Тревога и реальность. Вводная лекция проекта Lacanod. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Good afternoon, dear colleagues and
- 0:04everyone simply interested in
- 0:05psychoanalysis. Today, as part of our
- 0:08introductory lectures for the Locanot
- 0:11project, we will be talking about
- 0:13anxiety, and not just today.
- 0:15Specifically, our meeting today is
- 0:18titled Anxiety and Reality. The thing
- 0:23is, the next 20 to 30 years will be
- 0:25difficult everywhere, for the world
- 0:27faces global upheavals, which I think
- 0:29has become obvious to many. And because
- 0:33of that, anxiety will continue to sweep
- 0:35over those around us, and ourselves,
- 0:38like storm waves. For the shock
- 0:42associated with the loss of a familiar
- 0:45world, of jobs, homes, loved ones,
- 0:48emigration, and so on, is really always
- 0:51about our state of powerlessness that
- 0:54arises when our usual foundations in
- 0:57the world are destroyed. And where we
- 1:02feel our helplessness, we are
- 1:04inevitably gripped by anxiety. Humanity
- 1:09has faced the fact of its powerlessness
- 1:11before certain phenomena since ancient
- 1:13times. Death, disease, earthquakes,
- 1:17wars, floods, or other events that
- 1:20intrude upon the usual course of life.
- 1:24This is what raises waves of anxiety
- 1:27within a person. It would probably be
- 1:31more accurate to say it raises waves of
- 1:34anxiety rather than simply provoking a
- 1:37state of anxiety. Since anxiety, in
- 1:40actual fact, lives within each one of
- 1:43us. For millennia, religion has offered
- 1:47us a way to cope with our anxiety
- 1:49precisely through the act of accepting
- 1:52our lack of omnipotence, our
- 1:54powerlessness in the face of an
- 1:57inability to change the course of
- 1:59events, for humanity has been dying,
- 2:02falling ill, killing, and perishing
- 2:04throughout its history. And this,
- 2:09namely the institution of religion or
- 2:12the church, really worked. For where I
- 2:16accept my impossibility as something
- 2:20self-evident, my anxiety level
- 2:23inevitably decreases. And regardless of
- 2:28whether we are religious people or
- 2:30atheistically inclined, we must
- 2:32acknowledge the following fact.
- 2:36Religion or the institution of the
- 2:39church, in a broad sense, has had an
- 2:42anxiety-reducing effect on believers
- 2:44for millennia. However, due to the fact
- 2:49that during the 20th century science
- 2:52was placed on a pedestal as something
- 2:54meant to replace the supposedly
- 2:56outdated institution of the church and
- 2:59gift people a new truth, the truth of
- 3:02scientific knowledge. We encountered
- 3:05the fact that a new myth, a new master,
- 3:08had established itself on that pedestal
- 3:11. Its name is science. It turns out
- 3:15everything in this world can be
- 3:17measured, broken down into particles,
- 3:19or set into motion. And thus, the power
- 3:23of scientific knowledge was transmitted
- 3:25to us as truly limitless. And a couple
- 3:30of decades after launching a human into
- 3:33space, apple trees were supposed to be
- 3:36blooming on Mars, but it didn't happen
- 3:39because, on one hand, science was
- 3:41ultimately placed at the service of
- 3:44capital and the corporations that small
- 3:47family businesses of the 19th century
- 3:49and earlier had turned into. Whether we
- 3:53are talking about razors, chocolate,
- 3:56cars, or something else? And on the
- 4:00other hand, scientific achievements are
- 4:03surprisingly and effectively used every
- 4:06time where the talk turns to
- 4:08destruction. But the most interesting
- 4:12circumstance is, perhaps, the fact that
- 4:15science has proven not to be
- 4:16all-powerful. To this day, science
- 4:21cannot explain certain phenomena, and
- 4:23there will always be something that
- 4:26science, at its current stage of
- 4:28development, is unable to explain. Thus
- 4:33, as of today, the institution of
- 4:35religion does not work as effectively
- 4:38as it once did with the rising waves of
- 4:41human anxiety. At the same time,
- 4:44science has also demonstrated its
- 4:46limitations. And on the other hand, its
- 4:51vulnerability to enormous capital,
- 4:54which makes it biased. Science has also
- 4:59failed to live up to the hopes placed
- 5:01in it for creating a happy world, and
- 5:04therefore, for global relief from
- 5:06anxiety. It is precisely scientific
- 5:10achievements that made the nuclear bomb
- 5:13, chemical, biological, and the most
- 5:15modern types of weaponry possible.
