Matt Dillahunty vs Braxton Hunter (Does the Christian God Exist) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00the following individuals deserve credit
- 0:01for helping me prep for this debate
- 0:03Layton flowers for inviting me to debate
- 0:05mic like Kona for hours spent on the
- 0:07phone discussing recommend biography and
- 0:09HL literary conventions Jonathan
- 0:11Pritchett for serving as the
- 0:12quintessential devil's advocate Erick
- 0:14Hernandez for providing insights from
- 0:16his own debate with Matt Tim Stratton
- 0:18for his incredible advice regarding my
- 0:19own freewill argument Andrew Armstrong
- 0:22for the late night discussions about my
- 0:24approach Russell Crawford for serving as
- 0:26my sparring partner and my wife Sarah
- 0:28hunter for putting up with an often
- 0:30absent-minded husband focused on this
- 0:32event to learn formally and achieve your
- 0:34degree from home visit Trinity College
- 0:36of the Bible and Theological Seminary
- 0:37today
- 0:44good evening I know some are still
- 0:47making their way over from the parking
- 0:49lot and into the facility and we want to
- 0:52first begin by thanking Truitt for
- 0:55hosting tonight's debate so let's give a
- 0:58hand for Truitt Baylor University true
- 1:04it's a great school got a great lot of
- 1:06great friends that go here and are part
- 1:07of a part of Truitt and so if you're
- 1:09looking for a higher education the
- 1:11Truitt's a great place to go and they
- 1:12didn't ask me to say that either that's
- 1:14this is just something that I've come to
- 1:16believe and know about true it's a great
- 1:17place for you to consider for a higher
- 1:19education
- 1:20my name is Leighton flowers I am the
- 1:22director of evangelism and apologetics
- 1:24for Texas Baptist Texas Baptist is what
- 1:26is sponsoring this event called on the
- 1:29unapologetic conference which will begin
- 1:31tomorrow at Columbus Avenue Baptist
- 1:34Church and there at Columbus you will be
- 1:37hearing more from obviously atheistic
- 1:41Christian perspective about why we
- 1:44believe what we believe and learning how
- 1:46to defend and to explain why we believe
- 1:49what we believe but here tonight you're
- 1:50going to actually see it unfold
- 1:52firsthand live in a debate between a
- 1:55Christian and an atheist and though we
- 1:59are having a debate and sometimes when
- 2:03people hear debate they think oh well
- 2:05that means people are going to be really
- 2:06mean and angry and ugly with each other
- 2:07you will not be witnessing that because
- 2:10I know both of the the two gentlemen
- 2:11sitting on this stage and neither one of
- 2:13those gentlemen are going to be that way
- 2:15they are both very firm in their
- 2:18convictions and they believe what they
- 2:20believe very strongly but they also know
- 2:22how to speak about what they believe
- 2:24without being overly contentious in
- 2:26other words they can disagree without
- 2:28being overly disagreeable I think it was
- 2:31Aristotle who says it is the mark of an
- 2:33educated mind to be able to entertain a
- 2:35thought without necessarily accepting it
- 2:37and what we're doing today is a part of
- 2:39Education it is learning to understand
- 2:42other people's perspectives learning how
- 2:44to make sound reasoned arguments against
- 2:47this perspectives and we're going to see
- 2:48that played out live before we get
- 2:51started I have a few just announcements
- 2:54and things that I want you to be aware
- 2:55of first I want to thank us
- 2:57via Atherton for her or helping to
- 2:59organize this event and it was well as
- 3:01the unapologetic conference and did his
- 3:03parish and his crew for the camera work
- 3:05that they're going to be doing also the
- 3:08newest one on our staff our new lead
- 3:11apologist Eric Hernandez is right here
- 3:12in the front row stand up Eric in DL
- 3:14recognized he'll no booing no bearing
- 3:19Eric and Matt have had debates before on
- 3:23other topics and so they have a history
- 3:26together and that actually your perfect
- 3:27introduction for what I was going to say
- 3:28next as audience participants tonight
- 3:31we're gonna ask that you not boo or
- 3:33applied during the the course of the
- 3:37event we obviously want you to be
- 3:39engaged and so we have actually planned
- 3:42for a time for you to engage with your
- 3:44own questions so you can begin to think
- 3:46and even well maybe write down your
- 3:48questions as we go through the first
- 3:50portion of this debate because the mics
- 3:52will be open later for you to come up
- 3:54and let me emphasize this ask a question
- 3:58okay not make a debate point not try to
- 4:02finish something Matt didn't say that
- 4:03you wanted him to say or that that that
- 4:06dr. hunter says that you wanted even say
- 4:08you wish you would have said this and he
- 4:10shouldn't that's not what this is for
- 4:11okay this is to ask a question so about
- 4:14under 30 seconds and we'll have people
- 4:16monitoring your microphone there so
- 4:17under 30 seconds just voice a question
- 4:20and there's not going to be follow-up so
- 4:22you're just going to ask the question
- 4:23and to move on now if you'd like to get
- 4:24back to the back of the line again and
- 4:25ask another question that's your
- 4:26prerogative but it's just the one
- 4:28question and then allow our our
- 4:30presenters to to answer that question we
- 4:34want you as audience participants to
- 4:38learn from this discussion we're not
- 4:41having a debate in order to spread
- 4:43dissension or to say hey this is this is
- 4:47a way to divide or the way to have
- 4:50trouble within the church or the body a
- 4:52lot of times people put down having
- 4:56debates and and I think this is actually
- 4:59one of the best teaching tools that are
- 5:02available to our students because if a
- 5:05person's able to engage with a cordial
- 5:08and rational debate and arguments over
- 5:12key issues that is one of the the best
- 5:15ways for you to become educated about
- 5:16what another person believes and and and
- 5:20I promise as you go through this evening
- 5:22if you objectively consider but the
- 5:26presenters and what they're saying and
- 5:27how they're saying it
- 5:28and listen to their arguments and learn
- 5:31this can be one of the greatest
- 5:32education tools that you have at any
- 5:35university and so I hope that this this
- 5:38evening is going to be beneficial for
- 5:39you as as an education as well the
- 5:44structure of the tonight's tonight's
- 5:45debate will go like this we will begin
- 5:47with openers 20 minute openers from each
- 5:49of our presenters and then we will have
- 5:52ten minute rebuttals from each of our
- 5:54presenters and then we will have two
- 5:56rounds of cross-examination where each
- 5:58presenter will lead in a
- 6:00cross-examination of the other and I
- 6:02will be guiding each one of these
- 6:04sections as we go through them and then
- 6:06finally in closing we'll have the
- 6:08audience question-and-answer time and so
- 6:11that's how tonight's debate will be
- 6:13structured and so though you're going to
- 6:15be holding your applause for the rest of
- 6:17the evening right now let's get all of
- 6:19our plaza in for our two presenters Matt
- 6:21del Conte and dr. Buxton hunter
- 6:30first up will be dr. hunter with his
- 6:3320-minute opener well first I want to
- 6:42say what a privilege it is to be
- 6:43engaging in tonight's debate in this
- 6:45incredible institution and I have
- 6:47nothing but the utmost respect for the
- 6:49unapologetic skon furan s-- and i'm
- 6:51excited to be sharing the stage with
- 6:52Matt Dillahunty who is a really sharp
- 6:55guy and an excellent debater and so that
- 6:57should make for a lively discussion this
- 6:59evening and I don't want to be too
- 7:01forthright in my predictions about
- 7:03what's gonna happen on the stage tonight
- 7:05but I do we'll make this prediction if
- 7:07there is a clear winner to tonight's
- 7:09debate it will be a bald-headed bearded
- 7:12man just saying now I'm going to be
- 7:16defending the proposition that the
- 7:17Christian God does exist and in order to
- 7:19do that I'm going to be presenting two
- 7:21arguments for God's existence and a case
- 7:23for the resurrection of Jesus if God
- 7:26exists and God raised Jesus from the
- 7:28dead the Christian God exists period no
- 7:31matter what we want to say about
- 7:32anything else I'll begin with a simple
- 7:34syllogism tonight if you freely chose to
- 7:37come to tonight's debate then God exists
- 7:40you've really chose to come to tonight's
- 7:42debate therefore God exists now let's
- 7:45putting it a bit to simplistically it's
- 7:47not really my syllogism let's just back
- 7:49up and get a little more complex but
- 7:51hopefully not too much if God does not
- 7:54exist then libertarian freedom does not
- 7:56exist to libertarian freedom does exist
- 8:00therefore God exists when philosophers
- 8:03talk about human freedom that usually
- 8:05divided into two general categories on
- 8:07the one hand we have determinism which
- 8:09says that no free will exists or at
- 8:11least not the way that you think it does
- 8:13kind of sad on the other hand you have
- 8:15libertarian freedom which says Free Will
- 8:17exists yay and I would wager that for
- 8:20most of you out there the kind of
- 8:22freedom that you think you're talking
- 8:24about when you speak of your own freedom
- 8:25in your own free will every day is
- 8:27probably libertarian freedom and it's
- 8:29certainly the position that I affirm
- 8:31what liberty and freedom says is that
- 8:33you are the originator of your actions
- 8:35and your choices or you have the ability
- 8:38to do other than whatever
- 8:40you ended up doing determinism instead
- 8:42says that what we call your decisions is
- 8:44merely the result of what amounts to an
- 8:46extremely long train of dominoes or
- 8:48something like that events in the
- 8:50history of the universe led to your
- 8:51existence your life experiences the
- 8:54formation of your neural structure and
- 8:55the firings of neurons in your brain but
- 8:58we call those your choices but they
- 9:00literally could not have been otherwise
- 9:02in other words on determinism you had to
- 9:05come to tonight's debate there was
- 9:06really no other option it couldn't have
- 9:09been otherwise but here's the thing if a
- 9:12theism is true I suspect that that means
- 9:14determinism is true and if atheism is
- 9:18true then you have no free will and as
- 9:20others have said like my friend Erik
- 9:21Hernandez the last thing you are is a
- 9:23free thinker some thinkers however posit
- 9:26what they think amounts to a middle
- 9:28option between these two extremes
- 9:29perhaps it's not as bad as determinism
- 9:32hard determinism maybe it's what we
- 9:34could call compatibilism and I'm sorry
- 9:36for these really you know big words here
- 9:38at the beginning of the night but
- 9:39compatibilism basically says look you're
- 9:42free to do whatever it is that you want
- 9:44to do and what more do you want than the
- 9:46freedom to do whatever you want
- 9:48the problem is that on compatibilism
- 9:50your wants and desires that drive your
- 9:52actions those are also determined and
- 9:55it's backed just dominos all the way
- 9:57back again so ultimately what we're left
- 9:59with is still determinism no free will
- 10:01or libertarian freedom free will now the
- 10:04last I heard Matt held the position that
- 10:06I described as compatibilism which I say
- 10:09reduces to any other form of hard
- 10:11determinism in a discussion with
- 10:13Lawrence Krauss and sam harris matt not
- 10:15too long ago said quote we all agree
- 10:18there is no such thing as libertarian
- 10:20free will the idea that I could have
- 10:23done differently so while it seems
- 10:25intuitively obvious to you and I but
- 10:26when I do like this I could have just as
- 10:29easily not done that or done this
- 10:30instead ultimately given the
- 10:33circumstances that was determined and it
- 10:35could not have been otherwise now in
- 10:38summary either you have free you you are
- 10:40free such that you could have done other
- 10:41than you end up doing or do you have no
- 10:43free will and all is determined like
- 10:45Matt's position requires but if you
- 10:47believe that you have freedom of the
- 10:48will that you should know that on
- 10:50naturalistic atheism libertarian free
- 10:52will is just
- 10:53an option for the universe would merely
- 10:55be a natural system of cause and effect
- 10:57if you have freewill God is the best
- 11:00explanation for that freedom for if God
- 11:03exists then the universe is not merely a
- 11:06natural system of cause and effect God
- 11:08could grant us libertarian freedom and
- 11:11deep down I think we all know that we
- 11:13have the freedom to do other than
- 11:14whatever we end up doing you really
- 11:16could have chosen not to come to
- 11:18tonight's debate but if you believe that
- 11:20then libertarian freedom exists as I've
- 11:22argued then God exists now there are
- 11:25actually a couple of implications to
- 11:26this argument that should also be
- 11:27mentioned first
- 11:29if determinism is true then we're left
- 11:30with what I would call moot morality now
- 11:33what I mean by that is that whether
- 11:35someone ends up becoming a
- 11:36philanthropist and helps people or ends
- 11:38up becoming a sex offender or some other
- 11:40kind of criminal ultimately whether
- 11:42that's good or bad right or wrong they
- 11:44ended up doing whatever they were
- 11:45determined to do and they'd have a novel
- 11:48new approach if they stood in court to
- 11:49answer for their crimes they could say
- 11:51it's not my fault judge the universe
- 11:53made me do it but if you all believe
- 11:56like I do that we really could have
- 11:58chosen otherwise and these people who
- 12:00engage in hate crimes or do whatever
- 12:02evil thing they do really didn't have to
- 12:04do that given their circumstances they
- 12:06could have chosen not to do that and
- 12:08lived moral lives than you're affirming
- 12:09libertarian freedom and of course as
- 12:11I've argued along with that comes God
- 12:13secondly if libertarian freedom does not
- 12:15exist then it means that whatever we
- 12:18believe is merely what we were
- 12:20determined to believe now this may
- 12:22stretch the mind and the brain and the
- 12:24head well the fact is it's not just your
- 12:26actions that are determined on
- 12:28determinism but also your thoughts and
- 12:30your beliefs so while you may think you
- 12:32have good reasons for believing that two
- 12:34plus two equals four that you're
- 12:35watching a debate right now or that
- 12:37bald-headed bearded men are the most
- 12:38attractive kinds of men those and all
- 12:41other beliefs were determined and could
- 12:44not have been otherwise this means that
- 12:46you are not free to choose against those
- 12:48things which are irrational that means
- 12:50that you can affirm determinism you can
- 12:53affirm atheism but you can't rationally
- 12:55affirm anything at all including your
- 12:58determinism as atheist philosopher John
- 13:01Searle says quote actions are rationally
- 13:03accessible if and only if the actions
- 13:05are free the
- 13:06reason for the connection is this
- 13:07rationality must be able to make a
- 13:09difference rationality is possible only
- 13:12where there is a genuine choice between
- 13:13various rational and irrational courses
- 13:16of action if the act cannot be otherwise
- 13:18then rationality can make no difference
- 13:20it doesn't even come into play in quote
- 13:23here's what this means for tonight's
- 13:24debate if mat is unsuccessful in
- 13:27overcoming this argument then at least
- 13:28on the basis of tonight's debate
- 13:30you have libertarian freedom and should
- 13:32believe in God as I've argued but get
- 13:34this if he is successful in overcoming
- 13:36this argument there on the basis of
- 13:38tonight's debate determinism is true and
- 13:39you can't rationally affirm anything at
- 13:41all including that atheism is true or
- 13:44that the Christian God doesn't exist so
- 13:46let's just put it this way you're darned
- 13:47if you do darn if you don't secondly God
- 13:50is the best explanation for the
- 13:51beginning of the universe here I'd like
- 13:53to present a case that begins with the
- 13:55Kalam cop logic alarm --nt now for those
- 13:58who are familiar with these discussions
- 13:59you might say come on Braxton you're not
- 14:01gonna bring the old Kalam argument are
- 14:03you again you're darn right I've got a
- 14:04personal philosophy for my life if it
- 14:06ain't broke don't fix it and it ain't
- 14:08broke folks the argument may be stated
- 14:10like this everything that begins to
- 14:12exist must have a cause for its
- 14:14existence the universe began to exist
- 14:16therefore the universe must have a cause
- 14:19for its existence now when I say
- 14:21everything that begins to exist must
- 14:22have a cause we have zero counter
- 14:25examples of this principle 100% of the
- 14:28evidence backs this up and when I say
- 14:30the universe began to exist by universe
- 14:32I mean all of nature including
- 14:34multiverses vacuums or anything else if
- 14:37the universe had no beginning it has
- 14:39existed infinitely and without even a
- 14:41beginning to start from we could never
- 14:43have arrived at this particular moment
- 14:46that we're experiencing today because if
- 14:48it exists infinitely in the past and you
- 14:50crossed half of infinity you still have
- 14:52infinity to go and we would have never a
- 14:54lot arrived at this moment if you want a
- 14:57simpler way of saying it try jumping out
- 14:59of a hole without a bottom to it not too
- 15:01easy I'll leave it to Matt to bring the
- 15:02challenges to the individual premises of
- 15:04this argument but simply put for those
- 15:06that have never heard it before what I'm
- 15:07saying is that whatever begins to exist
- 15:09begins to exist because of something
- 15:12else and the universe is like that
- 15:14something or someone serves as the cause
- 15:16of the physical universe
- 15:18but what
- 15:19that cause well the universe is made up
- 15:21of three things generally speaking time
- 15:23space and matter
- 15:26now since things can't cause themselves
- 15:28to come into existence and since time
- 15:30space and matter are the natural
- 15:31universe and it makes no sense to say
- 15:33that nature came before nature to cause
- 15:35nature then whatever the cause of the
- 15:37physical universe is must be a spaceless
- 15:39timeless and non material cause it also
- 15:43had to be able from a timeless state to
- 15:45bring the universe into existence from
- 15:47nothing are there things like that well
- 15:49some might say that the laws of logic or
- 15:51numbers could exist spaciously
- 15:53timelessly nah materially but the
- 15:55problem is they don't have what
- 15:56philosophers call causal powers that is
- 15:59to say they don't do anything however a
- 16:01mind without a body a mind independent
- 16:04of a body who would serve as a fitting
- 16:05explanation and would also explain how
- 16:07the universe could be created from a
- 16:09state of nothingness which has no
- 16:11potentialities no properties no powers
- 16:14and no possibilities thus a spaceless
- 16:17timeless non material sufficiently
- 16:19powerful mind serves as the best
- 16:21explanation of the beginning of the
- 16:23universe now interestingly when Matt has
- 16:26been faced with this evidence in the
- 16:27past and he has on several occasions
- 16:30responded by saying well perhaps maybe
- 16:32there's maybe all that's true but it's
- 16:34not God maybe the explanation is a
- 16:36spaceless timeless not material
- 16:39sufficiently powerful group of universe
- 16:41creating Pixies that's right Pixies now
- 16:45I understand that Matt is probably
- 16:46saying this tongue-in-cheek I understand
- 16:48that but hey let's just go with these
- 16:50universe created Pixies because Occam's
- 16:52razor the principle that you should
- 16:54shave away everything anything that's
- 16:57unnecessary to explain your position all
- 16:59the unnecessary variables would leave us
- 17:01with one universe creating pixie so
- 17:03you'd have a spaceless timeless
- 17:04non-material sufficiently powerful
- 17:06singular universe creating pixie folks
- 17:09that is a description of God and they're
- 17:11just calling God a pixie so I'd like to
- 17:13be the first one to welcome Matt to
- 17:14theism but you pixie theist
- 17:18so in summary however you want to dice
- 17:20it God's the best explanation for the
- 17:21beginning of the universe
- 17:22third I'd like to express that I think
- 17:24we can actually go further than the god
- 17:26of merely the philosophers god I think
- 17:29we can specify that this God is the god
- 17:31of Christian theism
- 17:32if God raised Jesus from the dead a
- 17:34small feat for a God who could create
- 17:36the universe from nothing then Christian
