Microéconomie (Comportement du consommateur) : Utilité marginale, TMS Courbe d'indifférence... — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00H
- 0:00Well, hello everyone. Hello to you all.
- 0:04I am here with a few students for a
- 0:06review session to prepare for exams on
- 0:09general economics, and more
- 0:11specifically on the microeconomics
- 0:14portion. Microeconomics, that is to say
- 0:19microeconomic calculations, and we will
- 0:21focus on consumer behavior. Consumer
- 0:25behavior. I should specify that
- 0:27everything related to calculations
- 0:29regarding consumer behavior comes from
- 0:31neoclassical thought dating back to the
- 0:3419th century. Well, I am not going to
- 0:37go into the history of economics; we
- 0:39will focus here on mathematical
- 0:41calculations. Our review will be
- 0:45divided into two parts. In the first
- 0:49part, we will just talk about the
- 0:51concept of total utility and marginal
- 0:54utility. We will take a concrete
- 0:57example using a small table. We will
- 0:59calculate marginal utility and
- 1:01determine the optimal utility together,
- 1:05et cetera. And in the second part, we
- 1:08will take the most well-known example,
- 1:10which is often tricky: what is called
- 1:12the utility function. You are given a
- 1:15utility function with two variables, X
- 1:17and Y. And you are asked to maximize
- 1:20this utility function while taking into
- 1:22account the price and the budget
- 1:24constraint. For that, we will use two
- 1:28methods that you know: the MRS method
- 1:30and the Lagrange method. Once we have
- 1:33used these two methods, we will move on
- 1:35to a graphical representation of the
- 1:37indifference curve and the budget line.
- 1:40There, I have summarized a little bit
- 1:42of what we are going to do, and we will
- 1:45start right away with the first part.
- 1:47The first part, which concerns
- 1:50everything regarding the concepts of
- 1:52total utility and marginal utility. If
- 1:56you have any questions, don't hesitate
- 1:58to stop me so that I can answer them.
- 2:01Is that okay? Very well. Let's go. Well
- 2:07, we begin with this first part, which
- 2:09I call the basic first part. You must
- 2:12understand what total utility, marginal
- 2:15utility, and the maximization—well,
- 2:17the maximization, I should say—of
- 2:20consumer utility are. What is the
- 2:22concept? Actually, we can say that in
- 2:26the 19th century, the neoclassical
- 2:29school, which followed the classical
- 2:31school of the 18th century, took an
- 2:34interest in the economic agent. They
- 2:38said, we are going to look at the
- 2:39individual and the firm. Agreed? We are
- 2:42going to focus on the individual, the
- 2:44consumer. What do they tell us? They
- 2:46tell us that every consumer is free in
- 2:48their choices. They know what they are
- 2:50doing. Agreed? And every time a
- 2:53consumer goes to buy a good,
- 2:55psychologically and instinctively, they
- 2:58will seek to get the best, I would say
- 3:00the best benefit from that good. First,
- 3:04one, they will look at their natural
- 3:06needs, they will look at the price, and
- 3:08they will look at their budget. And
- 3:11from there, they will choose a good, or
- 3:13rather, they will compose their basket
- 3:16of goods. Let me give you an example.
- 3:20You want to buy some chocolate, a bar
- 3:21of chocolate. So when you go to buy a
- 3:24bar of chocolate, you know its price.
- 3:25You like chocolate. Okay? So you take
- 3:28your bar of chocolate and you eat it.
- 3:31It gives you a certain satisfaction, a
- 3:34certain utility, right? It makes you
- 3:37want to buy a second one, right? A
- 3:40third, a fourth, a fifth. But you have
- 3:43to know that this good you bought,
- 3:45which you consume, first gives you
- 3:47enormous satisfaction at the beginning.
- 3:50This satisfaction will increase, but at
- 3:52a certain point, you reach saturation,
- 3:53and you say, "I don't want any more of
- 3:55this chocolate." And if you have more,
- 3:58it will do you more harm than good.
- 4:01That is actually total utility. Meaning
- 4:04you buy and you consume a good, it
- 4:07gives you a satisfaction that can be
- 4:09growing, it does you good, but at a
- 4:12certain moment, there is saturation and
- 4:14there is no more utility. Total utility
- 4:18. Look at an example, I took an example
- 4:20here, an example. This time, you are
- 4:24led to choose two goods that I call two
- 4:27products X and Y. Okay? Knowing that
- 4:31you are obliged to buy these two
- 4:33products. This means you must compose a
- 4:36basket of two goods X and Y. Okay?
- 4:39Imagine you say to yourself, "Chocolate
- 4:42is becoming so expensive that now I
- 4:44have to find a combination that works
- 4:47for my income." So you say, "Okay, I'm
- 4:50going to the supermarket." And I'm
- 4:53going to look for white chocolate and
- 4:55cheaper dark chocolate. Okay? So, how
- 4:59are you going to compose your basket
- 5:02with white chocolate and dark chocolate
- 5:04, knowing that you will be satisfied by
- 5:08consuming the chocolate? Are you
- 5:10following me? Do you understand the
- 5:12logic? You have products X and Y. Okay?
- 5:17The goal is how many quantities of X
- 5:19and Y? Should we choose so that the
- 5:23utility, the satisfaction of consuming,
- 5:26is at its maximum? You can choose 2X
- 5:31and 3Y. You can choose 5X and 1Y. You
- 5:35can choose 2X and 6Y. But those are
- 5:39infinite choices. But among all these
- 5:43choices, there is one that provides the
- 5:45most satisfaction for the consumer. And
- 5:50the neoclassicals, the neoclassical
- 5:52school quantified and mathematized this
- 5:54, integrating mathematics into
- 5:56economics in the 19th century. So we
- 5:58can calculate it now. You have
- 6:00understood the concept and this example
- 6:02we have before us will serve as a basis
- 6:04, you'll see it's not complicated. X is
- 6:08the quantity of X the consumer chooses.
