L’Experte du Microbiote : Ce qui vous empêche VRAIMENT de perdre du poids (Dr Cotinat) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Can we have a microbiota that appears
- 0:02normal but is profoundly dysfunctional?
- 0:05Anyway, when there is a malfunctioning
- 0:06microbiota, it doesn't come from the
- 0:07microbiota itself. I’ve known people
- 0:09who ate incredible amounts of sugar.
- 0:11For example, even in pasta. So there,
- 0:13you need to get help. I am a
- 0:14gastroenterologist by training. I
- 0:16practiced traditional gastroenterology
- 0:18for quite a few years. I quickly
- 0:20shifted towards nutritional
- 0:22modification, phytotherapy, and
- 0:23aromatherapy. For someone who eats
- 0:25according to their needs, would they
- 0:27gain weight because they have an
- 0:29imbalanced microbiota?
- 0:30You stop eating fiber, you only eat
- 0:32ultra-processed products, meat, sugar,
- 0:33and you unbalance your microbiota in 24
- 0:35to 48 hours.
- 0:36Regarding a temporary imbalance, can we
- 0:38recover from it fairly quickly?
- 0:40We can lose certain strains completely.
- 0:42It’s quite incredible to think that
- 0:44we can change our moods or even have a
- 0:46different personality depending on our
- 0:48microbiota.
- 0:49And it is also the idea for future
- 0:51therapy and future diagnostics.
- 0:52That we will have identified specific
- 0:54strains that will create a depressive
- 0:55pattern, others that might create a
- 0:57pattern of ambition.
- 0:58Well, that’s a thing, that’s a
- 0:59great question. Can you be thin and
- 1:01have an imbalanced microbiota? A simple
- 1:12little question. Can we have a
- 1:15microbiota that appears normal, where
- 1:17we feel like everything is fine, but it
- 1:19is profoundly dysfunctional? Does that
- 1:22exist in your opinion? Well, perhaps we
- 1:27should define the microbiota a little
- 1:29bit for everyone so that everyone
- 1:31understands. Here, we are talking about
- 1:34the gut microbiota because, in fact,
- 1:37the gut microbiota is this huge tribe
- 1:40of microbes living together in our
- 1:42intestine. But well, you have to
- 1:47understand that there are microbiotas
- 1:50everywhere around us: in the soil, in
- 1:53plants, in the air, in the sky, and
- 1:55deep in the seas. So, there are
- 1:58microbiotas everywhere. And, at the
- 2:01human body level, there are some
- 2:02everywhere too, throughout the whole
- 2:04human body. However, it is in the
- 2:07intestine where we have the largest
- 2:09tribe of microbes, and that is why
- 2:12scientists from all over the world have
- 2:14taken a huge interest in this gut
- 2:17microbiota because we realized it was
- 2:19so numerous that it contributes to many
- 2:22pathologies, both digestive and
- 2:24extra-digestive. Your question, if I
- 2:27translate—is this what you mean—
- 2:29it's asking: can one have a total
- 2:31absence of digestive symptoms while
- 2:32having a dysfunctional microbiota?
- 2:34That's sort of the idea, actually.
- 2:36Exactly,
- 2:36that is pretty much the idea, exactly.
- 2:38Yes, indeed, and that is misleading,
- 2:40meaning we can have an intestinal
- 2:43microbiota that we don't particularly
- 2:46feel. Meaning the stomach is not
- 2:48sensitive, not painful, there are no
- 2:49transit issues, there is nothing, there
- 2:51are no symptoms at all. Yet, on the
- 2:54other hand, there are conditions that
- 2:56suggest the existence of an imbalanced
- 2:59intestinal microbiota, and that is
- 3:01relatively common in everything we
- 3:03observe, in all the lifestyle diseases
- 3:06we encounter today, such as diabetes,
- 3:08obesity, and so on. Well, in many
- 3:11conditions, of course, whether
- 3:13digestive or non-digestive—but here
- 3:15we are outside of digestive diseases—
- 3:17but yes, of course, in rheumatoid
- 3:19arthritis, etc., autoimmune diseases.
- 3:22Yes. Exactly. So, indeed, it is very
- 3:25misleading, and we will perhaps see
- 3:28later, at some point or now as you wish
- 3:30, what can alert us, what are the signs
- 3:33that will alert us, that will tell us,
- 3:35"Hey, our microbiota is actually
- 3:37malfunctioning." So we can look at it
- 3:40right away. Well, in what circumstances
- 3:43can we imagine that our microbiota is
- 3:44malfunctioning, that it's not perfectly
- 3:46optimal? Well, for example, if one is
- 3:49sick, yes, if one is sick, whether we
- 3:52have digestive or non-digestive
- 3:53diseases, if we take medication,
- 3:55because if we take medication, well,
- 3:58that means we have a chronic illness.
- 4:01If we have biological blood markers
- 4:04that are disrupted, meaning, for
- 4:06example, an increase in blood sugar, an
- 4:08increase in cholesterol, triglycerides,
- 4:11etc. Uh, yes. So, and then if we aren't
- 4:15feeling completely well in our head, if
- 4:17we are depressed, if we are anxious,
- 4:19etc., well, all these signs point to a
- 4:21microbiota that is malfunctioning.
- 4:24Understood? So, from the moment there
- 4:28is an imbalance or clinical signs of
- 4:31major dysfunction, it means that,
- 4:34possibly, the microbiota is one of the
- 4:38causes.
- 4:39So, the microbiota, the microbiota,
- 4:41Jérôme, it means it is disturbed. And
- 4:44right now, we have a lot of trouble
- 4:47saying whether an accompanying state of
- 4:52affairs, etc. We have a lot of trouble
- 4:55thinking. Well, I think it contributes
- 4:58a lot to the progression and worsening
- 5:00of the disease, but it's true that for
- 5:02many conditions, we haven't solved
- 5:03everything yet. Exactly, so it's still
- 5:06part of the uncertainties at the moment
- 5:08. But in any case, by working on the
- 5:11microbiota, we can improve the
- 5:13pathology. So that's already quite
- 5:15interesting. It's one of the
- 5:17pathophysiological mechanisms that is
- 5:19part of the disease.
- 5:21Right. Is it possible to have diseases
- 5:24without there being any dysfunction of
- 5:27the microbiota, where it actually has
- 5:29absolutely no impact? Is that possible?
- 5:32Well, I'm not aware of any, but why not
- 5:35? But I'm not aware of any. There you
- 5:37go. No knowledge. Most of the time,
- 5:40when we look, we find. I mean, I have
- 5:43patients who have asked me very, very
- 5:45complex questions, for example: "Can I
- 5:48have a disturbed gut microbiota when,
- 5:50for example, I have an eye disease,
- 5:52like glaucoma, and...""...so on?" And
- 5:56it's true that when you look at what's
- 5:58in the international literature, well,
- 6:00it's true that we always find, we
- 6:01always find answers, so we always find
- 6:03disturbed microbiota. Well, so, anyway,
- 6:07yes, we can always find it in somewhat
- 6:10atypical pathologies, we will find it.
- 6:14I imagine the biggest difficulty is
- 6:16managing to confirm a cause-and-effect
- 6:18link, because just because there is
- 6:20glaucoma and an imbalance in the
- 6:22microbiota at the same time doesn't
- 6:23mean the two are linked. Maybe they are
- 6:25two things that are completely separate
- 6:27.
- 6:27Are there other factors that can add up
- 6:28? Of course. Absolutely. That's the
- 6:30difficulty, is that there are surely,
- 6:32there are always other factors. In any
- 6:33case, when there is a microbiota that
- 6:35is malfunctioning, it doesn't come from
- 6:36itself. So we will surely see it at
- 6:38some point in the discussion, but there
- 6:41are tons of causes that promote the
- 6:43dysfunction of the microbiota. So we
- 6:45are also partly responsible for this
- 6:47dysfunction. So all of that is part of
- 6:51a multitude of causes that combine to
- 6:54trigger the disease or worsen it. And
- 6:59is it possible to have an imbalance, a
- 7:01problem with the microbiota that does
- 7:04not necessarily manifest in terms of
- 7:06disease or symptoms? Regardless of the
- 7:08area? Can we have dysfunctional
- 7:12imbalances for years that do not
- 7:14manifest themselves? And at some point,
- 7:18is it inevitably going to show? Uh, I
- 7:22think if the microbiota malfunctions
- 7:24for years, uh, I think at some point,
- 7:27uh, normally, theoretically, things
- 7:29must happen, because, in fact, you have
- 7:32to understand that this gut microbiota
- 7:34participates in many, many functions
- 7:37within the body. But very many—
- 7:39meaning that, basically, I don't mean
- 7:41it in a bad way, but I always say they
- 7:43meddle in everything, actually. Yes,
- 7:45but it participates in everything, and
- 7:47we really need it to work with us
- 7:49because, in fact, we work as true
- 7:51partners; there are things we cannot do
- 7:53without it. So we are completely
- 7:56dependent on it. So it's hard to
- 7:59imagine that a microbiota that is
- 8:00malfunctioning could correspond to a
- 8:02state of optimal health. That seems
- 8:05difficult to imagine because, well, it
- 8:08synthesizes vitamins, it promotes the
- 8:10digestion of fibers that we don't know
- 8:12how to digest, it manufactures
- 8:14extraordinary molecules from fibers
- 8:17called short-chain fatty acids, which
- 8:19will play a fabulous role in all immune
- 8:21regulation, inflammatory regulation,
- 8:24and so on, of our body. And we know
- 8:26that inflammation is the basis of all
- 8:28current chronic diseases. Uh, so it's
- 8:31hard to imagine. Yeah. Okay. Well, to
- 8:36scare everyone, today, if we talk in
- 8:39terms of population and even evolution
- 8:43and demographics, is our microbiota in
- 8:46French-speaking countries in worse
- 8:49shape than elsewhere, or in worse shape
- 8:53than before? Have we observed any
- 8:57changes?
- 8:57Yes, we certainly have. Well, first of
- 9:00all, we notice it clinically because
- 9:02over the last few years that I've been
- 9:05practicing, it's true that we realized
- 9:08that all chronic diseases were
- 9:10increasing in frequency and, above all,
- 9:12were appearing earlier and earlier in
- 9:15our patients. Those were things we
- 9:18didn't see 30 or 40 years ago. Cancers
- 9:21appearing at age 35, well, we didn't
- 9:24see that. So, in fact, we have seen
- 9:27this degradation. So if there is
- 9:30degradation and an increase in all
- 9:33these current diseases we call diseases
- 9:36of civilization, well, that corresponds
- 9:39quite well to a somewhat harmful
- 9:41evolution of our microbiota. And
- 9:45furthermore, in all these pathologies,
- 9:47we have noticed that there is a
- 9:49decrease in biodiversity. So, a decline
- 9:53in biodiversity. And what's interesting
- 9:55, and what has always intrigued me too,
- 9:58is that you see, we are in a perpetual
- 10:00relationship with nature, and in nature
- 10:02, you also observe this decline in
- 10:05biodiversity. The planet is also
- 10:08experiencing some of the same
- 10:09pathologies as human beings, so we are
- 10:11linked, in fact, for life, with our
- 10:13entire environment. And people need to
- 10:18realize this, that when, for example,
- 10:21they eat vegetables that come from soil
- 10:24that is hyper-farmed,
- 10:25hyper-industrialized, full of
- 10:27pesticides, etc., they won't get a
- 10:30vegetable that is very rich
- 10:32nutritionally or microbiologically.
- 10:36Because you have to understand that all
- 10:38vegetables and fruits have a microbiota
- 10:40, and that the microbiota will differ
- 10:43depending on how they are grown. ure
- 10:46often. And so, you ingest this
- 10:48microbiota, and of course, it will also
- 10:51modify the evolution of your own
- 10:53intestinal microbiota. So you have to
- 10:56understand that we are completely
- 10:57linked to our environment, and people
- 10:59aren't very aware of this yet. They
- 11:02tend to start protecting their health
- 11:04while forgetting that you also have to
- 11:06protect the environment to protect your
- 11:08health. When you say the biodiversity
- 11:12of the microbiota, is that the number
- 11:14of bacterial populations, the great
- 11:17diversity of bacterial populations?
