Kaufpreisaufteilung: Mehr Abschreibung sichern und vor dem Finanzamt begründen — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Um, as you mentioned in the
- 0:01introduction, today we're discussing
- 0:02the allocation of purchase prices for
- 0:03real estate. It’s actually a
- 0:05perennial hot topic in the real estate
- 0:06industry from a tax perspective. Um,
- 0:09the question is about, um, how much of
- 0:11the purchase price is attributable to
- 0:13the land and how much to the building?
- 0:16It’s an exciting question because
- 0:18only the building itself is subject to
- 0:19tax-deductible depreciation. And today
- 0:23we want to briefly outline the key
- 0:25points that matter, what needs to be
- 0:28considered in practice, and how to
- 0:30defend the purchase price allocation
- 0:32you may have pre-arranged in your
- 0:34contract against the tax office. A
- 0:38quick word about us. Um, we are Ridonis
- 0:40, we are tax advisors, lawyers, and
- 0:42auditors. We advise primarily in the
- 0:45areas of corporate transactions, asset
- 0:47management, and family offices, and we
- 0:50have a very large advisory component in
- 0:52the field of real estate taxation. Um,
- 0:55and we are happy to be here again. Uh,
- 0:58joining me today is my colleague
- 1:00Michael Demmelhuber, who will be giving
- 1:02the majority of the presentation.
- 1:06Yes, let's take a look at what to
- 1:07expect over the next 30 minutes, uh,
- 1:09what you should be able to take away
- 1:10from this. We’ll start by looking at
- 1:13why the allocation is important at all,
- 1:15why it is so decisive for the tax
- 1:17burden. Then we’ll take another look
- 1:19at the depreciation rates. Depreciation
- 1:22rates—that means depreciation, as
- 1:23Jakob already mentioned, depreciation
- 1:25on the building. Land cannot be
- 1:27depreciated. What rates there are in
- 1:292026 we will take a look at. Then
- 1:34we’ll look at the three methods of
- 1:36purchase price allocation and the
- 1:38associated pitfalls. We’ll illustrate
- 1:40the whole thing with a calculation
- 1:42example so you can see what it actually
- 1:44means in euros. We’ll look at the
- 1:46current case law and give a brief
- 1:48outlook: are there any current
- 1:50developments for me? And finally,
- 1:53we’ll just look at a kind of
- 1:55checklist: What is important when
- 1:56drafting the contract? What is
- 1:59important in a dispute with the tax
- 2:01office, or perhaps even in tax court?
- 2:03And we’ll list the most common
- 2:05mistakes from our practice and
- 2:07experience. Why is it so important? Yes
- 2:14, as already mentioned, only the
- 2:16building provides depreciation, and
- 2:18from a tax perspective, it is very
- 2:20important to distinguish between the
- 2:23land on one side, which is not
- 2:25depreciable, and the building on the
- 2:27other. In tax terms, you simply say:
- 2:29The building is subject to a certain
- 2:31amount of wear and tear over its useful
- 2:33life, and for that, there are so-called
- 2:36imputed costs in tax law. Ultimately,
- 2:38because it is depreciation, it is not
- 2:40cash flowing out of my pocket, but
- 2:43rather it is purely imputed, which is
- 2:45the so-called depreciation or also
- 2:47known as AfA. In practice, there is
- 2:51always a lot of talk about depreciation
- 2:53rates, meaning the useful life, and how
- 2:55to maximize them with an expert report,
- 2:58for example, that certifies a shorter
- 3:00useful life. Um, but what is ultimately
- 3:03also decisive is the assessment basis
- 3:06for depreciation. Uh, and that is
- 3:08simply the value of the building. And
- 3:10we have illustrated this here with a
- 3:12vivid example in the right-hand column.
- 3:16If I have a building value, a building
- 3:18of 500,000 euros, then 10 percent is
- 3:21more or less 50,000 euros as the
- 3:23assessment basis, upon which the
- 3:25depreciation is then calculated. But
- 3:28that is simply an incredible lever.
- 3:31Before I start playing around with
- 3:33depreciation rates, I can already
- 3:35secure the assessment basis from the
- 3:37start with a clean purchase price
- 3:39allocation—we will see that in a
- 3:41moment—and simply get the maximum tax
- 3:43benefit from the beginning. Here we
- 3:49have listed the current depreciation
- 3:50rates again, which we won't go into in
- 3:52detail now. Most of you will be experts
- 3:55in this yourselves and will know this.
