Liberal Atheist Gets Absolutely DESTROYED — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05I think we can move on to DSA or we can
- 0:08try to move on to Christian values in
- 0:10the government if we wanted to kind of
- 0:13talk about that. Um
- 0:14>> Yeah, I'd love to get into Christian
- 0:16values in the government.
- 0:18>> So let's talk about um Christian
- 0:33>> You want me to go first?
- 0:34>> Oh yeah, go ahead.
- 0:35>> Yeah. And
- 0:36>> Yeah, so it's really easy. So um unless
- 0:38you're going to get rid of men who are
- 0:40in black robes who give the law
- 0:42and you're going to get rid of Bibles
- 0:44that people swear oaths on
- 0:46or you're going to give them something
- 0:47else to swear oaths on
- 0:50if unless it's the case that uh you want
- 0:53to get rid
- 0:54of all of the national mysticism that we
- 0:58rely on which includes enforcement arms
- 1:01in costumes,
- 1:03judges in black robes giving the law
- 1:06and law interpreters, law keepers, and
- 1:09oath makers,
- 1:11uh then you're banking on religion, my
- 1:13friend,
- 1:14because those are not
- 1:17secular ideals.
- 1:18Those are religious ideals.
- 1:21And I'm guessing that you probably want
- 1:22to keep them intact, don't you?
- 1:26>> I mean yeah, obviously. That's not
- 1:28really an an argument. That seems kind
- 1:30of strange to
- 1:32say that somehow removing
- 1:35um religious um
- 1:38driven law
- 1:39is
- 1:41uh tantamount to anarchy.
- 1:43>> Well, you're not removing religious law.
- 1:45You're just banking on it.
- 1:47See what you've done is you've now
- 1:48created rituals.
- 1:50See you have all sorts of little rituals
- 1:52and you just take them for granted every
- 1:53day. But you have guys who sit up on an
- 1:56elevated bench who look down at you
- 1:58and they get to decide your disputes.
- 2:00They get to decide if you're in prison.
- 2:02They get to decide if you're
- 2:04executed.
- 2:05You have a little ritual of a little
- 2:07jury of your peers who comes in. You
- 2:08have a ritual of a constitution and
- 2:11constitutional law, which is all made
- 2:12up.
- 2:13But there's some like ritual of
- 2:15patriotism that upkeeps it, some ritual
- 2:17of Americana that upkeeps it. It's all
- 2:20religious. It's all dogmatic. All of it
- 2:22is dogma, bro.
- 2:24And it's not like you people are going
- 2:26to get rid of dogma. You just want your
- 2:29dogma there instead of Christian dogma.
- 2:31And I say no. Christian dogma is way
- 2:33better than your dogma.
- 2:35>> I mean, you don't know my dogma, so
- 2:37that's kind of a strange
- 2:38>> If you're advocating for socialism, then
- 2:40I have a pretty good understanding of
- 2:41it.
- 2:43>> I can understand where like I I don't
- 2:45have any argument against your point
- 2:47that the dogma of what our religion is
- 2:49or or
- 2:51government is, our institutions are
- 2:54can't really be removed. And it is
- 2:55ritualistic, but
- 2:58things being ritualistic at its heart
- 3:00isn't Christianity.
- 3:03>> No, she is worse. She is really funny
- 3:05because you'll say, ah, Andrew, you
- 3:08believe in this sky fairy in the sky who
- 3:11who like tells you to do things. You're
- 3:13delusional. And yet you believe in a
- 3:15piece of paper. You're delusional. You
- 3:17believe in judges. You're delusional.
- 3:19You believe in the constitution. You're
- 3:21delusional, [ __ ] You're
- 3:22delusional. That's all You just made all
- 3:25that up.
- 3:26And yet I'm supposed to follow it?
- 3:29Why the [ __ ] should I follow any of that
- 3:31Why should I?
- 3:33It's all made the [ __ ] up, right?
- 3:35>> I mean, man, if you're going to say
- 3:36that, everything humanity has ever done
- 3:39is made up. All we've ever done is make
- 3:41up.
