YouTube2Text

Michael Howell: FED Rate Hikes Will Trigger The Biggest Bull Run Ever — Transcript

by New Era Finance Podcast · 10,476 words · 1,479 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00that central banks come in and support
  2. 0:01the system. They simply have to
  3. 0:03otherwise the system would fail. I mean
  4. 0:04the whole economy will collapse. They
  5. 0:06start printing money furiously and what
  6. 0:09happens is that monetary inflation
  7. 0:11hedges [music] go up. The price of gold,
  8. 0:14silver, bitcoin, all these assets tend
  9. 0:17to skyrocket in size. So in other words,
  10. 0:19for every 10% increase in global
  11. 0:22liquidity, you get something like a a
  12. 0:24doubling of the Bitcoin price. You don't
  13. 0:26need very much in a portfolio to give
  14. 0:28yourself very good protection. How many
  15. 0:30people have got anywhere near 3 or 4% or
  16. 0:33whatever it may be in Bitcoin? Very few.
  17. 0:36All you need to do is to have a few% of
  18. 0:38your portfolio in
  19. 0:42Quick One before we continue. If you're
  20. 0:45not subscribed yet, can you please check
  21. 0:47beneath if you clicked that subscribe
  22. 0:49button? It helps us enormally grow this
  23. 0:51channel. Thank you very much, Michael.
  24. 0:54It's great having you back here at New
  25. 0:57Era Finance and I want to dive into the
  26. 0:59topics immediately because there's so
  27. 1:02much to discuss and one of the quotes
  28. 1:04that I've heard from you in a different
  29. 1:06show was the west is bust and the world
  30. 1:09is changed.
  31. 1:11So my broad question at first is why is
  32. 1:14the west bust and what has happened that
  33. 1:17the world is changed?
  34. 1:20Well, I think the um the first thing to
  35. 1:22say is the west is bust if we focus on
  36. 1:24that first. Uh it's just basically
  37. 1:27saying that um there's a huge debt
  38. 1:29overhang um that is saddling economic
  39. 1:32growth or economic performance and that
  40. 1:34debt burden is likely to get worse not
  41. 1:36not better. And the reality is that
  42. 1:39we're living in a world of both aging
  43. 1:41demographics and what I've described
  44. 1:43before as capital wars. and those
  45. 1:46capital wars for example between the US
  46. 1:48and China uh for the dominance of um of
  47. 1:52um the dollar or the yuan system uh in
  48. 1:55the long term that is likely to morph
  49. 1:57into maybe military conflict at some
  50. 2:00stage and I think if you start to uh
  51. 2:02think about that particular avenue uh it
  52. 2:05tells you that austerity policies uh by
  53. 2:08governments are just not going to happen
  54. 2:10uh I mean it would be uh it would be a
  55. 2:11great tactical mistake uh for
  56. 2:13governments to basically cut cut back on
  57. 2:15spending at this time. So you're
  58. 2:17actually looking at a US economy for
  59. 2:19example that's running on uh with a
  60. 2:21fiscal deficit of 6% of GDP year after
  61. 2:24year uh accumulating debt and um that is
  62. 2:29likely to grow exponentially but it's
  63. 2:31not just a US phenomenon because we know
  64. 2:33that Europe is being coralled into more
  65. 2:35defense spending uh as well and um China
  66. 2:39is likely to keep pace. So the world is
  67. 2:41moving into a very different uh uh you
  68. 2:43know a very different uh shape. Um so
  69. 2:46that's number one. That's why the world
  70. 2:48is bust. But you know technically it's
  71. 2:50not bust because governments can always
  72. 2:51pay their bills. Uh I mean that's the
  73. 2:53reality of it. Uh the question is at
  74. 2:55what price and what detrimental effect
  75. 2:58does it have on the private sector and
  76. 3:00that's things we need to consider. And
  77. 3:02then the other point about the world
  78. 3:03changing which is partly to do with this
  79. 3:05but it's the fact that if you think
  80. 3:07about financial markets uh as a result
  81. 3:09of all this debt they are no longer new
  82. 3:12capital raising mechanisms uh for the
  83. 3:14private sector they're basically debt
  84. 3:16refinancing uh engines. Uh debt has to
  85. 3:19be rolled over uh you know an average
  86. 3:22period of about 5 years you take out a
  87. 3:24debt but you've got to effectively
  88. 3:26refinance it. And so the bulk of
  89. 3:28transactions in financial markets now
  90. 3:30are all about refinancing. And in a
  91. 3:32refinancing world, often the you know
  92. 3:36things look to topsyturvy. The polarity
  93. 3:38of the system changes.
  94. 3:40>> So if we talk about debt, um how big of
  95. 3:44an issue is it currently?
  96. 3:48>> Well, it's an it's an issue because I
  97. 3:50mean we just got to look around and
  98. 3:51we've got we see that uh bond yields are
  99. 3:53rising uh all around the world. I mean
  100. 3:56with probably one exception being China
  101. 3:58where yields are depressed because of
  102. 4:00the state of the Chinese economy. Uh but
  103. 4:02in the west and in Japan uh you're
  104. 4:05looking at rising uh rising yields. Now
  105. 4:07I think it would be wrong and misguided
  106. 4:10to say that this is all because of
  107. 4:12excessive government spending. I mean
  108. 4:14that's what the media like to say but
  109. 4:16that's not quite true. Uh the reason
  110. 4:18that you've got rising bond yields is
  111. 4:20that bond bond markets are readjusting
  112. 4:23to a different uh economic backdrop uh
  113. 4:26and one which is probably uh you know
  114. 4:28going back to a precoid situation where
  115. 4:32the underlying growth of the world
  116. 4:34economy is significantly higher in
  117. 4:36nominal terms than it has been for much
  118. 4:38of the last uh 10 years. uh so for
  119. 4:41example if you look at the US economy
  120. 4:43the US economy is growing in nominal
  121. 4:45terms I stress that with inflation and
  122. 4:47real growth at something like 7 to 8% uh
  123. 4:50you know peranom as a sort of trend
  124. 4:52growth rate and that is a rate that we
  125. 4:55haven't seen since the mid1 1980s now in
  126. 4:58the mid1 1980s bond markets were
  127. 5:00yielding about 8% and uh you would
  128. 5:03expect um that yields tend to move uh
  129. 5:06pretty closely with NGDP nominal GDP
  130. 5:09growth So if you look around the world,
  131. 5:11this is really what's happening. This is
  132. 5:13why bond markets are adjusting and
  133. 5:14they're adjust adjusting at a faster
  134. 5:17rate than the policy environment is.
  135. 5:20>> The first thing that comes up to my mind
  136. 5:21when you talk about the fact that the
  137. 5:23rates have been like 8 9% back in 1980 I
  138. 5:26think even they peaked at like 14% is
  139. 5:28that with the current amount of depth
  140. 5:30that there is in the system this cannot
  141. 5:33continue
  142. 5:35like at some point it's going to crack.
  143. 5:38Well, I I think the cynic in me says
  144. 5:40that maybe it does continue because
  145. 5:42governments can always finance
  146. 5:44themselves. They just basically find
  147. 5:45different avenues. U you know, if you
  148. 5:47look at how much debt has increased
  149. 5:49since year 2000. Uh I mean, in the in
  150. 5:52the American economy, public public debt
  151. 5:54is probably something like uh what 12
  152. 5:57times bigger than it was in uh uh in
  153. 5:59year 2000. I mean, that's a phenomenal
  154. 6:01increase. And including we've had a lot
  155. 6:03has gone on since then. uh we've had the
  156. 6:06GFC and we've had COVID etc. uh but then
  157. 6:09you've had a proflegate state and uh
  158. 6:11effectively you know we're still waking
  159. 6:13up every morning and we're still going
  160. 6:15to work and well a lot of us are and
  161. 6:16we're still looking at financial markets
  162. 6:18which seem uh broadly stable at least
  163. 6:20for now. So you can kick the can down
  164. 6:23the road here. The question is what cost
  165. 6:25does it does it imply? And the cost is
  166. 6:28that you're basically creating uh
  167. 6:30long-term monetary inflation.
  168. 6:32[clears throat] And that's the thing to
  169. 6:33thing to think about. Uh you know, we've
  170. 6:35argued that, you know, it's slightly
  171. 6:37misguided to talk about financial
  172. 6:38repression. That's not really the the
  173. 6:41full story. The full story is you're
  174. 6:43getting monetary inflation. And that's
  175. 6:45why gold and crypto are basically going
  176. 6:47up because [clears throat] they tend to
  177. 6:48be extremely good monetary inflation
  178. 6:50hedges. Um and you know the reality is
  179. 6:54and you know let's sort of put it in
  180. 6:56slightly wonkish terms but the reason
  181. 6:58that um you're getting this phenomena is
  182. 7:00that governments are increasingly
  183. 7:02funding at the short end of the market.
