?" Those words had
  134. 4:58a weight I didn't recognize until much
  135. 5:00later. I paid the nanny share for 2
  136. 5:02years. I paid for a minivan when their
  137. 5:04car got too small. I replaced a furnace
  138. 5:06in January. I covered the dental bill
  139. 5:09that their plan only half covered and a
  140. 5:11flooded basement. And a week at a
  141. 5:13lakeside resort in Muscoa when
  142. 5:15Kimberly's mother turned 70. When their
  143. 5:17daughter Violet came along, 18 months
  144. 5:20after Asher, the requests came faster. I
  145. 5:23gave every time I gave, I told myself
  146. 5:25that's what family does. But something
  147. 5:27shifted in how Kimberly asked. In the
  148. 5:30early days, she looked uncomfortable,
  149. 5:31even apologetic. Over time, the
  150. 5:34discomfort wore off, like a coat she no
  151. 5:36longer needed. By the time Asher was
  152. 5:38six, she didn't ask at all. She
  153. 5:40described a problem, paused, and looked
  154. 5:42at me with an expectation I had somehow
  155. 5:45taught her to have. One Sunday, she sat
  156. 5:47at my kitchen table, scrolling on her
  157. 5:49tablet. She turned the screen toward me.
  158. 5:52A brick house with a wide front porch, a
  159. 5:54big yard on a street in Oakville I knew
  160. 5:56was expensive. This is the one, she
  161. 5:58said. Four bedrooms, great schools. The
  162. 6:01listing price was $1,100,000.
  163. 6:04We're preapproved, but we'd need a
  164. 6:06significant gift toward closing. I asked
  165. 6:09what she meant by significant. She said
  166. 6:11$250,000 would cover it comfortably. She
  167. 6:15said it the way you'd ask somebody to
  168. 6:17pass the salt. I didn't answer right
  169. 6:19away. That evening, I sat in Royy's
  170. 6:21armchair for a long time and thought
  171. 6:23about what he said to me the week before
  172. 6:25he died when his head was clear and the
  173. 6:27room was quiet. The money's a tool,
  174. 6:29Joyce. Don't let anyone turn it into an
  175. 6:32entitlement. At the time, I thought he
  176. 6:34meant strangers. I understand now he was
  177. 6:37telling me something specific. The next
  178. 6:39week, I called Gregory Walker, the
  179. 6:41lawyer who had helped me settle Royy's
  180. 6:43affairs. I told him I wanted irrevocable
  181. 6:45trusts for Asher and Violet, one each,
  182. 6:48for education, medical needs, and a
  183. 6:50first home when they came of age. A
  184. 6:52trust company would act as co-rustee
  185. 6:54alongside Sside Me. Gregory said it was
  186. 6:56a sound plan. When both were funded,
  187. 6:58they held just over $900,000
  188. 7:01between them, beyond the reach of
  189. 7:03creditors, of divorce, and most
  190. 7:05importantly, of their parents. The terms
  191. 7:08were plain. Nobody could touch that
  192. 7:10money without my signature and the trust
  193. 7:12companies and a documented purpose.
  194. 7:14David called on a Tuesday evening, his
  195. 7:16voice flat. Mom, why didn't you tell us?
  196. 7:19I said I'd done it for the children, he
  197. 7:21said. But we're their parents. I said,
  198. 7:23yes, and I'm their grandmother and the
  199. 7:24money is for them. He was quiet.
  200. 7:27Kimberly is upset. I said I understood.
  201. 7:29He hung up. For 3 months, things were
  202. 7:32cold. Visits got shorter. David texted
  203. 7:35instead of calling. Kimberly was polite
  204. 7:38in that hollow, deliberate way people
  205. 7:39are when they're furious and trying not
  206. 7:42to show it. The children knew nothing.
  207. 7:44They still ran to me with drawings and
  208. 7:46questions about dinosaurs and asked for
  209. 7:48the same picture book seven times in a
  210. 7:51row. That part stayed the same. Then
  211. 7:53came Violet's fifth birthday party. It
  212. 7:56was a Saturday in June in their backyard
  213. 7:58with paper streamers, a sprinkler going
  214. 8:01in the corner, and a homemade cake
  215. 8:02leaning slightly to one side. Violet
  216. 8:05wore a purple dress and refused to eat
  217. 8:07anything that wasn't icing. I'd brought
  218. 8:09her a butterfly garden kit because she
  219. 8:11had told me three times that she wanted
  220. 8:13to watch a caterpillar turn into
  221. 8:15something. She hugged me around the
  222. 8:17knees and said, "Grandma, you brought me
  223. 8:20the exact right thing." I knelt and held
  224. 8:23her small face in my hands. "Of course I
  225. 8:25did," I said. "I always pay attention."
