Michael Hudson: Nvidia, the AI Bubble & the Financial Crisis — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Welcome back everyone. We are joined
- 0:03again by Professor Michael Hudson uh who
- 0:06does excellent work on his website and
- 0:08I've made sure to leave to have left a
- 0:10link in the description so please follow
- 0:12his uh great work. Uh good to see you
- 0:15again.
- 0:16>> It's good to be back Glenn.
- 0:19So uh if we look around well across the
- 0:22western world now from Poland to
- 0:25Germany, France, United Kingdom, the
- 0:28United States the question about what
- 0:31democracy means is well increasingly
- 0:34questioned that is formally we have
- 0:37democracies as a political system but at
- 0:40the same time we see this rising
- 0:42economic and financial oligarchy. So u I
- 0:46was wondering yeah I guess it's a big
- 0:49question but how how do you see this
- 0:51issue? I mean how does um uh the
- 0:54financial oligarchy impact our
- 0:56democracies?
- 0:58>> Well Aristotle wrote long ago in his
- 1:01study of Greek constitutions that many
- 1:03constitutions claimed to be democracy
- 1:06but they were actually all oligarchies.
- 1:09And he had a whole dynamic that I said
- 1:12well uh the there are autocracies and
- 1:16then uh some protesters within the
- 1:19autocracy take the public and the army
- 1:22and the citizenry into their camp and
- 1:25they overthrow the oligarchy and they
- 1:27create democracy. But it all turns back
- 1:30into oligarchy again and oligarchies
- 1:32make themselves hereditary and uh that
- 1:35becomes an aristocracy and you have the
- 1:37whole eternal triangle all over again.
- 1:40So I think that what claims to be a
- 1:42democracy has really turned out to be
- 1:45oligarchy because the voters in Europe,
- 1:48the reason they're having all of these
- 1:50riots from France and uh Spain and
- 1:54Germany uh demonstrations are that they
- 1:58don't have a voice at the polls at
- 2:02electoral politics in solving the
- 2:04immediate problems they have. And the
- 2:06problems they have are largely the
- 2:09financial squeeze on household budgets
- 2:13and also the closing down of employers,
- 2:16the economic shrinkage especially that's
- 2:19going to be caused now that there's an
- 2:21oil crisis because the higher prices are
- 2:24increasing the cost to families of
- 2:27heating and lighting their homes and uh
- 2:29of gasoline and electricity uh for
- 2:34everything and for whole
- 2:36The danger is that this oil crisis is
- 2:39going to make many economies look just
- 2:41like Germany looked after 2022 when it
- 2:45stopped uh getting Russian gas and oil.
- 2:50Well, uh the
- 2:53the voters in Europe don't seem able to
- 2:56get rid of Merits and Macron and change
- 3:00the British Labor Party. So, they really
- 3:02don't have a voice. So what what kind of
- 3:04uh democracy in that it no no matter
- 3:07what they vote for they're subject to
- 3:11the world as it is and it's largely
- 3:14under the US uh policy to fight Russia
- 3:19to fight Iran and to do to them what it
- 3:21did to Venezuela to take over their oil
- 3:24and all of this is a fight for oil. We
- 3:27want to control the choke point of oil
- 3:30and who's going to get the profits uh
- 3:33from all of the world oil trade. If uh
- 3:36Russia and Iran want to keep these uh
- 3:39their oil export proceeds for
- 3:40themselves, that doesn't help us. We're
- 3:43going to war with them. And uh that's
- 3:45really uh what is causing the whole
- 3:48backwash of uh uh problems. Well, uh,
- 3:52obviously there's a rising pressure in
- 3:54Europe from, uh, the populist group, the
- 3:57nationalists who want domestic
- 4:00sovereignty. They want their countries
- 4:02to be able to say we're going to uh run
- 4:05our foreign policy and domestic policy
- 4:08in the interest of preserving prosperity
- 4:11and helping us not simply to be
- 4:15satellites of uh the US fighting in
- 4:18against Russia, Iran and all of its war
- 4:21on the rest of the world for its own
- 4:23self-interest. Well, you saw, as we've
- 4:26discussed before, the fight in Poland
- 4:27was over the constitutional crisis is
- 4:30could Poland have its own rules
- 4:32independently of the EU, Vondan,
- 4:36Kayakalis, etc. And uh they're basically
- 4:40uh arms of NATO, arms of the US uh
- 4:44policy and Pentagon. So all of this
- 4:47democracy, it really comes down to
- 4:49national sovereignty. Is Europe going to
- 4:51be run for the benefit of it the
- 4:54majority of its citizens who need uh
- 4:59less expensive energy or else enormous
- 5:02government subsidy that the EU rules of
- 5:05uh national budgets won't permit
- 5:08governments to fund especially if the
- 5:10government budgets are all moving away
- 5:13from social support to military spending
- 5:16which I think the majority of European
- 5:18voters aren't in favor of what can they
- 5:21do in the fact that Europe seems to have
- 5:23lost its democracy.
- 5:27That was a good question and uh it
- 5:29seemed that over all these years we
- 5:32hollowed out everything of public
- 5:34ownership and we called it the economic
- 5:37growth and uh as we saw yeah the
- 5:40economic interest shift more away from
- 5:43the public the
- 5:46uh the political elites they began to
- 5:48have less and less interest in the
- 5:50public or at at least begin to respond
- 5:54um to others which has caused this
- 5:57populist growth now where the elites are
- 6:00very very distant from the actual people
- 6:02and uh I guess in Europe you hear it so
- 6:06openly though when you have uh political
- 6:08leaders from Germany to Italy they're
- 6:10asked well the public doesn't really
- 6:11support you sending the little money we
- 6:14have left off to to wars and the
- 6:18argument essentially is well you know we
- 6:20know better uh and and that's that's
- 6:22kind of the end of it and you know you
- 6:24can wait for the next election but it
- 6:26really doesn't matter who you vote for
- 6:28because the policies are written in
- 6:30stone. Uh but how do you see this? So
- 6:33how how do you conceptualize this? Is a
- 6:36political crisis, an economic crisis? Is
- 6:38it a civilizational crisis?
