YouTube2Text

LA BURBUJA ECONÓMICA DE RD A PUNTO DE EXPLOTAR? - JULISSA CÉSPEDES — Transcript

by Julissa Cespedes · 4,869 words · 759 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01Hi, Maris Escuder is with us tonight,
  2. 0:03our in-house economist. The economist
  3. 0:06we have full confidence in to ask how
  4. 0:08the country is doing. It seems to have
  5. 0:11improved; some sectors have grown,
  6. 0:13which is good, although others have
  7. 0:14also slowed down a bit more. Whether
  8. 0:18the dollar and the peso remain balanced
  9. 0:20in terms of appreciation and
  10. 0:22devaluation, and there is also talk
  11. 0:24that there should be changes in the
  12. 0:26country's economic policy, including
  13. 0:27that there should be changes in the
  14. 0:29Superintendency of Banks and the
  15. 0:31Central Bank. That's a good summary. It
  16. 0:34tells you right there. Good evening. Ha
  17. 0:35.
  18. 0:35Go ahead. Good evening. How are you?
  19. 0:38Good, and better with you here.
  20. 0:40I'm glad. Look, let's start with
  21. 0:42the changes.
  22. 0:44But what changes? Let's see. It is time
  23. 0:47to change the leadership of the Central
  24. 0:48Bank and the Superintendency. Why? No,
  25. 0:51look, I think the Superintendency has
  26. 0:53done an excellent job, I mean,
  27. 0:55excellent. Today I saw an article
  28. 0:58Uh, by Alejandro Fernández W regarding
  29. 1:01the financial system, the measures that
  30. 1:03have been adopted to improve its
  31. 1:05supervision, the way in which risk must
  32. 1:08be managed: not just credit risk, but
  33. 1:11market risk, liquidity risk,
  34. 1:13operational risk, risk...all types of
  35. 1:15risks. And that is something that was
  36. 1:18already happening even before him, but
  37. 1:20he has emphasized it more in the
  38. 1:21supervision schemes. I think he has
  39. 1:23done a great job, without a doubt.
  40. 1:26Alejandro Fernández W has done a great
  41. 1:28job at the Superintendency of Banks; he
  42. 1:30has also established mechanisms for in
  43. 1:32case there is a situation where a bank
  44. 1:34has problems, how to dissolve that bank
  45. 1:37, how to resolve that, that issue. Uh,
  46. 1:40and he has the experiences that have
  47. 1:42occurred in the United States, in
  48. 1:43addition to the experience of the
  49. 1:45Dominican Republic itself. From that
  50. 1:47point of view, one can say that he has
  51. 1:49done an extraordinary, an extraordinary
  52. 1:50job at the Superintendency of Banks. As
  53. 1:53for the Central Bank of the Dominican
  54. 1:55Republic, look, I think it is an
  55. 1:57institution that enjoys a lot of
  56. 1:59credibility, without a doubt. It has
  57. 2:01earned it through hard work. Uh, from
  58. 2:03the year 2012 to 2019, it has carried
  59. 2:06out what is known as the inflation
  60. 2:09targeting scheme. I think it was very
  61. 2:13successful, the application of rules
  62. 2:15quite consistent with what the
  63. 2:18inflation target goal was. I think that
  64. 2:22was something positive.
  65. 2:24Uh, that doesn't mean the
  66. 2:25administration was perfect in every
  67. 2:26step, because nobody is perfect; nobody
  68. 2:28, let's say, runs an administration for
  69. 2:30so many years without making mistakes.
  70. 2:33I believe mistakes were made, like in
  71. 2:352005, going from 42 to 29; that
  72. 2:37over-appreciation of the currency was a
  73. 2:39mistake. I said so at the time. I said
  74. 2:42the cost would be the creation of a
  75. 2:44huge Central Bank debt that would be
  76. 2:46difficult to pay, and there is the debt
  77. 2:48, which was 89 billion pesos. It went
  78. 2:52on to exceed one trillion pesos. That
  79. 2:54is a trillion in English or a billion
  80. 2:56in Spanish. That is a million million
  81. 2:59pesos.
