Mountain View City Council Candidate Forum October 2024 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:14okay think we'll
- 0:17go okay good evening everyone if
- 0:21everyone could please take their seats
- 0:22we'll get
- 0:25started we're here for the Mountain View
- 0:27city council candidate for um and um
- 0:31I'll first take a few minutes to review
- 0:33the rules and procedures um in the
- 0:35meantime does anyone have any
- 0:38questions
- 0:41okay I'm Jan pepper and I will be the
- 0:44moderator for this evening's Forum all
- 0:47of you candidates reviewed and signed
- 0:49the League of Women Voters ground rules
- 0:51and most importantly everyone will treat
- 0:54each other with respect and candidates
- 0:56will not interrupt each other our timer
- 1:01right over here we'll use a phone to set
- 1:04each segment of time and then hold up a
- 1:07yellow paddle when 15 seconds are left
- 1:10and a red stop sign when time has
- 1:13expired at that time I will say thank
- 1:16you you may finish your sentence and
- 1:19then we will move on to the next
- 1:20candidate or next
- 1:22question are there any questions about
- 1:24the format or
- 1:27procedures okay and I um have verified
- 1:32the pronunciation of your names but um I
- 1:36will I will go over that in a moment
- 1:41um so I'd like to welcome the candidates
- 1:43and the audience members to the Mountain
- 1:45View city council candidate Forum um I
- 1:49am with the League of Women Voters Los
- 1:50Altos Mountain View and am today's
- 1:53moderator first a few housekeeping items
- 1:56our Forum will last 90 minutes and is be
- 1:59being record recorded by
- 2:02kmvt all League forums will be recorded
- 2:05and available on our elections page at
- 2:09lwv
- 2:11lamv League of Women Voters Los Altos
- 2:14Mountain view.org about two days after
- 2:17each event as well as on our YouTube
- 2:20channel through a link on our
- 2:22website we would like to thank the
- 2:24Mountain View voice for co-sponsoring
- 2:26today's forum and there are some members
- 2:28of The Voice staff in the audience
- 2:30tonight including voice editor Karen
- 2:33Kevin
- 2:35forestieri can you raise your hand there
- 2:37he is okay and Clay
- 2:39Lambert okay the peninsula uh Clay is
- 2:44the peninsula editorial director for the
- 2:46nonprofit parent company of the voice
- 2:48and its siblings so other voice staff if
- 2:51you're here could you please raise your
- 2:54hands great thank you for being here
- 2:57they have helped to spread the word
- 2:59about tonight's forum and suggested
- 3:01questions to ask kmvt is also a
- 3:05co-sponsor tonight thank you Josh Jim
- 3:08and Jacob for recording it so that
- 3:10voters can watch it
- 3:12later questions for candidates were
- 3:14submitted in advance by community
- 3:16members League members and Mountain View
- 3:18voice staff similar questions were
- 3:21combined to maximize the topics covered
- 3:24the League of Women Voters is a
- 3:26nonprofit organization of all genders
- 3:29that promotes informed active
- 3:31participation in government we do not
- 3:33support oppose or evaluate political
- 3:37political candidates or parties but
- 3:40after careful study we do take positions
- 3:43on some political issues the league
- 3:46invites anyone who is interested in
- 3:47supporting democracy and local
- 3:49government to join us you will find easy
- 3:52voter guides lists of our forums voter
- 3:55registration forms and other helpful
- 3:58information at the league table in the
- 4:01back of the room back there now a little
- 4:04bit about Mountain View and this office
- 4:07that these candidates are vying for
- 4:10Mountain View's population has grown to
- 4:12about 81,000 economically and ethnically
- 4:15diverse residents the city council has
- 4:18seven members you may vote for four of
- 4:21these nine candidates in this year's
- 4:24election ballots were mailed October 7th
- 4:26so you may already have yours here is
- 4:29the format for today's Forum each
- 4:32candidate will make a two-minute opening
- 4:34statement we've asked them to include
- 4:36the qualifications experience and
- 4:38strengths that make them well suited to
- 4:41this office questions were selected to
- 4:43be relevant to all candidates and to
- 4:45provide useful information to the
- 4:47audience about issues in this race
- 4:50candidates will have one minute to
- 4:52answer each question finally the
- 4:55candidates will each have one minute to
- 4:56make a closing statement our timer will
- 4:59signal to each candidate when 15 seconds
- 5:02remains and when time has expired we ask
- 5:05our candidates to abide by the following
- 5:08first speaking order this will be
- 5:10rotated so each candidate will have at
- 5:12least one chance to speak first and last
- 5:15I will read the order before each
- 5:17question time limits when the stop sign
- 5:20is held up I will say thank you and
- 5:22candidates May complete their current
- 5:24sentence respect candidates will not
- 5:27interrupt each other and fairness
- 5:30campaign marketing materials will not be
- 5:32worn or visitable in the room now I
- 5:35would like to introduce an alphabetical
- 5:37order the nine candidates who are
- 5:39running for Mountain View city
- 5:41council Chris
- 5:43Clark Devin
- 5:46Conley Jose
- 5:48Gutierrez Nicholas
- 5:51haras John
- 5:54McAllister Eric
- 5:58pone Emily Le
- 6:00Ramos Pat
- 6:03Showalter Ida Rose
- 6:05Sylvester thank you all for
- 6:07participating in today's Forum we are
- 6:10now ready to
- 6:11begin so we will first start with
- 6:13opening statements you each have two
- 6:15minutes and we will go in the following
- 6:17order Emily Chris Nicholas Devon Jose
- 6:24John Ida Rose Eric Pat
- 6:29Emily go ahead Oh yay it's on um hi my
- 6:34name is Emily Anne Ramos and I have the
- 6:36privilege of being your city council
- 6:38member for the past two years um and now
- 6:41I'm running for a full term I was
- 6:43honored to be appointed uh when a
- 6:45vacancy appeared um in that time uh we
- 6:49passed a strong housing element uh which
- 6:53also made Mountain the city of Mountain
- 6:55View uh the only city in Santa Clara
- 6:57County to receive the pro housing
- 6:58designation from the state um we pass a
- 7:02a very strong economic Vitality strategy
- 7:05and a wildlife strategic plan so that we
- 7:07can uh help protect our environment
- 7:09especially in the areas of such as North
- 7:11Bayshore uh where uh precious uh
- 7:15precious creatures like our burrowing
- 7:16owls are are staying um I'm focused on
- 7:22uh housing affordability climate
- 7:24resilience and Civic engagement in my
- 7:26day job uh I worked at a housing
- 7:29advocacy organization uh focus on
- 7:31policies to address displacement which
- 7:34are tenant protections and preservation
- 7:36of affordable housing uh through that
- 7:38job I'm able to see what other cities
- 7:40are doing to address the displacement
- 7:42issue that is facing us on a regional
- 7:44level um I hope to earn your vote uh on
- 7:49or by November 5th um I uh am excited to
- 7:54hear the great ideas of my colleagues
- 7:57and my fellow candidates um and we are
- 8:00EXC I'm excited to do that with the
- 8:02League of Women Voters which I am
- 8:04honored to be a member of League of
- 8:05Women Voters and an active member in the
- 8:07affordable housing committee for the
- 8:09League of Women Voters so thank you uh
- 8:12so much for this opportunity to uh share
- 8:15our hopes and dreams of what we have for
- 8:18our city and I once again I hope to uh
- 8:22earn your support indorsement and
- 8:24passion for our race thank you thank you
- 8:27Emily Chris
- 8:30well good evening everyone I'm Chris
- 8:31Clark uh and I've served Mountain View
- 8:33for 15 of the 17 years that I've lived
- 8:35here including eight years on our city
- 8:37council and seven years on our
- 8:38commissions I also had the honor of
- 8:40serving as Mountain views mayor and vice
- 8:42mayor during my time on the council I
- 8:44earned a reputation as a pragmatic
- 8:46consensus Builder who worked closely
- 8:48with my colleagues to get things done we
- 8:50balanced our budgets even during the
- 8:52toughest of times and permitted
- 8:54thousands of new housing units including
- 8:56subsidized uh units for our teachers and
- 8:58First Responders we also raised our
- 9:00minimum wage supported our renters and
- 9:02working families during covid prepared
- 9:05for climate change added nearly a dozen
- 9:07new parks and renovated the beautiful
- 9:09facility that we're stated in this
- 9:10evening I'm proud of our accomplishments
- 9:13but there's still much work left to do
- 9:15we have two longtime Mountain View
- 9:17council members Ching out of office this
- 9:18year and three more in
- 9:202026 so we need to elect experienced
- 9:23candidates who will provide a healthy
- 9:24level of continuity while we also
- 9:26welcome new
- 9:27leadership I have the experience
- 9:29necessary to hit the ground running and
- 9:31maintain our reputation as a well-run
- 9:33city that values its residents
- 9:34neighborhoods small businesses and most
- 9:36importantly fact-based
- 9:38decision-making in addition to
- 9:40experience what sets me apart is my
- 9:42breath of support I'm endorsed by our
- 9:44congresswoman Anna ESU both of our state
- 9:46lawmakers our County Supervisor Joe
- 9:48sidian and many former mayors and
- 9:50residents who span the political
- 9:51spectrum they support me because they
- 9:54know I work hard listen to all
- 9:55perspectives and value sound
- 9:57policymaking over politics with nine
- 10:00candidates I know you face a tough
- 10:01decision about who to elect as you
- 10:03evaluate us tonight please keep in mind
- 10:05that you can vote for up to four of us
- 10:07to best represent you in uncertain times
- 10:10I look forward to our conversation and
- 10:11hope to earn your support this
- 10:13evening thank you Chris
- 10:16Nicholas good evening everyone my name
- 10:19is Nicholas haras and I'm proud to be
- 10:21your candidate for Mountain View city
- 10:23council thank you to the League of Women
- 10:25Voters and the Mountain View voice as
- 10:28well as kmv for hosting us these three
- 10:31organizations are at the heart of
- 10:34mountain views
- 10:35democracy so what does the Mountain View
- 10:38of tomorrow look like to me it's a place
- 10:41to call home with safe neighborhoods
- 10:44built around beautiful Parks Economic
- 10:47Opportunity and lifelong
- 10:49friendship I grew up locally graduating
- 10:52from St Francis High School today I'm
- 10:56proud to be a senior field
- 10:57representative for Congress woman Anna
- 10:59ESU cutting through bureaucracy for
- 11:02Mountain View
- 11:04residents my guiding principles are
- 11:06Equitable growth Public Safety
- 11:09sustainability and Community well-being
- 11:13we must take on the High Cost of Living
- 11:16by making it less costly for homeowners
- 11:18to renovate and strengthening renter
- 11:21protections we can tackle inequality by
- 11:25building affordable housing for our
- 11:27vulnerable populations including cling
- 11:29seniors large families and people with
- 11:33disabilities Public Safety is the most
- 11:36important service a government provides
- 11:38we need to continue supporting our
- 11:40police and fire
- 11:42departments tackling climate change
- 11:45requires bold
- 11:47leadership transportation makes up 60%
- 11:51of our carbon emissions let's build a
- 11:54city-wide EV charging Network and make
- 11:57our public transit more efficient
- 12:00and our roads sidewalks and bike Lanes
- 12:03need to be better maintained the Common
- 12:06Thread that unites my policy is
- 12:08community well-being that's why I'm
- 12:10focused on expanding Child Care
- 12:13developing a lowincome laundry
- 12:15assistance program and banning the sale
- 12:17of ecigarettes thank you Nicholas Devon
- 12:22thank you good evening my name is Devon
- 12:24connley and I'm the current president of
- 12:26the Mountain View wisman School Board
- 12:28I'd like to thank the league of voters
- 12:29as well as kmvt and the Mountain View
