YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → My Best Friend's Toxic Ex Called Her… But What I Said Changed Everything

My Best Friend's Toxic Ex Called Her… But What I Said Changed Everything — Transcript

by Heartstrings Stories · 7,374 words · 1,205 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00She said his name like she was still
0:01deciding whether to be afraid of it. And
0:04that was the second I knew something was
0:06wrong before I knew anything else.
0:08I was standing in her kitchen with a
0:10grocery bag in one hand, the kind of
0:12ordinary Tuesday errand that doesn't
0:15usually end with your whole life
0:16shifting sideways
0:18when her phone lit up on the counter and
0:20she went still in a way I had never seen
0:22her go still before.
0:24Not annoyed still, not busy still, quiet
0:27in the way a room goes quiet right
0:29before something breaks.
0:31Who is it? I asked, even though some
0:33part of me already knew I wasn't going
0:34to like the answer.
0:36She didn't pick it up. She let it ring
0:38out, watched the screen go dark and said
0:40nobody in a voice that made it very
0:42clear it was somebody.
0:44That was the night everything I had
0:46spent four years pretending not to know
0:48finally had nowhere left to hide.
0:50My name is Ben Calloway.
0:53I'm 31. I install and service commercial
0:56HVAC systems for a company two towns
0:58over.
0:59And most days my biggest decision is
1:01whether a building's air handler needs a
1:03new motor or just a good cleaning.
1:06I am not by nature a man who gets swept
1:09into other people's drama. I like quiet
1:11houses, finished projects, and being
1:13able to predict my own week,
1:16which is probably why I spent four years
1:18standing two feet away from the most
1:19important relationship of my life and
1:22calling it friendship because friendship
1:24was easier to predict.
1:26Her name is Sasha Raze.
1:28We met because she backed her car into
1:30mine in a grocery store parking lot, got
1:33out, looked at the small dent in my
1:35bumper, looked at me and said completely
1:37deadpan
1:38that was already there. I told her it
1:40was not already there.
1:42She told me to prove it. I did not have
1:44photographic evidence of my own bumper
1:46from before that afternoon, so legally I
1:49suppose she won.
1:51We exchanged insurance information
1:53anyway, and somewhere between her
1:55writing her number on the back of a
1:56receipt and me realizing I was in no
1:59hurry leave that parking lot, we became
2:01friends.
2:03Not the kind of friends who see each
2:04other twice a year and like old photos,
2:07the kind who show up.
2:09She was the person who drove 40 minutes
2:10at midnight when my father had his first
2:12heart scare, sat with me in a hospital
2:15waiting room until 5 in the morning
2:18and didn't say a single comforting
2:19cliché the entire time, just stayed,
2:22which I have since learned is the harder
2:24and better thing to do.
2:26I was the person who helped her move
2:28apartments three times in four years,
2:30who learned her coffee order without
2:32being told twice,
2:34who could tell from the sound of her
2:35footsteps coming up my porch steps
2:37whether she'd had a good day or a day
2:40that needed pizza and bad television.
2:43People got it wrong constantly.
2:45New coworkers, my cousin at every family
2:47event, the barista at the place we went
2:49to too often.
2:51They'd see us together and assume, and
2:53one of us would always correct them,
2:55usually me. We're just friends, I'd say,
2:58easy, automatic, like a line I'd
3:00rehearsed so many times it had worn
3:01smooth.
3:03Sasha would just smile in that way she
3:05had, the one that didn't agree or
3:06disagree, just absorbed the moment and
3:09moved past it.
3:10I told myself that smile meant she found
3:13the assumption funny.
3:15It took me four years and one phone call
3:17I wasn't supposed to hear to understand
3:19it might have meant something else
3:20entirely.
3:22The dates I went on in those four years
3:24were forgettable in the specific way
3:26that only becomes obvious in hindsight.
3:29I'd come home and within the hour I'd be
3:31on the phone with Sasha, narrating the
3:33evening like a man filing a report
3:35nobody asked for.
3:37She always had a question that cut
3:39straight to the truth of it, something
3:41like,
3:42did you check your phone under the
3:43table? Or did she laugh at the joke
3:45about your dad's tools? And somehow she
3:48always knew the answer before I gave it.
3:51I never thought about why I needed her
3:52opinion on every date I went on. I just
3:55assumed that was what best friends did.
3:57Looking back, I think I was asking her
3:59permission.
4:01I think some part of me wanted her to
4:02say, don't go again. And some other,
4:05quieter part of her must have wanted to
4:06say it too, and neither of us ever did.
4:10So that Tuesday, when her phone rang and
4:12she went pale and let it die without
4:13answering, I should have let it go.
4:16We had plans to put together the
4:18bookshelf she'd bought for her new
4:19apartment, a flat pack monster with 41
4:22screws and instructions translated badly
4:25from another language.
4:27And under normal circumstances, that
4:28would have been the whole evening, two
4:30friends arguing about whether shelf B
4:32went above or below panel C.
4:35But normal had just left the room.
4:37Sasha, it's nothing, Ben. You went
4:39white.
4:40That is not nothing. She picked up a
4:42screwdriver she didn't need yet, turned
4:44it over in her hands like it might give
4:46her something to say.
4:48It's an old number.
4:49I thought I deleted it. Whose number?
4:52She looked at me for a long moment, long
4:54enough that I started to understand this
4:56conversation was going to cost or
4:57something to have. Then she said the
4:59name.
