Level 1 Apologist Gets Destroyed on Every Argument and Runs from His Bible — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Your name Yikers is getting to be pretty
- 0:01appropriate. Do you think that women
- 0:03that are captured in war actually have
- 0:04consent?
- 0:08>> I'm telling you that Paul says in the
- 0:10>> I'm asking for a yes or no to my [ __ ]
- 0:12question. Do you think women captured in
- 0:13war have consent?
- 0:14>> You're a [ __ ] idiot. How about that?
- 0:16>> I need the answer to the question.
- 0:19>> Yeah, you know what? Let's let's debate
- 0:21on the atheist experience.
- 0:23I'll see you guys
- 0:23>> I would run the [ __ ] away from this one,
- 0:25too. Can't blame you. That checks out.
- 0:27>> Yeah, okay.
- 0:28>> I'm not running away. I
- 0:30>> It certainly looks like you're running
- 0:31away. It looks like It looks like we are
- 0:34going to make some extra time for one
- 0:35other guest, a Yo,
- 0:37who has been waiting patiently
- 0:40um with his
- 0:41probably audio and camera turned on. So,
- 0:44welcome in, Yo.
- 0:46>> Yeah, you guys can hear me?
- 0:47>> Yep.
- 0:49>> Yeah, you guys can hear me? Nice. All
- 0:51right.
- 0:51>> Yeah.
- 0:53>> Well, this is the first for me.
- 0:55>> Yeah, sure. Uh do you Are you at least
- 0:5818 and do you believe in God?
- 1:01>> Yeah, yeah. I'm uh 20.
- 1:02>> And what God do you believe in?
- 1:04>> do believe in I do believe in the straw
- 1:05you God, yes.
- 1:07>> Sure. So, like the God of the Bible?
- 1:12>> Yeah, that would be the one. Uh
- 1:14and I'm assuming you guys are atheists?
- 1:16>> Yes.
- 1:16>> You got us right.
- 1:18>> All right, good.
- 1:19>> Yeah, what makes you think that God is
- 1:21real?
- 1:24>> Well,
- 1:25it's due to a couple Well, more than a
- 1:27couple of reasons, but one of them would
- 1:29be the absurdity of the view that God
- 1:32isn't real. So, the moral argument, very
- 1:34very strong.
- 1:35>> Mhm.
- 1:36>> Uh there's also the tele- tag argument.
- 1:39>> Oh, [ __ ] We're cooked now, not tag.
- 1:42>> Um
- 1:42>> You're cooked now.
- 1:43>> Yeah, teleological argument, the uh
- 1:46>> Well, teleological argument isn't what
- 1:48you mean by tag, right?
- 1:50>> No, no, no. Tag is um
- 1:52>> the transcendental argument.
- 1:53>> Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's
- 1:54different, yeah. Um there's also
- 1:57arguments for math. So for example, math
- 1:59can predict outcomes in physics like in
- 2:03quantum mechanics when they were trying
- 2:04to find this particle, they were
- 2:06actually able to
- 2:08>> Oh no, the god particle? Holy [ __ ]
- 2:10>> predict
- 2:11>> Which particle?
- 2:11>> I don't think it was the god particle. I
- 2:13think it was one of the particles.
- 2:15And they were able to use principles in
- 2:16math to
- 2:18to actually determine the the behaviors
- 2:21of this particle before it was even
- 2:23found. So that makes way more sense in a
- 2:25theological view of god than it does in
- 2:28an atheistic view.
- 2:30Also the fact that you can't really
- 2:31ground morality as a subjectivist, you
- 2:34know, relativist.
- 2:35>> Why is atheism committed to
- 2:37subjectivism?
- 2:40>> Subjectivism would be
- 2:43truth dependent upon a stance. So if
- 2:45truth is going to be dependent upon a
- 2:47stance, then it's going to be dependent
- 2:49on you.
- 2:50>> I know I understand that.
- 2:51>> and the other guy.
- 2:52>> But why couldn't atheism be committed to
- 2:55like objective morals?
- 2:58>> Because there's no objective
- 3:02high ground to determine what is right
- 3:04and wrong.
- 3:05>> Well, so okay, let's [clears throat]
- 3:07>> truth out there because it's all
- 3:09materialistic, right? There's no
- 3:10epistemic transcendental category.
- 3:12>> That like super doesn't follow. Um so
- 3:14first of all, not all atheists are
- 3:16materialists. That's number one. Uh the
- 3:18second thing is that the laws of logic
- 3:20exist. Whoa, let's just calm down there.
- 3:22The the second thing specifically is
- 3:24that the laws of logic are objective. So
- 3:25presumably an atheist could just ground
- 3:27morals in the laws of logic.
- 3:30>> No, you couldn't. You couldn't because
- 3:31they're transcendental categories.
- 3:33>> I didn't consider that.
- 3:35I didn't consider that.
- 3:38>> I just said the transcendental category.
- 3:40So in order to
- 3:42ground those, you need an objective
- 3:45You need a god to ground those because
- 3:46without it
- 3:47how do you have a way of grounding
- 3:49those?
- 3:50>> Yeah, laws of logic are grounded in
- 3:52difference itself.
- 3:54>> So, you're saying they're axiomatic
- 3:55truths?
- 3:56>> No.
- 3:59I said they're grounded in difference.
- 4:01The fact that some things are not other
- 4:03things necessitates the laws of logic.
- 4:06>> Well, then we see in physics that um
- 4:09like for example [clears throat]
- 4:09>> past that quickly.
- 4:11>> Hm? What was that?
- 4:12>> Yeah, I just moved past that one
- 4:14quickly.
