Le jeu Nintendo que Nintendo déteste — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02Have you ever wondered why we enjoy
- 0:04watching two people beat each other up?
- 0:08I mean, the concept is weird, but the
- 0:11answer is pretty simple. Actually, we
- 0:14enjoy it because it's ingrained in us.
- 0:16It's a chemical reaction inside our
- 0:19brains. The midale spits out adrenaline
- 0:21and cortisol, showering us with
- 0:23dopamine and even endorphins in the
- 0:24event of a proxy victory. Except that
- 0:26our species today, it chooses its
- 0:29arenas à la carte. It isn't always
- 0:32done with a halberd in hand now. It can
- 0:34happen in a cage, on a TV set, or in
- 0:36front of a chessboard. The queen that
- 0:40fascinates me the least is Super Smash
- 0:42Bros. Melee. But competitive Smash
- 0:46Bros. Melee, for the very company it
- 0:48created, is a mistake. Because Mélé
- 0:50is a video game designed to be a simple
- 0:52family party game, designed to be
- 0:54anything but serious, designed to be
- 0:56anything but competitive, and for which
- 0:58absolutely nothing has gone as planned.
- 1:21There's a moment that I dread with each
- 1:23new video. It's not the writing, not
- 1:25the filming, not the editing. No, what
- 1:27sometimes ruins me mentally is the
- 1:30research. You think you're going to
- 1:31spend fifteen minutes checking out an
- 1:33interesting anecdote and you wake up 6
- 1:34hours later on a Wayback Machine page
- 1:36in Polish learning that the game's
- 1:37developer might be involved in a
- 1:39crypto-nudist sect. And that's often
- 1:41when your brain is constantly drinking
- 1:44something, and that's where Olit comes
- 1:46in. But since he put my email
- 1:49suggesting an incredible flavor in the
- 1:52trash again, which is frankly absurd
- 1:54because who doesn't want to taste
- 1:56ginger gravel, between us?
- 1:57Unfortunately, Olit prefers to stick to
- 1:59universally appreciated flavors like
- 2:01the new pink grapefruit that is simply
- 2:03incredible, the very solid Lichy Energy
- 2:05or the unbeatable lemon black tea.
- 2:07There are also several ranges: Energy
- 2:09for focus, I for freshness with real
- 2:11tea and antioxidants as well as the
- 2:12perfect hydration for when you realize
- 2:15you haven't drunk any water since the
- 2:17industrial era. And our new arrival:
- 2:19milkshakes for little moments of
- 2:21glycemic tenderness. Mind you, of
- 2:23course, we are discussing a more
- 2:25responsible, cleaner alternative to the
- 2:27sugary drinks we often consume without
- 2:29much thought. It is not a magic elixir
- 2:31either and Olie does not claim to be a
- 2:34healthy drink. Like everything, it
- 2:36should be consumed in moderation. That
- 2:38being said, to get some, there are two
- 2:41codes: combo 5 for a € 5 discount on
- 2:43your first order and combo for a robust
- 2:46-10%on all others. The link is in the
- 2:48description. Thanks to Ol for
- 2:50supporting my work once again and allow
- 2:52me to welcome you to the year 2000. The
- 2:54Gamecube, the best console of all time
- 2:56according to a large panel of experts
- 2:58including myself, is about to be
- 3:00released and on Nintendo's shopping
- 3:02list, just below destroying my
- 3:03childhood with Majoros Mask, there is a
- 3:05name that keeps coming up. Super Smash
- 3:08Bros. The truth is that the first Smash
- 3:10released on Nintendo 64 was too
- 3:12successful to not consider a sequel
- 3:14with its completely counterintuitive
- 3:16percentage system. The usual classic
- 3:17life bar is replaced by percentages
- 3:19that increase with each hit received
- 3:21and will increase the chance of
- 3:23ejecting. Smash has found its audience.
- 3:26But Nintendo wants a faster, more
- 3:28ambitious, more spectacular sequel and
- 3:31for that they call on the man who
- 3:33invented the legal way to hit your
- 3:36friends, Massaio Sakura. But this time
- 3:39it took an absurd 13 months. Nintendo
- 3:42gave him just 13 months to create a
- 3:44full-fledged fighting game, with 25
- 3:47characters, dozens of arenas, a full
- 3:49gang, an opening cutscene, and multiple
- 3:51game modes in a full single-player
- 3:54adventure mode. All on a console that
- 3:56wasn't even finished. It was completely
- 3:59impossible. So Sakura agreed, he agreed
- 4:02because he had the vision. He was going
- 4:04to make the most fun fighting game of
- 4:06all time, even if it meant not seeing
- 4:08the sun for a little over a year. So it
- 4:11was under completely inhumane working
- 4:14conditions that Mélé was developed,
- 4:16and in December 2001, the game went on
- 4:19sale, and it was incredible. Of the 612
- 4:30games released on the GameCube, Mélé
- 4:32would end up being the best-selling of
- 4:34all, selling over 7 million copies.