- 5:19Furthermore, it is thanks to scientific
- 5:22advancements that mass-market food
- 5:25products in bright, colorful packaging
- 5:29appeared, which, due to flavor
- 5:32enhancers and dyes, not only make
- 5:35people dependent on them but also
- 5:38significantly shorten our lives while
- 5:41worsening their quality. As diseases of
- 5:47the gastrointestinal tract arise after
- 5:50consuming chips, sodas—yes, with
- 5:53their entire periodic table—and so on
- 5:56, as well as metabolic disorders and
- 5:59immune system failures. So, at least
- 6:05two global paradigms have been formed
- 6:08in the world, two global systems
- 6:10helping people cope with anxiety.
- 6:14Arising in situations of loss: loss of
- 6:18a familiar way of life, loss of a
- 6:22familiar worldview, loss of a loved one
- 6:26, loss of a familiar environment, loss
- 6:30of familiar space. These two paradigms
- 6:34are, yes, religion and science. And we
- 6:38see that for certain categories of
- 6:41people, each of these systems can work,
- 6:44and still works today. However, let's
- 6:49be frank: we much more often encounter
- 6:52people for whom the usual mechanisms
- 6:56for suppressing or rationalizing
- 6:59anxiety do not work. And now we are
- 7:04going to talk about individual ways of
- 7:07defending against anxiety. Well, first
- 7:10of all, there is aggression. And we can
- 7:13see situations where a person flooded
- 7:16with anxiety acts aggressively toward
- 7:19those around them. Thus, the principle
- 7:22of aggression as a way to cope with
- 7:25anxiety is built on active acting out.
- 7:30By attacking someone, I, first of all,
- 7:32get the opportunity to discharge my
- 7:35impulses, my libido. Anxiety, as we
- 7:40have seen, is a state of excessive
- 7:43flooding of our psyche that is not
- 7:46linked to any objects of the outside
- 7:49world, for example, to people valuable
- 7:53to us, work, hobbies, sports, alcohol,
- 7:56or sexual relationships. And where we
- 8:02cannot place ourselves into the world,
- 8:04because our state, our internal state
- 8:07turns out to be excessive in relation
- 8:10to the world around us, as we have
- 8:12already seen, we, what you might call,
- 8:15get overwhelmed. Beyond providing a way
- 8:20to discharge tension through aggressive
- 8:23action, which is a method of acting out
- 8:25anxiety, it is said, for example, that
- 8:28one should never corner a rat. Why?
- 8:32Because, being in a state of complete
- 8:35helplessness, and finding itself—as
- 8:38we might assume—in a state of anxiety
- 8:40under the threat of destruction, it
- 8:43will lash out, lash out furiously at
- 8:45its opponent. Regardless of its size.
- 8:50But this is not the only way of coping
- 8:53with anxiety that we observe time and
- 8:56again. And besides providing the
- 9:01opportunity to discharge excess,
- 9:04unrealized, undischarged, or
- 9:06unsatisfied impulses in the world
- 9:09through aggressive action—which is a
- 9:13way of acting out anxiety—aggression
- 9:16possesses another obvious advantage,
- 9:20namely, a sense of control over the
- 9:23situation. Where a person lacks what is
- 9:29colloquially called "cool-headedness,"
- 9:32they prove unable to keep their
- 9:34internal anxiety in a suppressed or
- 9:37contained state. And, being overwhelmed
- 9:42by anxiety, they strike first or commit
- 9:45some other fatal mistake. Sigmund Freud
- 9:51tells us about a situation he observed
- 9:53with his grandson. Whenever the mother
- 9:57of Sigmund Freud's grandson—that is,
- 10:00his daughter-in-law—would leave, the
- 10:04indignation of the infant left in the
- 10:07crib knew no bounds, for he was left
- 10:10without the person his physical
- 10:12survival in the world depended on, as
- 10:15well as his sense of stability, since
- 10:18the mother’s care provides him the
