LA SITUACIÓN es PEOR de lo que PENSABAN - Caso Loan — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Two years have passed. Two years have
- 0:03passed since Loan went to play in an
- 0:05orange grove 500 meters from his
- 0:06grandmother's house and never returned.
- 0:10Two years of searches, dogs, divers in
- 0:12the marshes, millionaire rewards, and
- 0:14today, with the oral trial underway, we
- 0:17are still stuck on the only question
- 0:19that matters: where is Loan? And this
- 0:22is going to be the most disturbing part
- 0:23of all. The lead prosecutor, Carlos
- 0:26Schaefer, stood before the cameras the
- 0:29day the trial began and said a phrase
- 0:31that personally shocked me: "We know
- 0:33who took him, what we don't know is why
- 0:35." We know who, but we don't know why?
- 0:39Do you understand the gravity of all
- 0:41this? The State sits in a trial to say
- 0:43it has identified those responsible for
- 0:45the disappearance of a five-year-old
- 0:47boy, but there is a pact of silence so
- 0:49tight that after two years, no one has
- 0:51said where the boy is. We are going to
- 0:53do what television doesn't. We are
- 0:55going to separate what is confirmed
- 0:57from what is merely a hypothesis. We
- 1:00will also see who the 16 defendants in
- 1:01the case are, what they are charged
- 1:03with, and why this trial may be one of
- 1:05the most difficult in Argentine
- 1:07judicial history. I need you to pay
- 1:09attention because the legal aspect here
- 1:11is perhaps as compelling as the human
- 1:12one. Let's start with what we do know.
- 1:26What is in the file and what no one can
- 1:29dispute. On June 13, 2024, Saint
- 1:31Anthony's Day, there was a lunch at the
- 1:33home of Catalina Peña, Loan's
- 1:35grandmother, in the El Algarrobal area,
- 1:38on the outskirts of 9 de Julio,
- 1:40Corrientes. A common family lunch, even
- 1:43though it was a Thursday. There is a
- 1:46photo, a photo taken at 1:53 PM that
- 1:49shows the group at the house gate. This
- 1:52is the last visual record of the quiet
- 1:54day, because at 3:36 PM, as documented
- 1:56in the case, the notice was given that
- 1:58the boy was missing. After eating, a
- 2:01group went out to look for oranges in
- 2:03an orange grove located about 500 to
- 2:05600 meters from the house. In that
- 2:07group were several children and three
- 2:09adults. Antonio Benítez, the partner
- 2:11of Loan's aunt, Daniel Ramírez, alias
- 2:14Fierrito, and Mónica Millapi. At some
- 2:16point during that walk, Loan
- 2:17disappeared. The adults returned, the
- 2:20boy did not. And this is where it all
- 2:22begins, because the first thing that
- 2:23was activated was a massive search.
- 2:26Over 500 people in the first few days,
- 2:2810,000 hectares raked, Gendarmerie,
- 2:30Prefecture with divers, Federal Police,
- 2:33Army, drones, dogs, and horses. The
- 2:35Sofia Alert was even activated, and
- 2:37Interpol issued a notice. A deployment
- 2:39the country hadn't seen in years. And
- 2:41they didn't find anything, not even a
- 2:43sneaker. Well, let me pause there for a
- 2:45second because you have to be extra
- 2:47careful with that sneaker. And I will
- 2:49explain why shortly. From one missing
- 2:52boy to 17 defendants. Notice how this
- 2:54case evolved, because it's essential to
- 2:56understand the situation we are in
- 2:58today. First, the charge was child
- 3:00abandonment, a boy lost in the fields.
- 3:02Then it shifted to child abduction, and
- 3:05at one point, when suspicions of a
- 3:07network arose, it jumped to human
- 3:09trafficking. That was the turning point
- 3:11that brought everything to the federal
- 3:13courts on June 24, 2024. Now, and this
- 3:15is fundamental, the trafficking theory
- 3:17collapsed. The investigation formally
- 3:19discarded it. Federal Judge Cristina
- 3:22Pozzer Penzo, of the Goya Federal Court
- 3:24, maintained in the indictment that it
- 3:27could be ruled out with certainty that
- 3:29Loan had gotten lost or was the victim
- 3:31of a trafficking network, drug
- 3:32trafficking, or a sex crime. Pay
- 3:36attention to this because many people
- 3:37in the media keep talking as if it were
- 3:38a trafficking network, and the
- 3:39judiciary itself has already ruled it
- 3:41out. So, what was the case sent to
- 3:43trial with? With the charge of
- 3:45abduction and concealment of a minor,
- 3:47Article 146 of the Penal Code. The
- 3:49commitment to trial was signed in June
- 3:512025, and this is the most important
- 3:53part. Two cases ended up being merged
- 3:56into a single mega-trial. On one hand,
- 3:59the main case, seven defendants for the
- 4:01abduction and concealment of Loan, and
- 4:03on the other, a parallel case with 10
- 4:05more people, the so-called hotel gang,
- 4:07accused of diverting the investigation,
- 4:09staging a fake reconstruction, and
- 4:11pretending to belong to a foundation
- 4:13that the foundation itself later denied
- 4:15. 17 defendants in total, an
- 4:17unprecedented trial due to the number
- 4:20of accused. Let's look at the names now
- 4:28because the heart of the accusation
- 4:29lies here, and let me insist on one
- 4:31thing before we start: none of these
- 4:32people have been convicted; the
- 4:33presumption of innocence applies.
