Links vs. Rechts: Wie Deutschland sich spaltet. Mit Christoph Werner (dm-Chef) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The second thing that has been added is
- 0:02a kind of affective polarization. That
- 0:05means we say, I don't even need to talk
- 0:07to that person. If you hold that
- 0:09opinion, you're a nutcase anyway, and
- 0:12so I don't need to listen to it. So the
- 0:15mere fact that the opinion comes from
- 0:17this person means I won't even engage
- 0:18with it anymore. And that is of course
- 0:22a real problem, because then we start
- 0:24surrounding ourselves only with
- 0:25opinions we find agreeable. But it is
- 0:29precisely by reflecting on other
- 0:30opinions that we can arrive at new
- 0:32points of view. One gets the feeling
- 0:36that society is becoming increasingly
- 0:39political and polarized, and often
- 0:41people are drawn into debates they
- 0:43never intended to be part of or didn't
- 0:45want at all. This affects ordinary
- 0:48citizens just as much as corporate
- 0:50leaders. One of them is Christoph
- 0:52Werner, head of Europe's largest
- 0:54drugstore chain, DM. The left-wing
- 0:57organization Campact put him in the
- 0:59pillory because, as an entrepreneur, he
- 1:01held—and continues to hold—a
- 1:03somewhat different stance on the "
- 1:05firewall" than the mainstream. Today,
- 1:08Christoph Werner is my guest on the
- 1:10podcast, and I want to talk to him
- 1:12about all of this, about Campact, the
- 1:15firewall in the economy, and of course
- 1:17Germany as a business location. Hello,
- 1:20Mr. Werner. It's nice to have you here.
- 1:22Hello, Mr. Ronzheimer, it's nice to be
- 1:23here with you.
- 1:25Mr. Werner, Campact chose around 60
- 1:28YouTube channels in August, which the
- 1:31organization labeled as so-called hate
- 1:34channels, and called on companies to
- 1:37stop running advertisements there.
- 1:42Campact then publicly declared that DM
- 1:44was among those companies that would
- 1:47adjust their blocklists and react
- 1:49accordingly. You later contradicted
- 1:53this account. Could you explain from
- 1:56your perspective, for those who haven't
- 1:58heard anything about this, what has
- 2:00happened from your point of view over
- 2:02the past weeks and months?
- 2:04Yes, I am happy to summarize. So, what
- 2:07it was about was the serving of
- 2:09advertisements on YouTube channels. You
- 2:13have to know that serving ads on
- 2:14YouTube channels is different from what
- 2:16it's like in other classic media. When
- 2:19you advertise, you generally buy
- 2:21broadcast slots. So the program is
- 2:24known, and then you decide which slots
- 2:26you want to buy depending on the target
- 2:28groups you want to reach. On YouTube,
- 2:31it's a bit different. It's not that you
- 2:33buy specific broadcast slots, but
- 2:36rather that Google's algorithm serves
- 2:38the ad clips. So, if you watch
- 2:40something on YouTube and then an ad
- 2:42comes up—which we all know—it
- 2:44wasn't specifically booked, but is
- 2:46served by the algorithm according to
- 2:48some criteria. That means, as an
- 2:51advertiser, you cannot influence it
- 2:53directly. You can only say that you
- 2:55want to block certain channels to avoid
- 2:58being shown there. So that is the big
- 3:00picture. And then there was a letter,
- 3:04where over 60 channels were mentioned
- 3:07by this NGO that were classified as
- 3:10right-wing hate speech. And companies
- 3:14were asked to block them or to revise
- 3:17their blocklists. And at dm-drogerie
- 3:19markt, it works like this: When we are
- 3:21contacted, we naturally take a look at
- 3:22it. And so we looked at those 60
- 3:25channels, or rather the team that is
- 3:27responsible for that did. And there
- 3:30were some among them that were indeed
- 3:32abysmal, and that is why we then
- 3:34reported, in response to the questions
- 3:36we were asked, that we had indeed
- 3:38revised our list. Following that, the
- 3:43NGO announced in a press release that
- 3:45many companies had joined this campaign
- 3:48, and we were mentioned there as well.
- 3:53Yes, the challenge now was the
- 3:55interpretation, meaning all, some, or a
- 3:58few. Uh, and that got mixed up, which
- 4:02led to talk that we had adopted it
- 4:05entirely just because it came from this
- 4:07NGO, which was not the case, because we
- 4:10reviewed it again according to our own
- 4:13criteria and then simply adjusted our
- 4:15blocklist.
- 4:18Just so that people understand, how
- 4:19does something like that work? So, uh,
- 4:22first for those who don't know Campact,
- 4:25uh, what kind of organization is it
- 4:28from your perspective, and how does it
- 4:31happen that this organization contacts
- 4:34companies like yours and such a
- 4:36situation arises? Is this a normal
- 4:39procedure? Does it happen often, uh,
- 4:42that associations or groups contact you
- 4:44and ask you, for example, not to
- 4:46advertise somewhere anymore, or is this
- 4:48a rather unusual situation? Yes, I
- 4:51would say it doesn't happen every
- 4:53single day, but it does happen, and in
- 4:55my assessment, it is part of a
- 4:57pluralistic society. So there are
- 5:00different opinions, there are
- 5:02initiatives that advocate for certain
- 5:03causes, and that is absolutely fine.
- 5:07And that they approach companies with
- 5:09ideas, wishes, and demands is also part
- 5:12of it. I think the decisive factor is
- 5:14that, as someone responsible, I have to
- 5:16ask myself, and we as a company have to
- 5:18ask ourselves, how do we handle this
- 5:19now? And we then have to do what we
- 5:22consider to be right. Things get
- 5:24difficult when it turns into a campaign
- 5:26. You know, with the attitude of "don't
- 5:28buy here or there because they behave
- 5:30this way or that." That's when it gets
- 5:32difficult. That is something we
- 5:34experienced intensely in connection
- 5:36with this NGO at the end of last year.
- 5:39I defended myself against that at the
- 5:41time. And now we have been contacted
- 5:43again. It was then announced that we
- 5:47had joined them. Which I personally
- 5:51don't find that bad, to be honest,
- 5:53right? They can write whatever they
- 5:55want and whatever they think is right.
