YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → Mom Dressed Her Halloween Scarecrow In My Old Uniform, Not Knowing Why A Party Guest Took It Down

Mom Dressed Her Halloween Scarecrow In My Old Uniform, Not Knowing Why A Party Guest Took It Down — Transcript

by Buried Ranks · 10,853 words · 1,466 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00I'm Leah Hartwell, 38, and I grew up a
0:02few miles outside an army post in
0:04Missouri. The daughter of a mechanic who
0:06fixed trucks and a mother who believed
0:08that family always shows up. For 8
0:11years, I kept a secret from her about
0:12the week my father died. And I let her
0:14believe the worst about me because I
0:16thought it was easier for her to carry.
0:18But when she dressed her Halloween
0:19scarecrow in my old uniform and posed
0:21for photos with 40 guests, I learned
0:24that silence has a price for everyone.
0:26Have you ever let someone you love
0:28believe the worst about you? If so, tell
0:31me your story in the comments. You're
0:33not alone. Before I get into what
0:36happened, let me know where you're
0:37tuning in from. And if you've ever had
0:39to stand up for yourself after being
0:41wronged, hit that like button and
0:43subscribe.
0:45One more thing, I made an audio book
0:47called She Never Told Them. Perfect for
0:49a long drive. Eight stories over 12
0:53hours, no ads, and five you have never
0:56heard on this channel. Scan the code on
0:58your screen or find the link in the
1:00description at familytablestories.com.
1:04My mother asked me things now. She asked
1:06what a husky is. She asked what the
1:08patch on my right shoulder meant, the
1:10one I wore from my second deployment.
1:13She asked why I wear long sleeves in
1:14July. She asked how long the drive is
1:16from Kansas City to St. Robert and
1:18whether I want her to leave the porch
1:20light on and whether I still take my
1:22coffee black. Small questions, ordinary
1:25ones. She asked them carefully, the way
1:27you test ice on a pond in January. For 8
1:30years, she asked me nothing at all. It
1:32is Memorial Day weekend as I tell you
1:34this, 2026. I am sitting on the back
1:37porch of the house I grew up in on the
1:39edge of St. Robert, Missouri, a few
1:41miles outside the main gate of Fort
1:42Leonard Wood. My mother is inside making
1:45potato salad. There's a wooden post at
1:47the far end of the yard near the fence
1:49where something used to stand that does
1:51not stand there anymore. There's a
1:53folded uniform in the house in a place
1:55it was never meant to be. I will tell
1:57you how it got there. It took a
1:59scarecrow. But first, you have to know
2:01about the rule.
2:03I grew up in the sound of trucks. My
2:05father, Frank Hartwell, was a civilian
2:07mechanic in the motorpool on post for 31
2:10years. He worked on Humvees and 5-tonon
2:12trucks and anything else the army could
2:14break. He came home every night at 5:40
2:17with grease in the creases of his
2:19knuckles that no soap ever fully got
2:21out. He smelled like diesel and lava
2:24soap. He was a quiet man. He fixed
2:27things. That was how he talked.
2:30My mother, Carolyn, was the secretary at
2:32the elementary school on Missouri Avenue
2:34for 26 years. She knew every child's
2:36name and every child's mother's name and
2:38which ones were behind on lunch money.
2:40She ran our house the way she ran that
2:42front office. calendars, lists, a place
2:46for everything. And she had one rule.
2:50In this family, we show up, she told my
2:53brother, Nate, and me more times than I
2:55can count. That's the whole rule.
2:58Birthdays, recital, funerals, Sunday
3:00dinner, you show up. She meant it. She
3:03had grown up with a father who did not
3:05show up. A long haul driver who missed
3:08most of her childhood and then all of
3:10the rest of it.
3:12She built her whole life around never
3:14being that. She came to every school
3:17play, every ball game, every science
3:20fair. She sat in the front row with a
3:23camera and a thermos and a sign she had
3:25made herself. I loved her for it. I also
3:29learned early that she kept score.
3:32When I was nine, my father missed Nate's
3:348th grade band concert. A convoy of
3:37trucks had come back from a field
3:39exercise with half their transmissions
3:40shot and the motorpool kept everyone
3:43late. He called the school office from a
3:45pay phone on post at 6:15. My mother
3:48took the call herself. She said, "I
3:51understand." in her front office voice
3:54and hung up and sat through the whole
3:56concert with his empty folding chair
3:58beside her and her purse on it so nobody
4:00would take it. He came in the back door
4:02at 9:30 with Diesel on his coveralls.
4:05She had left his plate in the oven. She
4:07did not speak to him for 3 days. Not
4:09loudly, not cruy. She simply was not
4:12there for him. She set his plate and
4:15poured his coffee and answered when he
4:17asked her something, and that was all.
4:20On the fourth day, she was herself
4:22again. It was never discussed.
4:25Nate and I watched it happen the way you
4:27watch weather. Why does she do that? I
4:30asked my father once in the garage.
4:33I was maybe 12. He was rebuilding a
4:36carburetor on a towel on the workbench.
4:38He did not look up. Her daddy never came
4:41home, he said. Not for anything. She
4:44waited on a lot of porches. He set a
4:47tiny spring down on the towel. She's not
4:50mad at me. She's mad at the porch. I
4:52didn't understand that for a long time.
4:55I understood it later. Much later. There
4:58was one more thing about my mother. She
5:00kept an extra chair. At every holiday,
5:02every birthday, every Sunday dinner, if
5:04somebody who should have been there was
5:05not there, she set their place anyway.
5:08Plate, fork, napkin, glass, she left it
5:12empty through the whole meal. She said
5:15it was so that we would remember. I
5:17think it was really so that the person
5:18who wasn't there would know somehow that
5:21they had been missed, that they had been
5:24counted. It never occurred to me as a
5:26child that one day the empty chair would
5:28be mine or what it would cost. both of
5:31us. In high school, I ran cross country
5:34and took every math class they had. I
5:38worked summers at the hardware store on
5:40Old Route 66, cutting keys and mixing
5:43paint. I was not a remarkable student in
5:46most ways. I was stubborn. I liked
5:49problems that had an answer. My mother
5:51came to every meet, standing at the
5:53finish line in her school sweatshirt
5:55with her thermos. She shouted my time
5:57out loud as I crossed every race whether
5:59it was good or not. My father came when
6:02he could. When he couldn't, she told me
6:04afterward that he had wanted to. She
6:06always told me that. I believed her. Our
6:09town lived and breathed the post.
6:11Convoys rolled down the main road at all
6:13hours. Half my classmates had a parent
6:15in uniform. The other half had a parent
6:17who worked for one. I watched engineers
6:20train at the ranges past the airfield. I
6:23watched them build bridges across creeks
6:25in an afternoon and take them down by
6:26dark. I was 11 the first time I saw it.
6:30I thought it was the most useful thing I
6:32had ever seen a person do. My father
6:34took me to the Posts Engineer Museum on
6:36a Saturday that same year. He walked me
6:38through it slowly, his hands in his
6:40pockets. He stopped at a display of a
6:42soldier in a dusty uniform with a small
6:44black and gold tab on his left shoulder
6:46that said sapper. Those are the ones who
6:49go first, my father said. They clear the
6:51road so everybody behind them comes
6:53home. I didn't say anything. I just
6:55looked at the tab for a long time. I
6:58went to Rola for college, Missouri
7:00University of Science and Technology,
7:01Civil Engineering, Army Rot.
