Joseph Smith Was A False Prophet (with Ethan Muse) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00How's it going everybody? Since 33 here.
- 0:02Today I'm being joined by my good friend
- 0:04Ethan Muse who has recently become quite
- 0:06popular in the online apologetic sphere.
- 0:09He first, at least from what I am aware
- 0:11of, he first
- 0:13debated Sean Luke, an Anglican, on the
- 0:15miracle of Our Lady of Fatima. And then
- 0:17recently he's been engaging a lot of
- 0:19Mormons online. He's becoming quite
- 0:20popular, even to the point of going on
- 0:22Pints with Aquinas. So, Ethan, how are
- 0:25you doing?
- 0:26>> I'm doing great. How are you?
- 0:28>> I'm doing great. I'm really excited for
- 0:29this. Thanks for being here and thanks
- 0:30for taking the time to be here.
- 0:32The reason I think this is very
- 0:33important is because I usually engage, I
- 0:35either just present Catholic theology
- 0:38straight forward or I'll mostly engage
- 0:40Protestantism, maybe Eastern Orthodoxy
- 0:43here and there, but I've never done
- 0:44anything related to Mormonism.
- 0:47Yet nevertheless, I don't want to limit
- 0:49my scope. Just because I don't know
- 0:51about Mormonism doesn't mean that we
- 0:52can't do something about it because it
- 0:54is something that I think all my viewers
- 0:56are going to most of my viewers are
- 0:58going to encounter.
- 0:59It could be at their jobs, it could be
- 1:01in their day-to-day life where they will
- 1:03have, you know, maybe co-workers or just
- 1:06friends somewhere that that are in the
- 1:08Mormon religion and they just might not
- 1:10know anything about it. They might not
- 1:12know, you know,
- 1:13its history, what it what they believe,
- 1:15what they hold.
- 1:17And I think it's important to be able to
- 1:18evangelize those people as well. I know
- 1:20I'm not prepared to evangelize them
- 1:21because I don't know at least enough
- 1:23about what they believe sufficiently.
- 1:25And I think it's just important in
- 1:27general and I I don't think there's a
- 1:28better, I guess, person to have on than
- 1:30you right now given how relevant you are
- 1:32right now on the you know, the Mormon
- 1:34apologetics scene. So, before that
- 1:37though, can you kind of just introduce
- 1:38yourself, you know,
- 1:40who are you, I guess kind of how did you
- 1:42grow up and and what got you interested
- 1:43in this?
- 1:44>> Yeah, [snorts] no, so I'm a Catholic
- 1:47neophyte. So, I just got baptized
- 1:48recently. I converted to
- 1:50Catholicism recently after having
- 1:52previously, I mean, I grew up
- 1:54Protestant, but I really was an atheist
- 1:56for most of my life and then I've um
- 1:59basically that you know I have a I have
- 2:01a few interviews out there explaining
- 2:02the full journey, but I just recently
- 2:03became Catholic. And then I something I
- 2:06discovered after I became Catholic that
- 2:08really strengthened my faith and
- 2:10confirmed me in my decision to become
- 2:12Catholic while I was in the process of
- 2:13converting was it was just for the first
- 2:15time I actually started taking seriously
- 2:17like Catholic miracle claims and looking
- 2:19into the evidence for Catholic miracle
- 2:20claims. And so I was just blown away by
- 2:24how overwhelming the evidence was to
- 2:26where I felt like I could go to any
- 2:27critic like even these very staunch
- 2:30atheists and present them a case that I
- 2:32felt like was just bulletproof like
- 2:33irrefutable. And so I started writing a
- 2:36doing a lot of research about that and
- 2:37looking into primary sources and writing
- 2:39a blog about it over at my Substack
- 2:43which is called like Motiva
- 2:44Credibilitatis. And so that's where I've
- 2:46put out a a series on Catholic miracles
- 2:49and presenting the evidence for it and a
- 2:50few responses to people that have
- 2:51engaged with me. Now recently
- 2:54and I'm not planning on doing this for
- 2:56any extended period. In fact, this may
- 2:57be my last interview for a while where I
- 2:59discuss Mormonism, but recently I've had
- 3:01a whole sort of narrative arc where
- 3:05after I've been doing these debates
- 3:07defending Catholic miracles, people are
- 3:09like well what about all these other
- 3:10sects that have miracle claims? And one
- 3:12of the most common examples that people
- 3:14would put forward was Mormons. And so I
- 3:17decided to start looking into and
- 3:19researching Mormons basically to do a
- 3:21compare and contrast, right? So here's
- 3:24what it looks like when we look at like
- 3:25Fatima or Padre Pio, you know, or
- 3:27Eucharistic miracles, then let's look at
- 3:29these rival claims and then see what
- 3:32it's like when we start applying so I
- 3:34I've shown you positive criteria and how
- 3:36to exclude negative criteria. Now let's
- 3:38apply negative criteria and show that
- 3:41there really is a clear distinction
- 3:42where there's a
- 3:43there's a polarization between the true
- 3:46miracles and the demonic counterfeits.
- 3:48>> Nice, yeah. So I I guess I have a few
- 3:51questions. So the first one would be you
- 3:52said it's after you became Catholic that
- 3:54you started noticing or hearing about
- 3:56the miracles. Is Is you mean
- 3:58before you're before you entering the
- 4:00church, but after your decision, you
- 4:01mean? To become Catholic, is that what
- 4:03you mean?
- 4:04>> Yeah, after So, before I started
- 4:06professing the Catholic faith, I hadn't
- 4:08looked into it. And then I started
- 4:09professing it and started basically
- 4:11getting started in OCIA, and that's when
- 4:13I started to look into. I'm like, "Okay,
- 4:15well, I know Catholics have miracle
- 4:16claims, so let me see if there's any
- 4:17truth to it." And that's when I really
- 4:19appreciated it for the first time. Cuz I
- 4:21knew about Christian miracle claims,
- 4:23right? So, and like even for
- 4:26contemporary Christian miracles, so like
- 4:28I knew about Our Lady of Zeitoun, though
- 4:30that's not a Catholic miracle. It
- 4:31occurred in the context, you know, in a
- 4:32Coptic Orthodox context. And I knew I
- 4:35knew about like, you know, the Shroud
- 4:37and Shroud studies. And so I I had some
- 4:39familiarity with Cath- with Christian
- 4:41miracle claims. But it wasn't really
- 4:43that I started seriously investigating
- 4:45Catholic claims until after I had
- 4:46already
- 4:47made that sort of initial decision to
- 4:49start the process of conversion.
- 4:52>> Okay, thanks for explaining that. I I
- 4:54wonder how did you, you know, cuz I
- 4:56think when people start at least I've
- 4:58encountered people who are analyzing
- 5:00miracles or at least commenting on
- 5:02Catholic claims of miracles. And it
- 5:04seems to me that many people, and it's
- 5:05not their fault, but just the way that
- 5:07we that you know, we are, they tend to
- 5:09approach the examination of miracles, I
- 5:11think, in a very I mean, they're coming
- 5:13in a way that doesn't really make a lot
- 5:14of sense. In other words, for example,
- 5:17they might say something like, "Well,
- 5:19you know, this other sect also has a
- 5:21healing, therefore this this certain
- 5:23healing is, you know, doesn't prove your
- 5:24religion." They might say something like
- 5:26that, which is very very basic
- 5:28I think misunderstanding of what the
- 5:29actual claim for miracles are. So, I
- 5:31guess how did you come into this and how
- 5:33like why should we trust what you have
- 5:35to say about miracles
- 5:36than somebody else, you know? How are
- 5:37you just not misreading the data? Um
- 5:40Do [snorts] you have And also, do you
- 5:41have to be like a super smart guy with
- 5:42like a philosophy degree or is this
- 5:44something that uh that is open to
- 5:46everybody.
- 5:48>> Yeah, well, so maybe I'll So, I I see
- 5:50three questions there, so I can take
- 5:52each of those in turn. So, one of them
- 5:54is basically just like well, what about
- 5:57these claims that people make where they
- 5:58say, "Well, everybody has miracle
- 6:00claims. So, like even if your miracles
- 6:02check out, like who cares?" Mhm. And so,
- 6:04this was something that I really wanted
- 6:06to hammer home to people when I started
- 6:08writing about it.
- 6:09And it I think the first time I ever
- 6:11appreciated it was when I saw a priest
- 6:13go on Pints with Aquinas and make this
- 6:15point where he had a science background,
- 6:17but he and he was presenting the
- 6:18miraculous case
- 6:20for Catholicism on Pints with Aquinas,
- 6:22and I had heard him make this point, and
- 6:23I really appreciated that point, which
- 6:26is basically just No, there's really
- 6:27this distinction between just the fact
- 6:30that miracles have taken place in a
- 6:31religious context, and then the
- 6:33doctrinal content that the miracle is
- 6:35intended to vindicate, right?
- 6:37>> Sure. Yeah.
- 6:38>> a miracle being performed with the
- 6:40intent to confirm a revelation and to
- 6:42promulgate a revelation is a cat- is
- 6:45categorically different from a miracle
- 6:47that's being performed, you know, in
- 6:49answer to a prayer as a reward for faith
- 6:52or to confirm someone in faith, right?
- 6:53>> And that's common sense.
- 6:55>> Right. It's common sense.
- 6:56>> Yeah.
- 6:57>> And but may- And it starts to get to the
- 6:59veracity of God when you start denying
- 7:02that vindicatory miracles could actually
- 7:03point you to the true religion. Cuz
- 7:05basically, it would be God
- 7:07bearing witness to a lie cuz miracles
- 7:10are the way that he can sign his
- 7:11signature to a revelation objectively
- 7:13rather than subjectively. Right? So, if
- 7:15there were to be any objective signs by
- 7:17which you could determine whether God
- 7:19had spoken to the world, it would need
- 7:21to be that there were rules for when
- 7:24certain miracles or things with the
- 7:26false appearance of being miracles could
- 7:27be performed in furtherance of a
- 7:29revelation to promulgate it. And ex-
- 7:31pectually, another thing that I came to
- 7:33appreciate later when I started studying
- 7:35this field of fundamental theology is
- 7:37that there was a real difference
- 7:39to between cases where a person was just
- 7:42working a miracle
- 7:44and they had religious beliefs that were
- 7:46incidental to the miracle that they
- 7:48worked. So, even a person is a miracle
- 7:49worker and when a person is demanding
- 7:51faith. So, they're actually trying to
- 7:54say, "Here's a divine law that I'm
- 7:56promulgating and I'm trying to bind your
- 7:58conscience to accept it to where you can
- 8:00sin if you reject what I'm saying." And
- 8:02I realized that there was a totally
- 8:04different thing where it would be
- 8:05scandalous
- 8:07for God to support rather than to oppose
- 8:11somebody who was going out and trying to
- 8:12bind consciences to accept your
- 8:14revelation. And I realized that really
- 8:16matters even for private revelations for
- 8:18Catholicism cuz even if the prophetess
- 8:21in Fatima doesn't claim to be able to
- 8:23bind the conscience,
- 8:25the miracle is confirming the Catholic
- 8:27Church which is a divine legate, which
- 8:29does claim to bind the conscience. So,
- 8:31it's it is actually even the private
- 8:34revelations can have the same sort of
- 8:37force because they're occurring in the
- 8:38context of the Catholic Church's claims
- 8:40to speak on behalf of God and confirming
- 8:42in us in that and pointing us to it. And
- 8:45so, once I started to appreciate that
- 8:46distinction, I started to realize,
- 8:48"Okay, well, this really is an empirical
- 8:49question, you know?"
- 8:51>> Yeah.
- 8:51>> Has God What has God performed
- 8:54vindicatory miracles to support?
- 8:57>> That's fantastic. Yeah, that's
- 8:58fantastic. Yeah.
