LE GROS MENSONGE SUR LA FIABILITÉ DES VOITURES ÉLECTRIQUES… ET LE COÛT DES PANNES ! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this new video in which we
- 0:02are going to talk about the reliability
- 0:04of electric cars. It is one of the
- 0:06arguments most put forward by
- 0:07manufacturers to make us switch to
- 0:08electric. They are supposedly just more
- 0:10reliable than combustion engines. Now,
- 0:12it's true that on paper, they don't
- 0:14have turbos, EGR valves, or timing
- 0:15belts bathed in oil, and their motor
- 0:17has on average 90%fewer moving parts
- 0:19than a combustion engine. So logically,
- 0:22fewer parts equals fewer breakdowns.
- 0:25Except that this week, there was news
- 0:26that caught my eye and made me want to
- 0:28dig a little deeper into the subject of
- 0:30EV reliability: it's the supplier ZF, a
- 0:32huge German supplier, which unveiled
- 0:34over 100 variants of repair kits for
- 0:36electric motors, for their inverters,
- 0:37and for their gearboxes. And that's
- 0:40when a question came to mind. If the
- 0:42electric car is really as simple and as
- 0:44easy to maintain as we were told, why
- 0:46is it now necessary to create an entire
- 0:48ecosystem to repair its components? And
- 0:50in trying to answer that question, I
- 0:52realized that in reality, there were
- 0:53already plenty of mini-scandals, plenty
- 0:55of issues linked to the reliability of
- 0:57electric cars which are certainly much
- 0:59less publicized than the Purtech or 1L
- 1:00TCE scandals, for example, on the
- 1:02combustion engine side, but which are
- 1:04very much real: breakdowns that are
- 1:05sometimes very expensive to repair, and
- 1:07are sometimes even completely
- 1:08irreparable. So I wanted to make this
- 1:10short video for you in which we will
- 1:12take stock of the reliability of
- 1:13electric cars, their main problems,
- 1:15repair costs, and of course also the
- 1:17comparison with the reliability of
- 1:18combustion engines. I hope this special
- 1:20edition video will interest you. If
- 1:22that's the case, I'm counting on you to
- 1:23show it as usual by leaving a like,
- 1:25subscribing, boosting this video, and
- 1:27commenting to share your experiences
- 1:28with us. Maybe you are among the
- 1:30electric car owners for whom everything
- 1:32has gone well so far, but maybe you are
- 1:33among the owners who have already had
- 1:35to deal with reliability problems or
- 1:37breakdowns on their electric vehicles.
- 1:39Don't hesitate. We will start this
- 1:41video with a few examples of cases that
- 1:43have affected electric cars lately,
- 1:45just to start with a few brands and
- 1:46models to avoid and to give you some
- 1:48examples of repair costs as well. First
- 1:50, there was the Renault Zoé case. I
- 1:52already told you about this one in a
- 1:53video. Don't hesitate to go watch it
- 1:54for more details. The Zoe is quite an
- 1:56interesting case because, as I
- 1:58explained earlier in the intro to this
- 2:00video, electric motors usually contain
- 2:02very few moving parts, but they do
- 2:04still have bearings. And on the Zoe,
- 2:06these bearings have a design-related
- 2:08weakness that starts to manifest around
- 2:10the 100,000 km mark. A problem that,
- 2:12until the arrival of unofficial kits
- 2:14offered by third-party brands, had no
- 2:16possibility of being repaired
- 2:18separately according to Renault. For
- 2:20Renault, the entire motor had to be
- 2:21replaced. The result: a bill of around
- 2:23€ 5,000. So at Stellantis, there are
- 2:25quite a few examples as well.
