YouTube2Text

LIVE: Killer Susan Smith Fights to Get Out of Prison — Parole Hearing — Transcript

by Justice Is A Process!!!! · 9,756 words · 1,452 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:03[Music]
  2. 0:10the systems Rigg man it's time to break
  3. 0:12free Eyes Wide Open got to see what I
  4. 0:15see standing on the front lines fighting
  5. 0:17for the truth lift the V of Lies it's
  6. 0:20time to be the proof take a stand don't
  7. 0:23you back down
  8. 0:32[Music]
  9. 0:39the systems rig man it's time to break
  10. 0:40free Eyes Wide Open got to see what I
  11. 0:43see standing on the front lines fighting
  12. 0:45for the truth lift the veil of Lies it's
  13. 0:48time to be the proof take a stand don't
  14. 0:51you back down back down Raise Your Voice
  15. 0:56let's shake the town sh the to where the
  16. 1:00voices that won't be
  17. 1:04ignored Breaking Chains yeah we're ready
  18. 1:09forward with the
  19. 1:18[Music]
  20. 1:23power the systems Rigg man it's time to
  21. 1:26break free Eyes Wide Open got to see
  22. 1:29what I see standing on the front lines
  23. 1:31fighting for the truth lift the ve of
  24. 1:33Lies it's time to be the proof take a
  25. 1:36stand don't you back down back down
  26. 1:40Raise Your Voice let's shake the
  27. 1:44town with the voices that won't be
  28. 1:49ignored Breaking Chains yeah we're ready
  29. 1:55forward with the power
  30. 2:03[Music]
  31. 2:58e
  32. 3:28e
  33. 3:58e
  34. 4:28e
  35. 4:58e
  36. 5:28e
  37. 5:58e
  38. 6:28e
  39. 6:58e
  40. 7:28e
  41. 7:58e
  42. 8:28e
  43. 8:58e
  44. 9:28e
  45. 9:58e
  46. 10:28e
  47. 10:58e
  48. 11:28e
  49. 11:58e
  50. 12:28e
  51. 12:58e e
  52. 13:38the board is I'm sorry I still had you
  53. 13:40muted my apologies the board is I just
  54. 13:44need to confirm there is some other
  55. 13:45conversation is everything okay yes
  56. 13:48ma'am we are ready thank
  57. 13:51you thank you so much Miss Hunter if you
  58. 13:53can advise when the recording has
  59. 13:57begun the recorder has be
  60. 14:00done thank you the time now was 11:41
  61. 14:03a.m. we're resuming our hearings our
  62. 14:06next case will be case number
  63. 14:0934 case number 34 Susan
  64. 14:13Smith one moment as leth connects and
  65. 14:17she does have supporters and we'll be
  66. 14:19represented by attorney Tommy Thomas
  67. 14:22thank you one moment as all parties
  68. 14:24connect Miss Brown Henry H I do have a
  69. 14:26statement that I need to read into the
  70. 14:28record please
  71. 14:30please yes ma'am thank you I have
  72. 14:33received this
  73. 14:35correspondence it is addressed to The
  74. 14:37Honorable chair Kimberly Frederick dated
  75. 14:40November 20th
  76. 14:412024 please be advised that I will
  77. 14:44recuse myself in the parole hearing of
  78. 14:46Susan Smith number
  79. 14:5022487 I was acting Warden at Camille
  80. 14:53gram Correctional Center in 1999 where
  81. 14:56inmate Smith was housed and subsequent
  82. 14:59ly transfer to Le Correctional
  83. 15:01Institution I have determined that it is
  84. 15:03appropriate to recuse to eliminate any
  85. 15:05appearance of affecting her opportunity
  86. 15:08for Paro respectfully Gerald deine P
  87. 15:12Mir thank you Mrs Mir this is accepted
  88. 15:15if you would please exit the
  89. 15:17room thank
  90. 15:25you Mrs miror has recused herself of
  91. 15:28this case and has exited the R thank
  92. 15:32you thank you we have moved her site
  93. 15:35into the lobby
  94. 15:37briefly and one moment as we admit to
  95. 15:40all
  96. 15:54parties there at least May I'm
  97. 15:56confirming you are Miss Susan Smith
  98. 16:01yes
  99. 16:02ma'am you and attorney Tommy Thomas are
  100. 16:05you able to hear us yes ma'am I am thank
  101. 16:08you and they're at the support site
  102. 16:09confirm you are hearing support of Miss
  103. 16:11Susan
  104. 16:14Smith ask can you
  105. 16:17hear yes we can
  106. 16:20hear and you're here in support of Miss
  107. 16:23Smith yes ma'am thank you all for
  108. 16:26joining you before the board please a
  109. 16:28wait for the chairman to address you
  110. 16:31good morning Miss Smith good morning Mr
  111. 16:33Thomas and good morning to the folks at
  112. 16:35Watkins thank you all for being here
  113. 16:37with us today we hope everyone is doing
  114. 16:39well miss Smith I want you to know that
  115. 16:42we have received the packet of
  116. 16:43information that Mr Thomas's office
  117. 16:46provided to us on your behalf and we
  118. 16:48have reviewed that packet so thank you
  119. 16:50for submitting that in advance of this
  120. 16:52hearing today Mr Thomas are you going to
  121. 16:55begin or is your client going to begin
  122. 16:59uh yes ma'am I'll be glad to begin yes
  123. 17:03sir uh members of the board good morning
  124. 17:06uh this is Susan Smith's um role hearing
  125. 17:09this has probably been one of the most
  126. 17:12difficult cases that um I have had to
  127. 17:15put together for a parole presentation
  128. 17:18um just lots of different factors to
  129. 17:20consider um she's been convicted of
  130. 17:23murder of course uh she has served 30
  131. 17:27years and she was 23 at the time time
  132. 17:29that this incident occurred um she was
  133. 17:32sentenced to life with the elig
  134. 17:34eligibility appr Pro so that's why she
  135. 17:36is here today um I'm not really going to
  136. 17:39speak much about the crime um there are
  137. 17:41some things that I want to cover and
  138. 17:44that's not out of
  139. 17:45disrespect um we were very concerned
  140. 17:48about that um today is Susan's parole
  141. 17:52heing and uh so today it's going to be
  142. 17:55about Susan and I want to make sure that
  143. 17:58uh the things that are important not
  144. 18:00only to her uh but to this hearing and
  145. 18:03this board um are presented and I want
  146. 18:06to thank you in advance for your time um
  147. 18:09to listen to everything um this story is
  148. 18:13really a mental health story um some of
  149. 18:17this stuff I've known Susan for a couple
  150. 18:19of years and we've been working on this
  151. 18:22case um one of the things when I first
  152. 18:25met her was of course trying to kind of
  153. 18:28figure out out some Rhyme or Reason as
  154. 18:30to you know how these things have
  155. 18:32happened and uh was able to uh find and
  156. 18:37have uh someone come to see her on a
  157. 18:40routine basis for uh
  158. 18:42counseling and um also to try to help
  159. 18:46her you know through the daily things
  160. 18:48with Department of
  161. 18:49Corrections um as a result that's kind
  162. 18:52of what I kind of uh came to the
  163. 18:54conclusion was it is a mental health
  164. 18:57story um it's about about uh the dangers
  165. 19:01of untreated mental health it is about
  166. 19:04um the lack of insight the lack of
  167. 19:08diagnosis into mental health and it's
  168. 19:12about stigmas uh old stigmas um of
  169. 19:15course I'm 68 years old I remember those
  170. 19:18um hopefully they're not as bad today
  171. 19:20Susan was hospitalized uh as a young
  172. 19:24teen uh for a short period of time uh
  173. 19:27for mental health health treatment and
  174. 19:31not to disparage anybody but her mom um
  175. 19:35was telling folks that she was in the
  176. 19:36hospital because she had a um strip uh
  177. 19:40infection so those were things that we
  178. 19:42didn't talk about those were things that
  179. 19:45um were pushed under the rug so to speak
  180. 19:49because they were embarrassing they
  181. 19:50showed weakness I don't know what they
  182. 19:53showed um but they showed up and
  183. 19:56culminated in Susan um as a result of a
  184. 20:01day that all of this uh came together
  185. 20:05and produced um some horrendous um
  186. 20:08results so I think it's important to
  187. 20:11Susan if anybody if anything comes out
  188. 20:14of this hearing it's that people
  189. 20:18understand um there's nothing to be
  190. 20:20ashamed of um there's nothing and no
  191. 20:23reason not to reach out and seek
  192. 20:26treatment and there is certainly um um
  193. 20:29no Stigma that should be involved in
  194. 20:32trying to better yourself help yourself
  195. 20:35um for yourself and for others members
  196. 20:37of the family and everyone Susan uh
  197. 20:40moving on Susan is a high school
