Lindsay Clancy’s Psychiatrist Grilled Over Missed Warning Signs — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Every single one of them were by
- 0:02television and web.
- 0:04>> Yes.
- 0:04>> Until you came in this courtroom Friday,
- 0:07you never saw this woman in person, did
- 0:09you?
- 0:10>> Correct.
- 0:11>> Were you ever concerned about her mental
- 0:13health as a person?
- 0:17>> Absolutely.
- 0:18>> She was crying. She told you symptoms
- 0:21that she couldn't get out of bed. Isn't
- 0:24that right?
- 0:26>> At one time she said it was it was
- 0:27difficult to get out of bed. Oh,
- 0:29difficult to get out. Why was it
- 0:30difficult for Lindsay Clancy to get out
- 0:32of bed?
- 0:33>> Cuz she was very depressed.
- 0:34>> And And did you give her a hug? Oh, no.
- 0:36You're on tele medicine, so you couldn't
- 0:37give her a hug, could you?
- 0:40>> You didn't have any chance to even look
- 0:42at her in person, did you?
- 0:45>> I I could look at her. It was It was
- 0:47always a video appointment. I couldn't
- 0:50give her a hug, but that's not actually
- 0:53something that psychiatrists typically
- 0:55do with patients. I imagine now I'm
- 0:58looking at you and you've got the
- 1:00witness stand cutting you off in half,
- 1:03right? So I can't see from your waist
- 1:07down, your legs, your feet, your hands,
- 1:09anything. That's the same you that you
- 1:13have on the tele medicine, right?
- 1:15>> Yes.
- 1:16>> Isn't it fair to say that you've studied
- 1:19and that you've learned that there are
- 1:21objective manifestations that patients
- 1:23may have that would be A tell like if
- 1:27you're playing poke you have a tell that
- 1:29would be an indisha of the fact that
- 1:30they're stressed or emotionally
- 1:33disturbed right
- 1:36>> yes
- 1:36>> like hand ringing right
- 1:38>> yes
- 1:39>> were you able to see the hands ringing
- 1:41when you were on tele medicine
- 1:44>> um I don't believe I don't recall seeing
- 1:47her hands
- 1:48>> you recall you know how people sit there
- 1:50and they do this with their leg and the
- 1:51leg bounces because they're going
- 1:54through some type of emotional stress
- 1:55stressed. You couldn't even see her
- 1:57legs, could you?
- 1:58>> I couldn't see her legs, but I knew that
- 2:00she was under stress.
- 2:03>> So, when she came to you,
- 2:08um, September 15th, I believe, is the
- 2:12first time that you all actually
- 2:15discussed her [snorts] condition,
- 2:18correct?
- 2:20>> Yes.
- 2:21And looking at
- 2:23the medical records, which the jury will
- 2:25be able to look at, it says visit date
- 2:29September 15th, 2022. And you can look,
- 2:32you can look along with me if you wish.
- 2:35Um,
- 2:37indicates why she came to see you,
- 2:39right?
- 2:43>> Yes.
- 2:43>> Right.
- 2:44>> Yes.
- 2:45>> Yes.
- 2:45>> Okay. What? Why did she come to see you?
- 2:48According not not guessing and
- 2:50speculating, never mind the TV. You just
- 2:52look at your notes. Tell me what brought
- 2:55Lindsay Clancy to your office.
- 2:59>> Postpartum anxiety.
- 3:02>> Is that it? Is that what you noted in
- 3:03the records?
- 3:05>> Well, those were her words when asked,
- 3:08"What are the problems for which you are
- 3:10seeking help?"
- 3:11>> I postpartum anxiety.
- 3:15Now, as a psychiatrist meeting with this
- 3:18young woman
- 3:20after a month or so of working as a
- 3:22psychiatrist for Hester.
- 3:25There are tests that you administer to a
- 3:28woman who's in postpartum to find out
- 3:31what type of anxiety they have. Right.
- 3:35>> Well, there are some screening tests,
- 3:37but the most important thing is what the
- 3:40patient tells you and what my assessment
- 3:42is in the session.
- 3:44>> I see. And that would carry through the
- 3:46TUS evaluations for all 14 of those
- 3:50meetings. It's what the patient tells
- 3:52you, right?
- 3:54>> Yes. And what I observe in the session
- 3:57>> through the television
- 3:59>> through the computer.
- 4:02>> What if you can tell me is the Edenberg
- 4:06test?
