YouTube2Text

Many Worlds meets the Multiverse — Transcript

by bgaede · 4,147 words · 611 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I talked a little bit about um suicide
  2. 0:04yesterday, you know, dying. And we've
  3. 0:07talked about in the last few weeks about
  4. 0:09um out of body, near-death experiences.
  5. 0:13And so, one of the questions that pops
  6. 0:15up is where do you go after you die?
  7. 0:20Well, uh traditionally, you know, in the
  8. 0:22old days, you know, people used to
  9. 0:24believe in uh ghosts and goblins. you
  10. 0:27know, you had this spirit, right? And
  11. 0:31they came to visit you, I guess,
  12. 0:34and uh maybe it was the spirit of your
  13. 0:36grandmother or who knows what, you know,
  14. 0:39and um yeah, uh this is what they
  15. 0:42believed in. So, they created god uh
  16. 0:44gods, they created spirits, they created
  17. 0:47ghost, uh soul that is outside the body,
  18. 0:51that kind of thing, right? And uh when
  19. 0:54you died, your soul essentially went to
  20. 0:56heaven. You know, you you went up to the
  21. 0:59clouds. I guess your soul did uh talk
  22. 1:02about, you know, out of body experience.
  23. 1:04And this is one of them, right? And this
  24. 1:07is what people believed in. They really
  25. 1:09thought that, you know, there was
  26. 1:10something called the soul that it was
  27. 1:12your you. You know, your body was one
  28. 1:15thing and you what you had inside you
  29. 1:17was something else. And that something
  30. 1:18else is what came out of your body at
  31. 1:20your, you know, when you died. And
  32. 1:23hopefully you went upwards and not
  33. 1:24downwards.
  34. 1:26Okay. And yeah, this is what people
  35. 1:29believed in. And um where did they go?
  36. 1:33Well, they went up to if you were good,
  37. 1:35you know, if you were naughty, you went
  38. 1:37south. If you were nice, you went
  39. 1:39upwards. Okay? And you went to this
  40. 1:41place. You went to heaven. Okay? You get
  41. 1:44to meet your favorite characters. uh
  42. 1:46Jesus, Mohammed, Buddha, you know,
  43. 1:49Casper, all of them. And if I go there,
  44. 1:53I want to make sure that, you know, it's
  45. 1:55got beer in it. I mean, I'm going to
  46. 1:57spend an eternity. I want I want to be
  47. 1:59with a god of beer. Okay? Without beer,
  48. 2:01I think that would be punishment. Okay?
  49. 2:04So, I just hope God has a pub up there
  50. 2:08or something. Okay? Whatever they have
  51. 2:11up there. Uh but that's what the old
  52. 2:13people believed in. And uh you know the
  53. 2:16modern people you know we don't believe
  54. 2:18in all that stuff right especially the
  55. 2:20mathematicians they uh they are all
  56. 2:22atheists right or great majority of them
  57. 2:25are they don't believe in a god and you
  58. 2:28know like there's a heaven out there
  59. 2:30none of that no they've they've gone
  60. 2:32beyond that they're smart they're
  61. 2:34intelligent they've done their
  62. 2:35experiments and they believe that when
  63. 2:38you go up there you go to many worlds
  64. 2:42and before you do you travel maybe
  65. 2:43through the wormhole, you know, uh,
  66. 2:46enter a black hole maybe. I don't know.
  67. 2:49Uh, but it it looks more or less like
  68. 2:51this. Okay, here it goes. Let me show
  69. 2:53you. It looks more or less like this.
  70. 2:57Ah.
  71. 2:59Uh, you go through that wormhole there,
  72. 3:01right? And it takes you to somewhere
  73. 3:05somewhere
  74. 3:07spacetime somewhere there. You float
  75. 3:09around, I guess, in space. Now, this is
  76. 3:11done in a split second, you know. It's
  77. 3:13just instantaneous essentially, right?
  78. 3:15Here's in very very slow motion. You
  79. 3:18would travel through the galaxies. And
  80. 3:21where do you go? Well, you would end up
  81. 3:24um in uh one of these multiverses. Okay?