- 4:36Everything about Mélé became iconic.
- 4:38From the rather strange art direction
- 4:41to the improbable gameplay, but
- 4:43especially its cast of characters. Link
- 4:45Mario in anyone who needs no
- 4:47introduction, ghosts of the past like
- 4:48Game and Watch or the Ice Climbers.
- 4:50Mart who will introduce Fire Emblem to
- 4:51the West. The absence of Wigg to
- 4:53directly strike my heart and Fox, the
- 4:55fastest character in the game who
- 4:57literally defies what is humanly
- 4:59possible to do with a Gamecube
- 5:00controller between the two. Because
- 5:04yeah, mixing it up goes fast. It really
- 5:06goes really fast. In fact, the
- 5:08completely inhumane and chaotic
- 5:09conditions of its development
- 5:11introduced bugs that would become the
- 5:12game's competitive signature. Because
- 5:14after scratching the surface, we
- 5:16quickly discover that each character,
- 5:18each stage, each action reveals
- 5:20invisible layers of depth. We discover
- 5:22hidden mechanics that are not
- 5:24necessarily documented, some of which
- 5:26are glitches and others probably
- 5:28glitches too. We have the Wave Dash
- 5:30which allows your character to slide on
- 5:32the ground by canceling his aerial,
- 5:34thus moving much more fluidly. The L
- 5:36cancel, which will reduce the recovery
- 5:38time of an aerial attack. The H face
- 5:40short, a fairly technical combination
- 5:42that allows you to chain aerial attacks
- 5:44at an absurd speed, and the dash dance,
- 5:45literally moving without moving forward
- 5:47. More simply, the game is full of
- 5:49dozens of advanced techniques,
- 5:51including techniques exclusive to each
- 5:53character, such as Fox and Falco's
- 5:55iconic Shine, which is the most broken
- 5:57move in the game since it comes out in
- 5:59frame 1 and is both offensive and
- 6:00defensive. In short, take a game that
- 6:03is basically very fast and add moves
- 6:06executed in 60 seconds, and you get a
- 6:08competitive depth that a party game is
- 6:11not supposed to have. You get a game
- 6:14that is just broken enough to be
- 6:15infinite. This is exactly the kind of
- 6:18game in which the difference between a
- 6:20good player and an excellent player is
- 6:22huge, but where the difference between
- 6:24an excellent player and one of the very
- 6:26best is trivial. Take a simple scene.
- 6:31Fox hanging off the stage, Mart
- 6:34standing. For an average player, it's
- 6:36simple: Fox climbs, Mart strikes. In
- 6:38reality, not at all, because by
- 6:39grabbing the ledge, Fox has 37 frames
- 6:42of intangibility, barely more than half
- 6:44an E at 60 fps. If he lets go of the
- 6:46ledge exactly on the 9th frame, jumps
- 6:49instantly on the 10th, then air dodges
- 6:51his leg and triggers a diagonal dodge
- 6:53to slide on the ground, this allows him
- 6:55to land and act while remaining
- 6:57intangible and invincible for 15 frames
- 6:59. However, if he misses just one of his
- 7:02frame-perfect actions, he's decapitated
- 7:05. And in the meantime, on Martha's side
- 7:07, she has to guess whether Fox will
- 7:09choose this invincible slide jump or a
- 7:11classic jump, which is punishable, or a
- 7:13normal climb. If he acts too early,
- 7:14it's a big sword blow into the air that
- 7:15is sent. By acting too late, Fox is
- 7:17already behind him with an up smash
- 7:19ready to kill. In less than 0.6 seconds
- 7:22, both opponents memorize four timings
- 7:24on the line and countercard three
- 7:25possible outcomes and play their entire
- 7:28stock in the blink of an eye. And this
- 7:30is probably not the best example, just
- 7:32the most popularizable. But what is
- 7:34certain is that while some people see
- 7:36it as a happy accident, many others
- 7:38will see it as a competitive
- 7:39masterpiece. And soon enough something
- 7:42strange happens. Another facet of Melee
- 7:45comes to life, one that should never
- 7:46have existed, a surprisingly serious
- 7:48version of Melee because the game has
- 7:50that little something extra that makes
- 7:52playing it great but watching the other
- 7:54toys almost as cool. So it starts to
- 7:57gather in garages, in basements, in the
- 7:59back room of Marie Blascher or a party
- 8:01room lent by a cousin of a cousin. The
- 8:04competitive community slowly grows on
- 8:07the fringes in silence. what there is
- 8:10to win or nothing, sometimes a hot dog,
- 8:12most often nothing at all. We come here
- 8:14to clash in the real melee, the one
- 8:17hidden beneath. And for that, for that,
- 8:19we had to create rules. No objects
- 8:21because objects add variance and we
- 8:23want as little variance as possible.