- 17:38theism emerges can the case be made I
- 17:40think so some reject the resurrection
- 17:43because it involves a miracle for some
- 17:45this means that it requires
- 17:46extraordinary evidence of the sort that
- 17:48overcomes the implausibility inherent
- 17:50any such supernatural claim nevertheless
- 17:53I'd like to head that off with something
- 17:55that I call recalibrated plausibility
- 17:58what is recalibrated plausibility well
- 18:00if God did not exist or if Jesus was
- 18:03just any other first century Jew and of
- 18:05course the resurrection would be
- 18:07incredibly implausible but I've given
- 18:09good reason tonight to believe that God
- 18:11does exist and it is universally
- 18:13accepted or at least almost universally
- 18:15accepted by scholars that Jesus thought
- 18:17of himself at the very least as God's
- 18:18special agent to bring about the Kingdom
- 18:21on earth so those two features together
- 18:23give us what I would call recalibrated
- 18:26plausibility and I'll give you an
- 18:27analogy for how that works
- 18:28imagine that you encountered a group of
- 18:31people in a coffee shop somewhere who
- 18:33were excitedly telling you how they just
- 18:35saw this guy Neil walking on the moon
- 18:38can you believe it we have video of it
- 18:40we just saw this guy Neil walking on the
- 18:43moon
- 18:43now let's also imagine that you don't
- 18:45know anything about NASA you don't know
- 18:46anything about the moon landing or space
- 18:48exploration and so this sounds
- 18:50incredibly implausible in fact it's
- 18:52extraordinary it's an extraordinary
- 18:53claim but then let's imagine that later
- 18:55you actually do find out about this
- 18:57organization called NASA that has the
- 19:00sufficient power to put a man on the
- 19:01moon and you also learn that there's
- 19:03this guy named Neil who was in the 1960s
- 19:05claiming to be a part of NASA's program
- 19:08as if he was saying just watching my
- 19:10life and see what happens
- 19:11now go back to your friends in the
- 19:13coffee shop does their claim seem
- 19:15implausible no in fact it seems very
- 19:17plausible why because we have
- 19:19recalibrated the plausibility for the
- 19:21discussion now hopefully the analogy is
- 19:24simple enough to see NASA is like God
- 19:26and that God is the sufficient power to
- 19:28do something like raise someone from the
- 19:30dead and Neil is like Jesus in that
- 19:32Jesus was walking around basically
- 19:35holding up a sign saying watch my life
- 19:37and see what I do as a part of God's
- 19:38special program this results in
- 19:40recalibrated plausibility for our
- 19:42discussion also I'd like to say that the
- 19:44majority of my case
- 19:45we'll be built on what historians call
- 19:48bedrock facts a bedrock fact is
- 19:51considered as such by historians if it
- 19:53has two things going for it one it is
- 19:55highly evidenced and two and enjoys the
- 19:57consensus of critical scholarship and
- 20:00that includes atheists and agnostics and
- 20:02Christians and perhaps others with these
- 20:04caveats were prepared to consider the
- 20:05evidence first Jesus died by Roman
- 20:08crucifixion though it is sometimes
- 20:10argued that perhaps Jesus was able to
- 20:12pull off the resurrection because he
- 20:14never actually died by crucifixion this
- 20:16is no longer a serious consideration
- 20:17among sober minded scholars in T right
- 20:20response to swoon or apparent death
- 20:22theories like these thusly quote the
- 20:24hoary old theory that Jesus did not
- 20:25really die on the cross but revived and
- 20:27the cool of the tomb has likewise
- 20:29nothing to recommend it and it is
- 20:31noticeably important that even those
- 20:32historians who are passionately
- 20:34committed to denying the resurrection do
- 20:36not go by this route but you know what
- 20:38nc writes a Christian scholar and you
- 20:40would expect him to say something like
- 20:41this so maybe you'd rather hear from an
- 20:43atheist scholar German atheist New
- 20:45Testament scholar GERD lute Aman writes
- 20:47Jesus death as a consequence of
- 20:49crucifixion is in disputable but maybe
- 20:52you don't want a Christian or an atheist
- 20:54what's up with these extremes maybe
- 20:56you'd like a Jewish scholar gays affirm
- 20:58ash says The Passion of Jesus is part of
- 21:01history but maybe when a Christian an
- 21:03atheist or a Jewish scholar maybe you'd
- 21:05rather have a liberal Christian scholar
- 21:07like John Dominic Crossan who writes
- 21:09there is not the quote slightest doubt
- 21:11about the fact of Jesus crucifixion
- 21:13under Pontius Pilate he says Jesus
- 21:15crucifixion is quote as sure as anything
- 21:17historical can ever be and quote but
- 21:20maybe you don't want a Christian an
- 21:21atheist a Jew or a liberal Christian
- 21:23scholar maybe you'd like a liberal
- 21:25Jewish scholar Paula Fredrickson says
- 21:28quote the single most solid fact about
- 21:29Jesus life is his death he was executed
- 21:32by the Roman prefect Pontius Pilate on
- 21:34or around Passover in the manner Rome
- 21:36reserved particularly for political
- 21:38insurrectionists namely crucifixion end
- 21:40quote
- 21:41we have non-christian reports that
- 21:43testify to the death of Jesus from
- 21:44others like the greatest historian of
- 21:46ancient Rome Cornelius Tacitus so one
- 21:49can maintain that Jesus perhaps never
- 21:51existed or that he never died on the
- 21:53cross but one would be arguing that in
- 21:55the face of literally all the historical
- 21:57evidence to the contrary - geez
- 21:59appeared after his death this is
- 22:02evidenced by the early creedal nature of
- 22:04Paul's statements in first Corinthians
- 22:0615 3 through 8 for reasons that we can
- 22:09get into if necessary this Creed though
- 22:11provided for us by Paul in the early to
- 22:12mid 50s ad can be dated to perhaps less
- 22:15than five years after the events in
- 22:17question it indicates that almost
- 22:19immediately after the events early
- 22:21Christians were claiming that Jesus was
- 22:22dead buried and rose again and now some
- 22:26Scot skeptical scholars actually granted
- 22:28these people had such experiences to
- 22:30quote Fredrickson again she says quote
- 22:31the disciples conviction that they had
- 22:33seen there is in Christ their permanent
- 22:35relocation to Jerusalem their principled
- 22:37inclusion of Gentiles as Gentiles all
- 22:40these are historical bedrock facts known
- 22:43past doubting about the earliest
- 22:45community after Jesus death Gary
- 22:47Habermas has been cataloging the
- 22:49positions of scholars who have written
- 22:50on this since 1975 and he comments as
- 22:53firmly as ever most contemporary
- 22:55scholars agree that after Jesus death
- 22:57his early followers had experiences that
- 22:59they at least believed were appearances
- 23:01of their risen Lord now the explanation
- 23:04for why these early believers actually
- 23:06thought Jesus had risen to appear to
- 23:07them is most often that they experience
- 23:09mass hallucination hallucinations of the
- 23:12Risen Jesus even though mass
- 23:14hallucination is both highly
- 23:15controversial as well as an attempt to
- 23:17do group psychology on people from a
- 23:19different culture from 2,000 years ago
- 23:21when it's hard enough to do psychology
- 23:22on someone in America in the 21st
- 23:24century who's sitting in front of you
- 23:25three the earliest disciples were
- 23:28committed to this belief such that they
- 23:30were willing to die for it as many
- 23:32before me have said Liars make poor
- 23:34martyrs it's one thing to die for
- 23:35something that's not true when you
- 23:37believe that it's true such as the
- 23:39Muslim terrorists who flew the planes
- 23:40into the towers on September 11th but
- 23:42it's an entirely different issue to die
- 23:44for something that's false when you know
- 23:46it's false and this would have been the
- 23:47case about the earliest disciples of
- 23:49Jesus since if it was made up they were
- 23:51the ones who made it up now one might
- 23:53say this is a false dichotomy perhaps
- 23:55they weren't lying but were mistaken
- 23:56because of visionary appearances of
- 23:58Jesus that weren't actually real but
- 24:00this would of course loop us back to the
- 24:02previous consideration the
- 24:04hallucinations or visions would have to
- 24:06be defended as a hypothesis Fredrickson
- 24:09says quote I know in their own terms
- 24:11that they saw the Rays Jesus
- 24:13that's what they say and then all the
- 24:15historical evidence we have afterwards
- 24:17attest to their conviction that that's
- 24:18what they saw I'm not saying that they
- 24:20really did see the race Jesus I wasn't
- 24:22there I don't know what they saw I'm not
- 24:25I'm just saying as soon as I wasn't
- 24:27there I don't know what they saw but I
- 24:28do know that as a historian that they
- 24:30must have seen something for scholars
- 24:34testified to these facts here I simply
- 24:35mean to reaffirm that scholars agree
- 24:37Jesus lived died by Roman crucifixion
- 24:39that others believed they had witnessed
- 24:41him alive after the fact and that those
- 24:43others were willing to die for that
- 24:45claim thus were it not for the fact that
- 24:47many would disregard the resurrection on
- 24:49the basis of its nature as a miracle it
- 24:51would easily serve as the best
- 24:53historical hypothesis however since what
- 24:56I've termed recalibrated plausibility I
- 24:58think accounts for that I think we're
- 24:59now free to make our conclusion and so
- 25:01the best explanation is the resurrection
- 25:03and the most appropriate that God raised
- 25:05Jesus from the dead and the most
- 25:06appropriate response is repentance unto
- 25:08salvation repentance by the way means to
- 25:10turn from your life without Jesus to a
- 25:12life with Jesus it means to turn from
- 25:14your sin and that doesn't mean you're a
- 25:15bad person from in my eyes or from a
- 25:18human perspective but we're all sinners
- 25:19and so to turn from that life without
- 25:21Jesus to a life with Jesus now Matt is
- 25:24an outstanding speaker he has a quick
- 25:26wit
- 25:27he's sharp on his feet and he has a
- 25:29fantastic beard as we all can see and
- 25:31all of these things can be very
- 25:32persuasive and he's really smart guy and
- 25:34he really does try to investigate the
- 25:36facts and deal with what's being
- 25:37presented and I appreciate that about
- 25:38him but I think he would agree with me
- 25:40tonight that we shouldn't be moved
- 25:41merely by rhetoric we shouldn't be moved
- 25:43merely by you know cliches or jokes that
- 25:46I might bring or that he might bring we
- 25:48need to be moved by the facts because
- 25:50cliches and quips don't change the facts
- 25:52in order to defend his position as the
- 25:55more appropriate into a rational
- 25:56position Matt will have to overcome
- 25:57these lines of evidence until he does
- 26:00this I'd like to invite you all to
- 26:02freely embrace Christian theism thank
- 26:05you
- 26:08[Applause]
- 26:15are they allowed to clap then apparently
- 26:22this would be weird cuz I need my
- 26:24glasses to read this but not to see you
- 26:26guys so hi hey yeah I know you're not
- 26:29supposed to clap or acknowledge or
- 26:30whatever girls thanks so much for having
- 26:32me I'm really thrilled to be here
- 26:34my former church the church I grew up in
- 26:36would have never done anything like this
- 26:38and I realized we're not technically in
- 26:39a church that to this but you know
- 26:41there's a Church of Christ that invited
- 26:43me down to San Antonio to do three
- 26:45nights of debates they haven't had me
- 26:47back but the unapologetic conference has
- 26:50invited me back I did this was it two
- 26:52years ago year and a half ago in Austin
- 26:54Mike Laconia and I debated the
- 26:56resurrection and actually no it's like
- 26:59to Mike but I wish we had done that
- 27:01because I think we're on a slightly a
- 27:03different track there so tonight does
- 27:05the Christian God exist there's probably
- 27:07some people who thought that dr. hunter
- 27:09was gonna walk in and say yes and I was
- 27:11going to march in and say no and then
- 27:12there'd be like this WWE brawl and
- 27:14that's just not the way things work
- 27:17there the arguments that are used here
- 27:21if we're going to be defending
- 27:23Christianity shouldn't be arguments it
- 27:25could be used by other religions because
- 27:26if you present an argument that's
- 27:27equally viable to Hindus Sikhs Muslims
- 27:29Jews whatever then we're not
- 27:31specifically talking about the Christian
- 27:33God that's happened a little bit but
- 27:35we'll get to more of that in the
- 27:36rebuttal the interesting thing here is
- 27:38that I'm not here to disprove God my
- 27:40position is not even there is no God
- 27:41which is what everybody thinks the
- 27:43Atheist position is instead I am not
- 27:45convinced that there is a God and for
- 27:46some gods I'm actually convinced that
- 27:48they don't exist now how do we go about
- 27:51solving a mystery and figuring out what
- 27:53the right answer is this is something we
- 27:56have to do all the time
- 27:58simple things there was a jar cookies in
- 28:01the kitchen and now some of them are
- 28:02missing let's solve the mystery
- 28:04hey Joey did you eat those cookies nope
- 28:09maybe there are plausible candidate
- 28:14explanations that we propose for
- 28:16anything and everything maybe the kid
- 28:18ate cookies but if we have exactly one
- 28:21occurrence of something
- 28:23like we have never interacted with this
- 28:25child before we've never had cookies in
- 28:27the house before the cookies have never
- 28:29gone missing before we don't really have
- 28:31a pile of evidence how do we draw a line
- 28:34between its most probable that little
- 28:37Joey ate the cookies than it is that God
- 28:39magically made the cookies disappear or
- 28:41that aliens came down and beamed part of
- 28:43those cookies up how do we do that on a
- 28:45single occurrence and particularly with
- 28:48regard to historic events where we don't
- 28:50have a time machine as far as I'm aware
- 28:51we can't go back and actually get the
- 28:53information we have to build the most
- 28:55plausible cases that we can now with
- 28:57historical events what we end up doing
- 28:59is saying okay are there other similar
- 29:02sorts of events and what do we know
- 29:03about people in general and we build up
- 29:06a case for what seems to be the most
- 29:08plausible explanation does that mean
- 29:10we're right no we might be so of the
- 29:15plausible candidate explanations there
- 29:17based on what we understand and
- 29:19sometimes we have to acknowledge that we
- 29:22just don't have enough information to
- 29:24reach a conclusion about what's the
- 29:25right answer there are answers that
- 29:29maybe the best answer that we currently
- 29:31have and they can be monumentally
- 29:33incorrect there can be answers that seem
- 29:35reasonable based on the preponderance of
- 29:37the evidence and those can also be
- 29:39correct it's entirely possible for you
- 29:40to be completely reasonable and wrong
- 29:43you want evidence of this consider how
- 29:46long people thought it was that this Sun
- 29:48went around the earth it was a most
- 29:51reasonable conclusion all of the
- 29:52available evidence pointed to it it's a
- 29:54completely natural thing it feels right
- 29:56it looks right it adequately describes
- 29:58what's going on and yet it is
- 29:59fundamentally wrong and it's completely
- 30:01counterintuitive to think that we're on
- 30:03a spinning ball that's spinning around
- 30:04and that's what makes it look like the
- 30:06Sun goes around us it took a long time
- 30:08to sort through all the details that led
- 30:10us to what we now understand to be the
- 30:12most correct answer and that's another
- 30:13thing about scientific findings they're
- 30:15not making proclamations about truth
- 30:17they are coming up with models that are
- 30:20the most consistent at making
- 30:22predictions based on what we know about
- 30:24what's likely to occur so maybe a little
- 30:27Joey didn't eat the cookies maybe he did
- 30:29but if we have a history if we have a
- 30:31trend where we know that Joey really
- 30:33likes cookies we've caught him doing it
- 30:35before
- 30:36we know that joy is a little liar that
- 30:38we've given birthday did you brush your
- 30:39teeth Joey yes well let's go check then
- 30:42I remember as a kid I wish I hadn't done
- 30:45this but it's true story I didn't like
- 30:48to brush my teeth and so my mom would be
- 30:51like well let's go check and she'd go in
- 30:52the bathroom and then she'd feel the
- 30:53toothbrush to see if it was wet and I
- 30:55kid you not in order to get around that
- 30:57I would go in and wet the toothbrush and
- 30:58put it back in there I just didn't want
- 30:59to brush my teeth and she'd go in and
- 31:01check yep toothbrushes rat thank you for
- 31:04brushing your teeth you're so good honey
- 31:05I tricked her and that was that was the
- 31:08game for me later on I brushed my teeth
- 31:10because I saw what it looked like when
- 31:11you stopped brushing your teeth so I had
- 31:13good good reasons to do that when we go
- 31:15for the best explanation there are
- 31:16explanations that are sufficient to
- 31:19serve as an explanation or serve as a
- 31:21causal thing the god proposition is like
- 31:26a panacea I can't think of too many
- 31:28possible questions that couldn't be
- 31:29answered by God did it it's
- 31:32indistinguishable from magic it's the
- 31:35reason why I use the universe creating
- 31:36Pixies on occasion as an alternative so
- 31:40how could we look around the world and
- 31:42figure out whether or not religions or a
- 31:43particular religion a plausible well we
- 31:45can look at what we know now we don't
- 31:48know everything about the history and
- 31:49origin of religions but we do know that
- 31:51ancient people worship stones and then
- 31:54they worshipped spirits and then they
- 31:56worship spirits in the sky and then they
- 31:58were worshipped or respect it or admired
- 32:01or revered a single spirit in the sky
- 32:04and then after that we started listening
- 32:06to the people who claim to be speaking
- 32:08for these spirits in the sky and then it
- 32:11gradually progressed into the point
- 32:12where now now we're listening to the
- 32:14people who are giving us their
- 32:15interpretation of a translation of a
- 32:17translation of a copy of a translation
- 32:19of what somebody said that somebody in
- 32:20this guy wanted you know and I
- 32:22understand I shouldn't be glib within
- 32:23the sky and as a side note if I offend
- 32:25anybody tonight that's obviously not my
- 32:28intent
- 32:28I'm here because I want you to
- 32:30understand that there I was the Southern
- 32:32Baptist for more than 25 years we went
- 32:35through that last time when people from
- 32:37my old church came down to the debate I
- 32:39just want you to understand why people
- 32:41don't accept it and I think that it'll
- 32:44be intuitively obvious in some regard
- 32:46and that's because we know people lie we
- 32:50know
- 32:50people are mistaken we know that
- 32:51eyeglasses are relatively new a new new
- 32:54invention and that people didn't always
- 32:56see very well I'm reminded of this every
- 32:57time I look down and realize I forgot to
- 32:59put mine back on most people tend to
- 33:03think that religions other than theirs
- 33:05are mistaken that these are the result
- 33:07of human inventions human mistakes
- 33:09sincere things it doesn't have to be
- 33:11that somebody lied we're not we're not
- 33:12always talking about an intentionally
- 33:14manufactured fraudulently religion as we
- 33:16would with Scientology or Mormonism
- 33:18where we know that somebody actually
- 33:21manufactured the claims about those
- 33:23religion in modern times and the
- 33:25evidence for this is just overwhelming
- 33:27to the point where I mean there's a
- 33:29Broadway musical
- 33:30exposing the Book of Mormon but we don't
- 33:33tend to think about that about our
- 33:34religion I took a comparative religions
- 33:36course my freshman year of high school
- 33:37and I remember sitting there going
- 33:39cashed all these other religions are so
- 33:41weird and not mine and then it was much
- 33:45later I was over 30 by the time I sat
- 33:47down and applied my skepticism and
- 33:49critical thinking to what I believed and
- 33:51why I didn't have a bad experience in
- 33:53church I didn't have man and get mad at
- 33:55God and I lost my job and thought God
- 33:57want me to me to be a preacher which is
- 33:59what people in my church had thought and
- 34:00so I was like okay god I'll do it let's
- 34:02get busy let's get started and then I
- 34:04found out that some of the things I
- 34:06thought I had good reasons for I just
- 34:07didn't doesn't mean they're false my
- 34:10position is not there's obviously no God