- 2:26Unfortunately, they have quite a few
- 2:28issues, just like with their combustion
- 2:29engines. I won't list every single
- 2:31example here because, unfortunately,
- 2:32there are far too many, but there are
- 2:34two that are fairly well-known. The
- 2:35first one, we also talked about it in a
- 2:37video some time ago; I invite you to go
- 2:38see the case in detail because it's
- 2:40quite exceptional. It involves
- 2:42powertrain issues affecting the
- 2:43electric version of the Fiat 500X, for
- 2:45example, but also other vehicles in the
- 2:46Stellantis ranges that are based on the
- 2:48same platforms. There are a bunch, with
- 2:52cars that simply stop while driving,
- 2:53without any real explanation, sometimes
- 2:55right in the middle of the highway,
- 2:57with no real solution found from
- 2:58Stellantis yet, and cars sometimes sent
- 3:00to the garage three or four times for
- 3:02the same problem that never gets fixed.
- 3:04Sometimes the vehicle is immobilized
- 3:06for several months, as we have already
- 3:08seen in some cases, resulting in bills
- 3:10of several thousand euros to fix a
- 3:11failure that may not even be
- 3:13potentially corrected. The second
- 3:15problem that is fairly well-known at
- 3:17Stellantis is the issue with the
- 3:18charging management software, which can
- 3:20malfunction for no apparent reason,
- 3:22causing the vehicle to refuse to charge
- 3:24. It’s a real shame for an electric
- 3:27car, with in some cases on 208s, Corsas
- 3:29, or Fiat 500s, the entire internal
- 3:31charger needing replacement with a bill
- 3:34of nearly € 5,000 in the process.
- 3:36There are also examples on the
- 3:38Volkswagen Group side. At Volkswagen,
- 3:40they specialize mostly in battery
- 3:42issues, both on entry-level models and
- 3:44higher-end models. For example, at
- 3:46Porsche, we have already seen cases
- 3:48with bills of nearly € 5,000 to
- 3:50replace high-voltage battery control
- 3:52units. Invoices of over € 15,000 for
- 3:55Volkswagen ID.Buzz battery replacements
- 3:57, and invoices of € 8,000 to €
- 3:5910,000 to replace not the entire
- 4:01battery, but faulty cells on some newer
- 4:03models where it's possible, like the
- 4:05Volkswagen ID.3. Now, these issues
- 4:08don't just affect European
- 4:10manufacturers; for example, at Hyundai,
- 4:11which was one of the pioneers in
- 4:13electric cars, there were the famous
- 4:15ICCU problems on the Ioniq 5 and Ioniq
- 4:176. The ICCU is the software component
- 4:20that manages various essential
- 4:21functions related to charging and
- 4:23low-voltage power supply. Its failure
- 4:26can simply immobilize the car, even
- 4:28while the motor and battery are still
- 4:30fully functional, with, again, quite
- 4:32high costs to replace this ICCU unit,
- 4:34which can reach up to € 4,000. Even
- 4:36among industry leaders like Chinese
- 4:38brands or Tesla, there are also
- 4:39problems that are fairly unknown but
- 4:41are nonetheless present. At Tesla,
- 4:43there were issues with contactors. It
- 4:44is, to put it simply, a switch that
- 4:46allows connecting or disconnecting the
- 4:48battery from the rest of the car. On
- 4:51recent Model 3 and Model Y vehicles,
- 4:52there was an internal connection
- 4:54problem in the contactor coil that
- 4:56could cause it to open suddenly. And if
- 4:59that happened while driving, well, the
- 5:00car would have an immediate loss of
- 5:01power and could simply become
- 5:02immobilized. And among Chinese brands,
- 5:05which are yet considered to be the most
- 5:08technologically advanced, MG had a
- 5:10major issue on its MG5s in 2022 with a
- 5:12cooling fan that could simply seize up
- 5:15and cause its control system to
- 5:17overheat, with a significant risk of
- 5:19fire. As you can see, over a relatively
- 5:22short period, there are quite a few
- 5:24examples of reliability issues that,
- 5:26most of the time—outside of the
- 5:27Renault Zoe case—affect relatively
- 5:29new vehicles, vehicles of all brands,
