YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → Jodi Aris Trial : Day 2 : 2 Of 2 : Evidence Reviewed (No Sidebars)

Jodi Aris Trial : Day 2 : 2 Of 2 : Evidence Reviewed (No Sidebars) — Transcript

by David Lohr · 13,960 words · 2,191 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:12please be seated the record will show
0:14the presence of the jury the defendant
0:15and all
0:16councel Mr Martinez you may continue
0:19with redirect your name sir stean FLOTUS
0:23and you in the person testifying before
0:24lunch correct yes please take a look at
0:27exhibit 275
0:32are you familiar with that yes or no yes
0:35I am and with regard to that item is
0:38that the is that the what is it first of
0:41all it's a copy of uh instant message
0:45emails sent back and forth between uh
0:47jod Aras and Travis Alexander and you
0:50were asked previously on Cross
0:52examination about this reference to a
0:54three-hole Wonder correct yes is that
0:57the document contains that reference
1:00yes it is with regard to that reference
1:02involving that particular comment um why
1:07was that comment made as indicated in
1:09that document calls for
1:13speculation sustained as phrased well
1:16let's go go to page eight the bot at the
1:20bottom what is he complaining about what
1:24page was that against eight at the
1:25bottom four lines from the
1:28bottom uh reference to being used
1:31sexually by Miss Aras what is he saying
1:35uh specifically let me read it from here
1:38I think I was little more than a dildo
1:41with a heartbeat to you and that's what
1:43he's saying to her right
1:46yes in the previous Pages pages one and
1:51two and three is there do they talk
1:56about whether or not to tell the truth
1:58yes
2:01answering the the questions posed in
2:03Cross Mr
2:05Martinez it's part of the same um
2:09document and it's part of the reason why
2:11he's calling what he's calling
2:14her there's no link I mean he's he's had
2:17to speculate on the
2:19link Council approach and bring the
2:22transcript please
2:33P starts with
2:36Facebook yes just read it though okay uh
2:40me no no no no no read it to yourself oh
2:42okay I thought you wanted me to read it
2:43out loud okay and in terms of the
2:46reference to the three one it's toward
2:48the bottom correct yes go ahead and read
2:50the next page which is 4 16 to yourself
2:53okay what is the context of that
2:57comment the context of throughout those
3:01two pages is uh Travis Alexander and jod
3:05Aras are having a conversation and
3:07Travis is complaining about her lying to
3:13him sir you were asked
3:16about some iers and these are set out in
3:20exhibits
3:22numbers 265 through
3:252711 do you remember those and I'll
3:27start with 265 for example
3:35yes first of all you see the scale on
3:37there right this is exhibit number
3:40265 yes and what is that word there it
3:45says
3:46metric and with regard
3:50to these spaces in between in terms of
3:53the metric scale what are they cenim
3:56millimet kilom what are they uh the
3:59large section
4:00the small ones
4:02millimeters and how many millim are
4:06there in an
4:07inch uh approximately
4:1125 is it's a little bit more than 25 is
4:14it yes how
4:16much uh well there's
4:182.4 cm in an inch and then there's 10 so
4:22it's 2.54 or yeah
4:242.54 so you're talking
4:2825.4 millim to an inch right yes and so
4:31that will tell us for example by looking
4:34at this by counting out 25 mm how much
4:37an inch is right
4:39yes with regard
4:42to those particular items
4:46there can you tell whether not this
4:48really is a piece of a rope it looks
4:51more like a small
4:53thread and if you take a look at
4:56exhibits 63
4:59and 81 take a look at those first of all
5:02yes do you recognize those yes what are
5:05those photographs of uh photographs of
5:08the interior of Travis Alexander's house
5:11uh more in particular uh his bedroom and
5:15part of the bathroom near the
5:17shower and were those taken back at the
5:21time of the investigation of the crime
5:22in June of 208
5:25yes exibit 6381
5:33no
5:34objection exhibit 63 and 81 will be
5:37admitted take a look at exhibit
5:4263 what are we looking at
5:45here uh a photograph of Travis
5:48Alexander's bedroom and
5:53specifically what is this item here
5:56those are uh throw pillows and what's
5:59around around the corners of those throw
6:01pillows um tassel like uh
6:06fibers those tassel like fibers if we
6:08take a look
6:11at exhibit number
6:19265 you were there can you tell us
6:22whether or not they similar to
6:26those yes they are and let me show
6:31you another exhibit it's exhibit number
6:37271 you see this that's on
6:42there this item here you see that yes I
6:46do take a look at
6:50uh exhibits
6:53numbers 64 68
7:02okay those are photographs are they true
7:04and accurate depictions of an area and
7:06an item from the scen that existed back
7:08when the investigation was being
7:09conducted in June of 2008 Yes they are4
7:30no objection your honor exhibit 64 and
7:32exhibit 68 will be admitted this is uh
7:35exhibit
7:3764 and Orient us a little bit what are
7:40we looking at here looking at the uh
7:44interior of Travis Alexander's bedroom
7:47um looking from just behind the entry
7:51door you can actually see the door on
7:53the right hand side door handle and
7:55you're
7:56looking what direction kind of like a
7:59northe East Direction into the bedroom
8:01what does this door lead to that one is
8:04actually to the closet that parallels
8:06the hallway into the
8:09bathroom and exhibit
8:12number and there is something in the
8:14middle here this Photograph the first
8:16one 2 64
8:18correct right there yes the sandals
8:23Okay then if we take a look at exhibit
8:2568 that's a closeup of what the sandals
8:29in in the middle of the room and with
8:31regard to these
8:38sandals do they have any covering on
8:41them where a person would
8:42step yes uh full of fibers and you see
8:46this right here what is this these items
8:48that are sticking out from around the
8:49sandals those are the uh the actual
8:52fibers that the sandals are covered
8:57with and then if we take a look at
9:00exhibit number
9:04271 what is that in your opinion could
9:07that be is that consistent with having
9:09come from those shoes yes it is
9:11consistent and looking through this
9:15whole house was there ever a rope that
9:18was found no so if there had been a rope
9:23there and you didn't find it what would
9:27have happened to the Rope objection C
9:29ation is beyond the scope of
9:31cross
9:33overed uh we would have taken it I know
9:36but it wasn't there would you have taken
9:38it no if somebody had taken it before
9:40you would you have taken it no I
9:42couldn't have but did you find any long
9:46lengths of rope or anything like that
9:47when you were there
9:49no and did you find for example in
9:52exhibit 63 was
9:55that bedroom