- 4:15>> Well, I'm giving you an example to show
- 4:17you how you can't really ground that.
- 4:18>> Sure.
- 4:19>> First of all, you can't even you can't
- 4:21even know that
- 4:23um
- 4:25you can't even ground epistemology
- 4:27without a god because I mean, [laughter]
- 4:28how can you ground epistemology
- 4:30>> abandoned the moral claim. So, you tried
- 4:32to run the moral argument, it collapsed
- 4:33immediately. Where do you like to Where
- 4:35would you like to pivot to now?
- 4:36>> No, no, wait. How are you not an a-
- 4:38>> And now we're doing epistemology
- 4:39clearly.
- 4:40>> Sorry, how are we
- 4:42Go ahead.
- 4:43>> Yeah, what was your question?
- 4:45>> How are you not a subjectivist if you're
- 4:47an atheist?
- 4:47>> I'm a moral realist.
- 4:48>> an ought from an is.
- 4:50>> Yeah, you can't.
- 4:50>> Yeah, there's going to be oughts that
- 4:51are intrinsic to agency itself. So,
- 4:53there is no is-ought gap.
- 4:56>> Um no, but you still have to do a leap
- 4:59in logic. For example, even if it is
- 5:03preferable to you to live longer, like
- 5:06for example, if they wanted to do
- 5:07surgery on you, you still can't
- 5:11get the ought from that
- 5:13even itself. You know
- 5:14>> Ian is not making the claim that you can
- 5:17go from an
- 5:18is to an ought. Ian is making the claim
- 5:20in the same way that you make the claim
- 5:22that there is an intrinsic ought to
- 5:23reality. In your view, it's based in
- 5:25God. Ian is making the claim that there
- 5:27is an intrinsic ought to agency. So, the
- 5:29fact that agents exist gives you the
- 5:31ought facts.
- 5:32>> Explain Explain that. Explain
- 5:34>> Yeah, sure. So, I'm an agent. What that
- 5:36means is that I take actions to achieve
- 5:37goals. If something is necessary to
- 5:40achieve my goal, then I have a reason to
- 5:42do that thing. That is to say that I
- 5:44ought Sorry, do you reject any of that?
- 5:47>> So Hitler has an objective, it's good
- 5:49for him to achieve his goals.
- 5:51>> back to me the the premises that I put
- 5:52forward or were you not listening?
- 5:53>> you just said you just said
- 5:55>> What premises did I put forward?
- 5:58>> You Okay, go ahead. Finish what you're
- 5:59saying.
- 6:00>> Brutal. Damn, he started like fake
- 6:01laughing and he wasn't even listening.
- 6:03Gosh, you know, unfortunately when you
- 6:05start fake laughing that you inject into
- 6:07the argument it's just going to
- 6:08humiliate yourself.
- 6:09>> with things sounding stupid.
- 6:10>> Go ahead, Ian.
- 6:11>> Yeah, sure. Uh so premise one, I'm an
- 6:14agent. Premise two, if I'm an agent then
- 6:16I take actions to achieve goals. Premise
- 6:18three, if something is necessary to
- 6:20achieve my goal then I have a reason to
- 6:21have it. Premise four, if I have a
- 6:22reason to have something uh then I ought
- 6:25have it. Uh premise five, um if I or so
- 6:28premise five, uh my freedom and
- 6:30well-being are necessary to achieve
- 6:31every goal. Uh premise six, uh
- 6:34if I ought have my freedom and
- 6:36well-being then others ought not
- 6:37interfere with it. Uh premise seven, if
- 6:40others ought not interfere with my
- 6:41freedom and well-being then I have a
- 6:42right to it.
- 6:43And then we can take a step back.
- 6:45Premise eight, uh you know, if agency is
- 6:47sufficient for me to have these rights
- 6:48then they're sufficient for everyone to
- 6:50have these rights. Therefore, everyone
- 6:51has a right to freedom and well-being.
- 6:53So which premise there would you reject?
- 6:56>> Well, first of all, I'd have to write
- 6:57that all down, but it sounds like you
- 6:59made a leap in logic from you need to
- 7:02have these goals be achieved so
- 7:05therefore it's good. Where do you
- 7:07>> Uh sorry, I don't think the word good
- 7:09appears in any premise.
- 7:11Would you agree that you have a reason
- 7:14to take the actions that are necessary
- 7:16to achieve the things that you take
- 7:17yourself as having reason to bring
- 7:19about?
- 7:21>> Yeah, so how do you know that those
- 7:23reasons are actually good?
- 7:25>> No, I don't.
- 7:27>> You would you disagree that you have a
- 7:29reason to achieve the things that you've
- 7:31set as a goal?
- 7:33>> Uh sometimes people have fallacious
- 7:35reasoning.
- 7:36>> Sorry, what do you think the question
- 7:37I'm asking you is?
- 7:39>> You're You're
- 7:40basically trying to put an argument
- 7:42forth for more realism and
- 7:45What question do you think I asked you
- 7:46kind of follow I think I reject premise
- 7:48two.
- 7:49>> You reject that? Okay, so premise one
- 7:51was I'm an agent premise two is if I'm
- 7:54an agent then I take actions to achieve
- 7:56goals. You reject that agents take
- 7:58actions to achieve goals?
- 8:01>> Well, first they need to think of what
- 8:02actions they need to do first. So you
- 8:04skipped a couple steps there.
- 8:05>> But do you reject that agents take
- 8:07actions to achieve goals?
- 8:10You disagree with that?
- 8:11>> to be a
- 8:13Go to
- 8:14and go to
- 8:15I mean no, I think that's sound. I think
- 8:17that's sound.
