[🇺🇦⚔️🇷🇺] LIVE SITUATION UKRAINE - Succès ukrainiens - Polémique Federov / Syrsky — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02Hello and welcome to this live
- 0:04broadcast with some competition tonight
- 0:06in terms of audience since you chose
- 0:08the right channel, the one where we'll
- 0:10have interesting topics with a
- 0:12pointless match from a minor
- 0:13competition. There you go, I'm back.
- 0:17First question, is the sound okay?
- 0:20First answer, I'm in Bulgaria after
- 0:23having toured Moldova after having
- 0:25spent 2 weeks in Ukraine. It was funky
- 0:29to say the least. I'll show you some
- 0:32footage of 3 minutes in the Kill Zone
- 0:35in a moment where things went really
- 0:37badly and could have gone even worse.
- 0:40Thanks for the feedback on the sound.
- 0:42There you go, I'll show you 3 minutes
- 0:43in the Kill Zone in a moment and what
- 0:45that means. It was really, I have the
- 0:48most, it wasn't supposed to be the most
- 0:50dangerous thing I did and it really
- 0:52almost went badly. You'll see that
- 0:54later, it'll be a short one, we'll do
- 0:57it in 45 minutes. Okay, 9:45 p.m. It's
- 0:599:45, I'll stop at 10:30 for my live
- 1:01LCI broadcast, which is also set for
- 1:0310:30. So, I can't be everywhere at
- 1:07once. You are 600 now. Thank you all.
- 1:10So, the last few days have been full of
- 1:11twists and turns. I had a lot of things
- 1:13to do. I promised you, a status update.
- 1:17A status update. I've done the best 15
- 1:19minutes of editing, which is about 20
- 1:21hours of work. There are 15 minutes of
- 1:24editing left, so another 20 hours of
- 1:26work. So don't worry, it's coming soon.
- 1:29And here it is, there are quite a few
- 1:32videos coming. As you can see, I have a
- 1:35real problem now. You saw the last
- 1:37video I published on long-range strikes
- 1:39with Casper, who is the head of the
- 1:42first USC, which is the first corps,
- 1:44the first battalion of the corps, uh,
- 1:47of long-range strikes. He announced in
- 1:50May the strikes on Moscow that took
- 1:52place in June and early July. It hadn't
- 1:54happened on a massive scale until then.
- 1:56So, I have information that I can't
- 1:57publish and now I have information that
- 1:59goes up to September-October that I
- 2:01can't share with you. So I pre-filmed a
- 2:03video to explain to you what was going
- 2:04to happen in September-October. That
- 2:06way, you'll see that I already knew.
- 2:07And now, in the same way, I knew what
- 2:09was going to happen in Moscow. And I
- 2:11have lots of other information, uh,
- 2:13that sometimes I tell you, well, maybe
- 2:15and so on, but there you have it, I
- 2:17have information that is still sexy.
- 2:21I’ll just give a quick update on the
- 2:22donors. Thank you very much. Of course,
- 2:25you still have the collections, because
- 2:27I donate money to the collections, but
- 2:28it is tax deductible if you make direct
- 2:30donations to the collections that are
- 2:32in the comments and in the pinned link
- 2:34of this video. So don't hesitate to
- 2:35donate directly to them. The money
- 2:38really goes to the right place. And
- 2:42hello to the potatoes who are there. We
- 2:45will start with the question of the day
- 2:47between Federov and Sirski because I
- 2:48have the impression that there is
- 2:50opposition. So, I will first talk about
- 2:53the state of mind of the Ukrainians and
- 2:55the situation between the two. First,
- 2:59you have Sirski who has had a certain
- 3:01number of operational successes for a
- 3:04while, whether it be the operations in
- 3:07southern Russia, or even the June 1st
- 3:09operation last year when he carried out
- 3:12Operation Spider Web. There you have it
- 3:15. So there are a lot of things that we
- 3:18can credit him with, deep operations
- 3:19that are sometimes operations by
- 3:21special forces. For example, when I was
- 3:24on the ground this time, I was in a
- 3:26bunker. Bunkers are crazy. Now, the
- 3:31ones the Ukrainians are in are
- 3:33defensive lines. I'll show you that in
- 3:35a video soon. You'll see, these are
- 3:39bunkers in which we have, uh, deep
- 3:41concrete bunkers with armored doors.
- 3:53The live broadcast doesn't work there
- 3:54anyway. So even if you have a Russian
- 3:56gliding bomb that falls on it, it won't
- 3:59kill the people inside. And that's
- 4:01buried under 4 meters of earth. So it's
- 4:06really something, I was saying, the
- 4:08defenses I found myself in, the
- 4:10situation I found myself in, the armor
- 4:12the Ukrainians are now in are what we
- 4:14call Sirsky protections. That is to say
- 4:17, the Ukrainians themselves are happy
- 4:18with the protections they have. So
- 4:21there are a certain number of areas in
- 4:23which the Ukrainians today have
- 4:24positions and they thank SSKI for a
- 4:26certain number of elements. Federov,
- 4:28for his part, arrived at a good time.
- 4:30He arrived at a time when manufacturers
- 4:32had developed, manufacturers had
- 4:37developed a certain number of
- 4:38performance features, and Feof arrived
- 4:43at a time when these technologies were
- 4:45mature enough to be able to
- 4:46successfully strike in depth. And it
- 4:48must be said clearly, Sirski is a very
- 4:53good one. We'll give a concrete example
- 4:55, there are several, but I think this
- 4:56one really speaks for itself. Federf.
- 4:58Then, there are questions from people,
- 5:00old and so on, from the new, old
- 5:02generations. Federov canceled, without
- 5:05asking Serski, he canceled artillery
- 5:07orders, saying objectively artillery on
- 5:09the front is useless. If you get within
- 5:1315 km of the target, you're dead. So
- 5:16Federov had artillery orders canceled,
- 5:20uh, in favor of drones. So that is to
- 5:25say that you have switched from the old
- 5:27school to the new school and this was
- 5:30done without, uh, without the consent
- 5:32of Serski. And so that is the type of
- 5:35tension that we have had. There are
- 5:37several other examples that we have had
- 5:39recently because there are many small
- 5:40tensions like that that come to the
- 5:42surface. Another one is that there have
- 5:45been no orders for armored vehicles,
- 5:47even though it is a Ukrainian armored
- 5:48vehicle producer. Uh, and these
- 5:52Ukrainian armored vehicle manufacturers
- 5:54, they didn't receive any orders from
- 5:56the Ministry of Defense in the first
- 5:59half of the year because the Ukrainians
- 6:01and Fedeov wanted to bet everything on
- 6:03ground robots. And ground robots, mam,
- 6:06there are everywhere. I was in a
- 6:09headquarters where he was piloting
- 6:11ground robots with the 5th battalion of
- 6:13the Rubige brigade. It was just
- 6:16incredible. They piloted I don't know
- 6:18how many at the same time. And the
- 6:20official statistics for last month, for
- 6:22the month of June, hold on tight, the
- 6:26Ukrainians carried out 24,000 missions
- 6:32with ground robots last month. So
- 6:35that's just a huge number. And hold on
- 6:38tight, they lost 3,000 ground robots
- 6:40last month. That is to say, they had
- 6:42the capacity to engage thousands and
- 6:44thousands and lose 3,000. So when I
- 6:46hear this statistic, I say, "[ __ ], it's
- 6:49catastrophic." He says no, but in fact
- 6:52a year ago we wouldn't have lost 3,000
- 6:54robots, we would have lost 3,000 men,
- 6:56we would have had 3,000 dead and
- 6:58wounded. And so from the Ukrainian
- 7:01point of view, the directions that
- 7:03Federov was able to take mean that
- 7:05instead of having armored vehicles to
- 7:08carry out missions with men on board,
- 7:10we have ground robots that will
- 7:12certainly be destroyed more often. But
- 7:16on the other hand, well, it avoids
- 7:19losing dead. So I confirm the figures.
- 7:2124,000 missions carried out, 3,000
- 7:26armored vehicles destroyed. So one
- 7:29mission, one destruction every hour.
- 7:31The lifespan of a ground robot is 7 to
- 7:348 missions on average. That's what I
- 7:35was told. It's confirmed at the front.
- 7:37There are areas in which there is a
- 7:39record with a robot that has already
- 7:40carried out more than 130 missions. It
- 7:41really depends on the areas of the
- 7:42front. There are certain zones like
- 7:44Pokrov where I was located, where the
- 7:46situation is, on the contrary, truly
- 7:49quite complicated. Seriously. Wait,
- 7:55I'll see if I can lower the resolution
- 7:57of my camera. Maybe that's what's
- 7:59blocking it. Okay, I'll put it in 720.
- 8:04There you go. There you go. I hope that
- 8:10in 720, it'll be a little better. It's
- 8:12funny to me, because I have feedback
- 8:14from my own camera and, apparently,
- 8:15it's okay. But hey, so you see, there's
- 8:17the old school and the new school,
- 8:19which doesn't mean that Sirski was bad,
- 8:22but on the other hand, it confirms that
- 8:24Federov was very, very, well, he did
- 8:26some things that were successful. Feder
- 8:29did some things that were very
- 8:30successful. The first one is 3 days
- 8:33after he arrived, uh, Starling was cut
- 8:35off directly for the Russians and I
- 8:37think that's thanks to him and his
- 8:39vision of Haiti and the war. Uh, and
- 8:44it's nice, there are friends on the
- 8:46front who are watching us. Hop. So,
- 8:49I'll take some of these questions later
- 8:51, I'll mark them down and I'll answer
- 8:54you little by little. So to finish with
- 8:58Sirski Federov, the other problem today
- 9:00is that with opposition between the two
- 9:03, Zelenski couldn't keep both. But
- 9:07given the weight of SSKI who has been
- 9:09in place for a long time, who really
- 9:11has brigades that support him or
- 9:12perhaps through patronage, we don't
- 9:14know exactly, it's really difficult to
- 9:16get rid of him. And Federov having only
- 9:19been there for 6 months, well, it was
- 9:21perhaps easier to get rid of him.
