Making A Murderer: EXCLUSIVE: MY INTERVIEW WITH MARTY TANKLEFF — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00yeah can you hear me I perfect got it
- 0:05took a little while but we got it
- 0:08alright so how are you okay that's good
- 0:13I'm so I'm really glad you decided to
- 0:17come a lot a lot of people are very
- 0:19interested in your case thanks to
- 0:22brendan dassey's case and with making a
- 0:25murderer i know you're familiar with it
- 0:27um tell me I mean I could give you a
- 0:29whole intro but tell me your story like
- 0:33I know your story obviously but Tommy in
- 0:36your words how it started like
- 0:38background everything person I'm that
- 0:51you were falsely accused on September
- 0:547th of 2 of 1988 for killing your
- 0:58parents or executing your parents which
- 1:00you were you I'm admitted to a crime
- 1:04that you did not do you knew from day
- 1:06one that it was your father's business
- 1:11partner we all knew was your father's
- 1:13business partner and somehow you got
- 1:17roped into confessing to this because of
- 1:20the police lies saying that you know
- 1:23your father told you that you did it
- 1:25when you didn't do it saying that your
- 1:28father you know woke up from a coma and
- 1:30said you did it when you didn't do it
- 1:32and just told you a whole bunch of lies
- 1:33so is that about the record in the
- 1:45interrogation is not so what was
- 1:49determined early deviating was nothing
- 1:54near the cornea and masochism chose not
- 1:59to it was a really steaming there's
- 2:12[Music]
- 2:39oh okay how did you feel that they were
- 2:58pinning it on you from day one I mean
- 3:04when you know in your heart you know
- 3:07actually did it Jerry Stewart did George
- 3:22to me was my last words there he faded
- 3:28now he changes of appearance
- 3:30he told the family be swimming in the
- 3:32fish between the planet from New York
- 3:37New Jersey
- 3:45you've landed from New Jersey California
- 3:49he changed to the cavalry he was in a
- 3:53psychiatric take all of those factors
- 3:58and say clearly either the son of
- 4:01clearly considered as honest fact
- 4:04especially we add in the fact that his
- 4:07son was a drug dealer you
- 4:10for others when Jerry himself and I
- 4:16remember that I vaguely vaguely remember
- 4:19that now that you're saying it but I
- 4:21remember because we used to hang out at
- 4:23the bowling alley all the time and
- 4:24Schroth more and I vaguely remember that
- 4:27it's funny that you said that because I
- 4:28just but even as a teenager I remember
- 4:49everybody saying it was his dad's
- 4:51business partner why didn't the cups
- 4:54ever I mean if we were like what 17 when
- 4:57you were arrested and then 1920 I mean I
- 5:00left after 9/11 but you know 17 18 19
- 5:04the rumor mill all over Belle Terre
- 5:06Belle Terre country club like oh it was
- 5:09definitely the business partner and we
- 5:54argued we argue that how it was for be
- 5:58there and you know and what was even
- 6:07freakier was that photo had an appointed
- 6:10water walking theme we're the only
- 6:13University
- 6:14you also that a time and had an
- 6:15initiative in the breeding so every step
- 6:19of the way it was a little rush
- 6:22inclusion misconduct the people don't
- 6:27want to acknowledge because she's our
- 6:31famous I think that's been shaken
- 6:35recently over the last I would say ten
- 6:38years pretty much in every department
- 6:40between all the racism with the cops and
- 6:43or suppose it racism and so on and so
- 6:46forth when I did my masters in criminal
- 6:49justice one thing that I've always felt
- 6:52and I get feedback positive negative is
- 6:56that a lot of the problem in the system
- 6:58is public defenders not that rich people
- 7:01don't go to jail or not that you know
- 7:03hired attorneys don't go to jail but so
- 7:06many public defenders are against
- 7:08clients and as soon as cops here they're
- 7:11gonna have a public defender now all of
- 7:13a sudden they're shooting for these
- 7:14false confessions and everything else
- 7:16that's what I have found whether there