- 3:58I think it's just important to know: on
- 4:00one hand, there is straight-line
- 4:02depreciation, and on the other hand,
- 4:04there is declining-balance depreciation
- 4:06. Straight-line depreciation, as shown
- 4:08here. e.g., 3%, 2%um, is simply a fixed
- 4:13absolute euro value based on the
- 4:15assessment basis, uh, which does not
- 4:17change over the useful life, so to
- 4:19speak. As for declining-balance
- 4:22depreciation, it is currently available
- 4:24again for a certain time window. We see
- 4:27it here for new residential buildings,
- 4:30construction, contract conclusion until
- 4:32'29, so really only for a limited
- 4:34period, and "declining," as the name
- 4:36implies, means that you calculate, for
- 4:39example, 5%on 100,000 euros, which is
- 4:415,000 euros. In the next year, I have
- 4:46an assessment basis of 100,000 minus
- 4:485,000 euros, so 95,000 euros, and I
- 4:51calculate the 5%on that, and so on, and
- 4:53as a result, the absolute depreciation
- 4:56decreases and becomes less and less. Uh
- 4:59, whereas with straight-line
- 5:01depreciation, the absolute amount is
- 5:03always the same. Besides that, there
- 5:06are of course certain combination
- 5:08options, which we actually don't want
- 5:09to go into right now. Because today we
- 5:12are really concerned with the
- 5:13assessment basis, i.e., what the
- 5:15depreciation, the "AfA," is calculated
- 5:17on. Um, just very briefly and
- 5:19importantly here, what you can see here
- 5:22and what tax law works with are
- 5:23standardizing assumptions regarding
- 5:25buildings and apartments, um, as you
- 5:28can see in the depreciation rates, what
- 5:30is always possible and what is, of
- 5:32course, a constant topic in practice.
- 5:35is to prove through an expert—but
- 5:37really through an expert report that
- 5:40meets certain requirements—that the
- 5:43building has a shorter useful life. Um,
- 5:46because then you can claim higher
- 5:48depreciation rates. For a depreciation
- 5:51rate of 3%, for example, one assumes a
- 5:54useful life of 33.33 years. Or simply
- 5:5750 years at 2%. But if I can prove that
- 6:01my building will not last that long, so
- 6:03to speak, because it is already so old,
- 6:05then I can also increase the
- 6:07depreciation accordingly. But as I said
- 6:10, very importantly, a proper appraisal
- 6:13is necessary for that. Three ways to
- 6:19allocate the purchase price. Very
- 6:23important, and what should always be
- 6:25given priority, so to speak, is the
- 6:27contractual allocation. This means that
- 6:30I specify exactly in the notarized
- 6:33purchase agreement what portion of the
- 6:35purchase price is attributable to the
- 6:38land, to the building, and, very
- 6:40importantly, if there are any other
- 6:43independently depreciable assets. For
- 6:45example, if a kitchen is included that
- 6:47I am also purchasing. Then, ideally,
- 6:50that should really be listed separately
- 6:52in the purchase agreement with its
- 6:54respective value. Because once that is
- 6:57fixed and once the tax office has
- 6:59approved it in the income tax return,
- 7:01let's say, then you save yourself a lot
- 7:03of effort from having to argue about it
- 7:06later. Because if it has been accepted
- 7:08once, it will usually be accepted for
- 7:10the coming years as well. Therefore, it
- 7:14is very important to regulate this in
- 7:15the notarized contract if possible,
- 7:17which is also clear. Of course, you
- 7:21cannot just put made-up values in there
- 7:24. For example, building worth a million
- 7:27and land 10,000 or something. Land
- 7:3110,000, no one in Munich would believe
- 7:33that. The notary probably wouldn't even
- 7:36let that stand in the document either.
- 7:40But it is simply important to try to
- 7:42present the real value ratios there.
- 7:47Beyond that, looking toward appraisals,
- 7:48you can of course also determine it
- 7:50using a capitalized earnings method.
- 7:53For example, even retroactively, if you
- 7:55haven't made a purchase price
- 7:56allocation in the contract, you can
- 7:58always prove it with an appraisal. As a
- 8:03third option, there is the so-called
- 8:05BMF working aid, from the Federal
- 8:07Ministry of Finance. That is really a
- 8:10very helpful tool. It is basically a
- 8:14very simple Excel file that works with
- 8:17certain assumptions and allows you to
- 8:19select them using a dropdown function.
