L'IA va-t-elle remplacer les traders? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00So, since the arrival of ChatGPT at the
- 0:02end of 2022, there is a topic I have
- 0:05never addressed on this channel, even
- 0:07though literally every trading
- 0:09influencer has jumped on it, seeing the
- 0:11opportunity to get easy views and
- 0:13promise a new way of presenting trading
- 0:16. Hundreds of videos explaining how to
- 0:19become profitable in trading with AI,
- 0:21how to create strategies from scratch
- 0:23with AI, and how to develop a trading
- 0:25bot that will help you in your place
- 0:27and make you money while you sleep. And
- 0:30as I just told you, it’s the new
- 0:32marketing trend in the trading niche.
- 0:35And yet, it’s been almost four years,
- 0:37and I haven’t jumped on this new
- 0:39trend, this new fad, this new subject
- 0:41that I know ultimately excites retail
- 0:43traders and that I know would get tons
- 0:46of views here on YouTube. But then, why
- 0:50? Why have I never talked about
- 0:53artificial intelligence when it is
- 0:55clearly the new marketing way to
- 0:57present trading as a simple solution to
- 0:59financial freedom? And above all, in
- 1:03this video, we will see together: will
- 1:05AI end up replacing traders? Could this
- 1:08profession completely disappear? And if
- 1:11you are already a trader or want to
- 1:13become one, what does it really change
- 1:15for you? So to start, the reason why I
- 1:18waited so long to address this subject
- 1:20is quite simple. I’ve been trading
- 1:24for over 12 years, and I’ve spent
- 1:26years developing a methodology that
- 1:28works, a trading system that has
- 1:30allowed me to have consistent results
- 1:32over the long term. And the thing is,
- 1:35when you have something that works, you
- 1:37don't necessarily want to change
- 1:39everything just because a new trend has
- 1:40just exploded on social media. OK?
- 1:44Because you have to understand one
- 1:46thing: adding variables to a strategy
- 1:48that works can potentially improve it,
- 1:50but it can also completely degrade it,
- 1:52or even destroy it. And personally, I
- 1:55am not someone who changes methods
- 1:57every 3 months because there is
- 1:59something new buzzing on Twitter or
- 2:00YouTube. As I’m telling you, I’ve
- 2:02had my way of doing things for years. I
- 2:04am very cautious about adding new
- 2:05variables. OK? That is actually the
- 2:08reason why I have been in the financial
- 2:10markets for over 10 years and have
- 2:11never done anything else. I have never
- 2:14seized another opportunity because I
- 2:17found the field in which I managed to
- 2:19stand out and the field in which I am
- 2:22good. And the icing on the cake, the
- 2:25field that I really love, that makes me
- 2:27vibrate and gives me a good reason to
- 2:28be happy when I wake up in the morning
- 2:30and even to love Mondays. That is, that
- 2:33is very important. But now, what I’m
- 2:35telling you does not at all mean that I
- 2:37am against AI. OK? Over the last few
- 2:40years, I’ve spent a huge amount of
- 2:42time understanding this technology,
- 2:44running tests, and starting to
- 2:45integrate it into certain parts of my
- 2:47work. And today, I finally have enough
- 2:51perspective to share a real opinion
- 2:53with you. Not, uh, the opinion of a
- 2:56trading influencer trying to sell you
- 2:58the new miracle solution to easily
- 2:59become a trader or sell you some new "
- 3:01vibe-coded" software that will
- 3:02absolutely change everything in your
- 3:04trading thanks to artificial
- 3:05intelligence that will allow you to
- 3:07become profitable. Anyway, before
- 3:10starting this video, I’d first like
- 3:12us to take a trip back in time because
- 3:14this isn’t the first time that we
- 3:17traders have faced new technologies.
- 3:20Thirty or 40 years ago, trading was
- 3:23literally people in trading pits
- 3:25shouting out buy and sell orders. It
- 3:29was notably during my invitation to the
- 3:32New York Stock Exchange that Peter
- 3:34Tuchman, also known as the Einstein of
- 3:36Wall Street, told me stories from that
- 3:38era as well as various archives. Anyway
- 3:41, fascinating. And for example, let’s
- 3:44go see this. Hop. What you see, for
- 3:48example, right here, is a miniature of
- 3:51the 1870 Edison Stock Ticker with the
- 3:53glass dome. And in fact, at that time,
- 3:57stock tickers—if you will, all the
- 3:59prices, all the tickers that came
- 4:01through—worked with this machine, so
- 4:03from 1870, and then it came out through
- 4:05here. So, in short, stock quotes back
- 4:09then were done like this with this
- 4:11machine. I can, let's look up "Edison
- 4:14stock ticker," and then after that,
- 4:16computers arrived. Electronic platforms
- 4:20developed, and executions became much
- 4:22faster. A huge portion of manual work
- 4:25started to be automated. It was at that
- 4:28time, I think you can imagine, a
- 4:30revolution in the world of trading.