5:01Derek, I knew the name the way you know
5:03a scar on someone else's body, something
5:05you've heard referenced but never
5:07actually seen up close.
5:09Derek was the boyfriend before me
5:10knowing her, the one she didn't talk
5:12about except in careful, edited
5:14fragments. I knew he'd been older.
5:17I knew it had ended badly, two years
5:19before the parking lot, before the dent
5:21in my bumper, before any of this.
5:24I knew that whenever his name came up,
5:26even by accident, Sasha's whole posture
5:28changed like she was bracing for
5:30weather. What did he want? I don't know.
5:33I didn't answer. Has he called before?
5:36She hesitated, and that hesitation told
5:37me more than any answer would have.
5:39Sometimes, not often.
5:42I usually just block the number again,
5:43and it stops for a while. Sasha, I set
5:46down the bag of screws I'd been sorting.
5:48How long has this been happening? On and
5:50off. A year, maybe. A year.
5:53A full year of this man's name appearing
5:55on her phone, and not once had she
5:57mentioned it to me, the person who
5:59supposedly knew everything about her
6:01life worth knowing.
6:03That stung in a way I didn't examine
6:05closely at the time because there was a
6:07more immediate problem sitting in the
6:09room with us. And the immediate problem
6:11was that whoever Derek was,
6:14he had just made my best friend go quiet
6:16in a way I'd never seen.
6:18We didn't finish the bookshelf that
6:19night.
6:21We sat on her half-furnished living room
6:22floor instead, her back against the
6:25unbuilt panel bed, me across from her
6:27with my elbows on my knees. And for the
6:29first time in four years,
6:32she told me the parts of the story she
6:33usually skipped.
6:35Derek Voss, 11 years older than her,
6:38charming in the specific way that makes
6:40everyone in the room comfortable except
6:42the person closest to him.
6:44He'd taken her to nice restaurants and
6:46remembered her birthday and told her
6:48early and often how lucky he felt to
6:50have found someone like her,
6:53which she had once mistaken for
6:54tenderness and later understood was the
6:56opening move of a much longer game.
6:59He didn't yell.
7:01Sasha was clear about that, almost
7:03defensive about it, like she needed me
7:05to understand the absence of shouting
7:06didn't mean the absence of harm.
7:09He simply, slowly reorganized her life
7:11around his comfort. He didn't like her
7:13working late, so she stopped taking the
7:15shifts that paid better.
7:17He didn't like her oldest friend from
7:19college, so visits got shorter then
7:21stopped.
7:23He'd ask where she was going in a tone
7:24so mild it took her over a year to
7:26notice it was never actually a question.
7:28It was an inspection disguised as
7:30curiosity.
7:32It wasn't even a big thing that finally
7:34got me out, she said, picking at a loose
7:36thread on the carpet.
7:37It was small. He criticized the way I
7:40packed his lunch, the way I folded the
7:42sandwich bag.
7:44And I remember standing in my kitchen
7:45thinking, I have become a woman who is
7:47being graded on sandwich bags, and I
7:50don't know how I got here.
7:51She left two weeks later,
7:54quietly, methodically, the way she did
7:56most things, no dramatic exit,
7:59just a slow withdrawal that left him
8:01grasping at a relationship that had
8:03already ended in every way that mattered
8:05before he noticed.
8:07He hadn't taken it well. He'd called
8:08constantly for the first few months,
8:11showed up at her work once, which was
8:13the only time she'd ever called the
8:15police.
8:16And even then she downplayed it to the
8:18responding officer because some part of
8:20her still felt embarrassed for taking up
8:22the space.
8:24He'll get bored, she said now, like she
8:26was reciting a fact she'd told herself
8:28so many times it had become load
8:30bearing.
8:31He always does.
8:32I block the number, it goes quiet for a
8:34few months and then it starts again.
8:36It's not a big deal.
8:38It's a big deal to me, I said before I'd
8:40fully thought about how that sounded.
8:43She looked up at me, something shifting
8:44behind her eyes. Why? I should have had
8:47an easy answer ready.
8:49I am after all a man who likes
8:51predictable things, finished sentences,
8:53plans that don't require improvisation.
8:56But sitting on that floor looking at
8:58her, the question landed somewhere I
9:00hadn't built a wall around yet. And what
9:02came out instead was the truth,
9:05unrehearsed and a little too honest for
9:07a Tuesday night assembling furniture.
9:10Because the idea of someone making you
9:12feel small enough to apologize for a
9:13sandwich bag makes me want to put my
9:15fist through that panel be you're
9:17leaning against.
9:18She laughed, short and surprised,
9:21and some of the color came back into her
9:23face.
9:24That's not actually an answer to my
9:25question. I know. Then why? I looked at
9:28her for a long moment.
9:30The lamp in the corner threw soft yellow
9:32light across half the room, the other
9:34half still in shadow from boxes she
9:36hadn't unpacked yet. And somewhere
9:38outside a car alarm went off and
9:40stopped.
9:42And none of it mattered because every
9:43small detail I'd been filing away for
9:46four years without naming it was
9:47suddenly all I could see.
9:49The way she remembered which mug I liked
9:51at every coffee shop we'd ever been to.
9:54The way I'd started measuring every date
9:57I went on against a standard I never
9:58consciously set. A standard that I was
10:01beginning to realize had her name
10:03written all over it.