- 8:59A lot could be said there but I don't
- 9:01want to dwell on that too for too long
- 9:03cuz I think my audience at least would
- 9:04understand they've seen me talk about
- 9:06that. I just released a video about that
- 9:07not too long ago. So, let's get into
- 9:09into Mormonism then. I guess just
- 9:11starting off for those like me who I
- 9:13mean, I've heard different things here
- 9:15and there but I've never actually gone
- 9:16and checked the sources myself. Uh you
- 9:18know, can you kind of kind of explain
- 9:20what is this religion, how did it start,
- 9:23and uh you don't have to go through all
- 9:25the you know, the 200 years but
- 9:27basically like why is it here today?
- 9:29>> Yeah.
- 9:30Well, basically what happened was
- 9:33that there's an American from the 19th
- 9:36century which is something that also
- 9:38peaks my interest about Mormonism, which
- 9:40is it's so there's something interesting
- 9:42about it where you think about prophet,
- 9:44you think about something that's like
- 9:45ancient or medieval, you know, like oh
- 9:47that's where the prophets were hanging
- 9:49out, right? And a new religion getting
- 9:51started. That's we think about that as
- 9:53something in the past and it's all these
- 9:54distant places with these names that we
- 9:56don't know. And in this case, no, it's
- 9:58actually an American guy, you know, a
- 10:00lot of the major events are occurring
- 10:02while he's living in New York, you know,
- 10:04around the places where I hang out and
- 10:05where I live. And he's moving and he
- 10:07moves to Ohio near Michigan where I've
- 10:09lived and then he's going to Illinois
- 10:11and I've lived in Illinois. So it's a
- 10:13guy where all the major activities that
- 10:15he's doing are on all these places that
- 10:16I've been with cities that are still
- 10:18around. So it's there's something that
- 10:20is fascinating about that. But basically
- 10:23what happened is
- 10:24that
- 10:25there's this guy, Joseph Smith, and we
- 10:26can get into his background where I tell
- 10:28you some of the the
- 10:31I guess I give you a more critical
- 10:32history of it, but right now I'm going
- 10:33to tell it from a Mormon perspective
- 10:34even though I don't actually think this
- 10:35is the real story. And then we can
- 10:37revisit
- 10:38So from but from the Mormon perspective,
- 10:40basically there's this teenager who
- 10:42starts receiving a series of divine
- 10:44revelations where he's going and he's
- 10:47praying and he's asking for forgiveness
- 10:49from his sins and he's inquiring as to
- 10:50which church in the world is the true
- 10:52one. And he's receiving an answer from
- 10:54God, which is none of them are, you
- 10:57know, and all their creeds are
- 10:58abominations, right? And so therefore
- 11:00actually the gospel has been corrupted
- 11:03and now needs to be restored.
- 11:05And so then that's in 1820 he has his
- 11:08first vision and then in 1823 he starts
- 11:11receiving basically visits from this
- 11:13angel Moroni who starts telling him
- 11:15about these golden plates that have been
- 11:18buried in the ground, okay? And so he
- 11:20has to go seek them out and he doesn't
- 11:21get them at first, they're withheld, but
- 11:23he has to keep returning yearly for
- 11:24instruction from this angel about these
- 11:27golden plates. But in 1827 finally he
- 11:29receives them and they're written in a
- 11:31foreign language called Reformed
- 11:33Egyptian, okay? And he's the only guy
- 11:35who can translate them. And so, he
- 11:38starts the Book of Mormon translation
- 11:39project, and he reaches out to this guy
- 11:41who help get him to finance the project.
- 11:44And basically, what he does is he
- 11:46dictates the translation of this book
- 11:47called the Book of Mormon,
- 11:49which is supposedly ancient records,
- 11:52okay? From these lost Native American
- 11:54civilizations.
- 11:56And he dictates the translation by
- 11:58looking into to a seer stone with his
- 12:00head in a hat, and apparently, the word
- 12:03for He never uses the golden plates.
- 12:04They're They're supposedly concealed on
- 12:06the table alongside him for a lot of it.
- 12:09Sometimes, he's even behind a curtain
- 12:11while he's dictating it. But he has his
- 12:12head in a hat looking into a seer stone,
- 12:15and supposedly, the English translation,
- 12:17word for word, of the plates is
- 12:19appearing to him in the seer stone, and
- 12:20he's reading that out to scribes. And
- 12:22so, the scribes are writing down the
- 12:24translation of this book, okay? And this
- 12:27really is occurring mostly over 90
- 12:28working days, but really, it's an It's
- 12:31from 1827 to really 1829, and the book
- 12:34is going to get published in 1830.
- 12:36And so, and so, and a lot of what this
- 12:38was was There was a lot of speculation
- 12:40at that time about how to reconcile the
- 12:42discovery of
- 12:44indigenous American peoples with the
- 12:46biblical narrative, right?
- 12:48>> Right.
- 12:48>> And so, the Book of Mormon actually is
- 12:49an answer to this question, which is
- 12:52actually the basically this the answer
- 12:54in the book is that the Native Americans
- 12:57are actually the descendants of this
- 13:00these Israelites that sailed overseas
- 13:03long ago to the Americas. And then there
- 13:05was this whole bunch of civilizations
- 13:08that start battling with each other. And
- 13:09I won't get into all of it cuz it's not
- 13:10really that important.
- 13:12>> Yeah.
- 13:12>> But basically, now these ancient records
- 13:15have been discovered by Smith and
- 13:17translated, and it turns out the major
- 13:20important thing is that apparently,
- 13:21Jesus Christ actually, after coming to
- 13:24become incarnate in the old world, also
- 13:28appeared to the Native Americans in the
- 13:29new world. And so he had a prophetic
- 13:31ministry in the new world where he
- 13:32reached the natives in addition to have
- 13:34after he basically had come to the old
- 13:36world. And so that's like the key
- 13:37concept behind this. And so it's a it's
- 13:40a sort of interesting answer to a
- 13:41theological question that was that had
- 13:44been raised recently in the immediate
- 13:46context of this, which is
- 13:48like how do Native Americans fit into
- 13:51like the plan of salvation? So how what
- 13:54are their origins and how do they relate
- 13:56ministry, you know? And so Joseph Smith
- 13:58claims an answer to that. And so then
- 14:01starting from continuing on from there
- 14:04there's a lot of developments that
- 14:06happen in Joseph Smith's theology. But
- 14:09so he establishes a church, you know?
- 14:11And the name of the church changes a few
- 14:12times, but now they're like the Church
- 14:14of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. So
- 14:16that's what they
- 14:17>> What does that mean? Latter-day
- 14:18Latter-day Saints, I hear that all the
- 14:19time.
- 14:20As opposed to like
- 14:23>> Well, basically they're speaking about
- 14:24the themselves. If you think about it
- 14:27and and this is something this is a
- 14:28theological category that actually makes
- 14:29a lot of sense within the Mormon
- 14:31worldview.
- 14:32And so think about it, the early
- 14:34Christianity from their perspective
- 14:37almost immediately goes into an
- 14:38apostasy, right? Where the church So
- 14:41they don't believe in the
- 14:42indefectibility of the church, but
- 14:43instead they believe that the church was
- 14:46basically destroyed and that the true
- 14:48doctrine was corrupted, right?
- 14:50>> Right.
- 14:50>> So that's what Smith is teaching. But
- 14:52then they're believing in a restoration.
- 14:55So there's a sharp distinction between
- 14:57who would be the saints in the early
- 14:58days, right? These earlier days, and
- 15:01then the latter days after the
- 15:02restoration
- 15:03after this another testament of Jesus
- 15:05Christ is what's printed at the bottom
- 15:07of every Book of Mormon I mean on the
- 15:09title page of every Book of Mormon like
- 15:10the front page of the Book of Mormon
- 15:11another testament of Jesus Christ,
- 15:12right?
- 15:13>> Yeah.
- 15:13>> And so the So in these latter days, the
- 15:17latter days of the world after the
- 15:18second coming of Joseph Smith where his
- 15:20church now it have indefectibility even
- 15:22though Christ didn't.
- 15:24>> Right.
- 15:24>> [laughter]
- 15:25>> Right. Okay.
- 15:26>> But so anyways, the the the important
- 15:29thing to understand here is
- 15:31at first the Mormon theology
- 15:34is like heretical, but like compared to
- 15:37what's going to come, this is very
- 15:39actually milk toast, okay? Cuz basically
- 15:42what they start out with
- 15:43is and the Book of Mormon itself
- 15:45actually large parts of it are just
- 15:47directly derived from the King James
- 15:49version of the Bible where we can just
- 15:50show like there are places where the
- 15:52King James translators made translation
- 15:55errors and they're like copied word for
- 15:56word into the Book of Mormon in the
- 15:58sections that reproduce the King James,
- 16:01which raises very interesting questions
- 16:03given how the book was supposedly
- 16:04translated. Yeah. But [laughter] but
- 16:06setting those to one side for a moment
- 16:09largely what it is is it has very normal
- 16:12like Protestant theology with like
- 16:14deviations and maybe a few respects,
- 16:16right? So one of them is the doctrine of
- 16:18God where one is it seems to be teaching
- 16:20modalism, right? So it actually there's
- 16:23literally in the Book of Ether there's a
- 16:25statement from Jesus Christ where he
- 16:26says, "I am Jesus Christ. I am the
- 16:29Father and the Son." You know.
- 16:31>> Really? I did not know that. So so can
- 16:34we can we can we pause there for a
- 16:35second? Can we just talk about what is
- 16:36their doctrine of God because I think
- 16:38everyone has has this broad maybe vague
- 16:41idea of of you know, we're all if we're
- 16:43saved according to Mormonism, we're all
- 16:46going to die and we're all going to get
- 16:47something like our own planet. How much
- 16:49truth is there in that? Is that like a
- 16:50straw man or is that pretty accurate?
- 16:52And then if that's the case, it was my
- 16:55understanding that the Father was at
- 16:57some point man, but he had his own he
- 16:59got his own world. And the same thing
- 17:01this was Christ this Christ was a man
- 17:03here, but then he you know, he he got
- 17:05this is his world. Would that be
- 17:06correct? So why would he also say that
- 17:07he's that he himself is the Father
- 17:09according to them?
- 17:10>> Well, cuz they So again, here's the
- 17:12point that I'm actually making, which is
- 17:14the theology of Mormonism develops very
- 17:18radically within the lifetime of Joseph
- 17:20Smith where we can say there are
- 17:22probably three or four distinct phases
- 17:24where he's teaching like radically
- 17:25opposed heresies from each other trying
- 17:28to authoritatively promulgate them.
- 17:30And so the first big thing and it's
- 17:34basically him getting further and
- 17:35further from the Protestantism that he's
- 17:37grown up in, right? And the way the
- 17:39Mormons try to spin it is actually kind
- 17:41of like a progressive revelation and
- 17:42like a Smith's growing consciousness of
- 17:45so like basically getting rid of his
- 17:46Protestantism. Like another thing you
- 17:48need to keep in mind is that well, this
- 17:50we'll actually return to that. But but
- 17:53he starts out where it's very close to
- 17:55Protestantism and if anything the
- 17:56problem is he's like hyper classical
- 17:59theist rather than rejecting classical
- 18:00theism where he's going the sort of
- 18:02middle stick root. And you know, they
- 18:04have like soteriological errors. So
- 18:06we're saved by like another line that's
- 18:08a very famous line that's brought up
- 18:10when critiquing Mormons is we're saved
- 18:12by grace after all we can do.
- 18:15>> [laughter]
- 18:15>> Which is a very It's a very bad
- 18:17soteriological error, you know.
- 18:19>> Sure.