- 4:33Next came algorithmic trading and,
- 4:35above all, high-frequency trading.
- 4:39Suddenly, we had machines that were
- 4:41capable of analyzing markets and
- 4:43executing thousands of orders in a few
- 4:45microseconds. Yes, you heard that right
- 4:47: microseconds. But despite all these
- 4:50technological evolutions, did trading
- 4:52and traders disappear? The answer is no
- 4:55. The markets continued to function,
- 4:59traders adapted, and new opportunities
- 5:01emerged. And that is exactly what I
- 5:04find interesting. With every major
- 5:06technological shift, the same question
- 5:09keeps coming up. Is this the end of
- 5:11traders? But history has taught us that
- 5:15market opportunities never truly
- 5:16disappear. Some opportunities vanish,
- 5:20yes, but others appear. Now, what I
- 5:23want to share with you is my opinion on
- 5:25what this technology can actually bring
- 5:28to a trader. This technology being
- 5:32artificial intelligence, and especially
- 5:34why I think many people are completely
- 5:36mistaken about its utility in our work
- 5:38as traders. I sincerely believe that AI
- 5:43represents a huge opportunity for the
- 5:45trading world, and I even think it can
- 5:47allow certain traders—the ones
- 5:49already profitable—to become even
- 5:51better, and also to reduce the gap, the
- 5:53informational gap between institutional
- 5:56traders and retail traders. Take my
- 5:59case: I’ve been in the markets for
- 6:00over 12 years. I’ve accumulated a
- 6:02vast amount of experience, developed my
- 6:05understanding of macro and financial
- 6:07markets, built strategies, and most
- 6:09importantly, I've accumulated years of
- 6:11data on my own trading. And so, in my
- 6:14current situation, thanks to AI, I can,
- 6:17for example, potentially leverage all
- 6:19this information much more efficiently.
- 6:22And by the way, by sharing this with
- 6:24you, I’m referring to the advice
- 6:26I’ve been giving here on YouTube for
- 6:28years, which is to absolutely track
- 6:30everything in your trading and even in
- 6:32your personal finances. OK? Because
- 6:35without this tracking—which I always
- 6:37strive to tell you to do, track
- 6:38everything you do or else it’s
- 6:40pointless—analyzing your own data,
- 6:42even with AI, unfortunately becomes
- 6:43impossible. Anyway, let me give you a
- 6:46concrete example. Let’s say you’ve
- 6:48been a profitable trader for 5 years.
- 6:50You’ve documented all your positions.
- 6:52You have a complete trading journal
- 6:54with market conditions, your entries,
- 6:56exits, results, gains, losses, and the
- 6:59reasons behind every position. All this
- 7:02information you’ve collected is
- 7:04thousands of data points accumulated
- 7:05through your experience. That is
- 7:08priceless. Right? Now, imagine you
- 7:11could use artificial intelligence to
- 7:14study all of that, identify errors you
- 7:16repeat, market environments where you
- 7:18perform worse without even realizing it
- 7:21, or even risk management adjustments
- 7:23that could potentially improve your
- 7:25results. That’s where AI becomes
- 7:28extremely interesting. OK? Because here
- 7:32, AI doesn't come to replace your
- 7:34strategy, it potentially helps you
- 7:36improve it. And it’s exactly the same
- 7:39thing with macroeconomic analysis. OK?
- 7:41You can use artificial intelligence to
- 7:44synthesize economic reports. OK?
- 7:46Compare central bank decisions, and
- 7:48speed up research that previously would
- 7:50have taken several hours. OK? But
- 7:53personally, it's in this type of use
- 7:55that I'm starting to find more and more
- 7:57value in this technology. But there is
- 8:00a big, a very big nuance that we are
- 8:02going to study together. The problem is
- 8:06that the use of artificial intelligence
- 8:08in trading is absolutely not presented
- 8:11and sold this way to the majority of
- 8:13retail traders online. The perspective
- 8:18I'm sharing with you, unfortunately, is
- 8:20not the popular view on using Claude or
- 8:22ChatGPT in trading. Because if you look
- 8:27at a good portion of the content today
- 8:29on AI applied to trading, what is the
- 8:30message they're trying to send you?
