"John A. MacDonald: The Impossible Idea" (1961) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:12[Music]
- 0:24Quebec City in 1861 was unsettled and
- 0:29quarrelsome as was most of British North
- 0:31America was a time of bitter conflicts
- 0:35particularly bitter for one man John a
- 0:38McDonald at only 46 he was exhausted by
- 0:43political struggle haunted by personal
- 0:45tragedy weary and discouraged he was
- 0:49convinced his public service was
- 0:50finished
- 0:52in fact it had really just started
- 0:56[Music]
- 1:27the April session of the Parliament of
- 1:29Upper and Lower Canada was a stormy one
- 1:31deep divisions plagued the two
- 1:33candidates it seemed a time for young
- 1:36nations to explode apart
- 1:38Canadians public and parliamentarians
- 1:41alike were appalled by the civil war
- 1:43being waged over the border in the
- 1:45American states yet shocked as they were
- 1:48by this bloody example of disunity they
- 1:51seemed powerless to preserve the smaller
- 1:52union of the two candidates
- 1:55this was the scene against which a
- 1:57discouraged politician began to play out
- 2:00his greatest role
- 2:03John a
- 2:06My dear sir what Oh we from Kingston to
- 2:09report this debate for the paper myself
- 2:11huh what's gonna come of all this John
- 2:12elocution well elocution and wind
- 2:19tell me how did that several of us work
- 2:22out trouble and mr. Sears threatened to
- 2:24sue you because your son Ted graded his
- 2:26apple tree haha did he know I'd
- 2:28forgotten that Oh
- 2:30pensee you're remembering a thing like
- 2:31that oh that was during the free
- 2:37yes that was during Isis funeral bill
- 2:42and good memory as a mixed blessing I'm
- 2:45sorry I shouldn't have reminded you I
- 2:47think for all the time these days should
- 2:51have done more for her how could anyone
- 2:53have done more
- 2:55I could've quit politics kept to the law
- 2:59stayin at home during the bad years so
- 3:04often I left her to suffer in loneliness
- 3:06to fight these empty battles that the
- 3:09number one
- 3:12you did everything possible for her you
- 3:15couldn't quit you're indispensable no
- 3:20one is indispensable
- 3:25who else could have managed a working
- 3:27relationship between Upper and Lower
- 3:28Canada without your leadership there
- 3:30would have been no government and for
- 3:32every compromise I'm a scoundrel well
- 3:36tonight we need another compromise to
- 3:40please nobody compromise now surely you
- 3:44must give in on this question the
- 3:45personal attacks on you for resisting
- 3:48have never been so vile have you seen
- 3:49the glow but nothing surprise you
- 3:53especially what you read in the globe
- 3:55doesn't surprise me it horrifies me only
- 3:58the customer here's something to horrify
- 4:01you Civil War in the States
- 4:04guard against brother killing each other
- 4:06John what will you do
- 4:08out of this if I'm a course good to see
- 4:10you again bill John they're all waiting
- 4:12to hear what you'll say tonight they
- 4:14claim they'll try to evade the whole
- 4:15issue so we meet later I know an
- 4:18excellent restaurant I've got good
- 4:19stories to tell you
- 4:20we'll talk till breakfast
- 4:25Monsieur Burton of Kingston Monsieur
- 4:28Marchand you honor us tonight
- 4:30yes I'll sit with you in the press
- 4:31gallery by me that's really a collision
- 4:34shall we go up
- 4:39let this house me Warren if this country
- 4:42is to be won and not to then we must
- 4:45have representation in Parliament is
- 4:46abit where one and not to Lord Sun Joon
- 4:49denied watching roast MacDonald we are
- 4:53not two countries each sending an equal
- 4:56number of delegates to a conferences
- 4:58have each had the same problems in the
- 4:59same population where one country and we
- 5:02demand justice for everyone and that
- 5:05means we demand representation by
- 5:07population here here the time is passed
- 5:09for the ministerial party to take refuge