- 6:41>> Well, it's a civilizational crisis in
- 6:43the sense that it's world right
- 6:45worldwide right now. H how is uh the
- 6:50rest of the world going to respond to
- 6:52the United States trying to control and
- 6:56bully other countries by creating choke
- 6:59points in the international economy? The
- 7:02oil trade is a choke point. It'll f
- 7:04force countries into the financial choke
- 7:07point. Are they going to have to make a
- 7:09swap agreement with the Treasury or the
- 7:11IMF and the World Bank? and will that
- 7:14will the Treasury and essentially its
- 7:17satellites and the IMF and the World
- 7:19Bank said we'll you know we'll save you
- 7:21countries from having to depreciate your
- 7:23currency and you'll uh we'll lend you
- 7:26enough so that you can support your
- 7:28businesses so they don't have to close
- 7:29down and cause unemployment but you uh
- 7:32there are conditions for this and you'll
- 7:35have to agree to the sanctions that the
- 7:39Trump administration has imposed on
- 7:41Russia and China as well as Iran. You
- 7:45know, you'll have to break all you'll
- 7:46have to isolate Russia, isolate China,
- 7:50and especially do just what you're doing
- 7:53now, not permit uh Chinese expansion
- 7:55there. And you'll have to shift to uh
- 7:58enable American AI and internet and
- 8:02computer technology to uh become
- 8:05monopolized in the United States. You
- 8:08Europeans can't have uh your own uh
- 8:10internet. we have to uh avoid China's
- 8:14open-source AI and all of this. So, it's
- 8:18a civilizational war in the sense that
- 8:20the United States along with its
- 8:22European satellites and Japan and South
- 8:25Korea are against the global majority.
- 8:29uh uh China, Russia and Iran is a
- 8:32critical mass that are self-supporting
- 8:35and any of the BRICS countries that they
- 8:37can absorb into their sphere of
- 8:40influence to say well you know we don't
- 8:43the war is against us but you will do
- 8:46much better with an alignment of us than
- 8:49an an alignment of the United States and
- 8:52the alignment with us is an alignment
- 8:55for your prosperity because uh the west
- 8:57is basically
- 8:59finance capitalist as you just pointed
- 9:01out and uh their idea is to make wealth
- 9:05financially but that the result is
- 9:08de-industrialization.
- 9:10We're the major producers and you can uh
- 9:13join us and uh the kind of economy that
- 9:16we have and uh we want to go back to
- 9:19what the original policy of industrial
- 9:22capitalism is uh in large corporate
- 9:25employers
- 9:27uh create goods and services and they
- 9:30plow their profits back into expanding
- 9:33production to employ more labor and
- 9:35expand the economy. But that's not
- 9:37what's happening in the West since the
- 9:391980s. You've had a whole pressure for
- 9:43financialization and corporations use
- 9:45their money for dividend payouts, for
- 9:48stock buybacks. They're trying to make
- 9:51uh increase the value of uh their stock
- 9:54prices not the value of what uh and
- 9:58usefulness of what they produce. So yes,
- 10:00it's a civilization is our economy is
- 10:03going to be run for the purpose of
- 10:06tangible industrial growth or making
- 10:09financial fortunes which end up in the
- 10:12hands of the wealthiest 10% or even the
- 10:161%. And these fortunes take the form of
- 10:20financial claims on holding the majority
- 10:23of citizens in debt. And uh so it's an
- 10:27extractive policy. And will civil will
- 10:30the world economy become largely
- 10:32extractive sucking foreign economic
- 10:35surpluses into the United States or will
- 10:39other countries be able to use their own
- 10:41surpluses to grow and become successful
- 10:45uh by essentially keep ultimately
- 10:48keeping money creation and credit
- 10:51allocation in the hands of the public
- 10:54sector to steer in favor of actual
- 11:00tangible capital investment and social
- 11:02spending instead of uh into supporting
- 11:06the financial sector. So in a way you
- 11:09could say it it's more than a class war.
- 11:12It's a war between what kind of
- 11:14capitalism are you going to have? And
- 11:17industrial capitalism already in the
- 11:2019th century was evolving into socialism
- 11:23because the whole idea of industrial
- 11:27success making Britain the workshop of
- 11:29the world and then making the United
- 11:31States replace Britain as it rise to
- 11:34affluence. Well, the government the
- 11:37government is uh we're going to lower
- 11:39the cost of living, lower the cost of
- 11:41production by preventing monopolies, and
- 11:44we're going to keep natural monopolies
- 11:47in the public domain as public
- 11:48enterprises, transportation, uh
- 11:51education, medical care, communications,
- 11:54and all of the key technologies. Uh and
- 11:59the ID, it was industrial capitalism
- 12:02that wanted the government to do this.
- 12:04That's why in America we had the
- 12:06antirust laws of 1890, the Sherman Act,
- 12:10you had Teddy Roosevelt, the
- 12:12trustbuster. That's what you want in
- 12:14other countries. Whereas the US plan is
- 12:17to establish as many monopolies, as
- 12:20choke points as it wants over other
- 12:23economies and to control them and to
- 12:26become the beneficiaries of what they
- 12:28they produce. Well, let's look at what's
- 12:31going to happen right now and how the
- 12:33how all of this is going to come to a
- 12:35head. Countries are going to have uh in
- 12:39in the next few months, most countries
- 12:41are going to run out of the ability of
- 12:44the US and Asian and European national
- 12:47petroleum reserves to be thrown onto the
- 12:49market to keep down oil and gas prices.
- 12:53Well, that means oil and gas prices are
- 12:55going to rise. And as you and I have
- 12:57discussed before, this is going to close
- 13:00uh uh force a lot of companies to close
- 13:03down just as occurred in Germany in 19
- 13:06in 2022. Well, how are other countries
- 13:10going to happen? Look at what happened
- 13:12in the 1997 and 98 Asia crisis. They had
- 13:16a balance of payments crisis like this.