- 9:23Except that the reality on the ground
- 9:25is that he is so appreciated in the
- 9:27brigades because he saves lives, not
- 9:29because people don't want to fight
- 9:31because people see concretely that
- 9:33modern methods save lives. So he is
- 9:36appreciated in the brigades, he is
- 9:38appreciated in the civilian population,
- 9:43he is appreciated by industry. So then,
- 9:47he makes choices that displease certain
- 9:49industrialists and nevertheless, he
- 9:50would favor certain British
- 9:52industrialists because he launched real
- 9:53calls for tender rather than private
- 9:55contracts which can effectively allow
- 9:57money laundering. Which means that
- 10:00American or English companies have won
- 10:01contracts and so there are some
- 10:02Ukrainians who say "Yeah but be careful
- 10:04, they favor the Americans." So there
- 10:05are people who are for it and people
- 10:07who are against it. Let's be clear
- 10:08about that. Uh, to make RF, but in the
- 10:11end, there are other things too. There
- 10:13are tongues loosening about Sirski,
- 10:15with a certain amount of embezzlement,
- 10:18with favoritism, with, uh, people who
- 10:20have...There really were deaths, with
- 10:23the abandonment of the wounded, uh,
- 10:25under the pretext that it was necessary
- 10:27, uh, well, because he had given the
- 10:30order, in, to abandon certain men
- 10:32rather than trying to save them. It
- 10:35means withdrawing brigades protecting
- 10:36others because they failed to reach an
- 10:38agreement with a leader. The protection
- 10:41, uh, of certain rotten leaders, uh,
- 10:43who were almost mafia-like in which
- 10:45there were far too many deaths and
- 10:47injuries also during training. And
- 10:50suddenly, little by little, we discover
- 10:52a dark side of Sirski that did not
- 10:54appear because there was a kind of
- 10:55cover. And in addition, Sirski asked
- 10:58the units to send messages to defend
- 11:00him, to say "Yeah, we are completely
- 11:02with you." And those who have openly
- 11:05said, "Well no, we would rather Feder
- 11:07stay and find a replacement for Syirski
- 11:09." Well, those have apparently been
- 11:12arrested. So we have a situation where
- 11:14things aren't going well. In my opinion
- 11:17, Zelensky will make a decision
- 11:18tomorrow, very quickly, to get rid of
- 11:21Sirski and put Federov in another
- 11:23position where he will be useful, in
- 11:25technological coordination, industry,
- 11:27etc. Deepen industrialization,
- 11:29digitalization, why not a ministry for
- 11:31the digitalization of the army,
- 11:33something that I think he would be very
- 11:35, very good at. And then there is a new
- 11:38defense minister who has been appointed
- 11:40. His role is clearly to act as an
- 11:44intermediary since the deputies refused
- 11:48to vote for the planned replacement for
- 11:52Federov. So you see, politically, a lot
- 11:55of things are happening and I think
- 11:57that the outcome will be that Sirski
- 11:59will be removed, perhaps charged, given
- 12:01that he launches investigations into
- 12:02everything that has been revealed about
- 12:04him. But overall, the situation is set
- 12:08to stabilize with Feder who will
- 12:10probably stay on, even if his position
- 12:12is going to be changed, the scope of
- 12:13his position may change. And the person
- 12:18acting as the new interim defense
- 12:21minister is a guy from the SBU who is
- 12:25really good and who we can especially
- 12:28thank for the victory in the Battle of
- 12:32Serpent Island. You see, these are very
- 12:36good people. So, Zalogenni is back.
- 12:43Zalogen has lost quite a bit of support
- 12:45recently because of his positions,
- 12:47because he gives the impression that he
- 12:49wants to get into politics instead of
- 12:51having a national unity behind Zenenski
- 12:53for the time being. Okay, listen to the
- 12:57images, I see how, uh, I, uh, I have a
- 13:01very limited connection. I'm in
- 13:04Bulgaria and I'm sorry, the quality
- 13:06level is not great. I'm going hiking so
- 13:08I prefer to do this today because after
- 13:09that I'll be in the mountains for a few
- 13:11days. So it had to be done today. That
- 13:13was the first point. Federov, Sirski,
- 13:16Federov's victory is expected tomorrow,
- 13:19or the day after, in my view, and for
- 13:21Sirski, we shall see. But overall, uh,
- 13:24the concerns that the Russians had for
- 13:26the soldiers, for the defense, for the
- 13:29good prospects, well, we're rejoicing
- 13:31in the situation and now we're being
- 13:34rational. Second point, what the hell
- 13:38did I do in Ukraine? So, in Ukraine, as
- 13:41usual, I was there to deliver a vehicle
- 13:44. So, I delivered a vehicle that went
- 13:46to the Rouige brigade. There are people
- 13:50who tell me the perfect image. There
- 13:52are people who say I'm stuck. Uh, wait.
- 13:58Okay, never mind the image. Wait, I'll
- 14:00still...Hop, let's remove the image.
- 14:04We're putting the image back. Maybe
- 14:05it'll be a little bit of a shock. Let's
- 14:14try to share a video with you, hoping
- 14:15that the quality is good enough to do
- 14:17it. There you go. So, first in Ukraine,
- 14:21I had a vehicle delivered to me and I
- 14:24delivered it directly to Dombas. I went
- 14:27to meet up with, as you know, my friend
- 14:29Demitro Dimitro from Armata Volontiers
- 14:31and so on. You've already seen Demitro
- 14:35on the channel several times, he's also
- 14:37been involved in live broadcasts. And
- 14:41we went on several missions directly to
- 14:44the front. First, we had a mission in
- 14:51which, uh, it was ground robotics. So
- 14:54there, we went to see the guys who are
- 14:56preparing the robots in a workshop so
- 14:57that we can make them. 80%is logistics.
- 15:0210%is medical evacuation, including
- 15:04bringing back wounded Russian prisoners
- 15:06. 5%is assault. So ground robots with
- 15:12cannons and 5%will be the missions of
- 15:16what we call military engineering. So
- 15:20basically mining, demining, it's more
- 15:22like mining in reality. And today, as
- 15:25I've already told you, the front is so
- 15:28dense that in reality, we can't bring
- 15:30equipment by land, even with ground
- 15:33robots, all the way to the front line.
- 15:37That is to say, there are intermediate
- 15:38points that will be, for example, 15 km
- 15:40away. The ground robots will go 15 km
- 15:42away. At 15 km, you have the robots,
- 15:45the aerial drones, the vampires, the
- 15:46Babayaga, which will then take care of
- 15:48the logistics for the last 15
- 15:50kilometers. Today, infiltrations in
- 15:52certain areas, you have to imagine, the
- 15:55Ukrainians start walking and can no
- 15:57longer use vehicles 40 km before the
- 16:00zero line. They are dropped off 40 km
- 16:03before, they infiltrate for 40 km.
- 16:05There you go. It's really unbelievable.
- 16:08The situation is getting more and more
- 16:10difficult. But when he talks about it
- 16:13to the Ukrainians, they tell me "Yes,
- 16:14but we are making the Russians suffer
- 16:16so much worse, their logistics are even
- 16:18worse that in the end we have to walk
- 16:2040 km." There you go, they accept it.
- 16:23So that's pretty crazy. So a ground
- 16:26robotic mission then in the HQ and
- 16:29there we see the missions live and so
- 16:32on. It was really impressive to see how
- 16:34he worked and coordinated. The problem
- 16:37is that I wasn't allowed to film the
- 16:39screens, so I don't know exactly what I
- 16:41could do with this video, but we could
- 16:42see the jammers, we could see the
- 16:44access routes, the coordination with
- 16:46the FPVs and so on. It was really,
- 16:48really crazy stuff. So secondly, a HQ a
- 16:52notch above where there was
- 16:54coordination, FPV, observation drone,
- 16:56ground robotics. Third mission, here we
- 17:00were in the kill zone. So here, this is
- 17:03the kill zone, where we were dropped
- 17:05off 15 km from the front line. And when
- 17:08we got to 15 km, I walked for 4 km
- 17:11after what is already considered the
- 17:14kill zone. 4 km to be able to access.
- 17:19When I say 4 km, what I mean is that it
- 17:20could be 5, 6, or even three. Well, I'm
- 17:23giving you approximate figures for
- 17:25going into an environment in which
- 17:28we're intercepting Russian drones. The
- 17:32Russian drones will be Molnias, which
- 17:34are mini-Shaeds that are designed to
- 17:36strike 50 to 70 km on the front.
- 17:40Basically, these are Russian drones
- 17:42that need to be intercepted. It's not
- 17:44like the Shids where you can have an
- 17:46interceptor that will be 50 km behind
- 17:48the front line. Here, you have to be in
- 17:50the kill zone to be able to intercept
- 17:52them before they go and kill your
- 17:53friends behind them. So, I was in that
- 17:56position and from that position, they
- 17:57took off. They destroyed four Molnias
- 18:00in front of my eyes and so they
- 18:02destroyed the Russian observation
- 18:04drones and these are FPVs which are
- 18:05slightly improved FPVs, in particular,
- 18:07they have resistance to be able to
- 18:09operate in a jammed environment. I'm
- 18:12leaving from this position, you'll see
- 18:14the video. Most importantly, I'm
- 18:16arriving at the city behind. It's a
- 18:19little north of Dobropil. And north of
- 18:21Dobropilet there, so wait, I'll put the
- 18:23video on, you'll understand. There,
- 18:26there are actually FPVs arriving. Hop.
- 18:31So, [ __ ]! [ __ ], my friends. Ha. [ __ ],
- 20:26we can see them. Holy [ __ ]. I don't
- 21:06have any weapons. I'm here, I have a
- 21:08shotgun to have the right to take a
- 21:14[ __ ].
- 21:25Okay, red b. Let's run. There you go. I
- 21:34hope you enjoyed it. That was 3 minutes
- 21:37. Okay. It lasted over a quarter of an
- 21:44hour and, damn it. Okay, I'm sorry if
- 21:47once again the connection is really too
- 21:49weak. And so it lasted more than a
- 21:51quarter of an hour during which we were
- 21:53chased by FPVs with things blowing up
- 21:55around us, with other groups defending
- 21:58themselves when they were attacked and
- 22:00the extraction vehicle when it arrived
- 22:02at the end was chased by FPVs. [ __ ],
- 22:07that was really dangerous. Okay, I'm
- 22:10sorry. Well, the connection didn't
- 22:12allow me to share properly, but believe
- 22:14me, it was tough. I'm going to try to
- 22:17lower my camera resolution again. Okay,
- 22:21I'm going to switch to 480. I hope it
- 22:26works. So that was the second, well, a
- 22:29good part of the mission. It was tough.
- 22:34I'm glad to have gotten out and it's
- 22:35the second time I've sworn to myself
- 22:37I'll never go back to Donbas. So I
- 22:38don't know if there'll be a third, but
- 22:40there you go. And I'm...Yeah, I have a
- 22:43front like David. No, but theoretically
- 22:45, the press badge I have on me means
- 22:47the Russians shouldn't shoot at me. So,
- 22:50I have the nice press badge and I go
- 22:52with my camera and when the others pull
- 22:54out their guns, I pull out my camera. I
- 22:56have nothing else to defend myself from
- 22:58and I assume that, but that's
- 22:59completely stupid. The rule is stupid,
- 23:02but I would like to have a gun, a
- 23:05shotgun, to defend myself, but it's
- 23:07apparently illegal. I'll see next time.
- 23:11In any case, uh, after that, I went
- 23:14back to KF. I had industrial meetings,
- 23:17I went to see friends who were injured,
- 23:20I also went to see Tatouagia, who is in
- 23:22the south, who is a drone interceptor,
- 23:25especially shades drones, and so on.
- 23:27They have up to twenty a day in their
- 23:29team, so they are really very good too.
- 23:32Uh and there we have it! No, but the
- 23:37quality of the live, my friends, the
- 23:39quality of the video, it will be
- 23:41limited to the quality of my connection
- 23:43and the quality of the Wi-Fi I am
- 23:45connected to and because I have already
- 23:47exceeded my 5G quota, so I can't switch
- 23:50back to 5G. There you go. But lastly, I
- 23:53went to see Alan. Alan, a Frenchman who
- 23:56was injured, who jumped on a plane, I
- 23:57did an interview with him. You've been
- 24:00supporting him for a while now through
- 24:01the Berliose team and this is the first
- 24:03time I've been able to go, uh, because
- 24:04now that he's injured, I can show his
- 24:06face, he had the right. And, uh, you'll
- 24:09see some, some ideas, some visions of
- 24:11the terrain seen by a French fighter
- 24:12who, a former member of the French army
- 24:14who was there, who was part of several
- 24:16elite units and in particular he is in
- 24:18the Ukrainian special forces. And so,
- 24:20he was injured in a mission in the
- 24:22Zaporeja area, uh, when he was in the
- 24:25special forces, and today he is in
- 24:27remission. He has a good part of the
- 24:30flesh of his leg that was torn off. Uh,
- 24:35but the tendons are good, the artery is
- 24:37good so he's getting through it. There
- 24:39you go. Uh, Franck is doing very well.
