Kylo Wins 3-0: Does the Catholic God Exist? | DOTF Full Debate — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00No 15 10 105. So 15 for the opening uh
- 0:0410 minutes for the first rebuttal.
- 0:07Cross examination
- 0:1110 questions allow
- 0:14second round rebattle is 10 minutes and
- 0:175 minutes closing
- 0:23monitor.
- 0:27Correction 15 15 l
- 0:30no uh 10 uh 15 10 15 10 15 for the
- 0:34opening tapos 10 minutes for first round
- 0:37of pre battles and second round of pre
- 0:38battles is 10 minutes 5 minutes para sa
- 0:41closing so cross examination
- 0:44kasi 10 questions lang
- 0:49okay okay na yeah yeah yeah 15 10
- 0:56Okay. I think Okay. So, let's start
- 1:00again. I I guess we are ready. So, let's
- 1:02give 1 minute each uh flame para
- 1:05affirmative and say Kylo para self
- 1:08introduction nila. Could we do that? 1
- 1:10minute each para self introduction nila.
- 1:13Go on. Uh Chester you will be having 1
- 1:16minute self introduction. Go on. Uh
- 1:20hello. Uh my name is Chester D.
- 1:21Everybody, Catholic apologist here and
- 1:25um I dedicate this uh debate uh to my
- 1:28pro uh one of my respective friends,
- 1:30Professor Mani um and also to my friends
- 1:34at the Matahimic platform uh also of
- 1:37course to the mother church and almighty
- 1:39God. Thank you so much Chester dudes
- 1:41once again Catholic debator
- 1:47also Kylo you will be having 1 minute
- 1:49for your self introduction. Kylo, go on.
- 1:53>> All right. M check. M check. Yeah. How's
- 1:54it going? All right. Well, my name's
- 1:57Kylo.
- 1:58I'm new to the PHCOM. I've been debating
- 2:01for about 2 years now. I stumbled across
- 2:03a PH community. I found Chester Dudes
- 2:06and, you know, was looking for a formal
- 2:08debate, so I'm here now. Um, I just plan
- 2:12to show my skill set and show you guys,
- 2:15you know, what, you know, what Maincom
- 2:16has and what other debaters from other
- 2:18communities have.
- 2:19I'm looking to come to the PHCOM, come
- 2:21to the Philippines soon. So, yeah, I
- 2:23hope you guys enjoy uh my debate.
- 2:28>> Thank you, Kylo. Before the before the
- 2:31uh debate will start, let me just
- 2:33clarify that both of our debaters agreed
- 2:35upon the pre-debate that no point of
- 2:37clarification and information during the
- 2:40opening rebuttals and closing. Objection
- 2:42will only entertain during a
- 2:44crossexamination po. uh affirmative will
- 2:48always go first uh during the uh opening
- 2:50uh rebuttal cross examination as well as
- 2:53in the close uh closing statement. So
- 2:55let's start this debate. I guess
- 3:01Chester Dud's host. We need Chester Dude
- 3:04needs uh to present uh his presentation.
- 3:08Could we do that host?
- 3:13Before
- 3:22the time will start, I guess Chester's
- 3:25dude need need to present something.
- 3:27Host, are you there?
- 3:33Ren.
- 3:37>> Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Ren. Okay.
- 3:38Could we lend the screen to Chester?
- 3:41Dude Beast
- 3:46wait.
- 3:58>> Thank you.
- 4:00>> Hello.
- 4:04>> Uh, your time will start, Chester. Dude,
- 4:06whenever you utter your first mood, go
- 4:08first word. Thank I go on.
- 4:10>> Good afternoon everyone. Well, I cut the
- 4:13motion here. The Catholic God exists. I
- 4:15cut the motion into two parts here. I go
- 4:18from right to left. I prove logic.
- 4:21First, I will prove logically that God
- 4:23exists. Then show that this is the same
- 4:25God that Catholicism professes. All
- 4:27right. So, um I proceed from the
- 4:31argument from change. So in our
- 4:33experience and reasoning, we notice that
- 4:35change happens. It's a constant change.
- 4:37So the song goes, right? But what is
- 4:39change? For simplicity sake, let's talk
- 4:42about a ball on the ground. This ball is
- 4:44about to change its location. It has the
- 4:46potential to go to position G or it has
- 4:50the potential to go to position F. Which
- 4:52position it will actually be on depends
- 4:54on the actualizer. This toy car here is
- 4:58one of those actualizers. If it bumped
- 5:00the ball, ball will go to position G.
- 5:03Now, while if this foot here kicks the
- 5:06ball, instead ball will take position F.
- 5:09Actualizers make potentials actual. But
- 5:12the foot and the toy car are themselves
- 5:14actualized too, and so are the things
- 5:16that actualize them. Here we learn the
- 5:19existence of chain of actualizers. In
- 5:21metaphysics,
- 5:23these are called uh the causal chains.
- 5:26For any event, for example, this one or
- 5:29for any event, there are two directions
- 5:31the causal chain could recede to. Either
- 5:33back in time or what we call linear
- 5:35causal chain or down to contingency
- 5:38which we call hierarchical causal chain.
- 5:40Linear chain could be infinite or not.
- 5:43But it's the hierarchical chain that
- 5:45couldn't be infinite as you will see
- 5:47later.
- 5:49Why is the why is the toy car running
- 5:51actual? Well, it's because infrared
- 5:55signal is actual, right? And why is
- 5:58that? Well, it's because transmitters
- 6:00are actual. These explanations stack on
- 6:03top of each other such that if you
- 6:05removed anyone below, the upward stack
- 6:08will not um will not realize or will not
- 6:11um actualize, right? So uh for example
- 6:16if the ground remain just potential this
- 6:18ground here just remain potential it
- 6:21will not have the causal power to cause
- 6:23or put into effect any of those uh above
- 6:26it and if it will not have a causal
- 6:28power to actualize anything above it
- 6:30because potentialities mere
- 6:32potentialities do not have causal
- 6:34powers. All these actualizers here are
- 6:37just causal power borrowers. They are
- 6:39borrowing from the one beneath them.
- 6:42Right? But the same way um but there
- 6:45there couldn't be an infinity of
- 6:46borrowers. The same way that there
- 6:48couldn't be an infinite book borrowers
- 6:50without anyone to lend that book in the
- 6:52first place. The only reason this chain
- 6:54could exist at all is if there is a
- 6:57base. It has to have a base and that and
- 7:00and that base must not be just another
- 7:02borrower but itself the causal power
- 7:05choice uh power source. Right? Okay. So
- 7:09change is the actualization of a
- 7:11potential. In our scenario, uh the toy
- 7:14the the toy car uh runs the toy car has
- 7:17an infinity of potentials actually. It
- 7:18could run backwards, it could run
- 7:20forward, it could explode, it could tilt
- 7:22sideways. But uh how does the selection
- 7:25happen of which potentiality becomes
- 7:27actual? Well, the selector is the green
- 7:29arrow here, right? For a potential to P
- 7:33to become actual A, an arrow is needed.
- 7:35We call that arrow the actualizer. But
- 7:38then we ask what is this arrow made of?
- 7:40If we zoomed in we find out that it's
- 7:42also a set of potentialities like press
- 7:45forward boy press left o boy throws
- 7:47remote control which is reduced uh to an
- 7:50actual thing. This actual thing also
- 7:53needs an arrow of its own. We keep
- 7:54zooming but arrows which requires arrows
- 7:57themselves keep on appearing.
- 7:59Nevertheless, we already know that for
- 8:01this causal chain to exist at all, it
- 8:03has to have a stopping point. It has to
- 8:05have a base. But how?
- 8:08Obviously, we need to stop arrows from
- 8:12going um on and on, right? So simple. We
- 8:16just erase the arrow uh at the middle.
- 8:19There, problem solved. Hooray, right?
- 8:23No, this is a contradiction. Without the
- 8:26arrow, potentiality and actuality cancel
- 8:28each other out. One has to go. Should
- 8:31actuality vanish? But if it did, what
- 8:33remains is potentiality? But as we have
- 8:35seen earlier, potentiality has no causal
- 8:37power. So for us to have a stopping
- 8:40point that retains its causal power, it
- 8:42is potentiality that must say um that
- 8:45must say bye-bye. Right? So that leaves
- 8:48us with just actuality.
- 8:51Okay? Uh purely without mingling of any
- 8:53potentiality. In other words, purely
- 8:55actual. Ladies and gentlemen, behold the
- 8:58acturus. So the acturus looks like looks
- 9:01something like this. This is the cosal
- 9:03chain in 3D here. It is the base of all
- 9:06causal chains. And in fact, the octopus
- 9:09must exist. It does not only exist, but
- 9:12it is the necessary base of all that
- 9:14exists. Not only for actual things, but
- 9:17even of all potential things. Right?
- 9:20There is by the way an infinite causal
- 9:21chain as as represented in my drawing
- 9:23here. Each line here represents a causal
- 9:26chain. So for one event is uh just like
- 9:29the one that we discussed the toy car
- 9:31runs on the ground. There are infinite
- 9:34causal chains that we can conceive. We
- 9:36only discussed one kind of causal chain
- 9:38so far. This blue here I represent as
- 9:40the aristatilian causal chain. There is
- 9:43also the causal chain of composition.
- 9:46Right? So the the chains of
- 9:48actualization came from Aristotle. The
- 9:50chains of composition came from Plato
- 9:52and chains of essence and their
- 9:53existence which came from St. Thomas
- 9:55Aquinas. Each chain behaves differently
- 9:58but they ultimately burst forth from
- 10:00porous totus simplex in English that's
- 10:05purity totality and simplicity. St.
- 10:07Thomas Aquinas famously called it divine
- 10:10simplicity. Right? So before I proceed
- 10:12to my the next part of my um talk um
- 10:16before I proceed to the next part I like
- 10:17to pull up a side note the principle of
- 10:19proportion causality. So PPC the effect
- 10:22everything in the effect is already in
- 10:24the cost either in manner formally,
- 10:26virtually or imminently. Formally is if
- 10:28for example I can give you a $20 bill
- 10:30because I have a $20 bill and virtually
- 10:33if I can cash out from a $20 bill from
- 10:35the G-Cash app then give it to you then
- 10:38imminently if I was given access to the
- 10:41national bank to print a 20 bill any
- 10:43time. So even though I don't have it yet
- 10:45I have the power to print it. All right.
- 10:48So in our pre- debate um in the pre-
- 10:51debate, Kylo asked me for four
- 10:53attributes. Okay, four attributes of
- 10:55God. Namely, omnisient, omnipotent,
- 10:57allloving, um the four guys. So way too
- 11:01many for me to handle. So today I'm just
- 11:03going to go and give 10. Now let's
- 11:05interrogate. Okay. So are there multiple
- 11:08octurus? Are there actor puri instead of
- 11:11just octopurus? AP1 and AP2. But um
- 11:15there are parts in AP2 that AP2 AP1
- 11:17should not have to distinguish between
- 11:18the two, right? And vice versa. Meaning
- 11:20both APs have potentials that are not
- 11:23actualized. Ain't no acturus with an
- 11:25actualized potential. It's a fake
- 11:27because the octurus must be um where is
- 11:31it? Yeah. The octurus must be one and
- 11:34Catholicism adheres to that. So does it
- 11:37change? Meaning to actualize a potential
- 11:39it has uh has it uh does it change? it
- 11:42meaning it has a potential of its own.
- 11:44So that is not uh possible because it
- 11:47has a potential. So it's changeless and
- 11:50it's uh adhered to by the fourth lateran
- 11:52council and uh the the catechism of the
- 11:55Catholic Church. All right. Next. Is it
- 11:57in time? Okay. Uh is it in time? So well
- 12:02to be in time is to have a before and
- 12:04then after. And those denote uh change.
- 12:06Ain't no spot that change. Get out of
- 12:09here. Right. And is it material? Well,
- 12:12material is made of particles and those
- 12:14particles can occupy potential potential
- 12:16other places. So the octtopus purus
- 12:19could not be material. It has to be
- 12:21immaterial and capitalisticism. Here I
- 12:24cited Augustine who is a doctor of the
- 12:25church and Gregor Gregory of Nasiansis
- 12:27also a doctor of the church affirms
- 12:29that. Is it imperfect? Does this have a
- 12:32potential to be perfect? Um uh it will
- 12:36be perfect someday. It has potential to
- 12:38be perfect. Ain't no spurus with a
- 12:39potential. and so affirms Catholicism.
- 12:42The actus purus has to be uh has to be
- 12:46perfect. Okay. And Catholicism adheres
- 12:49to that. Okay. Does it lack something?
- 12:52Is it deprived of something? No. Because
- 12:54to be deprived of something means that
- 12:56you lack something which is you have the
- 12:58potential to get it. So meaning without
- 13:00any deprivation it is all good. And
- 13:03Catholicism adheres to that. Is there
- 13:05anything it cannot do? Well, if it's if
- 13:08it couldn't do uh one thing, then it
- 13:11couldn't be called an octopus because it
- 13:13couldn't be the source of all possible
- 13:14existence, right? And Catholicism says
- 13:17that yes, it is omnipotent. Ain't no
- 13:19octoorus with a potential. So, it is
- 13:21omnipotent as Catholicism adheres to in
- 13:24the catechism along with the Bible. Is
- 13:26it made of parts? Well, if it's actually
- 13:28made of parts, this means that somebody
- 13:30else has uh assembled it together. But
- 13:33by who? A said. So uh it couldn't be
- 13:36made of parts or non-composite. So
- 13:39Aquinus said it is it should be simple
- 13:42because it cannot be composite or made
- 13:43of parts that's assembled by somebody
- 13:45else. This is adhered to by catechism,
- 13:47St. Thomas Aquinus and of course St.
- 13:49Augustine. Now there is there anything
- 13:52it doesn't know? Okay. Things that exist
- 13:54already exist in the octurus though not
- 13:56formally but imminently. So even if
- 13:58material things did not exist in the
- 14:00octtoospurus there are three exist there
- 14:03are it could through the principle of
- 14:05proportions gausality they could exist
- 14:07in the octto purus if not formally they
- 14:09are there eminently. So like like if if
- 14:13an artist right if an artist like an
- 14:15idea of a painting it exists first in
- 14:16his mind. Uh so since it is uh it could
- 14:20not exist materially it is in the form
- 14:22of abstract. So these are ideas and
- 14:24propositions. Therefore we can conclude
- 14:26that this octaspurus is uh has abstract
- 14:29ideas and could concret concretize them.
- 14:32It has all the basis of Socrates or
- 14:34mortal man and the the the assembly of
- 14:37thou thought Socrates as a mortal man.
- 14:39It also contains Kylo the thought of
- 14:41Kylo or the sako and it could also have
- 14:45Kylo in the sacko as a thought in inside
- 14:47that mind. All right and then we go to
- 14:50the final question. How many minutes do
- 14:52I have? Four minutes. All right. Is it
- 14:53all loving? Okay. So according to uh
- 14:57individual mind substantial and
- 14:58rationalist that consists of a a person
- 15:02right and we have proven that it is a
- 15:04mind it has intellect and rationality
- 15:06from the previous uh here. So will uh
- 15:10since we uh being a mind that chooses
- 15:12chronologies of causation denotes will
- 15:14and rationality uh Butheus proposed and
- 15:17Kant and Libnets are are close followers
- 15:19of that as actress Purus is a person the
- 15:22deep uh we look at the experience of
- 15:24persons namely human beings us we look
- 15:26into the deepest questions of our lives
- 15:28and that deepest question is what is
- 15:30love. Aquinus defined it as a willing
- 15:32the good of the other. Right? The
- 15:34willing the good of the other. Um we
- 15:37distinguish four kinds of the willing.
- 15:38First stoay love that thrives or dies
- 15:41depending on what it requires from
- 15:42nature. Requires is just a fancy word
- 15:45for receive in return. Second is filia.
- 15:48Love that thrives or dies depending on
- 15:50what requires from a companion. Third is
- 15:52arrows. The synergy or combination of
- 15:54the previous two. And then finally agape
- 15:56a love that is not requisitely
- 15:58dependent.
- 16:00returning to PPC. Um we let's check
- 16:02these four. Which of these can be
- 16:04ascribed formally to the octurus? All
- 16:06right. The first three the first three
- 16:08here are requisitely dependent meaning
- 16:10they require an other. So though they
- 16:13exist in the AP they exist only in a
- 16:15manner eminently. But since agape is
- 16:18totally donative or effusive meaning
- 16:20it's totally donates it's asiatic in
- 16:22nature it depends only on itself. Agape
- 16:26is present in the octtoospurus in a
- 16:28manner formally. If it is present in the
- 16:31octoporus in a manner formally,
- 16:34it is present in toto because remember
- 16:37the octopurus has no parts. So in toto
- 16:41in totality. So love agape
- 16:45love is all loving. God is all loving.
- 16:49But now we discuss right this is the god
- 16:52that exists. Catholicism affir a affirms
- 16:55all these attributes. No Catholic
- 16:57doctrine contradicts any of these
- 16:59attributes. Therefore, this is the god
- 17:01that Catholicism professes. Okay, let's
- 17:04go here to the first part. Catholic god
- 17:06exists. So what's the Catholic god? So
- 17:09when we say Catholic god, the god that
- 17:10Catholicism recognized, right? And just
- 17:13like when we say Muslim god, the god
- 17:15that Islam recognized or Greek gods, the
- 17:17gods that ancient Greeks recognized. So
- 17:19but we don't say it like Catholic god.
- 17:22God is a Catholic man that God prays the
- 17:24rosary or goes to confession. This just
- 17:26means that Catholic is just under the
- 17:28roof of Catholicism and that
- 17:30Lutheranism's roof has a non- good under
- 17:32it. Right? Uh and so does all the other
- 17:36denominations. But that is not the claim
- 17:39here. The claim is that even though
- 17:42Catholicism
- 17:44points to this god along with uh Calvin
- 17:47and Luther, it doesn't makes it wrong
- 17:50that Catholics point at this god that
- 17:52exists. So even if we go back in time
- 17:55and found out that the pyramids actually
- 17:58we can actually see in their
- 17:59heroglyphics that it says omnisient,
- 18:02one, immutable, immaterial, timeless,
- 18:04omnipotent, all loving, all good. Then
- 18:06more power to the Egyptians.
