YouTube2Text

Michael Bachner & Jesse Weber Tak Nicholas Godejohn Trial & Chris Watts Sentencing — Transcript

by Law&Crime Network · 5,173 words · 740 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00okay we're starting from the beginning
  2. 0:01and let's start from the beginning right
  3. 0:02now joining me as a special guest here
  4. 0:04on the network I haven't been on with
  5. 0:06him before so I'm happy he's here now
  6. 0:07criminal defense attorney Michael
  7. 0:09Bachner Michael great to see you
  8. 0:10pleasure so what on earth do you think
  9. 0:13it's like to defend a case like this
  10. 0:15with so many moving parts well job of
  11. 0:18the prosecute the job of the defense
  12. 0:20lawyer rather is to try and comprar
  13. 0:22mentalize your arguments in a way where
  14. 0:24you can really focus them and get the
  15. 0:26jury to really understand what that
  16. 0:28initial argument is some defense lawyers
  17. 0:30feel in cases where it's difficult to
  18. 0:31defend they use that old shotgun
  19. 0:32approach where they throw a lot of stuff
  20. 0:35up and hope jurors go back there and
  21. 0:36start arguing with each other and create
  22. 0:37reasonable doubts or you can try and
  23. 0:39create them but case like this it's very
  24. 0:41important in my opinion to focus the
  25. 0:43argument on really what you believe that
  26. 0:45reasonable doubt is really get your
  27. 0:47evidence in order hone in on it and in
  28. 0:49this case it would be there be the
  29. 0:50autistic condition of one of the
  30. 0:52individuals the Munchausen's related
  31. 0:54issues related with with DD and to
  32. 0:58really demonstrate that this was a woman
  33. 1:00as far as DD is concerned who was under
  34. 1:01an enormous amount of of pressures and
  35. 1:04and Gipsy etcetera what those
  36. 1:06relationships are and as far as the
  37. 1:07autistic issues to really try and create
  38. 1:09those doubts the scatter a scatter board
  39. 1:11approach is not going to work in a case
  40. 1:12like this a tough job for the defense
  41. 1:14attorney but let's kind of see what
  42. 1:16they're up against so we played a little
  43. 1:18bit of the prosecution's opening
  44. 1:19statement let's continue on okay
  45. 1:23important point here and I want to make
  46. 1:25sure we get this Michael the idea that
  47. 1:26the prosecution is saying really he
  48. 1:29deliberated on this for about a year do
  49. 1:32you believe based upon what you've seen
  50. 1:33in this case that's an accurate
  51. 1:35statement that he deliberated on and for
  52. 1:37quite some time are they really making a
  53. 1:39strong argument by saying this is
  54. 1:41first-degree murder because he did have
  55. 1:44the opportunity to make a different
  56. 1:45choice and did it or is the one who play
  57. 1:47the defense's opening statement a minute
  58. 1:49but I'm curious are they articulating a
  59. 1:50strong point there well the idea of
  60. 1:52showing premeditation is obviously very
  61. 1:54important in trying to demonstrate a
  62. 1:55first-degree offense premeditation
  63. 1:58though and the judge will instruct us
  64. 1:59that the jury can be formed in the
  65. 2:01matter of seconds so the fact that it's
  66. 2:03been going on arguably for a year I
  67. 2:05think is important to dust of all rebut
  68. 2:08any proposition that this was some type
  69. 2:10of the
  70. 2:10the impact of some type of impulsive
  71. 2:13mental disorder as compared to a really
  72. 2:15premeditative type of issue and this was
  73. 2:17an individual who would ever disorder he
  74. 2:19may have had really did not have any
  75. 2:21problem with him forming the
  76. 2:23premeditation so I think it's important
  77. 2:25for the prosecution to show that in
  78. 2:27order to rebut the idea that this is
  79. 2:28going to be some impact of some type of
  80. 2:30autistic disorder that now this is a guy
  81. 2:33who may who may have been somewhere on
  82. 2:34the spectrum but this was premeditated
  83. 2:36careful behavior by him that lasted a
  84. 2:39very long time and he could have backed
  85. 2:41out he could have changed he could have
  86. 2:42done a lot of other things and the
  87. 2:43defense is about to argue that look he
  88. 2:45has diminished capacity he cannot form
  89. 2:47the requisite intent necessary for
  90. 2:50first-degree murder now let's hear how
  91. 2:52they articulated that in their opening
  92. 2:54statement take a look let's really ask
  93. 2:58the million-dollar question here Michael