9:57examined yes it was was the area here
10:00around the bed examined yes was the
10:06area exhibit number 64 was the area
10:10right around here examined yes and I
10:13mean I mean the lower portion was did
10:16any officers look underneath the bed yes
10:19did they look behind the headboard yes
10:22was there ever a knife found anywhere
10:25near there no was there ever any rope
10:27found anywhere near there in other words
10:29words any of these little strands that
10:31we're talking about were any of those
10:32found anywhere near the bed
10:36no you talk about cording off the street
10:40and that sort of thing when you got
10:41there and the house being coined off do
10:43you remember that yes I do what's the
10:45purpose of that to secure the the
10:47residents to keep anybody from going in
10:49and disturbing any evidence so that from
10:52the time that the police received the
10:53call till the time the police first
10:55police officer came that meant that
10:57nobody had access to him that place
11:00correct that's correct and how long did
11:01you keep the scene open or how long was
11:03the scene secured so to speak uh almost
11:06three days I don't have any other
11:08questions thank
11:12you I have one question from a jur are
11:15there any other questions from the
11:19jury if there are questions ladies and
11:22gentlemen raise your hand and if you
11:23need some time to write it out just let
11:25me know and we will wait for you Council
11:27please approach all right detective a
11:30jur has a question for you are the
11:32exhibits number 272 273 and 274 from the
11:38same
11:39conversation what exhibits are those
11:41could I see them again
11:44yes yes they
11:48are Mr nurman you may recross and follow
11:52up on the juror question if you have
11:55anything thank you
11:59a moment
12:02please
12:04yes find the approach owner
12:10Yes actually will put up exhibit
12:1663 again Mr Martinez showed you that
12:21just a minute ago you recall seeing that
12:24yes okay um based on the observations
12:29you made and I believe what you told us
12:31was that uh this picture accurately
12:34depicts what you saw at the crime scene
12:35on June 9th and or June 10th is that
12:38correct yes okay and it would appear
12:41that those pillows are in an unmolested
12:44state would you
12:45agree yes
12:51okay and you recall Mr Martinez also
12:54asked you about pair sandals or flips
12:57with some fibers on cor yes
13:00okay let me step back a bit um Mesa P
13:05Mesa Police Department you're how long
13:07have you been employed there uh 19 years
13:09okay so you're pretty familiar with the
13:11practices and the procedures and those
13:12sort of things correct yes okay um and I
13:17suspect then uh could you tell us
13:18whether Mesa police department has a
13:20crime lab yes we do okay and what sort
13:24of things does that crime lab do uh
13:26everything from uh DNA typing uh
13:30fingerprint
13:31analysis uh blood work uh those kinds of
13:35things okay so if they had known fibers
13:39for example from these pillows or from
13:41sandals or that sort of thing they could
13:44compare that against items you found at
13:46the crime scene correct um our lab does
13:49not do that okay so you there there
13:51would be no way for you to compare we
13:53would have to send those out to another
13:56lab okay was that done no okay so the
14:00estimation you're making that these
14:02These are similar characteristics are
14:03just based on your observation not any
14:07actual data testing is that correct
14:09that's correct okay thank
14:12you Mr Martinez those three exhibits or
14:16the three DVDs that you have in front of
14:17you those were from the same
14:19conversation correct yes they were what
14:21date was the conversation that you had
14:23of those three DVDs they were uh June
14:2710th
14:29and who initiated that in other words I
14:31know you made the call but were you
14:33returning a call I was returning a call
14:35uh a message to call Jody area back I
14:38don't have any other questions thank
14:40you you may step down the state may call
14:43its next witness State calls Heather
14:48Conor can you spell your first and last
14:51name please Heather h a t h e r Conor c
14:56o n n e r raise your right hand you do
15:00solemnly swear the testimony you're
15:01about to give will be the truth the
15:02whole truth and nothing but the truth so
15:04help you God thank
15:06you please walk right around and have a
15:10seat May proceed may I have your name
15:12please yes my name is Heather Conor who
15:15do you work for I work for the Mesa
15:17Police
15:18Department and how long have you worked
15:20for the Mesa Police Department I was
15:22hired in June uh or excuse me September
15:25of 2004 and what were your duties when
15:28you were ini hired when I was originally
15:31hired at the Mesa Police Department I
15:32was hired as a crime scene technician I
15:34was promoted in June of 2005 to lat and
15:37print
15:41examiner and what kind of uh do you have
15:43to have a degree for that sort of thing
15:45what kind of experience did you have or
15:46education prior to being hired I hold a
15:49Bachelor of Science degree in
15:51anthropology and journalism I have an
15:53associate of science degree in forensic
15:56technology
15:59and what were your duties back in June
16:02of
16:032008 in June of 2008 I was a Laton print
16:07examiner among my duties includes the
16:10Performing the comparative analysis of
16:13unknown finger and palm prints that are
16:16recovered from crime scenes and items of
16:19evidence to known subjects prints I also
16:23process evidence in the laboratory using
16:26various chemicals and powders and I
16:29respond to Major crime scenes I take
16:31photographs collect evidence and process
16:34for Laten prints with regard to this
16:36issue of a latent fingerprints um what
16:39is a latent
16:40fingerprint a latent fingerprint is a
16:42chance impression on the polymer sides
16:45of your hands and the soles of your feet
16:48we have a specialized type of skin
16:51that's called friction Ridge
16:53skin it's very similar to Corduroy in
16:56that there are Peaks and valleys to that
16:58skin
17:00and throughout the day you can collect
17:02different materials on the surface of
17:04your skin including oils from your face
17:07or hair grease from the food that you
17:09eat or other things um throughout your
17:11day and when you touch a surface you can
17:15leave an impression of the arrangement
17:18of friction ridges on your hands or
17:20Palms onto that surface so as I
17:22understand what you're saying is that
17:24these Impressions that are left behind
17:27wow let me ask it this way are they left
17:29behind every single time that a person
17:31for example touches a surface like I'm
17:33doing here on this Podium no there are
17:36many reasons of print may or may not be
17:38left behind well does environment have