- 18:08they can point to that God with us. So
- 18:12it's an a straw man if if my opp if my
- 18:14opponent would counter me by saying well
- 18:17you don't believe the same way the the
- 18:19Lutherans or the Calvinists. No the it's
- 18:22even irrelevant to say it's even
- 18:24irrelevant to say that Komi here is
- 18:26pointing at a version of God who likes
- 18:2810%. Right? It's irrelevant to the
- 18:32question because even if this guy points
- 18:35here and Abdul here points to a god who
- 18:38who has the idea that you can get um
- 18:42six-year-old girls even if those are
- 18:44real and these are real you know even if
- 18:47those are real events that does not
- 18:49affect the fact that Catholicism or
- 18:52Peter here is pointing at this god.
- 18:55Therefore the first notion or the first
- 18:58part or the fir the second half God
- 18:59sufficiently proven by the 10 classical
- 19:01attributes exists and then god of the
- 19:05Catholics exist. So that just means in
- 19:08totality the god sufficiently proven
- 19:10necessary by the 10 classical attributes
- 19:12exists. This is the god of the catholics
- 19:15the catholic god exists. Thank you so
- 19:18much.
- 19:18>> Thank you so much. Yeah. Thank you.
- 19:20Thank you so much. uh Chester dude. That
- 19:22was really a fascinating yet absorbing
- 19:24opening statement coming from our
- 19:26affirmative which is Chester Dudes. So
- 19:28I'm exciting. I I mean I really it
- 19:31really is an exciting uh opening
- 19:32statement coming from our affirmative. I
- 19:35I am also excited to hear uh opening uh
- 19:37the opening statement of our opposition
- 19:39side which is the uh King Kylo. So we
- 19:43will be giving King Kylo also a 15
- 19:45minutes time for uh for his opening
- 19:48statement. Okay. Okay. King Kylo, your
- 19:51time will start whenever you enter your
- 19:52first word. Go on.
- 19:54>> Yeah, it was a it was a cool opening.
- 19:56This guy drew that all out. Sure. So, I
- 19:59just have my opening written. I'm just
- 20:01going to read over it. All right. So, I
- 20:03first want to thank the opponent and the
- 20:05judges for participating in this debate.
- 20:07As this is my first formal debate within
- 20:09the PHCOM and I've done immense
- 20:11studying, I just hope to, you know, show
- 20:13you guys what I'm here to do. So, the
- 20:15proposition is the Catholic God exists.
- 20:18Um and that's what we'll be in
- 20:19contingent today. So
- 20:22my first position is that the
- 20:23proposition has not been adequately
- 20:25established and I will challenge the
- 20:27philosophical arguments offered in this
- 20:29defense. Before presenting my case, I
- 20:31want to clarify the burden of proof.
- 20:33Okay. So the affirmative bears the
- 20:34burden of proof and must provide a
- 20:36logically valid and defensible argument
- 20:39supporting the existence of a Catholic
- 20:40god. My burden of rejoinder is to
- 20:43identify and defend objections to the
- 20:44affirmative argument.
- 20:47And for this debate, my opponent has
- 20:48defined a Catholic God as Okay, I want
- 20:51all the adjudicators I want all the
- 20:52adjudicators to please take notes while
- 20:54I'm giving the opening. Remember, in the
- 20:56pre-debate, my opponent has defined a
- 20:58Catholic god. Let me go back to where
- 20:59I'm at.
- 21:04Okay.
- 21:08Okay. My opponent has defined a Catholic
- 21:10god as a logically necessary being.
- 21:12Remember that for the audience, for
- 21:13everyone listening. My opponent defined
- 21:15a god as a logically necessary being,
- 21:17omnisient and omnipotent creator of the
- 21:19universe who possesses a mind. My case
- 21:22will examine whether these attributes
- 21:23can coherently be maintained and whether
- 21:25the additional metaphysical commitments
- 21:27required by this conception are
- 21:30justified. Okay, so my first argument
- 21:32concerns the aloneess argument. This is
- 21:34an argument uh created by Joe Schmidt
- 21:36and Ryan Mullins. Um yeah, Ryan Mullins.
- 21:40Um, and the argument challenges the
- 21:42compatibility of divine simplicity,
- 21:43divine omniscience, and divine creative
- 21:45freedom together with the possibility
- 21:47that God exists without anything
- 21:50distinct from himself.
- 21:53Divine simplicity is the doctrine that
- 21:55God has no metaphysical composition and
- 21:57possesses no accidental properties.
- 21:59Omniscience is the claim that God knows
- 22:01every truth. Divine created freedom is a
- 22:04claim that God is not compelled by a
- 22:06necessity to create a universe. And an
- 22:08accidental property is a property entity
- 22:10possesses but could have could have
- 22:12lacked while remaining that same entity.
- 22:15Okay. So I want you guys to consider a
- 22:17possible world which God exists but
- 22:20creates nothing. God have created he
- 22:22could have created a universe um yet he
- 22:24does not. The truth that God creates
- 22:26nothing is contingent if he could have
- 22:29chosen otherwise. Okay. So if he could
- 22:30have chosen to not create that means
- 22:32that that creation is contingent. God's
- 22:34omniscience requires him to know the
- 22:36truth about his own creative activity in
- 22:39that world. Okay. So I will argue that
- 22:41knowledge must be wholly intrinsic and
- 22:43that contingent intrinsic knowledge
- 22:45conflicts with divine simplicity given
- 22:47cath cath given Catholicism commits you
- 22:50to divine simplicity on the basis this
- 22:52argument is sound the Catholic god
- 22:54cannot exist. That's the first argument.
- 22:56It's going to be a commulative case.
- 22:57It's going to be a multi-stage argument.
- 22:58Okay. The second argument I'm going to
- 23:01be running in this debate concerns
- 23:03theoretical virtues. Specifically,
- 23:06quantitative parsimony. Okay. So,
- 23:08quantitative parsimony is the principle
- 23:10that all else being equal. A theory
- 23:12positing fewer entities is preferred to
- 23:14the one positing more entities without
- 23:16providing additional explanatory
- 23:18benefits. The justification that every
- 23:21additional entity introduces additional
- 23:23onlogical commitments requiring
- 23:25justification.
- 23:27If two theories explain the phenomena
- 23:29equally well but one requires fewer
- 23:31entities, there is a rational reason to
- 23:34prefer the theory with with um fewer
- 23:36commitments. This does not mean that the
- 23:38simpler theory is always true. Parsimony
- 23:40is a comparative virtue, not an
- 23:42infallible truth. Okay. Additional
- 23:45entities are justified when they explain
- 23:47evidence that a simpler theory cannot
- 23:49adequately explain. My opponent may
- 23:51respond that parsimony cannot pro um
- 23:54prove um physicalism is true something
- 23:56of that nature. I agree that's not the
- 23:58whole point. The whole point is
- 23:59comparative. So it's not deductive. It's
- 24:01just a comparative analysis. The
- 24:03question is whether the additional
- 24:04immaterial substance is justified um by
- 24:08explanatory benefits that some
- 24:10naturalistic account cannot adequately
- 24:12provide. If the affirmative cannot
- 24:14demonstrate such benefits, then it has
- 24:16not been established that the additional
- 24:18ontological commitments is necessary.
- 24:20Quantitative parsimony consequently
- 24:22gives us reasons to prefer um some
- 24:25naturalist account when the competing
- 24:27explanations are otherwise comparable.
- 24:29The burden um the burden remains on the
- 24:31affirmative to show why its additional
- 24:33metaphysical commitments are warranted.
- 24:35Okay, so that's two arguments so far.
- 24:39The third argument and this is this is
- 24:42this is the key. I want all the
- 24:43adjudicators please note this down. My
- 24:46third objection concerns the claim that
- 24:48God exists necessarily. Okay. My
- 24:51opponent maintains that God is a
- 24:53logically necessary being. Meaning that
- 24:56God exists in every logically possible
- 24:58world. Oh wow. I will challenge this
- 25:00claim by um arguing that a possible
- 25:02world containing no minds is possible
- 25:04and that if such a world is genuinely
- 25:06possible, the Catholic God cannot exist
- 25:08as a logically necessary being. First,
- 25:11we must define logically a logical
- 25:14necessity. A proposition is logically
- 25:16necessary if it's an if its negation
- 25:19entails a contradiction. Conversely, if
- 25:21a proposition is logically possible, its
- 25:23truth does not require that it holds in
- 25:25every possible world. Therefore, to
- 25:27establish that God exists necessarily,
- 25:29my opponent must demonstrate that a
- 25:31world without God is impossible.
- 25:35Okay. Consider a possible world
- 25:37containing physical reality but no
- 25:39minds. Okay. So, just saying can we can
- 25:41we do we think that there are possible
- 25:42worlds where there are physical state of
- 25:44beings but there are just no minds.
- 25:45Okay. No humans, no human minds, no
- 25:48animal minds, um no conscious organisms,
- 25:50no mind. Simplicity. In this world,
- 25:53physical processes occurs but there are
- 25:55no mental subjects, thoughts, beliefs or
- 25:57acts of consciousness. In this
- 25:59description or or sorry, if this
- 26:01description is logically coherent and
- 26:03does not entail a contradiction, then a
- 26:05mindless world is logically possible.
- 26:07Now consider the implication for my
- 26:08opponent's view. The Catholic God is
- 26:11defined as a being possessing a mind and
- 26:13existing necessarily. Okay? If God
- 26:16exists necessarily, then God must exist
- 26:18in every logically possible world.
- 26:20Consequently, every possible world must
- 26:22contain at least one mind, which is
- 26:25God's mind. Okay. So, just to wrap up my
- 26:28opening statement, what I've now done is
- 26:30I've given three arguments um which are
- 26:32in contention with my opponent's view.
- 26:34Um like I said, you know, my name is
- 26:36Kylo. I'm here to just show you guys um
- 26:38what I can do from the main com. I hope
- 26:39the PH com enjoys my presentation and
- 26:41what I can uh do for this debate. But
- 26:43with that being said, I can relinquish
- 26:44the rest of my time and we can get into
- 26:47um the meat and potatoes.
- 27:05Uh, did the adjudicator hear me?
- 27:08>> Yeah. Yeah, we're here.
- 27:10>> Or not the adjudicators, but the
- 27:11moderator. I'm I'm relinquishing the
- 27:13rest of my time.
- 27:14>> Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, you're waving your
- 27:15time. Thank you. Thank you so much,
- 27:16Kylo. So let's move forward to the next
- 27:19part of the debate which is the first
- 27:21rebuttal round that will come first uh
- 27:23to our uh affirmative side which is uh
- 27:26Chester dudes. So are you ready Chester?
- 27:30>> Is it possible that we go um side by
- 27:32side like two two boxes
- 27:34>> after? Yeah. After this after this first
- 27:36rebuttal uh then let's go to you uh King
- 27:39Kylo. Yes. What what I'm asking is like
- 27:41the format like are we able to format it
- 27:43where there's like two two
- 27:45>> May I just may I just request uh the
- 27:47host
- 27:49yeah to let back in the uh first format
- 27:52of the debate.
- 27:57I think we're good. Thank you. Thank you
- 27:58so much host. So uh we will be having
- 28:01our first round of rebattle. First uh uh
- 28:04first is the our affirmative side. Uh we
- 28:06will we will give uh 10 minutes time I
- 28:10guess. Am I right? Yeah, we will give 10
- 28:12minutes for the uh affirmative
- 28:15uh flames. Let's give uh Chester do the
- 28:1710-minut time.
- 28:18>> Sorry sir, sorry to cut you off. Um did
- 28:21you say 10 minutes? I thought it's 10
- 28:23questions.
- 28:24>> No. Uh we will be having a first round
- 28:26of pre battle first then uh we will we
- 28:28will be going in the uh cross
- 28:30examination and then a second round of
- 28:32rebattle. That's what you agree upon in
- 28:34the in your free debate. Yeah. So, uh we
- 28:37will be starting our first round of pre
- 28:39battle. Go on. Uh Chester, dude, you
- 28:40will be having uh 10 minutes.
- 28:42>> Yeah. Can I request again to show my
- 28:45screen, please?
- 28:49>> Guest host uh Chester Dudes will be
- 28:54having a presentation again.
- 28:57Okay.
- 28:59>> That's
- 29:01all right.
- 29:02>> Go on.
- 29:03>> All right. So please start my time. So
- 29:05actually I I don't know if anybody
- 29:08caught it but I actually have here a
- 29:10trap card. I call it the ontological
- 29:12trap card. So I welcome Kylo to my
- 29:16ontological trap card. Let's dive in. So
- 29:18he said that uh he said um he made a
- 29:21claim that u is in the ontological um
- 29:24liitian model ontological model um the
- 29:29god would not exist right in every
- 29:32possible world right so here in the trap
- 29:35card that I made I actually made a a
- 29:37little cartoon here so it's like I was
- 29:39building my argument right I was
- 29:41building my argument and I said hey man
- 29:43made my house come destroy it but what
- 29:46did my opponent do he built his own
- 29:48house said no thank you I'll build my
- 29:50own ontological argument I don't know
- 29:52how I caught it like I just thought that
- 29:54it could come up into the conversation
- 29:56he made his own castle of ontological
- 29:58argument and instead of attacking my
- 30:00house
- 30:02he kicked his own house
- 30:05tore that flag away right so he did that
- 30:08so the burden of rejoinder he failed the
- 30:10burden of rejoinder at that part right
- 30:12because it's not at all related to what
- 30:15I'd laid out here and I I was able to
- 30:17prove that it's necessary being. I was
- 30:19able to prove that in this part here. So
- 30:22this part here I said that the causal
- 30:26chain has to have a base. It is a
- 30:28necessary base for anything to exist at
- 30:31all. If you don't have that base then
- 30:33don't expect anything to be existing
- 30:36because the existence borrows from some
- 30:38something under it. And we also already
- 30:41discussed I already showed that there
- 30:43couldn't be an infinity of book
- 30:46borrowers. One has to lend that book in
- 30:49the first place. So that's my first trap
- 30:52is the uh ontological uh argument. I saw
- 30:56I saw that coming. So the respondi oh
- 30:59no.
- 31:03So that's my first trap here. And I it
- 31:06was quite wild um for me to be able to
- 31:08predict that by thanks so much for that
- 31:11Kylo. And also uh your next um one of
- 31:14your other you said the parimony of the
- 31:17additional material substance. Okay so
- 31:20Aquinus made it claim that uh creation
- 31:22is ex nihilo right from nothing. Uh
- 31:26welcome again come again welcome again
- 31:27to my trap card here the anthological
- 31:30trap card. So, so there is actually
- 31:32what's called uh creation by here. So,
- 31:36what's your do you take creation as
- 31:39something like like if God created a
- 31:41triangle, right? Do you take the
- 31:43perspective that God plus triangle
- 31:46essence plus the essence of triangle
- 31:48creates a triangle? Therefore, this is
- 31:50called the bringing forth ideiation of
- 31:52creation. So it's like the uh the common
- 31:56uh thing to think about when you when
- 31:59you think of creation, right? So and uh
- 32:02Kylo actually gave the word addition. So
- 32:04that's why this symbol is here. God plus
- 32:07triangle essence equals triangle that
- 32:10brings forth triangle. So this actually
- 32:13is what's called the X material creation
- 32:15creating from material, right? But the
- 32:19creation from Xnihilo is something else.
- 32:21It's actually subtractive. And that's
- 32:22why uh uh Thomas Aquinus also discussed
- 32:25about via negativa or the negative way.
- 32:28So God minus so in creating a triangle
- 32:32he God does this. God is already a tri
- 32:35God is already among other things
- 32:37triangle among every other thing a a
- 32:39triangle. So in creating a triangle what
- 32:42God did is God minus all non- triangle
- 32:46essences. So he removed a squareness, he
- 32:48removed circlesness, he removed catness,
- 32:50dogness, every nest that you can think
- 32:52of and what remains is a triangle. So
- 32:56God did not add something to create
- 32:58something. God actually withdraws. So
- 33:00this is called the drawing back ideation
- 33:03of creation. It's something like when
- 33:04you say when we say that light uh white
- 33:08the white color is the presence of all
- 33:10color, right? How do you create the
- 33:13color red from white? Okay, if we we
- 33:17want to make this purple here, we
- 33:19actually take a color purple and shade
- 33:22in the white, right? But that is not the
- 33:24way God created. God created via
- 33:28negativa according to to Aquinus ex
- 33:30nilo. And so for example, if I want to
- 33:33create the color red, what I do is to
- 33:35withdraw all non reds in that color
- 33:37wheel. I with redraw the blue, I
- 33:39withdraw the green. All right? So and
- 33:41that's why what would remain is the red.
- 33:44So God if God created the red God is
- 33:46already in the red right or God did not
- 33:50created a red a new outside of itself
- 33:53but God the octopus purus has all
- 33:55potential and actualities already intact
- 33:58all we need to do is to give way for
- 34:01that particular thing for example if I
- 34:03want so earlier when we colored the
- 34:05circle here um purple we added a purple
- 34:10color but here if you want to create a
- 34:13purple in the via negative away, you
- 34:15actually remove the red, remove the
- 34:16orange, remove every other color and
- 34:19you'll remain with a purple. So it's
- 34:21like this when God created X nihilo. So
- 34:25if when God created catnness or the cat,
- 34:28what actually God did is not to have
- 34:31this is God, right? This is God. And
- 34:33then he create outside of himself a cat.
