YouTube2Text

Men and Women after #metoo, a new relationship? (part 1 of 3) — Transcript

by Rebel Wisdom · 5,532 words · 783 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00[Music]
  2. 0:05welcome to the latest rebel wisdom
  3. 0:07podcast I'm really excited about this
  4. 0:09one because it's some of the best
  5. 0:12interviews that we've done recently that
  6. 0:14we're making live at the same time as
  7. 0:16we're releasing this I'm going to show
  8. 0:18some clips from them and there is a
  9. 0:21theme and the theme is masculinity and I
  10. 0:25guess the sub theme is it's what about a
  11. 0:29year now since me too and since a lot of
  12. 0:32these gender dynamics started becoming
  13. 0:33really prevalent and really part of the
  14. 0:36culture and that's been a big theme of a
  15. 0:37lot of the stuff that we've been doing
  16. 0:38so what we've got coming up at the same
  17. 0:41time is two interviews and another round
  18. 0:46of content probably bout a week after
  19. 0:48that so we have an interview with Cassie
  20. 0:51J who directed the red pill film and
  21. 0:54we've got into Warren Farrell who is
  22. 0:57often called the father of the men's
  23. 1:00movement but I think our experience when
  24. 1:03we met him in America and interviewed
  25. 1:06him is that he's got a lot more to offer
  26. 1:10than that sort of characterization he's
  27. 1:12a therapist he does couples counseling
  28. 1:14he's deeply interested in how to create
  29. 1:16healthy relationships and this
  30. 1:18ultimately I think is the theme of a lot
  31. 1:21of the content we're putting out is what
  32. 1:25if if what we're seeing at the moment is
  33. 1:28tantamount to a kind of dysfunctional
  34. 1:30relationship between men and women
  35. 1:32playing out on the wider cultural stage
  36. 1:34what does a healthy relationship look
  37. 1:36like kind of linked to what we've been
  38. 1:38discussing recently around the shadow I
  39. 1:40think along with that question is what
  40. 1:42is the shadow of masculinity but then
  41. 1:45also less discussed what is the shadow
  42. 1:48of femininity and I was thinking about
  43. 1:52this but before I think about this a lot
  44. 1:54actually because the shadow of the
  45. 1:57masculine that that was the me to
  46. 2:00movement as well was kind of showing up
  47. 2:03the shadow of the masculine which is
  48. 2:04obviously something that needs to happen
  49. 2:06the shadow of the feminine is harder to
  50. 2:10pin down I think
  51. 2:11if you look at it in if you were to take
  52. 2:14it just as a thought experiment in kind
  53. 2:15of Taoist terms and you had each
  54. 2:18opposite implies the other but there
  55. 2:21really have to be opposite so if you see
  56. 2:23and they would in kind of Chinese towers
  57. 2:26and they see the masculine is obvious
  58. 2:28and it's bright and it's right there
  59. 2:31so the masculine shadow would be the
  60. 2:34same it's so clear it's domination it's
  61. 2:37controlled it's it's sort of its
  62. 2:39aggressive it's all these things that
  63. 2:41are quite easy to look at and easy to
  64. 2:43define absolutely so by by that then the
  65. 2:47shadow of the feminine should
  66. 2:48automatically be shrouded mysterious
  67. 2:51complex and I think that is one of the
  68. 2:55powerful things about the red pill in
  69. 2:56the whole phenomena of red pilling is
  70. 2:58that it lifts a veil on AHA Wade this
  71. 3:03there's a sense with the red pill I
  72. 3:05think that a lot of people have watching
  73. 3:06it I certainly did where I had a sense
  74. 3:10of were the very water the very cultural
  75. 3:13water I was swimming in is not what they
  76. 3:15appear to be I think it I want to
  77. 3:17interject here because we're two men
  78. 3:22talking about the female shadow what I
  79. 3:24want to say and what I think is really
  80. 3:26interesting about the content we've got
  81. 3:27coming up because we've got there was a
  82. 3:29film done by a friend of ours Hannah who
  83. 3:33did this film called from women to men
  84. 3:35all about the female shadow and we've
  85. 3:38got a long interview with her and a long
  86. 3:39interview with a couple of the other
  87. 3:40women who appeared in that film about
  88. 3:42the female shadow and about their
  89. 3:44ownership of of the ways they've acted
  90. 3:47out and I think what's interesting as
  91. 3:49well now is that there is a cultural as
  92. 3:51I said we're about a year after me too
  93. 3:52and I think the cultural conversation is
  94. 3:56now at this point of recognizing we had
  95. 4:00me to this kind of essential voicing of
  96. 4:03a lot of suppressed anger or a lot of
  97. 4:05suppress a lot of boundary setting by
  98. 4:07women saying no this is not acceptable
