La Pologne refuse l'euro ! Pourquoi nous le cache-t-on ? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05My fellow citizens, I would like to
- 0:08speak to you today—today, that is
- 0:10July 30, 2026—about a report from
- 0:12Warsaw that arrived the day before
- 0:14yesterday, stating that the Polish
- 0:16Prime Minister, Mr. Donald Tusk, has
- 0:18informed his country, his fellow
- 0:20citizens, and the entire world that
- 0:22Poland is once again postponing its
- 0:25adoption of the European currency, the
- 0:27euro. To ensure you truly understand
- 0:32the importance of this subject that no
- 0:34one is talking about, especially in
- 0:36light of the 2027 presidential election
- 0:38, the question of the euro is being
- 0:39completely ignored, even though it is
- 0:41one of the most fundamental issues
- 0:43regarding the future of our country.
- 0:46That is why I am going to talk to you
- 0:48about this. And so that you fully
- 0:50understand, I must take a brief look
- 0:52back to ensure that things are
- 0:54perfectly clear in your minds. Until
- 0:571992, there were 12 member states of
- 1:01the European Economic Community. In
- 1:05mid-December 1991, these 12 states met
- 1:11in Maastricht, a city located in the
- 1:13southeast of the Netherlands. There was
- 1:18a meeting of heads of state and
- 1:20government in Maastricht on December 9
- 1:23and 10, 1991, where they agreed on the
- 1:25final version of this Maastricht Treaty
- 1:28. The formal signing of the treaty by
- 1:32the plenipotentiaries—generally the
- 1:34head of state or government and the
- 1:36minister of foreign affairs—took
- 1:38place on February 7, 1992, also in
- 1:40Maastricht. This Maastricht Treaty
- 1:44notably planned to transform the
- 1:47European Economic Community into a
- 1:49European Union, that is to say, a
- 1:52federal Europe by another name; it
- 1:54planned to create a common foreign and
- 1:57security policy, which became the EU's
- 1:59foreign and defense policy; and it also
- 2:02planned for a monetary union that was
- 2:05to lead to the creation of a common
- 2:07currency to be called the Ecu, which,
- 2:10in the end, at the Germans 'request,
- 2:13was named the euro. The Maastricht
- 2:17Treaty having been formally signed by
- 2:20the governments on February 7, 1992, it
- 2:22was then necessary to proceed with
- 2:24ratifications, which could take place
- 2:27either by referendum or by a vote in
- 2:29parliament. The first country among the
- 2:3412 that prepared for ratification was
- 2:37Denmark. A referendum was held on June
- 2:422, 1992, and to the general surprise
- 2:45and the astonishment of many observers,
- 2:47the Danes rejected the Maastricht
- 2:50Treaty with a slim majority of 50.7%of
- 2:52the vote; however, they did reject it,
- 2:55which obviously caused general
- 2:57disturbance and consternation, because
- 3:00the first of the 12 that was supposed
- 3:03to ratify it started by not doing so.
- 3:09Nevertheless, the procedure continued,
- 3:10but the 12 agreed that the problem of
- 3:12Denmark would have to be resolved. We
- 3:16then arrived in France, where the
- 3:18referendum on the Maastricht Treaty
- 3:21took place on September 20, 1992, where
- 3:23our compatriots ratified it under
- 3:26incredible conditions of propaganda,
- 3:28since we know that the "Yes" supporters
- 3:31took up about 80%of the airtime on
- 3:33television. The French ratified it as
- 3:37well, but by a razor-thin margin of 51%
- 3:39of the vote; they ratified the
- 3:40Maastricht Treaty. All of the countries
- 3:45in what was the European Economic
- 3:47Community ratified it before December
- 3:4931, and it turned out that the problem
- 3:51of Denmark had to be resolved. And so,
- 3:55in the meantime, it had been decided
- 3:57that the Danes would vote again, since
- 3:58you know that the European construction
- 4:00, being a fundamentally tyrannical and
- 4:02totalitarian construction......does not
- 4:04allow for the possibility of
- 4:05disagreement. So if a people votes no,
- 4:09it is obviously because they made a
- 4:11mistake, were deceived, or were
- 4:12manipulated by demagogues, and so on.
- 4:15So they will have to be made to vote
- 4:17and vote again until they follow
- 4:19through, until they vote. Yes. So the
- 4:23Danes were asked to hold a new
- 4:25referendum, but the government in
- 4:28Copenhagen began to explain that it
- 4:30could not propose the exact same text
- 4:33to its compatriots again. The Danish
- 4:37government argued that if the Danish
- 4:39people had rejected the Maastricht
- 4:40Treaty, it was because the Danes were
- 4:42very attached to the Danish national
- 4:43currency, which is the Danish krone.
- 4:46And so an exception was made, which was
- 4:49defined by a summit of heads of state
- 4:52and government. It was decided, as an
- 4:55exception to this treaty, that Denmark
- 4:57would be exempted from adopting the
- 5:00euro. To be precise, there was another
- 5:04country that had, at the time of the
- 5:06negotiations, already obtained the same
- 5:08exemption: it was the United Kingdom,
- 5:09since I remind you that at the time the
- 5:11United Kingdom was part of the 12, and
- 5:13the United Kingdom had negotiated it
- 5:15before any ratification, having
- 5:17requested the exemption. Just as a side
- 5:20note, but it matters for what followed.
- 5:23The other member states of what was to
- 5:25become the European Union could have
- 5:27refused this exemption. France could
- 5:30very well have said to the United
- 5:32Kingdom and Denmark, "It is out of the
- 5:34question for you to have this exemption
- 5:35; otherwise, I am not going along with
- 5:37this scheme, I do not agree." But there
- 5:42are such powerful forces acting upon
- 5:43the governments of Western countries,
- 5:45and particularly upon the French
- 5:46government. At the time, we were with
- 5:49François Mitterrand, and do you know
- 5:52who his special advisor was? It was
- 5:55Jacques Attali who worked enormously
- 5:56behind the scenes. He explained it
- 5:59himself, so that France would adopt
- 6:01this currency.
- 6:02First of all, all those of whom I had
- 6:04the privilege to be a part held the pen
- 6:05to write the first versions of the
- 6:07Maastricht Treaty. We made sure to
- 6:09ensure that leaving would not be
- 6:11possible. We carefully forgot to write
- 6:15the article that allows for an exit.
- 6:22It's perhaps not very democratic,
- 6:24obviously, but it was a great guarantee
- 6:26to make things more difficult to force
- 6:27us to move forward.
- 6:30So we made François Mitterrand
- 6:32understand that he could not oppose
- 6:33giving these exemptions to the United
- 6:35Kingdom and Denmark because otherwise
- 6:37the matter would get stuck. The Danes,
- 6:41once they knew they were going to keep
- 6:44the Danish krone, well, they voted yes
- 6:46in the second referendum and thus
- 6:48entered the Maastricht Treaty. To
- 6:51summarize, therefore, on January 1,
- 6:541993, all the states of the European
- 6:59Economic Community had ratified the
- 7:01Maastricht Treaty, two of which, the
- 7:03United Kingdom and Denmark, had
- 7:05obtained an exemption that they would
- 7:07not enter the common currency. The euro
- 7:13therefore gradually came into force,
- 7:15not right away since there was a
- 7:17convergence policy that lasted quite a
- 7:20long time, since in fact the Maastricht
- 7:22Treaty entered into force on January 1,
- 7:251993, and it was July 1, 1997. It had
- 7:32been planned like that in the treaty
- 7:34and it was postponed by 2 years to July
- 7:361, 1999, which is to say, more than 6
- 7:41years after the entry into force of the
- 7:44Maastricht Treaty, the euro was created
- 7:46for interbank exchanges. And it was on
- 7:50January 1, 2002, that the euro appeared
- 7:53in the form of coins and banknotes for
- 7:55everyone. And it was from January 1,
- 7:592002, that all prices were transformed
- 8:02from francs to euros, deutschmarks to
- 8:04euros, from the Italian lira to euros,
- 8:07and so on. Following this period, we
- 8:13had in 1995 the accession of three new
- 8:16states that were not in the European
- 8:19Economic Communities and which brought
- 8:23the number of states from 12 to 15. The
- 8:28three new states being Austria, Sweden,
- 8:33and Finland. And when these three
- 8:38countries joined the European Union and
- 8:40entered the European Union in 1995,
- 8:42they were forced to ratify the existing
- 8:44treaties and therefore they were forced
- 8:47, these three countries—Finland,
- 8:49Austria, and Sweden—to accept the
- 8:51principle of the euro. Except that
- 8:55Sweden, while having ratified the
- 8:57Maastricht Treaty, asked and said that
- 9:00from a political point of view, it
- 9:03could not move to the adoption of the
- 9:05euro without asking for the formal
- 9:08authorization of the Swedish people.