  82. 3:00Uh, it went up and now that debt is
  83. 3:02nearly 900 billion pesos, that is to
  84. 3:04say, 10 times more than it was in the
  85. 3:06year 2004. And that is related to that
  86. 3:10handling of the exchange rate policy at
  87. 3:12that time, which I criticized the
  88. 3:14authorities for. Where I also believe
  89. 3:18the Central Bank has made mistakes was
  90. 3:20after March 2020, when a monetary
  91. 3:23policy of liquidity injection began to
  92. 3:25be applied; they got a taste for
  93. 3:27injecting liquidity and then
  94. 3:29withdrawing it, which is what I have
  95. 3:31called zig-zag monetary policy. I think
  96. 3:35that has also been a mistake by the
  97. 3:37Central Bank, and I hope they correct
  98. 3:39it, that they don't do those kinds of
  99. 3:40policies again because all it does is
  100. 3:42create more volatility. If I look at
  101. 3:45the volatility of the exchange rate,
  102. 3:47the interest rate, the gross domestic
  103. 3:49product, the economy's growth, the
  104. 3:51volatility in some of those variables
  105. 3:53is up to three times the volatility
  106. 3:54there was before. In other words,
  107. 3:57volatility is like the uncertainty that
  108. 3:59exists. It could have been avoided; it
  109. 4:01could have been foreseen.
  110. 4:02Sure, sure. It could have been avoided.
  111. 4:04You, I justify the liquidity injection
  112. 4:06of the year 2020 because at that time
  113. 4:08we didn't know what was going to happen
  114. 4:10. Back then, we didn't know if we were
  115. 4:12going to be alive or dead. So, it was
  116. 4:14logical that you had to do whatever was
  117. 4:17necessary to Exactly.
  118. 4:19It was like going all-in; I mean, you
  119. 4:21bet 100%. But after that, well, what
  120. 4:25happened in '23, '24, '25, it was no
  121. 4:28longer necessary to have those types of
  122. 4:31policies.
  123. 4:31It can be said that it was a bad policy
  124. 4:33. So,
  125. 4:34that monetary policy, yes, I think so.
  126. 4:37That monetary policy from '20 to '25,
  127. 4:40'26, uh, has been, uh, that zig-zag
  128. 4:42monetary policy is suboptimal in
  129. 4:45consideration or comparison to what
  130. 4:47happened from '12 to '19. Let's put it
  131. 4:51this way.
  132. 4:51What are the consequences? Jaime, of
  133. 4:53that 6-year policy by now
  134. 4:55of monetary policy. Look, uh, how is it
  135. 4:58how can people perceive and say, well,
  136. 5:00the consequence for the people's
  137. 5:02economy, socially,
  138. 5:05uh, because if you tell them it was
  139. 5:06this much for the macroeconomy,
  140. 5:07probably not everyone will understand
  141. 5:09you. I mean, how do we translate that
  142. 5:10for people? What have the consequences
  143. 5:12been in that regard? Okay. Look, first
  144. 5:14of all, you have more volatility, as I
  145. 5:16pointed out to you; with more
  146. 5:18volatility, you have less investment,
  147. 5:20less capital accumulation, and that
  148. 5:22process of less capital accumulation
  149. 5:24gives you less growth capacity for the
  150. 5:26economy. That's why, for example, we
  151. 5:29grew by 5.5%from '12 to '19, and from
  152. 5:32'20 to '25 we grew by 3.2%. Mm.
  153. 5:35So, notice there that there is 1.8
  154. 5:37percentage points less growth in this
  155. 5:40period than in that period. And we also
  156. 5:43have a situation where right now the
  157. 5:45inflation rate is at 5.7%, meaning it
  158. 5:46has gotten out of hand. The inflation
  159. 5:50rate is above the upper limit of the
  160. 5:51target. The range goes from 3 to 5%,
  161. 5:56and we are at 5.7%, and it is likely
  162. 5:58that the inflation rate will continue
  163. 6:00to rise over the next 2 months before
  164. 6:03it begins to decrease. So there we are
  165. 6:07going to have a situation in which,
  166. 6:09obviously, the consumer is harmed. For
  167. 6:12example, if you break down that
  168. 6:14inflation and look at the food and
  169. 6:16non-alcoholic beverages group, you have
  170. 6:18a 7%increase over the last 12 months. A
  171. 6:217%increase is above the target and is
  172. 6:24affecting the poorest segments of the
  173. 6:26country. In other words, that part has
  174. 6:29been negative. Does the Central Bank
  175. 6:31have the capacity to recover from that?
  176. 6:32Of course it does, because the Central
  177. 6:34Bank has credibility, and that is why I
  178. 6:36have defended it so much. Some get
  179. 6:38annoyed when I correct the Central
  180. 6:42Bank's course. I like doing that,
  181. 6:44correcting their course even if they
  182. 6:45get annoyed.
  183. 6:46You are a professor; that is part of
  184. 6:47your nature.
