YouTube2Text

John Lobell Louis Kahn's Philosophy — Transcript

by John Lobell · 4,402 words · 713 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02my name is John Lael I teach
  2. 0:04architecture Pride Institute in Brooklyn
  3. 0:06New York I blog at creativity
  4. 0:10discourse. review movies from a
  5. 0:12mythological point of view at cinema.com
  6. 0:15and you can reach me at John lell atmac
  7. 0:20maac.com
  8. 0:23we're talking today about the architect
  9. 0:26Lou Lou ion and his uh approach to
  10. 0:30architecture as philosophy or how to
  11. 0:35live in the modern
  12. 0:38world uh in
  13. 0:41outline we'll talk briefly about how do
  14. 0:44we live in the modern
  15. 0:46world who is Louie Khan we'll talk about
  16. 0:50Boart architecture which is the approach
  17. 0:53to architecture that KH studied then
  18. 0:56modern
  19. 0:57architecture finding a third way and
  20. 1:00archetypes and then K's spiritual
  21. 1:06philosophy so how do we live in the
  22. 1:09modern world do we live in
  23. 1:13Traditions which give us a
  24. 1:16rootedness but have questionable
  25. 1:20relevance to a a world rich with our
  26. 1:24scientific knowledge or do we live in a
  27. 1:27contemporary material reality
  28. 1:30uh but then missing those Traditions or
  29. 1:34is there a third
  30. 1:37way we see that contrast in
  31. 1:42architecture there are a lot of uh
  32. 1:44historically rooted Styles but we'll
  33. 1:47just focus on Bozart uh architecture in
  34. 1:50this discussion so Bozart monumentality
  35. 1:55brought us the solidity of Rome and the
  36. 1:57Renaissance but was that relevant to our
  37. 2:01Democratic industrial 20th
  38. 2:04century uh modern architecture rejected
  39. 2:08this celebration of the past a famous
  40. 2:10quote from the architectural critic
  41. 2:13Lewis mford if it's a monument it's not
  42. 2:17modern and if it modern it cannot be a
  43. 2:23monument so we'll get back to that as
  44. 2:27our story unfolds
  45. 2:30but now very briefly who is Lou KH so
  46. 2:34Lou KH is an architecture of major
  47. 2:37stature sometimes regarded as maybe the
  48. 2:40second most important American architect
  49. 2:42after Frank lyd Wright he was born in
  50. 2:45Estonia to a poor family and came to the
  51. 2:48United States to Philadelphia when he
  52. 2:50was
  53. 2:51five he uh studied architecture at the
  54. 2:54University of Pennsylvania which at that
  55. 2:57time had a Bart program he was there
  56. 3:00between 1920 and
  57. 3:021924 graduated in 1924 just as a Bozart
  58. 3:06was fading and modern architecture was
  59. 3:10Rising after he graduated the country
  60. 3:13entered the Great Depression and uh
  61. 3:17Khan's few buildings were based on a
  62. 3:20kind of social approach to architecture
  63. 3:22and were very
  64. 3:24undistinguished KH struggled with
  65. 3:28monumentality um if rejecting this
  66. 3:31historical Boart monumentality what are
  67. 3:34our values what do we stand for what
  68. 3:36should our architecture be uh addressing
  69. 3:40and as a result of this struggle he
  70. 3:43eventually produced a profound spiritual
  71. 3:45philosophy and between 1957 and when he
  72. 3:49died in
  73. 3:501974 designed a series of buildings
  74. 3:53considered some of the finest of the
  75. 3:5520th
  76. 3:58century let's look at his buildings
  77. 4:02we'll uh just look a little bit at his
  78. 4:06first building of major importance it's
  79. 4:08called the medical Towers Research
  80. 4:11Laboratories at the University of
  81. 4:12Pennsylvania and then several
  82. 4:16others so the building is distinguished
  83. 4:19by being highly articulated he's showing
  84. 4:22us the structure the air handling Ducks
  85. 4:27uh very much in contrast to a building
  86. 4:29being built
  87. 4:30at just the same time M Vander Ro's seum
  88. 4:33building in Manhattan which was very
  89. 4:37um uh simplified clearly within a sheath
