YouTube2Text

La France fonce vers la FAILLITE... (voici les chiffres) — Transcript

by Elliot Hewitt - YoungTraderWealth · 5,736 words · 844 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00So, imagine a friend asks you to lend
  2. 0:02them € 1,000. You look at their
  3. 0:06financial situation and notice they
  4. 0:09already owe € 119 for every € 100
  5. 0:12they earn this year. The question is,
  6. 0:16do you lend it to them? I think if
  7. 0:17you're sensible, you'd say no. And yet,
  8. 0:19what I just explained, that ratio, is
  9. 0:22France's current situation. What you
  10. 0:24see right behind me here is France's
  11. 0:26debt. And yet, every day, thousands of
  12. 0:29institutions around the world agree to
  13. 0:32lend billions of euros per week to
  14. 0:35France. So the real question is, who is
  15. 0:38still lending to France? And more
  16. 0:41importantly, at what price are they
  17. 0:42lending? And especially, until when
  18. 0:45will this price remain, let's say,
  19. 0:47sustainable for France? And that is
  20. 0:49exactly what we are going to break down
  21. 0:51in this video today. I'm warning you
  22. 0:53right now, we're going to stay in the
  23. 0:55world of finance, which I'll try to
  24. 0:57simplify for you—rates, bonds,
  25. 0:59markets. I promise that by the end of
  26. 1:02this video, you will understand all
  27. 1:03these terms and how the economy works.
  28. 1:06There will be no politics in this video
  29. 1:08, no Macron, no pension talk. My job is
  30. 1:11to follow the money. So, that is
  31. 1:13exactly what we are going to do in this
  32. 1:14video. So, if you don't know me, I'm
  33. 1:16Elliot, and I am not French. But I
  34. 1:19speak French, as you can see, and I am
  35. 1:21a trader with over 12 years of
  36. 1:22experience. I have worked in
  37. 1:23institutional finance. Today, I manage
  38. 1:25a fund with several million dollars
  39. 1:27from abroad. My job is to analyze the
  40. 1:31economic situations of different
  41. 1:33countries and economies to determine
  42. 1:35probabilities and make decisions. I
  43. 1:39want to clarify before starting this
  44. 1:41video that I have no political bias
  45. 1:42regarding France. My profession as a
  46. 1:45trader is not based on my opinions, but
  47. 1:47rather on what the markets are
  48. 1:49literally telling us. Okay? My job is
  49. 1:52to follow the money and understand the
  50. 1:54world we live in. And that is exactly
  51. 1:57what I want to share with you through
  52. 1:58this video by simplifying all these
  53. 2:00concepts. Make sure to stay until the
  54. 2:02end of the video because I will show
  55. 2:03you all the charts and figures that you
  56. 2:04will be able to understand. So, anyway,
  57. 2:07a state, like any other economic actor
  58. 2:10or person, if you will, has revenue—
  59. 2:13money it earns—and expenses, just
  60. 2:15like you and me. State revenue comes
  61. 2:18from income taxes, other taxes, and
  62. 2:20social contributions. OK? Expenses, on
  63. 2:24the other hand, include civil servant
  64. 2:26salaries, pensions, healthcare, public
  65. 2:29services, various investments, and—
  66. 2:31something we don't always consider—
  67. 2:33interest on debt. Already existing debt
  68. 2:37. Exactly like taking out a bank loan
  69. 2:39and having to pay back the credit. Well
  70. 2:41, that credit is also part of your
  71. 2:43expenses. It's exactly the same thing
  72. 2:44for the State. So, we have revenue and
  73. 2:47we have expenses. If we look at a
  74. 2:50simple example: if € 100 goes into
  75. 2:52the State coffers but € 110 goes out,
  76. 2:55the State enters what we call a deficit
  77. 2:57, which in this case would be € 10.
  78. 3:00OK? And these € 10 of deficit must be
  79. 3:03financed. That is when the State
  80. 3:06borrows, and that is ultimately how the
  81. 3:09debt grows. The more deficits there are
  82. 3:11each year, the more money is missing,
  83. 3:13the more money must be borrowed, and so
  84. 3:16France's debt increases. The debt, if
  85. 3:18you like, is the accumulated stock of
  86. 3:21everything that had to be borrowed to
  87. 3:23cover past deficits, plus unfortunately
  88. 3:26, what has not yet been repaid. OK? Now
  89. 3:29, it is important to understand the
  90. 3:31difference between the deficit and the
  91. 3:34debt. OK? The deficit, as I explained,
  92. 3:37is the shortfall for the year. OK?
  93. 3:39Between income and expenses. The debt
  94. 3:42is the accumulation of all these
  95. 3:44shortfalls over decades. That is what
  96. 3:46gives us the debt. So here, we are on
  97. 3:49my screen, and what you see right here
  98. 3:52is the graph of French debt. Here, from
  99. 3:551995 to today. You can see that the
  100. 4:00current debt stands at 3.6 trillion, or
  101. 4:033,600 billion euros of debt. OK, that
  102. 4:07is the French debt. And you can see the
  103. 4:09trend. You can see that this trend
  104. 4:12exploded around 2008, and likewise, we
  105. 4:14had another explosion starting in 2019.