  198. 20:42graduate she has uh some college with uh
  199. 20:45USC Union she uh has attended
  200. 20:48International Christian college and
  201. 20:50she's worked on an associates degree
  202. 20:52she's still actually working on that uh
  203. 20:55in Christian Counseling um she has no
  204. 20:58prior record that I'm aware of uh if her
  205. 21:02she be living with her brother uh Scotty
  206. 21:04Von Scotty is here today and very
  207. 21:06briefly wanted to address the board the
  208. 21:09job for her um she has served 30 years
  209. 21:12so she's been in Department Corrections
  210. 21:14for a long time would be through
  211. 21:16vocational rehab um the P program as
  212. 21:20probation of Paro uh would know it and
  213. 21:23we have made arranged much for after
  214. 21:26care uh with the licensed mental health
  215. 21:29professional uh you have that
  216. 21:30information in the packet that's been
  217. 21:32provided to you um some of the programs
  218. 21:36that I I took the time to look at
  219. 21:38everything to look at the programs that
  220. 21:40she's been involved in and um I'm not
  221. 21:43going to speak about all of those that
  222. 21:45you because you have those in the packet
  223. 21:48uh the ones that I think are important
  224. 21:50and relevant
  225. 21:51today uh is the uh self harmers group uh
  226. 21:56she has committed uh a attempted to
  227. 21:59commit suicide uh on several different
  228. 22:02occasions within the Department of
  229. 22:03Corrections uh seven habits uh Beyond
  230. 22:07abuse jump start uh which she is a great
  231. 22:10fan of she does not have um a drug or
  232. 22:14alcohol addiction thank goodness um she
  233. 22:17has been active on OVO and the cipher
  234. 22:20Works programs uh loss and grief uh
  235. 22:23healing seminars women's empowerment
  236. 22:27anger management
  237. 22:29self-esteem and domestic violence uh
  238. 22:32workshops I normally and I've presented
  239. 22:35a number of parole hearings um I first
  240. 22:39started with this thinking that it had
  241. 22:41to be different than normally what I
  242. 22:43would do as far as a
  243. 22:45presentation um and I came to the
  244. 22:47conclusion maybe this week that it
  245. 22:50doesn't um I think it is and I will
  246. 22:53stick with what I would normally do in
  247. 22:55as far as the structure of my
  248. 22:56presentation
  249. 22:58um what I always begin with with the
  250. 23:01board is contributing factors because I
  251. 23:03believe that's important um we need to
  252. 23:07know um what was going on why it was
  253. 23:10going on for the board to be able to uh
  254. 23:14make a informed decision about her
  255. 23:16parole um expectations and her parole
  256. 23:20eligibility uh and um what kind of
  257. 23:22candidate she is for parole one of the
  258. 23:26things that has jumped out at me and I
  259. 23:27saw this last night um in the media um
  260. 23:31and I know that Susan wants to speak and
  261. 23:34because she feels like it's important to
  262. 23:36get the truth out there is this is not
  263. 23:40about the love for another man um I saw
  264. 23:42it on local TV about uh how this was all
  265. 23:45about another man and and him not
  266. 23:47wanting children from what I have been
  267. 23:50able to determine that is just not true
  268. 23:53uh I had spoken with David Brook who was
  269. 23:55the defense attorney on a number of
  270. 23:57different occasions
  271. 23:59uh David has been a great source of
  272. 24:01information uh in regards to Susan uh he
  273. 24:05indicated to me that uh this was a
  274. 24:09theory um of uh a motive um by the state
  275. 24:14that's think that's where we think it
  276. 24:16developed uh however um this was never
  277. 24:19proven at trial and it was actually
  278. 24:22abandoned uh by the state so um but it
  279. 24:25has stuck and I just wanted to I know
  280. 24:27it's important to her to bring this to
  281. 24:29your attention um the contributing
  282. 24:32factors in this case were multiple
  283. 24:35stress points um they converged all at
  284. 24:38the same time and um we are certainly
  285. 24:42not trying um to to uh say anything
  286. 24:47about you know the horrific of this
  287. 24:50crime it is and she was found guilty but
  288. 24:53we're trying to kind of maybe present to
  289. 24:55the parole board how how these
  290. 24:58um things developed and how it's
  291. 25:01possible that something like this could
  292. 25:03happen um one of the things that has
  293. 25:06been important in her life and I think
  294. 25:08is a um a huge contributor uh to this
  295. 25:12crime is the suicide of her dad at age
  296. 25:15six um horrific um just horrific and she
  297. 25:20was she blamed
  298. 25:23herself uh how could he leave me um and
  299. 25:27I think it sets the stage um for the
  300. 25:30beginning of some serious mental health
  301. 25:33issues some serious
  302. 25:35depression um which just kind of
  303. 25:37culminates and and continues to to
  304. 25:40snowball um and the lack of you know
  305. 25:43recognition and treatment for this issue
  306. 25:45with her dad I mean it was like uh the
  307. 25:48old stigma of um you know we just tough
  308. 25:52through these these terrible situations
  309. 25:55and you know that's how it's done um
  310. 25:58it's not done that way um there were
  311. 26:01some attempts to get some sort of
  312. 26:04psychological help for her after a
  313. 26:06couple of suicide attempts um and uh
  314. 26:11never R went anywhere she was the child
  315. 26:15um the adults in the picture um did not
  316. 26:19can't blame them I think it was the
  317. 26:21times uh did not seek and try to uh
  318. 26:25understand the depth and the
  319. 26:26significance of this and what it was
  320. 26:28going to produce um at a later date um
  321. 26:33severe
  322. 26:34depression
  323. 26:36um
  324. 26:37potentially um depression after um the
  325. 26:42birth of her last child um which was
  326. 26:45also
  327. 26:46undiagnosed and that postpartum
  328. 26:49depression that existed in a severe
  329. 26:52situation um just in culmination I
  330. 26:56apologize for reading something to the
  331. 26:58board but I've looked at so much
  332. 27:00material and if I can beg the board's uh
  333. 27:03attention for a few minutes I would like
  334. 27:05to say this and read this because I
  335. 27:08think it summarizes everything that I've
  336. 27:11been talking about and everything that
  337. 27:14um Susan uh wanted to talk about what
  338. 27:17happened um she said to me and this was
  339. 27:20not in preparation for parole I found
  340. 27:23this uh buried in a bunch of documents
  341. 27:26that had been provided to me and it is
  342. 27:29from Susan and she says I believe this
  343. 27:32is what happened to me on October 25th
  344. 27:361994 I lost touch with reality my
  345. 27:40thoughts were not rational nor logic I
  346. 27:44don't think I understood that if I
  347. 27:46allowed this car to go into the lake um
  348. 27:50that I would never see my children again
  349. 27:53the finality of it was not real to me
  350. 27:56because my thought were so screwed up at
  351. 27:58the time my mind I thought was doing
  352. 28:02what was best for them I knew Jesus
  353. 28:05would take better care of them than I
  354. 28:09could I was truly it was truly a moment
  355. 28:12of
  356. 28:13insanity there are no easy explanations
  357. 28:17and not um much understanding how can
  358. 28:21you make sense of something that is
  359. 28:24senseless and I think that um shows the
  360. 28:28remorse that she's had she's lived with
  361. 28:30this for forever since this thing um
  362. 28:34when I first met her and I would go and
  363. 28:36see her um remorse is difficult you know
  364. 28:40that's something with the parole
  365. 28:42hearings that I presented for years is
  366. 28:45to how do you say uh how do you
  367. 28:48demonstrate remorse um people do it in
  368. 28:51different manners and I always look for
  369. 28:53that I always ask my clients um you know
  370. 28:56and and look for the remorse I could see
  371. 28:58the pain on her face um it was so
  372. 29:03difficult um talking about things were
  373. 29:06extremely difficult and not because she
  374. 29:11didn't want to talk about them it's just