- 7:18is stuffed document to back that up
- 7:22probably not but I have always found
- 7:25that that whenever you have lost
- 7:27confession to have public defenders all
- 7:29or no defender any all the time so when
- 7:33I say that the large law percent but it
- 7:40was a small percentage who were in fact
- 7:47everyone else routine before there were
- 8:00lawyers involved lawyers may have more
- 8:09experience more knowledge where we get
- 8:12abilities insult with fault none of
- 8:14agilent's purely probably for that is
- 8:20overworked underpaid they don't have the
- 8:23same resources right
- 8:35so the benefit of reporting is the
- 10:17training and training whether they dc+
- 10:21the record one of his own interrogations
- 10:25he wasn't a cop he went back and read
- 10:28wash and he sort of he did knowingly
- 10:36because
- 10:37we'll recorded everyone got to see what
- 10:41exactly what happened what happened was
- 10:43is that even Bert Lee he was as many
- 10:46facts and also those facts that is why I
- 10:53say recording available but even when
- 10:58they recorded again I go back to look at
- 11:00Brendan Dassey that was recorded that
- 11:03was I mean looking at it blindly I first
- 11:09time I ever saw it I thought of you
- 11:11honestly because I'm like this is he's
- 11:1416
- 11:15Martin was 17 I just people don't
- 11:19realize and I've said this over and over
- 11:21whether you have a high IQ from and you
- 11:24were spoiled rich kid or you're a scum
- 11:26of the lowlife when you have cops in
- 11:29your face yelling at you or being nice
- 11:32to you it's very easy to say I did it
- 11:35just to shut them up and you want to
- 11:38leave and you want to get them out I
- 11:39don't think people realize how easy it
- 11:43is to say I did it for someone not
- 11:45experienced in the law someone
- 11:48experienced it I say is really
- 12:43ultimately all motivations are or the
- 12:48ultimatums that are get it in the mail
- 14:21your camera a little because we're
- 14:23getting like your nose a perfect so I
- 14:29said it you just came to us I said both
- 14:34of the pilots balance a defines all of a
- 14:37sudden you're an interrogation room
- 14:41freedom in hours and hours and hours and
- 14:46essentially you get everything hold the
- 14:50only way you're leaving this room is
- 14:52tell everyone here every five six seven
- 14:56in other words you fart like what am I
- 15:01all over this behind and quite a little
- 15:03bit you're the Levites who believe that
- 15:05we need a life look at written a see
- 15:09what I agree and it is very
- 15:20understanding until you sort of water
- 15:23you know when you want other
- 15:25determinations of what an innocent son
- 15:33effect does that a minute right already
- 15:37and you get to somebody with your family
- 15:42members like okay you say something like
- 15:59that or they got my had or now with
- 16:08Brendan a lying
- 16:09totally off track from everything I
- 16:11wanted to ask you but speaking of
- 16:13Brendan into even speaking of you I
- 16:17understand it from Brendan's standpoint
- 16:19being for lack of a better way say
- 16:22disabled mentally challenged not it's
- 16:27the not respectable member of society
- 16:29from a bad home dysfunctional home I can
- 16:33see why his mom said no don't worry
- 16:35about you he doesn't need a lawyer you
- 16:37on the other hand I always wondered and
- 16:40always wanted to ask you why didn't
- 16:42anyone in your family get you a lawyer
- 16:44immediately why didn't your dad's lawyer
- 16:53father Tollman pretty degree I don't
- 17:03want more smoke okay
- 17:13every time they did in the case when
- 18:03they want to hide evil and in my case he
- 18:10was a lawyer
- 18:11Wow did your dad's partner ever he died
- 18:15right before a justice Koster was dead
- 18:26and the last prosecutors private
- 18:30convenient relevant news that so later
- 18:32them and Akriti is dead and creamy with
- 18:35that but you pursue your parents never
- 18:37got justice the partners still know is
- 18:45when the over with me that the
