Meister Eckhart: The Enlightened Man The Church ALMOST Executed — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Time is what keeps the light from
- 0:02reaching us. There is no greater
- 0:04obstacle to God than time.
- 0:06Meister Eckhart,
- 0:08Sermon 67.
- 0:11All things were created out of
- 0:12nothingness, and thus their true origin
- 0:14is the not.
- 0:16Meister Eckhart, Sermon 52.
- 0:20God is not found in the soul by adding
- 0:22anything, but by subtracting.
- 0:24Meister Eckhart, attributed.
- 0:27All things are born of being. Being is
- 0:29born of non-being.
- 0:31Lao Tzu, The Tao Te Ching.
- 0:37Meister Eckhart, the 14th century
- 0:39medieval mystic, shattered theological
- 0:42boundaries and beckoned humanity to a
- 0:44transcendent realm, challenging minds to
- 0:48grasp the ungraspable, and inviting
- 0:50souls to dance with the divine.
- 0:53Meister Eckhart's extraordinary
- 0:54mysticism is rooted in a profound
- 0:57understanding of the intimate
- 0:58relationship between the human soul and
- 1:00the divine.
- 1:02Eckhart's teachings deeply challenged
- 1:04the spiritual understanding of the time.
- 1:07He pointed to a God beyond
- 1:08conceptualization,
- 1:10a God with which one could have a
- 1:12direct, unmediated communion.
- 1:14Eckhart's exploration of the ground of
- 1:16the soul reveals the very essence of
- 1:18human existence. His spiritual concepts
- 1:21of the relationship between the Godhead
- 1:23and God still have the capacity to
- 1:25awaken one spiritually and to radically
- 1:28change one's understanding of the
- 1:29divine.
- 1:31Meister Eckhart's insights have not only
- 1:33inspired innumerable spiritual seekers,
- 1:35but also informed and inspired many of
- 1:37the deepest thinkers of Western
- 1:39philosophy, such as Martin Heidegger.
- 1:42Today, Eckhart continues to invite
- 1:44contemplation and dialogue at the
- 1:47intersection of profound spirituality
- 1:49and radical intellectual inquiry.
- 1:52Born in 1260,
- 1:53Eckhart's life unfolded in an era marked
- 1:56by intellectual ferment, religious
- 1:58fervor, and political upheaval.
- 2:01Eckhart entered the Dominican order at
- 2:03an early age and began to pursue
- 2:05spiritual knowledge within the confines
- 2:07of a monastic setting.
- 2:09Dominican friars are well known for
- 2:11their commitment to scholarship, and
- 2:12they provided Eckhart with a platform to
- 2:14immerse himself in Christian theological
- 2:16thought.
- 2:18However, as Eckhart's intellectual
- 2:20pursuits unfolded, so did his mystical
- 2:22inclinations. Eckhart began to deeply
- 2:25inquire into profound theological
- 2:27concepts, particularly the relationship
- 2:30of one's soul to God.
- 2:32Eckhart became increasingly convinced
- 2:35that if one was to experience the
- 2:36divine, it could only happen presently,
- 2:39that is, in the present moment. Thus,
- 2:42Eckhart began to see the concept of time
- 2:44itself as one of the greatest barriers
- 2:47to the experience of God.
- 2:49He also began to intuit and understand a
- 2:52radical difference between God and the
- 2:54Godhead.
- 2:55This concept has the capacity to utterly
- 2:57revolutionize our spiritual
- 2:59understanding.
- 3:00Another theological concept which would
- 3:02become important throughout Meister
- 3:04Eckhart's life was detachment.
- 3:07For Eckhart, detachment was not a mere
- 3:09renunciation of the material world, but
- 3:12a dynamic process of inner liberation, a
- 3:15letting go of all attachments that
- 3:17hindered the soul's union with the
- 3:18divine.
- 3:19We will explore Eckhart's concept of the
- 3:21Godhead and the importance of detachment
- 3:24and Gelassenheit in more detail further
- 3:26in this video.
- 3:28Meister Eckhart's revolutionary
- 3:29spiritual teachings were not popular
- 3:32with the church authorities of the time.
- 3:34Accusations were brought against
- 3:35Eckhart, and he found himself accused by
- 3:38the Inquisition. The Inquisition was a
- 3:40powerful arm of the medieval church,
- 3:43which identified supposed cases of
- 3:45heresy. The Inquisition would become an
- 3:47increasingly formidable and dangerous
- 3:49presence for the rest of Eckhart's life.