- 12:32voice for putting on this forum tonight
- 12:33and giving us the opportunity to talk
- 12:35about the future of our city I am
- 12:37running for city council because I
- 12:39believe that familyfriendly City
- 12:41Planning benefits not just Children and
- 12:43Families but all of Mountain View I
- 12:46moved to Mountain View about 18 years
- 12:48ago and since then I have taught and
- 12:50volunteered in our Public Schools served
- 12:52on our Parks and Recreation Commission
- 12:55and I was elected to the school board in
- 12:562018
- 12:59I have a master's in City Planning from
- 13:01UC Berkeley a degree in architecture
- 13:03from Yale and a master's in education
- 13:05from Stanford and over the last 22 years
- 13:08I've spent my career working directly
- 13:09with Children and Families at the
- 13:11intersection of education and City
- 13:15policy I love serving on our public
- 13:17school board but every day I see where
- 13:20the needs of our students extend beyond
- 13:21the classroom and are tied to our larger
- 13:24communities well-being from housing to
- 13:26Transportation parks to sustainability
- 13:29my priorities for a familyfriendly
- 13:32Mountain View include creating thriving
- 13:35neighborhoods prioritizing Public safy
- 13:38Safety and ensuring a healthy
- 13:41Community with my unique perspective as
- 13:44a former teacher and a parent now in our
- 13:46Public School District my expertise in
- 13:49City Planning and architecture and my
- 13:52experiments my experience passing and
- 13:54getting policies implemented as a
- 13:56Schoolboard member I know I could serve
- 13:58our community well I'm honored to be
- 14:01endorsed by congresswoman Anna ASU and
- 14:03our County Supervisor Joe sidian as well
- 14:05as the Mountain View police officers and
- 14:07firefighters the dean Democratic Club of
- 14:10Silicon Valley and Mountain View
- 14:13yimi I would be honored to earn your
- 14:15vote this evening and you can learn more
- 14:18about my campaign at Devon conley. comom
- 14:21thank you thank you Devon
- 14:25Jose good evening everyone I'm Jose Gus
- 14:27Jr and many of you know me as a former
- 14:30soccer coach I've been involved in as an
- 14:32IO soccer coach for I don't know about
- 14:3410 years I coached my daughters I want
- 14:36to thank my daughter Grace Gutierrez
- 14:38who's my campaign manager you're doing a
- 14:39great job and Alena Gutierrez director
- 14:41of media and social relations perfect I
- 14:44I I thank you for everything this has
- 14:46been a journey for us and a family
- 14:48adventure but more importantly we want
- 14:50to make a difference in the community in
- 14:522015 I was appointed to a school board
- 14:54that was chaotic 2016 I was reelected to
- 14:56that position from 2016 2020 I Serv with
- 14:59the honorable Bill Lambert and Ellen
- 15:00Wheeler at the end of that we were
- 15:02effective organized and together we were
- 15:05able to get things done we brought
- 15:07districtwide solutions to districtwide
- 15:09problems at the time we had a vision for
- 15:10what a portrait of a graduate would look
- 15:12like and we made it happen we had
- 15:14successful results for reclassifications
- 15:15of our English language learning
- 15:16students we realized that that standard
- 15:19of the test was too hard and Beyond the
- 15:21expectations of what any child should be
- 15:23able to pass because it was unfair so we
- 15:25rooted that systemic bias out and
- 15:27replaced it with something that was
- 15:28moreal Arian so that everyone could
- 15:29succeed and have a fair shot at success
- 15:31and academics that's what it's all about
- 15:34with me problem solving responsibility
- 15:36accountability I'm high energy I don't
- 15:39settle for the status quo I'm your
- 15:41outside
- 15:42candidate with me I like to push a
- 15:44little bit because I want to give back
- 15:46what I can together by creating a moment
- 15:49where we have a difference of opinion to
- 15:51be a moment where we can build something
- 15:53better together that's how we were able
- 15:55to negotiate with the city to create
- 15:57teacher housing our board was functional
- 15:59and organized enough to get that done we
- 16:01had balanced budgets we worked with city
- 16:03council we were effective and in 2020 we
- 16:05passed the bond to finally pay off
- 16:06school the school teacher housing
- 16:08project now we have teachers moving in
- 16:10in 20 I think in early next year in
- 16:12January that's what I'm about effective
- 16:14change as your Vice chair for the
- 16:16environmental Planning Commission I hope
- 16:18to serve at the next level at city
- 16:19council and I can't wait to hear the
- 16:20ideas of my fellow candidates here thank
- 16:22you very much thank you Jose John thank
- 16:26thank you good evening every everyone
- 16:29I'm John mallister I'm running for city
- 16:31council because I believe in continuing
- 16:33improve the lives of mountain residents
- 16:35through pratic thoughtful leadership
- 16:38I've had the privilege of calling Mount
- 16:39View home for many years my journey
- 16:42started when my dad moved up here to
- 16:43work for locked I've been deeply
- 16:45invested not just as a resident but as a
- 16:47business owner for over 22 years in fact
- 16:50I am the Mount View chamber business
- 16:52person of the year I'm proud to say I'm
- 16:54the only candidate running who has owned
- 16:56a business in this community as a of
- 16:59premium ice
- 17:03cream pause I've learned firsthand what
- 17:06it takes to build something successfully
- 17:08from the ground up by business degree
- 17:10from UC Berkeley H School of Business
- 17:13and having a certified public accountant
- 17:16uh certificate have sharp shaped my
- 17:18approach to solving problems I've always
- 17:21sted to be pragmatic fair and committed
- 17:23to finding the best solutions for
- 17:25Mountain View over the past 20 years
- 17:27I've had the honor of serving you as
- 17:28your mayor vice mayor city council
- 17:31member chair of the Performing Arts
- 17:33environmental Planning Commission PTA
- 17:35treasure and schoolside Council in that
- 17:38time I've proven my ability to lead
- 17:41always focusing on what's best for our
- 17:43community whether it's ensuring the city
- 17:46was fiscally responsible during
- 17:48challenging times or advocating for key
- 17:50issues like affordable housing Public
- 17:53Safety and Open Spaces I'm here today
- 17:56because Mountain View needs experience
- 17:58level-headed leadership especially with
- 18:00two senior council members triming out I
- 18:02bring that leadership and a deep
- 18:04understanding of how to think how to get
- 18:05things done for our city thank you thank
- 18:08you John Ida Rose good evening I'm Ida
- 18:12Rose Sylvester and I'm very excited to
- 18:14be here tonight it's an honor to talk to
- 18:16you about my experience and my
- 18:18qualifications that will help me be an
- 18:20excellent city council member in the
- 18:21city I love and have called home for 25
- 18:24years I have served on two advisory
- 18:26bodies for several years including the
- 18:29human relations commission and the
- 18:30environmental sustainability task force
- 18:33in both of these roles I got big things
- 18:35done including a multi-year study on the
- 18:37history of housing discrimination in our
- 18:39city and policy recommendations that are
- 18:41now enacted for our climate future I'm
- 18:44also a city of uh Mountain viw mediator
- 18:47and I created an Innovative nonprofit in
- 18:49the midst of the pandemic called
- 18:50appetite for good we simultaneously
- 18:52saved businesses while alleviating food
- 18:55insecurity in our
- 18:56city I also lead on the board of
- 18:59multiple nonprofits which give me a
- 19:01unique lens through various aspects of
- 19:03our city including CSA chck the
- 19:07historical Association the Coalition for
- 19:10sustainable planning and carbon-free
- 19:12Mountain
- 19:13View from this experience I gained
- 19:16several qualifications including
- 19:17in-depth knowledge about our community
- 19:19from a policy perspective on housing
- 19:22climate our social needs our
- 19:24neighborhood needs zoning history and
- 19:27Design I also have a depth of knowledge
- 19:30about the people in our community its
- 19:32cultures organizations our business
- 19:35leaders and even our city staff which
- 19:37I've had the honor to work very closely
- 19:39with and I had proof that I can solve
- 19:42big problems like I did with my
- 19:44nonprofit I have a Relentless purs
- 19:47passion for the pursuit of justice and
- 19:49for solutions that serve all of our
- 19:51residents now and for those who come in
- 19:53the future and I have a depth of
- 19:55relationships that will make me
- 19:56successful I'm well known well regarded
- 19:59and trusted endorsements that back me up
- 20:01include the Democratic party Sierra Club
- 20:04and the Los Altos town crier thank you
- 20:08thank you ader Rose
- 20:10Eric good evening everyone uh thank you
- 20:12all so much for coming here uh tonight
- 20:15uh whoops can y'all hear me okay okay
- 20:18perfect uh my name is Eric Bon and the
- 20:21reason why I'm running for Mountain View
- 20:23city council it's because I believe that
- 20:25no single mother no working family or
- 20:27child should ever feel the fear of being
- 20:30displaced in a city they've grown to
- 20:31love I was raised by a single mother of
- 20:33four and know the atrocities or what
- 20:36it's like to struggle just to keep a
- 20:38roof over your head and it's what
- 20:40compelled me to dedicate my life to
- 20:41serving families just like mine some of
- 20:44the work I've done here locally in malie
- 20:46has been being your uh covid-19 positive
- 20:49relief team lead U at the height of the
- 20:52pandemic making sure not only that
- 20:54families were fed but ensuring they were
- 20:56housed providing a rental assistance
- 20:58programs wherever they were needed um I
- 21:01also during the 2020 census fought
- 21:03misinformation against Trump making sure
- 21:06that not only our community members were
- 21:08counted but our most vulnerable
- 21:10community members our undocumented
- 21:11members were counted because they were
- 21:13fearful of being that signing a sentus
- 21:17was a death sentence for them um now I
- 21:20have the privilege of serving as your
- 21:22human relations commissioner where I'll
- 21:23be leading projects with uh in
- 21:26partnership with the county making our
- 21:28community much more aware about uh
- 21:30deepening our relationships with our
- 21:32queer community members and also raising
- 21:34awareness of how we can um be more
- 21:37readily prepared especially our most
- 21:38vulnerable community members when
- 21:40natural disasters happen what I bring to
- 21:43the table is really compassionate
- 21:44leadership I'm not one who just likes
- 21:47sitting behind a board seat I'm someone
- 21:49that likes to be active and be present
- 21:50in front of community members being
- 21:52willing to listen and hear and uh and
- 21:56mobilize them in whatever shape or form
- 21:58I may be uh able to I'm proud to be
- 22:00endorsed I'm one of four endorses for
- 22:03the planed Parenthood of aronte I'm
- 22:05proud to be endorsed also by uh
- 22:07supervisor Joseph Midian the Democratic
- 22:10party as well as our local union seu 521
- 22:13thank you Eric
- 22:16Pat well hi everybody it's great to be
- 22:19here first I want to thank the um League
- 22:21of Women Voters and the voice and kmvt
- 22:25for um helping with this forum I really
- 22:28thought that candidate forums are just a
- 22:30fabulous way to learn about the
- 22:32candidates because you get to see us all
- 22:34at the same time and um not only do they
- 22:37put on forums related to council C races
- 22:41but pretty much every race up and down
- 22:43the ticket you could think of um up to
- 22:46the state level I'm the current mayor U
- 22:48of Mountain View it's a great honor and
- 22:51privilege uh I've been on Council for
- 22:53eight years and I've been a champion