10:05The way I had once told a co-worker,
10:07half joking, that I'd probably never
10:09find anyone who got my sense of humor
10:11the way Sasha did.
10:13And the coworker had given me a look I
10:15dismissed at the time, and now
10:17understood completely.
10:19Because I think I've spent four years
10:21telling people we're just friends, I
10:23said slowly.
10:24And I think some part of me has known
10:26for a while that wasn't the whole truth.
10:28I just kept it filed under friendship
10:30because friendship didn't require me to
10:32risk anything. The room went very quiet.
10:35Sasha didn't move.
10:37Ben, you don't have to say anything
10:38back, I said quickly.
10:41Because watching her face do something
10:42complicated made me suddenly aware of
10:45how much I had just put on the table of
10:46a woman who'd spent the last hour
10:48talking about an ex who'd spent two
10:50years making.
10:51Her feel small.
10:53That was a terrible time to say that.
10:56I just heard myself talking about
10:58wanting to punch furniture on your
10:59behalf and realized I don't talk like
11:01that about people I see as just friends.
11:04She was quiet long enough that I started
11:06preparing
11:07myself for the version of this where she
11:09gently
11:11kindly put it back where it belonged.
11:13Then she said, voice barely above the
11:15hum of the radiator,
11:17I have spent four years watching you go
11:19on dates with women who were perfectly
11:21nice and feeling like I was being slowly
11:23erased every single time
11:26and telling myself that was an
11:27unreasonable thing to feel about a
11:29friend.
11:30I didn't move.
11:31I used to time how long it took you to
11:33call me afterward, she said, a small,
11:36embarrassed laugh escaping.
11:38If it was under 20 minutes, I let myself
11:40feel something I had no right to feel.
11:42If it was longer, I told myself I was
11:44being ridiculous and went to bed angry
11:46at myself instead.
11:48It was always under 20 minutes, I said.
11:51I know.
11:52I counted every time.
11:54Something in my chest moved like a door
11:56swinging open after years of being
11:57painted shut.
11:59I shifted closer, the unbuilt bookshelf
12:02panel scraping against the carpet
12:03between us, close enough now that the
12:05careful, performed distance we'd
12:07maintained for four years didn't make
12:09sense anymore.
12:11Not after everything we just said out
12:13loud.
12:14So what happens now? I said.
12:16She looked at me, really looked, the
12:18same look she'd given the dent in my
12:20bumper four years earlier, like she was
12:22deciding whether to argue or admit
12:24something.
12:25Now, she said, I think you're supposed
12:27to stop being a coward about it.
12:29I laughed, and the sound broke whatever
12:31was left of the tension in the room, and
12:33I reached up
12:34slow enough to give her every chance to
12:36stop me, and she didn't stop me, and I
12:39kissed her there on the floor of her
12:40half-furnished apartment,
12:42surrounded by cardboard boxes and 41
12:45screws and a bookshelf that was never
12:47going to assemble itself.
12:49And it felt less like the beginning of
12:51something new and more like finally
12:53admitting to something that had been
12:54true for a very long time.
12:57When we pulled apart, she rested her
12:58forehead against mine, breathing like
13:01she'd been holding it for longer than
13:02the last few minutes.
13:04We are going to have to explain this to
13:05your cousin, she said.
13:08She has been insufferable about this for
13:09two years. She can wait. She really
13:12cannot.
13:13She has a betting pool.
13:15I laughed again, and for a moment, just
13:17a moment, the whole evening felt simple,
13:19two people finally saying the thing out
13:21loud, no complications,
13:23no history standing in the doorway.
13:26Those four days before anything went
13:28wrong were some of the best of my life,
13:30and I want to take a moment to actually
13:32sit in them
13:33because everything that came after makes
13:35it easy to forget how ordinary and good
13:37they were before Derek's name showed up
13:39again, to remind us both that endings
13:41aren't always as finished as they look
13:44from the outside.
13:45We didn't tell anyone right away. That
13:47was Sasha's idea, not mine.
13:50She said she wanted a few days where it
13:52was just ours before it became a thing
13:54other people had opinions about,
13:57before my cousin started keeping score
13:59and Sasha's co-workers started asking
14:01pointed questions in the break room.
14:04So for four days, we existed in this
14:05strange, private bubble where everything
14:07felt new and nothing had been announced,
14:10which somehow made it feel more real,
14:12not less.
14:13The first morning after, I made
14:15breakfast in her kitchen using
14:17ingredients that did not obviously
14:18belong together.
14:20Because I had stayed over without
14:22planning too, and her fridge was not
14:24stocked for a man who needed actual food
14:26in the morning.
14:28She came out in an old college
14:29sweatshirt, hair a mess, and stood in
14:32the doorway watching me attempt to make
14:33eggs work with what amounted to a half
14:35onion and some questionable cheese.
14:38And she didn't say anything for a long
14:40moment, just watched, like she was
14:42checking whether the version of this
14:43morning that existed in her head matched
14:46the one actually happening in her
14:47kitchen.
14:49You're staring, I said without turning
14:50around. I'm allowed to stare. This is
14:52new information. I didn't know you could
14:54cook. I can't.
14:56I'm improvising. That tracks. She
14:59crossed the kitchen and leaned against
15:00the counter beside me, close enough that
15:02her shoulder brushed mine.