- 8:17>> Sure, so that was premise two.
- 8:19>> Yeah, it was yeah.
- 8:21Go to premise three. Let's hear.
- 8:22>> Yeah, premise three if something is
- 8:24necessary to achieve my goal, then I
- 8:26have a reason to take that action or
- 8:29have that thing.
- 8:30>> Yeah, but the problem there is that
- 8:32Hitler
- 8:33has an has a reason to achieve his goal.
- 8:36>> That's adjusted later in the syllogism.
- 8:38>> he does have a reason.
- 8:39>> Just engage
- 8:40>> in this one and we'll we'll get to that
- 8:42objection later.
- 8:45>> Why not now?
- 8:46>> Because it
- 8:47>> Well, so I I actually I totally agree. I
- 8:48mean from from Hitler's point of view he
- 8:50does have a reason to take that, but
- 8:52unfortunately Hitler's worldview is a
- 8:53contradiction because Hitler's both
- 8:55committed to him having the freedom and
- 8:57well-being to carry out the Holocaust
- 8:59while denying agents that same right,
- 9:01which means that agency is both
- 9:03sufficient for the right to freedom and
- 9:04well-being, but also insufficient for
- 9:06the right to freedom and well-being. So
- 9:08Hitler's view is a contradiction and
- 9:09it's self-defeating.
- 9:10>> also it's ultimately grounded on your
- 9:12intuition. So how can you know that
- 9:14you're
- 9:14>> No, it's not.
- 9:15Which of these Which of these premises
- 9:17are intuition?
- 9:18>> Cuz your intuitions are really falling
- 9:20apart here.
- 9:21Your intuitions are really going to
- 9:23derive That's how you're going to derive
- 9:25>> Which premise makes any reference to
- 9:26intuition?
- 9:28My My argument is grounded in laws of
- 9:30logic. I know you're probably used to
- 9:32subjective morals because your morals
- 9:33are subjective, but no my morals are
- 9:36objective. Sorry, wait, why ought I do
- 9:38what God tells me to do?
- 9:40>> There was a
- 9:41>> Why ought I do what God tells me to do?
- 9:46>> Because you have the objective
- 9:48um
- 9:49If we If we run the
- 9:52uh argument from contingency
- 9:55we
- 9:55>> Brutal.
- 9:56>> We run it back all the way to God.
- 9:58>> Yeah, I switched to a new one, too.
- 10:00>> him, and he's the ultimate
- 10:02kind of arbiter of what we should do.
- 10:05>> What reason do I have to do what God
- 10:07tells me?
- 10:11>> Because God is the creator. God created
- 10:13morality. God is the creator.
- 10:14>> if I don't Whoa, wait. Sorry, that's
- 10:15question begging. In order for him to
- 10:17create morality, I would need to have
- 10:18some reason to do what he tells me to
- 10:20do. Let's say I don't give a [ __ ] what
- 10:22God tells me to do. What reason do I
- 10:24have then to do what he tells me to do?
- 10:30Uh his mic cut out.
- 10:32>> God cut your mic, bro.
- 10:35>> He was about to blaspheme in the in the
- 10:37name of the Lord, and so
- 10:39>> Yeah.
- 10:42>> You might need to refresh.
- 10:48It's okay, you'll come right back up.
- 10:55>> I do love the overconfidence.
- 10:58>> There's something intrinsically
- 10:59satisfying, you know? Can you Can you
- 11:01think of like I feel like it's like an
- 11:03independent argument for God's ex- or
- 11:05for God's existence, like the intrinsic
- 11:06goodness
- 11:08um and satisfaction that comes out of
- 11:10absolutely stomping people who run the
- 11:12transcendental argument. You know,
- 11:14there's like a qualitative experience
- 11:16there that's like really really quite
- 11:17profound.
- 11:19>> I really would love to see uh how he
- 11:22deals uh with Baby Paste if he uh
- 11:25defaults to uh divine command theory.
- 11:29>> I wonder if this guy's even coming back.
- 11:31>> If he was smart, he wouldn't.
- 11:33>> Yeah. I'm I'm super curious about that.
- 11:35Yeah. I've been reading up on
- 11:37I I'll I guess I'll like fill to to
- 11:40prevent like dead air while we wait for
- 11:41this guy to return. I've been reading up
- 11:42on 1 Samuel 15. I'm convinced that this
- 11:45is completely unsolvable and in fact, I
- 11:47think I might I might start reading I
- 11:49read one article one like academic
- 11:51article on like the interpretations of
- 11:53the word harem. Uh and I'm I'm reading
- 11:57more. I'm looking I'm reading more about
- 11:59it. It looks interesting.
- 12:00>> I have some literature on harem if you
- 12:02if you need any. It's basically it's
- 12:05killing for God and dedicated to God.
- 12:07Like set apart.
- 12:08>> Hey, I'm back.
- 12:09>> Yep.
- 12:10>> Welcome back.
- 12:11>> Okay, the question that we were
- 12:12previously at. Let's say I don't give a
- 12:14[ __ ] what God tells me to do. I don't
- 12:16care. What reason then do I have to do
- 12:19what God tells me to do?
- 12:21>> Because God morality is going to be up
- 12:23subject to God.
- 12:25>> Oh, so it's subjective?
- 12:27>> are
- 12:28No, no, no. It's going to be subject to
- 12:31So, I'm using you're using an
- 12:32equivocation fallacy. So, it's subjected
- 12:34in a different You're equivocating on
- 12:35the term.
- 12:35>> No, [clears throat] I'm I'm using it in
- 12:37the literal sense namely that the
- 12:39morality that you espouse is subject to
- 12:42God's mind.