  184. 7:04Um so in other words rather than issuing
  185. 7:06a bond a longdated bond uh which may
  186. 7:09have a maturity of 10 years what
  187. 7:12governments are increasingly doing now
  188. 7:14led by the US but clearly copied by many
  189. 7:16others now is they're issuing three
  190. 7:18month or six month treasury bills and
  191. 7:20those treasury bills are like printing
  192. 7:22money um and basically that's what's
  193. 7:25going on and that percentage of debt
  194. 7:27issuance which is currently about a
  195. 7:29quarter of total debt issuance is now in
  196. 7:32in this short-term these short-term
  197. 7:34instruments it's going to grow to
  198. 7:35probably a third uh in the in the
  199. 7:37foreseeable future. So, this is the
  200. 7:39trend that we're on and it means more
  201. 7:41monetary inflation. Now, monetary
  202. 7:43inflation uh which let's let's be clear
  203. 7:47about this. Monetary inflation uh
  204. 7:49destroys your wealth. [snorts] High
  205. 7:51street or main street inflation destroys
  206. 7:53your real incomes. Okay? Uh but this is
  207. 7:56a uh you know this is a a nasty uh
  208. 7:59process monetary inflation because it
  209. 8:01basically makes pe it makes people
  210. 8:03poorer in the long term. Their assets
  211. 8:05basically if their their assets don't
  212. 8:07keep up um they basically lose wealth
  213. 8:10and the assets that will keep up are the
  214. 8:13dedicated monetary inflation hedges uh
  215. 8:15like cryptocurrencies or gold. Now I can
  216. 8:18show you that or maybe evidence um that
  217. 8:21that process and if I uh maybe just
  218. 8:24swing along to uh some of these charts.
  219. 8:27This one this one is the one to think
  220. 8:29about. What this chart is basically
  221. 8:31illustrating is the sensitivity of
  222. 8:34different assets to global liquidity or
  223. 8:37to a global liquidity shock. And what it
  224. 8:40does is you can see by the height of the
  225. 8:42bars they rank the sensitivity. And what
  226. 8:46you can see on the left hand side are
  227. 8:48some of the most sensitive assets to a
  228. 8:51global liquidity shock. And then as you
  229. 8:53start to move towards the uh right hand
  230. 8:55side, you've got more traditional
  231. 8:57investments like equities or fixed
  232. 8:58income. Now fixed income tend to do very
  233. 9:01badly. Uh and you can see the two
  234. 9:03negatives are uh the yield curve and
  235. 9:0510-year US Treasury bonds. Uh they they
  236. 9:09basically uh fall in value if you get a
  237. 9:12positive liquidity shock. In other
  238. 9:13words, they're negatively correlated to
  239. 9:15global liquidity. Um, if you look on the
  240. 9:18left hand side, you'll see their
  241. 9:19Bitcoin, Ethereum, Salana, um, various
  242. 9:23combinations of those, gold, silver, uh,
  243. 9:26etc., which all have relatively high
  244. 9:28sensitivities. And the point about this
  245. 9:30analysis is what it's basically telling
  246. 9:32us uh is that in order to protect
  247. 9:35portfolios against um money printing if
  248. 9:38you like uh you've got to start skewing
  249. 9:41your portfolio more towards these
  250. 9:42dedicated monetary inflation hedges and
  251. 9:45that's really what we've been arguing
  252. 9:47for much of the last few years. Uh the
  253. 9:49world has changed. Um governments
  254. 9:51particularly in a world where
  255. 9:53geopolitics are at the forefront and
  256. 9:55aging demographics uh are sort of
  257. 9:57weighing on us. You've got to recognize
  258. 9:59that governments are going to
  259. 10:00increasingly find um you know more uh
  260. 10:04ingenious ways of funding themselves
  261. 10:06which ultimately come back to printing
  262. 10:07money. If we if we talk about monetary
  263. 10:10inflation and if you describe this
  264. 10:14entire phenomenon and the reaction and
  265. 10:16response in society brings me to the
  266. 10:19fact that it the more and more people
  267. 10:21realize that there is such a high
  268. 10:22inflation they are being forced to
  269. 10:24invest into asset classes that are
  270. 10:27outperforming the inflation but they
  271. 10:29don't have the actual experience of
  272. 10:31doing so of investing into those assets
  273. 10:34which then leads to a big bubble which
  274. 10:37at some point is going to burst. So my
  275. 10:40question then becomes is where's the
  276. 10:42risk of this entire system and where's
  277. 10:44the risk of having such a high
  278. 10:45inflation? Is it private debt?
  279. 10:49Yeah, I mean in short, yes. And I'm
  280. 10:51going to try and risk going back to
  281. 10:53another slide in the presentation and I
  282. 10:55don't know whether whether it's catching
  283. 10:57up or not. Uh but I put um u I put a
  284. 11:00slide up which is called the the debt
  285. 11:03liquidity cycle and I can describe it
  286. 11:06and what this is broadly saying is the
  287. 11:09whole nature of the financial system has
  288. 11:10changed and with it the risks that are
  289. 11:13associated with um with liquidity. Now
  290. 11:16what you've got is a world where as I
  291. 11:19outlined earlier on um debt refinancing
  292. 11:22is paramount and debt refinancing is
  293. 11:25really what capital markets are all
  294. 11:27about. Now if you pick up a textbook a
  295. 11:30finance or an economics textbook it will
  296. 11:32tell you contra-wise that actually a
  297. 11:34financial or capital market is all about
  298. 11:36raising new money for new investment
  299. 11:38spending. But there's there's not a lot
  300. 11:40of that going on right now. Um,
  301. 11:42basically financial markets are all
  302. 11:44about debt refinancing and that seems to
  303. 11:47be the the sort of the dominant feature.
  304. 11:49We would reckon that about 80% of all
  305. 11:51primary transactions in capital markets
  306. 11:54worldwide are now debt refinancing
  307. 11:56transactions. Now, if you're refinancing
  308. 11:58debt, uh what matters is balance sheet
  309. 12:01capacity. If you're investing um for new
  310. 12:04capital raising, in other words, you
  311. 12:06want to make a uh invest in a project,
  312. 12:09the cost of capital tends to be
  313. 12:11important. So, the interest rate is is
  314. 12:13maybe a key factor. But in a world where
  315. 12:16you've got to refinance your debt, it's
  316. 12:18not the interest rate that matters. Uh
  317. 12:20because you know, you've got to survive.
  318. 12:22Therefore, what you require is the
  319. 12:24capacity of the system to lend to you.
  320. 12:27Now what this says is that therefore
  321. 12:28liquidity is key to the stability of a
  322. 12:32of the modern financial system and the
  323. 12:35paradox that's at the heart of the
  324. 12:37system is that debt needs liquidity for
  325. 12:39refinancing but equally liquidity needs
  326. 12:42good quality debt as collateral because
  327. 12:45we live in a world of collateral and
  328. 12:48ever since the GFC uh we've had we've
  329. 12:51had a situation where uh again another
  330. 12:5480% or so of total
  331. 12:56uh liquidity is collateral backed. So in
  332. 12:59other words, if you want to take out a
  333. 13:01loan uh you need some form of collateral
  334. 13:03backing. Now that may be a
  335. 13:05straightforward home mortgage or it may
  336. 13:07be uh a treasury bond or a treasury bill
  337. 13:10that a financial institution posts with
  338. 13:13a lender to borrow uh or a hedge fund
  339. 13:15may do that. So what you're seeing is a
  340. 13:18world where collateral uh and repo
  341. 13:20what's called repo are really important.
  342. 13:22Now, when do you get a problem in the
  343. 13:25system? You get a problem when liquidity
  344. 13:28and debt are mismatched. And that tells
  345. 13:30you that you get you're likely to see
  346. 13:33either an asset bubble, if there's too
  347. 13:36much liquidity, or if there's too much
  348. 13:38debt to refinance, you'll get a
  349. 13:39financial crisis. And the way to monitor
  350. 13:42that is to look at the stability of the
  351. 13:44repo and collateral markets. And the two
  352. 13:46variables or uh things that we reckon
  353. 13:50are worthwhile monitoring are what's
  354. 13:52called sofa spreads. So that's uh the
  355. 13:55system overnight funding rate in the US
  356. 13:58which is the old euro dollar rate if you
  357. 14:00like. Um and look at that relative to
  358. 14:02fed funds target rates and then look at
  359. 14:05the move index which is an index of bond
  360. 14:07volatility. And that's telling you how
  361. 14:09stable collateral markets basically are.
  362. 14:11Now, if you can um see um the slide that
  363. 14:15I'm about to put up um here, you uh
  364. 14:18hopefully you can see this, which is
  365. 14:20looking at the history of the debt
  366. 14:22liquidity ratio for the advanced
  367. 14:24economies worldwide. And what this is
  368. 14:27basically telling us is that that
  369. 14:29particular process is indicating that
  370. 14:33the cycle of of liquidity in debt uh
  371. 14:37causes a fluctuating ratio of debt to
  372. 14:41liquidity. And when you get spikes in
  373. 14:43the debt liquidity ratio, what you find
  374. 14:46um is that the system effectively fails.