  226. 8:2820 minutes later, Kimberly found me by
  227. 8:30the drinks table. Her voice was soft and
  228. 8:32very controlled. Joyce, I need to say
  229. 8:35something. She said I'd been inserting
  230. 8:37myself into their family for years. She
  231. 8:40said the trusts and the way I went
  232. 8:42around David to make decisions about the
  233. 8:43children had to stop. I told her those
  234. 8:46decisions were mine to make. She said
  235. 8:48the trusts were just a way of
  236. 8:49controlling them. I said they were a way
  237. 8:52of protecting Asher and Violet. Her eyes
  238. 8:54narrowed. You need to understand that
  239. 8:56David and I are their parents, not you.
  240. 8:59I understand that completely. Then act
  241. 9:02like it. She stepped closer, and if you
  242. 9:05can't respect our boundaries, we need
  243. 9:07some distance. Behind her, Asher was
  244. 9:09chasing a balloon that had slipped its
  245. 9:11ribbon. Violet was laughing at something
  246. 9:13her cousin said. "Neither child was
  247. 9:16watching. I said I wasn't going to
  248. 9:18discuss this here," she said. "Then
  249. 9:20we're done discussing it and walked
  250. 9:22away." I stayed another 30 minutes
  251. 9:24because I was not going to let her drive
  252. 9:26me out of my granddaughter's birthday.
  253. 9:28Then I said quiet goodbyes, kissed the
  254. 9:31top of Violet's head while she was bent
  255. 9:33over her butterfly kit and walked to my
  256. 9:35car. My hands were shaking. I sat at the
  257. 9:38end of their street for several minutes
  258. 9:40before I could drive. Then I called
  259. 9:42Gregory and told him everything. He
  260. 9:44listened without a word. When I
  261. 9:46finished, he said, "Joyce, I'd like to
  262. 9:49review the trust documents with you this
  263. 9:51week. There are some protections we
  264. 9:52might layer in." I asked why. he said
  265. 9:55carefully. I've had two calls from David
  266. 9:58in the past month. He asked
  267. 10:00hypothetically whether parents can apply
  268. 10:02for access to funds held in trust for
  269. 10:04their minor children. I closed my eyes.
  270. 10:08Joyce, Gregory said, that wasn't a
  271. 10:10hypothetical question, which brings me
  272. 10:12back to the kitchen sink and the
  273. 10:14document with my name typed on it. I had
  274. 10:17read it properly after Kimberly left. It
  275. 10:19was a consent releasing funds from the
  276. 10:21children's accounts toward the purchase
  277. 10:23of a property on a street in Oakville
  278. 10:26with a deposit due Friday. She had
  279. 10:28already written an offer on the house.
  280. 10:30She had told the agent a gift was
  281. 10:32coming. There was even a gift letter in
  282. 10:34the package on what looked like my own
  283. 10:36stationary with a signature that was a
  284. 10:38good attempt at mine. I know my own
  285. 10:40hand. The loop of the J was wrong. I did
  286. 10:43not sign. I called Gregory from the
  287. 10:46porch and he did what a good lawyer
  288. 10:48does, which is act first and talk
  289. 10:49afterward. By that evening, both
  290. 10:52accounts were frozen to everyone but the
  291. 10:53trustees. He wrote to the bank and to
  292. 10:55the trust company, and he put a note on
  293. 10:57the file that no one but me in person
  294. 11:00with identification could so much as a
  295. 11:02question. 3 days later, Kimberly walked
  296. 11:05into the branch with her letter and her
  297. 11:07purse and her certainty. Gregory phoned
  298. 11:10me that afternoon, his voice more
  299. 11:11measured than usual. She came in to
  300. 11:14withdraw from Asher's account. She said
  301. 11:16she was his mother and had parental
  302. 11:18authority over his assets. She presented
  303. 11:20a letter purporting to be from you. I
  304. 11:23gripped the phone. She has no power of
  305. 11:25attorney, no court order, no trustee
  306. 11:28authority. The manager declined and she
  307. 11:30became very loud. She said the bank was
  308. 11:32protecting a stubborn old woman over the
  309. 11:34children's own parents. What does she
  310. 11:37think those accounts are? I asked. I
  311. 11:40think, Gregory said. She has always
  312. 11:42thought of them as hers. That night, I
  313. 11:44didn't sleep. I lay in the dark and
  314. 11:46thought about all the money I had given
  315. 11:48without a single piece of paper. The
  316. 11:5085,000 I'd called alone. The nanny
  317. 11:53share, the minivan, the furnace, the
  318. 11:55dentist, the resort in Mskoka. I had
  319. 11:58given because I loved them and because
  320. 12:00it felt like generosity. But in the
  321. 12:02dark, I could see what I'd really been
  322. 12:04doing. I'd been funding a version of my
  323. 12:06family that stood on my yes. Every yes
  324. 12:08made the next request easier. Every yes
  325. 12:11moved the line a little further. In the
  326. 12:14morning, I told Gregory to add every
  327. 12:15layer of protection he could think of
  328. 12:17and to move quickly. Then I asked him
  329. 12:19something else. Those transfers, I said.