- 4:09Um, it is a
- 4:11scale that looks at symptoms of
- 4:14postpartum depression.
- 4:16>> And when you administer that's a that's
- 4:18a major test, isn't it, for a doctor to
- 4:20evaluate a patient for PPD?
- 4:24>> I wouldn't say it's a major test.
- 4:25>> It's a pretty big one though, isn't it?
- 4:28It's the only one that measures their
- 4:29postpartum depression, right?
- 4:32>> It's a common one.
- 4:33>> It's a what?
- 4:34>> Common Commonly used.
- 4:36>> Commonly. All right. So when you used it
- 4:38on Lindsay,
- 4:40when was that administered to her?
- 4:42>> I did not use it on Lindsay.
- 4:44>> Why?
- 4:47>> We used the PHQ9, which is
- 4:50>> PHQ9.
- 4:52>> It's a depression screening form.
- 4:54>> That's that's like generalized anxiety
- 4:56disorder, general depression. It's got
- 4:58nothing to do with a woman suffering
- 5:00from postpartum depression, does it?
- 5:02>> I disagree. Well, do you agree that
- 5:06people perhaps that may know a little
- 5:08more than you determine that the
- 5:09Edenberg scale is the appropriate scale
- 5:11to administer to a pregnant or
- 5:13postpartum woman?
- 5:15>> To stay as the form,
- 5:16>> you're familiar with the Edenberg scale,
- 5:18right?
- 5:19>> I've heard of it.
- 5:21>> And can you explain to me how it's
- 5:23graded?
- 5:24>> No, I cannot.
- 5:28>> There are 30 questions in it, are there
- 5:30not?
- 5:32I don't use this scale so I don't know
- 5:34how many questions there are.
- 5:36>> So the Edenberg scale do you even know
- 5:39that the cut off for someone that is
- 5:42depressed in their condition of
- 5:44postpartum would be 15 anything over
- 5:47that they're in severe depression.
- 5:51>> Okay. You know that her first Edenberg
- 5:55test that was administered to her put
- 5:57her at a 23
- 5:59>> objection
- 6:00>> overall
- 6:01>> severe depression.
- 6:03>> I I was not aware of this test. I was
- 6:06not aware that this had been
- 6:07administered to her.
- 6:12Well, you know that except for the
- 6:15Prozac that she had when she was a
- 6:17nurse, what 23, 24, 23 years old,
- 6:22she hadn't, other than seeing her own
- 6:25doctor for having the baby, she hadn't
- 6:27seen any doctors. You knew that, right?
- 6:31>> Um, I didn't know exactly which doctor
- 6:35she sees. I think we, you know, we ask
- 6:38about your primary care doctor. Um, but
- 6:41she did not report any other medical
- 6:44issues that she was under treatment for.
- 6:47>> So, is it important for Dr. Jennifer Tus
- 6:50to know whether or not a patient who is
- 6:53coming to you for help has a prior
- 6:55medical history other than what they
- 6:57might tell you?
- 6:59[cough]
- 6:59>> [clears throat]
- 7:01>> Well, when patients are are able to
- 7:03advocate for themselves and share their
- 7:06medical history, um, we rely on on what
- 7:09they tell us.
- 7:13>> Was she able to advocate for herself in
- 7:16your opinion when she came to see you
- 7:18when you evaluated her in September?
- 7:21>> Absolutely.
- 7:22>> About October?
- 7:24>> Yes.
- 7:25>> How about November?
- 7:26>> Yes.
- 7:27>> How about December?
- 7:29Yes.
- 7:30>> And your medical records, you would
- 7:32agree, show that during that period of
- 7:35time
- 7:37that she was deteriorating. Was a word
- 7:41that was used on Friday. Isn't that
- 7:43right?
- 7:45>> Um, so
- 7:46>> no, no, no. So, you use the word
- 7:49deteriorating on Friday, did you not?
- 7:52>> She was a little bit worse at certain
- 7:54appointments. And the deteriorating word
- 7:57which is not my word choice is what is
- 7:59in the note because I had to select that
- 8:02>> because why? You have some kind of a
- 8:03program that you have to check the box
- 8:05and you have to bring down the Dropbox.
- 8:07You can't take a pen and write something
- 8:09down about a patient.
- 8:12>> Um there are certain parts of the note
- 8:14where I can write um whatever I I feel
- 8:17is is necessary. But that specific
- 8:20aspect of the note is a a button where
- 8:23you have to click one of three choices.