- 10:21means to deflate anxiety. We could put
- 10:26it in drier terms. A mother stabilizes
- 10:30an infant's mental state through her
- 10:32care. So, the child encounters loving
- 10:37eyes, encouraging intonations, and
- 10:41gentle hands that lovingly rub his
- 10:44little body with lotion or oil in his
- 10:47relationship with his mother. And all
- 10:52of this calms him down tremendously. He
- 10:57feels under maternal protection and
- 10:59therefore becomes calm. However, when
- 11:03facing periods of his mother's absence
- 11:06from his crib, Sigmund Freud's grandson
- 11:08, like many other infants, uh, realized
- 11:13, or shall we say, transformed his
- 11:16anxiety into aggression. And then his
- 11:20sense of rage, mixed with despair, knew
- 11:23no bounds. Psychoanalytic classics like
- 11:29Melanie Klein and Donald Woods
- 11:31Winnicott tell us that for an infant,
- 11:34minutes without mom feel like an entire
- 11:36eternity. Perhaps you remember how
- 11:40slowly time dragged in childhood. For
- 11:43an infant, it seems, time drags even
- 11:46more slowly. And this brings us to what
- 11:51has been termed "transitional objects"
- 11:53in psychoanalysis. A pacifier,
- 11:56replacing the mother's breast or a
- 11:58bottle of milk or formula in the
- 12:00infant's mouth. A stuffed toy or a
- 12:05plastic rattle fulfills the function of
- 12:08an object for the child's libido
- 12:11investment during those periods when
- 12:14mom is absent, when he cannot be in
- 12:17that stabilizing, life-saving contact
- 12:20with a feeling, loving, accepting, and
- 12:23caring mother. And the child begins to
- 12:28play with these objects, namely, as
- 12:32Sigmund Freud points out, with his
- 12:35thumb, yes, using it as a substitute
- 12:38for the mother's nipple. Also with
- 12:42rattles, soft toys, and so on, playing
- 12:45out in his imagination certain
- 12:48relations with his mother, with the
- 12:51maternal Other, as Jacques Lacan would
- 12:54say. The child can, in his fantasies
- 12:59and certain actions with these toys,
- 13:01these transitional objects, realize
- 13:04everything he feels in relation to his
- 13:06mother. And for Sigmund Freud's
- 13:11grandson, such a transitional object
- 13:13became the following toy. A wooden reel
- 13:16with a string tied to it. And so in
- 13:21periods, in periods, let's say, of the
- 13:24child's anxious absence of his mother,
- 13:27with a shout of "fort," which
- 13:29translates as "gone," yes, in which
- 13:31Sigmund Freud recognizes the word "gone
- 13:34"? He would throw this reel away,
- 13:38however, without letting go of the end
- 13:41of the string tied to this wooden reel.
- 13:45That is, he did not cease to control it
- 13:49and discharged his anxiety through an
- 13:52aggressive act, through aggressive
- 13:56acting out. The little boy would pull
- 14:00this reel back by the string into his
- 14:02crib, accompanying this action with a
- 14:05cry of satisfaction. Yes. And Sigmund
- 14:11Freud examines the dramaturgy of his
- 14:14grandson's action. A grandson who had
- 14:18formed his own way of coping with
- 14:19anxiety during moments of his mother's
- 14:21departure. He, on the one hand, has the
- 14:26opportunity to discharge part of his
- 14:28anxiety through the aggressive impulse
- 14:30of throwing away this reel, this mother
- 14:32. Physical actions themselves often
- 14:36alleviate the state of an anxious
- 14:39person. Yes, hence the recommendations
- 14:43that it is necessary, for example, to
- 14:45walk for a long time or to do a few
- 14:48dozen squats or push-ups, or to shake
- 14:50out your body and so on. But besides
- 14:55discharging anxiety through aggression,
- 14:58the infant goes through a state of
- 15:01satisfaction when the reel is pulled
- 15:04back into his bed. Thus, Sigmund