- 5:11in shiftiness and trickery and evasion
- 5:18yet they go on what are their words that
- 5:23the Union of Upper and Lower Canada was
- 5:25brought about in 1840 with equal
- 5:27representation for each and therefore
- 5:29despite all reason despite the growth in
- 5:32the West this must remain so for all
- 5:35time and forever amen
- 5:36I think is right you know I tell you
- 5:40this is intolerable and it will be
- 5:42tolerated no longer by the people of
- 5:44Canada West now the time has come the
- 5:47voice of the people must be heard the
- 5:51government can no longer evade this if
- 5:53we are to remain one country the census
- 5:57is now giving us the facts the facts can
- 6:00no longer be denied here are the facts
- 6:04the population of Upper Canada is now
- 6:07greater than that of Lower Canada by
- 6:09some 300,000 what does this mean under
- 6:14our present system of equal
- 6:15representation it means that the West
- 6:18contributes three pounds of Taxation for
- 6:21every one pound from Lower Canada
- 6:23it means that we have 300,000 citizens
- 6:26without representation without a voice
- 6:28in their own affairs and yet the
- 6:32government tries to pretend that these
- 6:34300 thousand souls do not betray their
- 6:46principles for the sake of alliances
- 6:51with the east because they were saying
- 6:55we are how do you expect to win
- 7:00government support for that sort of
- 7:02rubbish I know they're professionally
- 7:04humorless bored Hollywood my brilliant
- 7:07man with a great future
- 7:09he doesn't make levity of serious
- 7:11affairs now he leaves the joking to your
- 7:13John a every time that mcdonnen wit with
- 7:16demolition whant oh you know the
- 7:19gentleman from the penalty rope for
- 7:21globe an honest newspapers er the
- 7:24rattlesnake is also honest those who
- 7:26disagree and speak the truth or
- 7:28poisonous tonight I noticed McDonald is
- 7:32feeling the bite
- 7:34when this health failed after his wife
- 7:37died all your paper can talk about was
- 7:38drunkenness you don't care how you're
- 7:40slandering we expose a weak charlatan
- 7:43who corrupts government you call it
- 7:45slander I wonder that we have a single
- 7:47honorable man left in government with
- 7:49the wolves that slander their
- 7:51reputations
- 7:51I wonder he doesn't wash his hands of
- 7:54public affairs when we have
- 7:56representation by population we'll have
- 7:58a Western majority and we'll wash our
- 8:00hands of Johnny McGowan Lord Canada as
- 8:03well do not think sir that the East will
- 8:06ever allow it either way I'll predict
- 8:09that your man Johnny has no future in
- 8:11this country's politics MacDonald is
- 8:13speaking let's watch a regal I have been
- 8:23in Parliament for 17 years and I have
- 8:25never had any subjects of emily debated
- 8:27by honourable friends of the opposition
- 8:30claim that we have attempted to prevent
- 8:32discussion of this bill
- 8:34they must admit if so that we have
- 8:37failed signaling I have never had so
- 8:40much discussion of anything
- 8:46the arguments have been masterful we
- 8:49have now heard every conceivable reason
- 8:51for supporting representation by
- 8:53population my honourable friend has been
- 8:56eloquent and persuasive I for one feel
- 9:01quite fully prepared to vote immediately
- 9:03on the minutes of this bill well
- 9:11considering the build us from every
- 9:13point of view and considering also
- 9:17arguments in its favor I can now state
- 9:20my position I cannot give my vote to it
- 9:28mr. speaker we have all heard the tragic
- 9:32news from across the border despite this
- 9:35only the other evening remember rose in
- 9:38this house and threatened us with
- 9:39uprisings and bayonets unless we
- 9:43considered representation by population
- 9:47now it seems the Honourable member from
- 9:50Stealth Ontario implies the same threat
- 9:53and this despite the fact that he
- 9:57announced to his own parties to run to
