YouTube2Text

L'art de la Lumière — Transcript

by Pile et Face · 4,548 words · 659 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00You may have already had this feeling
  2. 0:02while watching a film or a series. The
  3. 0:04image is clean, beautiful, well-defined
  4. 0:06, and the actors look great. In short,
  5. 0:08perfect skin, really. But something is
  6. 0:10missing; it doesn't look like a movie,
  7. 0:12it looks a bit like a commercial or a
  8. 0:14TV set. Everything is a bit too sharp,
  9. 0:16no contrast, it lacks character, it
  10. 0:18lacks nuance, let’s say. And
  11. 0:21sometimes it's the complete opposite,
  12. 0:22you get a night scene that's so dark
  13. 0:24you wonder if there’s a problem with
  14. 0:25your TV, so you turn up the brightness
  15. 0:27because you can't see anything. And
  16. 0:29that is not just an impression.
  17. 0:30Lighting in cinema has changed in
  18. 0:32recent years, and not necessarily for
  19. 0:34the better. But to understand why, we
  20. 0:36must first understand what light really
  21. 0:39does in an image. Because we think at
  22. 0:42first that light is for seeing, for
  23. 0:43lighting the set and the actors so the
  24. 0:45image is well-exposed. And in itself,
  25. 0:47that’s not wrong. But in cinema,
  26. 0:49light is mainly used to decide what we
  27. 0:51should be looking at. So in this video,
  28. 0:54we’ll see how the greatest directors
  29. 0:56and cinematographers use light to tell
  30. 0:58a story, and where that history comes
  31. 1:00from as well. And at the end, we will
  32. 1:03come back to why so many films and
  33. 1:05series today have lost that, exactly.
  34. 1:07Welcome to the art of light. Before we
  35. 1:12start the video, if you have photo or
  36. 1:14video gear sleeping in a drawer or if
  37. 1:15you even want to buy equipment, I’ll
  38. 1:17quickly mention our sponsor IPLN, who
  39. 1:18has also been a partner of the channel
  40. 1:20for years. Because let’s be honest,
  41. 1:22reselling your equipment privately can
  42. 1:24be a bit of a hassle. You have to
  43. 1:26create the listing, answer messages,
  44. 1:27negotiate, and ship the package hoping
  45. 1:29not to run into a scammer. In short, it
  46. 1:31takes quite a bit of time. Whereas now,
  47. 1:34you just have to go to ipln.fr, enter
  48. 1:35your camera, lens, microphone, or
  49. 1:37whatever you want to sell along with
  50. 1:39its condition, and in less than 2
  51. 1:40minutes, you have its estimated price.
  52. 1:44So no need to send photos or ID, you
  53. 1:46get your estimate directly and then you
  54. 1:48can either take a bank transfer or use
  55. 1:50it as a voucher at IPLN, valid
  56. 1:52obviously on the whole site, whether
  57. 1:54for new or used items. And if that
  58. 1:56works for you, they'll give you a
  59. 1:58shipping label; you don't pay anything
  60. 2:00upfront, you just have to ship it or
  61. 2:01even drop the gear off at one of their
  62. 2:03stores in Lyon or Paris. Then their
  63. 2:06team will receive the equipment, test
  64. 2:07it themselves, and once the trade-in is
  65. 2:08validated, you'll be paid within 72
  66. 2:10hours. So what’s great is that
  67. 2:12between the estimate and the payment,
  68. 2:14it's more or less 3 to 5 days. So
  69. 2:16it’s actually pretty fast. And now,
  70. 2:18you also have a real account where you
  71. 2:19can track every step, and even your
  72. 2:21IPLN purchases, which you can either
  73. 2:23resell in one click or even trade in.