- 11:20That's right.
- 11:22Well, actually, an imbalanced
- 11:23microbiota manifests itself in three
- 11:25ways. First, pathogens—meaning
- 11:28pathogenic microbes that aren't good
- 11:31for our health—are present in
- 11:33slightly higher numbers. Those are what
- 11:36we call pro-inflammatory, meaning those
- 11:38that will further promote inflammation
- 11:41in the body. Then, you have protective
- 11:44bacteria, which, conversely, are in
- 11:46freefall, meaning they are really
- 11:47decreasing. And alongside that, you
- 11:50also have a drop in biodiversity. So,
- 11:52you have these three parameters, and in
- 11:55studies, what we generally find most
- 11:57often is this decline in biodiversity
- 12:00—in all countries, or are we only
- 12:02talking about France or Europe? Yes.
- 12:06Well, especially in industrialized
- 12:08countries, we see this drop and these
- 12:11microbiota disturbances much more than
- 12:13in less industrialized ones, where
- 12:16people have kept a connection to the
- 12:18land, eat more fiber, a more
- 12:20plant-based diet, and so on. So of
- 12:24course, yes, this corresponds to a very
- 12:25industrial diet, and the more
- 12:27hyper-industrial the diet is, with an
- 12:28increase in ultra-processed foods and
- 12:30so on, the more the microbiota will be
- 12:32depleted. I see. And the more this
- 12:37microbiota is depleted, the less
- 12:38diverse it will be in terms of strains
- 12:41and families, so to speak, the more
- 12:43prone we will be to developing
- 12:44deficiencies, deficits, and internal
- 12:47imbalances, since the microbiota itself
- 12:49helps create micronutrients. That's
- 12:51right. So it ends up unbalancing the
- 12:53whole system a bit.
- 12:53Of course, we become unbalanced.
- 12:55Certainly.
- 12:55Before we continue the episode, I have
- 12:57something exclusive to offer you. If
- 12:59you enjoy the Biomechanic podcast, then
- 13:00you will love the Biomechanic
- 13:02newsletter. It's a bit like the hidden
- 13:03version of the podcast, reserved for my
- 13:05subscribers. At the beginning of each
- 13:06month, I share my best discoveries for
- 13:08optimizing your health, improving your
- 13:09training, and increasing your longevity
- 13:11. You'll also find personal reflections
- 13:12on controversial topics and
- 13:14behind-the-scenes anecdotes about the
- 13:15podcast that you won't find anywhere
- 13:17else. I also reveal my personal
- 13:18recommendations for books, films, and
- 13:21documentaries that I consider
- 13:22unmissable. It's free, it takes only a
- 13:24few minutes to read, and if you don't
- 13:25like it, you can unsubscribe in a
- 13:27single click. So why not give it a try?
- 13:29And be aware, each newsletter is sent
- 13:30out only once. And if you aren't
- 13:32already subscribed, well, you've
- 13:33already missed all the previous ones.
- 13:34So, not to miss the next one, scroll
- 13:36down the description, click the last
- 13:38link that appears, and join the
- 13:39Biomechanic newsletter right away. Now,
- 13:43what is quite fascinating about the
- 13:46microbiota is that I have heard that,
- 13:48depending on the populations around the
- 13:52world and the location, the
- 13:54distribution of microbiota strains
- 13:57varies, and that it is currently
- 13:59difficult to have a kind of perfect map
- 14:02of the perfect microbiota, since it can
- 14:06be completely different from one
- 14:09country to another and yet still be
- 14:12considered very functional.
- 14:14It goes even further than that, because
- 14:16in reality, the microbiota is different
- 14:18from one person to another, even within
- 14:19the same country. That's why scientists
- 14:22have a lot of trouble defining what a
- 14:24normal microbiota actually is. And
- 14:26that's why it takes so long to
- 14:30standardize the technique for analyzing
- 14:32the microbiota. That's why it's not
- 14:35obvious yet because, you know, it's not
- 14:37simple; we're doing it, but it's still
- 14:39not easy to analyze. So we must always
- 14:43take the clinical picture into account
- 14:46to analyze it, because as you say, we
- 14:48don't have a defined optimal or perfect
- 14:51microbiota, since everything depends on
- 14:54the balance between the different
- 14:56strains. You have to understand that
- 14:59everything depends on the balance
- 15:01between pathogenic bacteria, protective
- 15:03bacteria, and so on, and then on the
- 15:06richness of that biodiversity. Which
- 15:09would mean that clinics or services
- 15:13that offer microbiota testing to see if
- 15:16there's an imbalance and to rebalance
- 15:19it are a bit of a marketing scam. So,
- 15:23I personally don't think it's a scam,
- 15:25it's progress. Meaning they are a
- 15:27little ahead of the curve, and well, it
- 15:30may be moving things forward, but you
- 15:32have to be careful; it's mainly in the
- 15:34interpretation that you must remain
- 15:36very pragmatic and close to the
- 15:37clinical reality. And that is the
- 15:40difficulty; it's more of an
- 15:42interpretation problem, meaning you
- 15:44really have to interpret it in relation
- 15:46to a specific person. Exactly. And that
- 15:49is the great difficulty. So that means
- 15:51the analysis must be very, very
- 15:53personalized by people who are used to
- 15:54reading them. And that is, that is the
- 15:57difficulty, actually. Or
- 16:00but it will become a routine test
- 16:02tomorrow, because tomorrow we won't be
- 16:05able to prescribe medications, like
- 16:07chemotherapy for breast cancer for
- 16:09example, without having a microbiota
- 16:11analysis because the results depend
- 16:13entirely on the gut microbiota. So we
- 16:17won't be able to do without it; it will
- 16:19become a routine exam.
- 16:22I see. So a bit like any other
- 16:27supplementary test, it must be
- 16:28supported by the clinical picture to
- 16:31get a general overview, the patient's
- 16:33background and context.
- 16:35Because the current difficulty is that
- 16:37every individual's microbiota is not
- 16:39only different from one person to
- 16:41another, but it also varies a bit over
- 16:43time based on various criteria. Well,
- 16:46for example, stress and diet. With an
- 16:50unbalanced diet, you can unbalance your
- 16:52microbiota in 3 days. Yes, it's very
- 16:54easy. You stop eating fiber, you only
- 16:57eat ultra-processed foods, meat, sugar,
- 16:59etc., and you unbalance your microbiota
- 17:02in 24 to 48 hours; it unbalances very
- 17:04quickly. Then, it will also depend on
- 17:07the medications you use. Medications
- 17:10have a significant effect on the
- 17:13microbiota, and it really depends on
- 17:16the effects of those drugs and many
- 17:19other factors that make one person's
- 17:22microbiota different from another.
- 17:28And in the case of a temporary
- 17:30imbalance like that over three days,
- 17:33can we recover fairly quickly? Yeah.
- 17:35Yes, we'll recover more slowly than we
- 17:37lost it, but we will recover, of course
- 17:39. Yes. Yes. However, with antibiotics,
- 17:41we can lose certain strains completely.
- 17:44Yeah. Some may return. I've seen
- 17:48patients who only regained proper bowel
- 17:49function after a year to feel really,
- 17:51really, very good. So it can be a long
- 17:54process to find a new balance, and
- 17:56often we do find a new balance, but not
- 17:58necessarily the same one we had before,
- 18:01because, well, we did indeed kill off
- 18:03certain strains. So yes, medications
- 18:06can be harmful. For example, proton
- 18:09pump inhibitors given for acid reflux
- 18:12can also be harmful to the microbiota.
- 18:14Right. Yes. So there are many drugs
- 18:17that can be harmful, and well, I think
- 18:19in a few years, we will perhaps be
- 18:21better at managing medications based on
- 18:24each person's microbiota and perhaps
- 18:26better protect that microbiota when we
- 18:28really need to prescribe a drug. So
- 18:33this means that for those who have
- 18:35clinical symptoms they can't seem to
- 18:36get rid of, and whose cause they don't
- 18:38necessarily understand. It is possible
- 18:41that, months or even years earlier, due
- 18:44to taking a medication or a few days of
- 18:47poor diet, there may have been gut
- 18:49imbalances that persist for months and
- 18:52months and could perhaps be the source
- 18:55of issues that seem unrelated and for
- 18:58which we can't find a cause. Well, it's
- 19:01true that, since the imbalance of the
- 19:05microbiota is called dysbiosis. Since
- 19:08intestinal dysbiosis is part of the
- 19:11pathophysiological mechanisms of
- 19:14diseases, just like inflammation,
- 19:16increased intestinal permeability, and
- 19:20so on. It is true that when we work on
- 19:23the microbiota, even if we aren't quite
- 19:25sure, well, we've explored the
- 19:27pathology and haven't really found a
- 19:29solution. The disease becomes more or
- 19:31less chronic. We don't really know how
- 19:33to get rid of it. It's true that
- 19:35working on your microbiota can only be
- 19:37beneficial because, in fact, you're
- 19:39working toward an optimal lifestyle, so
- 19:41in any case, it won't do any harm and
- 19:42it can only improve the situation, of
- 19:44course. So it's a very elegant way,
- 19:49perhaps, to bypass the problem by
- 19:52nurturing it again. We will see later
- 19:56how to try to nurture it, exactly.
- 19:58What's interesting is understanding a
- 20:00bit about how this dysbiosis works.
- 20:04Normally, bacterial populations are
- 20:07supposed to be found in the large
- 20:09intestine and not in the small
- 20:11intestine, sorry. Are we already in
- 20:14agreement on that? Well, you should
- 20:17know that they are actually everywhere
- 20:18throughout the digestive tract, that
- 20:20there are many in the mouth, that they
- 20:22pass into the esophagus, and at the
- 20:23stomach level, it's only partially
- 20:25sterilized because not all bacteria
- 20:27will necessarily be killed by the acid.
- 20:29So, there is a significant drop in the
- 20:32number of bacteria, and little by
- 20:34little, it gradually increases to reach
- 20:37a maximum in the large intestine, in
- 20:40the colon. Exactly. But they are
- 20:42everywhere.
- 20:43But the colon bacteria must not move
- 20:45back up into the small intestine,
- 20:46otherwise, we are dealing with a case
- 20:48of intestinal dysbiosis. Is that
- 20:50correct?
- 20:51That's no longer called intestinal
- 20:52dysbiosis. It's called small intestinal
- 20:54bacterial overgrowth, or now it's also
- 20:56called SIBO. So, indeed, it can cause
- 21:00problems when there is an excess of
- 21:02bacteria in the small intestine. So, we
- 21:07will notice it, for example, in certain
- 21:09surgeries, when we remove, for instance
- 21:12, the valve that connects the small
- 21:14intestine to the large colon during a
- 21:16right hemicolectomy, meaning when half
- 21:19of the right colon is removed along
- 21:21with this little valve, creating a
- 21:23direct circuit between the small
- 21:25intestine and the colon. So we can
- 21:29easily imagine that there are no longer
- 21:32any little doors locking those two
- 21:35areas. And for example, also in the
- 21:40case of chronic users of medications
- 21:42that block acidity because if we block
- 21:45the acidity, well, we will have an
- 21:48influx of bacteria located higher up
- 21:51with an imbalance. So, of course, one
- 21:54must be wary of this chronic use.
- 21:58Exactly. So there are plenty of other
- 21:59causes, right. There are diverse causes
- 22:01as well, all the surgical causes, and
- 22:04so on.
- 22:05And so what’s quite interesting is
- 22:08that I discovered, uh, not so long ago
- 22:10that there is also a nasal microbiota.
- 22:13So, there’s the oral microbiota, the
- 22:14nasal microbiota. Uh, are we at the
- 22:17beginning of, uh, mapping it, so to
- 22:20speak, or is it something that’s been
- 22:23known for a long time?
- 22:25Well, we know there are microbiotas
- 22:26everywhere, right. Okay? There’s a
- 22:29microbiota in the mouth, there’s a
- 22:31specific microbiota in, uh, when you
- 22:33have periodontitis, for example,
- 22:35there’s a very disturbed microbiota
- 22:37found there. So yes, we know there are
- 22:39microbiotas everywhere. There are, for
- 22:43example, disturbed microbiotas in blood
- 22:46tumors, for example, right. So we know
- 22:48the gut microbiota is disturbed, but
- 22:50there is also a disturbed blood
- 22:52microbiota, and so on. So yes, there
- 22:54are microbiotas everywhere
- 22:57actually. The, the, yes, we are
- 23:00bacteria, we are surrounded, invaded,
- 23:02infested by bacteria.