- 9:12And so, they requested permission to
- 9:14wait a little while for public opinion
- 9:16to evolve, since the Swedish government
- 9:18, the government in Stockholm, knew
- 9:20that the Swedes were in the same state
- 9:22of mind as the Danish people; that is
- 9:25to say, they wanted to keep the Swedish
- 9:27krona just as the Danes had kept the
- 9:29Danish krone. Moreover, the Swedes, the
- 9:32Swedish government, had tried to obtain
- 9:34the same exemption as the Danes. But at
- 9:36the time, it had been decided that it
- 9:38was out of the question, that we had
- 9:40made one exemption, um, for, um, well
- 9:42two exemptions: one for the United
- 9:44Kingdom because the British are British
- 9:46, and the second for Denmark, that we
- 9:48could not multiply the exemptions. When
- 9:52the euro came into force for interbank
- 9:55exchanges on July 1st, 1999, well, all
- 10:01the states entered the euro, but not
- 10:03Sweden, since Sweden said: "We will do
- 10:06it a little later, let us hold a
- 10:08referendum when the time comes." When
- 10:12on January 1st, 2002, euros in the form
- 10:14of coins and banknotes arrived in the
- 10:16wallets of the average person and all
- 10:19prices changed, the same thing happened
- 10:21; that is to say that out of the 15
- 10:23states of the European Union at the
- 10:25time, there were 12 where this change
- 10:27occurred and there were three where it
- 10:29did not happen. The United Kingdom and
- 10:34Denmark kept their national currency,
- 10:36and then Sweden also kept its national
- 10:38currency, even though Sweden said, "
- 10:40Don't worry, don't worry, we'll join,
- 10:42we'll do it soon too." You have to
- 10:47understand that the Stockholm
- 10:49government thought that, from the
- 10:52moment the Swedes saw that in Finland,
- 10:55which is the country across the way if
- 10:57I dare say, that in Germany, which is
- 11:00the country at the south of the, of the
- 11:03beginning of the Baltic Sea, that the
- 11:06Swedes would say, "Well, we'll do like
- 11:09everyone else, we'll adopt the euro."
- 11:13The Swedes therefore organized a
- 11:16referendum some time later, on
- 11:18September 14, 2003, to ask the Swedish
- 11:21people: do you agree to adopt the euro?
- 11:25Everyone thought it would go very well.
- 11:28And then, wham—I refer you to a video
- 11:30I made on the subject—the Swedes
- 11:32voted no. So that Sweden finds itself
- 11:36—and is still in the same situation
- 11:38now, by the way—that is to say, it
- 11:40has been 23 years since these events.
- 11:44Sweden is still legally required to
- 11:46join the euro, but it is dealing with a
- 11:49resistant population. And, well, with
- 11:5457%of the vote against it, by the way.
- 11:57And the Swedes, like the Danes, are
- 11:59democratic peoples, much more
- 12:00democratic than in France. Because when
- 12:02the French vote "no," as in 2005, their
- 12:05vote is absolutely ignored. The Swedes
- 12:08said, "Well, we'll put it off until
- 12:10later." Then came the major
- 12:15enlargements, notably in 2004, when we
- 12:18went from 15 member states to 25 with
- 12:21the entry of 10 new states into the
- 12:24European Union, including Eastern
- 12:27European countries plus Cyprus and
- 12:30Malta. When I say Eastern countries, I
- 12:34mean Poland, the Baltic states, the
- 12:36Czech Republic, Hungary, and so on. So,
- 12:40we went to 25 states in 2004, and then
- 12:44three years later, in 2007, we added
- 12:47two more with the entry of Bulgaria and
- 12:51Romania, which made 27. And then in
- 12:572013, we went from 27 to 28 with the
- 13:00entry of Croatia. And then, uh, in 2020
- 13:04, we went from 28 to 27 with Brexit;
- 13:09the referendum on Brexit took place in
- 13:112016, but the United Kingdom formally
- 13:14left the European Union in 2020. So
- 13:18that today, we are 27 states. Of these
- 13:2527 states, all the new entrants found
- 13:28themselves in the same situation that I
- 13:31described earlier for Austria, Finland,
- 13:34and Sweden. That is to say, they joined
- 13:39, they adhered to the European Union,
- 13:42signed and ratified treaties, and were
- 13:44legally committed to adopting the
- 13:46European currency. The problem that
- 13:50arose for these Eastern countries was
- 13:52the same as the one that arose for
- 13:54Sweden. Meaning, these countries joined
- 13:58the European Union with the justified
- 14:01hope that they would get lots of money,
- 14:04lots of subsidies from so-called
- 14:06European funds, essentially paid for by
- 14:08Germany, France, the Netherlands, and
- 14:11the United Kingdom until the UK left.
- 14:15So that, that appealed to the
- 14:16populations. They were told, "We're
- 14:18going to get lots of money." But
- 14:19obviously, it’s rare for people to be
- 14:21angry when they are told they will get
- 14:22lots of money. However, the fact that
- 14:25they were going to change their
- 14:26currency had been somewhat hidden from
- 14:27the people. And then, when the obstacle
- 14:30appeared, suddenly the governments
- 14:32realized it was much more complicated
- 14:34than it seemed. So that, among those—
- 14:39we went from 15 to 27, excluding the
- 14:42United Kingdom now. And so, with these
- 14:4612 new states that arrived up until
- 14:482013, it turned out that within these
- 14:50states, there were some where the
- 14:52population accepted joining the euro
- 14:54without too much trouble. This was the
- 14:58case, for example, with Malta or
- 15:01Slovakia. Uh, and then there are others
- 15:05, on the other hand, where the
- 15:06population did not agree at all.
- 15:09Because these are peoples—some of
- 15:11these peoples are very jealous of their
- 15:13national independence, very jealous of
- 15:15keeping their currency, because they
- 15:16are peoples who have thought about it,
- 15:18intelligent peoples who know that it is
- 15:20not trivial to no longer have a
- 15:22national currency, that, inevitably, a
- 15:24currency is a power that you give away
- 15:26to someone, you don't know who, in the
- 15:27end. And so it happened among these new
- 15:31states that entered the European Union,
- 15:33it turned out that there were a certain
- 15:36number whose population refused to join
- 15:38the euro. Which states are these?