- 8:23We will see it in a moment; we will go
- 8:25over the working aid again, and it can
- 8:27serve as an initial orientation. Very
- 8:30important, we will get to this in a
- 8:32moment, it is not a binding tool. So
- 8:35what comes out of it is not binding in
- 8:38any way, but what is very important and
- 8:40helpful is that it can provide an
- 8:42initial orientation. Um, this allows me
- 8:46to see: is the purchase price or the
- 8:49purchase price allocation realistic, or
- 8:52does it deviate so strongly from this
- 8:54work aid, um, that one has to say, okay
- 8:57, I probably need an additional
- 8:59appraisal to back it up? Because the
- 9:02tax office also uses this work aid, and
- 9:04if they enter the values into the Excel
- 9:06sheet and a different value comes out
- 9:08that deviates significantly from the
- 9:10values you have, for example. e.g., set
- 9:13out in the purchase contract, then you
- 9:15can actually expect questions to arise,
- 9:17and if you have an appraisal, um, then
- 9:19the matter is off the table very
- 9:21quickly. Yes, how does the work aid
- 9:25calculate? Um, for one thing, you need
- 9:28the land value, which is calculated.
- 9:31That is very simple. You take the
- 9:33standard land value multiplied by the
- 9:35area, if it's an apartment, then with
- 9:36the co-ownership share, otherwise just
- 9:38the plot area. um the building value in
- 9:42the simplified asset value method, that
- 9:44is the term from tax law. Um, the name
- 9:47naturally already suggests simplified.
- 9:50Um, that means it cannot reflect
- 9:53reality. Uh, it is it is an estimation
- 9:56method that also calculates with, yes,
- 9:59indexation. We have laid it out here in
- 10:01the box below. Um, it is simply based
- 10:04on construction costs determined at
- 10:06some point, the NHK, the normal
- 10:09construction costs, um, these are then
- 10:11used, indexed to the current year, and
- 10:14they are then, um, used for the
- 10:17estimate. Systematic weakness, we have
- 10:19laid it out, but I think it is
- 10:21straightforward. Sure, it cannot uh
- 10:23reflect the individual case, and, um,
- 10:26especially in high-priced areas like,
- 10:28for example, Munich, um, they simply
- 10:30result in land values that are way too
- 10:33high. And it is of course very
- 10:35important that you, um, yes, don't just
- 10:37accept that, but take counter-measures,
- 10:39because, as I said, if the–it is
- 10:40basically the inverse conclusion if–
- 10:42the land value is very high, um, of the
- 10:44purchase price, then the building value
- 10:46must of course be correspondingly lower
- 10:48. That is why I am giving away
- 10:51depreciation potential if I just accept
- 10:54it. because the tool is really helpful
- 10:59for practice for a first rule-of-thumb
- 11:01impression. Uh, we have also included a
- 11:04step-by-step guide here. Um, on the
- 11:07right you can see a snip of the Federal
- 11:08Ministry of Finance page, how it looks
- 11:10and how it is described. Below are the
- 11:12links to the tools, uh, on the page. We
- 11:15have also copied the links again into
- 11:18the box on the left for you. What you
- 11:21need, very simply, the purchase
- 11:22contract; most things are usually in
- 11:24there. Land register, parcel data, and
- 11:27standard land value are, of course,
- 11:28super helpful. From the state's land
- 11:31value portal, for example, which
- 11:33involves a fee. Um, sometimes you just
- 11:35get it from acquaintances or something
- 11:36similar. Um, but the land value is
- 11:39actually quite important in this regard
- 11:40. Then the year of construction, floor
- 11:43space, and also evidence of any
- 11:45modernizations, because that can, of
- 11:47course, contribute to an increase in
- 11:49the building's value. We also entered
- 11:54this into the worksheet and used the
- 11:57following case as a basis, which is
- 11:59actually a current advertisement from
- 12:01Munich from August. We have a
- 12:05condominium in a high-price location
- 12:08with a total purchase price of €
- 12:10358,000, built in '65, 2%depreciation,
- 12:13which means one would assume a 50-year
- 12:16useful life. You can already tell that
- 12:19for a '65 build, you could certainly do
- 12:21something with an appraisal regarding
- 12:22the useful life. For the calculation,
- 12:25we assume a marginal tax rate of 44.31%
- 12:28. That means 42%plus a 5.5%solidarity
- 12:32surcharge on the tax rate. And here on
- 12:35the right, we have presented it very
- 12:37strikingly, of course, just so you can
- 12:40see the effect. Um, we'll anticipate
- 12:44the result: in the worksheet, in the
- 12:46second column, the BMF worksheet would
- 12:49result in a building portion of 47%,
- 12:52rounded up. A market-based valuation,
- 12:56however, would be 70%, simply because
- 12:58the building is in such good shape.
- 13:02That means we have a difference here in
- 13:04the depreciation base of € 83,000,
- 13:07and over the useful life, that just has
- 13:09an immense impact. How do you enter it?