- 24:42Uh, Franck is doing well. He was, he's
- 24:45done several missions. So in fact, he's
- 24:47never in the same place as me at the
- 24:48right time. He was in Micolaif training
- 24:50. He was in Kerson for some guys. Now
- 24:53he's gone to the Eastern Front. I won't
- 24:56be more specific than that, but Franck
- 24:58is in excellent health. He's done a lot
- 25:01of things, and since he's good and has
- 25:03a lot of experience, they take him on
- 25:05as an instructor a lot. He even went to
- 25:07Poland and Romania to be an instructor
- 25:10for NATO. So, we're using his feedback.
- 25:14He would like to go back to the front,
- 25:16but for now he's more in training or
- 25:17support. That is to say, he's there in
- 25:19case something happens. He's part of
- 25:21the teams that will go and help out his
- 25:23friends who are having a hard time up
- 25:24front. But for Franck, everything's
- 25:26going well and there's no stress on
- 25:28that front. Any news from Cann? I've
- 25:34seen Cann too. Uh, Cannement, what he
- 25:37said about his medical situation, but
- 25:39Cann is also gradually healing himself.
- 25:43You know, when you have serious
- 25:44injuries like that, it takes 6 months,
- 25:461 year to get back to normal. So Can is
- 25:49fine, I went to eat out with him. So
- 25:52it's true that every time, I take time
- 25:54to go see my friends. But all the
- 25:55friends that you know, that you saw on
- 25:57the channel today, are either still in
- 25:59combat or they're doing well. So
- 26:01there's no injury. Uh, there you go.
- 26:08Okay, thanks for all your encouragement
- 26:09. Next, we come to the situation on the
- 26:13front. So, the reality on the ground
- 26:16today is that it's not any easier than
- 26:18before since the Russians are still
- 26:20making progress since they also have
- 26:22drones that go further and further. But
- 26:25the Ukrainians are way ahead in this
- 26:28area. That is to say, today the
- 26:30Russians are doing to the Ukrainians
- 26:32what the Ukrainians were doing to the
- 26:33Russians 6 months ago, and now the
- 26:35Ukrainians are 6 months ahead. That's
- 26:37because there is always a gap. The
- 26:39Russians have hardly focused on ground
- 26:42robots. The Ukrainians have. So the
- 26:44Russian progress in the field of
- 26:46long-range strikes, and therefore in
- 26:49logistics, means that there are no more
- 26:51deaths among the Ukrainians. Even fewer
- 26:53today than in the past. Whereas on the
- 26:57Russian side, well, you have this
- 26:59logistics being increasingly struck in
- 27:01depth and you don't have robots to
- 27:03provide logistics. So the losses on the
- 27:06Russian side are really significant,
- 27:08especially in the rear, especially in
- 27:10logistics. The Ukrainian capacity to
- 27:13strike not only vehicles, but also
- 27:15logistics routes with missiles, with
- 27:18missiles that have been able to hit
- 27:20bridges, railways, railroads, etc. So
- 27:23that's really important. And it has an
- 27:26effect which varies by place. On the
- 27:28southern front, there's clearly a real
- 27:30problem for the Russians. The Russians
- 27:32can't see enough shells coming in. On
- 27:35Kerson, even the commander of the
- 27:38brigade that manages the Kerson area
- 27:40confirmed that the Russians, for his
- 27:43part, can't get enough artillery pieces
- 27:46or shells. So on the southern front,
- 27:49the Russians are really struggling. On
- 27:52the eastern front, the Russians are
- 27:54struggling, but they're still managing
- 27:57to push back because they have dozens
- 28:00of roads next to each other. Not
- 28:02everything is based on a main highway.
- 28:06So you have a real difference in the
- 28:12perception of the two fronts. On the
- 28:14Donet, the Russians are advancing, but
- 28:16they're advancing more slowly than in
- 28:18the past and are suffering more losses.
- 28:20And Constantinfka, it's been 3 weeks
- 28:22since they announced that they had
- 28:24taken Constantinfka. In reality, they
- 28:26obviously haven't taken Constantinfka,
- 28:29that's all we can see. It's a gray area
- 28:31, meaning that there are streets where
- 28:33both Ukrainians and Russians are
- 28:35pushing. The Russians are committing a
- 28:37huge amount of resources to try to
- 28:39advance. It's the same thing in the
- 28:41Pogrovsk area, they're committing a
- 28:43huge amount of resources, but on the
- 28:45front, the front has never moved as
- 28:47slowly as in the last two months in the
- 28:50Donetsk area and the months before. It
- 28:52was even the Ukrainians who were
- 28:53liberating territories. You also have
- 28:55good news in the ISUM area where the
- 28:57Ukrainians have advanced. So, wait, I'm
- 29:01going to do something. I'm going to do
- 29:04something. Let's change cameras. We're
- 29:08going to switch to my crappy webcam. Do
- 29:14you like my crappy webcam? Is it better
- 29:17with my crappy webcam? If it's better
- 29:20with my crappy webcam, we'll stick with
- 29:22the crappy webcam. There you go. So now
- 29:24, I'll look you in the eye like this
- 29:26and tell me if the quality is better.
- 29:28So, uh, you're asking me a lot of
- 29:32questions, I'll save them all for later
- 29:36. Hop, hop. It's not better. It's the
- 29:44same, my friends. It's not possible.
- 29:49Hop, hop. So, on the situation on the
- 29:56front, we're on a front that's frozen,
- 29:58that hardly moves anymore, it's really
- 30:01very complicated. And we have a desire
- 30:07on the part of the Ukrainians to retake
- 30:08certain small areas and we've seen,
- 30:10they were particularly effective when
- 30:12they retaken the area in the south.
- 30:16Very clearly, they liberated more than
- 30:17400 km². Now, areas in ISUM. So, the
- 30:20Ukrainians are taking, I tell you, the
- 30:22risk of going there, including in
- 30:23certain areas. When they manage to
- 30:26completely clear the skies of Russian
- 30:27drones, well, at that point, they can
- 30:29afford to carry out assaults, and in
- 30:30particular mechanized assaults, and not
- 30:32just infiltrations as I said earlier.
- 30:35So the Ukrainians occasionally manage
- 30:37to clear the skies enough to come into
- 30:39contact with columns of armored
- 30:41vehicles and in some cases, they really
- 30:43get results. There you go, wait, let me
- 30:46do one last try. One last try. If it
- 30:50fails, hop, I'll stay like this after.
- 30:52Last try for now because I see that hop
- 30:56there, hop, I've refreshed the
- 30:58connection. If it doesn't work, it
- 31:00doesn't matter. We'll stay like this
- 31:01until the end now. So there really is
- 31:04this, uh, these are really two fronts
- 31:06that are different. So now, what we
- 31:08also have to understand is that this is
- 31:09no longer the objective today. I've
- 31:11been telling you for a long time,
- 31:13Ukraine will not collapse militarily on
- 31:16the front. The Russians will continue
- 31:18to advance little by little, with
- 31:20colossal and increasingly significant
- 31:22losses. But overall, there is no longer
- 31:24any real hope for the Russians of
- 31:26making Ukraine respond since Ukraine
- 31:28has received loans of 90 billion, which
- 31:30means that the military budget is
- 31:32guaranteed, drones and so on, robots,
- 31:34it works. So, I am happy about that,
- 31:36you are all happy about that. So, on
- 31:39the front, the Russians cannot hope for
- 31:41a collapse. They can hope to continue
- 31:43to gain ground millimeter by millimeter
- 31:45. It has no strategic interest because
- 31:47they will not be able to take the
- 31:49Donbas in several years at the current
- 31:51speed and at a cost that is absolutely
- 31:52disproportionate. As for the Ukrainians
- 31:56, for their part, they cannot, in my
- 31:57opinion, hope for a collapse of the
- 31:59Russian army because the Russian army,
- 32:01whatever people say, is stable, it is
- 32:03established, it is solid. And even if
- 32:07today, tomorrow, Russia had real
- 32:09economic problems, I mean, uh, like in
- 32:121991, even if the Russian army, uh,
- 32:14stopped pushing, the men who are there
- 32:17are enough to hold the front and Russia
- 32:19would do what it takes to hold the
- 32:22front. And Ukraine could certainly
- 32:26liberate some areas. Obviously, I hope
- 32:28for an economic collapse of Russia like
- 32:30in 1991, but I don't believe it. And
- 32:37wrong, well, I have a hard time
- 32:39imagining the Russians capable of
- 32:40collapsing, retreating, completely
- 32:42liberating territories, losing
- 32:44Meditopol, losing the southern routes,
- 32:46and the Ukrainians regaining access to
- 32:48the Asov Sea. I hope so, I hope so, but
- 32:50I really don't believe it. So then,
- 32:54given that on the front, that's not
- 32:56going to change, there are other things
- 32:58that the Ukrainians are doing
- 33:00strategically. In particular, you've
- 33:03seen what's happening in Crimea. Crimea
- 33:07is a strategic objective. Ukrainians
- 33:11have said this for long. They have the
- 33:13possibility of attacking Crimea with
- 33:16almost open skies. The thing is, when
- 33:19they attack the Sea of
- 33:20Azov, look at the map, the Ukrainians
- 33:22go through Crimea to attack the Sea of
- 33:25Azov. They don't go around the Black
- 33:27Sea or via the Crimean Bridge. They go
- 33:30straight through the middle because
- 33:31it's an open bar. There are no more air
- 33:33defenses; they've destroyed everything
- 33:34on site. The radars have been destroyed
- 33:36, the electronic warfare systems, the
- 33:38jamming systems, the air defense no
- 33:39longer exists. But what choice do the
- 33:41Russians have? They're obviously not
- 33:44going to abandon Crimea and they're not
- 33:53stopping bringing equipment back to
- 33:55Crimea to try to protect Crimea. But to
- 33:58protect Crimea, they're forced to
- 34:00reduce air defenses on the rest of the
- 34:03front and in the cities in the rear. So
- 34:06when fear strikes Crimea, it imposes
- 34:08itself. Well, when the Ukrainians
- 34:21strike Crimea, it forces the Russians
- 34:23to withdraw their equipment from the
- 34:25rest of the front. So it makes the
- 34:28airspace over the front more permissive
- 34:30and increases the proportion of
- 34:32long-range strikes that will be
- 34:33successful. That's for the FP7, the
- 34:37Firep FP7, which is the medium-range
- 34:40ground-based ballistic missile with a
- 34:43range of 280 km that has been tested
- 34:45several times. We have had images. I
- 34:48don't know where it is from an
- 34:50operational point of view, but from the
- 34:51moment the Ukrainians send images, it
- 34:52generally means that it is already on
- 34:54the front. So, even if today we don't
- 34:56see anything about it, we don't have
- 34:59any operational images of its use, we
- 35:01know that it works because it has taken
- 35:04off. And we know that it's a bit like
- 35:06the Flamingo: from the moment the
- 35:08Ukrainians shared images, in fact, they
- 35:10were already hitting the front, and it
- 35:11was only then that we had images,
- 35:13impacts and successes shared in
- 35:15particular by the Russians. So today,
- 35:17the fact that we don't have images of
- 35:19the F7 doesn't mean that it's not
- 35:20operational. I remind you that the
- 35:22Ukrainians had announced that the FP9,
- 35:25the heavy version, would be capable of
- 35:27striking Moscow this summer, August, so
- 35:29maybe it will be September or October,
- 35:31but in any case, the missiles continue
- 35:33to operate. The Flamingo, the Flamingo.