  375. 14:50uh you get a refinancing crisis and
  376. 14:53basically assets sell off as there's a
  377. 14:55scramble for liquidity uh which is
  378. 14:57necessary to finance the debts and at
  379. 14:59that point the central banks come in.
  380. 15:02Now the reason that central banks come
  381. 15:04in is that the paradox that equally is
  382. 15:07associated with the system is that new
  383. 15:09credit basically rests on old debts. So
  384. 15:13you simply cannot afford to default
  385. 15:16debts in the system. uh and that's the
  386. 15:18whole nature of our monetary system and
  387. 15:21this has become even more exaggerated
  388. 15:23over the last few years. So it's
  389. 15:25absolutely paramount that central banks
  390. 15:27come in and support the system. They
  391. 15:28simply have to otherwise the system
  392. 15:30would fail. I mean the whole economy
  393. 15:32would collapse as we saw sort of briefly
  394. 15:34uh at the time of COVID or in the 2008
  395. 15:37crisis. So central banks come back with
  396. 15:39elacrity. They start printing money
  397. 15:41furiously and what happens is that
  398. 15:44monetary inflation hedges go up. So
  399. 15:46they're creating monetary inflation. The
  400. 15:49price of gold, price of silver, Bitcoin,
  401. 15:52Ethereum, all these assets tend to
  402. 15:55skyrocket in size. And the most
  403. 15:57sensitive of those according to recent
  404. 15:59history has been cryptocurrencies.
  405. 16:02>> Yes. Because probably those assets are
  406. 16:04the most riskiest ones. So if there is
  407. 16:08um more liquidity into the markets or if
  408. 16:10there is more QE into into the markets,
  409. 16:13those tend to do really well. We've seen
  410. 16:15one of those signals where a few weeks
  411. 16:18ago we've had the news coming out from
  412. 16:20Bessant where he's doubling down on um
  413. 16:24the liquidity that he wants to inject
  414. 16:26into the markets and quite suddenly
  415. 16:28Bitcoin broke out on that specific day
  416. 16:31um and is currently trading around
  417. 16:32$80,000.
  418. 16:35Is that a [clears throat] signal where
  419. 16:36you could say okay the Fed and also um
  420. 16:40the government in the US in general is
  421. 16:43likely going to inject more liquidity
  422. 16:45into the markets to keep or to to
  423. 16:48basically continue the system that we
  424. 16:50currently have.
  425. 16:52>> Yes. And I think that what I mean I
  426. 16:55think the media in in many cases misread
  427. 16:58that Bessant move. Uh I mean all he's
  428. 17:01doing is acting at the margin. I mean,
  429. 17:03this is although you could argue that
  430. 17:05he's doubling the size of buybacks,
  431. 17:07buybacks, treasury buybacks are tiny,
  432. 17:09tiny, tiny uh part of the bond markets.
  433. 17:12The reason that it's important though is
  434. 17:15that what he's trying to do is not
  435. 17:17necessarily to influence yields. What
  436. 17:20he's trying to influence is volatility
  437. 17:22in the market. And what he wants to do
  438. 17:24is to create an orderly bond market. And
  439. 17:26that's what uh policy makers are really
  440. 17:30uh in the game for. Now the associated
  441. 17:32point which is is important to
  442. 17:34understand in this context is that at
  443. 17:37the same time or actually a couple of
  444. 17:40days before Fed chair Walsh said in the
  445. 17:44FOMC presser that one of the things that
  446. 17:46they intended to do was to keep uh bank
  447. 17:49reserves uh at uh adequate or ample
  448. 17:52levels. In other words uh banks have got
  449. 17:55enough liquidity. That's another way of
  450. 17:57saying that money markets need to be
  451. 17:59liquid. Now the reason that money
  452. 18:00markets need to be liquid is that if you
  453. 18:03if you achieve that you get stability in
  454. 18:06repo markets and all this I all this all
  455. 18:10these moves about um treasury buybacks
  456. 18:13keeping volatility in the bond market
  457. 18:15down that suppresses the move index. One
  458. 18:17of the key indicators I said to look at
  459. 18:19was the move index how stable it is.
  460. 18:22Bessence keeping a lid on that.
  461. 18:24Similarly, at the same time, Walsh is
  462. 18:26operating to basically keep the repo
  463. 18:28market stable. So, what you're doing is
  464. 18:30you're really controlling both ends
  465. 18:32here, collateral stability and repo
  466. 18:34liquidity. And that's really what
  467. 18:36they're trying to do. And I think the
  468. 18:38key signal that we got out of um or what
  469. 18:40we've had in the last few weeks uh is
  470. 18:42not really about interest rates. I
  471. 18:44interest rates don't matter at all in
  472. 18:46the modern world. Uh I mean, that's a
  473. 18:48that's a big statement. It's
  474. 18:49exaggerated, but let's let's put this
  475. 18:51into context. What really matters is the
  476. 18:53stability of the repo collateral markets
  477. 18:56because in a debt refinancing world this
  478. 18:58is really uh ensuring uh or governing
  479. 19:00the stability of the system. It may well
  480. 19:03be that they decide they want to push
  481. 19:05interest rates up. But the paradox in
  482. 19:07that is that if you think about what's
  483. 19:10going on, uh if you've got a government
  484. 19:12sector now that is facing a huge
  485. 19:15interest bill, which clearly the
  486. 19:17American economy is, what that means is
  487. 19:19they're transferring incomes uh to the
  488. 19:22private sector. They're paying the
  489. 19:23private sector to hold their debt. And
  490. 19:26because the government is a huge huge
  491. 19:28net borrower now, uh that means that's a
  492. 19:31big income transfer. So the paradox is
  493. 19:34if you increase interest rates in the
  494. 19:35US, you're actually giving the private
  495. 19:37sector more cash. Well, that's a
  496. 19:39stimulus, not not a not a contraction.
  497. 19:42And that's what we got to think about.
  498. 19:43The polarity has changed. We're in a
  499. 19:46topsyturvy world where rising interest
  500. 19:47rates don't really mean the same thing
  501. 19:49as they did before. Now, ironically, if
  502. 19:52they raise interest rates, they may give
  503. 19:55the bond markets a tad more stability,
  504. 19:58okay? because the bond markets are
  505. 19:59crying out for higher short-term rates.
  506. 20:02So, a little uh you know, a little push
  507. 20:04up uh inching you know, Fed funds up by
  508. 20:0725 bips uh may well uh satisfy the bond
  509. 20:11markets and therefore bond markets bond
  510. 20:12market yields could drop a little bit.
  511. 20:14Volatility could fall back and you know
  512. 20:17we're back to the same party. But the
  513. 20:19key point about this is is that what
  514. 20:21Bessant and Walsh have more or less said
  515. 20:23is that this is the regime that they're
  516. 20:25continuing. They want to fund the US
  517. 20:28government at the short end of the
  518. 20:29market which means maintaining liquidity
  519. 20:31in the system and my view what my view
  520. 20:33is that crypto and gold took that as a
  521. 20:36cue and that's why they took off.
  522. 20:39>> Interesting.
  523. 20:41So I think you also mentioned u when I
  524. 20:44was preparing this where you said the
  525. 20:46cycle end has been postponed and that's
  526. 20:49why you see gold and bitcoin go up um
  527. 20:51recently. But if I understand you
  528. 20:53correctly, you're also expecting these
  529. 20:55two assets to continue to do well,
  530. 20:56especially if there's going to be a
  531. 20:58world where the interest rates are going
  532. 20:59to go up and they basically need to
  533. 21:01inject even more liquidity into the
  534. 21:03system.
  535. 21:04>> No question. I mean, that that that's
  536. 21:06that's going to happen. They have no
  537. 21:08choice. I mean, you know, if you start
  538. 21:10to think about, you know, what's going
  539. 21:12on, I mean, number one is you've got
  540. 21:13aging demographics right across the
  541. 21:15West. Okay. Um clearly no politicians
  542. 21:19are standing up at the moment and say we
  543. 21:20are going to take away uh pension uh or
  544. 21:23social security benefits. I mean it will
  545. 21:25be a huge uh vote loser. So no no one
  546. 21:28has got uh the balls to do that. Uh it
  547. 21:31will be many years before that happens
  548. 21:32although it will happen at some stage
  549. 21:34clearly. Um the other thing that we've
  550. 21:36got as I indicated is we've got this
  551. 21:38capital war or geopolitical tension
  552. 21:40worldwide. Now, in a world where you've
  553. 21:42got Russia, you in a rattling saber, uh,
  554. 21:45and you've got China, uh, doing, you
  555. 21:47know, whatever China is doing, but it's
  556. 21:50a clearly a competitive threat, there is
  557. 21:52no way that governments in the west can
  558. 21:54actually turn towards austerity
  559. 21:55policies. So, they've got to keep
  560. 21:57spending, right? The tax base, the tax
  561. 21:59base has been squeezed out. Uh, so it's
  562. 22:02impossible to get any more tax juice out
  563. 22:04of uh out of out of taxpayers, and
  564. 22:07therefore, you've either got to print
  565. 22:08money or or raise debt. Well, it's a lot
  566. 22:11more difficult to issue debt comfortably
  567. 22:14in a world where interest rates are much
  568. 22:16bond yields are much higher. So, you
  569. 22:18basically turn towards money printing
  570. 22:20which is going to the front end of the
  571. 22:22market. Now, the thing is that no one is
  572. 22:24no one is going to stand up no
  573. 22:25politician and no policy maker is going
  574. 22:27to stand up and say, well, look, hey, uh
  575. 22:30we've decided we're going to print
  576. 22:31money. Okay, it doesn't work like that.