- 8:25>> So when the jury's going through your
- 8:27medical records, one of the things that
- 8:28they're going to see is that uh when you
- 8:31meet with a patient,
- 8:34you have a a form that you fill out
- 8:37where it says if you feel like you're
- 8:39going to harm yourself or somebody else,
- 8:41make sure you go to the emergency room.
- 8:42Right.
- 8:44>> Yes. If you have any urgence to harm
- 8:46yourself or others, go to the nearest
- 8:48emergency room. That's that's that's in
- 8:51every single time that you meet with a
- 8:55patient, right?
- 8:57>> Yes.
- 8:58>> And it indicates that um if there's any
- 9:04call the suicide prevention and crisis
- 9:07hotline. If you feel that you're in
- 9:09crisis, you may text home to a
- 9:12particular number any time. Um, what
- 9:15what's a suicide viol?
- 9:18>> Um, it's a phone number that patients in
- 9:22crisis can call and speak to a trained
- 9:27um counselor.
- 9:28>> Now, a psychiatrist, you'd agree with
- 9:30me, is not a counselor, that's for sure,
- 9:32right?
- 9:33Well, a psychiatrist has training in
- 9:35therapy as well as in medicine.
- 9:38>> Did you give Lindsay Clansancy any
- 9:39therapy?
- 9:41>> There was some therapy in incorporated
- 9:43in our sessions, but we did
- 9:47>> um providing emotional support,
- 9:50listening to her.
- 9:54>> Hold on everybody,
- 9:56>> she can you asked a question. We'll let
- 9:59her finish and then you can follow up
- 10:01with any questions you want.
- 10:03>> Go ahead, Doc.
- 10:05>> Um,
- 10:05>> anything else you want to say?
- 10:07>> So, her sessions were largely focused on
- 10:10the medication management, but there was
- 10:12an aspect of therapy including those
- 10:14those items.
- 10:16>> Okay. And the sessions were for what 17
- 10:18minutes?
- 10:18>> No.
- 10:19>> How long were they?
- 10:21>> 25 to 30 minutes.
- 10:23>> So, 25 to 30 minutes on the television.
- 10:25And you
- 10:28the TV screen with her for the full 25
- 10:30minutes.
- 10:31>> Yes.
- 10:32>> And that's not noted in your records. It
- 10:35says 17 minutes on all your records,
- 10:37doesn't it?
- 10:38>> So, if if you look closely, it it says
- 10:41the therapy component um was for 17
- 10:46minutes. Um it doesn't say the entire
- 10:48duration is is 17 minutes.
- 10:51>> So, what do you do when you're trying to
- 10:53give therapy as a psychiatrist to the
- 10:56patient that See what do you do?
- 11:00>> What do you do for therapy?
- 11:02>> It depends on the person.
- 11:03>> Well, how about Elizabeth? What did you
- 11:05do for therapy with her?
- 11:09>> I I listened to her. I listened to her
- 11:12concerns and provided support. I I tried
- 11:16to provide her um with hope that um
- 11:22eventually things would improve.
- 11:27So you listen to her, you listen to her
- 11:30concerns and you'd agree with me that
- 11:32her concerns were for example that she
- 11:36actually was unable to sleep is one of
- 11:39her concerns, right?
- 11:42>> She was having a lot of difficulty with
- 11:44sleep.
- 11:45>> Um on the September 15th meeting, you
- 11:47indicate that uh her mood was okay, but
- 11:50her affect was anxious and you called it
- 11:52in congruent. What does that mean?
- 12:04Um
- 12:06so her she said she was feeling okay. Um
- 12:09she appeared anxious and she also stated
- 12:12that she was anxious. So one of the
- 12:15things that you talked about Friday is
- 12:18when a patient presents with an
- 12:20inongruent
- 12:22something like I don't remember [snorts]
- 12:23appearance perhaps that would mean that
- 12:25they're saying I'm okay but they don't
- 12:28look like they're okay right
- 12:32>> well it it could um I I don't think her
- 12:37affect and her mood um were really that
- 12:42in congruent at that time. I I think
- 12:45that she didn't appear terribly
- 12:47depressed. Um I didn't say she was
- 12:50terribly depressed in that initial
- 12:51visit. Um but she said she was anxious
- 12:54and she appeared anxious. That's um
- 12:57pretty congruent.
- 12:59>> Okay. So did you put in the report that
- 13:02she was congruent
- 13:04or inongruent?
- 13:07Um, so that is not an option for me to
- 13:12indicate in that section, but it was
- 13:14congruent.