  99. 4:09behavior and where we are now especially
  100. 4:12with Asia Argento one of the prime
  101. 4:15movers of the me to movement has the
  102. 4:21has turned out to be it looks a sexual
  103. 4:24predator herself who'd paid off an
  104. 4:27underaged guy that she'd slept with and
  105. 4:30there was a really interesting article
  106. 4:32quite recently by Barry Weiss in the New
  107. 4:34York Times where she said this shows
  108. 4:37that women are human too which is
  109. 4:40basically what a lot of people have
  110. 4:44wanted to hear it's like this this very
  111. 4:46simplistic dynamic of women as only
  112. 4:49victims and men as only perpetrators is
  113. 4:51such a one-sided dynamic and now the
  114. 4:56cultural conversation seems to have
  115. 4:58swung to to this this place where we are
  116. 5:02hopefully allowed to say men have a dark
  117. 5:06side women have a dark side and it can
  118. 5:09now be a more balanced conversation and
  119. 5:11that's what I think really exciting
  120. 5:12about the content we're putting out
  121. 5:13because I think we're asking that
  122. 5:14question and we're also asking
  123. 5:17especially in the response to the red
  124. 5:19pill like there's one thing as the film
  125. 5:22and the the other thing is the cultural
  126. 5:26response to the film and the incredibly
  127. 5:28harsh reception that it got from a lot
  128. 5:30of media platforms especially millennial
  129. 5:31platforms like Vox and Vice I mean the
  130. 5:35red pill is a very controversial film
  131. 5:37and there were quite a few things said
  132. 5:40about it and it was when we were in
  133. 5:42America interviewing Warren Farrell and
  134. 5:44he happens to be a neighbor of Cassie J
  135. 5:45the the woman who made it and Cassie J
  136. 5:48still describes herself as a liberal she
  137. 5:50was a feminist when she went into making
  138. 5:51the film and I I had a bit of a
  139. 5:55suspicion as a filmmaker watching it it
  140. 5:58just seemed so convenient that a
  141. 6:02self-described feminist would go inside
  142. 6:04the men's rights movement and have her
  143. 6:06mind changed by what she found and I
  144. 6:08have to say I was a little bit
  145. 6:09suspicious about that I was a little bit
  146. 6:10suspicious about how how it was a
  147. 6:14perfect narrative and speaking to Warren
  148. 6:18and this was unprompted I wasn't kind of
  149. 6:21we weren't interrogating him about
  150. 6:22Kathy's journey or anything like that he
  151. 6:24just volunteered that Cassie had come to
  152. 6:26him and said I went in I wanted to do
  153. 6:29something we were an expose on the men's
  154. 6:31rights activists
  155. 6:32and even when she interviewed them she
  156. 6:35had in the back of her mind a lot of
  157. 6:38feminist talking points and a lot of
  158. 6:40arguments without the way of saying and
  159. 6:42it wasn't until she started watching the
  160. 6:45the rushes back watching the the the
  161. 6:47film back the footage to make the
  162. 6:49documentary that she started listening
  163. 6:51more to what they were saying and
  164. 6:53understanding what they were saying and
  165. 6:54came out with an appreciation of wow
  166. 6:56there are some men's stories that are
  167. 6:58not being heard there are some struggles
  168. 7:01that men are having that are not being
  169. 7:02heard and are not part of the
  170. 7:03conversation and so she like I have
  171. 7:08pretty much 100% certainty that her
  172. 7:12journey was genuine and this was a
  173. 7:15subtext of an awful lot of the the
  174. 7:18coverage that the the need that sort of
  175. 7:20negative coverage of the red pill was
  176. 7:24people saying well just insinuating it
  177. 7:28wasn't genuine that it was somehow it
  178. 7:29was funded by men's rights activists and
  179. 7:31it was a it was a Trojan horse done by
  180. 7:34men's rights activists and I don't
  181. 7:36believe that I think it was a genuine
  182. 7:38film I think it was a genuine journey
  183. 7:39and the irony is under a different in a
  184. 7:44different circumstance she might be
  185. 7:45looked on as a as a real feminist hero
  186. 7:48she's a very successful documentary
  187. 7:51filmmaker I think with a lot of bravery
  188. 7:54as well she she talks about she did
  189. 7:55actually lose some some friends when she
  190. 7:58made the film and she I saw recently
  191. 8:01she's even been outed or by the Prophet
  192. 8:04the Southern Poverty Law Center which is
  193. 8:06a kind of anti extremist organization in
  194. 8:09America which seems to be an extremist
  195. 8:13organization itself it had to backtrack
  196. 8:15it it outed magical or Nawaz recently as
  197. 8:18an extremist and he is an anti extremist
