Louis I. Kahn in Conversation: Interviews with John W. Cook and Heinrich Klotz, 1969-70 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:11uh good evening I'm Robert Stern the
- 0:13dean of the School of
- 0:14Architecture and on behalf of the school
- 0:18I'm pleased to welcome you to this
- 0:20evening's conversation and book
- 0:23signing the book Lewis ion in
- 0:27conversation edited by Jules David Brown
- 0:30and Karen e denavit and published by the
- 0:33AL University press is a remarkable
- 0:36document beautiful to look at and
- 0:39amazing in its
- 0:40scholarship a true labor of
- 0:44love Lewis ion holds a special place in
- 0:47the history of the School of
- 0:49Architecture when Khan joined the
- 0:51faculty in
- 0:531947 he was better known as a socially
- 0:56engaged architect specializing in
- 0:59lowcost housing than as the
- 1:01internationally revered advocate of a
- 1:04resurrected monumentality that he would
- 1:07later
- 1:09become in the late
- 1:111940s the department of architecture
- 1:13then part of the School of Fine Arts was
- 1:16rebuilding its programs following upon
- 1:19the widespread repudiation of the bozar
- 1:22pedagogy that had been Yale's Mainstay
- 1:26for 50
- 1:27years there was a new Dean Charles
- 1:30Sawyer who was influenced by Joseph
- 1:32Alber the former bow house
- 1:35Master Alber would himself joined the
- 1:38faculty as chairman of the Department of
- 1:41Art in
- 1:431949 when at the same time Khan was
- 1:47instrumental in seeing to the
- 1:49appointment as chair of the architecture
- 1:51Department of the highly respected boar
- 1:55trained modernist convert architect
- 1:58George how
- 2:01when Aeros saronin turned down the
- 2:04invitation to design the long delayed
- 2:07extension to the Yale Art Gallery
- 2:10arguing that he was too busy to take it
- 2:12on I've never heard of an argument more
- 2:15ridiculous um how in a remarkable Act of
- 2:19mentoring pushed Khan's name forward the
- 2:23art gallery extension proved to be
- 2:26crucial to Khan's career and to the
- 2:28history of Modern Art
- 2:30architecture leis k Khan remained on the
- 2:33architecture faculty until
- 2:351958 and afterwards occasionally visited
- 2:39the School of Architecture to
- 2:41lecture in
- 2:431969 a year of student turmoil at Yale
- 2:47and elsewhere Khan began the design for
- 2:51a second museum at Yale the center for
- 2:54British art consideration of which is
- 2:58what brings us together here
- 3:00tonight but enough with history it is
- 3:03now my pleasure to turn the platform
- 3:05over to my colleague Amy Myers since
- 3:092002 director of the Yale Center for
- 3:12British art who has done such so much to
- 3:16enliven its programs to reach out to
- 3:18students and the public and most
- 3:21significantly in the context of
- 3:23tonight's proceedings to see to it that
- 3:26Khan's Masterwork is treated with the
- 3:29same care and respect that is lavished
- 3:33on the very many Masterworks of art in
- 3:36its that it
- 3:38contains following this evening's
- 3:40program please join our speakers in the
- 3:43architecture Gallery which is on the
- 3:45second floor of this building for a
- 3:48reception now please join me in
- 3:51welcoming Amy Meyers to the podium
- 3:54[Applause]
- 4:05thank you for your kind words Bob we are
- 4:08so grateful to you and our colleagues at
- 4:10the School of Architecture for your
- 4:13support of our efforts to maintain and
- 4:15conserve our building to the highest
- 4:18standards indeed among the gifts that
- 4:21the center's founder Paul melon gave to
- 4:23Yale none apart from the collection is
- 4:27greater than the building itself a
- 4:29appreciating our building is an
- 4:31architectural achievement that must be
- 4:33preserved we recently published Lewis
- 4:36icon and the Yale Center for British art
- 4:39a conservation plan edited by Peter
- 4:41insip and Steven G with the assistance
- 4:44of our deputy director Constance Clement
- 4:47we hope that the publication will serve
- 4:49as a model for similar efforts in this
- 4:51country where such planning for the
- 4:53future is uncommon and almost never
- 4:56happens in relation to Modern buildings
- 4:59in preparing that book the editors and
- 5:02the Cent's building conservation
- 5:03committee had the benefit of
- 5:05Recollections and advice from Jules
- 5:07prown the first director of the center
- 5:10who initially had proposed con as the
- 5:13architect and who served as the client
- 5:15for the design and construction of the
- 5:17building on behalf of the University I
- 5:20also have to say a personal word um I
- 5:24among others at the center um was a
- 5:26student under Jewels writing my
- 5:29dissertation here at Yale just as the
- 5:31Center opened and there could have been
- 5:33no greater pleasure than to come to
- 5:36study under Jewels at a time when the
- 5:39great satisfaction of creating the
- 5:41institution um was so potent I think not
- 5:44just for Jewels but for all of us and
- 5:48the great collection and building was
- 5:52deployed to inspire here at Yale and I
- 5:55owe my great debt of thanks to Jules as
- 5:58well
- 5:59following his retirement from full-time
- 6:01teaching in
- 6:031999 Jules returned to the center as
- 6:06senior research fellow and he has
- 6:08devoted himself to recording the early
- 6:11history of the center and its building
- 6:14as one of the most important scholarly
- 6:16projects in which he now is engaged most
- 6:20recently he has focused on editing the
- 6:22interviews that his former Associates in
- 6:24the history of art department at Yale
- 6:26John Cook and heimr clz recorded with
- 6:30con at the time when initial planning
- 6:32for the center was just getting underway
- 6:35and this is extremely important and
- 6:37really is why the book is so meaningful
- 6:40to us um these interviews the tapes of
- 6:44which are preserved in the department of
- 6:46manuscripts and archives at Sterling
- 6:48Memorial Library here at Yale provide a
- 6:51direct insight into Khan's architectural
- 6:53philosophy at the time when he was
- 6:55developing his first concepts for the
- 6:57center and so have particular value for
- 7:00our institution the center is honored to
- 7:03serve as the publisher of the interviews
- 7:06that we launched tonight in concert with
- 7:08the Department of manuscripts and
- 7:09archives at Sterling and the
- 7:11architectural archives at the University
- 7:13of Pennsylvania with which we have
- 7:15worked so closely to produce this
- 7:18book in editing the transcript of the
- 7:20interviews viws Jules considered Khan's
- 7:23expression of his philosophy with the
- 7:25most careful attention to every word and
- 7:28to the emphasis of every phrase
- 7:31augmenting his own Recollections of his
- 7:33experience of working with KH on the
- 7:35design of the center with a new
- 7:38understanding of the architect's own
- 7:39thoughts During the period of their
- 7:42collaboration he has been helped with
- 7:44this meticulous intellectual process by
- 7:47Karen Devan denavit who prepared the
- 7:50verbum transcript of the interviews from
- 7:53which juul's edited transcript is drawn
- 7:56and who assisted him in deciphering
- 7:58Khan's words from tapes that are almost
- 8:01half a century old their work as a team
- 8:04has been
- 8:05exemplary and we owe them an enormous
- 8:08debt of gratitude for their persistence
- 8:10in retrieving for us and for posterity a
- 8:13living record of Khan's word we will
- 8:16have the chance to thank Jules
- 8:19momentarily but I would like to ask
- 8:21Karen to stand so that she can be
- 8:24recognized for this Monumental
- 8:26achievement Karen
- 8:28[Music]
- 8:29[Applause]
- 8:42am I I know I know I it's
- 8:46coming thank you we are on the same
- 8:50wavelength Bob always we remain deeply
- 8:53grateful to John Cook and Hinrich clz
- 8:56for pursuing their original interviews
- 8:58with KH
- 9:00and of course to con himself for the
- 9:02time he took to reflect with them on the
- 9:05thinking that underlay his projects both
- 9:08built and unbuilt we are especially
- 9:11thankful to cook and to Gert Kutz hinr
- 9:14klutz's Widow for their support of this
- 9:17edition of the interviews and for their
- 9:19encouragement to pursue a work that
- 9:21would enable Khan's words to
- 9:25be well both read heard and appreciated
- 9:30um beyond the condensed version of the
- 9:32interviews published in their aftermath
- 9:34in the book conversations with the
- 9:36Architects we have the honor and
- 9:39pleasure of having John with us this
- 9:41evening and I also would like to ask him
- 9:44to stand so that he might be recognized
- 9:46by us for
- 9:49[Music]
- 9:57preserving we ALS also are indebted to
- 10:00Christine Weidman director of Yale's
- 10:02Department of manuscripts and archives
- 10:03Sterling Memorial Library and Nancy
- 10:06Thorne archist and William Whitaker
- 10:09curator and collections manager at the
- 10:11architectural archives of the University
- 10:13of Pennsylvania for their great
- 10:15assistance with the project on so many
- 10:17fronts and for their collaborative
- 10:19Spirit we also are pleased that they can
- 10:22be with us this evening a print version
- 10:24of the transcript of the verbatim
- 10:26interviews has been deposited with the
- 10:28tape interviews as well as with the
- 10:31architectural archives at the University
- 10:33of Pennsylvania and the institutional
- 10:36Archive of the Yale Center for British
- 10:38art as we at the center find ourselves
- 10:41in the midst of our current project to
- 10:43conserve our great building addressing
- 10:46mechanical systems that now are almost
- 10:4840 years old and warm the worn fabric um
- 10:52of our actively used Galleries and
- 10:55Auditorium we are grateful not only for
- 10:58our deeply resp searched conservation
- 11:00plan but also for these interviews which
- 11:03illuminate further Khan's approach
- 11:04toward the design of the extraordinary
- 11:07structure in which we have the privilege
- 11:09to work with the publication of this
- 11:11thoughtful addition of the interviews
- 11:13and the making available of the r
- 11:15verbatim transcript we hope that the
- 11:18stewards of other con buildings and
- 11:20Scholars of his work will find The
- 11:22Architects own words to be of equal
- 11:25value I now am delighted to welcome my
- 11:28colleague Ava Lisa P pelen to the podium
- 11:32an assistant professor at the school of
- 11:34architecture and a fine scholar of KH in
- 11:37her own right who will give us some
- 11:39brief remarks about the architect and
- 11:41will welcome Jules and Alec pervis to
- 11:44begin what promises to be a rich and
- 11:46most satisfying conversation aaisa
- 11:49[Applause]
- 12:00can you see a slide yeah okay um as a
- 12:04preem to the main event of uh tonight's
- 12:07main event I would like to uh talk
- 12:10briefly about uh Khan's tenure at Yale
