Love is hard: why it is rare — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01I'm Dr. Orion Taraban and this is Psych
- 0:03Hacks and Better Living Through
- 0:04Psychology. And the topic of this short
- 0:06talk is love is
- 0:09hard.
- 0:11And if you appreciate how hard love is,
- 0:14you will begin to understand why there
- 0:16is so little of it in the world.
- 0:19Now, in a talk like this, we have to
- 0:21begin by clarifying definitions because
- 0:23love means 100 different things to 100
- 0:25different people.
- 0:27I'll begin defining it negatively. Love
- 0:29is not a feeling, like limerence. In
- 0:32fact, love has little, if anything, to
- 0:34do with feelings.
- 0:35What's more, love is not the same as
- 0:37getting along with someone or having a
- 0:39successful relationship. Though both of
- 0:42those things can be hard, love is
- 0:44infinitely harder. And finally, love is
- 0:47definitely not the same as being nice or
- 0:51practicing the kind of soft-headed,
- 0:54foolish indulgence that passes for
- 0:56compassion in today's day and age.
- 0:59So, what is love?
- 1:02As I discuss in my book, love is
- 1:04sacrifice for the good of the other.
- 1:07>> [snorts]
- 1:07>> If it ever is accompanied by a feeling,
- 1:09and it often isn't, it's the feeling of
- 1:12the humiliated self triumphant.
- 1:15The feeling accompaniment of love is
- 1:18passion. But passion in its true
- 1:21classical sense, namely, suffering, as
- 1:24in the passion of the martyrs. It may be
- 1:26an exaltant, ennobling suffering, but it
- 1:30is a suffering nonetheless.
- 1:32In any case, love is sacrifice for the
- 1:34good of the other, and the bigger the
- 1:36sacrifice, and the more useful the good,
- 1:39the greater the love.
- 1:41And I'm modeling this conception of love
- 1:43after the life of Jesus, who,
- 1:46irrespective of your religious beliefs,
- 1:48was clearly a great master.
- 1:50Now, among other things, Jesus told us
- 1:53to love our enemies. And this is our
- 1:55first clue that love has nothing to do
- 1:58with emotions because if you feel
- 2:00positively about people who might
- 2:03actively be trying to kill you,
- 2:06you are probably not loving. You are
- 2:08psychotic.
- 2:09Like it's not really natural to feel
- 2:12jelly good about people who hate you.
- 2:15In fact, love doesn't even involve
- 2:17liking the other person. You can dislike
- 2:20people and still love them in the sense
- 2:22that you respect their intrinsic value
- 2:24and wish to see them free of the
- 2:26ignorance or delusion that blinds them.
- 2:29It's also pretty clear that Jesus wasn't
- 2:31always very nice.
- 2:33At least in the sense that your aunt
- 2:34Karen would understand that word. There
- 2:36certainly wasn't anything nice about
- 2:39Jesus going into the temple and turning
- 2:40over the tables of the money changers.
- 2:43But what they were doing was wrong. They
- 2:45were polluting a sacred space and they
- 2:47were deaf to reason and appeal. The
- 2:50money changers were willful in their
- 2:52corruption and on some level allowing
- 2:55others to exist in a state of willful
- 2:57corruption is not love,
- 3:00but rather enabling or indulgence.
- 3:03It kind of gives up on the other as a
- 3:05lost cause, which is something that love
- 3:07would never do.
- 3:09What love does do, namely sacrifice for
- 3:12the good of the other, is very very
- 3:15hard.
- 3:16Consider this. In the Christian
- 3:18tradition, Jesus is divine. He is the
- 3:21son of God.
- 3:22On some level, there was nothing he
- 3:24couldn't do if you so willed.
- 3:27That said, we don't know much about his
- 3:28life. In the scriptures, we kind of lose
- 3:30track of him until he's around 30,
- 3:32which is when he begins to preach and
- 3:34perform his miracles. And he does this
- 3:36for all of
- 3:373 years
- 3:39before he's crucified at 33.