- 35:37So, I saw something that I didn't quite
- 35:38understand. People say that the
- 35:40Flamingo's success rate is decreasing.
- 35:44No, its success rate is very good. The
- 35:47problem is that the targets that were
- 35:49at short range have already all been
- 35:51destroyed. At 500, 800, 1000, 1500 km
- 35:53away, there are fewer and fewer of them
- 35:56. But of course, if you go further,
- 35:59when you have to strike at 2000, 2500
- 36:02km, your aerial drones that go at 250
- 36:05km/h, they're going to fly over Russia
- 36:07for 8, 9, 10 hours. The longer you fly
- 36:11over Russia, the more time it gives
- 36:13them to launch fighter jets or prepare
- 36:15a defense. So in fact, it's not a
- 36:18question of the Flamingo working less
- 36:20well, it's a question of the strikes
- 36:22being at longer distances, the
- 36:23interception rate is naturally lower.
- 36:28Finally, the rate of Yeah. the cost per
- 36:30target rate. In the same way, the
- 36:32Russians, they find it easier to strike
- 36:34Carkif than to strike Levive who is on
- 36:36the other side of the country. On the
- 36:38contrary, the Flamingo is becoming
- 36:39increasingly effective; it progresses.
- 36:42If today it had to strike targets at
- 36:44short range, at 800 km like in the past
- 36:46, it would be even easier now than it
- 36:48was 3 months ago, because the Russians
- 36:50have fewer air defenses and the
- 36:51Flamingo itself has progressed to
- 36:53better follow the terrain. But when you
- 36:57have to strike at 2,000 to 2,500 km,
- 36:58it's just that the further away you are
- 37:00, the lower the effectiveness rate will
- 37:02be. But it's not because of the
- 37:04effectiveness of the missile, it's
- 37:06because of the distance you're going to
- 37:07cover. So that's an important element.
- 37:09Those who criticize the Flamingo or who
- 37:11criticize long-range strikes, that they
- 37:12are less effective now than they were 6
- 37:14months ago, they just haven't
- 37:15understood how it works. Don't worry,
- 37:17the Ukrainians, they have more than one
- 37:18trick up their sleeve. which still has
- 37:19missiles that are not yet operational,
- 37:22that have not yet been released, but
- 37:24they now have the long Neptunes that
- 37:26strike from the ground from the
- 37:28mainland of Ukraine that manage to hit
- 37:30its bastions by arriving from behind.
- 37:32Finally, they manage to do crazy things
- 37:34and there are still missiles that are
- 37:36arriving and they now have a robot, an
- 37:38aerial drone that goes 3,500 km away.
- 37:41The FP2, so the FireP, the FP2, it now
- 37:44has autonomous guidance modules for the
- 37:46terminal strike. If ever they arrive in
- 37:49a jammed environment, for example on a
- 37:50boat, they can still hit. Oh yes, by
- 37:52the way on the boats, they explained
- 37:53something to me that was quite funny.
- 37:57So you know that the Ukrainians are
- 37:58doing a lot of logistics in the Black
- 38:00Sea, but they don't want to sink the
- 38:02boats because if they sink the boat,
- 38:03the insurance will reimburse them for
- 38:05the boat. They can buy one in China
- 38:08next week. On the other hand, if they
- 38:11damage the boat, if they hit the
- 38:13pilot's platform or if they damage the
- 38:15propeller, if the boat doesn't sink,
- 38:18then you have weeks and months of
- 38:20administrative procedures to be able to
- 38:22get a refund, to be able to start the
- 38:25work that will only be operational in 8
- 38:27months or 1 year. So if you destroy or
- 38:31sink a boat, it's less interesting than
- 38:33if you damage it. If you sink it in a
- 38:36month, it will be replaced. If you
- 38:37damage it in a year, it will be
- 38:39repaired. And so, of course, it's much
- 38:41more interesting for the Ukrainians to
- 38:43damage the ships than to sell them. So
- 38:45that was a small element that was also
- 38:47interesting. As for the delivery of the
- 38:50Gripon, we'll move on to the fighter
- 38:51jets. That's true, that's a good
- 38:53question from Antoine. The Gripons, you
- 38:57have, a priori, the very first ones, so
- 39:00Ukrainian pilots have been trained on
- 39:02them for quite some time. They've
- 39:05trained on Gripons since 2014, since
- 39:072024, sorry, on the Gripons. So they
- 39:10must be at their end. But what is
- 39:12particularly interesting about the
- 39:14Gripons is that the version that will
- 39:16be delivered will be the version, a
- 39:19priori it is not the E block, but
- 39:21nevertheless it is the CD block in
- 39:23which, above all, there is the package
- 39:25with the very long-range missiles, the
- 39:27Meteor supplied by France. You have
- 39:32seen that for the second time a Russian
- 39:35Sub-Coil 35 was shot down by an F16,
- 39:38certainly with a Sub-Coil 35 that was
- 39:41designated by an RR radar, a SAB radar.
- 39:45So this is the second time we have
- 39:48never had a Sub-Coil 35 shoot down an
- 39:51F16. That's twice now that F16s have
- 39:53shot down Su-35s; that is very bad. But
- 39:56when you do that with an Amram, an
- 39:58American RR missile, of a previous
- 40:00generation, we still have no proof that
- 40:02they have C or DD, they still have the
- 40:04previous version. If you have a Meteor,
- 40:07that is the missile with the longest no
- 40:10escape zone in the world. That means
- 40:13that the Ukrainians will be able to
- 40:14stay at a very low altitude, strike
- 40:16very, very far away to prevent sub-34s
- 40:18and so on. There you have it, this is
- 40:21still the beginning of a situation in
- 40:22which the Russians do not dominate the
- 40:24air, but the Russians 'ability to drop
- 40:26hovering bombs is diminishing today.
- 40:29And if you look at the statistics that
- 40:31you see with Clément Mollin on Twitter
- 40:33, in particular, you will see that,
- 40:34overall, the Russians are firing
- 40:36slightly fewer gliding bombs today
- 40:37because they have lost a lot of Sub-34s
- 40:39, because they have fewer Sub-35s to
- 40:41protect them, and then overall they are
- 40:43also suffering in their aviation sector
- 40:44, in which there are many planes that
- 40:46are unfit to fly, you have spare parts
- 40:48that are no longer arriving to ensure
- 40:50maintenance, etc. The second good news
- 40:54from July 14 is that the Ukrainians are
- 40:56starting training in 2026 on the Rafale
- 40:58for a delivery that should certainly
- 41:00arrive in 2028. So the first official
- 41:03order for the Rafale by Ukraine has
- 41:05been confirmed and therefore Ukraine
- 41:07will indeed be equipped with Rafale.
- 41:10Remember what I told you in 2023, that
- 41:13is, before the Ukrainians received
- 41:15their Mirage 2000s? I explained to you
- 41:18that giving Mirage 2000s was an
- 41:20opportunity for those who did not want
- 41:23to support Ukraine. From a purely
- 41:26industrial point of view, giving
- 41:27Mirages was an opportunity to sell more
- 41:29Rafales to countries from which we
- 41:31would take back the Mirages to supply
- 41:33them to Ukraine, such as Greece, or for
- 41:35example, I don't know which other
- 41:37countries: Brazil, Indonesia, Qatar.
- 41:41The Emirates could take back their
- 41:42Mirage 2000s, supply them to Ukraine,
- 41:44sell them more Rafales, and then when
- 41:46Ukraine starts with the Mirage 2000s,
- 41:48they will switch to the Rafale. That's
- 41:51normal, the Americans won't sell F35s
- 41:53to Ukraine because even if they fly
- 41:55F16s, they won't switch to F35s, and
- 41:57that's good for the Ukrainians because
- 41:59it's a plane. You know my opinion on
- 42:02H35. I'm not going to do another live
- 42:04on it, maybe soon because I'll prepare
- 42:06a video on F35 that will be very tight.
- 42:09Uh, but so they won't sell F35s. So the
- 42:13Ukrainians have Gripon because it's
- 42:15good, it's cheap, it's faster to
- 42:18deliver. They have Mirage 2000s, so
- 42:20they're switching to Rafale and so we
- 42:22can imagine that Ukraine will have
- 42:24Rafale and Gripen in its fleet. 2026
- 42:27for the Gripon, 2028 for the Rafal. So
- 42:30they have an air force that can face
- 42:33Russia and that's really important. So
- 42:36then, I see things happening there. The
- 42:39Russian economy is stable. The ruble
- 42:41lost 8%in the first year of the war and
- 42:43then it stabilized at 0.1%. We have to
- 42:45stop buying oil and gas from them and
- 42:46all that other crap. Yes, but on the
- 42:48other hand, you have a certain number
- 42:50of indicators that are extremely,
- 42:51extremely bad. Look at the Russian
- 42:54stock market. Wait, I'm going to show
- 42:55it to you anyway because I told you to
- 42:57look at it. We're going to look at it
- 42:58together anyway. Wait, don't move. The
- 43:09Russian indicators, they're bad
- 43:10indicators. There you go. Hop. So, I'll
- 43:16add. Hop there. There you go. That, my
- 43:30friends, is the Russian stock market.
- 43:33So you see, let's say that they were at
- 43:353,000. So sorry, I'll withdraw your
- 43:38comment, Robert. Hop. The Russian stock
- 43:41market, let's say that it was around
- 43:433,000 a year ago. It's below the 2,000
- 43:46mark today. So we still have
- 43:49developments that are extremely
- 43:50unfavorable. You have key rates that
- 43:52have risen to 14.5%. There you have a
- 43:56lot of factors that are very
- 43:58unfavorable for Russia, and the stock
- 44:01market is one indicator among others.
- 44:06It is important to know that the
- 44:07exchange rate, the currency, the ruble,
- 44:09the parity of the ruble, is also
- 44:11blocked because you have a ban on
- 44:13exporting rubles. People who have money
- 44:16in Russia cannot export it. So
- 44:18logically, you have a monetary stock
- 44:19that remains blocked in Russia. So you
- 44:21do not have parity like in the past. No
- 44:23one can sell rubles to buy dollars, for
- 44:25example, or euros, and so the currency
- 44:27is falsely overvalued, but in practice
- 44:29you have inflation that has been in
- 44:31double digits for 4 years in a row, 50
- 44:33in a row. You have a stock market that
- 44:35is collapsing. You have a sovereign
- 44:37fund that is almost empty and next week
- 44:39I will share a video interview with an
- 44:41economist specializing in the subject,
- 44:44specifically on the situation and the
- 44:46effect of sanctions on Russia. You will
- 44:48see that things are not as prosperous
- 44:50as the Russians would like to say.