- 12:13which lasted from 1947 to
- 12:181957 I will attain that this period was
- 12:21an important one for Khan's intellectual
- 12:24and artistic development not least
- 12:27because of people like Joseph Albert and
- 12:30his wife
- 12:32Annie
- 12:34um um Albert who arrived on campus two
- 12:38years later a loving couple
- 12:42um so let's begin uh where KH began upon
- 12:47his arrival he was like Bob said uh one
- 12:50of the first hires after the university
- 12:53had begun to modernize its Arts
- 12:55curriculum under the leadership of
- 12:58Charles soy
- 12:59the dean of the School of Fine Arts um
- 13:03aarin was one uh Committee Member in
- 13:06this
- 13:07effort he was hired to teach upper level
- 13:12Studios one of the first of which in the
- 13:15fall of
- 13:161948 was entitled National Center for
- 13:20UNESCO wait a second we go here um it
- 13:24was the first one to implement the
- 13:26so-called collab collaborative design
- 13:29problem which brought together
- 13:31Architects painters and sculptures to
- 13:34work I mean students of those fields to
- 13:36work on a collaborative project um as
- 13:39you can see uh the architectural
- 13:41language uh clearly favored and
- 13:43supported by KH was a a very kind of
- 13:46structurally expressive uh Monumental
- 13:49scale work and you can see in the
- 13:51worldall there the U kind of mural
- 13:54paintings uh by the art
- 13:57students two years years into his job
- 14:00Khan took a leading role in helping to
- 14:03convince the Alberts to take a job at
- 14:06Yale in
- 14:091949 um the two Joint Forces in a studio
- 14:12taught in um um in the Academic Year of
- 14:151949 and 1950 to teach a studio entitled
- 14:19an idea Center for
- 14:21Plastics Khan was the chief critic and
- 14:24coordinator and came up with the idea uh
- 14:27and Alber served as an in-house uh
- 14:30critic the new material as you can tell
- 14:33from these slides proved to be rather
- 14:35challenging to work on uh and the
- 14:38results varied both in style and quality
- 14:42it comes as therefore no surprise that
- 14:44when Alber came to critic the work being
- 14:48a master of restraint he was not very
- 14:51happy about the
- 14:54results the first indication that KH was
- 14:57going through a major shift in his own
- 14:59artistic sensibility comes with the set
- 15:02of drawings and pastels with names such
- 15:05as abstract planes and steps and
- 15:10transparency number one with
- 15:12intersecting and overlapping planes and
- 15:15surfaces executed in black and white
- 15:18they PIR a striking similarity to
- 15:21Albert's structural constellation series
- 15:24which KH had seen a year later when he
- 15:26visited Albert in Cincinnati where he
- 15:29was working on the series and here is
- 15:31the Smoking Gun um uh KH holding one of
- 15:36them um one that he had selected as a
- 15:40retirement gift to the departing dean of
- 15:42the architecture school at that time uh
- 15:45Department of architecture sorry uh
- 15:48George how so here you see George how in
- 15:51the middle I think that's the famous
- 15:53medal uh don't let the bastards let you
- 15:56down where you down where you down uh
- 16:00you see Vincent scl uh next to uh next
- 16:04to him uh holding the medal uh and here
- 16:08one of the series I couldn't quite
- 16:10decipher which one he's holding but this
- 16:12is uh They Are all uh somewhat similar
- 16:16um
- 16:18um uh wait a second
- 16:22uh so um um another important shift
- 16:27comes during uh con residency at the
- 16:30American Academy in Rome that lasted
- 16:32from December 50 to August
- 16:351951 when Khan gains an interest in Pre
- 16:38premodern
- 16:39architecture uh such extended historical
- 16:43View and this is actually uh again I
- 16:46this connection with uh with the Alber
- 16:49here as a as a subtext Alber was of
- 16:52course interested in traveled often to
- 16:54Mexico to uh to um do a photography of
- 16:58uh
- 16:59um this um type of architecture
- 17:04um um such extended historical
- 17:08perspective was shared with several
- 17:10other prominent faculty members in
- 17:12Departments of art history and
- 17:14philosophy such as Vincent Scully and
- 17:16George ker here are some books that they
- 17:19were working on at the same time that
- 17:21emphasized this type of U historical
- 17:24perspective there was also a philosopher
- 17:27Paul wise whose statement from
- 17:301945 here every existent has passed all
- 17:35have come to be every existence has its
- 17:39effects on future is echoed in Khan's
- 17:43declaration at the Aspen design
- 17:45conference in
- 17:481961 what was has always been what is
- 17:53has always been what will be has always
- 17:57been yet is it was Joseph Alber Joseph
- 18:01anani Alber who had perhaps the most
- 18:04profound impact on K's design
- 18:06philosophy compare for example the
- 18:09restrained geometry KH adopted in for
- 18:12the Yale art gallery and the spatial
- 18:15effect on Alber is homage a square Ser
- 18:18Series this is of course the light well
- 18:21above the
- 18:23staircase um compare
- 18:27also um
- 18:29these quotes Albert's writing in the
- 18:33Yale alumni magazine in
- 18:371950 to design is to plan and organize
- 18:41to order to relate and to control and L
- 18:45Khan's uh uh com U text called order is
- 18:50that he published in the third issue of
- 18:52perspect in 1955 5 years later order is
- 18:57design is for form making in order form
- 19:01emerges out of a system of
- 19:04construction in order is a creative
- 19:06force in design is the means where with
- 19:10what when with how
- 19:15much even the notion of servant and
- 19:18servant elements KH was famous for Echo
- 19:21Albert's
- 19:23words here a
- 19:26statement from actually very early text
- 19:29by Albert from
- 19:3128 that says we no no longer
- 19:35differentiate essentially between those
- 19:37Elements which are carrying and those
- 19:40which are carried between those serving
- 19:42and those served which is echoed uh in
- 19:46K's ellor speeech in from
- 19:501949 the space order concept must extend
- 19:53beyond harboring of the Mechanical
- 19:55Services to include the servant spaces
- 19:58and joining spaces
- 20:00third um I compare these notes not to
- 20:04say um you know make a point about
- 20:06derivation but you can see that these
- 20:08things were in the air and that there
- 20:10was this incredibly uh vital
- 20:13intellectual culture uh that KH uh truly
- 20:17uh enjoyed and and uh immersed himself
- 20:21in finally um I believe an alers had a
- 20:25major impact on K's thinking about
- 20:27materials
- 20:29importantly as we know she insisted on
- 20:31working with simple traditional
- 20:34materials and techniques believing that
- 20:37quotation traditions of operations which
- 20:40embody a set of law uh provides a
- 20:46discipline that balances the hybrids of
- 20:49creative ecstasy they hate it kind of
- 20:51this s of personal uh gestural
- 20:54architecture uh and also use of new new
- 20:57materials uh tellingly her art form
- 21:01baving uh was one of the most uh oldest
- 21:05art
- 21:06forms uh in fact this is uh interesting
- 21:10that when uh KH uh uh KH publishes the
- 21:15plans for the Yale uh art gallery for a
- 21:18first time in perspecta it's very
- 21:20beautiful he prints the different uh
- 21:22service system ventilation electricity
- 21:25on transparencies and let uh all
- 21:28collapse them to create this type of
- 21:31effect uh of uh uh of uh of weaving now
- 21:36I went too U far away um um
- 21:42uh and um finally um I would make a
- 21:46point about again about Annie's I'm
- 21:50missing a slide um Annie Albert's words
- 21:54when he says when she says being
- 21:57creative is perhaps not the desire to do
- 22:00something but listening to what which
- 22:04what that which wants to be done the
- 22:07dictation of materials which is again
- 22:10echoed by one of the Khan's most famous
- 22:14statement that he makes in 1959 CM
- 22:18conference in otelo again this is KH it
- 22:21is for the architect to derive from the
- 22:25very nature of things from his relation
- 22:29what the thing wants to
- 22:31be so to
- 22:33conclude it um KH left as a change man
- 22:38when he left Yale and left behind two
- 22:41magnificent buildings uh which bear both
- 22:45the lessons that he he learned uh during
- 22:48his time at Yale so now to the main
- 22:51event um uh I want to Welcome to the
- 22:56stage uh Jules Brown
- 22:59uh the Paul melon professor emeritus at
- 23:02the history of art department and the
- 23:04founding director of Yale Center for
- 23:06British art and Alec bis uh uh who has
- 23:10been a beloved faculty member and
- 23:13colleague at the School of Architecture
- 23:15since
- 23:161976 who knows he's
- 23:19KH thank
- 23:21[Applause]
- 23:30I'm going to move this over here uh oh
- 23:33where's
- 23:41the um
- 23:44right uh okay good evening everybody
- 23:46thanks for coming and it is my pleasure
- 23:49to have the opportunity to talk with
- 23:51Jules in a in a rather um somewhat more
- 23:54informal uh setting than standing at a
- 23:57Podium uh we've had many conversations
- 24:00about Khan over the years as you can
- 24:02imagine uh in full disclosure I should
- 24:05immediately tell you that I was not a
- 24:08student of K I did not know him uh he
- 24:12was here when I first came to the School
- 24:14of Architecture in
- 24:161958 uh he was working with the master's
- 24:19class I saw him of course and and heard
- 24:21him from time to time uh but the only
- 24:24other direct contact I had with him was
- 24:27when we went uh down to Philadelphia as
- 24:30in the third year studio uh to design
- 24:34housing and we spent an afternoon with
- 24:36him and it was one of the most memorable
- 24:38occasions that I um can remember his
- 24:42demeanor his character what he was
- 24:44talking about how he expressed things
- 24:47was so powerful that it resonated has
- 24:49continued to resonate with me for a very
- 24:51long time but my direct exposure to him
- 24:53was very limited as opposed to the
- 24:56gentleman to my right who probably
- 24:59uh knows him as well or better than
- 25:01anybody else here having worked with him
- 25:04uh hand and glove as it as it were uh
- 25:08for many years uh since the Inception of
- 25:11the idea of the British art center but
- 25:14to begin at the beginning Jules let me
- 25:16ask you
- 25:18um how did you come to be become
- 25:20director of the British Art Center um
- 25:24okay well it goes back to um the 196 60s
- 25:29uh in
- 25:311966 late in the year Paul melon offered
- 25:33his gift of the British art collection
- 25:35his British art collection to Yale along
- 25:38with funds to build the building acquire
- 25:40the space and endow the operation uh
- 25:43Kingman Brewster was president of the
- 25:45University then and he formed a
- 25:47committee uh to plan for what kind of a
