Mercedes halts investments in Germany, says may shut down factories | DW News — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00German-made cars were long seen as the
- 0:03standard for engineering excellence with
- 0:05brands like Mercedes being a symbol of
- 0:07luxury around the world. But now,
- 0:10they're a symbol of something else,
- 0:11Germany's troubled auto sector. Once the
- 0:14engine of Germany's economy, in 2026,
- 0:17German car makers are stuttering.
- 0:19Mercedes, BMW and Volkswagen have all
- 0:22cut their outlook for this year. They
- 0:24all cite high costs and competition from
- 0:27Chinese car makers. And Mercedes
- 0:29management now says it'll halt all
- 0:31investments in Germany, warning it could
- 0:34be shutting down factories. In an
- 0:36interview posted on the company's
- 0:37internal website, board member Britta
- 0:40Seeger said that Mercedes is, quote,
- 0:42being forced to examine in concrete and
- 0:44detailed terms which sites in Germany we
- 0:47can afford to maintain. We want to avoid
- 0:50plant closures at all costs.
- 0:52Unfortunately, we must now concretely
- 0:54pursue this option. My guest, Ferdinand
- 0:57Dudenhöffer, is one of Germany's
- 0:59best-known auto industry analysts.
- 1:02German media often call him the car
- 1:04pope. He's also the director of Center
- 1:07Automotive Research. Ferdinand, it's
- 1:09good to see you.
- 1:11>> Good evening, Edie Beech.
- 1:13>> So before we talk about the cuts at
- 1:15Mercedes in particular and whether
- 1:17there's even a future for German-made
- 1:19cars, I want to start with a statement
- 1:22you made that the German car industry is
- 1:25in its biggest crisis since its
- 1:28inception. That's a pretty big statement
- 1:30considering all that has happened in
- 1:33almost a century and a half of German
- 1:35history. Why is this the industry's
- 1:38biggest crisis yet?
- 1:41>> It's a couple of problems we see
- 1:45since, let's say, two or three years and
- 1:47they are
- 1:49going stronger and stronger and
- 1:50stronger. So first point is if we look
- 1:53at Germany, Germany has a lousy cost
- 1:58competition in the for producing cars.
- 2:03The second thing is the electric
- 2:05vehicles. The electric vehicles come
- 2:07from China, but also from Tesla.
- 2:10And the third thing is the production
- 2:12technologies. The German car makers are
- 2:17used to make a plenty of different cars.
- 2:20If you look at Tesla or you can tell me,
- 2:23they have chosen one or two models and
- 2:25have other
- 2:26production
- 2:28methods like giga casting which help
- 2:31them to reduce costs dramatically. So
- 2:35three problems which the German car
- 2:37industry is facing.
- 2:39>> So Mercedes now announcing to its
- 2:42employees anyway that it's threatening
- 2:43to close factories
- 2:45here in Germany. This comes as there
- 2:47have been a lot of fights between
- 2:49Mercedes and the unions, IG Metall,
- 2:52Germany's biggest and most powerful
- 2:54union. They're demanding higher wages.
- 2:56They're announcing strikes.
- 2:58Are these threats by Mercedes to close
- 3:00factories just a tactic to get the
- 3:03unions to work more for less pay?
- 3:08>> See, it's not just Mercedes. If you look
- 3:10at VW, it's the same problem. They want
- 3:13to reduce manpower by
- 3:16around 100,000 people in
- 3:20in Germany. So
- 3:22also VW told us that they
- 3:25have plans if they don't come back with
- 3:29better cost positions to close four
- 3:32plants. The trade unions have some
- 3:35privilege. The privilege is 35 working
- 3:38hours week. This is very expensive
- 3:41and the
- 3:43car industry says, okay, let's go away
- 3:46from that 35 hour, for example, to 40
- 3:50hours and then we can pay you the same
- 3:53wages. But the
- 3:56trade union says, no, that's very
- 3:58important for us. So we we are in a in a
- 4:00conflict um seems to be no solution at
- 4:05the moment. Um if they have no solution,
- 4:08car makers will quit Germany, will close
- 4:12plants and uh the trade unions and I
- 4:15think they don't believe in it.
- 4:19>> There there is this much quoted figure
- 4:21that uh the the the cost of labor in
- 4:24Eastern Europe is about a fifth of what
- 4:27it is here in Germany. Do these trends
- 4:31of of German car makers wanting to
- 4:33close, potentially close factories in
- 4:35Germany, do they threaten the future of
- 4:37German car companies or just the the
- 4:41German made cars by these companies?
- 4:45>> Um I think the major problem is that uh
- 4:49Germany by itself is facing a big
- 4:53deindustrialization.
- 4:55So the existence of the German car
- 4:57industry is in questioning, is
- 5:01questioned. So we see the problem, the
- 5:04first problem in Germany. Of course, in
- 5:07other country it's not easy to compete.
- 5:10However, it's possible. You will find
- 5:14solutions for that. But with the cost
- 5:17structures, it's energy costs. It's a
- 5:19lot of administration costs in Germany.
- 5:22It's a lousy logistics system uh with
- 5:26streets and bridges and trains which are
- 5:29very unreliable. So you have a big cost
- 5:34burden. If you don't stop start with a
- 5:38new thinking and a new uh
- 5:42future
- 5:44and better cost positions, we will lose
- 5:47our automotive industry.
- 5:51>> Obviously that's a that's a huge problem
- 5:52for the the German economy. The the
- 5:55automotive industry has been such an
- 5:57engine in the German economy for so
- 6:00long. I'm wondering though about these
- 6:02brands themselves and the
- 6:05I mean, Mercedes, BMW, all of these
- 6:08brands do make cars in other countries
- 6:11already. How much do their customers
- 6:13care if the cars are made in Germany or
- 6:16if they're made in Mexico?