  106. 4:172020. OK, so that is the debt. Now, we
  107. 4:21can also look at the economic data for
  108. 4:23the deficit I was telling you about.
  109. 4:25For that, we will look for FRGBP,
  110. 4:28France Government Budget. Right? And so
  111. 4:31right here, I have drawn a line at zero
  112. 4:33, which would represent either a
  113. 4:35surplus or a deficit. And as you can
  114. 4:39see here, France is currently at a
  115. 4:42deficit of 5.1%of GDP in 2025. In other
  116. 4:47words, the French public authorities
  117. 4:49have therefore spent significantly more
  118. 4:51than they have earned over the year.
  119. 4:54All right? Once again, the last time
  120. 4:58they earned more than they spent was in
  121. 5:001974, once we were above that zero line
  122. 5:03. All right? And then, before that, it
  123. 5:07was in 1966, and everything before 1966
  124. 5:10, France was in a budget surplus. But
  125. 5:14otherwise, since then, it's deficits,
  126. 5:15and more importantly, you can see the
  127. 5:17trend is getting worse. And so, as I
  128. 5:21was explaining, this 5.1%GDP deficit
  129. 5:23must be financed. How do we finance it?
  130. 5:27By issuing debt. Which therefore causes
  131. 5:29the debt to increase. So, if we compare
  132. 5:31this to FRGD, France Government Debt,
  133. 5:34we'll set a new price scale. I'll
  134. 5:36change the color so you can see it
  135. 5:38clearly. All right. We can see here,
  136. 5:40then, the debt we were looking at just
  137. 5:42before. All right. We have the figure
  138. 5:43here, which is 3.5 trillion. And
  139. 5:46remember, I showed you before that the
  140. 5:49debt had skyrocketed during that period
  141. 5:51after 2008, and it also skyrocketed
  142. 5:54during the Covid period. And as I
  143. 5:58explained to you, all of this comes
  144. 6:00from the deficit, and we can see that
  145. 6:01the deficit was extremely negative when
  146. 6:03? In 2020, all right? The deficit went
  147. 6:09from 2.4%of GDP to nearly 9%of GDP. So,
  148. 6:13more borrowing was necessary, and
  149. 6:15therefore the debt increased during
  150. 6:17that period. And it's exactly the same
  151. 6:19thing here after the subprime crisis,
  152. 6:21so in 2008, the deficit exploded,
  153. 6:24meaning it dropped. All right? It went
  154. 6:26from 3.5%to about 7.5%of GDP. And so,
  155. 6:32once again, if we compare it with
  156. 6:35French debt, we notice that during
  157. 6:37these periods of deficit, the debt
  158. 6:39tends to skyrocket during these times
  159. 6:42of crisis. So now that I've shown you
  160. 6:46how this works visually, you need to
  161. 6:48understand how France actually issues
  162. 6:51debt. All right? It does so by issuing
  163. 6:54what are called bonds. A bond is super
  164. 6:57simple to understand. Let's say you
  165. 6:59lend € 1,000 to the French state.
  166. 7:02Today, the state commits to repaying
  167. 7:04you those € 1,000 on a specific date,
  168. 7:06and in the meantime, it commits to
  169. 7:09paying you compensation that was
  170. 7:11negotiated beforehand. So, now that you
  171. 7:14understand that, let's talk about what
  172. 7:16it actually costs to borrow. This
  173. 7:18interest rate, if you will, is roughly
  174. 7:20the price of money. How much does money
  175. 7:22cost? Meaning, if you borrow money, how
  176. 7:25much does it cost you? And if you lend
  177. 7:27money—so you’re the one with money
  178. 7:28and you lend it to someone—how much
  179. 7:30do you earn? Right? That is ultimately
  180. 7:32the true value of money. And like any
  181. 7:34price, it always depends on supply and
  182. 7:36demand, but also, in quotes, on risk.
  183. 7:39It all boils down to the same thing. If
  184. 7:41something is very risky, there’s
  185. 7:42going to be less demand for it. In
  186. 7:43short, the law of supply and demand. To
  187. 7:45illustrate this even better, let’s
  188. 7:46take the example of two friends. You
  189. 7:48have your buddy Mathieu. This friend
  190. 7:50Mathieu has a permanent contract and an
  191. 7:52apartment that’s already fully paid
  192. 7:54for by his parents. Uh, the guy already
  193. 7:57has savings set aside, so that’s
  194. 7:59Mathieu. And next to him, you have
  195. 8:01Théo. Théo, uh, he’s unemployed.
  196. 8:03Théo has a car loan on his back, uh,
  197. 8:06and also a student loan. And now,
  198. 8:09let’s ask ourselves: if they both
  199. 8:11come to you and ask for € 500.
  200. 8:14Let’s say you’re okay with lending
  201. 8:16it, but who are you going to ask for
  202. 8:18extra interest to lend the money?
  203. 8:20Obviously, Théo. Okay. Why? Because
  204. 8:24the risk that he won't be able to pay
  205. 8:26you back is much higher than with
  206. 8:28Mathieu. And it’s ultimately the
  207. 8:31exact same logic in the bond markets,
  208. 8:33which, as I explained to you, is the
  209. 8:35market where France issues new debt.
  210. 8:38Okay? And so, the more a borrower is
  211. 8:42perceived as risky, the higher the
  212. 8:44return they must offer to find lenders.
