YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → Muslim Girl Question's Sam Shamoun about Islam

Muslim Girl Question's Sam Shamoun about Islam — Transcript

by Faith Defended · 3,443 words · 526 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00So, when a Muslim tells me, you ask me,
0:02"Why I don't follow Muhammad?" Because
0:04he contradicts my Bible. But then when
0:05you tell me it's contradict, you proved
0:07my point. Exactly. You just proved my
0:09point. Because if you agree with me the
0:11Bible's not corrupt, that means Muhammad
0:14is a false prophet. But I don't believe
0:16you and I don't accept the Bible's
0:18corrupt. So, what proof do you have for
0:20me to follow Muhammad?
0:21>> No, well like he said I want you to show
0:22me why you think Islam is for like is
0:25objective truth that everyone should
0:26agree.
0:27>> Why I Yeah, one of the reason I just
0:28told you it contradicts the revelation
0:30of Jesus Christ.
0:31>> Yes, yes. But you know, the Muslim going
0:32to say that the Bible is corrupt.
0:34>> But that But you just proved my point,
0:36right? You have to say my Bible is
0:37corrupt because if you agree that the
0:40Bible is not corrupt, that means
0:41Muhammad is a liar, right?
0:42>> Yeah, yes. But they not accept that. I
0:44mean the answer that everyone going to
0:45agree, you know.
0:46>> Yeah, but listen to what you just said.
0:48When I say Muhammad is a false prophet,
0:50he contradicts the Bible. What are they
0:51going to say to me? Your Bible's
0:53corrupt. Why do you think they say that?
0:54>> If the Bible is right, then Islam is
0:55wrong.
0:56>> Uh say it again.
0:58>> Because the Bible is right, then Islam
1:00is wrong. That's
1:00>> So, that's why you have to say that's
1:02why you have to say that the Bible's
1:04corrupt. Because if you admit the Bible
1:06has been preserved, and the Quran says
1:08the Bible's preserved, but I'm just
1:09saying, if you admit the Bible is
1:11preserved, then that means Muhammad
1:14cannot be a true prophet because
1:15Muhammad contradicts the Bible. So, then
1:18what do you have to say? Oh, you changed
1:19the Bible. Okay, let's say the Bible is
1:21changed. That doesn't mean Islam is true
1:23because then I'm left with maybe I
1:24should become Mormon. So, that still
1:26doesn't mean that Islam is true. But
1:29you're asking me
1:30>> historical things.
1:32>> The Quran makes claims about history is
1:33not true. One big
1:35>> The former one I know. I mean like the I
1:38watched this one documentary by Tom
1:40Holland, you know him?
1:41>> Yes, you see you study. So, Tom Holland
1:43did an investigation as an atheist. He's
1:45not a Christian.
1:46>> Yeah, yeah.
1:46>> And he saw the evidence outside of
1:49Islamic sources. The archaeological
1:50evidence and the written sources that
1:53are not written by Muslims from later
1:55time do not confirm Islamic history. So,
1:58again, since it doesn't have any strong
2:01proof confirming its claims, but we when
2:04we when we can test the Quran for
2:06history, it's wrong. I give you example.
2:07How do you interpret Surat An-Nisa 4:157
2:10where it says the Jews boasted they
2:12boasted, "We killed Jesus Messiah, son
2:14of Mary, the apostle of Allah." But then
2:16it says they neither killed him nor
2:17crucified him. But it's all cleared up.
2:19What does that mean?
2:19>> I want to hold that for a little bit. I
2:21know like in Islam they believe that
2:22Jesus was not crucified.
2:24>> So, if he's not crucified, is there any
2:27historian, even Bart Ehrman, who doesn't
2:29believe in Christianity?
2:31>> a lot of Bart Ehrman video, and yes, he
2:33not agree with Islam. I yes, I just
2:35>> I don't think he doesn't agree with
2:36Islam. Is there any historian that says
2:39Jesus was not killed? The one fact they
2:41all agree on, they go, "One fact we
2:44agree on is Jesus was killed by
2:46crucifixion." That that they say we all
2:49agree.
2:49>> I asked a lot of people, "Why do God
2:53wait 500 years to reveal that Jesus was
2:56not crucified?" And I don't get an
2:57answer.