- 9:59convention that representation by
- 10:01population was no remedy for the evils
- 10:04in question and is a false statement of
- 10:06my speech I merely asked where these
- 10:08words at and it is unfair to pick out
- 10:11one sentence one read the whole speech
- 10:20all principles in which they are not
- 10:23sincere the leaders of a great party
- 10:26threaten us with disunity and perhaps
- 10:29bloodshed they should consider the
- 10:33effect of their words and the people but
- 10:37at least we are in agreement that the
- 10:39bill is no remedy then what is the
- 10:44remedy can you do better
- 10:53there is a remedy
- 10:57the only feasible scheme to my mind a
- 11:02confederation of all the provinces of
- 11:05British North America England will be
- 11:13the center surrounded and sustained by
- 11:17an alliance not only with Canada but
- 11:21with the Australasian colonies and all
- 11:24her possessions there will just be a
- 11:28found an immense confederation of
- 11:32freemen the Foxes of tricks he can't
- 11:38hold together the province of Canada so
- 11:39he goes on to unite the world in the
- 11:42coming general election let us set aside
- 11:46party feelings on this disruptive issue
- 11:50let us work together for the common good
- 11:52in the principle of Union and not in the
- 11:58principle of one section fighting to
- 12:01annihilate the other
- 12:05speaker the Honorable gentleman says
- 12:08that we are insincere now I say he is
- 12:11the one who is instance here I say he is
- 12:14bankrupt of ideas bankrupt of policy the
- 12:18offices clothes to conceal the issue to
- 12:21conceal the truth I say he does this in
- 12:24despair to cling to office which he
- 12:27loves so dearly and manipulate so well
- 12:31you miserable Potter
- 12:38Wow no matter with you
- 12:46laughs is it the pup may have a bite
- 13:19Mille ailing me in the house in public
- 13:22before the country he's gone too far
- 13:25mr. Lord if I may make a suggestion yes
- 13:29MacDonald has always won in Kingston
- 13:31because he had no effective opposition
- 13:33man you sir are the son of a respected
- 13:36Kingston family as a leading figure in
- 13:39the Reform Party with a full power the
- 13:41party behind you and at this critical
- 13:42time you could be the one to eliminate
- 13:44MacDonald from the political scene
- 13:46you mean I should run in Kingston it's
- 13:50already in my mind sir we've got him out
- 13:52a step at the time opposing the public
- 13:55will muttering dreams of Confederation I
- 13:58run and I run him out of Parliament the
- 14:02pups on his tail will be sure of that
- 14:03good man splendid
- 14:13John I must talk to you not now bill
- 14:21they say if you lose your temper you
- 14:23lose the fight it's become too much for
- 14:25you it's time to quit more deserved it
- 14:28it's not Mart at 17 years of getting no
- 14:33queer no Long John I must tell you
- 14:37Hartmann arabel let's find that
- 14:40restaurant I need good company and
- 14:43laughter and no more politics
- 14:50in June of 1861 McDonald returned to
- 14:53Kingston to fight an election and to
- 14:55visit his family one of his first acts
- 14:58was to go to the graveyard where his
- 14:59wife was buried a pilgrimage he and his
- 15:02mother had made so many times
- 15:04[Music]
- 15:07but public life intruded as always on
- 15:10personal sorrow
- 15:11ahead lay an election battle and the
- 15:14challenge of Oliver Mort promised these
- 15:18promises at border we have propelled the
- 15:25government party does not appeal to you
- 15:27on the pieces of the past proponents
- 15:29although this has been considerable will
- 15:33settle the credulous and question we
- 15:36have prohibited imprisonment for debt
- 15:40and we have carried out an almost
- 15:43perfect what's wrong with my little
- 15:45spell now it is my intention next
- 15:49session should i be reelected
- 15:51to introduce a bankruptcy law call Upper