  213. 8:48Right? Once again, if your friend
  214. 8:50Mathieu says to you, "Hey, lend me 100
  215. 8:52bucks and I’ll pay you back 105," you
  216. 8:54say, "OK." Your friend Théo, who you
  217. 8:56aren’t sure will pay back the 100
  218. 8:57bucks, you say to him, "If I lend you
  219. 8:59the 100 bucks, I’ll lend them to you,
  220. 9:00but you pay me back 120." Okay? That
  221. 9:01way, it’s worth the trouble, if you
  222. 9:03want. Okay? And this difference in
  223. 9:05compensation between two borrowers,
  224. 9:07Mathieu and Théo, or two states,
  225. 9:09France and Germany, is what we call a "
  226. 9:12spread" in finance. Okay? So, between
  227. 9:15Mathieu and Théo, you lend to Mathieu
  228. 9:17at 10%interest. You lend to Théo at 50
  229. 9:20%interest. The spread from Mathieu to
  230. 9:23Théo is 40%. Okay? Now, if we stop
  231. 9:27comparing Mathieu and Théo and stick
  232. 9:29to countries, the cleanest comparison,
  233. 9:32let’s say, for France is France
  234. 9:34versus Germany. Why? because France and
  235. 9:38Germany have the same currency, the
  236. 9:39same central bank, which is the
  237. 9:40European Central Bank, and the same
  238. 9:42economic zone. So, let's say the
  239. 9:45difference in yield between a French
  240. 9:47bond and a German bond, where you lend
  241. 9:50your money for 10 years, allows us to
  242. 9:53isolate quite cleanly what the market
  243. 9:56demands extra to lend to France rather
  244. 9:58than to Germany. Once again, let's look
  245. 10:01at the charts. So, what I am showing
  246. 10:03you right here is the French 10-year
  247. 10:05yield. Okay? So, that is the French
  248. 10:08bond yield. Okay? So, if you lend your
  249. 10:12money to France for 10 years, France
  250. 10:14today, at the time I'm making this
  251. 10:16video, pays you 4.85%per year to lend
  252. 10:22that money. Okay? But you can see that
  253. 10:27in early 2022, France was only offering
  254. 10:310.4%. So, as I said, that is the French
  255. 10:35bond rate. Now, what we can do is
  256. 10:38compare it with Germany's. This way, we
  257. 10:41can take a look. Okay? Here we have the
  258. 10:43German rate. There is a correlation,
  259. 10:46meaning they tend to move together. But
  260. 10:48what can we see currently? Lending your
  261. 10:50money for 10 years to Germany, Germany
  262. 10:54pays you 3.47%per year. OK? Whereas
  263. 10:57France pays 4.8%per year. And as I was
  264. 11:01explaining, this is like our difference
  265. 11:03between Mathieu and Thomas. And what
  266. 11:04did I tell you? The difference between
  267. 11:07the French rate and the German rate is
  268. 11:09what we call the spread. And this
  269. 11:11spread, specifically, we can calculate
  270. 11:14it in a very simple way, which would be
  271. 11:16FRY, so the French yield minus the
  272. 11:18German rate. There. And that gives us,
  273. 11:21let's remove this. That gives us the
  274. 11:25spread between lending to France versus
  275. 11:27lending to Germany. And so this spread
  276. 11:31between France and Germany, as you can
  277. 11:33see, is currently hovering around 1.4%.
  278. 11:37In finance, we call that 140 basis
  279. 11:39points. In English, 140 BPS, basis
  280. 11:42points. 140 basis points if you hear
  281. 11:44that in the news. But it shows that the
  282. 11:48market demands 1.4%more per year to
  283. 11:51lend to France. Okay? And you can see
  284. 11:55that this spread has recently exploded
  285. 11:58to levels we haven't seen since the
  286. 12:00European debt crisis in 2011. Okay? And
  287. 12:04this is exactly where it gets
  288. 12:05interesting. If we go back to look at
  289. 12:08French debt, okay, and its evolution,
  290. 12:10we can see that there is really an
  291. 12:12acceleration since 2020. Okay? We were
  292. 12:16seeing an increase in debt; anyway, as
  293. 12:17you've understood, as long as the
  294. 12:19deficit is negative, the debt keeps
  295. 12:20growing. But since 2020, since Covid,
  296. 12:24that’s really when the French debt
  297. 12:28exploded, going from 2.4 trillion in
  298. 12:312019 to 3.6 trillion at the time I’m
  299. 12:34making this video. Simply talking about
  300. 12:38a country's debt and even trying to
  301. 12:40compare the debts of different
  302. 12:41countries honestly makes no sense, as
  303. 12:43each country is more or less large,
  304. 12:45more or less strong, and more or less
  305. 12:47wealthy. So, what we do in finance is
  306. 12:49compare this debt to the country's GDP,
  307. 12:52that is, the gross domestic product of
  308. 12:54that country. And a quick reminder: GDP
  309. 12:57is not, let's say, the government's
  310. 12:59revenue. GDP is the value created by
  311. 13:03the entire French economy over one year
  312. 13:06. Right? So we relate the debt to the
  313. 13:10GDP to get an order of magnitude for
  314. 13:12the size of the debt relative to the
  315. 13:15economy that will have to support it.