- 3:42>> So then it sounds like we really need
- 3:43dogma and ritual, and we really need to
- 3:45have dogma and ritual in order to
- 3:47organize humanity, doesn't it? And isn't
- 3:49it great that I can bank on a
- 3:512,000-year-old system that's done just
- 3:53that to great success all over the
- 3:55western world, and you got nothing?
- 3:58Nothing at all that you can replace it
- 4:00with. Nothing.
- 4:01>> Let me go back and say I'm not going
- 4:03>> to say that you're delusional. I don't
- 4:04have any reason to care about what you
- 4:07believe in or the way that you want to
- 4:09do things. That's fine with me because I
- 4:11live in America and it's okay for you to
- 4:13have different beliefs than I do and
- 4:15it's okay for you to pursue your
- 4:16religion the way that you want to. It's
- 4:18not okay for you to tell me that I have
- 4:20to live the way that your religion
- 4:21dictates that I should live.
- 4:23>> backwards and
- 4:25>> That you don't even believe that.
- 4:26>> of religion existing and that being the
- 4:28reason that we have dogma and that we
- 4:30have ritual isn't isn't true. We had
- 4:33morality, we had dogma, we had rituals
- 4:36before there was recorded religion. Once
- 4:38humans started to realize that
- 4:40that we succeed in the wild
- 4:43>> That let's clarify a couple of points.
- 4:45Let's go back to let's do the second
- 4:47point first. When do you think that we
- 4:49had rituals and dogma absent of religion
- 4:51again?
- 4:53When is this?
- 4:54>> Before recorded religion, we had ways of
- 4:57our societies dealing with this.
- 4:59>> was this?
- 5:01>> I don't know. It was before recorded
- 5:02religion.
- 5:03>> so you just made it up?
- 5:04>> No, I didn't. It was it was well known.
- 5:06>> an example of it?
- 5:07>> No, I can't.
- 5:08>> So you made it up.
- 5:10You just made it up, bro.
- 5:12Yeah, all of the all of the criteria
- 5:14that you would consider uh dogmas and
- 5:16faith you would consider religious. All
- 5:19of those things that are dogmatic and
- 5:20faith based you would consider religious
- 5:22based unless it comes to your system.
- 5:25And when you say, oh hey, uh you know,
- 5:28you don't have a right to impose your
- 5:29system on me. That's exactly what you're
- 5:31doing with secularism. What are you
- 5:32talking about? You're literally trying
- 5:34to make an imposition of a system on me
- 5:37that I disagree with. And while saying,
- 5:39wait, my system encompasses you. But
- 5:41wait, how wait, how are you going to say
- 5:43Christianity Hang on, hang on, almost
- 5:45done. How are you going to say
- 5:46Christianity doesn't encompass you when
- 5:47you sit there right now an atheist?
- 5:49Where are the Christians hamstringing
- 5:51you? Where are they stringing you up at?
- 5:53Where's that happening?
- 5:56>> That's not what I'm saying at all.
- 5:58What I'm saying is our religion or our
- 6:01Jesus, our institution, our rules, our
- 6:04government shouldn't be guided by
- 6:06religious
- 6:08>> Why not? They are right now.
- 6:11>> Because I don't necessarily believe what
- 6:13you believe about your religion.
- 6:14>> What do I care what you
- 6:16>> the street doesn't necessarily
- 6:17>> don't care about your constitution, but
- 6:19I got to follow it, right?
- 6:21>> Well, then if you don't care about I
- 6:22mean, that's kind of a absurd thing to
- 6:25say.
- 6:25>> should I How is it absurd?
- 6:27>> then what the [ __ ]
- 6:28>> How is it absurd for me to say I don't
- 6:31believe in your [ __ ] So why should
- 6:33I follow it? That's exactly what you're
- 6:34saying to me. Andrew, I don't believe in
- 6:36that whole Christianity So why should I
- 6:38have to follow it? I don't want to
- 6:40follow your rules. I don't want to
- 6:41follow your regulations.
- 6:42>> at all what I'm saying. You're putting
- 6:44those words in my mouth.
- 6:45>> are you saying?
- 6:45>> If you let me finish, I will get to what
- 6:47I'm saying.