- 13:14We've taken a snapshot of the input
- 13:16mask from the worksheet here. I hope
- 13:18you can see it. Um, yes, you simply
- 13:20have certain fields. I won't go into
- 13:23detail on the individual fields. You
- 13:25just fill them out. Um, you can already
- 13:28see here that there are red checkmarks
- 13:30everywhere, I'd say, where comments,
- 13:33descriptions, and such are stored. Um,
- 13:35but I think it's a really great tool,
- 13:38uh, very well done. And if you fill
- 13:41that out accordingly, then we see on
- 13:43the next slide what the result looks
- 13:45like. So, you get a preliminary
- 13:48capitalized earnings value here. And
- 13:51down there, in the bottom right, is
- 13:53ultimately the essential part, um, the
- 13:55figures we just saw: that's where the
- 13:57result comes out, based on this
- 13:59estimate, as to what the purchase price
- 14:01allocation would be. Very important
- 14:06again here: we have it later too, um,
- 14:08here it's only about the building.
- 14:10That's why it is really important to
- 14:13separate, even if, for example, a
- 14:15kitchen or other assets are acquired
- 14:18along with it, that you exclude those.
- 14:21Uh, because here in the worksheet, it's
- 14:23really only about the building, and, um
- 14:25, that's why all that should be
- 14:27separated out from the start. And as we
- 14:32said, um, the building year is '65, so
- 14:35we will likely work with an appraisal
- 14:39here to increase the tax base and also
- 14:42shorten the useful life, allowing us to
- 14:46boost the depreciation rate further. We
- 14:50definitely have some potential there.
- 14:54What does that really mean in euros? Um
- 14:57, we’ve summarized it here—a
- 14:58back-of-the-envelope calculation, so to
- 15:01speak—but it simply illustrates that
- 15:03the real leverage lies in this long
- 15:05useful life. It depends on how long I
- 15:08hold the building, of course, but
- 15:11fundamentally, for depreciation, you
- 15:14assume a useful life, and at a 2%rate
- 15:18over 50 years, it results in an
- 15:20additional depreciation volume of €
- 15:2483,000. Just through this, let's say,
- 15:28upfront optimization to increase the
- 15:31tax base. In this case, I have higher
- 15:35depreciation of 16, which we see here
- 15:37in the first box, times 50, which
- 15:40equals € 83,000. And when I apply the
- 15:44tax rate to that—we calculated with
- 15:4744.31%earlier—I arrive at a total tax
- 15:51saving of 36%. The compound interest
- 15:55effect is not even included here. Um,
- 15:57so there is even more that could be
- 16:00done there, so to speak. And very
- 16:03importantly, nothing was changed
- 16:05regarding the costs or anything else.
- 16:06It is the same property, the same
- 16:08purchase price. I just looked at
- 16:11optimizing the allocation from the
- 16:13start and was able, and can continue,
- 16:15to strongly influence my tax burden via
- 16:17the useful life. The reason for today's
- 16:25webinar is also, so to speak, a Federal
- 16:28Fiscal Court ruling that established
- 16:30exactly what we have done, namely that
- 16:33the contract counts. That means if
- 16:36there is a purchase price allocation in
- 16:39the notarized contract, it takes
- 16:41precedence—for example, even over the
- 16:43tax office if they arrive with their
- 16:45own allocation based on their
- 16:47guidelines, the contract takes
- 16:49precedence because those guidelines are
- 16:51not binding. The BFH, the Federal
- 16:54Fiscal Court, determined this. The
- 16:57guidelines are not binding. They are
- 16:59only a tool. The contract counts, and
- 17:02yes, if a dispute arises, if there are
- 17:05different views on the value of the
- 17:07building versus the land, well, then an
- 17:10appraiser usually helps to prove it. We
- 17:15have also included current rulings
- 17:18below that are relevant in this context
- 17:20. Uh, the first one is about a listed
- 17:24building. Um, it's more about,
- 17:27essentially, there was an attempt to
- 17:29argue that the land share is actually
- 17:30zero, because, well, an immovable
- 17:32property is never torn down, so the
- 17:34land has no independent value, but is
- 17:36always tied to the property. Um, it was
- 17:39stated today that, no, you always have
- 17:42to split it into land and buildings,
- 17:44and it's also important to split them
- 17:46separately. So I always have to perform
- 17:48a valuation for the land. A separate
- 17:50valuation for the building. Sure, in
- 17:53total it only, it can only add up to
- 17:55100%. Therefore, essentially, if I know
- 17:58one, then, um, I also know the other.