  316. 13:18Hence the first example I mentioned:
  317. 13:21would you lend to a friend who has €
  318. 13:23119 in debt for every € 100 of value
  319. 13:26they create each year? Right? And uh,
  320. 13:29France's debt-to-GDP ratio is currently
  321. 13:32at 119%. So that means there is € 119
  322. 13:36of accumulated public debt for every
  323. 13:39€ 100 of value produced annually in
  324. 13:42the economy. And here again, we can go
  325. 13:44look up this data. France government
  326. 13:47debt to GDP, right? And we can see this
  327. 13:50ratio actually increasing. But there,
  328. 13:52as I was telling you, what’s
  329. 13:53interesting is that now we can start
  330. 13:55comparing with other countries, in fact
  331. 13:57. So let's look at it compared to
  332. 13:59Germany, okay? Let's also look at it
  333. 14:01compared to Italy. Let's also look at
  334. 14:05it compared to Spain, and let's also
  335. 14:07look at it compared to Greece. Greece,
  336. 14:10which as you know, had, uh, some small
  337. 14:12problems in the 2000s. Uh, let's set
  338. 14:15this to regular. There. And that way,
  339. 14:18we’ll be able to compare everything.
  340. 14:20So at the very bottom, the lowest ratio
  341. 14:23, the number one top performer, is
  342. 14:25Germany, okay? Which finds itself with
  343. 14:30a debt-to-GDP ratio at 63.5%. Very good
  344. 14:34. Number two is Spain. For Spain, we
  345. 14:37are at 100 in terms of its debt. At
  346. 14:40number three, we have France, which is
  347. 14:43at 115%, and that was the latest data
  348. 14:45from December 2025, but as I said,
  349. 14:47today we are at 119%, so we would be at
  350. 14:49that level. Just above, we have the
  351. 14:53famous Italy. Italy, which historically
  352. 14:56has been in a, uh, bad economic
  353. 14:57situation. Right. Spain too, for that
  354. 15:00matter, but as you can see, France has
  355. 15:01overtaken them. Right? Overtaken them
  356. 15:04since 2022. And then in top spot, I
  357. 15:07remind you they are, quote-unquote,
  358. 15:08coming out of a sovereign crisis,
  359. 15:10that's Greece. Greece, which finds
  360. 15:13itself with a debt-to-GDP ratio of 146%
  361. 15:15at the time I'm making this video. So
  362. 15:18overall, France is less indebted than
  363. 15:21Italy and Greece as a percentage of GDP
  364. 15:23. But here is what the market is really
  365. 15:26looking at. What the market is looking
  366. 15:29at isn't so much the nominal figure,
  367. 15:31let's say, it's more the direction.
  368. 15:33Right? And over one year, Greece has
  369. 15:36significantly lowered its debt-to-GDP
  370. 15:39ratio. Right. You can see that since
  371. 15:432020, for 6 years now, Greece's
  372. 15:45debt-to-GDP ratio has been falling
  373. 15:46drastically. That's good.
  374. 15:49Congratulations. Italy is the same.
  375. 15:51Congratulations. Spain is the same. The
  376. 15:54direction is downward, that's very good
  377. 15:56. Even Germany, let's say, has remained
  378. 15:58more or less flat, or even bearish
  379. 16:00since 2020. The only one that has
  380. 16:02increased is France. And that's where
  381. 16:04the problem is. The direction matters
  382. 16:07just as much as, let's say, the
  383. 16:09snapshot of the current level. OK? And
  384. 16:12that is exactly why we can't ultimately
  385. 16:15summarize the situation with a simple
  386. 16:17ranking of debt levels. Right?
  387. 16:20Certainly, there's that, but there are
  388. 16:23also the recent trends. And France's
  389. 16:25recent trends are not very pretty. So,
  390. 16:28the question arises. Who are these
  391. 16:31people who are still lending hundreds
  392. 16:33of billions of euros to France? To
  393. 16:36answer this question, here is data from
  394. 16:39Agence France Trésor for the first
  395. 16:41quarter of 2026. We have about 57%of
  396. 16:44this debt held by non-resident
  397. 16:46investors in France. Potentially my
  398. 16:50case, or else big institutions or other
  399. 16:51governments. OK? And about 20%held by
  400. 16:54other French holders. We're going to
  401. 16:58have about 10%held by French credit
  402. 17:01institutions, about another 10%held by
  403. 17:03French insurers, and by the way, as I
  404. 17:06told you, non-residents. That doesn't
  405. 17:09just mean foreign governments that have
  406. 17:11decided, let's say politically, to
  407. 17:13support France and therefore lend to
  408. 17:15France. It generally includes more like
  409. 17:19asset managers, pension funds, banks,
  410. 17:21insurers, even central banks, and
  411. 17:23public institutions. Anyway, in short,
  412. 17:27these are generally institutional
  413. 17:29investors looking to park their money,
  414. 17:32who ultimately calculate whether the
  415. 17:34compensation they receive offsets the
  416. 17:37risk of lending to this individual—
  417. 17:39this famous individual who, at that
  418. 17:41moment, is, as I was telling you,
  419. 17:43France. But as for you in all this, I
  420. 17:47imagine that, well, there’s little
  421. 17:50chance you’re buying French bonds