  90. 4:44of bronze and
  91. 4:45glass so let's see how KH arrives at
  92. 4:49this articulation he has three
  93. 4:53Pavilions um and each of these is an
  94. 4:56open flexible laboratory and they are
  95. 4:59are all three linked to a central core
  96. 5:03with Central
  97. 5:05Services stairs elevators bathrooms and
  98. 5:08each is served by you see these squares
  99. 5:11here those are the towers that have
  100. 5:13stairs or uh air handling Ducks so K
  101. 5:17starts by saying there two parts to
  102. 5:20science one is measurement that takes
  103. 5:23place at the laboratory table
  104. 5:27experiment and we have here an area that
  105. 5:30we want to be flexible no columns
  106. 5:34interrupting and then con says after
  107. 5:37making uh measurements the scientist
  108. 5:40wants to go to the light and so at the
  109. 5:43perimeter where the windows are or the
  110. 5:45desks to then review the results of the
  111. 5:49experiments and render them into a
  112. 5:53theory now we don't want to interrupt
  113. 5:56any of this with structure so the
  114. 5:58columns go
  115. 6:00uh on the
  116. 6:02perimeter and we don't want to interrupt
  117. 6:04our views from the corners so the
  118. 6:06columns are at the third points and
  119. 6:09avoid the corners we then span between
  120. 6:14the columns and from the columns out to
  121. 6:17the corners by caner levers with our
  122. 6:19beams to provide our
  123. 6:22structure we then have our stairs and
  124. 6:25air duct very typically in a in an rice
  125. 6:29building those will be in the center but
  126. 6:31remember we wanted our Center clear for
  127. 6:34our Laboratories so those we don't want
  128. 6:36to put those in the corners obviously
  129. 6:38that'll disrupt our views so they go
  130. 6:41between the columns and these third
  131. 6:43points and we have three of these and
  132. 6:47then all three of these share a central
  133. 6:51core that has st's toilets store room uh
  134. 6:57Etc so this is very
  135. 7:00strong logic to the way Khan arrives at
  136. 7:03his building and Khan liked to say the
  137. 7:07building is the record of the making of
  138. 7:09the building so here we are he leaves
  139. 7:11out one of these Pavilions for the
  140. 7:13entrance the stairs are on the other
  141. 7:15side but get a better view
  142. 7:17here and as you come up into this uh um
  143. 7:21area before going through the doors you
  144. 7:23look up and the whole story I just told
  145. 7:26you is right there uh so the building
  146. 7:28communicat Ates to us how it is
  147. 7:33made the next important uh building by
  148. 7:37KH is his sulk
  149. 7:40Institute in La Hoya California Jonas
  150. 7:43sulk had seen KH lecture uh had been uh
  151. 7:48become famous for his development of the
  152. 7:51sulk polio vaccine and was building a
  153. 7:53research laboratory and asked Khan to be
  154. 7:58his architect and produced this uh
  155. 8:00magnificent
  156. 8:02building this is the Philips exitor
  157. 8:06Academy library and we have a very uh
  158. 8:10boxy brick building on the outside this
  159. 8:14brick is not veneer but it's structural
  160. 8:17and then inside the building explodes up
  161. 8:21into a light Court uh open at the center
  162. 8:26of the building
  163. 8:29this is a National Assembly Building in
  164. 8:31DCA
  165. 8:33Bangladesh a legislative building and KH
  166. 8:39um has a huge complex of support around
  167. 8:44this Central U Meeting Hall for the
  168. 8:48Congress and was planning to use these
  169. 8:52huge beam spanning above it to sort of
  170. 8:55Bounce the light and bring it in but it
  171. 8:58proved uh finished after KH died and
  172. 9:02proved these beams proved too heavy and
  173. 9:05were it was done instead with a uh light
  174. 9:08thin
  175. 9:11shell many people regard this excuse me
  176. 9:15as Khan's most beautiful building Kimble
  177. 9:18art museum in Fort Worth Texas and he