- 34:12it's not even Christianity as a
- 34:13manufactured fiction in the same way
- 34:15that I would say Scientology almost
- 34:16certainly is that's not it it's just I'm
- 34:19no longer convinced of that so we need
- 34:22something some methodology which when
- 34:25consistently applied manages to confirm
- 34:27one hypothesis and not others if you
- 34:30have a method that leads you to multiple
- 34:31different competing conclusions your
- 34:33method is flawed you know that's why we
- 34:36don't flip coins for things that are
- 34:38serious hopefully because you know a
- 34:40coin toss can lead you decide to cross
- 34:42the street and busy traffic or it can
- 34:44decide to have you stand there and wait
- 34:46for the traffic to go away we make
- 34:47decisions better decisions based on
- 34:49methodologies that consistently provide
- 34:52explanations problem is we don't always
- 34:54know what the answer is we don't need to
- 34:56have enough information to figure that
- 34:57out and so if there's several potential
- 34:59plausible or seemingly plausible
- 35:01explanations how do we tell which ones
- 35:03right
- 35:04now for Christianity in particular since
- 35:06the subject tonight is does the
- 35:09Christian God exist I have two lines of
- 35:12argument that are not going to disprove
- 35:14God at all but they are really difficult
- 35:19things to overcome if you're convinced
- 35:22that it is true and the first one is a
- 35:24notion that's been called the the
- 35:26argument from divine hiddenness
- 35:28essentially as we look around the world
- 35:30if there is give me any God model it
- 35:33could be the Christian God model could
- 35:34be a Hindu God model whatever define
- 35:36what its characteristics are what its
- 35:38goals are how it interacts with people
- 35:40what it wants and now you can make
- 35:43predictions about what sorts of things
- 35:45you would see in reality and if we don't
- 35:47see those things it's not confirmation
- 35:49that that God doesn't exist it could be
- 35:51that we're wrong about the nature of
- 35:52that God or what it wants but if you
- 35:54don't see those things that's a fairly
- 35:56strong disconfirming issue it's like if
- 36:00somebody says oh I got a dead body in
- 36:02the trunk of my car and I go out and I
- 36:04look and I don't find a body and I don't
- 36:06find blood and I don't find hair and I
- 36:08don't know the trunk looks pristine it
- 36:10doesn't look like there's ever been
- 36:10anything in there I can't prove that
- 36:13they didn't have a body in their trunk
- 36:14but there's strong evidence against the
- 36:17proposition now as a skeptic as somebody
- 36:21who advocates for scientific models all
- 36:24of my positions are tentative I'm not
- 36:26absolutely certain about anything as
- 36:27mayor of fact I don't think you can be
- 36:29absolutely certain about anything which
- 36:31I'm sure will come up shortly but my
- 36:34position is I should be able to find and
- 36:38be consistently reasonable and if in
- 36:42fact there were a God who cared about
- 36:45clarity and reason who as I believed
- 36:48when I was Southern Baptists and as
- 36:50people told me they believed this God
- 36:53wants us to know that he exists he wants
- 36:55us to know what is his purpose is for
- 36:57our life he wants us to be aware he
- 36:59wants us to be able to fulfill our
- 37:00obligation under first Peter 3:15 to
- 37:03give the reason for the faith that's
- 37:05within us and to do so with gentleness
- 37:07and respect which I used to say kindness
- 37:09and I got that wrong but I'll try and
- 37:12stick with gentleness respect and
- 37:13kindness if that's the kind of God that
- 37:15exists and there are certain things that
- 37:16we would expect to see
- 37:17and it leads to the second similar line
- 37:22of argument which is the problem of
- 37:25inconsistent revelations now these two
- 37:30together talk about essentially the
- 37:32reasonableness of non belief that an
- 37:35honest actor and I cannot convince
- 37:37anybody here there are people almost
- 37:39certainly who will leave here as they
- 37:41have from any interaction I've had with
- 37:44Krishna's in my life since identifying
- 37:46his atheist they will leave and they
- 37:47will think well Matt's just been given
- 37:49over to a reprobate mind he's
- 37:50unreasonable he won't accept accept
- 37:52evidence you know he's he's just not
- 37:54bright enough or he's hardened his heart
- 37:55or he's you can come up with any excuses
- 37:59you would like to but the fact of the
- 38:01matter is I am being honest when I say
- 38:04that I sincerely am not convinced that
- 38:06there's a God and in many cases I'm
- 38:07convinced that there's not I can't prove
- 38:09it to you any more than I can prove to
- 38:11you there's no God because if a
- 38:13proposition is unfalsifiable that means
- 38:15there's no way to show that it's false
- 38:17and most of the God propositions are as
- 38:19far as I can tell unfalsifiable and
- 38:21while we're talking about what's in
- 38:23somebody else's head I think that that
- 38:26might be unfalsifiable as well we can we
- 38:28can get an idea about what's truly in
- 38:30somebody's head by how they act the
- 38:33problem is is that you can't be
- 38:34extremely confident about any of this
- 38:36unless you know the person and know
- 38:37their motivations and you can't really
- 38:39do that without getting in their head
- 38:40this problem of inconsistent revelation
- 38:43is one that I've described really kind
- 38:47of straightforward and simply and that
- 38:49is the First Baptist Church can tell you
- 38:51what's wrong with the Second Baptist
- 38:52Church and they can tell you what's
- 38:53wrong with the Methodist Church and they
- 38:54can tell you what's wrong with the
- 38:55Presbyterian Church and they can tell
- 38:56you what's wrong with the Catholic
- 38:57Church and then a good chunk of the
- 38:59Christian community can tell you what's
- 39:00wrong with the Jewish tradition they can
- 39:02tell you what's wrong with Islam and
- 39:04they can tell you what's wrong with
- 39:04Hinduism all I'm doing is agreeing with
- 39:06all of them that's what I'm doing
- 39:08we it's not even appreciate the kind of
- 39:12life but this is what we do it's oh I
- 39:16recognize all these faults but I don't
- 39:17necessarily recognize them within my own
- 39:20and the only thing that changed about me
- 39:22was recognizing that my skepticism
- 39:24applied to my own religious beliefs as
- 39:26well and that if there was a God the God
- 39:28that I believed and if it was true and
- 39:29real that there were certain things I
- 39:31would expect to see and that as a
- 39:33sincere believer on my knees trying to
- 39:35do what God wanted me to do when I
- 39:36reached out for help I would get
- 39:37something other than silence and
- 39:39crickets which is what happened and
- 39:42people say well you know God will reveal
- 39:44to himself to you if you just do it in
- 39:46the right way and I put it in that
- 39:47phrasing because I've heard different
- 39:49ways of potentially doing it and when it
- 39:51doesn't happen they'll say well you
- 39:53weren't sincere your hearts been
- 39:57hardened God won't reveal himself to you
- 39:59he'll do it his time he'll do it when
- 40:02you're ready when you're contrite when
- 40:04you are repetitive how do you know that
- 40:06I wasn't I find people who have lost
- 40:09their car keys and God helps them out
- 40:11evidently I find people who never put
- 40:14any serious effort into understanding
- 40:16and studying either the history of
- 40:18religion the tradition the doctrines
- 40:19which church doctrine is based on which
- 40:22none of that they're just like I'm ready
- 40:24God and evidently God reveals himself to
- 40:26them now that's cool
- 40:29for them but when people tell me oh well
- 40:34you just did it wrong you try all that
- 40:35tells me is how convinced you are that
- 40:37you are correct it doesn't tell me how
- 40:40correct you are or that you have reason
- 40:42to think you're correct
- 40:43it's imagine that you came up to me and
- 40:45said hey I just did this nice thing for
- 40:47you and I said I don't believe you am I
- 40:50saying that you're lying no I'm just
- 40:52saying I'm not convinced but what if I
- 40:53looked at you and said you're a liar you
- 40:55didn't do that and you know for a fact
- 40:57that you're not lying
- 40:59how convincing am I ever going to be if
- 41:02there's any cautionary tale about how to
- 41:03engage with atheists or with skeptics
- 41:07and others who are sincerely portraying
- 41:10that they don't believe worst thing you
- 41:12can ever do is say oh you really believe
- 41:13worse than that you know there's a god
- 41:16you're just in denial because they don't
- 41:19know no matter how convinced you are
- 41:22that's the case and I know that I'm this
- 41:24is probably the most difficult thing I
- 41:25could ever convince somebody of they're
- 41:27almost certainly being sincere and it's
- 41:29a horrible mistake for you to challenge
- 41:31somebody sincerity because at that point
- 41:33all you're doing is talking about how
- 41:35you cannot be wrong it has nothing to do
- 41:38with whether or not they are in fact
- 41:40non-believers and reasonable
- 41:42I've heard the various excuses and to me
- 41:46and this may seem glib or insincere it's
- 41:50kind of like I've got a girlfriend but
- 41:52she goes to another school so you don't
- 41:54know her oh and I'd let you call her and
- 41:57investigate but you're kind of mean and
- 41:59you weren't nice to me about this and
- 42:01even if I let you call her and talk to
- 42:02her you wouldn't believe her anyway
- 42:03these are the same excuses that I get
- 42:06when I say you know what I was on my
- 42:07knees for a sincere sincerely sincerely
- 42:10Riya dove time and got nothing people
- 42:13would ask me what would it take to
- 42:15convince you that a God exists and in
- 42:16particular would it take to convince you
- 42:17the Christian God exists and for a while
- 42:19I gave the sort of glib answers that
- 42:21other people did you know if there was
- 42:23riding in this guy that said I'm the
- 42:24Lord that God and everybody could read
- 42:25it irrespective of what languages they
- 42:27understood or even if they were
- 42:28illiterate
- 42:28that'd be pretty empower powerful but it
- 42:32wouldn't confirm a God because I don't
- 42:34have a way to distinguish as arthur c
- 42:36clarke pointed out the difference
- 42:37between a god and a significantly
- 42:40advanced intelligence i'm a magician and
- 42:44on occasion a Mentalist mind reader and
- 42:46so i can do things that people have
- 42:49accused me of being in league with the
- 42:50devil actually they accuse me that just
- 42:52for doing the TV show but i do things
- 42:55that can blow people's minds now if I
- 42:58were to have somebody pick a random him
- 43:03from the hymnal and I don't even know
- 43:05which him know we have and then I were
- 43:06able to tell you the title of that song
- 43:08and what was about that'd be pretty
- 43:10impressive would you think that I got a
- 43:13message from God is that the best
- 43:16explanation or is the best explanation
- 43:19that there was some trickery involved
- 43:20maybe I can read minds maybe it's
- 43:22something has nothing to do with God but
- 43:24I can in fact read minds you how would
- 43:25you ever know that how could you tell if
- 43:27somebody could read minds my pretty my
- 43:30wife ex-wife or whatever doesn't matter
- 43:32she wants it said we were watching
- 43:34sci-fi shows that the first time
- 43:36somebody shows up who can actually read
- 43:37minds we should kill them immediately
- 43:39because they are definitely going to
- 43:41take over the world but yet we see
- 43:43people do this all the time it
- 43:44frustrates me to watch shows like
- 43:45America's Got Talent when you see
- 43:46Mentalist and mind reader's up there
- 43:48performing because it's it's like the
- 43:50judges believe there's actual magic and
- 43:54ocean limb has got
- 43:55some powers and that's why smoke comes
- 43:57out of his mouth and I'm not gonna ruin
- 43:58how the tricks work for you guys today
- 43:59but it's frustrating for somebody who
- 44:01does that to watch people who are
- 44:03gullible I did tricks for people while I
- 44:05was in the Navy and they would say oh
- 44:06you've got demonic energy running
- 44:08through you and at the time I was a
- 44:09Christian and there's no way I want
- 44:11anybody to think that I was using
- 44:12demonic powers to do a card trick and so
- 44:14I would show them how the trick was done
- 44:17and they would look at me and say that's
- 44:20not what you did the first time and that
- 44:24tells me that they're convinced they
- 44:26can't be wrong they've reached a
- 44:27conclusion they think it's reasonable
- 44:28and no amount of evidence to the
- 44:30contrary contrary is gonna change their
- 44:32mind at that time but that doesn't mean
- 44:34that our minds are immune to change and
- 44:36it doesn't mean that we're always right
- 44:38the objections that are launched by me
- 44:42at all religions are the same ones that
- 44:45are launched by you and others that
- 44:47other religions as well and what I'm
- 44:50striving to be is consistent when
- 44:52there's a methodology presented that's
- 44:53going to lead me to consistently
- 44:56plausible reasonable positions I'm gonna
- 44:59go with that and I have yet to find one
- 45:02that consistently our reliability points
- 45:05to any God let alone the Christian God
- 45:07and what's more if there is a god this
- 45:11God should have a great understanding of
- 45:14logic of reason of the nature of
- 45:17evidence of what should and should not
- 45:20be convincing and compelling to people
- 45:23and if that God exists where is he
- 45:27why doesn't he seem to care about
- 45:29clarity why is it that there's a debate
- 45:33ever what's preventing Jesus from
- 45:38showing up an appearing right here right
- 45:41now conclusively we're recording yes
- 45:44maybe picking dunya during the Super
- 45:45Bowl might have reached a bigger
- 45:46audience but I'm pretty sure if we
- 45:47posted this video it would eventually
- 45:49get views that outstrip any Super Bowl
- 45:52so why doesn't that happen it can't just
- 45:55be because I'm given over to some
- 45:57reprobate mind or God moves in
- 45:59mysterious ways and other things if in
- 46:01fact there's a God who cares about truth
- 46:03and clarity who cares about each one of
- 46:04us who wants us to know that in fact he
- 46:07died and was raised for our sin
- 46:08then he has to do something better than
- 46:11presenting a story that has been altered
- 46:16passed on in languages that died out
- 46:19people didn't understand Shakespeare
- 46:22particularly well and yet we're going
- 46:24back to try to figure out what happened
- 46:262,000 years ago thanks
- 46:36now each presenter will give a ten
- 46:38minute rebuttal dr. hunter will be first
- 46:50thank you for that Matt and I like the
- 46:53cordiality in the debate and so as you
- 46:55asked that if anything is offensive to
- 46:58anyone here that they would just
- 46:59overlook that no that's not your intent
- 47:01I hope that you know that about anything
- 47:02that I say about the positions as well
- 47:04much of what Matt said is personal
- 47:06testimony things that have happened to
- 47:07him and of course that's none of my
- 47:09business and I won't be responding to
- 47:11those things however ultimately what
- 47:13Matt has said tonight is that Christian
- 47:16apologists or Christian theologians have
- 47:18not presented good enough reason to
- 47:21believe or a good enough reason that it
- 47:24would warrant belief in the Christian
- 47:25God I think that much was clear and so
- 47:28when we begin here tonight I just want
- 47:30to say that it's important to understand
- 47:32what we mean by good enough evidence and
- 47:35bad enough evidence that's very
- 47:36important in a debate like this and when
- 47:39it comes to Matt's position I think Matt
- 47:41would agree this debate is not about
- 47:43Matt Dillahunty it's not about Braxton
- 47:45hunter it's about you and it's about God
- 47:47and where you stand with God and whether
- 47:49or not the Christian God exists and so
- 47:52for that reason it would be important
- 47:53for us to consider what Matt might think
- 47:56would count as good evidence now my
- 47:59understanding is that Matt isn't sure
- 48:00what would ultimately count for good
- 48:02enough evidence because it hasn't been
- 48:04presented to him and if it does exist
- 48:05God would know what it is but he
- 48:08couldn't put his finger on what would be
- 48:09convincing that's what I've heard in the
- 48:11past so we don't know what would count
- 48:13as good evidence to him but we do know
- 48:15what would not count as good evidence
- 48:17for Matt and I would wager that and I
- 48:20don't mean to sound harsh with this I
- 48:21really like Matt you can tell he's a
- 48:22likable guy enjoyable to listen to but
- 48:25for I think for most of you in the
- 48:27audience that might be skeptics or
- 48:28atheist I don't think you have the level
- 48:30of skepticism or atheism that Matt
- 48:32himself holds to in fact frankly and
- 48:35this is just a point about the position
- 48:36not about Matt personally I think it's
- 48:38frankly an unrealistic level of
- 48:40skepticism in a 20-17 debate at this
- 48:43conference with Mike like oh no Mike
- 48:44asked Matt what if a comet collided with
- 48:47the moon and
- 48:47suddenly anyone could look up in the
- 48:49night sky and see that in multiple
- 48:51languages Hebrew and Greek it was
- 48:52written God exists what would you think
- 48:55about that was basically the question
- 48:56and Matt's response was basically that
- 48:58all we could say about that is quote we
- 49:00don't know how or why this event
- 49:02occurred in other words he that was the
- 49:05end of the quote but in other words he
- 49:06doesn't think that would count as good
- 49:07enough evidence now folks I think that
- 49:10that's major here tonight I think for
- 49:12many people if suddenly a comic collided
- 49:14with the moon and it said God exists in
- 49:15multiple languages that would be pretty
- 49:17good evidence
- 49:18likewise in a 2014 debate with Matt
- 49:21slick slick asked parting of the Red Sea
- 49:23parting of an ocean you're sitting there
- 49:26and someone says in the name of Jesus
- 49:27and the ocean parts you're gonna believe
- 49:29in God now mass responds no slick-ass
- 49:32well what would it take Matt Dillahunty
- 49:35says I just told you I don't know what
- 49:37it would take so Matt doesn't know what
- 49:39it would take for him to believe and if
- 49:41someone parted an ocean in Jesus name
- 49:43that would not count as good enough
- 49:45evidence to warrant belief so I don't
- 49:47say this to throw mud at Matt that is
- 49:49not the point at all the point is this
- 49:51if we're talking about what counts as
- 49:53good and bad evidence if you and it's
- 49:55not also about whether those things have
- 49:57actually happened or will happen that's
- 49:58that's that's a different point the fact
- 50:00is that if they did happen Matt wouldn't
- 50:02count that as good evidence so if you're
- 50:04out there in the audience tonight as a
- 50:05skeptic or someone who's on the fence or
- 50:07an atheist and those things like it
- 50:09being written on the moon or if the
- 50:11ocean parted in Jesus name if that would
- 50:13count as good evidence to you it's a
- 50:16pretty good evidence well then Matt's
- 50:18opinions about what should count as good
- 50:20and bad evidence I don't think should
- 50:22have any serious hold on you now let's
- 50:24talk about what else he said in his
- 50:26discussion here he said you know when
- 50:28you're going to bring a case for the
- 50:30Christian God's existence or something
- 50:31like that then you you shouldn't be
- 50:33bringing arguments that can be used by
- 50:35other religions now he didn't actually
- 50:37spell this out but he and I kind of
- 50:39think about the same sorts of things and
- 50:40I think I know where he's going with
- 50:42this and if I'm wrong he can correct me
- 50:43later but my first two arguments were
- 50:45arguments merely that God exists the
- 50:48resurrection case was brought to
- 50:49demonstrate that what we're talking
- 50:50about here is the Christian God you'll
- 50:53recall that I argued if God exists and
- 50:55God raised Jesus from the
- 50:57then the Christian God exists period
- 50:59that's all there is to it
- 51:00so the first two arguments that I
- 51:02brought were simple theistic arguments
- 51:04that could be brought by someone from
- 51:06another religion as long as it's a
- 51:08monotheistic religion and perhaps maybe
- 51:09you could apply it in other cases but
- 51:12the fact is I didn't leave those
- 51:14arguments there alone I followed them
- 51:15with a resurrection case to put a name
- 51:17tag on that God this is the Christian
- 51:20God so I'm not sure if he wants to say