17:40anything to do with whether or not this
17:41impression is going to be left behind
17:44yes ex specifically what would what
17:47environmental factors affect whether or
17:49not a print is going to be left behind
17:51if it's a very warm day most of the
17:54perspiration on your fingers is water it
17:58can evaporate so if it's a very warm day
18:01you may not leave an impression behind
18:03you may have very dry hands the residue
18:06Left Behind could evaporate from the
18:08surface if it's been raining the residue
18:12could be washed away environmental
18:15factors like that can affect whether a
18:17print is Left Behind or not how about a
18:20surface for example if I get a hold of
18:22something that's made out of wood and I
18:23put my hands all over it and my more or
18:26less likely to leave a CH or L
18:29fingerprint
18:32behind depend it's got a lot of holes in
18:35it just a piece of wood I would say in
18:38that case you're less likely to leave a
18:40lat and print behind on a very rough
18:43holy surface than a smooth hard surface
18:46if you think of a fingerprint as a
18:49rubber stamp and think about if you ink
18:51up a rubber stamp and press it on a very
18:54rough surface you don't get a very clear
18:55impression of that stamp left behind a
18:57fingerprint is the same sort of thing
19:00what about movement what if I'm for
19:03example going through something and I'm
19:05moving very quickly and I slide my hand
19:08against the surface like I did of the
19:10podium there am my less or more likely
19:13to leave a
19:15fingerprint you may leave a fingerprint
19:18behind in that circumstance but you
19:20could be smearing the fingerprint and
19:22the the arrangement won't be visible it
19:24won't be very clear based on the
19:27movement so you get these fingerprints
19:30let's assume that you actually lift them
19:32um how do you go about determining who's
19:36the person that left the behind let's
19:38say in this world where you have
19:40billions and billions of
19:41people you don't know who the person was
19:44that left it behind that's why you're
19:45checking so how is it that you go about
19:48affecting an
19:50identification the methodology that we
19:52use to compare fingerprints it goes by
19:55the acronym ACV that's a c
19:59e-v that stands for analysis comparison
20:04evaluation and
20:05verification in the analysis phase what
20:08an examiner will do is examine the
20:11latent impression to determine its
20:13overall suitability for comparison the
20:16overall Ridge flow of that print can I
20:19tell if it's a finger or a palm can I
20:21tell the orientation of the print how
20:23clear is the information is there a
20:27great deal of difficult ulty in
20:29distinguishing between the raised
20:31portions which would be the ridges and
20:33the
20:34furrows we're looking for three levels
20:36of detail in a fingerprint uh level one
20:39detail is the overall Ridge flow and in
20:42the fingers will be pattern type and
20:45we're looking for level two detail
20:48that's called Ridge characteristics
20:51there's many other terms that can be
20:52used such as minutia Galt and detail
20:55things like that that's going to be
20:57where a ridge is flowing flowing along
20:59and abruptly ends call that an ending
21:01Ridge you also have ridges that flow
21:03along and then Branch into two ridges
21:04and that's called a bifurcation so
21:06that's the second level of detail that
21:08we're looking at in the analysis phase
21:11the third level of detail is pores on
21:14the friction Ridge surfaces there are
21:17pores that exude sweat the location
21:20shape and size of those pores is visible
21:23in some Impressions and the other part
21:25of third level detail would be the the
21:28shapes of the edges of The Ridges
21:31themselves so in the analysis phase
21:34we're looking for all of that
21:35information it's fact Gathering we're
21:37looking to see do we have level one
21:39detail do we have level two detail do we
21:41have level three
21:42detail that's all with just the latent
21:44impression then we move to the known
21:47Impressions or exemplars and we're
21:48performing an analysis let me stop you
21:51there okay what if you don't know who
21:52the person is when you go out to a scene
21:54you really don't know correct that's
21:56correct so are you familiar with
21:58something called aph yes what is aphis
22:01is an acronym correct it is and what
22:03does it aphis stand for aphis is the
22:06automated fingerprint identification
22:09system and without talking about the
22:12actual bank that's involved just I'm
22:15just talking about the machine I don't I
22:17don't want to know how the known go in
22:19there okay do you understand what I'm
22:20saying yes okay uh does this machine
22:24help you then make a comparison to other
22:28known that may be around yes or no yes
22:31and what is the advantage of having the
22:35AP system as opposed to a human being
22:38sitting down and making this
22:41comparison the apis system is a
22:43searching database so we're able to
22:46enter a latent print into the database
22:48the first joint of the fingers and the
22:50palms and it will create a mathematical
22:53algorithm and bring back 10 candidates
22:56that the computer believes are close to
22:58the lat an impression The Examiner then
23:01is able to well then let me stop you
23:02then are you telling me that the
23:04advantage of aphis is speed yes because
23:06it can go through thousands upon
23:08thousands of fingerprints within a very
23:10short period of time right yes and if
23:13any of them are similar then it spits it
23:15out right yes but as an examiner that's
23:19not an identification correct no it's
23:22not because then that's when the the
23:24human person comes in right yes and then
23:28the human person does what with those
23:32candidates that have been spit out the
23:35examiner initially views the latent and
23:38the known impression on the screen one
23:40at a time and determines whether or not
23:42they've um they have a hit if a hit is
23:46declared then a known Exemplar that
23:49known Exemplar will be obtained by The
23:51Examiner and a one one comparison will
23:53be performance between the latent and
23:54the known The Examiner is the one who
23:56does that compar final comparison
23:59in our talk today uh one of the things
24:02that we keep referring to is that the
24:04fingerprints and we've been talking
24:05about that how about palms for example
24:08are Palms also unique to individuals or
24:11is it a situation where the only
24:13comparison that can be done is involving
24:15the fingerprints no the arrangement of
24:19of skin on all the Palmer surface of the
24:21hands is unique and so once you let's
24:25say that you
24:26have does this apis system also have the
24:30palm prints in it that can be used or
24:32not yes it does when you look at a