- 15:07Freud's grandson, or, as I said a few
- 15:11minutes ago, more accurately Freud's,
- 15:14repeatedly plays out a favorable
- 15:17scenario that begins with the
- 15:20realization of aggression arising from
- 15:23the anxious state he found himself in
- 15:26during the absence of this primary big
- 15:30Other. Let us turn again to the
- 15:32Lacanian discourse. So, ultimately,
- 15:35having realized this anxiety, having
- 15:38discharged it in an aggressive act, he
- 15:41plays out a favorable scenario, which
- 15:44consists in the imaginary mother—the
- 15:48reel—returning to him, despite the
- 15:51fact that he cast her away, despite the
- 15:54fact that, in essence, by his
- 15:56aggressive act on an imaginary plane,
- 15:59the child had destroyed her. And this
- 16:03also reduces the amount of anxiety,
- 16:06this favorable finale to a situation by
- 16:09which the infant was overwhelmed. Since
- 16:13everything will be alright, and the
- 16:16unfaithful mother who left him will
- 16:18eventually return to him, he acts this
- 16:21out on the theatrical stage of
- 16:24relations with a significant person or
- 16:27with a significant Other. However, both
- 16:32the discharge of aggression and
- 16:34situations that end well for the infant
- 16:37would not work convincingly enough for
- 16:40him if they did not provide him with
- 16:42the illusion of control over the
- 16:45situation. After all, by reenacting his
- 16:50relationship with the disappearing
- 16:53mother himself, the infant shifted from
- 16:56a passive position, where he was, yes,
- 16:59in the passive voice. Those who study
- 17:03foreign languages understand, I think,
- 17:06this phrasing. So, he shifted from a
- 17:15passive position, where he was left and
- 17:17abandoned, to the position of an active
- 17:20participant in what was happening, to
- 17:22the position of an active participant
- 17:24in the situation. It wasn't that he was
- 17:27abandoned, it was that he himself
- 17:30abandoned such an unstable,
- 17:32disappearing mother. This is what
- 17:34happens in his fantasies. And this is
- 17:37what he acts out in his actions. He
- 17:41abandoned this unfaithful mother, who,
- 17:44despite the aggression he showed out of
- 17:48desperation, still, in the end,
- 17:50returned to him. One only needs to pull
- 17:54the string whenever he wants to. Thus,
- 17:59dear colleagues—and by colleagues I
- 18:02mean everyone interested in
- 18:05psychoanalysis, and therefore
- 18:07self-knowledge, for "know thyself and
- 18:10you will know the whole world"—So, in
- 18:14this way, dear colleagues, we move on
- 18:17to the second common way of coping with
- 18:20anxiety. We are talking, yes, after
- 18:23realizing it through aggression. The
- 18:27second method is the control of those
- 18:30around us. It smells like power. We can
- 18:34observe mothers who totally control the
- 18:37lives of their children. Sometimes this
- 18:40control, being literally boundless,
- 18:42reaches the point where it simply
- 18:44leaves no space for the person in the
- 18:46world. And some specialists, as we know
- 18:51, link such diseases as, for example,
- 18:54asthma and allergies, as well as many
- 18:57skin diseases—well, for example,
- 18:59eczema and psoriasis—to the anxiety
- 19:02directed at the infant by his mother,
- 19:05which is what pushed her. Yes, that is,
- 19:10her own inner anxiety provoked, pushed
- 19:12this woman toward increased control
- 19:14over the infant's behavior. And
- 19:19sometimes in everyday life, we say:
- 19:22anxious control. The mechanism of its
- 19:26action is built on the following scheme
- 19:28. The fact is that for an infant, there
- 19:32is no difference between what is
- 19:34happening around him in reality. Our
- 19:38topic today is anxiety and reality, and
- 19:40his fantasies about what is happening.