- 13:15>> You you're like a robot. You can't take
- 13:17a pen and write something down. You have
- 13:19to do the Dropbox and the X's on the
- 13:22computer.
- 13:23>> Um, well, if if it's on the computer, I
- 13:27I there I'm limited by the options that
- 13:30are up there.
- 13:31>> You're a doctor. Why are you limited?
- 13:34because of the technology.
- 13:37>> What technology? The fact that there's a
- 13:38form on a computer. You're trying to
- 13:41treat a human being who comes to you for
- 13:43help.
- 13:45>> And that's what's most important. What's
- 13:47most important was the treatment, not
- 13:50what is checked off on on a box.
- 13:53>> Makes sense.
- 13:54So you were unable to make a note as to
- 13:58whether or not her affect and her mood
- 14:02appeared to be in conflict and that she
- 14:04would have been in congruent
- 14:07um and that she had poor insight. You
- 14:10couldn't write that down. Is that right?
- 14:11Because the box doesn't let you.
- 14:16>> Correct.
- 14:19>> Um so basically she's telling you that
- 14:22I'm okay. Well, actually when she came,
- 14:24do you know that she never saw other
- 14:26than when she was in nursing school?
- 14:27Would it surprise you? A psychiatrist
- 14:30and that was only for like a week when
- 14:33she got the Prozac in nursing school cuz
- 14:35she was afraid of public speaking.
- 14:37>> Did you know that?
- 14:39>> Um I was aware that she did not have a
- 14:43significant past psychiatric history. I
- 14:46was I was aware of that.
- 14:47>> Okay. Okay. So, you were the first
- 14:48psychiatrist that she had the pleasure
- 14:51of meeting. Is that correct?
- 14:55>> Yeah.
- 14:57Uh, I think it was.
- 15:00>> And isn't that important for you as a
- 15:01doctor to take a history?
- 15:04>> I did take a history.
- 15:05>> So, can you tell us you're testifying
- 15:07here for the governor? Tell us whether
- 15:08or not she had any past psychiatric
- 15:10history other than in nursing school for
- 15:12a week.
- 15:14She did not report any other past
- 15:17psychiatric history other than the
- 15:19Prozac and um Bobby Tren.
- 15:21>> So when a patient comes to see you and
- 15:23you're treating to help that patient, if
- 15:25they don't report something to you,
- 15:29you don't know about it apparently,
- 15:30right?
- 15:31>> Well, I I think it depends. There are
- 15:33certainly things I can assess, but if
- 15:35it's related to their history, um I I do
- 15:40need them to tell me. Well, you can't
- 15:42assess it unless you ask, right?
- 15:45>> Well, unless I I ask or they volunteer
- 15:47it or pull it out.
- 15:48>> We already talked about the
- 15:49volunteering. How about you as a doctor
- 15:51when you when you're evaluating a
- 15:53patient coming to you for help? Do you
- 15:55ask them questions?
- 15:58>> Yes.
- 15:59>> You didn't ask her a prior history.
- 16:01>> I did.
- 16:02>> What did she tell you?
- 16:04She she said that her prior history was
- 16:07was what we discussed about the the
- 16:10Prozac in the nursing school.
- 16:14[clears throat]
- 16:15So
- 16:20basically
- 16:22other than hoping to give her hope is
- 16:26what you said for the therapy. How do
- 16:29you give someone hope for for therapy?
- 16:31The other doctor
- 16:34try to encourage them. And
- 16:37>> what did you encourage her on September
- 16:3915th?
- 16:39>> Sorry.
- 16:40>> What did you encourage her to give her
- 16:41hope on September 15th?
- 16:43>> What did I encourage her? Yeah,
- 16:44>> I I don't remember exactly the the
- 16:47words. It was it was on your records.
- 16:51>> No, we don't we don't write those, you
- 16:53know, details of every everything.
- 16:55>> That's the therapy you're talking about,
- 16:56right?
- 16:57>> Yes.
- 16:58>> Yes. And you don't write down the
- 17:00therapy you give the patient in the
- 17:01records, right?
- 17:02>> Well, I write something about it. I
- 17:04mentioned that. Excuse me. Hold on. Hold
- 17:06on. So, yes or no?
- 17:07>> Hold on. You let her finish the
- 17:09question. If you listen to the question
- 17:11and answer just what they asked. Okay.
- 17:13Go ahead. You can re rephrase that
- 17:16question. Coun.