- 15:54Canada concerning this important
- 15:57necessity may I see us about the
- 15:59railroad
- 16:02well tell us John a are you gonna build
- 16:05ball railroads Johnny Oh
- 16:08get away the people's money a railroad
- 16:11from New Brunswick to Detroit why not
- 16:14one to the Wild West free rides the
- 16:17Blackfeet oliver moored Rowdies now
- 16:20gentlemen gentlemen if you have
- 16:22questions I will answer them but if you
- 16:25seek levity may I recommend an excellent
- 16:28tavern
- 16:31trunk swindle tell us about that tell us
- 16:35how you look the public purse oh no Jill
- 16:37how you milk the country for 25 million
- 16:40for you to play it's in the club the
- 16:43Grand Trunk swindle a court the globe
- 16:46that would break up the railroad and
- 16:49divide the country and see it was all in
- 16:51the national goal dear
- 16:53what about the ships running in Kingston
- 16:55Harbour and Coburg because of your
- 16:56railroad and nothing to show for a fact
- 16:59it's what we have to show that our great
- 17:01works that will enjoy to our children's
- 17:03children for every pound so much
- 17:06railroad so much canal tell us how you
- 17:09sold yourself to the lower Canadians
- 17:11where do you stand on rep by pop we want
- 17:14representation what about our wasted
- 17:16votes give us ripped by pop Iona by pop
- 17:20whip by pop would divide the country and
- 17:23furthermore no government could be
- 17:25formed from either side the house to
- 17:28carry out such a principle all alone oh
- 17:30it says it can be done and that great
- 17:32old
- 17:33we want more you deserve Oliver Moyet
- 17:37but we must protect the innocent
- 17:42Boyd and rep by pop rip
- 17:49no don't don't hurt the little man you
- 17:55need cooling off my press so it's sport
- 18:00you want Johnny come on lads
- 18:12let's just be like the
- 18:20not to clean
- 18:33[Applause]
- 18:57you see they mean to win job this is no
- 19:00time for platitudes you've simply got to
- 19:03fire the people up in the old way
- 19:06[Applause]
- 19:10the meetings over gentlemen shall we
- 19:14dine dine a good squabble it's my
- 19:16appetite not a policeman in sight
- 19:18oh it won't go into the parade
- 19:43Ivano finish gypped marry finished
- 19:46eating yet
- 20:00good evening mrs. McDonald mr. Burton
- 20:03you did not come to dinner I wasn't able
- 20:05to I'm very sorry won't you go in mr.
- 20:10Burton but I just couldn't prevent it oh
- 20:15come in well I was just telling them
- 20:17about food dr. Stewart a bottomless pit
- 20:19one funny story after another three
- 20:22hours and 20 minutes without a stop sit
- 20:24down
- 20:25these are campaign plans I once defended
- 20:30dr. Stewart on a libel charge you know
- 20:32dr. Stewart of the arcus ugly Argus you
- 20:35never did what he libels you in his rag
- 20:38all the time calls you the apps criminal
- 20:40I defended him in court just the same I
- 20:43called witnesses to prove that no one
- 20:45ever read The Argus
- 20:47but no one ever believed anything that
- 20:48was written in it and therefore no one's
- 20:51reputation could be damaged in any way a
- 20:53case dismissed
- 20:55bless me what a man you are innocent
- 20:58because give exactly John what about the
- 21:02election you also what happened you
- 21:04can't rest now on reciting past
- 21:06performance in office no
- 21:09past performances can't a little you're
- 21:11right and I look back over my years in
- 21:16public life I feel what a foolish man I
- 21:20was to enter it how can you say such a
- 21:22thing even a politician has the
- 21:26privilege of speaking the truth what a
- 21:30man desires is peace
- 21:32domestic happiness not exposure to every
- 21:35puny lie blur in the land but with old
- 21:39friends around me I feel compensated
- 21:44gentlemen I must tell you a story he'll
- 21:47go on like this until 6 o'clock in the
- 21:49morning and we have nothing to offer the
- 21:51voters
- 21:51it's about William well on the