  94. 2:59okay have you ever seen a successful
  95. 3:03defense where the defense is my client
  96. 3:06was a autistic he is on the spectrum or
  97. 3:10she is autistic and on the spectrum and
  98. 3:11therefore you jurors should find this
  99. 3:14person not guilty because if you look at
  100. 3:17the intent necessary if you look at the
  101. 3:18elements of this crime they could not
  102. 3:21form that intent they could not have the
  103. 3:23mental capacity to commit this crime
  104. 3:24have you ever seen that work and never
  105. 3:26be successful I haven't seen it work as
  106. 3:29far as an autistic defense is concerned
  107. 3:31and the insanity defense generally
  108. 3:33contrary to public perception works less
  109. 3:36than 5% of the time juries routinely
  110. 3:39reject situations in which defendants
  111. 3:42raise mental capacity issues we still
  112. 3:44live in a world where people kind of
  113. 3:45think you know take responsibility for
  114. 3:46your conduct and I've been involved in
  115. 3:48cases in seen cases in which the
  116. 3:50behavior of the defendant has been just
  117. 3:53so extreme so crazy and juries have
  118. 3:55still rejected it so this is a very very
  119. 3:58hard argument to make particularly when
  120. 4:00you have a functioning individual and
  121. 4:02you can be autistic and hold a job you
  122. 4:05can be autistic and do a lot of things
  123. 4:07that require deliberation and content
  124. 4:09and knowledge so you have to demonstrate
  125. 4:10that the nature of the mental illness is
  126. 4:13so severe that you could not either
  127. 4:15distinguish between right and wrong or
  128. 4:17appreciate the wrongfulness of your
  129. 4:18conduct that is a very very high
  130. 4:20standard were you surprised
  131. 4:22when you see this case and yes there
  132. 4:24were mental health professionals that
  133. 4:25were called to talk about autism in the
  134. 4:28spectrum but I personally didn't see
  135. 4:31family and friends of Nicholas go to
  136. 4:33John come on to the stand and say any
  137. 4:35difficulties he had in his life or how
  138. 4:37he wasn't able to function you know in
  139. 4:40society as other people would and and
  140. 4:42the fact that maybe you didn't see that
  141. 4:44I'm curious what you thought of that
  142. 4:45because there are that's their defense
  143. 4:47it's interesting sometimes defense
  144. 4:50lawyers don't want to take the chance of
  145. 4:53putting on a lay witness that a person
  146. 4:54who's not an expert to testify to things
  147. 4:57that could kind of muck things up where
  148. 5:01you have an expert saying something
  149. 5:03sometimes you put a lay witness on all
  150. 5:04the sudden through cross-examination
  151. 5:05they start saying things that you regret
  152. 5:07yeah that's a good point all right we
  153. 5:09have a lot more to cover in this case
  154. 5:11we're gonna talk more about nicholas go
  155. 5:12to john right after this break crime
  156. 5:20scenes photos really do tell a story and
  157. 5:23back here with michael Bachner to ask
  158. 5:24really a different question though what
  159. 5:26is the defense's ultimate goal here were
  160. 5:29never they conceded the fact he
  161. 5:31committed this killing but they're
  162. 5:33arguing that he was manipulated by gypsy
  163. 5:36blanchard so what would be their
  164. 5:37ultimate goal is to get a not guilty
  165. 5:39verdict well i think the ultimate goal
  166. 5:41really here's a diminished capacity type
  167. 5:43of defense that is you're trying to get
  168. 5:45a reduction in the in the level of
  169. 5:47culpability and the level of
  170. 5:50responsibility of a defendant by arguing
  171. 5:52that although he may have committed the
  172. 5:53conduct because of some mental
  173. 5:55impairment whether it's alcohol
  174. 5:57sometimes whether it's drugs etc that
  175. 6:00that reduced his ability to form the
  176. 6:03requisite intent to act intentionally
  177. 6:04but it did not and it reduces it to the
  178. 6:06level where he may have acted either
  179. 6:08negligently carelessly or recklessly
  180. 6:10reducing the level of exposure that the
  181. 6:12defendant has in a criminal case but
  182. 6:14they would also be happy with hey at the
  183. 6:15jury they can convince the jury this is
  184. 6:17a pretty sympathetic guy he's the victim
  185. 6:19in this case then hey you if you find
  186. 6:20him not guilty of anything that would be