  178. 9:21has a series of uh Vault like
  179. 9:26shapes and open down the center
  180. 9:30um to let light in and then these
  181. 9:32reflectors to wash the light over the
  182. 9:36exposed concrete of the Interior
  183. 9:40Vault and uh Khan's last building that
  184. 9:44he finished um while it was finished
  185. 9:47just after he
  186. 9:50died the Yale Center for British art at
  187. 9:54y University on the outside concrete and
  188. 9:59stainless steel inside uh the concrete
  189. 10:03structure is exposed and infill panels
  190. 10:07are of a light oak wood and in the
  191. 10:11entrance Court we look up to skylights
  192. 10:15uh at the
  193. 10:18top one of uh Khan's uh earlier projects
  194. 10:23from
  195. 10:241974 just now finished in Manhattan
  196. 10:29Franklin D Roosevelt for Freedoms Park
  197. 10:33on Roosevelt Island at the
  198. 10:38tip now that's a very quick overview of
  199. 10:42Khan's
  200. 10:43architecture looking at these buildings
  201. 10:45in detail would be a a whole other
  202. 10:48discussion but we're talking about
  203. 10:50something else here which is Con
  204. 10:52spiritual philosophy and let's sort of
  205. 10:55work our way toward that and start with
  206. 10:58a very briefly looking at Bozard
  207. 11:04architecture now uh Khan's teacher the
  208. 11:08chief critic at the University of
  209. 11:10Pennsylvania when he was there was Paul
  210. 11:14Philipe CR a French Buzzard master who
  211. 11:18had come uh to teach in the United
  212. 11:20States and to have uh quite a successful
  213. 11:23practice doing some magnificent uh
  214. 11:26buildings on the top is the panan
  215. 11:28building in washing Washington DC
  216. 11:30beautiful little building 1903 early in
  217. 11:33cra's career and then here we have 1929
  218. 11:37also in Washington the Shakespeare
  219. 11:40folder Library a form of Bart called
  220. 11:44strip
  221. 11:45classicism and KH actually worked for
  222. 11:49cray on this building so and then while
  223. 11:53KH was a student at the University of
  224. 11:56Pennsylvania the uh Philadelphia Muse
  225. 11:59Museum was under
  226. 12:00construction and you can see how
  227. 12:04something this massive would be very
  228. 12:07influential on the students at the
  229. 12:10school now um very quickly let's define
  230. 12:14what we mean by
  231. 12:16boar we begin with the aold boar is a
  232. 12:20School of Architecture painting and
  233. 12:23sculpture in Paris now it was very
  234. 12:25influential on American architecture
  235. 12:28because
  236. 12:30in the um uh mid to late 1800s
  237. 12:36as architectural careers were starting
  238. 12:39to flourish in the United States there
  239. 12:41were no architecture schools and most of
  240. 12:43the famous architects of
  241. 12:47the uh late
  242. 12:491800s actually studied at the aold
  243. 12:51bazart in Paris it was free and open to
  244. 12:55any applicant uh as long as you could
  245. 12:58pass the tests so the term Boart comes
  246. 13:03from this school and then we have the
  247. 13:05term a Boart education well that was the
  248. 13:08education practice at da C Boart but
  249. 13:11then as they began to form the the
  250. 13:15schools in
  251. 13:17America they adopted many aspects of the
  252. 13:23uh educational model of the C de boar
  253. 13:26and one of the schools that uh adopted
  254. 13:28this model model was the University of
  255. 13:30Pennsylvania where KH studied the
  256. 13:33approach was used historical models
  257. 13:37particularly uh Rome Renaissance and
  258. 13:40broke and
  259. 13:44neoclassical and finally the term Boart
  260. 13:47architecture well that's the
  261. 13:48architecture that came from this
  262. 13:51education characterized by formal
  263. 13:54planning uh monumentality and historical
  264. 13:57Styles and in the York examples would be
  265. 14:00the Metropolitan Museum Grand Central
  266. 14:03Station the New York Public Library and