  185. 6:48Exactly. Exactly. When I see a student
  186. 6:50doing something wrong, I tell them, "No
  187. 6:51, no, wait, look, look, correct this
  188. 6:53here, correct this here, correct this
  189. 6:54here." And they get annoyed, but they
  190. 6:57start moving toward where they need to
  191. 7:00go. So, uh, the Central Bank has the
  192. 7:03full capacity to return once again to
  193. 7:05applying a policy based on inflation
  194. 7:08targets like the one we had from '12 to
  195. 7:10'19, where economic agents know what is
  196. 7:12going to happen. Uh, for example, the
  197. 7:15exchange rate. The exchange rate, you
  198. 7:17have to, uh, it used to move 15 cents.
  199. 7:2115 cents was what it moved, and 90%of
  200. 7:24the time it was an upward movement.
  201. 7:27Meaning it was a clear and very smooth
  202. 7:29trend; you could see it and you could
  203. 7:30forecast and conduct your business, you
  204. 7:32could buy and know at what price you
  205. 7:34were going to liquidate the merchandise
  206. 7:36, at what price you were going to sell,
  207. 7:38and at what price you would buy dollars
  208. 7:40again in 6 months, because it was a
  209. 7:41fairly predictable exchange rate. Now
  210. 7:45you have that what used to be a 15-cent
  211. 7:48movement up or down, you now have
  212. 7:51movements that can be 2.50 up or 2.50
  213. 7:54down in a single month. Right now, for
  214. 7:57example, so far this year, the peso has
  215. 7:59appreciated by 7%. Was it logical for
  216. 8:02it to appreciate 7%amid such a brutal
  217. 8:04deterioration in the terms of trade, as
  218. 8:07occurred after the United States began
  219. 8:09the war with Iran? No, that
  220. 8:11appreciation is not sustainable. So, it
  221. 8:15took the exchange rate from over 63
  222. 8:18pesos to 58 pesos. So, that reduction,
  223. 8:21who has it benefited? Who has it harmed
  224. 8:24? If you are a consumer, you tell me, "
  225. 8:27Oh, I benefit because I buy on Amazon,
  226. 8:30I buy my merchandise, and now I pay 58
  227. 8:32or 59, because we are going to talk
  228. 8:36because we are going to talk about the
  229. 8:37bank counter rate." Exactly. You tell
  230. 8:39me 58, 59. So, from the consumer's
  231. 8:41point of view, you could say it is
  232. 8:43benefiting you. But if you are a
  233. 8:46consumer who is receiving remittances
  234. 8:48from abroad, you are being harmed. Why?
  235. 8:52Because before, for every dollar they
  236. 8:54sent you, you received 63 pesos, and
  237. 8:56now you are receiving 58 pesos. I am
  238. 8:59simply giving you the data from the
  239. 9:00Central Bank. If you go to the bank
  240. 9:03counters, it's at 56 and change, so the
  241. 9:05situation is even worse. Why? Because
  242. 9:09this exchange policy has also generated
  243. 9:12an increase, since there is more
  244. 9:13uncertainty and more volatility, the
  245. 9:15gap between the counter purchase rate
  246. 9:18and the counter sale rate has increased
  247. 9:20to almost 4 pesos. 4 pesos is 7%,
  248. 9:23listen closely, 7%difference between
  249. 9:27the two. That margin is brutal. A
  250. 9:30percentage of 1%is fine. 7%is brutal.
  251. 9:37To give you an idea, for banks, among
  252. 9:40their commission income, currency
  253. 9:43exchange commissions represented 13-14%
  254. 9:46in 2018, 2017, 2016; now they represent
  255. 9:5030%of all their commissions. Why?
  256. 9:53Because they are making a lot of money
  257. 9:55due to this uncertainty created by the
  258. 9:57Central Bank, because there is
  259. 9:58appreciation now,
  260. 9:59but that doesn't rule out the
  261. 10:00possibility of depreciation later on.
  262. 10:02So, and I want to focus a lot on this
  263. 10:04topic, the issue of appreciation,
  264. 10:06notice that it hurts those who receive
  265. 10:08remittances, but it also hurts those
  266. 10:11who export, whether goods or services.