  187. 6:21great because the end of the day the
  188. 6:23question is who's the victim here is it
  189. 6:25nicholas go to john is it gypsy
  190. 6:27Blanchard is it DeeDee Blanchard was it
  191. 6:29everybody let's play now though in case
  192. 6:32you missed it
  193. 6:33is the forensic investigator from the
  194. 6:35medical examiner's office who's going to
  195. 6:36talk about the wounds sustained by Dede
  196. 6:39Blanchard and this also tells a story
  197. 6:43take a look
  198. 6:45miss Blanche Art's back taken from the
  199. 6:48right side and there are numbers there
  200. 6:53what are those
  201. 6:56dr. Harkey numbered each wound and this
  202. 7:01shows the numbers 1 through 14 for the
  203. 7:05stab wounds on the back and those 14
  204. 7:11wounds there on the back were there
  205. 7:14certain ones that caused significantly
  206. 7:17more damage than others of these wounds
  207. 7:21wound number three number five Number
  208. 7:27six number seven number 12 and number 14
  209. 7:33penetrated into the chest cavity and a
  210. 7:38couple of them on into the abdominal
  211. 7:40cavity of miss Blanche art and it can go
  212. 7:44ahead and flip the stage 41
  213. 7:49this is a photograph that I initial when
  214. 7:54I circled those six wounds these are
  215. 7:58pretty brutal wounds I don't want to
  216. 8:00talk about it Michael the idea of I mean
  217. 8:02we knew that he stabbed her does it
  218. 8:05matter
  219. 8:05how he stabbed her how many times where
  220. 8:08he stabbed her does that is that a
  221. 8:10really big factor when you're talking
  222. 8:12about first-degree murder
  223. 8:13well it's interesting sometimes one or
  224. 8:16two stabs may indicate that a person
  225. 8:18just acted out of some impulse and there
  226. 8:21was oh my god and stopped it could
  227. 8:23indicate that the person was very good
  228. 8:24at what they did and it didn't have to
  229. 8:26stab very much more and they were just
  230. 8:27experts in doing it so one or two could
  231. 8:29indicate a good premeditation but
  232. 8:31oftentimes how many times you stab could
  233. 8:34indicate whether you're acting and some
  234. 8:36crazy impulse whether it's some heat of
  235. 8:38anger that you couldn't control yourself
  236. 8:39so and the angle of the wound could
  237. 8:42indicate whether the person was acting
  238. 8:45in a defensive fashion or was acting in
  239. 8:47an aggressive fashion so all of these
  240. 8:49all of these the number of wounds the
  241. 8:51angle of the wounds how often the wounds
  242. 8:52came between each other even the even
  243. 8:54the space between the wounds these are
  244. 8:57all indicative of things that experts
  245. 8:58look at in determining things but you
  246. 9:01know the wounds weren't the only thing
  247. 9:02that we learned about at the actual
  248. 9:03crime we know that when Gipsy Blanchard
  249. 9:05testified she said that go to John asked
  250. 9:09if she wanted him to rape her mother
  251. 9:10what so the idea that he wanted to do
  252. 9:14that or came up with that idea what did
  253. 9:16you make of that well it certainly
  254. 9:18indicates a level of a level of evilness
  255. 9:22of my mind a level of thought that this
  256. 9:26is not just an impulsive individual
  257. 9:28killing someone but out to really
  258. 9:31inflict
  259. 9:32other types of conduct and it's what's
  260. 9:35also weird is the fact that you're
  261. 9:37comfortable asking her this question
  262. 9:39that's the most bizarre aspect of it all
  263. 9:42listen we got to hit a quick break but
  264. 9:43when we come back a lot more to discuss
  265. 9:45with Michael we'll be right back all
  266. 9:48[Music]
  267. 9:50right so that was the cab driver that
  268. 9:53actually dropped off Nicholas go to John
  269. 9:55at gypsies house and we know what
  270. 9:57happened then he ultimately stabbed her
  271. 9:58to death
  272. 9:59DeeDee Blanchard of course I'm talking
  273. 10:00about but Michael I gotta ask you this
  274. 10:03we can't talk about this case without
  275. 10:04focusing on gypsy Blanchard who was an
  276. 10:07active participant in this and we
  277. 10:09believe that she was in the bathroom
  278. 10:10while the stabbing actually occurred she
  279. 10:12heard it go down if she went to trial we
  280. 10:15all know that she pled guilty to
  281. 10:17second-degree murder faces ten years in
  282. 10:19prison might actually be up for parole
  283. 10:20in 2021 if she took this to trial would
  284. 10:23she have a successful defense that my