- 25:52institution might house that collection
- 25:54if it came to Yale uh at that time I had
- 25:57just got tenure in the history of art
- 26:00department and was also curator of
- 26:02American Art in the uh in in the Yale
- 26:05University Art Gallery um so my field
- 26:09was American art although my
- 26:10dissertation was on John Singleton
- 26:12Copley in England and I'd spent a year
- 26:13in England and and done quite a bit bit
- 26:16of work in in England and with that
- 26:19aspect of English
- 26:21art uh Andrew Richie was the director of
- 26:24the AL Art Gallery at that time and he
- 26:26and I sort of formed a subcommittee on
- 26:28the larger committee to come up with
- 26:31plans for a building what kind of an
- 26:34physical structure should there be to
- 26:36accommodate the collections the program
- 26:40so we um put together uh information on
- 26:44the kind of square footage requirements
- 26:46for the painting collection the prints
- 26:49and drawings the water coage rare books
- 26:50reference library and what would be
- 26:52needed for curators uh for uh registar
- 26:56all the needs that a a an institution
- 26:59might
- 27:00have uh and put uh came up with a rough
- 27:04estimate as to what the cost would be
- 27:06which poor Millan was interested um so
- 27:11that report went in and was accepted by
- 27:14Yale and by Paul melon uh and then uh
- 27:18early in
- 27:201968 uh Kingman booster asked me to be
- 27:23the director of the center which was a
- 27:26surprise uh and I was fairly reluctant
- 27:29because I had a kind of Captain's
- 27:30Paradise I was a professor of American
- 27:32art and I was curator of American art
- 27:34and I could use the collections just at
- 27:36my fingertips which is no longer being
- 27:38done here but uh it was nice it was very
- 27:42nice the um so I was reluctant but
- 27:46Kingman was very persuasive person and
- 27:48he um felt very strongly uh that it was
- 27:53important for the director to be uh
- 27:56preferably a member of the L faculty M
- 27:59uh I was reluctant because there were
- 28:00people who knew a lot more about British
- 28:01art and there were people who were more
- 28:03experienced at directing museums I had
- 28:05been a graduate student at Harvard at
- 28:07the fog had been assistant to the
- 28:09director uh of the of of the fog and had
- 28:13been a curator so I had some experience
- 28:15but there were really good directors out
- 28:17there um but as Bob alluded to early on
- 28:20this was a time of turmoil uh it was
- 28:23Vietnam War period uh there were a lot
- 28:25of reservations about the idea of a a
- 28:28wealthy alumnist dropping a collection
- 28:29of British art which was not that highly
- 28:31regarded at the time um on the
- 28:34University because there were other
- 28:36other needs that they felt would should
- 28:38be addressed um but he wanted the uh
- 28:42particularly The Faculty to know that
- 28:43this was an institution that was going
- 28:45to be consistent with the intellectual
- 28:48mission of the University so I said yes
- 28:51and that's how I got involved so then I
- 28:53guess you no I was just then why how did
- 28:56you come upon choosing con and was it up
- 28:58to you to make that recommendation well
- 29:01yes surprisingly it was uh they don't do
- 29:03it that way anymore no they don't um I I
- 29:08try to think you know how that came
- 29:10about uh and I think it was because I
- 29:14mean when I was asked to be director um
- 29:16I was asked by Kingman and Paul Paul
- 29:19came that so and I think Paul sort of
- 29:22felt that I was maybe his person at Yale
- 29:26as opposed to having a committee about
- 29:28which he was suspicious uh or having a
- 29:31uh a competition so yeah I asked Kingman
- 29:34the first question I asked him really
- 29:35was you know okay I'm director of the
- 29:36center what what's my responsibility
- 29:38specifically about a building he said
- 29:40well you're the client Yale University
- 29:43is the owner Paul melon's the donor so
- 29:46on uh so you're what you should do is is
- 29:49do some research figure it out and make
- 29:51a recommendation to the university uh as
- 29:53to an
- 29:54architect uh and that'll either be
- 29:57approved or Not by by the
- 29:59corporation so I set about doing that
- 30:01reading traveling but I brought with me
- 30:03quite a bit of baggage from my time at
- 30:06Harvard um the at that time the over the
- 30:11dominant idea for Museum
- 30:13architecture um was to create a kind of
- 30:17open area Loft space in which the
- 30:20whoever's installing installation could
- 30:22divide the space in whatever way they
- 30:24wanted in order to put things where they
- 30:25wanted and to use artificial
- 30:27illumination
- 30:28so again so they would have complete
- 30:30control over it um I didn't I didn't
- 30:33believe in that and because of my
- 30:35experience at the fog where I had
- 30:37installed some exhibitions and took
- 30:39courses in with John and I worked close
- 30:41with John kulage who was the director
- 30:43and who taught uh but I felt that
- 30:46objects works of art look best on under
- 30:48daylight natural light if you could
- 30:51control it for ultraviolet and the
- 30:53damaging effects of of daylight uh and
- 30:56that's you know paintings are very tough
- 30:58things and had survived for centuries
- 30:59under natural light and that's where
- 31:01they were painted under natural light so
- 31:03my preference was for for daylight if it
- 31:06could be that was a a very high priority
- 31:08the second one had to do with
- 31:10rooms uh the uh instead
- 31:13of undifferentiated space uh I wanted to
- 31:17have a welld designed room against which
- 31:22whoever is installing the exhibition had
- 31:24to work against the discipline of that
- 31:25room and I and I it seemed to me that
- 31:28the places where I had most enjoyed
- 31:30looking at works of art were domestic
- 31:32places domestic museums particularly the
- 31:35Philips Gall in Washington but the frick
- 31:38the Freer the The Gardener uh and even
- 31:40the fog itself was a pazo but still was
- 31:42domestic and had that room like quality
- 31:46so those things I wrote them up in a
- 31:48sort of a pre-program which were sort of
- 31:50General philosophical ideas and it
- 31:51talked about wanting those kinds of
- 31:54things also talked about this quadrant
- 31:56of the University as being the Arts
- 31:58quadrant and what what would be in here
- 32:00and and the fact that the building
- 32:02needed to be Humane and not brutal um
- 32:06not to make any immediate references
- 32:10to but uh so it laid out a series of
- 32:14things um the one thing that's in there
- 32:17that that was not follow things said
- 32:19that I didn't want uh also is I didn't
- 32:21want a a cold metallic surface and the
- 32:24facade um and I was very surprised when
- 32:27we ended up with a faad that we'll come
- 32:30back to that later on so uh yeah it
- 32:34narrowed it down to to did you have any
- 32:37trouble convincing the university which
- 32:40uh they knew KH from the art gallery but
- 32:43uh and also or Paul melon for that
- 32:45matter of of that choice yeah well they
- 32:47they did I asked Paul if he had any
- 32:48preferences just you know as far as an
- 32:51arch well I know I am P best because he
- 32:53had done uh Cho the AR Cho he done was
- 32:58the East Building the National Gallery
- 33:01he said but you know I'm not going to
- 33:02have to live in the building Yale is so
- 33:03you should you should make the decision
- 33:05so he was he was not inter interfering
- 33:08in that regard at all but both he and
- 33:11and Yale were well aware of Khan's
- 33:13reputation for never having brought a
- 33:15building in on time or on budget but
- 33:18they also knew he was a great architect
- 33:20so they and they and I I don't I don't
- 33:23know the the corporation um was um
- 33:28the building committee approved it did
- 33:30you take them to see for instance this
- 33:34building well yeah I well well when when
- 33:36I went to to see Lou I went to Lou's
- 33:38office and interviewed him yeah and um
- 33:43in in in the course of that interview
- 33:45you know I I really I liked him and we
- 33:47got along well um one thing that we may
- 33:50get to later on I don't know is talk
- 33:51about mentioned Venice but yeah the one
- 33:53thing that we didn't want was
- 33:54monumentality the the in the in of the
- 33:57of the times people were really opposed
- 34:00to buildings that were Monumental Museum
- 34:02that would had steps like the
- 34:03Metropolitan or the National Gallery
- 34:05which would really do a lot of damage in
- 34:08in New Haven um and um maybe just I can
- 34:12just mention that I don't want to go on
- 34:13too long but uh New Haven by by the plan
- 34:16of it um the commercial development of
- 34:19New Haven uh from Church Street uh West
- 34:23is one-sided because of the green and
- 34:26then and then y uh University the old
- 34:29campus then the art gallery and if on
- 34:33the other side of the street from the
- 34:34old art gallery and the and and and the
- 34:36new art gallery uh there was to be a
- 34:39another Gallery uh that would just cut
- 34:42the whole commercial development toward
- 34:44the west and be damaging uh to the city
- 34:46so people uh did not want that and um so
- 34:53um I was a little concerned because when
- 34:55I went into con's office there was a
- 34:58from his desk was this 8ot wide drawing
- 35:01of the palop congressi that he was
- 35:04planning for for for Venice and that was
- 35:07precisely what we didn't want but
- 35:08everything else
- 35:11went uh was there uh also some oh yeah
- 35:15you want to oh what you want to do
- 35:17Venice no doesn't make any difference
- 35:19we'll come back to but but I just wanted
- 35:21to mention that not only uh would the
- 35:24continuity of the uh shopping and the
- 35:26commercial be interrupted but really it
- 35:28would have been the first time that Yale
- 35:31moved across Chapel Street yeah that's a
- 35:33very important Point um and was there
- 35:35any student involvement boy than this
- 35:39yes uh particularly from uh um the
- 35:42architecture students they were they
- 35:43were very very much interested very much
- 35:46involved and uh they were they were very
- 35:50bright and uh not not really unfriendly
- 35:52but they they wanted to be involved they
- 35:54wanted to be informed uh a little bit
- 35:56aggressive but not not terribly so um
- 36:00and um they were concerned a number of
- 36:03things but that's the word monumentality
- 36:05is the one that comes in there one of
- 36:06Khan's first essays was entitled
- 36:09monumentality but it was monumentality
- 36:11on his terms which something rather
- 36:14different um they they didn't like the
- 36:18wall of the of the art gallery the new
- 36:20art gallery um um yeah this one right