15:04A small thing that four days earlier
15:06would have meant nothing and now meant
15:08everything.
15:10Four years of friendship and I'm only
15:11now learning you panic cook. I don't
15:13panic cook. You are visibly panicking.
15:17You've stirred that pan 11 times in the
15:18last 30 seconds.
15:20I set the spatula down and looked at
15:22her, and she was smiling in that quiet
15:24way she had.
15:26The one I used to mistake for amusement
15:28at someone else's expense and now
15:30understood was something closer to
15:31affection she hadn't let herself show so
15:34plainly before.
15:36Maybe I'm panicking a little, I
15:37admitted. This is new for me too. I keep
15:39waiting for it to feel different than it
15:41does. Does it? No, I said. That's the
15:44strange part.
15:46It feels like every other morning we've
15:48ever had together.
15:50Just with better mornings ahead of it.
15:52She kissed my cheek light and easy like
15:54it was the most natural thing in the
15:55world, which four days in it somehow
15:58already was.
15:59And went to go find actual bread so my
16:02eggs would have something to sit on
16:03besides good intentions.
16:06We spent that first weekend doing
16:08nothing in particular and somehow making
16:10it count.
16:11We went to the hardware store because
16:13she needed shelf brackets.
16:15And I spent 20 minutes explaining the
16:17structural difference between two nearly
16:19identical brackets, while she pretended
16:21to listen and actually just watched my
16:23face the whole time,
16:26which I only noticed afterward when she
16:28admitted she couldn't have told me a
16:29single thing I'd said.
16:32We watched a movie neither of us
16:33finished because we kept talking over
16:35it, comparing notes on four years worth
16:37of moments we'd apparently both been
16:39quietly cataloging without telling the
16:41other.
16:43She remembered the exact day I'd called
16:45her three years earlier, panicked
16:47because I thought I'd locked my keys in
16:49my work van during a service call.
16:51And she talked me through finding the
16:53spare in my own glove compartment while
16:55laughing so hard she could barely get
16:57the words out.
16:59I remembered a rainy Tuesday when she'd
17:01shown up at my door unannounced with
17:03takeout because she said she could hear
17:05in my voice on the phone that I'd had a
17:06bad day.
17:08And neither of us had called it anything
17:10other than friendship at the time, but
17:12looking back now it was obvious what it
17:14actually was.
17:16We were so bad at this, she said, lying
17:18on my couch with her feet in my lap, the
17:20movie long forgotten on the television.
17:23Four years of doing relationship things
17:25and calling it being friends.
17:27In our defense, we were doing it well.
17:30Just under the wrong label. That's a
17:32generous way to describe four years of
17:34cowardice. I prefer cautious. You drove
17:3740 minutes at midnight to sit with me at
17:39a hospital.
17:40That's not caution, Ben.
17:43That's just love with a different name
17:44on it. I didn't have an answer for that,
17:46mostly because she was right.
17:49And there's a particular kind of quiet
17:51that happens when someone says a true
17:52thing about you that you weren't quite
17:54ready to hear out loud, even when you
17:56already knew it.
17:58I just reached down and laced my fingers
18:00through hers instead, and she let her
18:02head fall back against the armrest, and
18:04for a long moment neither of us said
18:06anything else
18:07because nothing else needed saying.
18:10That was the version of the relationship
18:12I wanted to remember when everything
18:14else started happening.
18:15Not the part with Derek's name lighting
18:17up a phone screen, not the market, not
18:20any of it.
18:21Just two people who had finally stopped
18:23filing something under the wrong
18:24category, lying on a couch on a Sunday
18:27afternoon, in absolutely no hurry to be
18:30anywhere else.
18:31The complications arrived four days
18:33later, on a Saturday morning,
18:36while Sasha and I were standing in her
18:37kitchen drinking coffee out of
18:39mismatched mugs and pretending the
18:41previous four days hadn't completely
18:43rearranged both of our lives.
18:46Her phone buzzed against the counter.
18:48She glanced at it and the easy morning
18:50we'd been having disappeared in an
18:51instant. Derek again? I asked.
18:55She nodded slowly, staring at the screen
18:57like it might bite. He's not usually
18:59this persistent. Three calls and now a
19:01text. What's the text say? She turned
19:04the phone around so I could read it.
19:06I know you're seeing someone. I saw you
19:09too at the market. We should talk before
19:11this turns into something neither of us
19:12wants.
19:14A cold, careful kind of anger settled
19:16into my chest, the kind that doesn't
19:17shout, just sits there and waits. He's
19:20been watching you. He used to do this,
19:22Sasha said, her voice tight.
19:25Show of places, not stalking exactly,
19:27just always somehow knowing where I'd
19:29be.
19:30I thought that stopped when I moved. You
19:32moved twice since him. I know. I set my
19:35coffee down, my hand steadier than I
19:37felt. Sasha, this isn't an ex who's
19:39bored and lonely sending a few texts.
19:42This is a pattern.
19:43She didn't argue, which told me she
19:45already knew that, had probably known it
19:47for longer than she wanted to admit.
19:49The same way she'd known about the
19:51sandwich bags long before she let
19:53herself leave.
19:55We sat with the silence for a moment,
19:57and then her phone rang again, Derek's
19:59name lighting up the screen. And before
20:01I could say anything she answered it,
20:02Jaw set.
20:04Like she decided she was done running
20:06from this particular conversation.