  285. 10:26mother suffered from munchausen syndrome
  286. 10:28by proxy I was the victim of being
  287. 10:31confined to a wheelchair forced to shave
  288. 10:33my head I was improperly malnourished
  289. 10:35I'm the victim of child abuse I had to
  290. 10:38get free of her this is the only way
  291. 10:40well you know it's kind of the defense
  292. 10:42that in the old days the battered woman
  293. 10:44defense for battered husband defense
  294. 10:46where someone felt that the only way out
  295. 10:47of this horrible situation was to kill
  296. 10:50the spouse that's a very difficult
  297. 10:52defense to propose because jurors look
  298. 10:54at injured and judges instruct the jury
  299. 10:56about the ability the level of duress
  300. 10:59can you get out do you have an ability
  301. 11:00to call law enforcement and there is a
  302. 11:02good amount of premeditation even by her
  303. 11:05hear after the murders committed they
  304. 11:07emptied the safe and they do a lot of
  305. 11:09other stuff kind of consistent with
  306. 11:11someone who's acting out of perhaps a
  307. 11:14financial motive and other types of
  308. 11:16motives not necessarily a Munchausen by
  309. 11:18proxy situation it would be a very
  310. 11:20varied in my opinion a very difficult
  311. 11:22I'm defense for further proposed even
  312. 11:24never the Menendez brothers where you
  313. 11:26had all this information about sexual
  314. 11:28abuse and battery etc and we saw had
  315. 11:30that verdict done certainly initially
  316. 11:31when a jury can only take so much and
  317. 11:34what we're talking about right now is
  318. 11:35the premeditation aspect of what
  319. 11:37Nicholas go to John was charged with
  320. 11:39first-degree murder we listen to how he
  321. 11:41was dropped off at the house let's
  322. 11:43listen to John Harmon another cab driver
  323. 11:46who picked gypsy and him up after the
  324. 11:49killing take a look we're learning all
  325. 11:52the steps that were taken but was this a
  326. 11:54deliberate act did Nicholas go to John
  327. 11:57premeditated on this was this planned
  328. 11:59out because if so that really does look
  329. 12:01like first-degree murder even if he is
  330. 12:02an autistic individual the back door of
  331. 12:05Michael Michael Bachner to talk about
  332. 12:06this so Michael you and I were just
  333. 12:08talking about this in the break right
  334. 12:10even forget the fact what their defense
  335. 12:13is that you know he can't form the
  336. 12:14requisite intent because of him being an
  337. 12:16autistic individual the idea here though
  338. 12:19do you think that she really did take
  339. 12:21advantage of him and tried to get a
  340. 12:23willing accomplice to this crime because
  341. 12:26of his condition I mean because he's an
  342. 12:28autistic individual does that do you
  343. 12:30believe that well it certainly sounds
  344. 12:32like that's part of the their whole
  345. 12:33synergy together and their kind of how
  346. 12:36they begin the yang of their
  347. 12:37relationship but it's interesting she is
  348. 12:39somebody as a result of what she went
  349. 12:41through with her mother that is her
  350. 12:42mother casting on her all his diseases
  351. 12:46probably would help her understand how
  352. 12:49she could actually manipulate another
  353. 12:50person who has a disease and perhaps
  354. 12:53take advantage of that type of situation
  355. 12:55and it's clear he suffers from something
  356. 12:57and it's clear she wanted this thing
  357. 12:59done she pled guilty to wouldn't she and
  358. 13:01she's testified against them so I think
  359. 13:04there is this where they kind of like
  360. 13:07working off of he off of off of each
  361. 13:10other but at the end of the day the
  362. 13:12issue is really going to be whether or
  363. 13:14not he made an independent decision to
  364. 13:16engage in the conduct he get engaged in
  365. 13:18not whether she may have manipulated him
  366. 13:19I want to touch upon what you said
  367. 13:21though that she is being a victim of
  368. 13:23manipulation for her entire life she
  369. 13:25almost became an expert in manipulation
  370. 13:27is that something you see in your
  371. 13:29practice people who have that upbringing
  372. 13:31one way or another if they were taught
  373. 13:33to lying and she there by their parents
  374. 13:36that they ultimately become that person
  375. 13:38I mean is that something that's