- 8:25One against one, four lives, 8 minutes
- 8:27on the timer and only certain
- 8:28Lego-style terrains. It is only with
- 8:31this set of rules that we can really
- 8:33have a real duel, that we can really
- 8:35determine a winner. And at that time,
- 8:38the winner often had the same name. Ken
- 8:41. Ken is the king of melee. He is the
- 8:45one who never loses. Between 2003 and
- 8:472006, he and his Marte were untouchable
- 8:49. He traveled the United States to
- 8:51destroy tournaments like a traveling
- 8:52boss. And when he took part in a
- 8:54tournament, the only real question was
- 8:56who would finish second? Ken really is
- 8:58the guy who elevated Mee to a martial
- 9:01level at a time when Mee was virtually
- 9:03invisible. No Twitch, not really
- 9:05YouTube either. Matches were filmed on
- 9:08a family camcorder until 2005 changed
- 9:10all. The MLG Major League Gaming, which
- 9:15was the first truly professional sports
- 9:17organization in the United States,
- 9:19decided to include Mee in its
- 9:21competitive circuit. This moment was
- 9:24very important. It was from this
- 9:26precise moment that this family party
- 9:29game officially became an esport.
- 9:32Because suddenly these players who
- 9:33often slept on the floor or in their
- 9:35cars during tournaments started taking
- 9:36planes, getting room and board, and
- 9:38even getting paid. For a Gamecube game,
- 9:40this was unprecedented and yet it was
- 9:42only the beginning since in 2007, it
- 9:44was the consecration. Super Smash Bros.
- 9:47Mee was selected to make its first
- 9:49appearance at the Evolution
- 9:51Championship Series Levo, the most
- 9:53prestigious fighting game tournament in
- 9:55the world. Las Vegas, 270 players and
- 9:58at the top of it all, of course, the
- 10:00one and only Ken. Melee seems to be in
- 10:26his prime, and yet for Melee, it's high
- 10:30time to die. Nintendo's new console,
- 10:33the Wii, has already been out for over
- 10:35a year and the natural successor to
- 10:37Melee has been a bit long in coming,
- 10:38but here it is, in 2008, Super Smash
- 10:40Bros. Brawl finally arrives. On paper,
- 10:46Brawl is a blessing. 35 characters, an
- 10:48intro cutscene worthy of a movie,
- 10:50sumptuous stages, an adventure mode
- 10:52that will forever remain in my heart,
- 10:54even an online mode. And despite a new
- 10:56betrayal that I take as a personal
- 10:58attack, namely still no Wii, in theory,
- 11:00Brawl should be the ideal sequel, the
- 11:03sequel that is supposed to propel Smash
- 11:05into the future. And in any case,
- 11:07fighting game custom dictates that we
- 11:09almost automatically switch to the new
- 11:11game. Braw is supposed to be the future
- 11:16of Melee. Uh, except that in reality,
- 11:18it's quite the opposite because Braw
- 11:20has a problem. It's different, but
- 11:22different for all the wrong reasons.
- 11:25The online mode is a disaster. There's
- 11:27no serious matchmaking, no ranking,
- 11:29massive input lag, no rank, no
- 11:31statistics. For competitive players,
- 11:33it's an insult. And in terms of
- 11:35gameplay mechanics, it's even worse.