- 19:44And this state of affairs has an
- 19:46important consequence. Being in
- 19:48situations of confrontation with his
- 19:51helplessness, finding himself in
- 19:54situations of helplessness, gripped by
- 19:56anxiety, the infant begins to project
- 19:59his unbearable states in his
- 20:01imagination outward, and therefore—
- 20:04onto the mother, onto this very primary
- 20:07, yes, Lacanian Other, onto the
- 20:09maternal Other, with whom he is
- 20:12constantly in, actually, bonded
- 20:14symbiotic relations. And therefore, we
- 20:17cannot speak of the mother as a
- 20:19symbolic Other. Yes, for here we are
- 20:22talking about such a psychological
- 20:25symbiosis. Thus, for the infant, the
- 20:29mother becomes the one who contains
- 20:32everything bad and unbearable within
- 20:35him. Yes, he attributes to her, he
- 20:38projects in his fantasies an unbearable
- 20:41state onto the mother, for there is no
- 20:43one else. And in such moments, for the
- 20:48child, she becomes a persecuting and
- 20:50threatening figure. And so, instead of
- 20:55states of infinite falling or tearing
- 20:58himself to shreds, disintegration, the
- 21:00fragmentation that, for example,
- 21:02Melanie Klein talks about in states of
- 21:05anxiety and terror—what is left for
- 21:08him? It is only to control the one who,
- 21:13from now on, after the projection of my
- 21:16unbearable, aggressive, and destructive
- 21:20impulses into her, exudes anxiety, and
- 21:24therefore—danger. And controlling her
- 21:28doesn't necessarily have to be in
- 21:29reality. In reality, it doesn't really
- 21:33work out anyway. After all, as we
- 21:36remember, for an infant whose
- 21:38consciousness is just forming out of a
- 21:41chaos of instinctual impulses, what
- 21:44happens in actuality or reality is
- 21:47indistinguishable from what happens in
- 21:49his thinking. In his fantasies, in his
- 21:54hallucinations, in general, so to speak
- 21:56, in his head. That is, if I control my
- 22:02mother in my fantasies in any way,
- 22:05holding her, crushing her, tearing her
- 22:09apart in my fantasies, in fits of
- 22:12aggression that turn out to be
- 22:15reactions to the anxiety of being left
- 22:18alone and facing my own total
- 22:21helplessness. Yes. So, when I tear her
- 22:26to shreds in my fantasies, I am doing
- 22:29something with her, which means I am
- 22:31controlling her in reality too, meaning
- 22:34she is subject to me. And Sigmund Freud
- 22:39speaks not only of the infant's
- 22:41inability in the early stages to
- 22:43distinguish his fantasies from the
- 22:46actual state of affairs. We know that
- 22:50many people throughout their lives
- 22:54never cease to distinguish their
- 22:56fantasies from reality, from the actual
- 23:00state of affairs, and become indignant
- 23:03and shocked when what happens in
- 23:06reality does not coincide with their
- 23:09notions of that reality. As if reality
- 23:14itself owes us something, or must
- 23:17correspond to our expectations and
- 23:19fantasies. Therefore, in the infant, of
- 23:24course, this is most relevant—yes,
- 23:26this fusion, this flowing of his
- 23:28fantasies, and by and large, primarily
- 23:31hallucinations, into what is happening
- 23:33around him and vice versa. So, the
- 23:37point then is not only—as Sigmund
- 23:40Freud shows—that the infant is
- 23:43initially incapable of distinguishing
- 23:46his fantasies and hallucinations from
- 23:50what is happening around him, but also
- 23:53the prevalence, the primacy, the
- 23:56priority in his psychic reality, in his
- 23:59life, excuse me, in his thinking—the
- 24:03priority of psychic reality. Over
- 24:07reality, so to speak, the physical,
- 24:09material, over the reality of our world
- 24:11. In other words, how the infant sees
- 24:15and interprets what is happening, what
- 24:19fantasies he primarily fills his life's
- 24:22events with, turns out to be more
- 24:25important to him than how things
- 24:28actually stand. In reality, an infant's
- 24:31critical thinking is extremely low.
- 24:36They are incapable of grasping the real
- 24:39state of affairs, and, once again, this
- 24:42reminds us of certain recognizable
- 24:45adult figures rather than infants.
- 24:49After all, the world turns out to be
- 24:52very complex for them, so their primary
- 24:55, let’s say, hallucinating about the
- 24:58world, which gradually shifts later
- 25:06into more coherent and consistent
- 25:09fantasies, unlike fragmented
- 25:12hallucinations, is their way of
- 25:15interpreting what is unknown and
- 25:19incomprehensible to them. After all, in
- 25:23their fantasies, an infant can become
- 25:25omnipotent. And we see how later,
- 25:29preschool children tend to invent and
- 25:32fantasize, especially during the stages
- 25:35when the superego begins to take hold.
- 25:41They then strive to escape to their own
- 25:44island of freedom, away from the
- 25:47demands of the world around them and
- 25:50the demands of their forming superego.