- 18:19>> But for the most part you'll read the
- 18:21book and it's not like in a scream from
- 18:23every page like God's a man just like
- 18:25you or I that lives in the Kolob star
- 18:28system. That's not what you're going to
- 18:29get out of reading the Book of Mormon.
- 18:31>> Okay.
- 18:31>> But what
- 18:31what's later going to happen is
- 18:34so he first is basically in the
- 18:36mid-1830s he starts giving these
- 18:38lectures on faith.
- 18:39And this is already where we start
- 18:40getting into some pretty wacky now like
- 18:43theological innovations. Where we're
- 18:44starting to hear that like
- 18:46there's the Father and the Son are the
- 18:48only personages in the Godhead and the
- 18:50Holy Spirit isn't a person so we're
- 18:52starting to deny the Holy Spirit's
- 18:54status status as a personage and we're
- 18:57starting to get like a bunch but the
- 18:59real culmination of it like when he goes
- 19:01completely off the rails is this
- 19:04non-canonical speech that he gives which
- 19:07is this isn't part of their canonized
- 19:09scripture.
- 19:09>> an ex cathedra basically.
- 19:12>> Yeah, but it's like and they have a
- 19:13weird attitude, too, cuz they they have
- 19:15a weird attitude towards infallibility.
- 19:16So, we'll maybe we'll get back to that,
- 19:18but this King Follett discourse is when
- 19:20he goes completely nuts, off the rails,
- 19:23where he starts teaching basically like
- 19:25eternal progression. There's an infinite
- 19:27regress of gods. God was a man just like
- 19:29you or I, who then was exalted and
- 19:32became like gods, and we're going to be
- 19:33like gods one day. And there's sort of
- 19:35like an ontological parity between man
- 19:38and God, you know, to where he's not
- 19:40willing to draw these sharp ontological
- 19:41distinctions. And so, that really became
- 19:44mainstream Mormon thought.
- 19:47And there's some Mormons who push back
- 19:49on this or try to reimagine it. And so,
- 19:51there's not really one thing is like a
- 19:53coherent Mormon theology because there's
- 19:56so much picking and choosing and so much
- 19:58contradiction.
- 19:59>> from the official like Book of Mormon,
- 20:01you're not going to find consistency. Is
- 20:03that what you're saying? Cuz I guess we
- 20:05>> The Book of Mormon itself is a small
- 20:07part of their actual theological
- 20:10tradition that develops later, right? In
- 20:12a In a lot of cases, they're actually
- 20:13having to do lots of work to harmonize
- 20:15the Book of Mormon
- 20:17with their later theology. Cuz So, if we
- 20:19think about LDS scripture, one of them
- 20:21is the Book of Mormon.
- 20:23Another one is basically the Pearl of
- 20:25Great Price, okay? And so, this includes
- 20:27works like the Book of Abraham, which
- 20:29maybe you've heard of. But the Book of
- 20:31Abraham is basically Joseph Smith buys
- 20:34an Egyptian papyrus. He buys papyri from
- 20:38an antiquities dealer
- 20:39and then does a translation of it. And
- 20:42then, lo and behold, it turns out that
- 20:43it's records, you know, of the prophet
- 20:45Abraham's life, right? And
- 20:47>> You saw it right. That is Saint Michael
- 20:49the Archangel on my tie right now. And
- 20:52if you want to get similar amazing
- 20:54Catholic tie designs, go to
- 20:56proselytize.com.
- 20:58That is p r o s e l y t i e s.com. And
- 21:03use the promo code AD33 to get a 10%
- 21:07discount on your amazing Catholic
- 21:09purchase. I mean, they have absolutely
- 21:11everything. They have the Jerusalem
- 21:12cross, the Sacred Heart design, Our Lady
- 21:15of Guadalupe, St. Joseph, St. Peter. So,
- 21:18if you want to get an amazing Catholic
- 21:19tie, go to proselytize.com,
- 21:21use promo code AD33, and enjoy your
- 21:24fantastic tie. God bless you.
- 21:27>> Yeah, like records. So, for instance,
- 21:29from the prophet Abraham about his wife,
- 21:32the wife of Abraham.
- 21:33And so, he And so, then this actually
- 21:36becomes canonical scripture for Mormons.
- 21:38But, this is the biggest embarrassment
- 21:40for modern Mormons, because the problem
- 21:42is that actually first, he included um
- 21:46facsimiles
- 21:48from the text that he was translating
- 21:50from. And modern Egyptologists can look
- 21:52at it and say that we know that the
- 21:54source text from this was actually just
- 21:56a very standard funerary text from
- 21:59ancient Egypt that had nothing to do
- 22:01like his translations were completely
- 22:02wrong, and his interpretations of the
- 22:05hieroglyphs and all the symbolic
- 22:06representations in the facsimiles.
- 22:08An additional problem is that actually
- 22:10we discovered, you know, in the
- 22:12Metropolitan Museum in New York, near
- 22:14where I live, we discovered fragments of
- 22:17the source text. And we can also see And
- 22:19we have have something called the
- 22:20Kirtland Egyptian Papers. So, basically
- 22:22we can almost prove that the Book of
- 22:24Abraham was completely mistranslated,
- 22:27that there's no
- 22:28correspondence or similitude between
- 22:31what the actual text was and then what
- 22:33Joseph Smith represented it as being in
- 22:36their now canonical translation of it.
- 22:38>> What's the res- What's the response to
- 22:40that? I guess like Mormon apologists,
- 22:41what do they say? I guess to that
- 22:42specific point.
- 22:43>> Yeah, well, so they have a bunch of
- 22:44different ad hoc theories, and people
- 22:46should look up Dan Vogel for responding
- 22:48and refuting all of the various ad hoc
- 22:50theories, which are really desperate.
- 22:51Like, I think the Mormons recognize that
- 22:53this is one of the weakest, most
- 22:55devastating problems with their
- 22:56religion. But, the So, one of them is
- 22:59they come up with the catalyst theory,
- 23:01where it was never really meant to be a
- 23:02translation, but instead the funerary
- 23:04text was sort of the inspiration, but he
- 23:06was really dictating like de novo
- 23:09revelation. Um so and it's just oh how
- 23:13how could you think it was a
- 23:14translation? And you're like, well how
- 23:15about all the statements from everybody
- 23:17involved and all these internal
- 23:18indicators within the text itself and
- 23:20like
- 23:20there's no evidence whatsoever for this
- 23:22catalyst theory
- 23:24other than your need for it to be a
- 23:26catalyst. And there's other people
- 23:27who've come up with these things like
- 23:29the cipher theory and like so, you know,
- 23:32there's a there's a lot of desperation
- 23:34on their part, but this is definitely a
- 23:35weak point. But so that's one of their
- 23:37scriptures and then another thing to
- 23:39know is that a part of their scriptures
- 23:41is called Doctrine and Covenants.
- 23:43And so this will be important cuz these
- 23:45are basically like personal revelations
- 23:46throughout Joseph Smith's life that are
- 23:48just canonized for them that are claimed
- 23:50by Joseph Smith.
- 23:51>> Right.
- 23:53>> And there's lots of contradictions and
- 23:54inconsistencies within these and between
- 23:56them and other canonical scriptures.
- 23:58And you can also see
- 24:00the redaction history of them, where
- 24:03like the canonized versions often times
- 24:05have literally been edited from the
- 24:07original form to like say the opposite
- 24:09or to omit key details, which is very
- 24:11weird if you start thinking about like
- 24:13for instance in Doctrine and Covenants
- 24:15it claims that Joseph Smith receives
- 24:16revelations from God even as Moses did,
- 24:19right? So it's a little bit weird that
- 24:21they're going through this redaction
- 24:22process
- 24:24>> Yeah.
- 24:24>> uh later on,
- 24:26but regardless,
- 24:28so the situation is very complex, but
- 24:30because all of their theological loci
- 24:33are such an incoherent mess,
- 24:36it actually leads to a lot of
- 24:38theological creativity on the part of
- 24:40Mormons for how to piece everything
- 24:41together and make sense of it. And it
- 24:43means that there's a lot of different
- 24:44directions that they can go.
- 24:46But if you come at them
- 24:48with things that are very mainstream
- 24:49interpretations and had been throughout
- 24:51much of their history,
- 24:53su- many of them will accuse you of
- 24:54straw manning them because they go with
- 24:56some other way of piecing everything
- 24:57together in their own
- 24:59>> Interesting.
- 25:00>> Okay.
- 25:01>> But the other thing to understand when
- 25:03you want to understand
- 25:04their theology
- 25:06is that they believe
- 25:08basically that the president of their
- 25:09church
- 25:10as well as like the members of the
- 25:12Quorum of the Twelve they are actually
- 25:14prophets and revelators. So unlike us
- 25:17where we think, you know, the canon is
- 25:19closed and with the death of the last
- 25:20apostle public revelation has ceased.
- 25:23And so the role of the Magisterium is
- 25:25just to safeguard the deposit and to
- 25:26interpret it and apply it.
- 25:28>> Yeah.
- 25:28>> They think that no, there's actually
- 25:30ongoing revelation that's happening
- 25:32and that they're all of their leaders
- 25:34are basically prophets who are receiving
- 25:37revelations and from the Lord
- 25:39>> Okay.
- 25:40>> Interesting.
- 25:40>> on an ongoing basis.
- 25:42>> How often does that happen?
- 25:44>> Uh all well, all the time. But the
- 25:46problem is they don't think their
- 25:47prophets are infallible. And this is the
- 25:50problem.
- 25:51>> Wow.
- 25:51>> So they and so they talk about like
- 25:53prophetic reliability but not
- 25:54infallibility. But when you start
- 25:57looking at the history
- 25:58there are lots of things that their
- 25:59prophets have taught with very high
- 26:01levels of authority that now they would
- 26:03regard as outrageous heresies, you know?
- 26:06So it's
- 26:07it's a it's a very strange notion of
- 26:09reliability that they've adopted. Um
- 26:12where like you can even scandalize like
- 26:14for instance I'll just give you an
- 26:14example so you can see how severe this
- 26:16is. Like Brigham Young, the the direct
- 26:19successor of Joseph Smith is teaching
- 26:21things like the Adam God doctrine that
- 26:23Adam was God. He's teaching uh
- 26:27like the racial priesthood. So basically
- 26:29that black people because of this divine
- 26:32curse on their race are disqualified
- 26:35from being ordained to the priesthood.
- 26:37And there's all these restrictions on
- 26:38how they can receive temple ordinances.
- 26:40And that's not lifted until like the
- 26:411970s
- 26:43by the moment. And so it's being
- 26:45reiterated over and over and over again
- 26:47by their prophets. And they're giving
- 26:48theological rationales for this.
- 26:51>> Wow. I've heard about that. I didn't you
- 26:53know, you always hear about things and
- 26:54you don't really know how accurate that
- 26:55is. So, I guess if we could step back a
- 26:57little bit. So, I guess first question
- 26:59that would arise is um when it comes to
- 27:02the doctrine of God, right?
- 27:04Uh when someone is kind of dialoguing
- 27:06with some who they know somebody who
- 27:07they know is is Mormon, I guess would it
- 27:10be worth uh I guess engaging the
- 27:12conversation from the view of natural
- 27:14theology, the fact that your you know,
- 27:17uh doctrine of God contradicts what we
- 27:20can know from nature about God's unity,
- 27:22about God's oneness, about um his
- 27:25simplicity, his eternity, his
- 27:26immutability. Um uh would you recommend
- 27:29that that is a route I guess
- 27:31the best route to go through or would it
- 27:32be all these other inconsistencies in
- 27:34the religion itself?
- 27:36>> Yeah, well, I think it's I mean, in
- 27:37general,
- 27:39I think it tends to be hard, especially
- 27:41if you're dealing with an ordinary
- 27:42person,
- 27:43to do straight-up natural theology to
- 27:45get to all the divine attributes when
- 27:48the person is
- 27:48>> Yeah.