- 34:36No, that is not the case. So what
- 34:37actually happens is God withdraw all
- 34:40whatnesses and whnesses is the essence
- 34:43of a thing right it God withdrew all
- 34:47kyoness potness bookness spoonness
- 34:50forkness animeness triangelness phoness
- 34:54all of that he removed that and gave way
- 34:57and emptied it filled it with
- 34:59nothingness but he is still in he God is
- 35:02still in there why because God is also
- 35:05possesses catnness
- 35:08the existence of catness. Right? So
- 35:11imagine this. This whole gray thing,
- 35:13this whole gray thing here, that's God
- 35:17in creating a cat. Cat uh God, I'm
- 35:20sorry. God actually withdrew from the
- 35:23concept or the essence of a cat. But he
- 35:27uh and this boundary here, this broken
- 35:29line here denotes the boundary of
- 35:31everything that separates from cat.
- 35:34Okay? That's why what remains is cat.
- 35:36The space is the nihilo and catnness
- 35:39remains the the existence of god in the
- 35:41essence of the cat. So that's how we
- 35:43should understand creation. That's why I
- 35:46deny uh that my argument is coming from
- 35:49the parimony of additional material of a
- 35:52material substance.
- 35:54Right? And then finally uh I still have
- 35:573 minutes. God exists necessarily in a
- 35:59limnitian model or ontological argument.
- 36:02It's just the same as the first one he
- 36:04gave. It's still an ontological
- 36:05argument, but now he's he's adding that
- 36:09I I it's almost crazy. I uh I don't
- 36:12think he repeated himself, but it almost
- 36:15exactly is the same argument. So, I will
- 36:18go back to my first uh trap card here,
- 36:20right? He just Yeah, he just made
- 36:24Libnisen contingency argument. So, the
- 36:26first one is like the ontological
- 36:28argument and second one is just the lies
- 36:31contingency argument. So yeah, the same
- 36:33comic here but a different title on that
- 36:36castle. And by the way, I noticed that
- 36:38his argument um is from the atheist Joe
- 36:41Schmidt. He mentioned that the first one
- 36:45uh one of the proponents of that
- 36:47argument or one who expounded that
- 36:48argument is George Schmidt. Bro, he was
- 36:51an atheist. Uh have you heard the news?
- 36:54Um he's actually Catholic now. So I
- 36:56don't know uh how outdated these
- 36:58arguments are. So yeah, so um now as my
- 37:05rebuttal actually there would be as I I
- 37:08would like to kind of help my opponent
- 37:10here. There would be much more potency
- 37:13if you attack this argument here like
- 37:16you you did nothing to destroy or
- 37:19dismantle the the commulative pro
- 37:22proving that we did here at the 10
- 37:24steps. So you're requested for I gave 10
- 37:28and they are commulative they depend
- 37:30like here timelessness depended on the
- 37:33proof that God is changeless right it's
- 37:36commulative so the one builds up from
- 37:38the previous one and here god is loving
- 37:41has a will uh builds up from the reality
- 37:44that he has a mind he is able to to uh
- 37:48accomplish uh uh compose right in it in
- 37:52himself right okay So, so this one here,
- 37:57I was expecting that he would, you know,
- 37:59uh, show that, hey, that your idea of
- 38:02God is actually not more general. How
- 38:05about the idea of the Anunnakis? How
- 38:06about the idea of the, uh, these gods,
- 38:09the pagan gods, right? Then that would
- 38:12have more potency. But I see, I also do
- 38:15understand that Kylo has like a strength
- 38:17here over this part that god exists. So,
- 38:19this is his ontological arguments. And
- 38:21if uh uh these are his strength and so
- 38:24he focused here and even that did not
- 38:28suffice for him to uh to like where's
- 38:31your where's your argument to shake any
- 38:34commulative building I've I've done here
- 38:38right you you showed like ontological
- 38:40argument that's argues for necessary uh
- 38:43necessity I have necessity here and this
- 38:46is the not the type of necessity that
- 38:48you even graced for even a mile way,
- 38:51right? And this here, this is also
- 38:55necessity not only in manners of uh in
- 38:58manners of actual uh actualization
- 39:01chain, it's also the necessity for
- 39:04composition and essence and existence.
- 39:07Thank you so much.
- 39:08>> Well, thank you. Thank you so much,
- 39:09Kylo. That was a a remarkable yet
- 39:12engaging uh first round of pre-battle
- 39:14coming from our affirmative side. And
- 39:17so, Kylo, would you like this format or
- 39:19would you like to go to the first format
- 39:21that we have?
- 39:22>> Would you like to stay this format?
- 39:24>> It's it's up to what? It doesn't matter.
- 39:26It doesn't matter. We can we can leave
- 39:28it like this. It don't matter.
- 39:29>> Yeah. Go on with this format. So, you
- 39:30will be having a 10-minute time for your
- 39:33first round of rebattle. Go on, Kyla.
- 39:35Your time will start whenever you utter
- 39:36your first word. Go on.
- 39:38>> So, I always want to ask just
- 39:40adjudicators, please just note
- 39:42everything I'm saying down. So, there's
- 39:44a few problems already on his rebuttal.
- 39:46Okay, for the audience, everyone
- 39:47listening, the first problem is I gave
- 39:50the aloneess argument. Now, on the
- 39:52cross- examination, there was no
- 39:54response to the aloneess argument. He
- 39:55didn't respond to the alone world. He
- 39:57didn't respond to intrinsic knowledge.
- 39:59There was no response to the loness
- 40:00argument. So, I'm going to kind of give
- 40:01it again. So, we want to say this.
- 40:04There's a possible world where God is
- 40:06alone. Okay? In this possible world, God
- 40:09has contingent knowledge. Okay? Now
- 40:11given Ho's divine simplicity um
- 40:14everything intrinsic to God is identical
- 40:16to God. Okay. But God has contingent
- 40:19knowledge like dogs exist or he could
- 40:21have not created he could have created
- 40:23trees exist. He has he has contingent
- 40:25knowledge but it's intrinsic. Okay. So
- 40:27if you have contingent knowledge you're
- 40:28intrinsic. It therefore follows God as a
- 40:30contingent being. Catholics don't want
- 40:32to adopt that view. And so I want him to
- 40:35respond to that on his next cross but I
- 40:37don't have to like give it again too
- 40:39many times. He just didn't respond to I
- 40:40want the all the adjudicators to
- 40:42remember he didn't respond to it. Also
- 40:45he he made a mistake regarding the um
- 40:48the quantitative parsimony. We're not
- 40:51saying just because you know God um
- 40:53creates x nilo that the properties he's
- 40:56instantiate are like additional
- 40:57properties. That's not what we're
- 40:58saying. What we're saying is when we do
- 41:00a comparative analysis to a naturalistic
- 41:02hypothesis and a um theistic hypothesis
- 41:05and they both equally explain the datim
- 41:07the commitments of the theistic
- 41:09hypothesis embed additional properties
- 41:11i.e in material minds. So nothing about
- 41:14the ex nhilo talk responds to
- 41:17comparative analysis. I think that he um
- 41:20conflated or he wasn't understanding
- 41:21what quantitative parimony is. I I I
- 41:23doubt I hope my opponent on his next
- 41:25cross- examination can maybe even define
- 41:27what quantitative parsimony is because
- 41:29that response did not beat the
- 41:31quantitative parsimony and one of the
- 41:33adjudicators left the panel. I don't
- 41:34know what's going on. I hope he is
- 41:36writing all this down. Okay. So, I would
- 41:37just want to flag my opponent did not
- 41:40respond to the loness argument in his
- 41:41rebuttal. My opponent also did not
- 41:43respond to the theoretical virtue
- 41:45regarding quantitative parsimony when we
- 41:47do a um a comparative analysis. The
- 41:49third thing is my opponent also didn't
- 41:51respond to the objection regarding an
- 41:54impossibility. My opponent wants to say
- 41:55for all possible worlds there must be a
- 41:56mind. Now what does that mean? That
- 41:59means that a possible world where there
- 42:00is no mind and tells a logical
- 42:02contradiction. Okay. My opponent thinks
- 42:04that we take the proposition there's a
- 42:06possible world with no mind that would
- 42:08entail a logical contradiction. A
- 42:10proposition is direct negation. Logical
- 42:13contradictions are propositions and a
- 42:15direct negation. I.e. a squared circle.
- 42:17Um the circle has four sides and it does
- 42:20not have four sides or um you can take a
- 42:23merry bachelor. Um so these things you
- 42:26know they commit you to proposition
- 42:28direct negation. So my opponent is
- 42:29committed to giving a proposition in his
- 42:32direct negation. I hope to hear that on
- 42:33his next rebuttal. Now let's go over a
- 42:35few claims that was made um in his
- 42:36opening. So in his opening he said there
- 42:39cannot be an infinite regress um on the
- 42:42basis that it does not have an um
- 42:44ultimate foundation. When he says it
- 42:46cannot be there, cannot is a modal verb.
- 42:48Cannot refers to impossibility. I would
- 42:50inquire my opponent to prove that claim.
- 42:52So, we're going to we're going to track
- 42:53all the claims he's making. He's saying
- 42:56it's logically impossible or maybe he's
- 42:57using a different modality. Let's get
- 42:59clear on what kind of impossibility we
- 43:02have with infinite regress. I want that
- 43:04claim to be proven. Um, also my opponent
- 43:06said that, you know, the universe was
- 43:08created from nothingness. I want that
- 43:10claim to also be proven. Okay. I want to
- 43:13argument and like I know the drawings
- 43:16are cool and they look nice but the
- 43:18drawings are not actually arguments.
- 43:20They're kind of like representation of
- 43:22your ideas. So it's kind of bad that
- 43:24you're doing drawings and not giving uh
- 43:26clear-cut arguments. Okay. Um so I want
- 43:28an argument for the universe being
- 43:30created. Okay. He said God possesses
- 43:32catnness. I don't know what that means
- 43:34but I want to just flag that. That was
- 43:36weird. Okay. My opponent also keeps
- 43:39saying that um I've given a contingency
- 43:41argument. I'm not given a contingency
- 43:44argument at all. So, I want to flag for
- 43:45the judges that that's that's a straw
- 43:47man on my position. I've not given any
- 43:48contingency arguments. Getting back to
- 43:51his opening, he brought up change. He's
- 43:53saying, you know, there is change things
- 43:55that go from potentiality to actuality.
- 43:57Now, we want to ask what kind of change
- 43:58are you using? Like, uh what what is
- 44:00what is what is change even is? Is it
- 44:02just literally the transition from
- 44:04potentiality to actuality? Um and if
- 44:06that's what he's saying, we have some
- 44:08problems there. Also, my opponent has
- 44:10adopted this uh philosophical view
- 44:11called principle proportional uh
- 44:13proportion of causality. I'm well
- 44:15acquainted with it. He's saying for
- 44:17every effect um um it's already going to
- 44:20be in the cause either formally, virtual
- 44:22or emily. He's giving three options. So,
- 44:24my opponent is saying you necessarily
- 44:26have three options. But we can ask
- 44:28ourselves, wait, why are we committed to
- 44:30three options? Why do we have to even
- 44:32adopt this principle of proportional
- 44:34causality? Because for his argument to
- 44:35go through, we must accept these old
- 44:38Arisatilian metaphysics. We have no
- 44:40reason to accept these old Arisatilian
- 44:42metaphysics. How much time do I have? 4
- 44:44minutes. Okay. So, we're going to ask
- 44:46ourselves, why do we have to accept this
- 44:48principle? I want an argument in favor
- 44:50of principle of proportional causality.
- 44:52I also want an argument for why is the
- 44:55tricotomy, the three options, why is it
- 44:57exhaustive? How do you know that there's
- 44:58not a fourth option, a fifth option? Why
- 45:00are we committed to these three options?
- 45:01So, I would like an argument in favor of
- 45:03that claim. And I want to be clear for
- 45:04the adjudicators. What I'm doing right
- 45:06now is I'm taking all the claims, all
- 45:08the commitments needed for his view to
- 45:09go through and we're putting them all in
- 45:11contention. All of these claims require
- 45:13further justification. We're not going
- 45:15to just take them at face value or just
- 45:16adopt them. Okay? We want arguments for
- 45:18a lot of these claims. And it's not
- 45:20burden stacking. It's not jargoning. I'm
- 45:22making clear why these things must be
- 45:25proven. Okay? Let's go over a few things
- 45:27that he said. Um oh, also he did commit,
- 45:31this is the first fallacy within the
- 45:32debate. He committed a genetic fallacy.
- 45:34Genetic fallacy. He was basically giving
- 45:36scrutiny that I'm using Joe Smith's
- 45:39argument on the basis that Joe Smith is
- 45:41now a Catholic. Okay, that doesn't
- 45:43defeat the view. Okay. So, him trying to
- 45:45critique the view because Joe Smith is
- 45:47now a Catholic. That's fellacious.
- 45:48That's the first fallacy within the
- 45:50debate that um Chester dudes committed.
- 45:52I want the judge to fly that Chester
- 45:54dudes has committed a fallacy. Okay. Um
- 45:56and he also straw man me. Chester dude
- 45:58straw man me when he said I was using
- 45:59the onlogical argument. But I want to
- 46:01just How much time do I have? 3 minutes.
- 46:03So, I just want to kind of close up my
- 46:04my cross- examination with a few points.
- 46:06So, where we're at right now is there's
- 46:09been no response to the aloneess
- 46:12argument. Okay, I've given the argument.
- 46:14I'm motivated. I'm willing to do further
- 46:16motiv motivation. There's been no
- 46:18response to the comparative analysis
- 46:21regarding quantitative parsimony. My
- 46:23opponent must have thought I was using a
- 46:24different theoretical virtue and brought
- 46:26up Xnihillo. I want quantitative
- 46:28parsimony specifically to be responded
- 46:30to. And also all I was just saying is we
- 46:32take the naturalistic hypothesis the
- 46:34theistic hypothesis they both equally
- 46:36explain the datam but theistic
- 46:38hypothesis needs a immaterial mind
- 46:41that's an additional
- 46:42property within the view and then this
- 46:45is the crux the adjudicators this is why
- 46:48um Chester dudes is is unfortunately
- 46:51probably going to lose on the burden of
- 46:52proof he is committed to saying there's
- 46:54a logical contradiction in a possible
- 46:56world where there are no minds now we we
- 46:58determine logical possibilities at least
- 47:00in I view using conjunctive truth
- 47:02tables. So we say some proposition P is
- 47:04logically possible on the basis that it
- 47:06is outputed as true at least one
- 47:07evaluation. So you can take the
- 47:08postulate P there's a possible world
- 47:10postulate Q it the world has no mind and
- 47:12at least one evaluation is output is
- 47:14true. So we have the feasible reason of
- 47:15believing that it is logically possible
- 47:18to have a possible world with no minds.
- 47:20And like we can probably get literature
- 47:23there are no modal logicians, right?
- 47:25Like I'm I'm lic to believe there are no
- 47:26modal that says oh a possible world with
- 47:29no minds is logically impossible. You
- 47:31know maybe you can talk about
- 47:32metaphysical impossibility or some other
- 47:34notion of impossibility but a logical
- 47:35impossibility. Okay, that's a crazy
- 47:37robust claim that Chester Dude is going
- 47:39to have to back up that we have gotten
- 47:41no justification for. Okay. Um, I have
- 47:43one minute left. Okay. Um,
- 47:46I don't want to go in circles here, but
- 47:47there's a lot of things on the table
- 47:49that have not been responded to, but for
- 47:50the sake of conciseness, I'm willing to
- 47:52concede the rest of my time and let
- 47:54Chester dudes uh give a rebuttal.
- 47:58>> Thank you. Thank you so much. Uh, King
- 48:00Kylo, that was a thoughtprovoking uh
- 48:03first round of rebuttal coming from our
- 48:05opposition. So let's have first uh 2
- 48:08minutes break ion uh while they are
- 48:10preparing for this for the cross
- 48:12examinations. Let's have first two
- 48:14minute break. So uh if we can go back to
- 48:17the uh first format host uh may I just
- 48:20request to uh let's go back to the first
- 48:22format debate please so that
- 48:28highlight thank you thank you so much.
- 48:31So first of all
- 48:36sponsors
- 48:40to those who supports in this uh
- 48:42platform like smart uh enob smart ion.
- 48:46This program is brought to you by
- 48:47enobarter the parent company of GCL agri
- 48:51services. So I would just like also to
- 48:54uh say shout out s chairman of dof sir
- 48:57Tommy Gaston uh the president uh brother
- 49:00Renog uh the chief operator uh the chief
- 49:03operations uh officer brother Igato
- 49:05senior moderator uh and the moderators
- 49:08Rayo uh Jason
- 49:11RR proit
- 49:14razan
- 49:16shout out say and then of course
- 49:19promotional partners which is St. Pat
- 49:23if you are looking for a buy one take
- 49:26one
- 49:28just just message Sturilang promo uh Tik
- 49:32Tok rap community calling all aspiring
- 49:35rappers and battle enthusiasts if you
- 49:37are interested in joining the community
- 49:39and showcasing your skills in rap
- 49:41battles. Contact uh Sensei Elo for more
- 49:44details. And also we would also like to
- 49:47say thank you po sir JB or Kuya JB for
- 49:50always supporting the debate community
- 49:53for collaboration just PM do
- 49:56any brand
- 49:58of course
- 50:00the next part of the debate uh uh is uh
- 50:04our crossexamination both of our
- 50:06debaters agreed upon the uh pre-debate
- 50:09uh that was happened uh nights ago po
- 50:13they will only be entertaining 10
- 50:15questions each uh each sides po. Okay.
- 50:19Uh the first one uh to throw the uh the
- 50:21first one will be h that will be having
- 50:24uh the cross examination is our
- 50:25affirmative and of course uh begin we
- 50:29will be given a 10 uh 20 seconds time to
- 50:32expound the answer
- 50:34opposition as well as uh to our
- 50:36affirmative. Okay, I guess we are ready.
- 50:39Uh are you ready Chester dudes?
- 50:42So we will be given a uh sorry wala pala
- 50:45time we don't have time here. Uh we will
- 50:47be given 10 questions uh for for Chester
- 50:50Dudes. A ayion uh go on uh Chester dude.