24:35fingerprint and you're doing this
24:36comparison are you then also able to
24:38orient it and find out what part of the
24:42uh hand is involved whether it's one of
24:45the fingers or in the Palm can you do
24:46that it depends on the quality of the
24:49the latent well let's assume it's a
24:51great quality the best quality you ever
24:52had can you do it
24:54then in many cases yes and uh if you
24:58have the Palm you can tell what part of
25:01the Palm it is then right if there are
25:03certain if there's enough information in
25:05the Palm you can use those to help
25:08determine where the latent is from so in
25:11other words are you saying that if you
25:13have a palm print you cannot tell what
25:15part of the palm print it is what part
25:16of the Palm it is there are latent
25:19Impressions that are palm prints that
25:20are very clear that you cannot tell
25:22necessarily where it originates from on
25:25the hand on the yes correct but there's
25:27some that you can right yes so you are
25:30so that's part of what you do then
25:32correct that is part of is that done out
25:34at the scene or is that done somewhere
25:36else the entry of latent into aphys and
25:39the comparison of prints is done in the
25:40lab and so that the Gathering of these
25:44latent fingerprints how is that done out
25:46at the
25:47scene a majority of the processing that
25:50we'll do at a scene in order to collect
25:52Laten prints is done with powder and
25:54lift tape and the others which indicates
25:58that may be others what are the other
26:00processes that are out there there is
26:02some chemical uh processing techniques
26:04that we can use at the scene uh
26:06depending on the type of residue that we
26:08believe a latent impression may have
26:10been left in in this particular case for
26:13example was black powder the only method
26:18that was used at the scene to attempt to
26:19gather lightning prints no it was not
26:22why don't you tell me what those other
26:23processes were in this case lucco
26:26Crystal Violet and what is that
26:29that is a chemical um that is that
26:32reacts to the heem in hemoglobin to
26:34stain a dark purplish blue color if it
26:38comes into contact with it and what is
26:41the advantage of that what is the
26:43advantage of this Luc Crystal Violet
26:46lucco Crystal violet or
26:48lcv um is spec does not react with the
26:54regular constituents of fingerprint
26:55residue so if there's an impression that
26:58I believe is left potentially in oils or
27:02fats
27:03or lipids that sort of thing I would not
27:06use luuc crystal Violet lucco Crystal
27:09Violet would be used to search for
27:11potential Impressions that are left in
27:14blood for
27:16example so the value of Luco Crystal
27:19Violet is that the print may have been
27:22left in medium other than for example
27:25sweat or Oils or something like that
27:27correct that's correct and the way you
27:28sort of seem to say it it's specifically
27:30designed when you believe that perhaps
27:32the print is left in blood that's
27:35correct in this case also again as part
27:38of going to the scene lifting
27:40fingerprints and that sort of thing do
27:42you do anything with the evidence or
27:43items that are going to be taken back to
27:45the lab for future examination whether
27:47they be Laten fingerprints or whether
27:49they be anything else yes all items of
27:52evidentiary value are photographed and
27:54then collected by Meat which are then in
27:56turn impounded into our evidence section
27:58it would seem to me though that if you
28:00have all these items of evidence out
28:01there and if you're just photographing
28:03them and collecting them that you're not
28:04going to know where which is where you
28:06found something so for example if
28:08there's some shoes over there there's a
28:09gun over there how are you going to know
28:11what number what which is which the way
28:15in which we will document evidence to be
28:17collected is it will be marked typically
28:20with a an identifier such as a number we
28:23have what we call placards they look
28:26like small plastic tents that have
28:28numbers on them and we will typically
28:31put those next to an item of evidence
28:34photograph it with that placard to
28:37document how it will be identified
28:39later um that's with regard to items
28:42that you can take what about if there's
28:43an item one of the things that we've
28:44been talking about is L fingerprints or
28:46blood smears that sort of thing um how
28:48is it that do you also put a number by
28:50those or do you put a different sort of
28:52designation so that you know that what
28:53you have is something that you didn't
28:55take but you took a sample of certainly
28:58in in some cases a different type of
29:00identifier will be used in this case I
29:02used letters for those things that were
29:04photographed that could not be collected
29:07directly let me show you an exhibit you
29:10recognize exhibit
29:13249 yes I do what is
29:16it that is a diagram of a portion of the
29:20scene that I responded to which portion
29:23of the scene are we talking about it
29:25appears to be the master bedroom when
29:28it sounds like you're not sure are you
29:30sure or are you not sure yes it is it's
29:32the master bedroom closet and bathroom
29:35is this a true and accurate depiction of
29:37the scene as it existed when you were
29:40there and you conducted your work yes it
29:42is and how long were you there
29:44conducting your
29:46work we spent over three days at the
29:50crime scene when you say we it's sort of
29:51a royal thing I'm I'm not interested in
29:53what others may have done how long were
29:55you at the scene because that's what
29:56really is testifying
29:58three days all right and uh there were
30:01others that were there with you correct
30:03yes there were were there also
30:06technicians there with you yes and who
30:08else would have been there with you
30:09assisting throughout this
30:11event in what capacity in any capacity
30:15there were several detectives there at
30:17at various times um officers there was
30:21members of the biology unit of the Mesa
30:24Police Department and also another Laten
30:26print Examiner when you say uh the
30:30members of biolog biology unit what do
30:32they concentrate on uh DNA evidence and
30:36in this particular case you can see that
30:38there's a variety of numbers here and
30:41there's also red areas embodying that
30:44sort of thing is this a true and
30:45accurate depiction of all the items that
30:47were at seeing at the time that we were
30:49there during those three days in June of
30:502008
30:55Yes moment
30:59n ex exhibit 249 isend I think we may
31:02have already talked a little bit about
31:03this but just um your view area
31:12there where it says 44 and 24 do you see
31:15that there not from here I apologize I
31:18can't see