- 5:31of all origins, and especially vehicles
- 5:34of all ranges; even Porsche is not
- 5:35spared. Of course, over the same period
- 5:37, we could probably have found just as
- 5:39many problems related to internal
- 5:40combustion or hybrid engines. But one
- 5:42clearly cannot say, after seeing all
- 5:43these examples, that the electric car
- 5:45is completely reliable. The big problem
- 5:47is that it is extremely difficult to
- 5:49get a general idea of the reliability
- 5:51of electric cars compared to combustion
- 5:53engine vehicles, because studies on the
- 5:55subject say a bit of everything and its
- 5:57opposite for the simple reason that
- 5:59they haven't agreed on what they would
- 6:01consider to be a breakdown or a real
- 6:02reliability issue. This means that when
- 6:04you look at the various statistical
- 6:06studies on the reliability of these
- 6:07different powertrains, you can be
- 6:08completely lost. We have the ADAC, for
- 6:11example, which will explain to us that
- 6:13for 4-year-old cars, there would be 6.5
- 6:14breakdowns recorded per 1,000 electric
- 6:16cars versus 12.5 per 1,000 combustion
- 6:18vehicles, so technically half as many.
- 6:20But on the other hand, we have a
- 6:22Consumer Reports study that analyzed
- 6:24responses from around 400,000 vehicle
- 6:26owners and concluded that electric cars
- 6:28have on average 80%more problems
- 6:30compared to purely combustion cars. The
- 6:32big difference between these two
- 6:34studies, which simply say the opposite,
- 6:36is that the ADAC only counts cars that
- 6:38break down completely, stop, and leave
- 6:40you on the side of the road, whereas
- 6:41Consumer Reports takes into account
- 6:43problems more broadly encountered by
- 6:45owners. This could be a charging issue,
- 6:47it could be an electronic problem with
- 6:49the vehicle with reduced power without
- 6:50the vehicle necessarily breaking down
- 6:52entirely. To summarize these two
- 6:54studies a bit, one could conclude that
- 6:56overall, electric cars have half as
- 6:58many major breakdowns but four to five
- 7:00times more minor ones. The big lie from
- 7:03the industry regarding the reliability
- 7:04of electric cars is having turned this
- 7:06truth into a sales pitch meant to make
- 7:08future electric car buyers believe that
- 7:10by buying an electric one, they were
- 7:12buying a car that would never break
- 7:14down. Now, there are still two points
- 7:16on which breaking down with an electric
- 7:18car is much more annoying than with a
- 7:19combustion one. The first is the
- 7:22complexity of repairs. On a combustion
- 7:24car. When you break down, unless the
- 7:26engine or transmission is completely
- 7:28dead, it is, first, generally
- 7:29completely feasible to replace only the
- 7:31defective part and, second, it is
- 7:33doable in just about any garage. With
- 7:35an electric car, you can forget all
- 7:37that. First, most small rural garages
- 7:40or independent shops are not or not
- 7:41properly equipped to work on electric
- 7:43cars. Now, that’s not necessarily
- 7:46their fault, and that is perhaps
- 7:47something that will change thanks to a
- 7:49new European Union rule. Manufacturers
- 7:51will now be required to share with
- 7:53independent garages the resources and
- 7:55tools necessary to fix faults in
- 7:57electric vehicles, something which
- 7:59until now was not mandatory. This means
- 8:02that most of the time, when you wanted
- 8:04to get your electric car repaired, you
- 8:06couldn't go to the cheap little garage
- 8:07around the corner, because they usually
- 8:09didn't have the accreditation to work
- 8:10on electric cars. You were almost
- 8:13forced to go to your dealership or a
- 8:15brand-approved garage. And secondly,
- 8:19and this is perhaps where ZF has done
- 8:21something quite clever, until now most
- 8:23electric car breakdowns, whether they
- 8:24affected the motor or the batteries,
- 8:26required replacing the entire component
- 8:28. Up until now, a bearing failure.