7:05It was 40 minutes from home. My mother
7:07made me promise to come home every
7:09Sunday. I did most of them. I was
7:11commissioned a second lieutenant in May
7:13of 2009. 22 years old, engineer branch.
7:18My father pinned on my gold bars
7:20himself. His hands shook a little. He
7:23did not say much. My mother cried
7:25through the whole ceremony. "The army's
7:28going to take her," she said to him
7:30afterward in the parking lot, not quite
7:32quietly enough. "She's an engineer,
7:35Carol," my father said. "She builds
7:37things." "It's going to take her," my
7:40mother said again. She was right. I just
7:42didn't know yet how. The basic officer
7:45leader course was at Fort Leonard Wood
7:48home. I could see the water tower on our
7:50side of town from the ranges. Then in
7:532010, I went to the sapper leader
7:55course. 28 days, demolitions,
7:57patrolling, mountaineering, water
7:59operations, land navigation with a ruck
8:02that weighed more than some of the
8:04students. We slept maybe 3 hours a
8:06night. Half my class did not finish. I
8:09was one of two women who did. They gave
8:12me the tab on a Friday afternoon in a
8:14gravel lot behind the training area. An
8:16instructor slapped it onto my shoulder
8:18hard enough to leave a bruise. That is
8:21the tradition. I did not mind the
8:23bruise.
8:25I drove home that night, 20 minutes. My
8:28father was in the garage under the hood
8:29of the Buick. I walked in still in my
8:32uniform, filthy, 20 lb lighter than I
8:35had been a month earlier, and he looked
8:36up and saw the tab and set his wrench
8:38down very carefully on the fender. He
8:40did not hug me. He was not a hugger. He
8:43walked over and put his thumb on the tab
8:45and held it there for a moment,
8:46pressing. The way you press on a patch
8:48to see if it will hold. First one's down
8:51the road, he said. Yes, sir. That night,
8:54he took my uniform off the floor of the
8:56laundry room where I had dropped it and
8:57washed it twice and hung it to dry and
8:59then got out the iron. Dad, it's a field
9:02uniform, I said from the doorway. You
9:04don't iron it. I do, he said. And he
9:07did. Every single time I came home for
9:10the rest of his life, my father took
9:12whatever uniform I had worn in the door
9:14and washed it and pressed it with a
9:16sharp crease down each sleeve and hung
9:18it in the cedar closet at the top of the
9:20stairs next to his one good suit. It was
9:23the only thing I ever saw him iron. He
9:25kept them all in there. He said someday
9:28I would want them. My mother had one
9:30rule. I broke it only once in my life.
9:33And I never told her why. The army did
9:35take me. Not all at once, a piece at a
9:38time. My first deployment was
9:40Afghanistan, 2011 to 2012. I was a first
9:44lieutenant, 24 years old, a horizontal
9:47construction platoon leader. We built
9:49roads, gravel roads mostly, and drainage
9:52culverts and the paths that outposts sat
9:54on, graders and dozers and dump trucks
9:57in the dust. It was hard, plain work,
9:59and I was good at it. And I missed
10:01Thanksgiving and Christmas and my
10:02mother's birthday and Nate's wedding.
10:05Nate married Jess in April of 2012 in a
10:08church in Wesville. I watched part of it
10:10on a laptop in a plywood office at a
10:13forward operating base at 3 in the
10:15morning through a connection that froze
10:17every 40 seconds. My mother had set a
10:20place for me at the reception. Plate,
10:23fork, napkin, glass. Nate told me later
10:27she had walked over to it twice during
10:29the toast and straightened the napkin. I
10:32came home in the summer. My mother
10:34hugged me at the airport in Springfield
10:36for a long time. Then in the car, she
10:39said, "You missed your brother's
10:41wedding. I know, Mom. I'm just saying
10:44it. Somebody has to say it." That was
10:47the first time. I didn't think much of
10:49it. I had been gone a year and I was
10:51tired and I knew she had missed me. I
10:54made captain in 2013, 26 years old.
10:58career course, a staff job at Fort Hood
11:00in Texas, then a staff job at Fort
11:03Bragg. The holidays came and went. I
11:06made it home for some of them. More
11:08often, I didn't. The army runs on its
11:10own calendar, and that calendar does not
11:12care about Thanksgiving in St. Robert,
11:14Missouri. Every time I missed one, the
11:16chair was there. I know because Nate
11:18sent me pictures. He didn't mean
11:20anything by it. He thought it was sweet.
11:23A photo of the Thanksgiving table,
11:25turkey in the middle, and at the end the
11:27empty place with my name card on it in
11:29my mother's careful school office
11:31printing. Leah, Christmas, Easter, my
11:35father's 60th birthday. The chair. When
11:39I did come home, it was there in other
11:41ways. Nice of you to fit us in, she
11:44would say, hugging me at the door or at
11:46dinner to a neighbor. This is my
11:48daughter. We see her on the news more
11:50than we see her at this table. or worst
11:53of all, nothing. Three days of nothing.
11:56The same silence she had given my father
11:59when I was nine. She set my plate and
12:02poured my coffee and answered when I
12:04asked her something. I had watched it
12:06happen to him. Now I watched it happen
12:09to me.
12:10My father never said anything about it
12:12in front of her, but every time I came
12:14home, I would find him in the garage at
12:16some point, and he would hand me a
12:17wrench or a rag and put me to work on
12:19whatever he had torn apart, and we would
12:21not talk about anything at all for an
12:22hour. It was the best part of every
12:24visit. Then he would take my uniform
12:26upstairs and press it and hang it in the
12:28cedar closet. I counted them once, 11.
12:33In the spring of 2016, my father was
12:35diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. Stage
12:38four. I was 28. I was at Fort Bragg and
12:42I had just been told I would take
12:43command of a route clearance company
12:44that summer and deploy with it to
12:46Afghanistan in September. Route
12:48clearance is exactly what it sounds
12:50like. A company of engineers with a set
12:52of strange heavy vehicles. Huskies with
12:55their ground penetrating radar.
12:57Buffaloos with a long mechanical arm
12:59that reaches out to dig at whatever the
13:01husky finds. Mine resistant trucks in
13:04front and behind. You drive the roads
13:06before anyone else drives them. Slowly
13:08looking for bombs. You find them so
13:10other people don't have to. First ones
13:13down the road. It was the job my father
13:15had shown me in a museum when I was 11.
13:17I flew home the week after the
13:19diagnosis. My father was thinner
13:21already. He sat in his recliner with a
13:23blanket over his knees and asked me
13:24about the company, the vehicles, the
13:26number of soldiers, the deployment date.
13:28I'm going to turn it down, Dad, I said.
13:30I'll ask for a stateside job. I'll come
13:33home. He looked at me for a long moment.
13:35Then he reached over and took my hand.
13:38His was rough as a rasp. "No, you
13:41won't," he said. "Go take care of your
13:43soldiers. I've got your mother." "Dad,
13:47first one's down the road," he said.
13:50"Somebody's got to be. Might as well be
13:52somebody who knows what she's doing." He
13:54squeezed my hand once and let it go.
13:57I'll be here when you get back.
14:00My mother was in the kitchen doorway.
14:02She had heard all of it. She turned
14:04around and went back into the kitchen
14:06without a word, and I heard the water
14:08run in the sink for a long time. She did
14:10not speak to me for the rest of that
14:11visit. Not one word that was not about
14:14food or towels.