- 8:33It's that thanks to AI, you no longer
- 8:35really need to spend years learning how
- 8:37to trade. You no longer need to
- 8:39understand macroeconomics, financial
- 8:42markets, or even develop a real
- 8:43strategy. No, thanks to artificial
- 8:46intelligence today, you just need to
- 8:48find the right prompt or use the right
- 8:50software—which they are obviously
- 8:52trying to sell you—that is generally
- 8:55just a wrapper for ChatGPT or Claude,
- 8:57or use the right bot. OK, the AI will
- 9:00do all the work for you. But I'm sorry
- 9:02to tell you. To me, all of that is
- 9:05absolute. OK. And I've
- 9:07particularly come across ads over the
- 9:09last 6 months about using AI in your
- 9:11trading to become profitable. It's
- 9:14pathetic, it's just insane. OK, because
- 9:16the fundamental problem for a beginner
- 9:18trader is not that they lack a
- 9:19sufficiently powerful tool. OK? The
- 9:22problem is that they generally don't
- 9:25yet have the knowledge, the experience,
- 9:27and above all, a real competitive
- 9:29advantage in the markets. That's what
- 9:32we call an edge, OK? A strategy with a
- 9:35positive expectancy capable of
- 9:37generating profits over the long term.
- 9:40And this edge, this advantage, isn't
- 9:43just going to appear by magic because
- 9:45you've started using ChatGPT. Think for
- 9:47two seconds. If you can ask an AI to
- 9:50build a profitable trading strategy in
- 9:5230 seconds, what stops millions of
- 9:54other traders from doing exactly the
- 9:56same thing? And above all, what stops
- 9:59...The biggest hedge funds on the
- 10:01planet, which have financial and
- 10:02technological means far superior to
- 10:04yours, from exploiting these same
- 10:08strategies, but on a much larger scale?
- 10:10OK? If an opportunity is simple to
- 10:13identify, simple to automate, and
- 10:16accessible to everyone, it will
- 10:18precisely become less and less
- 10:20profitable as more capital comes in to
- 10:22exploit that edge, that advantage. And
- 10:26that's what bothers me about all this
- 10:28marketing around AI. Beginner traders
- 10:30are being led to believe that they can
- 10:33skip all the difficult stages of
- 10:34trading to reach profitability
- 10:36immediately. Once again, we see all
- 10:39these trading influencers jumping on
- 10:41the latest trends to try and sell a new
- 10:44solution. Yet in reality, trading
- 10:47remains a real profession, and like any
- 10:49profession, it requires knowledge,
- 10:51experience, and an enormous amount of
- 10:54practice. Granted, AI can amplify your
- 10:57skills, but it doesn't automatically
- 10:59replace the skills you have never
- 11:01developed. And I'll go even further. I
- 11:04think that for many beginners, it could
- 11:07even be dangerous because it will
- 11:09precisely give a false impression of
- 11:12competence. You can now produce
- 11:14analyses that look extremely
- 11:16professional, even develop quite
- 11:18sophisticated indicators, and get
- 11:20impressive backtests without
- 11:22necessarily understanding what you are
- 11:25doing. And believe me, after 12 years
- 11:27of experience in the markets, this
- 11:29illusion of competence can be extremely
- 11:31costly. Now, there is also another
- 11:34point that I don't think we talk about
- 11:36enough when discussing AI and the
- 11:38future of trading, which is that
- 11:40financial markets, despite all the
- 11:42technological developments we've seen,
- 11:44have always been influenced by an
- 11:46absolutely fundamental factor: human
- 11:48psychology. Look at the evolution of
- 11:51the markets over several centuries.
- 11:53Okay? You can look at the markets in
- 11:56the 19th century, in the 40s, in the
- 11:5880s, during the 2000 crisis, during the
- 12:002010s; the technology, the participants
- 12:02, and the execution methods were
- 12:04completely different from one era to
- 12:06another. And yet, what do we
- 12:08systematically find? Periods of
- 12:11euphoria, periods of panic, speculative
- 12:13bubbles, crashes, and human reactions
- 12:15that are sometimes completely excessive
- 12:16. Right? I'm thinking of 1929, I'm
- 12:19thinking of 1987, I'm thinking of 2000,
- 12:22I'm even thinking of Covid in March
- 12:242020. Okay. Radically different
- 12:27technological environments, and yet,
- 12:29each time we find the same mechanisms.