- 50:53May I just remind also the opposition
- 50:55King Kylo that uh if the question is
- 50:58categorical you you will oblige to
- 51:00answer first if uh it was if if if it if
- 51:04it was yes or no. Go on Chester.
- 51:13We can't hear you, sir. Your mic's
- 51:15muted.
- 51:18>> Yeah. Um, first question is, um, are you
- 51:21going to use the screen in presenting
- 51:23your answers?
- 51:26>> Am Huh?
- 51:27>> Are you going to use the main screen in
- 51:30presenting your answers? Yes or no?
- 51:33>> I don't know what you're asking.
- 51:36He is uh asking if you are going to use
- 51:38the screen if you are going to answer
- 51:40the question that was that will come to
- 51:43uh Chester.
- 51:45>> I'm just going to say yes or no.
- 51:46>> Okay. Okay.
- 51:47>> Okay.
- 51:48>> That's good.
- 51:49>> What is it? A yes or a no.
- 51:52>> So no, I'm not using the main screen.
- 51:53I'll just I'll say it verbally.
- 51:55>> I I request to use the main screen since
- 51:57he's not going to use the main screen.
- 51:59Thank you.
- 52:00>> Oh, you want to be big screened?
- 52:03>> Yes, bro.
- 52:04>> Okay. Okay. Uh he's want he's saying he
- 52:06wants to be on the big screen.
- 52:08>> Yes, sir.
- 52:10>> Post uh Chester dude is requesting that
- 52:13if he can use this screen for uh his uh
- 52:17cross examination.
- 52:19>> Does that count as a question?
- 52:22>> Yes, bro. That's my first question.
- 52:25Yeah, I have nine remaining. Yeah.
- 52:29So, thank you for your answer that.
- 52:30Okay. Um first question. you questioned
- 52:35uh the principle of proportional
- 52:36causality. So you questioned this
- 52:39proportional uh principle of
- 52:41proportional causality. You said that
- 52:44why are we committed to thinking of
- 52:46three? So can you uh speak of since you
- 52:51doubted this do you have any license to
- 52:53doubt and therefore provide like uh one
- 52:57possible uh proportional causality that
- 52:59may not belong into either of these
- 53:01three? Yes or no?
- 53:03No.
- 53:05>> Okay. Thank you. So is with saying no to
- 53:10that. Are you saying that? This is my
- 53:12second question by the way. Okay. So
- 53:16second question. Oh, sorry. Sorry.
- 53:18You're right. You're right. Third
- 53:19question. So third question.
- 53:23Since you don't have an example that
- 53:26could not belong either uh among these
- 53:28three
- 53:31would
- 53:32would you still consider thinking that
- 53:34there is a fourth one and we are not
- 53:36committed to three
- 53:39yes
- 53:41thank you so much so this is uh number
- 53:46fourth question am I right I'm okay
- 53:50thank
- 53:52Okay, fourth question here. So you said
- 53:55that um the you also questioned
- 54:01earlier
- 54:02the parimony the qual quantitative
- 54:06parimony in my explanation during um
- 54:10during God withdrawing or subtractive
- 54:14creation right did God increase or
- 54:19decrease or remained one in quantity
- 54:23>> yeah you can say so the question wasn't
- 54:26a yes or no but I'll still answer it so
- 54:29you can say you're licensed to believe
- 54:30that it remained one y
- 54:32>> thank you so much okay it remained one
- 54:35okay with the concept of uh which you
- 54:38keep you kept bringing up the qualit
- 54:40quantitative parim okay what what
- 54:45occasion
- 54:47in that um uh in this causal
- 54:51representation
- 54:52of the octtopus purus
- 54:55Since you said that it remained one,
- 54:57which occasion in my argumentation
- 55:02um was a signal for you to counter it?
- 55:08>> Uh that question is denied. We agreed to
- 55:10yes or no questions. That's not a yes or
- 55:12no question, sir. I only answered your
- 55:14last question with a yes or no cuz I'm
- 55:15charitable. So reframe the question.
- 55:18>> All right. All right. Um
- 55:21I would al I will only say uh
- 55:24categorical. I this would be a yes or no
- 55:26question if I say it was categorical.
- 55:29But this uh here you can say um like it
- 55:33did increase the number or no.
- 55:37>> We agree to yes or no moderator. Can we
- 55:39get a moderator? We agree to yes or nos
- 55:41only.
- 55:42>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I guess this is just a
- 55:43follow-up question. King Kyla, you could
- 55:45just answer yes or no.
- 55:48>> All right.
- 55:48>> Okay. What? be direct what's the
- 55:50question
- 55:51>> so since all right so let me rephrase my
- 55:53question to credit that uh either or
- 55:56question I'm sorry answer so you said
- 55:59that there was no increase it remained
- 56:01one
- 56:03question did my argumentation from uh
- 56:06the causal chain of the uncost cost of
- 56:08the actus purus
- 56:10did I negate
- 56:13the
- 56:14um the quantitative parimony that you
- 56:17kept bringing up Yes or no?
- 56:20>> No.
- 56:21>> Thank you so much. All right. Since the
- 56:24your your answer is no, that it did not
- 56:27challenge quantitative parimony.
- 56:31Is there a point in my argumentation of
- 56:33the octus purus that actually
- 56:36contradicts
- 56:39qualitative a quantitative parimony
- 56:43>> contradicts? No.
- 56:44>> Yes. All right. Thank you so much. So no
- 56:48on all the question uh no on all the
- 56:50questions. So quantitative pimony
- 56:53remains intact in my argument. All
- 56:55right. So next question I would like how
- 56:57many questions do I have remaining? Four
- 56:59questions.
- 56:59>> You still have three.
- 57:01>> I still have three. All right. So there
- 57:05was earlier we get back to my notes.
- 57:08Where is it? Yeah.
- 57:13So
- 57:15when I built my uh honest pro uh uh the
- 57:20burden of uh proof here,
- 57:25do you think you were able to attack any
- 57:28of the commulative argumentation that I
- 57:30I built up in this 10 attributes of God?
- 57:34Yes. Thank you so much.
- 57:38Okay. So since you said yes,
- 57:43right? Was it in the case of um God
- 57:47being built up from essence and
- 57:49existence?
- 57:52Yes.
- 57:54All right. Essence and existence. Okay.
- 57:57Is it with regards Okay. Is it with
- 58:01regards to God's simplicity and
- 58:05remaining intact as one? Final question.
- 58:07>> Yes.
- 58:08Oh, okay. Thank you so much. Got my got
- 58:11my answers. Thank you so much. Go ahead.
- 58:13>> Thank you so much. That was the 10th
- 58:15question coming from our affirmative.
- 58:17So, uh do you want to uh use the same
- 58:20format, Kylo or do you want the uh first
- 58:22one? Do you want to use the same format?
- 58:24Okay.
- 58:24>> Yeah. Big screaming. Big screaming.
- 58:26>> Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So, you will be
- 58:28having your 10 question. Uh also, Kylo,
- 58:30go on.
- 58:34>> Okay. Okay. Judicators, once again,
- 58:37please I ask you guys to just track this
- 58:38and listen. Okay,
- 58:41I'm ready. Does logical possibility mean
- 58:44that something contains no
- 58:45contradiction?
- 58:50>> Yes.
- 58:52>> Okay. Is a world free with no minds
- 58:56logically contradictory?
- 59:00>> Come again.
- 59:02>> Okay.
- 59:05Is a world free with no minds logically
- 59:08contradictory?
- 59:11>> Yes.
- 59:14>> Okay. If a world with no minds contains
- 59:17no logical contradiction, is the
- 59:19existence of a mind logically necessary?
- 59:22>> Yes.
- 59:28>> Is it possible according to Catholicism
- 59:30for God to exist without creating
- 59:32anything?
- 59:34Yes.
- 59:38>> If God exists alone, is God still
- 59:40required to be omnisient?
- 59:43>> Yes.
- 59:46Can God possess knowledge of contingent
- 59:48truths in a world where nothing exists
- 59:50outside of God?
- 59:55>> Yes.
- 1:00:00Can both naturalism and theism explain
- 1:00:02the same observable data about the
- 1:00:05universe?
- 1:00:06>> Come again. Come again.
- 1:00:08>> Can both naturalism and theism explain
- 1:00:12the same observable data about the
- 1:00:14universe?
- 1:00:15>> No.
- 1:00:23Does theism require an additional
- 1:00:25immaterial eternal mind to explain the
- 1:00:28data?
- 1:00:33>> Yes.
- 1:00:34>> Okay.
- 1:00:38>> Last one, Tyler.
- 1:00:40>> Yep. Last one. I see. I don't I don't
- 1:00:42make Yeah, I got mine written down. If
- 1:00:45naturalism explains the same data
- 1:00:47without requiring additional entities,
- 1:00:50is naturalism quantitatively more
- 1:00:52parsimmonious.
- 1:00:57>> No.
- 1:01:02>> Okay.
- 1:01:04>> All right.
- 1:01:04>> Okay. I guess we Yeah. Yeah. I guess we
- 1:01:07are we are done with this. That was a
- 1:01:10fast cross examination coming from our
- 1:01:12king Kylo. So, uh do you uh do you still
- 1:01:17need the screen Chester for your second
- 1:01:19round of pre- battles?
- 1:01:22>> Um yes sir.
- 1:01:24>> Okay. Okay. Okay. So, uh let me give you
- 1:01:26let me expand you I guess uh for those
- 1:01:28who are asking in the comment section if
- 1:01:30this was just yes or no. uh they will uh
- 1:01:33they will address all the questionnaires
- 1:01:35that they have done during the cross
- 1:01:37examination in their second rounds of
- 1:01:39rebuttal which will be happen uh uh now.
- 1:01:42Okay. Go on. You will be having 10
- 1:01:44minutes al 10 minutes time uh Chester
- 1:01:46dude for your second round of rebuttals.
- 1:01:50Right. Okay. Thank you so much. So my
- 1:01:54rebuttal actually takes the form of a
- 1:01:56critique of his rebuttal as well as of
- 1:01:59the uh cross-examination.
- 1:02:02All right. So
- 1:02:04first I go to I go to the critique of
- 1:02:07his rebuttal. So yes he is correct in
- 1:02:10saying that he has not uh shifted the
- 1:02:13burden. Actually what he did is quite
- 1:02:17other than that. He actually snatched
- 1:02:20the burden of proof from me and built
- 1:02:23his own argument which is the
- 1:02:24ontological and aloneeness argument and
- 1:02:28then had me uh question me and uh to to
- 1:02:33retort on that or to respond on that.
- 1:02:36Right? So it's like uh he never did
- 1:02:39anything and in the cross- examination
- 1:02:42he admitted that he did had uh like uh a
- 1:02:47contra uh uh counterargument
- 1:02:51right for here in the simplicity divine
- 1:02:53simplicity of Thomas Aquinas but
- 1:02:56actually he said that no I did not
- 1:02:59contradict your oneness right or the
- 1:03:03uniqueness and the wholeness and the
- 1:03:05simplicity and one remains intact. That
- 1:03:08was clear in my cross- examination. All
- 1:03:11right. Next thing uh when he said that
- 1:03:14he was not burden shifting actually I
- 1:03:17did I do agree with that. You were
- 1:03:18snatching the burden for me and you were
- 1:03:21also uh glib blasting there a lot of uh
- 1:03:25irrelevant uh point bypoint questions or
- 1:03:29counterarguments that actually not
- 1:03:31affect the commulative building of uh
- 1:03:34the attributes here that was discussed
- 1:03:37on the pre- debate. Right? So the pre in
- 1:03:40the pre- debate we we talk about the
- 1:03:42four um requirements or definitions that
- 1:03:46you had me agreed to in the pre-debate
- 1:03:48about God, omnipotent, omniscient, all
- 1:03:50loving and all good. And none of that
- 1:03:54you uh you broke. You only focused on
- 1:03:57the mind, right? So all of these uh all
- 1:04:01of those are necessary to for me to be
- 1:04:03able to build up to this concept that
- 1:04:05God is a mind. But you uh but you try to
- 1:04:09counterargument over here with the
- 1:04:11aloneeness argument. And once again in
- 1:04:14the aloneeness argument you said that uh
- 1:04:16God is alone. Therefore he needs to have
- 1:04:18like the intrinsic knowledge within
- 1:04:21himself. Right? If God is alone, God is
- 1:04:25an acttospurus and in intrinsic
- 1:04:27knowledge uh comes about when there is a
- 1:04:30relationship between propositions that
- 1:04:32have potentiality and hasn't uh and and
- 1:04:36is not all actuality.
- 1:04:38So uh intrinsic knowledge intrinsic
- 1:04:42knowledge there is will not exist in a
- 1:04:45manner that is um there's some there's
- 1:04:48an equivocation there. So intrinsic
- 1:04:50intrinsic means inside oneself or
- 1:04:53intrinsic relates to the relation uh
- 1:04:55relates to the connection of
- 1:04:56propositions right uh the layering of
- 1:05:00propositions and another thing that he
- 1:05:02does well he commented on my drawings
- 1:05:04and he said drawings are just drawings
- 1:05:06they do not represent well he actually
- 1:05:08does a part of that he poisons Lel by
- 1:05:10showing his face uh smiling grimacing
- 1:05:14and also what about your hand gestures
- 1:05:16your hand gestures just do the purpose
- 1:05:19of my drawings but setting that aside.
- 1:05:22So that's poisoning the well with our
- 1:05:24and uh the constant referring to the uh
- 1:05:27audicators educators. Look at this. Look
- 1:05:30at that. Right. So poison in the well.
- 1:05:32So uh that's the reason why I said glib
- 1:05:36blasting is because there are a bunch of
- 1:05:38arguments there that all he said as a
- 1:05:41reason is we have some problems there.
- 1:05:44Right? when there when there was uh we
- 1:05:46you said why would we commit to three um
- 1:05:50three principle of causal proportion uh
- 1:05:52proportions causality why is that we
- 1:05:54have some problem with that and how
- 1:05:55about uh god being a mind oh we have
- 1:05:58some problem with that he did not uh
- 1:06:00build up an attack uh over to that uh
- 1:06:04the these building arguments I have here
- 1:06:07okay now let's go on to his um uh
- 1:06:09questioning of me so first four
- 1:06:12questions there my responses are yes and
- 1:06:15there's actually no point in asking that
- 1:06:18in that succession because just at the
- 1:06:19final question at the fourth one it
- 1:06:22actually proved a point of and and I'm
- 1:06:25confused why he shifted to another set
- 1:06:28of line of questions all right and when
- 1:06:32he gave his final question there he said
- 1:06:34that oh uh with his face of course I
- 1:06:37read from his face that what is that you
- 1:06:39believe that like uh intrinsic uh
- 1:06:42knowledge is within in God.
- 1:06:46So is uh that there I said um the
- 1:06:51intrinsic knowledge comes in form
- 1:06:53equivocative right there are two
- 1:06:55meanings to this word. So if you say
- 1:06:59intrinsic knowledge that knowledge
- 1:07:00within himself and did not come from
- 1:07:02something else then I would agree to
- 1:07:04that because God is a satic as I've
- 1:07:07shown here in my chop card. Where is it?
- 1:07:09So in my trap card I actually showed
- 1:07:11here
- 1:07:13that God is uh asetic by oneself. So
- 1:07:18intrinsic in that sense could actually
- 1:07:21build up uh actuality of God and does
- 1:07:24not contradictus
- 1:07:26because it is uh intrinsic by oneself.
- 1:07:28Acetic intrinsic uh intrinsic knowledge
- 1:07:32and since knowledge here uh knowledge uh
- 1:07:35since knowledge is not just a part but
- 1:07:37the entire totality of God because
- 1:07:39remember
- 1:07:41uh God has no parts. Divine simplicity
- 1:07:43is non-composite.
- 1:07:45Um knowledge could not be one one side
- 1:07:50of God and therefore the rest is some
- 1:07:52other thing. No, God is this one simple
- 1:07:55thing like a diamond. Uh every facet
- 1:07:58like all these all these here are just
- 1:08:02faces that we recognize God from. It's
- 1:08:05pure but uh from from one side the
- 1:08:07immateriality the the perfection
- 1:08:11uh the um the all goodness right as well
- 1:08:15as the simpleness
- 1:08:17as well as the omniscience they are just
- 1:08:21one uh different interpretation outside
- 1:08:25interpretation we are outside um the
- 1:08:28octpurus right we are a mixture of
- 1:08:30potentiality and actuality we are
- 1:08:32outsider of that concept So we are
- 1:08:35viewing it from different angles and so
- 1:08:37we have these different facets. Remember
- 1:08:39these are facets to one simple uh
- 1:08:43eternally simple totous. Okay totus in
- 1:08:46totality simplex simple purus purity.
- 1:08:51So all of that
- 1:08:54would deny intrinsic if we take the
- 1:08:56first sense of the word intrinsic not
- 1:08:58the relations of concepts. If we take
- 1:09:00the first uh uh of intrinsic acetic by
- 1:09:04oneself, all right, it uh uh it applies
- 1:09:08to the octopus purus and does not
- 1:09:10contradict at all. All right, so that is
- 1:09:15uh my counterargument for the series of
- 1:09:18the questions which accumulated or um
- 1:09:22yeah uh which culminated in that
- 1:09:25question which is equivocative. So I
- 1:09:28call fallacy of equivocation on that on
- 1:09:30the far end question intrinsic. He seems
- 1:09:33to be meaning to be um a the
- 1:09:36relationship between compos uh parts
- 1:09:39composing the whole instead of coming
- 1:09:42from oneself.
- 1:09:44All right. Thank you so much. That would
- 1:09:46be my time.
- 1:09:47>> So are you waving your time? Uh Chester
- 1:09:50dudes.
- 1:09:50>> Uh thank you so much. Yes. Two two
- 1:09:52minutes I w my time.