- 3:52However, ignoring the threats to his
- 3:54life, Eckhart continued to teach the
- 3:56radical spiritual truths that had been
- 3:59revealed to him. At the end of this
- 4:01video, we will offer a guided meditation
- 4:04based on the teachings of Meister
- 4:06Eckhart.
- 4:11The concept of being and non-being, that
- 4:13is something and nothing, has long
- 4:16played a fundamental role in Christian
- 4:17thought and philosophy. Saint Augustine,
- 4:20354 to 430, was an early figure laying
- 4:24the Christian foundations for
- 4:26understanding of the nature of being.
- 4:28He drew on the philosophy of the ancient
- 4:30Greeks, particularly Aristotle, to argue
- 4:33that absolute non-being was an
- 4:35impossibility.
- 4:37According to Aristotle, all that was
- 4:39possible was only lesser degrees of
- 4:41absolute being.
- 4:43Augustine utilized this argument to
- 4:45posit that God was in essence this
- 4:47absolute and ultimate being. He also
- 4:50drew upon the concept of Platonic form.
- 4:53Platonic idealism or Platonic forms was
- 4:56the idea that there must exist an ideal
- 4:58form for all existing objects,
- 5:00qualities, and ideas.
- 5:03This included qualities and ideas such
- 5:05as goodness and beauty.
- 5:07According to Plato, for us to be able to
- 5:09measure any degree of goodness or
- 5:11beauty, there must exist somewhere
- 5:13goodness or beauty's ideal form by which
- 5:16we can measure that degree.
- 5:18Augustine took Plato's philosophy of
- 5:20ideal forms and applied it to a
- 5:23Christian context. Thus, God was the
- 5:26absolute ideal form. God became the
- 5:29ultimate, eternal, and uncreated being,
- 5:33the source and measure of all existence.
- 5:36In contrast, the created world is not
- 5:38quite absolute being. Rather, it is an
- 5:41expression of a type of non-being,
- 5:43utterly contingent and dependent upon
- 5:46the sustaining power God's absolute
- 5:48being.
- 5:49By doing this, Augustine resolved
- 5:51centuries of argument around being and
- 5:53non-being and their relation to
- 5:55understanding the nature of God.
- 5:57He laid the foundations for the
- 5:59Christian doctrine of God as the
- 6:01expression of ultimate pure being and
- 6:03the impossibility of non-being apart
- 6:05from God's being to become the accepted
- 6:07theological doctrine in the Catholic
- 6:09Church right up to the present day.
- 6:12Almost 1,000 years later, Meister
- 6:14Eckhart would completely and totally
- 6:16refute this. He would turn Christian
- 6:18theological doctrine upside down.
- 6:21He saw God as entirely transcendent,
- 6:23utterly unexplainable by any term
- 6:25whatsoever. That is, God is an ineffable
- 6:28reality that can never be grasped by
- 6:31humans.
- 6:32Eckhart believed that it is impossible
- 6:34for humans to say what God is,
- 6:37even to say that God is absolute being.
- 6:39We cannot even limit God to being.
- 6:42He pointed to the inherent limitations
- 6:44of human language in describing the
- 6:47ultimate nature of God.
- 6:49No word or understanding could ever
- 6:51capture the boundless nature of the
- 6:52divine.
- 6:53We can never ever say what God is. We
- 6:57can only ever say what God is not. This
- 6:59approach is called apophatic theology or
- 7:02negative theology.
- 7:04This is a mystical approach that posits
- 7:06that we can only approach the divine by
- 7:08negating human concepts and language. We
- 7:11come to accept that God's nature will
- 7:13always surpass human comprehension. This
- 7:16is at the core of Eckhart's teaching.
- 7:18Thus, in Eckhart's negative theology,
- 7:21silence is a sacred language.
- 7:24For it is only in silence that we strip
- 7:26away the linguistic and conceptual
- 7:29limitations to our understanding of God
- 7:31and unveil the truth of God beyond God.
- 7:36The transcendence of being.
- 7:39Eckhart assumes God's transcendence as a
- 7:41reality that surpasses human
- 7:43understanding.
- 7:45His sacred language of silence, a
- 7:47silence that is both outward and inward,
- 7:50an inherent removal of all conceptual
- 7:52limitations, invites us to contemplate
- 7:55this God beyond God.
- 7:57Central to Eckhart's contemplation of a
- 7:59God beyond God is his audacious concept
- 8:03of the Godhead as pure nothingness.