  74. 2:25I’ve put the link to IPLN in the
  75. 2:26description, and if you go through IPLN
  76. 2:28, remember to use the code "maxime" at
  77. 2:29the end of your purchase. It doesn’t
  78. 2:31cost you anything extra, and for me, it
  79. 2:32helps me out a lot in making these
  80. 2:33kinds of videos. So thank you to
  81. 2:35everyone who does it, and now let’s
  82. 2:36get back to our video. So before
  83. 2:38getting into the details, you need to
  84. 2:40understand one simple thing about our
  85. 2:42brain and, above all, our eye. In any
  86. 2:44image, we will always look at the
  87. 2:46brightest area first. It’s automatic.
  88. 2:48You can’t fight against that. So in a
  89. 2:50shot, if you have an object or a face
  90. 2:52that is well-lit and everything else is
  91. 2:54a bit darker, you will immediately look
  92. 2:56at the brightest area. And that’s
  93. 2:57funny because you don’t even need to
  94. 2:58think about it, actually. It’s
  95. 2:59automatic. It’s a principle we saw a
  96. 3:02bit in the video I made about
  97. 3:03composition, where I explain that an
  98. 3:05image that works is one where the
  99. 3:07viewer knows where to look; we guide
  100. 3:09them. We also saw this a bit with the
  101. 3:11same principle in the video about
  102. 3:13colors, where the brain hates to
  103. 3:14hesitate, so it will tend to look as
  104. 3:16quickly as possible at what it’s
  105. 3:18supposed to look at. And light is
  106. 3:21probably, I think, the most direct tool
  107. 3:23for that, even before color or framing.
  108. 3:27Because what isn't lit in a scene, for
  109. 3:29us as viewers, it’s as if it
  110. 3:30doesn’t exist at all. And that’s
  111. 3:33why in cinema, it’s important when
  112. 3:34lighting a scene not to light
  113. 3:36everything in the set. Normally, the
  114. 3:38goal is precisely to choose to light up
  115. 3:39what we need to look at and,
  116. 3:41consequently, to darken everything else
  117. 3:42. It's really one of the pieces of
  118. 3:44information that tells the viewer to
  119. 3:45look at this, that this is important
  120. 3:46and the rest we don't care about. And
  121. 3:48this, this language, it wasn't cinema
  122. 3:49that invented it, you know. Paintings
  123. 3:51and painters of that time were already
  124. 3:53using it; we've been seeing it for a
  125. 3:55long time. A painter quite well-known
  126. 3:56for this is Caravaggio. So, he's an
  127. 3:58Italian painter who, overall, really
  128. 4:00leaned into this style. He very often
  129. 4:02had very dark scenes, or rather very
  130. 4:05dark, black backgrounds, with a harsh
  131. 4:07light, you see, hitting only one side
  132. 4:09of the characters he painted. And this
  133. 4:12technique is also often called
  134. 4:13chiaroscuro. Basically, it's about
  135. 4:16contrasting a strong light against a
  136. 4:17very dark shadow. It creates what we
  137. 4:21call depth. So, Rembrandt, who was also
  138. 4:24a painter you might know now, he took
  139. 4:26this concept even further. He did a lot
  140. 4:30of portraits, and in every one of them,
  141. 4:32he left what is called a small triangle
  142. 4:34under the eye of his subject. And even
  143. 4:37today, in the videos we see, even in
  144. 4:38the video you are watching, I still use
  145. 4:40his technique. It adds a bit of depth,
  146. 4:42it adds a bit of character, it helps
  147. 4:44prevent everything from looking flat.
  148. 4:46And it's quite striking when you put
  149. 4:48certain film shots next to some of
  150. 4:50these paintings; you can see it, you
  151. 4:51can see that we reuse pretty much the
  152. 4:53same way of lighting our subjects. And
  153. 4:56that, well, since cinematographers,
  154. 4:57directors, and all of them grew up with
  155. 4:59these images, with these old films, and
  156. 5:01with these famous paintings, obviously,
  157. 5:02they draw inspiration from them. So now
  158. 5:07that we've understood that, we can ask
  159. 5:09ourselves how to properly light a scene
  160. 5:11, because it's not just about which
  161. 5:13light I'm going to use, it's mainly
  162. 5:14about where the light comes from and
  163. 5:16how we diffuse it across our scene.