20:08Derek, I could hear his voice faintly
20:11through the speaker, smooth, reasonable,
20:13the kind of voice that made you feel
20:14unreasonable just for being upset.
20:17Sasha, finally.
20:19I was starting to think you'd forgotten
20:20how phones work. What do you want? I
20:23want to talk. That's all.
20:25I saw you with someone at the market,
20:27and I think we should clear the air
20:28before you make a decision you don't
20:30fully understand the consequences of.
20:32I felt my jaw tighten at consequences.
20:35A word with no business in a sentence
20:38about someone else's relationship.
20:40There's nothing to clear up, Sasha said.
20:43We broke up two years ago.
20:45I don't owe you an update on my life.
20:47I'm not asking for an update, Derek
20:49said, his tone never once rising, which
20:51somehow made it worse. I'm asking you to
20:54be careful.
20:55You don't know this guy the way you
20:56think you do. People change when they
20:58think they've won something.
21:00Won something? Sasha repeated flat.
21:03You know what I mean? I really don't,
21:05Derek. There was a pause on the line
21:07just long enough to feel deliberate. I
21:09still care about you, Sasha.
21:12That doesn't go away because you've
21:14decided to be angry at me for two years.
21:17I just don't want to see you get hurt by
21:18someone who doesn't actually know what
21:20he has.
21:21Sasha looked at me across the kitchen,
21:23and I could see her debating whether to
21:25hand me the phone,
21:27whether involving me would help or
21:28simply give him exactly the reaction he
21:31was fishing for.
21:32She decided against it, which I
21:34understood even as every instinct in me
21:36wanted to take that phone and tell this
21:39man exactly how unconvincing his concern
21:41sounded from where I was standing.
21:44I need you to stop calling me, she said
21:46instead, voice steady. I mean that.
21:49Whatever this is, it needs to stop. I'll
21:51stop when I know you're safe. I am safe
21:54with a man you've known for four years
21:56and dated for four days.
21:58That's not safety, Sasha. That's
22:00convenience dressed up as something
22:01real.
22:02His voice finally had an edge to it now,
22:04thin but there.
22:06I watched you build a whole life
22:08avoiding anything that asked too much of
22:09you. That's what this is, the easy
22:12option.
22:13The friend who never challenged you
22:15because he was too busy being agreeable.
22:17I watched something flicker across
22:19Sasha's face, not doubt exactly,
22:22but the ghost of an old wound being
22:23pressed on with practiced precision.
22:26This was, I understood suddenly, exactly
22:28how it had worked for two years. Not
22:30loud, not obviously cruel, just calm,
22:34reasonable sounding sentences engineered
22:36to make her question her own judgment.
22:40said and hung up before he could answer.
22:42The kitchen was quiet. She set the phone
22:44down carefully like it had gotten
22:46heavier in her hand.
22:48He used to do that, she said after a
22:50moment.
22:51Take something I was sure about and find
22:53the one thread that would unravel it if
22:54I let it.
22:55Did it work this time? She looked up at
22:58me.
22:59And there was something fierce
23:00underneath the tiredness in her
23:01expression.
23:03No,
23:04but I understand now why it used to.
23:07I crossed the kitchen and pulled her
23:08into a hug and she let herself lean into
23:10it in a way I don't think she would have
23:12let herself a week earlier.
23:14Before any of this had a name.
23:17He's not wrong that you've known me a
23:18long time, I said into her hair. He's
23:21wrong about everything else. I know. I'm
23:23not the easy option by the way.
23:26I'm just quiet about being the right
23:27one.
23:28That got a real laugh out of her small
23:30and surprised, exactly the kind of laugh
23:33I'd been chasing without realizing it
23:34for four years. The calls didn't stop.
23:38Over the next 10 days, Derek shifted
23:40tactics the way a man does when his
23:42first approach fails to land the way he
23:44expected.
23:46The texts grew longer, more performed,
23:48careful paragraphs about how he only
23:50wanted to protect her, how he'd noticed
23:52things about me from a distance that
23:54concerned him, vague and unfalsifiable.
23:58The kind of insinuation designed to
23:59plant doubt without ever committing to
24:02an actual accusation.
24:04Sasha showed me most of them, which I
24:06understood was its own kind of trust,
24:08since the version of herself that had
24:10been with him for two years would have
24:11hidden them out of habit, out of shame,
24:14out of the slow conditioning that taught
24:16her his concerns were private business,
24:18something she needed to manage quietly
24:20so as not to upset anyone.
24:23Then he made the mistake of contacting
24:25me directly. It came as a text from an
24:27unknown number on a Wednesday evening
24:29while I was finishing up a service call
24:31across town. Ben, this is Derek Voss.
24:35I think you and I should talk man-to-man
24:37about Sasha. There are things you should
24:39know before this goes further.
24:42I sat in my work truck in an empty
24:43parking lot for a long moment, staring
24:46at the message, weighing whether
24:47engaging with it served any purpose at
24:49all.
24:51In the end, curiosity and a low
24:52simmering anger won out over good sense,
24:55and I typed back a single line. I'm
24:57listening. His response came fast like
24:59he'd been waiting.
25:01She's not as steady as she seems. She
25:04left me without warning after two good
25:05years together, no real explanation,
25:08just disappeared one day while I was at
25:10work.
25:11I'm not telling you this to scare you
25:13off. I'm telling you because I don't
25:15want you blindsided the way I was. I
25:17read it twice and something about the
25:18wording snagged. No real explanation.