  330. 12:22The 85,000. Do I still have the records?
  331. 12:25He said the bank would have everyone. I
  332. 12:28said, "Then pull them. All of them."
  333. 12:30David came alone 10 days later. He
  334. 12:32knocked this time. He had aged in a way
  335. 12:35I hadn't noticed until I saw him on my
  336. 12:37porch in the plain light of a Tuesday
  337. 12:39evening. He sat at the kitchen table
  338. 12:41with a mug of coffee he never drank and
  339. 12:43stared at the wood for a long time. Mom,
  340. 12:46things at home are bad. I waited.
  341. 12:49Kimberly's furious about the bank. She
  342. 12:52keeps saying you turned everyone against
  343. 12:53her. I haven't spoken to anyone about
  344. 12:56this. I know. He looked up. That's what
  345. 12:59I told her. His voice caught on the last
  346. 13:01word. She didn't believe me. He looked
  347. 13:04so tired that it hurt to see. He told me
  348. 13:06about the gift letter. He had known
  349. 13:08about the offer, he said. He hadn't
  350. 13:10known about the signature until the bank
  351. 13:12called. I asked him quietly, "David, why
  352. 13:15do you keep telling her yes?" He pressed
  353. 13:18his lips together. "Because it's
  354. 13:19easier." "What does your life look like
  355. 13:22in 10 years if you keep taking the
  356. 13:24easiest path?" "I don't know," he said.
  357. 13:27"I think that's the problem." We talked
  358. 13:29for almost 3 hours and hardly about
  359. 13:31money. We talked about his father and
  360. 13:34what Roy had built and why and what
  361. 13:36David was afraid of. Somewhere in the
  362. 13:39second hour, he laid his head down on
  363. 13:40his folded arms on my table the way he
  364. 13:42used to when he was eight and
  365. 13:44overwhelmed. I put my hand on his back.
  366. 13:46You're a good man, I said. You've been
  367. 13:49making bad choices because someone in
  368. 13:51your house is very good at making them
  369. 13:52feel necessary. He sat up, his eyes
  370. 13:55read. She's my wife, Mom. I know. You
  371. 13:58promised to take care of her. Yes. You
  372. 14:01also promised to take care of your
  373. 14:03children. Those are not the same
  374. 14:04promise. He sat with that for a long
  375. 14:07time. Two weeks later, Kimberly phoned
  376. 14:09me. It was not the soft voice I'd grown
  377. 14:12used to. It was cold and exact. She told
  378. 14:15me they were going ahead without my
  379. 14:17involvement. She said they'd found other
  380. 14:19financing and that the children did not
  381. 14:21need to see me every week. I thought you
  382. 14:23should know your stubbornness has
  383. 14:25consequences.
  384. 14:27I understand, I said. She hung up. I sat
  385. 14:31in my living room for a long while
  386. 14:32afterward, and the house was very quiet.
  387. 14:35I thought about Asher asking me last
  388. 14:37month whether butterflies remember being
  389. 14:39caterpillars. I thought about Violet
  390. 14:42insisting we read the same chapter four
  391. 14:44nights running because she loved the
  392. 14:46part where the dog came home. What it
  393. 14:48would mean to not see them, even for a
  394. 14:50while, hurt in a way I hadn't expected.