- 15:41States that have a long tradition of
- 15:43national independence, starting with
- 15:45Hungary. Hungary, which is a people, a
- 15:49Magyar people, descendants of, well,
- 15:51who are very particular, right, who
- 15:53have a specific language, Hungarian,
- 15:55which is called Magyar, which is linked
- 15:58to the Ural-Altaic languages, which is
- 16:00a very particular language and which
- 16:02showed, moreover, when it was attached
- 16:04to the Eastern countries under the
- 16:06tutelage of the USSR within the
- 16:08framework of the Warsaw Pact, well, it
- 16:10gave Moscow a hard time. Remember the
- 16:12attempted revolution in Budapest in
- 16:141956. The second country that is very
- 16:19jealous of its national independence is
- 16:21Czechia, the Czech Republic, since it
- 16:23is a country that has its own language,
- 16:25which is a bit embedded within the
- 16:27Germanic countries, but which has
- 16:29proven itself, notably because it is in
- 16:32Prague, with the Defenestration of
- 16:34Prague in 1618, which started the
- 16:36Thirty Years' War when envoys of the
- 16:38Holy Roman Empire were thrown out of
- 16:40the window of Hradčany Castle in
- 16:42Prague. And the Czechs similarly gave
- 16:47the USSR a hard time with the Prague
- 16:50Spring in 1968. And the third country
- 16:54particularly jealous of its sovereignty
- 16:57and its national independence is, well,
- 17:00Poland. Poland, which has a
- 17:01particularity. It is a country that has
- 17:03remained extremely Catholic. It is a
- 17:05bit of a Catholic isolate surrounded by
- 17:07Protestant countries. A country that
- 17:11also gave the Soviet bloc a hard time,
- 17:14and how, especially from the moment of
- 17:17the election of John Paul II, Cardinal
- 17:19Karol Wojtyła, to the throne of Saint
- 17:22Peter in 1978; and with Pope John Paul
- 17:25II, who gave, shortly thereafter, the
- 17:28impetus for the Solidarity union
- 17:30revolution, and, step by step, the
- 17:34beginning of the disintegration of the
- 17:36socialist bloc. I mention this because
- 17:41it is important to understand the
- 17:43history well. It happens that the three
- 17:47countries I just mentioned, Hungary,
- 17:49the Czech Republic, and Poland, are
- 17:52also three countries that have so far
- 17:54refused the euro. Hungary even wrote it
- 17:59into its Constitution, stating that the
- 18:01national currency of Hungary is the
- 18:03forint, meaning the Hungarian currency.
- 18:07The Czech Republic refused to adopt the
- 18:09euro, whereas Slovakia, which had been
- 18:12attached after the First World War—
- 18:14creating an artificial country called
- 18:16Czechoslovakia—did otherwise. The
- 18:19Slovak tradition, the Slovak people,
- 18:21are not the same as the Czechs. And the
- 18:23Slovaks easily accepted the euro, while
- 18:26the Czechs have totally refused it. The
- 18:30Czech Republic refused the euro, and
- 18:32finally Poland—the essential subject
- 18:35of this video—has put off adopting
- 18:38the euro because the adoption was not
- 18:41automatic. In fact, one had to meet a
- 18:44certain number of economic and
- 18:46financial criteria. This allowed the
- 18:49newly joined countries of the European
- 18:52Union to maintain a rather easy double
- 18:54discourse, saying, "Yes, yes, don't
- 18:57worry.""We will adopt the euro when the
- 19:00time comes, but you understand that for
- 19:03now, we can't because the macroeconomic
- 19:05data prevents us, but we will get there
- 19:07soon." Since these enlargements, we
- 19:11have found ourselves in a situation
- 19:13that still persists, where in fact,
- 19:15contrary to what many of our
- 19:17compatriots think, the euro is not the
- 19:19currency of the entire European Union.
- 19:23Today, as I speak, out of the 27 member
- 19:27states of the European Union, 21 have
- 19:31adopted the euro. There are six that
- 19:35have not adopted the euro. I have told
- 19:38you almost all of them. There is
- 19:41Denmark, there is Sweden. Denmark, as I
- 19:45told you, goes back to 1992, and Sweden
- 19:47with its 2003 referendum. There is the
- 19:51Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland,
- 19:53which have for now refused it and have
- 19:56postponed it to a later date. And
- 20:00finally, there is Romania, since
- 20:03Romania and Bulgaria were among the
- 20:06last to join, and Romania has been
- 20:08judged by European bodies and by the
- 20:11authorities in Bucharest. Furthermore,
- 20:15there is also a certain irredentism
- 20:17among the Romanian people. One must not
- 20:19confuse the Bulgarians and the
- 20:20Romanians. For example, Romanians have
- 20:24a Latin language. Romania, Romania, it
- 20:27actually comes from Rome. It is a
- 20:29country that was Dacia, which was
- 20:32conquered by Emperor Trajan in the 2nd
- 20:34century AD. Whereas the Bulgarians are
- 20:37a Slavized people who use the Cyrillic
- 20:39alphabet and are an Orthodox people.
- 20:42While the Romanians are Orthodox but
- 20:43have a language that is linked to the
- 20:45Romance languages. Moreover, if you
- 20:48hear people speaking Romanian or if you
- 20:50read a text in Romanian, you will find
- 20:52that there are a number of words that
- 20:53resemble French or Italian a bit. So
- 20:57those are the six countries that have
- 20:59refused for now, or have not yet
- 21:01accepted, or have dragged their feet on
- 21:03joining the euro. Now we come to Poland
- 21:06. Poland is the most important of these
- 21:09six states. It is a significant country
- 21:13in terms of geostrategy, size, surface
- 21:16area, population, but also in terms of
- 21:19the economy and also its historical,
- 21:21cultural, and civilizational tradition,
- 21:24with the Polish language, which is a
- 21:27language very much its own. So it is
- 21:30the most important country of all these
- 21:32nations that have not yet joined the
- 21:34euro. In 2008, the Polish prime
- 21:40minister was Donald Tusk. And when he
- 21:45came to power in 2007, European
- 21:47institutions said, "Well, you've been
- 21:50in since 2004, it's been three years,
- 21:53perhaps you should think about joining
- 21:56the euro." And in 2008, Donald Tusk,
- 22:01who was—and still is—very
- 22:04pro-European in the sense of submission
- 22:07to the American empire, Donald Tusk
- 22:10said in 2008, letting it be known, "Yes
- 22:13, yes, don't worry, Poland will join
- 22:16the euro before the end of 2012," thus
- 22:21keeping his promise and explaining to
- 22:24European leaders that Poland would
- 22:27honor its commitments. So, a consensual
- 22:31, pro-European approach, very different
- 22:34from the approach adopted by Viktor
- 22:36Orbán in Hungary, for example, who had
- 22:38it written into the Hungarian
- 22:40constitution that the forint is the
- 22:42Hungarian national currency, which is a
- 22:45problem with regard to European
- 22:47treaties. So some of you might ask, "
- 22:50But how is it that they can trample on
- 22:52and flout European treaties without any
- 22:54consequences?" The answer is that it's
- 22:58a very complicated subject, and as I
- 23:01said earlier, European institutions
- 23:03both want all states to join the euro,
- 23:06but under certain macroeconomic
- 23:08conditions. They don't want to
- 23:11completely destabilize the economies of
- 23:13the countries in question since, as
- 23:14they are poorer than the average of
- 23:16other countries, adopting the euro
- 23:17means forcing them to adopt a currency
- 23:19that is too expensive, whose exchange
- 23:21rates are too high on international
- 23:22markets, and are therefore. So that
- 23:25risks plunging those states into
- 23:28recession and poverty. So the European
- 23:31Commission and the European Central
- 23:33Bank are trying a sort of controlled
- 23:36drift, saying, "Well, you can wait a
- 23:38little bit," because they want them to
- 23:40join, but not too quickly. Which is
- 23:43exactly what the states in question are
- 23:44banking on. So, Donald Tusk, when
- 23:49Poland joined the European Union, it is
- 23:52estimated that its average income was
- 23:55about 40%of the income of the other
- 23:57countries, the rich countries of the
- 24:00European Union. In any case, its GDP
- 24:05was 40%, representing 40%of France's,
- 24:0840%in purchasing power parity. So
- 24:12Donald Tusk says Poland will join in
- 24:142012. Except that, well, a small
- 24:16problem arose that wasn't exactly in
- 24:19the plan. Starting in late 2008, and
- 24:23throughout 2009 and the following years
- 24:26, the crisis in Greece developed, the
- 24:29financial crisis in Greece with giant
- 24:32trade deficits and exponentially
- 24:35growing public debt. And, in fact, this
- 24:40financial crisis in Greece—and all
- 24:42economists who look at it closely
- 24:45understand—comes from the fact that
- 24:47Greece, which was much poorer, adopted
- 24:50the euro when it wasn't in a position
- 24:53to have a currency that was too
- 24:55expensive relative to the
- 24:56competitiveness of its economy.
