Mitul femeilor din România — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Brothers, last time we talked about what
- 0:02it meant to be a man in our history,
- 0:04about the outlaws driven into the woods
- 0:06by despair, the Phanariot boyars who
- 0:08learned to bow their heads to keep them
- 0:10from being cut off, the 1848
- 0:12revolutionaries ashamed of their fathers
- 0:14'world, and the workers silenced in
- 0:16communist factories.
- 0:18The question is, what were Romanian
- 0:20women doing while their men were trying
- 0:22to survive and define themselves in tune
- 0:24with the times?
- 0:26If you want to understand why, in so
- 0:29many homes in Romania, a man who feels
- 0:31constantly controlled or misunderstood
- 0:34clashes with an exhausted woman who
- 0:36feels she carries the whole world on her
- 0:39back, we must return to those same muddy
- 0:41lanes of the 1700s, 1800s, or 1980s and
- 0:44look in the mirror.
- 0:45When we speak about femininity in
- 0:47European history, we have the exact same
- 0:50reflex we have with men.
- 0:52We look toward the West.
- 0:54There, next to the knight in armor
- 0:56heading on a crusade or stepping out to
- 0:58a duel at dawn, the classic feminine
- 1:00ideal was built around the lady of the
- 1:03court.
- 1:06The woman in the songs of French
- 1:08troubadours or English novels was a
- 1:10delicate, almost unreal creature with
- 1:12porcelain-white skin, who would faint in
- 1:15her corset at the slightest emotion and
- 1:17wait in the castle tower to be rescued,
- 1:19courted, and protected.
- 1:24Later, in the 19th and early 20th
- 1:26centuries, this model was joined by the
- 1:28figure of the suffragette, the female
- 1:31citizen who took to the streets in
- 1:33London or Paris demanding the right to
- 1:35vote from a stable state with
- 1:36centuries-old institutions.
- 1:40It’s a beautiful history, full of poetry
- 1:42, but one that, just like in the case of
- 1:44the men, has almost nothing to do with
- 1:46what happened between the Carpathians,
- 1:48the Danube, and the Black Sea. Here, our
- 1:51feminine ideal didn't blush, didn't
- 1:53faint from emotion, and didn't drop
- 1:55scented handkerchiefs on the ground.
- 1:58Why?
- 1:59Because in a place where, every 10 or 15
- 2:02years, Ottoman, Tatar, Tsarist, and
- 2:04Habsburg armies would pass through,
- 2:07feminine fragility was a death sentence
- 2:09, not an ideal. Think about one simple
- 2:12thing, of historical common sense.
- 2:16When the Turks or Tatars came, when the
- 2:19prince's mercenaries entered the village
- 2:21for taxes, and the man was either taken
- 2:23by force to the army, killed, or took
- 2:25off to hide in the woods as an outlaw,
- 2:27who remained in the yard?
- 2:31Who stood on the threshold of the house
- 2:33with three or five children clinging to
- 2:35her skirts?
- 2:36Who hid the sack of cornmeal in pits
- 2:38burned into the earth?
- 2:40Who put out the fire on the thatched
- 2:42roof and who had to negotiate with the
- 2:44invader so her family wouldn't be
- 2:46slaughtered?
- 2:48The woman.
- 2:50If history forced the Romanian man to
- 2:53survive through adaptability and evasion
- 2:55, that same history forced the Romanian
- 2:57woman to survive through
- 2:59hyper-responsibility and emergency
- 3:01resilience.
- 3:03Hence a paradox that foreign travelers
- 3:05who passed through these territories and
- 3:07wrote about them have observed.
- 3:10We had a facade of patriarchy doubled by
- 3:13a matriarchy of crisis.
- 3:16At the gate, at church, and at the pub,
- 3:19the man was the absolute master, the
- 3:21rooster of the household, but inside the
- 3:23home and especially when disaster struck
- 3:25, the woman became the real governor,
- 3:28the crisis manager who could not afford
- 3:30to break down.
- 3:32So, instead of gathering around the
- 3:34ideal of the fragile damsel in the tower
- 3:36, our feminine subconscious was formed
- 3:38from four major survival archetypes that
- 3:40grew in parallel with the masculine ones
- 3:43. In order of appearance, it is about
- 3:45the fortress-woman, the peasant and
- 3:47mountain woman at the foundation of the
- 3:50house, the diplomat noblewoman, the
- 3:52woman behind the Phanariot curtain, the
- 3:54modernization Amazon and the salon lady
- 3:56, the 1848 revolutionary woman and the
- 3:59interwar woman, and finally the heroine
- 4:01mother and the tractor-driving woman
- 4:03from the chaos of the 90s.
- 4:07All these women lived in our
- 4:08grandmothers and mothers, and they all
- 4:10live today in the women beside us.
- 4:13So today, with the support of our
- 4:15brothers at psiholog.ro, we will see how
- 4:17the untold history of the Romanian woman
- 4:19was actually written.
- 4:22The fortress-woman, the peasant mountain
- 4:24woman, and the curse of Manole's Ana.
- 4:27The first and oldest of these archetypes
- 4:29, the one that lies at the foundation of
- 4:31our entire rural world, is that of the
- 4:34Romanian peasant woman, what we might
- 4:36call the fortress-woman.
- 4:38When we think today of the village woman
- 4:40from past centuries, the paintings of
- 4:43Nicolae Grigorescu or the idyllic verses
- 4:45of George Coșbuc immediately spring to
- 4:47mind.
- 4:50We see a young girl, rosy-cheeked, with
- 4:52a blouse white as milk foam, spinning
- 4:54peacefully on the porch in the sunset
- 4:56light, crossing the river with a pitcher
- 4:59on her shoulder, or smilingly awaiting
- 5:01her lad at the gate, while in the outlaw
- 5:03movies, the woman is either the fiery
- 5:05innkeeper pouring wine for Florin
- 5:07Piersic and hiding his pistols under the
- 5:10mattress, or the lady kidnapped in a
- 5:12carriage.
- 5:14It is a warm, soothing image that gives
- 5:17us the feeling of a settled and clean
- 5:19world.
- 5:20Except that the historical reality of
- 5:22the Romanian village in 1700 or 1800 did
- 5:25not resemble the museum painting at all
- 5:27.
- 5:28In the episode about men, we saw what
- 5:30happened when the lord's tax collector
- 5:32entered the peasant's yard and took his
- 5:34harvest and cattle for the hearth tax or
- 5:37the cattle tax.
- 5:39We didn't explain this, but the hearth
- 5:42tax is a tax you paid if smoke came out
- 5:44of your chimney.
- 5:45You had firewood to keep warm, you paid
- 5:48.
- 5:49Humbled and crushed by a system in which
- 5:51he could no longer be the provider, the
- 5:53man had two paths: either bow his head
- 5:55to the ground or take up his axe and
- 5:57flee to the forest as an outlaw.
- 6:01He would leave to be free under the
- 6:02beech leaves. The woman, however, had
- 6:05nowhere to run. There was no outlawry
- 6:07for mothers with five children.
- 6:10When the man disappeared into the forest
- 6:12, to war or into hiding, the woman
- 6:14stayed behind to face the wrath of the
- 6:16posse looking for the fugitive, to
- 6:18negotiate with the tax collector, and to
- 6:21scrape food from barren earth throughout
- 6:23the winter.
- 6:25In the world of the traditional village
- 6:27, labor was not divided according to the
- 6:29later Western model, where the man goes
- 6:31to work and the woman stays home.
- 6:34The Romanian peasant woman went out to
- 6:36the fields side by side with the man, to
- 6:39hoe, to reap, and to harvest hay, often
- 6:41with her infant in a cradle, hung from a
- 6:43branch at the edge of the field.
- 6:47And when they returned from the fields
- 6:49in the evening and the man sat on the
- 6:51porch, the second half of the day began
- 6:53for the woman: milking the cattle,
- 6:55kneading bread, cooking at the hearth,
- 6:57spinning wool, and weaving at the loom
- 6:59late into the night by the light of an
- 7:01oil lamp.
- 7:03Every shirt, towel, and blanket in the
- 7:05house came exclusively from her hands.
- 7:08To all this, we must add a biological
- 7:11reality of a harshness we can barely
- 7:13imagine today.
- 7:15The woman of the old village spent
- 7:17almost her entire adult life between
- 7:19pregnancy and breastfeeding.