  267. 10:14Imagine you are an exporter, in the
  268. 10:17agricultural sector, selling abroad;
  269. 10:19before, for every $ 100 you were
  270. 10:21receiving 6,000, now you'll receive 58,
  271. 10:2457, 56,000 pesos. Before you received
  272. 10:2863,000 pesos, that is, for $ 1,000 and
  273. 10:31so on. Now you are receiving 57,000
  274. 10:33pesos. When you do those analyses, you
  275. 10:36say, "Listen, exports are losing
  276. 10:38competitiveness, the productive sector
  277. 10:39is losing competitiveness." Imagine you
  278. 10:42are a local manufacturer. You are a
  279. 10:45local manufacturer of a product that
  280. 10:47might have some imported parts, but
  281. 10:49most of your added value is local. What
  282. 10:51happens there? You have to compete with
  283. 10:54an imported item, but for that imported
  284. 10:57glass, instead of paying 63 pesos, the
  285. 10:59exchange rate will pay 58 pesos. So you
  286. 11:03, whose cost structure stayed
  287. 11:04practically the same, you will now have
  288. 11:07to compete with a cheaper one, so you
  289. 11:09get displaced. So, that's why you
  290. 11:11observe that manufacturing grows little
  291. 11:14, meaning it's growing less than other
  292. 11:16sectors. So, that is something that
  293. 11:18must also be taken into account, the
  294. 11:19impact you have on the productive
  295. 11:21sectors. Who has actually benefited a
  296. 11:23lot? Apart from that consumer who is
  297. 11:25willing to import via Amazon, etc., who
  298. 11:28has benefited a lot? The government.
  299. 11:33Because when the government has to find
  300. 11:35$ 1,000 now to pay the external debt
  301. 11:37service, how much does it have to find?
  302. 11:39It only has to find 58. Exactly.
  303. 11:44It no longer has to find 63,000, and
  304. 11:46that generates savings that benefit
  305. 11:49public finances, but not just for debt
  306. 11:52service payments; for the electricity
  307. 11:55rate, when it has to pay generators, it
  308. 11:58has to buy dollars. It goes out to buy
  309. 12:01dollars and buys those dollars now at
  310. 12:0358, it no longer has to pay at 63, it
  311. 12:05saves there too. So that 7%savings is
  312. 12:09also a reduction in the amounts that
  313. 12:12must be found to pay for the
  314. 12:14electricity subsidy and also the fuel
  315. 12:17subsidy. So all those elements are
  316. 12:21equivalent to saying that this
  317. 12:22appreciation that the Central Bank has
  318. 12:24carried out—because it is the Central
  319. 12:26Bank that has promoted it, because if
  320. 12:28it had been the economy, that
  321. 12:29appreciation would not be justified—
  322. 12:31it is the Central Bank that has
  323. 12:33promoted the 7%appreciation. So, this
  324. 12:37has meant that the government now has
  325. 12:39something equivalent to an increase in
  326. 12:41tax revenue. It’s as if it were a tax
  327. 12:44, I mean, it’s a tax that was
  328. 12:45previously called a foreign exchange
  329. 12:47surcharge. Exactly.
  330. 12:49At some point in the past, and now it
  331. 12:51is simply that management that has made
  332. 12:54the exchange rate like a bubble. And
  333. 12:57why? Listen closely to this. Is the
  334. 13:00exchange rate of 58 pesos justified by
  335. 13:02the structural conditions of the
  336. 13:05Dominican economy? No, I challenged the
  337. 13:09Central Bank right here to present me
  338. 13:11with an econometric model that tells me
  339. 13:14that the equilibrium exchange rate for
  340. 13:16this date now is 58 pesos to one. I
  341. 13:20challenge any Central Bank technician
  342. 13:22to come here
  343. 13:23and show me the econometric model that
  344. 13:26justifies an exchange rate of 58 pesos
  345. 13:28to one.
  346. 13:29Anyone.
  347. 13:30None of them will show up. None. Most
  348. 13:32of them were my students. None of them
  349. 13:36will show up with a model that says, "
  350. 13:38The exchange rate is 58 pesos." Not one
  351. 13:40. They will all tell you that the
  352. 13:43exchange rate would be close to 66
  353. 13:44pesos to one. Listen to the number. 66
  354. 13:47pesos to one. And it's logical. If I
  355. 13:51take the years '12 to '19, from 2012 to
  356. 13:532019, and project it given that
  357. 13:55economic structure within the inflation
  358. 13:57targeting concept, what should the
  359. 13:59exchange rate be? It is much higher
  360. 14:01than 58. And the additional question is
  361. 14:05, but will it stay at 58, right? That
  362. 14:08level I’m pointing out to you of 66
  363. 14:10is like a magnet, because that is the
  364. 14:12equilibrium value, and the magnet is
  365. 14:14going to pull
  366. 14:16it from 58. So, 58, what is it? A
  367. 14:18bargain exchange rate. If you have
  368. 14:22pesos and you are a speculator, if you
  369. 14:24are a speculator, what would you do?
