YouTube2Text

Mao's Secret Police - Chinese MPS - Cold War DOCUMENTARY — Transcript

by The Cold War · 2,505 words · 172 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00The presence of large-scale, pervasive,  invasive, secretive and lethally effective
  2. 0:05internal security forces was, and is, a staple  of totalitarian regimes around the world.
  3. 0:11In Cold War terms, when it came to the  day-to-day surveillance of ordinary citizens,
  4. 0:16and the rooting out of counterrevolutionaries in  mass purges, we naturally think of organizations
  5. 0:21like the KGB and the Stasi. What we don’t  often think of is how this worked in the
  6. 0:27most populous Communist country on Earth. How did  the Chinese Communist Party keep tabs on hundreds
  7. 0:33of millions of citizens? I’m your host David  and today, we are going to take a look at Mao’s
  8. 0:37main internal security organ, the Ministry  of Public Security…This is The Cold War.
  9. 0:50After years of civil war, Mao Zedong finally  established control over mainland China by
  10. 0:54December of 1949. He quickly moved to dissolve  the existing intelligence agency that had been
  11. 1:00employed by the Chinese Communist Party,  the Social Affairs Department, or SAD.
  12. 1:04Instead, the functions of counterespionage  and secret police duties were transferred
  13. 1:09to a newly created body: the Ministry of  Public Security or Public Safety, the MPS,
  14. 1:15led by Luo Ruiqing, a long time Mao loyalist.  This massive organisation also oversaw regular
  15. 1:23police operations, therefore concentrating  all internal security under one roof.
  16. 1:28Luo, initially reluctant to take the ministerial  position, proved to be more than adept at his job.
  17. 1:34By the end of 1950, the MPS claimed to have  cracked down on 2,070 cases of espionage,
  18. 1:41including plots to assassinate Mao and other  Party officials. According to a CIA report
  19. 1:46dated from the 22nd of December 1952, the  MPS was structured in three main departments:
  20. 1:53a Secretariat, which included the administrative  offices, a Foreign Affairs Department, and an
  21. 1:58Investigation and Research Department. From its headquarters in Beijing,
  22. 2:03the MPS coordinated a network of Public Security  Bureaus, or PSBs, which were present in every
  23. 2:09large town and city in mainland China. Each  PSB included three main operative branches,
  24. 2:15the Public Security Division, the Public Security  Force and the Investigation and Research Division.
  25. 2:22The Public Security Division coordinated  platoon-sized detachments of ‘regular’
  26. 2:26People's Police, in charge of supervising  sanitation, traffic and monitoring members
  27. 2:32of the so-called special population. These  were known reactionaries, foreigners,
  28. 2:37former Kuomintang members, and citizens who  had lived abroad. The Public Security Force,
  29. 2:43by contrast, was a company-sized unit of  agents, recruited on the recommendation of
  30. 2:48Party members. They were in charge of protecting  Party cadres and arresting political criminals.
  31. 2:54Finally, the Investigation and Research Division  was a small team of five operatives, led by
  32. 3:00a chief and a deputy. These agents kept files  and statistics on suspected enemies of the CCP,
  33. 3:06handled civilian informants, and investigated  and arrested high profile political suspects.
  34. 3:13Besides the operative sections, each PSB also  oversaw a more sinister ‘correctional’ division,
  35. 3:19which administered both regular prisons as  well as forced labour camps. This put the
  36. 3:25MPS in charge of the infamous laogai labour  camps, the Chinese equivalent of the GULAG.
  37. 3:31Some estimates have put the  number of deaths caused by
  38. 3:33the laogai at anywhere between 15  and 25 million Chinese citizens.
  39. 3:39Further details on the operations of a  typical PSB were revealed to the CIA in 1958,
  40. 3:45by a defector based in Canton. The Canton PSB  employed 7,000 personnel, of which 2,000 were
  41. 3:53professionals. The remainder, presumably, were  civilian informants. The professional staff were
  42. 3:59recruited following strict criteria. Would-be  MPS agents had to be young, below the age of 30,
  43. 4:05with no history of family wealth, no history of  relations with political parties other than the
  44. 4:10CCP, no history of travel outside China and no  relatives living abroad. Most of the agents were
  45. 4:17recruited from four groups: the Party’s Youth  League, high school graduates, wives of MPS
  46. 4:22employees, and curiously, former Kuomintang  police or intelligence officers. Sometimes,
  47. 4:29existing skills trumped the risk of disloyalty. Fresh recruits were given basic training in
  48. 4:35public security operations at the  local Institute of Public Security,
  49. 4:39followed by a six-month trial period. They  were then fully hired and their training was
  50. 4:44completed on the job - a training which included  daily and thorough political indoctrination.