- 7:22She gave birth eight, ten, or twelve
- 7:24times on the packed-earth floor of the
- 7:27hut, assisted only by the village
- 7:29midwife, with folk remedies and charms,
- 7:31in a world where half of all infants
- 7:33died before reaching the age of five.
- 7:37Hard.
- 7:40Often, the day after burying a child in
- 7:42the hillside cemetery, that woman had to
- 7:44get up from her bed, light the fire in
- 7:46the hearth, and feed the other four who
- 7:49had remained alive.
- 7:52How does a human psyche withstand such
- 7:54pressure without disintegrating?
- 7:57The answer is found in the most
- 7:59disturbing founding myth of our culture
- 8:01: the ballad of Master Manole or the
- 8:03Monastery of Argeș.
- 8:06If we want to understand the
- 8:07subconscious of a people, we must look
- 8:09at the stories they have been telling
- 8:11themselves for hundreds of years.
- 8:13And our story about how something great
- 8:15and lasting is built on this earth goes
- 8:18like this.
- 8:20Ten great masons led by Manole try to
- 8:22raise a monastery, but everything they
- 8:24build during the day crumbles at night.
- 8:27For the wall to stand, a sacrifice is
- 8:29needed.
- 8:31The first wife or sister to arrive at
- 8:33dawn with food for her husband must be
- 8:35walled up alive in the foundation of the
- 8:37church.
- 8:39The other masons, terrified, break their
- 8:41oath and secretly warn their wives not
- 8:44to come.
- 8:45When Manole sees his wife, Ana,
- 8:47approaching from afar through the rain
- 8:50and wind, he prays to God to send storms
- 8:52and swollen rivers in her path to stop
- 8:54her.
- 8:56But Ana does not stop.
- 8:59Neither the torrential rain nor the
- 9:01stream sweeping everything away turns
- 9:03her back, because her duty to bring food
- 9:05to her working husband is stronger than
- 9:07any force of nature.
- 9:11And when she reaches the scaffolding and
- 9:13Manole begins to wall her in, telling
- 9:15her it is just a joke, Ana smiles and
- 9:18endures it.
- 9:19Even when the wall reaches her ankles,
- 9:22her knees, her thighs, and her chest,
- 9:24when she realizes it is no longer a game
- 9:26and that she is being crushed to death
- 9:28between the bricks, Ana does not curse,
- 9:31she does not try to tear down the wall,
- 9:33she does not strike Manole. Her only cry
- 9:36is: "Manole, Manole, master Manole, the
- 9:39cruel wall is crushing me, my breast is
- 9:41weeping, my baby is breaking."
- 9:44Even in the moment of death, her
- 9:46thoughts are not for her own life, but
- 9:48for the child left hungry at home.
- 9:51Stop for a second and think about what
- 9:53this myth says about us.
- 9:57Our folk culture placed at the
- 9:59foundation of society the conviction
- 10:01that nothing in Romania endures—neither
- 10:03house, nor family, nor church—unless a
- 10:05woman who suffers without complaint is
- 10:08walled up alive within its foundation.
- 10:13The man is the architect, the one who
- 10:15puts his name on the monument and
- 10:17receives the glory before the ruler, but
- 10:19the mortar that holds the bricks
- 10:20together is the silent sacrifice of a
- 10:22woman.
- 10:23The story of Sultana Gălășescu, of
- 10:26Pelaghia Roșu, and of Victoria Lipan.
- 10:28This "fortress woman" of the traditional
- 10:31world was not just a passive victim.
- 10:33Precisely because the physical survival
- 10:36of the family rested on her shoulders,
- 10:38old Romanian society recognized in women
- 10:40a final authority that very few European
- 10:43cultures possessed at the time.
- 10:46When the world of men went astray
- 10:48through blind violence, through outlawry
- 10:50, or through the collapse of the law,
- 10:52the woman was called upon to restore
- 10:54order.
- 10:55Remember the scene from 1817 that I
- 10:58recounted regarding Iancu Jianu.
- 11:00The feared outlaw of Oltenia was brought
- 11:03in chains through the streets of
- 11:04Bucharest, sentenced to death by hanging
- 11:07by the ruler Caragea.
- 11:09No army and no posse had managed to tame
- 11:11him.
- 11:12And then, from the crowd emerges a young
- 11:14woman, Sultana Gălășescu, and she utters
- 11:17the formula of the ancient law of the
- 11:19land. "I claim him as my husband, I take
- 11:21him from the executioner."
- 11:23Viewed from Jianu's perspective, the
- 11:25scene is about a rebel who saves his
- 11:27life, but viewed from the perspective of
- 11:29Sultana and the society of that time,
- 11:32the scene has another significance.
- 11:36The word of a woman had the legal power
- 11:38to annul on the spot the death sentence
- 11:40of the ruler and the divan.
- 11:43Why did this unwritten law exist in the
- 11:45Romanian lands?
- 11:48Because the elders of the villages and
- 11:50towns knew a truth of the land: that the
- 11:52only force capable of turning a wolf of
- 11:54the woods into a man of the city was the
- 11:57settled authority of a woman.
- 12:01Sultana did not perform a romantic
- 12:03gesture; she performed an act of social
- 12:05power.
- 12:07She took Jianu under her guarantee, just
- 12:09as a guardian takes care of a wayward
- 12:11minor, and turned him into a responsible
- 12:14man.
- 12:15And when the threat did not come from
- 12:17within, but from without, the
- 12:19fortress-woman knew how to take up arms
- 12:21as well.
- 12:22In 1848, in the Apuseni Mountains, when
- 12:24the Hungarian revolutionary armies tried
- 12:27to enter the Moți villages while Avram
- 12:29Iancu's men were on other fronts, who
- 12:31went out to the mountain passes?
- 12:35At Mărișel, in March 1849, a 49-
- 12:37year-old peasant woman named Pelaghia
- 12:39Roșu saw that the village was about to
- 12:42be put to the sword and fire, so she
- 12:44mounted a horse, gathered all the
- 12:46village women, had them put on men's
- 12:49peasant coats, wear Moți hats, and carry
- 12:51wooden stakes on their shoulders like
- 12:54rifles.
- 12:56Placed on the hilltop, in the bright sun
- 12:58, the women led by Pelaghia Roșu began
- 13:01to shout and bang on the objects they
- 13:03had, giving the impression that an
- 13:05entire legion of lancers was waiting on
- 13:07the ridge.
- 13:09When the enemy vanguard approached, the
- 13:11women rolled rocks and tree trunks down
- 13:13upon them, putting a regular military
- 13:15force to flight and saving their village
- 13:17.
- 13:18Perhaps the clearest portrait of this
- 13:20archetype was left to us by Mihail
- 13:22Sadoveanu in*The Hatchet*, through the
- 13:24character of Vitoria Lipan. Many of us
- 13:27hated this novel in school because it
- 13:29was taught to us dryly, with
- 13:30rote-learned essays, but if you read it
- 13:33today as an adult, you realize that
- 13:34Vitoria Lipan is the opposite of the
- 13:36outlaw.
- 13:38Her husband, Nechifor Lipan, is a man of
- 13:40revelry, long roads, and risks, who
- 13:43disappears without a trace.
- 13:46The state authorities, the prefect, and
- 13:48the gendarmes are helpless, bureaucratic
- 13:50, and overwhelmed by the situation.
- 13:53And so, who sets off in the middle of
- 13:56winter over the mountains with the
- 13:57lucidity of a detective and an iron will
- 14:00, not to take outlaw revenge, but to
- 14:02restore the order of the world, to find
- 14:04the bones, bury them in a Christian
- 14:06manner, and expose the killers at the
- 14:08memorial feast?
- 14:10The mountain woman.
- 14:12For Vitoria Lipan, the world has a
- 14:14sacred order, and when men break it, it
- 14:16is the woman's duty to repair it, no
- 14:18matter how hard the journey.
- 14:21The martyr syndrome of today.
- 14:23The trouble is that this centuries-old
- 14:25history, in which the woman was walled
- 14:27into the foundation of the home and had
- 14:29to keep the household standing at the
- 14:31cost of her own life, did not disappear
- 14:33with the electrification of the villages
- 14:35and our move to the city. It is still
- 14:37deeply etched into the emotional genetic
- 14:40code of the Romanian family.