  375. 29:12because it was so hard to talk about
  376. 29:15them so I think that she is truly
  377. 29:17remorseful for what happened um and I
  378. 29:20think she would do anything in the world
  379. 29:23um to bring these children back but
  380. 29:27moving on to the next um consideration
  381. 29:30in this presentation is really changes
  382. 29:33what changes has she made in herself in
  383. 29:36prison one of the things I think is
  384. 29:37important is that she has no prior
  385. 29:39history um nothing that would lead up to
  386. 29:44believe that um someone would be capable
  387. 29:47of a crime of this nature which I think
  388. 29:49is also indicative of what their risk is
  389. 29:53if the board was um inclined to allow
  390. 29:57her to to participate on parole I don't
  391. 30:00think that was is a risk and I think
  392. 30:02that's what our um counselor who uh had
  393. 30:07seen her on a regular basis for a number
  394. 30:09of years also uh indicated that it was
  395. 30:12very low risk she's been IRC uh chairman
  396. 30:16uh W within the institution that means
  397. 30:19something um you're voted on by your
  398. 30:22peers and uh it is an honor um to be in
  399. 30:25that position she is a been a math tutor
  400. 30:28in education she's helped uh numerous
  401. 30:31inmates uh obtain their GED she's been
  402. 30:34in the character arts
  403. 30:36program uh prison fellowship which is I
  404. 30:39think is extremely important to her um
  405. 30:42she's much stronger in her faith um than
  406. 30:46she has ever been um and that is a
  407. 30:51comfort for her it's something that um
  408. 30:54that she enjoys is something that is
  409. 30:56extremely important jum start good
  410. 30:58program um she's been in that program um
  411. 31:02she would actually like to go to jump if
  412. 31:05the board would consider her um for
  413. 31:08parole um he has been out of the program
  414. 31:11for a couple of years and that would be
  415. 31:13she'd have to do some other things for
  416. 31:15that to happen so that's why we have
  417. 31:17chosen that um she would go and live
  418. 31:20with her brother good solid individual
  419. 31:23in the community willing to um uh help
  420. 31:27her in any manner and um one thing I've
  421. 31:32noticed from the family and friends is
  422. 31:35that we mourn with her um the pain of
  423. 31:41this crime but um we still love her and
  424. 31:45we're there for her um so she has that
  425. 31:49uh for her and uh which is a great
  426. 31:53resource if the board was going to
  427. 31:54consider um her for uh parole
  428. 31:58one of the other things I've noticed is
  429. 32:00giving back to the community uh arts and
  430. 32:02crafts she's made arts and crafts that
  431. 32:05she's donated to charity uh she's helped
  432. 32:08uh St judees um she's helped staff
  433. 32:12members she said that um an insight into
  434. 32:16what's going on with her um stand on her
  435. 32:20own two feet not to be influenced by
  436. 32:22others uh live a better life think
  437. 32:26before acting um and you know other
  438. 32:29people are affected by um your decisions
  439. 32:32and your actions and the importance of
  440. 32:34mental health I think that comes back
  441. 32:37into what we're talking about um it's
  442. 32:41not a it's not an excuse but it is
  443. 32:44certainly uh some indication or maybe
  444. 32:47explanation as to um what was going on
  445. 32:51um the goals and this is is my final
  446. 32:54area for my presentation is that
  447. 33:00um I don't think she'll ever be able to
  448. 33:02forgive
  449. 33:03herself um that is something that she
  450. 33:05struggles with forever I don't think
  451. 33:07that creates a danger to anyone except
  452. 33:10potentially maybe a danger to her um her
  453. 33:14medications her mental health
  454. 33:16medications have been um balanced well U
  455. 33:20by the Department of Corrections um I
  456. 33:23think she thinks as clear now as she
  457. 33:25ever has um I think think that she is
  458. 33:28able to establish goals and what she
  459. 33:32would like to do um in her life and and
  460. 33:36I think on the top of that list is to
  461. 33:38give back and to try to help others um
  462. 33:43she said that um no one should suffer um
  463. 33:47in the way that um uh in their treatment
  464. 33:51um there is there is help available and
  465. 33:55um she wants to help to get out and
  466. 33:58maybe help to promote that um that
  467. 34:01concept that there's help out there um
  468. 34:04you just have to seek it and um she said
  469. 34:07she'd like to live a quiet life she
  470. 34:10would welcome supervision uh if granted
  471. 34:12parole and maybe that is the best thing
  472. 34:15about this situation um from that type
  473. 34:18of um situation is that uh if she's
  474. 34:22granted parole um it is for life and she
  475. 34:26will be supervised and she will be
  476. 34:28monitored by the uh Department of
  477. 34:31Probation and Parole services for the
  478. 34:33rest of her life um she said that she
  479. 34:36would welcome that because that is
  480. 34:39another pillar of stability that is
  481. 34:42available for her that she can reach out
  482. 34:45to and she said that that would be a
  483. 34:48vital and instrumental part of her life
  484. 34:50she loves animals um she said that would
  485. 34:54like to find a job helping with dogs and
  486. 34:56cats I often ask my clients um if you
  487. 35:01could choose and you could make these
  488. 35:03wishes come true what would you like to
  489. 35:05do you know what is the job that you
  490. 35:08truly would enjoy often that's different
  491. 35:11um than the job that we have and um I
  492. 35:15think that job for Susan is the the Care
  493. 35:18for Animals and being involved in um in
  494. 35:23that area uh of help um
  495. 35:30in
  496. 35:31closing
  497. 35:36um I think that uh she has indicated to
  498. 35:40me that her desire is to um make her
  499. 35:45life mean
  500. 35:47something um something other than uh the
  501. 35:51things that that she has
  502. 35:53done um to make a positive impact in her
  503. 35:58life I talked to somebody I've spoken to
  504. 36:01a number of people and I've spoken to
  505. 36:03one person that told me um State they
  506. 36:09were at the
  507. 36:10trial and they said that their
  508. 36:13impression of Susan was that she was
  509. 36:16living to
  510. 36:17die um I didn't really understand that I
  511. 36:22think the more that I have uh been
  512. 36:27talking to her and preparing this case
  513. 36:29that um uh maybe I do um I think that
  514. 36:33has been Susan's life is living to die
  515. 36:39um for the things that she has done and
  516. 36:44um I think that what she's asking today
  517. 36:48is to board is to ask the board to
  518. 36:50consider a parole for her um so maybe
  519. 36:54she can make something positive
  520. 36:58um out of a um a horrific situation I
  521. 37:02want to thank you for your time I know
  522. 37:03I've taken a lot of time today um I
  523. 37:06would just ask if you would please um
  524. 37:08consider her for for
  525. 37:10release thank you Mr Thomas and we
  526. 37:13appreciate all and again thank you for
  527. 37:16the the very detailed packet that you
  528. 37:18presented Miss Smith ma'am what would
  529. 37:21you like to tell us today
  530. 37:28first of all I want to say how very
  531. 37:32sorry I am
  532. 37:47um it's okay Susan
  533. 37:50just
  534. 37:52just just talk with us
  535. 38:01I know that what I do was
  536. 38:08[Music]
  537. 38:08[Laughter]
  538. 38:15horrible and I give anything if I can go
  539. 38:18back and change
  540. 38:20it and I love Michael and Alice with all
  541. 38:24my heart
  542. 38:37were you under the influence of drugs or
  543. 38:39alcohol the night that you murdered your
  544. 38:43children no ma'am I was
  545. 38:46not your attorney your attorney talked
  546. 38:49about working with mental health is that
  547. 38:52helpful to
  548. 38:55you Ma'am
  549. 38:58Mr
  550. 38:59Thomas Mr Thomas talked about the fact
  551. 39:02that you were working with mental health
  552. 39:03and my question is is that helpful to
  553. 39:08you yes ma'am is that something that you
  554. 39:11would be willing to continue with on the
  555. 39:13outside if he were granted