  164. 5:19Because depending on where you place
  165. 5:20your light source, for example in
  166. 5:22relation to a face, you won't be
  167. 5:23telling the same story at all. A front
  168. 5:25light is a light that shows everything.
  169. 5:27So the face is lit in a uniform way.
  170. 5:29There are almost no shadows. So, in
  171. 5:31essence, there's nothing to hide. This
  172. 5:33is typically the light you’ll find on
  173. 5:34a TV news broadcast, and in a lot of
  174. 5:36commercials too. Actually, it has a
  175. 5:38somewhat reassuring, readable quality
  176. 5:39to it. Since it’s quite flat, you
  177. 5:41don't really hide anything, so it lacks
  178. 5:43a bit of character. But from time to
  179. 5:45time, that’s also the emotion you
  180. 5:46want to convey. But it can also be
  181. 5:48useful, typically when you want to,
  182. 5:50quote-unquote, "strip people bare"
  183. 5:51during an interrogation. This type of
  184. 5:53lighting allows you to show, shall we
  185. 5:55say, the subject as naturally as
  186. 5:57possible. Side lighting, now, that gets
  187. 6:00a bit more interesting, because one
  188. 6:02half of the face will be in the light,
  189. 6:04and the other in shadow. Right away, it
  190. 6:07gives more of a sense of volume, 3D,
  191. 6:09and depth, really. You can actually see
  192. 6:11the relief of the person's head, and
  193. 6:13above all, it tells a bit more of a
  194. 6:14story. A character with part of their
  195. 6:17face in shadow feels more mysterious,
  196. 6:18someone who might have doubts or be
  197. 6:20torn between choices. It’s actually
  198. 6:23one of the most common lighting styles
  199. 6:25in cinema because, well, it gives more
  200. 6:27character to the image. And it’s also
  201. 6:30a type of light we find a lot in
  202. 6:31everyday life. It’s quite rare when
  203. 6:33you’re talking to someone that they
  204. 6:34are being completely illuminated by
  205. 6:35light. Usually, the light comes from
  206. 6:37the sun from one direction, or a window
  207. 6:40, or a lamp next to us. So generally,
  208. 6:42when we look at someone, there’s
  209. 6:44always a bit of depth, light that
  210. 6:45isn’t uniform across the whole face.
  211. 6:47Another type of light is the one from
  212. 6:49behind. Which is exactly what we call
  213. 6:51backlighting. Here, the light works a
  214. 6:53bit differently. It comes in to outline
  215. 6:55the character, their hair, and their
  216. 6:57shoulders. And that, too, can be quite
  217. 6:59interesting for maintaining that sense
  218. 7:00of mystery. You can even take it a step
  219. 7:02further to have a character completely
  220. 7:04in shadow. And there, you get what is
  221. 7:06called a silhouette. You don't see the
  222. 7:07face at all anymore, you just have the
  223. 7:09shape, and that's it. That also adds a
  224. 7:10little more to the question of who this
  225. 7:12person is. You can also light from
  226. 7:14above. Now, this one is interesting
  227. 7:16because it doesn't have the same effect
  228. 7:17. Actually, we'll light the forehead,
  229. 7:19nose, and cheekbones, but as a result,
  230. 7:22the eyes fall into shadow. It can
  231. 7:24create what is also known as a bit of a
  232. 7:25panda effect. It's something that isn't
  233. 7:27very flattering for a face, but it's
  234. 7:30also a way to see the person's eyes
  235. 7:32less. And as the expression goes, the
  236. 7:34eyes are the mirror of the soul. Well,
  237. 7:36by not seeing them clearly, we don't
  238. 7:38really know who the character is or
  239. 7:39what they're thinking. Actually, it
  240. 7:41creates a bit more power, a bit more
  241. 7:43mystery, like someone you don't really
  242. 7:45want to cross. And we also have a light
  243. 7:47that I really like, which is
  244. 7:48under-lighting. Now, you all logically
  245. 7:50know this type of light. We all did it
  246. 7:52when we were kids with a flashlight.