  376. 13:39consistent with what you've seen and
  377. 13:41we're assuming that she manipulated him
  378. 13:43but again that's is that something that
  379. 13:44you've seen well everyone's really the
  380. 13:47product of the environment they live in
  381. 13:48so I've certainly seen it in white
  382. 13:49collar offenses where stockbrokers for
  383. 13:51example who you know live their lives
  384. 13:54and become these penny stock cases lying
  385. 13:57to people and manipulating people and
  386. 13:58one philosophy a wolf of Wall Street
  387. 14:00Hawaii cross-examined for three days at
  388. 14:02the end of the day these are people who
  389. 14:04can train other people to actually find
  390. 14:06the weaknesses and the people they call
  391. 14:08and a lot of these people who actually
  392. 14:10are trained to do this some have those
  393. 14:12similar types of there's an old line the
  394. 14:14easiest person to sell is someone who
  395. 14:15sells they they actually so it's a there
  396. 14:19is that that type
  397. 14:20of that type of relationship that goes
  398. 14:21on okay so now if you sit in the
  399. 14:23defense's seat and you're listening to
  400. 14:25this and they're playing all this
  401. 14:26evidence about him taking the cab and
  402. 14:29planning this out and wanted to stab her
  403. 14:31and wanted to rape her and all this is
  404. 14:32it possible how would you argue as the
  405. 14:35defense attorney
  406. 14:35well that might all be true but this
  407. 14:37still isn't premeditation how would you
  408. 14:39argue that well you know you would have
  409. 14:42to try and argue that as a result of the
  410. 14:45disease you're suffering that you were
  411. 14:48brought into a situation and you were
  412. 14:51not going to engage in the conduct and
  413. 14:53the manipulative conduct that was
  414. 14:54brought upon perhaps by gypsy to put you
  415. 14:57in that position and it kind of over
  416. 15:00overcame your ability to act in in an
  417. 15:03appropriate way and as a result of the
  418. 15:05condition you have on the autistic on
  419. 15:07the autistic scale you or someone easily
  420. 15:10manipulated easily brought in to another
  421. 15:12type of reality very quiet arguments to
  422. 15:14make candidly very hard argument because
  423. 15:16autism is not a disease it's not really
  424. 15:17a defect it's just something that he was
  425. 15:21he was born an autistic individual so
  426. 15:23it's very difficult to argue this as
  427. 15:25opposed to as you said like an insanity
  428. 15:27defense or something else let's take a
  429. 15:28quick break when we come back a lot more
  430. 15:30to discuss welcome back to law and crime
  431. 15:39everybody we are switching gears right
  432. 15:41now and we were talking about our
  433. 15:42courtroom that we will be live in today
  434. 15:44that's right let's talk about Chris
  435. 15:46Watts Chris Watts pled guilty to the
  436. 15:50murders of his wife Shannon and also
  437. 15:53their two baby girls four-year-old Bella
  438. 15:56and three-year-old Celeste the actual
  439. 15:59cause of death of all three is sealed we
  440. 16:02don't know what the medical examiner's
  441. 16:03report is as of yet but we do know he
  442. 16:05pled guilty we believe he pled guilty
  443. 16:07because he wanted to escape the death
  444. 16:09penalty and today will begin his
  445. 16:12sentencing phase and this should be
  446. 16:14something to watch because he pled
  447. 16:15guilty to nine felony counts including
  448. 16:18five counts of first degree murder
  449. 16:20unlawful termination of a pregnancy and
  450. 16:23three counts of tampering with a
  451. 16:25deceased human body he could face that
  452. 16:27at least three
  453. 16:28life terms in prison without the
  454. 16:30possibility of parole and this is just a
  455. 16:33really incredible case we have a special
  456. 16:35report talking more about it in case you
  457. 16:38don't know anything about this whole
  458. 16:39situation
  459. 16:40take a look Chris Watts the man who
  460. 16:44admitted to murdering his pregnant wife
  461. 16:46Shannon and their two young daughters
  462. 16:48Celeste and Bella will be sentenced on
  463. 16:50Monday Watts pleaded guilty to three
  464. 16:53counts of first degree murder two counts
  465. 16:55of murdering a child one count of
  466. 16:58unlawful termination of a pregnancy and
  467. 17:00three counts of tampering with a
  468. 17:03deceased body the case drew national