14:16I took command in July. We deployed in
14:18September. 91 soldiers, 26 vehicles. We
14:23drove the roads around Kandahar and down
14:25toward the border. We found things. Most
14:27days we found them in time. I called
14:30home every week I could. My father's
14:32voice got thinner on the phone. In
14:34February, Nate called and told me it was
14:36weeks now, not months. I put in for
14:39emergency leave. It was approved for the
14:42middle of March. I would fly out on the
14:4414th. On March 9th, 2017, at 9:40 in the
14:48morning, the lead vehicle in my patrol
14:50hit a pressure plate bomb buried under a
14:52culvert that the husky had driven over
14:54clean. I am going to tell you this part
14:56plainly because that is the only way I
14:58know how to tell it. The truck was a
15:00mine resistant vehicle. It did what it
15:02was built to do. It kept the three men
15:05inside alive.
15:07But the blast ruptured a fuel line and
15:09the cab caught fire and the rear door
15:12was jammed shut by the blast.
15:14I was in the second vehicle. I was out
15:17and running before anyone else because I
15:18was closest.
15:20The front passenger door had buckled,
15:22but it moved. Staff Sergeant Curtis
15:24Ambrose was in the seat, unconscious.
15:27Specialist Thomas Ibara was behind him,
15:29conscious and screaming. Private First
15:31Class Jaylen Pierce was in the gunner's
15:33hatch, hung up in his harness. I got
15:35them out one at a time. It took about 4
15:38minutes. I do not remember most of them.
15:41I remember that my gloves melted. I
15:43remember my medic, Sergeant Alvarez,
15:45trying to pull me back by my vest and me
15:47shoving her off so I could reach the
15:48third one.
15:50I remember Pierce's harness buckle being
15:52too hot to touch and touching it anyway.
15:54I remember lying in the dirt afterward
15:56next to the three of them, all of them
15:58breathing and looking at my hands and
16:00thinking very clearly, "I am not going
16:03to make it home for dad." Ambrose never
16:05saw my face. He was unconscious the
16:08whole time. They flew the three of them
16:10out on one helicopter and me on another.
16:14I did not see any of them again. My
16:16father died on March 12th at home in his
16:19recliner with my mother holding his
16:21hand. I was in Germany at the hospital
16:24at Lensto being prepared to fly to the
16:26burn center at Brook Army Medical Center
16:28in San Antonio. Nate called me. I
16:31listened to him cry. I could not hold
16:33the phone myself. A nurse held it to my
16:36ear. The funeral was on March 17th. I
16:40was in the burn ICU in San Antonio. Both
16:44hands, both forearms, second and third
16:47degree. A concussion that made the
16:49lights too bright. They told me I would
16:51not travel for weeks. Nate called me the
16:53night before the funeral. He wanted to
16:55tell our mother. He wanted to drive down
16:57and get me somehow. Wheel me in. No, I
17:01said. Leah, she thinks you just didn't
17:03come. She thinks the army wouldn't let
17:05you. She thinks you didn't fight for it.
17:08She just buried Dad. I said she doesn't
17:11need to bury my hands, too. Not this
17:13week. Not like this. I closed my eyes
17:15against the lights. Tell her I couldn't
17:18get leave. Tell her I'm sorry. Please,
17:21Nate. Promise me. He was quiet for a
17:24long time. She's going to hate you for
17:26this. He said finally. Then she'll hate
17:29me. I said she won't be afraid. He
17:33promised. They set a chair for me at the
17:35funeral. Nate told me that much. Plate,
17:38fork, napkin, glass. at the lunch in the
17:41church basement afterward. Empty. I
17:44healed slowly, skin grafts, months of
17:46therapy. My hands work now. They are
17:49just not pretty. I wear long sleeves
17:51most of the year and I am used to it. I
17:54left active duty in 2018 as a captain.
17:5831 years old with a Bronze Star with a V
18:01device and a purple heart that I keep in
18:03a shoe box on a closet shelf in Kansas
18:05City. I took a job with the Missouri
18:08Department of Transportation as a bridge
18:10inspector. I like it. I climb under
18:13bridges and look for cracks. Most days I
18:16find them in time. I never told my
18:18mother. At first it was because she was
18:20grieving. Then it was because she had
18:22stopped asking. And then after a while
18:24it was because too much time had gone
18:26by. 8 years. You would be surprised how
18:29easily 8 years can go by. I still came
18:32home. Not for every holiday, but for
18:35more of them than before. Kansas City is
18:373 hours from St. Robert. I drove down
18:40for Thanksgiving and Christmas and my
18:42mother's birthday in June. I wore long
18:45sleeves. I kept my hands in my lap at
18:47the table or in my pockets or wrapped
18:50around a coffee mug. If anyone noticed,
18:52they did not say.
18:55My mother noticed other things. The
18:57first Thanksgiving after the funeral,
18:59she set the table and there was no extra
19:01chair. Everyone who was supposed to be
19:03there was there. I thought for a moment
19:06that it was a kind of peace. Then she
19:08raised her glass before the blessing. To
19:11Frank, she said, who never missed a
19:13single thing that mattered. She did not
19:16look at me. She did not have to. It went
19:18on like that. Not every visit, not
19:21loudly. My mother was never loud. She
19:23did it the way she did everything.
19:26Precisely. A remark at the right moment
19:28in front of the right people. to her
19:30friends from church. Leah's very busy.
19:33She was too busy for her father's
19:34funeral. So, you can imagine to Nate's
19:36wife, while I was standing right there
19:38drying dishes. Some people show up and
19:41some people send flowers. Once two
19:44Christmases ago, she gave me a framed
19:45photo of my father's funeral. The whole
19:48family in front of the church in the
19:49March wind, everyone but me. She had
19:52written on the back in her front office
19:53printing. So, you can see what it looked
19:56like. I hung it in my hallway. I do not
19:59entirely know why. I think I wanted to
20:02see what it looked like. Nate tried a
20:04few times to make me let him tell her.
20:07Every year it got harder for him. Every
20:09year I said no. By then the reason had
20:11changed though I did not admit it even
20:13to myself. I was not protecting her
20:16anymore. I was protecting the story. If
20:19I told her now after 5 years, 6 years,
20:227, it would sound like an excuse. It
20:25would sound like I was asking for
20:26something. pity, credit, forgiveness.
20:31I did not want any of those. I wanted
20:34her to have trusted me, and she had not.
20:38So, I let her keep her version, and I
20:39kept mine, and we sat at the same table
20:42three or four times a year and passed
20:44the green beans across a distance
20:45neither of us would name.
20:48There was one more thing that changed
20:49after my father died, the Halloween
20:51party. My father had loved Halloween. It
20:54was the one night of the year he was not
20:56quiet. Every October, for as long as I
20:58could remember, he built a scarecrow at
21:00the end of the backyard by the fence on
21:03a cedar post he had sunk himself in
21:051990. He dressed it in his own old
21:08motorpool coveralls stuffed with straw
21:10from the feed store with a burlap face
21:12he painted himself and a straw hat. The
21:16whole neighborhood came. Kids from
21:18Nate's school and mine. Soldiers from
21:20Post who had nowhere else to go. My
21:22father stood by the fire pit in a
21:24flannel shirt, handing out cider, the
21:27happiest I ever saw him. After he died,
21:30my mother kept the party going. I think
21:33it was the only way she knew how to keep
21:34him in the yard. She invited his friends
21:37and her friends and the neighbors and
21:39the neighbors friends, 40, 50 people
21:42some years. She kept his cider recipe.