- 5:57The deciding factor for me is that we
- 5:59are not being pressured. In this case,
- 6:01at least as far as I’m concerned, I
- 6:04didn't get the impression that they
- 6:07were putting us under massive pressure.
- 6:10They just said something about us and
- 6:13we corrected it. Now, the press release
- 6:17from Campact went to news outlets like
- 6:22Apollo News, Weltwoche, and Tichys
- 6:24Einblick, at least in the public eye.
- 6:27These are channels that are quite
- 6:29well-known. And in particular with
- 6:33these, they said that they—DM—had
- 6:36not excluded them from advertising, but
- 6:39these channels initially perceived or
- 6:42interpreted it that way due to
- 6:45Campact's press release. What happened
- 6:50then, when these channels said, "Look,
- 6:52DM and others don't want to advertise
- 6:54with us anymore"? What kind of backlash
- 6:58did you face? Well. Some of the
- 7:02mentioned channels did indeed report on
- 7:04it quite extensively. And what happened
- 7:08then was that we received a great many
- 7:11messages, primarily asking, "How come,
- 7:13Mr. Werner, after you spoke out in
- 7:16favor of a culture of debate at the end
- 7:19of last year, you are now essentially
- 7:21nodding along there?" That was the
- 7:24accusation that was circulating.
- 7:27Because it is true that we are
- 7:29committed to a culture of debate. We
- 7:32believe it is very important in a
- 7:33liberal and vibrant democracy that
- 7:35different viewpoints are debated in
- 7:37order to have a societal process of
- 7:39discovery. Um, and what was interesting
- 7:43about the letters—and in my
- 7:45perception, this was different from
- 7:47what we had at the end of last year—
- 7:50was that, especially at the beginning,
- 7:52there were many letters where it became
- 7:55clear that people were genuinely
- 7:57worried, right? That they asked, "Why,
- 8:00why are you boycotting certain news
- 8:03channels if we actually want pluralism
- 8:06of opinion in Germany?" So, it was
- 8:10interesting that they didn't say, "I
- 8:12find one of these channels particularly
- 8:14important," but rather that it's about
- 8:16a broad spectrum of opinion. Because
- 8:20some who wrote to us had the impression
- 8:22that we no longer have this spectrum of
- 8:24opinion in Germany, outside of what is
- 8:26broadcast on YouTube. Yes, and that was
- 8:30quite interesting for me to experience.
- 8:33So, there wasn't much polemic,
- 8:34especially at the beginning; towards
- 8:35the end, it all became a bit more
- 8:37standardized. I would say you could see
- 8:40that ChatGPT was likely a helper in the
- 8:42drafting process there. Uh, but at the
- 8:46beginning, that, that genuine concern
- 8:47—that was interesting for me to
- 8:49follow as a citizen. Uh, and ultimately
- 8:52I must say, Mr. Ronzheimer, I also
- 8:53found it a positive signal, regardless
- 8:55of how one might feel about these
- 8:57individual channels. But if we have
- 9:00people saying that pluralism of opinion
- 9:01is important for forming one's own
- 9:03views, then that is a very important
- 9:05foundation for a functioning, liberal,
- 9:07and vibrant democracy. Now you said
- 9:10that you looked at these channels, or
- 9:13your team looked at them, and you
- 9:15reacted to some, but not to the ones
- 9:17just mentioned, because for you, that
- 9:20is part of the pluralism of opinion.
- 9:23Where do you draw the line as a company
- 9:26, where you say, "This far and no
- 9:28further," and "We don't want to appear
- 9:31there"?
- 9:33Yes, well, Mr. Ronz, that is difficult,
- 9:34isn't it? It is difficult because it is
- 9:37not black or white, but rather there
- 9:39are many, many shades of gray that,
- 9:40that exist there. But for us, it was
- 9:44essential that channels that really, um
- 9:48, make things look extremely ridiculous
- 9:51—cynical and destructive, and there
- 9:54are a few of those—that we don't
- 9:57allow that, or what is also described
- 10:00as a modern version of gonzo journalism
- 10:04. Meaning, people who are constantly
- 10:07streaming, going to events, and
- 10:09harassing people. Um, there are
- 10:11examples of that, too. Um, that’s
- 10:15also something where we said that
- 10:16really doesn’t align at all with what
- 10:18we actually want to stand for.
- 10:20Regarding the other channels you just
- 10:22mentioned, there are varying opinions
- 10:23on those. But for me, that’s, so to
- 10:27speak, in that gray area, you know,
- 10:30where in our opinion it is perfectly
- 10:33reasonable in a liberal and vibrant
- 10:36democracy for such things to exist so
- 10:39people can form their own opinions. But
- 10:44when you say cynical or destructive,
- 10:47critics would say, wait a minute, that
- 10:50is certainly the case with Nius or
- 10:52Tichis Einblick, for example. So, what
- 10:56do you say to critics? Uh, they say,
- 10:59well, don't those channels go beyond
- 11:02what you just described? So, is it
- 11:06ultimately hate speech, to put it
- 11:08bluntly? Well, if we take the Tichis
- 11:13Einblick example, it was the case that
- 11:15there were links on that list, so you
- 11:17could click on them and watch it for
- 11:19yourself. And with Tichis Einblick, the
- 11:24example that was cited was an interview
- 11:27with the AfD candidate in Saxony-Anhalt
- 11:30.
- 11:32Ulrich Sigmund, right? Now, the
- 11:35question for me is, if a top candidate
- 11:38of a party that is predicted to get a
- 11:41large share of the vote is interviewed
- 11:43by a format, is that something that
- 11:46qualifies as a hate channel? Difficult.
- 11:50I don't think so, honestly. Um, to be
- 11:53honest, we didn't go into great depth.