  267. 14:06the Washington Square Arch so we have uh
  268. 14:11in New York these magnificent examples
  269. 14:14of bzar
  270. 14:16architecture and again it would be a lot
  271. 14:20of detail to go into to describe what
  272. 14:24this architecture was trying to do but
  273. 14:29uh very briefly and very generally what
  274. 14:32it was trying to do was the following so
  275. 14:37observe that it is
  276. 14:39using uh a
  277. 14:42vocabulary from Greece Rome the
  278. 14:44Renaissance in the Baroque namely
  279. 14:47columns arches and domes so this is sort
  280. 14:51of Roman
  281. 14:52architecture which uses a Greek
  282. 14:55vocabulary as adopted by the Renaissance
  283. 14:59under the
  284. 15:01brook now what is this saying uh why
  285. 15:04would you build an architecture like
  286. 15:06this here we have the uh 42nd Street
  287. 15:10Library in this Boart s Roman
  288. 15:14Renaissance Baro style what's it saying
  289. 15:17well it's saying that
  290. 15:21um the it's referring to the people of
  291. 15:25The Iliad in The
  292. 15:27Odyssey and Greeks and saying that our
  293. 15:31stories are built on theirs that it
  294. 15:35references us to Plato and Aristotle and
  295. 15:39says that our philosophy was built on
  296. 15:41theirs it refers to Greek and
  297. 15:45Renaissance humanism and says that our
  298. 15:48sense of what a person is is built on
  299. 15:51theirs it ties us to Leonardo da Vinci
  300. 15:55and implies that our mechanics was built
  301. 15:58on is the Isaac Newton and implies that
  302. 16:01our science was built on
  303. 16:03his it says that we are historically
  304. 16:07rooted but is this really
  305. 16:10us do we really come from the Odyssey or
  306. 16:14from the oran romances of the middle age
  307. 16:18is our philosophy built on that of Plato
  308. 16:21and Aristotle or is pragmatism something
  309. 16:24quite different do we accept Greek and
  310. 16:28Renaissance humanism or do we have a
  311. 16:30very different sense of what a person is
  312. 16:33today is our science and mechanics built
  313. 16:36on those of Leonardo and Isaac Newton or
  314. 16:40did science become quite something uh
  315. 16:46different so modern architecture felt
  316. 16:51that it
  317. 16:54was not adequate or not even correct to
  318. 16:57see our elves as built on these ancient
  319. 17:02cultures and uh it
  320. 17:05rejected monumentality as a
  321. 17:08glorification of an irrelevant past so
  322. 17:12here we see on the right
  323. 17:14above uh John Russell Pope's National
  324. 17:18Gallery in Washington DC completed
  325. 17:211941 Frank L Wright was already in his
  326. 17:25fourth phase by then and here we are
  327. 17:29doing a uh Bozart building in Washington
  328. 17:33based on as we see below the pantheon
  329. 17:36the Roman Pantheon so of course it's
  330. 17:39much more than that but you know we can
  331. 17:41say that the National Gallery is of
  332. 17:44Pantheon with two Wings why are we
  333. 17:46building a Pantheon Rome ended a long
  334. 17:49time
  335. 17:51ago so um the feeling was that
  336. 17:55Monumental buildings celebrate European
  337. 18:00Culture by using classical V
  338. 18:04vocabularies and by
  339. 18:07concretizing um the institutions of this
  340. 18:11European past and that that's just not
  341. 18:15the modern
  342. 18:19world so as an alternative to this we
  343. 18:23develop modern architecture this is a
  344. 18:26very simplified story but um we want to
  345. 18:29get to a a point of how KH develops an
  346. 18:33alternative to both the Boart and modern
  347. 18:38architecture so here we are
  348. 18:401953 uh lever house in New York and
  349. 18:45we'll take that as uh an Exemplar
  350. 18:51of um modern architecture it's within
  351. 18:54the international style and uh it's uh
  352. 18:58one of it's the first glass and steel
  353. 19:05skyscraper now how do we arrive at this