21:45She kept the post. For 8 years, she put
21:47his coveralls on the scarecrow. This
21:50year, she did not. She never asked. I
21:52never told. And the uniforms stayed
21:55upstairs in the cedar closet where my
21:57father had hung them. 11 of them pressed
22:01waiting. Halloween fell on a Friday in
22:042025.
22:06I worked a full day. I spent the morning
22:08under a bridge on Interstate 70 east of
22:11Kansas City with a flashlight and a
22:13hammer sounding concrete and the
22:15afternoon writing it up. I left at 4. I
22:19hit traffic in Lee's Summit and again
22:20outside Springfield and I did not get to
22:23St. Robert until 6:35 after dark. I
22:27almost did not go at all. I had a cold
22:29coming on. I had a report due Monday. I
22:32had sat through eight of my mother's
22:34Halloween parties since my father died
22:36standing by the fire pit in a long
22:38sleeve shirt making small talk with
22:40church ladies and I knew exactly how the
22:42evening would go. But it was the party
22:44he had loved. And in this family, we
22:47show up. The street was full of cars,
22:50pickup trucks with post decals in the
22:52windshields, minivans, a golf cart
22:54somebody had driven over from the next
22:56block decorated with orange lights. I
22:59parked three houses down and walked up
23:01the sidewalk with a bag of candy corn
23:03and a store-bought pie. The front porch
23:06was lit with jacko'lanterns, a dozen of
23:08them carved by my mother and Gloria Fen
23:11from next door, who had been her friend
23:13since 1994.
23:14Music was coming from the backyard,
23:16somebody's playlist, old rock and roll.
23:19I let myself in the front door, the way
23:21I always had. The kitchen was full of
23:23food under plastic wrap. Chili in two
23:26slow cookers, my father's cider steaming
23:29in the big enamel pot on the stove. I
23:31set the pie on the counter and went out
23:33the back door into the deck. The yard
23:35was full. 40 guests, maybe more, in
23:38costumes. A pirate, two witches, a man
23:41in a gorilla suit who was clearly
23:43regretting it.
23:44Several cowboys, a woman dressed as a
23:46bottle of ketchup and her husband as
23:48mustard, teachers from my mother's old
23:50school, couples from church, neighbors,
23:53a few young soldiers from post and
23:54homemade costumes, the kind of young
23:56soldiers my father used to invite
23:58because they had nowhere else to go. My
24:00mother still invited them. She called it
24:02his rule. The fire pit was going. String
24:05lights ran from the deck to the oak
24:06tree. Hay bales for seats. And at the
24:10far end of the yard, by the fence, on my
24:12father's cedar post, stood the
24:14scarecrow. I saw it from the deck. I did
24:17not understand what I was seeing at
24:19first. My eyes went past it and then
24:21came back. It was not wearing my
24:24father's coveralls. It was wearing my
24:26uniform, my army combat uniform. The tan
24:29and green pattern I had worn on my
24:31second deployment. The blouse buttoned
24:33up the front over a stuffing of straw
24:35that poked out at the collar and cuffs.
24:38The trousers tied at the ankles with
24:40bailing twine, straw sticking out the
24:42bottoms. A burlap sack for a head
24:44painted with a stitched smile. And on
24:46top of it, my patrol cap pulled down.
24:50Somebody had pinned a plastic crow to
24:52the left shoulder, black and glossy, its
24:54wings spread. It sat right over the
24:56place where the tab was. I knew which
24:59one it was. I knew from the fading on
25:01the right sleeve. It was the last one my
25:03father had pressed. the one I had worn
25:06home on my leave in 2016, the week he
25:09was diagnosed before I went back and
25:11took command. He had hung it in the
25:13cedar closet with the other 10. I had
25:15not seen it in 9 years. I stood on the
25:18deck with my hand on the rail. I did not
25:20move.
25:22I am not sure I breathed.
25:24A cluster of people had gathered around
25:26the scarecrow, phones up, laughing, and
25:29in the middle of them, posing, one hand
25:32on the scarecrow's straw stuffed arm,
25:34was my mother. She was dressed as a farm
25:36wife. Gingham apron, a straw hat, a
25:40pitchfork from the garage. She looked
25:42happy. She looked honestly the happiest
25:44I had seen her look in years. Gloria was
25:47taking pictures with my mother's phone.
25:49I walked down off the deck and across
25:51the yard. The grass was wet. My boots
25:54left dark prince. Okay, one more. Gloria
25:57was saying Caroline, turn a little
26:00there. My mother turned. She saw me
26:03coming. Her smile did not change. She
26:05waved me over with the pitchfork. Oh,
26:08look. She made it. Come here, honey. Get
26:09in the picture. She turned back to the
26:12little crowd and threw her arm around
26:14the scarecrow's shoulders, crow and all.
26:16Everybody, this is my daughter. And
26:18this, she patted the stuffed chest right
26:21over the name tape, is our little
26:22soldier. People laughed. Someone said it
26:25was the best decoration on the street.
26:27At least the uniform finally showed up
26:29for something, my mother said. The laugh
26:31got bigger. Not mean for most of them.
26:34Polite. The way people laugh at a
26:36hostess's joke at her own party. A few
26:38of the church ladies looked at each
26:40other. A couple of them knew. Everybody
26:42at that church knew the story of the
26:43daughter who did not come to her
26:44father's funeral. 40 guests in costumes.
26:48My mother in her gingham apron posing
26:50for photos beside a scarecrow in my
26:52uniform. My face was very hot. My hands
26:55were in my jacket pockets, and I could
26:57feel the grafted skin on them pulling as
26:59I made fists. "That's enough, Mom," I
27:02said. I said it quietly. I did not want
27:05a scene. I had never in my life made a
27:08scene at one of my mother's parties. She
27:10laughed. She actually laughed light and
27:11easy and patted my arm. "Oh, don't be so
27:14serious, Leah. It's Halloween. It's been
27:16sitting in that closet for years.
27:17Somebody might as well get some use out
27:18of it. She turned back to Gloria. Get
27:21one more. Get one with both of us, my
27:24two soldiers. She pulled me in beside
27:27her. I let her. I don't know why. I
27:30stood next to my own uniform full of
27:32straw and looked at the phone while
27:33Gloria held it up and I did not smile.
27:36That was when I noticed the man. He had
27:38been standing a few feet behind Gloria
27:40at the edge of the little crowd. I had
27:42never seen him before in my life.
27:44mid-40s, maybe broad through the
27:47shoulders, a flannel shirt and jeans and
27:49a battered cowboy hat. The kind of
27:51costume that is barely a costume.
27:54He had a red plastic cup of cider in one
27:57hand. He was not laughing. He was not
28:00looking at my mother or at me. He was
28:03looking at the scarecrow's left
28:04shoulder. He set his drink down on a hay
28:07bale. Slowly, he stepped forward past
28:11Gloria, past the phone as if nobody else
28:13was there. He reached up and unpinned
28:16the plastic crow from the shoulder. He
28:18held it for a second, looking at what
28:20was underneath. A small black and gold
28:22tab. Sapper under it, the unit patch.
28:26Then he looked at the right shoulder,
28:28the combat patch. He looked at it for a
28:31long time. Then he looked at the name
28:33tape over the left chest pocket.