- 6:13Y is the quantity of Y. UX is the total
- 6:16utility provided by the consumption of
- 6:20X. Y is the utility. We gave it a
- 6:26number, right? And it could be—assign
- 6:29it a value, for example, in monetary
- 6:32terms or a survey, a score, an
- 6:34evaluation. All right? But in any case,
- 6:38we have this data; you will have them
- 6:39for the exam, you will have this data.
- 6:41So UY is the total utility provided by
- 6:43the consumption of Y. How do we read it
- 6:45? Look, if we consume—if the consumer
- 6:49chooses no X, it’s normal that there
- 6:52is no utility. The consumption of one
- 6:56product X provides 10. All right? The
- 7:00consumption of two—a second, another
- 7:04product, two products, provides 18;
- 7:07that is to say, from there to there, it
- 7:10provides 18. Meaning 10 plus the
- 7:13consumption of an additional product
- 7:15gives us 18. Are you following me?
- 7:19Actually, these are increasing
- 7:21cumulative totals. The more I consume,
- 7:23the more utility is added to the
- 7:25previous one and we increase. All right
- 7:27? And you have at the end of 5, at the
- 7:30end of 5 products, we reach saturation.
- 7:33So that’s it, it’s good. Now it's
- 7:35saturation because normally after 6 it
- 7:37will go down. The same thing for 5. We
- 7:40reach saturation at 5 and that's it. So
- 7:42when you have this table, the first
- 7:45thing to do is calculate what is called
- 7:48marginal utility. Marginal utility. So
- 7:51I am going to calculate the marginal
- 7:55utility of X. And the marginal utility
- 8:01of Y. What is marginal utility Y? In
- 8:05fact, it is the utility provided by the
- 8:09consumption of one additional product.
- 8:14See, here I have consumed the first
- 8:17product, here I am consuming the second
- 8:21. All right? Well, between the first
- 8:24and the second, there is an additional
- 8:27utility of 8. Yeah. It can happen that
- 8:31when I get to the consumption of the
- 8:33second product, I have the consumption
- 8:35of the first plus this supplement that
- 8:37brings me to the total utility of 18.
- 8:40Did you understand that? So then for
- 8:42marginal utility, well, I do 18-10,
- 8:4424-18, and so on. That gives us the
- 8:47first one, so we don't calculate it,
- 8:50and there is no initial utility. I'll
- 8:54calculate for X: 10-0 is 10, 18-10 is 8
- 8:59, 24-18 is 6, 28-24 is 4. 30-28 is 2,
- 9:08and 2. Are you following me? Good, I'll
- 9:12do the same thing for product Y. You
- 9:17see the total utility of Y. So for the
- 9:19first one, we can't calculate it. So
- 9:2212-0 is 12, 23-12...Please check the
- 9:26calculations with me. 23-12 makes 11.
- 9:30That's right. That makes 9. That makes
- 9:347. And that makes 4. And and 4. That's
- 9:43good. Is that correct?
- 9:454 and 0 there. That's zero. Yes, look,
- 9:49I put it there, it is zero, you correct
- 9:50me because you see it's zero, we agree
- 9:52on that. Yes.
- 9:53Because 30 minus 30 is 0.
- 9:56Exactly, and there it's zero.
- 10:00That's fine, don't hesitate to correct
- 10:03me, because normally it's 30-30 equals
- 10:060 and 43-43 equals 0, that's good. I
- 10:11have finished my marginal utility.
- 10:13Agreed? Now, in the little review
- 10:17exercise I gave you, we are told, we
- 10:20are told...So, we have calculated the
- 10:25marginal utilities. We are told that
- 10:29knowing the prices, knowing that the
- 10:32prices of X and Y, knowing that the
- 10:35prices of X and Y are equal, okay? are
- 10:39eq-the price of X equals the price of Y
- 10:47equals € 2. OK? Equals € 2. And
- 10:54that the consumer's disposable income,
- 10:57the disposable income that I will call
- 10:59R, the disposable income is € 18.
- 11:04Agreed? And this € 18 income is
- 11:08entirely allocated to the purchase of a
- 11:10combination of X and Y. What does that
- 11:13mean? You have € 18, you must spend
- 11:16the entire amount on the purchase of a
- 11:18quantity of X and Y. Nothing should be
- 11:20left over, agreed? Of X and Y. What
- 11:27combination of quantities of the two
- 11:29goods, the two goods X and Y, should
- 11:31the individual choose at the optimum?
- 11:34In a way, you are being asked what is
- 11:36the combination of X and Y that
- 11:38provides the best satisfaction for the
- 11:41consumer, the optimal maximum
- 11:43satisfaction. Do you understand? So we
- 11:45must find it. Now, remember what I told
- 11:48you in class. The objective, the
- 11:52objective, I gave you the formula. I
- 11:54say the ideal, the objective, when one
- 11:57is calculating marginal utility, when
- 12:00one is studying consumer behavior. I
- 12:03told you, it is always this formula, we
- 12:06must arrive at this equality. Marginal
- 12:10utility of X divided by the marginal
- 12:14utility of Y. It must equal the price
- 12:18of X divided by the price of Y. You
- 12:22need to remember all this; it's your
- 12:26weapon. All right? It's always like
- 12:29that. That allows me to maximize and
- 12:33find the right combination. Well look
- 12:37here, you are told that the price of X
- 12:40equals the price of Y. That means 2
- 12:42divided by 2 equals 1. And what does
- 12:45that lead to? It means the marginal
- 12:47utility of X must equal the marginal
- 12:48utility of Y.
- 12:50Do you agree with me? So in our two
- 12:53columns, at what point do we see that
- 12:56the marginal utility of X equals the
- 12:58marginal utility of Y? As we said, the
- 13:01price of X divided by the price of Y, 2
- 13:04euros, means it equals 1. Are you
- 13:07following me? That means the marginal
- 13:10utility of X divided by the marginal
- 13:13utility of Y equals 1. That means the
- 13:17marginal utility of X equals the
- 13:19marginal utility of Y. Yes. Well, I
- 13:24will look for that in the table. So,
- 13:27where do we see that? Where do we see
- 13:31that MUx equals MUy? Go ahead.
- 13:34At 6. 6 for Y and 6 for X.