31:22that this area here do you see it here
31:25yes I do what is that area tell me a
31:28little bit about that area there that is
31:31the two doors those are the two doors
31:32leading into the master
31:34bedroom and those are numbers
31:37designating items of evidence that were
31:39collected from those doors with regard
31:42to the doors did were did you check or
31:46anybody that you you were supervising
31:49did anybody check to see what type of uh
31:52lock that was involved
31:54there there is a photograph of that
31:56locking mechanism and I have
31:59okay now after you walk in there and you
32:02take a look at this right here what is
32:05this that's marked this 45 I mean what
32:07are we looking at there 45 is a piece of
32:11carpeting that was at the
32:13entry to the hallway leading to the
32:16master bathroom that had a large area of
32:18red staining on it that was collected
32:20and did you walk down that hallway yes
32:23and as you walk down that hallway
32:28where did it take you to the master
32:30bathroom and once in the master B
32:34bathroom where is the tub in comparison
32:37to the door as you walk in it would be
32:39to your left and is that where the body
32:42was from the body was found in the
32:44shower that was to the left yes and just
32:46just to make clear they had both a
32:48bathtub and a shower correct yes was the
32:52body found in the shower I think is what
32:53you said correct yes all right let's
32:55take a look at some thanks
33:05take a look at exhibits one through S
33:08and see if you recognize what's depicted
33:10there guys what's there yes I do and
33:13what areas do those photographs
33:17depict this depicts the entry in the
33:20front of the home that I responded to
33:23the garage and a portion of the laundry
33:25room of that scene those true and ACC
33:28depictions of those areas again as they
33:30were on the date that you responded and
33:32took and were there yes they
33:44are no objection exhibits one through
33:47seven are
33:54admitted so we're going to take a f
33:56minute recess
34:00actually we'll make it a 10-minute
34:02recess
34:04uh so ladies and gentlemen be back in
34:06the designated area at 20 minutes till 3
34:09and we will resume promptly at that time
34:11please remember the admonition you are
34:20excused FTR is not currently working
34:24she's rebooting the computer so we need
34:25to make sure it's working before we can
34:27proceed
34:29proceed yes you can you can take a
34:34recess we are at
34:43recess the record will show the presence
34:45of the jury the defendant and all
34:47counsel you may
34:49proceed Heather Conor let's take a look
34:52at exhibit number one
34:58which I don't believe the monitors are
35:03on what are we looking at
35:06here this is the front of the
35:11house and the exposure of the house what
35:13direction is towards my pan This Way
35:18North okay wouldn't that be that way
35:20North that way rather than this way
35:21isn't this
35:23sound let's take continue looking at it
35:25okay exhibit number two
35:30what is
35:31that that is another view of the front
35:33of the house showing the front
35:36door and it also shows a closer up of
35:39what the vehicles that are parked in the
35:41garage and driveway and how many are
35:43there three
35:46total and exhibit
35:51number three
35:58what are we looking at
35:59there that is a photograph of the front
36:02door entry and the numbers of the
36:04residents and what's the address of the
36:06residents
36:0811428 and what's the Street Queens
36:20orrow zibit number four
36:28what do we see
36:29there that is a photograph of the open
36:33garage door view into the garage and the
36:35two cars in that garage what kind of car
36:37is this do you
36:39know a Toyota Prius
36:43okay and the color given how glary this
36:48photograph is what color was it when you
36:50were out there do you know I believe it
36:52was black okay
36:58exhibit number
37:01five the rear of that Toyota
37:04Prius
37:08okay if you
37:11then look over here to the right do you
37:14see what that
37:16is that is a doorway leading from the
37:18garage into the laundry room of the
37:21residents then
37:29and this right here is
37:34what it appears to be a garage door
37:36opener okay and this right
37:41here I don't know what that is you
37:43familiar with light switches yes does
37:45that look like it could be a light
37:48switch it it appears to
37:50be and then if
37:54we just shows us the rest of the garage
37:57and
37:58what's here correct yes and do you know
38:02what this
38:03is a bicycle
38:10okay now exhibit number six
38:16is
38:18what that is a view a a a a view of the
38:23laundry room that includes the washer
38:26and dryer that we're in inside that room
38:28and this door here where's does that
38:31lead to that door leads to the garage
38:35and if we take a look at exhibit
38:37number
38:39five do you see this door here yes I do
38:43are those one in the same doors they
38:50are exhibit number
38:52seven also shows us a door are you
38:55familiar with which door this this one
38:58is I believe that is the same door we've
39:01been discussing from the laundry room to
39:03the garage when you say you believe it
39:04sort of implies that you're not sure
39:06take a look at
39:08it and then if we take a look
39:11at exhibit number
39:14six you see that same door those are the
39:17same doors and is this then the door
39:20that leads out to the garage yes it is
39:23and what is this up here
39:27alarm keypad of some
39:29kind take a look at some more
39:33photographs take a look at exib 8
39:36through
39:3816 do you recognize those photographs
39:41yes I do what do they depict these
39:43photographs depict the washing machine
39:46and the contents of that washing machine
39:48and again were these photographs taken
39:51at the time of the investigation back in
39:53June of 2008 of this one yes they were I
39:57move for the admission of exhibits
39:59numbers 8 through
40:0316 exhibits 8 through 16 are admitted
40:07first of all let's take a look at
40:09exhibit number six that's the one that
40:13uh we just talked
40:19about and what is this right here that
40:23is a dryer and this right here washing
40:26machine all
40:31right exhibit number eight shows us what
40:35what are we looking at
40:38here that is a reddish stain that was on
40:42top of the the edge of the washing
40:48machine exhibit uh number nine what are
40:53we looking at there that is looking at
40:55the same area of the washing machine
40:57pulled back a little bit with some label
41:00some stickers to label and identify some
41:02stains seen on the washing
41:04machine are these the reddish stains
41:06that you guys were looking at or just
41:08stains generally reddish brown
41:14stains there's a red number on there you
41:19see
41:22that I'm red I'm sorry black you see
41:25that yes um um I thought in our previous