- 11:37The game is slow, cumbersome, the
- 11:39characters are all far too floaty, the
- 11:41combo potential is very limited, and
- 11:43goodbye to the wave dash, goodbye to L
- 11:45canceling, and hello to absurd
- 11:47mechanics like tripping and trebe. Your
- 11:50character can slip, literally trip, not
- 11:52because you played badly, but simply
- 11:54because the game decided so. The truth
- 11:56is that Nintendo never really
- 11:58recognized the competitive aspect of
- 11:59Melee and Braw and their response. A
- 12:01family-friendly, reassuring game,
- 12:03unequal by design with unpredictable
- 12:06random games where everyone can win
- 12:09almost by chance. Consequently, the
- 12:12Voices and MLG removed Melee. Sponsors
- 12:15left, forums shut down, and top players
- 12:17deserted Melee. It was over. In just a
- 12:21few months, the game returned to what
- 12:23it was in its early days. An
- 12:24underground scene with a few
- 12:26tournaments that continued to exist,
- 12:28but in gyms and basements. This was a
- 12:30period that is now known as the Dark
- 12:32Ages, a period lasting just over 2
- 12:34years after Braw's release during which
- 12:37literally no major tournaments were
- 12:39held. A period that would last until
- 12:41the competitive Smash community was
- 12:43faced with a choice. A very simple
- 12:45choice. We continue to suffer, hoping
- 12:48that the next Smash in several years
- 12:49will be better, when all indications
- 12:51seem to point to the fact that it will
- 12:53be worse. Or choice number 2, we revive
- 12:57Melee. Here is the Revival of Mé, a
- 13:02tournament held in New York on March 7
- 13:04and 8, 2009. A tournament with no
- 13:06sponsors, no professional cameras, no
- 13:08promise of glory. The only goal is to
- 13:10prove that Mêé can still bring people
- 13:12together at least a little bit. They
- 13:15expected 30 people, and more than 100
- 13:17showed up. Veterans, comeback players,
- 13:20unknowns, and players who sometimes
- 13:21came from the other side of the country
- 13:22. And when a young, unknown player wins
- 13:25the tournament, the class explodes.
- 13:27It's a magical moment that just proves
- 13:31one thing: Mêé isn't dead. And I
- 13:35can't tell you that the Revival of Mé
- 13:37single-handedly revived the sport and
- 13:38saved the scene. I'm not going to make
- 13:40you believe that. That kind of thing
- 13:42doesn't exist. But it was the little
- 13:44spark that was needed to light a big,
- 13:47really big bonfire. The kind of really
- 13:50big bonfire that even gives birth to
- 13:52gods. Between 2010 and 2015, something
- 13:56incredibly unlikely happened. For five
- 13:59years, no major tournament was won by
- 14:01anyone other than one of these five
- 14:04players. Mew King, the robot, Mango,
- 14:06the enfant terrible, Armada, the
- 14:08Swedish iseberg, Pippd, the strategist,
- 14:10and Angry Box, the most terrifying
- 14:12cuddly toy of all time. For five long
- 14:14years, these five dominated, but
- 14:16without question, forming a perfect,
- 14:18closed, almost mystical circle. They
- 14:21were called the gods of melee, and the
- 14:23history they wrote sent the game into a
- 14:26veritable golden age. Yeah. to lest
- 15:22forces him off. Wow. I don't think he's
- 15:26going to be able that's difficult to do
- 15:40. In
- 15:502013, somewhere in a corner of the
- 15:52internet, a videographer who goes by
- 15:54the name of sa mox released a 9-part
- 15:56documentary: The Smash Browser. Not the
- 15:58Nintendo Direct version, the dirty,
- 16:00defecated version, which smells of
- 16:01sweat, the raw style. The sound is
- 16:03sometimes very approximate, but at a
- 16:05time when no one tells the story, Monxe
- 16:08does it and does it with a lot of heart
- 16:10. As a result, the documentary explodes
- 16:12. The quotes become from the same
- 16:14players of legends and suddenly Mêlé
- 16:16becomes cool. Suddenly, everyone wants
- 16:19to see what it is about, and it could
- 16:20not be better timed because, at that
- 16:22moment, it is preparing its 2013
- 16:24edition. It plans h tournaments for h
- 16:26games. They have already chosen the
- 16:28seven winners but for the 8th, it
- 16:30decides to play democracy via a public
- 16:33vote. The games are presented, a poll
- 16:35is launched and they flatten any form
- 16:37of competition with the grace of a
- 16:39semi-trailer launched at full speed.
- 16:41Maybe even a little too much since it
- 16:44will make the organizers, let's say,
- 16:46skeptical. They will rush towards what
- 16:48is according to them the only logical
- 16:50conclusion: the results are rigged.
- 16:52Boots were definitely used. New
- 16:55announcement. To avoid any form of
- 16:57cheating. This time, the campaign will
- 16:59take the form of a donation battle for
- 17:00a good cause. EVO will select the game
- 17:02whose community has collected the most
- 17:04donations and the money will go to
- 17:06breast cancer research. It's a very
- 17:08good idea. It's a campaign that will
- 17:10succeed in raising more than $ 200,000.