  82. 3:28And this is a multiverse. This is an
  83. 3:32idea that was popularized
  84. 3:36by Hugh Everett. Apparently it was
  85. 3:39created already or suggested by
  86. 3:41Schroinger. Uh but even before then the
  87. 3:45Greeks and other people you know they
  88. 3:47already talked about many worlds
  89. 3:50possibly existing out there. You know
  90. 3:53this is not a new idea. They just kind
  91. 3:56of formalize it mathematically. That's
  92. 3:58that's what's happened here. Okay. And
  93. 4:01uh so why did he why did he come up with
  94. 4:03this nonsense of many worlds? you know,
  95. 4:07uh I mean what is this all about? Where
  96. 4:10did they get this idea that I mean
  97. 4:12officially, formally, mathematically,
  98. 4:15scientifically, why do we have many
  99. 4:17worlds? Where did this idea come from?
  100. 4:19Did did we just get it from the Greeks
  101. 4:21and say, "Well, if the Greeks believed
  102. 4:22in it, we're going to believe in it,
  103. 4:24too." No, they they got it from the fact
  104. 4:26that, you know, they believe that a
  105. 4:29particle can be in two places at once.
  106. 4:32You know, you you have the uh slid
  107. 4:34experiment and the only way they explain
  108. 4:36today is that particle is at two places
  109. 4:39at once. And here, let's have someone
  110. 4:42professional, you know, a professional
  111. 4:44physicist, mathematical physicist out
  112. 4:46there explain it to you. Okay, here it
  113. 4:49goes. Okay, listen.
  114. 4:53Instead of the two vertical bands that
  115. 4:54you'd expect, a series of vertical
  116. 4:56smudges appear. To make sense of this
  117. 4:58pattern, you need to look at it from the
  118. 5:00perspective of a single photon. The only
  119. 5:02explanation is that the particle has
  120. 5:04gone through both slits simultaneously.
  121. 5:06A single object is in two places at
  122. 5:09once. The double slit experiment has
  123. 5:11been replicated with electrons and with
  124. 5:13atoms. But we are made up of atoms. So
  125. 5:17atoms can be in two places at the same
  126. 5:18time. Why can't we?
  127. 5:27And you might say, well, that sounds
  128. 5:30reasonable. I mean, you know, uh, we
  129. 5:33can't explain the slit experiment except
  130. 5:35if when you shoot the photon, you shoot
  131. 5:36the electron, you shoot the atom, it by
  132. 5:41fks, it forks out and somehow one goes
  133. 5:43through one slit, the other one goes
  134. 5:44through the other, then they meet up at
  135. 5:46the screen in the background.
  136. 5:50You would think it sounds reasonable,
  137. 5:52right? at least the part where you know
  138. 5:54we have no other explanation but uh same
  139. 5:58from these these same people. Okay, here
  140. 6:00it is. Listen to them. They tell you
  141. 6:02what a photon is. And this is the super
  142. 6:04duper mathematical uh scientific uh
  143. 6:09definition of what a photon is. Listen
  144. 6:11carefully, okay? So that we know what
  145. 6:13we're talking about. Here it is. Okay,
  146. 6:16give me a second here. Here it goes.
  147. 6:20There are many many little particles and
  148. 6:22we call photons.
  149. 6:23>> What's a photon?
  150. 6:24>> Photon is just a um it's a good
  151. 6:29question. Um
  152. 6:32>> you know,
  153. 6:32>> you don't know what a photon is yet.
  154. 6:33>> I didn't prepare for this question. Yes.
  155. 6:35Uh this is a hard question.
  156. 6:37>> When we say photons, we always give this
  157. 6:39mass and the unit and size of it because
  158. 6:42there's no common language you can use
  159. 6:44to describe it. What it is photon and
  160. 6:46massless. So that's very difficult. So
  161. 6:49I'm sorry I asked.
  162. 6:50>> No, it's a good question. Very good
  163. 6:51question.
  164. 7:00So now all of you know what a photon is.
  165. 7:03Okay. No, don't don't let anybody
  166. 7:06convince you otherwise. Yeah. The the
  167. 7:09issue is they don't know what a photon
  168. 7:10is. And they're dealing with mass.
  169. 7:12They're dealing with charge. They're
  170. 7:14dealing with all this other stuff that's
  171. 7:16got nothing to do with what we deal with
  172. 7:19in physics which is objects. They don't
  173. 7:22treat they treat uh a photon as a
  174. 7:24physical object as a little ball really.