  422. 17:52directly. If you are, well,
  423. 17:54congratulations, I suppose you’re
  424. 17:56already quite advanced in the world of
  425. 17:58finance. But if you have, for example,
  426. 18:01a life insurance policy, okay, you need
  427. 18:03to understand that a portion of your
  428. 18:05savings may indirectly be funding
  429. 18:07states, including France. Okay? And the
  430. 18:11paradox is a bit ironic, honestly, and
  431. 18:13it always makes me laugh a little when
  432. 18:15I look at the media, especially since I
  433. 18:17don't live in France, I’m not French,
  434. 18:19and I see all of this from an outside
  435. 18:21perspective. But very often, in the end
  436. 18:25, you can see someone criticizing
  437. 18:27French debt in the morning, and by
  438. 18:29evening, they are a direct creditor to
  439. 18:32that same state through their life
  440. 18:34insurance policy, and ultimately, they
  441. 18:36don’t even realize it. Right? By the
  442. 18:40way, a big piece of advice—since I
  443. 18:42work in finance—don’t blindly trust
  444. 18:44your banker or the advice you might be
  445. 18:46given. I invite you to go check out
  446. 18:48this video. I made a video where I went
  447. 18:49to see my private banker in Singapore,
  448. 18:51and I was able to have conversations
  449. 18:53with him, from which I drew some
  450. 18:54conclusions and lessons. I really
  451. 18:56strongly invite you to watch that video
  452. 18:58; it might just open your mind. Anyway,
  453. 19:00let's get back to the video. Why do we
  454. 19:01still have so many investors who
  455. 19:04continue to lend money to France? Okay,
  456. 19:08if you put yourself in their shoes, you
  457. 19:10have to understand that first, they
  458. 19:13want to be compensated and ultimately
  459. 19:15consider that the available yield—
  460. 19:17which we saw is close to 5%, was it 4.7
  461. 19:20or 4.9?—largely offsets the financial
  462. 19:24default risk of France. Okay, that's
  463. 19:26the first thing. Another point is that
  464. 19:30the bond market is huge and extremely
  465. 19:33liquid. Right? You have to understand
  466. 19:37that for a massive institution, you
  467. 19:39can't just keep billions of euros in a
  468. 19:41bank. Right? That doesn't work. You
  469. 19:44can't keep that as cash, you can't keep
  470. 19:45that in paper money. They must have an
  471. 19:48immense and liquid market to be able to
  472. 19:52move these funds, to have the market
  473. 19:55depth necessary to move 300 billion,
  474. 19:58400 billion. Right? Once again, you
  475. 20:01don't keep that in cash, in euros, in a
  476. 20:03checking account. At that level, it
  477. 20:05doesn't work that way anymore. Right?
  478. 20:07So, there's that. And on top of that,
  479. 20:09bonds offer cash flows that are
  480. 20:11predictable. Right? So, you have the
  481. 20:13maturities and you have the payments
  482. 20:15where you know what the payment will be
  483. 20:16, and so on. So, this allows
  484. 20:18institutions, in addition to that, to
  485. 20:20manage their finances and ultimately
  486. 20:21manage future commitments. Even for my
  487. 20:25part, the fund I manage, the cash I
  488. 20:27have is not in cash, it is not in cash
  489. 20:29at the bank, it is entirely in
  490. 20:31government bonds. So precisely what we
  491. 20:35were talking about, that is to say, I
  492. 20:37lend this money to different states and
  493. 20:39they pay me back, and they pay me to do
  494. 20:41it, rather than having my money in cash
  495. 20:43at the bank, which isn't even secure,
  496. 20:45and earning what a savings account
  497. 20:47offers, which is what? Peanuts, I think
  498. 20:50. Anyway, I hope you understand. Once
  499. 20:52again, in finance, there is no emotion.
  500. 20:54We put all that aside, and so buying a
  501. 20:56French bond is not voting for French
  502. 20:59economic policy or the future of—no,
  503. 21:01it's accepting a financial transaction
  504. 21:04at a certain price. And in trading, in
  505. 21:07investing, emotions, opinions, as I
  506. 21:10tell you, must be set aside. That is
  507. 21:12why I ultimately love this job, it's
  508. 21:15that we really focus on the reality of
  509. 21:18things. Right? We generally say "money
  510. 21:20doesn't lie," money does not lie. Right
  511. 21:23? You look at the charts, they won't
  512. 21:25lie. You just have to follow the money.
  513. 21:28Now, if you listen to the media and the
  514. 21:30politicians and the promises, well,
  515. 21:32good luck with that. Now, I also want
  516. 21:38you to understand one fundamental thing
  517. 21:40. When market rates rise, which is what
  518. 21:43we saw recently for France, and even
  519. 21:46Germany but on a smaller scale, it does
  520. 21:49not mean that France suddenly goes from
  521. 21:52paying, let's say, 1%to paying 5%on all
  522. 21:55its debt. I remind you, there is 3.6
  523. 21:58trillion in debt. OK? You have to
  524. 22:00understand that a bond that has been
  525. 22:02issued, wait, let's go back over that.