  247. 7:54It's that little light under the chin
  248. 7:56when we want to try to tell a scary
  249. 7:57story. And this light, actually, it's
  250. 7:59not a coincidence. Light almost never
  251. 8:02comes from below us in general. Whether
  252. 8:05it's ceiling lights, lamps, or the sun,
  253. 8:08it's always from above. And so when we
  254. 8:10light a face from below, since we're
  255. 8:12not used to it, our brain immediately
  256. 8:14thinks that something is wrong or off.
  257. 8:17Actually, that's why we often find this
  258. 8:19type of setup in horror films, or when
  259. 8:21a character is, let's say, turning to
  260. 8:23the dark side. You see, something
  261. 8:25abnormal is happening. Actually, what I
  262. 8:28find powerful about all these different
  263. 8:30lighting types is that you don't need
  264. 8:31to know them all or know what emotion
  265. 8:33they're supposed to convey. It's
  266. 8:35instinctive. When we look at them, our
  267. 8:37brain doesn't think about where the
  268. 8:38light is coming from. So it means this.
  269. 8:40It just knows, it feels it. That's just
  270. 8:42how it is. So, once we know where the
  271. 8:46light is coming from, one very
  272. 8:48important question remains: how it hits
  273. 8:49the subject. In general, we have more
  274. 8:52or less two choices between hard light
  275. 8:54and soft light. And the same thing
  276. 8:55applies, the choice doesn't mean the
  277. 8:57same thing. A hard light is a light
  278. 8:59source that isn't diffused. So it could
  279. 9:02be, for example, the sun when there are
  280. 9:04no clouds, a bare lightbulb, or a
  281. 9:05spotlight with nothing in front of it.
  282. 9:07Actually, it produces very sharp,
  283. 9:09distinct, well-defined shadows, and so,
  284. 9:11when you look closely at the transition
  285. 9:13between light and dark, it’s quite
  286. 9:15harsh. You can really see the line, in
  287. 9:16fact. And soft light, on the other hand
  288. 9:18, is light that is well-diffused. Often
  289. 9:21, it’s a large light source. So it
  290. 9:24could be a cloudy sky, it could be a
  291. 9:25large window typically with curtains,
  292. 9:27and there it’s completely the
  293. 9:28opposite, and the shadows are much
  294. 9:30lighter. The transition between the lit
  295. 9:32area and the shadowed area is much
  296. 9:34softer, much more gradual. You don't
  297. 9:36really see the line. And often, we can
  298. 9:37present these two ways of lighting as a
  299. 9:39story of quality. Soft light would be
  300. 9:41more like a beautiful light that is a
  301. 9:42bit more flattering, and hard light is
  302. 9:44the opposite. It’s something we try
  303. 9:46to avoid a bit because it creates
  304. 9:48shadows that are too harsh. Except that
  305. 9:50in cinema, it doesn't work like that at
  306. 9:51all. Both are actually used, and both
  307. 9:53tell a different story. Soft light
  308. 9:55represents tenderness, intimacy, a
  309. 9:57memory, a calm moment, a beautiful
  310. 9:59moment. Whereas hard light is more
  311. 10:02about tension, danger, or perhaps an
  312. 10:04overwhelming heat. So once again, there
  313. 10:07is no good or bad light. There is light
  314. 10:10that supports the story and light that
  315. 10:12works against it. Now, up to this point
  316. 10:15, we’ve talked a lot about faces, but
  317. 10:17obviously, light tells us just as much
  318. 10:18through everything around them, like
  319. 10:20the sets and objects. It gives us
  320. 10:22information about what’s going to
  321. 10:23happen and where we should look.
  322. 10:25Typically, an illuminated object in a
  323. 10:27dark room is never a coincidence. Your
  324. 10:29eye will always go to look at it first.
  325. 10:31So, without you even realizing it,
  326. 10:33you’ve logically noted that okay,
  327. 10:34this part or this object is important.