  175. 7:27Uh but then when you ask them you know
  176. 7:29what is a photon you know we don't know
  177. 7:31it's just a lot of mass maybe it's got
  178. 7:34charge it travels at the speed of light
  179. 7:35they tell you all the properties of
  180. 7:37something that they can't identify. It's
  181. 7:40like you you're talking about a dog,
  182. 7:42right? And you know that he runs fast,
  183. 7:45you know how much he he jumps and maybe
  184. 7:47even flies, etc., etc. You know, all
  185. 7:50that. And you say, "But what's a dog?"
  186. 7:52Oh, I don't know. I don't know what a
  187. 7:53dog is.
  188. 7:56Okay, so uh this is the situation here,
  189. 7:59right?
  190. 8:02They can't tell you what a what a dog
  191. 8:03is. They can just tell you how it jumps
  192. 8:05and you know how much energy it's
  193. 8:07gotten, how much mass, that kind of
  194. 8:08stuff. But they can't tell you what your
  195. 8:10dog looks like or you know you you can't
  196. 8:13uh figure out from what they tell you
  197. 8:16you know what they're talking about what
  198. 8:18a what you know. Okay. And yeah all this
  199. 8:22notion also came from this fellow who
  200. 8:24said that a cat is both dead and alive.
  201. 8:27Okay. Um at the same time. And what they
  202. 8:32came up with is that you know it kind of
  203. 8:34forks out into two different worlds. In
  204. 8:36one world, uh, he's alive. In the other
  205. 8:39one, he's dead. And so when you open the
  206. 8:41box, you know, in your world, maybe he's
  207. 8:44dead. The the the cat is dead. But, uh,
  208. 8:47if you were in the other world, you
  209. 8:49would find that he's still alive.
  210. 8:51Okay. So, this is the nonsense the these
  211. 8:54people deal with. And that's how they
  212. 8:55came up with the, uh, many worlds
  213. 8:58notion. And so you might ask, well, what
  214. 9:02is this
  215. 9:04many worlds, this multiverse, you know,
  216. 9:06because you have both general relativity
  217. 9:08on the multiverse side and you have
  218. 9:11quantum mechanics on the many worlds
  219. 9:13side. They kind of meet mathematical
  220. 9:16physics. They came up with these ideas
  221. 9:19uh more or less. This fellow Everett, he
  222. 9:21popularized it around 1957, 1958
  223. 9:26thereabouts.
  224. 9:27And so he popularized this idea. This is
  225. 9:30a different type of physical
  226. 9:31interpretation for quantum, right? Uh
  227. 9:34forget about the Copenhagen
  228. 9:35interpretation where the uh wave
  229. 9:38function collapses. No, here it doesn't
  230. 9:40collapse or it collapses in this
  231. 9:43universe, but in another universe it
  232. 9:45doesn't collapse. So it's got all these
  233. 9:47different uh um outcomes, right? Uh the
  234. 9:50collapse of the wave function. And
  235. 9:53here's this lady. Uh she's a
  236. 9:55mathematical physicist uh Jan 11 and uh
  237. 9:59she's going to tell you in her own words
  238. 10:01what this many worlds multiverse uh
  239. 10:04thingy is okay so listen to her so you
  240. 10:07get the official version here it is
  241. 10:12the idea of many worlds is that even
  242. 10:14within a laboratory if I perform a
  243. 10:16quantum measurement that all
  244. 10:18possibilities all possible outcomes of
  245. 10:20that measurement actually branch off to
  246. 10:24multiple worlds. Now, these worlds
  247. 10:26aren't the same as universes physically
  248. 10:28bubbling off. They exist in parallel to
  249. 10:31each other, but disconnected. And the
  250. 10:33idea of many worlds is that every time a
  251. 10:37quantum event happens, these
  252. 10:39multiplicities occur.
  253. 10:45Okay? So, she says they're disconnected.
  254. 10:48One universe is not connected to the
  255. 10:50other universe. So when you branch, how
  256. 10:52you get there? I don't know. Because if
  257. 10:54we're not connected to it, how do you
  258. 10:55get there? I guess the soul travels
  259. 10:57there like in the old days.