- 8:05This divine nothingness is not a
- 8:07declaration that the Godhead is an
- 8:09absence or a lack.
- 8:11Rather, it points to the Godhead as pure
- 8:13potentiality.
- 8:15A brief example may help us to
- 8:17understand what Eckhart was pointing to.
- 8:20Silence is an example of pure
- 8:21potentiality.
- 8:23Out of silence, any sound can arise,
- 8:26anything from the sound of a car crash
- 8:28to a Mozart opera,
- 8:30any sound.
- 8:31Silence is thus both formless and of
- 8:34infinite potential.
- 8:36Silence in its infinite potential could
- 8:38also be said to be without a limit to
- 8:40its fullness.
- 8:41That is, there is no limit on the amount
- 8:43of sound it can allow.
- 8:45Eckhart pointed to the Godhead as this
- 8:48same pure potentiality. The pure
- 8:50potentiality of absolute non-being.
- 8:54According to Eckhart, the Godhead is
- 8:56absolutely silent.
- 8:58Not the silence of sound and silence,
- 9:01rather a silence deeper than all
- 9:03silence, an eternal and infinite
- 9:06silence. There is absolutely no movement
- 9:09in the Godhead.
- 9:10Not a stillness in relation to movement,
- 9:13but a stillness beyond stillness, an
- 9:16eternal and infinite stillness.
- 9:18There is no light in the Godhead. This
- 9:21is not the darkness of light and
- 9:23darkness. This is a darkness beyond all
- 9:26darkness. This is an eternal and
- 9:28infinite darkness. The Godhead is
- 9:30utterly simple. This is not the
- 9:33simplicity of the simple and complex.
- 9:35This is a simplicity beyond all
- 9:37simplicity. This is eternal and infinite
- 9:40simplicity of absolute non-distinction.
- 9:43There are absolutely no intentions in
- 9:45the Godhead.
- 9:46Thus, there is no divine will in the
- 9:49Godhead.
- 9:50Nothing is willed. This is absolute
- 9:52freedom.
- 9:53A freedom that is prior to the freedom
- 9:56of the will.
- 9:57An eternal and infinite freedom.
- 10:00A freedom from intention that is the
- 10:02Godhead. The Godhead is empty.
- 10:05Empty of distinction. Empty of
- 10:07intention. Empty of light. Empty of
- 10:10will. Empty of anything one could say of
- 10:12it at all.
- 10:13Except in the paradoxical language that
- 10:15Meister Eckhart uses. The language of
- 10:18negative theology. The language of
- 10:20saying only what the Godhead is not.
- 10:23What Eckhart did say about the Godhead
- 10:25was this.
- 10:26The Godhead is a pure unmanifested
- 10:29potentiality that precedes all creation.
- 10:32The Godhead is the boundless source from
- 10:35which all of existence emanates.
- 10:37What Eckhart would say next would be the
- 10:39reason the church fathers accused him of
- 10:42heresy.
- 10:43The Godhead is the source of God.
- 10:45This is not a completely unknown
- 10:47concept. We see it in the ancient Vedic
- 10:50teachings of India in their distinction
- 10:52between Brahman, God, and Parabrahman,
- 10:55God beyond God.
- 10:57We see it in the teachings of the great
- 10:5920th century Indian sage, Nisargadatta
- 11:02Maharaj, when he suggests that we
- 11:04realize Parabrahman by
- 11:07meditating on the sense I am until you
- 11:09realize that I am is illusory.
- 11:12Nisargadatta teaches that we realize God
- 11:15or Brahman by meditating on the sense of
- 11:17existing or I am. However, our ultimate
- 11:21destination is the God beyond God. That
- 11:25is Parabrahman, the source of God.
- 11:28To do this, we must penetrate the
- 11:30illusion of existence itself. We must
- 11:33recognize the sense of existing as
- 11:35utterly illusory.
- 11:37We must realize the God beyond God, the
- 11:40source of the sense of existence, that
- 11:42is non-existence, nothingness, or
- 11:45non-being.
- 11:47Another famous and well-regarded 20th
- 11:49century Indian sage also pointed to this
- 11:51source of existence, the God beyond God,
- 11:55Ramana Maharshi.
- 11:57Ramana said that his truest teaching was
- 11:59silence.
- 12:00Ramana also said that anything outside
- 12:02of deep dreamless sleep, sushupti, is
- 12:05illusory, anything at all.
- 12:13Eckhart's teaching that the Godhead, or
- 12:15nothingness, is the source of God, or
- 12:18being, turned almost 1,000 years of
- 12:20Christian theology on its head.