  469. 17:05attention in August after watts publicly
  470. 17:07pleaded for his family's safe return one
  471. 17:10day after reporting them missing from
  472. 17:13their Colorado home on August 13th I
  473. 17:15mean right now I don't even want to just
  474. 17:17like throw anything out there like I
  475. 17:19hope that she is somewhere safe right
  476. 17:22now and with the kids but I mean could
  477. 17:26she event cause she just taken off I
  478. 17:28don't know but if somebody has her and
  479. 17:30they're not safe like I want them back
  480. 17:32now like that that that's what Sam I
  481. 17:35like if they're safe right now they're
  482. 17:37gonna come back but if they're not safe
  483. 17:39right now that's what that's the not
  484. 17:41knowing part like if they're not safe
  485. 17:43last night I was at every light in the
  486. 17:45house on I was hoping that I would just
  487. 17:48get just ran over by the kids running in
  488. 17:50the door and just like barrel rushing me
  489. 17:51but it didn't happen and it was just a
  490. 17:54traumatic night trying to be here Watts
  491. 17:57was arrested one day later and led the
  492. 17:59police to the bodies he confessed to
  493. 18:01driving them to the property of the oil
  494. 18:03and gas company where he worked he
  495. 18:06buried his wife in a shallow grave and
  496. 18:08dumped Celeste and Bella in oil barrels
  497. 18:11he said Watts admitted to killing his
  498. 18:13wife but claimed he only did it after
  499. 18:15she killed the children aged three and
  500. 18:17four he stated he saw Shannon actively
  501. 18:20strangling them on the baby monitor but
  502. 18:23when he arrived they were both dead
  503. 18:25Watts plea deal spared him from the
  504. 18:27death penalty though he faces life in
  505. 18:29prison for the long crime Network I'm
  506. 18:31Rachel Stockman
  507. 18:39always Michael as we watch this case you
  508. 18:42see the porch interview right we know
  509. 18:45that he changed his stories about what
  510. 18:46ultimately happened he eventually pled
  511. 18:48guilty
  512. 18:48how does someone look in the face of a
  513. 18:51camera to the whole world and just lie
  514. 18:54how does that happen it's really
  515. 18:57remarkable the ability of some people
  516. 18:59who are have this I'm gonna call them
  517. 19:02psychotic but not in the medical sense
  518. 19:04this ability to divorce themselves from
  519. 19:06the criminality horrible just banal type
  520. 19:10of evil they've created just killing a
  521. 19:12wife and your children and the method
  522. 19:13wish I did it and to be able to look
  523. 19:15into camera takes a special kind of evil
  524. 19:18and it's this need to self protect etc
  525. 19:21and he came across as you know kind of
  526. 19:23credible looking you know you seemed
  527. 19:25didn't seem in total shock hoping
  528. 19:27they're still alive etcetera and you
  529. 19:30know it's so interesting this slip of
  530. 19:32the tongue when he was talking about
  531. 19:33there he said he hoped his kids would
  532. 19:35come home and barrel into him and of
  533. 19:37course we know what he did with his
  534. 19:38children I mean generally why do you
  535. 19:41think he took a plea deal here I mean
  536. 19:42what is it really he didn't want to even
  537. 19:44try this take it to trial what do you
  538. 19:47think was going on in their defense team
  539. 19:48well I think the defense defense lawyers
  540. 19:51in cases like this or doctors in the
  541. 19:53emergency room their job is to stop the
  542. 19:55patient from dying and they know that
  543. 19:57there's no way that he's ever going to
  544. 19:59have a normal life they no way he's
  545. 20:01never gonna really be acquitted of this
  546. 20:02case given his statements in the nature
  547. 20:04of the evidence and their jobs to try
  548. 20:06and save his life
  549. 20:07so I they sat him down and said your
  550. 20:09options are as follows you can go to
  551. 20:10trial be convicted and there's a
  552. 20:12substantial chance you could get the
  553. 20:14death penalty you take this plea you
  554. 20:16live the rest of your life in jail but
  555. 20:17you know what you're still alive that's
  556. 20:19that's and I think clients have to make
  557. 20:22those horrible choices we don't know why
  558. 20:24this happened really we don't know why
  559. 20:26he did this or the motive here is not
  560. 20:28entirely clear but we know some
  561. 20:29informations been coming forward since