- 1:09:53>> Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you so
- 1:09:54much. That was really a compelling uh
- 1:09:57still a compelling uh second round or
- 1:10:00last round of re battles coming from our
- 1:10:02affirmative side. So uh do you wish uh
- 1:10:04King Kylo to also use uh this kind of
- 1:10:07format? Do you want this uh format? King
- 1:10:10Kylo
- 1:10:12King Kylo, you're muted. Yeah.
- 1:10:14>> Hey, let's do it. Let's do it. Whoa.
- 1:10:16Yeah.
- 1:10:16>> Go on. Go on. You will be having 10
- 1:10:18minutes as well. King Kylo, go on your
- 1:10:21start in your first word. First the
- 1:10:24fallacy he just charged me with dismiss.
- 1:10:26Mind you, he didn't even prove it was a
- 1:10:27fallacy. He said a fallacy of
- 1:10:29equivocation and then moved on. So for
- 1:10:31the adjudicators, no, you can't just say
- 1:10:33someone committed a fallacy and then not
- 1:10:35justify it. We didn't hear any
- 1:10:36justification for the air fallacy. Like
- 1:10:38what? And then he said, I'm equivocating
- 1:10:40on the term intrinsic. I'm using
- 1:10:42intrinsic and the standard
- 1:10:43interpretation under Catholic the
- 1:10:45Catholic view. Also, this is a big
- 1:10:47mistake. He said God doesn't have any
- 1:10:50intrinsic knowledge. That's not true.
- 1:10:53Like the Catholic view, you're committed
- 1:10:55to saying God has intrinsic properties.
- 1:10:57For example, God and there's a plethora
- 1:10:59of things in God intrinsically has. He
- 1:11:01thinks that um God has nothing intrinsic
- 1:11:03related. God intrinsically is all
- 1:11:05knowing. God intrinsically is all
- 1:11:07loving. So to say God doesn't have any
- 1:11:09intrinsic properties is that's a big
- 1:11:12mistake, Chester dudes. You don't want
- 1:11:14to say that. Okay. Okay. Whoa. So
- 1:11:17there's a lot of things to go over.
- 1:11:18We're going to first go over the cross-
- 1:11:20examination section. Okay. So, he said,
- 1:11:23"A world with no minds has a logical
- 1:11:26contradiction." Now, we should all ask
- 1:11:28ourselves, has chess so there's a some
- 1:11:30there's some background noise going on.
- 1:11:32Can we please unmute that? Okay. Chester
- 1:11:35dude said a possible world, a logically
- 1:11:38possible world with no minds is actually
- 1:11:40impossible. But remember, for you to
- 1:11:42demonstrate some proposition P to be
- 1:11:44impossible, you're committed to a
- 1:11:45proposition and it's direct negation.
- 1:11:47The car is black and the car is not
- 1:11:49black at the same time. a P and not P.
- 1:11:51This is very simplistic model logic. If
- 1:11:54we all ask ourselves, has Chester Dudes
- 1:11:55given a P and not P? Have we heard any
- 1:11:58motivation for the impossibility? The
- 1:11:59answer is no. Okay, so that's a point
- 1:12:02off. Okay, another thing. Um let's see.
- 1:12:06He he said if naturalism explains the
- 1:12:09same datam without requiring additional
- 1:12:11entity, naturalism um is naturalism more
- 1:12:14quantitative parsimmonious. He said no.
- 1:12:17What? Okay. So the stipulation is you
- 1:12:19have two theories. One positive mind,
- 1:12:22one doesn't posit a mind. He said that
- 1:12:24the one that doesn't posit a mind
- 1:12:25wouldn't be uh um quantitatively
- 1:12:27parsimmonious. That's mistaken. It has a
- 1:12:30it has one less of an entity needed to
- 1:12:32explain the data. I would like I like
- 1:12:34reason to believe why it wouldn't be um
- 1:12:36less parsimmonious. I'm giving you
- 1:12:37reason to believe it would be less
- 1:12:38parsimonious on the basis that it
- 1:12:40doesn't need a mind. So every claim I'm
- 1:12:42making I'm backing up with
- 1:12:43justification. Okay.
- 1:12:45He said, um, naturalism cannot explain
- 1:12:48the datim of the observable universe.
- 1:12:50I'd like for that claim to also be
- 1:12:53backed up. Why? Why do why would we
- 1:12:55think naturalism can't explain the
- 1:12:56datam? Okay, so let's see where we're at
- 1:12:58right here. Okay, so we haven't gotten
- 1:13:00really any rebuttal to the comparative
- 1:13:03analysis. Why think that um the
- 1:13:06naturalist hypothesis is not um more
- 1:13:09parsimonious regarding quantitative
- 1:13:10talk? Okay, I I motivated it. We haven't
- 1:13:13got any objections. Now, when we get
- 1:13:15into the loness argument, I asked my
- 1:13:17opponent, okay, um, is it possible?
- 1:13:19Let's go back to the answers. Is it
- 1:13:20possible?
- 1:13:23Oh, this is another point. I asked him,
- 1:13:25if a world with no minds contains no
- 1:13:28logical contradiction, is the existence
- 1:13:30of a mind logically necessary? He said
- 1:13:33yes. Game over. I I want everybody
- 1:13:35listen to this. I asked him if so on the
- 1:13:38condition there is a a world with no
- 1:13:41minds and it has no logical
- 1:13:43contradiction. So on that condition
- 1:13:44there is a possible world with no minds.
- 1:13:46Is it going to still be the case that an
- 1:13:49um the existence of a mind is logically
- 1:13:51necessary? He said yes. That is
- 1:13:53problematic. If you accept that there
- 1:13:56could possibly be a world where there
- 1:13:58are no minds. You can't go to say a
- 1:14:00minded being would still be necessary.
- 1:14:02Because if a minded being would still be
- 1:14:04necessary, you couldn't get a possible
- 1:14:06world with no minds. I'm I'm going read
- 1:14:07this again for everybody, for the
- 1:14:08adjudicators. I asked him, if a world
- 1:14:11with no minds contains no logical
- 1:14:14contradiction, is the existence of a
- 1:14:17mind logically necessary? He said yes.
- 1:14:19Game over. Okay.
- 1:14:22So, let me go to some let me go to his
- 1:14:23rebuttal. Okay. Um he and then so in his
- 1:14:27in his cross- examination he said well
- 1:14:29does my view contradict the quantitative
- 1:14:32parsimony I said no it doesn't
- 1:14:34contradict it and he thinks that that's
- 1:14:36like means like his view is now
- 1:14:38quantitative parsimmonious like no
- 1:14:40quantitative parsimony doesn't
- 1:14:42contradict your view it's just not in
- 1:14:45favor of your view it actually be in
- 1:14:46favor of the contrary of your view
- 1:14:47tester dudes so the the contradiction
- 1:14:50talk was a little confused okay
- 1:14:53um he also said because I didn't attack
- 1:14:55properties like all lovingness and
- 1:14:57certain omni properties within his view
- 1:14:59that that just means that his view is
- 1:15:01now getting like permiss within the
- 1:15:03dialect. But that's a problem what the
- 1:15:05one argument I gave directly attacks all
- 1:15:07the omni properties implicitly because
- 1:15:09if the argument I gave and tells that
- 1:15:11divine simplicity is false and
- 1:15:13Catholicism presupposed divine
- 1:15:14simplicity then all the attributes fail.
- 1:15:17So I don't have to directly attack each
- 1:15:19attribute. I can give one argument that
- 1:15:21defeats all of them implicitly. Okay.
- 1:15:23Okay, so that was another mistake that
- 1:15:25um Chester made. Okay, so I responded to
- 1:15:29how much time do I got? 4 minutes. Okay,
- 1:15:31he also said that I'm poisoning the
- 1:15:33will. I want to flag. He's making a lot
- 1:15:35of charges that I'm being facious and
- 1:15:37I'm committing fallacies, but every time
- 1:15:39he charges me with a fallacy, he doesn't
- 1:15:41justify it. He just says, "Oh, he's
- 1:15:43poisoning the will." Or, "Oh, he's
- 1:15:45committing equivocation fallacy." And he
- 1:15:47just moves on to his next point. You
- 1:15:48can't charge your opponent with
- 1:15:50fallacies and not give a supple a
- 1:15:52supplementation or a justification for
- 1:15:54that charge. So I think that should be a
- 1:15:55point off for rhetorics for just
- 1:15:57charging fallacies out. Okay. Um we went
- 1:16:01over the intrinsic knowledge. So I mean
- 1:16:03realistically where we're at right now
- 1:16:05is um I need we haven't got no argument
- 1:16:08against um the alone world. And I'll
- 1:16:11just repeat that again just make sure I
- 1:16:12want to make sure all my points are
- 1:16:13clear and concise here. There's pos
- 1:16:15possibly there's possibly a world where
- 1:16:17God's alone and he has intrinsic
- 1:16:18knowledge. But within that intrinsic
- 1:16:20knowledge are contingent facts such as
- 1:16:22God could have created a world. God
- 1:16:24could have created dogs etc. Okay. Now
- 1:16:26my opponent said he doesn't believe God
- 1:16:28has intrinsic any intrinsic relations
- 1:16:30which is very problematic because
- 1:16:32obviously my opponent believes God has
- 1:16:35um intrinsically all knowingness and
- 1:16:37intrinsically all powerfulness. So if
- 1:16:40his objection to my alonus argument is
- 1:16:43that well God just doesn't have
- 1:16:44intrinsic property so of course he
- 1:16:46wouldn't have intrinsic knowledge of
- 1:16:47contingencies then he can bite that
- 1:16:49bullet but biting that bullet commits
- 1:16:52him to absurdities like God isn't
- 1:16:54intrinsically all knowing okay um when
- 1:16:57we go into the comparative analysis
- 1:16:59we've been over this so it's it's also
- 1:17:01another thing let make sure I'm going
- 1:17:03over his arguments I asked and for the
- 1:17:06adjudicators please maybe you guys maybe
- 1:17:08I missed something. This is crazy. I
- 1:17:10asked I wanted a justification, a
- 1:17:12supplementary argument for the PPC.
- 1:17:14Okay. In his cross- examination, he
- 1:17:16said, "Well, can you give me a can you
- 1:17:18give me a fourth option?" I said, "Well,
- 1:17:19no, I can't." But me not giving a fourth
- 1:17:22option doesn't mean there is no fourth
- 1:17:24option. Now, the PPC says there is
- 1:17:27exclusively only three options, which
- 1:17:29means there's necessarily not a fourth.
- 1:17:31So, as the burden of rejoinder, I can
- 1:17:33say, "Well, hold on. I don't know if
- 1:17:34there's not a fourth option, but prove
- 1:17:36to me there's not one." And all he did
- 1:17:37was say, "Well, if you can't give me
- 1:17:39one, then we're fine with saying there
- 1:17:41necessarily is no fourth option." Well,
- 1:17:43that doesn't follow. That's not how that
- 1:17:44works. You have to prove there's no
- 1:17:46fourth option. So, me being agnostic on
- 1:17:48a talk doesn't get him to his burden of
- 1:17:50proof. Okay? I want to respond. I want
- 1:17:52to point that out. Also, we ask, well,
- 1:17:54what kind of change are we talking
- 1:17:55about? Or when you talk about um you
- 1:17:57know, there goes from possibility to
- 1:17:59actuality. What what modal flavor are we
- 1:18:02using when we talk about possibility?
- 1:18:04logical possibility, epistemic
- 1:18:05possibility, anomalological,
- 1:18:06metaphysical, etc. Chester Dudes never
- 1:18:09explains the type of possibility his
- 1:18:12argument from change is using. So we we
- 1:18:14don't really ever get to get a nice
- 1:18:16critique on the argument from change
- 1:18:18because it's very ambiguous. And I asked
- 1:18:19him, what kind of change is being used?
- 1:18:21What theory of change is being invoked?
- 1:18:22And he never responded to that. I think
- 1:18:24that ought to be another point off for
- 1:18:26the lack of clarity. What kind of
- 1:18:28possibilities being invoked within the
- 1:18:29dialects? Okay, I have a minute left. I
- 1:18:32think Can I see the timer? I want to see
- 1:18:33how much time I have. I have a minute
- 1:18:34left. Okay, perfect. Another point.
- 1:18:37Chester dude said the universe came out
- 1:18:39of nothing. Ask him why I believe it
- 1:18:42came out of nothing. I didn't hear any
- 1:18:44ar like maybe the audience heard it. I
- 1:18:46didn't hear an argument for the universe
- 1:18:47coming out of nothing. We like I said
- 1:18:49the presentations are nice, but you
- 1:18:51don't get clear-cut arguments from that.
- 1:18:53Okay. Um also asked, "What is the
- 1:18:56logical contradiction in there being an
- 1:18:58infinite regress?" Chester Duce said
- 1:19:00there being an infinite regress where
- 1:19:01there is no ultimate grounds is
- 1:19:04logically impossible. Well, that commits
- 1:19:06him to another P and not P. So there
- 1:19:08there's two contradictions he needed to
- 1:19:10give us and we have not heard a
- 1:19:12proposition and it's direct negation
- 1:19:14yet. And if you don't give a P and a not
- 1:19:16P affirmed at the same time, you can't
- 1:19:18say that it's impossible. You can't give
- 1:19:20the contradiction. So that's two claims
- 1:19:22of impossibility that have not been
- 1:19:24justified. Okay.
- 1:19:26So, I mean, um,
- 1:19:30I'm not going to be long-winded. I think
- 1:19:32that I've responded to everything in
- 1:19:34this cross- examination, so I'm willing
- 1:19:36to relinquish the rest of my time.
- 1:19:40>> Thank you so much, King Kylo. That was
- 1:19:42an engrossing and absorbing uh last
- 1:19:44round of rebattle coming from our
- 1:19:46opposition. Uh, so let's move forward to
- 1:19:49the last part of debate uh which is the
- 1:19:51clo uh closing statement for uh the
- 1:19:53affirmative. Uh you will be given five
- 1:19:55minutes. Uh Chester dude I do you want
- 1:19:58to use again this uh kind of uh format
- 1:20:02Chester dudes.
- 1:20:05Okay go on. So you will be having 5
- 1:20:07minutes. Go on. All right. So okay so
- 1:20:11couple things there. Um the necessity of
- 1:20:14a mind he questioned that right? Uh so
- 1:20:17question with the onlogical argument. Uh
- 1:20:20there could be anything uh can there be
- 1:20:23many things like potent uh in what did
- 1:20:26you call it? Uh intrinsic things. No, he
- 1:20:29did not. Contingent things is what I'm
- 1:20:32looking for. Uh without a mind. Well,
- 1:20:36he should have listened to here. I said
- 1:20:39earlier here from my commulative case
- 1:20:41here uh that there couldn't be any act
- 1:20:46there couldn't be a a claim for an
- 1:20:48octtospurus if it is not a mind. So if
- 1:20:51it is not a mind it's not octurus at all
- 1:20:53I said if it doesn't have a mind I'm
- 1:20:56sorry you're not octopurus it has to
- 1:20:58have a mind. So there estab I already
- 1:21:01established what a necessity of a mind
- 1:21:04and said he said earlier that Aquinus
- 1:21:06presupposed divine simplicity. Bro
- 1:21:09divine simplity is a deduction from
- 1:21:12change from aristotilian metaphysics a
- 1:21:14deduction not a presupposition. So I
- 1:21:17have that uh validated and fact checked
- 1:21:20by the adjudicator. And you said
- 1:21:22earlier, it was really funny. You said
- 1:21:24um uh you said um uh to contradict. No,
- 1:21:28it does not contradict the parimony of
- 1:21:32quantity quant quantitative parimony. It
- 1:21:34does not contradict. It just what you
- 1:21:36what you said is no it does not
- 1:21:37contradict but it was contrary from your
- 1:21:40view. I don't know what you mean by
- 1:21:42that. Like really not contradict but
- 1:21:45contrary to my view. How's that
- 1:21:47possible? That's uh how would the LM
- 1:21:51love excluded middle apply there? I
- 1:21:52don't know. It's P. You're given the P
- 1:21:55and also the not P. It doesn't
- 1:21:57contradict and it's contradict from your
- 1:22:00view. And also I charged him of
- 1:22:02equivocation and he said you can't just
- 1:22:04charge me with equivocation then run
- 1:22:06away and then proceed to something else.
- 1:22:07Bro, I precisely said that you have to
- 1:22:11uh you have used intrinsic into a quivoc
- 1:22:15a quaocative sense. So here I did a
- 1:22:18little drawing where you were uh where
- 1:22:19you were taking your turn. So intrinsic
- 1:22:22from oneself a satic I've shown it
- 1:22:25before a satic and then what you mean is
- 1:22:27that and you precisely prove yourself to
- 1:22:30be saying this second sense because you
- 1:22:32said oh god isn't god allloving and
- 1:22:34isn't god all powerful and god is all
- 1:22:36this all that you are treating these as
- 1:22:39parts as I already said this is a
- 1:22:41totality viewed from different facets
- 1:22:44from our human experience now you said
- 1:22:47how can god does not have intrinsic uh
- 1:22:50intrinsic
- 1:22:51um knowledge if God is all loving. So
- 1:22:53you you reduce God to parts and that is
- 1:22:58not that is not possible. Okay, that is
- 1:23:00not possible because we have already
- 1:23:02established that God is simple. You
- 1:23:03already established it because you
- 1:23:05proceeded from the Catholic
- 1:23:07understanding of divine simplicity,
- 1:23:08didn't you? All right. So, and you also
- 1:23:11said uh when he established why change
- 1:23:13happens and why change has to proceed
- 1:23:15from an actual thing, he we didn't get a
- 1:23:18nice critique from him. Why are you get
- 1:23:21why are you expecting a nice critique
- 1:23:23from me? I'm sure everybody noticed you
- 1:23:26said you did not give a nice critique.