  354. 19:09architecture let's start here with a
  355. 19:11chess set so we look at the pieces in
  356. 19:14this chess set and where do the designs
  357. 19:18come from
  358. 19:21well they invoke the Medieval World and
  359. 19:25fortifications and battle so we have a
  360. 19:29king a queen a bishop a knight a rook or
  361. 19:34a castle and a pawn or a foot
  362. 19:37soldier so these chest pieces get their
  363. 19:41design through uh their rootedness in
  364. 19:45the past and then they bring that past
  365. 19:48into our world today so modernism
  366. 19:52says um okay suppose we want to play
  367. 19:55chess why would we need to evoke
  368. 19:58medieval
  369. 20:00kns so this is a chest set designed at
  370. 20:03the bow house
  371. 20:06and very different pieces now where the
  372. 20:10design of these pieces come from well
  373. 20:13okay they're abstract they're
  374. 20:16geometric a lot more than that so we
  375. 20:18look
  376. 20:19closely how does the um Knight or horse
  377. 20:25move well it goes
  378. 20:29uh over and then turns right or forward
  379. 20:32and then turns and so it moves in an
  380. 20:36l-shape and there we have the piece with
  381. 20:38that l in it uh indicating that how does
  382. 20:42The Rook or Castle move it moves up or
  383. 20:45down up and down or back and forth and
  384. 20:47so its
  385. 20:49rectilinearity shows that how does the
  386. 20:51bishop move it moves diagonally and it's
  387. 20:54showing us that and then how did the
  388. 20:57king and queen move move they can move
  389. 21:00in any direction the queen as far as she
  390. 21:02wants and the king one square at a
  391. 21:07time so the shape of the pieces is or
  392. 21:13the form is derived from their functions
  393. 21:17how they
  394. 21:20operate and now let's see that idea
  395. 21:24applied to a
  396. 21:26building this is the uh
  397. 21:29a bow house building 1929 by Walter
  398. 21:33gropius and look at the model below and
  399. 21:37we can see it's a symmetrical dispersed
  400. 21:41uh into the landscape say okay you know
  401. 21:45it sort of has a very crisp modern
  402. 21:47quality but where specifically do these
  403. 21:50forms come
  404. 21:53from see these four distinct parts of
  405. 21:57the building
  406. 21:59well uh first we have the studios and
  407. 22:04the studios are like um for being seen
  408. 22:08like an industrial Factory so we have
  409. 22:10floor to cealing Glass heavy
  410. 22:13concrete uh open Loft
  411. 22:16spaces for our modern um uh industrial
  412. 22:21Design
  413. 22:24Studios we have our classrooms and the
  414. 22:27classrooms can be of any width right I
  415. 22:31mean we can have a wide classroom a
  416. 22:33narrow classroom so we have these strip
  417. 22:35windows with these um bands dividing
  418. 22:40them and we can put our petitions
  419. 22:42flexibly inside uh based on how uh big
  420. 22:47we want each classroom to be we have our
  421. 22:51Administration and the administration
  422. 22:55Bridges uh between other elements of the
  423. 22:59school and ties them together and
  424. 23:02finally we have the
  425. 23:05dorms Studio dorms and these are not
  426. 23:09like the classrooms you know bands of
  427. 23:12windows
  428. 23:14but people's individual homes and so
  429. 23:18they each have a little balcony and a
  430. 23:21distinct window to show the individual
  431. 23:24identity if you're looking up there you
  432. 23:26would be able to spot which one was
  433. 23:29yours so the bow
  434. 23:31house in particular and much of modern
  435. 23:35architecture in
  436. 23:36general receives its form and response
  437. 23:39to the activities going on
  438. 23:47inside Oscar
  439. 23:49Schlemmer uh who did this famous
  440. 23:51painting of the stare at the bow house
  441. 23:53that we can see the museum Modern Art uh
  442. 23:57wrote for for AAS exhibit reason in
  443. 24:01science man's greatest powers are the