  395. 14:52Not sharp, steady, like a bruise you
  396. 14:55keep pressing without meaning to. But I
  397. 14:57thought about Roy, too. He used to say,
  398. 14:59"The hardest decisions feel wrong the
  399. 15:01day you make them and right every year
  400. 15:03after." I thought he meant business. He
  401. 15:06meant life. Here is what happened with
  402. 15:08the house, because people always ask.
  403. 15:11Kimberly had signed an offer on the
  404. 15:12strength of money she had no right to
  405. 15:14promise. Her agent had told the sellers
  406. 15:16a gift was on the way. When it didn't
  407. 15:19arrive, she couldn't close, and the
  408. 15:21deposit she'd put down from a line of
  409. 15:23credit in her own name, $42,000,
  410. 15:26was forfeited. The lender who had
  411. 15:28preapproved them took a second look at
  412. 15:30the gift letter and the file went to
  413. 15:32their fraud department. They never told
  414. 15:34us what came of it. They didn't need to.
  415. 15:36The preapproval was withdrawn. In
  416. 15:39September, David called on a Sunday
  417. 15:40evening. Something in his voice had
  418. 15:42changed, like a rope that had been
  419. 15:44pulled tight for years and was finally
  420. 15:46beginning to slacken. Mom, Kimberly and
  421. 15:49I are separating. I said nothing for a
  422. 15:52moment. I'm sorry, David. Are you? He
  423. 15:54wasn't angry, just honest. I took the
  424. 15:57question seriously. I'm sorry you're in
  425. 15:59pain. I'm not sorry you're making a
  426. 16:01clear decision. He was quiet. She told
  427. 16:04her lawyer you manipulated me, that you
  428. 16:07used the trust as leverage. What do you
  429. 16:09believe? A long silence. I believe I
  430. 16:12spent 9 years keeping the peace, he said
  431. 16:15finally. And forgot peace isn't the same
  432. 16:17thing as quiet. I pressed my hand over
  433. 16:19my eyes. Your father said something like
  434. 16:22that once. I know. I found it in one of
  435. 16:25his old notebooks.
  436. 16:26The separation was hard. Kimberly's
  437. 16:29lawyer tried twice to bring the trust
  438. 16:30accounts into the financial disclosure.
  439. 16:33Gregory shut both attempts down. The
  440. 16:35trusts weren't family property. They had
  441. 16:38never been family property. They
  442. 16:40belonged to Asher and Violet, and the
  443. 16:41documents said so clearly and without
  444. 16:44room for argument, because that was
  445. 16:46exactly what I'd meant. David was
  446. 16:48granted shared parenting time, which was
  447. 16:50fair. The children would spend equal
  448. 16:52weeks in both homes. Then came the part
  449. 16:55I had not expected to be involved in.
  450. 16:57Kimberly's lawyer, a sharp woman named
  451. 17:00Pierce, argued that the money I'd given
  452. 17:02over the years was a series of gifts to
  453. 17:04the family, and therefore part of what
  454. 17:06the two of them had built together.
  455. 17:08Gregory had the transfer history. He had
  456. 17:11the dates. He had the text messages,
  457. 17:13which I had never deleted, in which
  458. 17:15Kimberly wrote things like, "You'll be
  459. 17:17paid back, Joyce. I promise." And just
  460. 17:19until we're settled. The 85,000 had been
  461. 17:23described in writing as a loan by the
  462. 17:25very person now saying it was not. We
  463. 17:28sat in a mediation room with gray carpet
  464. 17:29and a box of tissues in the center of
  465. 17:31the table that nobody touched. Kimberly
  466. 17:34sat across from me with her arms folded.
  467. 17:36I realized I hadn't been this close to
  468. 17:38her since the afternoon in my kitchen.
  469. 17:41She looked smaller. She looked worn
  470. 17:43through. The mediator, a calm man in his
  471. 17:4660s, read through the records and then
  472. 17:48said plainly that the loan was
  473. 17:50documented and the repayment owing was
  474. 17:52hers and David's jointly with Kimberly's
  475. 17:55share to be paid from her portion of the
  476. 17:57sale of their home. The forfeited
  477. 17:59deposit was hers alone, and the gift
  478. 18:01letter, he said, was a matter on which
  479. 18:03he would advise her lawyer to counsel
  480. 18:05her very carefully, because I had the
  481. 18:08right to take it elsewhere. Gregory slid
  482. 18:10a single sheet across the table toward
  483. 18:12Kimberly, a repayment agreement.