25:22I thought about sandwich bags and
25:24shortened visits and a job she'd quietly
25:26given up because it made him
25:27uncomfortable, and I understood with
25:30total clarity
25:31that I was looking at a carefully edited
25:33version of events from a man who'd spent
25:36two years rewriting their relationship
25:38in his own favor and had clearly been
25:40rehearsing this particular performance.
25:43For whoever came next.
25:45She gave you plenty of explanation, I
25:47typed back. You just didn't like the
25:49answer.
25:50There was a longer pause this time
25:52before his reply came through, and when
25:54it did, the smooth, reasonable tone had
25:56thinned out at the edges.
25:58You don't know what you're getting into.
26:00I've watched her do this before, build
26:03someone up, lean on them completely, and
26:05then leave the second something better
26:06looks possible.
26:08Ask yourself why a woman with that
26:10pattern waited until I called to
26:12suddenly decide you were the one.
26:15I felt the accusation land exactly where
26:17it was aimed, a small, cold needle
26:19designed to make me doubt the timing of
26:21the last 10 days, and for one unguarded
26:24second it worked.
26:26A flicker of is that true passing
26:27through me before I caught it and
26:29recognized it for what it
26:31This was the same maneuver he'd run on
26:33Sasha in that phone call, repackaged for
26:36a new target.
26:37Find the one insecure thread and pull. I
26:39didn't take the bait this time either.
26:42I think you've spent two years rewriting
26:44a story you didn't like the ending of. I
26:46wrote, I'm not interested in your
26:47version. Don't contact me again. He
26:50didn't respond to that, not directly.
26:53But the following Saturday, he showed
26:54up.
26:56Sasha and I were at the same outdoor
26:57market where the bookshelf incident had
26:59started, this time looking for a coffee
27:02table.
27:03And we just stopped at a stall selling
27:05secondhand books when I felt Sasha go
27:07rigid beside me, the same stillness from
27:09that first night in her kitchen.
27:12I followed her gaze across the row of
27:13stalls and saw him,
27:16tall, put together in the particular way
27:18of a man who dresses to be taken
27:19seriously, standing maybe 30 ft away
27:22with his hands in his pockets,
27:25watching us with an expression that was
27:26trying very hard to look casual and not
27:29quite managing it.
27:31Sasha, he said, closing the distance
27:33before either of us could decide whether
27:35to leave.
27:36I thought that was you. You didn't think
27:38anything, she said.
27:40Her voice flat and controlled in a way
27:42that told me she'd had this exact
27:44conversation in her head a hundred times
27:47since the call started.
27:49You knew exactly where I'd be. His mouth
27:51tightened almost imperceptibly, a crack
27:53in the calm. I come to this market
27:55sometimes.
27:57It's not a crime to run into someone.
27:59It's not a coincidence either, and we
28:01both know it.
28:02He glanced at me then, a brief
28:03dismissive flick of his eyes,
28:06the kind designed to communicate that I
28:08wasn't worth a full conversation.
28:11Sasha, can we talk privately for a
28:13moment? No, I said before she could
28:15answer. His attention swung fully onto
28:17me now. I wasn't asking you. I know.
28:21I'm answering anyway. For a moment,
28:23something genuinely ugly moved behind
28:25his composed expression, the mask
28:27slipping just enough to show what was
28:29underneath.
28:30This is between Sasha and me.
28:32You do well to remember you're to this.
28:35I've known her four years, I said
28:36evenly.
28:38I think that makes me considerably less
28:39new to this than you, who she hasn't
28:41spoken to in two.
28:43A small crowd of market goers had
28:45started to slow near the stall.
28:47The particular gravity that forms around
28:49a public moment about to become a scene.
28:53Sasha straightened beside me, and when
28:55she spoke again, her voice had gathered
28:57something steadier.
28:58Something that sounded less like the
29:00woman bracing for weather and more like
29:02someone done apologizing for taking up
29:05space.
29:06Derek, she said, I want to be very clear
29:08here in public since you seem to need an
29:10audience to hear things. I left because
29:12you spent two years making me smaller.
29:15I didn't leave without explanation.
29:18I left because every time I tried to
29:20explain, you found a way to make it
29:21about something I'd misunderstood,
29:23something I was too emotional to see
29:25clearly.
29:27I am done being told my own experience
29:29wasn't real.
29:30That's not fair, he said, and for the
29:32first time his voice rose slightly, just
29:35enough that the nearby crowd's attention
29:37sharpened.
29:38I gave you everything. I was patient
29:40with you.
29:41You were patient the way someone is
29:42patient training a dog, Sasha said.
29:45I'm not interested in being praised for
29:47finally walking correctly.
29:49A woman nearby actually let out a short,
29:51surprised laugh, quickly stifled, and
29:54Derek's face flushed at the sound of it.
29:56The careful performance cracking further
29:58under an audience that wasn't responding
30:00the way he needed it to.
30:02This is exactly what I meant, he said,
30:05turning toward me now, grasping for a
30:06different angle.
30:08She does this.
30:09Turns it around, makes herself the
30:11victim, makes the other person look
30:13unreasonable for having a single
30:14concern.
30:16I think, I said, you've confused having
30:18concerns with needing control.
30:21And I think on some level you know the
30:23difference. You just don't like what it
30:24says about the last two years.