- 13:19And again in the COVID crisis they had
- 13:22to turn to the IMF, the World Bank and
- 13:25on US swap agreements. Well, Secretary
- 13:27of Bessant has said well uh other
- 13:30countries will can get our swap
- 13:32agreements but they're going to have to
- 13:34essentially the price of that is they're
- 13:36going to have to follow our policies and
- 13:39become political, military, and
- 13:42financial sacrifice
- 13:44satellites. That's going to be the
- 13:46sacrifice that they have to make. And uh
- 13:50where will Europe and the global south
- 13:54countries choose to go in all of this?
- 13:57Uh there I don't see what they can do
- 14:00except to say well we're not going to
- 14:03just passively give in to the US plans
- 14:07uh that uh where Donald Trump has said
- 14:10well you know we can keep the uh
- 14:12straight of horm closed as secretary
- 14:14Bessa said it doesn't we don't have to
- 14:16reopen it. America is the main gainer.
- 14:19Well, I don't believe America will be uh
- 14:22a gainer from this. I think the oil
- 14:24crisis will hit the United States
- 14:26economy, too. But certainly uh other
- 14:28countries will be uh the losers uh if
- 14:31they don't somehow respond to the
- 14:35balance of payments crisis that they're
- 14:37in by saying, "Well, we're who are we
- 14:40going to put first? Are we going to put
- 14:43our domestic economy first or our
- 14:45foreign bond holders? About the only
- 14:48choice that foreign uh countries have is
- 14:51uh in the immediate term is to say we
- 14:55can't afford to pay our dollar debts uh
- 14:58to the US whose dollar zone has caused
- 15:03the war with Russia and Iran that's been
- 15:08causing the oil crisis to begin with. Uh
- 15:10we're in an emergency. There has to be a
- 15:12moratorum on this to save us from being
- 15:16forced into a depression. And this is
- 15:18not only a problem for the global south
- 15:20countries, it's a problem for Europe
- 15:23because Europe is going to be in exactly
- 15:24the same position.
- 15:27the the demonstrations and the pressure
- 15:30right now you're having for let uh to
- 15:33avoid these high prices uh if the
- 15:36government cannot give us subsidies
- 15:39because it has to use its uh budget for
- 15:42military spending under the EU rules to
- 15:45fight Russia then let's trade with
- 15:47Russia and keep our prices down why are
- 15:50is it really worth sacrificing our
- 15:53standard of living and our employment
- 15:56and our business expansion just to fight
- 15:59Russia and China. What do we get out of
- 16:02this fight? Well, this is like what
- 16:04happened when uh Israel withdrew from
- 16:07Judea uh saying what uh do we have to do
- 16:11with the house of David? How is that
- 16:13benefiting all of us uh in the Bible
- 16:15that broke away? uh this this kind of
- 16:18split from an exploitative center has
- 16:21gone on ever since biblical times uh in
- 16:25countries and it I don't see how it can
- 16:27be done today but it requires planning
- 16:29it you can't just say well there's going
- 16:31to be a crisis what's going to happen
- 16:34they have to have a plan and any plan
- 16:37that uh Europe and the global south
- 16:39countries and the global majority has is
- 16:43well we have to have an alternative to
- 16:47the International Monetary Fund and the
- 16:49World Bank to supply credit on terms
- 16:52that do not require us to be satellites
- 16:56of American foreign policy and and uh
- 16:59join America's war on oil, which is uh
- 17:04destroying our economies. uh there there
- 17:06has to be a full-blown alternative and
- 17:09this must include United Nations reform
- 17:12as uh President Putin has been saying in
- 17:15Russia the Russians and the Chinese I
- 17:18think have been pretty open in the kind
- 17:20of an alternative that they're trying to
- 17:23sponsor and I think the this alternative
- 17:27that develops is going to be by Russia
- 17:30and China primarily along with Iran
- 17:33because the BRICS countries are too
- 17:35diverse all over the place uh uh
- 17:39politically, economically
- 17:42and in terms of their geographic
- 17:44loyalties. Where is uh India going to
- 17:47stand? Where will even
- 17:50Brazil stand? Uh there
- 17:54it's going to take the the crisis I
- 17:57think is going to take a few years to
- 17:59work out. It's not going to be brief.
- 18:01It's going to have a very problematic
- 18:05interregnum and uh the there's no way of
- 18:09telling how it'll be right now, but I
- 18:10think it will be civilizational in the
- 18:13sense of a break from a unipolar world
- 18:15order to a multipolar order. Sorry, I
- 18:18swallowed it. A apple core.
- 18:25I take your
- 18:26>> I agree with the yeah with the argument
- 18:28here though but that's also why I keep
- 18:31wondering how western capitalism can be
- 18:33reformed now because as you argue we we
- 18:37we strayed pretty far away from the
- 18:39industrial capitalism of the 19th
- 18:41century I mean what Alexander Hamilton
- 18:45Fedick list all of those spoke about I
- 18:47mean that's very long gone uh and we
- 18:52what we had now especially the last 40
- 18:54years this uh increasingly financialized
- 18:58economy and defined largely by as you
- 19:01said this extractive rent seeking
- 19:04activities which uh also make sure that
- 19:07the west can't really recover well
- 19:09because how is the US or the Europeans
- 19:12going to compete with China when you
- 19:14have all of these uh additional
- 19:17variables all these extra forces
- 19:19extracting wealth from the production
- 19:20process you can't uh possibly compete
- 19:24under the circumstances. So when we
- 19:27reached a point now also in this um
- 19:29extraction where our own public has
- 19:32become impoverished but also the ability
- 19:35to extract from other states as you
- 19:37suggest this is coming to an end because
- 19:40uh in the technological area the
- 19:44the financial there they're all pulling
- 19:46back and uh creating a large degree of
- 19:50geoeconomic autonomy. So just feels like
- 19:53we reached the end of the line here.