- 44:54Regarding what Ukrainian ground robots
- 45:01are doing in certain areas,
- 45:03particularly what they did on the
- 45:05Kinbur Peninsula. The Ukrainians have
- 45:08put a naval drone on board, you know.
- 45:11It was a naval landing drone. On board
- 45:14this strange naval landing craft, it
- 45:16opened up, there was a ground robot
- 45:19that went there and attacked a Russian
- 45:21position on the Kimburg Peninsula with
- 45:24a machine gun. There you have it, well
- 45:28that's very good, that's very nice, but
- 45:30for me it's still PR, let's be clear. I
- 45:35don't know how much it's worth to
- 45:37commit this type of equipment. So it
- 45:39doesn't cost much, it's Ukrainian. So
- 45:41yes, it's going to cost € 40,000. If
- 45:45it killed a few Russians, that's
- 45:46interesting. But I'm not convinced that
- 45:48the operational effect would be
- 45:50interesting. Uh, maybe it would have
- 45:53been better used elsewhere, but the
- 45:54fact that the Ukrainians can afford it,
- 45:56that they manage to approach the coast
- 45:58without the Russians detecting them,
- 45:59that they manage to get off ground
- 46:01robots, that they know how to pilot
- 46:03them until they reach an area where the
- 46:04Russians are located so that they can
- 46:06shoot at them, those are technical
- 46:08feats. And what we're seeing today in a
- 46:11prototype-style sample, which is very
- 46:14pleasing, will be something that will
- 46:16be massive and operational in 6 months,
- 46:19in a year. And if tomorrow we have to
- 46:23re-land in Crimea because the
- 46:25Ukrainians, I think they will return to
- 46:28Crimea at some point when the time is
- 46:30right, when Crimea is really weakened
- 46:33and it won't be long, I think they will
- 46:36do it by the fall. At that time, it
- 46:38won't be commandos who will come down
- 46:40to attack coastal batteries. It will be
- 46:43a flotilla of naval vessels that will
- 46:45certainly send commandos down, but
- 46:47these commandos will be accompanied by
- 46:50ground robots and all that stuff, they
- 46:52will have a firepower that will be
- 46:54quite strong because between the aerial
- 46:56drones that can provide air support,
- 46:59which was not the case 2 years ago,
- 47:01between the naval robots that can also
- 47:03fire FPVs and so on, between the ground
- 47:05robots that will accompany the men on
- 47:08the ground, I think there is really a
- 47:11way to do damage. Ukrainians, we must
- 47:14not imagine a landing, a liberation of
- 47:15Crimea by force of arms. Let's not get
- 47:17carried away either. But I really think
- 47:19that this is a foretaste of what we
- 47:20might see in the future. And the
- 47:22Russians aren't ready. The Russians
- 47:24aren't ready and that's a good thing.
- 47:25They can't be ready tomorrow. Hop. So
- 47:33hop. So, you have several questions
- 47:38about poison gas. Do the Russians use
- 47:41poison gas? That was something we had
- 47:42seen several times. In particular, they
- 47:44had used very high-concentration poison
- 47:46gas. They used mustard gas precursors
- 47:49but they didn't actually use poison gas
- 47:51. So because they pass, they always
- 47:53remain under the shadow of not being
- 47:55the big bad guys. They just killed
- 47:5780,000 civilians in Mariol but apart
- 47:58from that, they weren't really big bad
- 47:59guys. So no direct poison gas. Not
- 48:02those that are considered to be poison
- 48:04gas, but they use deadly gases in high
- 48:06concentrations, chlorine, and it's
- 48:08disgusting, it's unacceptable. The
- 48:10Ukrainians now have masks in their
- 48:12trenches. I don't know how to use them,
- 48:15but they were there. But what makes the
- 48:17Russians today allow themselves to do
- 48:19things that are completely forbidden by
- 48:22law, but in any case, today, there are
- 48:24no longer any real limits. What they
- 48:26had also done is that they had started
- 48:29to coat certain shaed with neurotoxic
- 48:31products. And when it falls to the
- 48:33ground, if you have a kid who goes to
- 48:34pick up a piece of shaed, it could be
- 48:36neurotoxic. So you can die just by
- 48:38touching it. They also have shaeds in
- 48:40which there are mines, cluster
- 48:41munitions. So when you destroy it,
- 48:43which is 490%of shaeds, well, it leaves
- 48:45mines here and there. There are some in
- 48:47the fields, there are some in the
- 48:49forests, there are some, it's really a
- 48:50mess. The Russians are doing everything
- 48:52they can to make the population suffer.
- 48:54I won't go back over the bombings they
- 48:55carried out last night in which they
- 48:57hit civilian buildings. Look at my
- 48:59friend Cyril Amours' account, the video
- 49:01he made on Twitter in which he is right
- 49:03in the middle of the buildings that
- 49:05were hit, a supermarket that was hit,
- 49:07three buildings, apartment blocks and
- 49:08civilian housing. It's just, it's just
- 49:11unbearable. The Russians are taking
- 49:14revenge on civilians for their
- 49:15inability to protect their military and
- 49:17strategic infrastructure. The
- 49:19Ukrainians are attacking the
- 49:21infrastructure that finances the war.
- 49:23The Russians are taking revenge on
- 49:25civilians and they brag about it and
- 49:26they say it and they share their own
- 49:28images, their success when they attack
- 49:30civilian warehouses, what we call
- 49:34Novaposta, the local postal system. So,
- 49:36there is a real situation, uh, which is
- 49:39unacceptable but to which we have ended
- 49:41up getting used and we don't even talk
- 49:43about it here anymore. Whereas every
- 49:47day and last night was probably the
- 49:49worst since it was ballistic missiles
- 49:52which are the ones that the Ukrainians
- 49:54cannot intercept, due to a lack of
- 49:56patriots and sufficient healthcare. And
- 50:00so logically, well, they are getting,
- 50:02uh, there you go, they are losing, they
- 50:04are losing a lot of resources in this
- 50:06area. There you go. So the Russians
- 50:08used combat gas; unfortunately, it was
- 50:10a reality. Hop, next question. Hop,
- 50:16that's a very good question from Mouse
- 50:19H2O. There are, uh, a certain number of
- 50:22authorizations that have been given to
- 50:25the Ukrainians for two reasons. First,
- 50:27because you know that the Ukrainians
- 50:29are developing a project called Freya.
- 50:31I refer you to the video in which I
- 50:33talk about the Ukrainian industry. And
- 50:35the Freya project aims to produce at
- 50:40the European level an integrated
- 50:42anti-ballistic defense system like the
- 50:44Patriot or Aster 30, better than the
- 50:47Patriot but at the Ukrainian cost, 10
- 50:49times cheaper. So the Americans, of
- 50:53course, know that they are going to
- 50:55lose the market. If the Ukrainians
- 50:58succeed, they will inevitably lose this
- 51:01market at the global level because the
- 51:03Ukrainians are effectively 10, 20 times
- 51:05cheaper than anyone else in the world
- 51:07for equal efficiency because they
- 51:09produce mass in large quantities. And
- 51:12so when they have this technological
- 51:15ambition for a company, what happens?
- 51:24There you go. So there is an
- 51:26operational reality that the Ukrainians
- 51:28will succeed in doing this kind of
- 51:31thing with Firepon. So the Americans
- 51:34today know very well how to earn a
- 51:36little money before the Ukrainians
- 51:38become sovereign. Well, by allowing the
- 51:41Ukrainians to produce Patriots
- 51:42themselves. The assembly lines in the
- 51:45United States are saturated. They are
- 51:47producing to the maximum for their own
- 51:49needs and for the needs of their allies
- 51:51in the Middle East, which we won't go
- 51:53into. But the defenses are largely
- 51:57undermined. And so you have the
- 51:59Americans who have authorized the
- 52:01Ukrainians to produce Patriots and a
- 52:03priori the first Patriot assemblies
- 52:04could arrive before the end of the
- 52:06summer. But my question is about the
- 52:09sub-components. I don't see how the
- 52:11Americans would deliver sub-components,
- 52:13in particular the seekers and all those
- 52:15things that require them, and the
- 52:16radars that are on board, and that
- 52:18requires more than a year to produce
- 52:20these sub-components. So, is this
- 52:22announcement today the culmination of
- 52:24real work to ramp up the production of
- 52:27sub-components that began over a year
- 52:29ago, in which case it is credible, or
- 52:31is it today that the sub-components
- 52:33will start being produced in the United
- 52:35States so that assembly can begin in a
- 52:37year in Ukraine? That is another
- 52:40possibility. So what is dreaming, what
- 52:42is behind this American announcement,
- 52:44is one, they want to try to make money
- 52:46before the Ukrainians become sovereign
- 52:47and so they are hurrying, they are
- 52:49accelerating, they are doing what they
- 52:51can. Two, it is also to meet public
- 52:53expectations. Trump turned against
- 52:56Putin today, which was not the case in
- 52:58the past. He wants to side with the
- 53:00winners, not a loser like Putin. He
- 53:03told Trump that Ukraine should hit
- 53:05Russia harder so that it finally agrees
- 53:08to sit down at the negotiating table.
- 53:11So Trump has become rational about
- 53:13Ukraine by supporting Ukraine,
- 53:15providing it with the means to defend
- 53:17itself, well, by authorizing it to
- 53:19produce its interceptor missiles and by
- 53:21clearly telling it that it was open bar
- 53:23to attack Russia. So we are still in a
- 53:26situation that has evolved a lot and
- 53:27that is very good. But that's not all,
- 53:29because you also have France which has
- 53:31authorized Ukraine to produce a certain
- 53:33number of interception systems and in
- 53:35particular the Aster, the famous Aster
- 53:37missile which is fired in particular by
- 53:42the new generation of the SAMPT. And
- 53:46the first NGs that will be delivered to
- 53:48France, France will not give them away
- 53:50but will lend them to Ukraine so that
- 53:51it can use them, and that will give us
- 53:53feedback, and it will be better. And so
- 53:56, it's Santé, just like those we've
- 53:58lent for several years, they've been
- 54:00tested and that allowed us to have
- 54:02feedback that was very interesting for
- 54:04Talè, Eurosam, in short all the MBDA
- 54:06producers. And so, the first of the new
- 54:10generations will be lent to Ukraine so
- 54:12that they can use them to protect their
- 54:14territory, and they will also be able
- 54:15to locally produce the interceptor
- 54:17missile. They will also be able to
- 54:20produce the Scalp cruise missile
- 54:22because, as you know, cruise missiles
- 54:24are essential for a certain number of
- 54:26targets that are hardened. In
- 54:29particular, we know that the Flamingo
- 54:31missiles are very good, but a priori
- 54:33the warhead is not hardened. That is to
- 54:36say that it will expose itself more on
- 54:38factories on the surface, but it cannot
- 54:40penetrate several meters into concrete
- 54:42to be able to explode deep down. It
- 54:45does not know when it will enter a
- 54:47building, count the number of floors to
- 54:50explode on the third basement, for
- 54:52example. It will arrive more or less
- 54:55horizontally, it will more or less
- 54:57descend towards the end, but it is not
- 54:58necessarily capable of counting the
- 55:00windows to enter the 8th window like a
- 55:02scalper missile would. So there are a
- 55:04certain number of things today that
- 55:06would be better with a scalper missile.