- 18:00But from a tax perspective, I always
- 18:03need proof, um, of how I calculated
- 18:05both, and I cannot just say 100%minus x
- 18:08equals the building or the land. Um,
- 18:12another very interesting ruling, which
- 18:15is related to an expert report
- 18:17regarding the reduction of the useful
- 18:20life. So not an expert report for the
- 18:23tax base, but specifically for the
- 18:24useful life. There was a ruling from
- 18:27the Münster Fiscal Court that for the
- 18:29report, in order for it to be a
- 18:30recognized report, the expert must
- 18:32actually be on-site and take a look at
- 18:34it. He can't just write a report from
- 18:37his desk based on a few details and
- 18:40shorten the useful life; he must
- 18:42actually inspect it on-site, though he
- 18:44can make up for the site visit later.
- 18:48Um, so be careful there, with
- 18:49everything related to expert appraisers
- 18:51. Um, there are various providers
- 18:54promising expert appraisers and clean
- 18:57reports; you really have to check,
- 18:59because before the tax office or the
- 19:01fiscal court, they are immediately
- 19:04dismissed if they don't meet certain
- 19:06requirements. We'll take a look at what
- 19:08those requirements are in a moment.
- 19:12Because, as a quick outlook, it's very
- 19:15important: this BFH ruling, in essence,
- 19:18states that the purchase contract
- 19:20counts, and the BMF guidance is only a
- 19:23working tool and is not binding. In
- 19:27case of doubt, um, an expert report;
- 19:29this will likely be cast into law. That
- 19:32is section 6f in the draft version, so
- 19:34it doesn't exist yet, the 6f in the
- 19:36Income Tax Act, and it is currently
- 19:38being planned. Um, there is a
- 19:40government draft. But it is strongly
- 19:42expected that it will come into effect
- 19:44like that, probably by the end of the
- 19:46year. And it essentially says exactly
- 19:49that—that, um, the purchase price
- 19:51allocation in the contract is
- 19:53preferable, or in case of doubt, an
- 19:55expert report; and I wouldn't go
- 19:57through it in detail, but here in the
- 19:59last paragraph, you can read again what
- 20:01the requirements for the report are. It
- 20:05must be an expert, um, who is sworn. If
- 20:08not, then it must be a certified person
- 20:11, with certified DIN standards and such
- 20:13. But um, such a flimsy expert report,
- 20:16so to speak, is not enough nowadays;
- 20:18you really need a high-quality report
- 20:20that meets the requirements and,
- 20:22accordingly, costs something. Um, but
- 20:26that often leans closer to 10,000,
- 20:28rather than just 1,000, 2,000, or 3,000
- 20:29. Um, that's why you naturally have to
- 20:33consider from an economic perspective
- 20:35whether it's actually worth it or not.
- 20:40We have also summarized the timeline of
- 20:42the draft once more. As I said, the
- 20:45government draft was released in August
- 20:48, and it will likely become valid at
- 20:50the end of the year, effective from the
- 20:53enactment of the law. Just a brief
- 21:01outlook, or rather, an insight into the
- 21:03practice. Um, the guidelines can serve
- 21:07as an orientation, and in our
- 21:09experience, there is some leeway where
- 21:12the tax authorities are more inclined
- 21:14to agree, while in other cases they are
- 21:17more likely to disagree and say that
- 21:20the allocation doesn't fit. And based
- 21:24on our experience, there is a margin of
- 21:26about 10%or 10,000 euros where the tax
- 21:29office says: "Yes, okay, even if we
- 21:31arrive at a different value, it's fine.
- 21:33" Um, there is also case law on this—
- 21:37the tax administration and the tax
- 21:38office on one side, but also the tax
- 21:40courts on the other. Um, the tax court
- 21:44rulings only apply to individual cases,
- 21:46where it clearly states that a 10%
- 21:49deviation is negligible. Um, there is a
- 21:53ruling where it was 20%, and they said,
- 21:55no, that is too much, so the allocation
- 21:57was rejected. We have also included
- 22:00those in the notes. It is very
- 22:02important from the start, especially
- 22:04when it comes to such deviations, to
- 22:06really focus on the building and
- 22:08determine its value, and if there are
- 22:10other parts like a kitchen, they should
- 22:12be excluded and valued independently.
- 22:18Jakob, you can also report a lot from
- 22:20your practical experience.
- 22:21I would be happy to. Yes, thank you
- 22:23very much, Michael. Everything we've
- 22:25heard from you boils down to the fact
- 22:28that you should include a primary
- 22:30purchase price allocation in the
- 22:32notarized sales contract. That is the
- 22:37hinge and pivot point for recognition
- 22:39in tax proceedings. Um, this means it
- 22:43is very important, um, if you are
- 22:45buying real estate and finalizing the
- 22:46contract, when you receive the draft
- 22:48from the notary, um, make sure that a
- 22:50purchase price allocation is included.