  51. 4:50Ambitious agents could apply for a two-year course  at the National Institute of Public Security in
  52. 4:56Beijing. Promotion to senior ranks, however,  was decided by the local committee of the CCP.
  53. 5:02The Party was also in charge of ensuring  discipline among PSB personnel. The CCP
  54. 5:08kept tabs on the political views of the agents,  imposing several degrees of sanctions in case
  55. 5:13of transgression, from ‘crawling sessions of  self-criticism’, up to criminal prosecution.
  56. 5:19Personnel were monitored for their private  conduct, expected to be impeccable. The
  57. 5:25defector we mentioned earlier had been  disciplined twice by the Party: the first time,
  58. 5:29for having struck his wife; the second time  for having criticised the party meetings as
  59. 5:35‘dull and time-consuming’. Which may have been  true, but you weren’t supposed to point it out.
  60. 5:41So, let’s talk operations. One of the MPS’  early successes was the Downey-Fecteau affair,
  61. 5:48which took place in November 1952. Between  July and September of that year, the CIA
  62. 5:54had air-dropped a team of six Chinese operatives  in the Jilin region of Manchuria. This was part
  63. 6:00of the CIA’s ‘Third Force’ project: a guerrilla  faction of anti-Communists, who were not aligned
  64. 6:06with the Kuomintang. They were instructed to  engage in sabotage, intelligence gathering and
  65. 6:11psychological warfare. The CIA’s strategy was for  the ‘Third Force’ to distract Chinese military
  66. 6:17resources away from the war being waged in Korea. It is not known exactly how, but between September
  67. 6:24and November, the six-man team was uncovered and  arrested by the MPS. The ‘Third Force’ agents were
  68. 6:31then ‘turned’ by the MPS, very possibly by simply  torturing them into compliance. Whatever the
  69. 6:38cause, the result was a clever ruse. In November,  the Third Force members radioed 22-year-old John
  70. 6:45Downey, their CIA handler. The team requested for  one of their operatives to be ‘air-exfiltrated’.
  71. 6:51This was a delicate procedure, which involved  a low-flying plane snatching up the target,
  72. 6:57strapped to a complex rig. Although the system  had been developed during the Second World War
  73. 7:02for the Air Force, it had been deemed too risky  to ever use and this would be the first time.
  74. 7:09Downey replied that the exfiltration would take  place on the 29th of November, at 2400 hours.
  75. 7:15The operation should have been carried by  trained personnel with Civil Air Transport,
  76. 7:20CAT, the CIA’s private airline. But due to a  last minute bureaucratic hitch, two of the CAT
  77. 7:26operators were replaced by Downey himself, along  with his colleague, 25-year-old Richard Fecteau.
  78. 7:33On the agreed date, a CAT C47 aircraft  flew towards the agreed pick up point,
  79. 7:38when the MPS sprung its trap. Two camouflaged  anti-aircraft guns opened fire, scoring hits
  80. 7:44on the Skytrain’s cockpit. The pilots managed to  steer the plane into a controlled crash landing,
  81. 7:49but both died in the impact. Downey  and Fecteau suffered minor wounds,
  82. 7:54and were immediately arrested by the waiting MPS. The two CIA agents were driven to a police station
  83. 8:00in Antu, where an MPS officer, clad in  a leather jacket and wielding a pistol,
  84. 8:05pointed at Downey and said in English:  ‘You are Jack. Your future is very dark’.
  85. 8:10Downey and Fecteau were shackled with heavy leg  irons and taken to Mukden for interrogation. They
  86. 8:16were neither tortured nor beaten, but subjected  to sleep deprivation and psychological abuse.
  87. 8:22Eventually, both confessed to being CIA spies,  but did not reveal any information of importance.
  88. 8:29For example, when the MPS insisted they provide  identities and descriptions of fellow agents,
  89. 8:34Fecteau only gave them first names, and described  his Boston University Football teammates!