  198. 8:21former Islamist that's really
  199. 8:23fascinating what can be said in the cult
  200. 8:25from what can't be said in the culture
  201. 8:26and the fact that a documentary like the
  202. 8:27red pill which along along with the
  203. 8:30men's rights activists in it also had a
  204. 8:32lot of feminist scholars in it as well
  205. 8:35and you don't have to kind of agree with
  206. 8:39everything the men's rights activists
  207. 8:40are saying in it but in terms of a film
  208. 8:43that adds an interesting perspective I
  209. 8:45think it's definite
  210. 8:46it definitely is that that film because
  211. 8:48why it was really interesting to talk to
  212. 8:49Cassie yeah just to back to your point
  213. 8:52about what you said that if I'm not
  214. 8:53really interesting in a different
  215. 8:55setting
  216. 8:55she might be held as a feminist hero I
  217. 8:58think that's true and I'm just trying to
  218. 9:00imagine what that setting might be it
  219. 9:02certainly it certainly seems kind of
  220. 9:04impossible now with the way feminism has
  221. 9:06moved at least because it's much more
  222. 9:08around it is in extra pick inextricably
  223. 9:12tied to the same postmodern ideologies
  224. 9:15that a lot of activism is tied to a lot
  225. 9:18of critical theory is kind of an
  226. 9:20academia is linked up in with the
  227. 9:22oppressor oppressed again a name just
  228. 9:24came up we were talking another very
  229. 9:27successful woman Clare layman and
  230. 9:29created the magazine quill let out of
  231. 9:31her kitchen and it's now one of the sort
  232. 9:33of most the biggest media success
  233. 9:36stories of the last couple of years but
  234. 9:39because quill let is very deliberately
  235. 9:42anti identity politics and an to the
  236. 9:45social justice left she is attacked on
  237. 9:47Twitter rather than celebrated as a as a
  238. 9:49successful woman the fact that it
  239. 9:52doesn't really matter even if you the
  240. 9:54ideology Trump's the personal story
  241. 9:57pretty much all the time with the
  242. 9:59identity politics left mmm yeah it does
  243. 10:01and it's it's also it's an impossible
  244. 10:05bind and it's also an interesting it
  245. 10:07it's an interesting indication the
  246. 10:08reaction to Clayman and Cassie J it for
  247. 10:13me really points this weirdness that we
  248. 10:15live in where the the identity politics
  249. 10:18left in particular has kind of the
  250. 10:20reigns of what's culturally acceptable
  251. 10:24and a lot of pop culture power and a lot
  252. 10:27of media power so they cannot even
  253. 10:32though they can act as the oppressor
  254. 10:34they can never admit that their acting
  255. 10:35is the oppressor because the entire
  256. 10:36worldview is based and there's only
  257. 10:38oppressor and oppressed and so when they
  258. 10:40are always on the side of the underdog
  259. 10:41yeah and so this makes it impossible for
  260. 10:44them to look inward of themselves and
  261. 10:46realize that they now have the power or
  262. 10:49a lot of power
  263. 10:50more than perhaps they realize or maybe
  264. 10:52not realize but want to realize and
  265. 10:55they're not using it responsibly and
  266. 10:56this is this the story of the last few
  267. 11:00years for me I think if you see it
  268. 11:02echoed everywhere and you see it echoed
  269. 11:04in the gender discussion as well I think
  270. 11:06so let's just hear a quick clip from
  271. 11:07that interview with Cassie I know that
  272. 11:09it helps a lot of people making this
  273. 11:12film and and but I don't think it's I
  274. 11:17don't think we're anywhere near where we
  275. 11:19need to be and I think the red pill
  276. 11:21movie was just a very early kind of
  277. 11:23icebreaker into these conversations but
  278. 11:25I think we have a long way to go with
  279. 11:27gender relations and and hopefully
  280. 11:30eventually finding a healthier
  281. 11:32relationship between the genders and the
  282. 11:35other interview that we're really
  283. 11:36excited about putting out is with Warren
  284. 11:38Farrell and we've talked before about
  285. 11:41how if you see culture as a kind of
  286. 11:44fractal pattern then the the fractal
  287. 11:48pattern or the patterns that we saw
  288. 11:49during the late 60s are still here but
  289. 11:52they've just got bigger and the the
  290. 11:54gender dynamics that first erupted in
  291. 11:56the 60s the rise of women's liberation
  292. 11:59and feminism and this this now to me
  293. 12:04feels like we're in the same dynamic but
  294. 12:06we look back and we kind of looked
  295. 12:08through the wrong end of the telescope
  296. 12:08we assumed that everyone back in the 60s