  444. 24:06Regents and the engineer is the sedate
  445. 24:10executor of unlimited possibilities
  446. 24:14mathematics structure and mechanization
  447. 24:17are the elements and power and money are
  448. 24:20the dictators of this modern phenomena
  449. 24:23of
  450. 24:24steel concrete glass and electricity
  451. 24:29or as one of my professors uh put it uh
  452. 24:33the modern Architects threw themselves
  453. 24:35into the hands of the sanitary
  454. 24:38Engineers um that the architecture is
  455. 24:44nothing more nor less than a response to
  456. 24:49these mechanical aspects of life and
  457. 24:56construction so there are two approaches
  458. 25:00one his uh historically rooted but uh
  459. 25:05irrelevant to perhaps to today and the
  460. 25:10other seeing us in mechanistic material
  461. 25:14terms again in
  462. 25:18architecture uh you can see right here
  463. 25:20in New York
  464. 25:22the Metropolitan Museum it's on an
  465. 25:26Avenue Fifth Avenue
  466. 25:29in Central Park you have a great stair
  467. 25:32announcing the importance of the
  468. 25:35activity as you go up into the building
  469. 25:38it's using the columns arches and vaults
  470. 25:43of Rome uh showing that our culture is
  471. 25:48rooted in Rome now let's look at the
  472. 25:51Museum Modern Art it's on a side street
  473. 25:5553rd Street not an Avenue there's no
  474. 25:58Step Up you enter right in through a
  475. 26:01revolving door just as you would into
  476. 26:06a department
  477. 26:08store uh inside the lobby is not uh
  478. 26:13Monumental doesn't have domes but brings
  479. 26:17you right into the art and into the
  480. 26:18building now Museum modern art has been
  481. 26:21renovated quite a few times but in the
  482. 26:24latest renovation they made a point of
  483. 26:27preserving some aspect
  484. 26:29of this goodwi and Stone original uh
  485. 26:37facade now here's a quote from uh a
  486. 26:42German Mystic Monk
  487. 26:44Angelus of
  488. 26:46salus and he
  489. 26:49says of what use Gabriel your message to
  490. 26:53Mary unless you can give the same
  491. 26:57message to me
  492. 26:59now there's from angelico's
  493. 27:02anunciation and Gabrielle is telling
  494. 27:05Mary that she's pregnant with a child of
  495. 27:07God what does our German Mystic mean
  496. 27:12here it does not
  497. 27:15mean that he wishes to be pregnant with
  498. 27:19the child of God what he means is
  499. 27:23that what's the point of these sto
  500. 27:28stories of a tradition unless they are
  501. 27:32informative about
  502. 27:35ourselves that the spirit of God should
  503. 27:38be born in me so if we can understand
  504. 27:43these Traditions not literally but
  505. 27:47metaphorically then they can continue to
  506. 27:50be relevant in a scientific era so here
  507. 27:55on the left we have a Renaissance uh
  508. 27:59early Renaissance
  509. 28:02crucifixion on the right is a painting
  510. 28:05by
  511. 28:07Monon and this is actually the same
  512. 28:11subject the play between life and death
  513. 28:16the vertical being life the horizontal
  514. 28:18being death and what do they mean to us
  515. 28:22today not from the point of view of one
  516. 28:26Middle Eastern culture but as a
  517. 28:29universal Arch typal idea that is
  518. 28:33accessible to everyone and accessible to
  519. 28:37us in our scientific
  520. 28:41age so let's see what Khan's approach to
  521. 28:45this
  522. 28:47was
  523. 28:49so here we were were in modern
  524. 28:53architecture rejecting
  525. 28:56monumentality but then
  526. 28:59um Architects began to ask okay we're
  527. 29:03rejecting all this stuff but what do we
  528. 29:07value what do we want to
  529. 29:10recognize what do we value and how might
  530. 29:14we do so what would be a new
  531. 29:18monumentality and after struggling with
  532. 29:22this for some time KH suddenly stopped
  533. 29:26using the word monumentality
  534. 29:28and replaced it with