30:26Something in him deflated visibly.
30:29The polish finally giving way to
30:31something closer to the truth
30:32underneath.
30:34A A who had spent two years certain of
30:36his own narrative and was now standing
30:38in a public market watching it not land
30:40at all.
30:41He looked at Sasha one more time, opened
30:44his mouth like he had one more
30:45reasonable sentence loaded and ready.
30:48And then seemed to realize there was
30:50nothing left in that particular well
30:52that hadn't already failed.
30:54Block my number, Sasha said quietly. I
30:57mean it this time. Don't call, don't
30:58text, don't come find me at markets that
31:01you suddenly remember you like. He
31:02didn't answer.
31:04He turned and walked off through the
31:05stalls and the small crowd that had
31:08gathered drifted back into their own
31:10business, the moment dissolving as
31:12quickly as it had formed.
31:14The way public scenes always do once the
31:16tension breaks.
31:18Sasha let out a long breath beside me,
31:20her hands trembling slightly as the
31:22adrenaline caught up with her.
31:24I steered her toward a bench at the edge
31:26of the row away from the stalls and we
31:28sat there for a minute while she pressed
31:30the back of her hand to her mouth like
31:32she was holding something in.
31:34You okay? I asked. I don't know yet. Ask
31:37me in an hour. She let out a shaky
31:39laugh. I've imagined that conversation
31:41probably a hundred times since I left
31:43him.
31:44In my head I was always so much calmer.
31:46You were calm.
31:48I was the one gripping a paperback like
31:50it owed me money.
31:52She glanced down at my hand, still
31:54curled around a second hand novel I'd
31:56apparently been holding the entire time
31:58without noticing.
32:00You bought that? I think the adrenaline
32:01bought it.
32:03I don't even know what it's about.
32:05That actually got a real laugh out of
32:06her, the tightness in her shoulders
32:08easing for the first time since Derek
32:10had appeared across the row.
32:12Thank you, she said quietly, for not
32:14taking the conversation from me. I half
32:17expected you to step in front of me the
32:18second he opened his mouth.
32:20I wanted to, I admitted.
32:23Every instinct I've wanted to plant
32:24myself between you and him and not move.
32:27But it wasn't my conversation to finish.
32:30He'd spent two years deciding what you
32:32were and weren't allowed to say for
32:34yourself.
32:35I wasn't going to do the the thing with
32:37better intentions.
32:39She looked at me for a long moment,
32:40something soft moving behind her eyes.
32:43That might be the single most attractive
32:45thing you've ever said to me, and you
32:47said it while holding a book about,
32:49apparently, naval history.
32:51I glanced down at the cover. Huh.
32:54So it does.
32:55She laughed again, leaning into my
32:56shoulder, and we sat there on that bench
32:58for a while longer, letting the ordinary
33:00noise of the market settle back around
33:02us, vendors calling out prices,
33:06a child somewhere laughing at something
33:07we couldn't see, the violin notes
33:09drifting faintly from a busker two rows
33:11over.
33:13It is a strange thing how quickly a
33:15place can return to feeling normal after
33:17it has just held something that
33:18significant.
33:20The world doesn't pause to acknowledge
33:21the moments that change your life.
33:24It just keeps selling lamps and
33:25secondhand novels around you while you
33:28sit there trying to catch up to what
33:29just happened.
33:31I don't think he'll be back, she said
33:33again, quieter this time, like she was
33:34testing whether she actually believed
33:36it. If he is, I said, we'll be ready.
33:39She smiled, small and real.
33:41We will, I confirmed. He didn't come
33:43back, not that week, not the month
33:45after.
33:46A single text arrived three weeks later,
33:49terse and stripped of all its previous
33:50performance, simply saying he hoped she
33:53was happy, and Sasha read it once,
33:55showed it to me without a word,
33:57and deleted it without responding, which
33:59felt less like closure and more like
34:01something better than closure, an ending
34:04that no longer required her input at
34:05all.
34:07We finished the bookshelf two days after
34:08the market, finally.
34:10The same 41 screws that had started this
34:13whole thing sitting in their little
34:14plastic bag on her kitchen counter for
34:17over a week, because neither of us had
34:19been able to think about flat pack,
34:22furniture in the middle of everything
34:23else.
34:24It took us three hours and one shouting
34:26match about which way panel C was
34:29supposed to face, and when it was
34:30finally standing upright against her
34:32living room wall,
34:34slightly crooked in a way neither of us
34:36wanted to fix. She stepped back, looked
34:38at it, and then looked at me.
34:40It's ugly, she said.
34:42It's structurally sound, which is more
34:44than I can say for some of the men in
34:46your life.
34:47She laughed, leaned into my shoulder.
34:49And we stood there for a long moment
34:51looking at a slightly crooked bookshelf
34:53in an apartment that finally, fully felt
34:56like it belonged to her and not to the
34:58careful
34:59smaller version of herself she'd spent
35:01two years learning to be.
35:03A few weeks after that, Sasha told me
35:05she wanted to talk to someone, an actual
35:07someone, a therapist she'd found through
35:10a friend from work.
35:12Because she'd realized somewhere in the
35:13middle of the market confrontation that
35:15she didn't entirely trust her own read
35:17on people anymore.
35:19Not after two years of being told her
35:21instincts were wrong often enough that
35:23she'd started believing it by default.