- 11:56We don't see that as our task; we
- 11:58simply looked at the links that were
- 12:00included. I looked at quite a few,
- 12:03especially the ones where we said we
- 12:04actually want to block them. And on
- 12:08YouTube, I kept being offered similar
- 12:10content afterwards. Mr. Ronzheimer,
- 12:14some of what's out there is abysmal,
- 12:16but that too is part of the spectrum of
- 12:18opinion. And I think the crucial
- 12:21question is not so much how can it be
- 12:23prevented, but how can we ensure that
- 12:26in public discourse, contributions and
- 12:28proposals emerge that actually get
- 12:30people interested in what I would call
- 12:33balanced and sensible content. That
- 12:36should be the approach. We should be
- 12:39talking about that much more than
- 12:41focusing on the outliers that, let's
- 12:43face it, do exist in a liberal society.
- 12:47You stated in connection with Campact
- 12:49that you, quote, do not want to be
- 12:52interrogated or threatened by an NGO.
- 12:55That is a very sharp turn of phrase.
- 12:58What exactly did you mean by that in
- 13:00your dealings with Campact? Because
- 13:04ultimately, they would probably say
- 13:05that no one here is being threatened or
- 13:07censored in any way, and that every
- 13:09channel can broadcast and every company
- 13:11can do what they want, but that they,
- 13:13as an NGO, are simply making public who
- 13:14supports such channels. So, uh, why
- 13:18this, this harsh, sharp formulation
- 13:21from you?
- 13:23Yes, that was in response to a question
- 13:25that a journalist from Die Welt asked
- 13:28me. That is how I expressed it. And it
- 13:31was simply in the context of the
- 13:33interaction we had with this NGO. The
- 13:36situation was that at the end of last
- 13:38year, we were given an ultimatum to
- 13:40withdraw from the Association of Family
- 13:42Entrepreneurs. And, uh, I had also been
- 13:47contacted personally and, uh, I was
- 13:50told that either we withdraw now or it
- 13:53would be announced that we, as a
- 13:56company, support the AfD. And I was
- 13:59offered a discussion with those
- 14:01responsible at the NGO. But I was also
- 14:03told that this conversation would be
- 14:05live-streamed. Those were the
- 14:06conditions, so to speak. I did not
- 14:08respond to that request at the time
- 14:10because I saw it as, uh, as coercion.
- 14:14And following that, the journalist, uh,
- 14:17Mr., Mr., Mr., uh, Serio Serauo, asked
- 14:20me that question again, and then I said
- 14:23it in this context: that I am therefore
- 14:26not obliged to comply when I am asked
- 14:29by an NGO, uh, to comment on something.
- 14:32And it differs from when the Federal
- 14:34Criminal Police Office, uh, summons me
- 14:36to question me about a matter, in that
- 14:39I, of course, uh, do not have to
- 14:40subject myself to that. That is the
- 14:43difference between a state authority,
- 14:45uh, and an NGO that happens to stand
- 14:48for certain things, which is their good
- 14:50right, but which has no claim, uh, to
- 14:52me subjecting myself to them
- 14:54accordingly. How is it when you say
- 14:58that one is being pushed into a kind of
- 15:00declaration, either against the AfD, or
- 15:02in case of doubt, Campact would say for
- 15:04it or for media that support the AfD,
- 15:07and then you are standing in a corner
- 15:09somewhere, either in one or the other?
- 15:12What does that do to a company like
- 15:14yours? And if we look at the polls, um,
- 15:17it is certainly the case that you have
- 15:19many employees who, like everywhere
- 15:21else in Germany, now vote for the AfD,
- 15:23or have many customers, um, who now
- 15:25vote for the AfD. What, what would it
- 15:29actually be like if a company were to
- 15:31say now, um, no, we, we won't let
- 15:33ourselves be pressured, but, uh, we
- 15:35also don't have a problem with the AfD?
- 15:38Yes, would you still experience a
- 15:40massive shitstorm today, or has that
- 15:42changed in recent years due to the
- 15:43strength of the AfD?
- 15:46Well, first of all, I think it is
- 15:48important that we distinguish between
- 15:50companies and citizens. Um, companies
- 15:53do not vote for parties. Companies are
- 15:55not permitted to participate in
- 15:57elections. So, when it comes to
- 15:58political parties, uh, citizens are
- 16:00permitted to do so, and I think one
- 16:01simply needs to make that distinction.
- 16:03As a company, we are not
- 16:04party-political. As a citizen, um, I am
- 16:08eligible to vote, uh, when elections
- 16:10are held in Baden-Württemberg, or when
- 16:12there are federal or municipal
- 16:13elections in Baden-Württemberg, I can,
- 16:15I can vote there, I have an opinion,
- 16:17but that is a secret ballot. Um, it is
- 16:20also not at all necessary for me to
- 16:22comment on that. I believe that when we
- 16:24as a company make a statement, it is
- 16:25important that we do not make
- 16:27party-political statements, because it
- 16:29has no relevance since we cannot vote.
- 16:31However, we can, of course, make
- 16:32political statements, and that means
- 16:33the framework conditions that we have
- 16:35in Germany. I think it is also good
- 16:36that we speak out on those. This is
- 16:39usually done by me as, uh, the CEO and,
- 16:41in a way, the face of the company to
- 16:43the outside world. But I draw a very,
- 16:46very clear line there. That is why, um,
- 16:49I also believe that, uh, that calls
- 16:52from companies regarding elections, how
- 16:55one should vote, um, ultimately have no
- 16:58major influence. Uh, that hasn't been
- 17:01observed in the past, and incidentally,
- 17:03it wasn't observed in the USA either in
- 17:05connection with the last presidential
- 17:07election, where there were also some
- 17:09apparent opinions that expressed
- 17:11themselves on it. Um, and, um, it is
- 17:14essential for me, especially when there
- 17:16are such, such, such storms in a teacup
- 17:19, to always look at what is actually
- 17:21happening in our DM stores. Are our
- 17:23colleagues being approached? Do we see
- 17:25it in our sales figures? And it has
- 17:27been the case in the past that we
- 17:29simply could not see that at all. So,
- 17:32in this virtual world, it was raging,
- 17:33but in the analog world, in the real
- 17:35world, it was not to be observed. And
- 17:38that is, of course, also incredibly
- 17:39important when assessing the
- 17:41significance of a particular event. You
- 17:45are likely referring to the situation
- 17:47during the weeks when you commented on
- 17:48the "firewall." Um, does this firewall
- 17:53against the AfD exist in companies and
- 17:57associations?