- 51:22more about that later but I'll look
- 51:23forward to what that will be he says how
- 51:25do we get the probability of a
- 51:26historical event now here's the thing
- 51:28about when we do a historiography when
- 51:30we do historiography what we don't do is
- 51:32to work some kind of a mathematical
- 51:35equation now there are a few historians
- 51:37do that there very few those are
- 51:39Bayesian historians and maybe there's
- 51:41some other kind of method that some
- 51:42historians use that I'm not aware of and
- 51:44they do kind of get into some
- 51:45mathematical probabilities but that's
- 51:47not how typically historians do their
- 51:49work what they do is what's called
- 51:51inference to the best explanation so
- 51:53what they'll sometimes do is they'll put
- 51:55out a spread of possibilities for any
- 51:57particular historical event highest
- 52:00possible probability very probably true
- 52:02more probable than not more possible
- 52:05than not possible improbable those kinds
- 52:08of things and then they'll look at the
- 52:10evidence and they'll look at the
- 52:11different kinds of criteria that they
- 52:15have does this thing have is the
- 52:16explanation the hypothesis we're putting
- 52:18forward have explanatory scope that is
- 52:20does it account for a large number of
- 52:21the data it doesn't have explanatory
- 52:23power does it account for it easily it's
- 52:25it's kind of not kind of like trying to
- 52:27force a puzzle piece where it doesn't go
- 52:29it should slide in there nicely
- 52:31it does it have plausibility that means
- 52:33is it more likely to be true than false
- 52:35is it less ad hoc now you may have to
- 52:38say some things that you know you don't
- 52:40really know we just have to assume
- 52:41certain things kind of like if you have
- 52:43a triangle and there's a little spot of
- 52:44the triangle that's missing you have to
- 52:46assume that that's making the shape of a
- 52:47triangle sometimes you have to do that
- 52:49with historical analysis but you want
- 52:51something that's less ad hoc it doesn't
- 52:53pause it a lot of stuff that you don't
- 52:55really have good reason to believe or
- 52:56evidence for it to make sense of it and
- 52:58it's nice if it has illumination that
- 53:00the things that we learned about this
- 53:01actually could illuminate what we think
- 53:03in other areas of history and so when it
- 53:06comes to historical argumentation and
- 53:08Hart historical investigations
- 53:10that we don't work with mathematical
- 53:11probability all the time like that we're
- 53:13looking and I'm not a historian but
- 53:14we're looking for plausibility what is
- 53:16more likely the case than not using
- 53:18inference to the best explanation now we
- 53:20get to the meat of what Matt was really
- 53:22trying to say and he was arguing from
- 53:24divine hiddenness why is it God more
- 53:26obvious now I want to pause and just say
- 53:29I understand that there is an emotional
- 53:32aspect of that now he didn't bring an
- 53:33emotional argument but it is emotionally
- 53:35powerful when someone is going through
- 53:37some sort of sickness or or terminal
- 53:39illness or they're going through a
- 53:41broken marriage or something like that
- 53:42it can be very difficult why isn't God
- 53:45more evidence in my life at this moment
- 53:48and I can't handle that emotional
- 53:50problem of divine hiddenness but I think
- 53:51we can do something about the
- 53:53intellectual problem of divine
- 53:55hiddenness this will sound audacious to
- 53:58my friends here who are not believers
- 53:59but I don't find God to be all that
- 54:02hidden we have incredible reasons to
- 54:05believe that God exists we have
- 54:07incredible arguments and evidences from
- 54:09almost every area of investigation we
- 54:11have inferences from history and science
- 54:13we have philosophical arguments we have
- 54:15arguments from I don't use these but we
- 54:18could argue from personal experience now
- 54:20he's right your personal experience of
- 54:22God is it really evidential for him but
- 54:24just to put a little gravy on top of
- 54:25this thing tonight how many of you are
- 54:27convinced you had an experience with God
- 54:28and it would be very difficult to
- 54:30convince you that you haven't would you
- 54:31raise your hands we have all of these
- 54:33kinds of arguments many of them I'm not
- 54:35even bringing tonight so when every
- 54:37physical object and concept in the
- 54:40universe could be used as a reason to
- 54:42believe that God exists I'm not trying
- 54:44to be critical of those who don't
- 54:45believe and I certainly wouldn't be
- 54:47presumptuous of someone who has
- 54:49genuinely tried to have a relationship
- 54:51with God and for whatever reason that
- 54:53hasn't happened I don't know what to say
- 54:55about that you know it's it's almost
- 54:57like I don't want to respond to the
- 54:59point because I don't want to sound
- 55:00insulting to your personal position and
- 55:03I would never want to do that and I'm
- 55:04not saying that you the that you've just
- 55:06didn't try hard enough or something like
- 55:08that all I'm doing is pointing to the
- 55:09evidence and it strikes me that
- 55:11everywhere I look there seems to be good
- 55:13evidence for God now I do understand why
- 55:15doesn't God show up every two years
- 55:17bodily and just announce it on
- 55:19television so that everyone can see but
- 55:20see that would mean that what God is
- 55:22looking for is mere
- 55:23intellectual belief the what God wants
- 55:26is not merely a lot of people to believe
- 55:27intellectually that he exists what God
- 55:30wants is for people to enter into a
- 55:31relationship of trust and loyalty with
- 55:34him and if God is aware as he would be
- 55:36that in this world with this amount of
- 55:38evidence the greatest number of people
- 55:40would freely choose to come into a
- 55:41relationship with him then God is not
- 55:43required to give more evidence than that
- 55:45just to suit our fancy and besides all
- 55:48of this Matt said in a video called who
- 55:51are you to question God that even if he
- 55:54were convinced that God exists that that
- 55:56doesn't mean that he would worship God
- 55:58in fact he said he doesn't believe in
- 55:59worship he wouldn't worship that God
- 56:01now folks that means that this whole
- 56:02thing of divine hiddenness while I admit
- 56:04that it can be persuasive sometimes
- 56:05rings hollow in tonight's debate he
- 56:08talked about inconsistent revelation so
- 56:10I'll be quick about this because I don't
- 56:11have a lot of time the fact is that one
- 56:13thing that all Christians everywhere who
- 56:15are Orthodox Christians have always
- 56:16believed is that God exists and God
- 56:18raised Jesus from the dead so I don't
- 56:20know about the folks at 1st 2nd or 3rd
- 56:21Baptist here in town I don't know what
- 56:22they think on the 1st or 2nd pew of that
- 56:24church about the other folks in the
- 56:25other churches but I'll guarantee if
- 56:27they're Orthodox Christians they all
- 56:28believe God exists in God raised Jesus
- 56:29from the dead I'd like to say more about
- 56:31this thing about 2,000 years ago how do
- 56:33we consider those people but I'll just
- 56:34say this it's almost like some people
- 56:36tend to think that the history is like
- 56:38Byrd box you've got to wear your
- 56:40something over your face and don't look
- 56:43because you might catch Christianity I'm
- 56:45not Sandra Bullock and this isn't Byrd
- 56:46box
- 56:54[Music]
- 56:59I'm just waiting as you say go okay I'm
- 57:03talking and there's gonna be a lot to
- 57:04get to because I've got to go through
- 57:05rebuttals and everything else so he says
- 57:08he's just pointed the evidence I would
- 57:10dispute whether or not we've actually
- 57:11pointed to anything like evidence what
- 57:13we pointed to his arguments that are
- 57:14interpreted in such way but early on he
- 57:17began with this notion about free will
- 57:19and determinism and while I am on record
- 57:21as being the compatibilist I've also
- 57:23done a video with rationality rules
- 57:25where he talked about that that's almost
- 57:29too much to begin going into but I will
- 57:31say that I don't accept that we have
- 57:34anything like libertarian free will and
- 57:36so if you're going to propose that God
- 57:37is the best explanation for something
- 57:39that I don't think we have I don't know
- 57:40how that can be convincing I also don't
- 57:42know how you could demonstrate that I
- 57:43could have done otherwise I can
- 57:45demonstrate that I feel like I could
- 57:46have done otherwise but we don't have a
- 57:48way to rewind the clock to in fact show
- 57:50that I could have done otherwise so how
- 57:52do you draw a distinction between the
- 57:53impression that you could have done
- 57:54otherwise and the fact that you could
- 57:56have done otherwise meanwhile the notion
- 57:58of an of a of God of classical theism
- 58:01which would apply to Christianity as
- 58:03well is in direct conflict with the
- 58:05notion of libertarian free will
- 58:06because if a God knows everything that's
- 58:09going to happen and created the universe
- 58:11and chose the universe in which I'm an
- 58:13atheist as opposed to choosing a
- 58:14different universe then I didn't get to
- 58:17make those choices I still made those
- 58:19choices within the context that universe
- 58:20but it was decided before me and when
- 58:22you have a Bible that says that
- 58:23everything goes according to God's plan
- 58:24and that he can actually make prophecy
- 58:27you can't have prophecy unless God
- 58:29already knows how things are going to
- 58:30turn out and all of this stands in
- 58:32direct conflict with the notion of
- 58:33libertarian free will now that's not a
- 58:36problem for me because I don't think we
- 58:37have a libertarian free will but we're
- 58:39probably not going to be well suited to
- 58:41go down that path this evening the next
- 58:43thing you presented was the Kalam
- 58:44cosmological argument and as I pointed
- 58:46out many many many many many many times
- 58:48the Kalam cosmological argument is not
- 58:50an argument for the existence of God God
- 58:52is not the premises God is not in the
- 58:54conclusion premise 1 everything that
- 58:56begins to exist has a cause through its
- 58:57existence premise 2 the universe began
- 59:00to exist conclusion therefore the
- 59:02universe had a cause for its existence
- 59:03that's the whole argument
- 59:05everything else that ties it to a God
- 59:07about saying oh that cause must be
- 59:08transcend space and time and be an agent
- 59:11none of that is part of the Kalam
- 59:12cosmological argument those are
- 59:14assertions that are glommed on thought
- 59:16things that I don't think that we can
- 59:17possibly know about what type of cause
- 59:19might be sufficient and necessary to
- 59:22explain the origin of the universe
- 59:23so the Kalam cosmological argument is
- 59:25not and anyway a proof for God what it
- 59:27is is it's a little hanging fruit that
- 59:30makes it seem like you're being
- 59:32reasonable because of course the
- 59:33universe had to have a cause and then we
- 59:35go on and have a secondary conversation
- 59:37about the nature of that cause I'm not
- 59:38convinced that we know enough to
- 59:40conclude what the origin of the universe
- 59:42is or how we ruled out things like
- 59:44universe creating Pixies or a multiverse
- 59:46or anything else I understand that in
- 59:48some of those cases it pushes it back
- 59:50but just to say that gosh the proposed
- 59:53explanation for the universe sounds a
- 59:55lot like God is not compelling at all
- 59:57because God is a specific invention in
- 1:00:00many cases to explain the things that we
- 1:00:02don't know every time there's something
- 1:00:04we don't know we stick God in there and
- 1:00:05if God can be an explanation for
- 1:00:07anything it's an explanation for nothing
- 1:00:09as a matter of fact it has no
- 1:00:10explanatory power it is functionally
- 1:00:12identical to saying it's magic because
- 1:00:16we tend to explain the unknown in terms
- 1:00:18of things that we know now he also
- 1:00:21mentioned that if I can't defeat this
- 1:00:23argument about determinism then you all
- 1:00:25have libertarian free will that's just a
- 1:00:27fallacy whether or not I can defeat any
- 1:00:29argument is irrelevant to what kind of
- 1:00:30will you have or anything else he
- 1:00:33measure that we have zero counter
- 1:00:34examples to this we also have zero
- 1:00:36examples of something not beginning to
- 1:00:40exist of something existing necessarily
- 1:00:42eternally we have zero counter zero
- 1:00:45examples of anything that has been
- 1:00:46identified as beyond nature I don't even
- 1:00:50know how we could begin to investigate
- 1:00:52the supernatural we can investigate
- 1:00:54manifestations in nature and we may come
- 1:00:58up with a model that allows us to
- 1:00:59conclude that these manifestations are
- 1:01:01caused by something outside of nature
- 1:01:02but we're not there yet and we have no
- 1:01:04way to confirm supernatural causation
- 1:01:06this is the reason why science is not
- 1:01:09based in philosophical naturalism it's
- 1:01:11based in methodological naturalism
- 1:01:12science methods cannot consider
- 1:01:14supernatural explanations so when we
- 1:01:17talk about hey I'm just
- 1:01:18the evidence and the evidence is all
- 1:01:20around and I don't think God's all that
- 1:01:21hidden what we're presenting here would
- 1:01:23not fit in with science by the way it
- 1:01:25also would not fit in in a courtroom
- 1:01:27because we no longer allow spectral
- 1:01:29evidence in a courtroom these are places
- 1:01:31where we learn how to live our lives and
- 1:01:33come up with new inventions courtrooms
- 1:01:34are places where we decide life and
- 1:01:36death decisions and that should be good
- 1:01:39enough I would think that if God can't
- 1:01:40stand up in a court of law or under the
- 1:01:42scrutiny of scientific rigor and
- 1:01:43critical thinking to where there's
- 1:01:45actually evidence for it then certainly
- 1:01:47would have to admit that we are using
- 1:01:48some alternate way of knowing that is
- 1:01:50necessarily on weaker footing than
- 1:01:52science and courtrooms now this notion
- 1:01:56that he brings up about recalibrated
- 1:01:58plausibility yes
- 1:01:59I completely agree and the way you
- 1:02:02recalibrate pause applause ability is to
- 1:02:05investigate and examine and come up with
- 1:02:07more data and that can't happen for a
- 1:02:09single occurrence
- 1:02:10it can't happen for historical events
- 1:02:12that we can compare it to other wins
- 1:02:14how shall not put the Lord thy God to
- 1:02:16the test
- 1:02:17well that already is going to prevent us
- 1:02:18from doing testing the Christian got it
- 1:02:20perfectly but when we try to test for
- 1:02:23this when for example the Templeton
- 1:02:24Foundation does a an investigation of
- 1:02:26intercessory prayer what we find is that
- 1:02:29prayer doesn't work it works at the rate
- 1:02:31of chance and as a matter of fact if you
- 1:02:32know you're being prayed for those
- 1:02:34people did worse the the contention is
- 1:02:36that perhaps they had performance
- 1:02:37anxiety that if they knew people were
- 1:02:39preyed on them and they praying for them
- 1:02:40it didn't get better this would somehow
- 1:02:42mock God so they actually got worse
- 1:02:44because of the stress is one thing this
- 1:02:47notion about the moon-landing there are
- 1:02:50people who deny the moon-landing I'm not
- 1:02:52one of them we've been to the moon the
- 1:02:53earth is not flat vaccines don't cause
- 1:02:55autism you know this is stuff that you
- 1:02:57can actually look up and investigate and
- 1:02:59you will find data and in many cases
- 1:03:01these are things that we can do multiple
- 1:03:02trials on now the bedrock facts and the
- 1:03:05minimal facts and Gary Habermas this
- 1:03:06thing I first of all there are people
- 1:03:09who don't think that Jesus existed the
- 1:03:11myth assists I don't think there aren't
- 1:03:13particularly good footing because it's
- 1:03:16not really that unusual to think that
- 1:03:17there's an itinerant Jewish rabbi in the
- 1:03:19first century because there were loads
- 1:03:20of but the facts that they're presenting
- 1:03:24as minimal effects are aren't
- 1:03:26confirmable and so what we're doing is
- 1:03:30saying he said well no you might not
- 1:03:31want to
- 1:03:32an assessment from a Christian
- 1:03:35theologian you might not want to
- 1:03:36assessment from an atheist you maybe
- 1:03:37won't walk from Hindu I don't want
- 1:03:39assessments from anybody
- 1:03:41I want data I want evidence because
- 1:03:44every single one of those things cited
- 1:03:46whether it came from an atheist a Jew a
- 1:03:48Hindu or a Christian is their opinion
- 1:03:50about what happened I want the data that
- 1:03:53leads to that opinion that's how we
- 1:03:55determine whether or not it's reasonable
- 1:03:56not because I can cite more references
- 1:03:59for my idea because the truth of a
- 1:04:00proposition isn't impacted in any way by
- 1:04:02the number of people who believe it or
- 1:04:04the sincerity of their convictions or
- 1:04:06how many other people agree with their
- 1:04:07opinions now I agree that we shouldn't
- 1:04:11be trying to do group psychology on
- 1:04:13people from 2000 years ago which means
- 1:04:14we which should point out that we also
- 1:04:16can't conclude that they were honest and
- 1:04:18reasonable well represented accurately
- 1:04:19presented and that we should accept it
- 1:04:21that's also an assessment of that there
- 1:04:24are people who would die for a lie I'm
- 1:04:25not I'm not assessing that anybody did
- 1:04:27or needed to die for a lie because what
- 1:04:29we have are claims and we have a dearth
- 1:04:31of evidence to actually be able to
- 1:04:34investigate and reach a reasonable
- 1:04:35conclusion on that I'm doing a video in
- 1:04:37the near future on compound inference
- 1:04:40it's a clever title but it gets into
- 1:04:42this notion of Occam's razor and
- 1:04:44problems with abduction and inference I
- 1:04:47won't go through it too much right now
- 1:04:49but this notion that I'm being too
- 1:04:52skeptical boy I get that a lot from
- 1:04:55people who believe all sorts of things
- 1:04:56that I don't believe mad I don't see why
- 1:04:59you believe that the Earth's around ball
- 1:05:00you're just too skeptical I don't think
- 1:05:03it's possible to be too skeptical
- 1:05:05because skepticism is not cynicism it is
- 1:05:07not asserting that something is wrong it
- 1:05:09is simply being intellectually honest
- 1:05:10and saying I am not convinced and I will
- 1:05:12not be convinced until the data compels
- 1:05:15me to be convinced and what somebody
- 1:05:17presents me with what convinced them it
- 1:05:19will either convince me or it won't and
- 1:05:21if it won't I need to be able to point
- 1:05:23out why I don't accept it and then they
- 1:05:25can evaluate whether or not I'm being
- 1:05:26too skeptical or whatever now when
- 1:05:29Laconia asked about you know the Comets
- 1:05:32smashing into the moon and producing
- 1:05:34that with that key you know God exists
- 1:05:36would that convince you know it wouldn't
- 1:05:38convince me that God exists for well the
- 1:05:39reason I already pointed out there would
- 1:05:41be arrogant of me and incorrect of me to
- 1:05:43think that I could tell the difference
- 1:05:44between what a God did
- 1:05:46and what some technology that I'm
- 1:05:48unaware of that this is how con artists
- 1:05:50work they play on what you think your
- 1:05:52kind of pop or folk understanding of
- 1:05:55what realities a magician's work I know
- 1:05:58too much about how we are fooling
- 1:06:00ourselves on a regular basis to say that
- 1:06:03yes that would be confirmation of God he
- 1:06:05did the same thing with regard to if we
- 1:06:07lopped off somebody's head and then they
- 1:06:09got up and walked out would you then
- 1:06:10believe in the supernatural
- 1:06:11no but I would believe that we lopped
- 1:06:13off someone's head and that they got
- 1:06:15back up from the dead the fact of
- 1:06:17something occurring is independent from
- 1:06:19whether or not I understand how it
- 1:06:20occurs and this is why when we talk
- 1:06:23about why won't God reveal himself yes
- 1:06:26if in fact a God revealed himself to me
- 1:06:28that does not compel me to worship or
- 1:06:29obey or anything else but it would
- 1:06:31certainly make it easier to get past
- 1:06:33these pedantic exercises about whether
- 1:06:36or not there's a god that actually
- 1:06:37exists and focus on whether or not this
- 1:06:39is a God that is worthy or deserving of
- 1:06:41worship or any whether any God could be
- 1:06:43there's no conversation confirmation of
- 1:06:46the supernatural ever any time the
- 1:06:50supernatural has been proposed as an