28:36Heartwell. I watched his lips move as he
28:39read it. I watched all the color go out
28:42of his face. He did not look at me. I do
28:45not think he knew yet which one of the
28:47people standing there was the name on
28:49the tape. He reached up and untied the
28:52bailing twine at the ankles. He lifted
28:55the patrol cap off the burlap head. He
28:58lifted the whole uniform off the post
29:00carefully, the way you lift something
29:02that is hurt, and the straw fell out of
29:04it in clumps into the wet grass. He
29:07shook the last of the straw out of the
29:09blouse. Then he folded it. Not the way
29:12you fold laundry, the way they teach
29:14you. Sleeves in square, tight, then the
29:18trousers. He laid the cap on top. He did
29:22it standing in the middle of my mother's
29:23yard with 40 people watching and his
29:26hands were shaking the whole time and he
29:28did not drop a single thing. My mother
29:30kept smiling for the camera. She did not
29:32understand. She thought, "I think that
29:34it was part of a joke, someone's bit."
29:37"Well," she said, laughing a little.
29:40"Are you the new scarecrow?" The man
29:42looked at her then, just once. Then he
29:45tucked the folded uniform under his arm
29:47like a flag and walked out of the yard
29:49through the side gate without a word.
29:52We heard a truck door close out on the
29:54street, an engine start, then nothing.
29:56The yard was quiet for a moment. The
29:58music kept playing. Then somebody
30:00laughed uncertainly and said, "Okay, who
30:02was that?" And Gloria said she thought
30:04he had come with the Pattersons from
30:06down the street, and the party slowly
30:08started back up again. My mother
30:10shrugged and handed the pitchfork to
30:11Gloria and went inside to check on the
30:13chili. I stood by the empty post. There
30:16was straw all around my boots. I did not
30:18know who he was. I had no idea. I had
30:21never seen his face. I stood out there
30:23by the fence for a long time. People
30:25drifted back to the fire. Somebody
30:27brought out the s'mores. I looked at my
30:29watch out of habit the way you mark time
30:32after a contact. 6:58.
30:35At 7:18, 20 minutes later, the doorbell
30:37rang. I heard it all the way out in the
30:40yard. My mother's doorbell is the old
30:42kind. Two loud notes. It rang once, then
30:46again. My mother went to answer it. I
30:49was already crossing the yard. I came in
30:52through the kitchen as she opened the
30:53front door and I stopped in the hallway
30:55behind her. There were three men on the
30:57porch. The man in the cowboy hat stood
31:00in front. He had taken the hat off. He
31:02was holding the folded uniform in both
31:04hands, flat, the patrol cap on top.
31:08Behind him, one on each side, were two
31:10younger men. One was tall and thin with
31:12a shaved head. The other was shorter and
31:15heavy set, and he had a long, smooth
31:17burn scar running up the left side of
31:19his neck into his hairline, the kind of
31:21scar I knew very well. They were both in
31:24civilian clothes. They both stood at a
31:26kind of attention without seeming to
31:27know they were doing it. My mother stood
31:29in the doorway in her gingham apron with
31:31her hand on the door knob. "Ma'am," the
31:34man in front said. His voice was rough.
31:37"I'm sorry to bother you. I'm looking
31:39for Captain Hartwell." He swallowed.
31:42"I've been looking for her for 8 years."
31:45My mother held the door open. She did
31:47not know yet what she was holding it
31:48open for. "I'm Leah Hartwell," I said
31:51from the hallway. All three of them
31:54looked past my mother at me. The tall
31:56one with the shaved head made a small
31:58sound like a breath let out wrong. The
32:00heavy set one with the scar on his neck
32:02put his hand flat against the porch
32:04post. The man with the uniform looked at
32:07my face for a long moment. I understood
32:10then that he had never seen it. He had
32:12been unconscious the whole time.
32:16Ma'am, he said, Curtis Ambrose, I was
32:19your lead truck commander. March 9th,
32:222017.
32:24He nodded to the tall one. Jaylen
32:26Pierce. He was on the gun, then to the
32:29other. Thomas Abara behind me. I know
32:33who you are, I said. My voice did
32:35something I did not expect it to do. I
32:38stopped and started again. I know who
32:41you are, Sergeant Ambrose.
32:43Behind me, the kitchen had gone quiet.
32:46People had come in from the yard. I
32:48could feel them in the doorway, in the
32:50hall. the pirate and the witches and the
32:52church ladies crowding to see. My mother
32:55had not moved. She still had her hand on
32:57the door knob. I'm sorry, she said. I
33:01don't understand. Do you know my
33:03daughter? Curtis Ambrose turned to her.
33:06He was very careful. He spoke the way
33:09soldiers speak to the mothers of other
33:10soldiers, which is a particular way,
33:13slow and plain and respectful. Yes,
33:16ma'am. Not her face. I never saw her
33:19face, but I know her name. I've had it
33:21written on a card in my wallet for 8
33:23years. He held the uniform a little
33:25higher. Ma'am, on March 9th, 2017, our
33:29truck hit a bomb outside Kandahar. It
33:32caught fire. The back door was jammed. I
33:34was knocked out. These two were trapped.
33:36Your daughter got to us first. She
33:38pulled all three of us out of that fire
33:40with her hands. Her gloves burned off.
33:42She wouldn't let the medic touch her
33:44until we were clear. Nobody in the
33:46hallway made a sound. They flew us out
33:48separately, he said. I tried to find her
33:52after. The army doesn't make that easy.
33:54I got as far as her name and her unit. I
33:57heard she'd been burned bad and sent to
33:59San Antonio. Then she got out and I lost
34:01her. He looked down at the uniform. I
34:04teach at the sapper leader course now on
34:06post 15 minutes from this porch.
34:08Tonight, my wife and I came with the
34:10Pattersons, and I saw a scarecrow with a
34:12tab on its shoulder and a name I've been
34:14carrying for eight years. He turned to
34:16me. I called these two from the truck.
34:18They live on post. They were here in 12
34:20minutes. "Ma'am," Jallen Pierce said to
34:23me, his voice cracked. "Ma'am, hi." I
34:27laughed. I could not help it. It came
34:29out wet. "Hi, Pierce." Then my mother
34:32spoke again very quietly. "March," she
34:36said. March of 2017. Curtis Ambrose
34:40looked at her, then at me, then back at
34:42her. I watched him understand that
34:44something was happening in that doorway
34:45that he did not know about.
34:48"Yes, ma'am," he said.
34:51The ninth. My mother's hand came off the
34:54doornob. She turned and looked at me.
34:57Her face had gone completely white under
34:59the brim of her straw hat. "Your father
35:02died on the 12th," she said. "I know,
35:05Mom. The funeral was the 17th.
35:09Her voice was getting smaller. You said
35:11you couldn't get leave. I did not say
35:14anything. I took my hands out of my
35:15jacket pockets for the first time that
35:17night and I held them up in the hallway
35:19light, palms out so she could see them.
35:21The graphs, the shiny pulled skin across
35:24the backs, the places where the knuckles
35:26do not quite bend all the way. My mother
35:28looked at my hands, the guests left over
35:30the next half hour. Nobody said anything
35:33much. Gloria moved through the yard,
35:35turning off the string lights and
35:36blowing out the jacko'lanterns one at a
35:38time, and people took their coats and
35:40their casserole dishes and went quietly
35:41down the sidewalk to their cars. Curtis
35:44Ambrose gave me his phone number on the
35:46back of a gas receipt. He asked if he
35:48could come back another day with his
35:50wife. I said yes. Pierce hugged me on
35:54the porch hard without asking. Ibara
35:57shook my hand very carefully. The way
35:59you shake a hand, you know, has been
36:00burned. Then they were gone and the
36:02street was empty and it was just my
36:04mother and me in the kitchen. The chili
36:06was still on. The cider was still
36:08steaming on the stove. The folded
36:11uniform sat on the kitchen table between
36:13us where Curtis had laid it, the patrol
36:15cap on top. My mother sat down across
36:17from it. She had taken off the straw
36:19hat. She looked older than I had ever
36:22seen her. "You let me think you didn't
36:24come," she said. "I let you think it," I
36:27said. "I'm sorry." She reached across
36:30the table slowly. She took my right hand
36:33in both of hers and turned it over in
36:35the kitchen light and looked at it at
36:37the backs of my fingers, at the wrist,
36:39at the long graft that runs up under my
36:42sleeve. She had never held my hand like
36:45that. Not since I was very small. She
36:48did not say anything for a long time.