- 12:44Meaning that it is
- 12:45dependent on God's mind and God's mind
- 12:47only, right?
- 12:48>> It's object because it's predicated on
- 12:51the object of God, the essence of God,
- 12:53not on the hypothesis.
- 12:54>> Wait, so then if if Dr. Blitz, if I just
- 12:56like listen to what Dr. Blitz was doing,
- 12:59you know, he just told me you should
- 13:00live this way, this way, and that way,
- 13:02and then I just do all those things,
- 13:04would that be objective because it's
- 13:06predicated to the object of Dr. Blitz?
- 13:09>> Well, you guys are monists. I'm pretty
- 13:11sure you guys aren't proponents of
- 13:12dualism. So, you guys wouldn't even be
- 13:14able to ground morality in that sense
- 13:16cuz you need to have it grounded in
- 13:17something exterior to the material
- 13:19plane.
- 13:20>> Yeah, sorry. Why?
- 13:22>> So, if you guys are monists, if you guys
- 13:24are materialist Are you guys
- 13:25materialist? I just want to know
- 13:27that.
- 13:28>> We're actually not
- 13:29>> Yeah, middle Platonism, so
- 13:30>> all actually on the same page.
- 13:33>> by quantum mechanics.
- 13:33>> Yikers, hey, pay attention. We're not
- 13:36all on the same page
- 13:37>> But
- 13:38>> with materialism. I think Blitz and I
- 13:40are materialists and Ian's not.
- 13:41>> I'm not a materialist.
- 13:43>> Okay, never mind.
- 13:43>> maybe
- 13:45All right, well, I'll keep debating with
- 13:47Ian then since he seems to have a view
- 13:49that's at
- 13:49>> But also, Yikers, just just
- 13:52Just as a just as a point of contention,
- 13:55I would suggest that you not bring up
- 13:56quantum mechanics again.
- 13:58>> I can bring it up again.
- 14:00>> Okay.
- 14:01>> Okay.
- 14:01>> It's your funeral.
- 14:02>> Yeah, why do you think quantum mechanics
- 14:04contradicts Platonism?
- 14:07>> So, you have, for example, photons,
- 14:09right? So, you have two different
- 14:10natures. One is going to be a particle,
- 14:12one is going to be
- 14:14Uh yeah, we have wave-particle duality,
- 14:17right? So, usually particles have
- 14:20>> There's not two
- 14:20>> Yeah, so that that would reject the law
- 14:21of non-contradiction cuz you have two
- 14:23different natures
- 14:24>> Yeah, So, there aren't two different
- 14:25natures
- 14:26>> by Leibniz's law.
- 14:28>> Yeah, except there aren't two different
- 14:29natures to a photon. A photon is a
- 14:30single thing.
- 14:32>> Uh no, because every particle in nature
- 14:34is going to be
- 14:36usually one or the other. It's going to
- 14:37be a particle or wave.
- 14:38>> No, there are no particles. All
- 14:40particles are waves. They just kind of
- 14:42behave like particles a little bit
- 14:43sometimes.
- 14:44>> it's only with photons, only with
- 14:45photons.
- 14:45>> No, this is this is with all particles,
- 14:47actually.
- 14:48This is with all all fundamental
- 14:49particles.
- 14:50In fact, it's even with composite
- 14:51particles. They all they are all waves,
- 14:53but they sometimes behave a little bit
- 14:55like particles. You might call them wave
- 14:56of course.
- 14:57>> When was this founded?
- 14:58>> When was this founded? Like 1925, 1926?
- 15:02>> My understanding was that particles
- 15:06like photons specifically are have the
- 15:08particle-wave duality.
- 15:10>> Your understanding is incorrect then. I
- 15:12don't know where you learned that, but
- 15:14it's it's strictly false.
- 15:15>> Well, can you give me the argument? Like
- 15:16show me show me how they're both wave
- 15:18and particle at the
- 15:20>> so, photons are a
- 15:22excitation of a of the electromagnetic
- 15:24field, in particular the quantized
- 15:26electromagnetic field. They obey a wave
- 15:27equation, therefore they are waves.
- 15:31So, that means to be a wave.
- 15:32>> They're they they behave they give off
- 15:36wave
- 15:38um
- 15:39like wave it's it's expelled in a wave
- 15:42faction or a wave form, but photons
- 15:44actually have both
- 15:47elements of
- 15:49um
- 15:50particles and waves together once. At
- 15:52least that's what I've heard. Maybe I'm
- 15:53wrong.
- 15:54>> You are.
- 15:55>> do some research.
- 15:57All right, then. Well,
- 15:58>> I mean, like strictly speaking, like
- 15:59photons are waves by construction.
- 16:02They're solutions to the wave equation.
- 16:03They have they they have some they have
- 16:05some properties that sometime they
- 16:07sometimes have some properties that look
- 16:09like what we would call classical
- 16:11particles, meaning that they can they
- 16:12can be localized in space, but that
- 16:14doesn't stop them from being waves.
- 16:18>> Fair enough.
- 16:19Uh but I still refute classical laws of
- 16:22logic. So, the three laws of logic I
- 16:24still reject.
- 16:25Um so, for example,
- 16:26>> Okay. So, you reject the law of
- 16:27non-contradiction?
- 16:28>> I do.
- 16:30Okay.
- 16:30>> That's crazy.
- 16:31>> You think some contradictions are true?
- 16:33>> WAIT, HOLD ON. HOLD ON. HOLD ON. If I
- 16:34say this sentence is false,
- 16:39just that right there, is that a
- 16:41contradiction? Does that make sense or
- 16:43not?