  370. 14:29Bet against the peso and go buy dollars
  371. 14:31if you were a speculator; I'm not
  372. 14:33saying to do it because you have to be
  373. 14:35a speculator for that, but that is what
  374. 14:37you would do. Why? Because it simply is
  375. 14:41not justified. You tell me, "No, but
  376. 14:43the Central Bank has 15 billion dollars
  377. 14:46in reserves." Yes, it has 15 billion
  378. 14:49dollars, of which a portion are
  379. 14:51government deposits, another portion
  380. 14:53are commercial bank deposits in the
  381. 14:55form of reserves, and other portions
  382. 14:57are items that the Central Bank cannot
  383. 14:59use, and that is the difference between
  384. 15:02net reserves and liquid reserves. So
  385. 15:06you do have a situation there where you
  386. 15:07say, "Look, the Central Bank could
  387. 15:09intervene, yes, it could intervene."
  388. 15:12Can it do it indefinitely, though?
  389. 15:14That is the point. If
  390. 15:16it cannot do it indefinitely, it can
  391. 15:18stop a speculative attack against the
  392. 15:20peso. It can do it. It can do it.
  393. 15:24Especially knowing the current governor
  394. 15:26, who is someone that has done it on
  395. 15:28different occasions, knows how to
  396. 15:30intervene in the market, has experience
  397. 15:32intervening in the market, is an expert
  398. 15:34at intervening in the market, and
  399. 15:36therefore stops any type of speculative
  400. 15:38attack against the peso. Now, does that
  401. 15:42mean the level of 58 pesos to one is
  402. 15:44correct? No. At what point will the
  403. 15:46exchange rate go up? That would be the
  404. 15:49other question.
  405. 15:50I'll tell you.
  406. 15:51Yes. Now or after the break. Now.
  407. 15:54Now, at what point will it rise? I mean
  408. 15:56, this isn't going to be maintained
  409. 15:57forever.
  410. 15:58That is what is called the stopping
  411. 15:59time. When you have a speculative
  412. 16:02scheme, a bubble that is a market
  413. 16:04anomaly, because as a disciple of
  414. 16:06Eugene Fama, Nobel Prize winner in
  415. 16:09Economics from the University of
  416. 16:11Chicago, who says bubbles don't exist,
  417. 16:13what exists are anomalies
  418. 16:16of the market, and I think this
  419. 16:18exchange rate level of 58 pesos to one
  420. 16:20is an anomaly. That is something
  421. 16:22transitory. So, as something transitory
  422. 16:24, it disappears. The point is that you
  423. 16:27can make it disappear in two ways:
  424. 16:29either it bursts, or you deflate it. So
  425. 16:33, what I am recommending to the Central
  426. 16:35Bank is that it take measures to
  427. 16:36deflate it little by little, letting it
  428. 16:38rise slightly, so it doesn't burst in
  429. 16:40their hands. Now, at what point can
  430. 16:43that situation come where
  431. 16:47it disappears? Look, I think he is
  432. 16:48going to try, what he is going to try
  433. 16:50is to make it release pressure little
  434. 16:54by little, and in that, he will adjust.
  435. 16:57That would be the healthiest thing,
  436. 16:58right? It would be the healthiest thing
  437. 16:59. It would be the healthiest thing, and
  438. 17:01he is an expert at that. You have to
  439. 17:02give that credit to the governor. What
  440. 17:04he is going to do is, starting in
  441. 17:06September, he will let the exchange
  442. 17:08rate rise. So, the exchange rate could
  443. 17:11end up at 61, 62 pesos to one by the
  444. 17:13end of the year. That would be the
  445. 17:15and stay at that value until 2028, or
  446. 17:17not?
  447. 17:18No, no, no. I mean, not right now,
  448. 17:21listen closely, it's at 58, 58.50,
  449. 17:2458.60. It will stay there until August,
  450. 17:28September. He gets ratified, the news
  451. 17:31comes out, everything is fine, ratified
  452. 17:33. Uh,
  453. 17:34oh, so it also functions as a policy.
  454. 17:36Of course, of course. It's related.
  455. 17:38As a personal policy.
  456. 17:39It's related. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.
  457. 17:42It's related. It's related. Of course
  458. 17:44it is. You see it in other years, in
  459. 17:46'22 the behavior was very similar to
  460. 17:49this, and starting in September it
  461. 17:51began to rise. In '24, no, because you
  462. 17:54have two objectives in '24,
  463. 17:56ratification, but there are elections
  464. 17:58too. And in elections you need growth.
  465. 18:02So, if you need more growth, you need
  466. 18:04to loosen up, either fiscal or monetary
  467. 18:07policy to stimulate the economy, and
  468. 18:10then the exchange rate takes a backseat
  469. 18:12.