- 18:01Well, I think it's more important to
- 18:04distinguish what the role of a company
- 18:06is and what the possibilities for
- 18:09citizens are. As a company, it's about
- 18:13providing good service for our
- 18:16customers, which leads them to come to
- 18:19us in our case to shop. Um, this means
- 18:24that when it comes to making decisions,
- 18:27let's say investment decisions or
- 18:30permits that are needed, where one has
- 18:33to talk to officials in our public
- 18:35administration, it is important that
- 18:38the party affiliation plays no role;
- 18:41rather, someone is elected or appointed
- 18:44to a public function to make decisions,
- 18:47and that is who we must speak with. I
- 18:51can't just say, because they belong to
- 18:53a certain party, we won't speak to them
- 18:55and therefore won't seek approval. If
- 18:58we were to proceed that way, I believe
- 19:00we would no longer be customer-oriented
- 19:02. Um, it is a different matter for a
- 19:06company to meet with parties and enter
- 19:09into dialogue. And it has always been
- 19:12the case that we at dm are relatively
- 19:14restrictive in that regard. So, we
- 19:17haven't had politicians appearing at
- 19:19our staff meetings, for example, or at
- 19:21all-hands meetings, as they are called,
- 19:24or at works assemblies. That doesn't
- 19:27exist, and in my opinion, it has no
- 19:28place there. I believe that the right
- 19:31to vote—the passive as well as the
- 19:34active right, meaning being able to go
- 19:36to the polls—is a civic right that we
- 19:39have in Germany. It is the foundation
- 19:43for a democratic society, and it is
- 19:45something that every citizen is
- 19:48entitled to personally. It is not up to
- 19:52me as the person responsible for dm to
- 19:55give people recommendations or to make
- 19:58certain promises or to incentivize it
- 20:01in any way. I believe that as a company
- 20:04, what we can do is strengthen trust in
- 20:07a pluralistic society and a culture of
- 20:09debate through the way we shape
- 20:11collaboration and how we treat one
- 20:13another. And I believe that also has an
- 20:18effect on how we deal with issues in
- 20:19society. I believe that is the
- 20:22essential contribution we can make, one
- 20:24that is truly effective. The other
- 20:26things are cheap, and doing them just
- 20:29because an NGO demands it, um, I would
- 20:31say is just for show.
- 20:34You have mentioned the culture of
- 20:36debate several times now, and your
- 20:37concern, uh, that there is no longer
- 20:39any real debate in Germany. How would
- 20:42you describe the current state of
- 20:45affairs? Will it get better and more
- 20:47open again? Will it become even more
- 20:50extreme? How do you personally perceive
- 20:52it?
- 20:52Yes, well, we certainly have a
- 20:54challenge when it comes to the debate.
- 20:57The question is always: how divided is
- 20:59society? It always depends a bit on
- 21:00where you look. When I speak with
- 21:02people, uh, I find that there are very,
- 21:04very many reasonable people in Germany.
- 21:07When we look at the public debate,
- 21:09including the reporting on it, it often
- 21:12, um, seems extremely polarized. I
- 21:14believe what we can observe are
- 21:16primarily two phenomena. One is
- 21:18something that has always existed, and
- 21:20the other is rather new. What has
- 21:22always existed is that there are very
- 21:24different opinions on substantive
- 21:26issues, uh, yes, even down to different
- 21:28ideologies. Um, but that can certainly
- 21:32be, so to speak, the creative tension
- 21:34that exists, so that we as a society
- 21:36keep addressing questions and gaining
- 21:38new insights and moving forward. But
- 21:40the second thing that has been added is
- 21:43this kind of affective polarization.
- 21:45That means we say, "I don't need to
- 21:47talk to that person." If they hold this
- 21:50opinion, they're a nutcase anyway, uh,
- 21:52and so I don't even need to listen to
- 21:55them. So the fact that the opinion
- 21:57comes from this person already means I
- 21:59don't engage with it anymore. And that
- 22:01is, of course, a real problem, because
- 22:04then we start surrounding ourselves
- 22:06only with opinions that we find
- 22:07agreeable. But it is precisely by
- 22:10thinking about other opinions that we
- 22:12can arrive at new viewpoints. That is
- 22:14at least what I experience in the
- 22:15collaborative culture at the drugstore
- 22:17chain, and why I value it so highly.
- 22:19And this affective polarization is
- 22:21something that, in my observation, has
- 22:23intensified, really since the
- 22:25coronavirus pandemic, when for the
- 22:27first time a real rift appeared. And
- 22:30this continues now, naturally
- 22:32reinforced by the public sphere we have
- 22:35, or this apparent public sphere we
- 22:37have in social media—this phenomenon
- 22:40of echo chambers, where you surround
- 22:42yourself with like-minded people, also
- 22:45driven by algorithms that focus on
- 22:47engagement and are highly emotional.
- 22:51And it leads to the point—we all know
- 22:53this—when we are only with
- 22:55like-minded people, um, constantly
- 22:57confirming each other in our views,
- 22:59that we eventually elevate an opinion
- 23:01to the level of reality. And that then
- 23:04leads to someone who comes with a
- 23:05different opinion not being heard by us
- 23:07at all, that we even react allergically
- 23:08, very, very thin-skinned, and in the
- 23:10end, we just scream at each other and
- 23:12are no longer willing to listen to the
- 23:13other person. And I believe this is a
- 23:15phenomenon we have, and it is a real
- 23:17challenge, um, that we must address
- 23:20with regard to shaping the public space
- 23:22. That is exactly where I keep making
- 23:25suggestions about what could be changed
- 23:27there. So, if you like, we can talk a
- 23:29bit about that as well. I would love to
- 23:31. I am interested. What do you
- 23:33personally do to avoid ending up in an
- 23:35echo chamber? So, what kind of people
- 23:37do you talk to or where do you meet
- 23:39them? Um, where where they have
- 23:41completely different opinions? Yes, so
- 23:45in the company, we fundamentally have
- 23:47the problem that when you are in
- 23:48executive management, you are in an
- 23:50ivory tower, so to speak, in your own
- 23:51bubble, and no longer notice what is
- 23:53happening in the company. Um, we at DM
- 23:57deal with this concretely by trying
- 23:59everything possible to keep the
- 24:01hierarchy as flat as possible, so that
- 24:04we are always close to where the
- 24:06contact with our customers actually
- 24:08takes place—that is, our many DM
- 24:10stores. That’s why I’m out and
- 24:12about a lot, talking to many people. Um
- 24:14, so that is the method within the
- 24:16company, and I apply that outside as
- 24:19well. I always try to get a
- 24:21comprehensive picture by how I inform
- 24:23myself: I read several newspapers,
- 24:24listen to many different podcasts—
- 24:26even podcasts where I don't share the
- 24:28same opinion, just to hear other points
- 24:30of view—and many interviews, right?