36:50She just held it. I slept in my old
36:52room. I did not sleep much. At 6:00 the
36:56next morning, I came down and found my
36:57mother at the kitchen table in her robe.
37:00The uniform was still there in front of
37:01her. She had not moved it. A cup of
37:04coffee sat beside it, cold with the skin
37:06on top. I poured two fresh cups and sat
37:09down. For a while, neither of us spoke.
37:13Outside, the yard was gray. The cedar
37:15post stood empty by the fence with straw
37:17scattered around its foot. "Your brother
37:20knew," my mother said finally. "It was
37:23not a question.
37:25I made him promise.
37:288 years. She turned her cup on the
37:30table. Quarter turn. Quarter turn. Eight
37:34thanksgivings. Eight Christmases. I said
37:36things to you, Leah, in front of people.
37:38I said things at church. She stopped. I
37:41gave you that picture. I know, Mom. I
37:44hung it up. She closed her eyes. Nate
37:47came at 8. I had texted him at 6:15.
37:50Just three words. She knows. Come. He
37:54lived in Wesville, 10 minutes away. He
37:57came in the back door in his work boots
37:59and stopped dead when he saw the uniform
38:01on the table. My mother stood up. You
38:04let me say those things to her, she said
38:06to him. For 8 years. She made me swear
38:10on dad's toolbox. Mom, he looked
38:12miserable. I tried every year. I tried.
38:15She wouldn't let me. Why? My mother
38:18turned to me. Why, Leah? I would have
38:20come. I would have driven to Texas. I
38:22would have sat by your bed. That's why,
38:25I said. She stared at me. You had just
38:29watched dad die in that chair. I said
38:32you were burying him. I couldn't hold a
38:34phone. I couldn't feed myself. They
38:36didn't know yet if I'd keep my right
38:37hand. I kept my voice level. That is the
38:40only way I know how to say it.
38:43If you had seen me like that the week of
38:45the funeral, you would have been
38:46terrified for months, years. You would
38:49have watched me every time I went back
38:51to post.
38:52I didn't want you to have to bury Dad
38:54and be afraid for me at the same time,
38:56so I chose. I let you be angry instead.
38:59Angry seemed easier to carry. It wasn't,
39:03my mother said. No, I said it wasn't. I
39:07was wrong about that. The kitchen was
39:09very quiet. Nate sat down slowly in our
39:12father's chair at the end of the table.
39:15And then I said, after a while it was
39:18too late. Every year it got harder to
39:20say. It would have sounded like I wanted
39:23something, like I wanted you to feel bad
39:26and you never asked. You decided what
39:29had happened and you never asked me. I
39:32looked at her. I thought you didn't want
39:34to know.
39:36I didn't ask, my mother said slowly.
39:39Because I was afraid of the answer. I
39:41thought you didn't come because you
39:43didn't love us enough to fight for it. I
39:45thought if I asked, you would tell me
39:46that. Her voice broke. I couldn't lose
39:49your father and hear that in the same
39:51year.
39:52There it was. 8 years of silence on both
39:55sides of the same table. We had each
39:57been protecting the other one from the
39:59same thing.
40:00I'm going to tell you all of it. I said
40:03everything. What happened, where I was,
40:05how long it took. Not to win. Not so
40:07you'll feel bad. Just so you know, just
40:10so you don't have to guess anymore. My
40:12mother nodded. She sat back down.
40:16Not today, she said quietly. I can't
40:19today, but yes.
40:22After Nate left, she picked up the
40:23folded uniform from the table. She held
40:26it against her chest with both arms, the
40:28way you hold a sleeping child. Then she
40:31carried it upstairs. I heard the cedar
40:33closet door open and then close. I heard
40:36her stand there in the upstairs hall for
40:37a long time. When she came down, her
40:40eyes were red. She went to the back door
40:42and looked out at the empty post in the
40:44yard. He made that scarecrow every year,
40:47she said. 30 years. I thought if I put
40:49your uniform on it, it would be like he
40:51was still out there. Both of you. I
40:53thought it was funny. She pressed her
40:55hand flat against the glass. I thought
40:57it was funny, Leah. I know, Mom. It
41:01wasn't funny. No, I said, but you didn't
41:04know. She stood at the door for a long
41:06time. Then she went out into the cold in
41:09her robe and slippers with a rake and
41:11she rad every last piece of straw away
41:14from the foot of that post into a pile
41:16and carried it to the compost bin by the
41:18garage.
41:20I drove back to Kansas City that Sunday.
41:23I had a bridge to inspect on Monday
41:25morning. I am telling you that because
41:26it is true and because life does not
41:28stop for things like this. The cracks in
41:30the concrete do not wait. My mother's
41:33world did not stop either, but it
41:35shifted. There were photographs. 40
41:38people had been in that yard with
41:39phones. By Saturday afternoon, half of
41:42St. Robert had seen pictures of Carolyn
41:44Hartwell in a gingham apron posing
41:46beside a scarecrow in her daughter's
41:48uniform. And by Saturday night, the
41:50other half had heard about the three men
41:52on the porch. Gloria told me later what
41:54that week was like. She came over every
41:56morning with coffee.
41:59On Sunday after church, three of the
42:00women my mother had told about the
42:02daughter who skipped her father's
42:03funeral came up to her in the parking
42:05lot. One of them hugged her and cried.
42:08One of them said very carefully that she
42:10was sorry, that she had had no idea. The
42:13third did not say anything at all, and
42:15my mother said later that was the worst
42:16one. On Monday, she sat down at her
42:18kitchen table with her phone and went
42:20through the photographs from the party.
42:22Gloria was there. My mother deleted them
42:24one at a time. Every picture of the
42:26scarecrow, every picture of herself
42:28beside it, smiling. You didn't know,
42:30Caroline, Gloria said. I didn't ask, my
42:33mother said. She kept deleting. On
42:36Tuesday, she drove on to Post. She had a
42:37visitor pass. She had not been on Post
42:40since my father's retirement party. She
42:41went to the Engineer Museum, the same
42:43one my father had taken me to when I was
42:4511, and she walked through it slowly
42:46with her purse over her arm. She found
42:49the display with the dusty soldier and
42:50the black and gold tab. There was a
42:52volunteer dosent there, a retired
42:54sergeant major in his 70s. My mother
42:57asked him what a sapper tab meant. He
42:59told her 28 days, the ruck marches, the
43:02demolitions, the patrolling, the sleep.
43:04How many start? How many finish? How few
43:07women had it when I earned mine. And
43:10route clearance, she asked. What do they
43:12do? They go first, ma'am. The old
43:15sergeant major said. They drive the
43:17roads looking for bombs so nobody else
43:18has to find them the hard way. My mother
43:21stood in front of that display for a
43:23long time. The dosan told Curtis about
43:25it later, and Curtis told me. He said
43:27she did not cry. She just stood there
43:29with her hand on the glass.