- 16:43>> I don't think that sentence is true.
- 16:46I don't think that's a proposition.
- 16:48>> is false. This sentence is
- 16:49>> also that. I don't think that sentence
- 16:50is a proposition because it lacks a
- 16:52value of being either true or false.
- 16:55So, I just think that's a
- 16:56non-proposition.
- 16:57>> the sentence itself. So, just the
- 16:58sentence itself.
- 16:59>> that's a proposition. But I take a
- 17:00proposition to be a statement that's
- 17:01either true or false.
- 17:04>> Yeah. It's So, if I say this statement
- 17:06>> or false, so it's it's not that.
- 17:08>> No, if I say this statement is false, is
- 17:11it true that the statement is false or
- 17:12is it
- 17:13false?
- 17:15>> It is.
- 17:16>> It's neither true nor It's not a
- 17:18proposition.
- 17:19>> Dude, go to the Stanford Encyclopedia
- 17:23of philosophy and you'll know what I'm
- 17:25talking about. Like like in modal logic
- 17:27they talk about this. Dude, they talk
- 17:29about this.
- 17:31>> I love it when I hear like
- 17:34baby apologists first attempts. This is
- 17:36really a good time.
- 17:38So, look, you can reject the law
- 17:41So So I mean you could you could reject
- 17:43the law of the excluded middle if you
- 17:44want. You can reject the law of
- 17:45non-contradiction if you want. You can
- 17:46reject all these things if you want. But
- 17:47if you do that, then that means that
- 17:49you're like if you reject the law of
- 17:50non-contradiction, then you
- 17:52>> No no just fight against the argument I
- 17:53presented.
- 17:54>> to be clear, are you rejecting the law
- 17:55of non-contradiction? Do you think that
- 17:56contradictions can be true?
- 17:57>> I'm just saying not in all circumstances
- 18:00can it really hold. Like there are like,
- 18:02you know, people will bring up the
- 18:04dilemma
- 18:04>> Okay, hold on. I'll give you an argument
- 18:05then and I'll try to follow along. So So
- 18:08under your view there exists a
- 18:09proposition A that it that um
- 18:12uh that is both true and false, yes?
- 18:15>> Yes.
- 18:16>> Okay, so if A is so so
- 18:18>> That's the definition.
- 18:19>> Okay, so then So there exists some there
- 18:20exists some proposition. Again, I'm
- 18:21adopting your worldview, we're doing an
- 18:23internal critique. There exists some
- 18:23proposition that is true and let's call
- 18:26that proposition A. A is true and A is
- 18:28false. So in particular, what that means
- 18:31is that A is true or unicorns are real
- 18:34because if you if you do a conjunction,
- 18:37sorry, a disjunction, then it's true if
- 18:39at least one of the
- 18:41sub sub parts is true. So you you you've
- 18:43asserted that A is true. So that means
- 18:45that the proposition A is true or
- 18:47unicorns are real is true. However,
- 18:49you've also asserted that A is false.
- 18:52And because the because the disjunction
- 18:54that A is because the disjunction A is
- 18:57true or unicorns are real is true, but A
- 19:01is false, it therefore follows that
- 19:02unicorns are real.
- 19:05Because the disjunction is true.
- 19:06>> they're two two different subjects in a
- 19:09different sense.
- 19:11>> They're two different subjects in a
- 19:12different sense. So, for example, you
- 19:13would have to use A
- 19:16Um and then B, you wouldn't you couldn't
- 19:18just jump over to
- 19:20>> It's the same proposition that's both
- 19:21true and false, correct?
- 19:23>> Cuz that's a metaphysical claim. One is
- 19:24a logical claim, right?
- 19:26>> Wait, to be clear, you're asserting that
- 19:28there is a proposition that is both true
- 19:29and false, yes?
- 19:31>> Well, I just just with the sentence that
- 19:33I gave you just now, yeah.
- 19:34>> Okay, so if it's the case that there is
- 19:36a
- 19:36if there's any proposition
- 19:38if there's any proposition that is both
- 19:40true and false, you get the you get to
- 19:42the principle of explosion, which is
- 19:43that any proposition is true. It derives
- 19:45from disjunction.
- 19:46>> Yeah. So, then you have to affirm at
- 19:48that point that it's true that God
- 19:49doesn't exist.
- 19:53>> No, because God is metaphysical claim.
- 19:55It's not a logical claim.
- 19:57>> God's not logical? You have to assert
- 19:59that the proposition God doesn't exist
- 20:00is true.
- 20:02You have to accept that rather.
- 20:03>> Not necessarily. Not necessarily. Well,
- 20:05just just in terms of what I proposed
- 20:07just now, what is in election being in a
- 20:10half for us? Cuz I just gave you the
- 20:11proposition this statement is false.
- 20:13>> I don't grant that that's a proposition.
- 20:16>> It is.
- 20:17>> Okay. What's the argument?
- 20:19>> move on. We can move on. We can move on.
- 20:21>> Do you have like an argument for why
- 20:22that's a proposition?
- 20:25>> Uh the proposition
- 20:27is
- 20:31>> Your mic cut out again. You have to
- 20:32refresh again.
- 20:34>> Your USB cable sucks. You keep moving
- 20:37your mic around and your USB cable's
- 20:39disconnecting.
- 20:40Get a mic stand and stop moving around.
- 20:52It's so sad. I was looking for my
- 20:53discrete mathematics book and I couldn't
- 20:55find it.
- 20:56>> Shame. I got rid of mine like 10 years
- 20:58ago.
- 20:59>> Yeah.
- 21:00>> Uh ooh, I we're he we're coming through
- 21:02through like your AirPods.