  577. 22:33Uh but they're doing it because they're
  578. 22:34issuing their funding at the short end
  579. 22:37of the market. And the point about that
  580. 22:39is that if you fund at the short end of
  581. 22:41the market, it's the banks that tend to
  582. 22:43buy that debt. And if the banks buy the
  583. 22:46debt, the bank balance sheets increase.
  584. 22:48And that is basically funding through uh
  585. 22:51money supply growth rather than taking
  586. 22:54uh uh taking funds out of existing
  587. 22:56savings. Uh and that's really the
  588. 22:58crucial point. So this is all about
  589. 23:00monetary growth. Now why has chair wash
  590. 23:02suddenly out of nowhere uh broken uh you
  591. 23:06know 20 years or 30 years of history and
  592. 23:09suddenly resurrected the monetary
  593. 23:11aggregates and saying that M2 growth or
  594. 23:14money supply should be part of a
  595. 23:15monetary policy framework. Well, of
  596. 23:17course it should be and it was foolish
  597. 23:19to actually drop it in the first place.
  598. 23:21But I think what he's giving himself is
  599. 23:23a sort of way out to say well it's not
  600. 23:26really interest rates you would be
  601. 23:27thinking about. You got to think about
  602. 23:28money supply growth. But it may well be
  603. 23:31uh one, two, three years before the
  604. 23:34monetary aggregates really start to
  605. 23:36spell trouble. And that means they're
  606. 23:38buying time. And this is all about
  607. 23:40buying time.
  608. 23:42>> Investing into the crypto markets can be
  609. 23:44quite tricky, especially if you see the
  610. 23:47chart of Ethereum. If you invested into
  611. 23:49that in 2021 and you're still holding
  612. 23:52it, you wouldn't have any return yet.
  613. 23:55However, as you can see, it has been
  614. 23:57hitting $1,000 and $5,000 multiple
  615. 24:00times. That's why we have created MN
  616. 24:04funds, which is a fund that actually
  617. 24:06trades the markets actively with multi
  618. 24:09strategies. And our goal is to
  619. 24:11outperform Bitcoin and to actually kill
  620. 24:14the volatility and to make investing in
  621. 24:16crypto safe again. Over the past year,
  622. 24:19we have outperformed Bitcoin by more
  623. 24:21than 20%. If you're interested, make
  624. 24:24sure to go to our website to get in
  625. 24:26touch with us directly.
  626. 24:28You know what's interesting is that the
  627. 24:30entire concept and context of interest
  628. 24:33rates and therefore the yield market or
  629. 24:36the bond markets, it's so different than
  630. 24:39what most people actually think it is.
  631. 24:42Like if you go into a regular FM forcy
  632. 24:44meeting where the expectations are that
  633. 24:47there will be a 25 bips rate hike or
  634. 24:49whatsoever there's a ton of fear on
  635. 24:52social media and amongst investors that
  636. 24:55expect the markets to to basically do
  637. 24:57poorly after that. But if I listen to
  638. 25:00you correctly it's actually not a bad
  639. 25:02case.
  640. 25:04>> It's not it's not a bad case at all. I
  641. 25:05mean what really matters is what happens
  642. 25:07to the repo collateral markets. So, you
  643. 25:09know, I would venture and I mean I may
  644. 25:11be wrong, but it would be my uh my
  645. 25:14assumption that if they decided that the
  646. 25:16next FOMC to raise policy rates by 25
  647. 25:19basis points, uh the long ending of the
  648. 25:21bond market would actually rally. Um
  649. 25:24now, that would be contrary to what a
  650. 25:25lot of the media are projecting, but I
  651. 25:27think that could be that's quite
  652. 25:28feasible and that would actually be
  653. 25:30clearly a good thing.
  654. 25:32It's it's uh that's so if the bond
  655. 25:35markets are going to become a little bit
  656. 25:37more stable, what's your pro projection
  657. 25:40for the coming few years ahead, what
  658. 25:41type of interest rates are we going to
  659. 25:43see?
  660. 25:45Well, the answer to the question is is
  661. 25:47actually very straightforward. Uh and
  662. 25:49that really depends on the rate of
  663. 25:50underlying economic growth. Now, if you
  664. 25:53take I mean, let's take the US economy
  665. 25:55as a benchmark. uh as I as I said you're
  666. 25:58looking at something like 7 to 8%
  667. 26:00nominal GDP growth right now clearly
  668. 26:03that is made up of two elements one is
  669. 26:05real growth um uh you know in other
  670. 26:08words underlying productivity of the
  671. 26:09economy etc and the other is inflation
  672. 26:12right um now add those two together you
  673. 26:15get NGDP growth and it's that underlying
  674. 26:17level which really determines the yields
  675. 26:19on the bond market so if you go back to
  676. 26:22the um let's say the mid 1980s uh you
  677. 26:26We're looking at um nominal growth in
  678. 26:29the economy of about 7 to 8%. There's
  679. 26:31clearly a lot more you know a lot more
  680. 26:32inflation than we're seeing now but uh
  681. 26:34that was the case and equally what we
  682. 26:37were seeing were bond yields of around
  683. 26:39that uh around that level. Now what we
  684. 26:42where we are now is we're looking at
  685. 26:44bond yields which are you know nearer 5%
  686. 26:46than 8%. uh but I think that you'll
  687. 26:49you've got to see over the next few
  688. 26:51years uh bond yields rise up to those
  689. 26:53levels assuming that NGDP growth
  690. 26:56continues there. Now if you've got a
  691. 26:58government that is spending uh spending
  692. 27:00furiously and you've got a budget
  693. 27:02deficit of 6% of GDP that is a lot of
  694. 27:05demand that the government sector is
  695. 27:06injecting into the system and as I say
  696. 27:08they're monetizing that so you've got to
  697. 27:10expect even though you may get growth
  698. 27:12you're going to get more inflationary
  699. 27:13growth coming out of that. uh which is
  700. 27:15why the bond markets are under upward
  701. 27:17pressure and you know I would fully
  702. 27:20expect yields at the 10-year uh tenor in
  703. 27:23the US to test 6% uh in the you know in
  704. 27:25the foreseeable future um and possibly
  705. 27:28go higher. One of the things that's
  706. 27:30keeping a lid on that to some extent and
  707. 27:33in fact the only tool they've got is to
  708. 27:35issue uh more debt at the front end of
  709. 27:37the market. Now, you see where I'm going
  710. 27:40with this? Because if they, in other
  711. 27:42words, what they're doing is they're
  712. 27:43they're starving long-term funds like
  713. 27:46pension funds and insurance companies
  714. 27:48who like bonds, uh, they're starving
  715. 27:50those of those type of securities, and
  716. 27:53they're issuing a lot more at the front
  717. 27:55end. Now, as I said, if you issue a lot
  718. 27:57at the front end, you're creating
  719. 27:59monetary inflation, which is storing up
  720. 28:01future problems. Uh, and you know, as a
  721. 28:04yeah, we're buying time. That's that's
  722. 28:06what's going on. But the endgame is
  723. 28:08still the same. The end game is monetary
  724. 28:10inflation.
  725. 28:12The thing is that if I listen to you and
  726. 28:14if you talk if you talk about monetary
  727. 28:16inflation like I understand it for the
  728. 28:19government's perspective but if you just
  729. 28:21have like wages are not going to follow
  730. 28:24the inflation in terms of growth on a
  731. 28:27yearly basis which means that if rates
  732. 28:29or yields are going to go to 6 7 8% the
  733. 28:33real estate markets for instance are
  734. 28:35going to suffer a lot from it I would
  735. 28:38assume so like most of the people that
  736. 28:40have a regular job or have two jobs
  737. 28:42can't really buy any property at all.
  738. 28:47>> Yeah, I think that's uh that that's
  739. 28:49true. You go back to the 1970s and you
  740. 28:54know what happened then was wages did go
  741. 28:56up uh and real estate prices did go up
  742. 28:59eventually. Uh there were better hedges.