- 1:06:51explanation for something that we've
- 1:06:52observed and we've actually been able to
- 1:06:54narrow it down to what is the most
- 1:06:56plausible explanation the explanation
- 1:06:58has never been supernatural or magic it
- 1:07:02doesn't mean it doesn't happen just
- 1:07:03means we can't confirm it
- 1:07:06all right during this next session of
- 1:07:08the cross examination it'll be 12
- 1:07:11minutes long six minutes being led by
- 1:07:13each of our presenters so dr. hunter
- 1:07:16will begin by asking questions and what
- 1:07:18I want to ask of our presenters is if
- 1:07:22you are to ask a question please at
- 1:07:25least give about 30 seconds before you
- 1:07:28start to interrupt or to jump on each
- 1:07:32other's words I want you to be able to
- 1:07:33have a good conversation but having been
- 1:07:36in debates before I know it can get
- 1:07:38really confusing if you ask a question
- 1:07:41and you immediately begin to interrupt
- 1:07:42them while they're trying to get out of
- 1:07:43answer so at least let the the one be
- 1:07:46responding go at least a good 30 seconds
- 1:07:48before you jump in or maybe redirect the
- 1:07:51question or something of that nature and
- 1:07:53I'm going to give them as much a freedom
- 1:07:54as I can but at the same time if I need
- 1:07:56to jump in too
- 1:07:57make sure that the audience is
- 1:07:58understanding and that there's clarity
- 1:07:59I'll do that and so there's six minutes
- 1:08:01on the clock and dr. hunter you'll lead
- 1:08:03in the first six minutes
- 1:08:05all right so Matt I think you've already
- 1:08:08answered this but I just like to get it
- 1:08:09clearly out there is it possible on your
- 1:08:12view to have absolute certainty about
- 1:08:15anything including your own existence I
- 1:08:16have no idea if it's possible I do not
- 1:08:19think that it is possible so in other
- 1:08:21words epistemic ly you're not certain of
- 1:08:23anything we're talking about Cartesian
- 1:08:25certainty like I know you have to accept
- 1:08:26the reality that you're in and all that
- 1:08:28but and as far as like Cartesian
- 1:08:31absolute certainty you would your
- 1:08:33position would be we can't have that
- 1:08:34even about our own existence so far as
- 1:08:36you know so I'll try to do this quickly
- 1:08:39it's a really specific point and we may
- 1:08:42be talking about two different things
- 1:08:43basically when they cart does the
- 1:08:46cacciatore or some Hobbs pointed out
- 1:08:47essentially that's contingent on the
- 1:08:49validity of reason and whether or not we
- 1:08:50can ever show that reason is reasonable
- 1:08:51may prevent us from getting to absolute
- 1:08:53certainty which is why when I debated
- 1:08:55sites in Bruton keitai i called what i
- 1:08:57feel as maximal certainty so if i begin
- 1:09:00with identity non-contradiction excluded
- 1:09:03middle from that we can directly derive
- 1:09:05mathematics and then from that point you
- 1:09:08either have deductive reasoning that
- 1:09:09leads to things that are as certain as
- 1:09:11logic but I don't call it absolute
- 1:09:14certainty because I don't know how we
- 1:09:16can confirm the validity of reason okay
- 1:09:18thank you now you have said many times
- 1:09:20and I'm not sure if you said it tonight
- 1:09:21that we should believe something when it
- 1:09:23has been demonstrated can you define for
- 1:09:26me what you mean by demonstrated sure so
- 1:09:30in it's gonna be different for different
- 1:09:32claims and different claims are gonna
- 1:09:33require different types of evidence if
- 1:09:35you say I just got a dog I'm just going
- 1:09:37to believe you and part of it has to do
- 1:09:39with how that fundamentally affects or
- 1:09:41changes my worldview I know I know dogs
- 1:09:43exist I know people don't have dogs as
- 1:09:45pets and so I'm willing to accept that
- 1:09:46if you say I just got a pet dragon to
- 1:09:49borrow Carl Sagan's example I'm not
- 1:09:51going to believe that I'm going to need
- 1:09:52more and so what would be required to
- 1:09:54convince me that is going to depend
- 1:09:57entirely on what the claim is so if
- 1:09:58you've got a dragon I would prefer that
- 1:10:00you just show me that the Christian God
- 1:10:01exists well see that's the thing when
- 1:10:04we're talking about something that is
- 1:10:05capable of doing anything
- 1:10:08I can't tell the difference between God
- 1:10:11did it and some advanced technology you
- 1:10:13know it's like going to a magic show
- 1:10:14when you know nothing about magic that's
- 1:10:16why we that's why people conclude that
- 1:10:18oh my gosh darren brown's really reading
- 1:10:20minds yeah he's not yeah and so so would
- 1:10:25you say that you don't know what that
- 1:10:26demonstration would look like for the
- 1:10:27Christian God's existence I I have said
- 1:10:30that and I tend to follow it up by
- 1:10:32saying that if God knows if if a God
- 1:10:35exists then God does know what would
- 1:10:37convince me and God should be capable of
- 1:10:40producing that and the fact that he
- 1:10:41hasn't means that either he doesn't
- 1:10:43exist doesn't want me to know he exists
- 1:10:44yet is it possible that given your
- 1:10:46epistemic framework and I know you said
- 1:10:48that you thought it was reasonable to
- 1:10:50say that if a person part of the ocean
- 1:10:51in Jesus name or something that that
- 1:10:53shouldn't convince you but but is it
- 1:10:55possible to giving your epistemic
- 1:10:56framework that there you've constructed
- 1:10:57a set up where it just isn't possible
- 1:10:59that short of God taking away your
- 1:11:01libertarian freedom which I know you
- 1:11:03don't believe you have that he could
- 1:11:05actually make you believe even if I had
- 1:11:07libertarian freedom god I don't see how
- 1:11:11that God demonstrating his existence
- 1:11:13would preclude my freedom now I'm saying
- 1:11:15short of him taking away your liberty
- 1:11:17and freedom and making you believe it
- 1:11:19may be that your epistemic framework is
- 1:11:21such that there's nothing that he could
- 1:11:23do that would actually make you believe
- 1:11:24no there's loads of things that I did
- 1:11:26not believe that I became convinced of
- 1:11:28based on good evidence the fact that I
- 1:11:29don't know what evidence would convince
- 1:11:31me for this particular claim is about
- 1:11:33the nature of the claim but God wouldn't
- 1:11:36have to violate my libertarian free will
- 1:11:39in order to convince me of this for
- 1:11:41example if somebody just appeared right
- 1:11:44here and said hey I'm Jesus I'm real I'm
- 1:11:46here to show you that would begin the
- 1:11:49process of figuring out okay do I have
- 1:11:51good reason to believe that's the case
- 1:11:52but you still might be skeptical that
- 1:11:54that's an apparition or that you're just
- 1:11:56having a mental issue or something that
- 1:11:58would be the initial assessment yeah
- 1:11:59that's why you investigate to make sure
- 1:12:01that you weren't you didn't just jump to
- 1:12:03a conclusion so if somebody parts the
- 1:12:05waters in the name of Jesus well what if
- 1:12:09they part of the water I'm sorry to your
- 1:12:10question time okay is it the case that
- 1:12:12you're not offering a competing
- 1:12:13hypothesis to the resurrection tonight
- 1:12:15correct okay I don't have a lot of time
- 1:12:19for that when it comes to let's say the
- 1:12:21freewill argument
- 1:12:21is it not true that on your view
- 1:12:23whatever you end up doing it could not
- 1:12:25have been otherwise and doesn't that
- 1:12:28extend to your thoughts and beliefs no
- 1:12:30it's my position that I have no way of
- 1:12:32knowing if it could have been otherwise
- 1:12:33yeah but you affirm the position of
- 1:12:35compatibilism right well I have in the
- 1:12:38past I've gone back on compatibilism
- 1:12:40just a little bit and and that's back
- 1:12:42toward libertarian freedom or toward
- 1:12:44determinism well compatibilism is the
- 1:12:46notion that determinism is true and not
- 1:12:48in conflict with so it's not a move back
- 1:12:50to come to determinism I was never in a
- 1:12:52position heed back to her libertarian
- 1:12:54freedom no I've moved back towards the
- 1:12:57notion that we don't have free will of
- 1:12:58any sort okay that's not this is why I
- 1:13:01said it's too complicated that it be
- 1:13:03something to be happy to discuss okay
- 1:13:05given else I don't know that it's
- 1:13:06relevant okay but given the
- 1:13:07circumstances my doing this right now
- 1:13:10even though I experienced that as a free
- 1:13:12choice and all those kind of things and
- 1:13:13there's thoughts and everything and I'm
- 1:13:15thinking through it that was determined
- 1:13:17and could not have been otherwise
- 1:13:18because our mental states are reducible
- 1:13:20to our brain states which are reducible
- 1:13:22to our biology right I'm just saying
- 1:13:24that I have no way of knowing that that
- 1:13:26wasn't determined how would you show
- 1:13:27that this was actually that whether or
- 1:13:30not this felt like something I did
- 1:13:31voluntarily or if I just feel it because
- 1:13:34we have scientific studies to show that
- 1:13:36the brain makes decisions before the
- 1:13:38consciousness is aware of it and that is
- 1:13:40troubling it's something we have a live
- 1:13:41in experiments we could talk about that
- 1:13:43but here's I'm not saying that we've
- 1:13:44reached a conclusion I'm just saying
- 1:13:45that that's what the data showed okay
- 1:13:46but the point is your position currently
- 1:13:49is that am i doing this could not have
- 1:13:52been otherwise no I have no idea if you
- 1:13:58could have done otherwise and I have no
- 1:13:59idea how you could demonstrate that you
- 1:14:01could have done otherwise so anyone
- 1:14:02saying that they could have done
- 1:14:03otherwise is now made that's determinism
- 1:14:06no okay we got to the effort into the
- 1:14:10first six minutes now Matt will
- 1:14:12cross-examine Lee the cross-examination
- 1:14:14for the sir I won't leave that as I know
- 1:14:16I'll use some of my time to get this
- 1:14:19saying you couldn't have done otherwise
- 1:14:22would be determinism saying I'm not
- 1:14:24convinced you could have done otherwise
- 1:14:26is not determinism it's a recognition
- 1:14:28that determinism is essentially part of
- 1:14:31this but I don't know how you would show
- 1:14:33that you could have done otherwise
- 1:14:35that's that's the problem with that well
- 1:14:37that that wasn't I mean that I was
- 1:14:39asking you and that sounds like a
- 1:14:40respectfully that sounds like a little
- 1:14:42bit of a dodge I don't know how you
- 1:14:44would determine that that wasn't what I
- 1:14:46was asking okay asking on your view how
- 1:14:48can you tell it's Mike my question how
- 1:14:50can you tell the difference between
- 1:14:51feeling like you could have done
- 1:14:52otherwise and actually being having been
- 1:14:54able to do otherwise okay here's a
- 1:14:56couple of things I know you won't like
- 1:14:57the first one you might like the second
- 1:14:59one but I doubt it okay the first one is
- 1:15:01I believe so our immediate experience
- 1:15:06that we seem to have liberty and freedom
- 1:15:08you know you've probably seen John
- 1:15:10Searle and and others say things like
- 1:15:12look it seems when I do this that I
- 1:15:14could have just as easily done this and
- 1:15:15that are very difficult and that's very
- 1:15:17powerful to escape so and trying to be
- 1:15:20quick but so my immediate experience of
- 1:15:24liberty and freedom a good argument has
- 1:15:27to have premises that are plausible
- 1:15:29which means more likely to be true than
- 1:15:30not and any argument structured that
- 1:15:33would try that would convince Otakon
- 1:15:35Vince me that libertarian freedom does
- 1:15:37not exist would rely on one or more
- 1:15:39premises they're less plausible than my
- 1:15:41immediate experience of a libertarian
- 1:15:42freedom sure but that doesn't okay so
- 1:15:45that's one how can you okay where's the
- 1:15:47second one okay the second one is that I
- 1:15:49think if we don't have libertarian
- 1:15:52freedom then rational affirmations are
- 1:15:55impossible so there's a third one to
- 1:15:57you'll need to go ahead and say it or
- 1:15:58wait no because I'll deal with this one
- 1:16:00and we've got other questions and I
- 1:16:01don't want to spend on that own free
- 1:16:02will I thought this was something I
- 1:16:05wanted to address in the rebuttal as
- 1:16:06well and that's the notion that a
- 1:16:08calculator can reach a right answer
- 1:16:09irrespective of whether or not it has
- 1:16:10any free will so saying that we couldn't
- 1:16:13have reasonable positions without free
- 1:16:14will just seems to me an assertion that
- 1:16:17doesn't have a justification is that a
- 1:16:19question no but it can be now that we've
- 1:16:24you can i address that since you did say
- 1:16:26it well this this will touch on that so
- 1:16:28maybe the first question I had is
- 1:16:30reasonable non-belief possible I think
- 1:16:34there are people who don't believe and
- 1:16:38from their perspective they feel like
- 1:16:40there are good reasons for their non
- 1:16:42belief Wow okay
- 1:16:46and trying to figure out which it was
- 1:16:47dodged more right then as long as we
- 1:16:50both admit we're dodging a little well
- 1:16:52so that actually I don't think it was
- 1:16:54people people can it seems to me and
- 1:16:56correct me if I'm wrong it seems to me
- 1:16:58that your city people can be convinced
- 1:17:00they're reasonable even if they're not I
- 1:17:03think yeah okay I would agree with that
- 1:17:07but like going back to the Moon example
- 1:17:09those people were being reasonable it's
- 1:17:10just their conclusion was wrong yeah
- 1:17:12okay sure is reasonable non-belief
- 1:17:15possible in the context of for example
- 1:17:17the moon or the Earth's on example as
- 1:17:20far as what now like you could come to
- 1:17:22the wrong conclusion but you could be a
- 1:17:24completely reasonable based on you can
- 1:17:25be reasonable and be wrong cat it's true
- 1:17:29oh boy so I still would like to answer
- 1:17:34that thing go ahead why not what was it
- 1:17:37again the calculator could be right but
- 1:17:44but but it's purely a deterministic
- 1:17:47piece of technology right basically yes
- 1:17:49here's the thing that's that kind of
- 1:17:51proves my point because my position is
- 1:17:54that if liberty and freedom does not
- 1:17:55exist then rational affirmations are
- 1:17:57impossible that doesn't mean that your
- 1:17:59beliefs are false in fact if it were
- 1:18:02possible for a person to have and I
- 1:18:04don't know that there's anything on
- 1:18:04contradictory about this for a person
- 1:18:06have 100% true beliefs they could have
- 1:18:08100% true beliefs and yet they didn't
- 1:18:12get there rationally sure and the reason
- 1:18:14for that is because rationality
- 1:18:16definitionally is reducible to reason
- 1:18:18and reason is the process by which you
- 1:18:20deliberate over between beliefs and
- 1:18:23choose which is a good or a bad thing
- 1:18:25to affirm and if the libertarian freedom
- 1:18:27does not exist then we don't have
- 1:18:29rationality is impossible because you
- 1:18:31can't choose against the irrational yeah
- 1:18:32I don't think that I accept that at all
- 1:18:35because I didn't we we our
- 1:18:37decision-making machines and the things
- 1:18:40that feed into us the fact that we're
- 1:18:42having an argument or whatever else
- 1:18:43somebody may or may not become convinced
- 1:18:45and to them they may have this
- 1:18:46experience of oh I've changed my
- 1:18:48position on this nothing about
- 1:18:50determinism suggestor implies that you
- 1:18:52cannot change your decision based on new
- 1:18:54information that you receive that you're
- 1:18:56not a computer
- 1:18:57it's the fact that it's more complex
- 1:18:59obfuscates that which is how why I'm the
- 1:19:02original question was how do you tell
- 1:19:04the difference between feeling like you
- 1:19:05could have done something different and
- 1:19:07demonstrating that you in fact could
- 1:19:09have done something different I have no
- 1:19:11solution I've never heard anybody give a
- 1:19:12solution that other than well I really
- 1:19:14feel like I can and it would be absurd
- 1:19:16for me to think well actually first of
- 1:19:18all I do think how do you test it yeah I
- 1:19:20do okay well I do think that if you do
- 1:19:23seem to have a belief about something
- 1:19:27that seems almost impossible to doubt
- 1:19:29then you are justified in affirming that
- 1:19:33and believing that until someone gives
- 1:19:34you good reason to believe that that is
- 1:19:36not the case so I do think that's true
- 1:19:38however however I actually have other
- 1:19:41reasons one of those is the moot
- 1:19:42morality thing I think that if
- 1:19:44libertarian freedom does not exist then
- 1:19:46we're left with moot morality and what I
- 1:19:48mean by that is whether someone ends up
- 1:19:50becoming a philanthropist or ends up
- 1:19:52becoming a sex offender ultimately it's
- 1:19:55not that they didn't think through
- 1:19:56things and it's not they didn't you know
- 1:19:58but ultimately it was determined yeah
- 1:20:00but that doesn't so the mere the prayer
- 1:20:02grant that hang on so I got 10 seconds
- 1:20:04there are 60 the the primary concern
- 1:20:06about freewill and morality is how do we
- 1:20:07hold people accountable and the truth is
- 1:20:09whether or not they have freewill
- 1:20:10that was the agent that took the action
- 1:20:11and we hold them accountable and we may
- 1:20:13not in fact have any choice in that
- 1:20:14thing but this notion that you should
- 1:20:17believe something and tell somebody
- 1:20:19change their mind is actually a fallacy
- 1:20:21the notion that the burden of proof is
- 1:20:24on somebody trying to change your mind I
- 1:20:25understand that's how it works in
- 1:20:26practice but that doesn't mean that your
- 1:20:29positions
- 1:20:29rational just I'll go ahead responded
- 1:20:31that if that's okay because it was
- 1:20:32supposed to be questioned okay so here's
- 1:20:35the thing this came up in your debate
- 1:20:36with Mike like Conan quite a bit if you
- 1:20:38felt like the whole night that that's
- 1:20:40what he was doing and I don't
- 1:20:42necessarily I don't think that's what he
- 1:20:44was doing but I can tell you tonight
- 1:20:45that's not what I'm doing I'm not saying
- 1:20:47if you believe something until there's
- 1:20:50good enough evidence you're justified in
- 1:20:52believing it even if it's something like
- 1:20:53the supernatural what I'm saying is
- 1:20:55something like libertarian freedom where
- 1:20:57it seems impossible it seems almost
- 1:20:59absurd to deny it yeah it seems like an
- 1:21:02extraordinary claim it seems like
- 1:21:04there's less willing suspension of
- 1:21:05disbelief in the Terminator movies
- 1:21:07because at least they're the robots were
- 1:21:08robots you
- 1:21:09so I would need I would need some
- 1:21:11extraordinary evidence
- 1:21:12where I come from extraordinary claims
- 1:21:13require extraordinary evidence meet you
- 1:21:15all right we're coming to our final
- 1:21:18round of cross-examination which again
- 1:21:20each presenter will get five minutes and
- 1:21:22we'll start again with dr. hunter but
- 1:21:24what I want to prepare you for is the
- 1:21:26question/answer time for the audience so
- 1:21:28you're about to get your chance to
- 1:21:29participate and so that'll happen in 10
- 1:21:32minutes from now so begin to prepare if
- 1:21:33you have not already the microphones
- 1:21:36will be on either side and and we will
- 1:21:38take them in order just in the line that
- 1:21:40you're standing and we'll just rotate
- 1:21:41from one side to the other
- 1:21:42if you'd like to stand behind the
- 1:21:44microphone and be in line for those
- 1:21:46those questions
- 1:21:47don't take your places yet but as soon
- 1:21:49as the cross-examination is over you can
- 1:21:51come to ask just one question remember
- 1:21:53no follow-up that way everyone has
- 1:21:55enough time that wants to ask questions
- 1:21:57so 5 minutes beginning with dr. hunter
- 1:22:00all right so when it comes to the Kalam
- 1:22:03cosmological argument I think you
- 1:22:04misunderstood me because I said in my
- 1:22:06opening statements I'm not I said I'm
- 1:22:08bringing a case that begins with the
- 1:22:10Kalam cosmological argument and so I've
- 1:22:12heard I've heard you before say look the
- 1:22:14Kalam doesn't even conclude with God
- 1:22:16therefore it's not an argument for God
- 1:22:17well but of course often when we move on
- 1:22:20to that stuff that follows up then the
- 1:22:22questions begin you know that would have
- 1:22:25been addressed by the Cologne so when it
- 1:22:27comes to premise one of the Kalam you
- 1:22:28questioned did you question whether it's
- 1:22:31true that everything that begins to