  297. 12:12was part of this movement but the fact
  298. 12:14that it that we know about it shows that
  299. 12:16it wasn't universal it was it was an
  300. 12:19outlier it was a new thing it was we
  301. 12:22were always attuned to the new and what
  302. 12:25some interesting about Warren Farrell is
  303. 12:27that he has been living this dynamic
  304. 12:29this same dynamic since the 60s a
  305. 12:32fascinating individual story because he
  306. 12:35was one of the very first male feminists
  307. 12:37he was part of the he was on the board
  308. 12:38of the National Organization for Women
  309. 12:40in America and he he then at the same
  310. 12:45time started leading men's groups and in
  311. 12:47the men's groups he was hearing stories
  312. 12:49that he realized were not part of the
  313. 12:50conversation and when he started
  314. 12:53bringing the experience of the way that
  315. 12:54men have been hurt and the way that men
  316. 12:56feel that they have to perform certain
  317. 12:58gender roles and that they are seen as
  318. 13:00success he uses the words for example
  319. 13:02that yes women
  320. 13:04women are often objectified and seen as
  321. 13:07sex objects and judged by their looks
  322. 13:09men feel that they're often judged by
  323. 13:11success he calls success objects they're
  324. 13:14judged by their ability to provide
  325. 13:16they're judged by their wealth they're
  326. 13:19judged by their status there was a
  327. 13:21beautiful moment I really I know that we
  328. 13:25both really enjoyed meeting him and
  329. 13:26spending time with him there's a really
  330. 13:28beautiful moment towards the end of the
  331. 13:29interview where he said men have makeup
  332. 13:31to male makeup is I am dr. Warren
  333. 13:35Farrell best-selling author of the boy
  334. 13:37crisis and what's my makeup I'm doctor
  335. 13:40best-selling author
  336. 13:43that's all makeup it's me being afraid
  337. 13:46of saying I'm also Warren Farrell
  338. 13:49vulnerable human being in these five or
  339. 13:51six ways considering he's often framed
  340. 13:54as the father of the men's movement and
  341. 13:56the men's movement especially in America
  342. 13:58has a really bad reputation and perhaps
  343. 14:01quite rightly I mean I asked him that in
  344. 14:03the interview whether he agreed that
  345. 14:05some of the bad press at the men's
  346. 14:07movement had was deserved and he agreed
  347. 14:08that it was and I think certainly a lot
  348. 14:11of the tactics that I see from some of
  349. 14:13the more extreme men's rights activists
  350. 14:15in America I can see why they have a bad
  351. 14:17reputation and it's not I don't think
  352. 14:20it's doing they're there cause any good
  353. 14:22they they kind of turn into the thing
  354. 14:24that they're supposedly fighting against
  355. 14:26but as I said at the beginning Warren
  356. 14:30Farrell is someone who's very much
  357. 14:32focused on what the healthy
  358. 14:34relationships look like what are the
  359. 14:36things that need to be expressed from
  360. 14:39men and from women so that we can have
  361. 14:40healthy relationships and if we have a
  362. 14:43culture where men are on one hand
  363. 14:48encouraged to express their feelings but
  364. 14:52also on the other hand often the culture
  365. 14:55will describe it as whining when then do
  366. 14:57express their feelings there's a kind of
  367. 14:59double bind and a lot of men feel stuck
  368. 15:02in that in the moment yeah what really
  369. 15:05struck me about Warren Farrell aside
  370. 15:07from him is an individual that I found
  371. 15:08it's very authentic is his his focus in
  372. 15:13in the myth of male power his first kind
  373. 15:15of best selling
  374. 15:15book it's very nuanced and it's really a
  375. 15:19balanced perspective of going into the
  376. 15:21economics and that also dictated the
  377. 15:26relationship structures we had for a
  378. 15:28very long time
  379. 15:29and pointing out that it's not as simple
  380. 15:31as just saying men were patriarchs and
  381. 15:33they held women down and just because
  382. 15:35you know because they're dysfunctional
  383. 15:36in some way it was it was a lot more
  384. 15:39complex than that and yes some of that
  385. 15:41went on of course but it was also a case
  386. 15:44of men had to go out and be the
  387. 15:46breadwinners men were expendable as well
  388. 15:49and then we shifted in the 60s and maybe
  389. 15:53slightly before to different kind of
  390. 15:55relationship for the first time ever
  391. 15:56happening so this is all very new the
  392. 15:58dynamics are experiencing all really
  393. 16:00fresh like yeah and so and now we said
  394. 16:04in the interview really nice thing which