- 6:17>> So, 50 years ago, people said, okay,
- 6:19it's a German car, it's a German
- 6:20quality, it's manufactured in Germany.
- 6:23The if you buy a Porsche, for example,
- 6:26today, it could be that the Porsche is
- 6:28not produced in Germany. If you buy a
- 6:31BMW
- 6:33SUV or a Mercedes SUV, it's produced in
- 6:37in the
- 6:38in the United States and shipped to
- 6:40Germany. So,
- 6:42the customer doesn't care about the
- 6:45country. The customer looks at the
- 6:47quality and looks at the brand. That is
- 6:50what
- 6:51the customer is paying for, not for
- 6:54Germany.
- 6:55>> Let's talk about not just the production
- 6:57in Germany, but the the future of German
- 7:00car companies globally. In total, for
- 7:03decades, they've been relying on high
- 7:06demand in China. That's now down. It is
- 7:10is demand in China over? Was that a
- 7:12mistake?
- 7:16>> So,
- 7:17China is the most important car market
- 7:19in the world. This year, they sell about
- 7:2120 million cars,
- 7:23or 19 million cars. Last year, they had
- 7:2624 million cars. So, they have a big
- 7:28recession in the automotive industry.
- 7:30Therefore, they have a lot of exports of
- 7:32its cars to Europe and to other export
- 7:34countries. That's point number one. And
- 7:37point number two is that the German car
- 7:39makers lose also market shares, very
- 7:42strongly market shares in China. At the
- 7:44moment, they have no strategy because
- 7:47the cars of the Chinese car makers
- 7:50and Tesla
- 7:52less priced
- 7:54compared to German to the German cars.
- 7:57One point is that the German cars
- 8:00have a production philosophy
- 8:04and method in which they try to uh
- 8:07produce a [clears throat] lot of
- 8:09variants, a lot of
- 8:11uh drivetrains, a lot of different
- 8:14options for each customer that he can
- 8:16individualize this car. If you go to
- 8:18Tesla, if you go to Xiaomi and to
- 8:20others, you have standard cars, but the
- 8:23standard cars have 30 40 50% less prices
- 8:27for the customers. Therefore, you have
- 8:29to find a solution to that and VW had a
- 8:32strategy. They called it in China for
- 8:36China. So all electric vehicles which
- 8:40will be coming to the market in China
- 8:43up to now in the next years will
- 8:45exclusively
- 8:47developed in China in a new development
- 8:50center and produced exclusively in China
- 8:54to reduce the costs and can compete to
- 8:57Chinese car makers and to Tesla in the
- 9:00electric market. China has
- 9:03the most knowledge and scale economies
- 9:08in batteries.
- 9:09China has the most knowledge in the car
- 9:14of the future, the car of the future,
- 9:16the car of tomorrow, the car which is
- 9:18automatically driving
- 9:20with automatic driving features or with
- 9:22a lot of entertainment in that.
- 9:25So the German engineers are more
- 9:27mechanical engineering
- 9:29people. The Chinese engineers are more
- 9:32IT driven. I think one strategy is to
- 9:36collaborate with the Chinese. VW is
- 9:39doing that with
- 9:42Celis, a big
- 9:45group, is doing that with Leapmotor. So
- 9:47come together and find a solution to
- 9:50integrate the know-how and the
- 9:54technologies which Chinese make its cars
- 9:58successful
- 9:59and take also the European part and make
- 10:02a new
- 10:04new unity out of this. And I think that
- 10:06could be one of the solutions for the
- 10:08future. The problem is we have of course
- 10:10a political problem because our
- 10:12politicians don't want to go to come to
- 10:16to close to China. So that that is a
- 10:18little bit problem at the moment. We
- 10:20have to solve that. If we can solve
- 10:21that, we can back come back in the most
- 10:25important market in the world.
- 10:27>> There's there's a lot of talk also about
- 10:28how the German car industry misread the
- 10:31future of electric vehicles, that it
- 10:35invested too late, too little, and that
- 10:38it then expected. No?
- 10:40>> No, no, no, no, no. That is not the
- 10:42problem. All people say, okay, the the
- 10:44Germans missed
- 10:46the the the time. They are too late.
- 10:48That is not true. The Germans had been
- 10:50very early in the market. The problem is
- 10:54they not they they are late with the
- 10:57product. The problem is that
- 11:00they have missed the production
- 11:04technology for the car, for the electric
- 11:07vehicle.
- 11:09Elon Musk is doing that with giga
- 11:10casting, with big machines. The same are
- 11:14doing the Chinese, for example, Dongfeng
- 11:17or Nio or Xiaomi, also Tesla. And if you
- 11:22do that, you have another structure of
- 11:25the car. You have a more standardized
- 11:27car, but you have
- 11:31you've reduced cost positions and that
- 11:34helps you to become competitive. That
- 11:36means we missed because our engineer all
- 11:40the time said we are the greatest in the
- 11:42world.
- 11:43And they
- 11:44laughed about Elon Musk. They laughed
- 11:46about giga casting. And now we see that
- 11:49they missed exactly that train.
- 11:52>> Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer saying Germany
- 11:54has to change. Thanks so much for
- 11:56talking to DW.
- 11:59>> Yeah, you're welcome.
- 12:01Take care. Bye-bye.
- 12:03>> What do you think? Is this the end of
- 12:05German-made cars or the beginning of the
- 12:07end? Let us know in the comments. I'm
- 12:09David Levitz. Thanks for watching.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Mercedes halts investments in Germany, says may shut down factories | DW News by DW News, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,694 words across 276 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.