- 23:05No, we are, we are inhabited.
- 23:07Inhabited, that’s better. I had a
- 23:09patient who always said, "We are like
- 23:11little planets and we are completely
- 23:13inhabited." And I said, "Yes, that’s
- 23:14it, it’s very lovely. That’s it, we
- 23:16are actually inhabited."
- 23:18So, there’s a very big topic
- 23:19concerning the microbiota and weight
- 23:21gain, sugar. Uh, there’s supposedly a
- 23:25theory that at the same caloric intake,
- 23:29one could gain weight, uh, because of a
- 23:32microbiota problem. First, let’s talk
- 23:35only about weight gain. So, someone who
- 23:37eats to match their needs would gain
- 23:40weight because they have an imbalanced
- 23:42microbiota. Are we in the realm of pure
- 23:44fantasy? Is it possible? Does it defy
- 23:47the laws of physics and thermodynamics?
- 23:51But this microbiota is absolutely
- 23:53fabulous. And by the way, it’s one of
- 23:56the books I wrote, I don’t know if
- 23:57you know it, Jérôme, it’s called "
- 23:59Slimming Down with Pleasure by Charming
- 24:01Your Bacteria." And it’s true, where
- 24:05I detailed the problem of this
- 24:07microbiota being disturbed in these
- 24:10weight issues, and we realize that
- 24:12indeed, the disturbed microbiota
- 24:15disrupts many mechanisms in our body.
- 24:19For example, it increases the caloric
- 24:20extraction from food. Indeed, we
- 24:22extract more calories from food. It
- 24:26increases intestinal absorption of
- 24:28nutrients, for example. Uh, it
- 24:31increases intestinal permeability.
- 24:35There, it creates inflammation,
- 24:37intestinal inflammation in the body,
- 24:39general, neuroinflammation. So we can
- 24:43imagine how far this will go. Insulin
- 24:46resistance, leptin resistance. And so
- 24:49there, we clearly understand that all
- 24:51these mechanisms are indeed mechanisms
- 24:53that cause weight gain because they
- 24:55also play a role in affecting fat
- 24:57storage.
- 24:59All right. So I understand the
- 25:02micro-factors that, put together, will
- 25:05lead to storing more calories. But to
- 25:09what extent does this happen for
- 25:11someone who has a need of, let's say,
- 25:142,000 calories a day and who consumes
- 25:16quality food, so no processed foods,
- 25:18raw food, 2,000 calories; what would
- 25:21the impact be? 5%more weight gain, 1%?
- 25:28I can't tell you the percentages, no, I
- 25:30don't think I can tell you that. What I
- 25:33can tell you is that by restoring a
- 25:36diet adapted to the microbiota, frankly
- 25:39, people lose weight again. That's
- 25:42important because that's actually what
- 25:44people want: to get back to a normal
- 25:46weight. And if we really take care of
- 25:49the microbiota's needs, we recover
- 25:51because, in fact, the microbiota's
- 25:53needs correspond exactly to the needs
- 25:55we also have for our health. And so,
- 25:58ultimately, that is why we are
- 25:59completely linked for life. And there,
- 26:02we have great results, really great
- 26:04results. So yes, I invite everyone, all
- 26:06people who have weight problems to
- 26:09wonder, to worry about perhaps
- 26:11pampering, feeding their gut microbiota
- 26:13better. Of course, that's interesting.
- 26:17So, just to tease a little bit on that,
- 26:19isn't it simply because they eat better
- 26:22, that by rebalancing their diet, there
- 26:24is necessarily a caloric reduction,
- 26:27there is less sugar, less saturated fat
- 26:29, less trans fat even?
- 26:31Of course. And then, when we have less
- 26:33saturated fat, less...That's why I tell
- 26:35you: the diet for it and for us is the
- 26:36same. Because as soon as you have a
- 26:39diet that corresponds to an optimal
- 26:41state of health, it actually promotes a
- 26:43good microbiota. And as soon as you
- 26:46find a good balance in the microbiota,
- 26:48there is no more disturbance, no more
- 26:50dysbiosis, no more inflammation, no
- 26:52more insulin resistance, no more...So,
- 26:55in fact, you modify all these
- 26:56parameters by modifying the gut
- 26:58microbiota. And have you ever had
- 27:03patients or people come to you who have
- 27:06a bit of a borderline diet, a bit
- 27:09high-calorie, maybe too much sugar, and
- 27:13who feel they aren't eating that poorly
- 27:16and easily blame their microbiota for
- 27:19their weight gain instead of their
- 27:22simple lifestyle? Uh, I imagine there
- 27:26are many who come to see you in that
- 27:27case because you'll be a bit of a
- 27:28savior for them. Do you ever have to
- 27:31set the record straight and say, "This
- 27:32isn't a microbiota problem"?
- 27:36You have to understand that when the
- 27:38microbiota is disrupted, you have to
- 27:40realize it's like living on a desert
- 27:42island in our gut, and in the end, who
- 27:44houses and feeds it? Well, it's us,
- 27:46isn't it? So, we really have to take
- 27:48that factor into account; it's
- 27:50important. So, we have a very important
- 27:53role to play in feeding it because by
- 27:56feeding the good bacteria, we make them
- 27:59proliferate. Depends on the others.
- 28:02When you bring in rather harmful foods,
- 28:05you are feeding other types of bacteria
- 28:07that are much more pro-inflammatory and
- 28:10that will promote pathologies. So,
- 28:13indeed, you see, it makes perfect sense
- 28:16. It's completely logical. You really
- 28:20have to understand that the gut is,
- 28:22well, it's like a desert island, and
- 28:24they are waiting to be fed by us; they
- 28:26wait for the market every day.
- 28:30Can we have specific cravings for
- 28:32certain tastes or foods depending on
- 28:35our microbiota? I'm saying this
- 28:39specifically regarding sugar, where
- 28:41we've heard several times that certain
- 28:44microbiota imbalances could lead to a
- 28:46much higher craving for sugar, which
- 28:49would then explain a calorie surplus,
- 28:51which would then explain weight gain.
- 28:54Uh, is that, then, is that really the
- 28:56case? Could that also be the case with
- 28:58other types of food? This famous
- 29:00microbiota that demands things, and so
- 29:02we have a craving for carrots, a
- 29:03craving for, I don't know, other things
- 29:04, fat, sugar, or whatever because of it
- 29:06? It has been well demonstrated with
- 29:09sugar, indeed. So with sugar, it has
- 29:11been well demonstrated, and it seems
- 29:13very easy to understand. Meaning that
- 29:16when you have a diet very high in sugar
- 29:18—and generally it's not just high in
- 29:20sugar, it's also high in
- 29:21ultra-processed foods—well, of course
- 29:23, you're going to select certain types
- 29:26of specific bacteria that feed more on
- 29:28it, therefore proliferate and produce.
- 29:32Because actually, the problem isn't
- 29:34that they proliferate, the problem is
- 29:35that they are real factories, these,
- 29:37these, these bacteria: they have
- 29:38quantities of enzymes that are much
- 29:40greater than our own, and that's why
- 29:41they are useful to us. When we have the
- 29:46right bacteria, because actually they
- 29:47will supplement our, I was going to say
- 29:49our deficiencies. Yes, a little bit,
- 29:52because we have a slight weakness in
- 29:54terms of enzymes and they really have
- 29:57an absolutely incredible enzymatic
- 29:59arsenal that will completely complement
- 30:01our own. And so, when we have selected
- 30:04less beneficial bacteria, they will
- 30:06produce metabolites that are less
- 30:08beneficial, meaning products that are
- 30:11much less good for our health. And
- 30:14which will promote hunger because, in
- 30:16fact, what they want is to continue
- 30:18eating even more sugar. Exactly. And so
- 30:21, through various metabolisms, etc., by
- 30:24way of tryptophan, by way of
- 30:26inflammation, etc., there will be many
- 30:29little pathways also that will be
- 30:31induced and will promote this hunger
- 30:33signal. I want more. In fact, there is
- 30:37also the dopamine circuit, all that, it
- 30:40all kicks in at the same time and all
- 30:42of that is indeed linked to microbiota
- 30:44dysbiosis. H
- 30:47And so that will create cravings. And
- 30:48someone who, um
- 30:50Well, I don't know, I imagine it's very
- 30:52individual-dependent, some might
- 30:53perhaps manage to
- 30:57stop
- 30:59uh, yeah. To thwart these cravings
- 31:01through a kind of mental strength,
- 31:03motivation, or something else. Others
- 31:06will have more difficulty, others will
- 31:08have such a strong appetite for sugar
- 31:10that even with all the willpower in the
- 31:12world, they won't manage to do it. I'm
- 31:15trying to cover a bit of the whole
- 31:16spectrum. Is what I'm saying true, or
- 31:17is there still a certain limit? You
- 31:19can't have no appetite. I mean, could
- 31:21everyone manage to control themselves
- 31:23and rebalance their microbiota or not?
- 31:25Well, a large portion of people, once
- 31:27they understand how it works. That's
- 31:30why it's so important to understand,
- 31:32because if someone tells you, "Well,
- 31:33you eat too much sugar, stop eating
- 31:35sugar tomorrow." Yes, I agree. Uh, it's
- 31:37it's not it's not that simple if you
- 31:39don't understand why you're doing it.
- 31:42If you understand that you're
- 31:43effectively stopping the feeding of
- 31:45bacteria, and by stopping the feeding
- 31:46of bacteria that crave sugar, you'll
- 31:48actually make them die off completely,
- 31:50and you won't have that sugar craving
- 31:52anymore, you can see that it's actually
- 31:54worth making the effort. After that, if
- 31:56you really can't because you've
- 31:58exceeded your own capacity or
- 32:00capabilities, etc., you need to get
- 32:02help. Of course, get help. Hypnosis
- 32:05works well for all these addictions,
- 32:06you know. Right, it works quite well.
- 32:08So you need to get help from a
- 32:10therapist, or otherwise get help with
- 32:12supplements, certain dietary
- 32:13supplements, and so on; we have
- 32:15supplements that can also help limit
- 32:17this sugar addiction. So yes, get help,
- 32:20don't stay all alone in your corner
- 32:22continuing to eat so much sugar.
- 32:25OK. So the goal is to rebalance your
- 32:29diet to rebalance your microbiota, to
- 32:31kill off these bacteria that are too
- 32:33greedy for sugar, or rather, that make
- 32:36us crave sugar too much. Uh, and if
- 32:40this this this this stage is very
- 32:42difficult, you might as well try to get
- 32:46support to have the, shall we say, the
- 32:49right mindset to not relapse. Is there,
- 32:53today, have we identified these
- 32:55bacteria, this specific group of
- 32:57bacteria that are very fond of sugar,
- 33:00so we could, I don't know, kill them in
- 33:03a targeted way?
- 33:05But isn't it simpler to just stop
- 33:06feeding them? Oh no, but for me yes,
- 33:11for me yes, but for many people, it
- 33:12would be nice if I could just kill them
- 33:14off all at once.
- 33:15Kill them, for example, with
- 33:16antibiotics, we'll kill others, uh,
- 33:18there we go, we'll kill others and, and
- 33:20so we'll cause damage. Uh, whereas here
- 33:23, we simply remove the sugar and we
- 33:25solve the problem. That seems more
- 33:28eco-friendly to me.
- 33:32Yeah, yeah, yeah. And for those who, uh
- 33:34, for those who are struggling, who
- 33:35want to say, "Hey, if I could just do
- 33:37it overnight,"
- 33:38you have to get help, Jérôme, you
- 33:40shouldn't stay all alone in your corner
- 33:41, because I've known people who ate
- 33:42incredible amounts of sugar. Uh, for
- 33:45example, even in pasta where the amount
- 33:47of sugar was greater than the pasta
- 33:48itself. At this point, it’s really
- 33:50becoming a true addiction. But at this
- 33:51stage, you really need to get help
- 33:53because you simply can't do it alone.