  395. 16:06was around like we're not designed to be
  396. 16:09functional
  397. 16:10we're design in terms of like
  398. 16:11relationships how we relate to each
  399. 16:13other's men and women like which is time
  400. 16:14to be dysfunctional
  401. 16:15we're designed to survive basically what
  402. 16:17he says and that you know so we have he
  403. 16:20says we have an opportunity now where we
  404. 16:23have a lot more equality to figure out
  405. 16:25how do we how the hell do we get on with
  406. 16:28each other in a in a way that is
  407. 16:31conducive to our health and our
  408. 16:32children's health as well and I found
  409. 16:34that was the overriding message I got
  410. 16:36from him I think is in his work as well
  411. 16:38is it's really about I find that really
  412. 16:41useful framing that globally and I think
  413. 16:43we might have talked about this before
  414. 16:44what we're seeing is the result of an
  415. 16:47incredibly dysfunctional relationship
  416. 16:49it's like the gender dynamics we're
  417. 16:51seeing on the macro scale feel like the
  418. 16:54micro scale would be like two parents
  419. 16:56having a massive argument more like two
  420. 16:59teenagers having a massive argument I
  421. 17:00think there's a second part to that
  422. 17:02interview with Warren Farrell which is
  423. 17:04going to be a patreon exclusive so if
  424. 17:06you want to see that become a patron I
  425. 17:08hope that we are now at a stage where
  426. 17:11all sides of that debate can be heard
  427. 17:14because the eruption of Me 2 which was
  428. 17:17October last year it were it was said
  429. 17:19quite explicitly at times men now is now
  430. 17:23is not your time to speak and I can
  431. 17:25understand that because these are a lot
  432. 17:28of the time or voices that have
  433. 17:29heard for a long time and but that it
  434. 17:33cannot remain that cannot remain as a
  435. 17:36dynamic by definition a relationship has
  436. 17:39to be both sides speaking and I think a
  437. 17:44healthy relationship is where both sides
  438. 17:45are allowed to speak and I think a
  439. 17:47healthy cultural dynamic is when
  440. 17:50something like the red pill is made it
  441. 17:53is not immediately shut down is it not
  442. 17:55immediately criticized as I think vice
  443. 17:57called it you men's men's rights
  444. 17:59documentary another thing just
  445. 18:02came up for me that that he said
  446. 18:04relating to the kind of that I guess
  447. 18:07necessary outburst that happens after me
  448. 18:10to was you know procedure therapist who
  449. 18:13said obviously the longer someone's held
  450. 18:15something in the more it comes the more
  451. 18:17anger is behind it when it finally comes
  452. 18:19out and now I think was that was very
  453. 18:22evident there and that makes sense
  454. 18:24and I wonder now I see that anger as
  455. 18:27well in the men's rights movement as
  456. 18:29well and I understand why it's there too
  457. 18:31I do
  458. 18:32but the what the next stage looks like
  459. 18:36for me is a kind of a meeting where the
  460. 18:41anger has extinguished itself somewhat
  461. 18:43and maybe we're getting to that point
  462. 18:44but where the conversation comes it's a
  463. 18:47conversation about responsibility I
  464. 18:49think ultimately it's a conversation on
  465. 18:51both sides around what does it mean to
  466. 18:56be responsible for yourself and your
  467. 18:58actions as a human being
  468. 18:59whether you're a man or woman that's
  469. 19:00what you do in couple you know in
  470. 19:01couples counseling you talk from the eye
  471. 19:03you talk about yourself you talk about
  472. 19:05you don't you know actually again Warren
  473. 19:08made a really good point where he said
  474. 19:09having a dynamic like feminism has at
  475. 19:13the moment where everything is men's
  476. 19:15fault I'm being broad with families and
  477. 19:16I'm talking about maybe the the worst
  478. 19:18sides of it where everything is men's
  479. 19:20fault
  480. 19:21he equates it to a man going to a
  481. 19:23psychiatrist and sitting down I mean
  482. 19:25like right okay well I'm here but what
  483. 19:28you need to know is that everything is
  484. 19:29my wife's fault
  485. 19:30the reason I'm Peter is because of her
  486. 19:32and I've listed out 14 points around
  487. 19:35where she's a total out and I'm
  488. 19:36gonna list them out to you and you
  489. 19:37better agree with me otherwise I'm gonna
  490. 19:39stop
  491. 19:39the therapist selection and a similar
  492. 19:41impossible dynamic where nothing can
  493. 19:43happen that I still feel is what we're
  494. 19:46kind of largely in and that's why people