  260. 11:01Uh because if you travel physically, I
  261. 11:03mean, what are you traveling through?
  262. 11:04How do you get there? If you're
  263. 11:05disconnected, you travel what? Through
  264. 11:07space. I mean, what are you traveling
  265. 11:09through? Time, space, time, uh fields.
  266. 11:11What are you traveling? Fields of corn?
  267. 11:13Uh I mean, what are you traveling
  268. 11:15through? Does anybody believe
  269. 11:18in this nonsense? uh many worlds uh
  270. 11:22multiverse. Well, here's uh one fellow
  271. 11:24and he's a mathematical physicist. He's
  272. 11:27also a philosopher, right? He teaches
  273. 11:29philosophy at one of the universities
  274. 11:31out there and he'll tell you in his own
  275. 11:33words that no, this stuff is real. Okay?
  276. 11:37And it's got all to do with this wave
  277. 11:39function. Okay? Here it is. Listen to
  278. 11:41him.
  279. 11:42>> I'm a a believer in the many worlds
  280. 11:44interpretation of quantum mechanics.
  281. 11:46It's just a theory that says you want
  282. 11:48the answer to the reality problem. Wave
  283. 11:50functions are real. They represent
  284. 11:52reality precisely and completely. What
  285. 11:55the wave function really is is a
  286. 11:58superposition of all possible
  287. 12:00measurement outcomes. And what you're
  288. 12:02seeing when you measure it is you're
  289. 12:04picking out one of the set of
  290. 12:05possibilities with different
  291. 12:07probabilities. Right?
  292. 12:11>> So this wave function is real. He says,
  293. 12:15"What is a wave function? I mean, you
  294. 12:18know, what do you mean it's real?" And
  295. 12:20here you have a definition. Okay, one
  296. 12:22fell put it out there. What is a wave
  297. 12:24function? It's a mathematical function,
  298. 12:26meaning an equation of some kind, right?
  299. 12:28It's got variables, numbers that
  300. 12:30describes the quantum state of a
  301. 12:32particle. Okay. So, it's gonna describe
  302. 12:36and it's got to do with this word called
  303. 12:38particle, which if you look it up, you
  304. 12:40you won't find a definition for it.
  305. 12:42Again, like this other fellow said, you
  306. 12:44know, they have mass, they have charge,
  307. 12:46they have all these properties of a
  308. 12:48particle, but they don't know what a
  309. 12:49particle is. It's not a real particle
  310. 12:51like a ball. That's that's my point.
  311. 12:54Okay. But anyways, this is what um Sean
  312. 12:57is referring to. He's saying uh the you
  313. 12:59know this is the wave function and it
  314. 13:02does does not tell us exactly where the
  315. 13:05particle is. So we're talking about
  316. 13:08location here. We're not talking about
  317. 13:10what what a thing is. We're saying where
  318. 13:13is the particle and that's when they
  319. 13:15have this wave function that covers all
  320. 13:18the bases like a field out there with
  321. 13:20all these numbers out there. And they
  322. 13:22say well we can locate the particle in
  323. 13:24this region. That's about it. you know,
  324. 13:27that's all there is. So, it says it
  325. 13:29predicts where, right, a particle may be
  326. 13:32found. Okay? And so, we're not talking
  327. 13:35about a what, we're talking about a
  328. 13:37where, we're talking about how to locate
  329. 13:38it. We're not talking about the treasure
  330. 13:40chest. We're saying how many steps you
  331. 13:42need to get to the treasure chest. Okay?
  332. 13:44So, that's essentially uh what he's
  333. 13:48saying. And again, one of the problems
  334. 13:50that all these people have is that they
  335. 13:51never defined a key word of physics, of
  336. 13:54real physics. And that's the word real.
  337. 13:57The word exist. They don't have a
  338. 13:59definition for it. So every time they
  339. 14:01say that something exists or that it is
  340. 14:03real, they don't know what they're
  341. 14:05saying, let alone you understanding what
  342. 14:07they're saying. Okay? They're not
  343. 14:09telling you what these words mean. And
  344. 14:11these are crucial words in their
  345. 14:12exposition, their physical
  346. 14:14interpretations. So if you don't know
  347. 14:16what the word real means to say that the
  348. 14:18wave function is real, we have they
  349. 14:20haven't said anything. Okay? Uh in
  350. 14:24physics, real things are only objects.