- 36:25yeah yes the what's on your on your
- 36:27that's on on your left there the the con
- 36:30building um they felt that was that was
- 36:34Monumental and and uh turned its back on
- 36:37on on the street and uh KH when he was
- 36:41asked about it later on and in in the
- 36:44book because John and hinr asked him
- 36:47about that um says oh it's not
- 36:50Monumental at all and I put these string
- 36:52courses in there because that break that
- 36:54prevents the water from from getting the
- 36:56thing but what really bothered me and
- 36:59really the way it is was those other
- 37:00windows yeah it's the the windows in the
- 37:03uh in the Edon schw out building the old
- 37:06art gallery which are enormous he said
- 37:09you know how do you make a window you
- 37:11know next to that he said so I put the
- 37:14windows on the other side you know yeah
- 37:17yeah I I I should I should add appr
- 37:19propo that that there um John's book um
- 37:24conversations with Architects which
- 37:25includes 10 or eight interviews with
- 37:29different
- 37:30Architects um has taken these uh um
- 37:34tapes or these long conversations and
- 37:36and done a a terrific job of editing
- 37:38them but editing them way down that
- 37:40interview is like 35 Pages whereas the
- 37:43actual tapes run to
- 37:46260 and so there are lots of things
- 37:49which turn up in this book which were
- 37:51news to me and one of them was that I
- 37:54never heard him say anything about how
- 37:56to deal with windows and I've been
- 37:59thinking about that recently too because
- 38:00it seems to me
- 38:01that in when we get to the if we get to
- 38:06the current British Art Center um the
- 38:10that facade which is a major element and
- 38:13deserves some conversation but he solves
- 38:16that problem of the
- 38:18windows in the in the British Art Center
- 38:20so it's the first time he really does
- 38:23Windows yeah it took him some de a long
- 38:26time but it come it comes out of his own
- 38:28philosophy he has a real reason for
- 38:29doing what he did but here he hadn't
- 38:33arrived at that I love the but I love
- 38:35the comment he made about the the the
- 38:37problem he had with that wall he said he
- 38:38made it blank I think I'm right because
- 38:41it's a combination of deference and
- 38:43indecision
- 38:46so but there's another building he had
- 38:48to uh I'm just going to move past this
- 38:50one there's another building he had to
- 38:52deal with yeah he did and and I and I
- 38:56should also say that all of the comments
- 38:59about this building do not show up in
- 39:02John's text but do show up in Spades in
- 39:06this one yes um well it's a it's a
- 39:10fascinating thing
- 39:13U one of the questions was how well just
- 39:17to back up a little bit about your
- 39:19earlier point about moving across Chapel
- 39:20Street and and breaching that boundary
- 39:24uh Yale had Chapel Street um um had
- 39:27always been considered sort of a an
- 39:29informal boundary for Yale and now Yale
- 39:31was expanding and there was real concern
- 39:33about that on the part of of the city uh
- 39:36and and opposition to it and
- 39:38particularly in the early planning for
- 39:39the center was going to have a bridge
- 39:41across Chapel Street uh and that made it
- 39:44all the more more
- 39:46obvious
- 39:48uh KH um but being aware of that site I
- 39:52I always thought well he'll be really
- 39:54make some particularly interested in his
- 39:56own early ear building and this this
- 39:58later building uh he wasn't uh he never
- 40:03talked about this W out building the the
- 40:05old art gallery although that was very
- 40:07much on his mind uh but the the new art
- 40:09gallery had been under Andrew Richie
- 40:12Andrew Richie came uh had been curator
- 40:15at the Museum of Modern Art uh the L Art
- 40:18Gallery was fairly sleepy prior to that
- 40:21and uh Andrew wanted to bring in big
- 40:24donors big supporters many of whom were
- 40:26Yale colle
- 40:28and so he tried to make it look like the
- 40:29museum Modern Art and he covered the
- 40:31wall interior walls beautiful interior
- 40:33walls uh with with drywall and uh and
- 40:37and also enclosed the staircase and Lou
- 40:40was Furious about that and um we had to
- 40:43go over there sometime because the print
- 40:45room the prints and drawings in the
- 40:48center was going to be at in the same
- 40:51height and orientation as the print room
- 40:53in the art gallery so we wanted to see
- 40:55what the effective light coming in so we
- 40:57would walk over there he would never
- 40:59look up you just walk right through
- 41:01through those Galleries and and right
- 41:03past the staircase into the elevator up
- 41:05and then
- 41:06out um it's it's my conviction now that
- 41:11the conversation that's taking place is
- 41:13not with his his building but with this
- 41:15one it's with the Rudolph building uh
- 41:18which he clearly didn't like uh and he
- 41:21there is in the book where it just comes
- 41:23out of his philosophy as it develops uh
- 41:27when uh he his his his his orientation
- 41:32is that um we may get to it too um but
- 41:37just
- 41:39philosophically um he he draws a
- 41:42distinction between fact and
- 41:45truth and fact is what the physical
- 41:48world gives you nature gives you the
- 41:51universe gives you uh we're all facts
- 41:54we're all material um
- 41:58truth is what humans require and so
- 42:05um when he builds a building he asks
- 42:09nature you know I've got to build this
- 42:11building and we want it to do this and
- 42:13client was you know make it for me and
- 42:16then nature says uh well I'll do what I
- 42:19can you know can only go so far and then
- 42:22the architect comes in and and inserts
- 42:25into that needs and and another one of
- 42:29khor is always doing binaries yeah
- 42:31another one and in fact at one point you
- 42:32said that every problem can be solved by
- 42:34a
- 42:35binary um which is coming at the at the
- 42:38dawn of the computer age is a very
- 42:40interesting kind of
- 42:41observation uh so uh so the so the
- 42:46architect you know humanizes it so he
- 42:48said you know I I take from nature and
- 42:51then make it suitable for human
- 42:55need this building he says is a willful
- 42:58building and what he says in a sense
- 43:00what what Paul Rudolph is doing is
- 43:02imposing his will on what he wants in
- 43:06that building and of course when the
- 43:08building was being constructed and
- 43:10you'll remember but I'll remember uh it
- 43:12was a fantastic piece of sculpture
- 43:14fabulous thing just incredible um but
- 43:19there are things that you would know
- 43:20better um structurally that that blue
- 43:24objec itude that where the beams meet
- 43:26the columns sometimes they're on top
- 43:28Sometimes they come in the side they do
- 43:29different kinds of things he would never
- 43:31do that there's an order you follow that
- 43:33order and and you stick with it so he
- 43:35felt that that this was the architect
- 43:38imposing his will uh he says that he
- 43:41says so in a sense he's saying Rudolph
- 43:43was a willful architect and I'm not a of
- 43:46course I wouldn't say anything bad about
- 43:47him no he said I don't want I wanted to
- 43:50Jud yeah but but he also says that it's
- 43:53not undisciplined I think that that's
- 43:55suggested either by Honor by hinry it's
- 43:58an undisciplined building he says no
- 44:00it's not an undisciplined building but
- 44:02it has a lot of willful things right in
- 44:04it that's correct and it's a kind of
- 44:05coming together of shapes I think is the
- 44:07phrase that he used to describe it
- 44:09that's great um I have I have to say
- 44:11just memory uh my first two years in
- 44:14school were in the in the art gallery
- 44:17building not this one the the con
- 44:20building and my last two years me on the
- 44:22fourth floor of the of the of the fourth
- 44:24floor of the art yeah yeah and and
- 44:27for us in that generation anyway those
- 44:30folks working in that building at that
- 44:32time I think I could speak for all of
- 44:34them maybe not uh but for most of them
- 44:37it was a great place to start because
- 44:41everything was so dactic it was so clear
- 44:43if you had a question all you had to do
- 44:45was look around a certain kind of
- 44:47question anyway about building and
- 44:49material other kinds of questions were
- 44:52not so um uh answered so clearly by that
- 44:56building but those were was a great
- 44:58place to begin but I have to say that
- 45:00when this building was under
- 45:01construction we would come over at night
- 45:03and climb around it which was a pretty
- 45:05stupid thing to do because it was
- 45:07extraordinarily dangerous but it was
- 45:09thrilling I mean as you said it was it
- 45:12was fascinating to have the experience
- 45:13of both buildings and to admire and to
- 45:16really cherish both of them but they
- 45:18speak to different parts of you U but
- 45:21both of them very
- 45:23eloquently um let's let's just see
- 45:26what's that's interesting here the uh
- 45:28well wait a minute we haven't go there
- 45:29yet no it's not there it will be will be
- 45:33there it is there it
- 45:34is yeah so it's a final word on the
- 45:37Rudolph building uh is when Khan made
- 45:39his presented his prospective drawing uh
- 45:42to the city to get approval to be able
- 45:44to proceed to build the uh the center he
- 45:48uh takes it from the from the corner of
- 45:52of chapel and high streets looking down
- 45:54Chapel Street that didn't really believe
- 45:57that that uh cars should be on the
- 46:00street that's so it's it's just it's
- 46:02just pedestrian thre away uh he thought
- 46:05cars should either be under the street
- 46:06or else way up up high and that the at
- 46:09the street level really belong to the
- 46:11people uh and to Society for commerci
- 46:15whether for commercial use but for
- 46:17hospitals schools uh any kind of things
- 46:19that serve General Public public needs
- 46:23um but by making the perspective join
- 46:26the the way he does he takes the Rudolph
- 46:28building which is really a very strong
- 46:30powerful building he just shrinks it
- 46:32down to this little thing at the end
- 46:34of barely can barely see you can finally
- 46:36sort of tucked behind the trees and in
- 46:38the clouds it's very hard and the
- 46:40however the El Dorado is very clear to
- 46:44see um the other thing which he talks
- 46:47about a lot in the book is the way in
- 46:49which the lower floor to the building
- 46:50belongs to the street essentially
- 46:52particularly an Institutional building
- 46:54that that is part of the street and it
- 46:56could even rise for a couple of floors
- 46:59uh as commercial in certain
- 47:00circumstances he he speaks a lot about
- 47:03streets and uh in in the book and you
- 47:06know he and John and heinrick get into