- 17:11And on the podium of the most popular
- 17:14games, we find Street Fighter 2 Turbo
- 17:17with a respectable $ 39,000, Skill
- 17:19Girls with an impressive $ 78,000 and
- 17:22on the top with $ 94,000 raised, Super
- 17:25Smash Bros. Melee, it's official. 12
- 17:28years after its release, Melee is back
- 17:30in the biggest fighting game tournament
- 17:32in the world. It's the end of a long
- 17:35and painful crossing in the desert. Uh,
- 17:38except no. On the contrary, it is the
- 17:42start of the problems. 24 hours to the
- 17:45tournament, a Nintendo email arrives.
- 17:48If andist translation, no match, no
- 17:50stream, no scrimmage. Go away. The game
- 17:53that raised almost $ 100,000 for
- 17:56charity. Banned, banned by its own
- 17:58creator, and banned 24 hours before an
- 18:00event that had been planned for almost
- 18:02a year. You have to imagine the extent
- 18:04of the stab in the back. Nintendo sent
- 18:07out its ban. After the players, after
- 18:10the spectators, had all already
- 18:12traveled to the event, already booked
- 18:14their hotels and tickets, there was a
- 18:16real desire to cause harm. And for many
- 18:18, it was confirmation. If Nintendo had
- 18:20just gone to buy milk and cigarettes in
- 18:222001 and never come back, that would be
- 18:23totally fine. Mê has always managed on
- 18:25his own. But no, this is Nintendo
- 18:27actively wanting Mêé to stay in the
- 18:30shadows, to stay in the basement, not
- 18:33on the main stage, not in the spotlight
- 18:36, not at Evo. And if you're wondering
- 18:38why, why Nintendo, creator of Smash
- 18:40Bros., is trying to do everything it
- 18:42can to bury a competitive scene that
- 18:44other publishers were killing to have,
- 18:46it's actually quite simple. In fact, we
- 18:48now know that Nintendo is the ultimate
- 18:50boss of intellectual property, to the
- 18:52point of having simple let's plays,
- 18:54even Super Mario 64 strategy guides
- 18:55that are 25 years old, removed from the
- 18:57Internet. And if that's the case, it's
- 19:00because Nintendo knows full well that
- 19:02the gold mine they're sitting on isn't
- 19:04based on their technique for making
- 19:05games, but rather on the intellectual
- 19:07property that these games and their
- 19:09licenses constitute. They own the most
- 19:12profitable franchise of all time, so
- 19:14for them there's no unreasonable
- 19:16defense since there's simply too much
- 19:18to lose. Everything is a threat, and
- 19:20this is especially true in the case of
- 19:22Smash Bros. Since the image that
- 19:23Nintendo wants to give to Smash is that
- 19:25of a friendly, joyful, family-oriented
- 19:27game, the complete opposite of a
- 19:29sometimes bitter competition, often
- 19:31accompanied by trash talk, broken
- 19:32controllers, and people breaking the
- 19:34ABM wall with Fox. On the contrary,
- 19:36Sakourai created and thought of Smash
- 19:38as an anti-fighting game, as an
- 19:40accessible fighting game. That same
- 19:43year, in an interview with Kotaku, he
- 19:45said, "We want to avoid a situation
- 19:47where the game is only enjoyed by a
- 19:49small group of passionate, manic
- 19:51players." But the real reason isn't
- 19:53even that. The real reason is purely
- 19:56and simply economic. Melee no longer
- 19:59makes money for Nintendo. Melee hasn't
- 20:02made money for a long time. It's not a
- 20:03product they can sell. Their real
- 20:05product, Smash. The one they want to
- 20:07highlight is Braw during the Wii season
- 20:10, and it will be Smash 4 a year later
- 20:12in 2014. Melee is unsaleable,
- 20:14uncontrollable, unacceptable. For
- 20:17Nintendo, Melee is a cockroach, and
- 20:19cockroaches get crushed. And that's why
- 20:22in 2013, there will be no Evu. It's
- 20:25just a return to the basement that
- 20:26Nintendo is proposing. Except this time
- 20:28, the basement is screaming, and
- 20:31screaming loud. Twitter is imploding,
- 20:34Reddit is on fire, and although Smash
- 20:36has often been mocked in the FGC, even
- 20:38pros from other games will be outraged
- 20:40by this. The press is starting to seize
- 20:42on the subject. We see articles popping
- 20:44up about Polygon, even Forb, with
- 20:46titles based on fans raising thousands
- 20:48for cancer research, and Nintendo
- 20:49cancels their tournament. It's a
- 20:51nightmare in terms of image for
- 20:54Nintendo. A nightmare so violent that
- 20:56for perhaps the first time in the
- 20:59history of the company, Nintendo backs
- 21:01down without apology, without
- 21:03justification, without anything at all.