- 17:16>> No, I'll let her answer it.
- 17:17>> All right.
- 17:18>> I mentioned that I provided supportive
- 17:21therapy.
- 17:22>> What is supportive therapy? It's
- 17:26listening to the patients concerns and
- 17:28providing emotional support and
- 17:30validation.
- 17:31>> So, emotional support and validation.
- 17:34All sounds good. Here's a young woman
- 17:36who was what, 20, 29, 30 years old, came
- 17:39to see you.
- 17:42>> Yes.
- 17:43>> And came to see you for help, right?
- 17:46>> Yes.
- 17:46>> Told you she couldn't sleep and she was
- 17:48anxious. Correct.
- 17:49>> Yes.
- 17:50>> You know that she was postpartum,
- 17:51correct?
- 17:52>> Yes.
- 17:53>> You know that as a patient who was
- 17:55postpartum. By the way, what is your
- 17:58opinion of the period of postpartum
- 18:00wherein one can have postpartum
- 18:03depression or more importantly
- 18:04postpartum psychosis?
- 18:07What's the time frame?
- 18:09>> Uh it's typically one year.
- 18:12>> So she was well within that time frame,
- 18:15correct?
- 18:16>> Yes.
- 18:18And you tried to provide therapy by
- 18:22giving her hope. And how long do you
- 18:24figure did that take? 5 minutes, 10
- 18:26minutes, 2 minutes?
- 18:28>> I'm not sure. I think it was different
- 18:30in in each session.
- 18:31>> Okay. So, the only thing that you
- 18:34diagnosed Lindsay with on September 15th
- 18:37was GAD, generalized anxiety disorder.
- 18:40Correct.
- 18:42It was generalized anxiety disorder as
- 18:45well as an adjustment disorder with
- 18:47depressed mood.
- 18:49>> And you prescribed medications to her,
- 18:51right?
- 18:53>> Yes.
- 18:53>> And the medication that you provided to
- 18:55her was the circulate, right?
- 18:58>> Yes.
- 18:59>> The certain would be Zolola, right?
- 19:03>> Yes.
- 19:03>> Now, this is a little chart that shows
- 19:06the prescriptions that Lindsay was on.
- 19:09And you have the yellow colors.
- 19:14Okay.
- 19:16See that?
- 19:20Do you agree with me that on September
- 19:2215th you prescribe certuline Zoloft 30
- 19:26count on September 15th 25 milligram?
- 19:29Right.
- 19:30>> Yes.
- 19:38Have you ever read the website for
- 19:41certuline?
- 19:44>> The the website for certuline.
- 19:46>> Yeah. I mean certuline zoa is a is a
- 19:50chemical that is marketed as a
- 19:53pharmaceutical. Right.
- 19:56>> Yes.
- 19:57>> Right.
- 19:59It's a pill. Right.
- 20:01>> Yes. And as we said, it's an SSRI tool.
- 20:04Correct?
- 20:06>> Yes.
- 20:06>> Do you know that Zoloft is not indicated
- 20:09for generalized anxiety?
- 20:12>> Why'd you give a Zolola?
- 20:14>> It is a very effective medication for
- 20:17generalized anxiety disorder.
- 20:19>> So, you're familiar with the drug
- 20:20labeling for Zolaf. Is that correct?
- 20:24Um
- 20:26>> generally
- 20:27>> generally
- 20:29um are you aware of what the
- 20:32manufacturer of Zoloft indicates it can
- 20:37be used for to treat?
- 20:43>> Um I'm aware that it's used to treat
- 20:46various forms of anxiety disorders as
- 20:50well as major depression. So when
- 20:52Lindsay came to see you, you know that
- 20:56she had stopped breastfeeding
- 20:58her son, right?
- 21:01>> Not at the time of the first
- 21:02appointment.
- 21:03>> When did she stop breastfeeding? In
- 21:04October,
- 21:06>> something around then.
- 21:08>> Um, you know that she had little or no
- 21:11psychiatric history other than seeing
- 21:13you, correct?
- 21:14>> And the Prozac? Yes. you know that uh in
- 21:17fact that she had stopped drinking
- 21:19whatever it was that she was drinking
- 21:21because you never asked, right?
- 21:24>> I was not concerned about her level of
- 21:26drinking.
- 21:28>> Did did Well, it's in your form, right?
- 21:30>> That was at the intake, but um I
- 21:34>> did you know that she wasn't drinking
- 21:35when you when you were meeting with her,
- 21:37correct?