- 27:49>> because Mormon indoctrination is very
- 27:51strong and like people [clears throat]
- 27:53like the thing they teach you
- 27:54is it's almost based off of like these
- 27:56like very they're very fideist and they
- 27:58have these like subjective experiences
- 28:00like a burning in the bosom the bosom
- 28:03that's like basically this Holy Spirit
- 28:05confirming to them witnessing to them
- 28:07that Mormonism is true even if they
- 28:08don't understand why, right?
- 28:10>> Okay.
- 28:10>> So, a lot of times it becomes really
- 28:12hard like
- 28:13to just try to straight-up reason with
- 28:15somebody
- 28:16um starting from
- 28:18they're willing to accept like
- 28:20an crazy polytheistic you know, doctrine
- 28:23of God to just go for through straight
- 28:25reason to get them to I mean,
- 28:28there maybe there'll be some people that
- 28:29are responsive to it and it's worth
- 28:31trying, but um if you're going to go for
- 28:33doctrine of God, I think the way
- 28:34stronger place to press
- 28:37is to how to reconcile their doctrine of
- 28:38God with the Book of Mormon itself,
- 28:40right? That's where I would I think they
- 28:42have a bigger vulnerability. Where like
- 28:45for instance, I was speaking with a
- 28:46Mormon apologist on Twitter, the top
- 28:48Mormon apologist Jacob Hansen on
- 28:50Twitter, and he was giving a syllogistic
- 28:52argument for why divine against divine
- 28:55immutability, right?
- 28:56>> Okay.
- 28:57>> And so, he was giving a syllogistic
- 28:58argument that was like, "Agents have to
- 29:00have the capacity to change to be
- 29:02agents." Was his first premise, which
- 29:04which is ridiculous, but then premise
- 29:06two is, you know, um
- 29:09"If God is immutable, he doesn't have
- 29:11the capacity to change." And then
- 29:14basically, the premise three, and I'm
- 29:16probably not reconstructing exactly how
- 29:18he said it, but
- 29:19>> Yeah.
- 29:19>> And then the premise three is like, "God
- 29:21is an agent." And so, then the
- 29:22conclusion is God is not immutable or
- 29:24whatever, right? And so, that's the the
- 29:26line. And so, I just respond to him with
- 29:27a whole bunch of quotes directly from
- 29:29his scriptures that say God is
- 29:31unchangeable being. In God, there is
- 29:33neither, you know,
- 29:35variation nor shadow of changing. You
- 29:37know, and you go through and then he's
- 29:40like, "Oh, well,
- 29:41even though God doesn't actually change,
- 29:44he has the capacity to change." And I
- 29:45say, "No, here's what unchangeable means
- 29:48in the American dictionary that Joseph
- 29:49Smith was using at the time he
- 29:51produced." It means not having the
- 29:52ability to change. And so, you go look
- 29:54at it and you realize
- 29:56>> Mhm.
- 29:56>> a huge weak point and vulnerability
- 29:58within their theology
- 30:00is that none of it is grounded in the
- 30:02Book of Mormon and it's all completely
- 30:05departing and deviating from the Book of
- 30:06Mormon. So, oftentimes you can catch
- 30:08them in contradictions with the Book of
- 30:10Mormon.
- 30:11>> That's very interesting. I was trying to
- 30:12find the the tweet there. I couldn't
- 30:13find it, which is fine. Um okay. So,
- 30:16that's very interesting. So, I I guess
- 30:18though
- 30:19it seems like you have a expansive
- 30:21knowledge on what the actual Book of
- 30:22Mormon teaches. Uh I guess is there an
- 30:25easier approach though for those who cuz
- 30:27I mean, I don't really I don't really
- 30:28think people want to go out of their way
- 30:29to Unless unless maybe they're in an
- 30:31area where there are a lot of Mormons
- 30:32and maybe that could be a little useful.
- 30:34Um but I think people generally have uh
- 30:36better things to do than like go learn
- 30:38it for themselves. I mean, you debate
- 30:39this, so you kind of have to. I guess is
- 30:41there kind of a You you kind of water
- 30:43that down for someone like me who's not
- 30:44going to go and read the Book of Mormon
- 30:45and isn't able like you are.
- 30:46>> need to and you don't I mean I don't
- 30:48think so that you need to read it.
- 30:50They're going to insist like if you want
- 30:51to have faith those who evangelize like
- 30:53a big problem for me is I haven't sat
- 30:55down and read cover to cover the
- 30:56600-page
- 30:57>> Yeah, so apparently you can't you're
- 30:59unqualified to do this according to
- 31:02them, yeah.
- 31:03>> And so it's just like and so I just
- 31:04focus on reading the things that are
- 31:05actually relevant rather than these
- 31:07repetitive battle stories in the
- 31:08vernacular of the King James, you know.
- 31:10But but basically um
- 31:13the I think it's going to be way easier
- 31:16to just go and like you can treat it as
- 31:18quote mining but it's you know, you go
- 31:20look at the Book of Mormon in these
- 31:21passages and you just read the passage
- 31:23in context and it doesn't require that
- 31:24much investment or effort. And so just
- 31:26if the person is denying a divine
- 31:28attribute chances are you can find it
- 31:30affirmed explicitly somewhere in Mormon
- 31:32scriptures and it actually wouldn't take
- 31:34that it doesn't take that much extensive
- 31:36knowledge find it cuz usually it's
- 31:38affirmed very plainly.
- 31:40>> Okay.
- 31:40>> um
- 31:41but I mean otherwise I think sometimes
- 31:43it just makes sense
- 31:45to focus on other things like for
- 31:46instance the indefectibility of the
- 31:48church is something that I think is easy
- 31:49for anyone who has a Catholic background
- 31:51to show demonstrate from scripture and
- 31:53explain the rationale for it, right?
- 31:55>> Now do they do they have do did they
- 31:57alter in any way our New Testament? Did
- 32:00they change cuz I know like the
- 32:00Jehovah's Witness they have their own
- 32:02translation which is kind of different
- 32:04to argue from cuz they've changed it. Do
- 32:05they have the same New Testament? So can
- 32:07we argue from the same source in that
- 32:09respect?
- 32:10>> Yeah, [snorts] so for the most part so
- 32:12the big problem is they're generally not
- 32:14going to accept biblical infallibility.
- 32:18And so in a lot of cases yeah, so and
- 32:20actually a big part of their apologetic
- 32:21against us
- 32:22is they side with like atheist critics
- 32:24of the Bible to show that the he they
- 32:28argue that there are errors in the Bible
- 32:29and so that this falsifies our theology,
- 32:31right?
- 32:32>> Really? Wow.
- 32:33>> And so like they'll push things like for
- 32:35instance, you know, the Canaanite the
- 32:37genocide of Amalek and the Canaanites
- 32:39and all of this actually falsifies our
- 32:42views about scripture. And so that's a
- 32:44it's actually kind of harder to appeal,
- 32:46though they do claim to respect
- 32:48scripture as part of their canon, but
- 32:50only in so far as it's correctly
- 32:52translated, right? And they don't tend
- 32:55to use textual criticism to figure out
- 32:57what the original autograph said in a
- 33:00very consistent and principled manner
- 33:02when they're backed into a corner. But
- 33:04there is something they have called the
- 33:05Joseph Smith translation of the Bible,
- 33:07which because it was incomplete and for
- 33:09a few other reasons,
- 33:10the Joseph Smith translation is not
- 33:12canonized for them, but it actually does
- 33:14have a certain authority um for them.
- 33:17And it's basically like a lightly
- 33:18redacted version of the King James Bible
- 33:20that's produced by Joseph Smith. And so
- 33:22like for instance, like here are the
- 33:24types of revisions, like in Genesis 50,
- 33:26he like just inserts a prophecy of
- 33:28himself.
- 33:30>> [laughter]
- 33:31>> It's very sly.
- 33:32>> Yeah, that's awesome.
- 33:33>> And he goes and he finds other places
- 33:35throughout the Bible that appear to
- 33:37contradict his doctrine, and a lot of
- 33:38times he'll like soften it or add little
- 33:40weasel words.
- 33:42>> Got you.
- 33:43That's very interesting. So, it seems
- 33:45like do they hold but they hold the Book
- 33:47of Mormon to be infallible, right? Or
- 33:49not even that?
- 33:51>> Well, even so even within the Book of
- 33:53Mormon they're willing to allow for
- 33:55translation errors.
- 33:57Um
- 33:57but in general, like their traditional,
- 33:59like I guess they don't have creeds per
- 34:02se, but their traditional confession of
- 34:04faith has just been the Bible's, you
- 34:06know, correct in so far as it's
- 34:08correctly translated and the Book of
- 34:09Mormon is correct, right? Cuz the
- 34:11translation was by the power of God by
- 34:13Joseph Smith, and we have the 1830
- 34:15autograph of it. So it's by his power.
- 34:17So
- 34:18the Book of Mormon should be like the
- 34:20highest theological authority for
- 34:22Mormons, like alongside, you know,
- 34:25Doctrine and Covenants and
- 34:26>> Okay.
- 34:27>> that are contemporaneous with Smith.
- 34:29>> Okay. Well, I I guess though it seems
- 34:32like besides in turn I so I guess would
- 34:34you say that internal critiques lack of
- 34:36consistency
- 34:38um is the way to go because maybe
- 34:40extrinsic, which I guess kind of goes
- 34:42into the intrinsic anyway, but like
- 34:44extrinsic arguments from like the the
- 34:45nature of God aren't always going to be
- 34:47the best cuz like you said the the
- 34:50you didn't call it brainwashing, you
- 34:52called it something the indoctrination
- 34:53right is so strong. So they might not be
- 34:55willing to always listen about uh maybe
- 34:57arguments from natural theology. But
- 34:59then again, you can't always appeal from
- 35:00the New Testament because that might
- 35:02have some errors. So I guess it seems
- 35:04like the best way is just to point out I
- 35:06I I guess the the evident mark that God
- 35:09has allowed and you know, I think
- 35:11providentially willed into the Mormon
- 35:13religion is just its massive
- 35:15inconsistency. Would you say that?
- 35:17>> Um well, I think
- 35:19I think there's way more to go after.
- 35:21>> Sure, there's definitely more. I'm
- 35:22saying more for the simple man who
- 35:23doesn't
- 35:24>> No, no, I'm I'm saying even even for
- 35:25someone who's pretty simple
- 35:28cuz
- 35:28a lot of this is actually just common
- 35:30sense reasoning
- 35:32like about how God is going to go about
- 35:35you know, like
- 35:37salvation history, you know. So like you
- 35:39can you can argue from these things
- 35:42for like
- 35:43like first is you obviously can always
- 35:45appeal they have a pretty high view of
- 35:48the New Testament anyways and if they
- 35:50don't accept everything outright where
- 35:52you can't proof text from it in the same
- 35:54way maybe and with some of them you can
- 35:56even proof text. So there's not really
- 35:57just one homogeneous answer. But at the
- 35:59very least you can treat these as like
- 36:01historical sources, right?
- 36:02>> Yeah.
- 36:03>> And so like
- 36:04and you can also appeal to Christian
- 36:06tradition as a historical witness
- 36:08>> Yeah.
- 36:08>> to Christ's teaching, right? And so you
- 36:10it's not like you're completely bereft
- 36:12of a basis upon which to make arguments
- 36:15such as this, you know.
- 36:16>> What is your What is your typical
- 36:18response to something like, you know,
- 36:19it's against the nature of God to allow
- 36:22so many men to be deceived while at the
- 36:25same time claiming to be preaching
- 36:27doctrine in his name.