  535. 29:32order and realized that he was looking
  536. 29:35for not a rootedness in a European past
  537. 29:40but a for how architecture and a
  538. 29:44building and we ourselves can be
  539. 29:47rooted in our own nature that quality of
  540. 29:53us or the building or the institution
  541. 29:56that makes it what it is
  542. 29:58now how do we go about doing
  543. 30:02that so con used this term
  544. 30:06order and he
  545. 30:08said um that he could not say what order
  546. 30:13is okay does that mean we stop right
  547. 30:16there well when you not being able to
  548. 30:20say what I'm going to say what order is
  549. 30:22order is the underlying principle of all
  550. 30:25things and the way in which things come
  551. 30:28into
  552. 30:29existence
  553. 30:32now um You just the in that sense order
  554. 30:37then
  555. 30:38transcends concept so if you define
  556. 30:41something that's a concept order
  557. 30:44transcends Concepts we can't Define it
  558. 30:47so how do you talk about something that
  559. 30:49you cannot talk about directly and the
  560. 30:52answer is metaphor so Khan used the
  561. 30:56metaphor of Silence and
  562. 30:59light and he said silence the
  563. 31:03immeasurable desire to be desire to
  564. 31:05express source of new
  565. 31:08need meets light the measurable Giver of
  566. 31:12all Presence by Will by law the measure
  567. 31:16of things already made at a threshold
  568. 31:19which is inspiration the sanctuary of
  569. 31:22art the treasury of
  570. 31:24Shadow so what we see in Khan's
  571. 31:28philosophy is a notion
  572. 31:31of that there's a realm of potential if
  573. 31:34we see beautiful building on a
  574. 31:38hill where was that building before it
  575. 31:41was there well in one sense it's a
  576. 31:43meaningless question in another sense it
  577. 31:46couldn't exist unless it had the
  578. 31:48potential to exist so it was in the
  579. 31:51realm of potential that's the realm of
  580. 31:54Silence we then as an artist or
  581. 31:58architect have a realization aha this is
  582. 32:02what it should
  583. 32:03be this it's now in the realm of light
  584. 32:06but then we've got to go further and
  585. 32:09actually make it happen whether it's a
  586. 32:12novel or a drawing or a building and of
  587. 32:14course when we start engaging with that
  588. 32:17reality it's going to undergo a lot of
  589. 32:21change and so um
  590. 32:28con says the final manifestation
  591. 32:31realization is realization in form which
  592. 32:34means in
  593. 32:36nature in other words if we're going to
  594. 32:38build our building a brick we now have
  595. 32:40to deal with brick or steel or
  596. 32:44concrete in one of his very famous
  597. 32:47quotes Khan says if you think of brick
  598. 32:50and you're Consulting the orders you
  599. 32:52consider the nature of brick you say to
  600. 32:54Brick what do you want brick brick says
  601. 32:56to you I like an arch you say to Brick
  602. 32:59arches are expensive and I can use a
  603. 33:02concrete lentil over an opening what do
  604. 33:04you think of that brick brick says I
  605. 33:06like an
  606. 33:09arch
  607. 33:11now we look at Khan's mystical
  608. 33:14writings and at first they
  609. 33:18seem opaque yes it's nice poetry does it
  610. 33:22really make sense and then we see these
  611. 33:24very strong
  612. 33:26parallels to other mystical Traditions
  613. 33:29particularly
  614. 33:30lau and the DTI Ching so Lau writes that
  615. 33:35thou that can be told is not the Eternal
  616. 33:39thou in other words you can't say what
  617. 33:42it is just way you can't say what order
  618. 33:44is now I I'll say what da is Da is the
  619. 33:49underlying principle of all things and
  620. 33:52the uh principle through which things
  621. 33:55come into existence
  622. 33:58exactly what order
  623. 34:00is he
  624. 34:02says ever desire less one can see the