- 19:54There is uh this is unlike you know the
- 19:57other economic crisis which are coming
- 20:00there's a you know there's a dip there's
- 20:02a recovery but I don't see the recovery
- 20:04this time though. So you know long long
- 20:08making a long question short how what
- 20:11what what comes after this for the west
- 20:14where it go
- 20:15>> well
- 20:16>> uh is I think we've been discussing now
- 20:19for a few months the question is what
- 20:22kind of capitalism are countries going
- 20:25to have and uh how can western
- 20:28capitalism uh be reformed that was the
- 20:31original question you were going to ask
- 20:33uh in this discussion
- 20:35And my solution is well the whole
- 20:38promise of industrial capitalism was a
- 20:41self-feeding economic growth. The idea
- 20:44of capitalism was well we're going to
- 20:47free economies from monopolies. We're
- 20:50going to free them from an absentee
- 20:52landlord class uh that extracts economic
- 20:55rent and adds to prices. The whole idea
- 20:58of capitalism was classical economics.
- 21:02the a concept of value and price and
- 21:05rent. The whole idea of making a country
- 21:07competitive like to make Britain the
- 21:11workshop of the world, you had to bring
- 21:13down prices uh in line with the actual
- 21:16cost value. You had to get rid of all
- 21:19the unnecessary costs of production that
- 21:22didn't have any role in production like
- 21:24land rent paid to the uh landed
- 21:27aristocracy. will Europe got rid of the
- 21:31House of Lords uh power in Britain and
- 21:35similar upper houses in Europe to uh
- 21:38enable the landed aristocracy to control
- 21:41tax policy. They cured that they got rid
- 21:44of the monopolies that had were a
- 21:47carryover from feudalism when
- 21:49international bankers had helped the
- 21:51kings create these monopolies in order
- 21:54to have some way of paying the war
- 21:57debts. uh they borrowed. So the whole
- 22:00idea of capitalism was, you know, to
- 22:02look at the whole Victorian uh century,
- 22:06you know, from 1815 to uh when the
- 22:09Napoleonic Wars ended to World War I was
- 22:14relatively free. There there was the
- 22:16Crimean War, there was the Franco
- 22:19Russian War, but uh this didn't really
- 22:23tear American apart. The whole idea was
- 22:25well use the economic surplus for
- 22:28domestic growth. And the whole
- 22:30international credit market beginning in
- 22:32the 1820s uh British French banks and uh
- 22:37stock brokerage companies be credit
- 22:40companies uh began to issue loans to uh
- 22:45government loans for purposes other than
- 22:47to go to war but to try to
- 22:49industrialize. The loans didn't go work
- 22:51didn't work well. They defaulted very
- 22:54quickly. But at least there was a whole
- 22:56attempt by fi uh industrial capitalism
- 23:00to uh essentially evolve into socialism
- 23:04with a rising role of government
- 23:06spending instead of private monopolies.
- 23:08It was the opposite of thatcherism, the
- 23:10opposite of regonomics. So you could say
- 23:13that uh what China has done and what
- 23:17China calls socialism with Chinese
- 23:19characteristics
- 23:21uh is uh
- 23:24exactly when you look at the details
- 23:26what have they done it's the same policy
- 23:28that first Britain and then the United
- 23:30States was following except what what
- 23:33China has done that's been much more
- 23:35intensive than what occurred in the west
- 23:38is it's kept money creation and credit
- 23:42allocation, who gets the loans and what
- 23:45are they going to spend the credit on.
- 23:47They've kept that as a public utility
- 23:49and that is what industrial capitalism
- 23:53always is moving towards and it occurred
- 23:55informally in Germany in the late 19th
- 23:59century. the whole idea of uh central
- 24:01European banking, a unity between uh
- 24:04three-way unity between government,
- 24:07heavy industry, steel and closely
- 24:09connected with the arms industry and the
- 24:12banks all together. uh the the German
- 24:15banks were encouraged don't pay out your
- 24:19uh earnings and dividends uh keep
- 24:22reinvesting them and we want our we
- 24:25creditors and banks want our profit and
- 24:28the increasing earning ability that you
- 24:30have is you increase production. That
- 24:34was the whole model of German industrial
- 24:36capitalism that was so far ahead of
- 24:40British uh
- 24:42capitalism that still was dominated by
- 24:45the banking class. Well, in the United
- 24:47States too, uh there was a a central
- 24:51idea of uh credit credit uh for
- 24:54industry. That was uh the ideology here.
- 24:57China has been able to actually do this.
- 25:00So when China creates money, it doesn't
- 25:03lend it to financial companies that say
- 25:06we're going to get use this. We're going
- 25:07to borrow money and buy up stocks and
- 25:10bonds to increase the prices and to take
- 25:12over corporations. And we can take over
- 25:15a company and we can sell off its
- 25:17property uh and then
- 25:20for a price create a a property owning
- 25:23corporation. And the property owning
- 25:25company like know whether it's the
- 25:26hamburger joint or something else can
- 25:28then uh uh release the the parent
- 25:32company can lease the ownership of uh to
- 25:36pay rent to this company and uh we the
- 25:39takeover artists can just pay ourselves
- 25:42a dividend. Well, at the end of this the
- 25:44whole economy looks like temp's water in
- 25:47uh England or all of the disastrous
- 25:50railway investments. they look like the
- 25:53post that economics. That's really what
- 25:56uh the choice is. So the way the west
- 25:58can be reformed is to roll back this
- 26:01evolution that it's had into finance
- 26:04capitalism that is essentially uh
- 26:07predatory. The uh the banking class
- 26:10doesn't actually produce uh a product.