- 47:08conversations about from their own lives
- 47:10as to how they like it when uh there
- 47:13would be carnivals in the summer and all
- 47:15the tables would come out in the street
- 47:16and people would have a good time they'd
- 47:17be very happy with the tables that are
- 47:19now out in front of the art gallery sum
- 47:21you love
- 47:22it uh let's talk for a minute about the
- 47:25task that you faced
- 47:28uh and first of all why did you feel the
- 47:32need to do this and what were the
- 47:35hurdles I mean you were presented with
- 47:38tapes as Amy said which are not recent
- 47:41which were probably inter terrible shape
- 47:43so what was involved in actually getting
- 47:47to the material itself and getting the
- 47:49transcript that that Karen did for you
- 47:52oh
- 47:54um well
- 47:57we WE John John very generously gave the
- 48:02gave those tapes to manuscripts and
- 48:05archives and went over and talked to
- 48:08Chris White who's head of it and to
- 48:11explore the possibility of of of doing
- 48:13something like this and then we had a
- 48:14meeting with Amy and um a few other
- 48:17people and and Karen uh to explore it
- 48:20and um they were enthusiastic about
- 48:24doing that but we were not able to use
- 48:26the tapes because the tapes were too
- 48:28fragile to use brittle uh so we made CDs
- 48:33from that and CC Clement was very
- 48:34helpful in getting those for us um and
- 48:38that's what we worked with uh then it
- 48:40was there just an interesting little
- 48:41side stories that I spent one summer
- 48:43really with headphones um listening and
- 48:46and and and trans trying to make this
- 48:49condensed version which I did out of it
- 48:52but but I came back and I told Chris
- 48:54that you know there's a lot of words I
- 48:56can't really understand there and she
- 48:58said well you know she said we could we
- 49:00could always have them for forensically
- 49:02edited what does that mean yeah well
- 49:05there is a little story I don't know how
- 49:06much time we have so there was a little
- 49:07little story about that that she told
- 49:10them um she because I asked the same
- 49:12question what that mean she said well
- 49:14one day U the FBI came here through
- 49:17manuscripts and archives they said we
- 49:19hear that you have that at the time of
- 49:21the Kent State massacre um that one of
- 49:25the students hung a microphone out of of
- 49:26his dorm window and recorded what was
- 49:29just going on out there and the FBI
- 49:32wanted to know whe because the National
- 49:33Guard was there and the students were
- 49:35coming up and putting flowers in their
- 49:37rifles uh and somebody shot and and a
- 49:40couple students were killed they wanted
- 49:42to know whether the order was given to
- 49:44fire other words was it done under a
- 49:46command or was it just somebody lost
- 49:47their nerve so they couldn't hear it on
- 49:50that on that tape that the student
- 49:51recorded So they they said well we can
- 49:53forensically edit it and they did it and
- 49:55they did it and they did it and they
- 49:56came back and they heard the word fire
- 49:58and that's that's that's what what it
- 50:00meant so um Chris said yeah well we'll
- 50:03take the tape we'll have it forensically
- 50:04edited at our expense um and um and they
- 50:09did so I listened I went through the
- 50:11whole thing again the next summer and
- 50:14and uh recorded and and and edited it
- 50:18and and it saved me from a number of of
- 50:20of errors that I would have made because
- 50:21words that I had misunderstood and
- 50:24misinterpret maybe we what about here a
- 50:27little bit of it because I think that
- 50:29everybody yeah oh yeah just just to say
- 50:31that's a great idea because it'll give
- 50:34you an idea of Khan's very distinctive
- 50:37manner of
- 50:38speaking um and you'll get a sense of
- 50:41why it needs to be uh sort of condensed
- 50:44and what I was trying to do would
- 50:46knowing that know having worked with
- 50:50him I knew that he could be very
- 50:52practical but when he would speak uh
- 50:55either a public lecture
- 50:57or to students he would get very
- 50:59elaborate very poetic uh And yet when I
- 51:02would see him with work charcoal in hand
- 51:04working over the the paper a drawing
- 51:07paper um or in in the field with with u
- 51:11working with people could be very
- 51:13precise direct and he could solve
- 51:15problems just like that that you know
- 51:16his associates be working on we put this
- 51:18here put this no this wants to be here
- 51:20there must so um and how how did he
- 51:24speak with Mr melon what how did he
- 51:26speak to Paul melon oh that was no when
- 51:28he spoke to Paul melon or to Kingman
- 51:31Brewster uh he would get poetic he would
- 51:33and it would drive me nuts
- 51:36because I was trying to get get them to
- 51:38be enthusiastic that yeah he con guy
- 51:41should do this and he that silence and
- 51:43thresholds and light and uh um very
- 51:47abstract poetic things and their eyes
- 51:50would roll but uh but they went they
- 51:53went with it they went with it they went
- 51:54with it um so yeah it would be good to
- 51:57hear just to hear his voice uh Trevor
- 52:00can you let me advance to this slide
- 52:02which is what he's talking about this is
- 52:04the very beginning of the book I think
- 52:06is it not it's right the beginning yes
- 52:08and uh Heinrich clz is asking the
- 52:11question can we hear it U actually this
- 52:15building that is lying in front of you
- 52:17this one here yeah we would have liked
- 52:19to ask to start out with that one and we
- 52:22would have liked to ask you uh to
- 52:24explain it to us
- 52:29it's a
- 52:31uh a building which personifies in a way
- 52:36how
- 52:40a how a structural
- 52:43order can
- 52:47um can
- 52:50um must have the
- 52:54power to unravel itself
- 52:58um not as a design see but as a
- 53:05characteristic
- 53:07yes
- 53:08[Applause]
- 53:10and it's it's a kind of a belief in the
- 53:14potentiality of
- 53:17um of man um willing and order thank you
- 53:25very much it's psychological order order
- 53:27as against a physical
- 53:28order but recognizing that the phys
- 53:32psychologic
- 53:33psychological recognizing that a that
- 53:36the physical order is what actually is
- 53:41the maker of it but the Willer of it the
- 53:45will you see is psychologic yes so in
- 53:49this case it was the it was allowing a
- 53:53physical phenomena to unravel itself you
- 53:56see to a conclusion without interference
- 53:59except that knowing it is to be used by
- 54:03humans that that it is that uh uh the
- 54:07spaces which it which it which it uh
- 54:11unravels is
- 54:13useful for the human
- 54:17you got
- 54:20it but you can you can understand that
- 54:23embedded in that is philosophy a lot a
- 54:27lot of philosophy well you mentioned his
- 54:29um using these sort of dichotomies or
- 54:32pairs and um one of them of course is
- 54:35silence and light yes uh but he also
- 54:37talked about um mind versus brain uh
- 54:43laws versus rules exactly um there are
- 54:47there parallel ideas there uh and this
- 54:50drawing uh which he made maybe you want
- 54:52to just comment on that yeah this is
- 54:54perhaps his most famous drawing is just
- 54:55one that
- 54:56well one peculiarity of it is that Khan
- 54:59had the ability to to draw with both
- 55:01hands and to write with both write
- 55:03Mirror Mirror writing so if you see here
- 55:06where it says silence to light then you
- 55:08see it coming the other way mirror
- 55:10writing silence to light and then under
- 55:13the desire to express and then the
- 55:15desire to express these there is ideas
- 55:18and they are very and they're very
- 55:19fundamental ideas what the what the
- 55:22symbolism is in the upper left in the
- 55:24upper left uh um these
- 55:27LS at least to me they they he call he
- 55:30calls them and it's just written written
- 55:32here The Inspirations uh the sanctuary
- 55:35of art the treasury of the shadows and
- 55:38what it is it's a kind of a platonic
- 55:40world and and it goes back to the to
- 55:42what Ava was saying the the statement
- 55:44about uh what was
- 55:48is what uh what what was has always been
- 55:52what is has always been what will be has
- 55:53always always been uh yesterday is today
- 55:56today is tomorrow tomorrow is today it's
- 55:58all there it's a platonic world of ideas
- 56:02so the
- 56:03architect trying to solve a particular
- 56:05problem can go into this realm of
- 56:08ideas and immers him him or herself and
- 56:13come up with what what it is that U is
- 56:18the sort of Ideal form for that
- 56:21particular need and it's a matter as
- 56:23with con it's always a matter of
- 56:24reduction reduce reduce reduce he always
- 56:27he said I don't try to get back to the
- 56:29number one I try to get back to the
- 56:30number zero zero yeah and and and that
- 56:33becomes clear after a while so what he
- 56:35really means by it uh and why light is
- 56:38so important an element to him um cuz I
- 56:42asked him about it once as the way I
- 56:44said did you mean like when the
- 56:46first creatures came out of that tepid
- 56:50uh pool and sense the world that they
- 56:53sensed light and and he said yes that's
- 56:56that right exactly and then in in the
- 56:58you read the in the in the text it's
- 57:00even more than that because he talks
- 57:01about desire and
- 57:03need his his thing is and he uh desire
- 57:08is what is
- 57:10human of any any living organism so that
- 57:14thing comes out of of the the the water
- 57:16and then feels that there's something
- 57:19out there and wants has this intense
- 57:21desire to see it he thinks that's how
- 57:23eyesight developed out of this you know
- 57:25desire
- 57:27and he he that's the kind of architect
- 57:30he was he said he was an intuitive AR
- 57:32architect not not a a logical
- 57:38architect yeah no go ahead well that's
- 57:40that so that's what that realm is then
- 57:42in the center of the pyramid uh that's
- 57:45the threshold and the architect is to
- 57:46bring the out of that he is to uh bring
- 57:50the the idea of what uh where where the
- 57:54treasury of the Shadows where their art
- 57:57resides and and make it real bring it
- 58:00into presence make it present uh but he
- 58:03uses that that form of a pyramid which
- 58:06goes back to the early drawing that uh
- 58:08his early work when he was at the
- 58:10Academy in Rome terribly impressed by
- 58:12early uh Egyptian and Greek structures
- 58:17as the most important um things in
- 58:19particularly if they're in Ruins because
- 58:21then the structure is revealed and
- 58:23that's the most important element uh but
- 58:26then bring it into into light so the
- 58:28area on the right is is light uh and
- 58:31give it give it presence and that's the
- 58:33task of the architect
- 58:37um so the the AR the architect uh turns