- 22:55during that time for housing
- 22:57sustainability and equity
- 22:59I've earned a reputation of treating
- 23:01people with respect and building
- 23:03collaboration keeping our community safe
- 23:05and providing excellent city services
- 23:08are crucial I'm running because Mountain
- 23:11View is my home I raised my children
- 23:13here and I've been involved with
- 23:14numerous neighborhood school and
- 23:16Community groups over the last 40 years
- 23:19for instance I served on the League of
- 23:20Women Voters board for about a decade
- 23:23and have remained a member um of the
- 23:25housing committee ever since my kids
- 23:28went to public schools and so did I I
- 23:30know this community and I know the job I
- 23:33want to use this experience that I've
- 23:36gained as your mayor and council member
- 23:38for another four years on city council
- 23:40the existential crisis of climate change
- 23:43and housing are far from solved I want
- 23:46to keep seeing that we move in the right
- 23:49direction to build a Mountain View that
- 23:51continues to be a great place to live
- 23:54work and play for Generations I'm the
- 23:56only civil engineer running or on
- 23:59Council I'm also the only environmental
- 24:03professional this technical expertise
- 24:05gives me a unique ability to analyze
- 24:08infrastructure indust issues and
- 24:10understand climate change I look forward
- 24:13to the rest of the Forum and answering
- 24:17what I'm sure are very probing questions
- 24:19thank you thank you
- 24:22Pat okay we'll go to our first question
- 24:25and each of you will have 60 seconds to
- 24:27respond
- 24:29the question is pick a topic that
- 24:31residents tell you the city is doing
- 24:33well but could be doing even better many
- 24:36changes take years to achieve name one
- 24:39Improvement that can be introduced and
- 24:42realized within a single year and the
- 24:44order we will go in is Jose John Ida
- 24:48Rose Eric Pat Emily Chris Nicholas Devon
- 24:54Jose thank you that's a great question
- 24:56to start with so to make it within onee
- 24:59time I I think one of the goals I had
- 25:01which I was going to speak to later in
- 25:03my in my conclusion um I think what we
- 25:07need is better oversight when it comes
- 25:08down to negotiations with outside
- 25:10entities like Google one of the big
- 25:12criticisms I've had to uh speak to and
- 25:15defend has been our inability to
- 25:18negotiate with Google on equal footing
- 25:20I'm a proponent because I work in the
- 25:22legal field is a pargal and I'm involved
- 25:23with litigations with Hightech companies
- 25:25that we needed to have outside council
- 25:27help our staff negotiate with outside
- 25:29legal councel that's in a top 10 in the
- 25:31legal profession we were outmaneuvered
- 25:33and outgunned at the end and that led to
- 25:35the loss of over 340 inclusion are
- 25:37affordable housing units under my watch
- 25:39that's not going to happen because we
- 25:40need to do better and we can't and we
- 25:42can do this quickly thank
- 25:44you John so if I restate the question
- 25:48it's what residents like about we've
- 25:51been doing for Mountain View what is the
- 25:54city doing well but could be doing even
- 25:56better and what Improvement can be done
- 25:59within a single
- 26:01year I hear a lot of compliments about
- 26:03our parks that we've maintained them
- 26:05well we try to uh we utilize them for
- 26:08all the local sports we use them for the
- 26:10dog walkers after the uh night and the
- 26:13morning um people just enjoy sitting
- 26:16through the shade and so forth and what
- 26:18we need to do need better is to one
- 26:20increase the amount of parks that we
- 26:22have and how can we do that well we
- 26:24could possibly work better with the
- 26:25school district to make sure we assure
- 26:27ourselves of parks and so that's one
- 26:29thing that could be done recently uh
- 26:30fairly quickly the other is possibly uh
- 26:33we need to buy we need to prioritize
- 26:35buying more open space so as the city
- 26:38continues to grow we have that open
- 26:40space so people can release energy and
- 26:42get out and and relax and that's part of
- 26:44being a quality of life is just being
- 26:46able to relax and look around and have
- 26:48some trees uh oh that's another thing is
- 26:50we could start putting more trees out
- 26:52that's one thing I forgot yeah parks and
- 26:54trees something that we they like
- 26:57something that they give us free trees I
- 26:59have a free Tree in my front yard so
- 27:01that's something that we could do across
- 27:02the
- 27:05board thank you John Ida
- 27:09Rose um one topic people talk to me all
- 27:12about is public transportation and safe
- 27:15active transportation in the city people
- 27:17love our climate here they love to be
- 27:19able to bike and walk um and they also
- 27:22love our Mountain View shuttle however
- 27:25we're getting some uh funding cuts for
- 27:27the shuttle where losing our funding
- 27:28from Google people don't want to see the
- 27:30shuttle cut they want to see it expanded
- 27:33the hours where it goes how it syncs up
- 27:36with Cal train and VTA and with bus
- 27:40lines they just want it to be more
- 27:42accessible to them at all different
- 27:44times they want to be able to use it to
- 27:45go out um to dinner on the weekends
- 27:47downtown and it's something we could
- 27:49very simply do we know how to do it um
- 27:52we know how to run the bus service we
- 27:54just need to find some money and we
- 27:55could instantly get up and start running
- 27:57again with more uh more buses within a
- 27:59year well within a year thank you a rose
- 28:04Eric thank you for the question um so
- 28:07yeah one of the many things I hear uh
- 28:10that mountain V does well has been how
- 28:12we've been doing regarding
- 28:14sustainability and how we're trying to
- 28:16meet our carbon neutral goals by 2035
- 28:20though ambitious I think that's
- 28:21something that all of us are pretty much
- 28:24uh have at the Forefront uh of a
- 28:27priority concern but the most pervasive
- 28:29one has been of course affordable
- 28:30housing and
- 28:31hopelessness um how the costs continue
- 28:34to remain high and it's being is
- 28:36essentially being making it more
- 28:38difficult to be able to afford a a home
- 28:41here especially those with fixed in
- 28:42income with our elderly communities I
- 28:44think one of the programs I would like
- 28:46to see implemented within the year and
- 28:48that we've seen great success with is
- 28:50our general basic income program seeing
- 28:52how people within uh the most improper
- 28:55situations being emboldened and being
- 28:57empowered to pay off some of their debts
- 28:59and still remain housed and being uh
- 29:02creating wraparound services around that
- 29:04too I think because we' have the
- 29:06statistics about it we can be successful
- 29:09about
- 29:12Pat um that's a really interesting
- 29:15question and I am I'm surprised that
- 29:18nobody answered the one I came up with
- 29:20in my head the first time people do say
- 29:23that we're doing a lot of good things I
- 29:25hear a lot about safety you know people
- 29:28really appreciate our um police and our
- 29:30fire but I'm not going to talk about
- 29:31that I'm going to talk about the
- 29:32downtown um people love our downtown and
- 29:36they particularly Love The Pedestrian
- 29:38Mall that we've put in place um during
- 29:41covid and since then and um we are you
- 29:45know it's a phase project we're in phase
- 29:47two where um we have kind of a
- 29:50semi-permanent um situation but phase
- 29:53three will be a permanent situation
- 29:55where um there will be a flush
- 29:58uh layer all the way across but one
- 30:02thing that we can do I think in the next
- 30:04year to make it better is just improve
- 30:06the programming we have great
- 30:08programming we have music every
- 30:10Wednesday night but those things um
- 30:13bring so much joy to our community thank
- 30:16you Pat that's
- 30:18Emily um one of the things that I I
- 30:21think that I've been hearing we've been
- 30:23doing very well and is is Outreach on a
- 30:26broad level so we programs like the
- 30:28language leadership acmy so uh we
- 30:31started off with the Spanish Leadership
- 30:33Academy and we have a cohort of of
- 30:35Spanish speaking residents that can
- 30:37Outreach to their communities and was
- 30:39super helpful during the pandemic and
- 30:41then we continued that program with the
- 30:43Chinese Leadership Academy um as we look
- 30:46at Outreach there's other things like
- 30:47our coun uh like our neighborhood
- 30:49associations I serve along with the
- 30:51mayor on our Council neighborhoods
- 30:53committee and we have a great grant
- 30:55program to help Community build what we
- 30:58can do to improve that is uh start
- 31:01helping them work together on making
- 31:03that money more efficient because the
- 31:05amazing thing is everyone really loves
- 31:07that grant program it's not enough money
- 31:10for everyone for everything that they
- 31:11want so we have to learn how to be more
- 31:13efficient with it and see how we can
- 31:15help each other make it work because
- 31:17people are just living their lives
- 31:18they're not going to go to every single
- 31:19council meeting like I am because I'm I
- 31:22love those kinds of things thank you so
- 31:23much Chris so I was going to talk about
- 31:27downtown but uh since that's already
- 31:28been mentioned the other thing that I'm
- 31:30hearing just walking around is people go
- 31:32back to what's been happening most
- 31:34recently in touches their daily lives
- 31:36and folks are really happy about um some
- 31:38of the infrastructure projects that are
- 31:40finally moving postco uh so whether it's
- 31:43um the addition of safe routes to
- 31:45schools or just repaving El Camino which
- 31:47granted isn't the city it's calr but we
- 31:49worked with um them closely on that um
- 31:52so people bring up infrastructure a lot
- 31:53but they're also frustrated that it's
- 31:55taken so long to bring a lot of those
- 31:58projects to fruition for example the uh
- 32:00the road diet and creating a safer
- 32:02Corridor along California Street um and
- 32:04granted you some of those got backed up
- 32:06due to covid but there should be things
- 32:08that we can do within a year like you
- 32:10know conceptualize a trial for certain
- 32:13things to make our streets and corridors
- 32:15safer and then Implement that trial on a
- 32:18segment of that um it shouldn't take
- 32:20years to to bring a trial like that to
- 32:22fruition um and so I think if we can um
- 32:25if we can move forward with doing that
- 32:26in a more efficient effective way that
- 32:28would make a big difference for folks
- 32:30here in Mountain View thank you Chris
- 32:33Nicholas people love the new Pedestrian
- 32:36Mall but they're very concerned about
- 32:38the downtown vacancy rate the downtown
- 32:40vacancy rate is twice as high as
- 32:43anywhere else in the city and I don't
- 32:45think that we should let those vacancies
- 32:47go to waste our windows need to give
- 32:51advertising to the other businesses in
- 32:53downtown that could use the support the
- 32:56city is currently working on a facade
- 32:59program and a window program to allow
- 33:02for popups in those vacant spaces we
- 33:05need to get that implemented as soon as
- 33:08possible so that we support our small
- 33:10businesses who have been downtown for
- 33:12years and show potential business owners
- 33:15the potential of those spaces I also
- 33:17believe that we need to make sure that
- 33:19our first floor retail isn't a Lobby for
- 33:23offices upstairs I'm very proud that
- 33:26last night the city council made sure
- 33:28that that wasn't the case uh on 198
- 33:31Castro the Agave
- 33:34site thank you Nicholas Devon thank you
- 33:37there are so many great ideas from my
- 33:39colleagues up here tonight it's actually
- 33:40very exciting to think about a year
- 33:42ahead of us to work on these things um