- 25:01Incidentally, we later learned that it
- 25:04was Goldman Sachs International that
- 25:06had advised the Greek government and
- 25:09had advised the Athens government to
- 25:11falsify a certain number of its own
- 25:13economic data so that Goldman Sachs
- 25:16could tell the European Commission that
- 25:18Greece was ready to join the euro. In
- 25:24the meantime, the Troika meets with the
- 25:27International Monetary Fund, the
- 25:29European Commission, and the European
- 25:32Central Bank—the three financial
- 25:34institutions that arrive in Greece,
- 25:37realize that the situation is
- 25:39catastrophic, and impose a drastic
- 25:41remedy on Greece, from which it has
- 25:44still not recovered, to try to limit
- 25:47the debt explosion. I am not going to
- 25:50talk to you here about the crisis in
- 25:52Greece; that would be a bit off-topic.
- 25:55But what is on-topic is that these
- 25:57draconian measures which were imposed
- 26:00on Greece, and which are quite likely
- 26:03to be imposed on France in the next two
- 26:06years as we get closer and closer to
- 26:08the Greek scenario. These measures have
- 26:14sown consternation in a certain number
- 26:16of European countries. In Greece, in
- 26:22particular, a whole series of assets,
- 26:24companies, and public institutions of
- 26:27the national heritage have been sold
- 26:29off to banking consortiums. The
- 26:34national lottery, the railways, a whole
- 26:36series of ports on all the Greek
- 26:37islands. There was the equivalent of
- 26:41the Caisse des Dépôts et
- 26:42Consignations, the motorways; in short,
- 26:44it was a carnage where everything had
- 26:46to be sold to banks. And incidentally,
- 26:50these draconian measures which were
- 26:53imposed from 2009-2010 will last until
- 26:562018 and will continue even despite the
- 27:00rise to power of the far-left Syriza
- 27:03and Mr. Tsipras, who becomes the new
- 27:06Greek prime minister, the equivalent of
- 27:09Mélenchon. Mr. Tsipras surrounded
- 27:13himself with a man named Mr. Yanis
- 27:15Varoufakis, his finance minister. Who
- 27:18believes that we absolutely must leave
- 27:20the euro. Mrs. Merkel's Germany says
- 27:23Greece must leave the euro, it is no
- 27:25longer possible. Except that it is not
- 27:27provided for in the treaties that a
- 27:29country can leave the euro. The only
- 27:31way to leave the euro is to leave the
- 27:32European Union at the same time. There
- 27:34are no procedures that allow for
- 27:36leaving the euro. And then,
- 27:39fundamentally, whatever Mrs. Merkel
- 27:42might say, or whatever a certain number
- 27:44of economists might say, or whatever
- 27:46the Greek finance minister might say,
- 27:49well, the oligarchy that supports all
- 27:51of this, that steers all of this from
- 27:53afar, said it was out of the question
- 27:56for Greece to leave the euro, because
- 27:58there would be a domino effect and the
- 28:00entire European structure would risk
- 28:02falling apart. So, they forced the
- 28:06Greeks to stay in the euro. All the
- 28:09more so since Tsipras, the equivalent
- 28:12of Mélenchon, who held the same
- 28:13speeches as Mélenchon does today, had
- 28:16said that in any case he would remain
- 28:18in the European Union. So Tsipras was
- 28:21trapped himself by the fact that he had
- 28:22campaigned saying he would remain in
- 28:24the European Union but that he would
- 28:26change everything. What Mélenchon is
- 28:29doing, and Tsipras was backed into a
- 28:31corner, he had to stay in the European
- 28:33Union, he had to stay in the euro, and
- 28:35so he had no choice. It means that his
- 28:39finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, was
- 28:42forced to resign, was told to go look
- 28:44elsewhere, and that Tsipras, betraying
- 28:46180 degrees the promises he had made to
- 28:48his electorate, was forced to adopt
- 28:50even stricter measures and, notably, to
- 28:52participate in the privatization of a
- 28:54whole series of public establishments.
- 28:57It is, after all, unimaginable coming
- 29:00from a far-left government. That is
- 29:03exactly what would happen, by the way,
- 29:06if the French elected Mélenchon in
- 29:072027; we would witness the same
- 29:09situation. Exactly. No, despite what
- 29:12all those watching me who will say, "No
- 29:14, no, no, that's not true about
- 29:15Mélenchon," might think. No,
- 29:16Mélenchon will bow to the oligarchy,
- 29:19just as he bowed in 2017 to get Macron
- 29:21elected, and as he bowed in 2022 to get
- 29:24Macron elected. The result of all this
- 29:29is that these measures were terrible.
- 29:33Not only was Greek heritage sold off
- 29:35wholesale, but there were also measures
- 29:37like, for example, the sale of a
- 29:39certain number of Ionian islands. I
- 29:42believe it was to the Emir of Qatar.
- 29:44But also, they cut deep into pensions.
- 29:47What happened in Greece was the same
- 29:48little tune we hear today in France. We
- 29:50must cut pensions. I even see YouTubers
- 29:53who are 25 years old saying, "It's a
- 29:55scandal, we must cut pensions."
- 29:57Obviously, when you are 25, you don't
- 29:59say exactly the same thing as when you
- 30:00are 65 and you have contributed for 40
- 30:02years of your life to have a pension.
- 30:05Well, what happened in Greece is that
- 30:08pensions were halved, and that caused
- 30:11dreadful human tragedies, with a
- 30:13suicide rate among retirees that
- 30:16doubled. I would point out, by the way,
- 30:19because we will have to talk about it
- 30:21during this 2027 campaign, that for all
- 30:23those who want to say "no" to pensions,
- 30:25we will tell them about what happened
- 30:27in Greece and the explosion of suicides
- 30:29and the extreme poverty of a whole
- 30:31series of Greek retirees. Be that as it
- 30:36may, this information was scrutinized
- 30:39by the Polish people, and the Polish
- 30:42people, who already did not want to
- 30:44join the euro, wanted to join it even
- 30:47less. And Donald Tusk was forced to eat
- 30:52his words. He had promised that Poland
- 30:55would enter before the end of 2012.
- 30:56Well, he didn't do anything of the sort
- 30:57. He was forced to postpone his promise
- 31:01, which did not bring him luck. He had
- 31:04become very unpopular in the meantime,
- 31:06the wear and tear of power, and so he
- 31:08was defeated in the legislative
- 31:10elections. And we saw the rise to power
- 31:14of a coalition centered around the
- 31:16party called PiS—PiS meaning Law and
- 31:19Justice—which is classified as
- 31:22right-wing, or even far-right, a
- 31:24conservative party with its allies,
- 31:27which is a Eurosceptic party, and this
- 31:30coalition was in power from 2015 right
- 31:33up until 2023. During this 8-year
- 31:38period, there were three prime
- 31:39ministers, two women who didn't stay
- 31:41long, each for about a year. And then
- 31:45Prime Minister Morawiecki, who is the
- 31:47one who stayed the longest. Obviously,
- 31:50as it was the product of a right-wing
- 31:53and Euro-critical far-right coalition
- 31:55that didn't want the euro at any price,
- 31:58they did not introduce the euro. So the
- 32:02postponement decision that Donald Tusk
- 32:04had made in 2012, well, it wasn't
- 32:06called into question by the successive
- 32:08governments, which kept the Polish
- 32:11national currency, which is called the
- 32:13zloty. And then, as usual, it's the
- 32:18game of democracy. The wear and tear of
- 32:22power hit this coalition, and starting
- 32:25in 2023, pro-European forces returned
- 32:28to power in Warsaw, and Donald Tusk
- 32:31became prime minister again, just as he
- 32:34had been in 2007-2008. So, 15 years
- 32:39later, he became Polish Prime Minister
- 32:41again and found himself facing this
- 32:44equation, which authorities in Brussels
- 32:46and Frankfurt—since it's also the ECB
- 32:49—reminded him of on this occasion,
- 32:51asking Poland: "So, when are you
- 32:53joining the euro, since you're back in
- 32:55power?" And so, Tusk found himself
- 32:59confronted with this dilemma, between,
- 33:01on one hand, the European treaties that
- 33:04still obligate Poland to join the euro.