  90. 8:40After two years of solitary confinement, Downey  and Fecteau were finally put on trial where a
  91. 8:45military court found them guilty of espionage.  Downey, as the ‘Chief Culprit’ was sentenced to
  92. 8:52life imprisonment. Fecteau, as ‘Assistant Chief  Culprit’ only received 20 years. On the 23rd of
  93. 8:59November 1954, the MPS publicly acknowledged that  the two agents, thus far presumed dead by the CIA,
  94. 9:05were both alive and in custody. The Agency  immediately requested for the US Government
  95. 9:11to put pressure on Beijing to free the two men,  but there were several diplomatic impediments.
  96. 9:17Officially, Washington had declared that  Downey and Fecteau were civilian employees
  97. 9:21with the Department of Defence. As such, their  freedom could not be negotiated, as had been
  98. 9:26the case with other POWs from the Korean War.  Moreover, the State Department had not officially
  99. 9:32recognised the Communist Chinese government,  and their stance was to avoid any bargain,
  100. 9:37concession or negotiation with Beijing. The two men endured their sentence,
  101. 9:43mostly in solitary confinement, throughout  the 1950s and 1960s. In December 1971,
  102. 9:50Fecteau’s sentence expired and he was released,  while Downey’s terms were reduced from life to a
  103. 9:56further five years from that date. The following  year, President Nixon resumed diplomatic relations
  104. 10:02with China, which allowed him to issue an  appeal for Downey’s release in March 1973.
  105. 10:08Following the ordeal, both agents received  the Distinguished Intelligence Medal. And as
  106. 10:13a curiosity, John Downey got married in 1975. His  wife Audrey, of Chinese origin, had been born in
  107. 10:20Manchuria, not far from where he was captured. OK, back to the MPS itself. Besides this
  108. 10:25successful action in counter-espionage, the MPS  is probably best known for being the strongarm
  109. 10:30of the Party when it came to large-scale  purges. Between 1950 and 1952, the MPS was
  110. 10:36the driving force of the Campaign to Suppress  Counterrevolutionaries. The identification of
  111. 10:41such targets relied largely on the millions of  voluntary tips provided by civilian informants;
  112. 10:46they were the MPS’ chief weapon at the  end of the day. Hundreds of thousands of
  113. 10:50citizens were arrested due to their allegedly  suspicious backgrounds, and up to 700,000
  114. 10:56were executed. Due process and accuracy may not  have been a guiding factor in many of these cases.
  115. 11:05By 1953, the MPS Director Luo Ruiqing may have  realised they had gone too far. Fearing popular
  116. 11:12backlash, Luo and Ling Yun, the Chief of  Beijing's PSB, enacted reforms aimed at
  117. 11:19finding actual hostile elements, rather  than just the mass murder of civilians.
  118. 11:24These reforms did not completely prevent future  purges, however. Purges, which, by the way,
  119. 11:29did not spare the CCP leadership, the MPS itself  nor other members of the intelligence community.
  120. 11:47In January 1952 the purge was already  in motion, as the Director and Deputy
  121. 11:52Director of the MPS' administrative office  had been arrested on charges of taking bribes.
  122. 11:58But the event that rocked the CCP to the core  was the Gao-Rao-Hannian affair. In the winters
  123. 12:04of 1952 and 1953, Mao chaired planning  meetings for the first Five-Year plan.
  124. 12:09During these meetings, Party leaders including  Premier Zhou Enlai and Vice-Chairman Liu Shaoqi
  125. 12:15disagreed with Mao’s proposed timetable  and implementation methods. This led to
  126. 12:21a rift within the Party, with Mao attacking  the ‘rightist tendencies’ of Zhou and Liu.
  127. 12:26Gao Gang, Chairman of the State  Planning Commission, and Rao Shushi,
  128. 12:31Minister of Organization Department of the  CCP, apparently sided with Mao, conspiring
  129. 12:36to isolate Liu. The Great Helmsman should have  been pleased, but in 1954 he changed his course,
  130. 12:43and attacked Gao and Rao instead, accusing them of  building an ‘anti-Party alliance’ to seize power.