- 4:36Referring to them as the accused or the
- 4:38defendant is what is appropriate until
- 4:39a court says otherwise. Laudelina Peña
- 4:42, Loan's aunt, a central figure for the
- 4:44prosecution. The prosecution attributes
- 4:47three maneuvers to her: trying to keep
- 4:49her youngest son from telling what he
- 4:51saw, participating in the discovery of
- 4:52the loot that the prosecutor believes
- 4:54could have been planted, and
- 4:55establishing the version of an accident
- 4:57that was later ruled out. She is being
- 4:59held at the seventh penal unit in
- 5:01Resistencia, and her defense is being
- 5:03led by Mónica Chirvin. Antonio
- 5:04Benítez, Laudelina's partner who was
- 5:06in the Naranjal group. He is defended
- 5:09by public defender Enzo Di Tella.
- 5:11María Victoria Caillava, a former
- 5:13municipal official from 9 de Julio, and
- 5:15her husband Carlos Pérez, a retired
- 5:17Navy captain. This couple is key, and
- 5:19you will soon see why the forensic
- 5:21examinations place them at the center
- 5:22of the scene. From the bench, Pérez
- 5:25handed his defense attorney a note
- 5:27titled "scapegoats." He said, "I don't
- 5:30know anything." Daniel "Fierrito"
- 5:32Ramírez and Mónica Millapi, the other
- 5:34couple who went to the Naranjal with
- 5:35the kids. One particular detail:
- 5:37Millapi is participating in the trial
- 5:39remotely from Neuquén under house
- 5:41arrest with an electronic ankle monitor
- 5:42. And the seventh, the one who causes
- 5:45the most talk, Walter Maciel, the
- 5:46former commissioner of 9 de Julio, the
- 5:48one in charge of the initial search,
- 5:50the policeman who was supposed to find
- 5:52Loan. Remember Maciel's name because
- 5:55his judicial situation has a twist that
- 5:56, to me as a lawyer, is textbook. The
- 5:58evidence, what is there and what is
- 6:00being said. What is confirmed, and what
- 6:02the Federal Chamber has validated, is
- 6:04the odorology expert report. The dogs
- 6:06tracked Loan's scent in two vehicles
- 6:08belonging to the Pérez-Caillava couple
- 6:10: a red Ford Ka with 100%probability
- 6:13and a white Ford Ranger with 50%. And
- 6:15something that is not minor: in the
- 6:17cars of the other couple, Ramírez and
- 6:18Millapi, the odorology tests were
- 6:20negative. The Chamber rejected the
- 6:22defense's motions for annulment and
- 6:23deemed that evidence valid. That is
- 6:25there; that is incorporated evidence.
- 6:27Now, as for what is being said but not
- 6:28confirmed in the same way, it has
- 6:30transpired that the luminol test was
- 6:31positive in the Ranger, and that stains
- 6:33and hairs were allegedly found. Listen
- 6:35to me closely because, yes, it is true
- 6:37that luminol reacts with blood, but
- 6:40also with rust, mud, bleach, and many
- 6:42other substances. And pay attention to
- 6:45this, because it is the key. Saliva,
- 6:46male genetic profile, yes, but the
- 6:48comparison with Loan's DNA was negative
- 6:51, and subsequent samples were
- 6:52insufficient. In other words, it is not
- 6:54that we are still waiting to confirm if
- 6:56it was Loan's; it was already compared
- 6:57and it didn't match. So, whoever tells
- 6:59you they found Loan's blood in the
- 7:01truck is selling you lies. That is not
- 7:03proven, and it is, in fact, ruled out.