- 22:53Usually, the first draft from the
- 22:55notary does not contain this because
- 22:56the notary simply doesn't know the
- 22:57circumstances of the property. They
- 23:00only know the land registry side of
- 23:01things. This means, above all, the
- 23:04clauses where it says the purchase
- 23:08price is 2 million, period, should be
- 23:12negotiated. It should then continue
- 23:15with, of which X is attributable to
- 23:17land, Y is attributable to the building
- 23:19, and so on. that are still included in
- 23:23the building portion. € 5,000 for a
- 23:26kitchen, € 20,000 for a PV system,
- 23:29€ 10,000 for a duplex garage system.
- 23:33Um, these are the usual topics that one
- 23:35includes. Um, also by the way, mobile,
- 23:39movable assets, even if they are
- 23:41connected to the building, are not
- 23:44subject to real estate transfer tax.
- 23:47While we are usually talking about 3.5%
- 23:50in Bavaria, but of course going up to
- 23:526.5%in Northern Germany, it's not the
- 23:55largest amount, but it's usually a few
- 23:57hundred euros as well. That means it is
- 24:00also worthwhile here with regard to
- 24:01real estate transfer taxes. But to
- 24:03return to the actual topic for today.
- 24:06The purchase price allocation between
- 24:08the building and the land in the
- 24:10purchase contract is important. One
- 24:12should not make a fake allocation. I
- 24:15would say, a single-or two-family house
- 24:19in exposed locations in major German
- 24:21cities with an allocation of 20 to 80,
- 24:2420%for land, will probably be very
- 24:27difficult and, yes, obviously not easy
- 24:30to estimate for a real estate layman.
- 24:34That means, um, if I buy a house in a
- 24:37good location in Munich or Düsseldorf,
- 24:41I am likely looking at land shares of
- 24:4430 to 50%. Yes, it's a shame for tax
- 24:46purposes, but unfortunately, that's the
- 24:48current market situation. Um, how do I
- 24:51arrive at the value in the contract? Um
- 24:55, as you already said, Michael, an
- 24:57appraisal is often important, so in
- 24:59terms of the order, it would probably
- 25:01be easiest to fill out the tax
- 25:02authorities 'tool. Um, in the second
- 25:06step, with the tax advisor who should
- 25:08look at the purchase contract anyway to
- 25:10see if the price allocation fits or if
- 25:12it can be optimized for tax purposes,
- 25:14perform a asset value or income value
- 25:16method. And if you want to be ambitious
- 25:21, it is usually advisable to have an
- 25:23appraisal done before the purchase
- 25:26contract. Um, you can also have an
- 25:30appraisal done afterward, but you know
- 25:32yourself, if you hire an appraiser that
- 25:34you pay yourself to deliver a certain
- 25:36result that was already in the notary
- 25:38contract two weeks ago, then it has a
- 25:40different standing. Um, compared to
- 25:44having an appraisal done beforehand,
- 25:46dealing with the allocation, and then
- 25:48naturally adopting this result, perhaps
- 25:51rounded by 2 percentage points in the
- 25:53taxpayer's favor, into the contract.
- 25:56There is the non-acceptance threshold,
- 25:58which Michael has already derived and
- 25:59explained based on case law, um, with
- 26:01the 10%. I mean, one shouldn't always,
- 26:04um, roughly exploit that. In practice,
- 26:07what's probably more important than the
- 26:0910%with today's real estate prices is
- 26:10likely the € 10,000. That means you
- 26:14should stay close to the market value
- 26:16here, and our recommendation—not
- 26:17because we're, um, advertising our own
- 26:19profession—is still, yes, to consult
- 26:21with your tax advisor. Because we are
- 26:25talking about this: the purchase price
- 26:27allocation is a one-time event, but it
- 26:29affects your tax return for 33 to 50
- 26:31years. And from that perspective, I
- 26:34believe that, um, yes, good preparation
- 26:36, whether with a report or a tax
- 26:38advisor, is a sensible investment. When
- 26:42are such contractual allocations
- 26:44typically rejected? Um, yes, when the
- 26:47building portion deviates significantly
- 26:49from the land value benchmark. Uh, by
- 26:52this I mean, if I use the tool and end
- 26:55up with, say, a 60/40 allocation, but
- 26:57the purchase contract says 90/10, then
- 27:00I believe one must assume that a very
- 27:02bold, um, allocation was chosen by the
- 27:05taxpayer, and one that is not
- 27:07economically sustainable. Um, if you
- 27:12then get a follow-up question from the
- 27:14tax office during the assessment
- 27:16process and cannot provide any
- 27:18derivation or appraisal, the tax office
- 27:20will, of course, assume even more that,
- 27:22uh, yes, that these were fake numbers
- 27:25or just highly optimized figures.