  484. 18:15Principal schedule, interest at the rate
  485. 18:17the bank would have charged, a line at
  486. 18:19the bottom for her signature. She looked
  487. 18:21at it. I watched her read. I watched her
  488. 18:24understand that the same pen that had
  489. 18:26hovered above my name would now be asked
  490. 18:28to sign hers. She looked up at me, and
  491. 18:31for the first time in 9 years, there was
  492. 18:33nothing careful in her face at all. I
  493. 18:36don't have a job, she said. I know, I
  494. 18:38said. I think it's high time you did.
  495. 18:41She signed. Her hand was steady. I'll
  496. 18:43give her that. Before the mediator could
  497. 18:46close his folder, Gregory said there was
  498. 18:48one more matter and that Kimberly's
  499. 18:50lawyer should hear it from him directly.
  500. 18:53Two weeks earlier, I had given a
  501. 18:54statement to the police about the gift
  502. 18:56letter. The bank on Gordon Street had
  503. 18:58given theirs about the withdrawal. The
  504. 19:00lender's fraud department had sent over
  505. 19:02its file as well. Kimberly's head came
  506. 19:05up. You went to the police. You put my
  507. 19:08name on a letter. I said the loop of the
  508. 19:10Jay was wrong. It was paper, Joyce. It
  509. 19:13was going to be paid back. That's what
  510. 19:15you told me. About $85,000.
  511. 19:18PICE put a hand on her client's arm and
  512. 19:20said very quietly that they were
  513. 19:21finished for the day. Kimberly pulled
  514. 19:24her arm free and stared at me. And for
  515. 19:26the first time, there was fear in her
  516. 19:27face instead of calculation.
  517. 19:30She said nothing else. She picked up her
  518. 19:32purse, the same purse she had set on my
  519. 19:34counter like she lived there, and walked
  520. 19:36out ahead of her lawyer. The repayment
  521. 19:39took most of her half of the house sale,
  522. 19:41and the rest in monthly payments she
  523. 19:43began making. After she took a position
  524. 19:45as a front desk coordinator at a dental
  525. 19:47clinic in Hamilton, she moved into a
  526. 19:50two-bedroom rental in Stony Creek. The
  527. 19:52children called it Mom's Apartment and
  528. 19:55said it had a pool they weren't allowed
  529. 19:57in without a grown-up. The criminal
  530. 19:59matter took longer. In February, I sat
  531. 20:02on a hard wooden bench in the courthouse
  532. 20:04in Milton with David beside me. He had
  533. 20:06not known about the signature, and the
  534. 20:08police had satisfied themselves of that.
  535. 20:11Kimberly stood at the front in a gray
  536. 20:13suit that was a size too big. She had
  537. 20:15pleaded guilty to uttering a forged
  538. 20:17document and to attempted fraud. The
  539. 20:20judge was a woman with reading glasses
  540. 20:21on a chain. She said she had read the
  541. 20:24file twice. She said the accused had no
  542. 20:26prior record and had pleaded early, and
  543. 20:29she took both into account. Then she
  544. 20:31looked down at Kimberly over the
  545. 20:32glasses. Those trust accounts held money
  546. 20:35for two small children set aside by
  547. 20:37their grandparents so that no one could
  548. 20:39reach it. You treated it as a purse. She
  549. 20:42sentenced her to 18 months of probation
  550. 20:44and 150 hours of community service. She
  551. 20:48ordered restitution of the legal costs
  552. 20:50Gregory had incurred to protect the
  553. 20:52accounts and she said the conviction
  554. 20:54would stand as a criminal record.
  555. 20:56Kimberly shoulders folded just slightly.
  556. 20:58The way a coat slides off a hook in the
  557. 21:01hallway afterward she came toward me
  558. 21:03alone. David stepped aside without being
  559. 21:05asked. Her eyes were red. I'm sorry,
  560. 21:08Joyce. I mean it. Can you forgive me? I
  561. 21:11thought about it honestly. I forgive you
  562. 21:13enough not to carry it, I said. But you
  563. 21:15will not be in my house. You will not
  564. 21:17ask me for anything and I will not sign
  565. 21:20anything with your name beside mine. You
  566. 21:22and I are finished. I will be kind to
  567. 21:24you in front of Asher and Violet always.