- 13:41Careful there, careful, we are in the
- 13:44process. Okay, it's not actually the
- 13:49one that provides satisfaction, but it
- 13:52must be logical, knowing that I must
- 13:55respect my income. So we'll take the
- 13:59one you suggested, you'll see, we'll
- 14:01take that one too. But you're telling
- 14:04me it's that one, so that means we have
- 14:08the combination, you're saying 6. And 6
- 14:13, is that it?
- 14:15That's what you're saying, and the
- 14:16other one? Well, 4 and 4?
- 14:21No, surely.
- 14:22Well, of course.
- 14:24It doesn't have to be on the same line.
- 14:25Not at all, it doesn't have to be on
- 14:27the same line, as long as it's the same
- 14:29marginal utility. All right. So it's 4.
- 14:36And 5. All right? 4 and 5. So I'll tell
- 14:46you right now, a marginal utility of
- 14:48zero means we've reached saturation, so
- 14:50we don't pick that one. All right? Do
- 14:54you understand me? Good. But we can...I
- 14:57can give you the answer another way. So
- 15:00we said, you tell me you found 6-6 and
- 15:034-5. Okay. But this choice must also
- 15:08respect the budget constraint.
- 15:11We are going to look at the budget
- 15:13constraint. Can I...can you see here?
- 15:15Can you see me there?
- 15:16Well, look at the budget constraint
- 15:18here. I am going to establish my budget
- 15:21equation. What is the budget equation?
- 15:28Income is R. Okay? To this income, I
- 15:33must assign products X and Y. That is
- 15:35to say, I must take the quantity of X
- 15:37multiplied by its price plus the
- 15:39quantity of Y multiplied by its price.
- 15:43Do you see what I am doing here? This
- 15:46is the budget line equation. Okay? I'll
- 15:49replace the income, we said it was 18.
- 15:53Agreed? The price of x is 2, so that
- 15:57makes 2x and the price of y is the same
- 15:59+ 2 + 2y. Agreed? I told you when
- 16:06marginal utility equals zero, we do not
- 16:08choose it. But if you want another
- 16:11proof, if you want another proof, look.
- 16:13Replace x right, replace uh x with the
- 16:18quantities. Agreed? You said it's 6, 6,
- 16:242 times 6
- 16:27+ 2 times 6
- 16:2812
- 16:2912 + 12
- 16:3024
- 16:31Greater than 18, we do not choose it.
- 16:33You see, we are not respecting this
- 16:34constraint. Do you understand now? So
- 16:37that one, already the fact that it is a
- 16:39marginal utility of zero, we already
- 16:41don't choose it. But I have now shown
- 16:43you the proof: we also don't choose it
- 16:44because it does not respect the budget
- 16:46constraint. Now, let's take the other:
- 16:49x4, y5, 4 times 2.
- 16:528
- 16:528, 5 times 2
- 16:5410
- 16:558 + 10
- 16:5618
- 16:57Exactly what is needed. So the answer
- 16:59is the combination X Y, it is this X
- 17:03and this Y. Did you understand? Yes.
- 17:08Your question.
- 17:09And if we have two, there are two,
- 17:10there is another possible combination.
- 17:13Well yes, if there is another
- 17:14combination. If there is another
- 17:16possible combination, you choose it,
- 17:18but you will see when you adapt it to
- 17:21the budget line equation with the
- 17:23budget constraint, it will select the
- 17:26best combination for you. I repeat now,
- 17:29marginal utility is what provides
- 17:33satisfaction to the client, well, to
- 17:36the consumer. Among all the
- 17:38combinations, the consumer must choose
- 17:41the best combination by paying
- 17:43attention to the price of x and y under
- 17:45the budget constraint. And I showed you
- 17:48how to do the budget equation. Did you
- 17:50understand that?
- 17:51Go ahead.
- 17:53Because the budget must be respected,
- 17:55it cannot be below. No, well, uh, when
- 17:58we maximize, it means the budget must
- 18:01be entirely allocated to the
- 18:03acquisition of X and Y. It shouldn't be
- 18:05below that, and it shouldn't be above
- 18:08that. That means when I give you € 18
- 18:10to go grocery shopping, you don't come
- 18:13back with any money left. There's no
- 18:17change, you spend it all, and in
- 18:18addition, you come out with a quantity
- 18:20of X and a quantity of Y. It's up to
- 18:22you to find the best combination.
- 18:24Actually, the neoclassicals are telling
- 18:26us what we are doing right now. In fact
- 18:29, they tell us that all human beings,
- 18:32all people, all consumers, do it
- 18:34instinctively without realizing it.
- 18:37Actually, they put numbers on the
- 18:40normal behavior of individuals. That's
- 18:43what they tell us, right? You say, "Oh
- 18:45dear, I don't do it like that, that
- 18:46doesn't work." But in fact, naturally,
- 18:48you do it like that when you go grocery
- 18:49shopping. Look, right now we're in a
- 18:52period of inflation. I'll give you an
- 18:55example with the same one: if I say €
- 18:57100, I give you € 100, you go grocery
- 18:59shopping. Since prices have gone up,
- 19:02you still spend the € 100, but you
- 19:04see that the quantity decreases. And
- 19:07well, instinctively, you are adapting
- 19:09instead of saying: "Well, usually I buy
- 19:12this product, but now, instead of this
- 19:14product, I'm going to buy two that meet
- 19:16the same needs but are complementary."
- 19:19We are always building our shopping
- 19:21basket. Here, for the example, we take
- 19:23two products, but it's the same
- 19:25reasoning with three products, four
- 19:26products, five products. Do you
- 19:29understand? It's very important. If you
- 19:31understood, normally, there shouldn't
- 19:32be any problem. Look now at what we've
- 19:34done here. Let's imagine now, in the
- 19:36exercise I gave you, let's imagine we
- 19:38tell you the price changes, you see,
- 19:42look, the price changes. This time, we
- 19:44tell you—can I erase? I can erase
- 19:47here. There. There we go, this time we
- 19:50tell you the price changes. This time,
- 19:55the price of Y is different from X.