- 21:04It's not good.
- 21:06>> Hold on. I'll switch your microphone to
- 21:07the right microphone.
- 21:13All right, see if that works now.
- 21:17>> Can you hear me?
- 21:18>> Yes.
- 21:19We're back.
- 21:20>> All right.
- 21:21>> Okay.
- 21:22You were about to give the argument for
- 21:23why that's a proposition.
- 21:25>> So, could you just go on the Stanford
- 21:28Encyclopedia of Philosophy and just look
- 21:31at what I've
- 21:32kind of just started just now?
- 21:34>> Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and
- 21:37you want which page?
- 21:40>> And I think it's
- 21:43Hold on, maybe I should take a look
- 21:44here.
- 21:45Um
- 21:45I I could be wrong, but
- 21:47>> that you're looking for is inside of the
- 21:49>> It's refu- Yeah, just search up like
- 21:50refutation of the
- 21:51>> to say, and I could be wrong, I think
- 21:53what he's trying to say is that because
- 21:55paradoxical statements exist, the laws
- 21:57of logic don't hold true.
- 22:00But that has nothing to do with the laws
- 22:01of logic. It has something to do with
- 22:03how you form sentences.
- 22:08>> Uh yeah, if I go to the I'll direct you
- 22:10to the Stanford Encyclopedia of
- 22:11Philosophy page on propositions.
- 22:14Um you know,
- 22:15between proposition and broad use in
- 22:17contemporary You You wait, you did say
- 22:19it was a proposition.
- 22:21>> Yeah, but I told you to go to
- 22:23specifically refutations of the three
- 22:24classes.
- 22:25>> Okay, well, I would tell you to go to
- 22:26the the page on propositions
- 22:29where it's going to define propositions
- 22:31as being the primary bearers of truth,
- 22:33whereas the statement you presented
- 22:34doesn't have a truth value,
- 22:36so it's not a proposition.
- 22:39>> Uh the truth value is the statement
- 22:41itself, so it's it's self-actualizing.
- 22:45>> Uh wow, that was a bunch of gibberish.
- 22:48>> Let's go to the Let's go to the
- 22:50the section here.
- 22:51>> Which uh which page?
- 22:52>> if there's a refutation.
- 22:54I'm just looking right now, bud.
- 22:59>> [snorts]
- 23:02>> Yeah, I I was looking at this the other
- 23:03day. I think I was looking at it in
- 23:05logic and classical Indian philosophy
- 23:07and then I was also looking at analytic
- 23:09philosophy. So.
- 23:11>> Like classical laws of logic or?
- 23:16>> This is just I'm just telling you what I
- 23:17was looking at the other day. Um.
- 23:21>> Do you reject all three of the laws of
- 23:23logic?
- 23:25>> No, I I I accept the law of identity.
- 23:29>> Huh. But you believe in the Trinity.
- 23:32>> Yeah.
- 23:33>> Uh the principle of explosion indicates
- 23:35that if you reject the law of
- 23:36non-contradiction, then you have to
- 23:37reject the law of identity.
- 23:39By the way.
- 23:41>> Yeah, but by rejecting it, you have to
- 23:43assume it, which means it's true. So
- 23:45there you go.
- 23:47>> Okay, so you do agree that the law of
- 23:48identity is false. You just also think
- 23:49it's true.
- 23:51>> Yeah.
- 23:52>> [laughter]
- 23:53>> Yeah.
- 23:53>> Ah yes, the best argument for God. Make
- 23:56no sense.
- 23:57>> Ah yes, I both am myself and am not
- 24:00myself.
- 24:02Ah.
- 24:02>> Okay, let's just let's just You know
- 24:03what? I'll just search this out. I'm
- 24:05trying to
- 24:05>> God both exists and doesn't exist.
- 24:07>> Yeah.
- 24:08>> You know, I was thinking next time I
- 24:09come up here, I'll have bookmarks of the
- 24:12links I want to show you guys and I'll
- 24:13have a presentation there.
- 24:15>> Yeah. I mean, we'll be live uh
- 24:18>> We'll let's run back to We'll be live
- 24:19tonight at uh 5:30 Eastern time on the
- 24:22Atheist Experience. All three of us are
- 24:24welcome to call in and try another
- 24:25attempt with your bookmarks.
- 24:27>> Uh so so I have a
- 24:28>> Am I just going to get yelled at the
- 24:29whole time?
- 24:30>> No, no, of course not. Um but I do have
- 24:32a quick question for you.
- 24:33>> by us.
- 24:33>> Um so
- 24:34>> Cuz Matt Dillahunty did that before.
- 24:36>> Matt Dillahunty
- 24:37doesn't go on the show anymore. He's on
- 24:39the line.
- 24:40So So in terms of uh in terms of the
- 24:43Bible, in 1 Samuel 15, God commands the
- 24:46slaughter of the Amalekites. He commands
- 24:48the slaughter of the men, the women, the
- 24:49children, and the infants. Uh my
- 24:51question for you is very simple. Do you
- 24:53think the newborn Amalekite infants
- 24:55deserved to get slaughtered.
- 24:58>> Yeah, so I reject that phrasing of the
- 25:02Let me just uh grab my book City of God
- 25:04here by Saint Augustine and see what
- 25:05>> Oh, boy.
- 25:11Yikes, indeed.
- 25:16Yeah.
- 25:17Looking forward to the Wait, can we get
- 25:19a spine check really quick? Can you turn
- 25:21Can you turn over to the spine?
- 25:23Pristine, never been opened. Wow, that
- 25:26was like a beautiful spine. You can
- 25:27literally see like a little like glimmer
- 25:29coming off of it. That's how unopened
- 25:31this [ __ ] is.