- 36:29>> Yeah, well, I mean it's I mean in
- 36:31general, it seems like they take like a
- 36:33pretty low view of like the veracity of
- 36:36God where like they seem to be willing
- 36:38to let God perform even lying signs if
- 36:40he has prudential reasons to do so. And
- 36:43we'll see
- 36:44a lot of these Mormons that I've been
- 36:45speaking to have actually even affirmed
- 36:47that like deception is okay in a lot of
- 36:49circumstances as long as you have a
- 36:50weighty enough reason to lie, you know.
- 36:53>> Interesting.
- 36:54Even on the part of [clears throat] God,
- 36:55they say?
- 36:56>> Well, that's very plainly contradicted
- 36:58by their scriptures, but
- 37:00>> [laughter]
- 37:00>> sometimes it seems like it it's almost
- 37:03tantamount to deception or they water it
- 37:05down so much that like
- 37:06they're allowing God to be so proximate,
- 37:09like such proximate cooperation by God
- 37:11in deception that
- 37:13>> Yeah.
- 37:14>> So, I mean it can it can be difficult.
- 37:15Um
- 37:17But I But I think it's a good point. I
- 37:19think it's a good point to press.
- 37:21Which is just like
- 37:23God I mean, first is obvious so you
- 37:25always, no matter what religion you're
- 37:26talking to, can go after them with a
- 37:28positive case for Catholicism, right?
- 37:31You can also say if there was to be an
- 37:33apostasy, we would expect this to be
- 37:36prophesied plainly before it occurred
- 37:38rather than for all the prophecies that
- 37:40we appear to have to be prophesying the
- 37:41opposite that there wouldn't be, right?
- 37:43Yeah. And then we would we would
- 37:45probably expect there to be very strong
- 37:48motives for the prophetic ministry of
- 37:50the person who's selected to restore the
- 37:52gospel, right? We'd probably We would
- 37:54probably expect that.
- 37:57And we probably also wouldn't expect
- 37:59that superior promises
- 38:01would be given to the church established
- 38:03by a fallible sinner
- 38:05than the one established by God himself
- 38:06incarnate, right? That's also something
- 38:08a little bit. So, there there's ways to
- 38:10press here, but I mean it's just you
- 38:12know, I think another strong avenue is
- 38:15just whether Joseph Smith is qualified
- 38:17to be a prophet because there's so many
- 38:20very evident signs
- 38:22of deception on his part and of
- 38:25basically like just like gross
- 38:27misconduct that's totally contrary to
- 38:28the mission that he's claiming for
- 38:29himself. They like you don't need to be
- 38:31a rocket scientist to see that there's a
- 38:32problem.
- 38:34>> Okay. Do you want to get a little more
- 38:35into that? I guess do you want to talk
- 38:37more about that? And then also there
- 38:38were other witnesses, right? Around
- 38:40Joseph Smith who also have kind of
- 38:43you could say sus behavior. Do you want
- 38:45to get into that a little bit so people
- 38:46can kind of be aware of that?
- 38:49>> Yeah.
- 38:50Well, so let's go back to the thing you
- 38:53really need to understand about the
- 38:54context in which the Book of Mormon
- 38:56emerges. Where you start to really
- 38:57realize
- 38:59basically the human demonic
- 39:01explanation for what's occurred here is
- 39:04far far more credible than a divine
- 39:06explanation for what has occurred here
- 39:08when you just get a basic familiarity
- 39:09with the facts, right?
- 39:11>> Yeah.
- 39:11>> And so the first thing that's really
- 39:12important to understand is that starting
- 39:14in 1820
- 39:16Joseph Smith becomes very involved in
- 39:18folk magic which is practiced in his
- 39:21local community, okay? And so big part
- 39:24of folk magic at the time is you get
- 39:26seer stones that you basically stare
- 39:29into and these will allow you to see far
- 39:31away locations and see hidden objects,
- 39:34etc. etc. And so big part of this was
- 39:37you would go hunting for treasure, you
- 39:40know, or for valuable items. And he
- 39:42believes that there's buried treasure
- 39:44all over the place from pirates or from
- 39:46the Spaniards or from and so in in cave
- 39:49networks all over in this local area in
- 39:51New York while he's living there.
- 39:53And so actually one of his his like
- 39:55primary occupation for extended periods
- 39:56of time
- 39:58becomes
- 39:59getting people to hire him to go around
- 40:01and hunt for treasure by staring into a
- 40:04seer stone and then locating these
- 40:06objects, okay?
- 40:08And so
- 40:09and that's actually the period where he
- 40:11starts getting involved in it and then
- 40:12when he stops getting involved with it
- 40:14is 1820 to 1827. Now remember the exact
- 40:17period where he's going to later claim
- 40:19that he gets his prophetic calling and
- 40:20all these series of visitations is 1820
- 40:22to 1827. So, the exact period where he's
- 40:25involved in all this occult activity
- 40:27working as a money digger hunting for
- 40:29buried treasure is actually exactly the
- 40:31period of time in which supposedly his
- 40:33prophetic election is happening, right?
- 40:35>> Yeah.
- 40:36>> Now, now then we look into this a little
- 40:39bit further. Okay.
- 40:41And so, what one of the ways that we can
- 40:42know this where we can just prove it
- 40:44where even Mormons will not deny this
- 40:46part because it's so plain
- 40:49is that he's arrested in 1826 as a
- 40:51disorderly person and goes on trial.
- 40:54And the defense that he puts on and that
- 40:57he brings friendly witnesses, you know,
- 40:59like Josiah Stowell, okay, and Jonathan
- 41:01Thompson to come testify in his defense.
- 41:03The defense that they put on is that he
- 41:05really does possess magical powers.
- 41:07That's his defense.
- 41:08So, it's not just hostile witnesses.
- 41:10It's his defense. He's saying, "I did
- 41:12practice this and I was this was my
- 41:14profession for a period of time. I'm
- 41:15quitting now cuz it makes my eyes hurt."
- 41:17The presumably the implication being
- 41:19that the stone lights up so brightly.
- 41:21>> Yeah.
- 41:21>> Now, this leaves us
- 41:23already on this basis alone
- 41:26with a few options for what what is
- 41:28going on here, right?
- 41:29>> Mhm.
- 41:29>> So, either this guy is a fraudster where
- 41:32he's consciously defrauding his clients
- 41:34and lying about the supernatural
- 41:35experiences that he's having. He knows
- 41:37he doesn't have powers and yet he's
- 41:38duping his clients. And so, he's
- 41:40consciously defrauding people about
- 41:42paranormal experiences that he's having
- 41:44for exactly the period of time when
- 41:46supposedly he's having all these
- 41:47revelations.
- 41:48>> Yeah.
- 41:48>> Or given the nature of a lot of these
- 41:50experiences
- 41:51he's like completely psychotic but
- 41:53somehow able to impress lots of people
- 41:54to the point where they think he has
- 41:55real powers, right?
- 41:57>> Yeah.
- 41:58>> Or
- 41:59he's doing unauthorized non-covenantal
- 42:03magic practices where he's not even
- 42:05claiming to invoke divine power to in
- 42:07order to enrich himself personally by
- 42:10doing all this superstitious divination.
- 42:12>> Right. And this is just taking the 1826
- 42:14trial at face value where we can't But
- 42:17what turns out is
- 42:19actually people who became disgruntled
- 42:21Mormons went and decided to collect
- 42:23testimony
- 42:25from everybody who knew Joseph Smith
- 42:27during these periods who lived in
- 42:28Palmyra and Manchester during his New
- 42:30York period.
- 42:32And what they find out about his
- 42:34activities is actually
- 42:36basically and these people go and we
- 42:38have their testimony where they're going
- 42:40and they're repeating it and they're
- 42:41reaffirming it so we know it's not
- 42:42completely fabricated and they're
- 42:43swearing oaths to it in court in front
- 42:45of justices of the peace and in front of
- 42:47judges, okay?
- 42:49These are his neighbors.
- 42:50Um in so these are called the Hurlbut
- 42:52affidavits.
- 42:54And so the neighbors start describing
- 42:56like way crazier stuff that he was
- 42:58involved in. So it turns out that
- 43:00everybody and their dog in New York at
- 43:02this time could find buried treasure
- 43:04using a seer stone, obviously. Everybody
- 43:06can do that. But the trick was that
- 43:09these were slippery treasures. So
- 43:11whenever you would find the treasure for
- 43:12some reason, you would never wind up
- 43:14ending up with the treasure at the end
- 43:15of the treasure quest cuz the treasure
- 43:17would just slip away with you even
- 43:18though you really found the treasure.
- 43:20And so the real problem, the skill, the
- 43:22art of treasure hunting was how do you
- 43:24get past the evil spirits that guard the
- 43:26treasure?
- 43:28>> [laughter]
- 43:28>> So so the guardian spirits, the treasure
- 43:30guardians are the real problem.
- 43:33And so what the neighbors tell us about
- 43:35is basically all the tactics and
- 43:37techniques that Joseph Smith is adopting
- 43:40from this guy named Luman Walters,
- 43:42right? Who's a traveling necromancer
- 43:43that the Smith family has worked with
- 43:45where Luman Walters he has a variety of
- 43:48techniques. He has incantations, he has
- 43:49like a Latin book with a bunch of like
- 43:51obscure rituals that you're supposed to
- 43:53perform. Like you draw circles around
- 43:55the spot of the treasure. You offer
- 43:57animal sacrifices to appease the evil
- 43:59spirits to allow you to access the
- 44:01treasure.
- 44:02And so we have stories. Like for
- 44:04instance, we have first-hand sworn
- 44:07testimony that's very near
- 44:08contemporaneous with the event from
- 44:10somebody a neighbor, William Stafford.
- 44:13Okay? And he's saying that he supplied
- 44:16so Joseph Senior, Joseph's dad, comes to
- 44:18him
- 44:19and says, "Can we have one of your fat
- 44:21black sheep for a sacrifice, a blood
- 44:23sacrifice, so that we can convince this
- 44:25evil spirit to let us have buried
- 44:26treasure?"
- 44:27And so Stafford says, he admits that he
- 44:30has a fourfold financial interest in the
- 44:32sheep sacrifice. But then offers an
- 44:34implausible excuse. Like, "I was just
- 44:36trying to gratify my curiosity. I didn't
- 44:37really think it would work." No, you're
- 44:39not giving up an expensive sheep with a
- 44:41and you and he's But notice, it means
- 44:43he's probably not fabricating it. Cuz if
- 44:45he's fabricating why didn't he say, "Oh,
- 44:46Joseph stole the sheep from me." That
- 44:48makes him look worse and doesn't
- 44:49implicate you at all. Why would you just
- 44:51mention this detail, "I have a fourfold
- 44:53financial interest in the
- 44:54>> So that's
- 44:55it's very When was this testimony like
- 44:57can you just give us a little bit of a
- 44:59dating, please?
- 45:00>> So this is testimony that's recorded in
- 45:031833 describing incidents that took
- 45:05place in the early 1820s.
- 45:07>> Okay.
- 45:08>> Got you.
- 45:08>> So he's describing incidents that
- 45:10happened in the early 1820s.
- 45:12But notice, if this is veracious
- 45:14testimony,
- 45:16and it seems like it very likely is,
- 45:18actually, this means during the exact
- 45:20period when his prophetic calling has
- 45:21occurred and when he's receiving all the
- 45:23foundational revelations of Mormonism,
- 45:25is a period when he is doing animal
- 45:26sacrifices to demons to get access to
- 45:28buried treasure.
- 45:30>> Right.
- 45:31>> So that's
- 45:32If anything is disqualifying, that's
- 45:33disqualifying.
- 45:34>> Right.