- 19:59Agreed? This time, we tell you the
- 20:03price of X equals € 2. Agreed? It
- 20:06doesn't change. Agreed? But on the
- 20:09other hand, the one for Y, it is now at
- 20:15€ 3. Are you following me?
- 20:18You've put PX PY. Correct me as we go,
- 20:22otherwise there will be some typos or
- 20:24errors that will appear. But the logic
- 20:26is there, that's the most important
- 20:27thing, the logic. OK. There, 3, it
- 20:30changes, and we tell you the budget,
- 20:33the budget also changes. Instead of €
- 20:3718, we tell you that it is an R, it is
- 20:39income. It is the income R, it is the
- 20:43budget equal to € 15. € 15. I
- 20:47should have written a bit more there,
- 20:51because the price of X and R, the
- 20:56income, equals € 15. And we ask you
- 21:01the same question: what is the best
- 21:04combination, okay, to arrive at, to
- 21:07arrive at, which is the best
- 21:09combination that provides maximum
- 21:11satisfaction for the consumer? So, when
- 21:15you have something like that, the first
- 21:17thing to do is to establish your budget
- 21:19equation. So I write it, 2, price
- 21:24quantity x + 3y = 15 = € 15. That is
- 21:31what we call the budget constraint.
- 21:34With € 15 I can buy a quantity of x
- 21:37at € 2 unit price and a quantity of Y
- 21:40to be calculated at € 3 unit price.
- 21:44Did you understand that? And we are
- 21:46told that the price of X = € 2, the
- 21:48price of Y = € 3. Remember what I
- 21:50said when we talk about consumer
- 21:52behavior, which is the goal, you must
- 21:54have that as a weapon with you. With
- 21:57that, what is the goal? What equality
- 21:59must we reach? I said the marginal
- 22:04utility of X divided by the marginal
- 22:06utility of Y equals the price of X
- 22:09divided by the price of Y. Agreed? So
- 22:17look, before it was equality, this time
- 22:19so there it is the marginal utility of
- 22:22x divided by the marginal utility of y
- 22:25equals this time 2/3. Which means the
- 22:31marginal utility of x will not be equal
- 22:33to marginal utility like that. However,
- 22:35I can put marginal utility of x divided
- 22:39by € 2 equals marginal utility of y
- 22:43divided by € 3. 3 Agreed, earlier we
- 22:49had done marginal utility of x divided
- 22:51by 2 equals marginal utility of y
- 22:53divided by 2, then I removed the 2,
- 22:55it’s the same. Well, I’m going to
- 22:58do the same thing there, look, I’m
- 23:00going to do the same thing: I will
- 23:01create a column here and call it
- 23:03marginal utility of x divided by 2, and
- 23:10I will make a column marginal utility
- 23:12of y divid...We'll see what happens.
- 23:22Let's go. You will help me if you have
- 23:24a calculator. OK. Yes, it is difficult,
- 23:27isn't it? So the first one, we agree.
- 23:3110/2 I do that first, it makes 5, 8/2 4
- 23:37, 3, 4/2, 2/2 1 and 0
- 23:420 equals 12/3 so that's easy 4 okay I
- 23:47said hop there's the first one so we're
- 23:54at 13 12/3 4 11/3
- 23:57366
- 23:58367 7 I'm rounding up. 8.
- 24:01There. Uh 9/3 7/3
- 24:072.33
- 24:104/3
- 24:11well 1.33 I
- 24:13what
- 24:131.33
- 24:14there and the last one
- 24:200 see it changed and well this time the
- 24:24equilibrium point is going to shift
- 24:28what is for you the combination that
- 24:33provides the best satisfaction for the
- 24:37consumer, it's 1x and 2y. No, it's Oh
- 24:43wait, it's 1 x and 2 y
- 24:45there.
- 24:46Yes.
- 24:47Why there? That one is it has 5.
- 24:49Oh well no,
- 24:50we don't find 5.
- 24:51It's 2x and 1 y. So
- 24:52so x 2 that one 4 but there is no 4. Oh
- 24:56very good.
- 24:57What? 3 and 3.
- 24:59We're good, you calculated the, we did
- 25:00the calculations well here. That makes
- 25:045 4 3 5 4 3 2 1 0 and here it makes 4
- 25:07uh 4 11 3 2 33 so these are the
- 25:10calculations. So what are the
- 25:13combinations? What are the identical
- 25:14numbers in both columns? First we start
- 25:16with
- 25:16there's 3 and 3 and 3.
- 25:17There's 3 and 3
- 25:18and there's 4 and 4 as well. There's 3
- 25:20and 3 and there's 4 and 4. The
- 25:24tie-breaker will be the budget equation
- 25:27. As simple as can be. So let's take
- 25:31the first one you tell me so since it's
- 25:344 and 4 so we can take we can take that
- 25:38one it means the quantity of 2x and
- 25:45it's good. replacing 2 x 2
- 25:504
- 25:514 + 3 x 1
- 25:533
- 25:55we're not within the budget. Are you
- 25:57following me? I repeat 2 x 2 4 + 3 x 1
- 26:02that makes 7. We have the second one 3
- 26:08and 3 left, meaning I take it's not 3x
- 26:13and 3y. A quantity of 3 of x and a
- 26:15quantity of 3y. Let's replace 3 x 2
- 26:196
- 26:20and 3 x 3
- 26:229 + 6
- 26:24that's the one you have to choose. Did
- 26:26you understand? So the answer, the
- 26:30solution is actually that we have the
- 26:33combination 3 see we can have several
- 26:38choices but we verify them with the
- 26:41budget constraint and we arrive at an
- 26:44answer. Is it complicated? See? So I
- 26:49told you it's not that complicated.
- 26:51It's a logic to acquire and normally
- 26:53there's no problem.
- 26:58Do you have any questions? No questions
- 27:01. But see here, you understood this
- 27:04principle of marginal utility, total
- 27:06utility, the maximization of utility.
- 27:09You understood that in the reasoning
- 27:11there is the quantity but when the
- 27:13consumer makes their choice what comes
- 27:15into play? Price and income. Well now,
- 27:20we are going to move on to the second
- 27:21part. Right, we are still within the
- 27:28realm of total utility, marginal
- 27:31utility, customer satisfaction,
- 27:35maximizing consumer utility, and so on.