- 18:48prosecutorial powers returned back to
- 18:51his phone really prosecute is there's a
- 19:03new digital economy so we're hopeful
- 19:06Matthews resound we can present all the
- 19:11events we've gathered over the last 15
- 19:13to 20 years okay
- 19:17do you think that if that had enough
- 19:19happened to you you still would have
- 19:21been an attorney or are you thinking you
- 19:23would have taken a whole different path
- 19:25whoa
- 19:27what round here I wanna be to this man
- 19:29okay I wanted to be like Tron so no I
- 19:58had no tension or aspirations become a
- 20:00lawyer or a a law professor or you know
- 20:04teacher Georgetown or I I know that were
- 20:07living in my role okay
- 20:10and I will say though that Sean Piko I
- 20:14think was his name he also has become
- 20:18successful after 15 years I mean he
- 20:21actually did his crime but he's actually
- 20:23got involved not as as well as you but
- 20:26he also deals with um education in the
- 20:29system and make sure the prisoners in
- 20:32New York had mean that's another kid
- 20:34that got arrested at fifteen and really
- 20:36turned his life around after doing so
- 20:38many years in prison
- 20:39um it's impressive and in case you guys
- 20:42don't know marty is now an attorney he
- 20:45used seventeen years there's still one
- 21:08or two more stops on going through it
- 21:11but I am a I were in a law firm
- 21:15I'm professor at were law school and
- 21:19also a professor at Georgetown
- 21:21University I'm going to class that and
- 21:24that's where you did where I found which
- 21:27I did a video on him Valencia Dixon
- 21:31Valentino Dixon what an incredible story
- 21:35like I do
- 21:36did all video
- 21:37I knew when I was a student for a law
- 21:41school
- 21:42we set up an evolve in terms of the
- 21:45program and it was actually working for
- 21:48a Bruce farkhad who's a Laura luminaries
- 21:50and he was working on this case and you
- 21:54know we were there there and kind of
- 21:57just wasn't going anywhere but I've made
- 22:00a conventional scheme now and I'm hold
- 22:01on did he know I said that I will never
- 22:03give up on you and hopefully one day
- 22:05down the road
- 22:06it'll change and when in more power and
- 22:10I started teaching this class so I was
- 22:12down
- 22:14Valentina's one of the things we picked
- 22:16for the students was 80 cases and the
- 22:22student case I did a video on it
- 22:32I was shocked so as some of my
- 22:34subscribers bought his artwork as well
- 22:36through his website I was absolutely
- 22:38shocked at how the whole thing came
- 22:41about how it's just wild
- 22:44I mean for a murderer
- 22:50that another man came forward probably
- 22:56said because the gun okay Valentino was
- 23:05a man whose artists before the prison
- 23:07super intensive a huge rollers golf
- 23:10course
- 23:10guy never just at a firm golf course
- 23:14thought it was a crazy idea and also
- 23:18NASA said I'm on a different path we're
- 23:19starting to learn golf courses and you
- 23:23know the first golf worst he's ever
- 23:25remains whose fella leash you know a
- 23:28leash
- 23:30or someone who's never set foot on a
- 23:33golf course and the first golfers
- 23:35anything any of your subscribers would
- 23:38probably say you know penalty just
- 23:41probably one of the top five that are
- 23:44you gonna go to yeah that's just wild
- 23:48now another statistic that I pulled up
- 23:51though and you work with exonerees all
- 23:53the time
- 23:5421 there are 2120 exonerations in the US
- 23:58since 89 actually felt like it was more
- 24:00than that I'm according to national
- 24:02registry right so you have to understand
- 24:05the reason why that number is what it is
- 24:08what the definition is
- 24:10okay that's very important to understand
- 24:14the national registry generation is a
- 24:17very very strict kind of standard to get
- 24:20it editor to their list so you read the
- 24:23definition on their website you must
- 24:25qualify satisfy that but if you think
- 24:28about those numbers yeah that's really