  743. 29:02Uh we didn't obviously didn't have
  744. 29:03cryptocurrency then but the gold market
  745. 29:06was uh was good. Uh precious metals
  746. 29:08performed well. Commodity markets
  747. 29:10generally did very well. Um the era of
  748. 29:13the 1970s was all about uh soaring
  749. 29:16commodity prices rather like we've got
  750. 29:18now. Uh and broadly in a monetary
  751. 29:21inflation environment, you tend to do
  752. 29:22well out of hard assets. Now there may
  753. 29:25be differences this time uh in the sense
  754. 29:27that uh you've got uh you've got a lot
  755. 29:30of young people who can't get onto the
  756. 29:32housing ladder and I clearly you know
  757. 29:34empathize with that. that that's clearly
  758. 29:36an issue and you've got uh maybe a
  759. 29:38restructuring of the uh of the
  760. 29:40industrial and commercial real estate
  761. 29:42markets because of AI or because of
  762. 29:44technology. So there are different there
  763. 29:46there are structural issues to face but
  764. 29:48but generally the the uh the the
  765. 29:51statement is correct that hard assets
  766. 29:53should do well in an environment where
  767. 29:55you've got more monetary inflation and I
  768. 29:57think that's the case. There may be
  769. 29:58better things to look at. As I say, gold
  770. 30:00will likely go up and you've also got
  771. 30:03crypto which is um you know uh clearly
  772. 30:05an exciting area to look at. But you
  773. 30:07know this is what we're what we're
  774. 30:09looking at which is which makes this
  775. 30:11very unusual is we're looking at a world
  776. 30:13where debt uh is a problem and it's a
  777. 30:16problem for everybody. And in fact the
  778. 30:19country that has the biggest debt
  779. 30:20problem by far is China. And that's the
  780. 30:23one you got to start thinking about. And
  781. 30:26what happens if the Chinese, which they
  782. 30:28are in fact, but what happens when the
  783. 30:29Chinese start to print money? Uh what
  784. 30:32assets will the Chinese buy? Um now we
  785. 30:35didn't we we would normally say that in
  786. 30:38actual fact given the structure of the
  787. 30:39Chinese economy and the fact that they
  788. 30:41have banned crypto uh crypto trading and
  789. 30:44crypto investment that the avenue that
  790. 30:47they tend to go down for monetary
  791. 30:49inflation hedges is gold. And um
  792. 30:53hopefully if you can see this chart
  793. 30:55which I I'm going to put up now but
  794. 30:57hopefully this chart will demonstrate uh
  795. 31:00that particular process as to what's
  796. 31:02going on in Asia. And um I don't know
  797. 31:05well hopefully you can see this but what
  798. 31:07this is demonstrating is the growth of
  799. 31:12People's Bank of China that's PBOC
  800. 31:14liquidity and the price of gold bullion.
  801. 31:17Now, um, contrary to what many
  802. 31:20commentators argue that the gold market,
  803. 31:23uh, catapulted higher after the Russian
  804. 31:25invasion of Ukraine, actually the key
  805. 31:27catalyst was the People's Bank of China
  806. 31:29printing money. And the reason that
  807. 31:31they're printing money is that China has
  808. 31:34a huge debt problem. Now, spoiler alert,
  809. 31:37what has happened in every other in
  810. 31:39every other instance uh in history where
  811. 31:42there have been big debt problems, when
  812. 31:44there's been big debt burdens,
  813. 31:46essentially policy makers have printed
  814. 31:48money. And China's no different. They
  815. 31:51can't afford to default debt in the same
  816. 31:53way as the Americans can't afford to
  817. 31:54default debt. So, they've got to devalue
  818. 31:56it, and they've got to get their price
  819. 31:58level and their wage levels up. And
  820. 32:00China can probably do that against the
  821. 32:02background of strict capital controls uh
  822. 32:05and compliant banks and big forex
  823. 32:07reserves. But that's what's going on in
  824. 32:09China. And my reckoning is that's why
  825. 32:11the gold market is going up. That's the
  826. 32:13the key factor. You haven't really had
  827. 32:15the great debasement in the west yet.
  828. 32:17That's coming. Okay, that's that's cream
  829. 32:20on top, right? This is what's happening
  830. 32:22right now in China. Now, we wrote a
  831. 32:24piece in our Capital Wall Substack uh a
  832. 32:28couple of days ago which said, "Let's
  833. 32:30investigate uh the proposition that
  834. 32:32China uh has no impact on the crypto
  835. 32:36market because you've got a sealed
  836. 32:39economic and financial system that
  837. 32:41prevents people buying." That's
  838. 32:43absolutely that's plausible. Okay. uh
  839. 32:46you would think that would be the case,
  840. 32:47but we looked at the data and actually
  841. 32:50the People's Bank of China has a big
  842. 32:52impact on the crypto markets too. And
  843. 32:54that may be an indirect influence, but
  844. 32:57it's certainly there and that may be a
  845. 32:59spillover via the real economy and via
  846. 33:01the gold market into crypto, but it's
  847. 33:03having a big effect, too. So, you know,
  848. 33:05what you've got to throw in here is it's
  849. 33:07not just the US, it's not just the US
  850. 33:09and Europe, it's the US, Europe, and
  851. 33:11Asia, which are all in the same boat.
  852. 33:14And that's why you've got this monetary
  853. 33:15debasement. Uh will it continue? Yes. Uh
  854. 33:18will it cause a financial crisis? I
  855. 33:20don't know. It could do. But the problem
  856. 33:22is is that as you're seeing more and
  857. 33:24more debt, uh liquidity has got to keep
  858. 33:26pace. And it's quite likely given the
  859. 33:29fact they can't afford to default debt
  860. 33:31that liquidity is going to keep pace.
  861. 33:32And it's a bit like saying, well, okay,
  862. 33:34this is going to end. Well, I would say,
  863. 33:36well, look at, you know, let's go back
  864. 33:37to 1900 and look at the purchasing power
  865. 33:40of a dollar or or sterling pound or the
  866. 33:44equivalent of what the euro would have
  867. 33:46bought in year 1900 and look at what it
  868. 33:48would buy today. And the answer is it
  869. 33:50would buy cents uh rather than uh you
  870. 33:53know anything else. It would it would be
  871. 33:54a fraction of what it was worth u you
  872. 33:57know 130 odd years ago. But the fact is
  873. 34:00we've survived. The financial systems
  874. 34:02have had their ups and downs, but
  875. 34:03they're still intact. People are still
  876. 34:05spending money. Politicians and policy
  877. 34:07makers have kicked the can down the
  878. 34:09road. But look how much the gold market
  879. 34:11has gone up in that time. Uh look how
  880. 34:13much you know stock markets have gone
  881. 34:15up. Bond markets may well have been
  882. 34:16dreadful performance. But that's the
  883. 34:18reality.
  884. 34:20I think you mentioned before that there
  885. 34:22might be a case that we're going to have
  886. 34:24financial crisis coming out of this
  887. 34:26cycle and I wanted to ask you two
  888. 34:29questions on that in the sense that
  889. 34:31first of all
  890. 34:33how in what way is it different from the
  891. 34:35great financial crisis and second what
  892. 34:38are some signals that you might be
  893. 34:39looking at in terms of data or behavior
  894. 34:42from the policy makers that might say
  895. 34:45okay we're getting into a worse period
  896. 34:47going ahead from
  897. 34:51Well, I mean the answer is that that it
  898. 34:52could it it could occur. You you could
  899. 34:55get a financial crisis. Um and that
  900. 34:58financial crisis is you know largely
  901. 35:02could largely occur because I keep
  902. 35:05saying that balance sheet is important
  903. 35:07uh in terms of understanding the
  904. 35:09capacity of the financial system uh to
  905. 35:11roll over debt. But the problem is
  906. 35:13within the financial system it's become
  907. 35:15very complex where you have a lot of
  908. 35:17overlapping balance sheets. Okay. Uh and
  909. 35:19that's because of the rise of things
  910. 35:21like shadow banking and you know A lends
  911. 35:24to B, B lends to C, C lends to D etc.
  912. 35:27And um you know before you know it you
  913. 35:30get one failure and you get uh that
  914. 35:32gives rise to a multitude or or or 26
  915. 35:35you know alphabetic failures and so the
  916. 35:37whole thing is multiplied and that
  917. 35:38that's really the risk. Um so we don't
  918. 35:42really know the extent to which there is
  919. 35:43balance sheet overlap but we suspect
  920. 35:45it's quite large and that's why the
  921. 35:47policy makers have got to make sure that
  922. 35:49markets remain liquid uh money markets
  923. 35:51in particular so the funding is
  924. 35:52available. Now the Federal Reserve has
  925. 35:54gone out of its way to try and do this.
  926. 35:56They've got things. They've got a
  927. 35:57mechanism called the standing repo
  928. 35:59facility which facilitates additional
  929. 36:02lending if there are crises and we hope
  930. 36:05[snorts] that is a good uh crisis uh
  931. 36:09protection tool. We don't know because
  932. 36:11it hasn't really been tested and the
  933. 36:13reality is that it probably will fail in
  934. 36:16a crisis because these things always do.
  935. 36:19So, you know, the reaction of the policy
  936. 36:21makers will have to be print more money.
  937. 36:23That's the only thing they can do.