- 3:42When I consider the life of Jesus, one
- 3:44of the takeaways for me
- 3:46is that even someone as divine and
- 3:49perfect as Jesus
- 3:51couldn't love for more than 3 years.
- 3:56It only took 3 years for his entire
- 3:59physical and material life to be ground
- 4:02to dust
- 4:04in the service of selfless devotion to
- 4:06others.
- 4:07And that actually could be impressive.
- 4:09Like we can certainly conceive of that
- 4:10process taking even less time.
- 4:13And if the son of God didn't love for
- 4:15more than 3 years,
- 4:17what kind of expectations do you hold
- 4:19out for other people?
- 4:21Are you finally ready to understand how
- 4:24relationships really work? Then get your
- 4:27hands on my book, The Value of Others,
- 4:29How to Get and Keep More of What You
- 4:32Want in the Sexual Marketplace. Learn
- 4:35what actually moves the needle, why
- 4:37relationships fail, and how to position
- 4:39yourself for success in this strange new
- 4:42world of mating and dating. Over 100,000
- 4:46copies sold. Get yours today. Now
- 4:49available in ebook, audiobook, and
- 4:51paperback formats. The links are in the
- 4:54description.
- 4:56Now I'm not saying that humans aren't
- 4:57capable of love. They are. But this kind
- 5:00of love is exceedingly rare. The closest
- 5:03I've come to observing this love in
- 5:05others was when I was working with
- 5:06cancer patients and their caregivers.
- 5:09And while the caregivers didn't always
- 5:11act altruistically or even selflessly,
- 5:14when they did choose to step fully into
- 5:16the role their oaths demanded, they were
- 5:19the men and women who for me most
- 5:22closely approximated this definition of
- 5:24love.
- 5:25Being the spouse of a terminally ill
- 5:27patient is often an emotionally brutal,
- 5:30demanding, and underappreciated task.
- 5:33After all, it's the patients themselves
- 5:35who tend to get most of the love and
- 5:37support, right?
- 5:39It's also a labor that has no clearly
- 5:40defined end point. Could take 6 months,
- 5:43could take 6 years.
- 5:44But let me tell you, at the end of that
- 5:47journey, when they finally see their
- 5:49spouses off to their long rests, there
- 5:52is often nothing left of them.
- 5:55The surviving caregivers might be
- 5:57financially drained or even bankrupt. In
- 6:00fact, one in three bankruptcies in
- 6:02America are caused by medical expenses.
- 6:05They might be emotionally devastated,
- 6:07intellectually exhausted, and
- 6:08spiritually depleted. Like the giving
- 6:11tree at the end of Silverstein's book,
- 6:13they are often stumps with nothing left
- 6:16to give.
- 6:18Of course, there is something very
- 6:19virtuous, very respectable, if not
- 6:22ennobling about this kind of love.
- 6:25And we certainly appreciate it in
- 6:26others.
- 6:28But I think very few people are praying
- 6:32for the opportunity to reduce themselves
- 6:34to nothing in the service of the other.
- 6:38But that's what love ultimately
- 6:39requires.
- 6:40It's also worth noting that I saw very
- 6:43few of these caregivers remarry.
- 6:47This is how we can understand that love
- 6:48has nothing to do or little to do with
- 6:51successful relationships, which to my
- 6:53mind are more the result of a satisfying
- 6:56exchange of value.
- 6:57Occasionally, people bulk at my
- 6:59definition of love and say, "Orion,
- 7:00well, that's just unsustainable."
- 7:02And I respond, "Yeah, that's absolutely
- 7:05correct. Love is unsustainable. That's
- 7:07my point. Taken to its extreme, it will
- 7:10strip you of everything in the crucible
- 7:12of your ordeal."
- 7:15And that's typically when they start to
- 7:16hedge. "Well, okay. Good relationships
- 7:20need love and boundaries."
- 7:23And that's not That's not true. I mean,
- 7:26it may be true that good relationships
- 7:29need boundaries, agreed.