- 24:33That’s why I am also a fan of your
- 24:34podcast, because you talk to people and
- 24:36it’s not an interpretation by a, well
- 24:38, by a journalist; rather, it’s a
- 24:40journalist who asks good questions so
- 24:42that the person being interviewed
- 24:43provides a deep insight, and one
- 24:45understands the motives behind why
- 24:47someone acts the way they do. Um, what
- 24:51I’ve also been doing now, especially
- 24:53in these situations we mentioned at the
- 24:55beginning, is to just personally reply
- 24:57to messages to see what happens. And
- 25:01now, with what happened at the end of
- 25:03August, I actually spoke to one of the
- 25:05people involved; I just gave them a
- 25:07call.
- 25:09What was that about? Was that the
- 25:10firewall debate in August? That’s
- 25:12right. Yes, in that case, it was about
- 25:15the question of why I don't stand up
- 25:17for freedom of opinion, right? Why
- 25:19don’t I stand by what I said back
- 25:21then on the Markus Lanz show? Uh, and I
- 25:25replied to her, and she replied again
- 25:26and included her phone number, so I
- 25:28just called her, and she actually
- 25:30picked up, and we had a very, very good
- 25:32conversation. Uh, and it was
- 25:34interesting for me because I can then
- 25:37simply understand why people react the
- 25:39way they do. Of course, it’s just an
- 25:41n = 1, right? It’s not representative
- 25:44, from a market research or statistical
- 25:46perspective, but it’s always an
- 25:49individual insight. And I think it’s
- 25:51incredibly important, especially when
- 25:53you have strong convictions, to
- 25:54constantly question them and realize
- 25:56that others might see things
- 25:57differently. And the important thing,
- 26:00Mr. Ronz, I believe, is that when we
- 26:02enter into a conversation, we can
- 26:03discover that there are significantly
- 26:04more commonalities than things that
- 26:06pull us apart. There is this initiative
- 26:09called "Germany Talks," right, from Die
- 26:11Zeit, which is also supported by other
- 26:13media companies. Springer is involved,
- 26:16for example, but also the Süddeutsche
- 26:17Zeitung. Um, an initiative that we at
- 26:19dm-drogerie markt also support. We
- 26:21supported it with our communications. I
- 26:23also took part in a session of "Germany
- 26:26Talks," where an app determines your
- 26:28stance on certain topics and then
- 26:30brings people together who have
- 26:33diametrically opposed views on these
- 26:35questions. And so I spoke to someone
- 26:38who was from Berlin, and it was really
- 26:40interesting to say, "Aha, so you see it
- 26:42quite differently; tell me again, how
- 26:44did you come to that assessment?" Uh,
- 26:47and we did that mutually and saw that,
- 26:49in principle, we actually had the same
- 26:51concerns, but just different
- 26:53perspectives on how to solve them. And
- 26:56there are always many roads that lead
- 26:58to Rome, which is why debates are so
- 27:00important, so that we can simply
- 27:02present the different paths to one
- 27:04another and, ideally, say in
- 27:06conversation: There is the path you had
- 27:08, there is the path I had, but if we
- 27:10talk about it together, suddenly a
- 27:12third path appears, opens up, and that
- 27:14is perhaps a path we can choose
- 27:16together. Incidentally, that is
- 27:18actually exactly what should happen in
- 27:20coalition negotiations. Yes, but that
- 27:22is obviously not as easy as we can
- 27:24currently observe.
- 27:25Yes, a very important point. I always
- 27:27feel the same way, uh, especially when
- 27:29it comes to topics that are incredibly
- 27:31close to my heart, but where I still
- 27:32think, um, that one must be open-minded
- 27:34, for example, on the topic of Ukraine,
- 27:36Ukraine aid, weapons deliveries; I keep
- 27:38experiencing people recognizing me
- 27:40somewhere on the street, and the topic
- 27:42really moves many people. Um, and I am
- 27:44then also open to discussing it and
- 27:46don't want to immediately label people
- 27:48somehow just because they have a
- 27:50different stance, yes, one simply has
- 27:52to respect that and then discuss it,
- 27:54and that is something we have really
- 27:56lost. I totally agree with you there.