- 12:22It directly contradicted Augustine's
- 12:24claim for the primacy of being, for God
- 12:27as ultimate pure being.
- 12:30His seemingly outrageous claim was that
- 12:32the Godhead, or nothingness, gives birth
- 12:35to God, or being.
- 12:37But how could Eckhart be so sure?
- 12:39After all, he was risking his very life
- 12:42by teaching what was considered an
- 12:43extreme blasphemy at the time.
- 12:46He understood that these truths were
- 12:47realized in direct experience by his
- 12:50practice of contemplative prayer,
- 12:52the type of prayer today we might call
- 12:54meditation.
- 12:56Contemplative prayer is not a series of
- 12:59formulaic words, but a dynamic and
- 13:02transformative engagement with the
- 13:03divine.
- 13:05It is prayer that transcends words,
- 13:07thoughts, and images.
- 13:09It is prayer that is a direct communion
- 13:11with God beyond the limitations of the
- 13:14intellect.
- 13:15It is interesting to note here that
- 13:17Eckhart's contemplative prayer is in
- 13:19communion with God, not the Godhead.
- 13:23This makes an intriguing parallel to
- 13:25Nisargadatta's instruction to first
- 13:27meditate on the sense of I am, Brahman
- 13:30or God, as the gateway to what is
- 13:32beyond, Para Brahman.
- 13:35Eckhart introduces a notion of unknowing
- 13:37in contemplative prayer, an intentional
- 13:39surrendering of the intellect's need to
- 13:41grasp and define the divine.
- 13:44Again, what is left to us in this state
- 13:46of unknowing, but the naked sense of
- 13:49existing or I am-ness?
- 13:52In this state of unknowing, the
- 13:53contemplative enters into a receptive
- 13:56silence, allowing the divine presence to
- 13:58unfold in the depths of the soul.
- 14:02Contemplative prayer is also the sacred
- 14:04space in which Gelassenheit is
- 14:06actualized.
- 14:08Gelassenheit is a concept that is put to
- 14:10much philosophical use by the German
- 14:13philosopher Martin Heidegger and later
- 14:15by the French philosopher Jacques
- 14:17Derrida.
- 14:18Gelassenheit embodies the idea of
- 14:21surrendering and relinquishing the
- 14:22personal ego.
- 14:24Heidegger would call this letting be,
- 14:26which allowed for a wholly different
- 14:28type of thinking, different than
- 14:30utilitarian or technological thinking. A
- 14:33thinking that allowed beings as subjects
- 14:35of thought to simply be in their
- 14:37beingness. Similarly, Derrida's
- 14:40deconstruction is in essence the undoing
- 14:43and letting go of binary thinking so as
- 14:45to open up a space of receptivity for
- 14:47new ways and forms of knowing. Both
- 14:50Heidegger and Derrida draw heavily on
- 14:52Eckhart's concept of Gelassenheit.
- 14:54Meister Eckhart pointed to Gelassenheit
- 14:57as the act of letting go of desires,
- 14:59attachments, and self-centered
- 15:01preoccupations so as to create space for
- 15:04God's transformative presence.
- 15:07Gelassenheit is not a passive
- 15:09resignation, but an active receptivity.
- 15:12Gelassenheit was not the mere
- 15:14renunciation of external possessions.
- 15:17Rather, it is a profound inner
- 15:19disposition, a state of openness where
- 15:22one releases their grip on temporal
- 15:24concerns and surrenders to the eternal.
- 15:27The surrender of the ego is a pivotal
- 15:29aspect of Gelassenheit.
- 15:32Eckhart does not suggest the eradication
- 15:34of the ego. Instead, the ego, when
- 15:37surrendered through Gelassenheit,
- 15:38transcends individual identity to merge
- 15:41with the infinite.
- 15:43This very much aligns with spiritual
- 15:45teachings east and west that teach that
- 15:47we do not so much as eradicate illusions
- 15:50as liberate them.
- 15:52That is, that the illusory nature of
- 15:54self and world are not destroyed, but
- 15:56rather are recognized as unnecessary,
- 15:59unserious, and utterly without purpose,
- 16:02and thus full of play, fun, and humor.
- 16:06In other words, our illusions are
- 16:08recognized as the humorous play,
- 16:12a god which finds its source in the pure
- 16:15non-necessity of nothingness.
- 16:22Find a quiet corner where the world
- 16:24falls away and you can turn inward
- 16:26without disturbance.