  470. 18:13So, the dollar will stay low until the
  471. 18:15governor is ratified, then they raise
  472. 18:16it.
  473. 18:16Exactly. Starting in September,
  474. 18:18starting in September
  475. 18:19and it could go up to 62, 63.
  476. 18:20Yes, it could rise more towards 61, 62.
  477. 18:24I think he would feel comfortable there
  478. 18:25.
  479. 18:26Yes.
  480. 18:27And the population as well. Look, what
  481. 18:29the population needs to understand is
  482. 18:31that what we are experiencing is a fire
  483. 18:33sale. It's like when you go to a store,
  484. 18:36and when I was little, the Plaza Lama
  485. 18:39guys used to have a lot of sales, real
  486. 18:41bargain sales, people would go and buy
  487. 18:44sneakers and stuff and leave very happy
  488. 18:46,
  489. 18:47but if you arrived too late, there were
  490. 18:48no bargains left. So that's it, right
  491. 18:50now there is a fire sale on dollars.
  492. 18:52There is a fire sale on dollars. Those
  493. 18:54who want to buy, buy, and those who
  494. 18:56don't, don't.
  495. 18:56Those who can, buy. Yes, yes. Those who
  496. 18:59want to, and can, buy. It's like the
  497. 19:01sneaker sale, you went and bought your
  498. 19:03sneakers.
  499. 19:04Whoever gets there first.
  500. 19:05Exactly. Right now, I have friends who
  501. 19:08are experts at buying, and they have
  502. 19:11bought a lot of dollars. So, that's one
  503. 19:14thing. Now, you tell me, "Jaime, but
  504. 19:17the economy is growing." So, the
  505. 19:20question is, why is the economy growing
  506. 19:22? Then you say, the economy is growing
  507. 19:26for several reasons. The economy is
  508. 19:29growing by an average of 4.5%from
  509. 19:31January to June. The 4.5%economy from
  510. 19:34January to June is very close to its
  511. 19:36potential. The potential is five, we
  512. 19:38haven't fully recovered. But remember,
  513. 19:41and this is the baseline point to start
  514. 19:43with, remember that last year the
  515. 19:45growth was 2.1%. If I take only the
  516. 19:48first semester of last year, it grew by
  517. 19:502.4%. If that 2.4, instead of being
  518. 19:54such low growth, had been the potential
  519. 19:57growth, or at least 4.5, which is,
  520. 20:00let's say, perhaps the new potential
  521. 20:03instead of 5, let's assume 4.5. Imagine
  522. 20:06it were 4.5. How much would we have
  523. 20:09really grown this year? Instead of that
  524. 20:114.5, how much would we have grown? 2.
  525. 20:13Yes, 2.
  526. 20:14Yes, yes.
  527. 20:15It was enough.
  528. 20:16Look, it's at least better than last
  529. 20:18year.
  530. 20:19Yes.
  531. 20:19Better. So, there is a base effect.
  532. 20:22First, there is a base effect. Now, if
  533. 20:24we look at it by sectors, now we're
  534. 20:26going to see the interesting part.
  535. 20:28By sectors, what is happening?
  536. 20:30There we have the construction sector,
  537. 20:32which is the one that has grown the
  538. 20:33most, but it was in the basement.
  539. 20:34Five consecutive quarters.
  540. 20:38Five consecutive quarters
  541. 20:40until December of last year. Five
  542. 20:43consecutive quarters. We had never had
  543. 20:45anything like that before. Five
  544. 20:47consecutive quarters retreating,
  545. 20:49retreating in January, because look how
  546. 20:51things are. In January, engineer Manuel
  547. 20:54Estrella, listen closely,
  548. 20:57makes some statements where he says, "
  549. 20:59Look, we need to take measures here to
  550. 21:01resolve this issue in the construction
  551. 21:03sector." This is the sector, it is the
  552. 21:05main sector of the Dominican economy.
  553. 21:07It represents, at that moment it
  554. 21:09represented between 14 and 15%, but
  555. 21:11with all those setbacks it came to
  556. 21:13represent 12.5%of the economy. He says,
  557. 21:16"It still remains the main sector. If
  558. 21:19you stimulate it,
  559. 21:20you are going to grow."
  560. 21:22So he says this. Now, the problem that
  561. 21:25I observe, says engineer Manuel
  562. 21:27Estrella, "The problem that I observe
  563. 21:29is that there are some permits, some
  564. 21:31licenses that are not coming out."
  565. 21:34Exactly.