  556. 39:18parole yes
  557. 39:22ma'am Miss Smith your crime took a lot
  558. 39:26of of resources is from the law
  559. 39:28enforcement Community what if anything
  560. 39:31would you say to the folks who worked so
  561. 39:34hard to find your children if you had
  562. 39:36the opportunity to speak to them
  563. 39:42today that I'm sorry that I put them
  564. 39:44through that I really really H and I'm
  565. 39:47especially sorry to the diers that I had
  566. 39:50to find
  567. 39:51them I wish I could take that thing I
  568. 39:54really do
  569. 39:57I was really I didn't lie to get away
  570. 40:01with it really didn't I was just
  571. 40:04scared I didn't know how I could tell
  572. 40:07the people that loved them that they
  573. 40:08would never see them
  574. 40:10again I didn't know how I could tell
  575. 40:12David he couldn't see his son
  576. 40:16again and I'm I'm I'm just I'm sorry I
  577. 40:20don't know I know that's not enough I
  578. 40:22know it's not but I don't know I know
  579. 40:26that's just how like words but they come
  580. 40:28from my heart they really
  581. 40:31do right one of the things that we
  582. 40:33review is your institutional record and
  583. 40:36you've had some infractions throughout
  584. 40:38the years um some involving um the use
  585. 40:43of some narcotics do you have any issues
  586. 40:46with drugs or alcohol at this
  587. 40:49point I don't no ma' I don't and you had
  588. 40:52a
  589. 40:53recent you had a recent disciplinary
  590. 40:56infraction just a few months
  591. 40:59ago so why should this board think that
  592. 41:03if we Grant you parole that you're going
  593. 41:05to go out and follow the rules and the
  594. 41:07laws of society if you do not follow the
  595. 41:11rules within the
  596. 41:16institution well this last
  597. 41:19infraction
  598. 41:22um I was trusted the wrong person this
  599. 41:25lady contacted me and I trusted her I
  600. 41:29thought she was going to do a
  601. 41:31documentary on mental health and I
  602. 41:34really am not guilty of what they what
  603. 41:36they charged me with and I have filed an
  604. 41:39appeal on that
  605. 41:41charge um and as far as your question
  606. 41:48um I've never been in trouble before and
  607. 41:51the things that I have been found guilty
  608. 41:53of in here
  609. 41:58have been just stupidity I just made I I
  610. 42:03know I made a lot of mistakes in here
  611. 42:05and I have learned from them and before
  612. 42:08this last infraction had been 10 years
  613. 42:11cuz I grew up and I knew that I needed
  614. 42:14to stop making dumb decisions and I did
  615. 42:18I I just I knew it was time to just to
  616. 42:22grow up and do the right thing I just
  617. 42:24made a lot of dumb choices and mistakes
  618. 42:28in here so I know I've learned from
  619. 42:31those
  620. 42:32mistakes what do you feel is the most
  621. 42:35that you've learned while you've been
  622. 42:38incarcerated ma'am what do you think is
  623. 42:41the most important thing that you have
  624. 42:42learned while you have been
  625. 42:48incarcerated that
  626. 42:52um that people are important that it's
  627. 42:58that forgiveness and love um that family
  628. 43:03is important and that decisions we make
  629. 43:06not just affect us they affect the
  630. 43:09people that we
  631. 43:11love and not to take things or people
  632. 43:13for
  633. 43:15granted all right is there anything else
  634. 43:18that you would like to tell us today
  635. 43:20that wasn't in your packet or that has
  636. 43:21not already been
  637. 43:25said um
  638. 43:27um I would just like to say that
  639. 43:32um I am a Christian and God is a big
  640. 43:36part of my life and I know he has
  641. 43:39forgiven
  642. 43:40me and it is by his grace and mercy that
  643. 43:44and I have a lot of faith and I live by
  644. 43:46that every day and I just ask that that
  645. 43:50you um show that same kind of Mercy as
  646. 43:54well um
  647. 43:59and I guess see yeah that's it thank you
  648. 44:04are there any other questions from the
  649. 44:08board Folks at Watkins I need each of
  650. 44:11you to please state your name for the
  651. 44:13record and your relationship to Miss
  652. 44:16Smith ma'am can we begin with you please
  653. 44:28what man St your name in the
  654. 44:32relationship I did not is it is it I yes
  655. 44:37uh I'm an Curry I'm a longterm friend
  656. 44:41and um
  657. 44:45supporter thank you Miss Curry and sir
  658. 44:47your name
  659. 44:50please and the I
  660. 44:54think your relationship name Rel okay uh
  661. 44:59I'm the Reverend Tom Curry uh I've known
  662. 45:04Susan briefly when she was a teenager
  663. 45:07when I was called in for one session
  664. 45:10each counseling about two different
  665. 45:13matters once by her teacher and once by
  666. 45:16Susan and I testified in her trial uh
  667. 45:21which the in the sentencing phase and I
  668. 45:25have kept up with her uh by writing
  669. 45:31her thank you we weekly for the last 30
  670. 45:35years I did this because I felt that she
  671. 45:40needed somebody to remind her that her
  672. 45:45whole life was not caught up in that one
  673. 45:49experience but that she could put her
  674. 45:53life back together because her life was
  675. 45:55in such ter more when all this happened
  676. 45:59and I think she's a different person now
  677. 46:01and that's what I want to talk about
  678. 46:03when I get a chance to say a word about
  679. 46:06it I have new hearing age and I can't
  680. 46:10always hear your questions but my mind's
  681. 46:13fine and uh I'm just retired pres
  682. 46:16Minister along well thank you Mr cry we
  683. 46:20appreciate that and you're welcome
  684. 46:22you're welcome to make your statement
  685. 46:24that you would like to make right now
  686. 46:28all right okay I want to start with her
  687. 46:31trial uh Mr Curry let me interrupt you
  688. 46:35before you get too far into that we are
  689. 46:37not here to retry her case in any form
  690. 46:40or fashion that is not the purpose of
  691. 46:43the parole board we are here to
  692. 46:45determine if she is a good candidate for
  693. 46:47parole and if so we would set the
  694. 46:49parameters of that parole but in no way
  695. 46:52can we discuss the trial or retry her
  696. 46:56case she was was convicted of two counts
  697. 46:58of murder if you'd like to speak to
  698. 47:00anything outside of that you're welcome
  699. 47:04to okay me now I just want to say two
  700. 47:08things about the trial I only went to
  701. 47:10the trial uh for one part of one morning
  702. 47:15to testify in the sentencing phe against
  703. 47:18the death penalty and the two things
  704. 47:20that I picked up for
  705. 47:29Tri itself was one a prison guard who
  706. 47:33came a female who said that uh she had
  707. 47:37not seen a a
  708. 47:40criminal as remor as Susan was uh and
  709. 47:46that she felt her remorse remorse for
  710. 47:48what she had done was genuine and the
  711. 47:51second thing was one of the jurors uh
  712. 47:54the prosecuting attorney was put pushing
  713. 47:57hard for the death penalty and the jury
  714. 47:59voted not and they voted life as you all
  715. 48:02have already mentioned but one of the
  716. 48:04juror said that she felt
  717. 48:08like that it would be harder for Susan
  718. 48:11to live with what she had done that to
  719. 48:16die and I thought that was a true
  720. 48:19statement and it certainly has been
  721. 48:21puruan during her 30 years in prison and
  722. 48:26especially the first part of her time
  723. 48:28that she was there it's been mentioned
  724. 48:30she attempted suicide several times and
  725. 48:34she had a couple of run-ins where guards
  726. 48:37were able to use her for their pleasure
  727. 48:41uh and uh that's a bad situation and uh
  728. 48:46was dealt with and she was not the only
  729. 48:48uh prisoner involved and thank you Mr
  730. 48:51Curry thank you for your
  731. 48:53comments thank you for your comments Mrs
  732. 48:56Curry do you wish to say
  733. 48:59anything um yes please and thank you for
  734. 49:02letting us speak I just want to say that
  735. 49:06I really think Susan is ready for Coro
  736. 49:09now she has surrounded herself with a
  737. 49:14caring support Community to that advises