- 55:08If we gave our scalper missile
- 55:09technologies, if we sold them under
- 55:10license to integrate them into the
- 55:12Flamingos, that would be even better.
- 55:14But now, apparently, the Ukrainians
- 55:16will be able to produce scalper
- 55:18missiles, French and American
- 55:20interceptor missiles, and, uh, that's
- 55:22already not bad. So, these are still
- 55:25good announcements in this area. That's
- 55:28really pleasing because finally we have
- 55:30partnerships that we should have had
- 55:33years and years ago, but it's sad that
- 55:35we had to wait so long for this. Hop.
- 55:39Were the shipyards in the Black Sea
- 55:42targeted? Well, not just any shipyards.
- 55:44All the shipyards have been targeted.
- 55:47Almost every day, Russian ships are
- 55:50being destroyed. And I'm not just
- 55:52talking about civilian ships, you've
- 55:54got military ships that are being hit.
- 55:57I'm going to show you a short video.
- 55:58Bash. Because it made me laugh not long
- 56:02ago. Bash. The Cronstat. Look at this
- 56:06pretty boat. Look. There you go. This
- 56:12is in a shipyard. So do you remember
- 56:14when you had the submarine that was hit
- 56:16, or this video is very short, it's not
- 56:18funny. You had a submarine that was hit
- 56:20, it was in the shipyard. The shipyard
- 56:22had been damaged. When you have this
- 56:24ship that's been hit now, when you have
- 56:27the FSB ship that's been hit, all of
- 56:29this is happening right in the shipyard
- 56:31. And you may remember that the
- 56:34Kerchout shipyard on the Crimean Bridge
- 56:37was hit. And that is why I have told
- 56:40you that between 2014 and 2024, the
- 56:41Ukrainians could strike the Crimean
- 56:43Bridge. They're not trying to do it
- 56:46because they're attacking the air
- 56:48defense bubble of the Crimean Bridge in
- 56:51the air. So all of this is directly
- 56:53around the area. So ultimately, the
- 56:56Ukrainians are actually attacking in an
- 56:59environment in the shipyards. This
- 57:02prevents the Russians from repairing
- 57:03their ships, from refitting them, from
- 57:05doing maintenance, since the Russians
- 57:07can't get their ships through the D3s
- 57:08of the Danielels because the Turks are
- 57:12preventing them from leaving. Because,
- 57:14under the agreements governing passage
- 57:17through this area, it's the Turks who
- 57:19can prohibit and close the strait to
- 57:21the belligerent country. Hence the fact
- 57:24that the Russians can't send
- 57:26reinforcements into the area because
- 57:29they're blocked outside in the
- 57:31Mediterranean Sea. And that, uh, thanks
- 57:33to the Turks for applying the law
- 57:35correctly. So yes, the Russians are no
- 57:38longer able to continue producing,
- 57:41repairing or refitting their ship. And
- 57:45maybe you also saw the submarine, by
- 57:47the way, it was quite funny, do you
- 57:48remember when there was the submarine
- 57:50that was hit? OK. It is because, in
- 57:53reality, the Ukrainians had sent a
- 57:55submarine naval drone which had managed
- 57:58to pass underneath the dike. The dike
- 58:00was a big boat. It had passed under it
- 58:02and crashed directly into the port. The
- 58:04Russians hadn't seen it go by. It's
- 58:06still quite big unfortunately. Why
- 58:08don't I believe in Russia's economic
- 58:10collapse? Well, I think Putin will have
- 58:14the wisdom to stop before the collapse.
- 58:18I hope he goes all the way. I hope he's
- 58:21stupid enough. to go all the way and
- 58:25continue his war until it cracks and
- 58:28the economy cracks. I think it will
- 58:32crack either economically or because of
- 58:33the morale of the population. But
- 58:36economically, the indicators are all in
- 58:38the red. But once again, remember the
- 58:41interview I did with my friend
- 58:42Alexander in Kif when I was in front of
- 58:44the university, an interview about the
- 58:47economy. Putin tomorrow, he gathers the
- 58:5150 biggest billionaires in Russia, he
- 58:53demands that each of them give him 2
- 58:56billion dollars. They have no choice,
- 58:59they will do it. We are not in a normal
- 59:02economy, we are in an economy in which
- 59:04it is a dictatorship and even in the
- 59:05economic domain, people who do not want
- 59:07to give their money, they will end up
- 59:09falling from the 27th floor because
- 59:10their window was not fixed properly. So
- 59:14if the Russian economy collapsed, it
- 59:16doesn't mean that the Russian state no
- 59:19longer has the money to continue
- 59:21fueling this war in one way or another.
- 59:24Either by spoiling the rich, in which
- 59:26case I think the rich would end up
- 59:28turning against Putin, or by stopping
- 59:30paying pensions and so on. And we know
- 59:33how resilient Russians are in this area
- 59:36. I don't know to what extent young
- 59:37people would be able to withstand the
- 59:39deprivations of their grandparents
- 59:41because their grandparents have
- 59:43suffered so much more than when they
- 59:45were in the Soviet era. But I don't
- 59:48think the Russian collapse that I want
- 59:50is imminent. I think Putin knows that
- 59:56he is in a dramatic economic situation
- 59:59and I think he will stop before a real
- 1:00:02collapse. And that is a real problem
- 1:00:05for us because in this context, if
- 1:00:07there is a real ceasefire, I will come
- 1:00:09to this question right after. If you
- 1:00:12have a real ceasefire, you have to know
- 1:00:15that Ukraine, if there is a ceasefire,
- 1:00:17when it produces 1,000 Flamingo
- 1:00:19missiles, 10,000 cruise missiles, it
- 1:00:22has a conventional pressure capacity,
- 1:00:25clearly a conventional deterrent that
- 1:00:27is gigantic, far superior to anything
- 1:00:30that any other country could do. So, I
- 1:00:34think that for the first time, a
- 1:00:36Russian ceasefire, uh, that, that
- 1:00:38finally accepted by the Russians,
- 1:00:40because they are the ones who are not
- 1:00:42in a position of strength today...If
- 1:00:44there were a ceasefire, the Russians
- 1:00:46would not be able to resume because,
- 1:00:47they would be in a situation where
- 1:00:49Ukraine could certainly strike even
- 1:00:51harder than what they are capable of
- 1:00:53striking. So what is Russia's weak
- 1:00:57point then? Georgia, the Baltic
- 1:01:01countries. Why the Baltic countries?
- 1:01:03Because if Russia just takes Narva and
- 1:01:07NATO is weaker than Ukraine. We have to
- 1:01:10be clear about that. NATO does not have
- 1:01:12the operational capacity of Ukraine.
- 1:01:14All the armies of Europe combined have
- 1:01:17a capacity, and they are smaller in
- 1:01:19volume than the Ukrainian army alone.
- 1:01:22And the Ukrainian army is made up of
- 1:01:24men who are capable of modern,
- 1:01:25high-intensity combat. All the NATO
- 1:01:27armies do not know how to produce the
- 1:01:2810,000 drones that the Ukrainians
- 1:01:30produce per day. They do not know how
- 1:01:32to produce the 300 low-cost, long-range
- 1:01:34drone missiles that the Ukrainians
- 1:01:35produce each day. We lack the Ukrainian
- 1:01:37electronic warfare to protect ourselves
- 1:01:39. We do not have the capacity to have
- 1:01:42an air defense that is even half of
- 1:01:44what the Ukrainians have. They have the
- 1:01:47best air defense, the best deep strike
- 1:01:49capability, the best capacity to
- 1:01:50produce drones in the world, the best
- 1:01:51capacity to protect ourselves against
- 1:01:53drones in the world. We have fighter
- 1:01:55jets. We have seen what American
- 1:01:58fighter jets do in Iran. Great. There
- 1:02:02you have it. What will it do? The
- 1:02:05Ukrainians are doing much more harm to
- 1:02:07the Russians with their drones than we
- 1:02:09could with our missiles, which we have
- 1:02:11in extremely limited quantities. So
- 1:02:15today, the weak zone, if the Ukrainians
- 1:02:16and Russians were to manage to cease
- 1:02:18fire, which I hope with all my heart,
- 1:02:20is Russia, could collapse, it would be
- 1:02:22even better. But anyway, if we were to
- 1:02:25manage to achieve a ceasefire, if this
- 1:02:27ceasefire were respected between
- 1:02:29Ukraine and Russia, Russia has an army
- 1:02:32today that is superior to ours, it must
- 1:02:34be said, with an army that is mobilized
- 1:02:39, for which they have no problem losing
- 1:02:413,000, 5,000 men, 10,000 men in an
- 1:02:44attempt. That's what they lose every 10
- 1:02:46days, you know. Every week, they lose
- 1:02:477,000 men. So, they are putting 30,000
- 1:02:50men into trying to take Narva. take
- 1:02:52Narva. Uh, we react, we don't react, we
- 1:02:56go into open war to liberate Narva,
- 1:02:57which is a small pocket in the north of
- 1:03:00Estonia. There you have it. The real
- 1:03:02question is, would we go and fight for
- 1:03:04Narva? If we don't fight for Narva, it
- 1:03:07means the collapse of the European
- 1:03:09security architecture at the level of
- 1:03:11the European Union and NATO. And the
- 1:03:14political cost is huge, much greater
- 1:03:16than taking Constantinfka in the
- 1:03:19Donbass, a pile of runes in the Donbass
- 1:03:22. There's no point in taking
- 1:03:24Constantinfka and it's going to cost
- 1:03:26Russia tens of thousands more men.
- 1:03:29There you have it. So that's why I'm
- 1:03:30saying that if tomorrow there's a real
- 1:03:32ceasefire, Russia should lift the
- 1:03:33sanctions. We won't have a choice. So
- 1:03:36lifting the sanctions gives Russia a
- 1:03:38breath of fresh air. It can produce
- 1:03:40weapons in large quantities. Its
- 1:03:42economy is not collapsing and it
- 1:03:44remains a threat, not to Ukraine, which
- 1:03:47will have won, but to its neighbors,
- 1:03:49Georgia and the Baltic States. And here
- 1:03:52I bet, uh, well, they have no reason to
- 1:03:55wait until we are ready to attack us.
- 1:03:58There you go, I obviously hope I am
- 1:04:00wrong. Hey, we are kind of on the same
- 1:04:04page here. A Russian drone attack on
- 1:04:07Poland to make them give in on the
- 1:04:09issue. Do you believe it? I don't
- 1:04:11believe at all that anyone who feels
- 1:04:14attacked by Russia would give up
- 1:04:17Ukraine. Poland today is the big one.