- 33:08And on the other hand, the continued
- 33:10refusal of the Polish people to join
- 33:12the euro. A Eurobarometer survey
- 33:15conducted a few months ago indicates
- 33:18that about 57%of Poles refuse tooth and
- 33:20nail to abandon the zloty. It's funny,
- 33:24by the way, because this 57%corresponds
- 33:26exactly to the 57%of Swedes who also
- 33:28refused the adoption of the euro and
- 33:31wanted to keep the Swedish currency,
- 33:33the Swedish krona. So Tusk said to
- 33:37himself, well, I have to do something
- 33:38because the European Union demands it,
- 33:40but 57%of the Polish people don't want
- 33:42it. He therefore found himself facing a
- 33:46dilemma. But in the meantime, time had
- 33:50passed. Meaning that this time, he had
- 33:55the benefit of hindsight to see,
- 33:57because in 2008, the euro had only just
- 33:59about come into force. Not exactly, it
- 34:02really came into effect starting
- 34:04January 1st, 1999, as I told you, in
- 34:05terms of interbank exchange, and
- 34:07especially in the public consciousness
- 34:09starting January 1st, 2002. So in 2007,
- 34:122008, 2009, one could still waffle a
- 34:16bit, whereas in 2023, 2025, well, it
- 34:19has now been more than 20 years. It
- 34:23will soon be 2026. Next year, in 2027,
- 34:26it will have been a quarter-century
- 34:28since the euro arrived in our wallets
- 34:30on January 1st, 2002. And so un-unlike
- 34:37his first term as prime minister,
- 34:39Donald Tusk was able to rationally
- 34:42judge which of the two he preferred.
- 34:46And what has he just decided? And this
- 34:47is the news from the day before
- 34:49yesterday. Well, he has just decided to
- 34:52once again postpone Poland's adoption
- 34:55of the euro. And what's important is
- 34:58why? Officially, he tried to muddy the
- 35:01waters. He made some rather vague
- 35:05remarks, to put it mildly, saying that
- 35:08of course Poland would adopt the euro,
- 35:11but that first, the standard of living
- 35:14of the Poles had to catch up to
- 35:16Germany's. Well, that the GDP in
- 35:20purchasing power parity should approach
- 35:22German income levels. And secondly,
- 35:26that the Polish population accepts the
- 35:30principle. Which is still not the case.
- 35:35He actually used the same argument as
- 35:37the Swedes, since I recall that the
- 35:39Swedes voted no in 2003, and there
- 35:41still hasn't been a new referendum on
- 35:43it because all the polls in Sweden show
- 35:45that the Swedish people are still 57%
- 35:47dead set against adopting the euro. And
- 35:52so Tusk examined the situation. He
- 35:57therefore said he was postponing it and
- 35:59brought up these two points. One, the
- 36:01Polish people must agree, and two, that
- 36:02our standard of living must more or
- 36:04less catch up to Germany's. But in
- 36:06reality, those aren't the real reasons.
- 36:08Those are diplomatic reasons. The real
- 36:11reasons. They were spelled out by the
- 36:13Polish finance minister of the Tusk
- 36:16government—a pro-European government,
- 36:18I should point out—who said, his name
- 36:21is Andrzej Domaniski, he made the
- 36:23following statement; you should look at
- 36:25it in blazing letters if you like. That
- 36:28is really the essential part. Look at
- 36:29what he said. The Polish finance
- 36:33minister just declared: "Our economy is
- 36:35doing clearly better than most of those
- 36:37that have adopted the euro." We have
- 36:42more and more data, economic research,
- 36:45and arguments for keeping the Polish
- 36:48zloty. Poland is now among the leading
- 36:53economies, and I see no compelling
- 36:56reason to abandon our own currency.
- 37:02Well, this is something that should be
- 37:06a subject of debate in France for the
- 37:08presidential election. We have one of
- 37:11the very large countries in the
- 37:12European Union whose finance minister,
- 37:14despite being pro-European, says we
- 37:15shouldn't adopt the euro because it
- 37:16would harm the currency. Why does he
- 37:18say that, by the way? Because in
- 37:212008-2009, there was a crisis in Poland
- 37:23, and this crisis was resolved by a
- 37:26currency depreciation of the zloty,
- 37:28which lost about 15%of its value
- 37:30against other currencies, especially
- 37:33against the euro of neighboring
- 37:35countries, since Poland has the zloty
- 37:38but Germany has the euro, as does
- 37:40France, and so on. And so, during the
- 37:442008-2009 financial crisis, this
- 37:47depreciation of the zloty suddenly
- 37:50boosted Polish exports. It became 15%
- 37:53cheaper, and therefore limited the
- 37:56damage, so to speak, and limited the
- 37:58recession that should have followed.
- 38:02And what the Polish government
- 38:03understood well at the time by
- 38:05examining this period is that if it had
- 38:07been in the euro, it could not have had
- 38:09this currency depreciation. And so the
- 38:13financial crisis it was undergoing,
- 38:15unable to be cushioned by the
- 38:20depreciation of the national currency,
- 38:23would have resulted in extremely
- 38:25painful measures from a social
- 38:27standpoint, with a drop in the standard
- 38:30of living and an increase in
- 38:31unemployment. Let us add to this that
- 38:38it is not only the finance minister,
- 38:40Mr. Domanski; there is also the
- 38:42governor of the Polish Central Bank who
- 38:44said that it was absolutely necessary
- 38:47to keep the Polish zloty, because he
- 38:49explained to his fellow citizens that
- 38:51it was much better to have one's
- 38:53national currency to manage interest
- 38:56rates. You just have to intervene in
- 39:00the financial markets to try to set
- 39:02targets in the financial markets for
- 39:03interest rates to have interest rates
- 39:05that best correspond to the needs of
- 39:07the Polish economy. Whereas the
- 39:12governor of the Bank of Poland
- 39:14explained that, if we were in the euro,
- 39:16if Poland were in the euro, the
- 39:18interest rates would be those resulting
- 39:21from the management of the European
- 39:23Central Bank located in Frankfurt, and
- 39:25the exchange rate, particularly of the
- 39:27euro, might not correspond at all to
- 39:30the needs of the Polish economy. The
- 39:35governor of the Central Bank of Poland
- 39:38was appointed by a government that was
- 39:40precisely Euro-critical, but his
- 39:42successor will be appointed by the
- 39:44Polish president, who himself happens
- 39:46to be Euro-critical, given that we are
- 39:49in a period of cohabitation in Warsaw.
- 39:54And so, the next governor of the Polish
- 39:56Central Bank, who will take office, I
- 39:58believe in 2028 for a 6-year term, is
- 40:00fiercely opposed to the adoption of the
- 40:02euro. Which means, if you have followed
- 40:08me, that in reality, what Donald Tusk
- 40:10has just announced, and if we examine a
- 40:12little bit the people around him, the
- 40:14configuration of personalities and
- 40:16forces, it means that Poland will not
- 40:18adopt the euro any sooner than 2035. We
- 40:26will have to wait until the end of 2034
- 40:27at the earliest for Poland to enter the
- 40:29euro. Even though I remind you that
- 40:32Poland joined the European Union in
- 40:342004. This means here is a country that
- 40:38for 30 years will still not have
- 40:41entered the euro. I point this out
- 40:44because it is not told to the French.