- 33:44Mountain View is one of the few places
- 33:46as a city that has said it wants to
- 33:48increase access to child care I've heard
- 33:50a lot of people who were very excited
- 33:52when um Mountain View first opened a
- 33:53preschool program but it's too small and
- 33:57um we know know that there's an
- 33:58incredible need for highquality child
- 34:01care and preschool experiences for
- 34:02children in our community the Mountain
- 34:05View wisman school district has a
- 34:06preschool program currently and part of
- 34:08it is state funded but we know that
- 34:12there's still more need within our
- 34:13community even amongst our staff and so
- 34:16recently Google canceled their leases on
- 34:18two preschool sites that they were
- 34:20leasing from the school district this is
- 34:22an incredible opportunity we can't fund
- 34:25it alone as a school district but in
- 34:27partnership with the City we could get
- 34:29many more preschool slots within our
- 34:31community that are affordable to a wide
- 34:33range of incomes thank you
- 34:36Deon next question is the city likely to
- 34:40meet the housing elements commitments on
- 34:42time has anything changed since the
- 34:45element was approved that can affect
- 34:48success how can the council help to hit
- 34:51the target and the order we will go in
- 34:54will be Pat Eric Ida Rose John
- 34:58Jose Devin Nicholas Chris and
- 35:03Emily go ahead
- 35:07Pat well it's like looking at a crystal
- 35:11ball to really say will we be able to
- 35:14meet this or not because um we have
- 35:17zoned for it we have a very robust
- 35:20housing element and um we put in a a
- 35:23hefty percentage over um of areas that
- 35:27are zoned so that it doesn't all have to
- 35:30be developed by any stretch of the
- 35:32imagination that said a city doesn't do
- 35:35the development um developers do and the
- 35:38economic forces are um are really an
- 35:41issue so the fact that the um interest
- 35:44rates went up to 7% has has has really
- 35:48slowed down uh Housing Development and
- 35:52um the uh they just went down recently
- 35:56so that's a good thing
- 35:58the things that the city can do is we
- 36:00have a great housing um Department that
- 36:03has a lot of knowhow for how to get
- 36:05money that people need to do affordable
- 36:08housing that's something that's thank
- 36:10you Pat that's a great
- 36:13Eric uh thank you for the question I
- 36:16think uh pertaining on whether or not we
- 36:19are GNA keep up with our C IM I think
- 36:22it's more important that we do so
- 36:24because if y'all remembered when we were
- 36:27working on the housing element it was
- 36:28turned in at a later period than what it
- 36:31was intended for and because of that now
- 36:33we're facing five building remedies as a
- 36:36result and if we don't continue uh uh
- 36:39committing to those obligations we're
- 36:41going to face more building remedies in
- 36:43the near future and that's I'm sure not
- 36:45even the council nor our residents want
- 36:47to face that and I think the council
- 36:49should be acting in good faith not only
- 36:51based off the work that the Planning
- 36:53Commission has done but also many of our
- 36:55coalitions that put in time and effort
- 36:57in order to see this housing element
- 36:59pass I mean we have to uh this includes
- 37:03developing a strategy to prevent
- 37:04displacement those are things that we
- 37:05need to ensure as we're seeing the cost
- 37:08of housing Rising even with measure V
- 37:10implemented the cost people aren't able
- 37:13to afford a $78 a month increase uh for
- 37:17years to come so um I think the more
- 37:19important thing is for us to set up a
- 37:21timeline thank you
- 37:23Eric Ida
- 37:25Rose I think we are at risk RK for
- 37:27meeting our um housing element numbers
- 37:30to be quite honest uh but anything can
- 37:32change we have seven-year Cycles in
- 37:34Silicon Valley typically with our
- 37:36economy um so we might hit a boom
- 37:39somewhere that will help us but right
- 37:41now uh we've seen uh some concern that
- 37:45North Bayshore development won't happen
- 37:46because Google has been pulling out of
- 37:48some of the work that they're doing
- 37:49there and as noted money cost a lot more
- 37:52money now and inflation makes everything
- 37:54expensive to do uh so I think we are at
- 37:58risk especially at North Bayshore um
- 38:00unless we have an economic turnaround
- 38:02which we can't control but one thing we
- 38:04can control is improving some of our
- 38:06zoning like our R3 zoning which will
- 38:08allow us to um zone for denser housing
- 38:12that would help the middle class
- 38:13especially in parts of our city and that
- 38:15we have some control over thank you
- 38:19John uh I don't think we're going to
- 38:21make it the housing element started out
- 38:23mid you know towards the end of covid
- 38:26and people were basing it on assumptions
- 38:28that we're going to continue to grow or
- 38:30it's going to recover pretty quick but
- 38:33it's not happening and recently there
- 38:34was an article in the paper about
- 38:36vacancy rate for Office Buildings at 22%
- 38:38the highest level ever so that sort of
- 38:40indicates that businesses are tightening
- 38:43up businesses are closing up businesses
- 38:45are laying people off so if there's no
- 38:48demand for housing developers aren't
- 38:49going to be coming knocking at our door
- 38:51to say well we're going to build here
- 38:52we're going to build there and it's
- 38:54going to be a time that we might have to
- 38:56Recon consider that if somebody wants
- 38:59some maybe we have to give some
- 39:01concessions maybe we have to you know
- 39:03bankroll some of this ourselves but as
- 39:06long as the economy is Contracting right
- 39:08now and the costs even though they're
- 39:09coming down it's still going to be if
- 39:12there's a demand and that's what we have
- 39:14to wait for and see what happens we
- 39:16maybe have
- 39:17to thank
- 39:19you Jose
- 39:34okay great um just checking look I'm the
- 39:37vice chair for the EPC the environmental
- 39:38Planning Commission Chris and I worked
- 39:40hard to be able to do the hard lift of
- 39:42being able to get community input into
- 39:43the haian element plan we spoke to every
- 39:46day folks from nonprofit organizations
- 39:48developers and members of the community
- 39:49as a whole and we try to do best we can
- 39:51to get letters of support so that we can
- 39:53have this be approved the fact of the
- 39:54matter is that when Google pulled out
- 39:56and they said no to those 300 50
- 39:58affordable housing units that set us
- 40:00back we immediately took action and we
- 40:02spoke to our uh City staff and we said
- 40:04Hey by when do we need to tell the state
- 40:06that we may not meet certain deadlines
- 40:08because we do have a timeline there is a
- 40:11schedule these things are reality and we
- 40:14have to give those updates to the state
- 40:16periodically so depending what comes our
- 40:18way for review and approval for said
- 40:20developments because we are at the
- 40:21ministry of developers let's not kill
- 40:23ourselves we do the best we can to
- 40:24inform the state where we're at and
- 40:26that's what we need to do continuously
- 40:27because we have no other choice but be
- 40:29responsible for
- 40:30that thank you
- 40:33Devin so 33% of the students in the
- 40:36Mountain View issman School District
- 40:37qualify for free and reduced price lunch
- 40:40this means for a family of four that
- 40:41they earn $55,500 or less these families
- 40:46qualify for very lowincome affordable
- 40:48housing and our housing element calls
- 40:50for over
- 40:522,700 units of very lowincome affordable
- 40:55housing it is incredibly hard to get
- 40:58built it takes significant subsidies
- 41:01it's very expensive and I think this is
- 41:03one area of the housing element that's
- 41:05really at risk of not being realized
- 41:07unless we focus on it I know that
- 41:10creative Partnerships pulling down
- 41:13federal and state funds as well as
- 41:15working with our regional um government
- 41:18and other supporters can help us find
- 41:21funding to do this but it's going to
- 41:24take work the housing bond that had been
- 41:26planned for 20 billion for the Bay Area
- 41:29did not get put on the ballot this year
- 41:31so we're going to need to keep
- 41:32advocating at these other levels to be
- 41:34able to build very low income housing
- 41:37thank you
- 41:39Nicholas in 2023 we did not keep Pace in
- 41:43order to meet our housing element goals
- 41:46so right now the answer is no and
- 41:50unfortunately the slow growth in the nor
- 41:52Bay North Bay Shore neighborhood is also
- 41:55not a good sign the good news is though
- 41:59that we have more than a thousand units
- 42:01in the pipeline we need to make the
- 42:04permitting process more efficient we
- 42:06have a a new staff a new community
- 42:09development director Christian Murdoch
- 42:12and we need to work with him very
- 42:13closely to understand exactly what we
- 42:16need in order to pass these permits I'm
- 42:20happy that the city council yesterday
- 42:22approved an application for a pro
- 42:25housing Grant and that we're seeking
- 42:27money from the federal government in
- 42:29this case $4 million for preservation
- 42:32and acquisition we need to continue
- 42:35doing that to leverage funds and put our
- 42:38money towards affordable housing
- 42:40projects thank you Chris so while we
- 42:44aren't on track right now the good news
- 42:46is that we do have a really solid
- 42:47housing element in place and so what we
- 42:50need to do is continue to do our best to
- 42:52implement that and as the mayor
- 42:53mentioned earlier by and large the city
- 42:55doesn't build housing we put put the
- 42:57policy Frameworks in place to hopefully
- 43:00incentivize it so what we can't force
- 43:02developers to build housing um so what
- 43:05can we do in the interim I've been on
- 43:07Council through multiple economic Cycles
- 43:08two recessions and a really significant
- 43:10boom period so hope isn't lost but we
- 43:13can't um we we don't want to lose the
- 43:15time that we have so what we can do now
- 43:18is continue implementing our housing
- 43:19element um we can pass prop five which
- 43:22will allow us to bring the regional
- 43:24measor back um and better fund
- 43:27affordable housing in the future um and
- 43:30so we're that way we kind of set the
- 43:32stage for when interest rates do come
- 43:34down and we have a better boom cycle and
- 43:35folks are building again we aren't
- 43:37behind the eightball and trying to play
- 43:38catchup like we were last time so really
- 43:41what we need to do is is put all the
- 43:43plans and Frameworks in place now so we
- 43:45aren't behind the aall later thank you
- 43:46Chris Emily so um what people generally
- 43:51don't notice is that our housing element
- 43:52is more than just our Arena goals and
- 43:54the buffer and the zoning uh the housing
- 43:57element also includes a lot of programs
- 43:59that remove the barriers to housing and
- 44:01something very uh important
- 44:02affirmatively furthering fair housing
- 44:04and that that includes uh programs
- 44:07against displacement um overall most
- 44:09cities are generally good about meeting
- 44:11their market rate housing goals it's
- 44:14when we start looking at the affordable
- 44:15housing goals and so we want to take a
- 44:18look at things like our community
- 44:19ownership action plan um and makeing
- 44:22sure that we have funding for that
- 44:24affordable housing so it's important
- 44:25that people here vote for measure G um
- 44:28as we also go forward I think we need to
- 44:31keep to the spirit of the commitments
- 44:33that we have made to these housing
- 44:34elements and we have a a we have a
- 44:36community that holds us accountable and
- 44:38we work closely with hcd or our
- 44:40community also works closely with hcd to
- 44:42tell us if we're not meeting that Spirit
- 44:44of commitment so I feel very optimistic