41:29discussion we indicated that if it's
41:31something that you can't seize or that
41:34you take a swab from that you would
41:36actually would give it a
41:37letter what's going on with these ones
41:40in
41:41Black these particular stains were
41:44labeled by a member of the biology unit
41:46so that presumptive testing could be
41:49performed I wasn't involved in these
41:52labels so in other words these are
41:54labeled by somebody from the D the
41:56biology unit to see see whether or not
41:57this was blood or something right
42:04correct exhibit number 10 is a closeup
42:08of one of those ones correct yes it is
42:11and if we bring it in a little bit
42:13closer it has something to the side of
42:16it you see that I do what is that the
42:19letter B so for example then if we go to
42:22the previous
42:24exhibit there are two ones there
42:28one would be either well we can look at
42:33it we can see that they're labeled with
42:35letters also correct this one is yes and
42:39then if you take a look at the other
42:41one doesn't seem to have a letter on
42:43there though right it does
42:51not exhibit number 11 what are we uh
42:55give you a better view of that
43:03what are we looking at there that is a
43:06photograph into the washing machine when
43:08the lid was lifted during the entry
43:10photos and there are some items in there
43:13correct yes there are this
43:20is exhibit number
43:2412 what are we looking at there that's a
43:27digital camera that was found inside of
43:30the washing machine and for the sake of
43:32completeness is this the way the camera
43:35was at the time that you guys went into
43:39it and started taking photographs of it
43:41yes it was and uh you were there on what
43:46dates June 10th 11th and 12th and it ran
43:51into the 13th on the 12th all right
43:57exhibit number
43:5913 what are we seeing
44:02here that is another photograph of the
44:05contents of the washing machine now with
44:07those evidence placards that I discussed
44:09to identify items that were going to be
44:11collected right 39 is what 39 is all of
44:16the contents of
44:19the the the washing machine with the
44:21exception of the camera so this is all
44:24the clothing articles and 38 is the
44:25camera that's correct
44:28and exhibit number
44:3214 is that just a different view of how
44:35the items are placed in there yes it
44:39is in just looking at this and you were
44:42there and that's the reason why I'm
44:43asking it doesn't seem like this is a
44:44full load does
44:48it
44:52over it didn't appear to be full no
44:59exhibit number 15 what are we looking at
45:02there that is a photograph of the camera
45:05after it's been removed from the washing
45:07machine and placed on butcher paper in
45:09order to take additional uh Vantage
45:12viewpoints of that camera and exhibit
45:15number 16 is what a top view of the
45:23camera let's take a look at exhibit
45:25number
45:32no thank you this is a digital camera is
45:36this a digital camera that we see
45:38pictured in exhibit
45:40number
45:4416 may I refer to my report your honor
45:47in order to refresh my recollection yes
45:49you
45:54may I agree
46:0026
46:04and this is the same camera that is
46:06depicted in the wash that's was
46:08collected from inside the washing
46:10machine but inside of that plastic is
46:14something else inside the camera
46:16right yes do you know what that
46:20is looks like power cords of some kind
46:24right but uh as as far as you're
46:26concerned the only thing that was taken
46:27from that washing machine is the camera
46:30that's in that exhibit correct yes I may
46:33have it
46:52back right exhibit 214 is admitted and
46:55it will be repackaged the power
46:59cord
47:00correct you know whether or not there
47:02was a SIM card attached to this thing
47:07there was a memory card inside of the
47:08washing machine that was also
47:10collected okay please take a look at
47:12exhibit
47:15number do you recognize that yes what is
47:18it this is the memory card that was
47:21collected from inside the washing
47:24machine and
47:27that actually packaged it I guess
47:28correct when it was originally in the
47:30envelope
47:31yes Mo for the admission of exhibit
47:3725 no objection 25 is
47:45admitted and what we're actually looking
47:47at is
47:48this square or rectangular blue thing
47:52correct yes it's not do you know the
47:54dimensions of this
47:57or is it just very small it's
48:00small let's take a look at exhibit
48:03Number
48:04220 you recognize that yes I do what is
48:08it this is what I labeled as a digital
48:10camera door that was found at the bottom
48:13of the washing machine and was collected
48:16was this after the clothing had been
48:17removed
48:22yes I move for the admission of exhibit
48:25number 2
48:3420 no objection y 220 is
48:37admitted and then this is the item that
48:39you collect right here correct yes it
48:43is let's take a look at
48:47exhibits
48:5117
48:5425 you recog those photographs yes I do
48:58what do they show they show the items
49:01that were removed from the washing
49:03machine as uh item number 39 laid out it
49:07also shows additional items of evidence
49:10that were identified to be collected
49:12with evidence placards and the contents
49:14of the dryer with regard to item 39 what
49:18was that that's all the clothing items
49:21that were in that that washing machine
49:24okay I move for the admission of exhibit
49:27numbers 17 through
49:2925 no objection exhibits 17 through 25
49:34are
49:35admitted go ahead and take a look at
49:39these exhibit
49:44number
49:4717 we see the placard 39 what is this up
49:52here it's a towel all right and directly
49:55underneath it what are those socks and
49:59to the
50:00left those are also socks
50:05okay it does seem
50:09that do you see this part up here on the
50:12towel I do does seem that the towel is a
50:15bit discolored doesn't
50:17it yes it
50:21does exhibit number
50:2418 is that the same towel
50:27yes it is and it shows this other end
50:29here right yes what is this right
50:34here a
50:36t-shirt or a shirt of some
50:40kind do you know what this is right here
50:43I know the glare is bad but I I don't
50:45recall specifically the particular
50:48clothing items that were
50:51contained and exhibit
50:55number 19
50:5819 do you know what these are right
51:01here
51:03underwear and
51:06this another
51:08shirt and these right
51:11here they appear to be shorts
51:35they appear to be all those items in the
51:46photographs scissors why don't you go
51:48ahead open up take a look at what's in
51:49there and then tell me if this is in
51:52fact item your item 39 okay
51:57yes this is item
52:0439 I for the admission of
52:07exib no exhibit 26 is
52:17admitted yes it
52:19does what bleach is yes I am what is
52:23bleach it's a liquid that we use to
52:27clean our our clean various things and
52:30do you know what it bleach does to a
