LO_Angelina Kallita Caumen_Stella Gracia School_Makassar — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:01Push and pull in centers to gorge
2. 0:02audience fame for their own favorite
3. 0:04athletes or cursing in another rival
4. 0:05league is exactly what makes sports
5. 0:07alive in the first place. What is debate
6. 0:09is bad is discussing the trend of how we
7. 0:11cheered athletes and sports on a broad
8. 0:13manner. That's the same. What is hate
9. 0:15watching? We think hate watching is the
10. 0:17dislike and rivalry. We think team
11. 0:19government's stance is quite correct on
12. 0:21hate watching. But we'd like to stress
13. 0:23it is on a speech not the act of
14. 0:25bullying or physically harming on other
15. 0:27athletes themselves. We think it comes
16. 0:30not only from the enjoyment of watching
17. 0:31someone fail, but also from the
18. 0:33legitimate expression that you want to
19. 0:35see your own athletes literally succeed
20. 0:37within other people. This is also how we
21. 0:39try to increase on the competitiveness
22. 0:41and also the rivalry within sports
23. 0:43communities. The kind of enjoyment that
24. 0:44we have. That is to say, notice this is
25. 0:47a narrative motion. We're going to prove
26. 0:49the rise of hate watching does not harm
27. 0:50that much. As long as people enjoy doing
28. 0:52this and there's no extreme harms in
29. 0:55their checks and balances, we think it's
30. 0:57quite legitimate. Why don't check and
31. 0:59bounces which defeats the government's
32. 1:00own claim on toxic culture and also why
33. 1:02athletes are vulnerable in the first
34. 1:03place. Three things. First, the sports
35. 1:05community is full of diverse amounts of
36. 1:07people. Moderate fans will try to call
37. 1:09it an extreme fans who try to bully
38. 1:12other people or other athletes and other
39. 1:14leagues. That is to say, there's checks
40. 1:15and balances. Second, fans who are
41. 1:17indeed professional, who already have a
42. 1:20extreme control within the sports
43. 1:22community, who try to endorse or try to
44. 1:24buy merchandise within their own um
45. 1:26athletes who do shape on a community's
46. 1:28own perceptions do not want to their own
47. 1:31athletes reputation to be ruined within
48. 1:33other leagues. The very case is because
49. 1:35they realize the harms that it causes to
50. 1:37their own athletes, the punishment that
51. 1:39their athletes will also face. But third
52. 1:41of all, agencies already protect
53. 1:43athletes from these kinds of hate
54. 1:45comments. Athletes also already know how
55. 1:48to cope with people who spread on these
56. 1:50hate comments against them. So we think
57. 1:52the most vulnerable people here are the
58. 1:53people who are never able to have the
59. 1:56chance to literally express their own
60. 1:59hate speech in legitimate ways. These
61. 2:01are the people that teen government is
62. 2:03going to offhand try to lock out from
63. 2:06the sports community.
64. 2:08>> [snorts]
65. 2:08>> First argument that the thesis of this
66. 2:11argument says it is within the people's
67. 2:13own preferences to actively express
68. 2:15their dislikes or likes within the
69. 2:17sports community in it of itself. Why do
70. 2:19we not root for someone we actually
71. 2:22like? We think that sometimes we hate
72. 2:24that other opposition team in
73. 2:25semi-finals simply because we are losing
74. 2:28and they are winning. We think it's
75. 2:29quite legitimate itself because it is in
76. 2:31the forms of your own emotions.
77. 2:33Sometimes the leisure of hate speech is
78. 2:36quite legitimate in two ways. First, it
79. 2:39comes from competition because it comes
80. 2:41in sports where you literally try to
81. 2:43compete with other athletes. Not only in
82. 2:45terms of your own athletes ability but
83. 2:47also in your athletes ability to endorse
84. 2:49and market to other fans. Fans are quite
85. 2:51dedicated to one athlete. They try to
86. 2:53have hate speech to one another league
87. 2:56because in is in a way to show
88. 2:58themselves the way they try to support
89. 2:59their own athletes and also the way they
90. 3:01try to increase the competitiveness
91. 3:03within other leagues to also engage
92. 3:05within their community. But second of
93. 3:06all what I want to stress on the
94. 3:09frustration of sports itself. Sometimes
95. 3:11people use this kind of hate watching as
96. 3:14a coping mechanism. Some people may not
97. 3:16learn how to be politable or how to be
98. 3:19polite. That's to say these are the
99. 3:20people that team government is literally
100. 3:23locking out. These are people who come
101. 3:24from different backgrounds. Perhaps
102. 3:26these people who are quite poor. These
103. 3:28people who are never able to literally
104. 3:30express themselves in a polite way in
105. 3:33ways that they never they will never be
106. 3:35able to in team government. That's to
107. 3:37say we try to respect that. We try to
108. 3:39platform every single different
109. 3:40background in the sports community in
110. 3:43our side of the house. The principle
111. 3:45that we're running in this debate is
112. 3:46direct harm. When do we think that this
113. 3:50kind of action is too extreme or too
114. 3:51wrong? People get to freely do whatever
115. 3:53they want so long as does not
116. 3:55continuously harm or physically harm
117. 3:58other people. So when you try to throw
118. 3:59stones to other athletes, we think that
119. 4:01already crosses a line especially during
120. 4:03their own tournament where they try to
121. 4:04be much more competitive. What we trying
122. 4:07to engage here is a competitiveness, the
123. 4:09ability of people to engage with one
124. 4:11another and try to comment with one
125. 4:12another, try to engage and just simply
126. 4:14have fun in sports people. We think that
127. 4:16that is what we trying to run on. What
128. 4:18gives the government team the right to
129. 4:20judge other people to express
130. 4:21themselves? This is the question that I
131. 4:23want to ask to against their own team.