  566. 21:34There is a micro problem, it is not a
  567. 21:36macro issue, it is a micro problem that
  568. 21:38we have in the construction sector. The
  569. 21:40permits are not coming out, the
  570. 21:42licenses are not coming out, and that
  571. 21:44is why we cannot start projects. So he
  572. 21:47says, besides that identification, that
  573. 21:49diagnosis of the problem, he says, "And
  574. 21:51it can be done this way," and gives a
  575. 21:53set of recommendations. The Ministry of
  576. 21:56Housing takes what is
  577. 21:58the recommendations,
  578. 22:00takes the bull by the horns, so to
  579. 22:02speak, and decides to take internal
  580. 22:05measures to make the delivery of
  581. 22:07licenses more flexible and efficient.
  582. 22:10And licenses have increased, for
  583. 22:12example, from January to June of this
  584. 22:14year compared to January to June of
  585. 22:16last year by 80%. And the investment
  586. 22:20amount related to those licenses has
  587. 22:23increased by 157%, rising to 330
  588. 22:25billion pesos in projects. Imagine.
  589. 22:28For the licenses,
  590. 22:29per license, meaning for those licenses
  591. 22:32that are being granted, it has
  592. 22:35increased by 157%.
  593. 22:37It's a thing, it's even a silly thing.
  594. 22:39If that is actually revenue for the
  595. 22:41government, why are there so many
  596. 22:42hurdles to getting those licenses out?
  597. 22:44I don't understand it.
  598. 22:44It’s something that doesn't have much
  599. 22:45of an explanation.
  600. 22:46I don't understand it, but the Ministry
  601. 22:48of Housing stepped up; the minister,
  602. 22:50Ito, stepped up following those
  603. 22:51recommendations or the challenge from
  604. 22:53Manuel Estrella, because it's a
  605. 22:54challenge when someone from the private
  606. 22:56sector drops something like that on you
  607. 22:58.
  608. 22:58Uh-huh.
  609. 22:59Listen, it’s a challenge for you as
  610. 23:01an official where you hold the primary
  611. 23:03responsibility. There are other
  612. 23:05institutions as well—agriculture, the
  613. 23:07city council, the environment, etc.—
  614. 23:09that need to step up, but the Ministry
  615. 23:11of Housing says, "At least I'm on this.
  616. 23:12" And so, it comes out with that
  617. 23:16increase in licenses, and that has
  618. 23:18favored the construction sector, which
  619. 23:20grew in June. It grew 14.9%in June,
  620. 23:24that is in year-over-year terms,
  621. 23:27but the January-June cumulative average
  622. 23:30has grown 6.7%. 6.7%. That is something
  623. 23:36that has helped the economy's growth
  624. 23:38toward that 4.5%a lot. And the 14.9%
  625. 23:42explained 30%of the growth recorded in
  626. 23:46the month of June in year-over-year
  627. 23:49terms. So, it is truly extraordinary
  628. 23:52what the construction sector has
  629. 23:54achieved. So, that is a sector that we
  630. 23:57must try to continue supporting through
  631. 23:59micro-reforms. They are positive, like
  632. 24:02this one regarding licenses, but we
  633. 24:05must also recognize that the government
  634. 24:07has done its bit, because public
  635. 24:09investment went from 1.6—a very low
  636. 24:11level, 1.6—to 1.9 in annualized terms
  637. 24:13in the first 6 months of the year; that
  638. 24:16is, it rose by 0.3 of GDP. So, the
  639. 24:19government also did its part, but the
  640. 24:21majority was the private sector. So,
  641. 24:24that sector has been very positive.
  642. 24:26Then there is the mining sector. The
  643. 24:28mining sector has grown 11.3%from
  644. 24:31January to June. Do you remember that
  645. 24:33here we said there was a bottleneck in
  646. 24:35mining as well? As soon as they
  647. 24:37replaced the Minister of Energy and
  648. 24:40Mines, look at how the sector begins to
  649. 24:42gain momentum. It had several quarters
  650. 24:46with negative variations as well, and
  651. 24:48now it is starting to accelerate its
  652. 24:50growth rate to the point where it is
  653. 24:52already growing at 11.3%, and that is
  654. 24:55volume. That is not because the price
  655. 24:57of gold was higher, no. That is volume
  656. 24:59that you obviously generate; you remove
  657. 25:01obstacles, and with a good price, you
  658. 25:03increase your exports in terms of
  659. 25:05volume. In other words, that has been
  660. 25:07positive. Tourism is at 5.8%; it’s
  661. 25:09not the 10%we used to have. If we had a
  662. 25:13better exchange rate, we would be even
  663. 25:15more competitive. So, that is something
  664. 25:16that must be taken into account. It is
  665. 25:19likely that the appreciation is not yet
  666. 25:20visible in that area; it works for a
  667. 25:22group of things, but for other groups
  668. 25:24of things, it does not.