52:32item that has color to it it will take
52:35that color out and and cause spotting
52:39with regard to the
52:41towel does that is that consistent with
52:44bleach being added to the
52:50load you may answer yes or no over
52:53rolled yes
53:10what is that a
53:12t-shirt you know what size it is on
53:17there it's medium and does it also have
53:21some spotting there yes it
53:24does let's see what else we have
53:35those are
53:38thewe yes what else do we
53:52have what are those pair of shorts
53:57let's see what else we have in that
54:07thing what is that a
54:10t-shirt what
54:17else let's start with one sock you have
54:19a blue sock in your left hand right yes
54:21okay
54:24next what color is that mostly gray does
54:28it have any spotting on it yes it does
54:30all right
54:36else what is that a black
54:40sock go
54:45ahead another sock yes what
54:51else is that a sock it is all right
54:58another so
55:01yes and another
55:08so and that's also another correct yes
55:11it is those all the
55:16Articles no they're not what
55:23else what is
55:25that pair of of pants are you familiar
55:29with the term sweatpants yes would that
55:32be what that is yes what size
55:36are they're marked men's large anything
55:40else
55:52that and what is that a T-shirt and
55:55what's the that
55:58t-shirt largea have that
56:20back let's take a look at another
56:22exhibit it's exhibit number 20
56:27and if we take a look at first of all
56:29exhibit 37 what is that or item 37 not
56:32exhibit 37 I apologize that is the
56:35memory card that was originally in the
56:37washing machine and then was collected
56:39as item 37 and it's what was the color
56:42of that memory
56:44card from my recollection it's blue
56:48okay
56:49and then we have some numbers here 40
56:52and 41 first of all this Appliance to
56:55the right is a what that's a
57:00dryer and now we have a closeup exhibit
57:0321
57:05of those items as in relation to the
57:09dryer correct yes and what is item 40 40
57:13is a piece of duct tape that was found
57:15on the floor in the laundry
57:20room and exhibit 22 shows us a closeup
57:23of that right yes
57:28exhibit 23 is the SIM card that we've
57:31been talking about right yes it
57:38is and
57:39exhibit 24 is a close-up of that right
57:45yes now exhibit
57:5025 are a bunch of items right yes it is
57:54and they were in the dry do you know
57:56what was in the
57:59drive beding items do you have uh your
58:03um the exhibit up there that will tell
58:04you what was in there yes I
58:11do I have it labeled as bedding
58:15items
58:18at
58:21exhibit 36
58:26sorry 30 28 I apologize 28
58:32through let's do it this way 27 28 29
58:3730 and
58:4226 you recognize that yes I do what is
58:45it those are photographs of the items
58:48from inside the dryer as well as a
58:50photograph of them inside the dryer and
58:53are these true and accurate depictions
58:54of those items back when the
58:55investigation was conducted in June of
58:572008 yes they are I move for the
59:00admission of exhibits
59:10numbers no obje exhibits 26 through 30
59:14are
59:21admitted that is a view of the contents
59:23of the dryer and the items that we're
59:25going to be colleting is item
59:3341 exhibit number 27 what are we looking
59:38at
59:40here that is a overall photograph of all
59:43of the contents of 40 of the of the
59:45dryer that were to be collected as 41
59:47laid out
59:50separated and exhibit 28
59:57what are we looking at here a portion of
59:59the contents of the
1:00:05dryer 30 I'm sorry
1:00:0829 those are additional contents of the
1:00:12dryer and finally number 30 what is that
1:00:16that is also something removed from the
1:00:19dryer take a look at um exhibit number
1:00:23212
1:00:44yes I recognize this what is it this is
1:00:47the um all the contents of the dryer as
1:00:50collected as item 41 I believe
1:00:57it is item it's excuse me it is item
1:01:0041 do you need more gloves to open it
1:01:04and get into that if we're going to put
1:01:06them out I would like some additional
1:01:07books
1:01:14please would you like me to cut this
1:01:16open entirely just enough so that we can
1:01:19p the it
1:01:45what is
1:01:46that a
1:01:48pillowcase all right what else do we
1:01:53have is it all right to lay them
1:01:55directly on the desk as I pull them out
1:01:57or would you like them put back in the
1:01:58bag you feel comfortable put them on the
1:02:00seat of the chair how about that all
1:02:11right and what is that a pillowcase
1:02:14right
1:02:20next that it's another pillowcase
1:02:30that is what a towel
1:02:39okay what are those a pair of pants do
1:02:43they have a size on
1:02:44them yes they do what size is that size
1:02:48large next
1:03:00what is that an additional
1:03:12pillowcase it's another pillowcase
1:03:27is that the last item in there no it's
1:03:30not right is that this is a bed covering
1:03:34of some sort with
1:03:37buttons
1:03:42so what else is in
1:03:58what is that a fitted sheet anything
1:04:17else what is that a flat sheet
1:04:33that another pillowcase I believe that's
1:04:38all yes it is
1:05:03for
1:05:34ma'am let me show you exhibits 31
1:05:36through
1:05:3946 and you recognize yes I
1:05:43do these are photographs of a portion of
1:05:46the downstairs of the house to include
1:05:47the laundry room office and downstairs
1:05:50bathroom as well as items inside those
1:05:52rooms and are these true and accurate
1:05:54depictions of seen as it existed
1:05:57backe yes they
1:06:02are exhibits 31 through 46 are admitted
1:06:06start with exhibit
1:06:1231 and what are we looking at here that
1:06:16is another view of the laundry room uh
1:06:20from the vantage point of the doorway
1:06:22leading into the garage into the corner
1:06:25what is this door here is this door
1:06:27leading to the garage or is that the
1:06:28door leading somewhere else that door
1:06:30leads into the house further into the
1:06:37house and exhibit 32 what is this that
1:06:42is the view into the laundry room
1:06:44through that doorway that we just
1:06:46discussed where is the doorway leading
1:06:49to the garage in this Photograph if you
1:06:51were to enter through that doorway it
1:06:53would be to your right okay
1:07:0633 this area here what is this back
1:07:09here that's the laundry room and what's
1:07:13to the left here do you know there is a
1:07:15closet and a doorway leading to an
1:07:18office space and to the right here
1:07:21what's there a
1:07:24bathroom do you know what what this item
1:07:26is
1:07:28here if you
1:07:30know it looks like a
1:07:33punching apparatus of some
1:07:39kind exhibit 34 first of all in the
1:07:43corner here what is this right
1:07:45here that's the doorway leading from the
1:07:47house into the laundry room and this
1:07:50right
1:07:51here that is the entryway into the
1:07:54office space
1:07:56exhibit