- 1:22:33exist must have a cause and is it your
- 1:22:35position that it is epistemic lees
- 1:22:37possible epistemic aliy possible that
- 1:22:39universe could have come to exist
- 1:22:41uncaused out of nothing
- 1:22:42I don't know and I didn't address that
- 1:22:44tonight okay do you think it's epistemic
- 1:22:46ly possible that universe came to exist
- 1:22:48uncaused out nothing and I don't know
- 1:22:51because this is this so there are things
- 1:22:52that we cannot investigate and so we
- 1:22:55can't get back beyond the Planck time
- 1:22:56math breaks down at that point we can't
- 1:22:58so the proposition and one thing that
- 1:23:03you kind of raised was this notion that
- 1:23:05either there
- 1:23:07to come out of nothing and I think
- 1:23:11you've heard I've heard you before use
- 1:23:13the the sort of nothing that rock stream
- 1:23:15of it was a reference to a quote from
- 1:23:17somebody else that's not what physicists
- 1:23:20are proposing my objection to Kalam is
- 1:23:22that the conclusion is therefore the
- 1:23:24universe had a cause for its existence
- 1:23:26well I give the klom at all why not just
- 1:23:28put that as a premise in the in the
- 1:23:30argument that you're actually building
- 1:23:31because if I already accept that the
- 1:23:33universe had a cause of its existence
- 1:23:34and that seemed superfluous okay but
- 1:23:36didn't you just raise a criticism that
- 1:23:38would have been addressed by the Kalam
- 1:23:41tonight raiser what you just raised a
- 1:23:43can I think you just raised a concern
- 1:23:45that I don't that's not didn't seem to
- 1:23:47be what physicists think that there's
- 1:23:49this nothingness that came before the
- 1:23:50gong doesn't address nothing this either
- 1:23:52no but you just said but this would have
- 1:23:54been addressed by the Kalam whatever
- 1:23:56begins to exist must have a cause for
- 1:23:58its existence that the word nothing does
- 1:24:00not appear anywhere so are you willing
- 1:24:01to move beyond the Kalam and talk about
- 1:24:02the claims after the Kalam of course
- 1:24:06okay so do you believe the universe had
- 1:24:09a beginning I'll say that I have no idea
- 1:24:11so here's the thing really short our
- 1:24:14local presentation of the universe the
- 1:24:16evidence points to some starting point
- 1:24:19that we cannot investigate and don't
- 1:24:21know anything about yeah it may in fact
- 1:24:22be absurd to talk about things prior to
- 1:24:24the Big Bang if in fact time began with
- 1:24:26a big bang I don't know I'm not a
- 1:24:27cosmologist and I don't know that we
- 1:24:28have sufficient understanding to
- 1:24:30actually say yes this is the case a
- 1:24:31matter of fact they haven't physicists
- 1:24:33friend who's working in an alternate
- 1:24:34model to that okay so when you say do
- 1:24:36you think the universe had a cause for
- 1:24:38its existence I don't know okay but
- 1:24:40multiverse universe vacuum all
- 1:24:43contiguous physical reality my question
- 1:24:46is do you believe okay so you either
- 1:24:49have the universes past eternal or it's
- 1:24:51not is your answer just I don't know
- 1:24:53correct how could it possibly be that
- 1:24:56the universe could be infinite into the
- 1:24:58past I don't know how is it how could it
- 1:25:00possibly be that God is infinite in the
- 1:25:01past well we believe God is timeless I
- 1:25:03know it doesn't matter what you believe
- 1:25:04it matters what you go dils
- 1:25:05definitionally you asked how is it that
- 1:25:08God could be infinite in the past I'm
- 1:25:10saying definitionally well maybe
- 1:25:12something doesn't make it so well I know
- 1:25:15but you asked me how could God exist
- 1:25:17infinitely you did not explain how God
- 1:25:19could exist you just
- 1:25:20certain that he does by definition you
- 1:25:23asked me definitionally something about
- 1:25:24the Christian God and I gave you an
- 1:25:26answer we believe he exists timelessly
- 1:25:28so so he doesn't exist infinitely so I
- 1:25:31don't have that problem actually you
- 1:25:34didn't give that answer touch us now but
- 1:25:35okay they're good oh yeah okay so the
- 1:25:39problem with the past infinite seems to
- 1:25:41be it doesn't it that if you crossed
- 1:25:45half of infinity if time and events
- 1:25:48there's no such thing as sorry Minh past
- 1:25:52events all just a series of events then
- 1:25:54infinity isn't a quantity it's
- 1:25:57unquantifiable it's a concept to
- 1:25:59describe something that is that is
- 1:26:01there's no number four right so there's
- 1:26:03no such thing is half of infinity right
- 1:26:05then similarly there's no such thing as
- 1:26:07half of eternity
- 1:26:08I know but sure descry aren't you
- 1:26:10describing the very problem that I'm
- 1:26:12raising is that when you posit that the
- 1:26:14universe has existed forever how
- 1:26:16whatever word you want to use for that
- 1:26:17isn't it the case that if that's true
- 1:26:19you would have this mathematical
- 1:26:21quandary where you never arrived at
- 1:26:23today no because if time began with the
- 1:26:25universe then the universe has existed
- 1:26:26since time again okay so then it's not
- 1:26:28past eternal I never said it was past
- 1:26:31eternal said you didn't know correct I
- 1:26:33don't know if the why is this so
- 1:26:35difficult I'm not a physicist I don't
- 1:26:36think anybody knows the difference
- 1:26:37between me and many apologists who also
- 1:26:40aren't physicists is that I'm not
- 1:26:42willing to pretend that I know just
- 1:26:44because I got stumped by a question and
- 1:26:46proposed something that can be an answer
- 1:26:48to everything why do you need to be a
- 1:26:49physicist in order to understand the
- 1:26:51philosophical point that the the
- 1:26:53universe can't be past infinite because
- 1:26:54we would have never arrived it today
- 1:26:56because a philosophical approximation is
- 1:27:00different from what actually happened at
- 1:27:03the origin of the universe all right
- 1:27:05five minutes now continuing with Matt
- 1:27:09leading the cross-examination yeah this
- 1:27:11is where the the frustrating things is
- 1:27:13that you know I constantly if I if I
- 1:27:16honestly don't know something I say I
- 1:27:17don't know and then people act as if
- 1:27:19it's absurd because they're convinced
- 1:27:21they do have the right answer so when
- 1:27:24we're talking about how one could
- 1:27:25demonstrate that God existed
- 1:27:28there's the filthy illogical assertions
- 1:27:31there's the philosophical arguments but
- 1:27:34there's no
- 1:27:35thing that I'm aware of that could enter
- 1:27:37into a scientific investigation or even
- 1:27:41investigation of a courtroom am I right
- 1:27:44about that are we kind of stuck in the
- 1:27:46philosophic well there are those people
- 1:27:48in the intelligent design community who
- 1:27:50do deal with science and stuff like that
- 1:27:53I'm not one of those guys you'll notice
- 1:27:55I didn't bring a teleological argument
- 1:27:56tonight a design argument but I would
- 1:27:58say this since you asked me the thing
- 1:28:00about it is I think and I think that
- 1:28:02lots of other apologists have mentioned
- 1:28:04this to you I don't I know you don't
- 1:28:05agree but it seems like you're using
- 1:28:07your it seems like you want to use a
- 1:28:09method like you prefer methodological
- 1:28:11naturalism know is that not the case
- 1:28:14okay well clarify preferred methods that
- 1:28:16demonstrate that they lead to
- 1:28:18consistently reliable results okay great
- 1:28:21scientific processes do that
- 1:28:23the theological processes don't ok faith
- 1:28:26doesn't faith is not a path to
- 1:28:28understanding there's no position you
- 1:28:30couldn't justify based on faith and I
- 1:28:31know you're not appealing to that yeah
- 1:28:33I'm saying if what methodology can
- 1:28:36somebody demonstrate that we have a good
- 1:28:39understanding of its reliability that
- 1:28:42leads to the conclusion that a god any
- 1:28:44God let alone the Christian God exists
- 1:28:45ok I think those kind of when you say
- 1:28:48and I want to understand you properly
- 1:28:49when you say that God needs to manifest
- 1:28:52in some detectable way and I don't know
- 1:28:53if you said that's night but you've said
- 1:28:55it sure or or God needs to you know it
- 1:28:57sounds like what you're saying is that
- 1:28:59there needs to be something kind of I'm
- 1:29:00not saying science but something kind of
- 1:29:02science II that we can kind of test this
- 1:29:04thing and here's the thing here use my
- 1:29:06response to that so I'll do it by
- 1:29:08analogy let's imagine that we have a
- 1:29:10metal detector and that metal detector
- 1:29:11represents science or whatever you're
- 1:29:14proposing and if you were to say man
- 1:29:16this metal detector every time there's
- 1:29:18metal this metal detector chirps it's
- 1:29:20like the best metal detector in the
- 1:29:21world therefore we have no good reason
- 1:29:24to believe that sand and water and trees
- 1:29:25and air exist that would be that would
- 1:29:28be a problem what you would do in other
- 1:29:29words is you would look for another
- 1:29:30device and I think what you brought
- 1:29:32tonight is philosophy and history and I
- 1:29:35think philosophy does reliably get us
- 1:29:37two answers and I've given you
- 1:29:39philosophical arguments but I haven't
- 1:29:40heard and it's not that you haven't said
- 1:29:42things about them you have and I've
- 1:29:43enjoyed it but I don't think you've said
- 1:29:45anything substantive to really deal with
- 1:29:48especially the Kalam cosmological
- 1:29:49argument so or the case that begins with
- 1:29:54the Kalam oh I did the substantive thing
- 1:29:57is that even if you concluded that the
- 1:29:58universe that next one it must have an
- 1:30:00explanation for its existence or must
- 1:30:02have a cause for its existence what do
- 1:30:04you know about that cause and how do you
- 1:30:05know it and whenever when you or anybody
- 1:30:07else has presented the case it is a list
- 1:30:09of assertions well can I answer so if
- 1:30:12it's if if it's the cause of all nature
- 1:30:14coming into existence then that would be
- 1:30:17if nature is space-time matter then the
- 1:30:21cause would have to be if your nature
- 1:30:24can't come before nature to cause nature
- 1:30:25how do you know that
- 1:30:26well because it's nature that we're
- 1:30:27trying to explain okay how do you know
- 1:30:29it's not a different nature well it
- 1:30:30could be but then you have I said all
- 1:30:32contiguous physical reality so what we
- 1:30:34would have is you would still have to
- 1:30:36have a cause for that nature coming into
- 1:30:38existence it would just mean you haven't
- 1:30:40gone back far enough yeah so what I
- 1:30:41would say then is the cause would have
- 1:30:43to be a spaceless timeless non material
- 1:30:45cause what what requires and how is that
- 1:30:48an assertion so I'm sorry it's your
- 1:30:51question the fact that I'm fine with the
- 1:30:53notion that people intuitively reach the
- 1:30:55conclusion that whatever caused the
- 1:30:57universe is apart from the universe but
- 1:31:01actually that sure apart from our local
- 1:31:04presentation of the universe Sagan use
- 1:31:06the word cosmos because the universe is
- 1:31:10a terrible word when you're talking
- 1:31:11about multiverse is else and even
- 1:31:13attendant conflict so the cosmos is
- 1:31:14everything there is ever was
- 1:31:16irrespective of time or anything else so
- 1:31:18if the local presentation of the
- 1:31:20universe had to have some cause then the
- 1:31:23only thing that I can that I can know
- 1:31:25about that is that it seems to be the
- 1:31:27case that it couldn't have been our
- 1:31:29universe it caused itself so there must
- 1:31:30be something else yeah what that
- 1:31:32something else is or needs to be I have
- 1:31:35no idea because I have no way to
- 1:31:37investigate it I have no other universes
- 1:31:39to compare this to you'll notice that in
- 1:31:41my opening statements I specified that
- 1:31:43I'm talking about our local
- 1:31:45representation multiverses vacuum models
- 1:31:47whatever you want to bring up and it
- 1:31:49can't be past infinite for reasons that
- 1:31:51I'm happy to defend and I know you say
- 1:31:52oh I just don't think we can know and
- 1:31:54I'm saying whatever comes before all of
- 1:31:56that that we can call Sagan's Cosmos
- 1:31:58which is a Greek word that means the
- 1:31:59world but Sagan's Cosmos all
- 1:32:01of that whatever comes before isn't that
- 1:32:04but I see what's the case that it needs
- 1:32:06to be an agent okay
- 1:32:08can I answer that we've got four seconds
- 1:32:10left but it was a question I'll I'll go
- 1:32:11ahead and answer that so there's a
- 1:32:13couple of reasons why it has to be an
- 1:32:14agent first of all an agent would have
- 1:32:16causal powers now that doesn't that's
- 1:32:18not the insistence that's not necessary
- 1:32:20but that's not the end of the story also
- 1:32:22you have types of causation right so
- 1:32:25event event causation would be if I took
- 1:32:28this water ball model and threw it at
- 1:32:29the moderator and the microphone fell
- 1:32:31out of his hand that's an event that
- 1:32:32caused another event and I won't do that
- 1:32:34but then there's State State causation
- 1:32:37which is like a frozen pond where you
- 1:32:39have a log resting on the top of that
- 1:32:40pond this stay is causing this other
- 1:32:43state what you would have with the
- 1:32:44beginning of the universe is state event
- 1:32:46causation you would go from a state of
- 1:32:49timeless nothingness to an events the
- 1:32:51beginning of the universe the only thing
- 1:32:53that makes sense of that is agent
- 1:32:54causation okay just an assertion that
- 1:32:57that's the only thing you can think of
- 1:32:58it's not the only it's not just that
- 1:33:00it's the only thing I can think of and
- 1:33:01lastly I'll say this it would have to
- 1:33:04have libertarian free will and the
- 1:33:06reason would and the reason it would is
- 1:33:08because there was no prior determinism
- 1:33:11to lead to that event and what sorts of
- 1:33:13things have liberty and freedom agents
- 1:33:15do all right well one thing I am certain
- 1:33:18of obvious it's obvious that intellect
- 1:33:20causes people to lose their hair and all
- 1:33:24the brain food just makes the hair go
- 1:33:26away give a give a round of applause to
- 1:33:30our presenters when they'll be a great
- 1:33:31job
- 1:33:32[Applause]
- 1:33:40we can go is I'm good all right we are
- 1:33:43ready now for the question to answer
- 1:33:44from the audience so please go ahead and
- 1:33:46take the microphone I have to pee but
- 1:33:48that'll just make me more anti hate just
- 1:33:51be and walk out alright then okay go
- 1:33:53ahead take your places this gentleman
- 1:33:54was at the mic first and I yes and so I
- 1:33:57will let him ask the first question
- 1:33:58again keep it to one question and keep
- 1:34:01it brief and if you'd like to go to the
- 1:34:03back of the line and and start again for
- 1:34:05another question that's fine but go
- 1:34:07ahead set your name and and ask to ask
- 1:34:09away
- 1:34:09I'm drew my question is for Matt the
- 1:34:13debate question tonight with does the
- 1:34:15Christian God exists and braxton answers
- 1:34:17that question with yes I'm wondering do
- 1:34:20you answer that question with a dogmatic
- 1:34:21no or a maybe and if you answer the
- 1:34:24question with a maybe then why do you
- 1:34:26self-identify as an atheist instead of
- 1:34:27an agnostic oh so I thought I hid this
- 1:34:30at the top but I was talking fast so I
- 1:34:32answer it with neither know nor a
- 1:34:33dogmatic no nor nor maybe my answer is
- 1:34:37that I have no idea if the Christian God
- 1:34:39exists but the case for it that I've
- 1:34:41examined has been unconvincing and I can
- 1:34:44point out why I'm not convinced and why
- 1:34:45I don't think other people should be
- 1:34:46convinced atheism is not the dogmatic
- 1:34:49assertion that God doesn't exist
- 1:34:50although that is a subcategory of it it
- 1:34:53is I am not convinced that a God exists
- 1:34:56it's essentially God's on trial being
- 1:34:58accused of existing and the atheists are
- 1:35:00voting did you shake your head like I
- 1:35:02got a theism wrong yes
- 1:35:04okay well I'm so glad that happened if I
- 1:35:09walked in here and told people they got
- 1:35:11Christianity wrong how you think they're
- 1:35:13gonna take that probably not well yeah
- 1:35:15the thing is there's multiple usages of
- 1:35:18lots of words including atheism atheism
- 1:35:21generally speaking is disbelief I do not
- 1:35:24believe I am not convinced
- 1:35:26wait you keep smirking I think it's the
- 1:35:28proposition of belief that there is no
- 1:35:30God I don't think it's well you're wrong
- 1:35:31I'm explaining that to you as a gang I
- 1:35:34don't really care how you define it
- 1:35:35that's not we're done traditionally if
- 1:35:37you don't care how I define it why are
- 1:35:38you at my iveco okay can I say yeah and
- 1:35:41what we'll do on the
- 1:35:43on the cross-examination please address
- 1:35:44who you want to ask the question to and
- 1:35:46then the the opposing side will we'll
- 1:35:49get about a minute to to rebuttal or to
- 1:35:51say anything and follow-up to the
- 1:35:52question that was asked so you want to
- 1:35:54actually want to take up format here for
- 1:35:55a second
- 1:35:57honestly I make no bones about the fact
- 1:35:59I'm an apologist second and an
- 1:36:01evangelist first I know that doesn't
- 1:36:03sound cool to anybody don't really care
- 1:36:05I want people to have real conversations
- 1:36:08with people that don't believe what they
- 1:36:09believe to come to the truth and so I
- 1:36:12personally I know there's a big debate
- 1:36:14about what an atheist should call
- 1:36:15himself or whether it's an agnostic or
- 1:36:17whatever and there are people that get
- 1:36:18real heated about that I want to tell
- 1:36:19you something in terms of actually
- 1:36:21getting traction with someone and having
- 1:36:23a real conversation what matters the
- 1:36:25most to me is that we find out what they
- 1:36:27mean by what they're calling themselves
- 1:36:28and then go with that yeah the label is
- 1:36:32irrelevant whether you think I'm an
- 1:36:33atheist way you think about fake
- 1:36:34atheists whether you think I'm an
- 1:36:36agnostic way to think I'm a dumbass
- 1:36:37whatever the label is irrelevant I
- 1:36:40stated what my position was and we can
- 1:36:43either address that or not but if you're
- 1:36:45here to tell me that I'm not a real
- 1:36:46atheist I'm gonna say that I've hosted
- 1:36:48the Atheist experience for 15 years and
- 1:36:50that's probably good enough credit for
- 1:36:53most people and if it's not I don't care
- 1:36:54all right young lady right over here go
- 1:36:56ahead
- 1:36:57hi my question is for Braxton Matt
- 1:37:00brought this up in his rebuttal but I
- 1:37:02don't believe that you answered it
- 1:37:04probably just because there are too many
- 1:37:05points but I'd be fascinated to know how
- 1:37:07do you personally reconcile your belief
- 1:37:10in libertarian free will with your
- 1:37:11belief in an omniscient God which would
- 1:37:14know the outcome of everyone he creates
- 1:37:15yeah thank you for asking that that
- 1:37:17gives me an opportunity to answer it
- 1:37:19I've actually done debates with people
- 1:37:21that are who don't believe the same as
- 1:37:23me about libertarian free will who are
- 1:37:25Christians and I didn't think this would
- 1:37:27be a Calvinism debate tonight but maybe
- 1:37:28it is though so when we tell when we
- 1:37:32think about a God who is omniscient he
- 1:37:35knows all future things so are you
- 1:37:37asking me if he knows everything it's
- 1:37:39like it's already set so then how are we
- 1:37:41free is that your question yes okay so
- 1:37:44that would be and I'm not accusing you
- 1:37:46of this but that would be what's called
- 1:37:47a modal fallacy it's a category error
- 1:37:49knowledge isn't causal knowledge doesn't
- 1:37:52cause anything so God's knowledge of
- 1:37:55what I'm going
- 1:37:55to do in the future doesn't cause me to
- 1:37:58do it he knows it because I'm going to
- 1:38:01freely do it so it's just it's just a
- 1:38:03category err it's a modal fallacy good
- 1:38:05Matt would you like to yeah this is why
- 1:38:07when I addressed it I pointed out that
- 1:38:09it's not contingent merely upon a God
- 1:38:11knowing it
- 1:38:11it's a God who knew it created the
- 1:38:14universe and had options did God create
- 1:38:16the universe yes did he have options of
- 1:38:18other universes here can I answer this
- 1:38:21can I answer that's why I yes okay so so
- 1:38:24when when we think now this is going to
- 1:38:25get really complex really fast so just
- 1:38:28hang with me but when we talk about
- 1:38:30philosophy Matt's aware of this we
- 1:38:31talked about full possible world