- 27:59On the other hand, uh, I'm just asking
- 28:02myself: When we talk about your
- 28:04situation, also that of your company,
- 28:07um, in this phase, in this discussion,
- 28:10but also before that, um, have we
- 28:13perhaps politicized too many areas of
- 28:15our lives in the end? I mean, does
- 28:19politics really have to be discussed
- 28:22everywhere? Like in the company, at the
- 28:24family dinner table, in clubs? Well,
- 28:27let me put it this way: In the past,
- 28:28choosing a drugstore probably wouldn't
- 28:30have been, or maybe it isn't like that
- 28:31today either, but it is being turned
- 28:33into almost a political decision. Um,
- 28:36today, the question of where a company
- 28:38advertises or which association one is
- 28:40involved with or whatever can trigger a
- 28:43huge political conflict, and I believe
- 28:45that was different in the past. Is that
- 28:48a sign of a vibrant society or is
- 28:51something going wrong with this
- 28:54politicization? Personally, I consider
- 28:58it an expression of a vibrant society,
- 29:00because the reality of everyday life is
- 29:02that even if there are such demands and
- 29:04such shitstorms in the virtual worlds,
- 29:06it is not actually observable in
- 29:08reality. That means it is a discussion
- 29:12being held very intensely in certain
- 29:13circles, but for the vast majority of
- 29:15the population, who are currently
- 29:16asking themselves where they should get
- 29:18their daily needs, it doesn't really
- 29:19play a role. That is why I believe it
- 29:24is incredibly important, when faced
- 29:26with this, not to react reflexively,
- 29:28but to first take a deep breath and
- 29:30look at the facts so that you can then
- 29:32deal with them appropriately, and in a
- 29:34way that you can personally stand
- 29:36behind. And I think these are great
- 29:39times we are living in for civil
- 29:41courage. We really need people now who
- 29:44don't let themselves be ground down,
- 29:45but who take a stand. And if we can now
- 29:48succeed in having such perspectives
- 29:50addressed in the media, and not just,
- 29:53not just continuing to polarize the
- 29:55discussion, so to speak, but asking
- 29:57instead: "What is actually happening
- 30:00here right now?" In other words, by
- 30:02taking a more analytical approach, I
- 30:04believe that something positive can
- 30:06emerge from it. And as an entrepreneur,
- 30:10my approach is to say that
- 30:12circumstances are, first of all, as I
- 30:14find them to be. They are shaped by
- 30:17very different interest groups, by
- 30:19people with concerns. And now, what it
- 30:21comes down to is the entrepreneurial
- 30:23perspective: saying, where do the
- 30:25opportunities lie in this? And I must
- 30:27tell you, Mr. Roniman, regarding what I
- 30:29experienced at the end of last year and
- 30:31now at the end of August. It was a
- 30:33super steep learning curve for me. So,
- 30:35I too had to grapple with the question.
- 30:39Yes, how do you stand on this? How do
- 30:40you deal with it? What does pluralism
- 30:43of opinion mean now? Where do you want
- 30:45to draw the lines? It is all not so
- 30:47clear-cut. In my opinion, there is no
- 30:49right or wrong there. I mean,
- 30:51absolutely not, right? Instead, there
- 30:53is only the possibility of asking
- 30:55yourself what you want to stand for,
- 30:57what is really important to you, and
- 30:59what decision you are making now. And
- 31:03then the question of what happens next,
- 31:05and do I have to adjust, or can I be
- 31:08responsible for what has grown out of
- 31:10this decision? That is how I deal with
- 31:14it. In that respect, I am very, very,
- 31:16very optimistic, you know? But I must
- 31:19also say, I hope—I am relying heavily
- 31:21on media professionals and also on
- 31:23multipliers, and you are one of them
- 31:25with your podcast, which now has an
- 31:27enormous reach. I believe the way you
- 31:30initiate discussions in Germany has a
- 31:33significant impact on whether we as a
- 31:36society succeed in focusing on the
- 31:40essential things or get worn out by
- 31:43trivialities.
- 31:45How has that debate evolved for you
- 31:49personally? You mentioned the Lanz
- 31:52broadcast and the reaction; that was
- 31:54already about the 'Brandmauer,' but I
- 31:56have the feeling that between, when was
- 31:58it, January or winter, and today, in
- 31:59the autumn of this year, so much has
- 32:01happened, politically as well as
- 32:03socially. How has your own thought
- 32:06process evolved since then, where do
- 32:09you stand today, and where do we as a
- 32:13society stand on this issue? Well, I
- 32:18believe the challenge we currently have
- 32:20, or fundamentally have as a company
- 32:22and as a society, is how do we make
- 32:24ourselves fit for the future? What must
- 32:28the decisions we make today look like
- 32:29so that opportunities in the future
- 32:31grow instead of shrink? For me, that is
- 32:34the definition of future-proofing or
- 32:37sustainability. And that is the big
- 32:40discussion we are having in society at
- 32:42the moment. And as an entrepreneur,
- 32:44that naturally interests me immensely,
- 32:46because it is exactly the same question
- 32:47that drives us within the company as
- 32:49well. DM is now 53 years old. Retail
- 32:52companies that have lived well over 100
- 32:55years are usually not in good shape
- 32:57because they somehow didn't manage to
- 32:59stay fit for the future. So, that is a
- 33:02topic that interests me enormously, and
- 33:04one I naturally follow in the societal
- 33:06discourse as well. And we are currently
- 33:10having, I believe, heated debates about
- 33:11that in Germany. I think that is good,
- 33:14because the Germany business model,
- 33:16which carried us for years, for decades
- 33:19, no longer works that way, right? It
- 33:21has been reported on many times. Namely
- 33:24these three pillars: security through
- 33:26the United States, cheap energy through
- 33:28Russia, and an export motor—and thus
- 33:31an economic motor—through China.
- 33:34These three pillars are no longer there
- 33:35. We in Germany are currently
- 33:37confronted with the question: yes, what
- 33:39does this mean for us now? How must we
- 33:41position ourselves to remain fit for
- 33:42the future? That these debates are
- 33:44taking place is important. Even if it's
- 33:47not yet entirely clear what the real
- 33:49success strategy will look like. It’s
- 33:52interesting that you say that, because
- 33:55my impression is that we’re really
- 33:57only having these debates about
- 33:59Germany's long-term viability on the
- 34:01sidelines, and instead—as we’re
- 34:03doing these days, weeks, and months—
- 34:06we're focusing much more on the
- 34:08political fights between the parties,
- 34:10the Chancellor, the AfD, Saxony-Anhalt,
- 34:13and so on. The economy plays a role
- 34:16somewhere, of course, but this crucial
- 34:18question you’re raising—Germany’s
- 34:20viability—isn’t a central theme
- 34:22right now, which I find quite
- 34:24astonishing in the public debate. So,
- 34:28parallel to these—let's call them—
- 34:31culture wars, the biggest challenge is
- 34:34actually this economic crisis. If you
- 34:39look at how bad things are right now
- 34:41and how much worse they could get—
- 34:43without painting horror scenarios, of
- 34:45course—I mean, we have to talk about
- 34:48the present first. Yes, a prosperous
- 34:52economy is a prerequisite for a
- 34:55prosperous society. We could see that
- 34:59very clearly after the Second World War
- 35:00, right? "Prosperity for all" relied on
- 35:03a consistent competitive economy, with
- 35:05the antitrust legislation that was
- 35:06introduced back then. That ultimately
- 35:09led to this enormous upswing, which was
- 35:12reflected in our standard of living.