  526. 22:04So, a bond that might have been issued,
  527. 22:08let's say, in 2016, okay? So 10 years
  528. 22:12ago, as you can see right here, and
  529. 22:14which was issued at 0.7%. This bond
  530. 22:18that was issued 10 years ago at 0.7%
  531. 22:21stays at 0.7%until it matures, so until
  532. 22:252026. Okay? The rate is fixed at
  533. 22:29issuance. But here is the mechanism.
  534. 22:31Every year, you have old bonds. So
  535. 22:35let's say we have the 2016 one, but
  536. 22:37before that, we had the 2015 bonds
  537. 22:39coming to term and needing to be fully
  538. 22:41repaid. Except that France, I remind
  539. 22:44you, has a persistent deficit. So it
  540. 22:47finds itself in a situation where it
  541. 22:50must constantly return to the market to
  542. 22:53issue new bonds. And these new bonds
  543. 22:56are issued at current market conditions
  544. 22:59to be able to pay the yield and the
  545. 23:02principal of the previous bonds. But
  546. 23:06these 2016 bonds that were issued at
  547. 23:080.7%, now when we have to reissue bonds
  548. 23:11, as I told you, current rates are at
  549. 23:134.8%. That is really not the same. Okay
  550. 23:16. Simple example. If we take 100
  551. 23:20billion euros that were financed, let's
  552. 23:23say at 1%, it means that France must
  553. 23:25pay 1 billion in annual interest. Okay,
  554. 23:29very good. Now, 10 years later, let's
  555. 23:31say these were 10-year bonds. So these
  556. 23:33same 100 billion must this time be
  557. 23:36refinanced, but at rates that are
  558. 23:38higher, at 4%. Well, suddenly, that's 4
  559. 23:41billion in annual interest. We have the
  560. 23:45exact same amount, but it costs us—
  561. 23:47well, it costs France 3 billion euros
  562. 23:50more every year. Okay. But in the real
  563. 23:55world, the French debt stock, as we
  564. 23:57have seen, is increasing in parallel on
  565. 23:59top of that. So you have France
  566. 24:02simultaneously suffering from a higher
  567. 24:06rate effect and, on top of that, a debt
  568. 24:09that is also higher. And right there,
  569. 24:12when we take the real figures, it
  570. 24:14really—well, you realize the problem
  571. 24:16in a slightly more concrete way. Okay?
  572. 24:19In 2026, just so you get it, France
  573. 24:21plans to issue about 310 billion euros
  574. 24:24of medium-and long-term debt. Okay? 310
  575. 24:27billion euros of debt in 2026. In 2027,
  576. 24:31it is expected to rise to 340 billion.
  577. 24:36And part of this increase comes
  578. 24:38precisely from old debt, notably issued
  579. 24:40during the health crises and the energy
  580. 24:43crisis. So it was 2021-2022 when we had
  581. 24:46a rise in inflation that is precisely
  582. 24:49coming to maturity now. So these were
  583. 24:52probably bonds of about 5 years. And
  584. 24:55these bonds now need to be refinanced,
  585. 24:57moving from a rate that was basically
  586. 25:00zero to a rate that is now nearly 5%.
  587. 25:03So when you realize we are talking
  588. 25:06about hundreds of billions of euros
  589. 25:08that must be placed back on the markets
  590. 25:12each year, you also understand why
  591. 25:14moving from, let’s say, 4%to 4.9%in
  592. 25:17just a few months ends up being
  593. 25:20extremely expensive. Right? We’re
  594. 25:22talking about tens and tens of billions
  595. 25:24. By the way, if you want to understand
  596. 25:27how to put your money into bonds or how
  597. 25:30government bonds—and therefore money
  598. 25:32—work, I made a video about it
  599. 25:34that’s displayed right here. I highly
  600. 25:37encourage you to go watch it. You'll
  601. 25:39see, it’s fascinating. At least, I
  602. 25:41personally find it fascinating. That
  603. 25:43said, there is one thing I’d like to
  604. 25:46clarify, which is that the 4.8%you
  605. 25:48currently see, let’s say the rate we
  606. 25:50see here at 4.8%, does not reflect the
  607. 25:52actual average cost of all French debt.
  608. 25:55I don’t know if you caught that. Okay
  609. 25:57, I think with my explanation earlier
  610. 25:59regarding the different maturities,
  611. 26:00you’ve been able to grasp it. But
  612. 26:03this average cost that France must
  613. 26:05actually repay on its total debt, so on
  614. 26:08the 3.6 trillion, is what we call the
  615. 26:11apparent interest rate. Okay? And in
  616. 26:16the end, there is a huge gap between
  617. 26:18this apparent rate and the bond yield.
  618. 26:23Right now, the 10-year bond yield is at
  619. 26:254.8%, while the apparent rate in 2026,
  620. 26:28when I’m making this video, is 2.3%.
  621. 26:31Now, in 2022 and 2023, it was around
  622. 26:351.8%. Okay? And last year, it was only
  623. 26:382%. So there, you can see that this
  624. 26:41rate is rising gradually. And meanwhile
  625. 26:44, the weighted average rate of new bond
  626. 26:47issuances in 2025 was around 2%. So
  627. 26:52there, you can see it is increasing
  628. 26:55gradually, but especially when you take
  629. 26:57into account that for the most recent
  630. 26:59issuances, the latest debt issued, the
  631. 27:01rates are around 5%, as we’ve seen.