- 26:14it uh lends money and takes its uh
- 26:18interest and financial fees and other
- 26:21revenue uh from the economy of
- 26:25production and consumption. Uh same
- 26:27thing with monopolies. Same thing with
- 26:30the in the United States the whole uh AI
- 26:34monopoly and the information technology
- 26:38monopoly is trying to be created and
- 26:40that's what the whole fight against
- 26:43Nvidia is and long it's an idea of
- 26:46isolating the uh Chinese economy uh from
- 26:51participating in this technological
- 26:54advance that we're having in the 21st
- 26:56century so that it be all subject to a
- 27:00US- centered financial monopoly because
- 27:03the financial sector has always been the
- 27:06mother of trusts. That's what banks are
- 27:09called in the United States, the mother
- 27:10of trusts. It was the financial sector
- 27:13that organized the steel industry into
- 27:15trusts, the copper trust, all the
- 27:18different trusts. All of this was
- 27:20financial management uh that created all
- 27:23this and that's what led
- 27:26uh the United States industrialists uh
- 27:29to say well we're not going to be able
- 27:31to rise to industrial power like uh
- 27:35Britain did if uh we let the whole
- 27:37economy be monopolized and that's going
- 27:39to increase our price of production and
- 27:42the cost of living for people and we're
- 27:44not going to be able to compete
- 27:47internationally. We have to get rid of
- 27:48monopolies to bring prices in line with
- 27:52cost failure. And that was the whole
- 27:54emphasis of classical value theory.
- 27:57Bring prices in line with value by
- 27:59getting rid of economic rent. And
- 28:01today's western economies have all
- 28:04turned into rontier economies,
- 28:06rentseeking economies, whether it's real
- 28:09estate for land rent, monopolies for
- 28:12natural uh natural resource rent uh and
- 28:16uh technology rents and wherever they
- 28:20can make a choke point. And of course
- 28:22the biggest monopoly at all is uh is
- 28:26banking because the private banks have
- 28:30uh something has happened in the last
- 28:32century that didn't occur at the
- 28:34beginning of banking. Uh in
- 28:38Europe central banking was developed as
- 28:41a means of the government uh providing
- 28:44credit to finance war spending by
- 28:48Britain and France. That was the whole
- 28:50idea of the Bank of England and John
- 28:53Law's Bank of France. But in the United
- 28:55States in when it created the Federal
- 28:58Reserve, the government had a rather
- 29:02backward bullionist uh not a very
- 29:05progressive uh financial policy and
- 29:08monetary policy. And so the Federal
- 29:10Reserve said, well, our function is
- 29:12going to be uh to support the private
- 29:16banking sector, not the US Treasury. The
- 29:19US Treasury all the way right right up
- 29:22to the 20th century insisted that all of
- 29:25the its major revenues, tariff revenues,
- 29:28all be paid in bullion, in silver and
- 29:31gold coinage, not in paper currency at
- 29:34all. And so the whole idea of the
- 29:36Federal Reserve was to enable the
- 29:38private banking system to create paper
- 29:41currency. That was the fight ever since
- 29:45uh President Andrew Jackson fought
- 29:47against Henry Clay in the 1890s where
- 29:50Henry Clay wanted the American system to
- 29:52include a banking system to fund
- 29:54industry. Well, it took a the Federal
- 29:57Reserve creation and a whole response to
- 30:00an American crisis to uh essentially
- 30:03bring uh create a kind of industrial
- 30:07capitalism that led to to a strong
- 30:11enough banking sector that the banks
- 30:13took control of where uh credit would be
- 30:17created and who it was going to create
- 30:20for the banking sector here and the same
- 30:23thing happened in Europe integrated ated
- 30:25with the real estate sector and the
- 30:27monopoly sectors to fight against
- 30:30classical economics. Uh if you look at
- 30:32the history of economic thought, the
- 30:34whole fight in the early 20th century
- 30:36was well there it's a fight against
- 30:39classical political economy. There's no
- 30:41such thing as economic rent. Don't tax
- 30:43the land is what Britain tried to do for
- 30:47a century. You know, don't t uh you know
- 30:49don't tax economic rent. Everybody's
- 30:52productive. banks do contribute to the
- 30:55process. And if you look at as we've
- 30:57said before in the gross national income
- 31:00accounts and GDP accounts, uh bank uh
- 31:04interest is uh counted as a a product.
- 31:07Rent is a product, interest is a
- 31:09product, bank penalty fees are a
- 31:12product. There's the the whole if you
- 31:14look at what's the component of Western
- 31:17Europe's and America's GDP, it's largely
- 31:20rent extraction. It's largely land rent
- 31:24and uh monopoly rent, natural resource
- 31:27rent and uh financial uh interest and
- 31:30returns. Well, that's why uh in China
- 31:35they create money and credit creation
- 31:38focusing on loans to produ economies,
- 31:44productive companies that are actually
- 31:46producing something. They've overmade
- 31:48loans to real estate and to building to
- 31:52construction industry as we've seen. But
- 31:54they've also made sure that there's been
- 31:57credit available for long-term uh
- 32:01research and development and investment
- 32:03that takes a long time to build up and
- 32:06the whole Chinese policy that's enabled
- 32:09us to accumulate enough international
- 32:12reserves to have a critical mass so that
- 32:15it doesn't have to depend on America's
- 32:19plans and uh finan foreign financial
- 32:23control. it can afford to be
- 32:25self-supporting and actually provide
- 32:28built and road uh investment and loans
- 32:30to its uh Asian neighbors so that it can
- 32:33expand its economy with other countries.
- 32:37Well, that's the expansion of a kind of
- 32:40you could say it's just what industrial
- 32:43capitalism is trying to do and you can
- 32:45call it socialism, but in the late 19th
- 32:48century even the industrial capitalists
- 32:50called it socialism before socialism
- 32:53became a bad word. Uh and uh essentially
- 32:56that's what uh Europe has to do. It has
- 32:58to pick up the tradition that it had
- 33:00that still ma made its social democracy
- 33:05so productive in the early decade after
- 33:08World War II. Uh and essentially it can
- 33:13it can go back to its origins. Uh but
- 33:16for that it needs an analysis of well
- 33:20what is our GDP analysis going to look
- 33:23at? What are we going to emphasize? Are
- 33:25we going to emphasize the production and
- 33:28consumption sector? Or are we going to
- 33:30emphasize the property owning real
- 33:33estate sector and its financing and uh
- 33:36essentially create credit to buy
- 33:39property, real estate and corporations
- 33:42and stocks and bonds already in
- 33:44existence or already existed that we're
- 33:47just creating credit to bid up the price
- 33:49and in and inflate asset prices. And
- 33:52that's how we create wealth in the west.