- 44:46about meeting our goals in the housing
- 44:48element um thank you thank
- 44:51you okay our next question empty
- 44:54storefronts on Castro at downtown office
- 44:58vacancy rate of about 25% and long
- 45:01vacant and blighted properties in
- 45:03commercial areas are issues what ideas
- 45:06do you have in one of these areas that
- 45:09you believe would be supported by a
- 45:11majority of the council the order we
- 45:13will go in is Ida Rose Eric Pat Emily
- 45:18Chris Nicholas Devon Jose
- 45:23John Ida Rose um focus ing in on empty
- 45:28storefronts I am really really excited
- 45:30for the potential of our downtown um if
- 45:33we reimagine what downtown could be and
- 45:35it not just be uh a few retail shops and
- 45:38a whole lot of restaurants if we can
- 45:40imagine uses that bring back daytime
- 45:43population um as well as stretch out uh
- 45:46different kinds of uses that bring more
- 45:48families in on different times and
- 45:49different days of the week I think will
- 45:52be golden now some of this is going to
- 45:53require how we Market our downtown but
- 45:56some of it is how we will allow
- 45:57permitting for different uses downtown
- 46:00um people have talked about recreation
- 46:02centers both um like an escape room like
- 46:05a commercial one but also a city-owned
- 46:06recreation center where families can
- 46:09meet and gather that could use up some
- 46:10of the large retail spaces that are
- 46:12currently there um we could bring in
- 46:14some Daytime uses like a co-working
- 46:16space or a business incubator so we can
- 46:18bring back some of that the missing
- 46:20population that is no longer there
- 46:22having lunch and shopping in the middle
- 46:23of the day thank you thank you Eric
- 46:27yeah thank you for the question so we do
- 46:29have an economic Vitality strategy which
- 46:32offers a comprehensive evaluation of
- 46:35approaches that we can take in order to
- 46:36best uh support our storefronts I think
- 46:39one of the ones especially with the
- 46:40empty ones is in one that I think that
- 46:43Council would be in favor of
- 46:45implementing is uh supporting a
- 46:47commercial vacancy tax and the reason
- 46:49why I say this is because especially for
- 46:51those air uh those places that are
- 46:53chronically uh vacant I would hate to
- 46:56believe that property owners are holding
- 46:57off on uh renting it out so much so that
- 47:00they can sell it at a higher price and I
- 47:02think this would be an essential push to
- 47:05those Property Owners to lease it out to
- 47:07someone at a market rate value instead
- 47:09of an expensive one as we see p uh as
- 47:12we're seeing right now and I think as
- 47:14we're transitioning from retail to much
- 47:16more entertainment as um our colleague
- 47:19has said I think it is trying to
- 47:22reimagine how our downtown streets look
- 47:24like not only for the familiar as aspect
- 47:27of it but also trying to bring youth
- 47:28entertainment into it as well thank you
- 47:32Pat well I'm glad Eric mentioned the
- 47:35economic Vitality plan I really think
- 47:37that is um what's key to getting um a
- 47:41lot of the vacancies down town fied it
- 47:44is 164 action plan when it came to
- 47:48council the first time it was very very
- 47:51theoretical and we sent it back and said
- 47:54no we need things on the ground that
- 47:56will make a difference um I Heard a talk
- 47:59today through the um Chamber of Commerce
- 48:02uh about how they're um working on that
- 48:06and they've basically analyzed the
- 48:08vacancies in all of the storefronts and
- 48:10talk and figured out what is the issue
- 48:13for each vacancy and some of those
- 48:16issues are things that we can handle
- 48:18pretty straightforwardly and easily
- 48:20others or more difficult I think that
- 48:22kind of triage is helpful and I think
- 48:25that one of the things that we could all
- 48:27agree on is upping their Grant
- 48:29renovation project I mean program we
- 48:32have a certain amount of money in it now
- 48:34and I think we could put a little more
- 48:35money in it and that would help get some
- 48:37morees Emily so um this actually led me
- 48:41to remember the most common question I
- 48:43was been I have been asked on Reddit um
- 48:47and that was a lot of people were asking
- 48:48like what's going on with El Camino as
- 48:51you go up and down elino you see a lot
- 48:53of uh vacant Parcels that are closed
- 48:55down and um I think one of the things
- 48:58that we were looking at we actually
- 48:59looked at that when we did a walking
- 49:02tour uh as part of our work for our
- 49:04housing element some of these sites
- 49:06they're weirdly shaped the permitting
- 49:08process is just so overwhelming for them
- 49:10to build something completely new to
- 49:12design standards um are are difficult
- 49:14for such a small plot of land I think
- 49:17one of the things we need to work on is
- 49:19the permitting and making it more
- 49:21flexible so that we could actually have
- 49:23an overall vision of it and if you are
- 49:25flexible and exactly how you want each
- 49:28tiny plot of land to do it's too
- 49:29prescriptive so as we look at more
- 49:32General um goals of that area as we have
- 49:35a precise plan on it that probably
- 49:36should be a little bit updated um but
- 49:40yeah we can work on those design
- 49:41standards thank you Emily Chris I think
- 49:45there are three things we could do
- 49:46pretty uh downtown that most folks would
- 49:48agree with one is something we've
- 49:50already started to do which is
- 49:51liberalize some of the uses on the
- 49:52ground floor to allow things like
- 49:54fitness centers um and other you know
- 49:56daytime uses that bring folks down um
- 49:59and activate things throughout the day
- 50:01the second is recognizing there are
- 50:03industries that are growing that aren't
- 50:04looking for Google size spaces but
- 50:06smaller you know expansion facilities so
- 50:08maybe they're based in San Francisco but
- 50:10the gross receipts tax is really hitting
- 50:12them hard up there and they're looking
- 50:13for peninsula South Bay locations and
- 50:16San Jose is taking advantage of this um
- 50:18and we should too because we now that
- 50:20Cal trains electrified we are the
- 50:21intersection of not just the freeways
- 50:24but um Express train stops and we can be
- 50:27that Hub uh on the South Bay of the
- 50:28peninsula for some of those companies
- 50:30and the third is the the mfet precise
- 50:33plan and the downtown precise plan
- 50:35expanding um the footprint of downtown
- 50:37and activation Beyond just the core but
- 50:39closer to El Camino and then down Moffet
- 50:41which is a longer term thing but I think
- 50:43that's really important to do thank you
- 50:47Nicholas as I touched on earlier I think
- 50:50that we need to take advantage of the
- 50:52windows in vacant spaces when there's a
- 50:55new store that is coming the new owner
- 50:58will put up a advertisement saying
- 51:01December 2025 this is what you can
- 51:04expect we should be taking advantage of
- 51:06all of those empty window spaces either
- 51:10promoting the space and what it could
- 51:11look like or advertising for other
- 51:14businesses that gets rid of the blight
- 51:17problem right there I think we also need
- 51:19to liberalize the use of the Street area
- 51:24in front of non-restaurant spaces
- 51:27outdoor dining is a fantastic setup for
- 51:30restaurants but retail hasn't been able
- 51:33to use that space the same way and so we
- 51:36need to look at how we can work with
- 51:38retailers to activate the space in The
- 51:41Pedestrian Mall which everyone loves so
- 51:44much thank you Devin thank you for the
- 51:48question um so where we work where we
- 51:50eat where we play where we shop it has
- 51:52all changed significant significantly
- 51:55since the pandemic and we need to really
- 51:58modernize our business infrastructure to
- 52:00be able to address that change um when
- 52:03we look at downtown The in the economic
- 52:06Vitality strategy is an excellent plan
- 52:09but it's huge and there's only a few
- 52:12staff people who are dedicated to
- 52:13working on it but one of the things
- 52:15that's positive about it is it includes
- 52:17metrics and goals that are hard numbers
- 52:19for Council to try and work towards and
- 52:22for example there's a goal of a 2 to 4%
- 52:24growth in the year-over year sales tax
- 52:27receipts for downtown right now that
- 52:30rate is negative
- 52:318.5% that's why you see those empty
- 52:34storefronts the economic Vitality
- 52:36strategy however the council had first
- 52:38asked that it just come back once a year
- 52:40as a written report I believe Council
- 52:43would agree hopefully to bringing it
- 52:45back at least every six months as an
- 52:47actual presentation to the public so we
- 52:49can stay focused on those metrics thank
- 52:51you
- 52:53Jose thank you so look there's no easy
- 52:55answer right I wish I could tell you
- 52:56great news and positivity all the time
- 52:58but sometimes you just deal with the
- 53:00reality that you have you've got a bunch
- 53:01of layoffs that have happened in the
- 53:02tech sector and because of that that
- 53:05affects the way we look at downtown and
- 53:06our businesses overall within the life
- 53:07of the city it's as simple as that but
- 53:10there's opportunity here and so I agree
- 53:12with honorable mayor Pat shalter and my
- 53:16fellow um commissioner Chris Clark you
- 53:17bundle those two sets of ideas that they
- 53:19presented plus the one that was
- 53:21presented to us as a whole in the report
- 53:22that said we need more small minority
- 53:24business-based loans and coupled with
- 53:26what we've been doing on the commission
- 53:28which is to change the zoning of certain
- 53:30sites so that we can have certain types
- 53:32of other businesses be available to um
- 53:35have as an opportunity for them to come
- 53:36in and participate in downtown when you
- 53:38look at land ordinance issues like that
- 53:40in zoning that gets a ball moving in the
- 53:42right direction and finally you use what
- 53:44Devon suggested every six months it
- 53:45comes back for us to review so that we
- 53:47can follow through be accountable and
- 53:49get things done thank you
- 53:52John 444 Castro Street
- 53:57top floor
- 53:58restaurant something bold something
- 54:01exciting you don't know what it is it's
- 54:04the tallest building on Castro Street
- 54:06got to start thinking out of the box
- 54:08sometimes think what get the answers how
- 54:10about a cooking school I got all these
- 54:12restaurants but something down there
- 54:14I've been fortunate to be able to travel
- 54:16around the United States and Europe and
- 54:18there's a place in Colorado Boulder
- 54:20Pearl Street if anybody's ever seen it
- 54:22go online and look at Pearl Street I
- 54:25think we're concentrating too much on
- 54:26restaurants and what we could do for
- 54:28them we needed to back off on
- 54:30restaurants CU if you look at the
- 54:31streets they're pretty crammed and you
- 54:33walk down I was there last night and you
- 54:35walk down the street and you see tables
- 54:37going this way chairs going this way and
- 54:38it just doesn't doesn't make you feel
- 54:40comfortable so I think we need to start
- 54:42looking at other deals off outside the
- 54:45box parking garage pickle ball courts
- 54:48aren't everybody looking for pickle ball
- 54:49courts you go hey that's sort of crazy
- 54:51how about a restroom we don't even have
- 54:53a public restroom downtown so we need to
- 54:55make it invite
- 54:58thank
- 54:59you okay the next question Mountain View
- 55:03has significant infrastructure projects
- 55:05planned but funding them is challenging
- 55:08if measor G fails what plan B funding
- 55:12ideas do you have and what would be your
- 55:15top priority
- 55:17projects we will go in this order Eric
- 55:20Pat Emily Chris Devin Jose John Ida Rose
- 55:25Nicholas
- 55:27Eric yeah um so I'm not even thinking