- 25:32>> I have a bookmark right here, bud. Look.
- 25:36>> That was the most pristine spine I think
- 25:38I've ever seen in my entire life.
- 25:40>> Okay, yeah, you don't think
- 25:41>> just take care of their books, Ian.
- 25:43Nah. I think if you read a book, it's
- 25:45like
- 25:47obliterated.
- 25:49That's a Bible, isn't it? That's a red
- 25:51book. That That book's been read.
- 25:53>> Iliad and the Odyssey. There you go.
- 25:56Also
- 25:56>> Oh, wait. No, hold on. That was
- 25:57secondhand. That was definitely a
- 25:58secondhand book, by the way.
- 25:59>> No, it isn't. I bought I got it for
- 26:01Christmas 2 years ago.
- 26:03>> And you destroyed the book in two How
- 26:04many times have you read it?
- 26:07>> I'm reading the Odyssey right now. I
- 26:08don't know how I got
- 26:09>> Why is the book destroyed if you're not
- 26:10even done with the book?
- 26:12>> [laughter]
- 26:13>> Oh, I finished the Iliad. I'm reading
- 26:15the Odyssey and getting
- 26:16>> that destroyed the book. Got it. Okay,
- 26:17that makes sense.
- 26:18>> The Dialogues of Plato, so I am reading
- 26:20that.
- 26:21>> Thanks. Yeah, gosh, I love show and
- 26:23tell.
- 26:24Uh But, what I'm looking for kind of is
- 26:26like the Apology.
- 26:27>> So, ancient war rhetoric is basically
- 26:29what Saint Augustine is saying here. So,
- 26:31basically
- 26:32it's uh if you look at um I'm sure
- 26:37deconstruction logic or deconstruction
- 26:39zone probably agrees [laughter] with me,
- 26:40but ancient Near Eastern texts
- 26:45used ancient war rhetoric that was very
- 26:49exhaustive, let's say, of the
- 26:52casualties of war. And then you can even
- 26:54see later on
- 26:55>> So, I think what you mean to say is that
- 26:57the ancient war annals will typically
- 27:00exaggerate how many they captured and
- 27:03killed in order to make the king look
- 27:04better, but that doesn't mean that they
- 27:06didn't still rape women and burn
- 27:09children alive, which they bragged about
- 27:11over and over again.
- 27:14>> Yeah, but in this case, like if you look
- 27:16at archeo- archeological evidence, you
- 27:18don't see
- 27:20I mean, who is raping women? I mean, the
- 27:21Bible doesn't say you can rape women at
- 27:23all.
- 27:23>> it does.
- 27:24>> It says you can take them as a No, no,
- 27:26no.
- 27:26>> he's God says he's causing it in Isaiah
- 27:2813:16 and Zechariah 14:2.
- 27:31>> That's a natural consequence of the
- 27:33sins. It's not actually
- 27:34>> No, it's actually not.
- 27:37>> No, no, no.
- 27:37>> God God actually commands the
- 27:40actually causes the rape of David's
- 27:43concubine in 2 Samuel chapter
- 27:46>> people.
- 27:47>> Nope, God says I'm causing it.
- 27:50>> He doesn't rape con- you You're supposed
- 27:52to marry a concubine. You're supposed to
- 27:54marry a con- If you prisoner of war,
- 27:57>> I'm not talking about prisoner of war.
- 27:59I'm talking about David's concubines.
- 28:02God is punishing David's concubines for
- 28:04David's sin, and the punishment that he
- 28:06bring In the punishment Are you going to
- 28:09listen to the verse or not?
- 28:11The punishment that is handed for
- 28:13David's sin is a natural consequence.
- 28:15The punish- I'm going to [ __ ] read it
- 28:17to you since you've never heard of it
- 28:18cuz it's not a consequence, it's a
- 28:19punishment.
- 28:20>> I literally read it.
- 28:21>> No, you haven't. No, you haven't.
- 28:23>> I have. I read the whole thing, but
- 28:25>> No, you haven't. So, David's wives
- 28:27>> The one in Isaiah and the one in Samuel
- 28:29is a natural consequence of the
- 28:31>> No, it's not, and if you shut up for 5
- 28:34seconds
- 28:35Okay, we'll just leave it there.
- 28:37Okay. You shut the [ __ ] up for 5 seconds
- 28:39and I'll read you the passage
- 28:41so you don't look stupid. In the
- 28:43passage, it's a punishment,
- 28:47and the punishment is caused by God
- 28:49directly.
- 28:50God says, "I will raise up trouble
- 28:53against you from within your own house
- 28:55and I will take your wives before your
- 28:57eyes and I will give them to your
- 28:58neighbor."
- 29:00God says, "I'm doing it." Which means
- 29:02God is the cause of it. It's not a
- 29:05natural consequence. It's something that
- 29:07God is causing to happen. When somebody
- 29:10causes something intentionally,
- 29:13it's causing it. It's not an unintended
- 29:15consequence.
- 29:17>> I agree. I agree.
- 29:19>> go. So, God is okay with causing women
- 29:21to be raped.
- 29:22>> But God is not God is not commanding
- 29:24individuals in the Bible. For example,
- 29:26in his law for rape
- 29:29people.
- 29:30>> He allows it in Deuteronomy 22.
- 29:32>> It's natural law. Yeah, as Yeah, as a
- 29:33>> No, no, no. In In Deuteronomy 22, he
- 29:35allows you
- 29:35>> God allows things to happen.