- 6:48>> All right.
- 6:48>> You should be allowed to believe what
- 6:50you believe and practice that per your
- 6:52own life.
- 6:54>> What the [ __ ] does that have to do with
- 6:56Christianity and government? What does
- 6:58it have to do with that?
- 7:00>> Why are we taking religious principles
- 7:02and making them what needs to happen in
- 7:05our government?
- 7:06>> Because all governmental principles are
- 7:08faith-based.
- 7:10All of them are faith-based, bro. Every
- 7:13one of them are faith-based. You made
- 7:15all that up and you want me to have
- 7:16faith in it.
- 7:19>> Okay. That's fine.
- 7:21>> You made all that
- 7:22up and you want me to have faith in it.
- 7:24But the second I say, oh, this other you
- 7:26think is made up, I want you to have
- 7:28faith in it, you cry foul. That no fair.
- 7:30No fair. I don't believe in that. It's
- 7:32like neither do I, [ __ ] just on
- 7:34the other end. But I got to follow the
- 7:35rules, so so do you.
- 7:37>> Yeah, I didn't say anything about not
- 7:38following the rules.
- 7:39>> take over this nice United States and we
- 7:41implement our fairy tale rules, you
- 7:43better follow them just like we got to
- 7:45follow your fairy tale rules.
- 7:47>> Are they not the same rules for the most
- 7:49part?
- 7:49>> No, they're not the same rules. There's
- 7:51all sorts of things that we're going to
- 7:52do, my friend. What do you mean? All
- 7:55sorts of uh like for instance, the
- 7:57outlawing of marriage, the affirmation
- 8:00that there's only two genders. We're
- 8:02going to have top-down propaganda that
- 8:04says, hey man, if it's not procreative,
- 8:06we really don't want to push it in
- 8:07society. We want to have high birth
- 8:10rates. We don't want immigration from
- 8:12non-Christian nations. We don't even
- 8:14want to have
- 8:15immigration for most Christian nations.
- 8:18Oh, yes, there's going to be lots of
- 8:20changes, lots and lots of changes, but
- 8:23you can't make an argument against any
- 8:24of them because it's all just made up
- 8:26[ __ ] anyway from your view.
- 8:28All of it.
- 8:30Your all made up [ __ ]
- 8:32and you think my all made up [ __ ]
- 8:35The only difference is if I got to
- 8:36follow your rules, then you got to
- 8:38follow my rules.
- 8:40>> My [ __ ] isn't made up [ __ ] It's
- 8:42it's simple morality and interdependence
- 8:44of of humans.
- 8:45>> What are you talking about? You can't
- 8:46justify morality. You'd be the first
- 8:48atheist in history who's ever justified
- 8:50morality is anything other than
- 8:52preference. Give me a single stance
- 8:53independent reason that I should do
- 8:56anything as a moral action. By stance
- 8:59independent, I mean didn't come from
- 9:01your own personal preferences or mind.
- 9:04Give me a single reason I should ever
- 9:05take a moral action.
- 9:07>> If that's if that's your point on it,
- 9:08then
- 9:09I don't like what is your stance
- 9:12independent?
- 9:13>> I know. That's the beauty of my system.
- 9:15I wouldn't need to have anything other
- 9:17than a stance in alignment with the god
- 9:18I believed in order to come in complete
- 9:20compliance with what you think morality
- 9:22is. Therefore, anything I do based on
- 9:25that system with god from your view is
- 9:27totally moral because that's how you
- 9:29derive morality, sir.
- 9:32Do you understand? Like there's no
- 9:33possible way for you to ever give a
- 9:35criticism to me for saying my stance is
- 9:37aligned with god's stances because all
- 9:39of us only have stance dependent reasons
- 9:41from your views for doing [ __ ] So as
- 9:43long as it's dependent upon my stance,
- 9:45that's just as moral as anything
- 9:47dependent on your stance.