- 55:31about measure G failing because I think
- 55:33we definitely do need it to pass and if
- 55:35anything you come out out of this today
- 55:38on top of uh meeting every great
- 55:40candidate here it's that measure G needs
- 55:42to pass so that we can use those funds
- 55:43that could be allotted to our green
- 55:45spaces our infrastructure affordable
- 55:47housing whatever we may need that to be
- 55:49in addition to that something that's
- 55:50been referenced in this conversation is
- 55:53passing prop five as well this will be a
- 55:55great way for us to start funding and
- 55:58stop being dependent on taxing y'all and
- 56:01making our B corporations or whomever uh
- 56:05uh accountable to paying paying their
- 56:07fair share in order to be able to self
- 56:09fund many of these projects as soon as
- 56:11interest goes low uh goes down and I
- 56:13mean I think like a lot of the uh
- 56:15projects I would like to see uh build is
- 56:18with regards to the R3 zoning oh and I
- 56:22think sorry my time oh I okay
- 56:27okay oh
- 56:30no thank you Pat okay uh Mountain View
- 56:35has significant infrastructure plans if
- 56:37measure G fails what will we do well
- 56:40we'll basically be where we are now and
- 56:43um that we're trying to plan for the
- 56:46mountain view of tomorrow and um if
- 56:49measure G fails then we'll have
- 56:51approximately $10 million less in the
- 56:54general plan than we had hoped for and
- 56:56that will mean we will do things more
- 56:58slowly but I don't think we should get
- 57:01too um really upset about that I mean it
- 57:06would be bad it would be much better if
- 57:08we have that money but we have a staff
- 57:11that's very very good at uh going after
- 57:13grants the um the IRA um and the B
- 57:18bipartisan infrastructure bill um they
- 57:21are huge sources of funding so I think
- 57:25that whether G passes or not we need to
- 57:28make sure that we go after all of those
- 57:31funding um opportunities that are
- 57:33available I just got a letter from Anna
- 57:36ISU that said she had written a um she'd
- 57:39written a letter to Pete Budaj asking us
- 57:41for money for more money for the
- 57:43railroad undercrossing so thank you Pat
- 57:46Emily so I agree with uh the past two uh
- 57:49C uh commenters um but the good news is
- 57:52is that overall measure G is not our
- 57:54only funding source we actually have a
- 57:56very strong budget with diverse Revenue
- 57:59sources um and we have been fiscally
- 58:01responsible up to this point and we will
- 58:03probably continue to be fiscally
- 58:05responsible so um and we like I was
- 58:09mentioned before we will leverage our
- 58:10state and federal funding we have
- 58:12actually started uh working a lot uh
- 58:15more uh harder and more smarter about
- 58:18getting some of that state and federal
- 58:19funding and accessing that funding uh
- 58:23some projects will probably be delayed
- 58:25until we get that funding funding but it
- 58:28if we plan for it we can get the funding
- 58:30eventually because there are a lot of
- 58:31cities that out there that we are doing
- 58:33so much better than and we we uh managed
- 58:37to get our projects done we have a good
- 58:39history of getting our projects done and
- 58:41so the state and the the federal
- 58:43government they like funding us because
- 58:45it'll look great on them it looks great
- 58:47on us and we get the stuff that we want
- 58:48done thank you
- 58:51Chris so uh if Major G fails I think
- 58:54three things will happen one is has been
- 58:55alluded to earlier we'll have to delay
- 58:57some projects uh and rep prioritize
- 58:59things which is really unfortunate but
- 59:01um because we can only come back to you
- 59:03every couple of years uh for funding we
- 59:06can't do it in an off cycle year um
- 59:08we'll just have to delay things the
- 59:10second is we will come back to you uh
- 59:12maybe with a transient occupancy tax
- 59:14increase or something different but we
- 59:16will have to come back to you because we
- 59:18cannot have a structurally imbalanced
- 59:19budget we need to maintain our choyee
- 59:21credit rating that is um that is a that
- 59:24is a one of the sacred cows Mountain
- 59:27View and then um the the third is we'll
- 59:30leverage our state and federal uh
- 59:32legislative relationships to try and get
- 59:33whatever grant money we can but I will
- 59:36say um there is risk there because as we
- 59:38saw with Cal Train electrification when
- 59:40we had a certain Administration come to
- 59:41power they tried to block the funding
- 59:43for that and it almost completely
- 59:45unraveled and we had to travel to DC to
- 59:46beg for that funding with Feinstein and
- 59:49others um so um hopefully measure G
- 59:52passes thank you Devon well you know
- 59:55what the quest and neighborhood uh
- 59:57Association candidate Forum asked this
- 1:00:00question of a team of us and we had to
- 1:00:01work on it together and come up with a
- 1:00:03solution and that was a really helpful
- 1:00:05discussion so part of what came out of
- 1:00:07that was I mean first thing you do if it
- 1:00:09doesn't passes is an analysis of why is
- 1:00:12it something that we could tweak in the
- 1:00:14ballot language is it getting prop five
- 1:00:17passed to bring down the passage rate so
- 1:00:19that we could get it past that way and
- 1:00:20then bringing it back in the future or
- 1:00:23something like it or another type of tax
- 1:00:26so it's not going to be that there
- 1:00:27aren't other options down the road and I
- 1:00:30agree with my colleagues this is the
- 1:00:32danger of going La near the end on a
- 1:00:34question um we do have to Advocate and
- 1:00:37other sources to get funding pulled down
- 1:00:39from state and federal grants and we're
- 1:00:42going to also need to you know really
- 1:00:44prioritize what's the most urgent
- 1:00:47projects for us now I lean towards
- 1:00:49implementing the vision zero plan
- 1:00:51because we're losing people we lost a
- 1:00:53child a few years ago who was hit on
- 1:00:55their way to school and passed away so
- 1:00:58that's my priority thank you
- 1:01:01Jose I I think when you look at this
- 1:01:03issue it's pretty complex no matter how
- 1:01:05you look at it right you have several
- 1:01:06opportunities but you also have several
- 1:01:08challenges one of the things that I look
- 1:01:09at is uh that I'm proud of being able to
- 1:01:12have done in the past is just to be
- 1:01:13fiscally responsible right I was never
- 1:01:15part of a board that overspent we always
- 1:01:17managed our budget really well and we
- 1:01:19got banged for a buck for it uh and
- 1:01:21that's the mentality I think we need I
- 1:01:22think measure to rely on measure G to
- 1:01:25pass
- 1:01:26I I criticize that we should have never
- 1:01:28been there in the first place we could
- 1:01:29have avoided this two years ago or even
- 1:01:30last year and presented it sooner rather
- 1:01:32than later because now the onus is on
- 1:01:33you to vote for it if that doesn't
- 1:01:35happen then we're in a pickle so we have
- 1:01:36to have better governance and better
- 1:01:37oversight on that and work with the city
- 1:01:39staff so that we're all accountable to
- 1:01:41the point that we don't need these last
- 1:01:42minute resorts to try and get ourselves
- 1:01:44out of a
- 1:01:46pickle thank you John I hate to ask this
- 1:01:50but there been duded a little bit
- 1:01:51because what was the original
- 1:01:54question uh m of you has significant
- 1:01:56infrastructure projects planned but
- 1:01:58funding them is challenging if measure G
- 1:02:00fails what plan B funding ideas do you
- 1:02:02have and what would be your top priority
- 1:02:04projects
- 1:02:05[Music]
- 1:02:07okay as a businessman you know when
- 1:02:09money's come short you start cutting
- 1:02:11back you look at where you can get the
- 1:02:13biggest bank for your buck and you look
- 1:02:15at things that you can get accomplished
- 1:02:17one of my goals if I get on to the
- 1:02:19council is to say Hey you have too many
- 1:02:21things on your plate when people were
- 1:02:23talking about well measure G was going
- 1:02:24to fund so many different things we got
- 1:02:26to go it's not realistic we need to take
- 1:02:29a priority we should have started this
- 1:02:31priority years ago we had all this money
- 1:02:34with all the development money was
- 1:02:35coming in we were flushed we could boom
- 1:02:37boom boom qu Melby ballpark 2020 was put
- 1:02:42in do you know that you can't sit in the
- 1:02:44bleachers and see Home Plate because we
- 1:02:46still because it was designed wrong and
- 1:02:48we work with Partners we need to focus
- 1:02:51on what we can do with the money we have
- 1:02:54and get things done brought tighten it
- 1:02:56up and so that as we go forward things
- 1:02:58don't take five years I know there was a
- 1:03:00death on El M Elman it took like four
- 1:03:03years to get a light in that is not
- 1:03:06right thank you Ida
- 1:03:09Rose there are both near-term immediate
- 1:03:12term um and then twoyear and Beyond term
- 1:03:15ways to look at this uh but let's be
- 1:03:17honest if measure G passes we still
- 1:03:19don't have enough money to do the things
- 1:03:21we want to do and I think that's really
- 1:03:24important um in the near term if we can
- 1:03:27I agree completely with Pat there is a
- 1:03:29lot of money at the federal level with
- 1:03:31the IRA and other acts there are a lot
- 1:03:34of grant money state money feder other
- 1:03:36Federal monies there are Partnerships
- 1:03:37with corporations and nonprofits that we
- 1:03:39should exploit and it's something that
- 1:03:41council members are actually in a good
- 1:03:43position to help the city do to have
- 1:03:46these relationships and to build them
- 1:03:48and to go find that money and help the
- 1:03:49city get it with that said in the longer
- 1:03:52term when we can put up other measures
- 1:03:54occupancy tax ours is lowest in the
- 1:03:56region we could raise around $5 million
- 1:03:58a year for modernizing ours and of
- 1:04:00course if prop five passes I'd like to
- 1:04:02see some specific bonds around Parks
- 1:04:05safe complete streets and the
- 1:04:07potentially even the Crossing
- 1:04:09downtown thank you
- 1:04:11Nicholas believe it or not we have to
- 1:04:14act faster if prop G doesn't pass or
- 1:04:18measure G doesn't pass because like some
- 1:04:21of my can fellow candidates have said
- 1:04:23the money is out there at the federal
- 1:04:25and state level when it comes to the
- 1:04:28inflation reduction act there's a tool
- 1:04:31called direct pay which allows the city
- 1:04:34to be fully reimbursed for things like
- 1:04:37electrification Mountain View recently
- 1:04:39started a partnership with block power
- 1:04:42to Electrify our multifam apartment
- 1:04:45buildings if we invest now before 2032
- 1:04:49we can be reimbursed for significant
- 1:04:51investments from the inflation reduction
- 1:04:53act the other big source of fund is
- 1:04:56Proposition one which passed in
- 1:04:58California a couple of years ago that
- 1:05:00would house atrisk populations if we're
- 1:05:03serious about affordable housing for
- 1:05:05atrisk populations we should be applying
- 1:05:07for prop one funding right now not when
- 1:05:10measure G uh comes
- 1:05:13out thank
- 1:05:16you okay we're on to our final question
- 1:05:19and then we'll follow that up with your
- 1:05:21closing statements so for this last
- 1:05:23question ask and answer answer a
- 1:05:26question you wish we had
- 1:05:29asked so we'll go in the following order
- 1:05:31Chris Nicholas Devan Jose Emily Ida Rose
- 1:05:36Eric Pat and John go ahead Chris um so
- 1:05:42one thing that I'm surprised hasn't come
- 1:05:44up uh in in most of the forums or even
- 1:05:46in some of the discussions is that um in
- 1:05:48the I believe in the next four years or
- 1:05:50so um the the Live Nation lease for
- 1:05:53Shoreline is going to come up and I
- 1:05:55think I think um that presents a really
- 1:05:57interesting opportunity so I I don't