- 35:17And the question now regarding the
- 35:19framework conditions for us to continue
- 35:22prospering as a society is the real
- 35:24issue, because the old business model
- 35:27we had in Germany no longer works. So,
- 35:31that is the central topic. I agree with
- 35:33you that we end up losing ourselves in
- 35:36trivialities during these discussions.
- 35:41And that’s why I believe everyone
- 35:43currently involved in political shaping
- 35:45is really called upon not to lose
- 35:46themselves in that, but to bring the
- 35:48central issue back to the center of
- 35:50attention. And the fact is, in my
- 35:55opinion, we really need to face a
- 35:58fundamental situation that applies to
- 36:01companies, but also to states. And in
- 36:05my view, it can be put into words as
- 36:07follows. If the speed of change outside
- 36:11a country is greater than the speed
- 36:13inside, the country loses its
- 36:15connection. That is what we can observe
- 36:18at the moment. In Germany, we are very
- 36:21much geared toward stability, really
- 36:23since the Second World War, through all
- 36:25our federal structures, which all have
- 36:27their real merits. But that makes
- 36:30decision-making processes very, very
- 36:31slow. This leads to the fact that it is
- 36:35not so easy to just push things through
- 36:37, to implement a party platform in its
- 36:39pure form, yes, when you do not have an
- 36:41absolute majority. That means that
- 36:44adjustment processes are very, very
- 36:46slow. We are also in a country where a
- 36:48great deal is regulated, where the
- 36:50state, where a great deal is expected
- 36:52of the state, because the state also
- 36:54promises a great deal. And this now
- 36:58leads to the fact that, when the speed
- 37:00of change outside the country suddenly
- 37:02gains significant momentum—and that
- 37:04is what we are observing—because
- 37:06these three pillars and the business
- 37:08model have collapsed, because we no
- 37:10longer live in a time where, uh, the
- 37:11strength of law prevails, but rather
- 37:13the law of the strong, which,
- 37:15parenthetically, is more the normal
- 37:17state in global development, one must
- 37:19also say. We find it incredibly
- 37:22difficult to adapt, we are very, very
- 37:25slow, and that is why we are currently
- 37:27losing our international standing,
- 37:29because as an export-oriented nation,
- 37:31we are suddenly subject to things that
- 37:33we do not have control over ourselves.
- 37:36And we are losing competitiveness. We
- 37:40can see this in the fact that net
- 37:41investments in Germany are declining.
- 37:43This means that less is being invested
- 37:45than is being depreciated. That means
- 37:47we are living off our substance. Um,
- 37:49jobs are no longer primarily being
- 37:50created in Germany; instead, production
- 37:52is increasingly moving abroad. This is
- 37:55something that we, or rather people in
- 37:57Germany, also wanted. This whole
- 38:00degrowth, um, the whole degrowth
- 38:02narrative was heading in exactly this
- 38:04direction. Uh, also what we did with
- 38:08the automotive industry, that was a
- 38:10strategy that was pursued by people, uh
- 38:12, which was also celebrated in the
- 38:13media at the time, and we are now
- 38:15paying the price for that. So anyone
- 38:19who looked at it with open eyes could
- 38:21have seen it. Uh, but the nice thing in
- 38:25this case, in quotation marks, is that
- 38:27we got ourselves into this, so we can
- 38:29also change it again. We just have to,
- 38:31we just have to tackle it. We have to
- 38:33roll up our sleeves. And I think a good
- 38:36image for what Germany is, is that we
- 38:39are simply like Gulliver in the land of
- 38:41Lilliput, as a giant among dwarves, no
- 38:44longer able to move because countless
- 38:46small regulations and rules are holding
- 38:48us down like strings. And that is why
- 38:52it is not just one thing, so to speak,
- 38:54one law that we have to change. We have
- 38:56to take a look at the whole picture and
- 38:58ask ourselves how we actually need to
- 39:00position ourselves so that the giant in
- 39:02the land of Lilliput can stand up again
- 39:03and truly unfold its power. I believe
- 39:06there are things we could do, things we
- 39:08should do, but of course that means
- 39:10everyone must be ready to change.
- 39:13What things are those? Well, I advocate
- 39:16primarily for three things that I
- 39:17believe would really make a difference.
- 39:20And that is, I believe we need longer
- 39:23legislative terms. Something that
- 39:26Ferdinand von Schirach has already
- 39:27brought into the conversation, which I
- 39:29find truly worth reflecting on and
- 39:31considering. With the four years we
- 39:34have now at the federal or state level,
- 39:37it's just the case that reforms take
- 39:39time to be implemented, and every
- 39:41development has a J-curve, like the
- 39:44letter J. That means it goes down first
- 39:46before it goes up, and can then
- 39:48continue going up for a very long time.
- 39:52The problem is that when we tackle
- 39:54reforms, they go down in this J-curve,
- 39:56and as a rule, we are already back in
- 39:59campaign mode for the next election.
- 40:02These growing pains of change must be
- 40:05explained well, explained with a strong
- 40:08vision, but they are obviously very
- 40:10easy to pick apart, and it leads to
- 40:13political leaders often no longer
- 40:15daring to tackle essential reforms
- 40:18because they are worried about being
- 40:20voted out in the next election. If we
- 40:25had longer legislative terms, for
- 40:27instance not 4 years, but 6 years, then
- 40:29there would simply be the possibility
- 40:32to get back onto the rising part of the
- 40:34J by the time the next election comes
- 40:37around and then also reap the fruits of
- 40:39these fundamental reforms. Also,
- 40:43regarding legislative terms, we should
- 40:45consider if we can bundle the many
- 40:47elections that keep happening; it’s
- 40:49not easy, because when government
- 40:50coalitions break down, there are new
- 40:52election dates. So, you can't always
- 40:55set everything to the same number, but
- 40:57just thinking about how to coordinate
- 40:59them to have some stability—that is
- 41:01the first proposal. The second proposal
- 41:03, Mr. Ronzheimer, I believe we should
- 41:05really commit to consistent term limits
- 41:07for elected offices. So, if we had
- 41:11longer legislative terms and went for
- 41:13two terms, totaling 12 years, that
- 41:15would have a significant impact on our
- 41:18situation in this country. Because that
- 41:22would mean that people who go into
- 41:24politics, who apply for elective
- 41:25offices, would know clearly that it
- 41:28would be over after 12 years. That
- 41:30means they would already be thinking
- 41:32beforehand: in what profession do I
- 41:34want to continue working afterwards?