- 21:38>> I Yeah, that's what she told me.
- 21:40>> Okay. And you and you believe what she
- 21:41told me, right?
- 21:42>> Yes.
- 21:45So when she sees you, she's not on any
- 21:48psychiatric anti-ropics or whatever
- 21:51they're called medications. Correct. She
- 21:53wasn't on any medication.
- 21:54>> Correct.
- 21:56>> And she had stopped drinking anything,
- 21:59whatever it may have been. Right.
- 22:02>> Um I'm not sure when she completely
- 22:04stopped drinking, but yes.
- 22:05>> You don't know when she started, when
- 22:07she stopped, what she drank, do you?
- 22:09>> Well, I was not concerned that she was
- 22:11an alcoholic.
- 22:12>> That's a yes or no. Did you did you have
- 22:14any idea because we spent a long time on
- 22:16Friday talking about her guilt and
- 22:19having that she drank uh alcohol. You
- 22:22don't know what she drank, when she
- 22:23drank, when she started, when she
- 22:25stopped being
- 22:27>> I know some details about her alcohol
- 22:29use, but it was overall minimal. So I
- 22:33>> What were the details then? Tell me what
- 22:34the details were. There was that one
- 22:36little box that was checked off. What
- 22:38What other details were there? that she
- 22:42drank one to two times a week. Five one
- 22:45to two servings five times a week.
- 22:48>> And And you don't know where what what
- 22:50it was. You have no idea, right?
- 22:52>> Um I I think she had mentioned at some
- 22:55point that it was it was calming. It was
- 22:59something that was
- 23:01>> calming.
- 23:01>> Calming. Okay. So she it was numbing. It
- 23:03was like like trying to numb something,
- 23:05I guess. Right.
- 23:07>> That's one way of saying it.
- 23:08>> I mean, you've treated
- 23:10I imagine you've treated veterans that
- 23:12have post-traumatic stress disorder,
- 23:14right?
- 23:15>> Yes.
- 23:15>> And would you agree with me that many
- 23:17times when people have an anxiety
- 23:19disorder or PTSD or whatever the case
- 23:21may be, they try to numb.
- 23:24Is that fair?
- 23:25>> Sometimes they do.
- 23:26>> And sometimes they use alcohol, right?
- 23:29>> Sometimes they do.
- 23:30>> We don't know what alcohol. We don't
- 23:31even know if it was a beer, do we?
- 23:34>> I didn't think that was relevant for
- 23:36her. So
- 23:38with all of that in with that
- 23:42information you then prescribed Zoloft
- 23:45to her correct?
- 23:47>> Yes.
- 23:48>> Um
- 23:50you went over the side effects of Zoloft
- 23:52certainly I imagine with her right?
- 23:55>> Yes.
- 23:56>> Did you tell her that one of the known
- 23:57side effects of suicidal thoughts and
- 23:59actions and ideation?
- 24:01>> Well that's specifically in in children.
- 24:03Um, so I I don't think I mentioned that
- 24:06cuz it wasn't relevant.
- 24:07>> Not really. Um, suicidal ideation and
- 24:10homicidal ideation. Uh, there's a black
- 24:13box warning
- 24:15you lot along with SSRI, right?
- 24:19>> Under a
- 24:21>> for children and adults younger than
- 24:23Lindsay.
- 24:23>> Thank you, doctor. I apologize. Can you
- 24:25just listen to my question and answer it
- 24:27yes or no? Is there a black box warning
- 24:32on Zoloft?
- 24:33>> Yes.
- 24:34>> Okay. And a black box warning is
- 24:39required or prescribed by what? The FDA?
- 24:43>> Probably.
- 24:44>> Probably.
- 24:46And it basically warns that especially
- 24:49with young people uh or young adults
- 24:54that it may cause suicidal or god forbid
- 24:58homicidal ideiation. Yes.
- 25:03>> Yes. And
- 25:04>> and you're aware that in fact the FDA
- 25:08has determined that that goes up
- 25:11possibly to a 23 or 24 25 year old. You
- 25:15know that, right?
- 25:17>> I think 24 is is what they say.
- 25:19>> I'll give you 24.
- 25:23>> It's possible, is it not? That the SSRI
- 25:29that get into a person's brain affect a
- 25:33person that's three or four years older
- 25:36than the FDA cutoff with suicidal
- 25:39ideiation or homicidal ideiation?