- 58:41to Nature to to find the order I me to
- 58:43get the order yeah and everything has
- 58:46its order yeah and U I'm just thinking
- 58:49whether let's this what is the order
- 58:52that he was searching for that's just a
- 58:54simple simple instance where I mean the
- 58:58first zigzag tower that that was a a
- 59:01city tower which he hoped would be in
- 59:03Philadelphia he had a terrible time in
- 59:05Philadelphia yeah um and uh was never
- 59:08built he also used the same idea as a
- 59:10plan for a concrete building uh U
- 59:14Corporation but it never was realized
- 59:17same thing this tower for for Kansas
- 59:19City uh as with many of his buildings he
- 59:23had a theory that if you designed it
- 59:25well enough
- 59:26it didn't matter what it cost because
- 59:28the donor would come up with the money
- 59:30come up with it because the ideas were
- 59:32so good and that's you know that's why
- 59:34so many of his buildings were not built
- 59:36so in this one was another one where the
- 59:38cost came in way higher than it was
- 59:40expected so he asked nature nature how
- 59:41can you help me solve this and he says
- 59:44so so nature gave him a gift of gravity
- 59:46so instead of building it from the
- 59:47bottom up he was going to build it from
- 59:48the top down so and then just let let
- 59:51gravity pull all the all the materials
- 59:54and everything down that say was conru
- 59:56this is this is a drawing of that of the
- 59:58idea the idea yeah but I I some other
- 1:00:02comments came up appropo of this which
- 1:00:04was interesting because I think that
- 1:00:05John you asked him about context in
- 1:00:08regard to this building uh and he made
- 1:00:10something an interesting comment which I
- 1:00:12think find a little bit um a little bit
- 1:00:15uh um hard to parse which is uh that um
- 1:00:21if there were buildings around which he
- 1:00:23uh felt needed to be honored then he
- 1:00:26would honor them uh if there weren't
- 1:00:29then he would hope that his building
- 1:00:30would be honored H but he never really
- 1:00:33defines what an honorable building is
- 1:00:36and I I find that's a little bit
- 1:00:37equivocal and I'm just kind of cute he
- 1:00:39never talked about that with you did he
- 1:00:41about what what buildings should be
- 1:00:44honored and what buildings need not be
- 1:00:46honored no we he never as I say he never
- 1:00:48talked about the buildings around here
- 1:00:50except in in in in the interviews he
- 1:00:52does with with with this particular
- 1:00:54building here but uh in general he he
- 1:00:57said I don't like to talk about other
- 1:00:59Architects um and uh he didn't he he
- 1:01:02liked to talk about Antiquity uh and he
- 1:01:05said and his own buildings huh and his
- 1:01:07own buildings and his own and his and
- 1:01:09his own buildings um and uh uh we had
- 1:01:13the building sock was we flash play sort
- 1:01:15of quickly but uh that was the building
- 1:01:17where he wanted to talk to Paul melon to
- 1:01:19make his Sal that he was the the
- 1:01:21architect and so that we flew out to was
- 1:01:24that the only con building other than
- 1:01:25this this one that that Paul melon went
- 1:01:28to see well he at that time at that time
- 1:01:32he we went to um uh Fort Worth to to see
- 1:01:36Rick Brown was was the director of the
- 1:01:38Kimble in Fort Worth was a friend of
- 1:01:40mine and he had gone to Harvard and had
- 1:01:43very similar ideas and he was doing new
- 1:01:45things with light which were in the same
- 1:01:47direction that we wanted to go here
- 1:01:49although we wanted to go a little
- 1:01:50further than than he was going um so we
- 1:01:53did fly down F fly there for uh to um
- 1:01:58talk to Rick and see the see the plans
- 1:02:00and the model and then later went down
- 1:02:02for the opening yeah uh so those those
- 1:02:04those were the two yeah that's that's
- 1:02:06something I think he was Notorious was
- 1:02:08he not for not wanting to finish
- 1:02:11designing I me Rick Brown just there's a
- 1:02:14comment in in a piece by Charles Sawyer
- 1:02:17that I read where Rick Brown asked him
- 1:02:20his opinion Sawyer whether Khan would be
- 1:02:23a good architect for the kimple his
- 1:02:25response was that you won't find a more
- 1:02:27sympathetic Humane creative architect
- 1:02:30but you've got to be willing to stay up
- 1:02:31all night working with him because if
- 1:02:33you don't you'll find that he's changed
- 1:02:35his mind while you were
- 1:02:37asleep yeah and he never wanted to
- 1:02:39finish a building because the creation
- 1:02:41ended yeah I wouldn't put it quite that
- 1:02:43way but I I talked to Rick a lot on the
- 1:02:45phone because he was really my adviser
- 1:02:46on whether to go with Khan and and he
- 1:02:49would talked a lot about how to handle
- 1:02:50him and and get get things moving along
- 1:02:53but it was it was not that it wasn't
- 1:02:55that he didn't want to finish it in fact
- 1:02:57when he did finish it I mean he he would
- 1:02:59say you know uh I'm satisfied with this
- 1:03:03building that that that that was a very
- 1:03:05important statement we didn't really
- 1:03:06know it we thought of course he would
- 1:03:07say any architect would say that but
- 1:03:09with Khan he wouldn't say it until he
- 1:03:10got to a point where he couldn't doing
- 1:03:12but what what he did not mind having to
- 1:03:17um do it over again he he didn't mind I
- 1:03:21was going to ask you about that what
- 1:03:22happened when the British Art Center
- 1:03:24scheme had to be reduced yeah we had to
- 1:03:26reduce it by a third because it was way
- 1:03:28over budget because of the was a time of
- 1:03:30runaway
- 1:03:31inflation um and
- 1:03:35um he was not unhappy with it he you
- 1:03:38know he didn't cheer but you know he was
- 1:03:39disappointed because he really loved
- 1:03:41that first building which a very
- 1:03:42powerful building and that would have
- 1:03:44had an interesting different kind of
- 1:03:46relationship I think with this building
- 1:03:47too with this one yeah because it itself
- 1:03:50was pretty Burly it was um but um it was
- 1:03:55Major at any rate he he just he loved to
- 1:03:57design and of course he did that
- 1:04:00uh day and night I mean when he got
- 1:04:03tired he would just fold up his jacket
- 1:04:05put on the floor and take a nap and then
- 1:04:07go back to the drawing board and that's
- 1:04:09what he loved to do were there just to
- 1:04:11talk about the building for a second or
- 1:04:13not the building but rather the book for
- 1:04:15a second were there things in it that
- 1:04:17surprised
- 1:04:20you um yeah uh I mean that's that's
- 1:04:24really the great thing about KH is that
- 1:04:26there a lot that that surprised me but
- 1:04:28where the surprises come is just in my
- 1:04:32own increased understanding of what he
- 1:04:34was about uh which I didn't really know
- 1:04:37when I was working with him I didn't
- 1:04:38think you know there's all this great
- 1:04:40philosophy stuff going on you know it
- 1:04:42was it's not what we talked about it was
- 1:04:45all very practical kind of kind of
- 1:04:47things and I was very very innocent
- 1:04:49about I didn't really understand you
- 1:04:51know I said well we hired this renowned
- 1:04:53architect and I waited for those first
- 1:04:55drawings to come I was so excited First
- 1:04:56drawings was going to come you know I
- 1:04:58expected to see a facade and it was just
- 1:04:59going to be beautiful and so so I get
- 1:05:01this Square rectangular drawing and with
- 1:05:05a little boxes in it rectangles and one
- 1:05:08would say registar one would say curator
- 1:05:11pains reference and uh it was very
- 1:05:15difficult to get out of him any uh uh
- 1:05:18sense of what it was going to look like
- 1:05:20uh eventually we would get some
- 1:05:22elevations but mostly it was plans plans
- 1:05:24plans and then some elevations
- 1:05:26finally some drawings of facades um but
- 1:05:29he was very wary of arousing false
- 1:05:33expectations he didn't want to do that
- 1:05:35and uh so he just really wouldn't do it
- 1:05:37the models when he would make a model
- 1:05:39was just Basswood no color nothing and
- 1:05:43the only articulation other than the
- 1:05:46forms was that where there was was was
- 1:05:49were windows with his penetration the
- 1:05:51grain is reversed and runs in the other
- 1:05:52direction that's it that's it that was
- 1:05:57um you know we could um we have enough
- 1:06:00to talk about for all night um and I'm
- 1:06:03just wondering whether we should just at
- 1:06:05this point ask people whether they have
- 1:06:07some questions because we've got plenty
- 1:06:09to talk about but we don't have time um
- 1:06:13but I'm just wondering whether there's
- 1:06:14some questions from the floor because I
- 1:06:18suspect that there are many and now is
- 1:06:21an opportunity I think probably the mics
- 1:06:24are out there somewhere in somebody's
- 1:06:27hands okay and
- 1:06:30uh did he ever mention
- 1:06:33Yung while we're waiting for mic KH or
- 1:06:36Melon Khan no
- 1:06:39notel no melon melon did I know it I was
- 1:06:42that's one of the reasons I asked
- 1:06:44because no because I hold hold on a
- 1:06:48second we need a mic just because you're
- 1:06:50for posterity
- 1:06:52now Jules and live streaming I into to
- 1:06:56Vince Gali yeah Lan liked a great deal
- 1:07:00the facade of the garage where iisa was
- 1:07:04in the floor first floor and now oia and
- 1:07:07that he composed the proportions of the
- 1:07:09British Art Center in relationship to
- 1:07:11the faad that's Vince Vince's idea in
- 1:07:15relationship to what to the High Street
- 1:07:21Garage uh well I'd like to hear Bob if
- 1:07:25you hear Bob talk about Vince ideas I
- 1:07:27had a different uh Theory I no I never
- 1:07:30heard that at all if if you look if you
- 1:07:32look at it from the parking lot you will
- 1:07:34see that it's a definite relationship
- 1:07:37well I think these things seeped in and
- 1:07:39and where it struck me you remember the
- 1:07:40the early drawing that was on here the
- 1:07:43first scheme with the arched roofs Y
- 1:07:46which really shocked me I you
- 1:07:48know didn't I didn't could could but I
- 1:07:51realized that at that time we used to
- 1:07:54then the airlines flew a lot between New
- 1:07:56Haven and Philadelphia and uh uh
- 1:08:00Stratford and Philadelphia Bridgeport
- 1:08:02Stratford and when you fly into
- 1:08:04Stratford airport there were these
- 1:08:05airplane hangers and he used to fly in
- 1:08:08there quite regularly and it just wonder
- 1:08:10I just wondered whether that image
- 1:08:12somehow seeped into his head somehow I
- 1:08:14just I didn't know where those I mean
- 1:08:16that the the arching shape something he
- 1:08:19had used in segmented arches in a number
- 1:08:22of places and it's in the lighting and