- 21:06But the cellar created enough for
- 21:07discreet authorization to be
- 21:09transmitted to the organizers of the
- 21:11event. Mêlé. will be able to enter
- 21:14the scene and it's a big Mêlé that
- 21:16will be offered. Nice weight, but he
- 21:28doesn't quite get it. That's after its
- 21:48release, Mêlé experiences its biggest
- 21:51media moment. From there, the game
- 21:52becomes a symbol. Against all logic,
- 21:55against its time, against its own
- 21:57creator, nothing can stop it. This is
- 22:00what is called the platinum age. It is
- 22:02the time when all finally seems to
- 22:04smile on Mêlé. This was the arrival
- 22:05of major sponsors like Cloud 9, Evil
- 22:07Genocises, Team Liquid, and TSM, who
- 22:09signed melee players. These were the
- 22:10first real salaries for a Gamecube game
- 22:12, and it was also the period when each
- 22:14tournament broke records for
- 22:16participants and viewership, and when a
- 22:18whole new generation of players
- 22:19exploded. First at APEX 2015, where the
- 22:21arrogant Lefen achieved the impossible
- 22:23by defeating Mew King in a tournament,
- 22:24officially becoming the first player in
- 22:26history to have defeated gods in
- 22:27official competition. But this was also
- 22:29the time when the meta was refreshed
- 22:31with the first major titles for Ax and
- 22:32his Pikachu, the emergence of Wizro and
- 22:34his Captain Falcom, and Plub who won
- 22:36majors with his chic. And paradoxically
- 22:38, this period, more particularly
- 22:40between 2017 and 2020, was also one of
- 22:42almost absolute domination. Hry Box's
- 22:45dominance and his cuddly toy are on a
- 22:47roll, giving him almost total control
- 22:49over the competitive scene. In reality,
- 22:51the peak of this rise will undoubtedly
- 22:54come around February 2020. Because,
- 22:56while a new Smash game has been
- 22:58released, Ultimate, which has—
- 23:00although I once again regret the
- 23:03absence of Wigi on the genre—900,000
- 23:05characters available—Ultimate is a
- 23:07very good game. It's very good Smash
- 23:10Bros. and on a particularly popular
- 23:12console, Nintendo, it's probably even
- 23:14the "best" Smash, in the sense that
- 23:16it's both a very good family party game
- 23:18and an excellent competitive game. Yet
- 23:21even despite that, Melee keeps writing
- 23:23such absurdly cool storylines. We'll
- 23:26see historic cash grabs with Smash 789.
- 23:29In short, all is well for Melee. Maybe
- 23:33things are going too well for Melee.
- 23:38March 2020, lockdown. The world is in
- 23:41lockdown and unlike other Mêlé games,
- 23:44this period is truly apocalyptic
- 23:46because Mêlé is a Gamecube video game
- 23:49. There is no online mode in Mêlé. It
- 23:51is a game that is played on a
- 23:53television, preferably CRT, and in
- 23:54person. It is a game that therefore
- 23:57logically has nowhere to exist. And the
- 23:59worst part is that it is not the worst
- 24:00because during the pandemic, tongues
- 24:02are loosened. There are many
- 24:03accusations of harassment, abuse,
- 24:06manipulation and sometimes even worse.
- 24:09We are talking about a list in
- 24:10alphabetical order of more than 100
- 24:12Smash figures who are being questioned
- 24:14and we are talking about people who
- 24:16were previously synonymous with trust
- 24:17and respect in the community. Nintendo
- 24:19of course took the opportunity to hit
- 24:21the still-warm corpse of the
- 24:23competitive scene, but this time it was
- 24:25deserved. As a result, most major
- 24:27events immediately distanced themselves
- 24:30by permanently banning several of these
- 24:32iconic players. A very large number of
- 24:34historic sponsors jumped ship and the
- 24:36community itself collapsed from the
- 24:38inside. This was the darkest period for
- 24:40Smash Bros., which by the way didn't
- 24:42just involve Mêlé but Smash in
- 24:44general, except that as far as Mêlé
- 24:46was concerned, it was without the
- 24:47support of its creator, under lockdown
- 24:49and with a community destroyed from the
- 24:51inside that and that's it, here we are.
- 24:53After 20 years of resistance, the
- 24:56cafarmélé was declared clinically
- 24:59dead. But as every time we tell Mêé,
- 25:02come on, that was great, it's time to
- 25:04die now. Mêlé once again replied no.