43:32Meanwhile, I was under a bridge over the
43:34little blue river with a hammer and a
43:36headlamp. I sounded the deck, tapping
43:38and listening for the hollow places
43:40where the concrete had separated inside.
43:43I found two. I marked them. I wrote it
43:46up. It was a normal week. It was strange
43:50how normal it was. On Wednesday, I had a
43:53voicemail from Curtis Ambrose.
43:56Ma'am, it's Ambrose. I hope I didn't
43:58make things hard for you Friday. I
44:01didn't know about your father. I'm real
44:04sorry. A pause.
44:07My wife Monica wants to meet you. And
44:09Ibara wants me to tell you he got
44:11married. And Pierce wants me to tell you
44:13he made Sergeant. I told him to tell you
44:16himself, but he says he can't do it
44:17without crying. So a short laugh, "Call
44:21when you can, ma'am. We're not going
44:23anywhere." I listened to it four times,
44:26sitting in my truck in the gravel lot by
44:28the river. Then I called him back. We
44:31talked for 40 minutes. He told me about
44:33the hospital at Launchto and the long
44:34year after, and how he had gone back to
44:36post as an instructor because he did not
44:38know what else to do with what he knew.
44:40He told me Monica had heard my name so
44:42often over the years that she called me
44:43the captain, like I was someone in a
44:45book. I told him about bridges. He
44:48laughed when I told him I still spend my
44:50days looking for things hidden under
44:51roads. Some habits stick, ma'am, he
44:54said. Stop calling me ma'am, Curtis.
44:56I've been out for seven years. No,
44:58ma'am, he said, I don't think I will.
45:01People sometimes think that when the
45:03truth finally comes out, the person who
45:04hurt you should suffer for it, that they
45:06should pay.
45:08I had imagined over 8 years a lot of
45:10ways it might come out. In most of them,
45:13I was angry. In some of them, I was
45:16right. But I did not feel any of that. I
45:19did not need my mother to pay. I only
45:22wanted her to stop guessing. On the
45:24following Monday, a letter came in my
45:25mailbox in Kansas City, a plain
45:28envelope. My address printed in my
45:30mother's school office printing, the
45:32same precise block letters she had put
45:34on the back of that funeral photograph
45:36two Christmases before.
45:38I stood in the parking lot of my
45:39apartment and held it for a long time
45:41before I opened it. The letter was one
45:44page. It said this. Leah,
45:47I went to the museum on post. I asked
45:50what the tab means. I should have asked
45:52you. I should have asked you a lot of
45:54things. I am going to start now if you
45:56will let me. I would like to cook
45:59Thanksgiving for those three young men
46:01and their families if they would come.
46:04Is that strange?
46:06You can tell me if it is strange. Mom,
46:10it was not strange. I called her that
46:13night. She picked up on the first ring.
46:15"I'd like to cook for them," she said
46:17before I could say anything. "Is that
46:20strange?" "No, Mom," I said. "It's not
46:24strange." I called Curtis. Curtis called
46:28Ibara and Pierce. They came.
46:30Thanksgiving was at my mother's house in
46:32St. Robert on the 27th of November.
46:35Curtis and his wife Monica came with
46:37their teenage son. Thomas Ibara came
46:39with his new wife, Anna. Jaylen Pierce
46:42came alone in a pressed shirt holding a
46:44pie he had very clearly bought at a gas
46:46station and was very proud of. Nate came
46:50with Jess and their two girls. Gloria
46:52came from next door. I drove down the
46:55night before and helped my mother cook
46:57standing beside her at the stove the way
46:59I had when I was 10. She had pulled out
47:01the extra leaf for the table. She had
47:03borrowed folding chairs from the church.
47:06She counted the places twice. She did
47:08not set an empty chair. Every chair was
47:10full. We ate at two. My mother asked
47:13Curtis to say grace. He did in a plain
47:16short way. And at the end, he said, "And
47:19for Frank Hartwell, who I never met, but
47:21who I hear ironed field uniforms." Nate
47:25laughed out loud. My mother put her
47:27napkin to her eyes. Halfway through
47:29dinner, Pierce set down his fork.
47:31"Ma'am," he said to my mother, "Can I
47:33tell you something about her?" My mother
47:36looked at me. I nodded. When she got me
47:39out of the hatch, Pierce said, "My
47:41buckle was stuck. It was too hot. You
47:43couldn't touch it. She touched it
47:45anyway." And after, when we were all on
47:47the ground, the medic came running to
47:49her first because her hands looked so
47:50bad. And she wouldn't let her. She kept
47:53pushing her away. She kept saying, "Them
47:55first. Them first." The medic had to
47:58treat all three of us before she'd hold
47:59still. He looked down at his plate.
48:02"I've got a daughter now. She's two.
48:04She's alive because your daughter
48:06wouldn't hold still.
48:08Nobody at the table said anything for a
48:10while. Monica reached over and took
48:12Curtis's hand. My mother stood up from
48:15her chair. She walked around the table
48:17to where Pice was sitting. She put her
48:19hand on his shoulder and left it there
48:21for a moment. Then she went back to her
48:23seat and passed him the sweet potatoes.
48:26After everyone had gone, my mother
48:27washed and I dried the way we always
48:30had. The kitchen was warm. The window
48:33over the sink was fogged.
48:35Your father knew, she said quietly, her
48:38hands in the dishwater. Didn't he before
48:41he died? I had wondered when she would
48:44ask.
48:45He knew I was hurt, I said. Nate told
48:48him the day after it happened. He didn't
48:50know how bad. Nate told him I'd be fine.
48:54I dried a plate. Nate said he just
48:56nodded and said, "First one's down the
48:59road." And then he asked Nate to bring
49:01him the iron. My mother stopped washing.
49:04The iron, she said. He wanted to press
49:07the uniform in the closet one more time.
49:09The last one. The one from my leave. He
49:12couldn't stand up by then, so Nate
49:13brought the ironing board to his chair.
49:15I set the plate down. That's the one you
49:18put on the scarecrow, Mom. That was the
49:20last thing he ever ironed. My mother
49:22stood at the sink with her hands in the
49:24water and did not move for a long time.
49:26Then she dried her hands on her apron
49:27and she reached over and took the dish
49:29towel from me and she held my burned
49:31hand in both of hers with the towel
49:33between them and she did not let go.
49:36That winter my mother started calling on
49:38Sundays. She had always called on
49:40holidays on birthdays. Now she called
49:43every Sunday at 4:00 the way she used to
49:45make me come home from Rola every Sunday
49:47for dinner. And she asked questions. She
49:49had a notebook. I know because she told
49:51me a spiral notebook from the dollar
49:54store. And every week she wrote down
49:56what she wanted to ask me and checked
49:57them off as she went.
49:59"What's a husky?" she asked in January.
50:02"A truck that finds bombs so people
50:04don't have to," I said. "How does it
50:07find them?" I told her. Ground
50:09penetrating radar, the panels
50:11underneath. How slowly you have to
50:13drive. How you learn to read the ground
50:16the way my father read an engine by
50:18sound. And the buffalo, that's the one
50:21with the arm. It digs up what the husky
50:23finds. She wrote it down. I could hear
50:25the pen. In February, she asked about
50:28the burn center. I told her about San
50:30Antonio, the tank room, the graphs, the
50:33physical therapist, a retired Air Force
50:35sergeant named Dolores, who made me pick
50:37up dried beans one at a time with
50:40tweezers for 6 weeks until my fingers
50:42remembered how.