- 14:43While for men the myth of the outlaw
- 14:45left behind a lack of discipline and the
- 14:47impression that rules are for suckers,
- 14:49for women the myth of Ana of Manole and
- 14:51the wall-bound woman birthed a cult of
- 14:53self-sacrifice and the martyr syndrome.
- 14:57Look around you, at our grandmothers,
- 14:59our mothers, and often even our sisters
- 15:01or wives. In how many homes in Romania
- 15:04have you seen the woman who, at Sunday
- 15:06dinner or Christmas, never sits down at
- 15:08the table?
- 15:10Everyone eats, laughs, and clinks
- 15:12glasses, while she stands by the stove
- 15:15or in the kitchen doorway, bringing the
- 15:17stuffed cabbage, clearing the plates,
- 15:19and when you say, "Sit down with us, Mom
- 15:21," she replies almost with pride, "Go
- 15:24ahead and eat, I'll eat later at the
- 15:26corner of the table."
- 15:28What's left over?
- 15:30And if there's a less-than-perfect piece
- 15:32of meat or a burnt slice of bread left,
- 15:34she takes it.
- 15:36We were raised in a culture where a
- 15:38woman's moral value is measured directly
- 15:40by her degree of exhaustion.
- 15:45A woman who rests at noon, who reads a
- 15:47book while there are two dirty plates in
- 15:49the sink, or who buys something just for
- 15:52her own joy before meeting all her
- 15:54family's needs, often lives with a dull
- 15:56guilt, as if she had deserted her duty.
- 16:02But no human being can be walled into a
- 16:04structure without harboring a huge
- 16:06amount of frustration.
- 16:09When sacrifice is not a free choice, but
- 16:12a cultural obligation, it demands
- 16:14payment.
- 16:16It is the dark and less inspirational
- 16:18side of our local feminine archetype.
- 16:21It is called authority through guilt.
- 16:26The woman who sacrificed herself her
- 16:28whole life without asking for help
- 16:30inevitably ends up using this sacrifice
- 16:32as an emotional weapon against her
- 16:34husband and children.
- 16:38"After all I’ve suffered in this house,
- 16:40after wasting my youth and health for
- 16:42you, is this how you thank me?"
- 16:45It is the cry of Ana in the wall, who
- 16:47doesn't know how to ask for love and
- 16:49rest directly, because no one taught her
- 16:51that she has the right to exist outside
- 16:53the wall.
- 16:54Right, I will talk more about the dark
- 16:57side of these cultural expectations of
- 16:59sacrifice. The question is what was
- 17:01happening higher up the social ladder,
- 17:03in the boyar mansions and palaces of
- 17:05Bucharest and Iasi in the 17th and 18th
- 17:08centuries. This is where our second
- 17:10great female archetype enters the scene
- 17:12, the direct counterpart to the boyar in
- 17:15his fur cap and caftan.
- 17:17The diplomat noblewoman, the power
- 17:18behind the Phanariot curtain.
- 17:21When we imagine the high-society woman
- 17:24of the Phanariot era, the first cliché
- 17:26that comes to mind is an oriental one: a
- 17:29lazy woman, shut away in her quarters,
- 17:31dressed in silk trousers and veils,
- 17:33eating rose petal jam, drinking coffee,
- 17:36and waiting submissively for her
- 17:38husband’s orders, with no rights and no
- 17:40voice in the city. Well, when our
- 17:43historians today—and I am thinking
- 17:45primarily of the extraordinary archival
- 17:47research of Professor Constanța Vintilă
- 17:49-Ghițulescu—opened the chests of old
- 17:52documents, dowry records, testaments,
- 17:54and lawsuits from the Metropolitan
- 17:56Church, they discovered a world very
- 17:58different from these prejudices.
- 18:01First of all, unlike many Western
- 18:03European countries, where a woman
- 18:05completely lost her legal personality
- 18:08upon marriage and all her wealth passed
- 18:10permanently into her husband’s
- 18:12possession, in Wallachia and Moldavia,
- 18:14the old Byzantine law, or "pravila," was
- 18:17in effect, and the "pravila" had a
- 18:19sacred institution that not even the
- 18:21ruler or the Sultan could touch: the
- 18:23dowry deed.
- 18:26When a girl from a boyar family, or even
- 18:28from a wealthy merchant or peasant
- 18:31family, got married, her parents gave
- 18:33her a dowry—estates, villages of serfs,
- 18:36vineyards, houses, jewelry, fur coats,
- 18:38and carriages—carefully recorded thread
- 18:41by thread in a document signed by
- 18:43witnesses and the priest.
- 18:45The husband had the right to manage this
- 18:47dowry for the duration of the marriage,
- 18:49but he was not its owner.
- 18:53If the boyar was a spendthrift, if he
- 18:55lost his fortune at cards, ran up debts
- 18:57with loan sharks, or fell into the
- 18:59ruler's disfavor and his goods were
- 19:01confiscated for treason, creditors and
- 19:03the state could take everything that was
- 19:05his, but they were not allowed to touch
- 19:07a single thread of the wife's dowry.
- 19:11Furthermore, in the 18th century, in a
- 19:13Europe where divorce was almost
- 19:15impossible in the Catholic or Protestant
- 19:17worlds, the archives of the
- 19:19Metropolitanate in Bucharest and Iași
- 19:21are bursting with divorce cases
- 19:23initiated by women.
- 19:24Boyar wives and townswomen would appear
- 19:27before church judges, leaving their
- 19:28husbands on the grounds that he had
- 19:30squandered their dowry, was excessively
- 19:33violent, or had fallen into the vice of
- 19:35drunkenness, and they would reclaim
- 19:37their estates down to the last penny.
- 19:39Then they would remarry.
- 19:42In an uncertain world, where men lost
- 19:44their heads and their ranks from one day
- 19:46to the next, the woman and her dowry
- 19:48represented the reserve bank and the
- 19:50family's anchor of stability.
- 19:53The story of Lady Marica Brâncoveanu.
- 19:56To understand the inner strength that
- 19:58lay within these elite native women and
- 20:01how they managed to save entire families
- 20:03when their husbands were forsaken by
- 20:05history, we must return to the year 1714
- 20:07, to the exact moment we left off with
- 20:10Constantin Brâncoveanu last time.
- 20:13August 15, 1714, in Istanbul. Constantin
- 20:17Brâncoveanu is brought in his shirt to
- 20:20the shores of the Bosphorus, before
- 20:22Sultan Ahmed III, and forced to watch as
- 20:25the executioner beheads his four sons
- 20:27one by one—Constantin, Ștefan, Radu, and
- 20:30little Mateiaș, only 11 years old—
- 20:32before he himself is beheaded.
- 20:35It was the tragic end of the old
- 20:36Romanian masculine ideal.
- 20:40But history did not end that day on the
- 20:42scaffold, because a few hundred meters
- 20:44away, in the damp darkness of the
- 20:46Yedikule prison, were the women of the
- 20:49family: Lady Marica Brâncoveanu, the
- 20:51prince's wife, along with her
- 20:52daughters-in-law, her daughters, and the
- 20:55only surviving male grandchild.
- 20:58Imagine what was in this woman’s soul on
- 21:01the evening of August 15, 1714.
- 21:04In a single day, she had lost her
- 21:06husband and all four of her boys.
- 21:09She was not even allowed to bury their
- 21:11bodies, as they had been thrown into the
- 21:13sea, while their heads were displayed on
- 21:15pikes at the gate of the Seraglio.
- 21:19Furthermore, the Turks were not finished
- 21:21with her.
- 21:22Convinced that Marica knew where the
- 21:24rest of Brâncoveanu’s jewelry and bank
- 21:26notes were hidden, they subjected her to
- 21:28horrific interrogations and pressure,
- 21:30threatening to sell her daughters-in-law
- 21:32and grandchildren as slaves in the
- 21:34markets of the Orient.
- 21:36Normally, after such a blow, a person
- 21:39fades away, goes mad with grief, or
- 21:41takes their own life.
- 21:43Marica Brâncoveanu did not allow herself
- 21:45to weep in front of her tormentors.
- 21:49She understood that the moment all the
- 21:51men of her kin died for honor and faith
- 21:53, her duty was not to die with them, but
- 21:56to live and save what remained of the
- 21:58family.
- 22:01From the depths of the dungeon and later
- 22:04from forced exile deep in Asia Minor,
- 22:06this woman, well past 50, transformed
- 22:08herself into a kind of foreign minister
- 22:11and clandestine banker.