  562. 20:31the sentencing will be happening in fact
  563. 20:33the woman who claims that she was having
  564. 20:35an affair with Chris Watts did an
  565. 20:37interview with Denver 7 News and she
  566. 20:40called what happened to Shannon and her
  567. 20:42daughter's horrific and she said that
  568. 20:44Chris lied about everything during the
  569. 20:46relationship and that also lied about
  570. 20:48what actually
  571. 20:49and to Shannon and his two daughters I'm
  572. 20:52curious why do you think this is coming
  573. 20:54out now do you think that how do you
  574. 20:58think she's gonna play in the overall
  575. 20:59arc of this story I think she's just
  576. 21:02relevant for sentencing purposes and for
  577. 21:05purpose and and and to give some some
  578. 21:07context to what what happened here but
  579. 21:09it's really for sentencing purposes and
  580. 21:11and look these are not it's not that
  581. 21:13unusual to hear stories where people who
  582. 21:15want to change their lives and they
  583. 21:17consider the families they have to be an
  584. 21:19obstacle into what they should have and
  585. 21:21what they should be you have you know
  586. 21:23the the Casey Anthony case which of
  587. 21:25course she was acquitted on and the
  588. 21:26evidence wasn't there apparently a jury
  589. 21:28found but the argument was that a child
  590. 21:30was killed because it kind of interfered
  591. 21:32with the lifestyle she wanted to have
  592. 21:33and you you have these types of these
  593. 21:35types of cases they're not that unusual
  594. 21:37for people who have are either overly
  595. 21:41narcissistic and feel it's all about
  596. 21:43them and their families or obstacles but
  597. 21:45that's I think what this woman is coming
  598. 21:46out to say that the classic example is
  599. 21:49you had an affair you'd do anything to
  600. 21:51be with that person now again we don't
  601. 21:52know exactly what happened and we're
  602. 21:54trying to predict what's gonna happen
  603. 21:56today when victim impact statements are
  604. 21:57read there's a bizarre turn of events
  605. 22:00that happened with Chris Watson's family
  606. 22:01his parents in particular I want to talk
  607. 22:03about that they wrote a letter to the
  608. 22:05judge alleging that Watts had been
  609. 22:07coerced into taking this plea deal that
  610. 22:10his constitutional rights were denied
  611. 22:12and that they attempted to make an
  612. 22:14appearance in this matter the judge
  613. 22:16denied that but said that they can speak
  614. 22:17out during the victim impact statements
  615. 22:19because they are in fact victims since
  616. 22:22their grandchildren were killed so
  617. 22:24Michael what is going on here it's a
  618. 22:26weird thing I've never seen anything
  619. 22:28like this the issue of a defendant being
  620. 22:30coerced into taking a plea happens all
  621. 22:32the time defendants feel they feel like
  622. 22:35oh we made a mistake or they they just
  623. 22:37want to retract they want to go to trial
  624. 22:38but he's not saying this his parents are
  625. 22:40and the fact that his parents are saying
  626. 22:42that raises no constitutional issues for
  627. 22:44the judge as far as the judge is
  628. 22:45concerned unless this defendant raises
  629. 22:47the issue that he was coerced into a
  630. 22:49plea and wants to move to a draw which
  631. 22:51is candidly an enormous ly difficult
  632. 22:53thing to do at the end of the day you
  633. 22:55know this is a weird thing and then to
  634. 22:56be given the right to speak at the
  635. 22:58sentencing I'm not sure what that's all
  636. 23:00about what are they going to go up there
  637. 23:01and say that mice
  638. 23:02is innocent and then he didn't do
  639. 23:04anything wrong how was that a statement
  640. 23:06on behalf of the victims what's their
  641. 23:07leeway what can they actually say I mean
  642. 23:09what they want to come on there and
  643. 23:10they're technically allowed because they
  644. 23:12are the grandparents of two of the two
  645. 23:14girls so that normally what would happen
  646. 23:16is they would come on and say hey you
  647. 23:18know this was a horrible crime my
  648. 23:20granddaughters were killed but here
  649. 23:21what's their leeway what can they
  650. 23:23actually argue well generally like you
  651. 23:25said on just they would get up there and
  652. 23:27they would say you know what this is a
  653. 23:29horrible case but please show mercy on