- 1:23:28Why would I critique my own? It's your
- 1:23:31task to critique my to critique what
- 1:23:33I've established. So the the real
- 1:23:36question is here why haven't I get a
- 1:23:38nice critique a nice I don't know what
- 1:23:40you mean by nice a nice critique for my
- 1:23:43argumentation. Instead, you proceeded
- 1:23:45built up your own castle and destroyed
- 1:23:48your own castle without giving mine to
- 1:23:50any of what I've established. All right.
- 1:23:52And you also said earlier,
- 1:23:55I claimed when I mentioned Xnihilo, you
- 1:23:58got this sense again. It's it's straw
- 1:24:00man. It's equivocative. Once again, you
- 1:24:02said came out of nothing. When when I
- 1:24:05showed you my drawing of a cat, I don't
- 1:24:07know where it is because it's an
- 1:24:09infinite canvas here. When I showed you
- 1:24:11my drawing of a cat,
- 1:24:14the nihilo is inside it. It's not from
- 1:24:16nothing but made of nothing. Okay? So,
- 1:24:20it's made of nothing by segregating
- 1:24:22what's cutness from everything else.
- 1:24:25Okay? That's my uh sub uh subtractive
- 1:24:28ideiation of creation.
- 1:24:30I literally show that to every I
- 1:24:32literally show that to you in my
- 1:24:34presentation. Okay. So um you said that
- 1:24:38uh those are nice drawings but nice
- 1:24:41drawings are nice but we don't we don't
- 1:24:44get clearcut argument from them. I know
- 1:24:47my burden of proof and therefore I use
- 1:24:49these devices to lighten it and instead
- 1:24:52of using my words I just show the
- 1:24:54pictures right and it it facilitates
- 1:24:57understanding to my audience. What what
- 1:24:59about your facial expressions bro? Your
- 1:25:02facial expressions are nice, but we
- 1:25:04don't get clear-cut arguments from them.
- 1:25:06You g this, you grimace that. It doesn't
- 1:25:09mean anything. Thank you so much.
- 1:25:11>> Well, thank you. Thank you so much. That
- 1:25:13was uh that uh closing statement coming
- 1:25:16from Chester. Dude, was unconventional
- 1:25:18indeed.
- 1:25:20So, let's move forward to uh King Kylo.
- 1:25:23Uh you will be having five minutes. Uh
- 1:25:25do you wish to use this format as well,
- 1:25:27King Kylo? Okay, go on.
- 1:25:29>> Okay. I want to show everybody something
- 1:25:31really quickly. Like in his clo, he said
- 1:25:34I was using it wrong. You could
- 1:25:36literally read x nilo. The term x nilo
- 1:25:39comes from Latin where x means out of
- 1:25:42and nilo means um the ablative of nah
- 1:25:46meaning nothing, right? So you get from
- 1:25:48nothing. So I was using the term
- 1:25:50properly. Okay. Now let me turn my
- 1:25:52screen back around. That was a that was
- 1:25:54a confusion there he made. So,
- 1:25:57um, now let me, cuz I know the the PHCOM
- 1:25:59might think like, oh, well, like, you
- 1:26:00know, there's this new guy from the
- 1:26:02States and bro, I love the PHC, okay?
- 1:26:04But let me just set my camera up. I love
- 1:26:06the PHC. I just came to debate, so it's
- 1:26:09all love to the PH. I'm going to come to
- 1:26:10the Philippines soon. Love the PHC,
- 1:26:12okay? I know there I know a lot of PH
- 1:26:14people feel like they have to like
- 1:26:15support him because he's PH or like, you
- 1:26:17know, these Filipino back. We got to
- 1:26:19just be honest. We had to be totally
- 1:26:21honest like okay the debate was the
- 1:26:25Catholic God exists. Okay did we get a
- 1:26:28argument for the Catholic god existing
- 1:26:29that went through? No. And irrespective
- 1:26:32of you guys having to support him but we
- 1:26:34have to be very we have to be um honest
- 1:26:36in a lot. Okay. So we didn't get an
- 1:26:38argument in favor of a Catholic God
- 1:26:39exist. Let me go back to my notes. So
- 1:26:42the burden of proofing of Bern Jr. he
- 1:26:44gave an affirmative argument in favor of
- 1:26:45Catholicism. Phenomenal. Perfect. But
- 1:26:48there were critiques to that argument
- 1:26:49that did not go through. For for one,
- 1:26:52his argument presupposes potentiality to
- 1:26:55actuality as the representational
- 1:26:56account of change. There was an inquiry,
- 1:26:59an attack relation type inquiry. Okay.
- 1:27:01When you talk about potentiality, are
- 1:27:03you referring to possible um under a
- 1:27:05logical modality, metaphysical
- 1:27:07epistemic, etc. Chester dues never
- 1:27:10answered these type of questions which
- 1:27:12were pertinent for further attacks,
- 1:27:14which just means that his view is
- 1:27:15ambiguous. his view is up for scrutiny
- 1:27:18regarding well what interpretation is
- 1:27:20being evoked. No, I don't know if he
- 1:27:22wasn't expecting me to give a counter
- 1:27:24argument, but I did. I gave the aloneess
- 1:27:26argument. I gave a comparative analysis
- 1:27:28and I gave um the impossibility of the
- 1:27:30contrary view, which is just essentially
- 1:27:32saying, well, you must be committed to
- 1:27:33saying there's a logical impossibility
- 1:27:35with there being a world with no minds.
- 1:27:37Now, I and I made this point a lot of
- 1:27:38times. Chester Dudes was committed to
- 1:27:40saying a possible world with no minds
- 1:27:43and tells a proposition and his direct
- 1:27:45negation which are affirmed at the same
- 1:27:47time. Somebody's chester dudes is making
- 1:27:49noise during my can we
- 1:27:52okay wow so he was committed to saying
- 1:27:56I'm going to repeat that a possible
- 1:27:58world with no minds has a logical
- 1:28:00contradiction in it now if we all ask
- 1:28:02ourselves did we ever get a proposition
- 1:28:04and it direct negation which were
- 1:28:05affirmed at the same time no if we don't
- 1:28:07get a P and a not P you are not licensed
- 1:28:10to say that a view is impossible I made
- 1:28:12that clear a few times I want okay so
- 1:28:14this is this is the problem okay when we
- 1:28:16talked about the comparative analysis we
- 1:28:18take a naturalistic hypothesis a
- 1:28:19theistic hypothesis he made the claim
- 1:28:22they both can't explain the datim I said
- 1:28:24well why can't they both explain the
- 1:28:26datim we have heard no argument from
- 1:28:28tester dudes that a naturalistic
- 1:28:30hypothesis can't explain the datam or
- 1:28:32the phenomena of a universe okay you
- 1:28:34once again tester dudes made a lot of
- 1:28:36claims within a dialect and then he
- 1:28:37moves past them he doesn't justify well
- 1:28:39why can't a naturalistic hypothesis
- 1:28:41explain it mind you we just said
- 1:28:43possibly they both explain the datam
- 1:28:45okay Well, I hope he's not saying it's
- 1:28:47impossible they both explain the datim.
- 1:28:49So, on the condition they both possibly
- 1:28:51explain the datam, which one's more
- 1:28:52parsimmonious? Well, obviously the one
- 1:28:54that doesn't need a immaterial um
- 1:28:57metaphysically queer or robust mind.
- 1:28:59However, whatever view you want to take,
- 1:29:01it's still an additional property. So,
- 1:29:03when you look at quantitative parsimony
- 1:29:05and if you ever guys ever read on
- 1:29:07theoretical virtues, the view that
- 1:29:09doesn't obtain this additional property
- 1:29:11would be more virtuous. Okay? So, I I've
- 1:29:13justified that claim within the debate.
- 1:29:15Okay. Wow. Um, a lot of other clank and
- 1:29:18I've been over this so many times, but
- 1:29:20I'm just going to have to repeat it for
- 1:29:21my closing. Reason why I went on the
- 1:29:23burden rejoinder is because I showed a
- 1:29:26lot of commitments my opponent has that
- 1:29:28he wasn't ready and equipped to justify
- 1:29:31such as things like infinite regress
- 1:29:33being impossible. We ask, well, why
- 1:29:34can't you have an infinite regress
- 1:29:36without this uh fundamental ground? We
- 1:29:38never heard many responses to the
- 1:29:40infinite regress talk. And I kept
- 1:29:41bringing it up. I kept bringing it up.
- 1:29:43He didn't respond to that. Um, he
- 1:29:44charged me Oh, and then also we're going
- 1:29:46to talk about the fallacy he made within
- 1:29:47the discourse, the genetic fallacy. I
- 1:29:49want to flag that member. Um, but he he
- 1:29:52he charged me with a lot of fallacies
- 1:29:54and then moved on. And then he also
- 1:29:56tried to say I was equivocating, but as
- 1:29:57you guys can see, I showed the screen.
- 1:30:00I'm using the term in the standard
- 1:30:02manner. I'm using it. I'm not I'm not
- 1:30:04being idiosyncratic. So to say I'm
- 1:30:06equivocating is is is a is disputed
- 1:30:09because I'm using the term how it should
- 1:30:11be used. Okay? It's comporting with the
- 1:30:13dictionary. So I'm I'm being adequate
- 1:30:14with the terminology here. Another thing
- 1:30:18he said and this for the adjudicators
- 1:30:19fact checking anybody knows any Catholic
- 1:30:21we going to have to talk with Chester
- 1:30:22Dudes about this. He said God does not
- 1:30:24have intrinsic properties. That's false.
- 1:30:27God in and then to to say that God
- 1:30:30intrinsically has um all lovingness and
- 1:30:32intrinsically has all knowledge does not
- 1:30:34commit you to there being parts that
- 1:30:36that's false.
- 1:30:38>> Well, thank you. Thank you so much Kyo.
- 1:30:40Oh, shout out Kyle
- 1:30:42>> and Sanji.
- 1:30:44>> All right, bro.
- 1:30:46>> Thank you. Thank you so much. That was a
- 1:30:47compelling and noteworthy uh closing
- 1:30:50statement coming from the king Kylo. So,
- 1:30:53let's have a 5 minutes break while
- 1:30:56begin. Let's give time to our
- 1:30:58adjudicators uh while they are preparing
- 1:31:00for their for their adjudications. May I
- 1:31:03just request the hostal?
- 1:31:05Let's go back to the first format of the
- 1:31:08debate.
- 1:31:10We will no longer need be needing this
- 1:31:13uh type uh of format.
- 1:31:16Uh if permission po
- 1:31:19Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Let's have a 5 minutes
- 1:31:22break.
- 1:31:24Okay.
- 1:31:27Okay. Okay. So, thank you. Thank you so
- 1:31:28much. Uh ano. I just like to uh to say
- 1:31:32now this program is brought to you by
- 1:31:34Enovmarter, the parent company of JCL
- 1:31:37Agri Service. And I just also like to
- 1:31:40shout out and call uh the chairman of
- 1:31:42DOTFS uh Sir Tommy Agaston the president
- 1:31:46uh brother uh Renog chief operations
- 1:31:48officer brother Igatno all our senior
- 1:31:51moderators and moderator Rayo Selvatiko
- 1:31:55Zet justipol RR Prosit LV uh Eli sorry
- 1:32:00sorry Rugs and Deshan I would also like
- 1:32:03to give a shout out s promotional uh
- 1:32:06partners which is St. Pat if you are
- 1:32:09looking for a buy one take one
- 1:32:13you could just me message them for
- 1:32:15inquiries and reservation contact uh the
- 1:32:17sale the number one sales executive sir
- 1:32:19Rayo uh also the Tik Tok rap community
- 1:32:23uh calling all the aspiring uh aspiring
- 1:32:25rappers and battles enthusiasts if you
- 1:32:27are uh interested in joining the
- 1:32:30community and showcasing your skills in
- 1:32:32rap battles contact uh sensei elo for
- 1:32:35more details ion we would also like to
- 1:32:37give shout out. A big shout out po sa uh
- 1:32:41big supporters ion. Thank you so much
- 1:32:43for supporting the debating communities
- 1:32:45kua JB Magis. Thank you. Thank you so
- 1:32:47much for collaboration.
- 1:32:51You could message the dof for any brand
- 1:32:53poy an thank you. Thank you so much and
- 1:32:56uh getting a praise coming from our
- 1:32:58chairman which is Suya Tommy that I'm
- 1:33:00doing a
- 1:33:02good uh that I'm doing great in my
- 1:33:05moderation. Well, it was really an honor
- 1:33:07on my end. Thank you. Thank you so much.
- 1:33:09And I would just like to commend also
- 1:33:11both of our debaters for having a great
- 1:33:14debate uh debate ethics sorry for for
- 1:33:16having a great debate ethics uh in this
- 1:33:19debate. It would also uh made me uh I
- 1:33:22mean it is a easy moderation on my end.
- 1:33:25Thank you. Thank you so much. So I guess
- 1:33:28ano let's start the adjudication. Let's
- 1:33:30start first with the notorious K. Go on.
- 1:33:34you will be having I guess we will be
- 1:33:36given them time
- 1:33:38host please correct me if we will be
- 1:33:40given them time adjudicate nila or we we
- 1:33:44can just let
- 1:33:47>> so let's give 5 minutes each nang for
- 1:33:50our adjudicators go on the notorious
- 1:33:52case
- 1:33:53>> uh okay so I want to establish the
- 1:33:56criteria first that has been sent by the
- 1:33:59DOTF which is the logical validity and
- 1:34:02coherence which weighs 20% % the
- 1:34:04soundness and defense of premises which
- 1:34:06is 20%. Effectiveness of rebuttals which
- 1:34:09is 20%. Cross examination which is 15%.
- 1:34:13Clarity and presentation which is 10%
- 1:34:16observance of debate rules which is 15%.
- 1:34:19So it's a total of 100 points right so I
- 1:34:21want to begin with the affirmative uh
- 1:34:23with affirmative constructive speech.
- 1:34:26Okay. So I recognize that quester dudes
- 1:34:30at the first part of his affirmative
- 1:34:32opening he acknowledged his burden that
- 1:34:34he must prove that number one God
- 1:34:36exists. Wait, hold on. Someone's calling
- 1:34:39me.
- 1:34:44Okay, thank you. So number one is that
- 1:34:47God exists and number two that that the
- 1:34:49Catholic God exists. So this is actually
- 1:34:53important to address whenever we're on a
- 1:34:56debate especially when we're affirmative
- 1:34:58because we want to be clear on what our
- 1:35:01obligation. So what Kuia Chester Dudes
- 1:35:04did is his signature which is the
- 1:35:06argument promotion. Dutellian he stated
- 1:35:09that um uh actuality and potency uh
- 1:35:13nothing nothing that that is potential
- 1:35:15can actualize itself.
- 1:35:18So I would say by establishing the
- 1:35:20premises and the justification it's
- 1:35:22good. He did it well. But the only
- 1:35:26problem that I
- 1:35:30came arise after this is how he tried to
- 1:35:34defend his premises and arguments. For
- 1:35:38example, the alone argument. So as we
- 1:35:42all know of the Arisotellian proof or
- 1:35:44the argument for motion it's an argument
- 1:35:46for classical theism and and the alonist
- 1:35:50argument that Kylo presented that is an
- 1:35:53argument against classical theism by Joe
- 1:35:55Smith in Ryan Mullins right so it
- 1:35:58attacks the the attributes that
- 1:36:01Quchester presented and I didn't see how
- 1:36:06Quchester
- 1:36:08address these things properly
- 1:36:11Okay. I didn't I didn't see that
- 1:36:12especially in in the most for me the
- 1:36:16most blunderous part is the parsimony
- 1:36:20the quantitative parim parsimony which
- 1:36:22Kylo is trying to press him that a
- 1:36:25fundamental entities the more
- 1:36:27fundamental entities you propose the
- 1:36:29more that the theory is improbable.
- 1:36:33So what Kuia Chester did there, he tried
- 1:36:36to save it on the cross- examination
- 1:36:38that it does not contradict the pure
- 1:36:40actuality. But that's not the case for
- 1:36:42the abductive argument because in the
- 1:36:44abductive argument, it will just appear
- 1:36:46that it does the the datim does not
- 1:36:48favor your position. It doesn't need it
- 1:36:51doesn't need to contradict. It's just
- 1:36:52that that the datim
- 1:36:54can be accounted simply within the
- 1:36:58alternative hypothesis.
- 1:37:00So that's my only critique to Kuya
- 1:37:03Chester for Kylo.
- 1:37:05Um I assess his objections about the
- 1:37:08aloneeness and the no world's man
- 1:37:11argument but I think I have a problem
- 1:37:13with the no worlds man. I think there
- 1:37:17there there's a bit for me the shifting
- 1:37:19of a burden that Kuya Chester must
- 1:37:21immediately show a defeater about the
- 1:37:23logical possib the logical impossibility
- 1:37:26of such world. I think what we must
- 1:37:29first uh do is to demonstrate the
- 1:37:32possibility.
- 1:37:35Yeah, we must demonstrate the
- 1:37:36possibility of a no man's world. The no
- 1:37:39a world where there's no mind. I ano po
- 1:37:42yun sorry we we must first demonstrate
- 1:37:45that. All right. And about the
- 1:37:47quantitative parsimony, the theoretical
- 1:37:50virtues. Actually, there are a lot of
- 1:37:52theoretical virtues that that we must um
- 1:37:57qualify when we're making these kind of
- 1:38:00abductive arguments such as the
- 1:38:02explanatory scope and the fruitfulness
- 1:38:04and the consistencies. But in my
- 1:38:06perspective, But in my perspective, I
- 1:38:09think Kylo because there has been a lot
- 1:38:13of blunder and Kylo showed the the
- 1:38:17implication of what Queser must do which
- 1:38:20is the PPC. The PPC must be proven and
- 1:38:23he doesn't have the burden to prove that
- 1:38:25it's exclusively three. He can be
- 1:38:27agnostic to that. And also Qua Chester
- 1:38:30dudes did do a a lot of overclaiming
- 1:38:34which is too overclaiming such as the
- 1:38:35impossibility of um theological
- 1:38:37impossibility of infinite regress or the
- 1:38:40necessary exist or the impossibility
- 1:38:43wait I wrote that in the cross-
- 1:38:45examination or the and the impossibility
- 1:38:47of no minds I think quester must
- 1:38:51establish that and I think via burden of
- 1:38:54rejoinder
- 1:38:56via burden of rejoin. I can give my
- 1:38:59points because I have no time now. So,
- 1:39:03uh, four and six, four and five, three
- 1:39:06and seven, four and six, 5 and 7, 10,
- 1:39:1010.