- 25:42It's possible. There's a lot of
- 25:44development that happens in the brain
- 25:46between ages like up to 24 and closer to
- 25:5130. The brain is is fully matured at um
- 25:55past age 24. And so it's it's less
- 25:57vulnerable than in a younger individual.
- 26:01>> So with 24 you're suggesting is a cut
- 26:04off. Are you suggesting to the jury that
- 26:06a drug that increases the risk of
- 26:07suicide in a 24 year old patient cannot
- 26:09increase the risk of suicide in a 29 or
- 26:12a 30-year-old patient? Just a little
- 26:14bit.
- 26:17>> There's there I don't believe there's
- 26:19evidence that it causes that at all in
- 26:22individuals over 24. So as a
- 26:25psychiatrist who had the ability to
- 26:28issue these types of medications to
- 26:31patients and citizens, what research did
- 26:34you do on Zolola and suicidal ideation,
- 26:37homicidal ideation?
- 26:39>> I was taught extensively about SSRIs and
- 26:44suicidal ideiation in my training,
- 26:46right?
- 26:48>> In Vermont, in Boston. Yes.
- 26:50>> Okay. So in Vermont was when you get
- 26:51your medical degree, right?
- 26:53Yes.
- 26:54>> And last would be when you were a
- 26:56resident, right?
- 26:57>> Yes.
- 26:58>> And then you have board certification on
- 27:02general psychiatry, right?
- 27:05>> Yes.
- 27:05>> You can have a certification on the sub
- 27:07specialty, right?
- 27:09>> There are certain subsp specialties.
- 27:10Yes.
- 27:11>> Right. And some of the subsp specialties
- 27:12deal with postpartum or women that are
- 27:15pregnant and have babies and have
- 27:18psychiatric
- 27:19symptomology. There's no board
- 27:21certification for perinatal or
- 27:24reproductive psychiatry.
- 27:26>> Well, there are plenty of classes that
- 27:28are recognized as for example um at
- 27:31Harvard Medical School there's an annual
- 27:36class or symposium if you will for
- 27:39postpartum. Do have you ever been to
- 27:41that?
- 27:42>> No sir.
- 27:43>> What have you done to research or to
- 27:47improve your educa? I understand you
- 27:48went to med school and that you're a
- 27:50resident. What
- 27:53programs,
- 27:54continuing education,
- 27:57symposiums have you attended since you
- 28:00got the ability to prescribe these
- 28:02medicines to people?
- 28:04>> I have not attended a symposium.
- 28:07>> Have you attended anything?
- 28:10I have not but I have done a lot of
- 28:13reading on my own of research and um
- 28:18guidelines about this area in
- 28:20psychiatry.
- 28:21>> Did you tell Lindsay when you were going
- 28:23because one of the things that you guys
- 28:25are always concerned about is what's
- 28:26called informed consent, right?
- 28:29>> Yes.
- 28:29>> And and what is informed consent? What
- 28:31does that mean?
- 28:32>> It means
- 28:32>> in a medical sense, not just like out in
- 28:34the street or something.
- 28:36explaining to a patient the risks and
- 28:40benefits of treatment um and possible
- 28:44alternatives and making sure that the
- 28:47patient understands what you're saying.
- 28:51>> Now, when you were going over the
- 28:53symptomology or when you were going over
- 28:55the side effects of Zoloft, one of the
- 28:57side effects of Zoloft is, and I quote,
- 29:00severe trouble sleeping, right?
- 29:04>> Yes.
- 29:05Did you tell her that?
- 29:08>> Um, well in insomnia is listed as a side
- 29:12effect.
- 29:12>> No, no, no, no. You already said yes.
- 29:14You know it. We just did you tell her
- 29:17that Zoloft
- 29:19has a side effect of giving the patient
- 29:22severe trouble sleeping. That's all.
- 29:26So, I didn't use the word severe because
- 29:28it typically doesn't cause severe
- 29:31trouble sleeping, but I thought you were
- 29:33referring to when she told me that she
- 29:36did have severe trouble sleeping.
- 29:38>> That's what she told me, right? That she
- 29:40had severe trouble sleeping, right?
- 29:41>> She told me. Yes.
- 29:42>> Yes. And you know that one of the side
- 29:44effects of Zolaf is, let's say, trouble
- 29:49sleeping. You know that, right?
- 29:51>> Yes.
- 29:52>> Your answer is yes. Jury has to be able
- 29:53to hear you. Yes.