- 7:06And the shoe? The famous sneaker. It
- 7:09appeared, yes, but over 1,500 meters
- 7:11away from the house, when, as you know
- 7:13—and we said this a few seconds ago
- 7:15—the orange grove is about 500 to 600
- 7:18meters away. And prosecutor Tamara
- 7:20Porcel stated during the trial that it
- 7:22is very possible the shoe was planted,
- 7:23and she pointed to Laudelina as the
- 7:25main suspect in that maneuver. In other
- 7:27words, a piece of evidence that,
- 7:28according to the prosecution, was
- 7:29placed there to lead the search astray
- 7:31rather than help find Loan. Do you see
- 7:32the difference? Confirmed odorology,
- 7:34unconfirmed rumors of luminol and blood
- 7:36, planted shoe—the prosecution's
- 7:37hypothesis. It is not the same; it is
- 7:40never the same. The trial began on June
- 7:4716th of this year at the Gendarmerie's
- 7:49Squadron 48 in the city of Corrientes,
- 7:51before the Federal Oral Tribunal
- 7:53composed of presiding judge Fermín
- 7:55Ceroleni, Eduardo Belforte, and Simón
- 7:57Braco, with Enrique Jorge Bosch as the
- 7:59substitute judge. The numbers are huge.
- 8:02The prosecution announced that 171
- 8:04witnesses will testify. The file
- 8:06arrives with more than 90 volumes and
- 8:08some 900 pages of evidence. And it is
- 8:11estimated that the trial will last at
- 8:12least 6 months. So, unless there is a
- 8:14surprise, we won't have a verdict until
- 8:16the end of the year. At the time of
- 8:18recording this video, the trial is in
- 8:20its eighth hearing, and 13 of Loan's
- 8:21direct relatives have already testified
- 8:23. What happened in the first few
- 8:24hearings? Well, several powerful things
- 8:26. The seven main defendants refused to
- 8:29testify—all seven of them. Laudelina
- 8:31did not speak, even though her defense
- 8:33had said she would. Neither did Maciel.
- 8:35None of the seven under Article 146
- 8:37said a word. The only ones who spoke
- 8:40were two defendants from the hotel
- 8:41group, Alan Cañete and Valeria López,
- 8:42and they didn't provide anything that
- 8:44shifted the accusations. That silence,
- 8:47that pact, is exactly what the
- 8:49prosecution is denouncing. Prosecutor
- 8:51Porcel said it plainly. We hope that
- 8:54one of them breaks. Then came the
- 8:55testimonies that broke everyone's heart
- 8:57. The grandmother, Catalina, also
- 8:59testified, who at the time had caused
- 9:01quite a controversy with her statements
- 9:02. The parents, María Noguera and José
- 9:05Peña, gave their statements. María
- 9:06collapsed in the courtroom, confronted
- 9:08the defendants, and begged them to say
- 9:10where her son is. The tribunal asked
- 9:12her who she was referring to, and she
- 9:13confirmed Laudelina and Carlos Pérez
- 9:15with a phrase that was etched in memory
- 9:17. He said three men went to tell
- 9:18Laudelina that she had to insist it had
- 9:20been an accident. Notice how important
- 9:23that is, because it shows that the
- 9:24hit-and-run story, according to the
- 9:26grandmother herself, was allegedly
- 9:27staged, not spontaneous, but scripted.
- 9:30That is the current status of the trial
- 9:31. The prosecution is pushing for
- 9:33someone to break their silence,
- 9:35defenses are filing for nullity while
- 9:37upholding the accident theory, and a
- 9:39family is testifying in tears as the
- 9:41country watches. The court ordered a
- 9:43pause for the winter break from July
- 9:4514th to the 23rd, resuming on the 29th.
- 9:48The prosecution had requested to hold
- 9:49sessions during the recess to keep up
- 9:51the pace, but it was denied. There is a
- 9:53question here that everyone asks and
- 9:55almost no one answers correctly. How
- 9:56can someone be judged for a child's
- 9:58disappearance if the child has not been
- 10:00found? Can you convict without a body?
- 10:02The answer is yes, and the key lies in
- 10:04the legal provision chosen. Article 146
- 10:07of the Penal Code punishes with 5 to 15
- 10:09years in prison anyone who abducts a
- 10:11minor under 10 from their parents '
- 10:13custody, or who retains or conceals
- 10:16them. Pay attention to those two words,
- 10:17because they are extremely important.
- 10:19Retains or conceals. That is where
- 10:21everything lies. Article 146 is what we
- 10:24in law call a permanent crime. What
- 10:26does that mean? That the crime is not
- 10:28committed in an instant and then over.