- 1:38:33semantics and what we mean by that is
- 1:38:35not other worlds that actually exist
- 1:38:37what we mean is other other hypothetical
- 1:38:39worlds and if something is a possible
- 1:38:41world if it is a world that contains no
- 1:38:43contradictions okay so is there a
- 1:38:46possible world where Matt remained a
- 1:38:47Christian yes and I hope that that's the
- 1:38:49actual world we got an organ over here
- 1:38:51we could have an altar call and I'd love
- 1:38:52to see him come to Jesus tonight not
- 1:38:54counting on it but I'm just saying so so
- 1:38:56there are there is a possible world
- 1:38:58where Matt remains a Christian there's
- 1:38:59nothing contradictory about that however
- 1:39:01it when if God chooses to give me a
- 1:39:04liver chain freedom then we have a
- 1:39:05subset of possible worlds which we call
- 1:39:07feasible worlds that's the worlds remain
- 1:39:09has liberty and freedom if God wants to
- 1:39:12give me an liberty and freedom it may be
- 1:39:14that among those feasible worlds there
- 1:39:16simply isn't a world where Matt freely
- 1:39:18chooses to remain a Christian now I
- 1:39:20personally don't believe that I'm
- 1:39:21praying that Matt does come to faith but
- 1:39:23that's the answer that we give okay just
- 1:39:26for clarity yeah are you suggesting that
- 1:39:28God could not have created a universe in
- 1:39:32which I have libertarian free will and
- 1:39:35sitting here today would have been a
- 1:39:38theist what I'm saying is that is a
- 1:39:40possible world but if God gives people
- 1:39:43libertarian free will that gives us a
- 1:39:46subset of those worlds and it may be
- 1:39:48that in none of those worlds where you
- 1:39:49have libertarian freedom you choose to
- 1:39:52become a Christian so if God wants to
- 1:39:54get so yes God could make a world where
- 1:39:55you're a Christian but it would be one
- 1:39:57where he it could be one where he does
- 1:39:59where you don't have a litter train
- 1:40:00freedom okay let me jump in here cuz I
- 1:40:02know I know this debate and you get some
- 1:40:04to Mullen ISM and Calvinism and it can
- 1:40:06go forever and
- 1:40:07ever ever because I've been a part of
- 1:40:09that world so read on Braxton's page on
- 1:40:12Mullen ISM and in Matt's page to get
- 1:40:14more information about that we're not
- 1:40:16gonna get through all our audience
- 1:40:17questions if we don't move along go
- 1:40:18ahead
- 1:40:18my name is Ellis and my question is
- 1:40:20directed to Matt I don't remember
- 1:40:21exactly what you said towards the end of
- 1:40:24the the debate but on element of faith
- 1:40:26and as if you reject that but so Mike
- 1:40:29and I believe very much the Christian
- 1:40:32God much ever very much is based on
- 1:40:36faith so my question is if there is a
- 1:40:38God
- 1:40:39they determine predetermined that faith
- 1:40:42is a necessary element to experiencing
- 1:40:45him then you categorically reject that
- 1:40:47at that point is that is that what
- 1:40:49you're saying so it would depend in part
- 1:40:52on how we're defining faith I had a
- 1:40:57whole debate on whether or not
- 1:40:59faith is reasonable and Blake was
- 1:41:00basically defending the notion that all
- 1:41:02faith means is confidence but I went
- 1:41:05more with the Hebrews 11:1 thing that
- 1:41:07faith is the evidence about seen I find
- 1:41:10that to be a grossly flawed epistemology
- 1:41:12that could be used to justify anything
- 1:41:14and and I'm not saying that that
- 1:41:17obviously doesn't mean you're wrong and
- 1:41:18it doesn't mean that you know if there's
- 1:41:19a God he picked that model that that's
- 1:41:21wrong I'm just saying that I have a hard
- 1:41:23time I could say white people are better
- 1:41:26than black people and say it's based on
- 1:41:27faith and that would be a problem and so
- 1:41:31for the most important questions that we
- 1:41:34could possibly ask is there God is there
- 1:41:36such thing as salvation what must I do
- 1:41:38to be saved it it's very troubling for
- 1:41:40me that not only is there not a clear
- 1:41:45obvious answer for those things you
- 1:41:47could still be able to reject it I mean
- 1:41:49anybody who believes in Satan thinks
- 1:41:50that there's somebody who absolutely
- 1:41:51knows God in his power and yet chose to
- 1:41:53rebel and reject it but to say that
- 1:41:57those things are conditioned on faith
- 1:41:59faith faith is some people called it
- 1:42:03gullibility I prefer faith is the excuse
- 1:42:06people give for believing something when
- 1:42:08they don't have a good reason because if
- 1:42:09you have a good reason you just state
- 1:42:10the reason and you never say it's based
- 1:42:11on faith approximate so I don't think
- 1:42:14that that's I don't accept that position
- 1:42:16on with Blake I don't think that's a
- 1:42:18good biblical definition the word pista
- 1:42:19is you
- 1:42:20227 times in the New Testament and we it
- 1:42:24often just means conviction of the truth
- 1:42:26of anything and that conviction can be
- 1:42:28based on evidence Hebrews 11:1 which you
- 1:42:30mentioned I think a good translation for
- 1:42:32that is faith is the assurance of things
- 1:42:34hoped for the conviction of things not
- 1:42:36seen and remember this comes in a
- 1:42:39chapter replete with examples of people
- 1:42:41exercising faith on the basis of
- 1:42:43incredible evidence I mean we're talking
- 1:42:45about all these characters in the Bible
- 1:42:47lastly I would just say Theophilus of
- 1:42:50Antioch in his letter to Otto like his
- 1:42:52book 1 chapter 8 begins to talk about
- 1:42:54what faith is and he describes it in and
- 1:42:57I won't read it but he he basically
- 1:42:58describes it as when you have good
- 1:43:00evidence for something in your trusting
- 1:43:02that evidence so I think that's a good
- 1:43:04biblical definition of faith and most
- 1:43:05people believe on the basis of something
- 1:43:07whether I think that what they're basing
- 1:43:09it on is good or not all right go ahead
- 1:43:11my name is Bob and I have hearing aids
- 1:43:16so the question is to Matt I think I
- 1:43:19heard you say that we are
- 1:43:20decision-making machines yes and so my
- 1:43:26question is do you agree that no
- 1:43:28decisions can be made pertaining to past
- 1:43:31events of which you have not been
- 1:43:32personally involved one more time do you
- 1:43:38agree that no decisions you can't make
- 1:43:41any decisions pertaining to any past
- 1:43:44event of which you have not been
- 1:43:46personally involved because you were
- 1:43:47saying I believe that unless if people
- 1:43:51had these opinions that was not really
- 1:43:53evidence so it seems as though you would
- 1:43:56have to be personally there in order to
- 1:43:59prove anything and that would rule out
- 1:44:01anything in the past no that's that's
- 1:44:04that's not what I'm saying I apologize
- 1:44:06if that's the way it came off but when I
- 1:44:08first heard the question I thought you
- 1:44:09were asking me if if I could make
- 1:44:11decisions that influence to Vince in the
- 1:44:12in the past and that's the case can I
- 1:44:14make assessments of past events where I
- 1:44:16wasn't involved right I can be I can
- 1:44:19make assessments of all of the available
- 1:44:21evidence I have and determine whether or
- 1:44:24not I can make any sometimes I'm not
- 1:44:25going to be able to make a reasonable
- 1:44:27reasonable conclusion you know if I'm a
- 1:44:29juror and the prosecution prevents
- 1:44:32presents all of its evidence
- 1:44:33I may not have enough evidence to reach
- 1:44:35a strong conclusion I may be forced to
- 1:44:37vote not guilty even if maybe I suspect
- 1:44:39that something's there I can of course
- 1:44:42make decisions about anything I'm
- 1:44:44presented past present future it's just
- 1:44:47that the the strength of my conviction
- 1:44:49and the accuracy and reliability of my
- 1:44:51reasonableness is going to be contingent
- 1:44:53on both what information I'm presented
- 1:44:55with and whether or not I'm exercising
- 1:44:57you know proper critical thinking
- 1:45:00methods so I don't have a problem with
- 1:45:03the notion that well I think we're
- 1:45:06always assessing past events like you
- 1:45:10ask me a question but that's in the past
- 1:45:12right and of course I was there for that
- 1:45:14but if somebody asked me did my parents
- 1:45:18have sex sometime between 1968 and 1969
- 1:45:22I'm pretty confident they did because
- 1:45:25I'm here actually would have been 68 but
- 1:45:28and but that is based on the fact that I
- 1:45:32know I'm here I know how biology works
- 1:45:35in procreation I know people have sex I
- 1:45:37know and so there's a mass of evidence
- 1:45:38it's not just that one event
- 1:45:40if you asked me about an event like did
- 1:45:43so did Jesus walk on water well now I
- 1:45:46have to assess that in in the sense of
- 1:45:48alright are we are we assuming it's not
- 1:45:50frozen and that he's not dynamo with a
- 1:45:53trick for doing it did he actually get
- 1:45:55out and walk on water well they all the
- 1:45:57available evidence suggests that this
- 1:45:59isn't possible by any normal means and
- 1:46:01so now I need to assess whether or not
- 1:46:03it's reasonable to conclude that there
- 1:46:05was some supernatural means and I have
- 1:46:07no evidence of anything supernatural
- 1:46:08lots of claims about things that are
- 1:46:11supernatural and to me it's really
- 1:46:12strange that the it the rate of miracle
- 1:46:17appearances in the world seems to
- 1:46:19decline as our ability to investigate
- 1:46:21and film them on camera increases it's
- 1:46:24just like mysteries have started going
- 1:46:26away
- 1:46:27you know once upon a time there is
- 1:46:28pillars of fire pose a cloud and manna
- 1:46:29from heaven and all this other stuff and
- 1:46:31of course the website way why won't God
- 1:46:33Hill amputees but now it's it's like you
- 1:46:37know oh we were having there was the
- 1:46:39thing I saw the other day where
- 1:46:40somebody's sister was killed in a bus or
- 1:46:43fire or whatever and the Bible survived
- 1:46:45and she's like it's a miracle and I'm
- 1:46:47like your sister died I I'm baffled by
- 1:46:52the way people want to twist things in
- 1:46:54order to make it look like wow you know
- 1:46:56it to God be the glory no matter what
- 1:46:57alright let's look at two things about
- 1:47:02that one I make no assessment about
- 1:47:04Matt's parents past copulation
- 1:47:06experiences and secondly you know I
- 1:47:11think miracles happen every day I know
- 1:47:13that sounds cliche I really do believe
- 1:47:15that and I know you're aware of Craig
- 1:47:17Keener's massive work on miracles I'm
- 1:47:19sure you've heard about that and I think
- 1:47:21that's a great evidential discussion of
- 1:47:23miracles and I speak in churches I've
- 1:47:25spoken in hundreds of churches over the
- 1:47:27past 20 years and I'll tell you what I
- 1:47:30know that we don't we I know that we
- 1:47:33haven't in all these cases looked at the
- 1:47:35evidence for these and all that but
- 1:47:36everywhere I go there are multiple
- 1:47:39people in every crowd that knows someone
- 1:47:41in their family who was healed of
- 1:47:43something in a way that the doctors have
- 1:47:45no explanation of what happened I
- 1:47:47realize that doesn't mean it's a miracle
- 1:47:48it could merely mean that there's some
- 1:47:50natural they're not aware of however
- 1:47:52when this happens again and again and
- 1:47:54again it does seem like there's smoke
- 1:47:55there's fire
- 1:47:55I'm not saying that those things are
- 1:47:57miracles I think they are but I'll tell
- 1:47:59you this much it means that the idea
- 1:48:01that miracles don't still happen it's a
- 1:48:04defeater for that I think thank you to
- 1:48:08your boat though I enjoyed it thank you
- 1:48:09okay so my questions about the Kalam
- 1:48:14cosmological argument and I have some
- 1:48:17major issues with it because I mean it's
- 1:48:22first premise is that everything that
- 1:48:25begins to exist must have a cause right
- 1:48:28but then if you claim that the cause
- 1:48:33must be some timeless spaceless God then
- 1:48:39you're making a special pleading because
- 1:48:42then what's the cause of the first cause
- 1:48:46what's the cause yeah of your God yeah
- 1:48:50thanks for that I I appreciate that so
- 1:48:52the reason that we do this it's not
- 1:48:54special pleading what we're saying is
- 1:48:56we're saying okay
- 1:48:57what what are we talking about we're
- 1:48:58talking about nature are we talking
- 1:49:00about we're talking about the physical
- 1:49:01universe Sagan's Cosmos however you want
- 1:49:03to put it we're talking about three
- 1:49:05things generally speaking space time and
- 1:49:08matter right so if we're looking for
- 1:49:11what the cause of all of space time and
- 1:49:13matter is you can't say well it's
- 1:49:16something in space or it's something
- 1:49:17that is in time or is made of matter it
- 1:49:21has to be something that is not those
- 1:49:23things that we're trying to explain
- 1:49:25which means it's spaceless timeless non
- 1:49:27material and as for then why we would
- 1:49:29say that it's a god or an agent that is
- 1:49:33sufficiently powerful first of all has
- 1:49:34to be sufficiently powerful to begin the
- 1:49:36universe but secondly we would say that
- 1:49:39you know like I said a moment ago you
- 1:49:41have state state causation you have you
- 1:49:44have event event causation here we have
- 1:49:46an example of state event causation and
- 1:49:49an agent is the explanation for that
- 1:49:51secondly it would have to have a
- 1:49:53libertarian freedom because there was no
- 1:49:54prior determinism to lead to that lastly
- 1:49:56you asked what about the cause of that
- 1:49:58kind of like the old question who caused
- 1:50:00God or who created God if God exists
- 1:50:03timelessly the only kinds of things that
- 1:50:04need beginnings or endings are temporal
- 1:50:07things things in time if God exists
- 1:50:09timelessly then he needs no beginning
- 1:50:11and he just exists yeah and I can
- 1:50:14actually try and help for half a second
- 1:50:15so it's I I spend as much time probably
- 1:50:19talking with atheists about how to
- 1:50:20better have better girl-- better
- 1:50:21arguments to not make mistakes this I do
- 1:50:23arguing with is the Kalam cosmological
- 1:50:26argument was specifically designed to
- 1:50:31avoid a circular pleading in the
- 1:50:33original cosmological argument because
- 1:50:35the original was everything has a cause
- 1:50:37for its existence and then of course the
- 1:50:39response is well what's God's cause so
- 1:50:40now you rework and the Kalam became
- 1:50:42everything that begins to exist so that
- 1:50:44you can exclude God because God didn't
- 1:50:46begin to exist it still has the problem
- 1:50:48that you're pointing out at the the
- 1:50:51second layer but it was designed to
- 1:50:53avoid that and demonstrate that that was
- 1:50:55the original Kalam no not the original
- 1:50:57Kalam the Kalam is does the original
- 1:50:59cosmological argument like I'd have to
- 1:51:02go look up okay maybe it's up to me
- 1:51:04later after sure and I could be wrong
- 1:51:07but that's the way I was taught was that
- 1:51:09there were so
- 1:51:09there is no be cosmological that's right
- 1:51:12category of cosmological arguments and a
- 1:51:14version of that began with everything
- 1:51:16has a cause and then LOM was everything
- 1:51:18begins
- 1:51:18all right this lines a little bit longer
- 1:51:20so we'll do two in a row on this side
- 1:51:22just to come help catch up because the
- 1:51:23gentlemen that have been sitting that
- 1:51:24long been standing a little longer than
- 1:51:25you guys so two in a row on that side go
- 1:51:27ahead my name is Jason and I got a
- 1:51:30question for Braxton it's about the
- 1:51:31cosmological argument to that kind of
- 1:51:34issue with that so this might be due to
- 1:51:37my confusion of apologetics but is the
- 1:51:40is the cosmological argument consistent
- 1:51:43with science up to the point of the Big
- 1:51:45Bang is that where God comes in and if
- 1:51:50that's the argument does that render
- 1:51:53like the whole creation part of the
- 1:51:55Bible metaphor and if if it's metaphor
- 1:52:00when does the Bible stop be being
- 1:52:03metaphor okay great questions I
- 1:52:05appreciate so let me make sure I
- 1:52:07remember the first part of your question
- 1:52:09okay science and in the second part the
- 1:52:11Bible okay I'm gonna go in reverse order
- 1:52:13so with the Bible there are various the
- 1:52:17Bible is a collection of books you know
- 1:52:19and so whenever somebody says well
- 1:52:21you're supposed to read the Bible
- 1:52:22literally I say I agree you are supposed
- 1:52:25to read the Bible literally where it's
- 1:52:26meant to be read literally we wouldn't
- 1:52:28look at the Psalms and say you have to
- 1:52:30read this literally because those are
- 1:52:32poetry right and so there's narrative
- 1:52:34there's poetry there's apocalyptic stuff
- 1:52:36in there the Gospels are greco-roman
- 1:52:37biography now Genesis chapter 1 which is
- 1:52:40really what you're talking about Genesis
- 1:52:41chapters 1 perhaps through 3 those just
- 1:52:45this one particularly is a very
- 1:52:46difficult
- 1:52:47genre to pin down and even before in
- 1:52:51pre-scientific even like way back with
- 1:52:53say augustine and they were talking
- 1:52:55already about what what exactly is it is
- 1:52:58going on here so there are various views
- 1:53:00on that I would point you to the work of
- 1:53:02obviously guys like William Lane Craig
- 1:53:04but also you could go there's a you know
- 1:53:07young earth creationists they have their
- 1:53:08stuff and then you can have guys like
- 1:53:09Walton John Walton he has a literary
- 1:53:11framework view there are various views
- 1:53:13on Genesis 1 so that's not a deal
- 1:53:16breaker if someone happens to believe
- 1:53:18that the universe is as old as whatever
- 1:53:21you know 15 to 20 billion years or
- 1:53:22whatever that's not a deal-breaker
- 1:53:24now as for science yes I don't argue for
- 1:53:28the Kalam using science because I'm just
- 1:53:30not that scientifically minded I'm aware
- 1:53:32of that
- 1:53:33someone like we and Len Craig would do
- 1:53:34that but or some maybe some others but I
- 1:53:38argue philosophically but yes it would
- 1:53:40be consistent with science all the way
- 1:53:43to that point of the beginning of nature
- 1:53:45which is what science studies and then
- 1:53:47when we talk about existence sans the
- 1:53:50physical universe yeah then we're gonna
- 1:53:52have to talk about philosophy and stuff
- 1:53:54like that Matt okay the next time on go
- 1:53:57ahead hi my name is Jonathan and I have
- 1:54:00a question for Matt but I guess it could
- 1:54:02be for both you guys
- 1:54:05I believe that desires drive us to seek
- 1:54:09answers and things I guess in the world
- 1:54:13and and that so my question I guess is
- 1:54:15what is it ultimately that you want to
- 1:54:19believe I guess both of you yes I'm just
- 1:54:22curious
- 1:54:22oh that's easy I want to believe as many
- 1:54:24true things in as few false things as
- 1:54:26possible I have this one I I'm a like an
- 1:54:29obsessive learner like I have way too
- 1:54:31many hobbies like if there are people
- 1:54:34who if they came over to my house would
- 1:54:35be like gosh you're just a really boring
- 1:54:37guy and they're right except that if we
- 1:54:40took a list of all the things that I've
- 1:54:42done and explored and tried to learn
- 1:54:44about and I tend to research until I get
- 1:54:46to a point of diminishing returns but if
- 1:54:49something's true I want to know it it
- 1:54:51there's a reason why the James Randi
- 1:54:53Educational Foundation would test
- 1:54:54psychics and dowsers because if there
- 1:54:56were psychics in dowsers that could
- 1:54:58demonstrate that they could do what they
- 1:54:59said they'd do that would be worth
- 1:55:01knowing it would fundamentally change
- 1:55:02our understanding of the world so if
- 1:55:04there's something supernatural I want to
- 1:55:06know if there's an even if and if it's
- 1:55:09the case that there's nothing beyond
- 1:55:10nature I'd like to know that - I don't
- 1:55:12assert that that's the case because I
- 1:55:13don't think we know wrexham I want to
- 1:55:17believe there's going to be a fifth
- 1:55:18Indiana Jones film I really want to
- 1:55:21believe that and see that the debate
- 1:55:22loser right there
- 1:55:24I want to believe and I want to believe
- 1:55:27it's gonna be awesome but where do I
- 1:55:29want to believe well I want to leave the
- 1:55:31truth and I think that's where me and
- 1:55:32Matt agree
- 1:55:33we both want to believe the truth and
- 1:55:34the thing about it is there are some
- 1:55:36true things that I don't like honestly
- 1:55:38there are some things that the Bible
- 1:55:40teaches that might not suit my every