- 45:35>> and notice, another thing we can confirm
- 45:38even more so than just individual
- 45:40stories of incidents like that one,
- 45:42we can confirm to just the general
- 45:44impression of everybody that knew the
- 45:45Smith family
- 45:47was that these were like disreputable,
- 45:48dishonest people who were largely
- 45:50preoccupied with a lot of these
- 45:51superstitious practices, right? And so
- 45:53that seems to be the overwhelming
- 45:54consensus of people that had met them
- 45:56was that you know, they're glad to be
- 45:58divorced to their company and that they
- 45:59couldn't rely on their word and that
- 46:01they wouldn't trust them as witnesses in
- 46:03even a trivial matter, you know.
- 46:05>> Yeah.
- 46:06>> And so and so already again, not lots of
- 46:09credibility indicators for this guy to
- 46:11be sort of the most fit choice to be a
- 46:14foundational prophet, right? Now,
- 46:17the next key thing here about this early
- 46:20period and then we can get to more stuff
- 46:23that comes later. But during this early
- 46:25period,
- 46:26the key thing is
- 46:27when what did Joseph Smith actually
- 46:29claim at first about how he got the Book
- 46:32of Mormon, the plates from which he
- 46:33translated the Book of Mormon and when
- 46:34he first discovered the plates.
- 46:36Cuz a lot of people will just take it
- 46:37face value the later histories that
- 46:39Joseph Smith writes down in 1832 and
- 46:411838, which give the official histories
- 46:44of these events and they'll just say,
- 46:45"Oh, well, always the story was that an
- 46:47angel had appeared to him and given him
- 46:48the plates."
- 46:49>> Okay.
- 46:50>> We actually have lots of very credible
- 46:51testimony
- 46:53that that's corroborated
- 46:55that that version of the story is really
- 46:56not getting invented until the Book of
- 46:58Mormon translation project is already
- 47:00begun,
- 47:00right? So, like fall of 1827 maybe is
- 47:03when it's invented. It could be even
- 47:04later, you know.
- 47:05>> Okay.
- 47:05>> It could have been invented even in the
- 47:061828. So, in while the book but it's
- 47:09while the Book of Mormon translation
- 47:10project is underway is the first time
- 47:12anybody's hearing about angels.
- 47:14And even in this period,
- 47:16when the angel story is first getting
- 47:17invented, nobody's going to hear that
- 47:19the angel that he first received the
- 47:21plates from was named Moroni until 1838.
- 47:24He writes an 1832 history that doesn't
- 47:26even call the angel Moroni. The Moroni
- 47:28is associated with the records, but the
- 47:30angel gets its name very late.
- 47:33Okay. And so and but but so we're
- 47:36looking at that and we're seeing
- 47:38that the story even on Smith setting his
- 47:40account side by side evolves and details
- 47:42are changing. Like for instance, in the
- 47:441821 vision, you know, are we dealing
- 47:47with one personage? Are we dealing with
- 47:49two personages? Depends on which Joseph
- 47:51Smith you ask. Like there's like 12
- 47:52different variants of story that depends
- 47:54on who he's he's it to.
- 47:56And we have stuff like in 1831 in this
- 47:59newspaper called the Palmyra Reflector,
- 48:02they're writing,
- 48:03"Now everybody knows that Joseph Smith
- 48:05never claimed to have any intercourse
- 48:07with angels until long after the
- 48:09pretended finding of this book." Now
- 48:11this is a local newspaper writing to the
- 48:14audience in the local area about what is
- 48:16common knowledge amongst them, the
- 48:17audience. So that's very credible,
- 48:19right?
- 48:20>> Well, yeah.
- 48:21>> argument that's appealing to what's
- 48:22common knowledge with all the people who
- 48:24can actually verify the facts.
- 48:25>> Yeah.
- 48:25>> Now meanwhile, Joseph Smith isn't
- 48:27writing down his first account of how
- 48:28all this played out until he's moved
- 48:30away to Ohio where the people can't
- 48:32scrutinize it. So notice that in the
- 48:34newspaper here, everybody's like,
- 48:36"Everybody knows that this angel story
- 48:38is a more recent novelty and that
- 48:40earlier on he hadn't, right?" And so
- 48:42then we actually have testimony from
- 48:43people about the stories that were told
- 48:45by Joseph Smith beforehand. And it turns
- 48:48out the original story that he told
- 48:50was much more like these other
- 48:52money-digging treasure guardian stories
- 48:54that he had been previously telling,
- 48:56telling before and telling after.
- 48:58And so it seems like at first this
- 48:59wasn't even an angel and he didn't have
- 49:01a prophetic calling and the entire first
- 49:04vision is probably just an anachronism
- 49:05that didn't happen, you never talked
- 49:07about at the time. And this 1823
- 49:09discovery
- 49:10first we know from Martin Harris telling
- 49:12this minister John A. Clark
- 49:14that the night
- 49:16when Joseph Smith supposedly
- 49:19met the angel Moroni for the first time
- 49:21and learned about the plates, he had
- 49:22just come home from a treasure quest.
- 49:25Hunting for buried treasure with his
- 49:26seer stone. So he'd just come home back
- 49:28home from that.
- 49:30And so he gets home
- 49:31and then he after he gets home this is
- 49:35supposedly when the vision occurs and
- 49:36it's directing him to this hill and he's
- 49:39going to go have to basically recover
- 49:41these ancient records from this hill.
- 49:43But then he's deemed unworthy and
- 49:44they're withheld from him. And that
- 49:46that's even on his story. That's on
- 49:48Joseph's story.
- 49:49Now isn't that weird already? If this
- 49:51guy is notorious as a money digger, that
- 49:53the way God is going to entrust him with
- 49:55this ancient record is by having him go
- 49:57on this adventure where he has to go get
- 49:59ancient records that are buried in a
- 50:01hill unsuccessfully and then have all
- 50:02these repeated interactions it none of
- 50:04the narrative structure matches
- 50:06prophetic calling in the Bible, but all
- 50:07of it perfectly matches these treasure
- 50:09stories.
- 50:10And so it seems like the original
- 50:11version of the story, like there's this
- 50:13guy Willard Chase who's also in those
- 50:14affidavits.
- 50:16He tells this version where he says so
- 50:18in the summer of 1827 before the Book of
- 50:21Mormon translation project starts, he's
- 50:23talking to Joseph's dad about how the
- 50:26plates were found.
- 50:27And Joseph's dad is telling him
- 50:29oh, well, so here's what happened. So
- 50:32Joseph gets a vision and in the vision
- 50:34he's told basically you need to come
- 50:36dressed in black riding a black horse to
- 50:39this hill to get these ancient records
- 50:41and you open this box and there's a toad
- 50:44inside the box and the toad transforms
- 50:46into the spirit of a deceased prophet
- 50:48and then physically assaults Joseph and
- 50:50beats him
- 50:51and then tells him because he has failed
- 50:52to follow the instructions correctly,
- 50:54the ancient record is going to be
- 50:55withheld from him, but he needs to come
- 50:57back with his brother Alvin next year.
- 51:00And then his brother dies before that
- 51:02meeting takes place.
- 51:04>> [laughter]
- 51:04>> And so then he's like, okay, well,
- 51:05you'll know the man who you're supposed
- 51:07to come with when you see him. Now you
- 51:08need to come again in next year.
- 51:10So that's the original version where
- 51:11it's a sort of treasure guardian and
- 51:13within this folk magic context the toad
- 51:16is actually an overt indication of like
- 51:18Satanism and like black magic. So it's
- 51:20like an evil spirit is this treasure
- 51:21guardian. And so that's Willard Chase's
- 51:23story.
- 51:23>> do you what do you what do you mean by
- 51:24this? Say that last part again. The toad
- 51:26is uh
- 51:27>> So within their context, different
- 51:30animals have different symbolic
- 51:31meanings, okay?
- 51:32>> Oh, so like the the town that was
- 51:34practicing this folk magic state
- 51:36contextually they considered a toad to
- 51:38represent Satan.
- 51:40>> And all the Anglo-American folk magic
- 51:41tradition, it was all the toad was
- 51:44universally associated with black magic,
- 51:46like dark evil magic, not good white
- 51:48magic. Okay?
- 51:49>> Okay. And later when they're recounting
- 51:50the story they say it was a toad who
- 51:52appeared.
- 51:54>> Well, so this is one of the neighbors
- 51:55are saying this was the original version
- 51:57of the story. Okay, and there's
- 51:58corroboration for it.
- 52:00That originally it's it appears as a
- 52:02toad and then becomes the spirit of a
- 52:04deceased prophet rather than of an
- 52:05angel.
- 52:06>> Yeah.
- 52:06>> Okay.
- 52:07Now, the next important thing to keep in
- 52:10mind here
- 52:11is how do we know that the neighbor
- 52:13isn't just making this up to embarrass
- 52:15Joseph, right?
- 52:17Now, we could just start out by saying
- 52:19we don't actually have good reason to
- 52:20believe that the story was told any
- 52:22other way before the basically 1820s,
- 52:26the fall of 1827. So, like like decades
- 52:29later by Joseph's own mother who can be
- 52:31shown to have changed facts to favor
- 52:32Joseph in other ways. That's not going
- 52:35to be a good basis. You know, these
- 52:36Kelly interviews that have been proven
- 52:38to be fabrications by like RLDS
- 52:40apostles. Those aren't going to be a
- 52:42good base. So, like the the actual Chase
- 52:45affidavit is some of the best historical
- 52:46testimony about the story the Smiths
- 52:48were telling
- 52:49before the Book of Mormon translation
- 52:50project. But in addition to that, like
- 52:53obviously we know we have tons of
- 52:54character problems with the Smith
- 52:55family. And we can show their short
- 52:57story changed over time. Meanwhile, we
- 52:59have lots of character witnesses that
- 53:00are saying that Willard Chase is known
- 53:02to be a man of veracity, right?
- 53:04But in addition to this,
- 53:06let's start thinking about details of
- 53:07the story for how we can confirm it. Cuz
- 53:09this is really important to confirm. Cuz
- 53:11if we prove it, it basically falsifies
- 53:12the whole religion, right?
- 53:13>> Yeah.
- 53:14>> The original claim to get it from an
- 53:15evil spirit, like that zeros the
- 53:17religion. Like it's over and then, you
- 53:19know. So, it's really important if this
- 53:20turns out to be true.
- 53:22So, in addition to being corroborated
- 53:23also by the newspaper testimony and the
- 53:25general sentiment that the Smiths were
- 53:26constantly contradicting themselves and
- 53:28that the angels were a later innovation
- 53:30that they hadn't heard about.
- 53:31>> Yeah.
- 53:32>> In addition to that, Willard Chase's
- 53:33testimony is corroborated in several
- 53:35other respects.
- 53:36So, one of them is the So, why would he
- 53:39invent that he was hearing the story
- 53:41from Joseph's dad if he was just fully
- 53:43making this up out of whole cloth.
- 53:45>> Yeah.
- 53:45>> But the even more damning thing that he
- 53:47would make up is I heard Joseph tell the
- 53:48story this way.
- 53:49>> Yeah, of course.
- 53:50>> So it's unnatural to put distance
- 53:53unnecessarily if you're just
- 53:54embellishing. So that's like an example
- 53:56of an indicator of credibility. Or like
- 53:57if you want to imply that it's evil, why
- 53:59not just say it's evil? All treasure
- 54:01guardians are sort of naturally
- 54:02interpreted as evil spirits. Like the
- 54:03most common treasure guardian in their
- 54:04context is literally Satan himself. And
- 54:07like the spirit of a dead pirate, etc.
- 54:09So why would you give it an unnecess-
- 54:11like it's too favorable to Smith to just
- 54:13say that it's the spirit of a deceased
- 54:14prophet cuz that's giving it a religious
- 54:16context, right?
- 54:17>> Yeah.