  328. 10:36Light also establishes the place and
  329. 10:38the moment before it’s even explained
  330. 10:39to you, and most importantly, it tells
  331. 10:41you a bit about how you should feel in
  332. 10:43that place. The same room with the same
  333. 10:45furniture can seem warm or completely
  334. 10:47cold just by changing how it’s lit.
  335. 10:49The set hasn't changed, and yet we are
  336. 10:51no longer in the same story at all. A
  337. 10:54light coming through the window that's
  338. 10:56a bit low, a bit warm with rays, well,
  339. 10:58we assume it's either morning or
  340. 10:59evening. And conversely, a light that's
  341. 11:02very high with very few shadows that
  342. 11:04falls straight down. We understand that
  343. 11:06we are generally in the middle of the
  344. 11:07afternoon. And we shouldn't forget
  345. 11:09everything that isn't lit, either. A
  346. 11:12corner of the image where you can't see
  347. 11:13a thing is either because there's
  348. 11:15nothing to show, so we don't want to
  349. 11:17show it, or conversely, it's often
  350. 11:18where a moment of tension hides because
  351. 11:20our brain does something funny: it
  352. 11:21fills in the darkness. It starts to
  353. 11:25imagine what might be in there, what
  354. 11:26might potentially come out, and it
  355. 11:27often imagines the worst. And that's
  356. 11:30why thriller or horror movies, for
  357. 11:32example, really abuse that—what's
  358. 11:34hiding in the darkness? Because in
  359. 11:36general, darkness is a little bit scary
  360. 11:38. Actually, what I find interesting
  361. 11:40about cinema is that, unlike paintings
  362. 11:41—where once the painting is done, the
  363. 11:43light is fixed and doesn't move. In
  364. 11:45cinema, we have the luck and the
  365. 11:46possibility of being able to evolve the
  366. 11:48light over time. And it's the same for
  367. 11:51shifting the emotion, evolving our
  368. 11:52character; it's very practical because
  369. 11:54in well-thought-out films or series,
  370. 11:56the lighting on a character isn't the
  371. 11:57same at the beginning of the story as
  372. 11:59it is at the end. A character starting
  373. 12:02the story is often in full light: their
  374. 12:03face is well-lit, we see everything,
  375. 12:05there's very little character, let's
  376. 12:07say, very little contrast on their face
  377. 12:09. And little by little, over time, we
  378. 12:11start to get more dramatic lighting,
  379. 12:13perhaps harsher with more shadows,
  380. 12:15right up to the final moments where it
  381. 12:17starts to get darker and darker. And I
  382. 12:20find that interesting because no one
  383. 12:21tells us, and I'm almost certain you
  384. 12:22don't even notice it yourselves. And I
  385. 12:24don't notice it either when I'm
  386. 12:25watching movies. And yet, our brain
  387. 12:27understands it. And it can also work
  388. 12:28the other way around, too. A character
  389. 12:30who starts off in the shadows and
  390. 12:32gradually begins to step back into the
  391. 12:34light. You see, we understand they're
  392. 12:35rebuilding themselves, rediscovering a
  393. 12:37taste for life, you know. It's it's
  394. 12:38truly an evolution. It can also be a
  395. 12:40difference in lighting between two
  396. 12:42characters. Between one who is a bit
  397. 12:44harsher, a bit rawer, more defined, and
  398. 12:46the other, on the contrary, who is much
  399. 12:48softer and fully lit. Both are in the
  400. 12:49same place, in the same setting, and
  401. 12:51yet they don't have the same light.