- 1:05:59know what the options will be you know
- 1:06:01maybe we just continue status quo but I
- 1:06:04think you know that lease has been those
- 1:06:06leases are so longterm and so much has
- 1:06:09changed since the last one that we
- 1:06:10signed that I think it presents a really
- 1:06:12interesting opportunity for us to think
- 1:06:14about the use of that not that there
- 1:06:16can't still be concerts and other things
- 1:06:18but maybe there are um even um better
- 1:06:22and revenue generating opportunities for
- 1:06:24us to better utilize um that that gem
- 1:06:27that we have so um I think um I think
- 1:06:29it'll be really interesting to see where
- 1:06:31the council comes down and and what our
- 1:06:33options are for that thank you
- 1:06:37Nicholas I'm surprised that we haven't
- 1:06:39talked about climate change more my
- 1:06:41heart goes out to the families and the
- 1:06:44people who are in the path of hurricane
- 1:06:46Milton
- 1:06:48tonight I think that the city needs to
- 1:06:51focus on climate resilience and climate
- 1:06:54mitigation we need to strengthen our
- 1:06:57fire department and our Police
- 1:06:59Department who our who are our First
- 1:07:02Responders when it comes to severe
- 1:07:04winter storms like we saw last year I'm
- 1:07:08a user of cooling centers during extreme
- 1:07:10heat waves because my apartment building
- 1:07:13doesn't have air conditioning we need to
- 1:07:15make sure that everyone knows where they
- 1:07:17can either find warmth or find air
- 1:07:21conditioning and when it comes to
- 1:07:22climate mitigation we need to look at
- 1:07:26serious electrification in every sector
- 1:07:28transportation makes up 60% of our
- 1:07:31carbon emissions I think that we need to
- 1:07:34build a Citywide EV charging Network
- 1:07:37especially downtown where people want to
- 1:07:39park their
- 1:07:41car thank you you C you can finish your
- 1:07:44last sentence when the stop goes up but
- 1:07:46no more sentences after that thank you
- 1:07:50Devon So 20% of the students at Castro
- 1:07:54Elementary School are homeless in our
- 1:07:57school district before the pandemic we
- 1:07:58had 175 homeless children and in the
- 1:08:012223 school year that number was at
- 1:08:04333 in the last school year we hit that
- 1:08:07number in January and we don't have our
- 1:08:09final data from the state yet so I wish
- 1:08:11we talked about homelessness tonight
- 1:08:13because having children and families
- 1:08:15lose their homes is a cost for our
- 1:08:18entire community and our future as a
- 1:08:21city we need to be looking at the case
- 1:08:24management that's going at at are going
- 1:08:26on at our RV parking sites as well as
- 1:08:28our transitional housing to make sure
- 1:08:30that we are moving families from those
- 1:08:33kind of stop Gap Solutions into
- 1:08:35permanent housing and we need to be
- 1:08:37looking at our overall homelessness
- 1:08:38response because when we invest in
- 1:08:41Children and Families we are investing
- 1:08:43as in our future as a community together
- 1:08:46thank you Jose why am I always after
- 1:08:49Devon it's like you know come on man I
- 1:08:52don't know but on a on a serious note
- 1:08:54though I
- 1:08:56I thought about this question and and
- 1:08:58and this is a hard one right look I I
- 1:08:59don't shy away from challenges I I
- 1:09:01relish them I'm FRG and everything
- 1:09:02the're first time I fin do everything
- 1:09:04graduate from high school go to Santa
- 1:09:05Clara be a board member be on the EPC be
- 1:09:08Vice chair and I fight the fight I push
- 1:09:10to rock up the hill because someone has
- 1:09:11to because that's what mountain is all
- 1:09:13about for me and when I looked at this
- 1:09:15question I thought about good governance
- 1:09:17for me is important it's not just a
- 1:09:18vision it's a reality so why can't our
- 1:09:21electeds work together to figure
- 1:09:23something out for funding for the school
- 1:09:24district why can't our electors be able
- 1:09:26to talk to one
- 1:09:28another one way or another forly
- 1:09:30informed to try and figure things out
- 1:09:32why is there an adversarial relationship
- 1:09:33between the staffs for me that's not
- 1:09:36good governance for me we deserve better
- 1:09:39we need to sit down the table make these
- 1:09:40decisions because it's the right thing
- 1:09:42to do though they're hard but it's for
- 1:09:44the best interest of the city that's
- 1:09:46what I've always been about whether at
- 1:09:47the school board or the EPC what's in
- 1:09:49the best interest for us all thank you
- 1:09:52thank you Emily uh one question that I
- 1:09:55would like to look at is campaign
- 1:09:57Finance reform uh one of the big things
- 1:10:00uh that we look at in politics in
- 1:10:02general is where is the money coming
- 1:10:04from um and we are I'm very proud in
- 1:10:07Mountain View we have a very robust uhi
- 1:10:10um voluntary expenditure limit that
- 1:10:13means that we are capped on and I
- 1:10:15believe everyone of us uh hold to that
- 1:10:18cap um that we're not going to spend
- 1:10:20more just next door in other cities
- 1:10:22they're spending twice three times what
- 1:10:24we're going going to be spending in this
- 1:10:26election cycle they're getting up to six
- 1:10:29figures in their elections and that is
- 1:10:31just ridiculous so I'm proud that Mount
- 1:10:34View has kept that uh voluntary
- 1:10:36expenditure limit and that we are all
- 1:10:37holding to it um it was put in place in
- 1:10:402000 capped at 15,000 and increase every
- 1:10:433% um I'm proud that I uh we also pushed
- 1:10:47for a disclosure act uh for the IES that
- 1:10:50could come in in our city so that we
- 1:10:53know where that funding is coming from
- 1:10:55I'm proud to have uh raised up to that
- 1:10:58limit um and don't need to raise any
- 1:11:00money anymore thank you IA
- 1:11:04Rose so something I think a lot about
- 1:11:07and wonder why we're not asked is why
- 1:11:09don't people ask about who we are beyond
- 1:11:12our qualification in our ideal ideas for
- 1:11:15example how do our values show up in our
- 1:11:17campaign so I'll answer that in my
- 1:11:20campaign collaboration is front and
- 1:11:22center I work with several candidates
- 1:11:24here on collaborative canvasing I also
- 1:11:27came up with an Innovative idea to uh
- 1:11:29work with some Mountain View wisman
- 1:11:31School District candidates and we are
- 1:11:33canvasing with each other extensively
- 1:11:35we're even hosting an event with a
- 1:11:37combined messaging if we can show how
- 1:11:38well we work together now imagine how
- 1:11:41well we can work together in the future
- 1:11:42to help restore the relationship and
- 1:11:44we're also very interested in making
- 1:11:46sure the Maga candidates stay out I
- 1:11:49focus also on inclusion thank you uh I
- 1:11:52have a diverse team and canvas and
- 1:11:54multip and multilingual and do
- 1:11:56multilingual Outreach I'm compassionate
- 1:11:59I will not speak ill of my fellow
- 1:12:00candidates or put them down in any way
- 1:12:02instead I reach out and see how they're
- 1:12:04doing and take care of them as much as I
- 1:12:06can thank you
- 1:12:10Eric I mean on top of just being asked
- 1:12:13how my day was I
- 1:12:15mean in all seriousness um gosh I I I
- 1:12:20think for me it does go back to the
- 1:12:23environment and reaching carbon
- 1:12:25neutrality goals by 2035 or being
- 1:12:28ambitious enough to reach them by 2035
- 1:12:30as some of you may know s
- 1:12:32sp38 is uh stuck in committee right now
- 1:12:36and should it pass this would be a great
- 1:12:39way for us to start not only having the
- 1:12:41discussion about carbon removal but also
- 1:12:44sequestration um especially when I'm
- 1:12:47thinking of like this isn't just a
- 1:12:48Mountain View issue issue this is a
- 1:12:50worldwide issue and that we need to
- 1:12:52start partnering up with our neighboring
- 1:12:54cities in order to share cost and also
- 1:12:57start start targeting um the global
- 1:12:59climate crisis because this also will
- 1:13:01have an impact in housing our local
- 1:13:03environment if we're worried about our
- 1:13:04green spaces consider those gone if we
- 1:13:06don't address this issue in a timely
- 1:13:09manner so um I hope that in the near
- 1:13:11future we are able to tackle this in a
- 1:13:14much more extensive manner
- 1:13:16Pat well I think the question you should
- 1:13:19ask is not just what we're going to do
- 1:13:20for the city but what we're going to do
- 1:13:21for the region because when you're um on
- 1:13:24City Council
- 1:13:25you also serve on all sorts of regional
- 1:13:28boards at the moment I serve on the San
- 1:13:31Francisco Bay conservation and
- 1:13:32development commission which is taking
- 1:13:35the lead on planning for sea level rise
- 1:13:38we're sort of analogous to the coastal
- 1:13:39commission but for San Francisco Bay so
- 1:13:43um my expertise as an engineer is is
- 1:13:47very important here as well as there um
- 1:13:50I also serve on the uh Silicon Valley
- 1:13:53clean energy board and again that's um
- 1:13:57an institution we we helped start um but
- 1:14:00it's uh it's very important for us
- 1:14:02collectively meeting our carbon
- 1:14:04neutrality goals I also am active in the
- 1:14:07National League of cities I serve on the
- 1:14:10energy environment and natural resources
- 1:14:13um policy committee and we put together
- 1:14:15the policies that that um that
- 1:14:17institution and all of the member cities
- 1:14:20um Advocate on thank
- 1:14:23you uh John
- 1:14:25I'm amazed no one asked me about my bold
- 1:14:28housing
- 1:14:29idea so I'll answer it my bold idea is
- 1:14:33that the city buys Apartments to take
- 1:14:35care of low-income housing subsidized
- 1:14:37housing rapid rehousing and how can we
- 1:14:40do it and save money there is an
- 1:14:43apartment there a website called loopnet
- 1:14:45there is an apartment complex in
- 1:14:47Mountain View 22 units at $8.4 million
- 1:14:51now when you do the math it's about
- 1:14:53$450,000 a door Mount and then we have
- 1:14:56complete control of who goes there how
- 1:14:58we can deal with it who's and we can we
- 1:15:00solve some problems Mountain View has
- 1:15:02spend in $800,000 or more for the
- 1:15:05Crestview hotel that is going to be
- 1:15:08shared with the county if we own the
- 1:15:11property we and we have the property we
- 1:15:14can make it denser we can uh build it
- 1:15:18you know rent it out there's many
- 1:15:20options to us and we have control and
- 1:15:22that's how it's one way to get done buy
- 1:15:24the property pay it with bonds rental
- 1:15:28money thank
- 1:15:31you okay now we are at the point for
- 1:15:35closing statements each um candidate has
- 1:15:37one minute and we will go in the
- 1:15:39following order Devin Nicholas Jose
- 1:15:45Emily Ida Rose Pat John Eric and Chris
- 1:15:51so Devon go ahead the first time I'm
- 1:15:53first is at the very end
- 1:15:55um so I'd like to you know be very clear
- 1:15:58that it has been an honor to serve on
- 1:16:00the school board and also to work with
- 1:16:03the city of Mountain View yes we have a
- 1:16:05challenging issue when it comes to the
- 1:16:07Shoreline funding because we're all
- 1:16:09facing economic uncertainty in the
- 1:16:11future and there's a lot of money there
- 1:16:13but there are so many ways in which we
- 1:16:15partner successfully all the time and I
- 1:16:17have a huge amount of respect for the
- 1:16:19council members here tonight for
- 1:16:21everyone on Council as well as for City
- 1:16:23staff when I was on the Parks and
- 1:16:25Recreation Commission I learned a lot
- 1:16:27about trees because it's also the urban
- 1:16:29forestry board and the canopy that grows
- 1:16:33from a sapling that's planted over time
- 1:16:37really benefits our entire community and
- 1:16:39you can see that in 10 2030 years the
- 1:16:42same perspective applies to our children
- 1:16:44and families when we are investing in
- 1:16:46our children and families it's going to