- 1:55:42preference but you know what it doesn't
- 1:55:44really matter what I want to be true it
- 1:55:46matters what is true and I think the it
- 1:55:48mattering what is true is what Matt and
- 1:55:50I would agree about tonight over here go
- 1:55:52ahead first I just wanted to say yeah I
- 1:55:54was in that line and I snuck over here
- 1:55:57to kind of cut like then you took two
- 1:55:59questions so maybe there is a guy but my
- 1:56:03question is for Brax figure we've heard
- 1:56:05you asked Matt several times what kind
- 1:56:09of evidence it would take for him to
- 1:56:10believe so my question is what kind of
- 1:56:12evidence would it take for you to not
- 1:56:13believe it if I a straight hit the moon
- 1:56:16and it said there is no God in multiple
- 1:56:18languages or if somebody split the sea
- 1:56:21and the name of Buddha would that change
- 1:56:23your mind yeah it's an interesting
- 1:56:24question actually my worldview my
- 1:56:26Christian is gonna hang with me here the
- 1:56:28Christian worldview actually accounts
- 1:56:30for supernatural stuff happening in
- 1:56:33other religions I make no bones about
- 1:56:35I'm not the least bit ashamed to say
- 1:56:37that I believe there are supernatural
- 1:56:38forces that are positive and there's
- 1:56:40supernatural forces that are evil and so
- 1:56:42for that reason yeah as a deception I
- 1:56:44think there could be things in other
- 1:56:46religions now that doesn't mean that my
- 1:56:48worldview is not falsifiable he brought
- 1:56:50up false pliability and I meant to get
- 1:56:51to that you're not gonna like what I say
- 1:56:53about falsifiability and by the way for
- 1:56:55those of you that don't know if
- 1:56:56falsifiability is the if you if you have
- 1:56:58a good hypothesis you should be able to
- 1:57:00provide something that would show that
- 1:57:02it's false one thing that would show
- 1:57:03that that Christian theism was false
- 1:57:05it's kind of hard to have Christian the
- 1:57:07Christian God if God doesn't exist so
- 1:57:09someone could show a lot of times people
- 1:57:11will say well you can't prove a negative
- 1:57:12well that's simply not true
- 1:57:14there are no married bachelors right I
- 1:57:16don't know that because I've looked all
- 1:57:18over the universe and I haven't found
- 1:57:19any it's because the idea is
- 1:57:20contradictory internally if someone
- 1:57:22could show that God so defined is
- 1:57:24contradictory
- 1:57:25well that would show that that God does
- 1:57:27not exist and people try to do that with
- 1:57:29problem of evil arguments and stuff like
- 1:57:31that so that would do it right there
- 1:57:33another thing would
- 1:57:34if you if you if maybe there was some
- 1:57:37one of the disciples and we had some
- 1:57:38good reason to believe we found some
- 1:57:39document that dates the right time maybe
- 1:57:42there's a group of these guys and
- 1:57:44they're all saying hey these guys are
- 1:57:45out there saying that Jesus rose from
- 1:57:47the dead and they're doing all this
- 1:57:48it's Buncombe and we know it's bunk and
- 1:57:50and they're liars and all that okay if
- 1:57:52there's something like that you know
- 1:57:54that would be powerful evidence so I
- 1:57:55would be willing to change my mind if I
- 1:57:58was presented with good enough evidence
- 1:58:00to change my mind Matt do you say
- 1:58:02anything there I'll keep it brief this
- 1:58:04is what I was talking about in the
- 1:58:06opening statement when I say that we're
- 1:58:08all trying to solve these problems in
- 1:58:09pretty much the same way I agree with it
- 1:58:12by and large I agree with him on you
- 1:58:15know the notion of falsifiability and
- 1:58:16and the process changing minds where we
- 1:58:18disagree is on what evidence would be
- 1:58:21sufficient to warrant belief and it gets
- 1:58:23us to this point this happens everywhere
- 1:58:25and it's no fault of is I do it to
- 1:58:27everybody in this room has done it where
- 1:58:29all of a sudden we've become convinced
- 1:58:31of something and now we're sticking with
- 1:58:33it until somebody actually proves us
- 1:58:35wrong and this is why what makes what I
- 1:58:37do so difficult because I can't prove
- 1:58:39you wrong all I can do is show that you
- 1:58:41might not have good reason to believe
- 1:58:43the thing that you're convinced you do
- 1:58:44that you know if we if I could show you
- 1:58:47that the ruler you used to measure by is
- 1:58:49not reliable you should walk away going
- 1:58:52Wow every measurement I've ever made
- 1:58:53with that ruler is unreliable not that
- 1:58:56it was necessarily wrong just that I
- 1:58:58don't have confidence to think it's
- 1:58:59right we're both doing the same thing
- 1:59:01we've just kind of reached different
- 1:59:02Clark over here in the red shirt go
- 1:59:04ahead hi my name is John it's for you
- 1:59:08Matt talked a lot about evidence
- 1:59:10uncertainty tonight so basically have
- 1:59:13two questions you know if if we can't
- 1:59:16really know for certain why things are
- 1:59:19certainly true one what benefit does it
- 1:59:22do to try to convince somebody that the
- 1:59:24wrong and two I'm sure my teenagers back
- 1:59:27here would like to know why they are
- 1:59:29asked to take asked to take tests on
- 1:59:32things that are certain dear drew such
- 1:59:34as math or English or science sure so
- 1:59:37when I say when I say they can't be
- 1:59:38absolutely certain I also talked about
- 1:59:39maximal certainty that I began with
- 1:59:41essentially the logical absolutes of
- 1:59:43identity nan Chi and everything's
- 1:59:44derived from them is
- 1:59:46as certain as we can be about everything
- 1:59:47and the world that we inhabit and
- 1:59:49experience it's as far as we can tell
- 1:59:51all contingent upon that so deductive
- 1:59:55arguments that tie back to that are as
- 1:59:56certain as we can be it could be that
- 1:59:58maximal certainty as I call it is
- 2:00:00ultimately absolute certainty we just
- 2:00:02don't have a way to demonstrate it
- 2:00:03because we don't have a way to
- 2:00:04demonstrate essentially that reason is
- 2:00:07unfold
- 2:00:08however the tools of reason consistently
- 2:00:13demonstrate the reliability in giving us
- 2:00:15an accurate model of the world it's not
- 2:00:17like I'm likely to walk out into traffic
- 2:00:20you know and a bus appears out of
- 2:00:23nowhere and science enemy the world
- 2:00:25appears to operate in an orderly fashion
- 2:00:28and as long as that's the case then the
- 2:00:30best it's like people would say how do
- 2:00:32you solve hard solve system how do you
- 2:00:33know you're not the matrix I don't but
- 2:00:36until somebody shows me I am in the
- 2:00:37matrix and a way out there's nothing I
- 2:00:39can do about it I have to deal with this
- 2:00:40reality based on the rules that it seems
- 2:00:43to present to me and so why should they
- 2:00:45take a test because they're stuck
- 2:00:47dealing with the reality that there are
- 2:00:49consequences to not taking that test and
- 2:00:51not gaining that understanding it
- 2:00:53doesn't matter even if you were in the
- 2:00:55matrix let's say you're not in the real
- 2:00:57world you're in a construct and tell
- 2:00:59until you have a way out you've got to
- 2:01:01deal with the rules of the matrix you're
- 2:01:03in now I I happen to be fairly convinced
- 2:01:05that I live in the real world and that I
- 2:01:08share experiences with other people but
- 2:01:10that's mostly because I don't think that
- 2:01:13my brain has written every wonderful
- 2:01:16song or been every obnoxious caller to
- 2:01:18the show so I'm fine with the notion
- 2:01:20that I share space with other people and
- 2:01:22tell somebody shows me differently
- 2:01:24Broxson you want to add to that no
- 2:01:25that's fine
- 2:01:26okay right over here this is a question
- 2:01:28for Matt are we only decision-making
- 2:01:34machines and I guess based this on your
- 2:01:38your current understanding and then is
- 2:01:40that Everett from a past understanding
- 2:01:42that you've had I don't know I don't
- 2:01:46know how that's difficult to answer I
- 2:01:50think there's a way you could look at it
- 2:01:52where we are merely decision making the
- 2:01:54same machines but you'd also have to
- 2:01:58look at it is that we are
- 2:01:59so much more than that as human beings
- 2:02:02because not everything we make is some
- 2:02:04not everyday not even every decision we
- 2:02:05make is some sort of rational process I
- 2:02:07don't choose what I like
- 2:02:09matter of fact I don't think beliefs are
- 2:02:11a choice at all I think you can you your
- 2:02:13as an agent you are acting in accordance
- 2:02:15with your beliefs you become convinced
- 2:02:17of things it's not something I I just
- 2:02:19I'm now I'm gonna believe that gravity
- 2:02:21doesn't work that that just doesn't work
- 2:02:22out but we're not always remotely
- 2:02:24reasonable either I didn't choose to
- 2:02:26like chocolate ice cream I didn't choose
- 2:02:28to fall in love with somebody and I
- 2:02:31don't think there's any problem at all I
- 2:02:32think that while we could look at like
- 2:02:34love romantic love for example as
- 2:02:37something that could be viewed as
- 2:02:38ultimately irrational I think there's a
- 2:02:40way you can look at it is ultimately
- 2:02:42rational as well because I'm stuck on
- 2:02:45this rock as far as they can tell and I
- 2:02:47have to share space with people and
- 2:02:49things in my life affect their life that
- 2:02:52things in their life affect my life
- 2:02:53and so finding a way to live and work
- 2:02:55cooperatively is I mean that's just
- 2:02:58straight-up game theory on how to do
- 2:03:00this and so maybe having someone that
- 2:03:03I'm potentially irrationally emotionally
- 2:03:05attached to is such a massive benefit to
- 2:03:08me in all these other areas that it's
- 2:03:10ultimately rational even if we don't
- 2:03:12recognize it that way so we're decision
- 2:03:14making machines but we're not anywhere
- 2:03:16near a perfect decision-making machine
- 2:03:18Broxson do you want to follow up no
- 2:03:19that's okay
- 2:03:20probably the last question we have 30
- 2:03:21seconds left Mantha's questions for you
- 2:03:24I don't want to misquote you did you
- 2:03:26mention that you believe the Bible might
- 2:03:27have been altered or certain stories in
- 2:03:29the Bible might be altered yeah I
- 2:03:31believe the version of the Bible we have
- 2:03:32is clearly altered and I don't think
- 2:03:35that that's remotely outrageous most
- 2:03:38Christian scholars that I've spoken to
- 2:03:39about it they don't deny that it's alter
- 2:03:41and it's just whether or not it's
- 2:03:42altered in any significant way it's like
- 2:03:44if you go to mark chapter 16 verses 9
- 2:03:46through 20 we were talking about earlier
- 2:03:47they don't exist in the oldest and best
- 2:03:49manuscripts and that's where it talks
- 2:03:51about you know if you're a true believer
- 2:03:52you can drink any poisonous thing and it
- 2:03:54won't harm you and you can handle snakes
- 2:03:56well Christians can argue all day long
- 2:03:59about whether that should be in there or
- 2:04:02not but there's no real debate on
- 2:04:05whether or not it was in the oldest
- 2:04:06manuscripts
- 2:04:07and it's things like that the comma
- 2:04:09Johanna Johanna things like that where I
- 2:04:12think there were possibly alterations
- 2:04:15but even if there were none that doesn't
- 2:04:18change whether or not I find it Mexico
- 2:04:21yeah this this some of what I say maybe
- 2:04:24quotations from Craig Blomberg
- 2:04:26but airman guard airman talks about
- 2:04:28there being 200,000 to 400,000 textual
- 2:04:30variants in all of the New Testament
- 2:04:32manuscripts before the printing press in
- 2:04:331440 AD since there are only a hundred
- 2:04:36and thirty-eight thousand words in the
- 2:04:37whole New Testament readers might think
- 2:04:39that that means every word was in
- 2:04:41question with most of them having
- 2:04:42multiple possible alternatives this is
- 2:04:45false
- 2:04:46these are spread among over 5,000
- 2:04:48manuscripts there are 220 thousand
- 2:04:50translations into other Middle Eastern
- 2:04:52Eastern and European languages from
- 2:04:54Greek that means you have an average of
- 2:04:558 to 16 unique variants per manuscript
- 2:04:58not that scary I agree with him about
- 2:05:00the ending to mark chapter 16 and maybe
- 2:05:03I wasn't quite paying attention maybe
- 2:05:04some of the other ones that are
- 2:05:05well-known and fortunately most of your
- 2:05:07Bibles though I grant not all have a
- 2:05:09scholarly notation because Christians
- 2:05:11are aware of this our seminaries teach
- 2:05:12this and good pastors let their
- 2:05:14congregations know about this so I agree
- 2:05:17with that part of what he said and I
- 2:05:18think it sounds like he agrees with me
- 2:05:20that the variations that we have the the
- 2:05:23you know the scare scare tactics about
- 2:05:26the difference is is way overblown yeah
- 2:05:28anybody anybody who's saying oh your
- 2:05:30Bibles just full of all kinds of false
- 2:05:33crap that somebody and they don't know
- 2:05:34what they're talking about there may be
- 2:05:36some of that blame the problem is
- 2:05:38because we don't have originals it's
- 2:05:41always an inference to figure out how
- 2:05:43reliable the version you have is it's
- 2:05:45one of the reasons why we ended up with
- 2:05:47a Protestant Reformation if the church
- 2:05:48isn't going to dictate what I need to
- 2:05:50believe I've had a personal relationship
- 2:05:51with Jesus and the Holy Spirit can guide
- 2:05:53me through the Bible and if that is
- 2:05:54actually all true that's fine and it
- 2:05:56doesn't matter if there's an error I
- 2:05:57think there are some errors that are
- 2:05:59perhaps significant to doctrine most of
- 2:06:02them probably aren't all right one more
- 2:06:05time let's give a round of applause for
- 2:06:06our two presenters
- 2:06:13now I will admit what I'm about to say
- 2:06:15now is not fair to our atheist friends
- 2:06:17but after all we are at a Baptist school
- 2:06:20and this is being hosted by Baptist so I
- 2:06:22take the prerogative to do as I wish
- 2:06:23because I'm a libertarian Lee free to do
- 2:06:25so and I will give a past world word in
- 2:06:27closing by just simply saying I'm very
- 2:06:30similar to to Matt in the sense that we
- 2:06:33were raised in Baptist churches both
- 2:06:35being told we were going to be growing
- 2:06:36up to be Baptist preachers and I came to
- 2:06:39a fork in the road I remember having
- 2:06:41those doubts in my life why we're
- 2:06:43looking up at my ceiling fan I said God
- 2:06:44if you're really there just turn on the
- 2:06:45fan and I'll believe in you I will trust
- 2:06:47you I will know what you're there just
- 2:06:48turn on my ceiling fan and it didn't
- 2:06:53happen
- 2:06:53remember notice I'm sitting there go
- 2:06:55Lord if you just make that pencil right
- 2:06:57over there do you just make it hover
- 2:06:58across the room then I'll just know
- 2:06:59you're there I'll know it I'll just know
- 2:07:01it and then I'll serve you I really just
- 2:07:02be committed and I know it and God got
- 2:07:05in my face that again he doesn't speak
- 2:07:07audibly to me I'm a Baptist I couldn't
- 2:07:08handle that but God it pressed upon me
- 2:07:12and saying Layton what if I did do that
- 2:07:15where would you start seeking for me the
- 2:07:19reason the Bible says it's a perverse
- 2:07:20generation that continues to look for
- 2:07:21signs and wonders is because when you
- 2:07:23begin to look on the external you will
- 2:07:25never hear the voice of God here and
- 2:07:27when you come to a fork in the road you
- 2:07:29either go to the fork in the road where
- 2:07:31you look for the science and the
- 2:07:32external or you start looking here and I
- 2:07:35started to realize that it's only when
- 2:07:37you begin to realize that God ordained
- 2:07:38faith and that he doesn't talk through
- 2:07:40the big storms and the big the big
- 2:07:43hurricanes he talks to the still small
- 2:07:46voice and when he gives you if he were
- 2:07:49to give you an external sign guess what
- 2:07:50you're going to be looking for the rest
- 2:07:51of your life you know what's going to
- 2:07:53happen I want to say okay guess what
- 2:07:54happened to me Braxton God turned on the
- 2:07:56ceiling fan for me it was just amazing
- 2:07:58and what's max is gonna think God didn't
- 2:08:00turn on my ceiling fan well maybe I
- 2:08:02should say ask God to turn on my ceiling
- 2:08:03fan so what Brock what's Braxton gonna
- 2:08:05do instead of looking for the still
- 2:08:06small voice in the internal what's he
- 2:08:08gonna do he's gonna start looking for
- 2:08:09the external he's gonna look for the
- 2:08:10sign he's gonna look for the wonder and
- 2:08:12he's gonna miss the still small voice
- 2:08:14because God chooses whether he believes
- 2:08:18this or not the Bible says God chooses
- 2:08:20to speak through faith
- 2:08:22and I'm here to challenge you I'm here
- 2:08:25to challenge you
- 2:08:26you can go match route and look for the
- 2:08:29external and never find it and even come
- 2:08:31to the conclusion that no matter what he
- 2:08:33did if he lobs somebody's head off and
- 2:08:34put it back on I'm still not gonna be
- 2:08:36convinced because it's not about what
- 2:08:38God's doing externally it's what he's
- 2:08:40doing here and I'm just telling you if
- 2:08:43you're still searching you're still
- 2:08:44seeking don't look externally look here
- 2:08:48and I promise you will find I promise
- 2:08:52you will find him if you continue to
- 2:08:53seek him with all your heart you may not
- 2:08:56believe that yet and that's fine if you
- 2:08:58come to the same conclusion I'm not
- 2:08:59trying to put him down here I'm simply
- 2:09:00saying that's my testimony that's what
- 2:09:03God did to me I can only say I was once
- 2:09:06blind but now I see I was once blind but
- 2:09:09now I see and you can never you can
- 2:09:11never take away the stories of the
- 2:09:13thousands upon thousands of people and
- 2:09:16I'll enter with the CS Lewis quote if
- 2:09:18Christianity false if it's false it is
- 2:09:21of no importance it's not but if it's
- 2:09:25true it's of the most importance what it
- 2:09:29cannot be is just moderately important
- 2:09:31it can't be that that's why these kinds
- 2:09:35of discussions are so valuable because
- 2:09:37this is ultimately what drives the
- 2:09:40purpose of our life why are we on this
- 2:09:42big ball why are we here why do we exist
- 2:09:46and if that's something you haven't
- 2:09:48grappled with as a college student or
- 2:09:50even as a 70 year old who's already
- 2:09:54retired it doesn't matter what stage of
- 2:09:55life here and if you haven't grappled
- 2:09:57with that truth and asking yourself the
- 2:10:00question why am I here what's the
- 2:10:02purpose of my existence my challenge for
- 2:10:04you as a theist as a Christian is don't
- 2:10:07look for the external because our God is
- 2:10:09one who speaks and the still small voice
- 2:10:11of faith please continue to seek Him and
- 2:10:13seek him with all your heart I'm gonna
- 2:10:15close with the word of Prayer father I
- 2:10:17do pray that God everyone in this room
- 2:10:19regardless of where they are in their
- 2:10:21faith and their walk where they are in
- 2:10:24their doubts and their skepticism I pray
- 2:10:27father that you in your own wisdom and
- 2:10:29your own ways will continue to review
- 2:10:31yourself through the still small voice
- 2:10:32that we won't look
- 2:10:34to the external but we would continue to
- 2:10:36listen through faith and that you may be
- 2:10:38glorified in Jesus name Amen I want to
- 2:10:42invite you to the unapologetic
- 2:10:43conference right down here in the front
- 2:10:44row there are some Flyers that if you
- 2:10:46would like to come it's not too late
- 2:10:48there will be registration open at the
- 2:10:49door if you want to come and register at
- 2:10:51the door if you can't afford to go come
- 2:10:53talk to me or Eric and we will provide
- 2:10:56you scholarship we will find you a
- 2:10:58scholarship if you literally just I
- 2:10:59can't come up with any money for it you
- 2:11:01come see one of us and we will provide
- 2:11:02we will help you find a scholarship for
- 2:11:05that so don't don't not come because of
- 2:11:07money please grab one of those brochures
- 2:11:10he's heading right through the back with
- 2:11:11those and as you leave you can grab one
- 2:11:13of those brochures and hopefully we'll
- 2:11:14see you at Columbus Avenue thank y'all
- 2:11:15for being here good night be safe going
- 2:11:16home
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Matt Dillahunty vs Braxton Hunter (Does the Christian God Exist) by Trinity Radio, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 26,225 words across 3,742 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.