- 33:55So, you have to seek help. You should
- 33:57potentially hire therapists. Either
- 34:00hypnotherapists, sophrology experts,
- 34:02and so on, or a nutritional therapist
- 34:05to coach you well. And I’m telling
- 34:08you, with food supplements, we can
- 34:10really help the person. We have other
- 34:14ways to try and limit compulsions with
- 34:165-HTP. Well, we have other solutions.
- 34:19Yes.
- 34:20Ah, that’s incredible. People who put
- 34:22sugar on pasta because it isn't sweet
- 34:23enough. What is the craziest thing
- 34:25you’ve seen in terms of nutrition? It
- 34:28was the amount of sugar that exceeded
- 34:31the amount of pasta. So, she was
- 34:34putting sugar everywhere. And that’s
- 34:36the most impressive thing I’ve seen
- 34:38in terms of the amount of sugar
- 34:40ingested. That’s what I’ve seen the
- 34:42most.
- 34:42And was the person huge?
- 34:44A bit, but not huge. No, a little bit,
- 34:46but nothing more. Yeah. I mean, if you
- 34:48don’t eat anything else, you’re
- 34:50still imbalanced. Now, that’s a great
- 34:53question. Can you be thin and have an
- 34:56imbalanced microbiota? Well, yes, you
- 34:58don't have to be fat. So, you can be
- 35:01completely normal weight and still have
- 35:03an imbalanced microbiota. So, weight is
- 35:06not a criterion.
- 35:07Okay. You can not be in a caloric
- 35:10surplus, not be putting on fat, but
- 35:12still have an internal system that
- 35:14doesn't function well, that’s a bit
- 35:16shaky. Everything depends on the
- 35:19different mechanisms involved by the
- 35:21bacteria, secondary to the bacteria,
- 35:22the types of bacteria, and so on. Yes.
- 35:24Yes, exactly. So, what we’ve
- 35:26understood is that the microbiota can
- 35:29vary, it can evolve according to life
- 35:31stages, diet, and stress. It’s quite
- 35:34interesting to see that stress alone—
- 35:36meaning if you don’t move, don’t
- 35:38change your diet, or your physical
- 35:41activity, but you only add the stress
- 35:43factor...I know I’m always using
- 35:45slightly unusual cases. There is never
- 35:47just a single parameter that changes in
- 35:48a life. But, uh, it's to try to
- 35:51understand, uh, how stress itself
- 35:53directly impacts our microbiomes. Is it
- 35:55a question of, is it a matter of
- 35:57cortisol? A matter of, we, we've
- 35:59highlighted some interactions with the
- 36:02bacteria.
- 36:03Yes. Well, there's certainly the factor
- 36:05of cortisol, the factor of the
- 36:07imbalance. So what you also need to
- 36:09know is that it works both ways, right.
- 36:12Meaning that an unbalanced microbiome
- 36:15can increase, uh, the perception of
- 36:19stress. That’s important to know
- 36:22because we often don't even know which
- 36:24way it starts. So, uh, it also modifies
- 36:29behavior; for example, an unbalanced
- 36:32microbiome—there was some very fine
- 36:34work by a Canadian gastroenterologist
- 36:37who showed that, by swapping intestinal
- 36:42microbiomes in little mice that had
- 36:44different behaviors, we had reversed
- 36:46those behaviors. So that’s where we
- 36:49wonder, well, ultimately when we're a
- 36:51bit daring or when we're rather shy,
- 36:53etc., is it ultimately us, or is it our
- 36:55microbiome? Well, in fact, it’s both.
- 36:58Actually, it's us, it’s what we call
- 37:00the holobiont, that is to say, it's our
- 37:02entire organism and our bacteria
- 37:03because it’s part of a whole. In fact
- 37:06, we couldn't live without these
- 37:07bacteria, could we? So, we conducted
- 37:09small studies with completely sterile
- 37:12mice and realized that they didn't
- 37:14develop their immune systems well, that
- 37:16they had more infections, and that they
- 37:19didn't properly develop or mature their
- 37:22intestines, etc. Actually, we
- 37:24completely need them to live normally
- 37:26in this world. And so, you have to
- 37:29understand that they were in this world
- 37:30well before us and that they have
- 37:32inhabited us since the very beginning
- 37:34of man, so since the dawn of human
- 37:36creation, they are actually part of us.
- 37:38There you go. So that’s why we
- 37:39shouldn't be afraid of them anymore.
- 37:41When we gave conferences 30 years ago,
- 37:44or 20 or 30 years ago, about this
- 37:46microbiome, we realized that people
- 37:48were completely disturbed to feel
- 37:50inhabited by these microbes, and now,
- 37:53well, it’s become habitual; people
- 37:55have understood that, well, we live
- 37:57with them. It panics people less. So
- 38:01the stress relationship, it’s, it’s
- 38:04in both directions. And what you have
- 38:07to understand is that the relationship
- 38:09between the microbiome and the brain
- 38:11happens through several factors. It
- 38:13happens through hormones, it also
- 38:14happens through the vagus nerve. Well,
- 38:18it happens through the vagus nerve,
- 38:20which also has very intimate contact,
- 38:23and through the fact that microbes
- 38:25produce a lot of metabolites that can
- 38:27influence the mind, like
- 38:28neurotransmitters, for example. So, in
- 38:34fact, there are many, many ways of
- 38:37communication between our brain, our
- 38:40gut, and our microbiota.
- 38:44It's quite incredible to think that we
- 38:47can shift our moods or even have a
- 38:49different personality depending on the
- 38:51microbiota, the population we host in
- 38:54our bodies. It’s quite amazing. Can
- 38:57we imagine, in maybe a few decades,
- 39:00that we will have identified specific
- 39:02strains that correlate more with
- 39:05depression, others that will create a
- 39:07depressive pattern, others that might
- 39:10create a bold or ambitious pattern?
- 39:14Yeah.
- 39:16And that's the idea; the main work
- 39:17currently is mostly focused on
- 39:19pathologies, because people really want
- 39:21to make progress on those conditions.
- 39:24So we're trying to find which type of
- 39:25bacteria might correspond to them, but
- 39:27it’s not that simple. That's why, for
- 39:30now, we've identified biodiversity as a
- 39:32criterion that is a common thread in
- 39:34all studies, but it can vary from one
- 39:36study to another. So it's complicated
- 39:38to interpret. But that is somewhat the
- 39:42goal of research: trying to find not
- 39:45only the germs responsible for the
- 39:48pathologies but also trying to find the
- 39:52right probiotics that will regulate a
- 39:55specific condition based on the strain
- 39:58used. So yes, that’s somewhat the
- 40:02idea for future therapeutics and future
- 40:04diagnostics as well. Now, I’m
- 40:07inevitably thinking about the market
- 40:09that’s going to move into this space.
- 40:11Could we have boxes or supplements with
- 40:14certain probiotic strains based on
- 40:16specific behaviors? I don’t know,
- 40:20someone giving a lecture might take a
- 40:22supplement of a certain bacterial
- 40:24strain to be a bit more extroverted. Is
- 40:28that possible?
- 40:29Why not, right? It doesn’t seem
- 40:32impossible, but for now, it's not
- 40:34currently a reality, though it’s true
- 40:36that there's no reason why it couldn't
- 40:38happen.
- 40:41Is there a point in early life where
- 40:43it’s really worthwhile to configure
- 40:46your microbiota as much as possible? It
- 40:50changes over the years, it can evolve
- 40:52as the years go by. But is there a
- 40:55solid foundation built before a certain
- 40:57age, during childhood, where it’s
- 41:00essential to have the greatest possible
- 41:02diversity to ensure that future
- 41:04imbalances, even from uncertain diets,
- 41:07will have less impact, so to speak?
- 41:12Well, what you have to understand is
- 41:14that first, to begin with, you have to
- 41:16understand that the microbiota is
- 41:21primarily established at the moment of
- 41:23birth. Exactly. So, there is microbiota
- 41:25, there are microbes everywhere, a bit
- 41:27in the placenta and all that, but it's
- 41:29at the moment of birth that the maximum
- 41:31number of microbes will colonize the
- 41:33newborn. And it's important to
- 41:37understand that when delivery occurs
- 41:40naturally, via the vaginal canal,
- 41:42that's when the baby can effectively
- 41:45and quickly acquire beneficial flora
- 41:48that largely comes from the mother.
- 41:53Unlike, for example, a baby born by
- 41:56cesarean section, who will initially
- 41:58acquire flora from the environment
- 42:00instead. So, indeed, there will already
- 42:03be an inequality there. Then, with
- 42:06breastfeeding, we also help, we provide
- 42:08the mother's microbes, which are
- 42:10beneficial and will further enrich the
- 42:12baby's microbiota. So, breastfeeding is
- 42:15a second important factor in helping to
- 42:19properly start a healthy gut microbiota
- 42:22. And we estimate that it takes about 2
- 42:25to 3 years to have a microbiota that is
- 42:27fairly well-established, like that of
- 42:29an adult. Exactly. So, it’s a
- 42:32microbiota that will evolve over time
- 42:34and will become roughly equivalent to
- 42:36an adult's by around age 3. Around age
- 42:393. I see. So, we realize that the
- 42:42quality of the microbiota is extremely
- 42:46dependent on the mother and almost not
- 42:49at all on the father, or only slightly
- 42:53through his presence in the environment
- 42:56, but not as intimately. Yes.
- 42:59Essentially. So, from several of the
- 43:01mother's types of flora, but especially
- 43:02the vaginal flora. And yes, absolutely,
- 43:05it is completely necessary. Also, what
- 43:09is interesting is all the studies
- 43:11showing that when children are born on
- 43:14farms and are in contact with animals,
- 43:17we realize that they actually develop
- 43:19much less asthma, allergies, and so on,
- 43:22and have a better immune system because
- 43:25of that animal contact. And so that is
- 43:29where the hygiene hypothesis came from,
- 43:31saying watch out, when there is too
- 43:33much hygiene, we shouldn't be excessive
- 43:35. Now, obviously, you're not going to
- 43:38let them suck on a pacifier that fell
- 43:40on the sidewalk. Do you see what I mean
- 43:42? And if a child touches the soil or
- 43:45plants, well, it's perhaps less serious
- 43:47; you have to try to modulate things.
- 43:51And, we've realized that people who
- 43:53touch the earth, plants, and so on, who
- 43:55are in greater contact with nature,
- 43:57have a more interesting and diverse gut
- 43:59microbiome.
- 44:02And what is your opinion on the diet
- 44:04that a child from 0 to 3 years old
- 44:05should have? We've understood a bit
- 44:09about breastfeeding, but what else?
- 44:12Then up to 6 years old, for example, if
- 44:13we were aiming for the ideal, should we
- 44:15quickly include vegetables, fibers, and
- 44:17prebiotic sources? Uh, how do you think
- 44:20we should organize that?
- 44:23I am not a pediatric gastroenterologist
- 44:25, but it is true that what is
- 44:27interesting is that there is real
- 44:29debate about whether one should
- 44:31introduce solid food early or not too
- 44:33early. It changes as time goes on and
- 44:36eras pass. So I think we shouldn't
- 44:38introduce things too early. I think
- 44:39that prolonged breastfeeding is
- 44:41interesting. After that, it depends on
- 44:43what you can do, of course, what the
- 44:45woman can do, but it is true that it's
- 44:46worth prolonging breastfeeding a little
- 44:47. And then, of course, what will count
- 44:50for the child who is growing and
- 44:52starting to eat is having a very
- 44:54diverse diet, especially rich in fiber,
- 44:57since we will realize—and perhaps
- 44:59we'll talk about this a bit later—
- 45:01that the preferred food for protective
- 45:03bacteria is dietary fiber. So
- 45:06everything like vegetables, uh,
- 45:07obviously certain fruits, essentially,
- 45:10legumes, uh, cereals, and so on. So
- 45:12everything that is fiber.
- 45:13And then fermented foods are also
- 45:15interesting. Uh, and also, uh,
- 45:18everything related to omega-3s, uh, so
- 45:21omega-3 fatty acids, polyphenols, and
- 45:23so on, antioxidants. So we'll also find
- 45:27a lot in vegetables and fruits.