  568. 21:26That is all I have left to give you."
  569. 21:29She nodded once and she did not argue.
  570. 21:31Then she walked down the long corridor
  571. 21:33to the stairs and I did not watch her
  572. 21:35go. I did not take pleasure in it. That
  573. 21:38surprises people. But she had paid for
  574. 21:41something she wanted in full for the
  575. 21:43first time in her life, and I think she
  576. 21:45stood a little straighter afterward.
  577. 21:47Asher asked me once, very quietly, while
  578. 21:50we were building a model of the solar
  579. 21:51system on my dining room table whether
  580. 21:54it was his fault that mom and dad didn't
  581. 21:55live together anymore. I put down the
  582. 21:58piece I was holding and turned to him
  583. 22:00completely. "No," I said. "Not even a
  584. 22:03little bit. Sometimes grown-ups have
  585. 22:05problems that are only about them. Both
  586. 22:07of them love you and neither of them is
  587. 22:09going anywhere. He nodded slowly. Will
  588. 22:12you still be my grandma? I pulled him
  589. 22:14close. I have never been so sure of
  590. 22:16anything in my life. By spring, David
  591. 22:19had rented a small apartment near the
  592. 22:21Burlington waterfront and was slowly
  593. 22:23building something new. He brought the
  594. 22:25children on Sunday afternoons, and we
  595. 22:27made lunch together, and Violet
  596. 22:29inevitably fell asleep in the armchair
  597. 22:32before the movie ended. One afternoon,
  598. 22:34David was washing dishes at my sink and
  599. 22:36said without turning around, "Mom, if
  600. 22:39you hadn't set up those trusts, I don't
  601. 22:41know what would have happened to that
  602. 22:42money." I handed him a dish towel. "Your
  603. 22:45father knew what he was building. He
  604. 22:48just needed someone to guard it." "Thank
  605. 22:50you," he said simply, without anything
  606. 22:52else attached. It was the most honest
  607. 22:55thing he had said to me in years. Before
  608. 22:57that, at Christmas, Shannon had flown in
  609. 22:59from Calgary. Asher ate three helpings
  610. 23:02of mashed potatoes and announced he
  611. 23:04wanted to be a geologist. Violet wrapped
  612. 23:06herself in the throw from the couch and
  613. 23:08wouldn't take it off all evening. David
  614. 23:10laughed at something, Shannon said, and
  615. 23:12for a second he sounded exactly like
  616. 23:14Roy. I had to look away. When David left
  617. 23:17that night, he hugged me the way he had
  618. 23:19as a teenager. The kind where you
  619. 23:21actually feel the other person. I
  620. 23:24watched his tail lights go down the
  621. 23:25street until they were gone. Then I went
  622. 23:28back inside and sat in Royy's armchair
  623. 23:30with the tree lights warm and the house
  624. 23:32still. I still believe in generosity,
  625. 23:35but I've learned that there is a
  626. 23:36difference between giving and being
  627. 23:37taken from and between love and
  628. 23:39compliance. There is a kind of care that
  629. 23:41looks like cruelty in the short run and
  630. 23:44reveals itself over time as the only
  631. 23:46real thing. Roy knew that. He tried to
  632. 23:49tell me Asher and Violet are growing up.
  633. 23:52They don't yet know what their
  634. 23:53grandfather set aside for them or what
  635. 23:56it took to guard it. Someday I'll sit
  636. 23:58with them and tell them about a man who
  637. 24:00labeled his jars and built a life from
  638. 24:03nothing because he believed the people
  639. 24:05he loved deserved a future no one could
  640. 24:07take from them. And I'll tell them their
  641. 24:09grandmother finally understood exactly
  642. 24:12what he meant. Most parents have given a
  643. 24:14lot to their grown children out of love.
  644. 24:16And it is rarely simple to see where
  645. 24:18generosity should stop. Where do you
  646. 24:21draw the line between helping a grown
  647. 24:22child and letting them take what is
  648. 24:25yours?

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of My Daughter-in-Law Demanded I Sign Away My Grandkids' Trust - So I Called My Lawyer and Froze Eve... by Silent Mother Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,616 words across 648 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.