- 21:52stagecoach mogul if you remember
- 21:54gentlemen I appealed to his right but
- 21:57what's to be done everything is left by
- 21:59pop we're running against the tide then
- 22:01we must answer rap by pop with the
- 22:03proposal to satisfy the people what
- 22:05propose well what about this
- 22:06Confederation thing well no it's hoping
- 22:08for that I heard his reaction in
- 22:10Parliament no that would be the worst
- 22:12thing that junk have mentioned right now
- 22:13but it seems a grand idea and people
- 22:17will talk about it till grand
- 22:19bring together all the different British
- 22:21colonies how we know it can't be done in
- 22:24this century and more what knows we know
- 22:26it but I should think a grand idea
- 22:29[Music]
- 22:47to do that what facts representation by
- 22:51population oh now now wait O'Connell you
- 22:53think about it support it more its own
- 22:56platform Kings Ennis Johnstown remember
- 22:59just so he gives the people what they
- 23:00want you mean take the election platform
- 23:04right out of mo its own blatherskite
- 23:05mouth it might be just the thing a
- 23:09button times do change and we don't want
- 23:12to be left behind gentlemen I have
- 23:16something to say about William Weller
- 23:20the stagecoach mogul Hall John hood when
- 23:24the railroads were closing out his
- 23:25business his bread and butter he said I
- 23:28am rejoiced to see old things passing
- 23:32away and conditions becoming more well
- 23:39and so it is with me let old things slip
- 23:42away even if I go with them let new
- 23:44things come but not disastrous things
- 23:48representation by population would be a
- 23:51disaster now if I am to go it must not
- 23:55be as an advocate of disaster then we
- 23:58tell funny stories and lose the election
- 24:00gentlemen if the one real cure for the
- 24:02ills of our time should be impossible
- 24:04let us go down recommending the
- 24:07impossible john not confederation please
- 24:09every to suffer let's make our suffering
- 24:11worthwhile imagine if it were to become
- 24:15possible what a purpose that would give
- 24:18to our lives the riches of both our
- 24:21oceans the forests of our east and west
- 24:25joined with our vast prairies a land
- 24:28secured at last against the american
- 24:31malady that threatens no know what to
- 24:34certainly won't I like the sound of it I
- 24:37do better the grand dream of
- 24:39Confederation then the wild idiocy of
- 24:42rep by pop and who knows it might not be
- 24:47so impossible if we should win this
- 24:51election let's keep it in mind for the
- 24:54right time
- 24:56at first we must win and that it seems
- 24:59is by no means certain now gentlemen to
- 25:02tactics toward man there's no doubt that
- 25:04Oliver more chose surprising strengths
- 25:06what we must do is have it away at his
- 25:09weak points while we exploit how strong
- 25:11once there was little strength in the
- 25:13issue of Confederation in the 1861
- 25:15elections MacDonald used it among others
- 25:18and he did win but few voters took to
- 25:21the dubious vision of a new nation yet
- 25:24this tentative idea political expediency
- 25:28and genuine foresight rapidly grew in
- 25:31strength and public favor six years
- 25:34later on July the 1st 1867 Confederation
- 25:39became a reality well gentlemen they
- 25:42have been tiring Labor's but I hope
- 25:45worthwhile I have noticed the bullet
- 25:50that the best interests in future
- 25:52prosperity of British North America will
- 25:56be promoted by a federal union under the
- 25:59crown of Great Britain
- 26:03[Applause]
- 26:03[Music]
- 26:33[Applause]
- 26:40[Music]
- 27:17[Applause]
- 27:18[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of "John A. MacDonald: The Impossible Idea" (1961) by Canada 160 Archive, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,052 words across 468 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.