- 22:14She managed to send secret letters to
- 22:17the ambassadors of France, Austria, and
- 22:19Russia in Istanbul, borrowed huge sums
- 22:21on her word of honor from Greek and
- 22:23Italian merchants, and knew exactly
- 22:25which doors to open and which purses of
- 22:27gold to send to the Grand Vizier and the
- 22:30Ottoman officials.
- 22:32After three years of cutthroat
- 22:34negotiations behind the scenes of the
- 22:36Ottoman Empire, with the replacement of
- 22:38the Grand Vizier, Marica Brâncoveanu
- 22:40obtained a pardon and permission to
- 22:42return to the Romanian land.
- 22:44Arriving in Bucharest, in a country now
- 22:47ruled by the first Phanariot princes who
- 22:49had divided up her family’s estates,
- 22:52Lady Marica began a second battle.
- 22:55She recovered the Brâncoveanu estates
- 22:57document by document, saved the funds
- 22:59deposited in banks in Venice and Vienna
- 23:02, strategically married off her
- 23:03daughters and granddaughters to the most
- 23:06powerful boyar families, and raised
- 23:08little Constantin, the surviving
- 23:10grandson, to carry the name forward.
- 23:13And in 1720, six years after the
- 23:15slaughter in Istanbul, Marica
- 23:17Brâncoveanu made one final gesture of
- 23:20incredible boldness.
- 23:23She sent trusted men with plenty of gold
- 23:26to the Greek monks on the island of
- 23:27Halki, where fishermen had secretly
- 23:29buried her husband’s headless body.
- 23:33She had the remains removed from the
- 23:35grave, brought them secretly across the
- 23:37Danube in a merchant convoy, and buried
- 23:39them by night in the Saint George the
- 23:41New Church in Bucharest.
- 23:44Since she wasn't allowed to write
- 23:45Brâncoveanu's name on the tombstone,
- 23:47because the Turks would have desecrated
- 23:49it immediately, she left a white stone,
- 23:51without a single letter.
- 23:54And above it, she hung a silver lamp
- 23:56with a tiny inscription engraved, almost
- 23:58invisible to anyone who didn't know
- 24:01where to look, saying only that there
- 24:03rested the servant of God, Constantin
- 24:05Brâncoveanu, murdered by a tyrant.
- 24:09The man died standing tall as a
- 24:11Christian martyr before history, while
- 24:13the woman was the one who negotiated
- 24:15with history, paid the debts, brought
- 24:17the bones home, and kept the lineage
- 24:19alive.
- 24:21Behold the Phanariot needle and the
- 24:23philosophy of the neck.
- 24:25After 1714, as the Phanariot regime
- 24:27fully established itself in Wallachia
- 24:30and Moldavia, this art of survival
- 24:32through backroom diplomacy became the
- 24:35way of life for all elite women.
- 24:38In the last episode, we saw how the
- 24:40chain of humiliation worked for men.
- 24:43Kiss up, kick down.
- 24:46The ruler kissed the sultan’s slipper,
- 24:48the boyar kissed the ruler’s hand and
- 24:50hem, the peasant was whipped by the
- 24:52boyar, and at the end of the chain, the
- 24:54man would vent his frustration at home.
- 24:57But what did the noblewoman do in this
- 24:59world where her husband returned from
- 25:02the divan humiliated, sweating from fear
- 25:04under his huge fur cap, and ready to
- 25:06explode?
- 25:07Women weren't allowed into the princely
- 25:10divan, held no public office, and
- 25:12carried no swords.
- 25:13If she had directly confronted the man
- 25:16in front of the servants, she would have
- 25:18struck at the only thing he had left:
- 25:20the illusion that he was master, at
- 25:22least within his own mansion.
- 25:25So, the woman of the Phanariot era
- 25:27developed another form of power,
- 25:29extremely sophisticated: oblique power,
- 25:32or the power behind the curtain.
- 25:36She learned to lead without seeming to
- 25:37lead.
- 25:38While men smoked pipes in the grand hall
- 25:41and measured their ranks by the length
- 25:43of their beards and the size of their
- 25:44hats, the country's real politics were
- 25:46conducted in the ladies' chambers.
- 25:50Since rulers changed every two and a
- 25:53half years and no law was certain, the
- 25:55only stable institution remained kinship
- 25:58and matrimonial alliances, a territory
- 26:00100%controlled by women.
- 26:05Noblewomen visited their sisters, drank
- 26:07coffee, learned who had sent a complaint
- 26:09to Istanbul, who had debts, who was in
- 26:11the ruler's wife's favor, and arranged
- 26:14their children’s marriages like peace
- 26:16treaties between clans.
- 26:19From that era, perhaps the best-known
- 26:21and most revealing saying in our culture
- 26:23about the relationship between the sexes
- 26:26has been passed down to us.
- 26:28The man is the head of the family, but
- 26:30the woman is the neck that turns it as
- 26:32she pleases.
- 26:33What does this proverb actually mean?
- 26:36That in a world where a man's ego is so
- 26:39fragile that he cannot bear to be told
- 26:41the truth or share decisions equally, a
- 26:43woman abandons honesty and chooses
- 26:45subtle manipulation.
- 26:49She lets him sit at the head of the
- 26:52table, cushions his back, agrees with
- 26:54him in front of guests, and feeds his
- 26:56vanity as master, only to turn him later
- 26:59in the evening—through whispers, hints,
- 27:01calculated tears, refined rebukes, or
- 27:03emotional blackmail—exactly in the
- 27:06direction she decided, making him
- 27:08believe it was his own idea.
- 27:12How many intelligent and capable women
- 27:14among us have been taught this lesson of
- 27:16domestic duplicity by their mothers and
- 27:18grandmothers since childhood.
- 27:21"Dear, don't ever cross a man.""Keep
- 27:23quiet, smile, agree with him, but do as
- 27:26you please."
- 27:27"Let him think he's the rooster; men are
- 27:29just like big children."
- 27:31"You have to know how to handle them."
- 27:33At first glance, it seems like a winning
- 27:36strategy. You avoid the scandal and get
- 27:38what you want.
- 27:41But in the long run, this dynamic
- 27:43between the vain head and the
- 27:45manipulative neck poisons the
- 27:46relationship to its roots, because when
- 27:48you treat your partner like a big child
- 27:51you need to outmaneuver and manage from
- 27:53the shadows, you inevitably end up
- 27:55despising him.
- 27:59You can no longer respect or truly
- 28:01desire a man you feel you can wrap
- 28:02around your finger.
- 28:07And the man, in turn, even if he cannot
- 28:09quite put his finger on the problem,
- 28:11feels a net of control hiding behind her
- 28:14smile and care, becoming increasingly
- 28:16defensive, absent, or aggressive.
- 28:21It is the direct legacy of the Phanariot
- 28:23influence that we still pay for today
- 28:25with the currency of our intimacy. The
- 28:27Amazon of modernization and the salon
- 28:30lady, from the 1848 revolutionaries to
- 28:32the interwar period.
- 28:33At the beginning of the 19th century, a
- 28:36western wind blew over this oriental
- 28:38world, locked within the walls of manors
- 28:40and the smoke of pipes, and changed
- 28:42everything.
- 28:44The men of the Romanian elite left for
- 28:47their studies and returned with
- 28:48revolutionary ideas, but the women of
- 28:50Romania had become Westernized a whole
- 28:53generation before the men.
- 28:55In the last episode, I told you about
- 28:57the young 1848 revolutionaries who,
- 28:59around 1840, left for Paris to study,
- 29:02threw away their traditional caps and
- 29:04robes, donned tailcoats and top hats,
- 29:06and returned home ashamed of their
- 29:08fathers 'world.
- 29:10The question is, how did those young
- 29:12people come to speak French and dream of
- 29:14Paris?
- 29:17Because their mothers and sisters had
- 29:19already opened the windows to Europe 20
- 29:21or 30 years earlier.
- 29:24If we read the journals of foreign
- 29:26travelers—French, English, German, or
- 29:29Russian—who passed through Bucharest and
- 29:32Iasi between 1810 and 1835, they were
- 29:34all left speechless by an almost surreal
- 29:37image in the boyar salons.
- 29:41On the divan sat the boyar, dressed just
- 29:43like in Istanbul, with wide trousers, an
- 29:46anteri, a fur-lined robe, backless
- 29:48slippers, a long beard, and a fur hat,
- 29:51speaking no European language other than
- 29:54Greek.