  632. 27:06So on one hand, we have a debt stock
  633. 27:08that still costs about 2.3%on average
  634. 27:11overall, thanks to the cheap bonds from
  635. 27:13a few years ago. Okay? And on the other
  636. 27:18hand, every new bond issued costs more
  637. 27:21and more. Even more so, as I was
  638. 27:24telling you, old bonds are reaching
  639. 27:26maturity and are being replaced by
  640. 27:28other bonds that have even higher rates
  641. 27:30, and so that rate is precisely
  642. 27:31increasing. And now, I'm going to give
  643. 27:34you what is probably the most useful
  644. 27:35concept for understanding the dynamics,
  645. 27:37let's say, of sovereign debt. Because
  646. 27:39at the end of the day, just looking at
  647. 27:42debt in relation to GDP, let's say you
  648. 27:44don't have a magic threshold from which
  649. 27:47point things break. It’s not 120%,
  650. 27:49130%, 150%. Oh, we just passed 125%,
  651. 27:51everything is exploding. No, okay. This
  652. 27:54magic threshold from which a country
  653. 27:56goes into complete default and
  654. 27:57bankruptcy does not exist. Now, what
  655. 28:00really matters is the interaction
  656. 28:03between three elements. First, you have
  657. 28:06the average interest rate paid on the
  658. 28:09debt. So that’s what we saw. OK.
  659. 28:11Which was therefore at 2.3%for France
  660. 28:13in 2026. We have that. Second, we have
  661. 28:16the nominal growth of the economy. So
  662. 28:19basically, you take the growth, but you
  663. 28:21also take inflation. OK? So we have
  664. 28:23that. And the third element will be the
  665. 28:25primary balance. The primary balance is
  666. 28:28the state of the public budget even
  667. 28:31before interest payments. So if the
  668. 28:34nominal economy grows much faster than
  669. 28:36the average cost of debt, well,
  670. 28:38basically the denominator grows faster
  671. 28:40than the interest, and thus it becomes
  672. 28:43easier to lower the weight of the debt
  673. 28:45relative to GDP. OK? Basically, it's a
  674. 28:48snowball effect, but a positive one. If
  675. 28:51your debt, say, costs 2%but your
  676. 28:54nominal economy is growing by 5%, then
  677. 28:56in fact you are indirectly and
  678. 28:59gradually diluting the relative weight
  679. 29:01of that debt. Right? Now, conversely,
  680. 29:05that's where the problem is. If the
  681. 29:08cost of debt sustainably exceeds
  682. 29:09nominal growth and the state continues
  683. 29:12to spend more than it collects even
  684. 29:14before paying interest—and I think
  685. 29:16that reminds you of someone, or rather
  686. 29:18it reminds you of a state—well there,
  687. 29:20it becomes a little more complicated,
  688. 29:22because the debt increases faster than
  689. 29:24the economy can absorb it. And the
  690. 29:28thing is, for years, France benefited
  691. 29:30from a fairly comfortable cushion,
  692. 29:32let's say, where we had very low key
  693. 29:35interest rates from the ECB, the
  694. 29:37European Central Bank. Uh, on top of
  695. 29:40that, we had inflation that was
  696. 29:42artificially inflating the nominal
  697. 29:44growth I was talking about, and the
  698. 29:46apparent rate itself, well, ultimately
  699. 29:48stayed well below the nominal growth.
  700. 29:51So, in the end, it was OK. But this
  701. 29:53cushion for France, with the variables
  702. 29:55I just gave you, I think you get that
  703. 29:57it is starting to disappear. OK? And
  704. 29:59what I am telling you here is seen very
  705. 30:01concretely in the budget forecasts. So
  706. 30:04the budgetary burden of the state's
  707. 30:07debt, meaning what the state expects to
  708. 30:10pay in interest for the year 2026, is
  709. 30:1363 billion euros in interest. OK? 2027
  710. 30:17is projected at 73 billion euros. That
  711. 30:21means it's an increase of 10 billion
  712. 30:23euros in just one year. So you grasp it
  713. 30:26, once again, it's important to have a
  714. 30:27sense of scale. 10 billion is
  715. 30:29equivalent to the entire annual justice
  716. 30:32budget for 2026. OK? And here, those 10
  717. 30:36billion won't be used to build prisons,
  718. 30:38schools, or improve courthouses. No,
  719. 30:42I'm talking about 10 billion euros in
  720. 30:44interest, which means additional
  721. 30:46interest costs paid to all the holders
  722. 30:48of French debt. But here is how all of
  723. 30:52this can potentially become problematic
  724. 30:54. Usually, the danger doesn't arrive
  725. 30:58because a gauge, as I told you, the
  726. 31:00debt-to-GDP ratio reaches 120%or 130%.
  727. 31:04OK. Or because the debt has passed 4
  728. 31:06trillion and is therefore enormous.
  729. 31:08Right. Usually, the problem arrives
  730. 31:11through a much more progressive
  731. 31:12mechanism and something potentially
  732. 31:14self-reinforcing, like a snowball
  733. 31:16effect. OK? So even before, let's say,
  734. 31:20no one wants to lend to France anymore,
  735. 31:22what we tend to see is that investors
  736. 31:24start demanding more yield, higher
  737. 31:26rates. Why? Because the risk is higher.