  654. 23:31on the defendant you know even though he
  655. 23:33did this horrible thing they can come
  656. 23:35out and say things like that but they're
  657. 23:37gonna go up there and say this is a
  658. 23:38horrible crime my grandkids were killed
  659. 23:40but he didn't do it
  660. 23:41that's not really a victim impact
  661. 23:43statement because you're not really
  662. 23:46showing the impact on the victim as far
  663. 23:48as the defendant is concerned so I think
  664. 23:51the judge may feel statutorily under the
  665. 23:53law they have a right to speak but they
  666. 23:55give it little or no credence and
  667. 23:57frankly I think it could be harmful for
  668. 23:58for this defendant ultimately the world
  669. 24:01will be watching today and hopefully
  670. 24:03they're all watching here on law on
  671. 24:05crime which I hope you do because we're
  672. 24:06gonna be live in that courtroom do you
  673. 24:07think Chris Watts will make a statement
  674. 24:09well it's interesting if I were the
  675. 24:11judge on this case to protect this
  676. 24:12record I would say to this defendant I
  677. 24:14would make it clear that you are not
  678. 24:16raising any issues as far as your guilty
  679. 24:19pleas concern so that ultimately down
  680. 24:21the road depending on what a sentences
  681. 24:23does erase some other appeal out there
  682. 24:25and say that you know my parents told
  683. 24:27you about this coercion and I was you
  684. 24:29know told to be quiet about it etc I get
  685. 24:32the judge to talk about it what he
  686. 24:33should do up there just talk about how
  687. 24:35sorry is remorsefully is the woman it
  688. 24:37won't matter on his sentence he's gonna
  689. 24:39be getting life sentences anyway oh yeah
  690. 24:41this is definitely something to watch we
  691. 24:44are gonna be live in that courtroom we
  692. 24:46believe maybe in an hour or so but if
  693. 24:49something should happen before we're
  694. 24:51gonna go up there and watch that so that
  695. 24:53is the Chris Watts sentencing that's a
  696. 24:54live feed into the Quorum obviously
  697. 24:56nothing's happening yet we'll take a
  698. 24:57quick break we'll be right back
  699. 25:01[Music]
  700. 25:05everybody welcome back to lawn crime I'm
  701. 25:08Jesse Weber thanks for joining us busy
  702. 25:10day here on the network we are first
  703. 25:12going to be covering the Nikolas go to
  704. 25:13John trial talking a little bit more
  705. 25:15about it and the verdict came in so
  706. 25:18we're talking more about this man who
  707. 25:19was on trial for the murder of DeeDee
  708. 25:22Blanchard his girlfriend's mother trying
  709. 25:24to understand why this happened what the
  710. 25:26defense is going to be arguing because
  711. 25:28they argued that he is an autistic
  712. 25:30individual on the spectrum manipulated
  713. 25:32by gipsy Blanchard his girlfriend to
  714. 25:34commit this crime and that anything jury
  715. 25:36you shouldn't find him guilty of
  716. 25:38first-degree murder maybe something less
  717. 25:39because he couldn't form the requisite
  718. 25:41intent necessary DeeDee was found dead
  719. 25:44in her home stabbed to death a pretty
  720. 25:46brutal crime and gipsy Blanchard has
  721. 25:48been portrayed as the mastermind behind
  722. 25:50all of this she testified in connection
  723. 25:52with this trial testified on behalf of
  724. 25:55the defense
  725. 25:55she took most of the blame and we're you
  726. 25:58know we're gonna talk more about if that
  727. 25:59worked or not and we can't forget the
  728. 26:02fact that munchausen syndrome by proxy
  729. 26:03which it's believed that DeeDee
  730. 26:05Blanchard suffered from and you could
  731. 26:07say that gipsy Blanchard was the victim
  732. 26:09of herself really becomes a big factor
  733. 26:11in this case so before we talk about go
  734. 26:15to John and before we talk about the
  735. 26:17Chris Watts sentencing I just want to
  736. 26:19say Michael Bachner who is our guest
  737. 26:21today really thank you so much for
  738. 26:23coming on it was a pleasure we're
  739. 26:24killing to have ya thank you you can't
  740. 26:26wait to have you back awesome all right

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Michael Bachner & Jesse Weber Tak Nicholas Godejohn Trial & Chris Watts Sentencing by Law&Crime Network, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,173 words across 740 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.