- 45:28OK. Before we talk a bit about all that
- 45:31, about solutions for what we can do to
- 45:33either keep the microbiota as
- 45:35high-quality and as diverse as possible
- 45:37or rebalance it. A little original,
- 45:39somewhat whimsical question. What do
- 45:41you think would happen? It's purely
- 45:44hypothetical, mind you, because it
- 45:46doesn't exist and won't exist if we had
- 45:48absolutely no intestinal bacteria. If
- 45:51we take a human being and remove
- 45:53absolutely all their microbiota, how
- 45:55long would they survive? We did the
- 45:58experiment with little mice. So with
- 46:00sterile little mice, well, as soon as
- 46:02you take sterile little mice, they
- 46:05develop their immune system poorly. So,
- 46:08especially since we took them as little
- 46:10ones at birth, we deprived them of
- 46:13intestinal bacteria, and so they don't
- 46:15develop their immune system; they have
- 46:18lots of infections, a high reactivity
- 46:20to stress, their intestines don't
- 46:22mature well, and so on. Anyway, no, we
- 46:26really need these bacteria, really need
- 46:28them. We can't live without them.
- 46:32And if, for example, we take a human,
- 46:34say a 25-or 30-year-old man, and we
- 46:36remove all his bacteria—let's assume
- 46:39there's a method that allows removing
- 46:41all microbiota everywhere—and we do
- 46:43nothing, we leave him like that. How
- 46:46many days would he survive? And
- 46:47according to you,
- 46:48What a question, Jérôme, I have no
- 46:50idea. I have no idea. What a question?
- 46:52Either way, he will recolonize. He
- 46:54can't, he can't stay without bacteria.
- 46:57It's like someone you give antibiotics
- 46:59to; you give them antibiotics and then
- 47:01they will It will kill a large part of
- 47:05their microbes, and then after a while,
- 47:06well, it will rebuild itself however it
- 47:08can. So after a while, well, the
- 47:10microbes will come back because they
- 47:12are everywhere. Unless you really put
- 47:15them in a sterile room, poor thing, so
- 47:17they have no access to anything and
- 47:19only eat sterile food; otherwise, it's
- 47:20not possible. That's really science
- 47:24fiction right there.
- 47:26Yeah, I like it. I like science fiction
- 47:27sometimes. I like imagining situations
- 47:30—well, situations to understand a
- 47:33little bit whether it's the system,
- 47:35whether it's the immune system that
- 47:37would really go first, or the neuro, or
- 47:40the...
- 47:41Well, then, surely there would be a
- 47:43restoration. Because if we eliminate,
- 47:45well, for example if we use massive
- 47:47antibiotic therapy and we wipe out the
- 47:49entire microbiota, well then the
- 47:51patient is still going to eat because
- 47:53otherwise they can't live. So they will
- 47:55reintroduce bacteria into their
- 47:57digestive tract, so in fact it will
- 47:58repopulate. So in fact, it will start
- 48:02over, perhaps with a completely
- 48:03different balance, but it will
- 48:05recolonize. We can't, you see, unless
- 48:08we live in a sterile room and eat
- 48:10sterile food. Exactly. But that's why I
- 48:12was telling you, it's a...well, now
- 48:14we're getting into medicine.
- 48:17Uh, are there profiles that are more at
- 48:19risk in your opinion, whether in terms
- 48:21of age, demographics, or geographic
- 48:24location, I don't know, more at risk of
- 48:26having microbiota disorders in their
- 48:28life? Well, in one of my books, this
- 48:34one, it's called "Gut Health," which I
- 48:37published with Terre Vivante, the gut
- 48:40health guide. I wrote a little piece of
- 48:45prose that I can read to you, as it
- 48:47actually answers your question. There
- 48:50we go. So, precisely to try and
- 48:53recognize oneself and say, "Hey, maybe
- 48:55I actually have dysbiosis." Exactly. So
- 49:02, genetic curse or rather the
- 49:04consequence of an unsuitable lifestyle,
- 49:07man most often and unconsciously
- 49:09participates in preparing his own
- 49:12illness. A complex and long recipe with
- 49:17a result that varies from one cook to
- 49:19the next. A recipe to know in order to
- 49:22better avoid it. A plate devoid of
- 49:27fiber, lots of animal products, plenty
- 49:30of ready-made meals, full of hidden
- 49:33sugar and salt, a good dose of
- 49:36saturated fat, omega-6 and trans fats,
- 49:39a cocktail of pollutants, pesticides,
- 49:42additives, toxic molecules,
- 49:44high-temperature cooking, grilling, and
- 49:47quite a bit of stress, hours of
- 49:50sedentary time, and a nice fat belly.
- 49:55Mix all these ingredients, let them
- 49:58simmer gently for a few years, and it's
- 50:01soon ready, in a digestive,
- 50:04cardiovascular, or other form. There
- 50:07you go. In fact, as soon as you start
- 50:11making mistakes in your lifestyle, at
- 50:14some point, unless you really have an
- 50:17amazing organism, at some point,
- 50:20something is going to happen. It can be
- 50:24different from one patient to another.
- 50:26We won't all experience the same things
- 50:27. One patient might develop a
- 50:30cardiovascular disease, another a
- 50:32digestive disease, another a fatty
- 50:33liver, perhaps cirrhosis, and so on. So
- 50:37there it is, we aren't equal at all,
- 50:39and as a result, we won't have the same
- 50:42repercussions from our lifestyle. And
- 50:45that's what's unsettling, what confuses
- 50:47people, because there are those who
- 50:49tell you: "Well, look, I...there's a
- 50:51person who smokes and doesn't get lung
- 50:53cancer, and then another who doesn't
- 50:55smoke and gets lung cancer, and so on."
- 50:58Exactly. So we are full of inequalities
- 51:00. We don't all react the same way to
- 51:03the various environmental stresses we
- 51:05put our bodies through. And yes. Now,
- 51:10we are going to get into that, because
- 51:12indeed, what you've described—for
- 51:14people who are a bit interested in
- 51:16health and what they eat—they are
- 51:17more or less aware of. Right, processed
- 51:21foods, sugar, trans fats, too much
- 51:23omega-6, and so on. People are more or
- 51:27less aware of that. Now let's talk
- 51:32about sweeteners or substances that
- 51:35might impact the microbiome but that, I
- 51:38feel, aren't certain yet. The
- 51:40scientific literature doesn't seem to
- 51:42be completely clear or in agreement on
- 51:45this. We see an impressive number of
- 51:48coaches and pseudo-nutritionists
- 51:51popping up on the internet explaining
- 51:53that sweeteners have absolutely no
- 51:55impact up to a certain dose, but that
- 51:58this dose is, in any case, much higher
- 52:01than what we consume daily. Others,
- 52:04much more "ancestral," might say, "No,
- 52:07even at the first dose, sweeteners will
- 52:09be a problem anyway." Others say, "I
- 52:11know, we don't know." I'm thinking of
- 52:13Anthony Berthou who says...maybe
- 52:15there's no consensus, but in principle,
- 52:17it's better not to consume sweeteners.
- 52:19If we really want to reach absolute,
- 52:21optimal health, let's not consume them.
- 52:24Then others will say, "No, but wait,
- 52:25having one can of Coke Zero won't
- 52:27change anything." The threshold is much
- 52:29higher...anyway, how do we navigate
- 52:32this, these micro-substances that get
- 52:34added to our diet and that we almost
- 52:37believe are beneficial?
- 52:39Well, what you have to understand is
- 52:41that, in fact, there is never a miracle
- 52:44solution. Even if you want to cheat
- 52:46with your microbiota, you can't cheat.
- 52:49Uh, you put sugar in your mouth, for
- 52:50example, or a sweetener in your mouth,
- 52:51and you’re going to secrete insulin.
- 52:53There you go, it starts in the mouth.
- 52:55So, in fact, you can't cheat with the
- 52:57body, right? It's, it's difficult. Uh,
- 52:59sweeteners, apart from stevia for now,
- 53:02because it's perhaps a bit newer, uh,
- 53:04it's true that we don't have, well, we
- 53:06don't have good studies, or rather, we
- 53:08have studies that show it's not great
- 53:10for our gut microbiota, right. But it's
- 53:14not just sweeteners; there are
- 53:16additives, pesticides, uh, there are
- 53:19pollutants, various pollutants, heavy
- 53:21metals, etc., well, cadmium and so on.
- 53:24So, as soon as you start getting into
- 53:26all these various pollutants and so on
- 53:29in our food and the pollutants in our
- 53:31environment, well, in any case, they
- 53:33will disrupt our microbiota. You have
- 53:35to understand that our microbiota has
- 53:37so many enzymes that it will play with
- 53:39them. Well, it will try to break them
- 53:40down and so on. But the problem is that
- 53:42while breaking them down, sometimes it
- 53:43does good things, and other times it
- 53:45makes the molecules even more toxic.
- 53:46There you go. And so it will depend on
- 53:48the type of bacteria we have. So, you
- 53:50can imagine the complexity, indeed, of
- 53:53the studies we have to manage. It's,
- 53:56it's very complicated. So that means
- 53:58the less we consume, the better off we
- 53:59will be. Furthermore, the problem with
- 54:02sweeteners is that the more you get
- 54:04used to having that sugary taste, the
- 54:06more you need it. So, it's true that,
- 54:09for example, everyone has experienced,
- 54:11well, sugar in coffee, sorry, coffee in
- 54:13sugar. And so when you remove that
- 54:16sugar and you stop completely, well,
- 54:18it's hard for a week, but after that,
- 54:20when you try to add it back, you
- 54:22realize it's not good at all. Uh, so
- 54:26there you go, it's also a habit we can
- 54:28form to try and diminish that taste for
- 54:30sugar. So there you go. But, uh, indeed
- 54:34, it's not just sweeteners, right? It's
- 54:38a whole set of things that combine,
- 54:40making our diet—especially the
- 54:42processed food currently, which is full
- 54:45of additives and emulsifiers. Because
- 54:48emulsifiers are very harmful, both for
- 54:50the microbiota and for the intestinal
- 54:52wall. They promote an increase in
- 54:54intestinal permeability and thus
- 54:56inflammation, an inflammation that will
- 54:58perpetuate throughout the entire body.
- 55:00So yes, saying that all of this is
- 55:03difficult is accurate. For example,
- 55:05lack of sleep can also disrupt the
- 55:08microbiota. So it goes very, very far.
- 55:10Alcohol, tobacco, well, tobacco also
- 55:12disrupts the microbiota at every level
- 55:14of the digestive tract and the
- 55:16respiratory system as well. You know
- 55:20that there are harmful bacteria in the
- 55:21micro-in cigarettes as well. So that
- 55:24doesn't help things. So, everything is
- 55:26complicated because, in fact,
- 55:27everything is inhabited. So as soon as
- 55:30we introduce something, well, in any
- 55:32case, it is inhabited,
- 55:33it modifies it.
- 55:34That's it. And it does indeed modify it
- 55:36. So it shows the complexity of the
- 55:38studies and shows that, indeed, with
- 55:40studies, well, we don't always get
- 55:42identical results.
- 55:45But the logic, if you want to take good
- 55:47care of your microbiota, is to limit
- 55:48all that.
- 55:50Specifically regarding sucralose, which
- 55:53is one of the most popular sweeteners
- 55:55right now that reproduces the taste of
- 55:57sugar perfectly well without having any
- 55:59calories or apparent glycemic impact.
- 56:02In your opinion, does it disrupt the
- 56:04microbiota from the very first dose or
- 56:06not?
- 56:08Well, I don't remember right now. I
- 56:09would have to look up sucralose, I-It's
- 56:14not-it's not part of my recent research
- 56:15. I couldn't answer that, but I could-I
- 56:18could tell you that if you're
- 56:20personally interested, I could tell you
- 56:23, but it's true that I haven't-I think
- 56:26it disrupts it too. But as for saying
- 56:29it's from the first dose, in my memory,
- 56:31it disrupts it, but I haven't-I haven't
- 56:33seen recent studies on that subject.