- 54:18>> Then in addition to that, we can keep
- 54:20pull- pulling back further.
- 54:22So remember,
- 54:24when he's told he has to come back in a
- 54:26year, he's supposed to bring his brother
- 54:27Alvin.
- 54:28Now here's where things start to get
- 54:29weird and some people start to lose me.
- 54:32The Alvin dies
- 54:34before the anniversary of the 1823
- 54:38visit with Joseph.
- 54:40But 3 days after the anniversary,
- 54:44Joseph's family digs up Alvin's body to
- 54:47refute rumors that earlier they had dug
- 54:50up Alvin and dissected him.
- 54:52But notice, what why did that happen?
- 54:54That's such bizarre behavior. Why would
- 54:56such a rumor start? And why would it be
- 54:58credible enough that they felt the need
- 54:59to respond by exhuming their son's body,
- 55:02right?
- 55:03Well, what if everybody in the local
- 55:04area had heard tell of an appointment
- 55:06between Joseph and Alvin that was
- 55:07supposed to take place on this date? So
- 55:09they said, "Oh, the way they decided to
- 55:11keep the appointment was by digging up
- 55:12Alvin."
- 55:13And so you start to realize, "Oh, so the
- 55:15reason why they're digging up Alvin
- 55:16almost exactly on the anniversary when
- 55:19Alvin and Joseph are supposed to have
- 55:20met according to Willard's version."
- 55:22This fact, which was otherwise puzzling,
- 55:24makes perfect sense if we take Willard
- 55:26Chase's testimony, right? Cuz if it was
- 55:28known in the local community that there
- 55:29was an Alvin-Joseph appointment, then it
- 55:31makes sense how that rumor started and
- 55:33was credible and they felt the need to
- 55:34respond the way they did.
- 55:36Another example is
- 55:37we can see there's this guy, Henry
- 55:39Harris,
- 55:40who's saying in like 1828
- 55:42he heard a version of the story from
- 55:44Joseph
- 55:45that basically involved, rather than it
- 55:48being with um Alvin, who he had to come
- 55:50back with, he needed to come back with
- 55:53his wife. And he would know the woman he
- 55:55was to marry when he saw her, and she
- 55:57would know him.
- 55:58Notice,
- 55:59the language has changed where it's been
- 56:01swapped out, right? So, the Saunders guy
- 56:04at first I'm getting the the first guy
- 56:06that he thought he was supposed to go
- 56:07with
- 56:09has been completely swapped out, and
- 56:10you'll know the man when you see him
- 56:11with his wife, Emma. And that's the new
- 56:14part of the story,
- 56:15right?
- 56:16But they're using exactly the same
- 56:17language. So, the accounts don't seem to
- 56:19be dependent on each other, and we're
- 56:20seeing how the account is evolving over
- 56:22time. Which is once this other guy
- 56:24doesn't become relevant, but the wife
- 56:25becomes relevant, they swap her in.
- 56:28And so, there's lots of stuff like that
- 56:29that we can go through, and there's like
- 56:30corroboration of the account where it's
- 56:32like there are accounts that don't seem
- 56:33to be drawing details from each other,
- 56:35but where there's similarities between
- 56:37them, where it doesn't seem like these
- 56:38accounts are being made up independently
- 56:40of each other. And so, it just it shows
- 56:42you if these two versions both existed
- 56:45in that 1827 period, the most logical
- 56:48explanation is actually that the pattern
- 56:49that continued from 1832 to 1838 where
- 56:53the folk magic elements are getting
- 56:55edited out, and the religious elements
- 56:57are getting edited in.
- 56:58>> Yeah.
- 56:58>> That kept going back all the way to
- 57:001823. And so, the original story of this
- 57:03was that it occurred in a treasure
- 57:05guardian context, which makes perfect
- 57:07sense. Why otherwise would this story
- 57:09have all the narrative elements of money
- 57:11digging, and God is choosing a money
- 57:13digger
- 57:14who knows the main credibility problem
- 57:15with this guy is he's a money digger,
- 57:17and then he's going to have him
- 57:19basically receive these revelations to
- 57:22restore the gospel after mass apostasy
- 57:24in exactly the same manner in which he's
- 57:26been doing all this disreputable money
- 57:27digging activity? It doesn't make sense.
- 57:30>> That's so interesting. That that's very
- 57:31insightful. And then you also said in
- 57:33the very beginning that Joseph Smith
- 57:35said that once he was getting these
- 57:36revelations, he said he was repenting
- 57:38for his sins. Does he ever say that, you
- 57:41know,
- 57:42this uh
- 57:43I guess spirit uh communicating
- 57:45communicating with spirits and doing
- 57:47this folk magic. Does he ever confess
- 57:48that that that was one of his sins that
- 57:49he's like left it or this is just a
- 57:52parallel story that we know and he never
- 57:54actually brings it up. Cuz you said he
- 57:55was repenting for his sins. Is this one
- 57:57of them that he mentions or
- 57:58>> No, and so suppose the well, the
- 58:00repentance is supposed to be occurring
- 58:02like even in 1820 when all the money
- 58:04digging is getting started then, right?
- 58:06So, he's clearly not repenting of it in
- 58:08that context. Now, there are times when
- 58:10he admits that in his childhood he had
- 58:12like committed indiscretions, but he
- 58:14said he was like guilty of levity,
- 58:16right? So, he's not like repenting like
- 58:17I was a demon worshiper. Like that's not
- 58:19what he's saying, right? He admits at
- 58:21various points that he was involved in
- 58:22money digging activity. So, we know he
- 58:24was involved in money digging, right?
- 58:26>> Yeah.
- 58:27>> Um
- 58:28Now, but he never publicly repents of it
- 58:29or proclaims clean or like condemns all
- 58:31this stuff is demonic or anything like
- 58:33that, right? So, he's not publicly and
- 58:35full-throatedly
- 58:36confessing to this. He's minimizing it
- 58:38and whitewashing it. So, he's sort of
- 58:40lying about it in ways that are outright
- 58:42deceptive.
- 58:43>> Interesting. Have you read
- 58:45>> One last quick detail is um
- 58:49the very same seer stones that he uses
- 58:51to hunt for buried treasure are the
- 58:53exact same seer stones that are used to
- 58:54translate the Book of Mormon.
- 58:58>> Okay. Interesting. That's a very Yeah,
- 59:00that's that's using basically you're
- 59:01using an instrument that's not holy to
- 59:04for something that's supposedly holy.
- 59:05That's very Wow.
- 59:06>> And and you're reappropriating it. The
- 59:08thing that he had used to communicate
- 59:10with evil spirits and to monitor them
- 59:12>> and for all these activities
- 59:13>> Not good.
- 59:14>> Now, and who has this huge credibility
- 59:15problem, this is supposedly the very
- 59:17instrument by which he's to mediate
- 59:19these revelations.
- 59:21>> Wow, not good.
- 59:23Okay, yeah, that's that's a very
- 59:24interesting detail as well. Um I guess
- 59:26if I had to ask one last thing here to
- 59:28to wrap it up,
- 59:30um, what is I think the point that
- 59:31you've found maybe from all this that
- 59:33you've already mentioned or maybe
- 59:34something you haven't mentioned when you
- 59:36were interacting with Mormon apologists,
- 59:37what is I guess one point that they just
- 59:39run from because it's like the most
- 59:41indefensible one. I think you might have
- 59:42already mentioned it maybe. Uh, but that
- 59:44you can just I I think obviously we
- 59:46don't want to God is ultimately the
- 59:48judge of all,
- 59:49but you can just kind of tell that they
- 59:51they have some sort of internal instinct
- 59:52that this is just, you know,
- 59:54obviously uh, false in any way. What
- 59:57what detail of the story is the most
- 59:58obvious one I think or you think?
- 1:00:00>> this is what comes later in his life
- 1:00:02which even the Mormon apologist like
- 1:00:04when I had a conversation with him which
- 1:00:06is posted on Capturing Christianity not
- 1:00:08not in my most recent debate but
- 1:00:10actually a previous conversation
- 1:00:12is Joseph Smith's practice of polygamy,
- 1:00:14okay, plural marriage, okay? And so they
- 1:00:18realize that there's a bunch of problems
- 1:00:19related to this. So I can just enumerate
- 1:00:21those quickly.
- 1:00:22>> Yeah.
- 1:00:22>> So one of them is Joseph Smith a month
- 1:00:25before he dies is giving a sermon in
- 1:00:28front of a large congregation in Nauvoo,
- 1:00:30Illinois and he says, "What a thing it
- 1:00:33is for a man to be accused of adultery.
- 1:00:35They say I have seven wives, but I can
- 1:00:37only find one. I'm as innocent now as I
- 1:00:40was 14 years ago. I can prove them all
- 1:00:43perjurers."
- 1:00:44Now, that's a statement Joseph Smith
- 1:00:45made a month before he died.
- 1:00:47Now, even conservative LDS historians
- 1:00:49concede that at the time he made that
- 1:00:51statement he had 33 wives. Okay? And he
- 1:00:56had slept with basically at least a
- 1:00:58dozen of them but very likely more than
- 1:01:00that. Okay, consummated the marriages.
- 1:01:03>> 33?
- 1:01:04>> 33 wives, yeah. And there are some who
- 1:01:06speculate much higher, but 33 are
- 1:01:08>> going to say like seven or something,
- 1:01:09but okay.
- 1:01:10>> No, no, no. So it's
- 1:01:12dozens and dozens of women that he had
- 1:01:13married over this um, short period of
- 1:01:16time actually. Now, the biggest So there
- 1:01:19is a bunch of reasons why it's really
- 1:01:20problematic for them besides this like
- 1:01:23public deception, right? Where he's
- 1:01:25lying about it to all of his followers
- 1:01:27that he's practicing it and he's
- 1:01:29maintaining his innocence when these
- 1:01:30accusations are being leveled against
- 1:01:31him, right?
- 1:01:33So, one of the problems with it is the
- 1:01:35Book of Mormon itself very plainly
- 1:01:37condemns polygamy.
- 1:01:39Okay? So, in Jacob 2, more plainly than
- 1:01:41anywhere in the Bible, it actually says
- 1:01:43that when David and Solomon practiced
- 1:01:44it, it was an abomination unto the Lord.
- 1:01:47But, that basically um
- 1:01:50that basically so we're not going to be
- 1:01:52like them of old and we're just going to
- 1:01:54be it's going to be one man with one
- 1:01:55wife. So, that's what it says. And
- 1:01:57there's a very limited exception that's
- 1:01:58provided for where it's like God by
- 1:02:00direct divine dispensation can allow it
- 1:02:02for the purpose of raising up seed.
- 1:02:04>> Yeah.
- 1:02:04>> So, this is the escape hatch that
- 1:02:06Mormons are going to use is for the
- 1:02:08purpose of raising up seed, right? Um is
- 1:02:12what it says in Jacob 2. Now, there's
- 1:02:14a bunch of problems with that though.
- 1:02:16One of them is that even though he slept
- 1:02:18with all these women and he had dozens
- 1:02:20of wives, he produced no verified
- 1:02:22children in any of the plural marriages.
- 1:02:24>> Really? You had no that he had he had no
- 1:02:26descendants at all?
- 1:02:28>> Well, no, he had descendants with Emma
- 1:02:29Smith, his actual main wife. But, none
- 1:02:31of the other plural marriages
- 1:02:33they can't Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:02:34His wife, his main wife. But, none of
- 1:02:36the other marriages he's producing
- 1:02:38offspring even though he's sleeping with
- 1:02:39all these women.
- 1:02:40So, and God obviously in his providence
- 1:02:42decides when you have kids, when you
- 1:02:43don't have kids. And obviously if he
- 1:02:45knew that this guy wasn't going to have
- 1:02:46kids, it's going to be so credibility
- 1:02:48destroying. Why would So,
- 1:02:50>> It doesn't make any kind of sense. Yeah.