- 1:04:21They are strong, they know how to
- 1:04:22resist, they are not as good as the
- 1:04:24Ukrainians, but they would definitely
- 1:04:26resist very, very well. The weak
- 1:04:28country is further north. And on the
- 1:04:31other hand, what...There are doubts
- 1:04:33about what Russia could do, uh, to
- 1:04:36provoke NATO. There are a number of
- 1:04:39people and intelligence services who
- 1:04:41are announcing that, uh, Russia is
- 1:04:43preparing to test us in some way,
- 1:04:46whether it's by taking a small island,
- 1:04:48moving buoys for naval borders, sending
- 1:04:51drones, and they do this so much every
- 1:04:54day that now it doesn't amount to
- 1:04:56anything. And possibly what was
- 1:04:59mentioned was that they would have a
- 1:05:02helicopter that pretended to crash and
- 1:05:05that helicopter made an emergency
- 1:05:09landing in a corner of Poland. And at
- 1:05:12that point, you would have a commando
- 1:05:14operation to evacuate the crew members
- 1:05:17of the helicopter that landed in Poland
- 1:05:20, and the Russians would stage it a bit
- 1:05:23like the Americans when they managed to
- 1:05:26exfiltrate their F15 pilot who had
- 1:05:28taken refuge in Iraq; well, who had
- 1:05:31ejected and was hiding over Iraq. And
- 1:05:34that's an option that is strongly, uh,
- 1:05:36strongly feared: that the Russians pull
- 1:05:39off some kind of spectacular stunt like
- 1:05:42that and then end up saying, "Oh, look,
- 1:05:44we're too strong, we managed to extract
- 1:05:47our men even though they had fallen
- 1:05:49into enemy territory." There you go,
- 1:05:52just to say once again, we're great at
- 1:05:54NATO, we're crushing time and so on.
- 1:05:55It's totally ridiculous, of course, but
- 1:05:58it's to test our limits. Are we going
- 1:06:00to shoot down rescue helicopters that
- 1:06:02come to pick up Russians who have
- 1:06:03broken down? Oh, the poor things, you
- 1:06:05didn't do it on purpose, they broke
- 1:06:06down on our side? That's the kind of
- 1:06:08question we have to ask ourselves. If
- 1:06:10there's no firmness on our side, the
- 1:06:12Russians have no reason to back down.
- 1:06:15If we're weak, they'll advance. That's
- 1:06:17what they've done from the start. And
- 1:06:19all their aggressions, whether in 1992
- 1:06:21in Moldova, throughout the 90s when
- 1:06:24they refused to withdraw their troops
- 1:06:26from the Baltic states, when they did
- 1:06:28not return the islands on the Narva
- 1:06:31rivers: the Russians did not wait for
- 1:06:33NATO to withdraw. In 1992, the war in
- 1:06:36Chiny, and so on, it is just Russian
- 1:06:38imperialism that remains a…it is the
- 1:06:40…it is the only constant since the
- 1:06:42beginning, when we know that they began
- 1:06:44at the end of the 90s to prepare the
- 1:06:46invasion of Moldova, that they began to
- 1:06:48distribute passports in the north of
- 1:06:50Georgia to pretend that there were
- 1:06:52Russians there, which was not the case.
- 1:06:55There you have it, that is Russia's
- 1:06:57preparation for war. When they build
- 1:07:00defense lines and infrastructure today
- 1:07:02to accommodate tens of thousands of
- 1:07:05soldiers on our borders, on NATO
- 1:07:07borders, it's not because they're
- 1:07:09afraid of being attacked. Is Estonia
- 1:07:12going to attack Russia? It's obviously
- 1:07:15because they're preparing exactly what
- 1:07:18they did with Ukraine because they know
- 1:07:21very well how far we're from the
- 1:07:24Ukrainians in terms of defense. There
- 1:07:34are challenges, so I'm not going to get
- 1:07:40into the debates about the national
- 1:07:42rally. Come on, the challenge of July
- 1:07:4614th is the foundation of a direct
- 1:07:48commitment from France in the near
- 1:07:49future. So, a commitment, no, I hope
- 1:07:52with all my heart, you remember
- 1:07:54Operation Skyshield. Operation
- 1:07:56Skyshield: there is a petition underway
- 1:07:58, we have more than 50,000, maybe
- 1:08:0060,000 signatures in which we would
- 1:08:03like non-Ukrainian aircraft to be able
- 1:08:05to intercept Ukrainian missiles over
- 1:08:08Ukraine, sorry, Russian missiles over
- 1:08:10Ukraine, and not just once they have
- 1:08:12violated our airspace. Uh, bam, I'll
- 1:08:17take note of your questions as they
- 1:08:20arise. So Skyfield, the goal is to
- 1:08:24commit resources, our own, those of the
- 1:08:27Air Force, those of the Army, why not
- 1:08:29with Latte drones, Latte helicopters
- 1:08:32that could go and hunt the Shahid over
- 1:08:34Ukrainian territory. Great Britain has
- 1:08:38taken the liberty of doing so. Great
- 1:08:39Britain destroyed a Russian missile
- 1:08:42over Ukraine. We have not entered a war
- 1:08:44. Great Britain is not at war with
- 1:08:46Russia. You saw the red lines, [ __ ]
- 1:08:48, once again. So, on the other hand, we
- 1:08:52conducted exercises in which we
- 1:08:55interfaced our Awax with Ukrainian air
- 1:08:58defense. We validated the technical
- 1:09:00aspects. All that remains is the
- 1:09:03political will, the political decision
- 1:09:04to go and save Ukrainians, to go and
- 1:09:06intercept these ballistic missiles, to
- 1:09:08go and intercept these areas, to prove
- 1:09:10the value of our equipment in the
- 1:09:11context of an external operation, for
- 1:09:13example. I have wanted to do this for a
- 1:09:16long time, it is legitimate, it is
- 1:09:17normal to go and protect civilians who
- 1:09:19are targeted every day. So that is
- 1:09:20normal. Is France going to do it? I
- 1:09:23think that what we saw on July 14th is
- 1:09:25very pleasing. It is very pleasing to
- 1:09:26see everyone, to see lots of planes
- 1:09:28from all over the world, to see lots of
- 1:09:29people marching, to see lots of
- 1:09:30political leaders gathered together.
- 1:09:33But that is, uh, just for show. The
- 1:09:36only reality of July 14 is that the
- 1:09:38Ukrainians will be able to produce
- 1:09:40weapons under license that will receive
- 1:09:42missiles, or rather, air defense
- 1:09:44systems, and in the future that others
- 1:09:46will be borrowed from them. But I see
- 1:09:49absolutely no sign that France will
- 1:09:51have the courage to commit to defending
- 1:09:53the Ukrainians who have been unjustly
- 1:09:56attacked. And I regret that. I don't
- 1:09:59want France to be on the front line
- 1:10:01studying Russian, but I think that we
- 1:10:03have a vocation to protect the
- 1:10:04Ukrainians. Operation Skyshield. There
- 1:10:08you go. There you go. Putin doesn't
- 1:10:14want to stop the war. Come on, I don't
- 1:10:21want to start a political debate. Yeah,
- 1:10:25let's just recall this little episode
- 1:10:27in passing. The Turks shot down a
- 1:10:29Russian fighter jet that violated their
- 1:10:30airspace for 17 seconds. Since then,
- 1:10:32the Russians have been careful with
- 1:10:33Turkey. Exactly. Except that for a very
- 1:10:36, very long time, including since 2014,
- 1:10:38well before, you have Russia violating
- 1:10:40our airspace, including that of Sweden,
- 1:10:42including all our neighbors. And we
- 1:10:45have more than 50 violations of our
- 1:10:47airspace by planes, aircraft. We have
- 1:10:50opened fire on German helicopters in
- 1:10:52the Baltic Sea, on an RC135, a British
- 1:10:55plane in the Black Sea. We have
- 1:10:58American drones that have been
- 1:10:59destroyed in mid-air collisions. You
- 1:11:02have attempts to destroy French drones
- 1:11:04over the Mediterranean Sea. You have
- 1:11:06French Atlantique 2s that have been
- 1:11:08caught on radar. That is to say, it is
- 1:11:10just before firing. This is the reality
- 1:11:12of what the Russians do every day. And
- 1:11:14we are never in the process of
- 1:11:16escalation. We are simply enduring. If
- 1:11:18we did the same thing, it would be a
- 1:11:19way of reestablishing the level of
- 1:11:21tension to lower them. And since we do
- 1:11:22not react, the Russians can afford to
- 1:11:24go even further. Shooting down a plane
- 1:11:27in flight. I mean, I don't know what we
- 1:11:31came close to, but we really came close
- 1:11:33. And it wasn't the Ukrainians, it
- 1:11:35wasn't the nasty English who were in
- 1:11:37the Black Sea who were at fault. It was
- 1:11:40the fact that the Russians were looking
- 1:11:41for a collision and trying to endanger
- 1:11:43the crews. So that's a real problem.
- 1:11:48Hop. Wait, there are a lot of questions
- 1:11:54I missed earlier. So, have we finally
- 1:12:01learned from the Ukrainians about
- 1:12:03destroying drones? I mean, you know
- 1:12:05that I've been saying this for a very
- 1:12:07long time, the Ukrainians intercept
- 1:12:09more than 90%of drones. The Gulf
- 1:12:13countries are showing us that our
- 1:12:16unlimited methods, as far as the
- 1:12:18Emirates, Kuwait and so on, Dubai only
- 1:12:20intercepts 60%of drones. The Ukrainians
- 1:12:25are better because they have both air
- 1:12:27defense and interceptors that are
- 1:12:28adapted, but they have interceptors
- 1:12:30that are piloted. That is to say, they
- 1:12:34will need to have a human in the loop
- 1:12:36to be able to reach impact. And as long
- 1:12:39as we are not on the front lines, we do
- 1:12:42not have pilots who are capable of
- 1:12:44doing this in large numbers. So, I say
- 1:12:47for now because in reality, we could
- 1:12:49very well have French pilots pilot the
- 1:12:51interceptors online. We have Sting
- 1:12:53interceptors that can be piloted
- 1:12:55remotely via the internet. We could
- 1:12:58very well form a partnership by saying,
- 1:13:00here is France, we have 50 pilots who
- 1:13:02will train to intercept Chaideds every
- 1:13:04day and it is not complicated. All we
- 1:13:06have to do is pilot them, intercept
- 1:13:07them, and destroy them. It gives the
- 1:13:08Ukrainians a helping hand with human
- 1:13:10resources. It trains us. We save lives
- 1:13:12without even getting involved. For me,
- 1:13:13Skyd can go very, very far. It doesn't
- 1:13:16even require going into the field. It
- 1:13:18allows French pilots to train by
- 1:13:20destroying Russian drones with
- 1:13:21interceptors that were set up directly
- 1:13:23by the Ukrainians in Ukraine. That way,
- 1:13:26we would learn how to do it. We would
- 1:13:28learn to be good. We would teach our
- 1:13:30pilots to work on the reality of the
- 1:13:32field and not just on software and so
- 1:13:36on. And for now, because we don't have
- 1:13:40the capacity to train in real life
- 1:13:42against a mass of people, we want
- 1:13:44interceptors that are 100%autonomous.
- 1:13:48And the 100%autonomous French drones,
- 1:13:51the Armatan and the Altares and so on,
- 1:13:53they don't manage to have interception
- 1:13:56rates that are as good as we would like
- 1:13:59. So for now, there is a company-
- 1:14:02surprise me if I'm not mistaken-so the
- 1:14:05first interceptor orders are not for
- 1:14:07French interceptors. It was announced
- 1:14:11as the first to win a call for tenders
- 1:14:13with the French Armaments Directorate.