  351. 14:26Only objects can be real. Anything
  352. 14:28that's not an object like a concept, you
  353. 14:31know, uh an abstraction um that cannot
  354. 14:35be real, cannot be said to exist. And uh
  355. 14:39and that's what separates, you know,
  356. 14:41physics from mathematical physics. They
  357. 14:43work with all these abstractions. In
  358. 14:45fact uh uh they shouldn't you know
  359. 14:48abstract is the opposite exact opposite
  360. 14:50the antonyym of physics of physics uh of
  361. 14:54physical right so we have abstract and
  362. 14:56physical and physics deals with the
  363. 14:59physical and these people are um dealing
  364. 15:02with abstractions so they should change
  365. 15:05the title of what they studied or what
  366. 15:07their degrees are to something along
  367. 15:09that uh says that references abstraction
  368. 15:13they should be called abstracist, not
  369. 15:15physicists. Okay. Anyways, he's the only
  370. 15:18guy. Here's another fellow. He's um he
  371. 15:21studied physics and then dropped out and
  372. 15:24I guess he became a mathemat uh I'm
  373. 15:27sorry, a philosopher of physics. Okay.
  374. 15:30His name is David Alurn. He's going to
  375. 15:31tell you in his own words uh what all
  376. 15:34this many worlds uh multiverse poppycock
  377. 15:37is all about. Listen to him. Okay. Here
  378. 15:39it is. Here's
  379. 15:42the true story of what happens to
  380. 15:45electrons when you put them through a
  381. 15:46two pans apparatus. They go into a state
  382. 15:49in which there fails to be a fact of the
  383. 15:51matter about where they're located in
  384. 15:53space. Electrons can under certain
  385. 15:55circumstances be in situations which we
  386. 15:58didn't previously think they could be
  387. 15:59in. It becomes sensible to regard these
  388. 16:03two branches of the superp position as
  389. 16:06two genuine self-contained worlds. It
  390. 16:10becomes more and more permissible to
  391. 16:13start talking about these superpositions
  392. 16:15as cases where the world splits into
  393. 16:18into a multiplicity of different
  394. 16:20universes.
  395. 16:28Okay. So we have all these worlds out
  396. 16:29there, these universes. And I guess uh
  397. 16:34my main objection towards it is the
  398. 16:36question that I asked next and that is
  399. 16:39what separates one of these universes
  400. 16:42from the other? What's between them? Uh
  401. 16:45Janna there Levin said they're
  402. 16:48disconnected. Okay. So what separates
  403. 16:51them? If if they're disconnected,
  404. 16:53there's no connection between them. What
  405. 16:55separates one universe from another? I
  406. 16:57think it's a valid question, right? And
  407. 17:00here, let me show you what I'm talking
  408. 17:01about. Uh, this is the big problem with
  409. 17:03the multiverse or many worlds theory
  410. 17:07proposal, okay? Whatever they're called
  411. 17:09argument. Um, here you have all these
  412. 17:12universes and of course in the uh in
  413. 17:15mathematical physics, they have each one
  414. 17:17of these, you know, pop in and pop out
  415. 17:20over billions of years, right? So, this
  416. 17:22is all in very very fast motion. uh you
  417. 17:25have one world arising another one
  418. 17:27disappearing and that's what's happening
  419. 17:29out there according to these people with
  420. 17:31this multiverse or many worlds theory
  421. 17:34right okay so the problem is you know
  422. 17:37what is the black stuff that separates
  423. 17:39all these universe okay that's the
  424. 17:42question okay so here you have let let
  425. 17:45me freeze that there okay so that you
  426. 17:47can see what I'm talking about uh we
  427. 17:49have this black stuff separating all
  428. 17:51these uh universes right multiverses
  429. 17:55And so what does each one of those
  430. 17:58balls, I'll call them balls, universes,
  431. 18:00balls, ball universes. What do they have
  432. 18:03in them? Well, they have space, time,
  433. 18:05and matter. Uh it's all in there. It's
  434. 18:08all enclosed within that uh bubble.