- 27:28Exactly. Should the whole thing deviate
- 27:31by more than 20%from the obvious market
- 27:34value, one must unfortunately assume
- 27:36that the tax office will not recognize
- 27:38it. So, those are the stumbling blocks,
- 27:40but the bottom line is: include the
- 27:42purchase price allocation in the
- 27:43contract. Um, yes, how do you then
- 27:46communicate with the tax office? As I
- 27:48said, you should get the standard land
- 27:50values, and you should also take photos
- 27:51of the condition and the modernizations
- 27:53. Um, this tool is very generalized.
- 27:56That means, if you have actually, um,
- 27:59bought an old building, but it has been
- 28:01extensively renovated. Um, sometimes
- 28:04also in the context of, um, historical
- 28:07preservation renovations or similar. Uh
- 28:10, then you have to document all of that
- 28:12well. Actually, as always when you
- 28:14invest, you should document the
- 28:16investment well, and then you have a
- 28:18very good foundation, not just for the
- 28:21tax office, but perhaps also for
- 28:23appraisers. The more support you can
- 28:27give the appraisers, um, the easier, um
- 28:29, they can create their reports, and it
- 28:32usually also impacts the cost structure
- 28:35of the appraisals. Um, if nothing else
- 28:39helps and the tax assessment notice is
- 28:41already in the mailbox, um, there is
- 28:43the classic process of filing an
- 28:45objection. That means, um, you file an
- 28:48objection against the income tax
- 28:50assessment notice within four weeks.
- 28:53Otherwise, it will generally be too
- 28:55late, and then it is what it is. This
- 28:58means please act quickly here and
- 29:01express your dissatisfaction by filing
- 29:04an objection with the tax office.
- 29:08Reference the judgment we mentioned and
- 29:11argue that for reason X or Y, the
- 29:13purchase price allocation made by the
- 29:15tax office is not appropriate. So,
- 29:19refer to an appraisal that you already
- 29:21have in your drawer. Refer to the
- 29:23purchase price allocation that, in your
- 29:25view, does not deviate too far from the
- 29:27tool. And fight, so to speak, for your
- 29:33depreciation volume. It is important
- 29:37here, as also mentioned on the previous
- 29:39slide, to get an idea of the situation.
- 29:43Unfortunately, the standardized land
- 29:45values, which are updated every two
- 29:47years, are not always in line with the
- 29:50market. There are also dampeners in
- 29:52real estate price development at times.
- 29:55Certain regions also experience a real
- 29:57price decline. This means you really
- 30:00need to engage with your investment,
- 30:02land values, and possibly exchange
- 30:03appraisals with your tax advisor. Your
- 30:06tax advisor will fill out the tax
- 30:08office tool for you or at least
- 30:09double-check it if you have filled it
- 30:11out yourself, and will run through the
- 30:12asset-based or income-based valuation
- 30:14methods for you. And then you are
- 30:17actually on the safe side; as mentioned
- 30:20, if the tax office remains stubborn,
- 30:22unfortunately only an objection will
- 30:25help. With an objection, the matter
- 30:28goes one level higher in the tax office
- 30:30hierarchy to the appeals department,
- 30:32where they naturally assess, from their
- 30:34perspective and experience, whether
- 30:36they will succeed or if it is a case
- 30:38worthy of discussion. As a rule, you
- 30:42can reach an agreement with the tax
- 30:44office, but if no agreement can be
- 30:46reached and you are sure of your
- 30:47position together with your tax advisor
- 30:49, then unfortunately only a lawsuit
- 30:51before the tax court remains. It's not
- 30:54pleasant. But sometimes you see that
- 30:57positive things can come out of it. You
- 30:59can see from the Federal Fiscal Court
- 31:01judgment that very taxpayer-friendly
- 31:03rulings are handed down quite regularly
- 31:05here. Michael, please. Next slide.