- 27:39Yeah. The consumer will look for the
- 27:42best combination of products to make up
- 27:44their basket. You see? And this time,
- 27:46we are going to move on to something
- 27:47else. Instead of using a table like we
- 27:50did earlier to explain what total and
- 27:52marginal utility are and trying to find
- 27:54the best combination. This time, we
- 27:56might give you, and it is often the
- 27:58case, what we call a utility function,
- 28:01right? A utility function that we often
- 28:04denote like this, U, there you go, U is
- 28:08a utility function always combining
- 28:12products X and Y. Agreed? And here, I
- 28:15will take an example, an example of a
- 28:17utility function. So, I will take 2xy.
- 28:22There you go. And 2xy. OK? Here is an
- 28:31example that we might give you. So, I
- 28:33want to clarify right away. I want to
- 28:35clarify right away that when we reach
- 28:38this stage, I strongly advise you to
- 28:42review your derivatives. This is what
- 28:46we call derivatives. This is what we
- 28:48call derivatives. I'm writing it here,
- 28:50derivatives. standard and derivatives.
- 29:00partial. Once again, there is nothing
- 29:05complicated about it. There is nothing
- 29:06complicated about it. Maybe I will do a
- 29:09quick review with you on standard and
- 29:11partial derivatives. But it is
- 29:14essential. It is truly essential to
- 29:18make the understanding easier. So you
- 29:22have understood that this video, this
- 29:24session, is not a course on standard
- 29:26and partial derivatives. So I assume
- 29:28that you have a certain mastery of
- 29:31derivatives.
- 29:33standard and partial. Well, standard
- 29:35derivatives are the derivatives you
- 29:36already know, they are the simplest
- 29:38ones, right? We will see if we need to
- 29:41do a little review of these derivatives
- 29:45later, but I can still explain how we
- 29:48find them at any time, no problem.
- 29:52Right. So, look, when you have a
- 29:54utility function like this one, the
- 29:57question is the same, it's about
- 29:59finding the best combination of X and Y
- 30:01, it's about maximizing utility. So,
- 30:04there are different steps. So, we can
- 30:06ask you more specific questions. Here,
- 30:10for example, in the review exercise you
- 30:12have in front of you, you are given the
- 30:15function, the utility function of x and
- 30:17y. And we tell you that X and Y are the
- 30:22quantities, they are the quantities
- 30:25consumed. X and Y, quantities consumed.
- 30:30And we ask you, we ask you to determine
- 30:33the combinations of goods X and Y that
- 30:37provide maximum satisfaction to the
- 30:40consumer. See, it's always the same
- 30:43thing, but this time, we tell you under
- 30:46constraint. Let's imagine that in this
- 30:49exercise, we tell you to maximize
- 30:51consumer satisfaction by finding the
- 30:54best combination of X and Y while
- 30:58adding a constraint. I put it under a
- 31:01budget constraint. Under a constraint,
- 31:04and we tell you the price of X is equal
- 31:06, for example in our exercise, to PX =
- 31:09€ 2. Price of Y price of Y = € 1.
- 31:17We'll make things easier, € 1. And we
- 31:20tell you your available income, the R,
- 31:22your available income, is € 100.
- 31:27Agreed?
- 31:30And there, the question asks you to
- 31:32determine the best combination. Are you
- 31:35following me? Very well. Remember what
- 31:38I said. What needs to be done? The
- 31:39first thing, establish the budget
- 31:43equation. I'm listening to you now. You
- 31:45understood my budget equation. 2x
- 31:492x
- 31:50+ 1y
- 31:52+ 1y. So I put y
- 31:541y, I can remove the 1+ y =
- 32:03there it is. Well there, we have our
- 32:08budget equation which is a constraint,
- 32:13okay? It will play a role in the
- 32:16calculation.
- 32:24So, what should we do when we have this
- 32:26? You saw, we no longer have a table,
- 32:29we have a function and this function
- 32:31will serve as a tool for mathematical
- 32:33calculations. So, you must know, and we
- 32:36did this in class, that to solve this
- 32:39type of exercise, we use two methods.
- 32:43Two methods, two methods. There is one
- 32:47that we call by the MRS, the marginal
- 32:54rate of substitution. Perhaps that is
- 32:58what you prefer.
- 33:00And the second method is using the
- 33:02Lagrange method. Whether I use this
- 33:08method or that one, I arrive at the
- 33:10same result. Is that good? And we are
- 33:14going to move immediately to the MRS
- 33:15method. Come understand, huh. And if
- 33:17you have any questions, don't hesitate
- 33:18to stop me. Is that good? So I'm going
- 33:20to start with, well there are two
- 33:21methods, the first and the second.
- 33:23There. So I'm going to start with the
- 33:25first, the MRS method. And that is
- 33:28where you must, and for both, you must
- 33:30master, you must master derivatives,
- 33:32huh, simple derivatives, standard
- 33:34derivatives and partial derivatives.
- 33:36But as I move forward, I can provide
- 33:38some clarification on that. But stop me
- 33:39if you don't understand. All right,
- 33:41I'll try to watch the time so we don't
- 33:43go over too much. OK, I can erase this
- 33:46and I'll take the first method, MRS.
- 33:50I'll just write this one down just to
- 33:54have some room, I'll write the budget
- 33:57equation here: 2x + y = 200, and I'll
- 34:01erase. And I said I'll start with the
- 34:06first method, MRS, marginal rate of
- 34:09substitution, please. There, MRS X =
- 34:12Alright? Well, let's remember, you see,
- 34:17every time I repeat the same thing.
- 34:19What is the goal? The goal for
- 34:22maximization is that we must reach an
- 34:24equilibrium, right? We must reach an
- 34:27equilibrium. Which one? Alright?
- 34:30Marginal utility of X divided by
- 34:34marginal utility of Y = PX/PY. It
- 34:39always comes back every time. That
- 34:44Alright. Knowing that I have to respect
- 34:51the budget constraint. So, when we have
- 35:01a utility function, to calculate the
- 35:05marginal utility of X, in fact, I must
- 35:09use partial derivatives. Alright? I
- 35:16must calculate the partial derivative
- 35:17of the utility function with respect to
- 35:20X and the partial derivative of the
- 35:21utility function with respect to Y.