- 29:57And on his arm, in the same room, sat
- 29:59his wife or daughter, dressed according
- 30:02to the latest fashion journal arrived by
- 30:04carriage from Paris or Vienna, wearing a
- 30:07high-waisted dress or crinoline, with
- 30:09bare shoulders, playing the piano,
- 30:11reading novels by Balzac and George Sand
- 30:13in the original, and conversing
- 30:15impeccably in French.
- 30:21Women gave up Oriental clothing and
- 30:23customs much faster and more willingly
- 30:26than men, because for the boyar, the
- 30:28Oriental world meant privileges, rank,
- 30:30and power over his subjects, so it was
- 30:32only natural for him to cling tightly to
- 30:35his caftan.
- 30:39For women, on the other hand, the Orient
- 30:41meant isolation and submission, while
- 30:43the West meant freedom.
- 30:46In French culture, the woman was the
- 30:48queen of the salon, participating in
- 30:50conversations about literature, art, and
- 30:52politics, strolling on the Mogoșoaia
- 30:55Bridge, going to the theater and the
- 30:57ball, and being treated as a dialogue
- 30:59partner.
- 31:00Back then, the old boyars were terrified
- 31:03by this change.
- 31:04The chronicles of the time are full of
- 31:07the laments of parents and the church
- 31:09that women had been corrupted by French
- 31:11fashion, as they left their arms and
- 31:13necks bare, danced the waltz and polka
- 31:15in the arms of Russian and Austrian
- 31:17officers, and read dangerous books.
- 31:20But the steamroller of modernization
- 31:22could no longer be stopped.
- 31:24These French-speaking mothers sent their
- 31:26children to study in Paris.
- 31:29Ana Ipătescu, Maria Rosetti, and the
- 31:32courage of 1848.
- 31:34When the revolution of 1848 broke out,
- 31:37it became clear that these women had not
- 31:40only adopted laces, perfumes, and the
- 31:42piano from the West, but also an
- 31:44incredible civic courage.
- 31:46In Bucharest, on June 19, 1848, the
- 31:49young revolutionary leaders—Eliade
- 31:52Rădulescu, Brătianu, Bălcescu, Golescu—
- 31:55had just seized power and formed the
- 31:57Provisional Government.
- 32:00Scared of losing their privileges, the
- 32:03conservative camp led by Colonels
- 32:05Odobescu and Solomon launched a military
- 32:07coup.
- 32:08Soldiers entered the Princely Palace and
- 32:10arrested all members of the
- 32:12Revolutionary Government.
- 32:14Panic and confusion took hold of the
- 32:16streets of Bucharest. The crowd of men
- 32:18gathered on the Mogoșoaia Bridge,
- 32:21today's Calea Victoriei, stared
- 32:23paralyzed at the palace surrounded by
- 32:25bayonets, not daring to advance.
- 32:29The Romanian Revolution of 1848 was
- 32:31about to end in less than two weeks,
- 32:33without a single shot fired, in a
- 32:36typically Phanariot resignation.
- 32:40And then, in the middle of the hesitant
- 32:42crowd, appears a 43-year-old woman, the
- 32:45wife of a treasury department official.
- 32:48Her name is Ana Ipătescu.
- 32:51Seeing men backing away from the
- 32:52soldiers, Ana Ipătescu pulls out two
- 32:55pistols, raises them above her head, and
- 32:57shouts with a voice that drowns out all
- 32:59the street noise.
- 33:01Death to the traitors, young men, have
- 33:03courage, save our freedom. Ashamed that
- 33:06a woman is leading them with a weapon in
- 33:09hand, the merchants, apprentices, and
- 33:11youths of Bucharest suddenly find their
- 33:13courage, rush after her, break the
- 33:15military cordons, disarm the guard, and
- 33:18free the arrested ministers.
- 33:21Without Ana Ipătescu's reckless gesture
- 33:24that June afternoon, our history of 1848
- 33:26would have likely ended right there.
- 33:30Or, look at Maria Rosetti, the wife of
- 33:33C.A. Rosetti, who served as a model for
- 33:35painter Constantin Daniel Rosenthal for
- 33:38the famous painting "Revolutionary
- 33:40Romania," the woman in a headscarf and
- 33:42blouse holding the tricolor flag.
- 33:45In the autumn of 1848, when Ottoman
- 33:47troops entered Bucharest and arrested
- 33:50all the leaders of the revolution,
- 33:52putting them on Turkish barges on the
- 33:54Danube to take them into exile, what did
- 33:56Maria Rosetti do, having just given
- 33:58birth to a baby girl a few days prior?
- 34:02She took her infant in her arms and
- 34:04walked for weeks along the banks of the
- 34:06Danube, through mud and cold, following
- 34:08from the shore the convoy of boats in
- 34:09which her husband and the other
- 34:11revolutionaries were imprisoned.
- 34:15At every stop, she bribed the Turkish
- 34:17guards to bring them food, sent them
- 34:19coded messages, and at Orșova, when the
- 34:22Turks wanted to hand them over to
- 34:24Austrian authorities, Maria Rosetti
- 34:26organized on the spot, with great
- 34:28composure, the drugging of the guards
- 34:30and the spectacular escape of all the
- 34:32revolutionaries across the border,
- 34:34saving the men who would, 11 years later
- 34:36, create the Union of the Principalities
- 34:39and modern Romania.
- 34:42"Forms without substance" in a feminine
- 34:45key, Caragiale and the interwar world.
- 34:47Of course, just as the sudden transition
- 34:50from the Phanariot robe to the French
- 34:52frock coat for men gave birth to the
- 34:54phenomenon Titu Maiorescu called "forms
- 34:56without substance," this fast-track
- 34:58Westernization had its share of
- 35:00caricature and confusion in the feminine
- 35:02world as well.
- 35:04The one who captured this world caught
- 35:06between the "Mahala" and Paris best was
- 35:09, of course, Ion Luca Caragiale.
- 35:12While Caragiale's men are either senile
- 35:15cuckolds like Zaharia Trahanache,
- 35:17hysterical demagogues who weep on
- 35:19command like Nae Cațavencu, or
- 35:21ridiculous cowards like Rică Venturiano
- 35:24, his women are of two kinds.
- 35:28On one hand, we have Zița and Mița
- 35:30Baston, the "slum girls" who learned
- 35:32three words in French—mon cher, parole—
- 35:35read dime novels, and turn their petty
- 35:37neighborhood jealousies into grand,
- 35:40passionate dramas involving bottles of
- 35:42vitriol.
- 35:44On the other hand, at the top of the
- 35:46hierarchy in "A Lost Letter" stands Zoe
- 35:49Trahanache, née Ana Joițica. Look at Zoe
- 35:52. In a world full of men who play
- 35:55politics, give speeches, and threaten
- 35:57each other with newspaper articles, Zoe
- 35:59is the only politician who is lucid,
- 36:01cold, and efficient in the entire play.
- 36:04When the love letter is lost, her lover
- 36:07, the prefect Tipătescu, loses his
- 36:09temper; he wants to run away or abuse
- 36:11his power to arrest Cațavencu. Zoe does
- 36:14not lose her head.
- 36:16>> Zoe,
- 36:17Zoe, do you love me?
- 36:19>> I love you, but save me.
- 36:21>> Zoe, let’s run away together.
- 36:24>> Fănică, are you crazy?
- 36:27>> She knows her social honor and the
- 36:29family’s power depend on a cold
- 36:31resolution to the crisis, so she takes
- 36:33command, negotiates directly with the
- 36:35blackmailer, and when she recovers the
- 36:37letter, she doesn’t seek petty revenge,
- 36:40but makes Cațavencu lead the celebratory
- 36:42rally in their honor.
- 36:45Zoe Trahanache is the Phanariot
- 36:47noblewoman in a Parisian dress, the
- 36:49woman who may not have had the right to
- 36:51vote on paper, but runs the entire
- 36:53county through the men around her.
- 36:56This feminine energy accumulated over a
- 36:58century truly exploded during the First
- 37:01World War and in the interwar period in
- 37:03Romania.
- 37:04In the episode about men, we saw that in
- 37:07the 20s and 30s, a large part of the
- 37:09young generation of intellectuals was
- 37:11overwhelmed by the anxiety that Romania
- 37:14was a small, irrelevant country and
- 37:16sought salvation in the mystical
- 37:18violence of the Iron Guard.