- 25:56This is their opportunity to realize in
- 25:58their fantasies what they already
- 26:01perfectly understand they cannot
- 26:03realize in real life. The amazing is
- 26:07near, yet it is forbidden. And here,
- 26:12returning to the topic of anxious
- 26:15control by adults, often parents, we
- 26:18can identify a situation involving an
- 26:22unstable person. A person with
- 26:26insufficient internal support and a
- 26:29lack of experience in having their
- 26:32emotions—especially aggressive and
- 26:35destructive ones—contained by their
- 26:39mother, faces an increase in their
- 26:42anxiety levels. And this happens quite
- 26:46often with such individuals. After all,
- 26:50their psychic apparatus is not
- 26:52regulated in a balanced way, so it
- 26:54cannot cope, and they are thrown from
- 26:56the frying pan into the fire. So, in
- 27:01such situations, the deeply ingrained
- 27:04state of a helpless infant comes alive
- 27:07within this person. That is, in
- 27:12critical situations, which such a
- 27:15person encounters a hundred times a day
- 27:18, they regress in their psyche to the
- 27:21level of an infant flooded with anxiety
- 27:24. And then, this adult acts in life
- 27:29like that infant. Specifically, they
- 27:32look for the cause of their anxiety not
- 27:34within themselves, but outside, because
- 27:36it is easier. And those close to them,
- 27:41especially when it comes to children
- 27:44who are inevitably at the mercy of
- 27:47adults, become very tempting targets
- 27:51for discharging or offloading such a
- 27:54person's anxiety. After all, as
- 27:59mentioned, and I am talking about
- 28:01children now, they are inevitably
- 28:03subordinate to their parents due to
- 28:05their dependent position. And at first,
- 28:09they are totally dependent, even
- 28:11prenatally. Uh, this is a parapraxis
- 28:15that is happening to me for the second
- 28:17time during today's web lecture. Yes,
- 28:20and Sigmund Freud speaks of parapraxes
- 28:23as a situation of internal conflict,
- 28:26where certain desires of ours strive to
- 28:29break through, manifest, and be
- 28:31realized in this life, but at the same
- 28:34time encounter some kind of...
- 28:36restriction, right? And so, at that
- 28:40moment where I, on one hand, yes, in
- 28:43the guise of morality, must somehow be
- 28:47accessible to the audience, but at the
- 28:50same time not vulgarize, not dumb it
- 28:53down, and on the other hand, I am in a
- 28:57hurry, yes, to provide something
- 28:59important and interesting, yes—that
- 29:03is where certain emotional intentions
- 29:06collide, uh, with, let’s say, a
- 29:09certain task. That is when a slip of
- 29:12the tongue occurs, for example, as
- 29:14Sigmund Freud shows, which is the
- 29:16result of a contraction, a kind of
- 29:18pulling together. And here, yes, I then
- 29:22say "natally," which consists of two
- 29:25words, yes, which consists of the word
- 29:27"totally" and the word "inevitably."
- 29:32Where, yes, children, after all, in the
- 29:35early stages, I say, turn out to be
- 29:37inevitably, totally subordinate. And
- 29:40here an equivocation is formed, and
- 29:42here a slip of the tongue is formed,
- 29:44and this very "natally" arises. Dear
- 29:46colleagues, it is very important for us
- 29:48to see what is happening to us in life.