2:57>> You don't [clears throat] get an answer
2:58to that.
2:59>> They say that Allah wait the perfect
3:00time to reveal the revelation when
3:02people like really deviate from the
3:04original Islam, that kind of thing.
3:06>> Let's see how perfect time is. So, Allah
3:08allowed for 500 years people to be
3:11deceived and confused thinking Jesus was
3:14killed and raised from the dead. And so,
3:17hundreds of thousands, if not millions,
3:19died believing Jesus was killed and
3:21raised from dead, and that was the
3:22perfect time to come 500 years later to
3:24solve the mess.
3:26>> Yes, I I I I don't get the answer for
3:28that question actually.
3:29>> Now, I want to show you a verse in the
3:31Quran, and I want to show you Paul.
3:32Remember, they say, "Paul, he's the bad
3:33guy. Paul, he's he's Antichrist." But
3:35Paul is better than Muhammad. Paul, who
3:37wasn't married, told husbands how to be
3:39with their wives. Muhammad, who was
3:40married, he didn't know how to treat his
3:42wives equally. That's why they always
3:43complain, didn't they? Didn't the wives
3:45of Muhammad complain? "You're spending
3:46too much time with Aisha. You're not
3:47giving enough time for all of us."
3:49>> Yes.
3:49>> And what What his excuse? Because I'm
3:51going to shock some people. they're
3:52going to think no way. In the sound
3:53Hadith, it says when Muhammad would go
3:55to visit Aisha, she had two days, not
3:57just one. Do you know why?
3:58>> Oh, because Sauda he divorce
4:00>> Astaghfirullah, you know all this and
4:01you're still Muslim. Okay, Sauda bint
4:03Zama
4:03>> Yes, he divorce her.
4:04>> Why he divorce her?
4:06>> Because
4:06he was old.
4:07>> You just admitted she was old and then
4:09one Hadith says she was fat and he
4:11wasn't attracted to her. So he wanted to
4:12divorce her and then she begged him,
4:13"Don't divorce me. Keep me as your wife,
4:15but you can take my day and give it to
4:17Aisha." And Muhammad accepted and Allah
4:18accepted. What kind of God is this that
4:20sees Muhammad about to divorce an old
4:22woman that he married cuz she was old
4:24and fat and he was not attracted instead
4:26of rebuking Muhammad. Why didn't Allah
4:28rebuke Muhammad? "Hey, shame on you.
4:30That's not how you treat her. She's your
4:31wife." Instead Allah says, "Subhanallah,
4:34if that's an agreement she accepts, go
4:38with it." Allah actually blessed that
4:40agreement, made it an ayah in the Quran,
4:41chapter 4 verse 128.
4:43>> Yes, it's really sad.
4:44>> You know that, right?
4:45>> Yes, I know.
4:46>> The woman is old, he's not attracted to
4:48her, he wants to divorce her. So she
4:50makes a deal with him. She says,
4:51"Please, I want to be one of your wives
4:53in Jannah." Cuz she was deceived.
4:55>> Mhm.
4:55>> "If you divorce me, I won't be your wife
4:57in Jannah. Keep me as your wife so in
4:58Jannah I'm your wife, but you don't have
5:00to visit me." You know that means,
5:01right? Because the Christians don't know
5:03It means Sauda was locked in her house
5:06without Muhammad ever visiting her until
5:08she died. This is mercy?
5:11>> No. You know, last year I was really sad
5:15because I just realized that Islam is
5:19really bad. You know when like the
5:21Islamic marriage law, I don't want the
5:22marriage when my husband can be
5:24everything. It's really sad to be a
5:25woman, I think.
5:27>> Yep, but that's good. God is showing you
5:29Allah is a false God and there's a
5:30better way, his name is Jesus. But I
5:31want to show you another way. Paul, who
5:33wasn't married, right?
5:34>> Yes.
5:35>> And the Muslims talk about how bad Paul
5:36was. Yet you see, the words I read to
5:38you was Paul's words. The words of Paul
5:40was not married. Do you have anything as
5:42beautiful as compassion and mercy of
5:44what Paul wrote about husbands and
5:45wives?