  435. 18:10Okay, so these are bubble universes, you
  436. 18:12could say. And the question is uh that
  437. 18:15space thinking, you know, what is
  438. 18:17separating one universe from another?
  439. 18:19You can't say space because space is the
  440. 18:22gray stuff uh that you see inside each
  441. 18:25ball. That's what space is. So the black
  442. 18:28stuff has to be something different than
  443. 18:30that for otherwise you know they the
  444. 18:32otherwise you would have a situation
  445. 18:34like this. Okay. Uh they would be
  446. 18:37separated. You would have just different
  447. 18:39um bits of matter in the same space. You
  448. 18:44know it's like what we see with uh the
  449. 18:46galaxies. galaxies are look like this
  450. 18:48and they have that blue dark dark blue
  451. 18:52or black stuff between them and they
  452. 18:55also have it on the inside.
  453. 18:57And so the question is you know does the
  454. 19:00galaxy have its own space that's
  455. 19:03different from our space? And the answer
  456. 19:05is no. And this is what all these
  457. 19:07universes would look like. You know they
  458. 19:10would look like just that just a clump
  459. 19:12of matter in the same space. We would
  460. 19:13all share the same space. Therefore, we
  461. 19:16are not in a different universe because
  462. 19:18we all share the same space no matter
  463. 19:20what. So, all we have is clumps of
  464. 19:22matter like you know like a galaxy.
  465. 19:25Okay. So, so again that's the big that's
  466. 19:28what destroys the notion the theory of
  467. 19:32the uh multiverse of the many worlds
  468. 19:35theory. They cannot make sense of that
  469. 19:38you know and if they can't you know I
  470. 19:40mean what is their proposal worth?
  471. 19:43Garbage. And and it turns out that you
  472. 19:46know there's um they claim there's
  473. 19:48several like seven different
  474. 19:50interpretations of quantum mechanics.
  475. 19:52One of them is the Copenhagen
  476. 19:54interpretation and the other one is the
  477. 19:56many worlds. Actually, you know, here's
  478. 19:59here's three more. Okay, they look like
  479. 20:01that. Okay. Uh you can look them up.
  480. 20:04They're not important at all. They're
  481. 20:06all just uh more garbage that was put in
  482. 20:09there. Uh what we really have is this.
  483. 20:12We have one and two. That's it. We have
  484. 20:14the Copenhagen, the many worlds. You
  485. 20:16either believe that the uh wave function
  486. 20:18collapses or that it doesn't. The many
  487. 20:21worlds simply says that the wave
  488. 20:22function never collapses. Every possible
  489. 20:25outcome of of a quantum measurement
  490. 20:28actually happens causing the universe to
  491. 20:30what? Branch into a vast or infinite
  492. 20:35mathematics, right? Infinite number of
  493. 20:37parallel non-interacting realities,
  494. 20:40meaning universes. Okay? because they're
  495. 20:42talking they're saying you know
  496. 20:45if you die well one guy goes to heaven
  497. 20:48the other guy goes to hell and um it's
  498. 20:52always you right so your maybe your soul
  499. 20:54goes to heaven and the other soul of you
  500. 20:57of you goes uh to hell and then others
  501. 21:01go to these different universes okay and
  502. 21:04one you maybe you die maybe in the other
  503. 21:05one you survive so so they have all this
  504. 21:08nonsense uh these interpretations ations
  505. 21:12and the question is whether any of them
  506. 21:14have any validity whatsoever
  507. 21:17and you say well Bill what other
  508. 21:19solutions are there? Well let me tell
  509. 21:22you what the bottom line what the big
  510. 21:24problem is. The big problem is that
  511. 21:27mathematical physics says well we had no
  512. 21:30one or quantum mechanics right general
  513. 21:32relativity whatever they said we have no
  514. 21:35other theories that have been proposed
  515. 21:37so nobody has falsified our theories you
  516. 21:40know and so the one issue is that you
  517. 21:43know they won't allow anything that's
  518. 21:45outside the bounds of quantum or general
  519. 21:47relativity because that's already been
  520. 21:49proven in their minds. So you have to
  521. 21:51work with that foundation whether you
  522. 21:53like it or not if you want to get
  523. 21:54published. In other words, you don't get
  524. 21:56published meaning they're not going to
  525. 21:57hear another theory because they're not
  526. 22:00interested in your physical
  527. 22:02interpretations. They want to see the
  528. 22:03math and what measurements you made and
  529. 22:06stuff like that that has nothing to do
  530. 22:08with physics. Physics is the physical
  531. 22:10interpretation. It's the qualitative
  532. 22:13physical interpretation. They dismiss
  533. 22:15that as philosophy.