- 24:31can about a year all right you but in
- 24:36the last two years right pick last year
- 24:38the year before you see how many is on
- 24:41arisians to the place last or the year
- 24:44before it's about one or two and a half
- 24:46days to a week three week every time it
- 25:00is exoneration for those damages that
- 25:02the guilty party have remained free
- 25:05coming and you different rods and victim
- 25:08on the news okay
- 25:11because one of the things that I have
- 25:13told subscribers for two years in
- 25:15multiple videos that everybody's
- 25:18focusing on the 5% max that are innocent
- 25:23in jail and I try to tell people 95% of
- 25:26the time we get it right
- 25:28it's that 5% that sucks but you can't
- 25:31hate an entire justice system because
- 25:3495% of the time they get it right it's
- 25:36just that 5% up to 5% but why are so
- 25:42many I understand New York's a big play
- 25:44but Suez Texas why is New York the
- 25:47second highest among states for false
- 25:49confessions I mean granted New York's
- 25:52big well you think about it it's
- 25:55probably one of the reasons why the
- 25:57training that goes it's the fact that we
- 26:01haven't had the mandatory electronic
- 26:04recording leaders of televisions I mean
- 26:06I think there was only one seam in
- 26:10America
- 26:11where was mandatory deportation in
- 26:14Alaska there's been introduction of
- 26:21electronic record generations I think or
- 26:28the because we're able to really watch
- 26:34them and understand you know what their
- 26:36problem is a default investor you lose
- 26:40weight the way law enforcement Macready
- 26:43in my case said he reported the reasons
- 26:53why they don't know if it's wrong
- 27:01somebody that inhibits that he what they
- 27:16migrate but even even when you do
- 27:19something wrong I go back to dasi every
- 27:22the whole world saw those interrogations
- 27:24and how the supreme not the supreme
- 27:27court how the 7th district
- 27:29appeals court you know half agreed half
- 27:33didn't agree one of the main reasons
- 27:36they didn't agree was the law that you
- 27:39know according to the law they did
- 27:40nothing wrong
- 27:42when is that gonna change because that
- 27:45needs to change because they did do
- 27:47stuff wrong he was a 16 year old kid you
- 27:49were a 17 year old kid
- 27:51so salty
- 28:00[Music]
- 28:19which I knew they would do you think I
- 29:17mean I know personally that Lauren and
- 29:20Steve der isn't have spent well over a
- 29:22million dollars in their time efforts
- 29:25everything try you know briefs it's not
- 29:28over but it kind of is over I mean it
- 29:31can they do anything else form or and
- 29:34now it's waiting on including everyone
- 29:48you know in normal condition he it's
- 29:51never okay with something they were
- 29:54doing
- 29:56there is more wood going on we're in
- 29:57Venice and I've known for very little
- 30:04for a million years ago
- 30:06and I can assure you in viewers and I
- 30:13would imagine so just because I mean
- 30:16it's kind of confusing because ok you
- 30:19get tonight from the Supreme Court
- 30:20you're done you know there's nowhere
- 30:22else to go but I'm like they have so
- 30:25many years invested in so many million
- 30:28over well over a million maybe even two
- 30:30million by this point invested you know
- 31:05if you really remember leaving in the
- 31:14lawyers mm-hmm
- 31:34but can she get through a completely
- 31:36corrupt County that's the problem
- 31:40I don't doubt her ability it's getting
- 31:43through the corruption of Manitowoc and
- 31:46what seemingly seems to be all of
- 31:49Wisconsin if you've heard what you know
- 31:56so you know
- 31:59humming a lawyer one better than okay
- 32:07mm-hmm and I think the one word or a we
- 32:35with the rain which he hears a lot of
- 32:40crap for that it's not scientific
- 32:44professor I'm sorry but he's got some
- 32:47credibility everyone
- 34:00okay so you in your heart you believe
- 34:03they're both completely innocent okay
- 34:39[Music]
- 34:44I took their words okay speaking of