- 37:20While many young men were fascinated by
- 37:23the cult of death, interwar women were
- 37:25concerned with the cult of life,
- 37:27construction, and emancipation.
- 37:30The supreme model of that era, however,
- 37:32was Queen Marie.
- 37:35Between 1916 and 1918, when half the
- 37:38country was occupied by German troops
- 37:40and the government and Royal Family had
- 37:42retreated to Iași in a Moldavia
- 37:44devastated by famine and typhus, where
- 37:47many politicians and generals had lost
- 37:49hope and were considering evacuation to
- 37:52Russia, Queen Marie refused to be a
- 37:54decorative palace figure.
- 37:59She dressed in the white uniform of a
- 38:01Red Cross nurse and went daily, without
- 38:03gloves or masks, into barracks crawling
- 38:05with lice where thousands of Romanian
- 38:07soldiers were dying, holding the hands
- 38:10of the dying and lifting the morale of a
- 38:12broken army.
- 38:15And in 1919, when at the Paris Peace
- 38:17Conference Prime Minister Ion I.C.
- 38:19Brătianu met with the coldness and
- 38:21arrogance of the great Western powers
- 38:23who refused to recognize the borders of
- 38:26Greater Romania, who boarded a train and
- 38:28went to Paris and London?
- 38:30Queen Marie.
- 38:32Through her charisma, intelligence, and
- 38:34diplomatic courage, she opened the doors
- 38:37of American President Woodrow Wilson and
- 38:39French Prime Minister Clemenceau,
- 38:41telling them directly, "Romania has a
- 38:43face today, and that face is me."
- 38:48Following in these footsteps, interwar
- 38:51Romania produced an extraordinary
- 38:53generation of women, from global
- 38:55pioneers like Sarmiza Bălcescu, the
- 38:57first woman in the world to earn a law
- 39:00doctorate at the Sorbonne, or Eliza
- 39:02Leonida Zamfirescu, one of the first
- 39:04female engineers in Europe, to writers
- 39:06of astonishing psychological depth like
- 39:09Hortensia Papadat-Bengescu and Cela
- 39:11Serghi, the aviators of the White
- 39:13Squadron—the only medical aviation unit
- 39:16in the world composed entirely of female
- 39:18pilots during World War II—or the unique
- 39:21, passionate, and free voice of Maria
- 39:23Tănase.
- 39:27However, this modern woman of interwar
- 39:29Romania lived a drama, a social
- 39:31schizophrenia that was hard to bear.
- 39:35In her mind, education, and work, she
- 39:37was a woman of the 20th century, but in
- 39:40the eyes of the law and the majority
- 39:42mentality, she was still treated as if
- 39:45it were 1860.
- 39:47According to the Civil Code in force in
- 39:49interwar Romania, a married woman was
- 39:51placed in the same legal category as
- 39:53minors and the mentally incapacitated.
- 39:56She could not open a bank account, sign
- 39:58a contract, or take a job without her
- 40:00husband's written consent.
- 40:04This gap between the speed at which the
- 40:06educated Romanian woman modernized and
- 40:08the inertia with which a part of our
- 40:10society lagged behind is clearly felt
- 40:12even today.
- 40:14Today's professional woman in our big
- 40:16cities—in Bucharest, Cluj, Timișoara, or
- 40:19Iași—is often a woman who has read
- 40:21widely, has a solid career in medicine,
- 40:24law, architecture, entrepreneurship, or
- 40:26the corporate world, who has earned her
- 40:29financial independence and goes to
- 40:31therapy to understand her emotions.
- 40:35And yet, many of these women live today
- 40:37in a crushing loneliness.
- 40:39Why?
- 40:42Because when they leave the office and
- 40:44look for a partner, they often run into
- 40:46men who either feel intimidated and
- 40:48emasculated by a woman who earns as much
- 40:50or more than them, or they expect that,
- 40:52once she crosses the threshold, this
- 40:54modern woman will leave her degree at
- 40:56the door and revert to their
- 40:57grandfather’s silent housewife.
- 41:01This would be an excellent moment to
- 41:02remind you that it is not only women who
- 41:04go to a psychologist. For me, the
- 41:06therapeutic process has considerably
- 41:08improved my life and, in my opinion,
- 41:10everyone should try to understand
- 41:11themselves in this way. If you are
- 41:13interested, visit psiholog.ro with
- 41:16confidence.
- 41:17The sessions are online, and many
- 41:19therapists on the platform offer the
- 41:21first session for free.
- 41:23Moreover, using the code HORIA20, you
- 41:26get a 20%discount on your next session.
- 41:29If you don't click with a therapist,
- 41:31which is perfectly normal, you have
- 41:33plenty of others to choose from.
- 41:35All the details are in the description.
- 41:38The heroine mother and the
- 41:40tractor-driving woman, the communist
- 41:42double burden, and the survivor of the
- 41:4490s.
- 41:45While until the mid-20th century women
- 41:48in Romania, from the mountain peasant to
- 41:50the Bucharest intellectual, fought this
- 41:53continuous battle between tradition and
- 41:55modernization, after 1948 history split
- 41:57in two.
- 41:59Soviet tanks arrived, the communist
- 42:01regime was installed, and the state
- 42:03decided to rewrite from scratch what it
- 42:05meant to be a woman.
- 42:08Thus was born the fourth great archetype
- 42:10, the one that directly shaped our
- 42:11grandmothers and mothers: the
- 42:13tractor-driving woman and the heroine
- 42:15mother.
- 42:17On paper and in the propaganda posters
- 42:20of the 50s and 60s, communism came with
- 42:22a bright promise: full equality between
- 42:25women and men.
- 42:27For the first time in Romania's history
- 42:30, the 1948 Constitution gave women equal
- 42:33rights, unhindered access to all
- 42:35professions, and equal pay for equal
- 42:37work.
- 42:40In cinema newsreels, you saw smiling
- 42:42young women with headscarves, driving
- 42:45tractors on collectivized fields,
- 42:47operating cranes on construction sites,
- 42:49pouring steel in mills, or working in
- 42:51chemistry labs.
- 42:55In reality, however, communist equality
- 42:57did not mean that men and women started
- 42:59sharing the hardships of life equally.
- 43:03It meant that women were forced to work
- 43:05just like men in the factory, without
- 43:07having a single bit of the housework
- 43:09taken off their shoulders.
- 43:11Sociologists call this phenomenon the
- 43:13double burden. In the episode about men
- 43:16, we saw how the communist regime
- 43:18stripped the man of his autonomy and his
- 43:20role as the pillar of the family,
- 43:22turning him into a simple industrial cog
- 43:24.
- 43:26We saw how after 10 hours of work in the
- 43:29cold and noise at the lathe, many of our
- 43:31fathers and grandfathers sought refuge
- 43:33in silence and in a glass at the corner
- 43:35pub, then came home to a 40-
- 43:37square-meter apartment, sat in the
- 43:39armchair with a newspaper, and demanded
- 43:41absolute silence because dad was tired
- 43:44from work.
- 43:47But let's shift the camera 2 meters to
- 43:49the right now, from the living room
- 43:51where dad sat in his armchair, to the 2
- 43:54-by-2 kitchen where mom was.
- 43:58She had woken up that same morning at
- 44:004:30 or 5:00.
- 44:03She had ridden crowded on the step of
- 44:05that same freezing bus, stood for eight
- 44:08or 10 hours on her feet in the same
- 44:10plant, the same garment factory, or the
- 44:12same cold office, only for mom, the
- 44:14second shift began at 4:00 PM.
- 44:18She would run from the factory gate with
- 44:20two bags in her hand to catch the queue
- 44:22at the grocery store, where there were
- 44:25rumors of chicken, oil, or a box of
- 44:26margarine.
- 44:29She stood for two hours, rain or shine,
- 44:31jostled in the crowd just to snag a bag
- 44:34of chicken feet and necks, the so-called
- 44:36"Petreus brothers."
- 44:39Then she would pick up the kids from
- 44:41daycare or school, climb the stairs to
- 44:43the fourth floor with bags full of
- 44:45potatoes, and head straight to the
- 44:47kitchen.
- 44:48The kitchen of the 80s was a kitchen of
- 44:50survival.
- 44:53When there was no meat, eggs, milk, or
- 44:55chocolate in the shops, and the gas
- 44:57barely flickered on the stove while the
- 44:59electricity cut out every night for two
- 45:01or three hours, Mom had to make a hot
- 45:03meal for the whole family out of nothing
- 45:06.