- 40:46The French are not told that there are,
- 40:48in fact, six states in the European
- 40:50Union that are not in the euro. And for
- 40:53some of them today, as I have said, it
- 40:55has now been 23 years that Sweden
- 40:57should have been in the euro and it has
- 40:59refused. And here, I tell you that for
- 41:02Poland, it has been 22 years that it
- 41:04should have been in the euro. It is
- 41:06still not there. And it announces to us
- 41:08that it still won't be there in 2044,
- 41:10that is to say, 30 years later. Now,
- 41:14this must be compared with another
- 41:17phenomenon, which is that Poland
- 41:21benefits from European funds. It is the
- 41:25number one beneficiary country of
- 41:26European funds. Poland receives,
- 41:28roughly—well, like all member
- 41:30countries of the European Union, you
- 41:32know me, I have explained this to you
- 41:33very often—Poland gives money to the
- 41:35European Commission, and the European
- 41:37Commission gives money back to Poland,
- 41:39like all states. But it turns out that
- 41:42there are states that are net
- 41:44contributors: one, Germany; two, France
- 41:45; three, the Netherlands since the
- 41:47departure of the United Kingdom. These
- 41:50net contributor countries give much
- 41:51more to the European Commission than
- 41:53they receive from it. Which is not the
- 41:56case for Poland, since Poland gives
- 41:58much less to the European Commission
- 42:00than what it receives. Because the
- 42:02surpluses go to the European Commission
- 42:04, since we contribute much more than we
- 42:06receive, but the European Commission
- 42:08takes a portion for its own operating
- 42:10costs and those of the entire structure
- 42:12of European institutions, the Court of
- 42:14Justice, the Parliaments, and so on,
- 42:16but it also handles equalization. And
- 42:20so the European Commission pays much
- 42:22more money to Eastern countries, which
- 42:23are poorer, to raise their standard of
- 42:25living. Poland receives approximately
- 42:3115 billion euros in net benefits every
- 42:33year, which is considerable. It’s
- 42:37roughly the net deficit of what France
- 42:40loses. We don't know the figures
- 42:43precisely; they vary, it's hidden, top
- 42:44secret, or whatever you want to call it
- 42:46. We know it's between 12 and 15
- 42:48billion euros. We don't know exactly,
- 42:50but it's probably around that. In the
- 42:52meantime, Poland has been a net
- 42:54beneficiary of 15 billion euros for
- 42:56years. Now, these 15 billion euros
- 43:00represent a significant windfall coming
- 43:02from abroad that helps boost the Polish
- 43:05economy. If I can use a comparison, a
- 43:09metaphor I've used before which is a
- 43:10bit harsh but captures the point quite
- 43:12well. Imagine in a hospital room, there
- 43:17are two patients, and one is having
- 43:20blood drawn to be given to the other
- 43:22who is sicker. The one who is sicker
- 43:27receives blood like that, more and more
- 43:29. What will happen? Well, what will
- 43:32happen is that the one receiving the
- 43:34fresh blood will gradually regain their
- 43:36strength and recover. But the one
- 43:40having their blood drawn will
- 43:41eventually struggle, as you know you
- 43:43can't take more than a liter of blood
- 43:44from a human. That is the absolute
- 43:47maximum. It is often more like 200 or
- 43:50300 ml taken during a blood transfusion
- 43:53. So, it's much the same thing. Meaning
- 43:57you have states like Germany and France
- 44:00from which resources are taken—taken
- 44:02and taken—that don't come back and
- 44:05aren't invested in the French economy.
- 44:08It contributes to the recession in
- 44:10countries that are net contributors.
- 44:14Which is something I’ve been
- 44:15explaining for years...But in the
- 44:17national debate, in the public debate,
- 44:19we never talk about it. But this is one
- 44:22of the fundamental causes of the
- 44:24long-term impoverishment of the French
- 44:26people: when we send billions of euros
- 44:29abroad each year that are never
- 44:31reinvested here, it is much worse than
- 44:33giving money, for example, for welfare
- 44:36benefits, right? I see the
- 44:39hyper-liberals, ultra-liberals, and so
- 44:42on, like Mr. Lissard, Ms. Knafo, and
- 44:44others, who tell us we must cut public
- 44:46spending. They simply forget—and I
- 44:49agree that there is too much public
- 44:50spending—that one must select which
- 44:51spending to cut. Because when it comes
- 44:54to welfare, yes, there are some abuses,
- 44:57that is no doubt true, but the people
- 44:59who receive these benefits spend the
- 45:01bulk of what they receive on expenses
- 45:03that keep the national economy running.
- 45:06Sure, they might buy imported products,
- 45:09but for things like services or when
- 45:11they buy food and so on, it still keeps
- 45:13the national economy going. Whereas
- 45:17when we give 15 billion euros to the
- 45:19European Union, and those 15 billion
- 45:20euros go to irrigate Poland, Hungary,
- 45:22etc., knowing that Poland receives 15
- 45:24billion euros, it doesn't just come
- 45:25from France; it comes from Germany and
- 45:27so on. When we give this money to the
- 45:30European Union, it is not reinvested in
- 45:32France. This is, moreover, why Jacques
- 45:36Chirac had protested so vehemently when
- 45:40, barely after joining the European
- 45:44Union, Poland decided in 2005 or 2006
- 45:48to buy American F-15 or F-35 planes
- 45:52rather than French ones. And so, Chirac
- 45:57had said that it really wasn't very
- 45:59fair, while Poland was starting to
- 46:01receive considerable funds from the
- 46:03European Union—that is to say, from
- 46:05German taxpayers and French taxpayers
- 46:07—for Poland to start buying only
- 46:09American products, I might point out in
- 46:11passing. So this effect is a recessive
- 46:15one for France and very positive for
- 46:17Poland. That's not all, either. Because
- 46:19with this money, Poland doesn't just
- 46:21buy American planes. It improves its
- 46:24infrastructure. Considerable work has
- 46:27been done in Poland: improvements to
- 46:29roads, bridges, railways, airports, and
- 46:31a whole series of infrastructures that
- 46:34have made the country very attractive
- 46:36and have, incidentally, encouraged
- 46:38companies, especially French companies,
- 46:41to go and invest in Poland, to the
- 46:43detriment, moreover, of investment in
- 46:45France. And furthermore, the posted
- 46:49workers directive meant that France,
- 46:51among others, had to let Polish workers
- 46:54come into France. God knows how much we
- 46:57talked about that famous Polish worker
- 47:00coming to work in France at a price
- 47:02that pressured the wages of French
- 47:05laborers. So, all of this functions for
- 47:08the considerable benefit of Poland and
- 47:10to the detriment of France in every
- 47:12single area. I remind you: Poland
- 47:16benefits from 15 billion euros,
- 47:18modernizes its infrastructure, benefits
- 47:21from investments coming from wealthy
- 47:24Western countries, and incidentally—
- 47:26though it is not at all incidental, it
- 47:29is fundamental—refuses to adopt the
- 47:32euro to be able to manage, to have a
- 47:34competitive currency to manage its
- 47:37foreign trade positively. What is the
- 47:41end result of all this? It is that when
- 47:45Poland joined the European Union in
- 47:472004, the Polish standard of living was
- 47:5040%of the French standard of living,
- 47:53and today in 2026, meaning 22 years
- 47:56later, it is 80%of the French standard
- 47:59of living. And, according to the
- 48:03International Monetary Fund, the
- 48:04standard of living of the Poles will
- 48:06have surpassed that of the French by
- 48:082034, which, by the way—and I am
- 48:13addressing the die-hard Europhiles here
- 48:16who say it is normal for France to pay
- 48:18more because everyone needs to be at
- 48:20the same level. I am putting them to
- 48:23the test because there will come a
- 48:25moment when France will be poorer than
- 48:26the country it is helping. And so, the
- 48:30Europhiles will have to explain to us
- 48:32how that will work in budget
- 48:34negotiations with the European Union,
- 48:36saying: "It will soon be time for
- 48:38Poland to be a net contributor and for
- 48:41us to once again be beneficiaries of
- 48:43aid, as we were in the early 60s, when
- 48:46France received more money than it gave
- 48:48." That was money coming from Germany
- 48:51for the benefit of farmers. If that
- 48:55were the case, it is not impossible
- 48:58that, knowing the mindset of the Poles
- 49:00—who are a people always very jealous
- 49:03of their sovereignty, their
- 49:05independence, but who also do their
- 49:07accounts very well and are very clever
- 49:10since they do what the English call "
- 49:13cherry-picking," which means taking
- 49:15only the best—that is to say, the
- 49:18Poles, like other Eastern countries,
- 49:21use everything that can serve them. So
- 49:24they accept subsidies coming from
- 49:26Europe, but they refuse the currency.