  938. 36:24They've got to keep markets liquid and
  939. 36:26if they trip up and they fall behind the
  940. 36:29requirements of the debt markets,
  941. 36:30they're going to have to catch up and
  942. 36:31print more liquidity. So this is the
  943. 36:33reality. So what you've got is a strong
  944. 36:35trend in monetary inflation, but make no
  945. 36:38mistake, there's a cycle as well. That
  946. 36:40cycle is a buying opportunity, right? Uh
  947. 36:42it's not a selling opportunity. So if
  948. 36:44you see the price of gold coming back or
  949. 36:46Bitcoin coming back, it's well worth
  950. 36:48buying it. there seems to be a lot of
  951. 36:50buying uh you know there's a flaw uh
  952. 36:52where buying comes back in quite quickly
  953. 36:54and I think we've seen that recently.
  954. 36:56>> Yeah. I mean [clears throat] I I'm
  955. 36:58looking at the markets. I've been going
  956. 37:00through a few crypto cycles before but
  957. 37:03especially when the sentiment is as
  958. 37:04awful as it has been with Bitcoin just
  959. 37:06prior to the statement that came out. Um
  960. 37:09there are a lot of people sidelines. So
  961. 37:11every little dip that we see are quickly
  962. 37:13being bought up and then price
  963. 37:16consolidates for a little bit of little
  964. 37:18bit of time and then there's another
  965. 37:20pretty strong severe move on Bitcoin
  966. 37:22going up but it never really comes back
  967. 37:24down again. So if I hear you correctly,
  968. 37:27>> the ones that are waiting for a bottom
  969. 37:29in October for the so-called fouryear
  970. 37:31cycle are probably going to be left
  971. 37:32behind.
  972. 37:34>> Yeah. I mean there's there's no there's
  973. 37:35no four-year cycle as far as we can see.
  974. 37:38I mean the cycle is different. the cycle
  975. 37:39is more like a refinancing cycle based
  976. 37:43around debt which is a five to six year
  977. 37:45cycle. Um and you know I mean in fair
  978. 37:48play I mean I I've been arguing that
  979. 37:50this year would be not a great year for
  980. 37:52Bitcoin um um simply because the
  981. 37:55liquidity cycle is losing momentum but
  982. 37:58that loss of momentum is largely because
  983. 38:00the real economies uh have been so
  984. 38:02strong they're sucking liquidity out of
  985. 38:04financial markets. Uh now one of the
  986. 38:06things again we wrote this up in our
  987. 38:08capital war substack but one of the
  988. 38:10other mechanisms of uh of liquidity
  989. 38:13creation particularly in the US is
  990. 38:15something that we've called treasury QE
  991. 38:18uh to differentiate it from Fed QE and
  992. 38:20the Treasury QE process is all about
  993. 38:23spending money in the real economy and
  994. 38:25funding that through the Treasury bill
  995. 38:28market uh which is really encouraging
  996. 38:30the banks to actually buy those bills
  997. 38:32and fund the fund the government. Now,
  998. 38:34in theory, that shouldn't have a big
  999. 38:37effect on financial assets. Okay? Um, it
  1000. 38:41will have an effect on real assets for
  1001. 38:43sure. And that really poses the
  1002. 38:45question, are are cryptocurrencies real
  1003. 38:48assets or are they financial assets? And
  1004. 38:51we've long leaned towards the idea that
  1005. 38:53they're more financial assets. But
  1006. 38:55actually interestingly and what this
  1007. 38:57piece actually looked at was how
  1008. 38:59sensitive crypto is to the Treasury QE
  1009. 39:02dimension as well as the Fed QE. And the
  1010. 39:05answer is they're very sensitive to
  1011. 39:07Treasury QE. So what you've got going on
  1012. 39:10is the Treasury spending money and
  1013. 39:12monetizing that spending and it's coming
  1014. 39:15through in higher crypto prices.
  1015. 39:18The only thing that I hear from you or
  1016. 39:20if I listen to you is that you I might
  1017. 39:23be wrong but if they the cycle expands
  1018. 39:26again so there's four five to six years
  1019. 39:28when it comes to the liquidity cycles we
  1020. 39:30are extending the current one um what I
  1021. 39:34kind of see in the markets is that the
  1022. 39:36volatility goes up by 10fold so we've
  1023. 39:39just had a big expansion on the gold
  1024. 39:41price also being pushed due to uh
  1025. 39:43liquidity that's going to be increased
  1026. 39:45in China most likely Bitcoin follows
  1027. 39:48through and every cycle it starts to
  1028. 39:50become more exponential or becomes
  1029. 39:52bigger which then also means that these
  1030. 39:56shocks are going to be more painful
  1031. 39:59after that. So my question then becomes
  1032. 40:02like how would you build a portfolio if
  1033. 40:06you are just an average investor if the
  1034. 40:08volatility is as high as it is?
  1035. 40:11Well, the I mean the answer my my answer
  1036. 40:14with that to that would be uh I mean
  1037. 40:16first of all one of the ways you control
  1038. 40:18volatility is by diversifying
  1039. 40:21and you don't put all your eggs in a
  1040. 40:23high volatile basket. Um so in other
  1041. 40:25words if you've got assets that are
  1042. 40:27highly volatile um you basically have
  1043. 40:30less of them. Now, one of the I mean
  1044. 40:32going back to my Substack and one of the
  1045. 40:34other things that we wrote several weeks
  1046. 40:35ago was to say given the sensitivity of
  1047. 40:38Bitcoin or Ethereum or crypto in general
  1048. 40:41to mon to uh to liquidity and monetary
  1049. 40:43inflation, you don't need very much in a
  1050. 40:46portfolio to give yourself very good
  1051. 40:47protection because they're so leveraged.
  1052. 40:50So you will find that looking at the
  1053. 40:52statistics and anyone can do these
  1054. 40:53calculations but if you look at the last
  1055. 40:56um uh 10 years and looking at the
  1056. 40:58performance of Bitcoin against global
  1057. 40:59liquidity you'll find that the
  1058. 41:01multiplier is about 10 times or
  1059. 41:03thereabouts. So in other words for every
  1060. 41:0510% increase in global liquidity you get
  1061. 41:08something like a a doubling of the
  1062. 41:10Bitcoin price. Now that that clearly
  1063. 41:13means that you're giving you get you've
  1064. 41:15got a lot of insurance uh protection uh
  1065. 41:17if anything goes wrong. So we said look
  1066. 41:20all you need to do is to have a few
  1067. 41:22percent of your portfolio in Bitcoin uh
  1068. 41:25or or maybe you know maybe a bit more in
  1069. 41:28gold if you want the diversification
  1070. 41:30hedge but you don't need much of it. Now
  1071. 41:32the question is how many people thinking
  1072. 41:34generally have got anywhere near um you
  1073. 41:37know 3 or 4% or whatever it may be in
  1074. 41:39Bitcoin. The answer is no. Very few.
  1075. 41:43>> Depends on which audience you're uh
  1076. 41:45you're targeting.
  1077. 41:45>> Of course. Yeah. I mean there are some
  1078. 41:47that are wedded to it and may have 100%
  1079. 41:49in Bitcoin [laughter] but the average
  1080. 41:51you know it's you know it's an inch deep
  1081. 41:54and a mile wide isn't it the average so
  1082. 41:56you know um a lot of people have
  1083. 41:59>> if I if I go to my social media audience
  1084. 42:01I think uh the percentage is a little
  1085. 42:04bit higher than that but
  1086. 42:06>> um I don't hear you talk about the
  1087. 42:07equity markets or the indices at this
  1088. 42:09point.
  1089. 42:11Well, I think the, you know, the the
  1090. 42:13issue with the indexes is is that they
  1091. 42:16look uh they they to my mind look more
  1092. 42:19vulnerable because um if you get I mean
  1093. 42:23let let me try and describe the the
  1094. 42:25process of what happens. I mean the way
  1095. 42:27that we envision how the world works is
  1096. 42:29you've got two pools of money. You've
  1097. 42:31got money in the financial markets and
  1098. 42:33you've got money in the real economy.
  1099. 42:34Okay? All money that is anywhere must be
  1100. 42:37somewhere. So if it's in the real
  1101. 42:38economy, it's not in the financial
  1102. 42:40sector and similarly vice versa. Now
  1103. 42:43bond markets get all their traction from
  1104. 42:45the financial sector. So if liquidity is
  1105. 42:48being lost in the financial sector, bond
  1106. 42:50yields will rise and that's what we're
  1107. 42:52seeing right now. If you get more money
  1108. 42:54going into the real economy, which we
  1109. 42:55have, things like commodity markets will
  1110. 42:58rise strongly. The real economy will
  1111. 43:00gain traction. That's exactly what we're
  1112. 43:02seeing. But if you think about it in
  1113. 43:03terms of in equity speak in the
  1114. 43:05financial sector the PE multiple is
  1115. 43:08formed the rating of the of the equity.
  1116. 43:11So as bond yields rise and liquidity in
  1117. 43:13the financial sector drops P multiples
  1118. 43:16contract as the real economy starts to
  1119. 43:19gain traction and economic growth speeds
  1120. 43:21up. The E the earnings tends to go up.