5:46>> No.
5:46>> Do you find that in the Quran?
5:47>> No.
5:48>> How is it Paul has better teaching, more
5:51merciful, compassionate teaching, and
5:53shows more love and respect for women,
5:54and he's not married than your Quran and
5:55your prophet? And he's supposedly
5:57receiving wahy. Your wives are a tilt
5:59for you. Are you okay with this verse?
6:00You are my field and I can plow into
6:02you.
6:03>> It is actually sad.
6:04>> Are you sure? Because this is Allah and
6:05his messenger. What Allah and his
6:07messenger decree, the believing man and
6:09woman have no say so. That's what the
6:10Quran says. The Quran says you have no
6:12say so. So, why are you complaining?
6:14Because you're not a Muslim at heart.
6:15You are who's falling in love with
6:17Jesus. It is not for a believer, man or
6:19woman, when Allah and his messenger have
6:21decreed a matter that they should have
6:22any option in their decision. So,
6:24why are you complaining? You have no
6:25choice. Whoever disobeys Allah and his
6:27messenger, he has indeed strayed in a
6:28plain error. So, why are you complaining
6:31that Allah says you are a field, a
6:33field, and the man owns you like a
6:35field. So, if I have field, it's mine. I
6:37don't know I know I own it. It means
6:39you're property. A man owns you. You are
6:40property. The Quran is saying, "Men, the
6:43women are your field.
6:46Plow into them into them any way you
6:47want. They don't have a say so."
6:49>> I talked to a lot of people in you know,
6:52in Twitter that
6:53Islamic law is not fair to woman. And
6:56they always say, "Oh, this is like a
6:58test." Because they are like one hadith
7:00say that
7:00>> Very testy.
7:01>> Um any woman that pray, uh fasting, obey
7:05the man, going to enter heaven paradise.
7:07Any Do you you know that hadith?
7:09>> Yes, yeah. But this says that the Jannah
7:11of woman lay at the pleasure of their
7:13husbands. If a husband So, do you have
7:15your Jannah? So, that means your
7:17salvation is dependent on a husband
7:18being happy with you.
7:19>> Yeah, that's why I say, "Why do Islam
7:22Why do I need to go to heaven based on
7:23my husband?"
7:25>> Oh, sister, astaghfirullah. Hold on.
7:27A'uzubillah. What did the Quran say?
7:29It's not for a man or a woman who are
7:31believers once Allah and his messenger
7:33decreed a thing to have any option. Why
7:35are you complaining? Ya kafirah.
7:37>> I know.
7:39>> It's right there.
7:40Ya kafirah. I'm giving you Quran. It is
7:43not for a believer man or woman when
7:44Allah and his messenger have decreed a
7:45matter that they should have any option
7:47in their decision. Why are you
7:48complaining? You are now kafira. But
7:50now, which what look what Paul says.
7:52First Corinthians 7:1-5. Now concerning
7:54the things about which you wrote, it is
7:56good for a man not to touch a woman.
7:57Meaning, it's good if you don't get
7:59married as long as you don't burn.
8:00Devote yourself entirely to worship and
8:02spreading the deen. But because of
8:03sexual immoralities, too much
8:05temptation, each man is to have his own
8:07wife and each woman is to have her own
8:08husband. Now, how many husbands can a
8:10woman have according to the Paul? Paul's
8:14teaching which is from Jesus. How many?
8:15>> One.
8:16>> How many wives does a man have? Only
8:18one.
8:20In the Old Testament, God allowed a lot
8:22of things that he did not like. Now what
8:24Jesus says, "No. We're going to now do
8:27it the way God intended originally. When
8:30God created the first couple, did he
8:31create one man and three women? One man
8:33or four women? Or one man and one
8:35woman?"
8:35>> One man and one woman.
8:36>> So that means it tells you that God's
8:38design from the beginning was one man
8:40one woman, right?
8:41>> Yes.
8:41>> And that's what Jesus came to say. "I'm
8:43taking you back to the way it was. God
8:46allowed a lot of evil, a lot of
8:49immorality cuz people were very corrupt
8:52and sinful and couldn't do any better.
8:54Now I'm telling you we're going back to
8:56the way it was before evil, before sin.