  738. 49:18and encourages her and she listens to
  739. 49:23them as um Mr Thomas said said she has
  740. 49:28done everything she can to prepare
  741. 49:30herself to live outside of prison and
  742. 49:33taking courses in learning how to teach
  743. 49:37in caring about other people in working
  744. 49:39on teams and projects together and
  745. 49:44thirdly as um both of them have said she
  746. 49:49is not the young woman who went into
  747. 49:51prison 30 years ago she is much stronger
  748. 49:56she has grieved is still grieving will
  749. 49:59always
  750. 50:00grieve um but she's learned from it and
  751. 50:04she has
  752. 50:06experienced paralyzing remorse and
  753. 50:10survived today she wants to begin to
  754. 50:14rebuild her life and I hope you'll give
  755. 50:17her that chance I want to say one more
  756. 50:20word for the last two years now remember
  757. 50:23I wrote her for 30 years once a week
  758. 50:26pretty close today every week and that
  759. 50:29is the last two years I've ended my
  760. 50:32letters by saying Susan you live in a
  761. 50:35needy Place PR share God's love with
  762. 50:40those around you and with your other
  763. 50:42contacts but always live in Hope for
  764. 50:45your own future there is a time when you
  765. 50:49will live on your own
  766. 50:51again past prison and that's what I hope
  767. 50:54you all will give her the chance to do
  768. 50:56do at this time she is a very different
  769. 51:01person from what she was 30 years ago
  770. 51:06and I've probably been in contact with
  771. 51:08her talking about spiritual things but
  772. 51:12also talk just trying to enlarge her
  773. 51:15life by telling her about what's going
  774. 51:18on in the world around her and in the
  775. 51:21curry family she's the same age as one
  776. 51:24of my children all right thank you Mr
  777. 51:26Curry
  778. 51:27we appreciate all of your
  779. 51:29comments we appreciate all of your
  780. 51:31comments and all of the information Mr
  781. 51:33Thomas anything in closing
  782. 51:36sir no ma'am um nothing further than um
  783. 51:41I really um would ask the board to take
  784. 51:43the time to consider um Susan's request
  785. 51:46for um parole I do believe that if we
  786. 51:51look at uh insight into uh things that
  787. 51:55uh we've done and as far as things that
  788. 51:57um we need to do to um to get out of um
  789. 52:01Department Corrections and to try to
  790. 52:03make our life worthwhile or mean
  791. 52:05something I think Susan is at that point
  792. 52:08and uh I just again want to thank you
  793. 52:10for listening today and um and hope you
  794. 52:13would um consider our presentation thank
  795. 52:16you Mr Thomas thank you Miss Smith and
  796. 52:18thank you Mr Mrs Curry we certainly
  797. 52:20appreciate all of you joining us today
  798. 52:22if you all will please exit the rooms we
  799. 52:24will have an answer for you later today
  800. 52:26thank you for joining
  801. 52:28us thank you one moment as the room
  802. 52:40clears and the room is clear we do have
  803. 52:43additional testimony facilitated by the
  804. 52:44office of victim
  805. 52:47services please wait as all victims join
  806. 52:50from central office
  807. 53:10good
  808. 53:18afternoon you come on thank you
  809. 53:27can you may just a little further around
  810. 53:28so we can get everyone in thank you so
  811. 53:38much thank you good afternoon you all
  812. 53:42are here for the coral consideration
  813. 53:44case of Susan Smith is that correct yes
  814. 53:48we are so very very sorry for the
  815. 53:50circumstances that brought you all to be
  816. 53:52a part of this hearing today but we
  817. 53:55cannot tell you how much we appreciate
  818. 53:56you joining us and being here with us
  819. 53:58today thank you so much before we begin
  820. 54:02I do need each of you to please state
  821. 54:04your name for the record and your
  822. 54:06interest in this case sir can we begin
  823. 54:09with you please stand up you don't have
  824. 54:11to stand up you you do whatever is
  825. 54:13comfortable for you I'm David Smith I'm
  826. 54:16the father of Michael Al thank you Mr
  827. 54:19Smith and um Tiffany Smith I Am David
  828. 54:23Smith's
  829. 54:25wife I'm Rebecca Smith French I'm the
  830. 54:28aunt of Michael
  831. 54:30N I'm Savannah Smith and I am David's
  832. 54:33daughter of Michael N
  833. 54:34sister Austin Hughes I'm a friend of the
  834. 54:37victim family I'm Tommy v i was the
  835. 54:40solicitor in the original
  836. 54:42trial I'm Kevin bracket I'm the 16th
  837. 54:45circuit solicitor currently and was a
  838. 54:47prosecutor on the original
  839. 54:49case Laura Hudson with the Crime Victims
  840. 54:53councel Mark Reynolds I'm with the
  841. 54:55victims
  842. 54:57Bailey Bailey personal
  843. 54:59friend Kathy Bailey personal
  844. 55:02friend Jeff Bailey Sheriff Union
  845. 55:05County Scott coper Sheriff's Office
  846. 55:08Union County Michael cogal
  847. 55:11documentarian Swan
  848. 55:15andicha Doug Smith Dave's
  849. 55:18Uncle thank you all and again we are so
  850. 55:21very very sorry for the circumstances
  851. 55:24but thank you for being here with us
  852. 55:26today we do have the facts of the
  853. 55:29offense and we've heard from this SM now
  854. 55:31we want to hear from you all whether you
  855. 55:33were for or against parole and if anyone
  856. 55:37would like to make a statement you are
  857. 55:39certainly welcome to do so Mr Smith
  858. 55:42would you like to begin or would you
  859. 55:44like to conclude at the end it's
  860. 55:46completely up to
  861. 55:47me conclude at the end please who would
  862. 55:51like to speak first I'll speak first
  863. 55:53please ma'am thank you yes sir so I'm
  864. 55:57Tommy Pope I was the 16th circuit
  865. 55:59solicitor and um this was a death
  866. 56:01penalty case and the reason it was a
  867. 56:03death penalty case you know the
  868. 56:05solicitor has that discretion but the
  869. 56:06reason it was a death Mony case uh you
  870. 56:09know the facts and circumstances and I I
  871. 56:11just felt strongly that had the black
  872. 56:13man with the deogan committed the crime
  873. 56:16people would expect a death penalty if
  874. 56:18David Smith had committed the crime
  875. 56:21people would expected the death penalty
  876. 56:23and I thought it was very important that
  877. 56:25the Betrayal that Susan Smith showed
  878. 56:27that she be treated the same we knew it
  879. 56:29was going to be difficult we knew there
  880. 56:31was a likelihood of of not achieving the
  881. 56:33death penalty uh but I think it's
  882. 56:35important to note the jury at the time
  883. 56:37actually asked would what did life mean
  884. 56:40and and you may be aware but in that
  885. 56:42time life did not mean life life became
  886. 56:44life in 96 we tried the case in 95 um so
  887. 56:48the jury was asking the judge was
  888. 56:50required to instruct the jury that you
  889. 56:52take life and death in its plain and
  890. 56:54usual meaning caring that forward the
  891. 56:57jury showed her mercy the jury gave her
  892. 56:59the life sentence but one of the jurors
  893. 57:01or more of the jurors after the fact and
  894. 57:03speaking to the media said that they
  895. 57:06believed the life sentence was the
  896. 57:08greater punishment because they believed
  897. 57:11that Susan should have to reflect on
  898. 57:13what she did to Michael and Alex that
  899. 57:16she should have to spend the rest of her
  900. 57:18life uh thinking about what she' done
  901. 57:21the two fallacies in that logic that the
  902. 57:23jury could not have known are number one
  903. 57:25obviously here today so life did not
  904. 57:27mean life uh number two and you have it
  905. 57:30before you Susan's conduct from the day
  906. 57:33she rolled the kids in the lake the
  907. 57:35defense claimed a a botch suicide but
  908. 57:38she was able to save herself she was
  909. 57:40able to blame a black guy she wasn't wet
  910. 57:42she wasn't injured when she runs to the
  911. 57:44house and concocts his story Susan has
  912. 57:47always focused on Susan I will believe
  913. 57:50to to the end of my time that Susan made
  914. 57:53a horrible horrible choice to choose a
  915. 57:56man over her family I said the boys were