- 8:31Meant systematically replacing the
- 8:33entire motor. Now, with third-party
- 8:35brands like ZF or other suppliers
- 8:36starting to offer kits, that might
- 8:38change things a little bit. And the
- 8:40same goes for batteries; we now have
- 8:42brands that offer batteries divided
- 8:43into several cells that can be repaired
- 8:45independently of one another. But we
- 8:47mustn't forget that a large portion of
- 8:49the electric vehicles found on the
- 8:50second-hand market still make this
- 8:52impossible. A problem with the battery
- 8:53means replacing the battery. And that
- 8:55brings us to the second point where
- 8:57combustion engines currently have a
- 8:58real advantage: repair costs. Because
- 9:01on a combustion car, when you have an
- 9:03engine or gearbox problem, or simply a
- 9:04wear-and-tear part to replace, whether
- 9:06it’s a clutch, a dead turbo, a
- 9:08clogged EGR valve, or a timing belt to
- 9:09change, it’s expensive, but it’s
- 9:11still cheaper than repairing an
- 9:13electric car. And on that point, all
- 9:15the studies agree. In France, we have a
- 9:18study by France Assureurs conducted on
- 9:201.9 million vehicles. So it's quite a
- 9:22massive sample size, which explains
- 9:23that electric vehicles cost on average
- 9:2511%more to repair than combustion cars.
- 9:27We have another study by the SRA based
- 9:29on 600,000 vehicles, which shows that
- 9:31the average repair cost for an electric
- 9:33car is 20%higher than for a combustion
- 9:35car. In the United Kingdom, an AX study
- 9:38explains that the average repair for an
- 9:39electric vehicle is 20%more expensive
- 9:41on average and also takes 2 days longer
- 9:43to fix. And we have Opteven, the
- 9:46specialist in mechanical breakdown
- 9:47warranties that works with automotive
- 9:49networks and French distributors,
- 9:51explaining to us that out of 700,000
- 9:52breakdown cases in France in 2026,
- 9:54electric vehicles were on average 27%
- 9:56more expensive to repair than gasoline
- 9:58ones. So yes, electric cars can break
- 10:00down. Yes, it costs much more to repair
- 10:02than a combustion engine, but to end on
- 10:04a positive note, there is still a good
- 10:06chance that the situation will improve
- 10:08for electrics in the coming years. For
- 10:10the simple reason that, believe it or
- 10:12not, for now, we are still on the first
- 10:13generations of electric cars sold to
- 10:15the general European public. Between
- 10:17the innovations in battery
- 10:18repairability, and the vehicle
- 10:20electronics and software that are
- 10:21improving day by day, for both current
- 10:22combustion and electric vehicles. the
- 10:25arrival on the market of new repair
- 10:27kits dedicated to electric cars. We can
- 10:30imagine that in 10 to 15 years, they
- 10:31might break down a little less often
- 10:32and that repair costs will have dropped
- 10:34. In the meantime, manufacturers talk a
- 10:36lot about the simplicity of their
- 10:38electric motors, but talk much less
- 10:40about the complexity of everything
- 10:41around them. In any case, I hope this
- 10:43video has helped you see a little more
- 10:45clearly the reality of electric car
- 10:46reliability, and what awaits you if you
- 10:48take the plunge. Don't hesitate once
- 10:51again to share your experiences with us
- 10:53in the comments, leave a like,
- 10:55subscribe, become a supporter via the
- 10:56join button below this video, and join
- 10:58me on social media as I now offer auto
- 11:00news on Insta, TikTok, and Facebook.
- 11:03Don't hesitate, I've put the links in
- 11:04the description. Thank you all. Ciao!
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of LE GROS MENSONGE SUR LA FIABILITÉ DES VOITURES ÉLECTRIQUES… ET LE COÛT DES PANNES ! by Ecki - News Auto , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,237 words across 353 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.