- 25:10Do you see how we made the word a bit
- 25:12generic? Oh, you're the god. Oh no,
- 25:13you're the god. Come on, we're both the
- 25:15gotes. No, I will present the GO to you
- 25:18. And his name is Fidzi. Fizzi is a
- 25:21passionate gamer, but his gaming skills
- 25:22certainly don't make him the GOT. In
- 25:24fact, during lockdown, he's just
- 25:26looking for a way to play melee with
- 25:27his friends. The problem is that at
- 25:29that time, Hunter Slader, the only tool
- 25:30that allows you to play ML online,
- 25:32relies on the delay-based net code
- 25:34system. Basically, the more lag there
- 25:36is, the more the game slows down in
- 25:38order to synchronize the actions.
- 25:39Needless to say, for a game as precise
- 25:42and surgical as melee, it's completely
- 25:44unplayable. Too unplayable in any case
- 25:46for Fidzi, who will spend months trying
- 25:48to solve this problem. He writes code,
- 25:50tests it, starts over. He
- 25:52reverse-engineers Dolphine, the
- 25:53Gamecube emulator. He turns it inside
- 25:56out, takes it apart, and recodes it for
- 25:58one goal: a free, stable, and fluid
- 26:01online melee. He's going to call it
- 26:03Sleepy. Sleepy is based on a system
- 26:05called roll backnet code, which
- 26:07basically predicts the different inputs
- 26:09locally and corrects them at the exact
- 26:11frame needed, which is vital in a game
- 26:14like Melee where frame perfection is
- 26:16omnipresent. But does it really work?
- 26:19Well, when pro players tell you that
- 26:21they feel like they're playing almost
- 26:23as smoothly as offline, it's probably
- 26:24the case. And since I was telling you,
- 26:27Fidzi is the GOT, it's also going to
- 26:29add automatic replays, ranked
- 26:31matchmaking, detailed statistics, and
- 26:33session history. As a result, while no
- 26:36one can see each other in real life,
- 26:38Melee has never been so accessible. And
- 26:41of course, the logical next step is to
- 26:43cheer everyone up during a really bad
- 26:45time. The logical next step is hosting
- 26:48tournaments. In late 2020, The Big
- 26:51House announced its first major online
- 26:53tournament. Over 2,000 participants,
- 26:55commentators, sponsors, prizes, and a
- 26:57charitable goal. Everything is ready.
- 26:59In the midst of a pandemic, we'll have
- 27:01the pleasure of seeing the world's best
- 27:03players slaughter each other. Except
- 27:05that Hello Mr. Foa, there's a guy all
- 27:11alone in his underwear in his room who
- 27:13has just created an online mode for
- 27:15mixing that's more powerful than
- 27:16anything we've ever managed to do and
- 27:18distribute it completely for free.
- 27:27Nintendo intervenes. A new 6ist is sent
- 27:29to the organizers with the reason.
- 27:31Unauthorized use of a modified version
- 27:33of Super Smash Bros. Me. So, a quick
- 27:35explanation for both the US and
- 27:37Japanese regions. Any creation that
- 27:40remixes, adapts, or transforms an
- 27:42already protected work becomes what is
- 27:44called a derivative work, and the
- 27:46exclusive right to authorize or
- 27:47prohibit these derivatives belongs to
- 27:49the copyright holder. No one else.
- 27:52That's why, for example, a completely
- 27:53buggy stage like Pokémon Stadium,
- 27:55which we are 100%capable of correcting
- 27:57with the injection of a single line of
- 27:59code, is not corrected in a tournament
- 28:01because that would mean playing on a
- 28:02modded and therefore illegal version of
- 28:04Melee. All this to say that by
- 28:06modifying protected code, Sleepy
- 28:08becomes an unlicensed derivative work.
- 28:11Hence the Big House 2020 seasonist, and
- 28:13it doesn't matter if The Big House uses
- 28:16Sleepy only because there is no other
- 28:18choice but to use Sleepy. It doesn't
- 28:20matter if it's a charity tournament and
- 28:23in the middle of a pandemic, Nintendo
- 28:25has simply pulled a lever that they
- 28:26have the right to pull. Except that
- 28:30here it just doesn't work. The hashtag
- 28:33frem is launched. Many content creators
- 28:34are taking a stand, including gods.
- 28:36Articles are appearing in the press.
- 28:38There are even Splatoon players who are
- 28:39going to boycott their own tournament,
- 28:41which is organized by Nintendo. And
- 28:43once again, Nintendo takes a huge slap
- 28:47in the face. What Nintendo wanted to
- 28:50stifle becomes a public scandal. A
- 28:53scandal so big that it will force
- 28:55Nintendo to do something simply
- 28:56incredible. Not to retreat this time,
- 28:59but to move forward. Nintendo is going
- 29:02to take a step towards the Melee
- 29:04community, an invitation, a proposal
- 29:06for peace. They finally get it, and
- 29:09with the help of an already established
- 29:11player, Panda Global, Nintendo is going
- 29:13to oversee the very first official
- 29:15Melee circuit, a sort of world
- 29:17championship, the Panda Cup. What could
- 29:20possibly go wrong? Oh, everything,
- 29:23absolutely everything will go wrong.