- 33:55And uh is uh the kind of wealth we want
- 33:58to create rising stock and bond prices
- 34:01or is it wealth in the form of
- 34:03productive capacity, productivity,
- 34:05employment, rising living standards and
- 34:09uh doing what you're seeing the leading
- 34:11Asian countries do? What's the choice
- 34:14going to be?
- 34:16>> Yeah, that's a good question. And well,
- 34:19I think the if there's no uh change
- 34:22being made, I think change will be
- 34:24forced upon many of these countries. Uh
- 34:26but we we do see some uh uh some uh
- 34:31shakeup now in in in the financial
- 34:33system. I maybe it's a bit of a detour
- 34:36here but uh since you mentioned the uh
- 34:40the te the the technology industry. I
- 34:43was wondering how do you see now this
- 34:45whole financial crisis going on that
- 34:47with Nvidia and you know because this is
- 34:50linked directly to the tech industry. I
- 34:52mean do you do you have a view on this
- 34:55whole drama playing out now with
- 34:58the Jensen Hang and uh all of these
- 35:01issues?
- 35:03Well, the financial crisis in the tech
- 35:05industry is purely financial. uh so so
- 35:08far uh and uh the from what I understand
- 35:12the press reports uh the
- 35:16Hong's uh the the Chinese company that
- 35:20was buying Nvidia chips uh was buying it
- 35:23actually to create uh data centers with
- 35:26Nvidia chips that uh were open for other
- 35:30countries uh to use uh uh including
- 35:34Chinese country companies as well as
- 35:36other countries. It's the same kind of
- 35:38data centers that the Arab republics in
- 35:41Saudi Arabia and Bahrain have been
- 35:43trying to do. This is uh all very legal.
- 35:45And there was there's already an
- 35:47argument that I've been reading for the
- 35:49last year or two where uh the uh Nvidia
- 35:52head hang I want the Chinese market
- 35:56because that's 20% of our profits if you
- 36:00look direct and indirectly you know
- 36:02who's uh buying our our chips and we
- 36:05need those profits in order to keep
- 36:08devel financing our research and
- 36:10development and our innovation. uh and
- 36:13uh we're using our profits to actually
- 36:16expand our operations. So uh that that
- 36:20was his argument and he persuaded the uh
- 36:24commerce department under Ludnneck uh
- 36:26and persuaded Trump that all of that was
- 36:29in the interest that actually it made
- 36:32Nvidia stronger and China for itself was
- 36:36trying to block these imports. that told
- 36:39its uh Chinese uh Chinese companies,
- 36:42don't buy the Nvidia chips. Uh we want
- 36:45uh even though the Chinese chips are
- 36:48slower, we're never going to be able to
- 36:50catch up and surpass the United States
- 36:53unless we develop our own technology to
- 36:55do it. And uh we Chinese companies like
- 36:58Huawei uh need to uh make enough profit
- 37:02so that they can afford the research and
- 37:04development uh to help uh catch up. and
- 37:07not to mention all of the engineering
- 37:09schools in China that we support. And
- 37:12remember, most of the of of China's uh
- 37:16central committee of the Communist Party
- 37:18have a STEM background, science and
- 37:21technology uh background. So that that's
- 37:24their their whole focal point on this.
- 37:27And there apparently are half a million
- 37:29Nvidia chips that are being uh uh held
- 37:33in Hong Kong that have not yet got
- 37:36permission from China to import for use
- 37:40by domestic Chinese firms. So it's just
- 37:43silly to say that uh the uh to try to
- 37:47frame uh Nvidia as a part of being
- 37:51subject to Chinese spies. Uh it's it's
- 37:54exactly the opposite. It's apparently
- 37:57Secretary of State Rubio that is the
- 38:00China hater and said no matter what you
- 38:02know we want to cut China off the
- 38:04Americans believe that imposing
- 38:06sanctions is going to do to China what
- 38:09never has happened before. Usually when
- 38:12you impose sanctions on a country the
- 38:14country becomes independent of them. It
- 38:17says okay if we can't buy from you we'll
- 38:19just have to develop it ourselves. And
- 38:21that was Huawei's argument saying uh if
- 38:24you sanction if you don't let Huawei I'm
- 38:27sorry that was Nvidia's argument. If you
- 38:29don't let Nvidia sell our chips to China
- 38:32then uh they'll become independent and
- 38:35uh they won't need uh to buy their chips
- 38:38in my American company anymore. Uh and
- 38:43uh the the the whole mentality of the
- 38:46Americans is somehow if you can cut
- 38:49other countries off from uh using
- 38:52contact with you, they'll just fall
- 38:54apart. They have no ability to respond
- 38:57by being independent. Well, look at all
- 38:59all of the sanctions on Russia have
- 39:01backfired. As we've discussed, Russia's
- 39:04replaced uh sanctioned uh sectors like
- 39:08agriculture,
- 39:09food produ uh food and clothing
- 39:12production that they've built their own
- 39:14independent companies and they now are
- 39:17independent of the west. So the US
- 39:19sanctions are driving other countries to
- 39:22become independent uh of all of this.
- 39:25And so all of this is backfiring. Well,
- 39:28it's now turned out that uh uh what H
- 39:31Wong was doing was not only this uh
- 39:34industrial capitalist policy, but also
- 39:37financial engineering, even more serious
- 39:40than uh the industrial engineering. He
- 39:43wanted to show how fast Nvidia's profits
- 39:48were growing. and the way they were
- 39:50growing. He was telling com companies uh
- 39:53you know we know you're going uh you're
- 39:55going to have to expand all of your uh
- 39:57the money that you've been raising is to
- 40:01create new data centers and you're need
- 40:03uh so that you'll be able to process
- 40:07even more information technology to sell
- 40:11to your uh uh clients and develop more
- 40:14artificial intelligence. Uh, well,
- 40:16you're going to have to buy uh more
- 40:18chips and uh here's, you know, we know
- 40:21that here's the order that you were
- 40:22going to invest this year, but it's
- 40:24going to take you five years to build
- 40:26these data centers. Uh, if you want uh
- 40:29if you want us to sell to you, there's
- 40:31going to be a limited capacity. If you
- 40:33want us to put you on the preferred list
- 40:36of customers to buy our Nvidia chips,
- 40:39you have to buy a year in advance, you
- 40:42know, stockpile. We want you to build up
- 40:44the stockpiles of us. So you had their
- 40:47major customers buying not only the
- 40:49Nvidia chips this year, but what they
- 40:52needed for next year and maybe the next
- 40:54year after. And all of these plans were
- 40:57on the assumption that data centers were
- 40:59going to be built throughout the United
- 41:01States. And that was before all of the
- 41:04response and the protests against local
- 41:07com communities here arose against well
- 41:10wait a minute if these data centers are
- 41:13built up in our areas number one they're
- 41:16all going to be run by electricity and
- 41:18that's going to push up our electricity
- 41:20prices and uh we're going to suffer.