- 41:36There would be many more people in our
- 41:37parliaments who had actually worked in
- 41:38a profession before. I believe that
- 41:40would, would, would do us good. It
- 41:43would also have the consequence that
- 41:46many more people could enter these
- 41:48offices because it wouldn't be possible
- 41:50to hold them for decades, but parties
- 41:53would also have to constantly look for
- 41:55new candidates who could actually take
- 41:57on these elective offices. I think
- 42:01there would also be more courage,
- 42:02because if it's clear that after the
- 42:04second term it's over anyway, I don't
- 42:06have to speculate on doing something
- 42:07that might lead to me being re-elected
- 42:09in the short term. We would have more
- 42:12political courage, we would have a
- 42:14closer connection between political
- 42:15parties and the population, and we
- 42:17would have more engagement from
- 42:19citizens to get involved politically.
- 42:21That is the second proposal. And the
- 42:23third proposal is what is generally
- 42:25referred to as sunset clauses. So,
- 42:28expiration clauses would be the German
- 42:30term. That means that for laws being
- 42:33enacted, we always commit ourselves to
- 42:36an expiration date and a mandatory
- 42:38review date. Depending on the law, the
- 42:41length can vary, but it would lead to a
- 42:44very careful examination at the time of
- 42:46the review date as to whether the
- 42:48existing laws continue to have the
- 42:50effect that was intended when they were
- 42:52put into force. Because, Mr. Simer, the
- 42:55problem isn't bad laws per se. The
- 42:57problem is laws that are out of date
- 42:59because the times have moved on. So,
- 43:02that would lead to this speed of change
- 43:04, this fitness for change, this ability
- 43:06to change being, so to speak,
- 43:07institutionalized. Parliaments would
- 43:10deal much more with what exists and
- 43:12wouldn't always introduce new laws, but
- 43:14would actually renew what is existing,
- 43:16because the secret of future viability
- 43:18is a clear vision and the ability to
- 43:20renew. And I believe we would really
- 43:22advance that with this. That is why
- 43:25these are three proposals that I
- 43:27believe would truly change our
- 43:28framework and give us a constitution
- 43:30that would better enable us to make the
- 43:32things happen that can really lead us
- 43:34into the future.
- 43:37If you look at the current government
- 43:40now, with all the problems that exist,
- 43:42which we talk about daily in this
- 43:44podcast, is there anything that still
- 43:46gives you hope that they will get it
- 43:48together? So, regarding the reforms—
- 43:52is something being done to help Germany
- 43:55move forward, or is the situation so
- 43:57gridlocked that it's barely going to
- 43:59work?
- 44:01Yes, Ronzheimer, I think that is, above
- 44:03all, a question for those in political
- 44:05leadership. Well, as a citizen, I’d
- 44:08say the sun rises again the next day,
- 44:10the earth keeps turning, or as my
- 44:12grandfather always used to tell me, the
- 44:14caravan moves on. So, if this
- 44:17government in its current configuration
- 44:19can't manage it, well, then the next
- 44:21thing will happen, right? And whatever
- 44:24happens after that is not the end of
- 44:26the world for Germany. Yes, things will
- 44:28continue to develop. The crucial thing
- 44:31is that those who want political
- 44:33responsibility must actually produce
- 44:35results, because citizens focus on the
- 44:37impact, on what really happens, not on
- 44:39what is promised. Mr. Ronzheimer, I
- 44:43think the problem we currently have in
- 44:45Germany is that we have a lot of
- 44:47analysis without vision, and a lot of
- 44:49realization without action, and that
- 44:51doesn't end well in the long run. We
- 44:54need strong visions. Um, because that
- 44:56is also my own realization as an
- 44:58entrepreneur. If I have a strong vision
- 45:01, it means I am describing a target
- 45:03state that we want to reach. And now
- 45:07the question is: how do I get from the
- 45:08current state to the target state? That
- 45:10only happens through change. Meaning,
- 45:13if we have a strong vision, then change
- 45:15becomes a departure toward reaching
- 45:17that target state. So, I am prepared to
- 45:20use the analogy Carsten Maschmeyer
- 45:23recently used: to reach the oasis, I
- 45:25must walk through the desert. Yes, but
- 45:28the oasis gives me the strength to walk
- 45:30through that desert. However, if I
- 45:33don't have that target state, then
- 45:35change is an imposition, because I have
- 45:37to leave the comfort zone I'm currently
- 45:40in. And many people understandably live
- 45:43by the principle that they would rather
- 45:45have known unhappiness than unknown
- 45:47happiness. That is why I believe those
- 45:51currently in political responsibility
- 45:53are called upon to clearly define what
- 45:55their target state is, what their
- 45:56vision for our country is. And I
- 45:59believe that would truly bring people
- 46:02together, and then reforms would also
- 46:04be accepted by the people because they
- 46:07would be seen as rungs on the ladder
- 46:09toward the goal we actually want to
- 46:11reach.
- 46:13Mr. Werner, thank you very much for
- 46:14your time. Uh, that was fascinating. Uh
- 46:17, thank you for the answers, and all
- 46:19the best.
- 46:20Yes, thank you very much, Mr. Ronzeimer
- 46:22, and all the best.
- 46:28Thank you very much for watching. For
- 46:30more interviews, analyses, and reports,
- 46:32just follow my channel here and
- 46:34activate the bell, so you won't miss
- 46:36anything.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Links vs. Rechts: Wie Deutschland sich spaltet. Mit Christoph Werner (dm-Chef) by Ronzheimer, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,648 words across 1,168 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.