- 35:23Alright? How do we do it? So I must
- 35:27calculate the partial derivative with
- 35:29respect to X divided by the partial
- 35:31derivative with respect to Y, which
- 35:33equals the price of X over the price of
- 35:35Y, which we already have as 2/1. It's
- 35:39good. So, partial derivative, I'll
- 35:43start with the partial derivative with
- 35:46respect to X. I'll write it like this:
- 35:48partial derivative of the utility
- 35:50function U with respect to X, that's
- 35:52just a mathematical notation, right?
- 35:56That's not an operation, it's just
- 35:59notation. So, how do we do it when we
- 36:03have a function like this with two
- 36:05variables, X and Y? When I have to
- 36:08calculate the partial derivative with
- 36:10respect to X, remember, listen
- 36:12carefully, if I have to derive x, y
- 36:16becomes a constant. Yes, I
- 36:21differentiate x y becomes a constant.
- 36:27That means it's as if—well, what is a
- 36:30constant? It's just any number. For
- 36:33example, 2 is a constant, 5 is a
- 36:35constant, -2 is a constant, 25 is a
- 36:37constant, 4/2 is a constant. It's a
- 36:40number. Alright? So, I'm telling you,
- 36:42when I'm looking for the partial
- 36:44derivative with respect to X, Y becomes
- 36:46a constant. Ultimately, to make it
- 36:49easier, when I differentiate X, instead
- 36:52of 2xy, transform it, put the constants
- 36:55together like yx. So, as I told you, y
- 37:02becomes a constant. So all of this is a
- 37:04constant. Are you following me? And you
- 37:07were taught derivatives when you have
- 37:09the form. Imagine a is a constant, a
- 37:14constant derivative of ax equals what?
- 37:21Equals a. Okay? Because a is a constant
- 37:26, but since we considered that all of
- 37:28this is a constant, so there I will
- 37:31find. Do you understand this logic? I
- 37:36do the same thing for the 2nd one.
- 37:38There we go. Derivative of Y, partial
- 37:40of Y. This time, if I take the partial
- 37:43derivative of Y, X becomes a constant.
- 37:46Okay? X becomes a constant. That means
- 37:48all of this is a constant, but only Y
- 37:51needs to be derived. So then, it
- 37:53becomes 2x. So, I can replace marginal
- 38:00utility of X is Y. The marginal utility
- 38:04of Y is 2x. Okay? Equal, the price of x
- 38:09is 2, the price of y is 1. Okay? I'll
- 38:14expand. That makes y/x = 2. Okay? So, y
- 38:23equals what?
- 38:292x. Are you following me? y divided by
- 38:35x = 2. So y = 2x. And look now, I have
- 38:47y = 2x. Actually, I can set up a system
- 38:50like this. Y = 2x and below, I put the
- 38:57budget equation 2x + y = 200. Well look
- 39:03, I replace Y here with its value there
- 39:06, what does it become? 2x + I replace y
- 39:11with 2x, so it will be 2x + 2x = 200.
- 39:17Is that good? 4x = 200 so x = 200/4 so
- 39:23x = 50. I already found the quantity of
- 39:29x. Now that I have x, I go back here.
- 39:34If x equals 50, y equals what here? If
- 39:40x = 50, y = 2*50, y = 100. And I found
- 39:47my, I found the combination yx. So the
- 39:51answer is this one. So I need a
- 39:53quantity of x of 50 and 100. Is it
- 40:02complicated? If you say it's
- 40:04complicated, it's rather that you don't
- 40:06master your derivatives. But if you
- 40:09master derivatives, usually it's super
- 40:11super simple. Remember what I say about
- 40:13partial derivatives. If I derive, if I
- 40:16look for the partial derivative of x, y
- 40:18becomes a constant. If I look for the
- 40:20partial derivative of y, x becomes
- 40:22constant. And usually, you do your
- 40:25calculations and you arrive at x, the
- 40:27quantity of x 50 and now to check, we
- 40:32will verify if this quantity of 50 and
- 40:35100 meets the budget constraint. x = 50
- 40:392 x 50
- 40:42100 + 100 200 is the answer.
- 40:47Yes. Your question.
- 40:48But does that mean when we take the
- 40:50derivative of x, we remove x and take
- 40:52the opposite? Ultimately when it's x
- 40:54and y. If we derive x, well, we
- 40:56inevitably remove x from
- 40:58well it all depends on the function. It
- 41:00all depends on the function because
- 41:02so every time we look for the
- 41:03derivative of y, it removes the y from
- 41:05it removes the y. Yes, yes, exactly.
- 41:07You're right. It removes the Y. But yes
- 41:09, it removes it. It depends, because if
- 41:11it were an addition, the reasoning
- 41:12wouldn't be the same. We
- 41:13don't have, when we derive x in the
- 41:15result, we don't have x, we have the y
- 41:17instead.
- 41:17Yes. No, but there can be an x in the
- 41:19derivative with respect to c.
- 41:21Let me give you an example. If it were
- 41:23x² instead of x, so 2y is a constant,
- 41:28it doesn't change, but we must derive
- 41:30x². X² becomes 2x. You see? So I
- 41:36would have 4yX. It all depends on what
- 41:41we have in the function, because
- 41:42actually I took the first degree,
- 41:43there's no second degree to explain it
- 41:45to you easily, but you must master the
- 41:46derivatives, you have to master them.
- 41:48There's nothing else to it. So we'll do
- 41:50a quick review on that, but okay, no
- 41:53questions, and I'll move on immediately
- 41:55to the second method, the Lagrange
- 41:57method. We are now moving on to our
- 42:03second method, the Lagrange method.