- 49:30They accept the investments, they
- 49:32accept the aspect of posted workers,
- 49:34but they always want to be net
- 49:37beneficiaries. And what if a day came
- 49:39when they were suddenly told: well, now
- 49:41you're going to be a net contributor.
- 49:44We can count on the Poles, like the
- 49:46Hungarians, like the Romanians, and so
- 49:48on and so forth, to say: we're not
- 49:50going along with this, we're leaving
- 49:52the European Union. That was absolutely
- 49:55written in the cards, because you have
- 49:57to be as naive as the French to believe
- 50:00in the grand ideals of the European
- 50:02project, right? Yet Charles de Gaulle
- 50:04had clearly warned us that in
- 50:06international affairs, there are no
- 50:08friends, there are no friends between
- 50:10states. There are only interests. So, I
- 50:13would now like to conclude, conclude
- 50:16this video by elevating the debate a
- 50:19little and taking all the countries of
- 50:24Europe, of the European continent.
- 50:26Because, in fact, on this European
- 50:28continent, you have three types of
- 50:30states. You have a small group of
- 50:34states that have refused to enter the
- 50:37European Union and adopt the euro.
- 50:42There are three of them in Western
- 50:44Europe. The three countries are
- 50:47Switzerland, Norway, and Iceland. That
- 50:51is the first group. To this, we can
- 50:56arguably add, for a few years now, the
- 50:59United Kingdom, which has just joined
- 51:02this group. There is the United Kingdom
- 51:04, which spent several years in the
- 51:06Economic Community that became the
- 51:07European Union starting in 1992. So it
- 51:09is a special case. There is a second
- 51:12group of states that entered the
- 51:15European Union but did not enter the
- 51:18euro. As I told you, these are the six
- 51:21states I already mentioned, which can
- 51:23actually be subdivided into two
- 51:25subgroups. The first group is Sweden,
- 51:29Denmark, and the Czech Republic, which
- 51:31are in the European Union but have not
- 51:34adopted the euro, and which can be
- 51:36considered countries that were already
- 51:39quite wealthy and developed. And then
- 51:44there is a second subgroup among those
- 51:47that did not accept the euro while
- 51:49entering the European Union: Hungary,
- 51:51Poland, and Romania. And then, there is
- 51:56a third group: it is the set of
- 51:59countries that entered both the
- 52:01European Union and the euro, and there
- 52:03are 21 of them, including Germany,
- 52:05France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, the
- 52:07Netherlands, Belgium, Austria, and
- 52:10Greece. There we go. So, I was
- 52:15interested in examining the situation
- 52:18of these countries now with the benefit
- 52:21of hindsight, since, as I said, it has
- 52:23been over a quarter of a century—a
- 52:26quarter of a century that the euro has
- 52:28been operating in interbank exchanges
- 52:31since '99, that's 27 years—and, since
- 52:342002, it is the currency that replaced
- 52:36the national currencies. It will be 25
- 52:40years, a quarter of a century, next
- 52:42year. We therefore have the benefit of
- 52:44hindsight. Just as we have hindsight on
- 52:47the benefits or drawbacks of the
- 52:50European Union, since in 2027, it will
- 52:52have been 70 years that we've been
- 52:55building Europe since the 1957 Treaty
- 52:58of Rome, and since 1992, it will have
- 53:02been 35 years that we have been in the
- 53:04European Union, in a federal Europe. So
- 53:07, we can at some point take stock, and
- 53:10that is what I will dedicate a part of
- 53:12the presidential election, the campaign
- 53:15for the 2027 presidential election to,
- 53:17because it is an assessment that all
- 53:19the other political parties will refuse
- 53:22to make, including of course the
- 53:24National Rally, which increasingly is a
- 53:26copy-paste of Macronism, and including
- 53:29Mr. Mélenchon as well, who refuses to
- 53:32leave the European Union and the euro.
- 53:37So what is this assessment? Let's keep
- 53:39it simple. When you examine the
- 53:43macroeconomic data, and you can use
- 53:46ChatGPT, you can use Claude, all the
- 53:48AIs will be able to help you make these
- 53:51comparisons. What will you discover?
- 53:56You will discover that the first group,
- 53:59the group of three countries that
- 54:01refused to join the European Union and
- 54:04the euro—that is, Switzerland, Norway
- 54:07, and Iceland—are the countries that
- 54:09are doing by far the best in all areas.
- 54:13These are countries that, in terms of
- 54:19public debt, growth, unemployment, and
- 54:24inflation, break all the records; they
- 54:29are the best positioned. And I would
- 54:31add, as I have had the opportunity to
- 54:34say before, that if you go check the
- 54:36United Nations website, specifically
- 54:38the United Nations Development
- 54:40Programme, you will find that these are
- 54:42the three countries at the very top of
- 54:44all the countries in the world in the
- 54:46Human Development Index, the HDI, which
- 54:49is a multi-factor index, a composite
- 54:51index that takes into account life
- 54:53expectancy at birth, I believe the
- 54:55participation of women in public life
- 54:57or whatever, and the level of GDP per
- 55:00capita. Well, there are several
- 55:02criteria for judging the general
- 55:04development index. These three
- 55:07countries are therefore the ones that
- 55:09are succeeding the best. And I might
- 55:12point out that these three countries
- 55:13are small countries. Switzerland has a
- 55:17little less than 10 million inhabitants
- 55:19, 9.5 million inhabitants. Norway has
- 55:23about 4 to 5 million inhabitants and
- 55:26Iceland has 330,000 inhabitants. And
- 55:30these are the countries in the world
- 55:32where people are doing the best, where
- 55:35people are the happiest, and in Europe,
- 55:37those whose macroeconomic data are all
- 55:39the best. That still poses a bit of a
- 55:43problem. It should pose an enormous
- 55:45problem, even for all our ideologues
- 55:47who, 68 years since the Treaty of Rome,
- 55:52keep telling us that France is far too
- 55:54small not to be in the European Union,
- 55:56who tell us that if we are in the
- 55:58European Union, we will be stronger
- 56:00than the others, and who tell us that
- 56:02thanks to the euro, we will be able to
- 56:04stand up to the others. Proof has been
- 56:07provided of the exact opposite. And I
- 56:11feel compelled to say this because, of
- 56:13course, I know the arguments like "Yes,
- 56:15but Switzerland is only banks." But
- 56:17that is not true at all. It is not true
- 56:19at all. The entire financial industry
- 56:21in Switzerland accounts for about 9%of
- 56:23GDP, and banks strictly speaking
- 56:25account for 5%of Swiss GDP. Switzerland
- 56:28is first and foremost a great power in
- 56:30services, and not just financial
- 56:32services, but also in industrial
- 56:34products. You have very large
- 56:35industrial companies in Switzerland.
- 56:36Does Nestlé mean anything to you? The
- 56:39world's great food giant is Swiss. You
- 56:43have major Swiss industries in optics,
- 56:46in electronics, and in watchmaking.
- 56:50There are people who say, "Yes, Norway,
- 56:52Norway," I've seen some say "It's a
- 56:54Nordic Scandinavian emirate.""Do they
- 56:56have gas?" Yes, it is true that they
- 56:58have gas, but they have managed it very
- 56:59well. They created a fund for future
- 57:01generations, which just proves that
- 57:03they are an industrious and intelligent
- 57:05people. And then there's Iceland;
- 57:08Iceland has nothing, they have
- 57:09fisheries and so on, they have no
- 57:11particular gas resources, they don't
- 57:13have an extraordinary industry, but in
- 57:15any case, they are doing very well.