- 7:31But love and boundaries are actually
- 7:33antithetical to each other.
- 7:36That they often don't appear so is due
- 7:38to the fact that people have an insipid
- 7:40or emotional conceptualization of love.
- 7:43At best, boundaries mean that you love
- 7:47to a point.
- 7:48Namely, the point at which you choose
- 7:51something else
- 7:52over the good of the other.
- 7:54And when you uphold a boundary, you are
- 7:56functionally saying that you love those
- 7:58things more than you love the other
- 7:59person.
- 8:00That you love your sanity or your
- 8:02comfort or your money or your lifestyle
- 8:05or your peace of mind more than the
- 8:06other person.
- 8:08And you know what?
- 8:09That is perfectly okay.
- 8:13It is perfectly okay to have boundaries
- 8:15in your relationships
- 8:17and to love others to a point.
- 8:20But it would be difficult to argue that
- 8:22the person who chooses a boundary over
- 8:24sacrifice is being loving.
- 8:27People will do all kinds of mental
- 8:28gymnastics to prevent themselves from
- 8:31thinking this because people generally
- 8:33have a problem thinking of themselves as
- 8:35selfish,
- 8:36but I don't see any way around this. I
- 8:38mean,
- 8:39Jesus didn't say while he was getting
- 8:41nailed to his cross, "Ah, ouch. Guys,
- 8:44guys, boundaries, boundaries, this is
- 8:46not okay. In fact, it's it's abuse.
- 8:49That's it. I'm no longer willing to
- 8:51sacrifice myself for your good."
- 8:54Quite the contrary.
- 8:55His sacrifice was especially for those
- 8:59people
- 9:00who he understood knew not what they
- 9:02did.
- 9:05It might be fair to say that the best of
- 9:07which most of us are capable is loving
- 9:10to a point. And that is likely because
- 9:13the vast majority of us have yet to
- 9:14realize the divine within.
- 9:16So, let's be patient with ourselves and
- 9:19others.
- 9:20If you're ready for more, love is always
- 9:22ready for you.
- 9:23And you don't need to be in a
- 9:24relationship to enter into it. Just
- 9:27remember that love has no boundaries.
- 9:30And that's what makes love very, very
- 9:33powerful
- 9:34and also very, very dangerous.
- 9:38And it's dangerous precisely because it
- 9:41might just be the only force ultimately
- 9:44capable of subverting the corruption of
- 9:46the world.
- 9:48What do you think? Does this fit with
- 9:50your own experience? Let me know in the
- 9:51comments below. And please,
- 9:53send this to someone who you think might
- 9:54benefit from its message. Private
- 9:56person, an influencer, I know you know
- 9:58somebody who needs to hear this because
- 9:59it's word-of-mouth referrals like this
- 10:01that really help to make the channel
- 10:02grow.
- 10:03Now, I have a lot of uh services these
- 10:05days, so I'm going to consolidate my
- 10:06pitch. So, I have a lot of extra value
- 10:08for you elsewhere. I have a free weekly
- 10:10newsletter.
- 10:11I have the opportunity to book paid
- 10:13one-on-one consultations with yours
- 10:15truly. I also have my books, my
- 10:17best-selling book on relationships, The
- 10:20Value of Others, where I talk about love
- 10:21in particular.
- 10:23And my novel about the final days of
- 10:24Vincent van Gogh, Starry Night.
- 10:26I have my agent, Orion AI, providing
- 10:29round-the-clock counsel whenever you
- 10:31need it. And I have my private
- 10:32community, The Captain's Quarters, where
- 10:35among other things I respond to your
- 10:36issues in real time in live group
- 10:39consultation calls. The links to
- 10:41everything are in the description below.
- 10:42Check them out. There's a lot of value
- 10:44there that I can't provide here. As
- 10:46always, I appreciate your support.
- 10:48And thank you for listening.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Love is hard: why it is rare by Orion Taraban, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,718 words across 291 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.