- 1:08:24the Kimble and the
- 1:08:26yeah clear clear story lighting but you
- 1:08:29just wonder about this but Bob you know
- 1:08:32you were you were here um and and you
- 1:08:36were close you were close to Vince and
- 1:08:38so I just was wondering what have were
- 1:08:41there um I I did I I used to go to
- 1:08:45Philadelphia quite a few times as we
- 1:08:47were doing archival research about early
- 1:08:50liuan for Vince's book student days and
- 1:08:53all of that because nobody knew anything
- 1:08:55about it and he he he did actually like
- 1:08:58to gossip um he would talk about other
- 1:09:00Architects and their work in those days
- 1:09:03because I'm talking about 1961 or two 10
- 1:09:06years before you God he wasn't quite the
- 1:09:09grand man I just want to say
- 1:09:11parenthetically also listening to him
- 1:09:13doesn't sound like the liuon I knew yeah
- 1:09:17uh it's funny some people sound exactly
- 1:09:19as you expect on it but either here or
- 1:09:22there two things one Aeros saronin also
- 1:09:25could draw with both hands that's very
- 1:09:28interesting was part of their training
- 1:09:29it was in the in the arrow Arrow could
- 1:09:32do he would write letters and the carbon
- 1:09:36copy
- 1:09:37absolutely he was Adept at it by all
- 1:09:40reports and the other thing is
- 1:09:42the L did not like Paul Rudolph on a
- 1:09:46professional basis because Paul Rudolph
- 1:09:49was the architect just when he arrived
- 1:09:52at Yale as the chairman he took on the
- 1:09:56commission from Andrew Richie to do the
- 1:09:58things you describ of closing the
- 1:10:01gallery and there was definite
- 1:10:04professional animosity which Rudolph
- 1:10:06regretted later on he never called Khan
- 1:10:09and said I've been asked to do this I
- 1:10:11hope you don't mind the kind of
- 1:10:13professional courtesy that is expected
- 1:10:15so those are the two things I would add
- 1:10:16to your I don't understand this drawing
- 1:10:19at all I've been looking at it for two
- 1:10:22days I can't I don't imagine what is it
- 1:10:25flat and arched no it's flat and arched
- 1:10:29yeah it's a it's a ver trust system uh
- 1:10:32and the yeah but it doesn't need to be
- 1:10:34curved I mean that's it doesn't need to
- 1:10:36be curved that's don't know where that
- 1:10:38comes from he's he's he's he's taking
- 1:10:40off from the Kimble which had the um
- 1:10:43clear story light over the four in on
- 1:10:45the fourth floor and now he wanted to
- 1:10:48make this really great curving clear
- 1:10:50story light and that's really the reason
- 1:10:53why we rejected this because we felt it
- 1:10:55would be such a powerful visual element
- 1:10:58that your eyes would leave the paintings
- 1:10:59and go up to this clear story very
- 1:11:02interesting do you remember that that
- 1:11:05when when the alterations were made to
- 1:11:07the gallery also they got rid of the
- 1:11:10stone at the base of the wall and
- 1:11:13replaced it with
- 1:11:14grass and which was a horrible thing to
- 1:11:18do but I remember Khan coming and giving
- 1:11:21a talk after when it was grass and just
- 1:11:24casually in in in a conversation about
- 1:11:27something else he said that stone is the
- 1:11:29grass of the city and the whole
- 1:11:32Auditorium erupted because of because
- 1:11:34all the Architects hated the grass and
- 1:11:36I'm glad to see that it's gone now
- 1:11:38because it never should have been there
- 1:11:40in the first place yeah no l love it
- 1:11:42love it the way yeah yeah we have
- 1:11:44another uh Eva yeah I have a question
- 1:11:47about the entrance uh both of the
- 1:11:50galleries have very interesting
- 1:11:51solutions to how to enter them kind of
- 1:11:55yeah you mean is this one or or the I
- 1:11:57mean both of them I mean Art Gallery you
- 1:12:00ENT kind of you know along the street
- 1:12:03and here the the kind of absent corner
- 1:12:06is quite brilliant I don't see it here
- 1:12:08when did that well it's in theer in the
- 1:12:11center he's very much concerned with the
- 1:12:13two the two sides of the building having
- 1:12:16an expansion joint in the center yeah
- 1:12:18but in the final final version the one
- 1:12:21now the one now which is quite brilliant
- 1:12:24uh the corner yeah way to ENT yeah well
- 1:12:26he had done that uh at the Richards and
- 1:12:29he had done it at exer and exer and and
- 1:12:33the Kimble are the two immediate
- 1:12:35predecessors of the center and that's
- 1:12:38fascinating because he was doing a
- 1:12:39library and an art gallery which is what
- 1:12:42the center
- 1:12:44has a lot a lot of both um plus the
- 1:12:48academic program uh
- 1:12:51so that is something we had a lot of
- 1:12:54experience with it the story though or
- 1:12:56at least as we tell it and being there
- 1:12:59at the time had it happened is that
- 1:13:02Brewster quite specifically said that
- 1:13:04the center should be oriented both
- 1:13:06toward the university and the city again
- 1:13:09it's within that social context and the
- 1:13:12thought was that in fact Khan picked up
- 1:13:13on Brewster's comment to have a corner
- 1:13:16entrance that would Orient both ways
- 1:13:18that's really a public CL that's the way
- 1:13:22wonderfully works now yeah and it also
- 1:13:24relates so beautifully to the interior
- 1:13:27Courtyards it's the same Dimension as
- 1:13:30the entrance Court um and it also
- 1:13:33relates to the exterior Court which is
- 1:13:35the scoozie court so there are all sorts
- 1:13:37of things that go on at one point in the
- 1:13:39design was there not an entrance off of
- 1:13:42High Street on axis yeah because you can
- 1:13:44look at the plan and see it as a bozar
- 1:13:46plan if the entrance came off of High
- 1:13:49Street right well see in this in this
- 1:13:51first one the stre the sidewalk goes
- 1:13:53past those two Center columns right uh
- 1:13:56and then just flows right through the
- 1:13:57building yeah to High Street yeah and
- 1:14:00there was the same thing in the second
- 1:14:01building is that it you would you would
- 1:14:04enter you would enter in the in the
- 1:14:07early plans for the second building in
- 1:14:09the off the center on Chapel and the
- 1:14:12street would go through in the same kind
- 1:14:14of way and at one point he said well go
- 1:14:16let's look at it the other way come in
- 1:14:17from High Street but he rejected he
- 1:14:20rejected that
- 1:14:22yeah yes there's Carter
- 1:14:26um hey um I'm just looking back at the
- 1:14:30history of this whole project and I
- 1:14:32think it's an extraordinary tribute to
- 1:14:34Yale that two straight
- 1:14:36arrow uh standup people like Paul melon
- 1:14:40and Kingman Brewster would have taken a
- 1:14:42chance on this very flaky rather untr
- 1:14:48untested individual and I was curious
- 1:14:51who else was on your short list and what
- 1:14:55you had to do if anything to persuade
- 1:14:57these two people to put the power of
- 1:15:00Yale and its Legacy behind the
- 1:15:03building right well I think you
- 1:15:05underestimate both Brewster and melon in
- 1:15:07that in that regard I mean think
- 1:15:09Brewster bringing co-education to Yale
- 1:15:11he was he was willing to to to do all
- 1:15:13sorts of things and and Paul was uh
- 1:15:17maybe a little less less adventurous
- 1:15:19than that so let me cond could you
- 1:15:22condent your question a little bit as to
- 1:15:24what it is that you want to know who
- 1:15:25else was on the short list oh who else
- 1:15:27was on the short list okay
- 1:15:32um the person that I was very interested
- 1:15:35in was Philip Johnson uh in part because
- 1:15:38when I was working at Harvard um uh at
- 1:15:41the fog Johnson came in one day and he
- 1:15:43wanted to see the plans for the fog
- 1:15:45because he had just gotten the
- 1:15:46commission for UDA for the mson Williams
- 1:15:48Proctor and he wanted to build it on a
- 1:15:50courtyard plan and he wanted the fog
- 1:15:52Courtyard to be um he wanted to have
- 1:15:55that in in his mind so I like that since
- 1:15:58I like the courtyard I like Courtyards
- 1:16:00and and I S guy thinks right that's good
- 1:16:04uh so the first place I really went was
- 1:16:06to udica to see the mson Williams
- 1:16:09Proctor uh and I liked the courtyard but
- 1:16:11I didn't like what he did uh he at that
- 1:16:14stage in his career he was very
- 1:16:17decorated decorator it's a bad word but
- 1:16:19you know finicky and little things would
- 1:16:21go so he had the paintings hanging but
- 1:16:23then he had a line going right through
- 1:16:24it middle of them uh it was just very
- 1:16:28distractive and and uh so there it was a
- 1:16:32kind of finicky equality to it in fact
- 1:16:34the one thing that always surprised me
- 1:16:35about Philip Johnson's buildings the
- 1:16:37ones that I saw there and at the Aman
- 1:16:40Carter and elsewhere is that when you
- 1:16:42went down into the basement and looked
- 1:16:44at the engineering was marvelous was
- 1:16:46just almost the opposite of of this very
- 1:16:49filigree kind of stuff that he would do
- 1:16:51up above so anyway that U
- 1:16:56he he was sort of running second uh in
- 1:16:59the ones looked you know I looked at a
- 1:17:00lot of others um I had liked Richard
- 1:17:03Meyer's early work and he was sort of on
- 1:17:06my list um but um um didn't like some of
- 1:17:12his later work uh Scully was of course
- 1:17:15very keen on
- 1:17:16dri um but you know if you think about
- 1:17:19the Football Hall of Fame I tried to put
- 1:17:21that together with Paul melon and that
- 1:17:22didn't work at all
- 1:17:25uh so anyway
- 1:17:29um um there was a proposal for
- 1:17:32competition and Gibson Danes the dean of
- 1:17:35the school of art and architecture and
- 1:17:37Charles Moore the then chairman had an
- 1:17:40idea of a competition and there is a
- 1:17:42list that they drew up which had
- 1:17:44Sterling who was very bitter Jim James
- 1:17:46Sterling about not being considered afro
- 1:17:49he was long associated with the Al and
- 1:17:51he was a British architect of
- 1:17:54Distinction
- 1:17:55and there were others but then obviously
- 1:17:58um you had the ear of the donor and the
- 1:18:01president and they were sort of fiddling
- 1:18:03off on the side but there's a huge
- 1:18:06literature of letters and so forth and
- 1:18:08Vince was writing to the to Kingman I've
- 1:18:10read them push pushing I've read them
- 1:18:12pushing Venturi and um and Venturi was
- 1:18:16commissioned at a certain moment to do a
- 1:18:17kind of Urban Design study for the
- 1:18:20street so the whole thing is quite
- 1:18:23complicated yeah isn't always as simple
- 1:18:26as it seems never it never seemed simple
- 1:18:29to me I I cuz you're an
- 1:18:33Insider there's a there's one back there
- 1:18:36who I can't see
- 1:18:39but um was there a particular question
- 1:18:42that was asked that you found his answer