- 34:48Kathleen Zellner real quickly a lot of
- 34:51feedback that she gets is she's
- 34:53unprofessional with her tweets and all
- 34:55that other stuff and supporters we
- 34:59always say like it doesn't matter like
- 35:01she's still gonna have the end result
- 35:03but one of the biggest things that we
- 35:06see as a supporter is she she has to
- 35:10have something up her sleeve somewhere
- 35:12like she's too vocal about this one did
- 35:16it or that one did it definitively but I
- 35:19feel like she's hiding the real person
- 35:21under her sleeve but doesn't want him to
- 35:24run am I totally off track or does that
- 35:27sound like a hotshot attorney would do
- 35:31that
- 36:27as they leave because you want to maybe
- 36:59okay that's kind of what I thought and
- 37:02I've always had that I'm wrapping up so
- 37:06besides getting admitted to the bar of
- 37:09New York State you spend 17 years in
- 37:12prison you are a professor of law you
- 37:14went through law school where does the
- 37:17future hold for Martin Tankleff and I
- 37:20know you married any kids thank you so
- 37:31one of the things I would love do you
- 38:59it's Suffolk and I grew up in Suffolk
- 39:02after Queens but it's Suffolk and my
- 39:04brother's a cop in Queens but if Suffolk
- 39:06County still so corrupt as it was and
- 39:21there's still the highest-paid police
- 39:24force in the entire country are you
- 39:42bitter towards what happened I mean you
- 39:43spent 17 years in prison are you bitter
- 39:47haha
- 40:50Wow
- 40:52morning I want to thank you so much for
- 40:54coming on um I know viewers are gonna be
- 40:57extremely happy I know they're gonna ask
- 40:59me you know well can you get them back
- 41:01for a live show so I will let you know
- 41:04feedback um anything you want to close
- 41:07on oh by the way verse I had her name my
- 41:12head Rosanna Scotto and Patti the
- 41:15videographer Patti's one of my best
- 41:17friends told me to tell you they said hi
- 41:20Patti told me tell you harm Rosanna said
- 41:21hi so I said okay I'll do that
- 41:46no work or well and overwork with
- 41:48chasing someone who's an ending remember
- 41:51the offensive object and there is a
- 41:53genuinely great very deep mobile and one
- 41:57of the most amazing reward is given
- 42:00there is a wrongful conviction in New
- 42:03York she's always open in mono Chapelle
- 42:06honoré explains agree sweet you just
- 42:14brought up some I was in the music
- 42:16business throughout the 90s I never knew
- 42:19Jason Flom was part of the Innocence
- 42:21Project granted it was like two separate
- 42:23lives for me I had no idea that he was
- 42:26all I had no idea it probably I think I
- 42:49learned this like a year ago I was like
- 42:51Jason Flom I was like how does he
- 42:54connect the two and everyone said yes
- 42:56but like a family member the Innocence
- 42:59Project like guess I just wasn't
- 43:00interested in criminal justice then but
- 43:03I never knew I was like wow he's got a
- 43:23list under him did he help with West
- 43:29Memphis Three because they had a ton of
- 43:41okay
- 43:42anything you want to close on new year
- 43:52sounds good Marty thank you so much and
- 43:55I'm gonna edit this little player nine
- 43:58one call I cannot even believe the 911
- 44:01call it I grew up in Suffolk County and
- 44:03to hear what a blatant bitch she was I
- 44:07was like wow have you heard of late
- 44:09recently
- 44:10oh thank you listen to me I was like wow
- 44:21so but I will send you a copy of the
- 44:24video I mean you can go to a channel but
- 44:26I'll send you a copy and if I don't
- 44:28speak to you I have a wonderful holiday
- 44:30Happy Hanukkah and happy New Year and
- 44:33I'll speak to you next year okay really
- 44:37thank you bye bye I don't everything's
- 44:40okay at the doctor's office
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Making A Murderer: EXCLUSIVE: MY INTERVIEW WITH MARTY TANKLEFF by Purplexed TC, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,314 words across 476 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.