- 31:10Thanks. How do you prepare not only for
- 31:13the purchase contract but also for the
- 31:15subsequent tax return? As mentioned,
- 31:19you have to record the rental property
- 31:22in Schedule V of your income tax return
- 31:25anyway. Usually, upon initial
- 31:29registration, the tax office will
- 31:30standardize the request for your
- 31:32purchase contract and all financing
- 31:33documents. The question of how and to
- 31:37what extent you have performed the
- 31:39purchase price allocation. Here, you
- 31:42might write a cover letter and refer to
- 31:44the purchase contract, which contains
- 31:46the purchase price allocation. And you
- 31:49usually have to put together a small
- 31:52list, Excel usually suffices, where you
- 31:54list all the incidental costs, such as
- 31:56notary fees, property transfer tax,
- 31:59agent fees, and so on. You must then
- 32:01also apply these incidental costs in
- 32:03proportion to your purchase price
- 32:04allocation. So, let's say you have
- 32:07agent fees, notary costs, etc., of
- 32:0930,000 euros and a purchase price
- 32:12allocation of 80/20; then 80%of those
- 32:1430,000 euros also apply to the
- 32:16depreciable building and can be
- 32:18depreciated as well. For this reason,
- 32:21the tax office will eventually request
- 32:22this documentation. Everything should
- 32:25be allocated within the contract. It
- 32:28really is—we keep repeating it after
- 32:29this ruling by the Federal Fiscal Court
- 32:31—the be-all and end-all that you have
- 32:33a clean purchase price allocation. In
- 32:37practice, we are always astonished when
- 32:39, with new clients after completed
- 32:41purchase contracts, we find there was
- 32:44unfortunately no purchase price
- 32:46allocation, even though it has been
- 32:48widely discussed. But it is still a
- 32:51common practical example. That the
- 32:53contracts unfortunately do not contain
- 32:55a purchase price allocation. Notaries
- 32:58are under no obligation to do so. They
- 33:00write at the very end that they do not
- 33:01provide tax advice. This means they
- 33:04will unfortunately not be available to
- 33:05help you with that. A good notary will,
- 33:09of course, advise a buyer to speak with
- 33:11a tax advisor about whether to make a
- 33:12purchase price allocation. But
- 33:15unfortunately, we still see negative
- 33:17examples time and again. As previously
- 33:20discussed, one should also separate
- 33:22everything beyond the actual purchase
- 33:23price allocation between land and
- 33:25building. We already had a question
- 33:28about this in the chat. It concerned a
- 33:32very large parking area in the millions
- 33:36. Such things should, of course, also
- 33:39be listed separately. Special outdoor
- 33:42facilities are economically separate
- 33:44units: operating equipment and
- 33:47independent assets, such as kitchens,
- 33:49technical systems for duplex garages,
- 33:52or carports. What else is there?
- 33:57Retrofit air conditioning systems that
- 33:59could theoretically be removed with
- 34:02little effort. Rooftop photovoltaic
- 34:04systems. In the commercial sector,
- 34:09these are often freight elevators that
- 34:11are considered movable. We naturally
- 34:15accept that for tax optimization.
- 34:18Therefore, it is very important to list
- 34:20such assets separately. Not only
- 34:22because we have significantly shorter
- 34:24useful lives for them, but also because
- 34:26we do not pay real estate transfer tax
- 34:29on these components. Exactly. Otherwise
- 34:33, separate valuation is usually how it
- 34:36is done in practice. You naturally
- 34:40think about what the PV system cost at
- 34:42the time. There are various websites
- 34:44where you can estimate the current
- 34:46market value of your PV system with
- 34:47just a few details. Estimates are
- 34:50usually sufficient as well. So, if
- 34:54garage shares or carports are excluded
- 34:56or listed separately in the purchase
- 34:58price allocation, they are usually
- 35:00estimated, and as long as you don't
- 35:02overdo it, it is generally accepted.
- 35:07Exactly, that would be the essential
- 35:10preparation in the end, and to
- 35:12summarize everything again, the core
- 35:14message is: please include a purchase
- 35:17price allocation in the sales contract.
- 35:22It is truly the case that we still see
- 35:24negative examples in every third or
- 35:26fourth contract: we have no price
- 35:28allocation and then struggle afterwards
- 35:30with the problem that we either need an
- 35:32expert opinion, which incurs additional
- 35:35costs, or the tax office digs in its
- 35:37heels and keeps pointing to their tool,
- 35:39which is unfavorable in many cases.
- 35:42Exactly. That is why the saying goes:
- 35:44the contract beats the tool. We now
- 35:46have the wind at our backs from the
- 35:48Federal Fiscal Court. And then, as a
- 35:51rule, you are well-positioned. And as I
- 35:54said, we are of course talking about
- 35:55additional costs being incurred: the
- 35:57tax advisor costs money, the appraiser
- 35:59costs money. But generally, these are
- 36:03tax-deductible costs, and we usually
- 36:06live with these costs for 30 to 50
- 36:08years. And, as Michael already showed,
- 36:12a difference of 1, 2, 3, or even 10
- 36:14percentage points in the purchase price
- 36:17allocation makes a significant
- 36:19difference in Euros and usually pays
- 36:22off.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Kaufpreisaufteilung: Mehr Abschreibung sichern und vor dem Finanzamt begründen by immocloud, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,560 words across 863 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.