50:44My mother was quiet a long time after
50:46that call. The next week, a package came
50:49to my apartment. a bag of dried beans
50:52and a pair of tweezers and a card that
50:54said for Dolores.
50:56Thank you. I mailed it on to San
50:58Antonio. Dolores wrote back.
51:02In March on the 12th, the anniversary of
51:04my father's death, she did not ask
51:06anything. She just called and we sat on
51:08the phone together for almost an hour,
51:10mostly not talking. Me and my kitchen in
51:13Kansas City, her and hers in St. Robert.
51:17At the end, she said, "Thank you for
51:19staying on the line." One evening in
51:22late March, I took the shoe box down
51:23from the closet shelf. I had not opened
51:26it in years. The bronze star in its blue
51:28case, the purple heart in its purple
51:31one. The citation for the bronze star
51:33folded in thirds. I read it standing in
51:36the closet doorway. It was strange to
51:39read about myself in that flat army
51:41language. It sounded like someone else,
51:44someone braver than I remembered being.
51:47I thought about bringing them to St.
51:49Robert. I thought about how my mother
51:51might look at them, whether it would
51:53help her or hurt her, whether it would
51:55look like I was finally asking for
51:57credit. After all, I put the box back on
51:59the shelf.
52:01In April, on a Sunday, my mother called
52:03at 4:00, the way she always did now. She
52:06did not have a question from the
52:07notebook that week, or if she did, she
52:10did not ask it.
52:12Leah, she said, Memorial Day is coming.
52:16I know, Mom. I'm going to go out to the
52:18cemetery to your father. I go every
52:20year. She paused. You've never been? I
52:24had not. Not once. 9 years. I had driven
52:27past the gate on Route 17 more times
52:30than I could count. I had never turned
52:32in. "Would you come with me?" my mother
52:34asked. I said yes before I could think
52:36about it, before I could talk myself out
52:38of it, before I could decide what it
52:40would mean. "Yes," I said. "I'll come."
52:44After she hung up, I stood in my kitchen
52:46for a while. Then I went to the closet
52:48and took down the shoe box again, and
52:50this time I did not put it back. The
52:52cemetery is on a low hill outside town
52:55off Route 17 with a view south over the
52:58trees toward Post. On the Saturday of
53:00Memorial Day weekend, the rows were full
53:02of small flags. My mother and I walked
53:04up from the car together. She carried a
53:06coffee can of red geraniums. I carried
53:09the shoe box. My father's headstone is
53:11plain gray granite. Frank Edward
53:14Hartwell, a wrench carved small in the
53:17corner, which my mother had insisted on
53:18and the stone cutter had argued about. I
53:21stood in front of it for a long time. My
53:23mother knelt and set the geraniums down
53:25and pulled the grass back from the edge
53:27of the stone with her fingers, the way
53:29she does every year. Then I opened the
53:31shoe box. I did not take out the metals.
53:34I took out something else. Something I
53:37had cut off the left shoulder of an old
53:38uniform in my apartment the week before,
53:41a small black and gold tab. sapper. I
53:44set it on top of the headstone. I
53:46pressed it down with my thumb and held
53:48it there for a moment, the way he had
53:50once held it on my shoulder in the
53:51garage. First one's down the road, Dad,
53:55I said. My mother stood up beside me.
53:58She looked at the tab for a long time.
54:00He ironed that uniform every time you
54:02came home, she said. Every single time.
54:06I used to tell him he was wasting his
54:07time, that you just wear it in the dirt
54:09again. She took my hand. My right one.
54:12The bad one. He said someday you'd want
54:15them. He said I'd understand someday. I
54:18never asked him what he meant. You
54:21understand now? I said. I understand
54:23now. We stood there a while longer. A
54:26breeze came up off the hill and moved
54:27all the little flags at once.
54:30That afternoon, we drove back to the
54:32house. Curtis and Monica came by and
54:34Pierce and Ibara and Anna and Nate's
54:36family and Gloria from next door. It was
54:39not a party. It was just people in a
54:41backyard on a holiday weekend with a
54:42cooler and a grill. At the far end of
54:45the yard by the fence, my father's cedar
54:47post was still there. My mother had not
54:49taken it down, but there was no
54:51scarecrow on it anymore. In March, she
54:53had asked Curtis to help her mount a
54:55flagpole bracket to the top. Now there
54:57was an American flag flying from it, and
54:59beneath the flag, a smaller one, black
55:02and gold, the engineer castle. Curtis
55:05had found it at the post exchange.
55:08My mother stood at the bottom of the
55:09deck steps and looked at it. In this
55:12family, we show up, she said. Not to
55:14anyone in particular. Then she looked at
55:17me. I know, Mom, I said. I did. I know
55:21you did, she said. I know that now.
55:24Later, when the light was going and the
55:26others were by the grill, Curtis came
55:28and stood next to me at the fence. He
55:30took out his wallet and slid a card out
55:32of it. An index card soft and furred at
55:35the corners from years of being carried
55:38on it in pencil in his blocky
55:40handwriting. Captain Hartwell and under
55:43that the name of my company and the
55:45date. March 9, 2017.
55:50I wrote that in the hospital in Germany.
55:52He said, "First thing I asked for when I
55:55could hold a pencil. Who got us out?" He
55:57held it out to me. figured you should
55:59have it now. I know where you are. I
56:02looked at it for a long time. Then I
56:04handed it back. Keep it, I said. I'd
56:07rather you had it. He nodded and put it
56:09back in his wallet carefully behind his
56:12driver's license where it had been for 9
56:14years. We stood there and watched my
56:16mother fuss over Pierce's little girl,
56:18who had come this time, and who was
56:20eating a hot dog bun with nothing in it,
56:22and seemed perfectly happy about it. The
56:24uniform is upstairs in a shadow box on
56:26the wall of my old bedroom, folded the
56:28way Curtis folded it, the patrol cap on
56:30top. There's no straw left in it. My
56:32mother hung it there herself. She asked
56:35me first. I have thought a lot since
56:37then about the 8 years we lost. Mostly I
56:41have thought about how easily it
56:42happened. Two people who loved each
56:44other, each one deciding they knew what
56:46the other one meant and neither one
56:48asking. If there is someone in your
56:50family you have stopped asking or who
56:52has stopped asking you, I hope you ask.
56:55Sometimes the person who hurt you is
56:57only grieving out loud. And sometimes
56:59the thing you were protecting them from
57:01was never as heavy as the silence you
57:03carried instead.
57:05Thank you for staying with me through
57:06this one. It is not an easy story for me
57:09to tell, and I am grateful you listened
57:11to all of it. I want to ask you a few
57:14things before you go. Was I wrong to
57:16keep the truth from my mother for 8
57:18years? Or would you have done the same
57:20thing in that hospital bed? If you had
57:22been standing in that yard on Halloween,
57:24would you have said something to her? Or
57:26would you have done what that stranger
57:27did and simply taken the uniform down?
57:30And is there someone in your own family
57:32you stopped asking? Or who stopped
57:33asking you? Tell me in the comments. I
57:36read every one of them. If this story
57:38meant something to you, please hit that
57:40like button and subscribe so the next
57:42one finds you. And if you have a veteran
57:44in your life who wears long sleeves in
57:46July, you don't have to ask them why.
57:48Just ask them how they're doing and then

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Mom Dressed Her Halloween Scarecrow In My Old Uniform, Not Knowing Why A Party Guest Took It Down by Buried Ranks, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,853 words across 1,466 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.