  916. 57:59in the car her wedding gown was in the
  917. 58:01car her wedding album was in the car she
  918. 58:04thought in a nice packet she could roll
  919. 58:06that away if she could have put David in
  920. 58:08the car he would have been there too she
  921. 58:09in a nice packet she could roll that
  922. 58:33away and start this new life with this
  923. 58:35other man and she led everyone on
  924. 58:37including David for nine horrible days
  925. 58:40and so as you look at her conduct in
  926. 58:42prison whether it was a relationship
  927. 58:44with guards um the social media the
  928. 58:48attention uh the conduct recently with
  929. 58:50the the publisher um Susan you know
  930. 58:53she's got people outside I'm sure you've
  931. 58:55heard from them that want to take care
  932. 58:57of her Susan has always focused on
  933. 59:00what's best for Susan and so the
  934. 59:02evidence that you have before you I
  935. 59:03think tells clearly that she has not
  936. 59:06focused on Michael and Alex she only has
  937. 59:09and continues to focus on herself and so
  938. 59:12on behalf of this family on behalf of
  939. 59:14justice and the justice for this case
  940. 59:17it's not about her behavior or what she
  941. 59:19would do when getting out but I know one
  942. 59:21of your criteria is the nature of the
  943. 59:23crime and whether the punishment is
  944. 59:25there and I would submit for the crime
  945. 59:27she committed the actions she committed
  946. 59:29that punishment has not been achieved
  947. 59:31yet and so I would ask you to deny
  948. 59:33perole now I thank you for your time
  949. 59:35thank rep appreciate
  950. 59:38it would anyone else like to
  951. 59:41speak yes yes sir Madam chairman uh
  952. 59:45chair lady and members of the board
  953. 59:47thank you so much for giving me the
  954. 59:48opportunity to speak here today I was on
  955. 59:50the prosecution team that handled the
  956. 59:53prosecution along with uh solic Pope and
  957. 59:56speaker pope now uh who you just heard
  958. 59:59from I wanted to bring to you a a couple
  959. 1:00:02of vignettes from the case to help bring
  960. 1:00:05this alive for you um in the course of
  961. 1:00:08preparing for today I've gone back over
  962. 1:00:10the case I've reviewed the file I pulled
  963. 1:00:13some of the evidence out which is in a
  964. 1:00:14closet just off my office evidence like
  965. 1:00:17the note that was written uh to Susan
  966. 1:00:20Smith by her her boyfriend the man she
  967. 1:00:22was cheating on her husband with who
  968. 1:00:24told her in the note that
  969. 1:00:26he could not be with her anymore because
  970. 1:00:28he didn't want children and that they
  971. 1:00:30had no long-term future because he
  972. 1:00:32didn't want children and then one week
  973. 1:00:34later she's rolling her car down the
  974. 1:00:37ramp at John D long lake with her two
  975. 1:00:39children strapped into the back she
  976. 1:00:41betrayed her husband when she cheated on
  977. 1:00:43him and she betrayed her
  978. 1:00:47children against the laws of
  979. 1:00:50nature when she should have been sworn
  980. 1:00:52to protect those children she betrayed
  981. 1:00:56them when she left them in the seat and
  982. 1:00:58rolled that car down and she was not
  983. 1:01:00trying to commit suicide she was trying
  984. 1:01:02to change her life she wanted to kill
  985. 1:01:03her old life and start a new she was
  986. 1:01:06wearing a sweatshirt that the man who
  987. 1:01:09she was cheating with had given to her
  988. 1:01:11when she was on TV two hours later after
  989. 1:01:15claiming that a black man in a tobogan
  990. 1:01:17had carjacked her and spirited her two
  991. 1:01:20children away how many black men in red
  992. 1:01:23Mazdas got pulled over across the
  993. 1:01:26country because they were looking for
  994. 1:01:28those two kids and they were looking for
  995. 1:01:29this fictitious man that didn't exist
  996. 1:01:32purely a figment of her
  997. 1:01:34imagination I was on the banks of John D
  998. 1:01:36long lake standing there with about 40
  999. 1:01:39or 45 people 50 people as the tow truck
  1000. 1:01:43from Greer's wrecker launched its line
  1001. 1:01:46into the water where divers hooked it up
  1002. 1:01:48to the car and pulled it
  1003. 1:01:50out total silence as that car emerged
  1004. 1:01:53from the Dark Water everybody sitting
  1005. 1:01:56there hoping and praying that maybe it
  1006. 1:01:58was a different car maybe it was a wrong
  1007. 1:02:00car maybe the kids weren't in there not
  1008. 1:02:03a word was said it was one of the most
  1009. 1:02:06haunting memories of my life and it will
  1010. 1:02:07live with me forever and that's the last
  1011. 1:02:10point I want to
  1012. 1:02:12make you're going to hear from this man
  1013. 1:02:15and he's going to tell you what this did
  1014. 1:02:17to
  1015. 1:02:19him I can't begin to describe it I sat
  1016. 1:02:22in court and listened to him testify and
  1017. 1:02:24it was heart-wrenching he described that
  1018. 1:02:26his hopes and dreams for the future were
  1019. 1:02:29destroyed that night when she killed
  1020. 1:02:32their two
  1021. 1:02:34children this didn't just traumatize him
  1022. 1:02:37it
  1023. 1:02:38traumatized Union it traumatized South
  1024. 1:02:41Carolina the entire country was in the
  1025. 1:02:45grips of her lie and her
  1026. 1:02:49treachery the entire country this was a
  1027. 1:02:52global sensation people were fixated on
  1028. 1:03:00this they're not the only victims and on
  1029. 1:03:03behalf of the community that I represent
  1030. 1:03:06now I don't believe she should ever be
  1031. 1:03:09released from jail until the last person
  1032. 1:03:13alive who remembers Michael and Alex is
  1033. 1:03:16dead and that will not be in her
  1034. 1:03:19lifetime she should never be released
  1035. 1:03:21and she should not be released now his
  1036. 1:03:24hopes and dreams were dashed I hope you
  1037. 1:03:26dash hers today and every two years here
  1038. 1:03:37after thank
  1039. 1:03:40you do anyone else wish to
  1040. 1:03:48speak
  1041. 1:03:50okay you're welcome to stay seated if
  1042. 1:03:53you're more comfortable whatever's best
  1043. 1:03:54for you thank you
  1044. 1:04:00I want to read what I wrote okay e you
  1045. 1:04:03don't mind when Susan murdered Michael
  1046. 1:04:05and Alex she altered the course of my
  1047. 1:04:08life and my family's life forever having
  1048. 1:04:11grown up with three older brothers Susan
  1049. 1:04:13was like the sister I never had I was a
  1050. 1:04:16teenage mom of just 16 so I looked up to
  1051. 1:04:19her and even admired her I thought she
  1052. 1:04:22was the best mother to the boys and I
  1053. 1:04:24strived to be just like her I would even
  1054. 1:04:26leave my own daughter with her while
  1055. 1:04:28attended night school Susan betrayed us
  1056. 1:04:31and took the lives of those boys and
  1057. 1:04:32then lied about it for days when she did
  1058. 1:04:36this she destroyed a trust in me that
  1059. 1:04:38I've never regained and as a result I do
  1060. 1:04:40not develop close relationships with
  1061. 1:04:42others easily in particular
  1062. 1:04:45females anxiety and depression have
  1063. 1:04:47plagued my life for years I push it away
  1064. 1:04:49during spring and summer as best
  1065. 1:04:51possible but it always creeps back
  1066. 1:04:54during back up around Alex's birthday
  1067. 1:04:56when it rolls around in August because I
  1068. 1:04:58know Michaels won't be far behind in
  1069. 1:05:01October and then the anniversary of
  1070. 1:05:03their death on the 25th cuz in my mind
  1071. 1:05:06it always refer to this period of time
  1072. 1:05:08as a sad
  1073. 1:05:09months throughout my career the majority
  1074. 1:05:12of any time missed at work is around
  1075. 1:05:15Michael Alex's birthdays and the
  1076. 1:05:17anniversary of their
  1077. 1:05:19death I stay in bed and sleep to deal
  1078. 1:05:22with the depression it's just easier
  1079. 1:05:25this way or at least it seems to
  1080. 1:05:29be something as simple as taking up a
  1081. 1:05:32new hobby turned into a nightmare for me
  1082. 1:05:34last year my boyfriend and I decided to
  1083. 1:05:36take scuba diving lessons I geared up
  1084. 1:05:39with all the equipment face mask on
  1085. 1:05:41oxygen tank on my back stepped off the