- 41:22That's called an external economy. Uh,
- 41:26and they're going to have to be cooled
- 41:28because electricity for running the
- 41:30Nvidia chips is going to heat cause a
- 41:33lot of heat and they're going to need
- 41:34water for that. But in a lot of water
- 41:37with the global warming and the extreme
- 41:39weather, a lot of America's western
- 41:41states are now suffering drought. Water
- 41:44levels are falling. There's a crisis on
- 41:47that. So almost all of the referendums
- 41:51that were put up for local voting in the
- 41:54elections that happened a few weeks ago
- 41:56uh were against
- 41:59data centers being built. That's become
- 42:02a political fight in the United States.
- 42:05Uh so what are all these companies that
- 42:08have pre-bought Nvidia chips for data
- 42:12centers that now have a problem being
- 42:15built? Well, uh, you're having, uh, for
- 42:18a while you had the Arab Republics and
- 42:21Saudi Arabia said, "We'll build data
- 42:23data centers here. We'll supply you with
- 42:27uh, with the energy uh, that you
- 42:29needed." Well, a lot of these have been
- 42:31bombed by Iran as part of the response
- 42:34to the Iran war and they're knocked out.
- 42:37Where will these data centers be built?
- 42:39And what are these companies going to do
- 42:41with the chips? Well, if they've already
- 42:43been pre- buying the Nvidia chips that
- 42:47they need for the next few years, all
- 42:49they're going to say, "Well, we have
- 42:50enough for what we need for a few years.
- 42:53We're not going to buy any more chips
- 42:54this year or next year until let's bring
- 42:57back uh just in time accounting
- 43:00practices here. Nvidia earnings are
- 43:02going to go way down." Well, you can
- 43:04imagine that a lot of this is going to
- 43:06be blamed on well uh
- 43:09Mr. Hong is not in charge of Nvidia
- 43:12anymore. s all that that this is going
- 43:14to cause a whole uh silloff of not only
- 43:20Nvidia chips but the whole AI bubble is
- 43:24going to be bursting and the bubble the
- 43:27the AI industry the magnificent seven
- 43:30companies that's what was holding up the
- 43:32stock market basically the lion's share
- 43:35of the gains of the entire American
- 43:38stock markets were all based on the
- 43:42planned expansion of AI that was all
- 43:45centered on Nvidia chips and all of that
- 43:49is coming down right now. Uh so I I
- 43:53think that's the fin the crisis that you
- 43:56were referring to.
- 43:59No,
- 43:59>> I just find it interesting is like a
- 44:01perfect storm. You have the you have
- 44:03financial crisis, you have the AI well
- 44:06that's also financial crisis as you said
- 44:08in the AI sector and kind of other
- 44:10countries are pulling back. All of these
- 44:12things are happening at the same time. I
- 44:14just feel like the learning curve as
- 44:15well among the political class is quite
- 44:18astonishing. I mean this as you
- 44:20suggested they they still behave as if
- 44:22it's the 1990s that is if if you
- 44:24sanctions or e economic coion that they
- 44:27won't have anywhere else to go. they
- 44:29will essentially either collapse or have
- 44:31to accept anything demanded by
- 44:35Washington. But uh but you know with
- 44:37many centers of power, the multipolar
- 44:39world we're currently living living in
- 44:41already here. I mean what we often see
- 44:44is all these sanctions all they do is
- 44:46isolate themsel. They're handing over
- 44:49this massive market share essentially
- 44:52cutting themselves off. And as you
- 44:54suggested with China, you have this,
- 44:57you know, the they're cutting themselves
- 44:59off from the Chinese chip market and
- 45:01this was a huge part of the market they
- 45:04were selling to. And you know, this
- 45:05money could have been used for research
- 45:07and development. Suddenly, you know,
- 45:09where's this money going to come from?
- 45:10And as you suggested already, the
- 45:12Europeans, they do the same. They cut
- 45:15themselves off from all this cheap
- 45:17energy from Russia. And what's going to
- 45:20happen to their energy intensive
- 45:22industries across Europe? Well, they're
- 45:23not competitive. And making matters
- 45:25worse, we see the Russians now
- 45:27redirecting that huge flow of energy
- 45:30eastwards to Asia. So suddenly they are
- 45:33flooded with uh with cheap energy and
- 45:36now their industries especially the
- 45:38energy intensive industries will now
- 45:40become much more competitive visa v the
- 45:43European. So it's just all of this was
- 45:45very predictable. I mean I remember
- 45:47warning about it almost 5 years ago when
- 45:50all this nonsense began and I remember
- 45:53being told ah no the Russians will fall
- 45:55apart in a week and uh you know
- 45:58essentially all the talk or organized
- 46:00around the idea that we're still living
- 46:02in the 90s and it was the same with the
- 46:05the the cutting off China. The idea that
- 46:08well all their tech giants would then
- 46:10begin to fall if they don't have access
- 46:12to American chips. the whole idea that
- 46:14the world is learning to live without
- 46:17the west I mean without the technologies
- 46:19industries the financial industry I mean
- 46:22it's uh yeah I wish there would have
- 46:24been a bit steeper learning curve here
- 46:26because uh you know any reform is going
- 46:29to become much more difficult now um and
- 46:33uh my great fear is in the absence of
- 46:35economic competitiveness that is uh when
- 46:38economic growth slows down the struggle
- 46:41shifts you know from creating wealth to
- 46:42capture ing wells and the rhetoric we
- 46:45now see from you know look we took their
- 46:48oil uh to you know to the victor belongs
- 46:52to the spoil like this kind of talk is
- 46:55very concerning uh anyways do you have
- 46:58any final thoughts
- 47:01well
- 47:02the situation's complicated by the whole
- 47:05war uh to get back to what we were
- 47:07talking originally about uh the war with
- 47:10Russia that uh is has locked the
- 47:15European the European Union into this
- 47:18partnership a very subordinate
- 47:21partnership uh with the United States
- 47:23and you have a problem US political
- 47:26meddling in uh has sort of ended the
- 47:29socialist parties uh in Europe uh the
- 47:32meddling has occurred since World War II
- 47:35uh and the other parties uh that used to
- 47:37be progressive so it looks like only the
- 47:40right-wing nationalist and populist
- 47:42parties uh are uh about to be an
- 47:46alternative, but their plans really
- 47:49don't include what we've talked about,
- 47:51an industrial plan because they're
- 47:53right-wing parties uh and all of this.