  534. 22:17And if that's philosophy, why are these
  535. 22:20people doing philosophy? Why are they
  536. 22:22giving you a physical interpretation
  537. 22:24which belongs to philosophy according to
  538. 22:26them if uh you know if uh that's you
  539. 22:30know if that's what they believe uh is
  540. 22:33is not a part of what they do every day
  541. 22:35of their job description of mathematical
  542. 22:38physics. So so they'll never hear
  543. 22:40another version because they've shut
  544. 22:43themselves out. They said unless you
  545. 22:45come through the quantum or relativity
  546. 22:48channels we will not allow you to
  547. 22:50publish your paper. So they never hear a
  548. 22:52different theory. Okay? They they never
  549. 22:55have in their minds a different
  550. 22:56proposal. They never see it. And so
  551. 22:59we're stuck with this. And what's the
  552. 23:01problem with this? The problem with this
  553. 23:03is that's based on the particle
  554. 23:04hypothesis. Meaning that everything in
  555. 23:07the universe is comprised of particles
  556. 23:09of discrete particles. particles which
  557. 23:12ain't particles
  558. 23:14because it turns out the particles ain't
  559. 23:15particles. They're, you know, this guy
  560. 23:18wasn't able to tell you what a photon
  561. 23:19is. So, it turns out that they ended up
  562. 23:22with saying saying that, you know, you
  563. 23:24say, "Well, but all your theories are
  564. 23:26irrational. I mean, the Copenhagen uh
  565. 23:30many worlds are they're all irrational."
  566. 23:33And you say, "Well, yeah. I mean, you
  567. 23:35know, we don't understand it." But see,
  568. 23:36the quantum world works a little
  569. 23:38different than our common sense world.
  570. 23:42Well, I thought that's what we
  571. 23:44criticized about the old religions that,
  572. 23:47you know, they came up with ghosts and
  573. 23:49spirits and souls and so on,
  574. 23:51consciousness floating out there, you
  575. 23:53know, and maybe God's work world also
  576. 23:57works a little different than our common
  577. 24:00sense world. Maybe there are ghosts and
  578. 24:03spirits and souls out there, right? I
  579. 24:05mean if we're going to allow these
  580. 24:09these idiots really because that's what
  581. 24:10they are to propose stuff that you
  582. 24:13cannot imagine like you know how do you
  583. 24:16explain gravity? Well, it's negative
  584. 24:18momentum transfer. In other words, you
  585. 24:20throw the ball but the ball uh also
  586. 24:24delivers negative momentum and the
  587. 24:27object it hits is attracted towards you.
  588. 24:30And you say but that's irrational. Yeah,
  589. 24:31but the quantum world works a little
  590. 24:34differently than, you know, our common
  591. 24:36sense world. And so, yeah, you can't
  592. 24:39make sense of it. And so, the question
  593. 24:40is, how is quantum mechanics any better
  594. 24:44than, you know, traditional religions
  595. 24:46which invented also, you know, ghosts
  596. 24:47and goblins and souls and whatever,
  597. 24:50heaven, hell, you know, God. So, so we
  598. 24:53have a problem because it looks like the
  599. 24:56same people of a thousand years ago in
  600. 24:58the middle ages, uh, the dark ages,
  601. 25:00whatever, they're the people now in
  602. 25:02charge of science and they're telling
  603. 25:05you that they believe
  604. 25:07and all this stuff that you cannot
  605. 25:09imagine, which is totally irration. They
  606. 25:11say it's okay because the universe out
  607. 25:14there does not work according to your
  608. 25:16way of thinking, to your rational way of
  609. 25:19thinking, to your common sense.
  610. 25:23And so I guess we're back to where we
  611. 25:26started thousands of years ago.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Many Worlds meets the Multiverse by bgaede, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,147 words across 611 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.