- 12:33Fear, uncertainty, excessive and
- 12:35unjustified optimism, speculation, and
- 12:38panic. Okay? Now, I'm not saying that
- 12:42all these crashes were solely caused by
- 12:44human emotions. There are obviously
- 12:47economic, monetary, and financial
- 12:49factors behind these movements. But the
- 12:52way investors react to these events and
- 12:55, let's say, their anticipation of the
- 12:58future, is really what causes price
- 13:01evolution and the fact that prices move
- 13:04. Right? And it is precisely in these
- 13:08moments that market inefficiencies can
- 13:11appear. One of the things I've learned
- 13:13from my experience is that it's not
- 13:15enough to understand economic
- 13:16information. Okay? You have to be able
- 13:19to understand, let's say, how other
- 13:21market participants will react to this
- 13:24economic information. All right? And
- 13:26that is exactly what is at the heart of
- 13:28my methodology and what I teach to
- 13:30traders in the Macro Trader Accelerator
- 13:32. I'll put the link in the description
- 13:34if you're interested, because my way of
- 13:36trading is absolutely not to look at,
- 13:37say, positive macroeconomic data and
- 13:39tell myself, "Ah, so I must buy." Or if
- 13:42the CPI comes out negative, "Ah, so I
- 13:44must sell." No, that is an extremely
- 13:46simplistic way of analyzing the markets
- 13:48. And if you trade like that in the
- 13:49long run, I can guarantee you that you
- 13:51will lose money. Let me give you an
- 13:52example. If you ask an AI what the
- 13:55impact of an interest rate hike should
- 13:57be on a currency? The AI will generally
- 14:01answer that, theoretically, higher
- 14:02rates make a currency more attractive
- 14:04and therefore should make it appreciate
- 14:06. And from a purely economic and
- 14:08theoretical point of view, that is
- 14:10consistent and correct. But does that
- 14:12mean that every time a central bank
- 14:14raises its rates, its currency will
- 14:15automatically gain value? Absolutely
- 14:17not. Because perhaps this hike was, in
- 14:20fact, already completely anticipated
- 14:22and integrated into the price. That’s
- 14:24what we call something that is "priced
- 14:26in," which is already included in the
- 14:27price. Maybe the markets were expecting
- 14:31an even bigger hike, let’s say, or
- 14:33maybe despite this hike, the central
- 14:35bank just announced that future
- 14:36decisions will be much calmer compared
- 14:38to the one that just took place. OK?
- 14:42And so in this kind of situation, you
- 14:44can very well have a central bank that
- 14:45raises its rates and its currency that
- 14:47crashes right after. Why? Because
- 14:51markets don't trade what just happened,
- 14:53they trade future expectations. It’s
- 14:55what we call a forward-looking
- 14:57mechanism. We trade future expectations
- 14:59and not what is happening today. OK?
- 15:02And that is exactly why in my trading,
- 15:05I seek above all to understand what I
- 15:07call the underlying macroeconomic
- 15:09narrative. OK? We have, if you will,
- 15:11the first level which is what is the
- 15:13current situation? What is driving the
- 15:15market? Is it geopolitics? Is it growth
- 15:18? Is it inflation? OK. What are
- 15:20investors 'expectations? That is the
- 15:23underlying narrative. Second level,
- 15:25once I have identified this narrative,
- 15:27I look at the positioning of the other
- 15:30market participants. Are investors
- 15:32already massively positioned in a
- 15:34certain direction, or what is already
- 15:37priced in? OK. And it's only after that
- 15:41that I look to identify the next events
- 15:43, the next data, or yeah, the next
- 15:45decisions, if you like, that could come
- 15:47to surprise these expectations, this
- 15:50underlying narrative. Because it is
- 15:54precisely when the market is surprised,
- 15:56when expectations change, that we can
- 15:58see significant repricing. And so
- 16:00before there is a repricing, there is
- 16:02therefore a mispricing. And that is
- 16:04where the opportunity lies. There, my
- 16:06job consists of understanding if this
- 16:08surprise we just saw really modifies
- 16:10the macro narrative and thus creates a
- 16:12new opposing trend, or if it is simply
- 16:15a, let's say, excessive short-term
- 16:16reaction that ultimately changes
- 16:18absolutely nothing about the
- 16:20fundamentals. And in this second case,
- 16:23for example, this excessive reaction
- 16:25can precisely offer me an opportunity
- 16:27to position myself in the direction of
- 16:29the initial narrative at a potentially
- 16:31much more attractive price. I hope you
- 16:34you grasp the difference. I'm not just
- 16:36looking to analyze a piece of data. I
- 16:39am looking to understand what the
- 16:41market expects, how the other
- 16:43participants are already positioned,
- 16:46and how new information could be
- 16:48interpreted and thus change their
- 16:50decisions. Right? And it is exactly
- 16:54this approach that combines
- 16:56macroeconomic analysis, the
- 16:58understanding of expectations,
- 16:59positioning, sentiment, and generally
- 17:02market psychology that I personally use
- 17:04. So now to come back to AI, yes, it
- 17:08can be extremely useful for analyzing
- 17:10certain data, identifying uh even
- 17:13trends, or studying the overall
- 17:15sentiment of investors. But its arrival
- 17:19does not make the human behaviors that
- 17:21influence the markets disappear. That
- 17:23will remain. So now, will AI make,
- 17:26let's say, certain market
- 17:27inefficiencies much more difficult to
- 17:30exploit? Maybe. Will it make all
- 17:34uncertainty, all excessive reactions,
- 17:36and all shifts in market expectations
- 17:38disappear? That, personally, I strongly
- 17:41doubt. OK? Because ultimately, tools
- 17:43change, and history has told us that.