- 57:17Good for them. They manage their
- 57:21economy in a collective optimum for a
- 57:23country of 330,000 inhabitants. Next,
- 57:29the group of countries that are members
- 57:31of the European Union but have not
- 57:34adopted the euro. I told you there are
- 57:37two subgroups. On one side, there are
- 57:39the most developed, that is to say
- 57:42Sweden, Denmark, and the Czech Republic
- 57:45. When you examine their macroeconomic
- 57:48results, well, they are very good.
- 57:51These are countries that generally have
- 57:53very low debt. Denmark, for example,
- 57:56has had budget surpluses for several
- 57:59years. It has reduced Denmark's public
- 58:02debt to something like between 25 and
- 58:0528%of GDP, compared to the 118%we have
- 58:08in France, and also what they have in
- 58:13Spain, what they have in Italy, what
- 58:15they have in Belgium, and so on. The
- 58:21same goes for the Czech Republic, the
- 58:24same for Sweden. This data is also
- 58:27flattering in terms of inflation and is
- 58:30also very good in terms of unemployment
- 58:33. Perhaps a bit less good for Sweden,
- 58:36which has a 7%unemployment rate, but
- 58:38unemployment in Denmark or the Czech
- 58:41Republic is around 4%; so it is very,
- 58:43very low. Inflation is contained, and
- 58:47so we can say that, globally, from a
- 58:48macroeconomic point of view, these are
- 58:50countries that are doing relatively
- 58:52well. There is a third—well, there is
- 58:57a second subgroup within this group of
- 58:59European Union countries that have not
- 59:01adopted the euro. As I told you earlier
- 59:04, it is Poland, it is Romania, it is
- 59:08Bulgaria, because Bulgaria has been in
- 59:11the euro only for a few months. So the
- 59:15data I am talking about is data that
- 59:17has been compared—you can see it on
- 59:19the screen—and that was compared
- 59:21using the Claude artificial
- 59:23intelligence engine. So, since Bulgaria
- 59:27has only been in the euro for a few
- 59:29months and the study was conducted over
- 59:32the last five years, we have attached
- 59:34Bulgaria to the group of EU countries
- 59:37outside the euro. So there is Poland,
- 59:41Hungary, Romania, and Bulgaria. In
- 59:45these four countries, what do we
- 59:47observe? We observe that they have
- 59:51phenomenal economic results in terms of
- 59:53growth. On the other hand, poor results
- 59:57in terms of public debt and inflation.
- 1:00:00And very good results in terms of
- 1:00:01unemployment. Obviously, when you have
- 1:00:03very strong growth, generally, you
- 1:00:04don't have much unemployment. Why this
- 1:00:07strong growth in Hungary and Poland,
- 1:00:09for example? Well, as I told you
- 1:00:12earlier, it's because first and
- 1:00:14foremost, you have a colossal injection
- 1:00:16of funds from European countries. Which
- 1:00:19allows you to have, afterwards, what we
- 1:00:21call the Keynesian multiplier. Because
- 1:00:23when you have, when you build
- 1:00:25infrastructure, you provide work for
- 1:00:27public works companies, electricians,
- 1:00:30roofers, architects, architectural
- 1:00:32firms, structural work, and so on and
- 1:00:34so forth, which will have
- 1:00:35subcontractors, which will have
- 1:00:37employees who will invest, or rather
- 1:00:40spend their money in the Polish economy
- 1:00:42. And with the multiplier phenomenon,
- 1:00:45that will push the country's entire
- 1:00:47economy upward. So, these countries
- 1:00:50benefit fully from the European Union's
- 1:00:53manna, but on the other hand, they have
- 1:00:56trouble keeping their public debt in
- 1:00:59check. And so, you have very
- 1:01:02significant rates of debt and budget
- 1:01:05deficit, for example in Poland, where
- 1:01:07the deficit has been around more than 7
- 1:01:09%in recent years, in the last year,
- 1:01:12which is higher than the French rate,
- 1:01:14as the French rate for 2026 is
- 1:01:16projected to be around a 6%deficit. But
- 1:01:20let's clarify that public debt in
- 1:01:23Poland, Hungary, Bulgaria, and Romania
- 1:01:26is still at a much lower level than
- 1:01:29that of the French Republic. So there
- 1:01:32is still some room for maneuver. The
- 1:01:34unemployment rate, correlated with the
- 1:01:36growth rate, is very low. And there you
- 1:01:39go. And then the last ones are the 21
- 1:01:44member countries of the European Union
- 1:01:47and the euro, including France, Italy,
- 1:01:50Spain, Portugal, Greece, Belgium,
- 1:01:52Germany, Austria, and so on. Well, look
- 1:01:56at the statistics that Claude gives you
- 1:01:58. Look at the conclusions that
- 1:02:01artificial intelligence provides you.
- 1:02:04Now, we are a quarter-century after the
- 1:02:07adoption of the euro. We are nearly a
- 1:02:11third of a century since the creation
- 1:02:14of the European Union and we are 68
- 1:02:17years after the start of European
- 1:02:19integration. What do we see? We see
- 1:02:23that these 21 countries are actually
- 1:02:25doing poorly. They have weak growth,
- 1:02:29significantly weaker than in other
- 1:02:31countries. They have high, and
- 1:02:35sometimes very high, debt, high public
- 1:02:38debt, sometimes very high. They have
- 1:02:42inflation that isn't very good and they
- 1:02:44have unemployment. Well, it depends on
- 1:02:46which ones. But there are some, notably
- 1:02:48France, that have all the handicaps
- 1:02:50combined. France has both a very high
- 1:02:52unemployment rate, not to mention that
- 1:02:55we disguise a number of statistics. It
- 1:02:57has completely disproportionate,
- 1:02:59completely excessive debt. It has
- 1:03:03inflation that isn't that great after
- 1:03:06all. Even though normally, when you
- 1:03:09have unemployment and a low growth rate
- 1:03:10, you don't have much inflation, and
- 1:03:12then we have a very low growth rate, we
- 1:03:14are almost at stagnation, if not
- 1:03:15recession. There, I'll end this video
- 1:03:19here. I hope this will give you some
- 1:03:22food for thought. What I mean by this
- 1:03:25fundamental video is that the French
- 1:03:27have been lied to and that no one wants
- 1:03:29to draw the real balance sheet of the
- 1:03:31euro. It is time to assess the euro a
- 1:03:35quarter-century after its introduction
- 1:03:38and a third of a century after the
- 1:03:40arrival of the European Union. It is
- 1:03:43time to start taking stock, and this
- 1:03:44balance sheet is not good. It's even
- 1:03:47bad. It is even very bad, especially
- 1:03:51when compared to countries that refused
- 1:03:54to adopt the European Union and the
- 1:03:57euro, and yet are much smaller in size,
- 1:04:00area, economy, and population than
- 1:04:03France. Overall, I hope I have
- 1:04:07demonstrated that since the dawn of
- 1:04:10time, a national currency means a
- 1:04:12people and a state, a sovereignty. I
- 1:04:15have had the opportunity to explain
- 1:04:16this. This concept can be found in the
- 1:04:19First Book of Maccabees in the Old
- 1:04:21Testament. I hope I have shown you that
- 1:04:25this is once again confirmed. A
- 1:04:27national currency is a currency at the
- 1:04:30service of a nation, of a people.
- 1:04:34Whereas the euro, which is a
- 1:04:36supranational currency, is not a
- 1:04:39currency at the service of the people;
- 1:04:41it is a currency at the service of an
- 1:04:44ideology and the caste of the oligarchy
- 1:04:47that drives this ideology for its own
- 1:04:49profit. Thank you for your attention.
- 1:04:55Long live the exit from this hell that
- 1:04:58is the European Union and the euro,
- 1:05:01long live national sovereignty and
- 1:05:03independence, and long live a restored
- 1:05:06France.
- 1:05:10Thank you for supporting the PR to
- 1:05:12continue the work of emancipation
- 1:05:13undertaken 18 years ago by François.
- 1:05:16Your donations are essential. Your
- 1:05:18mobilization is, too. Mr.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of La Pologne refuse l'euro ! Pourquoi nous le cache-t-on ? by Union Populaire Républicaine, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,527 words across 1,472 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.