  495. 19:49are allowed to talk at university that's
  496. 19:50why Cassie is still as of like today
  497. 19:52getting slammed in the press and why
  498. 19:54there's just a lot of
  499. 19:55mischaracterization all around the place
  500. 19:58and I think something has to give some
  501. 20:00kind of humility or humanity has to give
  502. 20:04in order for that conversation start
  503. 20:06happening and on that point it might be
  504. 20:09a good time to talk about Hannah's film
  505. 20:12yeah so this is one of the most
  506. 20:16interesting and it's a sort of
  507. 20:18experimental thing that we've done Hanna
  508. 20:21produced this film which has gone pretty
  509. 20:23viral on online called from women to men
  510. 20:25I am a woman
  511. 20:28[Music]
  512. 20:30who has been hurt by men I'm a woman who
  513. 20:36has hurt men who has hurt men and she's
  514. 20:39a she's a conflict negotiator that's
  515. 20:42what she did for many years in some of
  516. 20:44the world so the most intractable
  517. 20:45conflict and the thing that she realized
  518. 20:48is that we cannot move forward until you
  519. 20:51own our part of whatever dynamic we
  520. 20:54can't move forward in any in any
  521. 20:56conflict until we own our side and we
  522. 20:58own the stuff that we've done and she
  523. 21:02then went through a process of sending
  524. 21:05this poem out to many other women and
  525. 21:07they then came together to make the film
  526. 21:10and a lot of them would then choose the
  527. 21:12bits of the poem that really spoke to
  528. 21:14them the things that they'd done in the
  529. 21:16past and a lot of them said they went
  530. 21:18through a real process through doing it
  531. 21:19as well there's a really controversial
  532. 21:22piece it's it had really polarized
  533. 21:25reaction online but it's had about a
  534. 21:26million views altogether and I've seen a
  535. 21:28lot of especially men from some of the
  536. 21:31the men's groups that I've seen online
  537. 21:32very touched by it a lot of people said
  538. 21:35it brought them to tears I do mean over
  539. 21:40time when we all take responsibility for
  540. 21:43the part each of us plays in this battle
  541. 21:45when we can truly empower ourselves by
  542. 21:49owning our parts of the mess and bring
  543. 21:53an end to the cycle of hurting and
  544. 21:55blaming I begin today I begin today I
  545. 22:01begin today I begin today you got a
  546. 22:06couple of films off the back of that one
  547. 22:07of which is an interview with Hannah and
  548. 22:10a couple of the other women who appeared
  549. 22:12in the film asking why why they've got
  550. 22:16involved in the project in the first
  551. 22:17place what they got from it and what the
  552. 22:20reaction was whether they have any
  553. 22:21regrets and another film which is
  554. 22:26slightly more experimental which is and
  555. 22:29as Hannah said in her in her film what
  556. 22:32she wanted was to start a new kind of
  557. 22:33conversation between women women and men
  558. 22:35and so we try and model that with Hannah
  559. 22:40her friend Elaine who appears in the
  560. 22:42film myself and Rath
  561. 22:44who is a facilitator a therapist who's
  562. 22:47been working for about 40 years with
  563. 22:48these issues the male and the female so
  564. 22:51basically this is an attempt to model
  565. 22:54this kind of conversation what does a
  566. 22:56healthy conversation between men and
  567. 22:57women look like which involves us taking
  568. 23:00ownership of our staff and then meeting
  569. 23:02from a place of real ownership and real
  570. 23:05communication and we'll see if that
  571. 23:08works yeah well hopefully it kind of has
  572. 23:11to work I think at some point globally
  573. 23:14that kind of conversation has to be the
  574. 23:15norm and in fact again to bring it back
  575. 23:18to Warren Farrell opus it was a long
  576. 23:19interview and he said lots of
  577. 23:20interesting things they're doing it in
  578. 23:22Denmark they're having their teaching
  579. 23:24children these types of conversation and
  580. 23:27that seems the natural thing is that
  581. 23:29this is a skill that people need to have
  582. 23:31is to be able to and I think personal
  583. 23:34responsibility is the beginning of it
  584. 23:37and I think what's really powerful about
  585. 23:40Hannah's film or just powerful about
  586. 23:42just the idea of that kind of
  587. 23:43conversation is that it starts with
  588. 23:45personal responsibility and that's where
  589. 23:47that seems to be what the culture is
  590. 23:49crying out for at the moment is this
  591. 23:51kind of a reconnection to personal
  592. 23:52responsibility and a movement away from