- 10:29It continues to be committed over time,
- 10:31minute by minute, as long as the child
- 10:33remains hidden. It is like a photo that
- 10:35is actually a film that never stops.
- 10:37And this has two enormous legal
- 10:38consequences. First, there is no need
- 10:40to find the victim to bring charges.
- 10:42The concealment is the crime. As long
- 10:44as Loan is hidden, the crime is being
- 10:45committed. That is why this is a
- 10:48perfectly sustainable trial without a
- 10:49body. This is not a homicide trial
- 10:51where the body is central. This is a
- 10:53trial for abduction and concealment
- 10:55that are legally still ongoing today.
- 10:57Second, it does not expire as long as
- 10:59the child does not appear. Because the
- 11:01statute of limitations only starts
- 11:02running when the crime ceases to be
- 11:04committed, and it does not cease until
- 11:06Loan appears. It is a provision
- 11:08designed precisely for cases like this
- 11:09one. And here is the other subtle point
- 11:11: Maciel, the former commissioner.
- 11:13Initially, he was charged with cover-up
- 11:15, under Article 277. To cover up is to
- 11:18help after the fact, when the crime has
- 11:19already been committed and you come in
- 11:21to hide it. But the Federal Chamber of
- 11:23Corrientes changed his charges in April
- 11:252025. They dropped the cover-up and
- 11:28labeled him a necessary participant in
- 11:30Article 146. Why? With an impeccable
- 11:33argument. If he participated in the act
- 11:36itself, if his contribution was part of
- 11:37the plan, then he is not an accessory,
- 11:39he is a participant. And the difference
- 11:41between one role and the other is
- 11:43fundamental. The accessory comes after
- 11:45the fact. A necessary participant, on
- 11:47the other hand, is part of the crime.
- 11:49It is the person who provides a
- 11:50contribution to the crime without which
- 11:51it would not have been committed, if we
- 11:52are talking about a necessary
- 11:53participant. The necessary participant
- 11:55is the one on the inside, the one who
- 11:57contributes in such a way that without
- 11:58their participation the act would not
- 12:00have been completed. A police officer
- 12:02who, according to the accusation,
- 12:03instead of searching, set up a fake
- 12:05operation to buy time. He is not
- 12:07someone who covered it up; he is
- 12:08someone who, for the prosecution, was a
- 12:10participant. That reclassification
- 12:11changes his criminal future completely.
- 12:13Look at this case, a crime that does
- 12:15not expire, judged without a body, with
- 12:17a police officer accused not of
- 12:19covering up, but of participating. It
- 12:21is an open textbook on criminal law. I
- 12:23have to be direct here because we have
- 12:24been covering this case for a long time
- 12:26on the channel, even when other media
- 12:28stopped covering it, and I think it is
- 12:29an important opinion and that this case
- 12:31, in a way, compels me. There is a
- 12:33phrase from the prosecutor that I
- 12:35believe, in a way, right?,in my opinion
- 12:37, sums up a bit of all the anguish of
- 12:39this trial. We know who took him. And I
- 12:42want to pause there because in that
- 12:43phrase lies the deepest legal drama of
- 12:45all this. Knowing is not proving, and
- 12:47that distinction, which seems like a
- 12:49technicality, is actually the backbone
- 12:50of a rule of law. Luigi Ferrajoli, the
- 12:53great Italian theorist of penal
- 12:54garantismo, wrote that the criminal
- 12:56process is not a ritual to confirm what
- 12:58we already believe, it is a method to
- 13:00know. Procedural truth is not declared,
- 13:02it is proven, and it is proven with
- 13:04guarantees, with contradiction, with
- 13:06the possibility for the defense to
- 13:08refute every claim. For Ferrajoli, the
- 13:10presumption of innocence is not an
- 13:12annoying obstacle in the path of
- 13:14justice; it is the guarantee that we
- 13:15will not condemn anyone for what we
- 13:17intuit or for what we feel. Even though
- 13:20many do not like guarantees in criminal
- 13:22proceedings, it is something that
- 13:23limits the state's punitive power and
- 13:25helps us all if, eventually, by some
- 13:27injustice, we fall under the orbit of
- 13:28state power. This is without justifying
- 13:31criminals. Those who know me already
- 13:33know the content we produce and we are
- 13:35very far from that, but constitutional
- 13:37guarantees in a process are fundamental
- 13:38. And there is also an intense tension
- 13:41here within this trial, because
- 13:42everyone, absolutely everyone, feels
- 13:44that there are guilty parties. The
- 13:45scent evidence, the 2 years of silence,
- 13:47the shoes found 1500 meters away, the
- 13:49accident theory that the grandmother
- 13:51claims someone planted—everything
- 13:53ends up speaking. But all this outcry
- 13:55is not evidence. The moral certainty of
- 13:58an outraged society is not judicial
- 13:59certainty, and a serious court cannot
- 14:01convict just to appease the crowd,
- 14:02otherwise they give grounds to overturn
- 14:04a sentence. But beware, because here
- 14:07comes something important as well,
- 14:09where I believe that due process—at
- 14:10least serious, real due process, not
- 14:12the fake kind that wants to let
- 14:14criminals walk for no reason using
- 14:15absurd technicalities—is where this
- 14:17serious due process distinguishes
- 14:18itself from impunity. Ferrajoli never
- 14:21said that the benefit of the doubt
- 14:22applies to those who entrench
- 14:23themselves in silence to cover up a
- 14:24crime. Due process protects the
- 14:26innocent and does not shield a pact of
- 14:28silence. If the chain of evidence, the
- 14:31expert reports, the testimonies, and
- 14:33the contradictions align in a rational,
- 14:35unequivocal way, without gaps, then
- 14:36convicting without a body is not only
- 14:38possible, it is just. And that is why
- 14:42this article 146 is designed for that.