  669. 25:26It harms them. So, that must be taken
  670. 25:28into account; then, there is the little
  671. 25:31growth that we really need to watch
  672. 25:33closely: commerce at 2.2%, January to
  673. 25:35June at 2.2%. That one needs close
  674. 25:38attention because 20%of the employed
  675. 25:41people in this country work in commerce
  676. 25:43. Therefore, we must pay close
  677. 25:45attention to the commerce sector, which
  678. 25:46is only growing at 2.2%. Agriculture is
  679. 25:49at 2.4%; that is a sector that should
  680. 25:52grow more because it supplies food to
  681. 25:55the Dominican market and the Dominican
  682. 25:57consumer, but also to that entire
  683. 26:00tourist population that arrives, so it
  684. 26:02has to improve more. Free zones are at
  685. 26:06only 2.6%. Notice that all those are
  686. 26:09numbers well below the 5%potential, and
  687. 26:12local manufacturing is at 3.3%. In
  688. 26:15other words, those are large sectors
  689. 26:17because both the commerce sector and
  690. 26:19the manufacturing sector combined
  691. 26:21represent 20%of the economy. So, we
  692. 26:24have to try to get them to improve in
  693. 26:26order to have a higher growth rate for
  694. 26:28the economy. So, those are elements
  695. 26:30that must be taken very much into
  696. 26:31account. Those are elements you must
  697. 26:35focus on to try to make the entire
  698. 26:37economic sector improve. You then have
  699. 26:41to identify those measures that you
  700. 26:43must adopt at a micro level, just as
  701. 26:45you did in the construction sector,
  702. 26:47measures in the manufacturing sector,
  703. 26:48and measures in the commerce sector
  704. 26:50that you need to achieve a higher rate
  705. 26:52of economic growth.
  706. 26:54Briefly, Jaime, so as not to take more
  707. 26:56of your time than we already have at
  708. 26:58this hour. The people who say they are
  709. 27:02selling the same but are earning less,
  710. 27:04is that also related to the dollar rate
  711. 27:06? Look, it depends on the activity, but
  712. 27:10if you are in an activity where you
  713. 27:12have to face an importer, for example,
  714. 27:15an importer,
  715. 27:16the importers themselves are saying, "
  716. 27:18We are paying the same, importing the
  717. 27:19same, selling the same, but we are
  718. 27:21earning less."
  719. 27:22Hey, good. What happened? Imagine you
  720. 27:25are an importer and you imported a
  721. 27:28product at 63 or 64 pesos in December
  722. 27:31and you are selling it now at an
  723. 27:33exchange rate of 58. That reduction,
  724. 27:39that difference is a loss.
  725. 27:40You have a loss. So that is a point
  726. 27:43that might be happening to some
  727. 27:45activities. Meaning, that to be able to
  728. 27:48sell now they have had to reduce some
  729. 27:50prices. Uh, it depends, it depends on
  730. 27:52the market. It depends on the market.
  731. 27:56Uh, there are some that have done that
  732. 27:58and others simply haven't been able to,
  733. 28:00they go bankrupt, uh, and exit the
  734. 28:02market. I mean, uh, because remember
  735. 28:04that these are aggregate numbers.
  736. 28:06Everything I've told you is aggregate
  737. 28:08numbers. The economy is the aggregation
  738. 28:11of many highly heterogeneous economic
  739. 28:14agents, where you can have different
  740. 28:16activities, but within each activity,
  741. 28:19different types of economic agents: big
  742. 28:22, small, more efficient, less efficient
  743. 28:25, and who are impacted in a more
  744. 28:27aggressive or less aggressive way by
  745. 28:30some variables like interest rates,
  746. 28:32like labor costs, like the exchange
  747. 28:35rate; I mean, the results at a micro
  748. 28:39level can be very different.
  749. 28:41Complex.
  750. 28:42Yes, complex. Complex, but interesting.
  751. 28:45Very interesting.
  752. 28:46Very interesting. Of course. Of course.
  753. 28:48Let's see what happens between now and
  754. 28:49September.
  755. 28:49Let's see. And after September that's
  756. 28:51when things could get interesting.
  757. 28:52Oh, oh, oh. Thank you, Jaime. What a
  758. 28:55pleasure always to have you here.
  759. 28:56My pleasure. We have to take a bre.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of LA BURBUJA ECONÓMICA DE RD A PUNTO DE EXPLOTAR? - JULISSA CÉSPEDES by Julissa Cespedes, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,869 words across 759 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.