- 47:56So, the uh the euro itself is part of
- 48:00the problem for Europe. uh it it it
- 48:02limits the ability of uh national
- 48:06countries to run budget deficits and to
- 48:09engage in the Keynesian policy. Right
- 48:12now when the domestic European countries
- 48:15need government spending into the
- 48:17economy to subsidize this the coming
- 48:21rise in oil and gas prices, they're not
- 48:23going to be able to do it. Not only
- 48:25because they're limited as to how big a
- 48:27budget they can rise, but they're
- 48:29limited by the uh switch the uh shift of
- 48:33government spending to military buildup
- 48:35to give to Ukraine to fight Russia. Uh
- 48:40all to serve the US demands to break up
- 48:44Russia and isolate China so that the US
- 48:48can remain in control of the economy
- 48:50including Europe itself. So you could
- 48:52say that Europe by not becoming
- 48:55independent, by not fighting back is
- 48:58part of its own drive for
- 49:00self-destruction, but it doesn't have a
- 49:03program, a policy to fight back except
- 49:06for the right-wing policies because its
- 49:07left has been uh sort of destroyed. And
- 49:10uh it's not going to look uh for China
- 49:13as uh an example of British and American
- 49:17industrial capitalist policy uh being
- 49:20enacted in a successful way. So it
- 49:23doesn't really have an objective. It
- 49:25doesn't have a model. It's sort of
- 49:26floating right now. uh it's it's lost
- 49:33>> you know I well this is a concern that
- 49:35is I don't see any cohesive
- 49:39ideas or or visions about where Europe
- 49:42is headed I mean at least for the United
- 49:44States I I would have chosen a different
- 49:47path than uh extracting wealth from all
- 49:50the allies and uh you know seeking this
- 49:54dawn doctrine and you know all of this I
- 49:57would may have done a different uh
- 49:58something different but at least you see
- 50:00there's some plan for how to adjust to
- 50:03the new place in the world but for the
- 50:06Europeans there's no vision there's no
- 50:08talk there's nothing it's just uh we
- 50:11have to defeat Russia and uh you know
- 50:13some emotional slogan airing and u no
- 50:18it's there's nothing there and this is a
- 50:20massive crisis of civilization as you
- 50:23said this is u this is what kind of
- 50:26economic model will they have what's a
- 50:28kind of social model? I mean do you have
- 50:31leaders now saying oh we have to give up
- 50:33the welfare state to build a warfare
- 50:36state and no real descent no one can
- 50:40descent because we're also walking away
- 50:42from a lot of our political um freedoms
- 50:46as well and uh what's the geopolitical
- 50:48model now that the US is leaving? Oh,
- 50:50it's wishful thinking. It's uh let's
- 50:53subordinate oursel a little bit and
- 50:55weaken oursel a little bit and uh
- 50:58instead of the US seeing less value in
- 51:00Europe somehow they're going to reward
- 51:03Europe instead. I mean this is all
- 51:05wishful thinking and distractions and
- 51:08just yeah hoping that everything can be
- 51:11turned around in one big glorious war.
- 51:14It's uh yeah kind of depressing.
- 51:17>> Well, it's a mental model as much. the
- 51:19the Europeans that I talked to, they
- 51:21really keep telling me, "Well, we need
- 51:22the United States. We can't go it
- 51:24alone." And all this is reflected in how
- 51:27Vanderlayan
- 51:30surrendered to all of Trump's tariff
- 51:32demands to say, "Well, we'll roll
- 51:35tariffs on Europe back to 15%, but
- 51:39you're going to have to uh shift a lot
- 51:41of your investment to the United States.
- 51:43instead of investing to employ your own
- 51:45labor, you're going to have to invest
- 51:47here in America to employ American
- 51:49labor. And Vona agreed to all that. And
- 51:52uh how can how can that be? How can
- 51:55Europeans say, "Well, we don't have a
- 51:57choice. Uh we need uh American support
- 52:00because they're protecting us from the
- 52:02Russian army that would invade
- 52:04presumably with elephants like Hannibal
- 52:07uh invaded Russia." Some kind of fantasy
- 52:10uh that they have. So Europe's living in
- 52:12this fantasy of dependency. Uh it's
- 52:15almost as if it's been traumatized by
- 52:17its p past history and feels guilty of
- 52:20it all. So despite feeling guilty and
- 52:23traumatized by its fact past history,
- 52:26it's supporting the same kind of Nazism
- 52:29in Ukraine that killed it in World War
- 52:32II. That's what's so bizarre about all
- 52:34of this.
- 52:37>> Michael, thank you so much for taking
- 52:39the time as always.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Michael Hudson: Nvidia, the AI Bubble & the Financial Crisis by Glenn Diesen, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,764 words across 1,134 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.