- 56:36Regarding aspartame, which is somewhat-
- 56:39well, which is almost a bit out of
- 56:41fashion, do we have enough perspective
- 56:43on the impact of aspartame on the
- 56:45intestinal flora? Well, it's the same,
- 56:49all these-aspartame too, it is-it is in
- 56:52the-in the accused, in the dock, and
- 56:55all that, well, you will find it in
- 56:57this book. I have detailed them well in
- 57:00the book "Slimming Down with Pleasure
- 57:02by Charming Your Bacteria." I talked
- 57:05about all these sweeteners, I talked
- 57:07about all these issues, and I detailed
- 57:09them, indeed, and they were all-and
- 57:11they were all in the dock, in fact. All
- 57:15of them.
- 57:16Okay. Can we-can we say-can we
- 57:18summarize? I like to be a little bit
- 57:21extreme sometimes and say zero
- 57:23sweeteners, zero pesticides. It might
- 57:26be complicated, but in any case, from a
- 57:29voluntary standpoint, in choosing what
- 57:31we ingest, uh, it's better than a
- 57:34sweetener from time to time.
- 57:37Well, I would say it all depends on the
- 57:39context and what is going on. For
- 57:41example, you have people who follow, uh
- 57:44, ketogenic diets for certain
- 57:46pathologies and so on. Uh, it's true
- 57:49that it's also a bit difficult to
- 57:51deprive them of sweeteners. When, for
- 57:54example, we are on a normal diet and
- 57:57have no particular health problems,
- 57:59it's true that if we eat a cake from
- 58:01time to time and put a little sugar in
- 58:03it, I don't see the harm in using a
- 58:05little whole sugar when baking a cake,
- 58:07if we don't eat it often. I don't see
- 58:10the issue. There you go. Especially if,
- 58:13besides that, the meal is rich in fiber
- 58:15and so on, and if you don't overindulge
- 58:17in that cake, you don't eat it every
- 58:19day, and so on. So, uh, for someone who
- 58:23doesn't have any particular health
- 58:25problems and has a balanced diet, I
- 58:27don't see the point of consuming
- 58:29sweeteners. On the other hand, uh,
- 58:32someone who is working with a ketogenic
- 58:35diet in the context of specific
- 58:38pathologies, uh, yes, there I think I
- 58:40would more readily let patients do it.
- 58:44But it depends on where you stand,
- 58:45actually. There is a kind of hierarchy,
- 58:47obviously. Sweetener is better than
- 58:49sugar, and nothing at all is better
- 58:50than sweetener. A sort of, uh, thing
- 58:52like that.
- 58:53Then sugar, why not, if it's occasional
- 58:56, a mineral-rich whole sugar,
- 58:58occasional. Why not? It's not that
- 59:01dramatic either.
- 59:03Do you think we'll be able to know in a
- 59:06few years the impact, for example, on
- 59:08life expectancy of the regular
- 59:10consumption of these sweeteners like
- 59:13sucralose, for example? Or will it take
- 59:17time, will it take years to have the
- 59:19necessary perspective?
- 59:21Yes, as time goes on, studies will
- 59:22become more refined and we will have
- 59:24more and more interesting studies, and
- 59:26so on. Although there are always many
- 59:30contradictory studies, but well, it's
- 59:32Yes, yes, absolutely. In any case, we
- 59:35will have more and more studies
- 59:36regarding the microbiota since
- 59:38microbiota analyses are becoming easier
- 59:40to do nowadays. So, uh, indeed, we will
- 59:44have even more interesting studies to
- 59:47observe. And what is your take on the
- 59:51digital world of social media, where
- 59:54everyone is talking about nutrition, uh
- 59:56, a little bit about the microbiota too
- 59:59, but mostly about nutrition and
- 1:00:01micronutrition? There’s, well,
- 1:00:03there's a whole spectrum, I mean, the
- 1:00:05...you find everything. I mean, there
- 1:00:08are those who are for it, those who are
- 1:00:10against certain foods, those who are...
- 1:00:12There is absolutely a mosaic of
- 1:00:14opinions, ideas, and statements being
- 1:00:15made. Well, you who work in this field,
- 1:00:18who have a certain expertise, do you
- 1:00:20follow it? Does it annoy you? Do you
- 1:00:22pay attention to it? What is your
- 1:00:24I don't have time to spend my time on
- 1:00:27social media. What I can say is that I
- 1:00:29think when you receive information—
- 1:00:31and I’ll say this perhaps more for
- 1:00:33the public—but when you receive
- 1:00:35information, well, you need to know
- 1:00:37where it comes from. Uh, is it
- 1:00:40advertising information? And in that
- 1:00:43case, well, it loses some of its value.
- 1:00:45Is it information from someone who has
- 1:00:47no training? And in that case, well,
- 1:00:49perhaps you should also be wary of it
- 1:00:52and corroborate it with other other
- 1:00:54other publications or other or other
- 1:00:57interviews, etc. So, I think you should
- 1:01:00always be wary. There you go, you must
- 1:01:03always remain cautious, and besides,
- 1:01:05the problem is that since we are all
- 1:01:07different, we won't necessarily all
- 1:01:09react the same way to a nutritional
- 1:01:11change, and that is what makes it so
- 1:01:13very difficult. So that’s why you
- 1:01:16have a whole range of diets being
- 1:01:18proposed, which are diverse and varied.
- 1:01:22Uh, and so, indeed, I believe you have
- 1:01:24to, well, you have to find the one that
- 1:01:27fits. I think you have to start with
- 1:01:31the, the broad basic needs of the
- 1:01:33microbiota. And then, based on that,
- 1:01:37well, you have to find those
- 1:01:38particularities because you will have
- 1:01:40people who will be intolerant to
- 1:01:41anything that is gluten or modern wheat
- 1:01:43. You will have others who will be
- 1:01:45intolerant to everything that is dairy;
- 1:01:47you will have those intolerant to both
- 1:01:48gluten and dairy. Uh, so you will have
- 1:01:51to adapt the nutritional modification
- 1:01:55to each, to each person. And that is
- 1:01:58the great difficulty in giving somewhat
- 1:02:00general advice. And that is, that was
- 1:02:02the advantage of being in a
- 1:02:04consultation and being able to adapt
- 1:02:06the advice to the person who was
- 1:02:08actually going to work in partnership
- 1:02:10with their doctor. And so it's true
- 1:02:12that it's much easier in this context
- 1:02:14because we can readjust, we can adapt,
- 1:02:17and especially if the person
- 1:02:19participates, well, we arrive at, we
- 1:02:21obtain better results, effectively.
- 1:02:25Well, now that we've understood a
- 1:02:27little bit about what the microbiota is
- 1:02:30, its importance, and the impact it has
- 1:02:32on absolutely every area—and all
- 1:02:35areas having an impact on the
- 1:02:37microbiota as well—if we want to make
- 1:02:39our intestinal flora as healthy as
- 1:02:41possible, first, do you recommend
- 1:02:43taking pre-or prob-, well, pre-or
- 1:02:46probiotics (prebiotics being fibers, in
- 1:02:48any case), but especially
- 1:02:50broad-spectrum probiotics to restore
- 1:02:52biodiversity, following up a bit on
- 1:02:56what we were saying earlier, or do you
- 1:02:58advise against it entirely?
- 1:03:01So maybe we should also redefine for
- 1:03:04the public the difference between
- 1:03:06probiotic, prebiotic, and postbiotic.
- 1:03:11So, a probiotic is the microbes we
- 1:03:14ingest that are in little capsules,
- 1:03:17little living microbes. So probiotic, "
- 1:03:20pro" for life, that's what it means.
- 1:03:23And so these are little living microbes
- 1:03:26that we ingest, which have the mission
- 1:03:28of helping the intestinal microbiota
- 1:03:30function better during their transit.
- 1:03:34This means they won't settle in; they
- 1:03:37are just there to help. Those are the
- 1:03:42probiotics. Prebiotics are also fibers.
- 1:03:49So we have them in our diet. All food
- 1:03:52rich in prebiotic fiber, but we also
- 1:03:55find them in powder, capsules, etc., so
- 1:03:58in the form of prebiotics, which is the
- 1:04:01food for the good intestinal bacteria
- 1:04:04of the gut microbiota. So here, we are
- 1:04:07going to feed the bacteria directly.
- 1:04:10And postbiotics are when we have
- 1:04:13inanimate microbes, meaning we have
- 1:04:17killed them, or we also have the
- 1:04:20metabolites they produced, the products
- 1:04:24they created. There you go. So that is
- 1:04:28the difference between the three. So,
- 1:04:30when we give probiotics, you have to
- 1:04:32know that we are mostly at the first
- 1:04:34generation of probiotics currently.
- 1:04:37That is to say, it mainly consists of
- 1:04:40giving lactobacilli and bifidobacteria,
- 1:04:42which are bacteria judged completely
- 1:04:45harmless to our health. Meaning they
- 1:04:47will not damage our health and, on the
- 1:04:49contrary, will help us improve our
- 1:04:51health. There you go. And they are well
- 1:04:53tolerated. So, these are...there are
- 1:04:56various strains of bifidobacteria,
- 1:04:59various strains of lactobacilli, etc.
- 1:05:02There you go, it's mostly lactos and
- 1:05:04bifidos. Indeed, it's interesting.
- 1:05:08Personally, I’ve prescribed them
- 1:05:09quite a bit for various conditions. For
- 1:05:11me, of course, these are digestive
- 1:05:13issues I've encountered in
- 1:05:15consultations, and naturally, with
- 1:05:17improvements and happy patients.
- 1:05:19Sometimes, you have to switch
- 1:05:21probiotics because, frankly, we’re
- 1:05:22doing this a bit blindly, choosing good
- 1:05:25brands and products, but it’s still a
- 1:05:27bit of a guessing game. Meaning we test
- 1:05:29a type of probiotic to see if it works
- 1:05:31well. In general, it works well—in 75
- 1:05:34to 80%of cases—but if it doesn’t go
- 1:05:36well, for example, people get a lot of
- 1:05:38gas, bloating, and so on. After a week,
- 1:05:42well, you have to switch, so at that
- 1:05:43point, we give a different probiotic,
- 1:05:45and we can switch because we don't
- 1:05:46always get the same results depending
- 1:05:48on the type. So, those are the
- 1:05:50probiotics, and indeed, we can make use
- 1:05:51of them. And I’ve noticed that when I
- 1:05:54prescribe probiotics for digestive
- 1:05:55diseases, for instance, people come
- 1:05:57back and say, "Oh, I’ve been sleeping
- 1:05:59better since I started." Well, that
- 1:06:01makes sense because we know all these
- 1:06:04microbes have an influence on the brain
- 1:06:06, on sleep, and so on. So it’s
- 1:06:09interesting to see all these parallel
- 1:06:11effects that we can actually achieve.
- 1:06:13So, we can see an improvement in
- 1:06:15digestive symptoms, improvement in
- 1:06:17immunity, and we can improve quite a
- 1:06:20few interesting criteria. Yes, so I
- 1:06:23have certainly prescribed probiotics.
- 1:06:26Currently, we should prescribe them in
- 1:06:28combination with antibiotics, you know,
- 1:06:29as a precaution to protect the
- 1:06:31microbiota. Uh, there you go.
- 1:06:33Prebiotics, on the other hand, when we
- 1:06:36prescribe them, their mission is to
- 1:06:39enrich our microbiota because we are
- 1:06:41providing fiber, and the more varied
- 1:06:44the fiber in that prebiotic, the more
- 1:06:47we enrich the microbe's biodiversity.
- 1:06:49So that’s definitely better. And we
- 1:06:51think that right now, one of the
- 1:06:53problems is that people’s diets
- 1:06:55aren’t very diverse. Meaning that
- 1:06:58when I interview them in consultation,
- 1:07:00we realize that, ultimately, people
- 1:07:01always eat the same things. It’s
- 1:07:04always the same salad, always the same
- 1:07:05soup with the same three or four
- 1:07:07vegetables, and so on. So don't forget
- 1:07:09that when you blend things, you break
- 1:07:10down the fibers. So, there are fewer
- 1:07:12fibers. So you release more sugar
- 1:07:14molecules and you break the fibers. So,
- 1:07:17it's better to eat vegetables in chunks
- 1:07:20, preferably raw or cooked, but in
- 1:07:23pieces, not overcooked, and so on. So
- 1:07:26indeed, we must favor a fiber-rich, yet
- 1:07:29varied diet. The more varied it is, the
- 1:07:33more we feed different types of
- 1:07:34bacteria. We clearly understand the
- 1:07:37problem.