  593. 23:54everything's about being oppressed or
  594. 23:56being an oppressor and either being a
  595. 23:58victim or a perpetrator it's the yeah it
  596. 24:02seems to me like it that conversation
  597. 24:04can't really happen within that the
  598. 24:07environment within an environment based
  599. 24:10on a press or oppressed I think that
  600. 24:12just has to go like the broken green
  601. 24:14we've called it it had it's not a place
  602. 24:17for that conversation to happen that
  603. 24:18conversation needs to happen in some
  604. 24:21kind of new less ideological or post
  605. 24:25ideological space which hopefully is
  606. 24:28rising up somewhere or in the ether
  607. 24:31somewhere at the moment yeah I also want
  608. 24:33to say about Hannah's Vil that I've had
  609. 24:35very different reactions to it at
  610. 24:36different times when I first heard it
  611. 24:38when she delivered it as a poem in a
  612. 24:40therapeutic training I was really
  613. 24:42touched and it was it was a really
  614. 24:45powerful ownership and then when I've
  615. 24:47seen it since and I've seen the film
  616. 24:48sometimes I watched it and I just
  617. 24:50thought wow this is just it's so
  618. 24:53countercultural it almost feels too much
  619. 24:55because on its own it does feel
  620. 24:57balance it's like well okay but that's
  621. 25:00kind of the point is that it's almost
  622. 25:02like a little bomb in that inside that
  623. 25:04ideology because it's so anti the
  624. 25:07narrative that we live with all the time
  625. 25:08for women to pretty much just own their
  626. 25:14their stuff without any kind of context
  627. 25:19or balancing of men owning their stuff
  628. 25:21at the same time so it feels you know
  629. 25:24what
  630. 25:24on its own it feels slightly unbalanced
  631. 25:26but I guess that's the essence of great
  632. 25:28art in a way great art is not meant to
  633. 25:30make you feel comfortable it's mostly
  634. 25:32supposed to make you feel uncomfortable
  635. 25:33and even I have felt uncomfortable
  636. 25:35watching that film every now and again
  637. 25:37and yeah I hope that in the recording
  638. 25:42that we've put together with raffia
  639. 25:43there's a certain balance in terms of us
  640. 25:46owning our stuff and then building more
  641. 25:48of a complete conversation around it as
  642. 25:50well as you were as you're describing
  643. 25:52that that I know that feeling I call it
  644. 25:55like vicarious discomfort it's like a
  645. 25:58sense of how something will land in the
  646. 26:00culture and I feel like some part of me
  647. 26:03which of course were tribal pea beings
  648. 26:04now even if even there's a lot within
  649. 26:07the culture below I disagree with I
  650. 26:08still feel that twins I've again had a
  651. 26:11similar experience watching Hannah's
  652. 26:12film I think the first time it was
  653. 26:13incredibly emotional you know it's a
  654. 26:15real - really but a real heartfelt
  655. 26:18feeling of like relief of like wow okay
  656. 26:20that feels really just very loving and
  657. 26:23very responsible like really a really
  658. 26:25powerful loving feminine energy that it
  659. 26:29comes with that but also that feeling of
  660. 26:32like wow this is gonna be dynamite
  661. 26:33remember that was the that was what I
  662. 26:34thought first time so I was like wow
  663. 26:35this is gonna this is definitely gonna
  664. 26:37ruffle some feathers which it has yes
  665. 26:40yeah but again feather ruffling is is
  666. 26:43the point of art I think the point of
  667. 26:46good art and that's what leads to yeah
  668. 26:49growth I think it's worth also saying
  669. 26:51that our interest in these subjects it
  670. 26:53probably comes from our own histories in
  671. 26:56terms of a lot of the the kind of the
  672. 26:58inner work that we've done around
  673. 27:00masculinity we both teach men's work and
  674. 27:04ultimately these questions can only be
  675. 27:07resolved really an embodied
  676. 27:10it it cannot just become a conversation
  677. 27:13about masculinity and femininity because
  678. 27:15then you get into this kind of swampy
  679. 27:17relativistic suit of or what do you mean
  680. 27:19by masculine what do you mean by
  681. 27:20feminine surely we're just humans and
  682. 27:22then it it all starts to kind of become
  683. 27:24very relativistic very quickly whereas I
  684. 27:27know that my experience of doing work or
  685. 27:32a really connect with myself in my
  686. 27:34masculine that there's a real embodied
  687. 27:36presence that I can bring to these
  688. 27:37questions and then a lot of these kind
  689. 27:38of gender dynamics resolve themselves
  690. 27:41very very quickly and if you're watching