- 1:16:48pay off over the next 30 40 50 years and
- 1:16:51for our future Generations thank you
- 1:16:54thank you you
- 1:16:56Nicholas since this is my last
- 1:16:58opportunity to do so I would like to
- 1:17:00thank each of the candidates for running
- 1:17:03for public office thank you to Pat Chris
- 1:17:07Devin Ida Rose John Eric Emily and Jose
- 1:17:12for stepping up to the plate and running
- 1:17:16for city
- 1:17:17council I think that I have a unique
- 1:17:20background professional experience and
- 1:17:23policy platform to make an impact on
- 1:17:25city council for my first day on the job
- 1:17:28I hope that you get to check out my
- 1:17:30website nicholas4 mv.com and finally I
- 1:17:34would like to thank yall for being here
- 1:17:37this is what makes democracy work and I
- 1:17:40think to myself who did we not see here
- 1:17:42tonight how can we get them in the room
- 1:17:45because my motto is together we succeed
- 1:17:48I think that the best policy is made
- 1:17:50when everyone has a seat at the table I
- 1:17:52look forward to meeting each and every
- 1:17:54one of you
- 1:17:55thank you
- 1:17:56Jose speaking of everyone being a part
- 1:17:59of a table that's what my campaign's all
- 1:18:01about I believe that underrepresented
- 1:18:02neighborhoods where I live on leam
- 1:18:04street in California in apartments for
- 1:18:06over the last 20 years need
- 1:18:08representation we need new voices at
- 1:18:09City Hall we need New Perspectives I've
- 1:18:11been able to do that at the school board
- 1:18:13I'm doing that on the EPC I represent
- 1:18:15both renters and homeowners alike
- 1:18:17because I live in breathe the team
- 1:18:19mentality that's how I grew up that's
- 1:18:22how I was able to succeed and compete we
- 1:18:24have to relax one another to be able to
- 1:18:25get things done we need to believe in
- 1:18:27each other again but we need to be
- 1:18:28effective that's why my has has always
- 1:18:31been responsibility accountability and
- 1:18:33follow through because you have one shot
- 1:18:35to make a difference if you don't speak
- 1:18:36up at the day when the moment comes for
- 1:18:38you to speak up on behalf of someone or
- 1:18:40something or a cause you lose your
- 1:18:42moment and with that your Effectiveness
- 1:18:45we're leaders we have to be Fearless so
- 1:18:48I ask you to help me number three in the
- 1:18:49ballot thank you thank you Emily thank
- 1:18:53you to the League of Women voters for
- 1:18:55hosting this forum and and the mountain
- 1:18:57viiew voice I believe um I have been
- 1:19:00very fortunate to have been mentored by
- 1:19:03so many people with the League of Women
- 1:19:05Voters and outside of it I think about
- 1:19:08back in 2015 when I first started going
- 1:19:10to council meeting sitting in the back
- 1:19:11row with Julie lovens who was The
- 1:19:13Observer for the time I remember how in
- 1:19:172022 the last candidate forum for Mount
- 1:19:19city council was by uh moderated by
- 1:19:21Julie Kates who no who's no longer with
- 1:19:23us I I think think about how we are our
- 1:19:26ancestors greatest dreams and I feel
- 1:19:28like I am the the as we continue forward
- 1:19:32we continue to build and mentor and
- 1:19:34continue to grow uh I'm very fortunate
- 1:19:36to have the endorsement of the
- 1:19:38democratic party the Sierra Club Planned
- 1:19:40Parenthood League of conservation voters
- 1:19:42mie chamber I have a long list so I
- 1:19:45don't know if I'm get through to all of
- 1:19:46it South Bay labor Council Senator
- 1:19:48Becker Jose media and the entire Board
- 1:19:50of Supervisors uh in Santa Clara County
- 1:19:53and I hope to earn the rest of your
- 1:19:55support um by November 5th Ida Rose
- 1:20:00thank you to the League of Women Voters
- 1:20:02and baradero media media Mountain View
- 1:20:04voice for being here tonight and
- 1:20:06sponsoring this wonderful event and
- 1:20:08thank you to all of you the people of
- 1:20:10Mountain View is my why the reason I'm
- 1:20:12running to make a better world for all
- 1:20:14of
- 1:20:15us I have pragmatic experience grounded
- 1:20:18in years of doing the hard work I have a
- 1:20:20proven track record of thinking outside
- 1:20:22of the box to find solutions to our
- 1:20:24biggest problems and building
- 1:20:26relationships and uniting many players
- 1:20:28to make that happen I'm tenacious I
- 1:20:31listen well and I readily balance
- 1:20:33competing interests of people to find
- 1:20:35win-win Solutions in every case I'm
- 1:20:37involved in I am compassionate and
- 1:20:40passionate I love this city I love
- 1:20:43Mountain View I love its people I love
- 1:20:46our past our present and the future we
- 1:20:49will create working together thank you
- 1:20:52you can learn more about me at idos
- 1:20:53sylvester.com um thank you Pat well
- 1:20:58thank you um again to the uh League of
- 1:21:01Women Voters for sponsoring this I think
- 1:21:03it's been a great discussion and I also
- 1:21:05want to thank everybody who stepped up
- 1:21:08uh it's a lot of work to run for Council
- 1:21:11and you learn a lot on the trail and I
- 1:21:13really appreciate everyone for doing
- 1:21:15that it's great for our community I'm
- 1:21:18proud to be working to make Mountain
- 1:21:19View a community for all as a civil
- 1:21:21engineer I've collaborated across
- 1:21:23disciplines and agencies as your council
- 1:21:26member I apply those skills to Regional
- 1:21:28challenges such as protecting against
- 1:21:30climate change building new housing with
- 1:21:32minimal displacement enhancing Transit
- 1:21:34reducing and preventing homelessness and
- 1:21:36making our city more just I spent my
- 1:21:39career as a civil servant so I know how
- 1:21:42the patchwork quilt of government
- 1:21:44agencies in the Bay Area works the
- 1:21:46legislators legislators I worked with
- 1:21:48while on Council Anna isue Josh Becker
- 1:21:51Mark Burman and Joe sidian have all
- 1:21:53endorsed me as have um uh the League of
- 1:21:57Women voter no not the league sorry the
- 1:21:59league of conservation voters um the
- 1:22:02Sierra Club uh Planned Parenthood and
- 1:22:05the South Bay labor Council thank you
- 1:22:10John as we conclude tonight I want to
- 1:22:12leave you with this Mountain View as a
- 1:22:14city that I care deeply about from
- 1:22:17raising a family running a business to
- 1:22:19serving the city council every decision
- 1:22:21I've made has been driven by the desired
- 1:22:24improve the lives of our residents we
- 1:22:26Face challenges ahead slowing revenues
- 1:22:29the need for housing across all income
- 1:22:31levels and ensuring our Public Safety is
- 1:22:33well founded but with those challenges
- 1:22:35comes an opportunity to build a stronger
- 1:22:37more Vibrant
- 1:22:38Community I will continue to apply my
- 1:22:40experience as a successful business
- 1:22:42owner a problem solver and a
- 1:22:44collaborative leader to move Mountain
- 1:22:46View forward I'm proud to be endorsed by
- 1:22:49the voices like Joe sidian for my
- 1:22:51ability to collaborate with others the
- 1:22:52Sierra Club for my environment positions
- 1:22:55the firefighters for the support I give
- 1:22:58them at all times and the Los alos Town
- 1:23:00CER for my business background I ask for
- 1:23:03your vote so that together we can keep
- 1:23:04them mountain and view the best place it
- 1:23:07can be for all and I thank you thank you
- 1:23:10Eric thank you all so much for attending
- 1:23:13this evening I mean it's such a
- 1:23:14privilege to not only sit with y'all but
- 1:23:17alongside these leaders who have uh
- 1:23:19served the community T tremendously
- 1:23:21honestly I've seen them more than I've
- 1:23:23seen my own family by this
- 1:23:26point but honestly one of the things
- 1:23:29that's captured my eye about Mountain
- 1:23:31View has always been this idea that
- 1:23:33despite our different interest on what
- 1:23:35we want to tackle ultimately we all care
- 1:23:38about one another and want to see each
- 1:23:40one of us prosper in different ways but
- 1:23:42ultimately as a whole Community as well
- 1:23:45as you all listen I mean Mountain View
- 1:23:47is also at a critical juncture where
- 1:23:50decisions need to be made on housing
- 1:23:51Transportation sustainability Public
- 1:23:53Safety and these will not only have the
- 1:23:56impacts on our current lives but they
- 1:23:58impact they'll impact future generations
- 1:24:00to come so I hope to count on your
- 1:24:02support um I'm proud to be endorsed by
- 1:24:05just Midian uh plant Parenthood the
- 1:24:07labor Council our local workers here at
- 1:24:10SEIU 521 uh dayare workers as well so
- 1:24:14thank you Chris so as you've seen
- 1:24:18tonight we have a really great group of
- 1:24:20candidates this year democracy is very
- 1:24:22healthy in Mountain View thank goodness
- 1:24:23and the good news is that you can vote
- 1:24:25for almost half of us um I humbly
- 1:24:28request one of your four votes uh with
- 1:24:32your support we can maintain a healthy
- 1:24:33level of continuity over the next years
- 1:24:35while also welcoming new leaders we can
- 1:24:37have both I have a long impr proven
- 1:24:40track record of putting our city first I
- 1:24:42listen to all perspectives I analyze the
- 1:24:44facts options and paths forward and then
- 1:24:46I make a decision I feel is best for not
- 1:24:48just our current residents but future
- 1:24:50residents even when that means taking a
- 1:24:52political risk that approach along with
- 1:24:55my reputation for building consensus is
- 1:24:57why I'm supported by our local elected
- 1:24:59leaders at all levels of government as
- 1:25:01well as our neighborhood leaders our
- 1:25:03Public Safety employees the business
- 1:25:05Community Chamber of Commerce and many
- 1:25:06former mayors and advocacy groups who
- 1:25:08span the political Spectrum I hope I've
- 1:25:10earned your vote this evening and I look
- 1:25:12forward to continuing to serve you you
- 1:25:13can learn more at electris clark.com
- 1:25:15thank you thank you so this concludes
- 1:25:19our Forum I would like to thank the
- 1:25:21candidates for participating and running
- 1:25:24and all the volunteers who have made
- 1:25:26this forum possible the League of Women
- 1:25:28Voters believes that a democratic
- 1:25:30government depends upon the informed and
- 1:25:32active participation of its citizens and
- 1:25:35we hope that the insights you have
- 1:25:36gained from this forum will help in
- 1:25:37planning your vote thank you to all of
- 1:25:39you for attending this is great uh
- 1:25:41attendance tonight and we know that
- 1:25:43every vote counts and we don't know
- 1:25:46which race might be the race where that
- 1:25:48particular vote counts but please make
- 1:25:50sure to vote and every get everyone you
- 1:25:52know to vote to look at a personalized
- 1:25:55ballot with information about your
- 1:25:57candidates and ballot initiatives please
- 1:25:59visit
- 1:26:00vote411.org you will see profiles of the
- 1:26:03candidates and answers to questions
- 1:26:04posed by the league visit our web page
- 1:26:08lwv
- 1:26:10LV to see our election events including
- 1:26:14the pros and cons programs with balanced
- 1:26:16information about the local and state
- 1:26:18ballot measures and links to recordings
- 1:26:20of those that have already occurred for
- 1:26:23the no November 5th general election
- 1:26:26please vote early and deposit your
- 1:26:28signed ballot in a ballot Dropbox or
- 1:26:31mailbox as soon as possible and thank
- 1:26:34you all for helping make our democracy
- 1:26:38[Applause]
- 1:26:46work well dein did I do better this time
- 1:26:50you follow the rules I was so impressed
- 1:26:53I don't
- 1:26:55you did a great job
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Mountain View City Council Candidate Forum October 2024 by LWV of the Los Altos - Mountain View Area, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,065 words across 2,193 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.