- 29:37>> He allows you to do it. In fact, he He
- 29:38does demand it in Deuteronomy 21 as
- 29:40well. In Deuteronomy 21, you can take
- 29:43You can take a woman in war if she's
- 29:45pretty and make her your wife. That's
- 29:47rape. Women who are captured in war
- 29:49don't have consent.
- 29:49>> They're supposed to be your wife.
- 29:51>> Yeah, that's rape.
- 29:52>> That's rape.
- 29:53>> Wait, do you acknowledge that you can
- 29:54like rape your wife? Like it's possible
- 29:56to rape your wife?
- 29:59>> Yeah, of course in the US um
- 30:01>> Just in general, do you think that this
- 30:03is like
- 30:06Well, it's odd that you're specific that
- 30:08you know that law by the way.
- 30:10Yeah, it's pretty crazy.
- 30:12Wait, Yikers.
- 30:15Your name Yikers is getting to be pretty
- 30:17appropriate. Do you think that women
- 30:18that are captured in war actually have
- 30:19consent?
- 30:24>> I'm telling you that Paul says in the in
- 30:25>> I'm asking for a yes or no to my [ __ ]
- 30:27question. Do you think women captured in
- 30:28war have consent?
- 30:30>> You're a [ __ ] idiot. How about that?
- 30:31>> I need the answer to the question.
- 30:34>> Yeah, you know what? Let's Let's debate
- 30:36on the Atheist Experience. I'll see you
- 30:38guys
- 30:39>> I would run the [ __ ] away from this one,
- 30:40too. Can't blame you. That checks out.
- 30:42>> Yeah, okay.
- 30:43>> I'm not running away. I I Dude, I'm
- 30:45running
- 30:45>> looks like you're running away.
- 30:47>> have a spell about
- 30:48>> It's fine. Let him Let him come back.
- 30:52Let him come back with his sources and
- 30:53we'll destroy those, too. It's fine.
- 30:55>> Sure.
- 30:56All right, sounds good. And and you've
- 30:57already been destroyed, so
- 30:59>> On what point? Wait, what's one Wait,
- 31:01sorry. Before you leave, what's one
- 31:02argument that you think you did well on
- 31:03in this discussion? Just so we can study
- 31:05up, you know.
- 31:06>> prove objective morality.
- 31:08>> I was. You couldn't reject a premise.
- 31:10>> No, no, no. I rejected
- 31:13First of all, most of your
- 31:14premises [laughter] don't even follow
- 31:15logically.
- 31:17>> They [clears throat] do, actually.
- 31:18>> of all, you you had assumptions baked in
- 31:20there in the cake.
- 31:21>> Like what? Which one?
- 31:24Which one?
- 31:24>> So, for example, because you want to
- 31:27achieve a goal, therefore
- 31:29those goals must be achieved because
- 31:32>> No, that's not the premise. He wasn't
- 31:34[ __ ] listening.
- 31:35Nope, if something's your goal and
- 31:37something else is necessary to achieve
- 31:38that goal, then you have a reason to to
- 31:42do that thing. You know, if if my
- 31:45goal is to graduate from college and in
- 31:48order to graduate from college, I would
- 31:50need to attend my classes, well, then I
- 31:51have a reason to attend my classes. The
- 31:54reason is my goal is to graduate from
- 31:57college.
- 31:58>> Yeah, but if you're just matter, if
- 32:00you're just physical material,
- 32:03what does it matter if you
- 32:05>> You're arguing against the Platonist.
- 32:07Your your materialism critique falls
- 32:09flat.
- 32:09>> are blitzed and
- 32:10>> I'm all yeah, sprint away.
- 32:13>> I'm like I'm not even I'm not even a
- 32:15materialist.
- 32:15>> that I could argue against? Gosh, does
- 32:17one of one of Do you have an easier
- 32:19worldview?
- 32:21>> I don't think you ever said that I was a
- 32:22materialist.
- 32:23>> dude. I'll You know, I'll write it down.
- 32:25You know, how about
- 32:25>> So, Yikers,
- 32:27Yikers, go study up on Gewirth.
- 32:29You have like 4 hours to 4 hours to go
- 32:32read the book or read the paper, rather.
- 32:34>> Yeah, it's um it's on There's like a
- 32:36great article. It's the Internet
- 32:37Encyclopedia of Philosophy, iep.utm.edu,
- 32:40and then the article is Gewirth, g e w i
- 32:44r t h. This guy is the guy
- 32:47who lays out the ethical system that I
- 32:48hold to.
- 32:50>> So, just say what his name is again.
- 32:53>> Gewirth, g e w i r t h.
- 32:58>> His first name is Alan, if that helps.
- 32:59>> Yeah.
- 33:00>> Oh, yeah, that's good. And then And then
- 33:02I'll just type in like moral realism
- 33:04argument.
- 33:05>> Uh well, yeah, that's like his main
- 33:07thing, yeah.
- 33:10>> Okay, let's see. Oh, yeah, I'll say No,
- 33:12I will legit look into this.
- 33:15Yeah, he's a rationalist moral realist.
- 33:18I'll look at his I'll look at his
- 33:20arguments. I'll come back here and I'll
- 33:21absolutely destroy it. So.
- 33:23>> Yeah, please do.
- 33:23>> got me a lord lord and judge.
- 33:25>> Yeah, we're not worried about your
- 33:27fictional sky fairy, but also the other
- 33:30com The other people waiting in queue
- 33:31saying that this Yikers dude sounds
- 33:33cringey. Even the other theists here
- 33:35think you're cringey. But, come on back.
- 33:37We'll talk to you later tonight.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Level 1 Apologist Gets Destroyed on Every Argument and Runs from His Bible by Unapologetic, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,436 words across 1,079 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.