- 1:18:45to be most
- 1:18:51surprising particular question question
- 1:18:54that he asked of you you mean a question
- 1:18:57that the convers came AC was particular
- 1:19:01question you found
- 1:19:03answer oh oh yeah you mean in personal
- 1:19:06conversation oh yeah um well there were
- 1:19:09a lot of them was like the one about the
- 1:19:11you know crawling up out of the water
- 1:19:12but I guess the the question I always
- 1:19:14asked him was what's it going to look
- 1:19:16like yeah that's what I always wanted to
- 1:19:17know what's it going to look like
- 1:19:24question that oh that's different okay
- 1:19:27but let me finish that one that I was
- 1:19:28just going to say because I was just
- 1:19:30wanted to know what the building was
- 1:19:31going to look like and then finally yeah
- 1:19:33he said what it's you know on a on a on
- 1:19:35a sunny day it's going to look like a
- 1:19:36butterfly and on a cloudy day it'll look
- 1:19:39like a moth that was that that was okay
- 1:19:45what what was your reaction when he said
- 1:19:48he wanted to make it out of steel oh
- 1:19:50that was that was I you know I just kept
- 1:19:53saying that uh well that was funny cuz
- 1:19:55early on he asked melon whether melon
- 1:19:57had any material that he liked and melon
- 1:19:59said well stone is is good material and
- 1:20:03Lou said yeah stone is
- 1:20:05[Laughter]
- 1:20:09nice
- 1:20:11um no I kept I I asked him you know I
- 1:20:14remember because we were driving
- 1:20:15someplace and I and I and I asked him I
- 1:20:17said Lou did you ever see a a metalclad
- 1:20:21building that you liked he said no
- 1:20:25I said but you going to give us a
- 1:20:26metalclad building
- 1:20:30yes and I and I have to say that uh from
- 1:20:33the very beginning the one thing one
- 1:20:35heard constantly from people was I love
- 1:20:37the the y center of British art but I
- 1:20:39don't really like the facade and I have
- 1:20:41to say that personally it was my least
- 1:20:43favorite part of of the building now
- 1:20:47it's becoming to me the most important
- 1:20:48part of the building it's
- 1:20:50extraordinarily important and I'm
- 1:20:52learning more about that facade and what
- 1:20:54it's doing and why it's doing what it's
- 1:20:55doing I shouldn't say it's the most
- 1:20:57important but it's it's
- 1:20:59it's maybe it's just whether it's ahead
- 1:21:02of its time or or whatever maybe we're
- 1:21:04growing into it but that whole you think
- 1:21:07back back back that drawing of silence
- 1:21:10and light I mean that whole thing is uh
- 1:21:13light coming through the the glass you
- 1:21:15it's always this binary thing in here
- 1:21:16you've got the glass and the metal when
- 1:21:19L would sometimes refer to them as uh uh
- 1:21:23windows and opaque
- 1:21:26Windows Light No
- 1:21:28Light and that uh he viewed matter
- 1:21:34material as spent
- 1:21:37light that is if you could take if you
- 1:21:39could take matter and speed it up as in
- 1:21:43making a hydrogen bomb um why couldn't
- 1:21:47you reverse the process slow the light
- 1:21:50down and make it concrete material
- 1:21:54material and he said don't talk to
- 1:21:57scientists about that they'll tell you
- 1:21:59it doesn't work and I've tried I've
- 1:22:00tried it on scientists because I get you
- 1:22:02logical it seems logical and L and Lou
- 1:22:05said no he says it's it's not a
- 1:22:07scientific truth it's a poetic truth and
- 1:22:10that's equally
- 1:22:12important did you did you make a comment
- 1:22:15once I'm trying to think
- 1:22:17about your responsibility being for the
- 1:22:21cell of the building and the physical
- 1:22:24plant was responsible for the what was
- 1:22:27that that's a nice phrase well it's was
- 1:22:30one of the problems I Bob will kill me
- 1:22:34on this one I mean it seems to me that
- 1:22:36one of the problems with this building
- 1:22:38is that the architect was his own client
- 1:22:41so there was there was nobody there
- 1:22:43wasn't that other voice coming in all
- 1:22:46the time um the problem with
- 1:22:51uh the center and building the center is
- 1:22:54that in a funny way there were too many
- 1:22:56clients because I was a client Kingman
- 1:22:59said you're the client but he said
- 1:23:00Yale's the owner and so physical plan
- 1:23:04which is in you know they they do all
- 1:23:06the engineering all the all the
- 1:23:07mechanical stuff so they as as the thing
- 1:23:09progressed they became more and more
- 1:23:12involved and important and in a sense I
- 1:23:14had this this feeling that yeah I was
- 1:23:17sort of responsible for the soul or the
- 1:23:19spirit of the building but they were
- 1:23:20responsible for the for the body of it
- 1:23:23um and you know that they
- 1:23:26could but but they were usually
- 1:23:30overruled first by Lou and Lou was alive
- 1:23:34and then by Marshall Meyers who took
- 1:23:36over uh who was Lou's pupil and had been
- 1:23:39the job captain at the Kimble um they
- 1:23:43were very strong red and uh would not be
- 1:23:46moved easily and often dealing with
- 1:23:49Engineers l through that process of
- 1:23:52simplification that I referred to
- 1:23:54earlier here would reduce the
- 1:23:56problem uh that would bring about a
- 1:23:59solution that they would that they would
- 1:24:00solve it so for the big example is the
- 1:24:02air floor the two great Innovations at
- 1:24:05the center are the shops first Museum
- 1:24:08ever planned from the beginning to have
- 1:24:10commercial shops and secondly um the air
- 1:24:14floor uh it's the first my understanding
- 1:24:17what they say it's the first high-rise
- 1:24:19building first place where an air for
- 1:24:21has been used other than on grade uh on
- 1:24:24I'm sure it was Lou talking to the
- 1:24:26engineers and saying look you know you
- 1:24:28know the Air Supply we got we got these
- 1:24:30V beams we can lay ducks in there the
- 1:24:33other floors where you don't have V
- 1:24:34beams you show those Ducks great big and
- 1:24:36that get gets off into another
- 1:24:37theoretical thing as to why you want
- 1:24:39some big because he knows over time
- 1:24:41technolog is going to make things
- 1:24:42smaller so he said you want to give them
- 1:24:44room to to to do what they want to do
- 1:24:47without hurting the structure of the
- 1:24:49room which is which is all all important
- 1:24:52uh to one thing that surprised me I
- 1:24:55think in reading through it is that I
- 1:24:57don't think commandant his engineer is
- 1:25:00ever mentioned no he did he didn't they
- 1:25:02had they had had had sort of a falling
- 1:25:05out but just on that air for thing I I
- 1:25:07think KH was saying you know I want to
- 1:25:09return the air but I don't want he Ducks
- 1:25:10running in front of the windows you know
- 1:25:12how else can we do it and I think his
- 1:25:15questioning led abator to the idea of of
- 1:25:18the air foror but it's interesting
- 1:25:20because he's very very clear about some
- 1:25:23things in the building but is a little
- 1:25:24bit canny about others so that you see
- 1:25:26the way the air comes into the building
- 1:25:28with all those beautiful Ducks but you
- 1:25:30have no idea how it's going out the
- 1:25:32building does not inflate like a balloon
- 1:25:34so you know it's going out somewhere and
- 1:25:36you have to look very closely to find
- 1:25:38the little reveal in the base but it's
- 1:25:41there it's there it's there but you have
- 1:25:42to but that's the thing about that
- 1:25:44building is that everything is revealed
- 1:25:46no
- 1:25:47secret I don't
- 1:25:49think okay uh any other questions I'm
- 1:25:52sure there yes in the back there hand up
- 1:25:56why did Khan choose the pyramid to
- 1:25:58represent the threshold between silence
- 1:26:00and light in the diagram you showed what
- 1:26:02which term in the diagram you showed um
- 1:26:05in the presentation where you have
- 1:26:07silence and light on either side chose
- 1:26:09the pyramid
- 1:26:11threshold well it's
- 1:26:15the for him that's the fundamental shape
- 1:26:18I mean it's comes out of those early the
- 1:26:20Early influence of of Egypt and Greece
- 1:26:22and so on and the the the whole thing
- 1:26:25with that the zigzag Tower the city
- 1:26:27tower is the tetrahedrons and these
- 1:26:29things build by laying them on top of
- 1:26:31each other this just pure geometry um
- 1:26:34build build thems build themselves into
- 1:26:37a a structure that doesn't require a
- 1:26:39spine it's they do it themselves that's
- 1:26:42all explained in great detail in in in
- 1:26:45in that in that conversation but yeah
- 1:26:48you look at it and you say well that
- 1:26:50that pyramid doesn't look like a
- 1:26:52threshold at all but that's in his mind
- 1:26:55that's what it was doing was an
- 1:26:56intellectual
- 1:26:58threshold we have time for maybe one yes
- 1:27:01there's a hand in the
- 1:27:02back did Khan talk at all about the
- 1:27:05cylindrical stairwells their
- 1:27:07significance and maybe um what inspired
- 1:27:11them
- 1:27:17um uh he the stairwell is very important
- 1:27:20obviously and U the fact that the
- 1:27:23stairwell does not EX gaug this this
- 1:27:25this the ceiling is very important uh in
- 1:27:28terms of sources and that's another
- 1:27:31question we didn't get into a lot of
- 1:27:33places uh he always denied being
- 1:27:35influenced uh because he said the word
- 1:27:38influen way it used means like you sat
- 1:27:40down you copied something and says I
- 1:27:41never do that um but somewhere in the
- 1:27:44literature I I read and I stupidly
- 1:27:47forgot to make a note on it he said that
- 1:27:49the one influence on him with the
- 1:27:51British Art Center was
- 1:27:52carcasson and when you look at pictures
- 1:27:54of it you can see you can see it
- 1:27:56particularly in the stair Tower um but I
- 1:27:59can't find it I will find it someday but
- 1:28:01I haven't found it and didn't he do a
- 1:28:03wonderful drawing of the apps of Albi
- 1:28:06which has has those fantastic oh really
- 1:28:09things yeah okay but I mean well we
- 1:28:11could talk a lot about that because
- 1:28:12there are lots of things that are out
- 1:28:14there had at the back of his desk for
- 1:28:17years a huge copy of the map of Rome
- 1:28:21yeah with all the p p map p oh don't
- 1:28:25believe everything an architect tells
- 1:28:29you are you getting thirsty Bob
- 1:28:33yes would you like to invite everyone
- 1:28:35upstairs I did before but oh sorry I'll
- 1:28:37repeat the invitation thank than our
- 1:28:39great speakers
- 1:28:41[Music]
- 1:28:52[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Louis I. Kahn in Conversation: Interviews with John W. Cook and Heinrich Klotz, 1969-70 by Yale University, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,124 words across 2,008 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.