  1086. 1:05:44side of the pool into 15 ft of water and
  1087. 1:05:46immediately sank to the bottom from all
  1088. 1:05:49the weight I was caring normally you'd
  1089. 1:05:51remember to breathe and begin to ascend
  1090. 1:05:54as I had studied for all the the week
  1091. 1:05:55leading up to that point but nothing
  1092. 1:05:58prepared me for dropping into a body of
  1093. 1:06:00water and the feeling of being waited
  1094. 1:06:02down unable to breathe and seeing
  1095. 1:06:05Michael Alex's
  1096. 1:06:07face I immediately Panic ripping off my
  1097. 1:06:10face mask sucking in water and not being
  1098. 1:06:12able to come to the surface from all the
  1099. 1:06:13weight I was carrying I was drowning and
  1100. 1:06:17I knew in that moment that was the
  1101. 1:06:19closest I'd ever come to KN what my
  1102. 1:06:22nephews had endured and how her terrific
  1103. 1:06:25and scared their last moments had to
  1104. 1:06:28have B something as simple as taking up
  1105. 1:06:31a new hobby was yet one more thing Susan
  1106. 1:06:34was taken from
  1107. 1:06:36me in over 25 years I have found myself
  1108. 1:06:40finding Comfort going to the cemetery
  1109. 1:06:42where the boys are buried beside our
  1110. 1:06:44older brother I go there often and I'll
  1111. 1:06:47tidy up their graves where people have
  1112. 1:06:49left trinkets or gifts and I
  1113. 1:06:57talk to them I go there when I'm happy I
  1114. 1:07:00go there when I'm upset rainy days sunny
  1115. 1:07:04days cold days and hot days it doesn't
  1116. 1:07:07matter it brings me peace just being
  1117. 1:07:10there but as a result I'm I'm not able
  1118. 1:07:14to bring myself to move away from Union
  1119. 1:07:16County because now I don't want to leave
  1120. 1:07:20them we have missed Michael KN his
  1121. 1:07:23kindergarten
  1122. 1:07:24graduations humous birthdays birthday
  1123. 1:07:27parties summer vacations
  1124. 1:07:30easers along with annual Easter hunt egg
  1125. 1:07:33hunts at M malls thanksgivings
  1126. 1:07:36Christmases football soccer baseball
  1127. 1:07:38games
  1128. 1:07:39proms High School graduations possible
  1129. 1:07:44marriages and births of their own
  1130. 1:07:46children we don't
  1131. 1:07:48know because they never had a
  1132. 1:07:52chance they never had a chance to live a
  1133. 1:07:55life of their own Susan took that from
  1134. 1:07:58them she took that from us
  1135. 1:08:02all and now she wants a chance to be
  1136. 1:08:04free after only serving 30
  1137. 1:08:08years
  1138. 1:08:09no life should mean
  1139. 1:08:13life I'm respectfully asking you to
  1140. 1:08:16please not her request for
  1141. 1:08:18p thank you thank you ma'
  1142. 1:08:28I apologize if I get a little bit
  1143. 1:08:30emotional uh I drove down from
  1144. 1:08:35Detroit on Monday night which was
  1145. 1:08:37Halloween before uh of that week and um
  1146. 1:08:42young man middle-aged man then I'm an
  1147. 1:08:44old man now but the boys never got
  1148. 1:08:50to as Becky said they missed they missed
  1149. 1:08:53a lot they missed her life
  1150. 1:08:56today they would be in their 30s David
  1151. 1:08:59would probably be a Granddad the boys
  1152. 1:09:02were still
  1153. 1:09:03here I took my sister out to the lake
  1154. 1:09:07yesterday and it's a beautiful drive out
  1155. 1:09:10there I just
  1156. 1:09:12thinking all the all that time she had
  1157. 1:09:15time to change her mind to stop and turn
  1158. 1:09:18around and not go through with it but
  1159. 1:09:20she
  1160. 1:09:21did and then the boys were gone a year
  1161. 1:09:24later came back down for the trial Tommy
  1162. 1:09:29pope did a good job that proved that she
  1163. 1:09:32was
  1164. 1:09:34guilty during the sentence and trial
  1165. 1:09:38they came back and recommended life
  1166. 1:09:42Tommy had argued for for death penalty
  1167. 1:09:45the family was for death penalty they
  1168. 1:09:47come back and recommend a life but we we
  1169. 1:09:51said well we'll live with
  1170. 1:09:53it you know she'll have to live with it
  1171. 1:09:55for the every day for the rest of her
  1172. 1:09:57life so we were we were satisfied with
  1173. 1:10:01life but we do not want a Paro against
  1174. 1:10:05any parole for her and then two other
  1175. 1:10:08items going back 30 years the the Friday
  1176. 1:10:11morning
  1177. 1:10:23after apologize
  1178. 1:10:31but the Friday morning after David his
  1179. 1:10:34dad my brother's wife and and I the four
  1180. 1:10:37of us were sitting at hul funeral home
  1181. 1:10:40and
  1182. 1:10:41Union and uh discussing the funeral
  1183. 1:10:44arrangements David asked to see the
  1184. 1:10:46boys and Mr hulkin had a funny look on
  1185. 1:10:50his face and he he said Mr Smith could I
  1186. 1:10:53see you
  1187. 1:11:02so we we went out and he said you know
  1188. 1:11:06your nephew can't see the voice and he
  1189. 1:11:09told me why he said you know the boys
  1190. 1:11:11were in the water for N9
  1191. 1:11:19days so I went back and told David I
  1192. 1:11:23said you know you better that you don't
  1193. 1:11:25see the
  1194. 1:11:26boys and I think deep down he understood
  1195. 1:11:38why the next day Saturday three of us
  1196. 1:11:42David his dad and I went out to the uh
  1197. 1:11:44banville United Methodist Church
  1198. 1:11:48Cemetery and to look where the boys are
  1199. 1:11:50going to be buried and David's brother
  1200. 1:11:54Danny who who had died 3 years earlier
  1201. 1:11:56was buried there David one of his boys
  1202. 1:11:59buried next to his his uh brother their
  1203. 1:12:02uncle but the way the cemetery is laid
  1204. 1:12:05out there was no room for for the boys
  1205. 1:12:08to be put next to
  1206. 1:12:19Danny so I found the uh the uh Cemetery
  1207. 1:12:25estan and asked him it were possible to
  1208. 1:12:29move
  1209. 1:12:30Danny and he said well yes if that's
  1210. 1:12:32what the family wants we can move
  1211. 1:12:34Danny so I went back and told my
  1212. 1:12:39brother said you know David wants the
  1213. 1:12:41boys be next to their Uncle would you
  1214. 1:12:44have a problem if we move Danny
  1215. 1:12:56and he said
  1216. 1:12:57no so if you go out to the cemetery
  1217. 1:13:02you'll find that Danny and the boys are
  1218. 1:13:05side by
  1219. 1:13:14side does anyone else wish to speak
  1220. 1:13:20yese
  1221. 1:13:22um so as as David
  1222. 1:13:25wife I have stood by him for the last 30
  1223. 1:13:28years and watched his pain his
  1224. 1:13:32suffering his dark days that you cannot
  1225. 1:13:39imagine it's been hard as a loving wife
  1226. 1:13:43to stand back and watch him suffer the
  1227. 1:13:46pain that he has gone
  1228. 1:13:49through to not want to get out of bed
  1229. 1:13:51some days
  1230. 1:13:55to not be able to get out of
  1231. 1:14:01bed because the pain was so much for
  1232. 1:14:09him and for 30 years we had thought this
  1233. 1:14:12day would never come but yeah here we
  1234. 1:14:19are I don't feel that that it's time for
  1235. 1:14:22her to be let out because she took two
  1236. 1:14:25lives she didn't just take one she took
  1237. 1:14:28two gracious little
  1238. 1:14:30boys that we haven't been able to watch
  1239. 1:14:33grow
  1240. 1:14:36up and it's Becky stated earlier all the
  1241. 1:14:39things that we've missed out on because
  1242. 1:14:41of them not being here all the things
  1243. 1:14:44they missed out on growing up in and
  1244. 1:14:48doing
  1245. 1:14:56and for her to be in prison for the last
  1246. 1:14:5930 years you would think that she would
  1247. 1:15:00have thought about what she's done she
  1248. 1:15:03would have said I'm sorry but she hasn't
  1249. 1:15:05said I'm sorry she hasn't even called
  1250. 1:15:08him hasn't even told him she was
  1251. 1:15:12sorry much less the
  1252. 1:15:14world for nine days all I can think
  1253. 1:15:17about is how much she
  1254. 1:15:19lied and manipulated
  1255. 1:15:22everybody the whole world I watched it
  1256. 1:15:25and believed her
  1257. 1:15:29myself I wanted her to be telling the
  1258. 1:15:34truth but to be betrayed by her
  1259. 1:15:38lies and that just makes me feel like if
  1260. 1:15:41she could do that then whatever she's
  1261. 1:15:43told you today I'm sure will probably
  1262. 1:15:45lies as
  1263. 1:15:47well because she has shown in her last