  738. 31:30But the problem is that this higher
  739. 31:33yield itself contributes to
  740. 31:35deteriorating public finances because
  741. 31:37it suddenly costs more for France to
  742. 31:39refinance its debt. So its deficit
  743. 31:44increases even more, its debt grows
  744. 31:46even faster, and therefore investors
  745. 31:49become even more nervous. Naturally,
  746. 31:52they will demand even more yield. And
  747. 31:55then you enter a loop where it just
  748. 31:57keeps getting worse and worse and worse
  749. 31:59and worse. And this is finally exactly
  750. 32:02the mechanism that occurred in Greece
  751. 32:04between 2010 and 2012. OK, I won't
  752. 32:07dwell on it too much, especially since
  753. 32:09the situation between France and Greece
  754. 32:11is not exactly the same. But in March
  755. 32:152012, private investors who had
  756. 32:18invested in Greek debt accepted a 53%
  757. 32:21reduction in the face value of what
  758. 32:23they had lent, meaning old Greek bonds,
  759. 32:26as part of a restructuring. So
  760. 32:31basically, you had nearly 200 billion
  761. 32:33euros involved, and ultimately that is
  762. 32:36exactly what a sovereign default can
  763. 32:38mean for bondholders. As you can see,
  764. 32:41it’s not like a country just shuts
  765. 32:43its doors overnight; they can’t do
  766. 32:45that. But the creditors, on the other
  767. 32:48hand, can indeed suffer those losses
  768. 32:50and therefore not receive all of their
  769. 32:52money back. And that is what happened
  770. 32:54in Greece, then. That said, as I was
  771. 32:56saying, France today is honestly not in
  772. 32:59a situation of imminent default. The
  773. 33:01French economy is much larger than
  774. 33:04Greece's was in 2010. The French bond
  775. 33:07market is much deeper, as I explained
  776. 33:09to you. The investor base is more
  777. 33:13international, more global than
  778. 33:14Greece's was in 2010. And the average
  779. 33:19maturity of the debt—that’s also an
  780. 33:21important thing—is about eight and a
  781. 33:22half years in France. So that gives
  782. 33:25time to refinance. And that is exactly
  783. 33:27what I was explaining to you a little
  784. 33:29bit earlier. Okay, so finally, this is
  785. 33:31what the markets are really telling us
  786. 33:33about France today. Okay? So yes,
  787. 33:36despite what the media says, France
  788. 33:38still finds lenders, and even in large
  789. 33:41quantities. Okay? We are absolutely not
  790. 33:44in a liquidity crisis here. But let's
  791. 33:47say the real thermostat, the thing to
  792. 33:50gauge the temperature, is the price
  793. 33:52asked for this debt. And precisely the
  794. 33:56spread between France and Germany that
  795. 33:58I showed you at the start of the video,
  796. 34:01which is hovering around 140 basis
  797. 34:03points, so a 1.4%difference between the
  798. 34:05two, is near its highest since the
  799. 34:07European debt crisis. That is the
  800. 34:10market saying we are still here, we are
  801. 34:13still keen to lend, but we want to be
  802. 34:15better compensated for the risk we are
  803. 34:17taking. So anyway, with that, I
  804. 34:20sincerely hope that through this video,
  805. 34:22where I tried to popularize and
  806. 34:24simplify this world of finance a little
  807. 34:26bit, I hope you understand that the 10-
  808. 34:28year French rate on its own doesn't
  809. 34:30tell you much, except for the rate you
  810. 34:32will receive on your money for 10 years
  811. 34:34. But it's its interaction with
  812. 34:38everything else that counts: the stock
  813. 34:41of debt, the average life of this debt,
  814. 34:43the apparent rate versus the new market
  815. 34:46rates we are seeing, nominal growth,
  816. 34:48the deficit, and investor confidence in
  817. 34:51the budgetary trajectory. Okay? It is
  818. 34:55all these things together that matter.
  819. 34:57Now, I want to share that if you
  820. 34:59actually wish to, um, step out of the
  821. 35:01French system a bit, um, not be
  822. 35:03dependent, and be able to, um, analyze
  823. 35:05and understand it from a completely
  824. 35:08outside perspective so that, in the end
  825. 35:10, you can benefit from it. Well, that
  826. 35:12is exactly what the job of a trader,
  827. 35:14the job of an investor, is. I have been
  828. 35:16doing this for over 10 years, and I
  829. 35:18share it with you here on YouTube. We
  830. 35:20recently just passed 200,000
  831. 35:22subscribers on the channel. I am very
  832. 35:23happy. A big thank you. So, if you
  833. 35:26liked this video and you want to learn
  834. 35:28a little bit more about the world of
  835. 35:30finance around us—a fascinating world
  836. 35:32that is so important because,
  837. 35:34unfortunately, we cannot escape it—I
  838. 35:36highly invite you to subscribe to this
  839. 35:38YouTube channel and go watch all my
  840. 35:40other videos, which are a bit more "
  841. 35:42hands-on" directly regarding investing
  842. 35:44and trading. So with that, this was
  843. 35:47Iliot. I sincerely hope that you liked
  844. 35:48this video. Ciao!

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of La France fonce vers la FAILLITE... (voici les chiffres) by Elliot Hewitt - YoungTraderWealth, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,736 words across 844 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.