  625. 34:06mystery ever Desiring one can see the
  626. 34:0910,000 things desireless and Desiring
  627. 34:14they are different in name yet they are
  628. 34:16the
  629. 34:18same and if we look at Khan he says I
  630. 34:23liken the emergence of light to a
  631. 34:25manifestation of two brothers knowing
  632. 34:28quite well that there are not two
  633. 34:31brothers nor even
  634. 34:35one
  635. 34:38and KH says a great building in my
  636. 34:42opinion must begin with the unmeasurable
  637. 34:45must go through measurable means when it
  638. 34:48is being designed and in the end must be
  639. 34:52unmeasurable and finally a work is made
  640. 34:56in the urging sound of industry and when
  641. 34:59the dust settles the pyramid echoing
  642. 35:02silence gives the sun its
  643. 35:09shadow
  644. 35:11now this mystical philosophy of Khan at
  645. 35:16first we might think of it as
  646. 35:18idiosyncratic but then we find that he's
  647. 35:21in a
  648. 35:23very um powerful tradition Lou Sullivan
  649. 35:27wrote
  650. 35:28The Germ is the real thing the seat of
  651. 35:31identity within its delicate mechanism
  652. 35:34lies the will to power the
  653. 35:37function which is to seek and eventually
  654. 35:40to find its full expression in
  655. 35:44form
  656. 35:46so when Sullivan used the term form
  657. 35:49follows function which we also associate
  658. 35:52with Frankl
  659. 35:54right he says I do not mean the crude
  660. 35:58functionalism of the
  661. 36:01materialists by function he means the
  662. 36:04inner will that which seeks
  663. 36:08to uh find its full expression in form
  664. 36:13and he has an image of a seed here and
  665. 36:16there's the germ in the center and the
  666. 36:19inner will imagine an acorn an acorn
  667. 36:22wants to be an oak tree it has inner
  668. 36:24will to be an oak tree now we refer to
  669. 36:27DNA
  670. 36:28but uh speaking
  671. 36:30metaphorically so there is this inner
  672. 36:32driving
  673. 36:34force Frank leght said deeper than the
  674. 36:38truths of philosophy or the laws of
  675. 36:40morality is a sense of Honor what would
  676. 36:43be the honor of a brick that in the
  677. 36:46brick which makes the brick a brick in
  678. 36:50other words there's this inner force uh
  679. 36:54seeking to have it manifest itself and
  680. 36:59uh Mis
  681. 37:00vandero wrote architecture is the real
  682. 37:03battleground of the spirit architecture
  683. 37:07depends on its time it is the
  684. 37:09crystallization of its inner structure
  685. 37:12the inner structure of its time the slow
  686. 37:15unfolding of its form so that a Time an
  687. 37:19era has an in structure and architecture
  688. 37:23is the
  689. 37:24crystallization of that inner structure
  690. 37:27into to
  691. 37:31form KH gave his last talk at a Pratt
  692. 37:36Institute and when he was done with his
  693. 37:39talk speaking in the terms that we've
  694. 37:41been describing here uh student raised
  695. 37:44his hand Khan called on him and the
  696. 37:47student
  697. 37:49said why
  698. 37:51architecture and what he meant by that
  699. 37:55was why are you in
  700. 37:58why aren't you a mystical you know
  701. 38:02philosopher and Khan
  702. 38:05said uh let me uh tack your question
  703. 38:10with a hebraic uh uh approach of
  704. 38:14returning your question if you ask your
  705. 38:17question I then ask you why
  706. 38:21anything and student George uh
  707. 38:24immediately snaap back because it is and
  708. 38:29Khan agreed yes because it is so if
  709. 38:34you're interested in a more in-depth
  710. 38:37discussion of uh Khan's philosophy
  711. 38:40you'll find it in my book between
  712. 38:42silence and
  713. 38:56Light for

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of John Lobell Louis Kahn's Philosophy by John Lobell, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,402 words across 713 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.