8:59One man one woman. Just like a woman can
9:01only have one husband, a man can only
9:03have one wife." But now watch the
9:04fairness from a man who's never been
9:07married. "The husband must fulfill his
9:08duty to his wife. And likewise also the
9:11wife to her husband. The wife does not
9:13have authority over her own body, but
9:14the husband does." But now watch. "And
9:16likewise also the husband does not have
9:18authority over his own body, but the
9:20wife does." Do you get any more fair
9:21than this?
9:22>> No.
9:22>> How can Muhammad be an example for other
9:25people to marry the divorced wives of
9:26their adopted sons? Cuz that's what the
9:28ayah says. We'll come back. That's what
9:30the ayah says. It says, "You're doing
9:32this to be an example." Example for for
9:35here? "We joined her in marriage to the
9:37in order that in future there may be no
9:40difficulty to the believers in the
9:41matter of marriage with the wives of
9:43their adopted sons. So, what is he
9:44saying? You're an example so others can
9:46do the same thing if they want to.
9:48Okay, so you see it here, right?
9:51>> Yeah.
9:52>> My question is Allah knows everything,
9:54right?
9:55>> Yeah.
9:55>> According to them. Okay, well, Allah is
9:58saying this is why you're doing it
9:59Muhammad because then others will see
10:03they can marry the wives of their
10:06adopted sons there's no difficulty once
10:07a divorce has taken place.
10:09But then Allah knew he's going to
10:10abolish adoption.
10:12Because that's what he did afterwards.
10:13So, why have Muhammad marry his adopted
10:16son's wife after he divorced her when he
10:18knows shortly after this he's going to
10:20abolish adoption and this won't be an
10:22example for anyone cuz you can't have
10:23adopted sons.
10:25>> And they say
10:27that's an example because
10:29you can have feelings for her. So, this
10:31is the example that you can have
10:33feelings for her.
10:34>> [clears throat]
10:34>> Allah is saying later no more adoption,
10:37they're not your sons. He says the
10:39reason why I'm having Muhammad marry her
10:42so that others can marry the divorced
10:44wives of their adopted sons. Right here
10:46it says it. How then is this going to be
10:48an example if now later oh, they're not
10:51your adopted sons. Okay, so hold on but
10:54Muhammad married her so that I could
10:56then marry the divorced wife of one of
10:58my adopted son.
11:00But now you're telling me there's no
11:01adoption so he's not my son and then on
11:02top of that the son has to leave the
11:04house cuz you know about mahram, right?
11:06>> Yeah.
11:07>> So, if I adopted a son and now he's a
11:09man because he's considered my son, he's
11:12mahram he can stay with my wife
11:14and my daughter, right?
11:16>> Yeah.
11:17>> But now
11:19Allah says no more adoption, he's not
11:20your son. He's now got to get thrown
11:22out.
11:24He can't stay because he's not mahram.
11:27He can't be in the house with my wife
11:29and daughter anymore.
11:30Oops.
11:31Now they got to get thrown out.
11:33>> Yeah.
11:35>> Right?
11:36>> Right.
11:36>> So, what kind of law and logic is this?
11:39Because it caused a problem for one of
11:42the Muslims, and I'll show it to you.
11:45One of the Muslims, he had adopted a son
11:47living in the house, and now he's a
11:48grown man.
11:50He had a beard.
11:51Then Allah said in the Quran, chapter
11:5333, verses 4 and 5,
11:56"They are not your sons. Call them after
11:58their fathers." He abolished adoption.
12:00And the mufassirin, the commentators
12:02say, "This is because of the incident of
12:04Zaid." They were calling him Zaid ibn
12:06Muhammad, and they're saying, "How could
12:07you take your son's
12:09wife?" Then Allah said, "Don't call them
12:12your sons anymore." Chapter 33, verse 4
12:14and 5, "God has not made for any man two
12:15hearts in one body, nor has he made your
12:17wives, whom you divorce by zihar, your
12:19mothers. Nor has he made your adopted
12:21sons your sons.
12:23Such is only your manner of speech by
12:24your mouths, but God tells you the
12:26truth, and he shows the right way. Call
12:28them by the name of their fathers. That
12:30is just in the sight of Allah of God.