- 9:48>> So I don't really understand then what
- 9:50your point is about
- 9:51me saying that I don't believe that we
- 9:53should have religion guiding our rules
- 9:56at the same point that your morality is
- 9:57dictated by some something that you're
- 9:59determining to be the the dictation of
- 10:02morality. If our rules are based on,
- 10:05hey, we should be moral towards each
- 10:06other and this is the basis of our
- 10:08morality in our society, then I don'
- 10:10really understand how you should have
- 10:13the ability to tell me what the [ __ ] is
- 10:15moral and how I should be doing it.
- 10:17>> Because I'm using the same system. I'm
- 10:19using the same system you are.
- 10:21Because I'm using the same system you
- 10:22are. I'm using stances, a stance
- 10:25dependent reason, and then applying the
- 10:27same exact criticism based on faith, the
- 10:29same [ __ ] you're [ __ ] doing. You have
- 10:32a stance dependent reason. You decide to
- 10:34pass a law based on what your stance
- 10:36says is moral, and then you enforce that
- 10:38law based on your preferences for
- 10:40society that I now have to follow. I'm
- 10:42doing the exact same thing back.
- 10:44You can't have a critic. There can't
- 10:46What's the criticism? What?
- 10:48>> No, I said there's one difference.
- 10:49>> What's the difference?
- 10:51>> The idea that I would appreciate in our
- 10:54government is that you're okay to live
- 10:56your life the way you want to.
- 10:58>> No, you're not.
- 10:59Why do you just lie to my face? Why did
- 11:00you just lie to me? Do you think I'm
- 11:02stupid? Do you think I know I can't live
- 11:04my life how I want to? Let me ask you
- 11:06something, sir. Are you allowed to get
- 11:08up on top of your roof right now in your
- 11:10private dwelling and start off in view
- 11:12of the public?
- 11:13>> Yeah.
- 11:14>> No, you're not.
- 11:15>> Oh, yeah, I am.
- 11:16>> Oh, no.
- 11:18Oh, so you can't just do what you want.
- 11:20>> Oh, I can.
- 11:21>> There's rules.
- 11:21>> I have to be ready to deal with the
- 11:22consequences.
- 11:23>> are imposed upon you. Well, sure, then
- 11:25you could just say that about anything.
- 11:26Sure, I could go 30 people. I just got
- 11:28to be ready for the consequences, right?
- 11:30So the thing is is like, no, all it is
- 11:33is an imposition of rules that you
- 11:35decide that you're going to impose at
- 11:36the barrel of a gun and then get mad
- 11:38when I do the same to you.
- 11:42>> Yeah, but I mean,
- 11:45the basis of the argument, sure, you're
- 11:47right, but that's an absurd argument.
- 11:50I'm imposing that you can't just go kill
- 11:5230 people because it's somehow my faith
- 11:55that we should be decent to each other
- 11:57and we should have interdependence and
- 11:59the bettering of our society is done
- 12:01together.
- 12:01>> Yeah, I'll prove it to you. Because you
- 12:03can't come up with a single moral
- 12:05prescription that's not stance
- 12:06dependent, you can't even say that me
- 12:08going and killing 30 people is immoral
- 12:10except based on your own stance.
- 12:13>> I
- 12:13>> can say that it's immoral from the way
- 12:15that I would feel about it.
- 12:17>> your own stance, exactly. So you have a
- 12:19stance dependent reason based on your
- 12:21own stance, you would say this is
- 12:22immoral. That's the only justi
- 12:24>> people doesn't do harm.
- 12:25>> the only justification that you have for
- 12:27it. Even the harm principle is just
- 12:29self-justification based on personal
- 12:31preference and your own stance. Great.
- 12:33Okay. So all I'm doing is the same
- 12:35thing. I'm taking a stance which I think
- 12:37aligns with God's stance and I'm willing
- 12:38to enforce it at the barrel of a gun
- 12:40just like you are. There's no difference
- 12:42at all. The only difference is you say,
- 12:44well, my system's better. And we could
- 12:46even get into that. If you want to, I'll
- 12:48even throw you the bone and we can
- 12:50compare the systems and see which ones
- 12:51are even better by your own standards
- 12:53cuz even by your standards your system
- 12:55sucks.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Liberal Atheist Gets Absolutely DESTROYED by The Crucible , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,547 words across 396 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.