  402. 12:53Always with the idea of showing the
  403. 12:55difference between the two characters,
  404. 12:57who thinks what, who has control or
  405. 12:59power over whom. Light, just like
  406. 13:02framing or color, is there to convey a
  407. 13:04message and explain to you indirectly
  408. 13:07what is happening. And that, typically,
  409. 13:09is the job of someone we often call a
  410. 13:11cinematographer. They work on this in
  411. 13:13advance. It's almost a writing task,
  412. 13:15you know, to understand who the
  413. 13:16character is and what we want to make
  414. 13:18the audience feel in that scene. And
  415. 13:21based on that, we choose the light, how
  416. 13:22we're going to diffuse that light,
  417. 13:24where we're going to place it, and
  418. 13:26obviously, throughout the series or the
  419. 13:28film, will that light evolve? It's it's
  420. 13:31a profession that I find quite
  421. 13:32fascinating. It's extremely important,
  422. 13:34it's what forms the entire foundation
  423. 13:35of a film for me, and as a viewer, it's
  424. 13:37often something we don't necessarily
  425. 13:39think about, but light is everything to
  426. 13:41me in an image. And so, we arrive at
  427. 13:43something a bit paradoxical, because
  428. 13:45one might think that the job of a
  429. 13:46cinematographer is precisely to add
  430. 13:48light. Well, that's partly true. They
  431. 13:50will inevitably set up lights,
  432. 13:52illuminate a set, and make sure we can
  433. 13:54see well on screen. But we often forget
  434. 13:56that a huge part of their work is
  435. 13:58actually taking light away, finding a
  436. 14:00way to cut the light that's hitting a
  437. 14:01wall. Often placing black around a face
  438. 14:04so that the shadow is even more
  439. 14:06pronounced. That's something that is
  440. 14:08done a lot on on film sets. There is
  441. 14:10often a lot of gear that is there just
  442. 14:12for that, in fact. Black actually
  443. 14:14absorbs light and helps remove a little
  444. 14:17bit of the brightness, typically from a
  445. 14:19face. So, on film sets, you see a lot
  446. 14:22of it. So keep in mind that lighting is
  447. 14:24as much about deciding where the light
  448. 14:26goes and how to diffuse it, as it is
  449. 14:28about how to remove it, how to hide it,
  450. 14:30in fact. And the second paradox is the
  451. 14:32light that looks the most natural. It
  452. 14:34is very often crafted, it is very often
  453. 14:36artificial. And a good
  454. 14:38cinematographer's job is precisely to
  455. 14:39make it seem like it's just the light
  456. 14:41in the room, when it's not at all.
  457. 14:43There are dozens of lights right next
  458. 14:44to it, really. So very often when it
  459. 14:46feels like the scene is lit just by a
  460. 14:48candle, a small lamp, a little light,
  461. 14:50no, there is work behind it, there are
  462. 14:52other lights behind it. That is what we
  463. 14:55call motivating a light. The goal is to
  464. 14:58make it look like reality without
  465. 15:00overdoing it. And that slider is very,
  466. 15:03very hard to set at our level. It is
  467. 15:05quite complicated to do. That's
  468. 15:06actually why it's a profession. And now
  469. 15:08that we've seen all that, we can return
  470. 15:10to the initial question. Why do so many
  471. 15:13films and series today have an image
  472. 15:15that is too flat, too clean, too smooth
  473. 15:17? I mean, I don't know if it's just me,
  474. 15:20but I really have the impression we've
  475. 15:21lost that. First, there is something to
  476. 15:24understand: we often confuse two things
  477. 15:26. We tend to mix up lighting and color
  478. 15:28grading. And they are not at all the
  479. 15:30same thing. Lighting is what happens
  480. 15:32during filming and how we light, how
  481. 15:34the light hits a face. Color grading is
  482. 15:36done during editing. It's afterwards,
  483. 15:38we rework the colors, the image
  484. 15:40contrast, the brightness, and sometimes
  485. 15:42we can play with the shadows. But we
  486. 15:44cannot recreate what was filmed on set.