  131. 12:50This sparked another round of purges. Gao  committed suicide on the 17th of August 1954
  132. 12:56leading the MPS to focus its attention on Rao and  anybody who was or had ever been connected to him,
  133. 13:03especially during his time as Shanghai’s Party  Secretary. In Autumn of 1954, the former Chief
  134. 13:09of Police for Shanghai, Yang Fan, was arrested,  alongside former spy Hu Junhe. Some 1,000 Party
  135. 13:16members in Shanghai alone were arrested and  mistreated. In April of 1955, Rao himself was
  136. 13:23detained by the MPS for counter-revolutionary  crimes. Only a few days later, the MPS came
  137. 13:29knocking on the door of Pan Hannian, who had been  a master spy with the MPS’ predecessor, the SAD,
  138. 13:35as well as deputy mayor of Shanghai since 1949.  Pan was also charged with counter-revolutionary
  139. 13:42crimes. Shockingly, the MPS had dug up evidence  that, during the Second Sino-Japanese War and the
  140. 13:49Civil War, Pan had entertained contacts with both  the Japanese secret services and the Kuomintang!
  141. 13:55But, the alleged traitor had an unlikely ally:  General Li Kenong, attached to the CCP’s Central
  142. 14:02Military Commission. General Li conducted a  lightning fast investigation on Pan’s background,
  143. 14:07producing a full report for Mao by the  29th of July. According to Li’s findings,
  144. 14:13Pan had indeed been in contact with both the  Japanese and the Kuomintang. But he had done
  145. 14:18so on orders from Mao and other party leaders!  Pan, a masterful spy, had been the handler of
  146. 14:25several Kuomintang double agents up until 1949.  And during the war with Japan, he had been feeding
  147. 14:32false information to the Japanese occupation  forces in Shanghai to prevent an early peace
  148. 14:37between Tokyo and the Nationalist faction. It would seem however, that Mao and his
  149. 14:42politburo ignored Li’s report, and proceeded  to punish Pan Hannian and his wife Dong Hui,
  150. 14:48also a former secret agent. Pan and Dong  were arrested and sentenced to a laogai,
  151. 14:53dying in 1977 and 1979 respectively. They were  posthumously exonerated of all charges in 1982.
  152. 15:03But back in 1955, the campaign of internal  terror did not conclude with Pan’s arrest. It
  153. 15:09was exacerbated by the bombing, on April 11, of an  Air India passenger flight - a plane on which Zhou
  154. 15:16Enlai was supposed to fly! The MPS investigation  found that the aircraft had been destroyed by a
  155. 15:22bomb planted by the Kuomintang in Hong Kong.  This led to another wave of investigations
  156. 15:27against alleged counterrevolutionaries:  18 million people came under scrutiny,
  157. 15:33with almost 260,000 arrested or executed. During the rest of the 1950s and early 1960s,
  158. 15:40the MPS established an iron grip on Chinese  society, by deploying a devastating weapon:
  159. 15:44bureaucracy. And one of its more devilish  incarnations in particular: the hukuo system. This
  160. 15:50is a household registration policy, which requires  all citizens to record their home area, forbids
  161. 15:56internal movements without permission and records  all visits outside the area of one’s residence.
  162. 16:00Very similar to the Soviet propiska, in fact. The MPS will return to become a protagonist of
  163. 16:07mass security operations, and, naturally, purges,  in 1966, with the onset of Mao’s infamous Cultural
  164. 16:13Revolution. But, we are going to look at that  separately in a different video. But before
  165. 16:18that we’ll return to the world of Chinese  espionage with a dedicated video on the Shi
  166. 16:23Peipu-Boursicot affair, a story so incredible it  should probably be made into a movie. Actually it
  167. 16:28was, David Cronenberg’s 1993 film, M. Butterfly. So to make sure you don’t miss those or any
  168. 16:35of our future epsiodes, be sure to like and  subscribe but don’t denounce the bell button
  169. 16:39as a subversive counterrevolutionary…it’s just  doing its job. Please consider supporting us on
  170. 16:45Patreon at www.patreon.com/thecoldwar or through  YouTube membership. We can be reached via email
  171. 16:51at [email protected]. This is the Cold  War Channel and as we think about the Cold War,
  172. 16:56please remember that history is shades  of gray and rarely black and white!

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Mao's Secret Police - Chinese MPS - Cold War DOCUMENTARY by The Cold War, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,505 words across 172 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.