- 1:14:17And so we have interceptors that will
- 1:14:19be delivered soon. So it costs €
- 1:14:2225,000 instead of € 3,000, but
- 1:14:24apparently they have succeeded in
- 1:14:26intercepting during tests conducted on
- 1:14:28Levent Island and at the Landes test
- 1:14:30center. So, we have an initial foreign
- 1:14:34European intermediate solution,
- 1:14:36validated in Ukraine, and which—and
- 1:14:38which, I hope, will also have a
- 1:14:40successor that is national, because
- 1:14:43that's what I want: to have a French
- 1:14:45interceptor that can destroy systems
- 1:14:47because we have two great companies
- 1:14:50that have spent millions trying to
- 1:14:52develop interceptors and which, for the
- 1:14:54moment, unfortunately, are not up to
- 1:14:57the standard of this little Laiton that
- 1:14:59won the first contract with the French
- 1:15:01army. So, after that, what the
- 1:15:04Ukrainians do at home, they also do in
- 1:15:07the Middle East to protect certain
- 1:15:10bases. But they didn't have the
- 1:15:13opportunity, and they certainly weren't
- 1:15:14asked to do it on the entire front,
- 1:15:16because that would create hundreds and
- 1:15:17hundreds of pilots and thousands of
- 1:15:19interceptors as well. So the Ukrainians
- 1:15:22do not have autonomous interceptors
- 1:15:24they have really let loose. They have
- 1:15:27plenty of them. They have many examples
- 1:15:29of autonomous interceptions. But the
- 1:15:32interception rate of autonomous
- 1:15:35interceptors is around 60%, while a
- 1:15:38human pilot's rate is over 90%. So
- 1:15:43again, even in Ukraine, interceptors
- 1:15:45with 100%autonomous artificial
- 1:15:47intelligence are not fully developed at
- 1:15:49the moment. Hop. So sorry, I've already
- 1:15:55answered that. So I'm just going to
- 1:15:58show my t-shirt because two of you, or
- 1:15:59rather several, have asked me for it.
- 1:16:01This is Star Wars Slava Ukraini. We
- 1:16:05can't get more Ukrainian tonight with
- 1:16:07little Yoda. There you go. Will this
- 1:16:12war ever end, my friend? The war
- 1:16:16between Ukraine and Russia. I like
- 1:16:22Russian economic indicators, whatever
- 1:16:24people say, unless Russia resorts to
- 1:16:26unconventional means like I said
- 1:16:28earlier, a priori in September, I don't
- 1:16:34see how it can continue since the
- 1:16:35sovereign wealth fund will be
- 1:16:36practically empty. The plundering of
- 1:16:39Africa, of the African continent, also
- 1:16:41has its limits. There you go. So, there
- 1:16:44are many things that mean that, before
- 1:16:47winter, I think the Russians will have
- 1:16:50to move on to another phase of the war
- 1:16:52because every day, every day, the
- 1:16:56destruction that Russia suffers has a
- 1:16:59stratospheric cost and infinitely
- 1:17:01higher than anything they could hope
- 1:17:04for from the territorial gains they
- 1:17:06would make in the coming months by
- 1:17:08conquering two or three razed cities in
- 1:17:11Ukraine. If in 3 months, 2 months, 1
- 1:17:15month, they take Constantinevska,
- 1:17:17during the next month, well, the
- 1:17:19Ukrainians, they will have destroyed
- 1:17:21what? A hundred ships, four refineries,
- 1:17:25twenty factories. Do you think that
- 1:17:28taking these piles of ruins is worth
- 1:17:31the loss of thousands of men, thousands
- 1:17:34of pieces of equipment and billions of
- 1:17:37euros in value of factories and systems
- 1:17:40that will have to be rebuilt? So in
- 1:17:43fact, the longer Russia waits for a
- 1:17:46ceasefire, it will not win. I already
- 1:17:48said this earlier. So it is only a
- 1:17:50question of will. And the question, the
- 1:17:53problem is that Putin's power is linked
- 1:17:56to this war. If he gives up this war,
- 1:17:59he will collapse. He knows it very well
- 1:18:01. He will be replaced quickly and he
- 1:18:02will leave a very bad memory in history
- 1:18:04. So he is still hoping for a Ukrainian
- 1:18:06collapse that will not come. And so
- 1:18:09today, there is no longer any
- 1:18:10rationality in continuing this war. Any
- 1:18:12rational man should have withdrawn.
- 1:18:14Donald Trump should have withdrawn from
- 1:18:16Iran in the first week. We are still at
- 1:18:19the same point today and it could last
- 1:18:21another month. I think it will change
- 1:18:22absolutely nothing. America is
- 1:18:24demonstrating its inability to overcome
- 1:18:27Iran. Russia is demonstrating every day
- 1:18:30its inability to overcome Ukraine. And
- 1:18:33on top of that, with each passing day,
- 1:18:35it is weakening demographically,
- 1:18:37economically, and strategically.
- 1:18:40Strategically because its allies no
- 1:18:41longer believe in it, because its
- 1:18:43allies in the tournament, because the
- 1:18:44countries, the PCs in Africa, etc., no
- 1:18:46longer believe in it. So we are seeing
- 1:18:50Russia retreat in many different areas
- 1:18:53and I don't see how it could get out of
- 1:18:57the situation it has put itself in. But
- 1:19:02nevertheless, if Russia cannot accept
- 1:19:05that the least bad solution would be to
- 1:19:08stop right away, but well, I think it
- 1:19:11would be October, November, September,
- 1:19:14October, November, October November,
- 1:19:17I'll say that today. It's July 19, I
- 1:19:21say October, November, Russia accepts a
- 1:19:23ceasefire. Well, at that point, if they
- 1:19:27are not on a CCFE by that point,
- 1:19:29Ukraine will continue to suffer very
- 1:19:33serious attacks on its electrical
- 1:19:35infrastructure, even more serious than
- 1:19:36in previous years. And really, it was
- 1:19:39tough last year, I assure you, I was
- 1:19:41there, it was -24 degrees, it was 3
- 1:19:42degrees in my apartment, it was really
- 1:19:44very tough. But on the other hand,
- 1:19:48Ukraine will also have the means to cut
- 1:19:50off Russia's electricity and because
- 1:19:52today, it is attacking military
- 1:19:54infrastructure, but it has already
- 1:19:56warned. If you still want to attack our
- 1:19:59electricity, now we have the means to
- 1:20:02attack yours. And if Moscow is deprived
- 1:20:05of power just as KEF is, then the game
- 1:20:07will simply no longer be the same. So
- 1:20:10the Ukrainians, certainly this winter
- 1:20:12could be even worse than the previous
- 1:20:15ones, but what level of acceptance are
- 1:20:17the Russians ready to tolerate in order
- 1:20:19to continue to endure, to suffer
- 1:20:21without seeing any strategic objective
- 1:20:23for this war? China is now openly
- 1:20:26making fun of Russia, for example in
- 1:20:28the negotiation of the route and
- 1:20:30financing of the gas pipeline that is
- 1:20:32supposed to supply China. They want to
- 1:20:35further reduce the prices of
- 1:20:36unbelievable things by three. So we are
- 1:20:39in a situation where Russia is losing
- 1:20:42its allies, losing its support, and is
- 1:20:44being ripped off by all its
- 1:20:46pseudo-partners. India is negotiating
- 1:20:50oil at low prices to sell it to them at
- 1:20:53market price, doing a somersault. There
- 1:20:55has been a transfer of wealth from
- 1:20:57Russia to India that has been
- 1:20:58mind-blowing since the beginning of the
- 1:21:00war. China is selling all these spare
- 1:21:02parts to China and to Russia, and it is
- 1:21:04doing so on an absolutely unbelievable
- 1:21:06scale. All the so-called brick
- 1:21:10countries, Azerbaijan, Egypt, they are
- 1:21:13arming Ukraine. They have nevertheless
- 1:21:16chosen their side. Serbia is arming
- 1:21:17Ukraine, Bulgaria is arming Ukraine. In
- 1:21:19short, there are no more allies. So
- 1:21:21Russia is only losing influence. The
- 1:21:23longer we wait, the harder it gets. But
- 1:21:25as I was saying, Putin knows that he is
- 1:21:28risking his life in this war and that a
- 1:21:31failure and therefore a pause now, a
- 1:21:34negotiation now would be to the
- 1:21:36advantage of the Ukrainians. And I
- 1:21:39don't see how it would be any different
- 1:21:41next winter. If Russia does not accept
- 1:21:43a ceasefire before the winter, it will
- 1:21:46enter the winter in a situation where
- 1:21:49it will no longer have electricity.
- 1:21:51These factories will also be destroyed.
- 1:21:53That's the difference between the
- 1:21:54Ukrainians and them, they can rely on
- 1:21:55their allies. Russia has no allies, it
- 1:21:58has suppliers who are trying to fleece
- 1:21:59it. It's not exactly the same thing.
- 1:22:03It's 10:27 p.m., friends, and in 3
- 1:22:05minutes, I'll be live on LCI. Ah, look,
- 1:22:11for those who are asking about Federof,
- 1:22:13watch the beginning of the video. Does
- 1:22:16Hungary support Ukraine today? Hungary
- 1:22:19is no longer a hindrance to Ukraine.
- 1:22:20That's important. It's not a real
- 1:22:22support in the same way as the other
- 1:22:24country. But even with Poland, things
- 1:22:26are calming down. Many things are
- 1:22:28calming down. There you have it. Thanks
- 1:22:30to all my friends. Long live Napoleon.
- 1:22:32Long live free Ukraine. Long live
- 1:22:34Ukraine and Europe. Long live Ukraine
- 1:22:37in Europe. We have to be convinced of
- 1:22:39that. They are the ones who will help
- 1:22:40us. They will have growth like Poland x
- 1:22:4210 because they truly have strategic
- 1:22:44and economic interests, industries, an
- 1:22:46educated, patriotic, sovereign
- 1:22:48population that believes in Europe. The
- 1:22:50real European sovereignists are the
- 1:22:52Ukrainians and the French. They are the
- 1:22:55ones who want to have European weapons.
- 1:22:56They are the leading army in Europe.
- 1:22:58And if tomorrow there is a war, let's
- 1:23:00be clear, between Russia and Europe,
- 1:23:02you want to be helped by the Americans.
- 1:23:05Do you want to be helped by the
- 1:23:06Ukrainians, those who have the right
- 1:23:08weapons, or those who are unable to
- 1:23:09defeat Iran and who are unable to
- 1:23:10protect their allies in the Middle East
- 1:23:12? Ukraine is infinitely stronger than
- 1:23:15Russia and the United States to defend
- 1:23:18us in a conventional war with Russia.
- 1:23:22And that is something we really need to
- 1:23:23keep in mind. It is in our interest to
- 1:23:24hold on to Ukraine because they are the
- 1:23:26good ones, they are the strong ones and
- 1:23:27they are the ones who represent the
- 1:23:29future of European growth as well.
- 1:23:30There you have it, I believe in it
- 1:23:31wholeheartedly, my friends. I hope you
- 1:23:33enjoyed it. I will see you in 5 minutes
- 1:23:35on LCI. See you soon. Thanks and sorry
- 1:23:38again for the technical issue at the
- 1:23:39start.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of [🇺🇦⚔️🇷🇺] LIVE SITUATION UKRAINE - Succès ukrainiens - Polémique Federov / Syrsky by Xavier Tytelman, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,475 words across 1,989 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.