- 17:47Technologies evolve, history has told
- 17:49us that too, but markets remain the
- 17:51reflection of the decisions,
- 17:53expectations, and emotions of millions
- 17:56of participants trading at the same
- 17:58time. And that, I think, will remain.
- 18:01So, to finally answer the question of
- 18:03this video a little bit, will AI
- 18:06replace traders? Personally, I don't
- 18:08think it will completely make this
- 18:09activity disappear. However, I do think
- 18:12it will potentially transform the
- 18:14profession over time. OK? And that it
- 18:18could make certain strategies and
- 18:19certain skills disappear and,
- 18:21conversely, cause new opportunities to
- 18:23flourish. OK? Maybe in 10 or 20 years,
- 18:26trading will potentially be completely
- 18:28different from today. It's possible.
- 18:31But that is my main point. Financial
- 18:35markets will remain markets—places
- 18:37where millions of participants make
- 18:39decisions, where capital flows, where
- 18:41expectations shift, and where
- 18:43uncertainty remains a constant. Agreed?
- 18:48And so, for me, as long as there are
- 18:50these shifts, these imbalances, and
- 18:53these uncertainties, there will be
- 18:55opportunities to exploit, with or
- 18:57without AI. But I want to end on a
- 19:01final point that is probably the most
- 19:03important in this entire video: I want
- 19:06you to keep in mind that just because
- 19:08you have access to the same tools as a
- 19:10professional trader doesn't mean you
- 19:12have the same skills as that
- 19:14professional trader. OK? And that is
- 19:18exactly the trap I see many people
- 19:20falling into today with ChatGPT or
- 19:22Claude—you can have analysis software
- 19:25, trading bots, even paid services or
- 19:27quantitative tools. But if you don't
- 19:31have a real understanding of the
- 19:33markets behind it all, and no
- 19:35methodology with a proven statistical
- 19:37edge, all you have are tools, and
- 19:39anyone can have tools. That hasn't been
- 19:42the difficulty for a long time, except
- 19:44maybe back in the 50s. So my advice,
- 19:46whether you're already a trader or just
- 19:48starting out, is don't fear AI, but
- 19:50don't fall for the marketing that
- 19:52promises this technology will solve all
- 19:54your trading problems, okay? Learn your
- 19:58trade, develop a real strategy, measure
- 20:00your results, track absolutely
- 20:02everything—I've already told you that
- 20:04—and only then use new technologies
- 20:07when they actually add value. Because
- 20:10AI can potentially make a good trader
- 20:12even better, but it won't magically
- 20:14turn someone who knows nothing into a
- 20:17profitable trader who suddenly becomes
- 20:19a multi-millionaire, I can guarantee
- 20:21you that. And by the way, I'd be
- 20:23curious to get your opinion: are you,
- 20:26watching this video, already using AI
- 20:28in your trading? And above all, has
- 20:32using AI in your trading actually made
- 20:34you better—has it objectively
- 20:36improved your results in a way that you
- 20:38can quantify? Anyway, let me know in
- 20:42the comments; I'd be really curious to
- 20:44know. On that note, I sincerely hope
- 20:46you liked my take on this topic and
- 20:48that I was right to stay on the
- 20:50sidelines all these years instead of
- 20:52just making videos to get lots of views
- 20:54on the latest way to use Claude or
- 20:56ChatGPT to become a profitable trader.
- 20:58With that, this was Elliot. See you in
- 21:00next week's video. Ciao!
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of L'IA va-t-elle remplacer les traders? by Elliot Hewitt - YoungTraderWealth, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,313 words across 533 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.