- 45:09She made schnitzel from bologna breaded
- 45:11with crumbs, coffee from roasted
- 45:13chickpeas, and cake from crushed
- 45:15biscuits with cocoa and margarine; she
- 45:17mended socks by the lightbulb and washed
- 45:19the family's laundry by hand in the
- 45:21cast-iron tub with water heated on the
- 45:24stove in the soup pot, because hot water
- 45:26only flowed from the tap two hours a
- 45:28week.
- 45:31Then she would iron shirts and school
- 45:33uniforms for the next day and pack the
- 45:35lunch boxes.
- 45:37Decree 770, when the state confiscated
- 45:40women's bodies.
- 45:42On top of all this daily physical
- 45:45exhaustion, there was Decree 770 from
- 45:48October 1966.
- 45:50If for men the nationalization of land
- 45:52and workshops was an amputation of
- 45:54social dignity, for women, Nicolae
- 45:57Ceaușescu’s regime nationalized their
- 45:59very bodies.
- 46:01Obsessed with the idea of increasing the
- 46:03labor force of socialist Romania to 30
- 46:06million inhabitants, Ceaușescu decided
- 46:08overnight that the Romanian woman's womb
- 46:10was the state property of the Communist
- 46:13Party.
- 46:15Abortions were banned under threat of
- 46:17imprisonment, and all modern means of
- 46:19contraception disappeared completely
- 46:21from pharmacies and hospitals.
- 46:26Think about what this meant for the
- 46:28intimate daily lives of millions of
- 46:30women and couples in Romania for 23
- 46:33years, between 1966 and 1989.
- 46:37In factories, plants, and offices, women
- 46:39were periodically pulled from production
- 46:42, lined up like soldiers, and taken to
- 46:44the workplace medical office for
- 46:46mandatory gynecological exams under the
- 46:48supervision of the militia and the
- 46:50secret police.
- 46:54If the doctor discovered a woman was
- 46:56pregnant, she was immediately put under
- 46:58surveillance, and if she lost the baby,
- 47:00even naturally due to overexertion or
- 47:02the cold in the factory, she was
- 47:04interrogated by the prosecutor while
- 47:06bleeding in a hospital bed, often
- 47:08refused surgery by doctors until she
- 47:10confessed who had helped her induce the
- 47:12abortion.
- 47:15In apartments without heat or food,
- 47:17where a family could barely manage to
- 47:19raise the two children they already had
- 47:21, the bedroom became a place of terror.
- 47:25Physical love between husband and wife
- 47:28was no longer a space of tenderness,
- 47:30refuge, and closeness, but a constant
- 47:32source of panic.
- 47:36Every month was measured in days of
- 47:38dread, and when they happened to get
- 47:40pregnant with a third, fourth, or fifth
- 47:42child, knowing they had nothing to feed
- 47:44them, hundreds of thousands of desperate
- 47:46women resorted to extreme measures on
- 47:49kitchen tables, in medieval conditions.
- 47:54Thousands of women died in Romania
- 47:56during the Ceaușescu regime due to
- 47:58sepsis and hemorrhages caused by illegal
- 48:01abortions.
- 48:05Young mothers, leaving behind thousands
- 48:07of orphans, died in silence, teeth
- 48:09clenched, refusing until the very last
- 48:11moment to name the midwife or friend who
- 48:14had tried to help them, so they wouldn't
- 48:16go to prison.
- 48:19How can we wonder today that our parents
- 48:21' generation had so much coldness in
- 48:24their relationships, so much unhealthy
- 48:26prudishness, and so much silence
- 48:28surrounding the body and sexuality?
- 48:33How could our mothers have spoken openly
- 48:35to their daughters about femininity,
- 48:37pleasure, and affection, when for them
- 48:39the female body had been a battlefield
- 48:41supervised by the police for two decades
- 48:44, and intimacy had been synonymous with
- 48:46the fear of death?
- 48:50The 90s, mothers with raffia bags and
- 48:53suitcases for Italy.
- 48:55Then came December 1989, communism fell
- 48:57, the decree was repealed in the first
- 49:00days of freedom, but the steamroller of
- 49:02the 90s transition swept across the
- 49:05country. In the last episode, we talked
- 49:07about the terrible tragedy of the men
- 49:09who were 40 or 50 years old at the time
- 49:12, when the great factories and
- 49:13industrial plants were shut down and
- 49:15sold for scrap metal.
- 49:18Millions of men who had built their
- 49:19entire identity on their trade and their
- 49:22status as the breadwinner collapsed
- 49:24psychologically.
- 49:26Many shut themselves away, stayed on the
- 49:28couch in front of the TV, and faded into
- 49:30alcohol, paralyzed by the shame of no
- 49:32longer being who they once were. Why
- 49:35didn't our mothers, struck by the exact
- 49:37same unemployment and the same abject
- 49:39poverty, collapse in the same way?
- 49:43Because in the female psyche, forged
- 49:45through centuries of struggle, the pride
- 49:48of social status has always mattered
- 49:50less than the survival of the nest.
- 49:53An unemployed man in 1994 would think: I
- 49:56was a foreman at IMEGB or a design
- 49:59engineer.
- 50:00How can I go out to the market and sell
- 50:02socks on a cardboard box?
- 50:04If people see me, I’ll die of shame.
- 50:08A mother in 1994 didn't care what the
- 50:10neighbors thought.
- 50:12She looked at her two children who had
- 50:14to go to school the next day and thought
- 50:16of only one thing: what to put on the
- 50:18table for them tomorrow.
- 50:20So our mothers swallowed their pride,
- 50:22put their diplomas in engineering,
- 50:24accounting, or technical fields at the
- 50:27back of the closet, and went out to
- 50:29fight in the jungle of the wild
- 50:30capitalism of the 90s.
- 50:34They were the women who boarded old
- 50:37buses at night and traveled 20 hours to
- 50:39Istanbul, sleeping in their seats with
- 50:41money sewn into their coat linings for
- 50:43fear of thieves, returning with those
- 50:46huge red-and-blue plaid raffia bags on
- 50:48their backs, filled with jeans, sweaters
- 50:50, leather jackets, and Turbo gum.
- 50:55They were the women who stood in -10 °
- 50:58weather wearing three pairs of wool
- 51:00socks in their boots, in markets and
- 51:02bazaars across the country or in small
- 51:04metal kiosks on the street corner,
- 51:06selling cigarettes, biscuits, and
- 51:08powdered juice by the piece to keep
- 51:10their children in high school and
- 51:12college.
- 51:15And at the end of the 90s and into the
- 51:172000s, when even the kiosks were no
- 51:19longer enough and maintenance debts
- 51:21threatened to leave their families
- 51:23homeless, hundreds of thousands of
- 51:25Romanian mothers packed a suitcase,
- 51:27kissed their children on the forehead at
- 51:29the bus station, and left for Italy,
- 51:31Spain, or Germany.
- 51:37Educated women, housewives, and devoted
- 51:40mothers accepted cleaning floors in
- 51:42strangers 'homes, caring for sick
- 51:44elderly people 24/7, and living in tiny
- 51:47rooms, eating bread and yogurt so they
- 51:49could send every hundred euros earned
- 51:51back home month after month via Western
- 51:54Union or minibus drivers.
- 51:59They built houses in Romania they never
- 52:01got the chance to live in. They paid for
- 52:04college, weddings, and installments for
- 52:06their children, crying in secret in
- 52:08bathrooms in Rome, Turin, or Madrid, and
- 52:11raising their children over the phone.
- 52:15They are the 21 st-century wives of
- 52:17Manole, women who walled themselves up
- 52:19alive abroad so that the wall of their
- 52:21family back home would not collapse.
- 52:25The syndrome of the hardened superwoman
- 52:27and love in a lunchbox.
- 52:31All this history from the last 70 years
- 52:33, the double burden of communism, the
- 52:35trauma of the Decree, and the survival
- 52:37struggle of the 90s left deep scars on
- 52:39both our mothers and the young women of
- 52:41today who were raised by them.
- 52:45Look first at the way our mothers knew
- 52:47how to show their love.
- 52:50If our fathers didn't tell us they loved
- 52:53us because they were trained to believe
- 52:55that emotion is a weakness, our mothers
- 52:57didn't have the time or energy for
- 52:58relaxed tenderness, because they lived
- 53:00their whole lives in a state of siege.