12:32But if you know not their fathers'
12:34names, they're brothers."
12:36That's is when Allah said, "No more
12:37adoption."
12:38"Or your mawlas, but there's no blame on
12:40you if you make a mistake therein.
12:42What counts is the intention of your
12:43hearts, your niya, and God is
12:44oft-returning, most merciful." Because
12:46of this, a Muslim man
12:49was now uncomfortable because he adopted
12:52a son, Salim,
12:55and he was grown, but now he's no longer
12:57a son, and he was now uncomfortable with
12:59him living in the house with his wife
13:01because he's not mahram. I want you,
13:03after I I read this to you, go in the
13:05Quran, find me something similar to
13:08this. Just you between you and God.
13:10Here's Jesus speaking. Let me show you
13:12what Jesus says. And I want you to go in
13:14the Quran and say, "Man, can I find
13:16something like this, such promise and
13:19hope?" Here, Matthew 11:27-30, "All
13:22things have been handed over to me by my
13:24father."
13:25According to Quran, Allah is not the
13:27father of Jesus. That's another story.
13:29No one knows the son except the father,
13:31and no one knows the father except the
13:32son.
13:33And anyone to whom the son decides to
13:35reveal him. Now, look, this is Jesus
13:36speaking. Come to me,
13:39all you who are weary and burdened, and
13:42I will give you rest. Salaam.
13:45That's why we say salaam al Masih.
13:48Take my yoke on you and learn from me,
13:51because I am gentle,
13:54humble in heart, and you'll find rest
13:56for your souls. For my yoke is easy to
13:59bear, and my load is not hard to carry.
14:02Please, do me a favor. Next time when we
14:03meet, say, "Sam, I found an ayah like
14:05this that sounds as beautiful like
14:07this." And then the final one.
14:09John 14, verses 1 to 6.
14:12John 14, verses 1 to 6. Do not let your
14:15hearts be distressed. You believe in
14:17God, believe also in me. Now, who's the
14:18God?
14:20There are many dwelling places in my
14:22father's [snorts] house. God is my
14:24father.
14:25Otherwise, I would have told you,
14:26because I'm going away to make ready a
14:28place for you. Now, look at his promise.
14:30You will believe in me, I'm preparing a
14:32place for you in Jannah.
14:35I'm going to build you a home in Jannah.
14:38I I'm going to do it.
14:40I.
14:41Okay? And if I go and make ready a place
14:43for you, I will come again and take you
14:46to be with me, so that where I am, you
14:48may be too. So, he's promising.
14:50When death comes, and you believe in me,
14:53I will be the one to bring you to your
14:56home in heaven, cuz at death, I will
14:58come and meet you and take you home.
15:01And you know the way where I'm going.
15:02Now, watch. Thomas said, "Lord, we don't
15:05know where you're going. How can we know
15:06the way?"
15:07So, if you're praying sincerely, here's
15:09your answer. When you pray, Allah guide
15:11you sirat al mustaqim,
15:13Jesus says, "You don't need to look.
15:15It's me." Jesus replied, "I am the way,
15:19al tariq.
15:21And the truth, al haqq. And by the way,
15:24one of the 99 names of Allah is Al-Haqq.
15:26Al-Haqq?
15:27Nowhere in the Quran Hadith
15:29the words Al-Haqq is given to anyone but
15:32Allah, not even to your prophet.
15:34Jesus says,
15:35Anil Haqq, I am the truth and the life.
15:39I am the life.
15:41Al-
15:43Hayat
15:44Nowhere in the Quran and Sunnah
15:46does any prophet say he's a life. Jesus
15:49says, I am the way, the truth, and the
15:50life. No one comes to the Father except
15:52through me. So, Jesus says,
15:55"You want God to be your father? You
15:56need to come to me and I'll take you
15:58home to your father. But in Islam, Allah
16:01is not your father, he's your master and
16:02you're his slave. In Jesus, God is your
16:05father and Jesus is the one who gives
16:07you life and takes you home cuz he is
16:09the way."

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Muslim Girl Question's Sam Shamoun about Islam by Faith Defended, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,443 words across 526 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.