- 29:56>> And why would you prescribe Zoloft to a
- 29:59young woman who's postpartum, who's
- 30:02coming to you with anxiety, who's
- 30:04telling you he can't she can't sleep,
- 30:06she's got all of these symptoms, and you
- 30:08prescribe a medication that would have a
- 30:11side effect of trouble sleeping.
- 30:14>> So, individuals have very varied
- 30:17responses to medications. Some have no
- 30:20side effects, some have one or two. It's
- 30:22impossible to predict, but Zoloft is a
- 30:25top choice, a firstline medication for
- 30:28her. It was
- 30:29>> says who?
- 30:31>> Um, says it's it's the general
- 30:33consensus.
- 30:36Again, we can't have both of you talking
- 30:38at the same time. So, let her finish her
- 30:41answer and then I'll give you plenty of
- 30:44time to follow up any uh questions
- 30:46regarding her answer. So um
- 30:50you finish your answer on that.
- 30:52>> There's extensive research supporting
- 30:54the use of search for lean um in this
- 30:58instance and the general consensus among
- 31:01psychiatrists is that it's a firstline
- 31:04safe medication for individuals
- 31:07including postpartum women.
- 31:09>> How about the kids that shoot other kids
- 31:11in high schools and the lawsuits that
- 31:12come out of that against? Have you read
- 31:14about them? Objection
- 31:16>> overrule.
- 31:18>> Sorry.
- 31:21>> I I wasn't sure what the question was.
- 31:23>> The question was in response to your
- 31:26observation about how all the
- 31:27psychiatrists or psychiatrists think
- 31:29it's a very very safe wonderful first
- 31:32line drug and you researched it. How
- 31:37about the kids that kill other kids in
- 31:39schools with the lawsuits that arise out
- 31:42of the use of SSI? Have you ever
- 31:44researched that?
- 31:46>> I I don't know much about that.
- 31:48>> We know about the SSRI
- 31:51messing with someone's brain. They they
- 31:53go out and they shoot people for no
- 31:55reason, right?
- 31:56>> I'm not aware that that's linked to
- 31:58SSRIs.
- 32:01>> So, you didn't really talk to her about
- 32:04increased risk of suicide and 24 year
- 32:07olds are down because she's four or five
- 32:09years older than that. You didn't talk
- 32:11to her about the trouble sleeping that
- 32:13can a side effect, but describes there's
- 32:16other drugs that you could have given
- 32:18her that would be perfectly safe and
- 32:21calm and allow someone with no
- 32:23psychiatric history to sleep better,
- 32:25right?
- 32:27>> Not necessarily.
- 32:29>> Okay. So, you prescribed her with the
- 32:31Zolaf, it was 25 milligrams, right?
- 32:34>> Yes. And when you prescribed her with
- 32:37the Zolaf 25 milligrams, was that
- 32:40increased up to up to uh 0.05 milligrams
- 32:44or did you increase it at some point?
- 32:47>> Um the instructions were to increase it
- 32:50to 50 after one week.
- 32:52>> After one week?
- 32:53>> Yes.
- 32:54>> Um and you expected that she would
- 32:55listen to your instructions, right?
- 32:58>> Yes.
- 32:58>> And she did, right?
- 33:00>> She waited about a month, but then yes,
- 33:02she did. Why did she wait a month?
- 33:05>> I think it took her some time to decide
- 33:08whether that was truly what she wanted
- 33:09to do.
- 33:10>> Right. She was afraid of the drugs,
- 33:11wasn't she?
- 33:12>> She was afraid of side effects.
- 33:14>> And she didn't want to take the pills,
- 33:15did she?
- 33:18>> She eventually did want to take the
- 33:20pills because she wanted to feel better
- 33:22>> a month later, right?
- 33:24>> Yes. So you prescribe
- 33:27the Zoloft SSRI
- 33:30and then you tell her after a week to
- 33:33increase it
- 33:35and she doesn't take that medication for
- 33:39a month. Correct.
- 33:41>> Correct.
- 33:42>> And then she did take the medication,
- 33:45right?
- 33:46>> Yes. And and did you meet with her or
- 33:50talk to her before she actually started
- 33:52to implement that particular regimen?
- 33:55>> I had met with her beforehand, but I was
- 34:00not aware um of when she made the
- 34:03decision to go ahead and take it.
- 34:06>> So, you met her on the 15th of
- 34:09September, right?
- 34:11Yes.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Lindsay Clancy’s Psychiatrist Grilled Over Missed Warning Signs by Law&Crime Trials, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,086 words across 875 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.