132. 4:25So why do we think expression is
133. 4:27important? We think it's important in
134. 4:28two things. First expression literally
135. 4:30lets people to have different kinds of
136. 4:33expressing their own ways and the
137. 4:35variety of ways of how we feel because
138. 4:37the different ways of how we try to
139. 4:38support these kinds of sports is quite
140. 4:40subjective. We try to um welcome every
141. 4:43single people who do these things in
142. 4:45different ways. Second of all,
143. 4:46suppressing expression leads to a
144. 4:48simmering frustration. When people are
145. 4:50unable to literally lash out, they
146. 4:52result which will break when they're
147. 4:55unable to control it. That's to say
148. 4:56extreme viewers who are already extreme
149. 4:58in the status quo are likely to double
150. 5:00down when they are not even given a
151. 5:02place in the first place to literally
152. 5:04express their own self. We think while
153. 5:07their own incidents like physically
154. 5:08harming other athletes may happen less
155. 5:10in team government site, we think the
156. 5:12severity like the physical harm
157. 5:14literally is going to be much more
158. 5:16severe in their side of the house
159. 5:17because they're suppressing their own
160. 5:18hate within other leagues and other
161. 5:21athletes. Even if that were not true,
162. 5:22I'm going to explain the kinds of
163. 5:24comparative and the incentives that team
164. 5:26government literally failed to express
165. 5:28in their side of the house. So within
166. 5:30the comparative in team government is a
167. 5:32world where people incapable of
168. 5:34literally hate. What is not a world
169. 5:36where people incapable of hate but what
170. 5:38stops them from literally hate watching.
171. 5:41It's a world where people feel are being
172. 5:43continuously censored or being
173. 5:44continuously judged or feel like they
174. 5:46can't able to express themsel especially
175. 5:48in the digital community. We think that
176. 5:50in a lot of these cases people are going
177. 5:52to lash out more. People are unable to
178. 5:55find a place where they're able to
179. 5:57express themselves quite legitimately
180. 5:58and feel like they belong to a community
181. 6:00within these sports leagues. That is to
182. 6:02say, team government tries to eliminate
183. 6:05every single kind of hate watching and
184. 6:07tries to increasingly moderate that kind
185. 6:09of hate watching. In team opposition,
186. 6:11you don't need to sacrifice good speech
187. 6:13for a complete hate speech because you
188. 6:15have both an outside who try to platform
189. 6:18on every single thing. I'm going to
190. 6:20rebut on a few of their own comments.
191. 6:21They said how their own rivalry is a
192. 6:24necessity that sometimes this kind of
193. 6:27rivalry is welcome but only as a
194. 6:29necessity. We think that already
195. 6:31eliminates the own meaning of sports
196. 6:33community themselves because sports
197. 6:34communities are fundamentally
198. 6:36competitive. It's the one that increases
199. 6:38the feel for other people to engage and
200. 6:40literally just have fun within the
201. 6:42sports to have the freedom to express
202. 6:44your own self. They literally limit that
203. 6:46in every single way. just see on every
204. 6:48single analysis of our own arguments.
205. 6:51But also secondly, second secondly, we
206. 6:53think there's no a priority rational to
207. 6:55be polite in sports or literally to be
208. 6:58polite in everything because human
209. 6:59beings are fundamentally quite
210. 7:01emotional, right? within that in sports
211. 7:03especially the quite competitiveness
212. 7:05when I see someone that I literally hate
213. 7:08or perhaps an athlete that I don't like
214. 7:10I can to have I am quite legitimate to
215. 7:13have hate watching because we think it's
216. 7:15quite legitimate for you to express your
217. 7:17own self and clear on what comparative
218. 7:20team government is trying to offer they
219. 7:22don't really have a comparative at all
220. 7:24we think in our side of the house people
221. 7:26feel much more comfortable to literally
222. 7:28share or express their own opinions to
223. 7:31literally just to have fun in the sports
224. 7:34communities. That's to say, we try to
225. 7:36platform on every single side where
226. 7:38people people try uh to promote more on
227. 7:41hate speech or perhaps try to be
228. 7:43politely critiquing on other athletes
229. 7:45who promote every single thing. That's
230. 7:47to say, how do you weigh this? Even if
231. 7:49team government manages to concede on
232. 7:51the likelihood that yes perhaps this
233. 7:53kind of hate speech hate watching is
234. 7:55going to be quite extreme. We will tell
235. 7:58you that at least in our side of the
236. 7:59house we get to we get to give the
237. 8:02chance for people to express themselves
238. 8:03as individuals the ability for them to
239. 8:05choose on choice because we think that
240. 8:08that is the most important thing
241. 8:09especially in a competitive community
242. 8:11where all of you want to have fun. We're
243. 8:13very proud to propose