- 1:39:12So, I give 48, 67, gap by 19 points for
- 1:39:17me. Winner, Kylo, that's my that's my
- 1:39:19education.
- 1:39:20>> Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you.
- 1:39:21Thank you so much.
- 1:39:24So let me just clarify it for the for
- 1:39:26the next for the next adjudicators. Uh
- 1:39:29I'm so sorry. I'm so I'm so sorry the
- 1:39:31notorious K. Uh Kylo is requesting that
- 1:39:34uh if we could do now we we we will not
- 1:39:37be given time anymore for the
- 1:39:40adjudicators for them to adjudicate
- 1:39:42well. I'm so sorry. And let me clarify
- 1:39:44for the viewers the debate scoring
- 1:39:46criteria
- 1:39:48so that you will know
- 1:39:50Chester for the criteria of scoring
- 1:39:52here. First of all criterion is logical
- 1:39:56validity and coherence we will be having
- 1:39:5820% soundness and and defense premises
- 1:40:0120% effectiveness of rebuttals 20%
- 1:40:04crossexamination 15% clarity and
- 1:40:07presentation 10% observance and uh
- 1:40:10debate rules 15% uh which is total 100%
- 1:40:14go on ATS teacher you will be uh we will
- 1:40:17not giving you a time anymore go on
- 1:40:20>> yeah hi good evening so teacher here
- 1:40:23of freeth thinking and free free speech.
- 1:40:25Uh so first I would like to note that
- 1:40:28these two debators have different duty.
- 1:40:30The affirmative have the burden of proof
- 1:40:33and the negative side have the burden of
- 1:40:35reputation or in Kyla's case is the
- 1:40:38burden of uh the all that. Anyways so
- 1:40:43this this would settle who won this
- 1:40:45debate. So first let's proceed with the
- 1:40:47opening. uh Chester provided a removal
- 1:40:50of distinction from the Catholic to the
- 1:40:53Christian God. But for me it will not
- 1:40:56just suffice to say that it is the case.
- 1:40:59You need to justify why is it is the
- 1:41:02case. Right? So next he also laid down
- 1:41:06the causal change linear and
- 1:41:08hierarchical. That's a good point. But
- 1:41:11this thing answers
- 1:41:14what we have when it comes to causal
- 1:41:16change. that why it exists. So it
- 1:41:19doesn't answer existence because let us
- 1:41:21remember the topic of this debate is the
- 1:41:23Catholic god exist not how the Catholic
- 1:41:26god operates. All right. So next he also
- 1:41:30provide the theological definition of
- 1:41:33aospurus that's okay but remember uh in
- 1:41:38every debate and theological discussion
- 1:41:43let's remember that theology only works
- 1:41:45if you already accept the actions
- 1:41:48presented by the framework but if you do
- 1:41:51not accept it doesn't work right so next
- 1:41:55uh he also provided uh I'm I'm Still
- 1:41:58talking about Chester, he also provided
- 1:41:59a good effort in explaining the
- 1:42:02theological perspective. I could give
- 1:42:04credence to that. But the question is,
- 1:42:07can it be otherwise?
- 1:42:09And the one thing that lacking for me in
- 1:42:12in the burden of of Chester is the
- 1:42:16definition of existence. Why why does it
- 1:42:18need to exist? What's the criteria for
- 1:42:22existence?
- 1:42:23and what are the ways for us to discern
- 1:42:26what exist from what does not exist
- 1:42:28because we can talk all day about
- 1:42:30concepts abstract ideas but it still
- 1:42:35wouldn't settle what exists and that
- 1:42:37does or what doesn't exist uh finally in
- 1:42:41his opening he provides uh the
- 1:42:44attributes of God well the Catholic
- 1:42:48attributes of God I've already said that
- 1:42:50he provided a a removal of distin ution
- 1:42:54but again where's the bridging between
- 1:42:58uh the Catholic god into existence
- 1:43:01uh simply defining the terms or citing
- 1:43:04theological perspective doesn't provide
- 1:43:08existence right so let's proceed with
- 1:43:11Kylo for his opening
- 1:43:14uh he attacked the burden of proof no or
- 1:43:18the burden of rejoiner for his case he
- 1:43:21provided the aloness argument
- 1:43:23He provided a quantitative person.
- 1:43:27He said that there are lesser
- 1:43:29commitments, ontological commitments,
- 1:43:32no into a naturalistic perspective.
- 1:43:35In other terms, Okam's traor
- 1:43:38also said that if God exists
- 1:43:41necessarily,
- 1:43:43it would be impossible
- 1:43:46for a reality or a a a
- 1:43:50universe where no man's exist. that no
- 1:43:53mind's a universe where there is no mind
- 1:43:56is possible then
- 1:44:00God being a a an entity with a mind
- 1:44:06couldn't exist in that reality right so
- 1:44:10in a possible world where there is no
- 1:44:12mind God has a mind therefore God cannot
- 1:44:15exist in this possible world which
- 1:44:17entails a contradiction so that's what
- 1:44:19he showed in his opening statement so
- 1:44:21that's the the the the premises and the
- 1:44:23conclusion that he brought up there. So
- 1:44:25let's now proceed with the rebuttal of
- 1:44:27Chester. So Chester provided his own
- 1:44:30ontological argument.
- 1:44:32But I don't think that you have to uh
- 1:44:35distinguish a different house because
- 1:44:38let's remember this is a debate and you
- 1:44:40had a pre-debate and you agreed upon the
- 1:44:43the the standard on which you will be
- 1:44:46debating and in this case it is logic.
- 1:44:48So you're not technically standing on
- 1:44:52different grounds, but you're using the
- 1:44:53same method which is logic in order to
- 1:44:57dismantle your opponent's argument. So
- 1:45:00there there's no other house here. We
- 1:45:01are all standing in the same house.
- 1:45:03Okay. So what he did here, what I I
- 1:45:06didn't like on what he did here is he he
- 1:45:08just repeated his opening statement. uh
- 1:45:12again as an adjudicator of course I do
- 1:45:15have my preferences and I don't think
- 1:45:17repeating your opening statement in this
- 1:45:19case in the rebuttal stage would be
- 1:45:21necessary because for me your duty as uh
- 1:45:27a debater on the rebuttal stage is to
- 1:45:29refute the arguments laid out by your
- 1:45:32opponents not just solidifying
- 1:45:36your opening statement. So I have a
- 1:45:39problem with the par person parimony
- 1:45:41because we all know but that that the
- 1:45:44addition in
- 1:45:47in the ontological commitment is not
- 1:45:49material again it is it is ontological.
- 1:45:54So there there's a bit of confusion
- 1:45:56there. Now let's proceed with what he
- 1:45:58said about the the triangle essence. So
- 1:46:02I would like to raise a question here
- 1:46:03because again when we talk about
- 1:46:05triangles what would be the difference
- 1:46:08of the essence of a triangle and the
- 1:46:10definition of a triangle. If we cannot
- 1:46:12distinguish between its definition and
- 1:46:14its essence then there's no difference
- 1:46:16between essence and its definition then
- 1:46:19we haven't made a case why a triangle
- 1:46:22has essence. We can merely say that the
- 1:46:24triangle has a definition. All right. So
- 1:46:27let's proceed with the next case of this
- 1:46:29rebuttal which is the via negativa. So
- 1:46:32this is a good explanation but we should
- 1:46:34ask ourselves how does this prove God?
- 1:46:38Uh God being able to create something
- 1:46:42out of nothing. Sure. But does that mean
- 1:46:45that this God exists? Well, conceptually
- 1:46:47we can say that everything is possible.
- 1:46:50But when we talk about existence, we
- 1:46:52have criterias in
- 1:46:54in determining whether something exists
- 1:46:57or not. And the caveat here is that it's
- 1:47:00wrong that everything is removed. To
- 1:47:02make a cat, let's remember that a cat
- 1:47:05has shapes. Cat has figures, movements,
- 1:47:09colors. So I I would say that it is not
- 1:47:12a good case to point out in your
- 1:47:13rebuttal that God via ex Miilo no remove
- 1:47:19all the properties in order to make
- 1:47:20account that that's not a good case. No.
- 1:47:24So next second to the last the the
- 1:47:27conversion of Jose has nothing to do
- 1:47:29with argument as long as it stands
- 1:47:32whether he converted or not we can still
- 1:47:35use his arguments. We can still justify
- 1:47:37why why it is the case. And let's
- 1:47:39remember we're talking philosophy here.
- 1:47:41So everything is on the table, right? Uh
- 1:47:45I would like to remind also that uh
- 1:47:47again rebattle is used to refute your
- 1:47:50opponent's argument, not review your
- 1:47:52opening statement. So now let's proceed
- 1:47:55with the the rebattle of Kylo. Uh he
- 1:47:58pointed out that there are no answers to
- 1:48:01his uh opening statements. So this is
- 1:48:05what a good debater should do. You
- 1:48:08should point out which are the the moot
- 1:48:11points that you've presented that your
- 1:48:14opponent fails to answer. All right? So
- 1:48:17there's no answer in the alone argument
- 1:48:20in his rebattle. There's no answer in in
- 1:48:23Chester's case regarding the comparative
- 1:48:26analysis, the possibility of a mindless
- 1:48:29possible world. No. And let us remember
- 1:48:33there's a big burden when talking about
- 1:48:34impossibility.
- 1:48:36No. When you state impossibility,
- 1:48:39it is as if you need omniscience to to
- 1:48:42to tell whether something is impossible.
- 1:48:46Right? So, so the most humble thing to
- 1:48:48do is say that yeah, it is possible, but
- 1:48:51why should I accept this, right? So, now
- 1:48:54let's proceed with what Kylo said about
- 1:48:57the exhilo. He also said that it still
- 1:49:00needs to be proven, right? So simply
- 1:49:04defining something into existence
- 1:49:06doesn't mean that that thing exist or
- 1:49:08that entity exist. We can define
- 1:49:11something like a square circle or a a
- 1:49:15number one with multiple uh amounts but
- 1:49:19then doesn't mean it it exists. Right?
- 1:49:22So he also called out the the strawman.
- 1:49:25Kyle also called the straw man. But I'm
- 1:49:28going to let it slide because this
- 1:49:30really happened in debates. No,
- 1:49:32sometimes you you miss of course through
- 1:49:35language barriers.
- 1:49:37Uh maybe you're not accustomed to uh
- 1:49:40idiosyncrasies of the speaker. So uh I
- 1:49:44would be lenient in in the calling out
- 1:49:47of the straw man. So third to the last
- 1:49:51Kylo also stated in his rebuttal
- 1:49:55about the proportionate causality. He
- 1:49:58said that there's no good reason to
- 1:49:59accept this and why this is exhaustive.
- 1:50:02Now this is a good a good way to
- 1:50:05dismantle or your opponent because again
- 1:50:08he is on a negative side and you must
- 1:50:10show no having the burden of reputation
- 1:50:15that it it is not just the case. This is
- 1:50:18not exhaustive. There are other option I
- 1:50:21may not know other options but you have
- 1:50:23to prove that there are no other
- 1:50:25options. That's the duty of the
- 1:50:28affirmative. Uh so he also called out
- 1:50:32the genetic fallacy when it comes to Joe
- 1:50:35Smith. So that's okay. I would grant
- 1:50:37that because that that really is a
- 1:50:39genetic fallacy. Doesn't matter who is
- 1:50:41speaking or what the sources are as long
- 1:50:43as it provides a justification or
- 1:50:46explanation in in the debate that we are
- 1:50:49having. uh he also pointed out that
- 1:50:51there are no rebuttal on the ontological
- 1:50:53contradiction of a mindless possible
- 1:50:55world. Again this is a draft argument
- 1:50:58because the his opponent fails to
- 1:51:02satisfy why it is logically
- 1:51:05contradictory to have a mindless
- 1:51:07possible work. So let's proceed with the
- 1:51:10cross examination. Chester to Kylo uh
- 1:51:13proportionate causality question if
- 1:51:14there are other options. Kylie said no.
- 1:51:17Uh admittedly
- 1:51:21he also asked Chester also asked do you
- 1:51:23still consider the fourth option Kylo
- 1:51:25and Kylo said yes of course uh did God
- 1:51:28increase or decrease in in quantity
- 1:51:32it remained one the caveat here is uh
- 1:51:37you don't have to grant or even provide
- 1:51:42a full justification in your answer. So
- 1:51:45even if sometimes
- 1:51:48it seems like you are trapped, you can
- 1:51:50always answer it in in the latter
- 1:51:52rounds. For example, the second
- 1:51:54rebuttal. No. So
- 1:51:59Chester also asked, "Did you attack the
- 1:52:0110 commulative arguments?" Kylo said
- 1:52:03yes. Again, uh this is a good strategy.
- 1:52:06Why? Because
- 1:52:08remember the the reputation can mean two
- 1:52:12things. one is that you negate your
- 1:52:14opponent's position or you provide
- 1:52:17another
- 1:52:18uh alternative in that position. So
- 1:52:23second to the last God built up on
- 1:52:25essence and existence there. Kylo said
- 1:52:28yes this doesn't have any bearing to the
- 1:52:30cross examination and God's simplicity
- 1:52:32as being one he also said yes. So in
- 1:52:35this part Kylo is the one answering. Now
- 1:52:38let's proceed with the cross of Kylo. Uh
- 1:52:41one thing I noticed with the cross of
- 1:52:42Kylo is that his uh line of questioning
- 1:52:46is very restrictive in a sense that even
- 1:52:49if duds answered no he would proceed
- 1:52:53with a question that as if he said yes.
- 1:52:56So that's not a good strategy but we we
- 1:52:58can be lenient about that simply because
- 1:53:00we we are time bound. We have
- 1:53:03restrictions in the time and the number
- 1:53:05of questionings that we could ask. So I
- 1:53:08think Kyler is just you know managing
- 1:53:10his his best possible strategy in this
- 1:53:13game. So yeah uh he asked the logical
- 1:53:17possibility if it entails no logical
- 1:53:20contradiction. Now this is the the
- 1:53:22turning point because
- 1:53:25Chester B said yes. And the problem is
- 1:53:28if there's no logical contradiction then
- 1:53:30we can grant that there's a possible
- 1:53:32world where no minds exist. And if there
- 1:53:35are no minds exist in that world that
- 1:53:37God that has a mind cannot exist. All
- 1:53:40right. I think that's the strongest uh
- 1:53:44question that Kylo asked to Chester that
- 1:53:46he answered wrongfully. No. I also asked
- 1:53:51uh is a world with no possible minds
- 1:53:55technically contradictory. Existence of
- 1:53:57a mind is necessary if God is alone. No
- 1:54:01theism and naturalism explanation. Now
- 1:54:03in in in the law of parimony when we're
- 1:54:06talking about the explanatory power
- 1:54:09as I've said in the outcomes razor
- 1:54:11argument that it doesn't need to provide
- 1:54:14a better explanation
- 1:54:17we only pick the ones who has less
- 1:54:20commitments whether epistemic or
- 1:54:22ontological. So the fact that uh
- 1:54:27naturalism technically provides less
- 1:54:30ontological commitment then we can say
- 1:54:33I'm not saying in full certainty but we
- 1:54:36can say that it has a better explanatory
- 1:54:39power by the law of parimony. So he also
- 1:54:42asked does theism additionally
- 1:54:46uh provide additional entity to explain
- 1:54:49and he said yes. So by this answer he is
- 1:54:53admitting Chester is admitting that by
- 1:54:57the law of person is not a better option
- 1:55:00because it has more commitments. It has
- 1:55:03more case to prove it needs more
- 1:55:06justification in order to be granted as
- 1:55:09a better explanation.
- 1:55:11No. So he also asked I think there's a
- 1:55:14confusion between what dudes understand
- 1:55:18but maybe this is just uh a problem with
- 1:55:21linguistics or how we pronounce our
- 1:55:23words because specifically asked
- 1:55:27which is a better
- 1:55:30choice if one provides lesser entpusion
- 1:55:38on that part.
- 1:55:40So I think that's a a a lack of
- 1:55:42knowledge on Chester's parts with
- 1:55:44regards to parimony. So let's now
- 1:55:46proceed with the second rebuttal of
- 1:55:49Chester.
- 1:55:51He said that it does not affect the
- 1:55:53commulative building. God is alone and
- 1:55:57poisoning the well. Well uh with regards
- 1:56:00to poisoning the will I I would say that
- 1:56:05every every debate I've tried this
- 1:56:09strategy once and it is not it is not
- 1:56:12something that is ad no in in the kind
- 1:56:15of debates that we have here on Tik Tok
- 1:56:17simply because the viewers could be
- 1:56:19expecting a more entertaining part and
- 1:56:24questioning the way to entertain our
- 1:56:26viewers. So I I would let it slide.
- 1:56:29Uh shifting the questions. That's what I
- 1:56:32said earlier when when
- 1:56:35uh Chester answered no
- 1:56:39yet Kylo proceeded with the an with
- 1:56:41another question as if he said yes. So
- 1:56:44that's a good catch in his regard in
- 1:56:46Chester's regard. He also attacked
- 1:56:49Chester also attacked the semantics. But
- 1:56:52we we all know that uh you two live in
- 1:56:55two different parts of the world. So
- 1:56:57semantics would just be a common problem
- 1:57:00in your discussion. It's not a big deal.
- 1:57:03But what should what should you focus on
- 1:57:06is on
- 1:57:08justifying and providing a better
- 1:57:10explanation why is your case better than
- 1:57:13the other side. All right.