- 1:07:39That is interesting. Eating, without
- 1:07:42over-processing the structure of the
- 1:07:45vegetable or food we consume, allows
- 1:07:48for better fiber levels and better
- 1:07:51probiotic levels, or good bacteria that
- 1:07:54will—I mean, if we blend a vegetable,
- 1:07:57we aren't exactly removing its
- 1:08:00probiotics, are we? It's only the
- 1:08:03prebiotics that we might be destroying.
- 1:08:05Wait, be careful. If you blend a cooked
- 1:08:07vegetable, there is nothing left. There
- 1:08:09are no more microbes. They are dead. I
- 1:08:13see. We still have fiber, but the
- 1:08:15microbes are gone. When we eat raw
- 1:08:17vegetables, we are introducing microbes
- 1:08:18. It’s important to distinguish
- 1:08:20between the two, you know. When we eat
- 1:08:22raw, we bring in microbes. When we eat
- 1:08:24cooked, there are no microbes left.
- 1:08:26We’ve killed them. That’s the
- 1:08:27principle of cooking.
- 1:08:28So we should eat raw? Ah, we shouldn't
- 1:08:31eat only raw, because green beans,
- 1:08:33leeks, things like that...No, we need
- 1:08:35to eat raw, we need to eat cooked, we
- 1:08:37need to eat a varied diet; that’s the
- 1:08:39importance of variety. That’s
- 1:08:41what’s important. You have to eat a
- 1:08:42varied diet.
- 1:08:43And one thing I learned from your last
- 1:08:45book, The Magic of Fermented Foods, is
- 1:08:48that probiotics—what I thought, and
- 1:08:51what I believe the entire population
- 1:08:54thinks—was that we take probiotics,
- 1:08:56and these bacteria go straight into the
- 1:08:59gut flora and, essentially, get
- 1:09:01integrated. But actually no, we don't
- 1:09:04retain them, yet they do leave,
- 1:09:06quote-unquote, beneficial traces. But
- 1:09:09the majority of these bacteria aren't
- 1:09:11actually retained; they come to
- 1:09:13rebalance the flora slightly, they help
- 1:09:16change its composition, but we don't
- 1:09:18retain 100%of the bacteria we ingest.
- 1:09:21Exactly. So what you need to understand
- 1:09:24is that...Whether through probiotics or
- 1:09:29through fermented foods, where we bring
- 1:09:32in incredible amounts of beneficial
- 1:09:35microbes—provided, of course, they
- 1:09:38aren't pasteurized. These microbes will
- 1:09:42indeed work throughout their entire
- 1:09:44transit. You have to understand that
- 1:09:46fermentation is an acidification of the
- 1:09:49environment, right? That's it. When you
- 1:09:52put vegetables in a jar to ferment, for
- 1:09:54example, the fermentation will acidify
- 1:09:56the environment, the pH will drop, and
- 1:09:59it will select for different types of
- 1:10:01bacteria. And that's why lactobacilli,
- 1:10:05which tolerate acidity well, will be
- 1:10:08able to thrive at the expense of
- 1:10:10harmful bacteria, for example, thereby
- 1:10:13providing safety to the fermented food.
- 1:10:17These bacteria that proliferate, which
- 1:10:19are generally mostly lactobacilli, are
- 1:10:21able to withstand acidity. So, that
- 1:10:26means they will transit, they will pass
- 1:10:29through the stomach and continue to
- 1:10:31work all along the digestive tract,
- 1:10:34synthesizing vitamins and creating
- 1:10:37various types of short-chain fatty
- 1:10:39acids, for example, which will modulate
- 1:10:42immunity and so on. So they will
- 1:10:46temporarily participate in the work of
- 1:10:49the microbiota and help it. Hm. So,
- 1:10:54it's an interesting type of help. Now,
- 1:10:56if it does implant, it will be in very
- 1:10:58small percentages, because we think
- 1:11:01that indeed there is a part, a very
- 1:11:03limited percentage, that might
- 1:11:05potentially implant, but it's very,
- 1:11:07very limited. And so, most of the time,
- 1:11:10it's just a transit. A transit, but an
- 1:11:12interesting one. You shouldn't be
- 1:11:14afraid of fermented foods. That's what
- 1:11:17my latest book is about. The Magic of
- 1:11:18Fermented Foods. I think it's very
- 1:11:22interesting to understand a bit about
- 1:11:24the life of these microbes in the jar.
- 1:11:28When you close the jar with your food
- 1:11:31and you actually see this proliferation
- 1:11:34happening, which makes noise because it
- 1:11:38is noisy, it releases bubbles, it
- 1:11:40spreads a little beyond the jar. In
- 1:11:44fact, it's quite impressive to see this
- 1:11:46bacterial multiplication taking place.
- 1:11:50In this jar, we reach levels of about
- 1:11:5410 ^ 8 to 10 ^ 9 germs per gram. It's
- 1:11:59impressive. So, since you don't just
- 1:12:02eat one gram, you can imagine the
- 1:12:04quantities of bacteria we are able to
- 1:12:06ingest. It's absolutely incredible. So
- 1:12:08yes, it is interesting. And what's more
- 1:12:12, these fermented foods, when they are
- 1:12:14fermented, the lactic acid bacteria
- 1:12:16produce types of fibers that are
- 1:12:18interesting because they will digest
- 1:12:21some of them, because that is how they
- 1:12:23feed themselves, of course. They will
- 1:12:28produce others called
- 1:12:30exopolysaccharides that will serve as a
- 1:12:32prebiotic. And so these these exercises
- 1:12:37, these EPS shall we say, let's call
- 1:12:40them that for simplicity, will actually
- 1:12:42nourish the gut microbiota and thus
- 1:12:45serve as a prebiotic for our gut
- 1:12:47microbiota. So there you go. So it's
- 1:12:50Yes. Yes, it's interesting. Well,
- 1:12:52I’ve given you an extreme summary of
- 1:12:55fermentation because it has so many
- 1:12:58other benefits. But it's interesting
- 1:13:02for those who want to look into it to
- 1:13:04observe the relationship between the
- 1:13:07evolution of this world of microbes in
- 1:13:10the jar compared to what happens in the
- 1:13:12gut, and the interaction between these
- 1:13:15jar microbes and gut microbes, which is
- 1:13:18what fascinated me. It’s a total
- 1:13:23pre-probiotic jackpot with a great, a
- 1:13:25great probiotic richness in these
- 1:13:27fermented foods. Is there a superiority
- 1:13:31in making fermented foods compared to
- 1:13:34pre-and probiotics found in supplements
- 1:13:37, generally speaking? Is there
- 1:13:42ultimately an additional reason why we
- 1:13:44should do it ourselves? We should make
- 1:13:47fermented foods. We should consume them
- 1:13:49. Each product has its own benefit.
- 1:13:55Meaning that when, for example, we see
- 1:13:57a patient in consultation who is
- 1:13:59suffering, has stomach aches, etc., we
- 1:14:00aren't going to tell them, "Go ahead,
- 1:14:02make your own fermented foods," we're
- 1:14:04going to give them a probiotic for a
- 1:14:06quick fix. It’s the emergency
- 1:14:08medicine, in a way; it’s what will
- 1:14:10help, and so on. A prebiotic is more of
- 1:14:13a long-term medicine that will help,
- 1:14:15for example, all those people who have
- 1:14:17weight issues, metabolic problems, and
- 1:14:19so on. So that will be taken over
- 1:14:22longer periods, taking the time to
- 1:14:24provide nutrition, for the bacteria to
- 1:14:26multiply, and so on. So there you go,
- 1:14:29you really have to see these two
- 1:14:30different ways of prescribing them. And
- 1:14:33then, besides that, fermented foods are
- 1:14:35for everyone. Well, that's interesting.
- 1:14:38Now, I say for everyone, yes and no,
- 1:14:39because you will have a few people who
- 1:14:41won't tolerate them well. Well, it's
- 1:14:43like everything, really, it's like
- 1:14:45gluten, dairy, and so on. You'll have
- 1:14:47people who won't tolerate them well,
- 1:14:49who will have either some slight
- 1:14:51stomach pain, etc. Well, it's a very
- 1:14:53small percentage, but there you go.
- 1:14:55After that, you have to adapt to
- 1:14:56everyone. It depends on the type of
- 1:14:59fermented food because, for example,
- 1:15:01yogurt, which is widely fermented,
- 1:15:04might go down well, whereas fermented
- 1:15:06vegetables left for maybe too long
- 1:15:08might be too acidic or less
- 1:15:10well-tolerated. So, it's really a
- 1:15:13personal matter, but most of the time,
- 1:15:16I'd say 80 to 90%of the time, it will
- 1:15:19be very well-tolerated and can indeed
- 1:15:21be an interesting future option for
- 1:15:24increasing the biodiversity of our
- 1:15:26microbiota. That's what was shown in a
- 1:15:29study, so, of course, we need to wait
- 1:15:31for more. But it's interesting to see
- 1:15:34that it is indeed one way to increase
- 1:15:37the biodiversity of all these guts that
- 1:15:40have very poor microbes at present,
- 1:15:43which corresponds to all these current
- 1:15:46pathologies and diseases we encounter
- 1:15:48today. It can be beneficial for someone
- 1:15:54who, as you said, has issues other than
- 1:15:57intestinal ones, to test eating a bit
- 1:16:00more raw food or perhaps fermented
- 1:16:03foods to see if it has an impact, not
- 1:16:05necessarily on intestinal problems, but
- 1:16:08on sleep, mood, or many other things,
- 1:16:11even for someone who is apparently in
- 1:16:14good health but has minor issues.
- 1:16:17Certainly. So, what I can say is that
- 1:16:19when incorporating fermented foods, you
- 1:16:21must always go slowly, because why?
- 1:16:24Because we are going to disrupt our
- 1:16:25already established microbiota. It’s
- 1:16:27a bit like being in August and seeing
- 1:16:30all the tourists arrive; it disrupts
- 1:16:32the locals a bit. Well, it's pretty
- 1:16:34much the same thing. So, you have to
- 1:16:35take it slow. We'll take it easy. So,
- 1:16:37we’ll start by incorporating two
- 1:16:39teaspoons or maybe a maximum of one
- 1:16:40tablespoon. That's all. And then, we'll
- 1:16:43eventually reach a dose of two
- 1:16:45tablespoons of vegetables per day.
- 1:16:47Fermented ones, that's all, no more.
- 1:16:49Right, it's small, regular doses that
- 1:16:51are needed because you shouldn't
- 1:16:52introduce too much acidity to the body,
- 1:16:54otherwise, you risk unbalancing the
- 1:16:56intestinal microbiota as well. So, you
- 1:16:59just need the right doses, but it's
- 1:17:01interesting. Well, plus possibly a
- 1:17:04yogurt for those who tolerate dairy,
- 1:17:07kefir, fruit kefir, and so on. All
- 1:17:10these fermented foods are interesting,
- 1:17:12or rather, these fermented drinks are
- 1:17:13quite beneficial. So yes, I advise
- 1:17:17everyone to at least try introducing
- 1:17:19fermented foods. Now, what you need to
- 1:17:22know is that most people consume them
- 1:17:23without realizing it, right? For
- 1:17:25example, bread is a fermented food, but
- 1:17:27the difference is that it has undergone
- 1:17:29cooking. So, it has undergone cooking
- 1:17:31which means that, well, the bacteria
- 1:17:33are killed. However, it was still able
- 1:17:36to benefit from all the advantages of
- 1:17:38fermentation, which are numerous and
- 1:17:40which we haven't had time to describe,
- 1:17:42but which are very many since, in fact,
- 1:17:44the bacteria will produce vitamins,
- 1:17:46etc. They will increase the antioxidant
- 1:17:48potential of the food, etc. So they
- 1:17:50will have various benefits. So when you
- 1:17:53eat fermented foods for example, there
- 1:17:55are others that I haven't mentioned
- 1:17:58either. Now, what people know well is
- 1:18:00sauerkraut, of course. So with
- 1:18:02sauerkraut, you have two ways to eat it
- 1:18:04. Either you eat it raw, or you eat it
- 1:18:06pasteurized. Now, when it is
- 1:18:09pasteurized, it is also interesting
- 1:18:11because, in fact, you might not be
- 1:18:13getting the bacteria, but you are
- 1:18:14getting all the work the bacteria
- 1:18:16already did in that product. And so
- 1:18:19it's an interesting product
- 1:18:21nutritionally, which will be poor in
- 1:18:22bacteria of course, but which will be
- 1:18:24interesting nutritionally. So there you
- 1:18:27go, even if you sometimes can't handle
- 1:18:30raw foods, well, cooked foods that are
- 1:18:32pasteurized for example can be
- 1:18:33interesting if they were fermented
- 1:18:35beforehand. There you go.