  691. 27:45this new you're interested in this
  692. 27:47subject we are teaching we've got a
  693. 27:49men's workshop coming up in November
  694. 27:50we've got a women's workshop coming up
  695. 27:52in September at the end of September
  696. 27:54that is being taught by some amazing
  697. 27:57facilitators including Hannah actually
  698. 27:59who did the film and we've got a
  699. 28:02polarity workshop coming up in January
  700. 28:04as well I think it's so important to tie
  701. 28:06this this content the ideas together
  702. 28:09with the embodied work because otherwise
  703. 28:12if we just stay up in the heads we just
  704. 28:13stay up in the conceptual realm and then
  705. 28:15nothing gets resolved I think it's also
  706. 28:17important to add none of the workshops
  707. 28:19about telling anyone what masculinity or
  708. 28:22femininity is it's really because you
  709. 28:24can't you each individual has to connect
  710. 28:27to what that is experientially within
  711. 28:30themselves and a space like that it's
  712. 28:33it's a flow state it's getting into a
  713. 28:35flow state and in a flow state the
  714. 28:38concepts the ideas they are of like
  715. 28:41they're not important at all in a sense
  716. 28:43it's the experience and so experience
  717. 28:46again is also what really like meeting
  718. 28:48human to human and communicating human
  719. 28:50to human that's also absolutely key in
  720. 28:54developing our own ideas but then also
  721. 28:56developing ideas collectively and on
  722. 28:59that now we also have another event
  723. 29:00coming up which is join the great
  724. 29:03intellectual awakening and that's going
  725. 29:05to be on the 18th of September in London
  726. 29:08we'll put
  727. 29:09notes down in the show notes with a link
  728. 29:12to it but again that event it's not just
  729. 29:14us talking about what's that's run it
  730. 29:17this is pretty much us trying to create
  731. 29:19that we've always wanted to create a
  732. 29:21community around these ideas and this is
  733. 29:24our first event to try and create that
  734. 29:25kind of community so we're gonna talk
  735. 29:28about rebel wisdoms were gonna talk
  736. 29:30about a history and show some of the
  737. 29:31clips from some of the films and then
  738. 29:33trying to create some kind of way of
  739. 29:36having having these kind of generative
  740. 29:37dialogues which we've talked about
  741. 29:39before what does it mean to have a
  742. 29:41dialogue where you go in genuinely
  743. 29:43trying from a place of not knowing and
  744. 29:45inquiring and and finding the answers
  745. 29:48for yourselves rather than this kind of
  746. 29:50very ideological way of trying to kind
  747. 29:53of persuade someone that you're right
  748. 29:54yeah or what Jordan Greene whole talk
  749. 29:55about like the old broadcast model or
  750. 29:58something you know T we cultural be
  751. 30:01broadcast to you an idea through
  752. 30:02broadcast to you and we live in a
  753. 30:04different paradigm now which is the more
  754. 30:06decentralized kind of knowledge sharing
  755. 30:1018th of September if you're in London
  756. 30:12come along to the great intellectual
  757. 30:14awakening and one other thing we've got
  758. 30:19we've recently put up a few pieces on
  759. 30:21patreon for patrons only
  760. 30:24we've got another amazing piece with Tim
  761. 30:27lot who we had an interview with
  762. 30:29recently talking about the links between
  763. 30:32Jordan Peterson and Alan Watts and
  764. 30:35Jordan Pederson has often been described
  765. 30:38as doing for Western philosophy and
  766. 30:42Western spirituality what Alan Watts did
  767. 30:46for Eastern spirituality back in the 50s
  768. 30:48and 60s and there's really interesting
  769. 30:51parallels between the two and really
  770. 30:54interesting differences between the two
  771. 30:55as well and Tim lot who was the first
  772. 30:57guy to write a profile of Jordan
  773. 30:59Peterson for The Spectator magazine in
  774. 31:02look yeah last year also is an expert on
  775. 31:07Alan Watts so we had a really
  776. 31:09interesting dialogue with Tim and that's
  777. 31:11we're gonna put that live on patreon in
  778. 31:13the next few days so if you're
  779. 31:15interested in that or you want to see
  780. 31:16the second part of the Warren Farrell
  781. 31:17interview then become a patron
  782. 31:21thanks for watching and see you next
  783. 31:22time

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Men and Women after #metoo, a new relationship? (part 1 of 3) by Rebel Wisdom, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,532 words across 783 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.