- 1:57:16So uh I would like to note for Chester's
- 1:57:20future debate that
- 1:57:22uh explaining theology or explaining
- 1:57:26your theological position is not
- 1:57:28technically a rebuttal. No, you should
- 1:57:31uh all future debater should avoid this
- 1:57:34because it gets you nowhere. Explaining
- 1:57:36your theology, no only gives you another
- 1:57:41catch or another way to explain it. it
- 1:57:45you must no provide a justification why
- 1:57:50no this theology works why we should
- 1:57:52accept this why it is the better case
- 1:57:55rather than the opponents not just
- 1:57:57reexplaining it so let's proceed to the
- 1:58:00secondary battle of Kylo he also pointed
- 1:58:03out that
- 1:58:05fallacies needs justification to be
- 1:58:07granted that's a good point no intrinsic
- 1:58:11rebuttal God does not have intrinsic
- 1:58:14knowledge
- 1:58:14Well, theologically speaking, the the
- 1:58:17that aristocratistic
- 1:58:19philosophy or theology
- 1:58:22really does not accept that God has
- 1:58:24intrinsic knowledge because
- 1:58:27uh if he has an intrinsic knowledge then
- 1:58:29he wouldn't be acturus. If he if he is
- 1:58:32aosporous then he wouldn't have
- 1:58:34intrinsic knowledge. that the the thing
- 1:58:37that we needs to we we need to digest
- 1:58:40here is how does that justify God's
- 1:58:43existence?
- 1:58:44>> If it doesn't if it doesn't then we
- 1:58:48shouldn't have a problem with God having
- 1:58:50no or there is intrinsic value. So he
- 1:58:55also pointed out the the wrong answer of
- 1:58:58dudes regarding the law of parimony. No,
- 1:59:02he reiterated the no mind world possible
- 1:59:05without contradiction.
- 1:59:07The intrinsic properties destroy
- 1:59:10amnesia. There's a good catch actually
- 1:59:12because
- 1:59:14if
- 1:59:16he would be able to provide a
- 1:59:19justification and he did on the earlier
- 1:59:22part that
- 1:59:24his intrinsic property no from from
- 1:59:27being to becoming means that God is not
- 1:59:31atosporus
- 1:59:32and I think he he established that well
- 1:59:36in his opening statement and his rebat.
- 1:59:39So he also reiterated the fourth option
- 1:59:43which is not necessary for the negative
- 1:59:46side. The negative side doesn't have the
- 1:59:48duty to provide another option. They can
- 1:59:51just refute no negate deny the
- 1:59:56affirmative side regarding having a port
- 1:59:59option or not having the port option.
- 2:00:02So
- 2:00:04lastly the impossibility of infinite
- 2:00:06regress. It is a widely accepted
- 2:00:08philosophical position. Let's remember
- 2:00:11that uh in philosophy no it is one of
- 2:00:14the answers considered whether we appeal
- 2:00:17to authority we accept infinite regress
- 2:00:20or the other one that that is the the
- 2:00:23trillemma epistemic trillemma. Now I
- 2:00:26would like to note to the debators that
- 2:00:28uh I do not grade conclusions because
- 2:00:30for me conclusions are just reiterations
- 2:00:33of what happens and it should not be
- 2:00:35used for justification or rebuttal. It
- 2:00:38is meant to close your argument.
- 2:00:41So let's remember that burden of proof
- 2:00:44is more heavy in the affirmative
- 2:00:47and I as an adjudicator didn't say
- 2:00:50enough in this case with regards to
- 2:00:52existence to satisfy this burden.
- 2:00:56Theology only works if you accept the
- 2:00:58actions entailed in that theology. And
- 2:01:02with that, I would declare 90 over 80 in
- 2:01:06favor of
- 2:01:09>> so much uh ATS teacher for that
- 2:01:12adjudication.
- 2:01:13Uh ion I don't want to be rude by saying
- 2:01:17this. But please a reminder for everyone
- 2:01:19who's watching especially adjudicator or
- 2:01:23adjudicate please if you adjudicate
- 2:01:25sometimes could we just please at least
- 2:01:28uh give a pass adjudication because
- 2:01:30everyone is you know uh but in respect
- 2:01:33to ATS teacher uh I respect the
- 2:01:35adjudication well that's a highly
- 2:01:38appreciated adjudication and but please
- 2:01:40uh to all adjudicators who's watching
- 2:01:42especially in the panels please just
- 2:01:44give a fast adjudication no thank you
- 2:01:46thank you so much on Pragmarites.
- 2:01:49>> All right. Um, first of all,
- 2:01:50congratulations to the both of you. Um,
- 2:01:53let's start with Chester Dudes. Uh, I
- 2:01:56like the presentation. I like the
- 2:01:58creativity of it. But unfortunately,
- 2:02:01I agree with Kylo that how no matter how
- 2:02:04beautiful your your presentation is, it
- 2:02:08doesn't prove anything without
- 2:02:10arguments.
- 2:02:11So I heard I heard the rational
- 2:02:15arguments for the existence of the
- 2:02:17Catholic God, but there's still a gap on
- 2:02:21the It seems to me that the God you are
- 2:02:25committing the same mistake as Anelm
- 2:02:27like existence in the mind. It seems to
- 2:02:31me that the existence of the Catholic
- 2:02:34god uh remains in the realm of
- 2:02:36potentiality not in actualized
- 2:02:39um because you have to bridge that
- 2:02:42synthetically right it's either God
- 2:02:45exist or he doesn't um
- 2:02:50Pascal said that you cannot prove God's
- 2:02:52existence logically or the negation of
- 2:02:55it so
- 2:02:57I I did not hear like Jesus Christ I
- 2:03:00heard the beautiful or the majestic
- 2:03:03attributes of God. Um, that's fine, but
- 2:03:06there's still a gap. You you haven't
- 2:03:09bridged the existence of God through
- 2:03:12Jesus Christ. I think that's a good way
- 2:03:14to actually bridge it. So, you have a
- 2:03:17rational argument and an empirical one.
- 2:03:20And then with the with the
- 2:03:23with the opening of Kylo, I really like
- 2:03:27the the strategy of the reverse
- 2:03:29ontological argument because um I don't
- 2:03:34know if Chester dudes caught it, but
- 2:03:37he's putting you in a very awkward
- 2:03:40position on claiming the impossibility
- 2:03:43of the mindless world. Um it's covered.
- 2:03:47It's covered. Um, he covered the
- 2:03:50argument of the non-existence of God
- 2:03:53through that, but you did not actually
- 2:03:56address it. I think you should next time
- 2:03:59you should address that because that's a
- 2:04:01a very devastating attack on your on
- 2:04:04your argument because
- 2:04:09you have to say that it is impossible to
- 2:04:13have a mindless a mindless world. um
- 2:04:18you're going to have to prove that
- 2:04:19because it it's not about it's not about
- 2:04:23proving that necessary there's no mind
- 2:04:26in the world. But
- 2:04:29if you understand the argument, it's
- 2:04:32like the argument of the model
- 2:04:33ontological argument that the
- 2:04:35possibility and then the burden of
- 2:04:36impossible impossibility goes to the
- 2:04:39atheist, right? So he reversed that and
- 2:04:42then he gave you the burden of proof to
- 2:04:46prove the impossibility of it. You did
- 2:04:49not catch it. Uh you should address it.
- 2:04:52I think and then there's there's a
- 2:04:55problem with quantitative parimony. I
- 2:04:58think you misunderstood it.
- 2:05:01I don't know if you misunderstood it
- 2:05:03because what he's saying is the natural
- 2:05:07um the naturalism and theism
- 2:05:10um can explain the phenomena or
- 2:05:13everything in this universe but the
- 2:05:15problem is the theism side has to posit
- 2:05:19one more entity the supernatural one to
- 2:05:22actually explain it all. So you have to
- 2:05:25explain why it is necessary for that
- 2:05:27supernatural to be entertained in the
- 2:05:30explanation.
- 2:05:32So I think that's what he's saying that
- 2:05:35what he's saying but you did not
- 2:05:37actually attack that too. Um those are
- 2:05:40two strongest arguments that he made. He
- 2:05:43laid down and you just ignored it.
- 2:05:47And with with the with the cross
- 2:05:50examination, I think I I I'm not sure if
- 2:05:55if this is about the rules or
- 2:05:58because it seems to me that Kylo
- 2:06:00understood the rules to ask the question
- 2:06:03in categorical framework uh framing.
- 2:06:07But I think the rules is
- 2:06:10if the c if the question is categorical,
- 2:06:13you should answer categorically, right?
- 2:06:15So, you can ask an open-ended question
- 2:06:18or explain, but I don't know if that's
- 2:06:21the rules. I don't know if if that's the
- 2:06:23pre-debate rules. I don't know that. So,
- 2:06:26and then on the PPC, I think Kylo made
- 2:06:31an error there because he said that um
- 2:06:35what makes you think there's only three,
- 2:06:37right? Um how about four?
- 2:06:41But the burden of proof to prove that
- 2:06:44there's a fourth one is on Kylo's side
- 2:06:48because you your justification is not an
- 2:06:52empirical one. You just need your mind,
- 2:06:54your pen and your paper and you just do
- 2:06:56a thought experiment to actually prove
- 2:06:57that there's a fourth option. If there's
- 2:07:00a fourth option, then you posit it and
- 2:07:02then you actually destroy the argument.
- 2:07:04But since there's no practical
- 2:07:06distinction between um you haven't
- 2:07:09thought of it and there's no fourth
- 2:07:11option, then I don't think it's a good
- 2:07:14argument to say that there's a fourth,
- 2:07:16there's a uh there's a fifth. Um I don't
- 2:07:19I don't buy that argument because uh
- 2:07:21it's like it's like we're chasing a
- 2:07:23ghost and you cannot you cannot actually
- 2:07:25attack the argument that way. But again,
- 2:07:30the reason uh I I'm voting for Kylo is
- 2:07:33because uh the affirmative failed to
- 2:07:35bridge the gap of analytic and
- 2:07:36synthetic. And he um the affirmative
- 2:07:41has
- 2:07:43um
- 2:07:45a bigger um
- 2:07:48a heavier burden of proof than Kylo
- 2:07:53because he just needs to undermine it.
- 2:07:56and you are brave enough to take the
- 2:07:58existence position uh tester dudes. So
- 2:08:02um for me Kylo won but good debate.
- 2:08:09Thank you so much from Maritess or
- 2:08:11Caillou for that adjudication.
- 2:08:13I guess we have a clear a clear winner
- 2:08:15here. Again both I would like to commend
- 2:08:19both of our debaters for not uh making
- 2:08:21this hard for me especially in your
- 2:08:23cross examination. It was really a
- 2:08:25smooth moderation in both of the
- 2:08:28debaters. Thank you. Thank you so much.
- 2:08:30I will give uh 2 minutes each uh for our
- 2:08:33debaters to say their thank yous, shout
- 2:08:35out to everyone who's supporting them.
- 2:08:37First of all, I would like to give uh
- 2:08:39Kylo King Kylo a 3minut time to give a
- 2:08:43shout out and thank yous to all uh his
- 2:08:45supporters.
- 2:08:49Wait, hold on. So me and Chester dudes
- 2:08:52made agreement that whoever.
- 2:08:57>> You got it. You got it. Don't worry
- 2:08:59about it.
- 2:08:59>> So wait, wait. What? What did you have
- 2:09:01to call me?
- 2:09:03>> Master debater Kylo.
- 2:09:06>> No, not master debater. Master Kylo,
- 2:09:09right?
- 2:09:10>> Master Kylo. I can see that. He can be,
- 2:09:13bro.
- 2:09:16So, so my opponent agreed that if he
- 2:09:19loses to me, he has to call me Master
- 2:09:21Kylo. So, you guys ever see Chester on
- 2:09:24the panel when he refers to refer to me
- 2:09:26as Master Kylo, but irrespective of
- 2:09:28that, that's just a little joke cuz in
- 2:09:30his opening, he did make a little joke,
- 2:09:32too. So, I make a little joke, but
- 2:09:34irrespective of that. Um, shout out, you
- 2:09:36know. Okay, so who helped me? My
- 2:09:38boyWami. Shout outwami. My boy Kwami
- 2:09:40sent me the loness argument. He sent me
- 2:09:42papers. He sent me literature. He sent
- 2:09:43me videos. Shout outwami. Also, shout
- 2:09:46out to PHCOM. I love you guys. You guys
- 2:09:48are welcoming. You guys are good. Good
- 2:09:50marketing, good management. Like,
- 2:09:52everything's been phenomenal. I come
- 2:09:54from maincom. There's a lot of big
- 2:09:55debates going on. The way you guys have
- 2:09:57things structured here is proper. It's
- 2:09:59set up. I like it. I appreciate that.
- 2:10:00So, shout outwami. Shout out to
- 2:10:01Peachcom. Obviously, shout out to Young,
- 2:10:04all the SDS guys, Saji, Kio, all the SDS
- 2:10:07guys. Shout out them. But all I want to
- 2:10:09say is realistically like in this sport,
- 2:10:12you're going to win, you're going to
- 2:10:13lose. Um, it's really just about your
- 2:10:16preparation. It's really about how long
- 2:10:17you've been in the game. I've been in
- 2:10:18the game for about two years now. I
- 2:10:20understand rules and regulations
- 2:10:22regarding debating. So, it's not
- 2:10:24unexpected that I won this, but a shout
- 2:10:26out to my opponent for getting in the
- 2:10:27ring, even giving it a shot. My first
- 2:10:29ever formal debate, I lost. I think I'm
- 2:10:31right now like I'm like five and one on
- 2:10:33formal debate. So, losing is going to be
- 2:10:35a part of the game. But, that's all I
- 2:10:36got to really say from, you know, my
- 2:10:38last wrapping up closing.
- 2:10:48Oh, no. No. Yeah. Yeah. I'm done. I'm
- 2:10:50done. I'm done.
- 2:10:55>> Well, to Chester, dude, uh for uh to
- 2:10:57thank uh his fans and everything and
- 2:10:59everyone who supports him.
- 2:11:06>> Hello. Uh yeah, thank you. Thank you so
- 2:11:08much for my support system here in Tik
- 2:11:10Tok and of course uh my families who are
- 2:11:13watching right now maybe I don't know.
- 2:11:16Uh also thank you so much for Kylo. Um
- 2:11:18you know I was expecting if I lost this
- 2:11:21uh he would be you know rubbing at my
- 2:11:22face but it's all good man. Thank you so
- 2:11:24much for that. But yeah Master Kyle I
- 2:11:27have no problem calling you that. You
- 2:11:29did win this. Uh also big shout out to
- 2:11:33DOTF. like it's my first time being on a
- 2:11:36as big a platform as this and also the
- 2:11:38promotional videos are peak you know and
- 2:11:41yeah uh that's correct Ko I did uh
- 2:11:44prepare as much as I could I budgeted my
- 2:11:46time to prepare for it uh but it came
- 2:11:49short and I accept that also um thank
- 2:11:53you so much for our adjudicators um
- 2:11:55there was a lastm minute change which I
- 2:11:59wasn't informed about kind of surprised
- 2:12:01me but it's fine Um he was uh Notorious
- 2:12:06K is of course credible for adjudicating
- 2:12:09and he was actually one of the first
- 2:12:10options as well. Uh I was just uh caught
- 2:12:13by surprise in that. Um yeah um maybe I
- 2:12:18would just like want to address um one
- 2:12:22thing. The reason why I uh challenged or
- 2:12:26I agreed to the challenge from Kylo, I
- 2:12:29can't remember who challenged between
- 2:12:31the two of us, but um is that he he
- 2:12:35addresses that he is the best PH
- 2:12:37debater. I wanted to test that. Um I
- 2:12:41want I don't want my fellow Filipinos to
- 2:12:43be talked down like that. So I agreed to
- 2:12:45this debate. Uh I'm not the best
- 2:12:48Filipino debater. Not by a not by a long
- 2:12:51mile. So I'm expecting
- 2:12:54uh should we let Kylo be the best in our
- 2:12:57platform or in our circle? So I also
- 2:12:59challenged uh those who are way ahead of
- 2:13:02my level to also engage Kylo. Um I also
- 2:13:06would like to shout out uh Professor
- 2:13:08Manny uh whom I asked u whom I asked the
- 2:13:14advice uh from of course and he uh
- 2:13:17really said that I shouldn't take this
- 2:13:20debate. I'm really sorry that I went
- 2:13:23away at the to the other direction. Uh
- 2:13:26but yeah, I dedicate this still to Prov
- 2:13:28Manny. Uh as also uh I really kind of
- 2:13:33felt heart that one of our uh foundation
- 2:13:36here in Tik Tok uh is um Kylo you you
- 2:13:40spoke with him like a little roughly he
- 2:13:43respect he's widely respected here in
- 2:13:45our platform. uh calling him what? I I
- 2:13:48should not remind anybody what you call
- 2:13:50him. But yeah, bro, Kylo, thank you so
- 2:13:53much. Uh I was actually a fan the first
- 2:13:55time I heard you hear your videos over
- 2:13:58there at YouTube. Uh the first time it
- 2:14:00was introduced to me and I'm going to be
- 2:14:02and I'm I'll take your advice. Uh losing
- 2:14:04is just good. Thank you.
- 2:14:08>> Well, it really made me sad because I
- 2:14:11didn't get a shout out from both of the
- 2:14:13debators.
- 2:14:17to the PH count, brother. You're in.
- 2:14:19Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I'm just
- 2:14:21joking. Ayan, by the way,
- 2:14:22congratulations.
- 2:14:24>> Go on. And I'm sorry. I will plug an
- 2:14:28short of time. Go on.
- 2:14:29>> Okay. I will plug my upcoming debate on
- 2:14:32November, I
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Kylo Wins 3-0: Does the Catholic God Exist? | DOTF Full Debate by Debate of the Future, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 21,158 words across 3,182 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.