- 29:51It is very important for us not to run
- 29:54away from what, yes, sometimes happens
- 29:56to us. So, with full attention to what
- 30:01is happening to us, let us move on. As
- 30:05has already been said, children are
- 30:07inevitably, totally subordinate to
- 30:09their parents by virtue of their
- 30:12dependent position on them. And besides
- 30:15that, they always find themselves in
- 30:17the zone of parental reach. If not
- 30:22physical, then virtual, through the
- 30:24internet, messengers, and phone calls,
- 30:27yes, which, for example, anxious
- 30:30mothers will resort to many times a day
- 30:33. It is important to note that an
- 30:40over-controlling mother leaves a deep
- 30:43mark, a traumatic imprint on a
- 30:46child’s psyche because of how
- 30:49hypersensitive infants are to
- 30:52non-verbal maternal expressions, to
- 30:55non-verbal maternal signals. And
- 31:00therefore, an infant cannot be deceived
- 31:02in this sense. Behind maternal care, he
- 31:05reads her anxiety, and therefore may
- 31:07react aggressively to the manifestation
- 31:10of what would seem to be maternal care
- 31:13for him. And some adults, we see, are
- 31:16very aggressive where there arises, yes
- 31:20, for some reason very aggressive where
- 31:23maternal care towards them arises. And
- 31:28an over-controlling mother can become
- 31:31the cause of psychoses in a person’s
- 31:35future life or even the cause of
- 31:38psychoses unfolded already in his
- 31:41childhood. And here we are by no means,
- 31:45colleagues, talking about blaming
- 31:47mothers. Every mother is a living
- 31:51person with her own traumatic, early
- 31:54experience of entering this world, when
- 31:58her own mother gave her what she could
- 32:01give in those conditions and how she
- 32:04could give it by virtue of her own
- 32:07history of, uh, coping with anxiety or
- 32:10failing to cope with it. And now the
- 32:16mother herself does what and gives what
- 32:20she can give, not coping with her
- 32:23anxiety where she cannot cope with it,
- 32:27and coping where and how she is
- 32:30accustomed to coping with it. So here,
- 32:35colleagues, we are simply stating a
- 32:38fact. A mother who is limitless in her
- 32:43overanxious care is perceived by the
- 32:46child as someone who constantly presses
- 32:49in and, in fact, intrudes upon his
- 32:52space, disrupting the formation of his
- 32:56stable self-image, right? That is, the
- 33:00boundary between "I" and "not-I" is not
- 33:03marked or built, because it turns out
- 33:06to be fragile and at any moment
- 33:09transparent to the intrusion of this
- 33:12anxious, overcontrolling mother. And,
- 33:17of course, the self-image of such a
- 33:21child is disrupted from the very moment
- 33:25it begins to form. After all, in these
- 33:31conditions, such an infant never
- 33:33develops a clear picture of where he
- 33:35ends and his mother begins. He then
- 33:41remains, on a psychic level,
- 33:43unseparated, not individuated. Yes, he
- 33:50continues to dwell in symbiosis with
- 33:53the one who, through her
- 33:55overcontrolling anxious care, deprives
- 33:58him of the chance to test the world, to
- 34:02perform trial actions, to get his own
- 34:05bumps and bruises, and by facing
- 34:08difficulties, to acquire, live through,
- 34:12reflect upon, and make sense of his own
- 34:16unique experience of interacting with
- 34:19the world. Such a child, alas, is
- 34:22deprived of this all-important
- 34:24opportunity. And, consequently, he
- 34:28cannot then form his own foundations
- 34:31for interpreting the world. He will not
- 34:37be able to start thinking for himself,
- 34:40for he will inevitably, not being
- 34:43separated, continue to act in a way
- 34:46that ensures the greatest reduction of
- 34:49his mother's anxiety. So, colleagues,
- 34:56we see that when there is someone to
- 34:59worry about, it becomes easier for
- 35:01oneself. The main thing is to project
- 35:05your anxiety onto someone who cannot
- 35:08get away from you and present it,
- 35:11translate it all under the guise of, of
- 35:14course, concern for another person’s
- 35:17life and well-being. Yes, what a noble
- 35:21argument, which will endlessly justify
- 35:25anxious care by citing the dangers of
- 35:28the modern world. As if the world of
- 35:33primitive man or the Middle Ages was
- 35:37safe for every individual. Thus, both
- 35:43aggression and over-care for another
- 35:46person can be viewed as mechanisms for
- 35:49coping with anxiety. Mechanisms, of
- 35:53course, that are symptomatic, which, as
- 35:56we see, do not make a person's life
- 35:59more fulfilling. More happy, more rich,
- 36:03because on the contrary, they create a
- 36:06whole range of additional difficulties
- 36:09in life. And so, people will
- 36:13deliberately try to avoid an aggressive
- 36:16person who discharges their anxiety in
- 36:19this way, while they will simply run
- 36:22away from the over-caring one. And run
- 36:26away often, for example, from their
- 36:29partner, into the bottle, so to speak.
- 36:32That is, to retreat from the anxiety
- 36:35that arises when encountering someone
- 36:37who is limitless, and therefore, early
- 36:40on, experienced by the child as
- 36:42threatening. For, after all, a sense of
- 36:45security does not arise here. There is
- 36:48no territory of one's own, no intimate
- 36:50zone, in the end, no intimate space.