  487. 15:47If the face was lit in a completely
  488. 15:49flat way, well, it will remain flat. We
  489. 15:51won't be able to do anything. Actually,
  490. 15:52during editing. And so, a good part of
  491. 15:54what we criticize in films today
  492. 15:55doesn't come so much from the color
  493. 15:57grading. It's everything that was
  494. 15:59decided during filming, and there are
  495. 16:00several reasons for that. The first is
  496. 16:02the cameras. Back then, films had more
  497. 16:04contrast, more difference between the
  498. 16:06shadows and the lit areas because we
  499. 16:08filmed extensively on film stock. So,
  500. 16:11we had a bit less range, what we call
  501. 16:12dynamic range, which was available
  502. 16:14specifically with cameras from that era
  503. 16:16. But there was also the fact that when
  504. 16:19you film with film, you don't see the
  505. 16:20final result right away. We would
  506. 16:22discover it the next day at the rushes
  507. 16:24screening. So, the cinematographer had
  508. 16:26to set the exact lighting on set
  509. 16:27because they knew that, afterwards, we
  510. 16:28wouldn't be able to go back and change
  511. 16:30it. Today, well, it's different.
  512. 16:32Digital sensors see really well in the
  513. 16:34dark. They handle differences in light
  514. 16:37quite impressively. So, we can recover
  515. 16:39a lot of information, whether in the
  516. 16:41shadows or even in the highlights.
  517. 16:43Technically, it's incredible, but it
  518. 16:45pushes us to think, "Well, we'll decide
  519. 16:47what to do later; we'll decide on the
  520. 16:49contrast, the light, and so on in
  521. 16:51editing." So, we light everything in a
  522. 16:53fairly neutral way, telling ourselves
  523. 16:55that this way we keep options for the
  524. 16:56edit. The problem is that an image that
  525. 16:59keeps too many options is often an
  526. 17:00image where no real choice was made. So
  527. 17:02, it's neutral, and therefore, it's
  528. 17:03flat. Second reason: special effects.
  529. 17:06When a good part of the set will be
  530. 17:08added later, either on green screen or
  531. 17:10in 3D, it's complicated to use very
  532. 17:12distinct lighting on set because you'll
  533. 17:14eventually have to match everything
  534. 17:16with elements that don't exist yet. So
  535. 17:20we stay cautious, we don't take risks,
  536. 17:22and we light in a rather uniform way,
  537. 17:24telling ourselves we'll adjust later.
  538. 17:27The third reason is screens. The
  539. 17:29problem is that today, a film will be
  540. 17:31watched just as well in a cinema with a
  541. 17:33great projector. We'll be able to
  542. 17:35control the contrast effectively. It
  543. 17:36will be well-defined. But the issue is
  544. 17:39that most consumption now happens on
  545. 17:41phones with a tiny screen, in the
  546. 17:43subway or on public transport, with
  547. 17:45lighting that isn't necessarily good.
  548. 17:48And so, a scene that's too dark, which
  549. 17:50was designed and graded for a movie
  550. 17:52theater, for instance, won't look
  551. 17:54nearly as good on an iPhone, iPad, or
  552. 17:56computer screen. And so, the same thing
  553. 17:59, we don't take risks because we know
  554. 18:01our video will potentially be watched
  555. 18:03on a screen that won't show much detail
  556. 18:05. So we try to use less contrast so
  557. 18:07that our image remains more legible.
  558. 18:10And then there’s perhaps a slightly
  559. 18:11more human reason on big productions.
  560. 18:13There are more and more people giving
  561. 18:15their opinions. The footage passes
  562. 18:16through a bunch of hands between
  563. 18:18filming and broadcast. And so when
  564. 18:21there are many decision-makers like
  565. 18:22that, well, there are different
  566. 18:23opinions, and so ultimately we try to
  567. 18:24have something more homogeneous, and
  568. 18:26therefore we take fewer risks. And
  569. 18:28that's how we end up with an image that
  570. 18:30is certainly clean and beautiful, but
  571. 18:32actually looks more like a commercial
  572. 18:33than a film. And personally, I find
  573. 18:35that a shame. That’s just my opinion,
  574. 18:37but I find it actually impoverishes the
  575. 18:39image of quite a few films and quite a
  576. 18:40few series. Particularly series that
  577. 18:42are formatted. I’m thinking in
  578. 18:44particular of the Netflix catalog. I
  579. 18:45find that’s where I see it the most.