- 1:02:52>> second
- 1:02:53is in Doctrine and Covenants 132, which
- 1:02:56is part of their canonical scriptures,
- 1:02:57this is where Joseph Smith is privately
- 1:02:59explaining to his followers
- 1:03:01that's introducing the practice of
- 1:03:02plural marriage and why it's actually
- 1:03:03okay for him to do this, right?
- 1:03:07And basically
- 1:03:09what he says
- 1:03:10here is
- 1:03:11part of the theological rationale that's
- 1:03:13given is literally
- 1:03:15that David didn't sin by plural wives,
- 1:03:19but only he only sinned in so far as he
- 1:03:21had this like adulterous affair with
- 1:03:23Uriah's wife.
- 1:03:25And so, it's actually a direct straight
- 1:03:27contradiction between Jacob two and the
- 1:03:29supposed revelation authorizing his
- 1:03:31polygamy about whether David sinned or
- 1:03:33didn't sin by having plural wives.
- 1:03:36Then, so it's a it's a contradictory
- 1:03:38revelation is the one that he's claiming
- 1:03:39to give the authorization that's part of
- 1:03:41their canonized scriptures.
- 1:03:43A third problem is
- 1:03:44that he's claiming that an angel is
- 1:03:47coming to threaten him with a drawn
- 1:03:49sword to coerce him into practicing
- 1:03:50polygamy, but he's actually reluctant
- 1:03:52and he's going and telling the women
- 1:03:53that he's basically being coerced into
- 1:03:55becoming a polygamist, and he's a
- 1:03:57reluctant polygamist.
- 1:03:58>> Where where does he say this?
- 1:03:59>> He's telling all the women that he's
- 1:04:01basically when he's pressuring women to
- 1:04:03marry him, and we have this from all the
- 1:04:04testimony from the wives.
- 1:04:06>> Okay.
- 1:04:07>> Basically, a lot of people have heard
- 1:04:09and the husbands also, cuz this is
- 1:04:10something else we're getting to, is he
- 1:04:12cuckolded lots of his male followers
- 1:04:15by convincing them to marry off their
- 1:04:17wives to him while they're also married
- 1:04:19to their husbands. Okay, so he practices
- 1:04:21polyandry,
- 1:04:23which is there's no biblical precedent
- 1:04:24for that, and there's a bunch of reasons
- 1:04:25to think basically wife sharing is off
- 1:04:28limits, you know.
- 1:04:30>> Yeah, and this is and this is also like
- 1:04:31I guess is this acknowledged by
- 1:04:34LDS historians as well?
- 1:04:36>> Yeah, well they have to concede it. So,
- 1:04:38the thing that they'll say is that oh,
- 1:04:40well none of the ones where they had uh
- 1:04:43basically living husbands
- 1:04:45were uh sexual polyandry. So, this is
- 1:04:48another concept they have of an eternity
- 1:04:50only sealing to where it's basically
- 1:04:52something only in for heaven, but not
- 1:04:53for earth, right? And they're saying
- 1:04:55that a polyandry is like that. That it
- 1:04:57was just eternity only ceilings. Now,
- 1:04:59the problem is so even LDS LDS
- 1:05:01historians will try to maintain that.
- 1:05:03Now, the problem is that's really not
- 1:05:05a credible theory at all. And also the
- 1:05:08eternity only ceiling theology is like
- 1:05:10if anything more problematic cuz it's
- 1:05:12implying that polygamy is part of the
- 1:05:14ideal state
- 1:05:16of the world, not just something God's
- 1:05:18reluctantly tolerating for a limited
- 1:05:19purpose. If it's something that's going
- 1:05:21to endure in heaven, right? And it also
- 1:05:23just plainly contradicts our Lord's
- 1:05:24teaching that we'll be as the angels in
- 1:05:26heaven cuz there's no marriages in
- 1:05:27heaven. And so, it's a it's a very
- 1:05:29problematic. But there's also just very
- 1:05:30there's very credible evidence. Like for
- 1:05:32instance,
- 1:05:32we have a daughter saying that her
- 1:05:34mother told her on her deathbed that her
- 1:05:38father was Joseph Smith.
- 1:05:40But we have DNA evidence proving that
- 1:05:42her father was actually that woman's
- 1:05:43husband. Well, the way there would be a
- 1:05:45paternity mix-up is if she was sleeping
- 1:05:47with both of them at the same time and
- 1:05:48then got confused and thought that
- 1:05:49Joseph was the father. So, that is
- 1:05:51actually very strong indication that
- 1:05:53it's sexual polyandry and not just
- 1:05:55eternal ceiling. And so, there's very
- 1:05:57strong circumstantial evidence for a
- 1:05:58bunch of other of these wives, too. So,
- 1:06:00it's it's very hard to actually
- 1:06:02maintain this.
- 1:06:03And so, I mean, you can keep going and
- 1:06:05going, but I'll just leave off with one
- 1:06:08final point about why it's especially
- 1:06:09just kind of despicable from this guy.
- 1:06:12Which is that he did it behind his wife
- 1:06:14Emma Smith's back. So, Emma Hale Smith
- 1:06:17didn't know for extended periods that he
- 1:06:19was sleeping with other women, right?
- 1:06:21And he's hiding it from her. And even in
- 1:06:23the case of the Partridge sisters, we
- 1:06:24have testimony indicating, here's what
- 1:06:26happened.
- 1:06:27So, he goes to Emma at one point and
- 1:06:30gets Emma to give him authorization to
- 1:06:32sleep with these women.
- 1:06:34Okay, to basically have plural wives.
- 1:06:37And Emma reluctantly agrees. And she
- 1:06:39basically picks the wives. And she says,
- 1:06:40"Well, how about you marry the Partridge
- 1:06:42sisters?" Okay?
- 1:06:43And then
- 1:06:45what Emma doesn't know is that he was
- 1:06:46already married to the Partridge
- 1:06:47sisters.
- 1:06:48So, what does he do?
- 1:06:50They have another wedding ceremony in
- 1:06:51the presence of Emma that's a sham
- 1:06:53wedding ceremony so that they can cover
- 1:06:55up that he's already married to these
- 1:06:57women. And they So, we have this from
- 1:06:58the Partridge sisters' testimonies,
- 1:07:00these affidavits from the Partridge
- 1:07:01sisters.
- 1:07:02So, he's going this far, you know,
- 1:07:04whatever their justification is.
- 1:07:06Sometimes they'll give a justification
- 1:07:07for his lying where they're like, "Well,
- 1:07:08he knew the saints would be persecuted
- 1:07:10if he they he was open about the
- 1:07:12polygamy, so therefore he was justified
- 1:07:14cuz it's like lying to the Nazis." So,
- 1:07:15that's what a Mormon apologist said.
- 1:07:17>> Got you.
- 1:07:18>> Now, meanwhile
- 1:07:19meanwhile
- 1:07:20is Emma Smith the Nazis? And it seems
- 1:07:23like she had a right to the truth.
- 1:07:24>> Right, yeah.
- 1:07:26Yeah, that's insane, honestly. And I
- 1:07:27think that's honestly that's when I
- 1:07:29asked for a final point, I think that
- 1:07:31was probably one of the best ones you
- 1:07:32could bring up. Uh couldn't have thought
- 1:07:34of anything better myself. Um so, yeah,
- 1:07:37I guess could you just kind of
- 1:07:39to wrap up to wrap it all up because
- 1:07:40those are great, I guess, talking points
- 1:07:42and those are great points to bring
- 1:07:44when talking to somebody who is Mormon.
- 1:07:45I guess what it can you speak to the
- 1:07:47heart
- 1:07:48can [clears throat] you speak to the
- 1:07:49heart a little bit, right? And what
- 1:07:50would be the what would you given this
- 1:07:52what would you say to somebody who is
- 1:07:53Mormon, right? And to kind of open them
- 1:07:56up to the Catholic Church if you had to
- 1:07:57say one last final statement?
- 1:08:00>> Yeah, well, so what I would really do
- 1:08:03is I would just say and I would really
- 1:08:04ask myself,
- 1:08:06"Go look into this work that I've done
- 1:08:08about Our Lady of Fatima and look into
- 1:08:10this moral character of the seers from
- 1:08:13Our Lady of Fatima. So, the women and uh
- 1:08:16the well, the girls and the boy that
- 1:08:17were chosen to be the prophetess the
- 1:08:20prophetesses and the prophet uh to speak
- 1:08:22on behalf of Our Lady and to promulgate
- 1:08:24her message.
- 1:08:25And you see the inspired sanctity of
- 1:08:27these children where there's no sex
- 1:08:29scandals, there's no seer stones,
- 1:08:31there's no deception, nothing like it.
- 1:08:34There's extraordinary public miracles.
- 1:08:35There's 15,000 medically verified
- 1:08:38healings in connection with it. There's
- 1:08:39a message that very directly and
- 1:08:41straightforwardly confirms Catholicism.
- 1:08:43And there the prophet and the
- 1:08:44prophetesses have inspired sanctity. And
- 1:08:47then I want you to compare and contrast
- 1:08:48that with Joseph Smith's wife and the
- 1:08:51evidence of signs that Joseph Smith
- 1:08:53brought to bear and witness to his
- 1:08:54revelations. And I just want you to
- 1:08:56dwell on the question,
- 1:08:58"Why is it that if we have the fullness
- 1:09:00of truth
- 1:09:01God is using and raising up eminently
- 1:09:04virtuous prophets and prophetesses for
- 1:09:06another religion and giving them more
- 1:09:08spectacular signs in the modern period
- 1:09:10when our church exists. While we are
- 1:09:12stuck with this guy where we're having
- 1:09:14to constantly make excuses for all of
- 1:09:15his high jinks and shenanigans.
- 1:09:17>> Yeah.
- 1:09:18>> And that's I think when you really dwell
- 1:09:19on that question, if you take it
- 1:09:20seriously and you're seeking out the
- 1:09:21truth, I think you'll arrive at the
- 1:09:23answer that no, just the difference is
- 1:09:25that Catholicism is from God and Joseph
- 1:09:28Smith did not speak for God.
- 1:09:31>> That's awesome, man. Thank you. Ethan, I
- 1:09:33guess do you have anything personal you
- 1:09:35want to end with? Maybe where can people
- 1:09:36find you? I know on your Substack you've
- 1:09:38mostly written about I think Eucharistic
- 1:09:40miracles in Fatima.
- 1:09:41I
- 1:09:42I couldn't tell or maybe you do have
- 1:09:43some Mormon
- 1:09:44articles, maybe you don't.
- 1:09:46>> No, no, no.
- 1:09:46>> but where can people find you and I
- 1:09:48guess anything else you want to share
- 1:09:49before we finish?
- 1:09:51>> No, yeah, that's great. Um yeah, people
- 1:09:52can find me on Substack. That's the main
- 1:09:54place where I've been producing content.
- 1:09:55Then you can find a bunch of videos just
- 1:09:57by searching my name where it's YouTube.
- 1:10:00Yeah, I know, the Pints with Aquinas
- 1:10:01interview would be a good one to watch
- 1:10:02if you're interested in my work on
- 1:10:03miracles.
- 1:10:05>> All right, cool. Anything else?
- 1:10:06>> No.
- 1:10:07>> All right, this was super fun. I learned
- 1:10:08a lot and I'm sure my audience as well
- 1:10:11did as well. So, thank you, Ethan. God
- 1:10:12bless you and God bless you, viewers.
- 1:10:14>> Thank you so much.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Joseph Smith Was A False Prophet (with Ethan Muse) by Since Thirty Three, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,119 words across 2,268 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.