- 29:27Why? Because in fact, in parallel with
- 29:29the Panda Cup, there is another Melee
- 29:31World Cup project that has just been
- 29:33set up, which has just secured enough
- 29:35funds to exist completely independently
- 29:37: it is the Smash for the Tour,
- 29:38organized by the VG Boot Camp team, who
- 29:40are truly a historic pillar of the
- 29:42Smash scene. At first, everything goes
- 29:44well; for months, all goes well. The
- 29:46two circuits coexist, nothing has been
- 29:48reported. In any case, nothing has been
- 29:51reported publicly, but it would seem
- 29:52that unofficially Panda is starting to
- 29:54put a bit of pressure on. Tournament
- 29:57organizers receive advice,
- 29:58recommendations, this "It would be a
- 30:00shame if something happened to you"
- 30:01message, like losing your Nintendo
- 30:03license. And this is a situation that
- 30:06will last until November 2022. A few
- 30:08days before the Smash World Tour global
- 30:10finals scheduled for December, Nintendo
- 30:12cancels the Smash World Tour. We don't
- 30:16really know why, the reason is unclear.
- 30:18A license was allegedly refused, not
- 30:19granted or, per Nintendo, not requested
- 30:21; the result is the same. It's an
- 30:24entire circuit destroyed in an email.
- 30:28Hundreds of players in the lurch, jobs
- 30:30destroyed, months of organization
- 30:32ruined and a community model shattered.
- 30:34It's a doubly sad situation since the
- 30:36immediate reaction was an absolute
- 30:39boycott of the Panda Cup and therefore
- 30:41the cancellation of this championship.
- 30:44And to be completely honest, in reality
- 30:46in this story, everyone has their gray
- 30:48areas and their share of responsibility
- 30:50. For example, do some tournament
- 30:52organizers benefit from the fact that
- 30:54Nintendo is not directly involved in
- 30:56order to, I don't know, set the prices
- 30:58they want or be sponsored by
- 30:59cryptocurrencies? And maybe, but for
- 31:02sure, once again, they are implicated
- 31:05and punished to exist. Once Nintendo
- 31:08intervenes, once an official project
- 31:10starts, the censorship returns. Control
- 31:14returns, the problems return. And that
- 31:20day, I think something was broken
- 31:23forever. The Nintendo game that
- 31:25Nintendo hates will have to do what it
- 31:27has always done, which is to go back to
- 31:29its roots, to managing everything solo
- 31:32without Nintendo because it's ugly,
- 31:34it's noisy, but it's mixed. And
- 31:36strangely enough, that's how it works
- 31:38because maybe Mêé is the Nintendo
- 31:41game that Nintendo hates, but more
- 31:43importantly Mêlé is the Nintendo game
- 31:46that never needed Nintendo. Even today
- 31:48in a sports industry where everything
- 31:51is calibrated, monetized, optimized,
- 31:53Mêlé is still there. The meta
- 31:56evolution. Ever crazier stories
- 31:57continue to be written. The new lord of
- 31:59Mélé, that of those who didn't grow
- 32:01up with the game but who conquered it,
- 32:02the Sleepy Kids. Players who discovered
- 32:04Mêlé with Sleepy, and Sleepy at
- 32:06Mêlé's scale, that's two days ago.
- 32:08But above all, new prodigies like Zin
- 32:10who now sits on the roof of Mélé,
- 32:12Jook who reinvents Chic at each
- 32:13tournament, Ax and his Pikachu who are
- 32:15still shocking the competitive scene
- 32:17and Hamza who wins a major with Yoshi.
- 32:20With Yoshi Mélé, it's a game that has
- 32:24seen gods born, die and be reborn. It's
- 32:27a game that has survived an
- 32:28incalculable number of clones that were
- 32:30supposed to kill it, watching other
- 32:32publishers put millions into their
- 32:34competitive circuit while its own did
- 32:36everything to destroy it almost by
- 32:37reflex. It's a game that has been
- 32:40forgotten, rejected, sabotaged, banned,
- 32:42betrayed, that has had every reason to
- 32:45die, to die 100 times and yet strangely
- 32:50inexplicably has never been so alive.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Le jeu Nintendo que Nintendo déteste by Kombo, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,312 words across 820 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.