  580. 18:47Actually, you get the impression that
  581. 18:48everything comes from the same mold,
  582. 18:50you know, there are almost, like, the
  583. 18:51codes—the Netflix codes. We have soft
  584. 18:53lighting just about everywhere. We have
  585. 18:55the same slightly soft contrasts, we
  586. 18:57have the same, you know, perfect skin.
  587. 18:59And whether it’s a romantic comedy, a
  588. 19:00thriller, or even a period film, well,
  589. 19:02they look the same. I also thought that
  590. 19:05when a platform like that releases so
  591. 19:07much content so quickly, everything
  592. 19:08goes through the same production line,
  593. 19:10from lighting to color grading, and we
  594. 19:12end up with a recipe, a cleaner image
  595. 19:14that has to work on all screens,
  596. 19:16because people will watch it on a phone
  597. 19:18, on a computer, and in the cinema. And
  598. 19:21so, we create images that don't offend
  599. 19:23anyone, that suit everyone, that suit
  600. 19:25all screens, and thus images that don't
  601. 19:27stick in our minds. And actually,
  602. 19:29that’s what bothers me the most;
  603. 19:30it’s not that it's too bright or too
  604. 19:32dark, it's that we don't take risks
  605. 19:33anymore, we don't make choices anymore.
  606. 19:35And it’s not a digital problem,
  607. 19:37because even today, we have series that
  608. 19:39are incredible, we have films that are
  609. 19:41lit in a way that, you know, sticks
  610. 19:42with you. We have shots that leave an
  611. 19:44impression on us, so that means we know
  612. 19:45how to do it. The difference for me is
  613. 19:48simply that someone dared to make
  614. 19:49choices, and they were allowed to make
  615. 19:50those choices. So, I can't help but
  616. 19:53feel that I preferred the look of films
  617. 19:55from back in the day. It was more
  618. 19:57distinct, it had more character, it had
  619. 19:59more visual flair—it spoke to me more
  620. 20:00; I don't know, I just found it more
  621. 20:02natural. Maybe I'm the only one, and
  622. 20:04let me know in the comments if you
  623. 20:06agree with me or not, but I loved that
  624. 20:08side of it with more character, more
  625. 20:10risk-taking, really. And for us in our
  626. 20:12videos, on our small scale as creators,
  627. 20:14we should try to do the same. The
  628. 20:16problem is that we have cameras that
  629. 20:18film, well, very well in low light. We
  630. 20:19can shoot in log. Now, equipment costs
  631. 20:21much less. We can buy LEDs, lights, all
  632. 20:24that. And so, our reflex is to try to
  633. 20:26add more everywhere, to show a lot of
  634. 20:28things, to have a very busy image.
  635. 20:30Whereas the only question to ask is:
  636. 20:32does it actually have a bit of
  637. 20:34character? What are we actually showing
  638. 20:36on screen? Is what we’re showing
  639. 20:37clear? So the next time you go to film
  640. 20:39someone or something, try to ask
  641. 20:41yourself this question before hitting
  642. 20:43record: what do I want to show the
  643. 20:44viewers? What is important in my image?
  644. 20:47How can I try to give it a bit more
  645. 20:50style, a bit more character? So perhaps
  646. 20:53limit the lights a bit more, try to add
  647. 20:55a bit more shadow as well on your
  648. 20:56subject or on your object. And more
  649. 20:59broadly, try to take your time when you
  650. 21:01watch your films. Try to look at shots
  651. 21:03that speak to you or, conversely, shots
  652. 21:04that don't speak to you as much. Try to
  653. 21:06understand where the light is coming
  654. 21:07from and what is motivating it. And
  655. 21:09little by little, you will understand
  656. 21:11better and better what lighting a scene
  657. 21:13means, which isn't just making an image
  658. 21:15visible, but deciding what we show and
  659. 21:17what we hide.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of L'art de la Lumière by Pile et Face, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,548 words across 659 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.