  1264. 1:15:5030 years what she does in prison she's
  1265. 1:15:53all about herself
  1266. 1:15:55is all about what she can do to to make
  1267. 1:15:58her life
  1268. 1:16:04better Michael and Alex didn't get a
  1269. 1:16:07chance at life they were forced to death
  1270. 1:16:12penalty she took that from
  1271. 1:16:23them the lives of this family has been
  1272. 1:16:25forever
  1273. 1:16:29changed it caused us to be a little
  1274. 1:16:31overprotective of our now
  1275. 1:16:33daughter little bit more than we
  1276. 1:16:35probably should have
  1277. 1:16:38been because we were afraid something
  1278. 1:16:40might happened to
  1279. 1:16:46her it's changed the way we look at life
  1280. 1:16:49has changed the way that we look
  1281. 1:16:51at everybody who can I trust
  1282. 1:16:56for a long time I didn't trust a lot of
  1283. 1:16:57people I had to be careful you know
  1284. 1:17:00around certain people I didn't know if I
  1285. 1:17:02could trust them or
  1286. 1:17:03not all because of her
  1287. 1:17:13lies so to help give us to give this
  1288. 1:17:16family some
  1289. 1:17:18peace it would be best if Susan stayed
  1290. 1:17:20behind
  1291. 1:17:23bars and stay in prison for the rest of
  1292. 1:17:26her
  1293. 1:17:27life I respectfully ask you to keep her
  1294. 1:17:30in thank you thank
  1295. 1:17:37you does anyone else wish to speak for
  1296. 1:17:41Mr SMI she
  1297. 1:17:48anyone forgive me
  1298. 1:17:55most of what I have to say is going to
  1299. 1:17:57be pretty
  1300. 1:18:01redundant but
  1301. 1:18:04um primarily I would just like to focus
  1302. 1:18:10on since I came after the
  1303. 1:18:13fact what I had stolen from
  1304. 1:18:16me was two older
  1305. 1:18:19brothers the good and the bad of having
  1306. 1:18:21older siblings
  1307. 1:18:27and I now try to use my
  1308. 1:18:31life as a way to live for
  1309. 1:18:35them and growing
  1310. 1:18:38up I didn't quite understand it my whole
  1311. 1:18:40life but when I finally
  1312. 1:18:42did I felt like I had witnessed it like
  1313. 1:18:45I was
  1314. 1:18:47there the pain that Not only was caused
  1315. 1:18:49to
  1316. 1:18:51me and
  1317. 1:18:55like a domino effect but what I have
  1318. 1:18:57seen
  1319. 1:18:58firsthand with my father my
  1320. 1:19:03aunt and our whole
  1321. 1:19:08Hometown we can no longer say that we're
  1322. 1:19:11from Union County without Susan's
  1323. 1:19:13actions being brought
  1324. 1:19:20up and just for the sake of all of us
  1325. 1:19:24and our whole Community I asked that you
  1326. 1:19:26deny her
  1327. 1:19:34request Mr Smith you're welcome to stay
  1328. 1:19:38seated if you
  1329. 1:19:45are Madam chairman members of the
  1330. 1:19:48committee
  1331. 1:19:55it's been a tough 30
  1332. 1:19:58years
  1333. 1:20:01um I'm not here to speak about what
  1334. 1:20:04she's done in prison you all have the
  1335. 1:20:08records and accounts of all
  1336. 1:20:10that just here to
  1337. 1:20:12Advocate on Michael Alex's
  1338. 1:20:16behalf and as their
  1339. 1:20:22father you know
  1340. 1:20:25God gives us free
  1341. 1:20:27choice and she made free choice at night
  1342. 1:20:31to end her life this wasn't a tragic
  1343. 1:20:35mistake wasn't something that she didn't
  1344. 1:20:38mean to do she
  1345. 1:20:43purposly meant to end their
  1346. 1:20:48life I
  1347. 1:20:49never have felt any remorse from her for
  1348. 1:20:53it she never express any to me I've
  1349. 1:20:56never seen it on
  1350. 1:21:00paper
  1351. 1:21:06um now she you've heard she changed my
  1352. 1:21:10life for the rest of my life that night
  1353. 1:21:25some for the better some for the worse
  1354. 1:21:33but but what she did not only to Michael
  1355. 1:21:37and
  1356. 1:21:40Alex she came pretty
  1357. 1:21:43close to causing me to end my
  1358. 1:21:46life because of the grief that she
  1359. 1:21:49brought upon
  1360. 1:21:53me but thank she
  1361. 1:21:58didn't I understand back
  1362. 1:22:02in
  1363. 1:22:0495 that through the state's
  1364. 1:22:07law life impr prisonment 30 years to
  1365. 1:22:12life and now that's different but at
  1366. 1:22:14that time that's what counts I
  1367. 1:22:17understand
  1368. 1:22:22that but ultimately to me that's only 15
  1369. 1:22:27years per
  1370. 1:22:29child her own
  1371. 1:22:34children it's just not
  1372. 1:22:39enough so I'm asking that you
  1373. 1:22:42please do not hurt PE
  1374. 1:22:48today and hopefully in the future but
  1375. 1:22:51specifically today
  1376. 1:22:55not let her
  1377. 1:22:58out I miss him very
  1378. 1:23:01much and I love them very
  1379. 1:23:04much and I will be here every two years
  1380. 1:23:08going
  1381. 1:23:10forward to ensure
  1382. 1:23:13that your death doesn't go in
  1383. 1:23:16V thank
  1384. 1:23:19you thank you so much Mr SMI
  1385. 1:23:25again please know how very very sorry
  1386. 1:23:28this board is to all of you for all the
  1387. 1:23:32pain that this CRM caused you but we
  1388. 1:23:36sincerely appreciate you all being here
  1389. 1:23:38with us today thank you very much and
  1390. 1:23:41thank you for the reminder with the
  1391. 1:23:44picture of Alex and Michael they were
  1392. 1:23:46beautiful
  1393. 1:23:49children say thank you for reminding us
  1394. 1:23:51of that
  1395. 1:23:53today we wish the very best and if no
  1396. 1:23:57one else has anything else that they
  1397. 1:23:58would like to say if you all will exit
  1398. 1:24:01with these ladies over here we'll have
  1399. 1:24:02an answer for you
  1400. 1:24:04shortly thank you so much for being here
  1401. 1:24:44the room is clear
  1402. 1:24:55as a reminder Mrs Mir did recuse
  1403. 1:24:59herself Miss Sean Smith is Deni parole
  1404. 1:25:03the vote is unanimous numbers one and
  1405. 1:25:06six thank
  1406. 1:25:11you thank you the time now is 12:51 p.m.
  1407. 1:25:15we will pause our recording Miss Hunter
  1408. 1:25:18if you can advise when the recording has
  1409. 1:25:20been
  1410. 1:25:22paused the recording has been paused
  1411. 1:25:25thank you so much thank you so much this
  1412. 1:25:27is Valerie sub associate deputy director
  1413. 1:25:29for pearls pards and relief services if
  1414. 1:25:31everyone would just give me a moment to
  1415. 1:25:33give some instructions as the room
  1416. 1:25:35clears from the board I would like for
  1417. 1:25:37media to pay attention you are given the
  1418. 1:25:41next 15 minutes for bathroom break
  1419. 1:25:43please use the restroom prepare
  1420. 1:25:45yourselves for the press conference we
  1421. 1:25:47will allow you into the building
  1422. 1:25:48beginning 15 minutes from now once we
  1423. 1:25:50check you in we'll start the press
  1424. 1:25:52conference once everybody is inside if
  1425. 1:25:54there are any questions please address
  1426. 1:25:56it to the staff and we'll get you an
  1427. 1:25:57answer as quickly as possible again
  1428. 1:25:59there is 15 minutes between the time we
  1429. 1:26:02are ending this and beginning entrance
  1430. 1:26:05back into the building anybody who is in
  1431. 1:26:07the building who needs to leave and get
  1432. 1:26:09their cameras or phones are allowed to
  1433. 1:26:11do so during that 15minute period and
  1434. 1:26:13then check back in at the front door
  1435. 1:26:15thank you all so much and the board will
  1436. 1:26:16be at recess for
  1437. 1:26:17lunch thank you
  1438. 1:26:24sh
  1439. 1:27:05[Music]
  1440. 1:27:12the systems rig man it's time to break
  1441. 1:27:14free Eyes Wide Open got to see what I
  1442. 1:27:17see standing on the flood lines fighting
  1443. 1:27:19for the truth lift the veil of Lies it's
  1444. 1:27:21time to be the proof take us stand don't
  1445. 1:27:25you back down back down Raise Your Voice
  1446. 1:27:30let's shake the
  1447. 1:27:32town we're the voices that won't be
  1448. 1:27:37ignored Breaking Chains yeah we're ready
  1449. 1:27:43forward with the power
  1450. 1:27:51[Music]
  1451. 1:27:58the systems Rigg man it's time to break
  1452. 1:28:00free Eyes Wide Open got to see

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of LIVE: Killer Susan Smith Fights to Get Out of Prison — Parole Hearing by Justice Is A Process!!!!, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,756 words across 1,452 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.