  1121. 43:24So if you look at the transition as the
  1122. 43:26cycle matures, initially you've got a
  1123. 43:29big kicker on the PE u and not much
  1124. 43:32earnings then you start to get earnings
  1125. 43:34picking up and then as the cycle matures
  1126. 43:36the PE multiple comes under downward
  1127. 43:38pressure and earnings keeps going until
  1128. 43:41you start to see an economic slowdown.
  1129. 43:43Now in our view what you were likely to
  1130. 43:44start seeing uh this year and we've been
  1131. 43:47wrong because we thought that Wall
  1132. 43:49Street would be largely rangebound this
  1133. 43:51year. uh our view was that rising bond
  1134. 43:53yields would basically contain the PE
  1135. 43:56multiple and you wouldn't get such a big
  1136. 43:58earnings kicker that we've had. So we've
  1137. 44:00been surprised by the E number uh and
  1138. 44:03we've been surprised as well by the fact
  1139. 44:05that PE have held up. Now, if you
  1140. 44:07extrapolate that thought, what we're
  1141. 44:09saying is, you know, this is just
  1142. 44:11really, you know, delaying things. And
  1143. 44:13what you'd expect to see is in 2027,
  1144. 44:16you'd expect to see weaker earnings
  1145. 44:18growth. Um, and you'd expect to see a P
  1146. 44:21multiple that probably contracts because
  1147. 44:23you've got still upward pressure on bond
  1148. 44:25yields. So, I wouldn't say equities, I
  1149. 44:27think, are going to be a great a great
  1150. 44:29place to be. I'm not suggesting there
  1151. 44:31will be a crash, but I think that, you
  1152. 44:33know, you're looking at underperformance
  1153. 44:35and you've had a good run out of
  1154. 44:36equities already. And so, you know, my
  1155. 44:39view, and as I say, I've been wrong this
  1156. 44:40year, but we've been saying to people
  1157. 44:42top slice and go into commodities. Uh,
  1158. 44:45that's been a good trade clearly. Uh,
  1159. 44:47but, you know, maybe people would have
  1160. 44:48hung around in equity markets longer,
  1161. 44:50but there the equities are much more
  1162. 44:52cyclical than many of these other
  1163. 44:54assets. They're risk assets. I I don't
  1164. 44:56know the exact numbers, but I think that
  1165. 44:58the fragility of the indexes right now
  1166. 45:01is that there's not much liquidity
  1167. 45:03required in order to move it upwards. I
  1168. 45:05think that the net liquidity on the
  1169. 45:06index market is relatively low at this
  1170. 45:08point.
  1171. 45:09>> Yeah, it's true. And that that's because
  1172. 45:10of a lot of passive investing.
  1173. 45:12>> Yeah, exactly. Um what's the role of AI
  1174. 45:16um in this entire context? Would that be
  1175. 45:19the reason why you see the earnings
  1176. 45:21still pick up momentum?
  1177. 45:23It
  1178. 45:23>> it's possible. Um it's I mean I I'm I'm
  1179. 45:27old enough and cynical enough to know
  1180. 45:28that um you know we we've been through
  1181. 45:30this situation before. If you go back to
  1182. 45:33uh the Y2K bubble or uh or around those
  1183. 45:36times I mean think of what happened with
  1184. 45:38fiber optic cable uh and a company
  1185. 45:40called Global Crossing uh which was then
  1186. 45:43the darling of the stock market like
  1187. 45:44sort of the Nvidia of the of the day and
  1188. 45:47uh you know people couldn't get enough
  1189. 45:49of fiber optic cable that was the the
  1190. 45:51future. Uh clearly that fiber optic
  1191. 45:53cable is still around. Uh [snorts] but
  1192. 45:55global crossing isn't. It went into
  1193. 45:57chapter 11 sort of within 5 years and
  1194. 46:00that's the nature of capitalism. Uh and
  1195. 46:03what happened was the margins on fiber
  1196. 46:05optic is collapsed. Uh and you can see
  1197. 46:08maybe the same thing happening. Uh
  1198. 46:09competition is fierce. Uh and whether
  1199. 46:12that's from other AI companies uh in
  1200. 46:15America or whether it's from the
  1201. 46:16Chinese, who knows? Uh but I think that
  1202. 46:18that's going to be a problem. So um you
  1203. 46:21know I'm a great believer in AI. Whether
  1204. 46:25I'm a great believer in specific AI
  1205. 46:27companies is a different question.
  1206. 46:29>> I think um um one of the interesting
  1207. 46:32factors here is as well that if the
  1208. 46:34interest rates are going to go up in
  1209. 46:36order to invest into those tech
  1210. 46:39companies or AI companies, it becomes
  1211. 46:41more expensive to hold the depth which
  1212. 46:44then would also push down the earnings
  1213. 46:47rate or the earnings data. And by I I
  1214. 46:50just had at doubt on the show and he
  1215. 46:52said
  1216. 46:53>> the current markets are basically
  1217. 46:54overpricing positivity and once the pri
  1218. 46:58the earnings data come in and they are a
  1219. 47:00little bit worse than expected it will
  1220. 47:02have a shock impact to the underlying
  1221. 47:04asset.
  1222. 47:05>> Yeah, I think very reasonable statement.
  1223. 47:08>> So
  1224. 47:10how much longer can those index markets
  1225. 47:12continue to go up if your expectancy is
  1226. 47:15that the interest rates are going to go
  1227. 47:16up?
  1228. 47:19Well, I don't think it's well, as I
  1229. 47:21said, I don't think it's about policy
  1230. 47:22rates or Fed funds rates. And I think
  1231. 47:24the the irony is that you may well get a
  1232. 47:27rally in the bond markets if the Fed
  1233. 47:29decides it's going to hike rates a
  1234. 47:31little bit, right? Um because the
  1235. 47:33markets will get some uh you know, some
  1236. 47:35reassurance that the Fed is at least
  1237. 47:37being disciplined here. So, uh I I
  1238. 47:40wouldn't say that's that's necessarily
  1239. 47:42concern. What the concern is is whether
  1240. 47:44the liquidity situation continues. Now
  1241. 47:47we've got a lot of um challenges to face
  1242. 47:50in terms of liquidity. One of those is
  1243. 47:53the fact that the real economies are
  1244. 47:54buoyant and clearly real economies need
  1245. 47:56liquidity as well as the financial
  1246. 47:57system and the real economies can crowd
  1247. 48:00out financial markets unless policy
  1248. 48:03makers are alert or adept at actually
  1249. 48:05putting liquidity into the system. Okay.
  1250. 48:08What you've also got to think about is
  1251. 48:10that there's a lot of debt to uh be
  1252. 48:12issued to be refinanced and more
  1253. 48:15particularly uh if you look back at the
  1254. 48:17uh at the COVID environment, there was a
  1255. 48:20lot of debt then that was refinanced uh
  1256. 48:23to the later years of this decade uh the
  1257. 48:26so-called debt maturity wall which is
  1258. 48:28coming back uh in the next few years and
  1259. 48:30that means there's another big debt um
  1260. 48:33you know surge of refinancing for the
  1261. 48:35markets to cope with. So that's going to
  1262. 48:37put quite a load uh onto uh onto the
  1263. 48:40shoulders of liquidity which is why the
  1264. 48:42central banks need to be alert here uh
  1265. 48:44or at least maintain money market
  1266. 48:46liquidity and this all comes back to the
  1267. 48:48stability of the repo collateral markets
  1268. 48:50which one hopes hold up but you know we
  1269. 48:53need to monitor
  1270. 48:55>> what it suggests that investing into or
  1271. 48:57holding bonds makes becomes interesting
  1272. 48:59again after all those years
  1273. 49:02>> investing in bonds
  1274. 49:04>> well I mean from a yield perspective
  1275. 49:06yeah I that yeah I mean I mean the I
  1276. 49:09mean bonds are investment in bonds is
  1277. 49:11really a mathematical exercise. So, you
  1278. 49:13know, what really matters is your
  1279. 49:15starting yield. And, you know, if you've
  1280. 49:18got a starting yield of 5% and you think
  1281. 49:22about um uh yields rising uh by another
  1282. 49:26um what let's say 100 basis points, make
  1283. 49:29the maths make the maths um um
  1284. 49:32straightforward. Uh and you've got a
  1285. 49:34duration of 10 years on the bond, uh
  1286. 49:37then you're going to see a capital loss
  1287. 49:39of about 10% on your holding a bond.
  1288. 49:42Now, if you've got a 5% carry, that
  1289. 49:44means you're only facing a 5% uh loss
  1290. 49:47overall on your total return. And you
  1291. 49:50get the idea of how the how the math
  1292. 49:52could work. So, in other words, if
  1293. 49:54you're only talking about uh a 50 basis
  1294. 49:56point rise in yields, then you're sort
  1295. 49:58of breaking even. So, you're absolutely
  1296. 50:00right to say that the higher the yield
  1297. 50:02base goes, the more attractive the bond
  1298. 50:04markets are. And of course, we have a
  1299. 50:06big constituency out there who have to
  1300. 50:09buy government debt. I mean that that's
  1301. 50:10the reality.