- 53:05When your entire youth was measured in
- 53:07bread lines and the worry of not having
- 53:09enough to feed or clothe your child,
- 53:11love in your mind becomes synonymous
- 53:13with food and physical protection.
- 53:17That is why in the native language of
- 53:19Romanian mothers, the sentences "I love
- 53:22you,""I missed you," and "I'm glad you
- 53:24exist" almost always translate to "Have
- 53:27you eaten?" Did you take your scarf?
- 53:29There's a draft. I put four containers
- 53:31of cabbage rolls and schnitzels in your
- 53:33trunk.
- 53:34To them, a container of food is not just
- 53:37food; it’s concrete proof that you are
- 53:39alive, that you aren’t starving like in
- 53:411987, and that she is still fulfilling
- 53:43her duty as a mother.
- 53:48But this care born of fear often comes
- 53:50with suffocating anxiety, catastrophic
- 53:53scenarios for every unanswered call, and
- 53:55a permanent need to control their
- 53:57child’s life, even when that child is 35
- 54:00or 40.
- 54:04I remember how Vintilă Mihăilescu spoke
- 54:06about this at a conference, describing
- 54:09how food is love and how, all across the
- 54:11country, on buses and trains, kilos of
- 54:14love are transported daily to university
- 54:16students.
- 54:19Then, look at what happened in the
- 54:20hearts of the daughters who grew up in
- 54:22those homes in the 80s and 90s.
- 54:26The little girl who for 20 years saw a
- 54:28mother who did it all—working, carrying
- 54:31grocery bags, cooking, cleaning,
- 54:33vacuuming, managing the household money
- 54:35, and solving every crisis—while her
- 54:37father sat in an armchair or was
- 54:39overwhelmed by events, drew a harsh
- 54:42conclusion in her subconscious.
- 54:45In life, you can't rely on any man.
- 54:48If you want to be safe, you have to
- 54:50manage on your own and control
- 54:52everything.
- 54:54That is how the archetype of today’s
- 54:56driven modern woman was born: the
- 54:58hyper-vigilant superwoman. She’s the
- 55:00woman with a demanding career who leads
- 55:02office projects, takes her child to
- 55:04three extracurricular activities,
- 55:06remembers when the car insurance expires
- 55:08, when it’s her mother-in-law's birthday
- 55:10, and what’s missing from the fridge,
- 55:12but who cannot delegate anything at all
- 55:14.
- 55:15Even when she has a well-meaning man
- 55:17beside her who wants to help, she stands
- 55:20behind him with a heavy heart,
- 55:21correcting him at every step.
- 55:24That’s not how you chop an onion; that’s
- 55:26not how you dress the child. Move over,
- 55:29I can do it faster, until the man gives
- 55:31up and retreats to the sofa.
- 55:34And the moment he retreats to the sofa,
- 55:36she sighs bitterly and confirms the
- 55:38prophecy she brought with her from her
- 55:40parents' home.
- 55:42See? Everything falls on my shoulders. I
- 55:45can't rely on anyone.
- 55:48It’s a prison of control, built from the
- 55:50ancient fear of our mothers that if you
- 55:52let your guard down for a single second
- 55:54, everything will collapse.
- 55:57The end of archetypes and the
- 55:58reconciliation between the weary outlaw
- 56:00and the fortress woman.
- 56:02And here we are today in our living
- 56:05rooms in 2026, face to face. The
- 56:07Romanian man and the Romanian woman,
- 56:09each carrying 300 years of untold
- 56:11history on their backs.
- 56:14If we understand this whole story,
- 56:16suddenly our 10:00 PM arguments in the
- 56:18kitchen no longer seem like simple
- 56:20personality clashes.
- 56:22We realize that when a man and a woman
- 56:24collide in a couple today in Romania,
- 56:26often it’s not just them arguing.
- 56:29Behind them, the ghosts of our ancestors
- 56:31are clashing.
- 56:34On one side stands the man carrying the
- 56:36outlaw who feels suffocated by any rule
- 56:38or domestic responsibility, the
- 56:40Phanariot who stays passive-aggressively
- 56:43silent instead of openly saying what
- 56:45bothers him, and the communist worker
- 56:47who fears that if he shows vulnerability
- 56:49or asks for help, he’ll look weak.
- 56:54On the other side stands the woman
- 56:56carrying Ana, walled into the foundation
- 56:58, who works until exhaustion and then
- 57:00scolds you for not seeing her sacrifice
- 57:02, the Phanariot noblewoman who tries to
- 57:04direct her partner from the shadows
- 57:06through hints and guilt because she
- 57:08doesn’t trust she’ll be heard directly,
- 57:10and the mother from the 80s who lives in
- 57:13a constant state of alert and doesn't
- 57:15know how to stop running.
- 57:19That is why radical camps aimed at women
- 57:21, just like alpha masculinity networks
- 57:24for men, have so much traction on the
- 57:26internet today.
- 57:29On one side, you see influencers selling
- 57:31young girls the illusion that
- 57:33independence means cold cynicism, that
- 57:35all men are useless, or that a
- 57:37relationship is just a financial
- 57:39transaction where you must extract as
- 57:42many resources as possible, following
- 57:44the old Phanariot "peshkesh" model.
- 57:47On the other side, you see nostalgia
- 57:49beautifully packaged on TikTok about the
- 57:52return to the traditional submissive
- 57:54woman, who only finds happiness staying
- 57:56in the kitchen and smiling on command.
- 57:59But, just as with men, you cannot heal
- 58:01three centuries of being walled into
- 58:04foundations, hidden diplomacy, and
- 58:06exhaustion with social media slogans.
- 58:08The true liberation of the Romanian
- 58:11woman today and our true reconciliation
- 58:13with one another, men and women, lies in
- 58:15three things. First, exiting Manole’s
- 58:18wall.
- 58:20To understand once and for all that an
- 58:22exhausted mother, wife, or daughter is
- 58:24not a monument of virtue.
- 58:28Your family doesn’t need a martyr buried
- 58:30in the bricks of the house, but a person
- 58:32who is alive, whole, and joyful.
- 58:35Taking an hour for yourself, eating at
- 58:37the table alongside everyone else,
- 58:39saying "I’m tired today, I can’t do it
- 58:42anymore," without feeling guilty.
- 58:45It doesn’t mean selfishness; it means
- 58:47breaking the chain of bitter sacrifice
- 58:49and no longer leaving your children the
- 58:51burden of feeling indebted for your
- 58:53suffering.
- 58:54The second one: giving up the Phanariot
- 58:56strategy of backhanded maneuvers.
- 59:01We no longer live in a 1750 Bucharest
- 59:03boudoir where you need to manipulate
- 59:05your partner indirectly, protect their
- 59:07ego with pretty lies, and wait for them
- 59:09to guess your thoughts from your gaze or
- 59:11the way you slam the fridge door.
- 59:16Maturity means the courage to speak
- 59:19openly, as equals.
- 59:22I need your help with this.
- 59:24It hurt me when you said that.
- 59:26Let’s make this decision together.
- 59:29Power assumed openly with gentleness and
- 59:31firmness is the only kind that doesn’t
- 59:33breed contempt in a relationship.
- 59:37Then, the courage to let go of control.
- 59:43For a woman raised by a mother who held
- 59:45the house together on her own in the 80s
- 59:47and 90s, the hardest thing in the world
- 59:50isn't working, but trusting, taking a
- 59:52step back, and leaving room for the man
- 59:54beside her to be a partner and father,
- 59:56even if he does things differently, even
- 59:58if he puts mismatched socks on the child
- 1:00:01or cooks more slowly.
- 1:00:06If you treat him like an incompetent
- 1:00:08subordinate in his own home, you will
- 1:00:10remain alone in command.
- 1:00:13Only when you lay down your weapons and
- 1:00:15accept that you don't have to be the
- 1:00:17fortress defending everything do you
- 1:00:19give the other person the chance to rise
- 1:00:20to their role.
- 1:00:23That’s all for today. Thank you for
- 1:00:25watching, and I also want to thank the
- 1:00:27brothers at psiholog.ro for their
- 1:00:29support. Take care of yourselves and the
- 1:00:31people around you, and I’ll see you next
- 1:00:33time.
- 1:00:34Bye-bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Mitul femeilor din România by Zaiafet, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,481 words across 1,559 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.