- 16:28Sit in a position that is both alert and
- 16:30relaxed and gently close your eyes.
- 16:33Begin to draw your attention to the
- 16:35breath.
- 16:36Inhale deeply, inviting calmness into
- 16:39your being.
- 16:40Exhale slowly, releasing any form of
- 16:43inner turbulence or tension.
- 16:45Let your breath find its natural rhythm,
- 16:48becoming an anchor in the present
- 16:49moment.
- 16:51You are preparing to explore a realm of
- 16:53profound stillness and expansive
- 16:55silence.
- 16:57Focus on the concept of being, the sense
- 16:59of I am that you identify with, your
- 17:02personal narrative, your body, your
- 17:04thoughts and feelings. Recognize them,
- 17:07then gently set them aside one by one.
- 17:11As you detach from each layer, envision
- 17:13yourself approaching a deeper, more
- 17:15universal truth.
- 17:17Imagine an all-encompassing nothingness,
- 17:20not a vacuum or void, but an infinite
- 17:22presence that is the foundation of all
- 17:25existence.
- 17:27This nothingness is brimming with
- 17:28potential, the absolute ground from
- 17:31which all things emerge and to which
- 17:33they return.
- 17:35As you breathe in,
- 17:36imagine this nothingness as an ocean
- 17:38without shores, limitless and profound.
- 17:42As you breathe out, feel your
- 17:44individuality blending into this vast
- 17:46expanse.
- 17:48In this expanse, personal boundaries
- 17:50dissolve and the very source of it all
- 17:53is revealed as an limitless absence, a
- 17:55boundless openness of pure potential.
- 17:59In this openness, all that defines you
- 18:01begins to disappear. Your labels, your
- 18:04history, your ambitions, your fears.
- 18:07There are no thoughts, no judgments, no
- 18:09expectations, only an unfathomable
- 18:12vastness.
- 18:13Let go. Let go. Let go.
- 18:17Until you reach the deepest, until you
- 18:19let go of even the subtle sense of I am.
- 18:22Release this last attachment to the
- 18:24feeling sense of existing.
- 18:26Go beyond the primary illusion,
- 18:29I am.
- 18:30Rest in the nothingness that is the
- 18:32source prior to the arising of the
- 18:35feeling sense, I am.
- 18:37Rest in this profound freedom beyond any
- 18:40possible intention.
- 18:41Rest in this pure simplicity beyond any
- 18:44possible distinction.
- 18:46Rest where nothingness and the potential
- 18:48for everything coexist without
- 18:50contradiction.
- 18:52There is no striving here, no need to
- 18:55attain anything.
- 18:57This absolute non-being is not an end
- 18:59point, but the very ground of all
- 19:01possibility for any arising of
- 19:04existence.
- 19:05This is the blank canvas before the
- 19:07first stroke of the brush.
- 19:09This is the empty page before the first
- 19:11word.
- 19:13This is the pure potentiality that is
- 19:15always present, regardless of whether
- 19:17anything appears or not.
- 19:20This is the unmanifested essence, the
- 19:22foundational nothingness from which all
- 19:25arises and into which all returns.
- 19:28Recognize that this is not a denial of
- 19:30the world, but the most profound
- 19:33affirmation of life's source.
- 19:35The infinite diversity of forms and
- 19:37experiences are all non-necessary and
- 19:40thus playful expressions of the infinite
- 19:43potential of nothingness.
- 19:45Each moment is a utterly unique and
- 19:47non-necessary manifestation of the
- 19:49boundless. Now, begin to slowly return
- 19:52to the sensory world.
- 19:54Feel the ebb and flow of your breath. As
- 19:56you open your eyes, maintain the
- 19:59serenity and expansiveness that you now
- 20:01know to be the source of you.
- 20:03Carry the deep serenity of nothingness
- 20:06throughout your day.
- 20:08Recall that beneath the dynamic dance of
- 20:10forms, absolute non-being is
- 20:13ever-present.
- 20:14Nothingness is the source of everything.
- 20:17Thus, be relieved of everything.
- 20:20Absolutely nothing matters because it is
- 20:23all merely nothing mattering. In this
- 20:26recognition, you will find a deep and
- 20:28enduring peace and a boundless freedom.
- 20:32But perhaps most surprisingly, an
- 20:34unconditional, thus profoundly free,
- 20:37love for all and everything that exists.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Meister Eckhart: The Enlightened Man The Church ALMOST Executed by Asangoham, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,862 words across 531 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.