- 1:18:37So it still offers possibilities for
- 1:18:39everyone.
- 1:18:40Yeah, there are quite a few things. And
- 1:18:41so, to try and look at the big picture
- 1:18:44to have the healthiest microbiome and
- 1:18:46be at your best, you need fiber, which
- 1:18:49will feed the microbiome, which will
- 1:18:51feed our microbiome in the right way.
- 1:18:54Probiotics, which are bacteria that we
- 1:18:56ingest directly, which can be in
- 1:18:57fermented foods or can already be in
- 1:18:59raw vegetables. Uh, and also the
- 1:19:02products of these probiotics, because
- 1:19:04these probiotics, these bacteria,
- 1:19:06produce micronutrients, produce
- 1:19:08vitamins, certain minerals, certain
- 1:19:10fatty acids. Uh, and in fact, when we
- 1:19:14eat both pre-and probiotics, whether
- 1:19:16fermented or directly in vegetables,
- 1:19:19we're bringing all of that in at the
- 1:19:21same time. That's it. And in fact, you
- 1:19:24have to bring all that in with the
- 1:19:26greatest possible diversity.
- 1:19:27Well, it's true that it's interesting.
- 1:19:29We are simply not allowed to use the
- 1:19:32term probiotic for all these germs
- 1:19:35found in fermented foods. Simply
- 1:19:38because we haven't analyzed them.
- 1:19:40That's all there is to it. So, in fact,
- 1:19:42we can say they act like probiotics,
- 1:19:44but we can't call them probiotics
- 1:19:46scientifically. There, that’s all. It
- 1:19:48was just a detail I wanted to point out
- 1:19:50. But indeed, they do act like
- 1:19:53probiotics. Indeed,
- 1:19:55it's interesting. Um, I had a quick
- 1:19:57question. So, do you know if physical
- 1:20:00activity, uh, and different types of
- 1:20:04physical activity can have a measurable
- 1:20:06impact on the microbiota? I’ve heard
- 1:20:09a lot about endurance sports or those
- 1:20:11who do very, very long sports, like
- 1:20:12marathons, triathlons, who might have
- 1:20:14their microbiota completely unbalanced.
- 1:20:18Well, it's like everything; everything
- 1:20:20in the body is a matter of balance.
- 1:20:24Everything in the body. So, for example
- 1:20:27, if you take too many antioxidants,
- 1:20:29well, you become pro-oxidant, so the
- 1:20:31reverse. Uh, so it’s all a system
- 1:20:35like that. It’s all a story of
- 1:20:37balance between all the balances that
- 1:20:39govern us. And so, the more intense the
- 1:20:42sport, the higher the risk, especially
- 1:20:45regarding the intestinal wall and
- 1:20:47intestinal permeability. Uh, so you
- 1:20:50always have to be careful, of course.
- 1:20:54With all intense sports. Uh, everything
- 1:20:57that involves endurance sports, of
- 1:20:59course, is much easier, and indeed, a
- 1:21:01sedentary lifestyle is associated with
- 1:21:03a higher risk of dysbiosis, of course.
- 1:21:06So, you have to avoid a sedentary
- 1:21:08lifestyle and you have to, you have to
- 1:21:10get moving. You have to move, you have
- 1:21:12to sleep well, you have to eat well.
- 1:21:13Actually, our microbiota is very
- 1:21:15demanding. It wants all of that.
- 1:21:16Okay. To finish, I would just like to
- 1:21:19come back to postbiotics. Postbiotics,
- 1:21:21which we don't hear about at all. You
- 1:21:24mentioned them a little bit earlier, um
- 1:21:26, so that we can really understand what
- 1:21:28a postbiotic is, and is it something we
- 1:21:30should be taking separately, or
- 1:21:32something we should worry about, in
- 1:21:33addition or separately?
- 1:21:38For now, I don't think so. Except for
- 1:21:41certain indications, perhaps for
- 1:21:43butyrate, but well, there it is, we
- 1:21:45might still need a few more studies on
- 1:21:48that. But what’s interesting is, uh,
- 1:21:51well, mainly to fuel your, to have a
- 1:21:54plate that’s rich, rich in foods that
- 1:21:57promote a healthy microbiota, rich in
- 1:22:00germs, in live microbes; meaning, for
- 1:22:03example, as we were saying earlier,
- 1:22:06don’t forget to incorporate some raw
- 1:22:09foods into your plate. Uh, not just
- 1:22:12that, but there needs to be some as
- 1:22:13well. Uh, so, uh, raw vegetables, for
- 1:22:16example, carrots, salad, and so on. You
- 1:22:20have to think about inviting variety
- 1:22:22into your diet. Don't forget spices,
- 1:22:25herbs, and so on; garlic, onion, all of
- 1:22:28that, these are excellent prebiotics,
- 1:22:31right. So, and then, uh, and then
- 1:22:33providing fermented foods in the form
- 1:22:36of germs. I think that’s really the
- 1:22:39key to health nowadays, more than
- 1:22:41taking supplements. Now, supplements,
- 1:22:44well, they help, of course, when you
- 1:22:45have medical conditions, they certainly
- 1:22:47help, right. We must, we do use them,
- 1:22:50we do use them, we help our patients
- 1:22:52with all these supplements of course,
- 1:22:53even postbiotics, we can help them for
- 1:22:55certain conditions.
- 1:22:58OK. And uh, just to add a bit of,
- 1:23:00likewise, nuance, because sometimes we
- 1:23:02have a tendency to remember what
- 1:23:03interests us, specifically, well, let's
- 1:23:05eat as much raw food as possible since
- 1:23:07we’ve understood that’s where the
- 1:23:09probiotics are. Uh, that’s without
- 1:23:11forgetting that some foods release
- 1:23:13substances when cooked and if we only
- 1:23:15eat raw, uh, we don’t get these
- 1:23:17substances and we’ll end up with a
- 1:23:19deficiency. No, but these are things
- 1:23:21we’ve seen a lot with "raw foodism,"
- 1:23:23and then when we talk about microbes,
- 1:23:24people say, "Oh, raw is amazing, you
- 1:23:25only have to eat raw." But no, because
- 1:23:27some need to be cooked to provide
- 1:23:28what’s necessary.
- 1:23:29Exactly. Green beans, leeks, all that,
- 1:23:32it’s difficult to eat them raw. So I
- 1:23:34think, there you go, it has to be a
- 1:23:37balanced plate. There has to be a
- 1:23:38little of everything. There must be
- 1:23:40cooked food, there must be raw food,
- 1:23:41and so on. There has to be both,
- 1:23:43that’s all. And the problem is, well,
- 1:23:45all these people who can't eat raw food
- 1:23:47. So you have plenty of people who have
- 1:23:49digestive issues who can't eat raw food
- 1:23:52. They need to know that there are
- 1:23:53solutions for them. Of course, I’ve
- 1:23:55detailed them extensively in my books,
- 1:23:57but there are always solutions when the
- 1:23:59gut is suffering. You just have to try
- 1:24:02to understand why and readjust in order
- 1:24:04to be able to eat raw fruits and
- 1:24:06vegetables again. That’s all.
- 1:24:08Very good. Let's finish with something
- 1:24:10a bit whimsical. What is your take on
- 1:24:13fecal transplantation as an ultimate
- 1:24:16solution for the microbiota? Is it
- 1:24:20strictly a last-resort medical
- 1:24:22treatment? Will we see fecal
- 1:24:24transplantation methods flourish in the
- 1:24:26coming decades to live longer,
- 1:24:28healthier lives?
- 1:24:30Well, it’s true that the microbiota
- 1:24:33influences longevity, and many
- 1:24:36researchers are working in this field,
- 1:24:39questioning the importance of this
- 1:24:41microbiota for better longevity,
- 1:24:44especially having a well-diversified
- 1:24:47one. So, there is research being done
- 1:24:50on that. Indeed, regarding
- 1:24:53transplantation, you should know that
- 1:24:54currently, it is only done in a very
- 1:24:56specific case, which is Clostridioides
- 1:24:58difficile colitis, a particular
- 1:25:00infectious colitis that can be quite
- 1:25:02severe, and when it is resistant to
- 1:25:04medical treatment, that is the
- 1:25:05indication for a transplant. It is the
- 1:25:09only official indication at the moment,
- 1:25:12and all other transplantations are
- 1:25:14being done as part of studies. So,
- 1:25:17studies in the context of Crohn's
- 1:25:19disease, ulcerative colitis, obesity,
- 1:25:22diabetes, etc. All of this is under
- 1:25:24research. It poses significant problems
- 1:25:28, ethical problems, not just ethical
- 1:25:32issues, but also the risk of
- 1:25:35transmitting genes and thus seeing
- 1:25:38other pathologies emerge. So, it is not
- 1:25:42simple. And besides, the main problem
- 1:25:46is that if people go back to eating and
- 1:25:49living the same way, I don't think you
- 1:25:52can maintain a healthy microbiota if
- 1:25:54you don't provide it with adequate
- 1:25:57living conditions. And so, I think that
- 1:26:01is a core issue that leads to many
- 1:26:04study failures, because we only focus
- 1:26:06on the transplant and perhaps forget
- 1:26:09the entire lifestyle required to
- 1:26:11maintain this healthy microbiota. So,
- 1:26:15there you go, I think it's coming; it
- 1:26:18will certainly be interesting,
- 1:26:20especially for certain pathologies,
- 1:26:23maybe even severe ones, I believe it
- 1:26:25will be a solution. Uh, but anyway, for
- 1:26:29now, it's not quite fully perfected yet
- 1:26:30, you know.
- 1:26:33Doctor Martine Cortina, Cotina, sorry,
- 1:26:35thank you very much for your input, it
- 1:26:36was still interesting. We’re leaving
- 1:26:39with, uh, not just fears, uh, and
- 1:26:42doubts, but also with, uh, some
- 1:26:44solutions and some good, uh, some good
- 1:26:47guidelines to, uh, some good guidelines
- 1:26:50, sorry. Your latest book, The Magic of
- 1:26:54Fermented Foods, uh, is very
- 1:26:55comprehensive. Uh, it explains how to
- 1:26:59make your own fermented foods, explains
- 1:27:01how the microbiota works in depth, how
- 1:27:04to improve it, and how to use, well,
- 1:27:06certain probiotics to, to be in better
- 1:27:08health for as long as possible. Uh, do
- 1:27:11you have a final word to add before we
- 1:27:13officially leave our audience here?
- 1:27:16Perhaps become more aware of your gut
- 1:27:19microbiota and that it is part of your
- 1:27:21family, your great family; even if you
- 1:27:23don't have the same type of
- 1:27:25relationship with it, well, you'll
- 1:27:27still have to learn to pamper it in
- 1:27:29order to feel better, better in your
- 1:27:31own skin and better with others as well
- 1:27:33.
- 1:27:34Thank you Martine, thank you to you, to
- 1:27:36all of you for your loyalty to this
- 1:27:38podcast. Uh, take care of yourselves,
- 1:27:40don't do anything too stupid, and see
- 1:27:41you very soon in a future episode of
- 1:27:42the podcast de mécanique.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of L’Experte du Microbiote : Ce qui vous empêche VRAIMENT de perdre du poids (Dr Cotinat) by Biomécanique, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,593 words across 2,179 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.