- 36:54And yes, to escape the anxiety that
- 36:58arises when encountering a persecuting,
- 37:02threatening other, people often turn to
- 37:07addictions: alcohol, drugs, medication,
- 37:11or gambling. So, the third one. After
- 37:17aggression and controlling others, a
- 37:20common way to reduce one's anxiety is,
- 37:23colleagues, through addiction. During
- 37:29my internship at a Brussels clinic for
- 37:33people with drug, alcohol, or
- 37:36medication addictions, I frequently
- 37:39observed how those with psychosis
- 37:42attempt to escape the anxiety of
- 37:45interacting with unbearable others by
- 37:49turning to substances. Addiction is one
- 37:55way to escape the anxiety that arises
- 37:58in relationships with that very
- 38:00unbearable, overwhelming, and therefore
- 38:03threatening other. Such an
- 38:07interpretation of the other emerges
- 38:10very early in these individuals, which
- 38:14is why it becomes so deeply ingrained.
- 38:19Here we can recall the situation with
- 38:22overprotective mothers. It is difficult
- 38:26for a mother to detach from the child
- 38:29with whom she was once a single whole.
- 38:33And a weak father—weak in terms of
- 38:36asserting his position, in terms of his
- 38:40internal backbone or, in Lacanian terms
- 38:43, his phallic capacity—prevents the
- 38:47child from separating from the mother.
- 38:53The next, which is the fourth way of
- 38:57coping with anxiety after, as we have
- 39:01seen, aggression, control, and
- 39:03addiction, is avoiding people who
- 39:07trigger anxiety or fleeing from
- 39:10triggering situations. In life, we can
- 39:14observe examples of such avoidant
- 39:17behavior. As Sigmund Freud said, flight
- 39:21is a natural reaction to a sense of
- 39:24threat, and therefore, to a state of
- 39:27anxiety. As a rule, a person with this
- 39:32way of coping with anxiety can and will
- 39:35flee from relationships, just as they
- 39:38will flee from their own psychotherapy
- 39:41or psychoanalysis. And extreme sports,
- 39:46which are even often promoted and
- 39:49advertised today. These are extreme ski
- 39:53descents down sheer cliffs, parachute
- 39:57jumps from helicopters, bungee jumping
- 40:00—leaping headfirst into an abyss with
- 40:03a cord tied to your legs—rafting down
- 40:07mountain rivers, or climbing
- 40:09skyscrapers. All of this provides an
- 40:16opportunity for a deep, albeit
- 40:18temporary, release of anxiety. And so,
- 40:24the person will strive again and again
- 40:27to bring their anxiety level to a
- 40:30maximum, only to then carry out an
- 40:33equally maximal, depleting, and
- 40:36therefore calming release of adrenaline
- 40:40. Approaching the end of our lecture
- 40:48today, we can say that entering
- 40:51relationships is something the subject
- 40:56counts on to close off their anxiety.
- 41:04Such people turn out to be quite clingy
- 41:07and intrusive, don't they? That is to
- 41:12say, while some people avoid or run
- 41:15away from what might trigger their
- 41:18anxiety—primarily relationships with
- 41:22others—other people, in an attempt to
- 41:25shut away or seal off their anxiety,
- 41:28instead seek out relationships where
- 41:32they place the responsibility for their
- 41:35anxiety onto their partner, expecting
- 41:39that, through their partner, they can
- 41:43stabilize their state once and for all.
- 41:48And, of course, such people, in their
- 41:51strive to cope with the anxiety
- 41:53flooding them, turn out to be quite
- 41:56clingy and even intrusive, I would even
- 41:59say, obsessively pursuing. And so, they
- 42:05will, no matter what, seek to hold on
- 42:08to their chosen one very tenaciously,
- 42:11as opposed to those who use a strategy
- 42:14of, let's say, running away and
- 42:17avoidance, and therefore regularly jump
- 42:20from one relationship to another. So,
- 42:24these clingy, sticky, or obsessively
- 42:28pursuing individuals, while trying to
- 42:31cope with their anxiety, can sometimes
- 42:35drive their partner to despair, because
- 42:39the partner is forced, so to speak, to
- 42:43do the work for both. Next time, dear
- 42:49colleagues, we will talk about anxiety
- 42:53in psychoanalysis. See you next time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Тревога и реальность. Вводная лекция проекта Lacanod. by LACANOD: психоанализ Жака Лакана, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,815 words across 782 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.