  1302. 50:12>> Um so yeah, we're we're getting to more
  1303. 50:15interesting periods. The bond markets
  1304. 50:16are functioning uh more normally now
  1305. 50:19than they were at any time in the last 5
  1306. 50:21years because the COVID nonsense. I mean
  1307. 50:24basically push yields into neg negative
  1308. 50:26territory. And I mean that was that's
  1309. 50:28just insanity. uh you know I I used to
  1310. 50:31be at Saloron Brothers and the the the
  1311. 50:33book that everyone uh was required to
  1312. 50:36read uh at Salon Brothers was a book
  1313. 50:38called the history of interest rates by
  1314. 50:40Sydney Homer which went back four
  1315. 50:42millennia I think in terms of the
  1316. 50:44history of interest rates and nowhere in
  1317. 50:46that pages is there any reference at all
  1318. 50:48to zero or even negative interest rates.
  1319. 50:51It just didn't happen. This is this is a
  1320. 50:53you know this is a new world the policy
  1321. 50:55makers bought us into and it's a mad
  1322. 50:57world because if you have negative
  1323. 50:59interest rates you clearly incentivize
  1324. 51:01people to take on more debt. That's
  1325. 51:03precisely what we don't want to do.
  1326. 51:05>> If um if we have such an enormous amount
  1327. 51:08of debt to refinance at what point it
  1328. 51:11becomes a risk for the entire financial
  1329. 51:12system?
  1330. 51:14>> Well, it's always a risk and there's no
  1331. 51:15question about that. But it but the
  1332. 51:17point is as I as I've said look the long
  1333. 51:19history of financial systems is that you
  1334. 51:22just end up kicking the can down the
  1335. 51:24road. The question is is what is the
  1336. 51:26gold price um that is sort of that
  1337. 51:30you're looking at uh behind you. And the
  1338. 51:32fact is that you know the gold market in
  1339. 51:35uh in what 19 in 1970 was $35 an ounce
  1340. 51:39and here we are now at um you know skyh
  1341. 51:42higher levels. So you've seen a pretty
  1342. 51:44decent return on gold over that period.
  1343. 51:46And if you look simply at the period
  1344. 51:47since n sorry so since year 2000 I think
  1345. 51:50I'm correct in saying that the S&P is up
  1346. 51:52six or seven times uh in that period
  1347. 51:55since year 2000 uh but the gold market
  1348. 51:57is up 12 13 times and bitcoin is some
  1349. 52:00magnitude more than that but [snorts]
  1350. 52:02anyway u but you get the idea so in
  1351. 52:05other words this is just kicking the can
  1352. 52:06down the road you may get a financial
  1353. 52:08crisis but that you know the paradox
  1354. 52:11here is that you will just spur policy
  1355. 52:13makers to print even more liquidity
  1356. 52:15because they realize that the place has
  1357. 52:16been too too slack.
  1358. 52:18>> If we um if we look ahead from now and
  1359. 52:20it's now 2026 um if we do another show
  1360. 52:24in 2030,
  1361. 52:27what would need to happen for you to say
  1362. 52:29well I clearly have been wrong about the
  1363. 52:31cycle?
  1364. 52:35Uh well, I think that uh wrong. Well, I
  1365. 52:39think if there's um [snorts] some magic
  1366. 52:42way of funding debt um that we haven't
  1367. 52:47thought of, but I I I you know, I mean,
  1368. 52:49in in in thousands of years of history,
  1369. 52:52I mean, that's that's never appeared. uh
  1370. 52:54you know it's possible the Martians land
  1371. 52:55and they they bring gold from another
  1372. 52:58planet and everyone's happy but I mean
  1373. 53:00the reality is you've basically got to
  1374. 53:02fund debt and effectively as I keep
  1375. 53:05stressing uh financial markets now debt
  1376. 53:08refinancing mechanisms and in a world of
  1377. 53:10debt refinancing it's basically all
  1378. 53:12about money printing
  1379. 53:14>> and that's that's that's it
  1380. 53:16>> there are two factors that might may be
  1381. 53:18a concern which is you don't know what
  1382. 53:20AI is going to do in the coming few
  1383. 53:21years um and I I think secondly, you
  1384. 53:24also don't know what Trump is going to
  1385. 53:26do. [snorts] But other than that, I
  1386. 53:28think markets are going to remain the
  1387. 53:30same, right?
  1388. 53:31>> Well, that's right. But I mean, what you
  1389. 53:32know, okay, what what could Trump do? I
  1390. 53:35mean, well, let's not let's not get on
  1391. 53:37that right, but let's let's say you know
  1392. 53:39what the worst situation is that
  1393. 53:41basically you get some sort of kinetic
  1394. 53:43war. Okay. Uh but then how do they
  1395. 53:46that's got to be funded so they print
  1396. 53:48money. I mean that's really been the
  1397. 53:49history of wars. uh you know your um u I
  1398. 53:53think it was was it Cicero who said that
  1399. 53:55your uh that your military capacity is
  1400. 53:57based on how much money you can create
  1401. 54:00um and that was you know true in Roman
  1402. 54:02times. So you know this is this is you
  1403. 54:04know another spur to money printing.
  1404. 54:07>> Mhm.
  1405. 54:08It's been fascinating to listen to you
  1406. 54:10again um um at Newer Finance and I
  1407. 54:13wanted to ask you the final question
  1408. 54:15which is
  1409. 54:17for my audience that tries to understand
  1410. 54:19the bond markets and tries to understand
  1411. 54:22liquidity in the markets. What would be
  1412. 54:24your key takeaway that you would give to
  1413. 54:26anyone that's listening and tuning in?
  1414. 54:29Well, the first thing to say is if you
  1415. 54:31want to understand the bond markets,
  1416. 54:33don't read the financial media because
  1417. 54:34they they are they they've got it
  1418. 54:36completely wrong right now. Uh I mean
  1419. 54:39it's the bond bond markets bond yields
  1420. 54:41are going up much more because of strong
  1421. 54:44economic growth than the fact that
  1422. 54:46governments are um uh are basically
  1423. 54:48being proflegate with debt. That that's
  1424. 54:50not the reason. Um it's it's a lot it's
  1425. 54:54it's a lot more complicated than they
  1426. 54:56tend to argue. And I think if you look
  1427. 54:58at the if you look at global equity, I
  1428. 55:00mean we track global equity around the
  1429. 55:02world. We've been doing that for 30 over
  1430. 55:0430 years. U and it's a concept that we
  1431. 55:07devised I mean back in the late 1980s.
  1432. 55:10But broadly speaking it it's you know
  1433. 55:13it's it's it can be done. It's not a
  1434. 55:14straightforward exercise but you've got
  1435. 55:16to understand the liquidity mechanisms.
  1436. 55:18And as I said the easiest way to
  1437. 55:20understand is to look at some of the
  1438. 55:23indicators. And the first indicator is
  1439. 55:25to look at the repo markets uh and to
  1440. 55:27look at what sofa spreads are. The
  1441. 55:30second thing to look at is uh to look at
  1442. 55:33uh bond volatility through the move
  1443. 55:34index. And the third thing to look at is
  1444. 55:37something which is again wonkish which
  1445. 55:39is term premium in the bond markets
  1446. 55:41which is the risk premium that bond
  1447. 55:43markets that bond investors demand. But
  1448. 55:45the easiest way to monitor that is
  1449. 55:48rather than doing it directly is to look
  1450. 55:49at the slope of the yield curve. Uh, and
  1451. 55:51that's another way of of understanding
  1452. 55:53it.
  1453. 55:54>> Well, as I said, thanks again for
  1454. 55:57spending the time and explaining
  1455. 55:58everything surrounding these topics with
  1456. 56:00us. Um, I'm sure that people will be
  1457. 56:02interested to learn more. So, where can
  1458. 56:05people find you?
  1459. 56:07>> Well, as I've mentioned, um, we do a
  1460. 56:09Substack. It's called Capital Wars. Uh,
  1461. 56:12we write, um, two, three times a week
  1462. 56:14on, uh, on relevant topics. We do stuff
  1463. 56:17about crypto. We provide a lot of data.
  1464. 56:19uh we do general uh analysis as well of
  1465. 56:22uh what the financial markets are doing.
  1466. 56:24Uh there's also uh I wrote a book
  1467. 56:27although it's getting a little bit dated
  1468. 56:28now was written before COVID but the
  1469. 56:30broad idea is the same with the same
  1470. 56:32title called capital wars and if you
  1471. 56:35want uh more data or an institutional uh
  1472. 56:39service then we have a website which is
  1473. 56:41called glindexes.com.
  1474. 56:44Thank you very much, Michael. And uh
  1475. 56:46hopefully we can have you on the show in
  1476. 56:48a in a few months time again to explain
  1477. 56:51whatever craziness there is happening in
  1478. 56:54the markets.
  1479. 56:55>> Look forward to it. Thank you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Michael Howell: FED Rate Hikes Will Trigger The Biggest Bull Run Ever by New Era Finance Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,476 words across 1,479 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.