- 42:05Okay? I will now set up the Lagrange
- 42:07function. How is it written? L refers
- 42:10to the Lagrange function, equals the
- 42:15utility function 2xy, okay, 2xy, okay,
- 42:19minus and here I add a lambda factor of
- 42:24my budget equation, but I bring the
- 42:29income over to this side, to this side
- 42:332x + y. Okay? There you go. So I will
- 42:43calculate the derivative of X with
- 42:45respect to the L, Lagrange function.
- 42:47The derivative of Y with respect to the
- 42:48L, Lagrange function. So d derivative
- 42:55of X equals, remember, I said that when
- 42:59we derive X, okay? X, y becomes a
- 43:04constant. So the derivative of 2xy
- 43:07becomes 2Y. Minus the same thing here.
- 43:13Uh, lambda is the same, it's a constant
- 43:16, y is a constant, derivative 0, 200 is
- 43:19a constant, derivative 0. I'm left with
- 43:242x lambda, and derivative, so lambda
- 43:27and 2 are constants, derivative of x is
- 43:301-2 lambda. Okay? And I set this
- 43:34equation equal to 0. Now I
- 43:38differentiate y with respect to the
- 43:43Lagrange function. I do the same thing.
- 43:47If I look for the partial derivative of
- 43:49y, x becomes a constant. So the
- 43:52derivative of 2xy, knowing that 2x is a
- 43:54constant, is 2x. Right? Minus, same
- 44:00thing here; except for y, everything
- 44:05else is a constant, so 2x is a constant
- 44:09, 0. 200 is a constant, derivative 0,
- 44:14I'm left with lambda y and the
- 44:16derivative of lambda y, knowing lambda
- 44:19is a constant, becomes lambda. So I set
- 44:25this equal to 0, that's good, which
- 44:27brings me here. Okay. So here, what
- 44:32does lambda equal? Lambda equals, if I
- 44:37move it, lambda = 2y. So lambda = y.
- 44:43Are you following me? I'll do 2y = 2
- 44:46lambda, y = it equals, lambda = y. So I
- 44:53can replace it here with y. Are you
- 44:56following me? So that gives 2x-y = 0.
- 45:06Right? Which means that y equals what?
- 45:11Y equals what? I'm listening. 2x-y = 0.
- 45:16So y =
- 45:172x
- 45:182x. Right? That's good. y = 2x. So now
- 45:27that I've found that, I'll write it
- 45:30here. y = 2x and I'll create a system
- 45:35with my budget equation, okay. 2x + y =
- 45:42200. You see, I'm solving this system.
- 45:48So, I just need to replace y with its
- 45:51value. That gives me 2x + can we see
- 45:54here?
- 45:56No.
- 45:57No. So I'll go to the next line up to
- 45:59here. We can see clearly.
- 46:01Yes.
- 46:02So look here. Here 2x + y = 200.
- 46:06Knowing that y = 2x, I found that below
- 46:09. Well, I replace y with 2x. That gives
- 46:12me 2x + 2x = 200. 4x = 200, x = 200/4,
- 46:21x = 50. x = 50. Now that I've found x =
- 46:3250, well, I just need to replace it up
- 46:34there, look there.
- 46:37I just need to replace x with its value
- 46:39, 50, and we find that y = 2 times 50.
- 46:45Do you see? And there, I found X and I
- 46:50found Y. So, I found my combination of
- 46:54X and Y that provides the maximum,
- 46:56optimal satisfaction. Did you
- 47:00understand? So here, I used another
- 47:03method, Lagrange, but which actually
- 47:05starts from this Lagrange function by
- 47:07integrating lambda, which allows me to
- 47:09arrive at the same thing. Do you have
- 47:11any questions? So it's up to you to
- 47:15choose between MRS or Lagrange. Yes, we
- 47:19don't need
- 47:22lambda.
- 47:23Yes,
- 47:25We can derive it later, but this is
- 47:26just to save you from complications. We
- 47:29can do it directly like this. We can
- 47:31derive lambda later, and that way I'll
- 47:33have a system with three unknowns. But
- 47:37I'm giving you this method for
- 47:38simplicity. We just do X, Y, and there
- 47:40you go. And then we use the budget
- 47:43equation, and we have our quantity of X
- 47:45and our quantity of Y. Any questions?
- 47:48Yes.
- 47:50No. Very well.
- 47:55Now, after determining the quantity of
- 47:58X and the quantity of Y that satisfy
- 48:00the consumer—meaning that these two
- 48:03quantities allow the consumer to
- 48:05maximize their utility. All right? Now,
- 48:09we are going to look at the
- 48:10indifference curve. What does that mean
- 48:12? We are going to represent the
- 48:14quantities of X and Y that allow the
- 48:17consumer to maximize their utility on a
- 48:19graph. And on that same graph, we will
- 48:22also plot and establish the budget line
- 48:24. So, I'll recap what we've done so far
- 48:27. We worked on the utility function U
- 48:31of XY. We have this budget constraint
- 48:36of 2x + y = 200. Knowing that 2 is the
- 48:39price of X, and for Y, the price is 1
- 48:42euro. That's why we don't put a one.
- 48:44And the budget constraint is 200 euros.
- 48:47We found, using the MRS method
- 48:50confirmed by the Lagrange method, that
- 48:53the quantity maximizing this utility is
- 48:5650 for X and 100 for Y. Now, based on
- 48:58these calculations, we can create a
- 49:01graphic representation of the
- 49:03indifference curve. But to create this
- 49:08graphic representation, we must
- 49:10establish the indifference curve
- 49:12equation. To establish the indifference
- 49:18curve equation, I will first substitute
- 49:20into the utility function—the one
- 49:23given in the exercise at the start. I
- 49:27will substitute X with its value of 50
- 49:29and Y with its value of 100. So, this
- 49:33becomes 2 multiplied by 50...plus, uh,
- 49:392 multiplied by 50 multiplied by 100,
- 49:42actually. There we go. All right? So,
- 49:4610,000. We arrive at 10,000. I hope you
- 49:50can see the...equals 10,000. Good. So,
- 49:55I'm setting up my equation. So, the
- 49:58utility function equals 10,000.