- 14:44They have, thank God, a very hard time
- 14:46escaping with impunity. So, what is the
- 14:49real risk behind this entire trial? I
- 14:51see it as twofold, like two paths that
- 14:54are equally complicated. One extreme is
- 14:56to convict wrongly, to convict someone
- 14:58because the country needs a culprit and
- 15:00to force the evidence, filling in with
- 15:01outrage what the evidence fails to
- 15:03prove. That would be an injustice in
- 15:05the form of justice. And the other
- 15:07extreme is to acquit because of silence
- 15:09, for the pact to win, for 2 years of
- 15:11systematic silence to end up rewarded
- 15:13with a misunderstood doubt, for the
- 15:15strategy of not saying where the boy is
- 15:17to be the very thing that guarantees
- 15:19their freedom. And let me also tell you
- 15:21something clearly. The silence of the
- 15:23accused, like it or not, is a right; it
- 15:25is a way to defend oneself. No one is
- 15:27obligated to testify against themselves
- 15:29, but it is one thing to stay silent
- 15:31because it is a guarantee and a right
- 15:32you have, and quite another to stay
- 15:34silent and not say where a 5-year-old
- 15:36boy is. How much of a lowlife can you
- 15:38be? The first is a guarantee, we all
- 15:40agree on that. The second, if the
- 15:43accused know, is a cruelty that no
- 15:45procedural guarantee can ever explain.
- 15:48Loan Danilo Peña would be 7 years old
- 15:50today. He went out to look for oranges,
- 15:53as any child might, and he didn't come
- 15:55back. And 2 years later, we still don't
- 15:57know where he is. It’s incredible, I
- 16:00mean, it’s an identifiable, traceable
- 16:02child, yet nobody knows where he is.
- 16:04Hopefully, this trial will bring back
- 16:05something small and cold. A truth.
- 16:08Names, responsibilities, a verdict, and
- 16:11perhaps, if someone breaks, the only
- 16:13thing that really matters: a place, a
- 16:16where. If you're interested, I can
- 16:18follow every hearing, every piece of
- 16:19evidence, every testimony, just as we
- 16:20did with the Fernando Báez Sosa trial.
- 16:22Obviously, as always, separating
- 16:24what’s confirmed from what’s pure
- 16:26theory, or absurd media hypotheses used
- 16:28to fill up shows. Because this case
- 16:30deserves for us to tell it properly,
- 16:31Loan deserves it. And if this video was
- 16:33useful to you, as always, thank you for
- 16:35supporting and sharing. Honestly, on
- 16:37this side, it’s greatly appreciated.
- 16:39If it helped, sharing it helps me a lot
- 16:41, and leaving your opinion or feedback
- 16:43—always with constructive criticism
- 16:45—is more than welcome. And if you
- 16:48aren't subscribed, subscribe to the
- 16:49channel because I'll surely be bringing
- 16:51more on this case. And if you want more
- 16:53frequent updates, let me know in the
- 16:55comments as well, as I always read them
- 16:57and we often chat there. Thanks for
- 17:00being here, thanks for the support, and
- 17:01I'll see you in the next video. I hope
- 17:03justice is served for Loan.
- 17:26Oh!
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of LA SITUACIÓN es PEOR de lo que PENSABAN - Caso Loan by LeanRiccio, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,332 words across 506 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.