35:26I drove her to the first appointment and
35:28sat in the parking lot the whole hour,
35:30not because she asked me to, but because
35:32I wanted to be the first face she saw
35:34afterward.
35:36And when she came out, she had that
35:37particular look people get after they've
35:39said something difficult out loud for
35:41the first time, tired and lighter at the
35:43same time.
35:45How was it? I asked as she climbed into
35:47the passenger seat. Strange, good
35:49strange.
35:50She asked me why I apologized three
35:52times in the first 10 minutes for things
35:54that didn't need apologizing for.
35:57Sasha stared out the windshield for a
35:58moment.
36:00I didn't have a good answer. You will
36:01eventually. That's annoyingly optimistic
36:04of you. I contain multitudes. She
36:06laughed and reached over to squeeze my
36:08hand on the gear shift.
36:10And we drove home in the kind of
36:12comfortable quiet that didn't used to
36:13come easily to her, not in the months
36:16right after Derek, when silence had felt
36:18to her like waiting for the other shoe
36:20to drop.
36:21It took time that part. I won't pretend
36:24it didn't.
36:25There were nights in the weeks that
36:26followed when she'd go quiet in the
36:28middle of an ordinary conversation,
36:30bracing for a correction that never
36:32came.
36:33And I learned to just let the silence
36:35sit there until she found her way back
36:37out of it on her own.
36:39Because rushing her out of it would have
36:40meant becoming exactly the kind of
36:42person who didn't let her have her own
36:44pace.
36:45Six months later, my cousin collected on
36:48her bedding pool loudly at a family
36:50dinner in front of everyone, which Sasha
36:52found far funnier than I did.
36:54Apparently, there had been factions.
36:57My aunt had bet on us getting together
36:59within the year.
37:01My cousin had bet on exactly this
37:02scenario, an accidental confrontation
37:05forcing the issue, though she admitted
37:07she'd guessed wrong about which ex would
37:09be involved,
37:11having assumed it would be one of mine.
37:13Sasha laughed so hard at the dinner
37:15table that she had to put her fork down.
37:18And I sat there mildly betrayed by how
37:20thoroughly my entire extended family had
37:23apparently been watching us for two
37:24years while I remained completely
37:27oblivious to my own life.
37:29You're telling me, I said, that everyone
37:31at this table knew before I did?
37:33Everyone at this table knew before
37:35either of you did, my aunt said,
37:37entirely too pleased with herself.
37:40We still argue about furniture, by the
37:42way.
37:43The crooked bookshelf became something
37:45of a running joke, a small monument to
37:47the week everything changed. And Sasha
37:49has flatly refused to let me fix the
37:51lean, insisting it has character,
37:55which I have come to understand is just
37:57her way of keeping a small, deliberate
37:59reminder of how we got here.
38:01She still remembers my coffee order
38:03without being told, and I still know
38:05within the first 10 seconds of a phone
38:07call whether she's had a good day or a
38:09day that needs pizza and bad television.
38:13Except now there's no pretending
38:14underneath any of it, no careful filing
38:17of feelings under the wrong category
38:19just because the right one felt too
38:21risky to name.
38:22Derek never resurfaced.
38:25The last we heard, secondhand through
38:27someone who knew someone, was that he'd
38:29moved to a different city for work.
38:31And Sasha received that information the
38:33way you receive news about whether in a
38:35place you no longer live, distantly,
38:38without much weight attached to it at
38:39all.
38:41I think that more than anything was the
38:42real ending, not the scene in the
38:44market, not the texts, just the slow,
38:47ordinary fact of him becoming irrelevant
38:49to her life.
38:51A name that used to make her go still,
38:52finally settling into something closer
38:55to forgettable.
38:56We moved in together the following
38:58spring into an apartment with enough
39:00wall space for two bookshelves, the
39:02crooked one and a new one we built
39:04together this time properly.
39:06With both of us reading the same
39:08instructions out loud and somehow still
39:10managing to put one panel in backward,
39:13which felt right, honestly.
39:15Like a tradition we hadn't meant to
39:16start but were keeping anyway.
39:19Sometimes late at night she'll ask me
39:21what would have happened if her phone
39:23hadn't rung that Tuesday, if Derek had
39:25simply stayed quiet,
39:27if I'd never seen her go still in that
39:29particular way for the first time.
39:32I don't have a good answer for that.
39:34I like to think we would have gotten
39:35here eventually.
39:37That four years of under 20-minute phone
39:39calls and remembered coffee orders were
39:42always going to add up to something
39:44neither of us could keep filing under
39:45friendship forever.
39:47But I'm also honest enough to admit that
39:49sometimes the thing that finally pushes
39:52you toward the truth isn't courage.
39:54Sometimes it's just fear showing up at
39:56exactly the wrong moment and
39:58accidentally clearing a path you've been
40:00too careful to walk yourself.
40:02Either way, I'm glad it rang.
40:05So tell me, if you were standing in that
40:06kitchen and watched someone you loved go
40:08quiet like that, would you have asked
40:10the question or let it go?
40:13And have you ever had an old
40:14relationship resurface right when a new
40:16one was finally becoming real?
40:18Tell me your story in the comments.
40:20If you liked this one, leave a like,
40:22subscribe, and I'll see you in the next
40:24video.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of My Best Friend's Toxic Ex Called Her… But What I Said Changed Everything by Heartstrings Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,374 words across 1,205 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.