- 50:03Therefore, the maximum utility reached
- 50:05is 10,000. And to reach 10,000, one
- 50:09must consume 50X and 100Y. So now, to
- 50:14create the graphic representation of
- 50:16the indifference curve, you simply need
- 50:18to set the utility function, the
- 50:20utility equation. So, we put utility
- 50:25equals 2XY, which equals 10,000. You
- 50:32see? 2XY. Actually, I don't even need
- 50:36to put the u there. I only need to put
- 50:392x y = 10000. And there, I’ll do my
- 50:42graphical representation. So I’m
- 50:44going to pick a few points. So there, a
- 50:46few points to draw the curve. But
- 50:48before drawing the curve, I advise you
- 50:50to set up your budget line first. How
- 50:53do we set up the budget line? The
- 50:55budget line is this one here. It is
- 50:56generally given in the exercise. You
- 50:58have to establish it. So how do I do
- 51:00that? So I know our budget is € 200.
- 51:04The price of x is 2, the price of y is
- 51:07€ 1. Well, to draw the line, first I
- 51:11assign 0 to x. Let's imagine, so let's
- 51:14imagine x = 0. If x = 0, what is y?
- 51:18Look, I'm at the coordinates. If I
- 51:21assign 0 to x, y = 200. So it's this
- 51:24point, you see, I have it here. OK, I
- 51:26have it there. If y = 0, what is x
- 51:32equal to? 200. If y = 0, I'm left with
- 51:362x = 200. So x = 200/2 = 100. So it's
- 51:39right there. Yeah. I repeat, to draw
- 51:43the budget line, I must first establish
- 51:46the budget equation. The budget
- 51:48equation equals the price of x times
- 51:50the quantity of x plus the price of y
- 51:52times the quantity of y = 200. That is
- 51:55given in the exercise. You just need to
- 51:57set up the equation. And then I draw my
- 51:59line. To get the line, I need two
- 52:01points. So I assign 0 to x, so y equals
- 52:06200. If y = 0, x = 200/2 = 100. Now
- 52:12that I have the two points, I draw the
- 52:14line. Let’s say I don't have graph
- 52:17paper. There. So this one, we call it
- 52:22we call it the budget line. Meaning all
- 52:28the expenses we can make, it’s the
- 52:30maximum. I cannot...It’s all I can
- 52:34buy, this space here.
- 52:37I cannot exceed it because I am limited
- 52:39by the budget. That means all X Y
- 52:41combinations must be within this space.
- 52:45But what is the best combination of X
- 52:48and Y? Well, I have to draw the
- 52:50indifference curve. And the point where
- 52:53the indifference curve touches the
- 52:57budget line, well, that point
- 52:59corresponds to the maximum X and Y. So
- 53:02to draw my indifference curve, I need
- 53:04to pick points too. Look. So I’m
- 53:07going to place myself here like this.
- 53:10Hop. And I will put X and Y. Okay? And
- 53:14this time, I will base myself on, well,
- 53:18the utility function equal to 10,000.
- 53:2110,000 which I found by replacing X
- 53:24with 50 and 100 to find this maximum
- 53:26utility. So, I'll do a quick
- 53:28calculation. So, if I give 10 the value
- 53:32of 10, y = 500, right? If I give x the
- 53:35value of 10, that makes 10 times 2, 20,
- 53:38and then I have 10,000 divided by 20,
- 53:41which is 500. If x is equal to, for
- 53:46example, 20, then y = 250. Do you
- 53:49understand how I found that? Yes.
- 53:52And 30 if I replace X with 30, for y I
- 53:59find about 167; it's 166.7, but that's
- 54:02rounded. And if I give x the value of
- 54:06100, for example, okay? Well, y = 50. I
- 54:10have enough points to plot my curve. So
- 54:14look, 10 has an image of 500. There we
- 54:17go, it's going to be there. There's a
- 54:20first point, the second one 20 has an
- 54:24image of 250, it's there. About there,
- 54:30you see, the 30, the 30 has an image of
- 54:34about 167. It's going to be about there
- 54:36, and so on. And 100 for example, if I
- 54:42take 100, 50, the 50 here, hop, the 100
- 54:44is there, there it is. And normally, if
- 54:49I draw this curve, well, the curve will
- 54:52touch the budget line at the point,
- 54:55normally 50x and 100y, or these are the
- 55:02points we found, that we calculated
- 55:04when we maximized utility. This means,
- 55:06at that point, normally, the curve
- 55:08comes and touches it. So it's just to
- 55:11show you. You see, we do it like this.
- 55:21See? So I should have done it in
- 55:23another color. This means it's just to
- 55:25show that it's at this point. You see,
- 55:28it's this point here. We have to look
- 55:31at the tangent, but I won't bother you
- 55:33with that. So the curve, this is called
- 55:36an indifference curve. Indifference
- 55:40curve. I'll write it better than that.
- 55:48It's called an indifference curve.
- 55:57Indifference with a utility equal to
- 56:0010,000. That's what we did. Okay? And
- 56:06when we plot it properly as it should
- 56:08be, you've understood, it's just to
- 56:09show you how it's done. I don't have
- 56:11graph paper and all that. Well, this
- 56:14point is the minimum, we will find it,
- 56:16it's the minimum of the indifference
- 56:19curve and it is the maximum, let's say,
- 56:21of the budget line, or to put it
- 56:23another way. This point where the
- 56:28indifference curve intersects the
- 56:31budget line corresponds to the X50 Y100
- 56:35combination we calculated when
- 56:37maximizing consumer utility. Meaning
- 56:42the best combination the consumer can
- 56:45achieve with a budget of € 200 is by
- 56:48buying 50 units of X and 100 units of
- 56:51Y. That is what I wanted to show you
- 56:54regarding this part. So, what really
- 56:58matters is understanding the logic. If
- 57:00you have understood the logic, you can
- 57:01succeed in any exercise. Well then, I
- 57:04hope you have understood everything now
- 57:05. You can do all the exercises. Redo
- 57:07the exercises I left for you first, and
- 57:09if you have any questions, don't
- 57:10hesitate to ask me.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Microéconomie (Comportement du consommateur) : Utilité marginale, TMS Courbe d'indifférence... by L'Économie-Gestion Simplement, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,605 words across 1,101 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.