1:07:5935 first of all we look what is this
1:08:01right here the laundry
1:08:04room and here the office
1:08:11space exhibit number
1:08:1536 what is that that's the view of the
1:08:18office space from the
1:08:21doorway exhibit 37 is
1:08:26a a different view in the office space
1:08:28from a different corner of the
1:08:32room exhibit number
1:08:3938 what are we looking at there that is
1:08:43the desk in the office space and there
1:08:45are items marked with evidence placards
1:08:47in that
1:08:48photograph this up here what is that up
1:08:52here do you see that white item there
1:08:54it's a closet door
1:09:00item I'm sorry exhibit
1:09:0339 what do we see
1:09:05here that is a photograph of the item
1:09:08that was collected as item 35 lb and
1:09:10it's a
1:09:15check take a look at exhibit number 222
1:09:25it yes what is it this is the the Box
1:09:30including the check that was collected
1:09:31as item 35
1:09:38okay I move for the admission of exhibit
1:09:44222 no
1:09:46objection exhibit 222 is
1:09:50admitted let take a look at that
1:10:03first of all what is the date on
1:10:06it
1:10:085258 and what's the amount of the
1:10:11check
1:10:13200 and who's the person what's the
1:10:17account what's the name holder on the
1:10:20account jod Aras it does have an address
1:10:23can you read that address or not I can
1:10:27what is it
1:10:299634 East Neo Avenue
1:10:33nio Mesa Arizona
1:10:3885209 D
1:10:402243 and the person that it's made out
1:10:43to Travis
1:10:45Alexander and what's the amount of the
1:10:47check I think you
1:10:49already 2 and0
1:10:53C and what is it for can you see what
1:10:55that's
1:10:56for the note section indicates car
1:11:00payments D April and May 2008 and is it
1:11:04signed yes or no
1:11:13yes exhibit number 40 is what what are
1:11:17we looking at
1:11:24here that an additional view of a
1:11:26different corner of the office space
1:11:29from a different Vantage
1:11:34Point exhibit
1:11:3641 what uh do we see
1:11:40here that's the final corner of the
1:11:42office space and you're seeing the entry
1:11:44doorway from where the photographer is
1:11:46standing if we were to take a right
1:11:48where would we be headed
1:11:51towards out of the door right you'd be
1:11:54headed towards the living Liv area and
1:11:56kitchen if you went to the right if we
1:11:58were to go left where would would be we
1:12:01be going the laundry
1:12:05room exhibit number 42 is
1:12:09what that's a photograph of the
1:12:12downstairs bathroom from the doorway is
1:12:14that straight across from that door that
1:12:16we just saw essentially straight across
1:12:20maybe a bit to the left and
1:12:23across and exhibit
1:12:2643 shows us what another view of the
1:12:30inside of that downstairs
1:12:33bathroom exhibit
1:12:3644 what are we looking at
1:12:39there that is a labeled stain that was
1:12:43tested by our biology unit and that has
1:12:46a number three by there right
1:12:49yes exhibit uh
1:12:5345 is what
1:12:56that's a view of a stain a reddish brown
1:12:59stain inside of the sink in that
1:13:00downstairs bathroom that was tested by
1:13:02the biology unit and exhibit 46 shows us
1:13:06what that's a closeup of the stain from
1:13:09inside the sink of the downstairs
1:13:12bathroom let's take a look at exhibits
1:13:1647
1:13:17through 61
1:13:26what are they these are photographs of
1:13:28the remainder of the house the
1:13:30downstairs portion of the house the
1:13:32staircase leading to The Loft upstairs
1:13:35and uh the stairway itself all right and
1:13:39again for these accurate depictions of
1:13:41when you were out of the scene back in
1:13:42June of 2008 yes they are for the
1:13:45admission of a tibits 47 through
1:13:4961 no objection y exits 47 through 61
1:13:54are admitted
1:14:07okay what are we looking at
1:14:09here that's a view of the dining room
1:14:13living room area and the hallway that
1:14:15led down to the office space laundry
1:14:17room and downstairs bathroom in the far
1:14:19portion of the photograph and what is
1:14:21this right here that's that punching
1:14:26apparatus that was in in near that
1:14:30hallway number
1:14:3348 that's a view of the front door from
1:14:39that dining room living room area
1:14:41where's the uh laundry room door from
1:14:44here it would be to your to my left
1:14:47where your pen is leading yes that
1:14:53direction and I guess ask about this 48
1:14:56what is this right
1:14:59here a floor cleaner of some
1:15:07kind
1:15:1149 that's a view of the entry room and
1:15:16the front door and what are these items
1:15:18here do you
1:15:19know they're metal grids of
1:15:22of materials that are linked together by
1:15:24the round pieces
1:15:29okay exhibit number 50 is
1:15:36what you're seeing a view of the
1:15:40kitchen um from the area that had the
1:15:43couches near the dining
1:15:46area okay and what's this right
1:15:49here that's the stair staircase
1:15:56exhibit uh 51 do we see that same
1:15:59staircase yes is that right there yes it
1:16:05is exhibit
1:16:1252 what are we looking at
1:16:15there that's a view from the hallway
1:16:17that you would enter from the front door
1:16:19looking into the dining kitchen living
1:16:22area and the the beginning of the
1:16:25staircase and these things right here
1:16:27what are
1:16:30those those metal grids similar to what
1:16:33was shown in that entry area but those
1:16:35are not aligned in any way right in
1:16:37other words they're not put up
1:16:41no exhibit
1:16:4453 now what are we looking
1:16:47at you're seeing a view down the hallway
1:16:51towards the laundry room office space
1:16:54bathroom as well as as a portion of the
1:16:55staircase to show their relationship to
1:16:57each other and this is the staircase
1:17:00right here yes it
1:17:03is exhibit uh
1:17:1154 shows us what that is a view of the
1:17:15staircase and what you see from the
1:17:16bottom of the
1:17:20staircase exhibit
1:17:2355 is What A View From about halfway up
1:17:27the stairs slightly more
1:17:34perhaps exhibit 56
1:17:39is that is showing a small F possible
1:17:43fiber piece
1:17:44of
1:17:46fabric that was collected as an item of
1:17:51evidence exhibit number 57
1:17:56that is what that's a closeup of that
1:17:59that item that was um identified and as
1:18:01an item of evidence and collected later
1:18:05on now number 58 what are we looking at
1:18:10here that is a view from a corner of the
1:18:13Loft that is at the top of the staircase
1:18:16it's showing the area where the
1:18:19staircase ends and the entry into the
1:18:21master bedroom and is this the master
1:18:24bedroom
1:18:26door
1:18:29yes exhibit number
1:18:3459 that is showing a black bag that was
1:18:38um identified as an item of evidence to
1:18:40be collected in The
1:18:48Loft familiar with exhibit number 231
1:19:03yes I am what is it this is the item
1:19:06that I collected as item number 24 lb
1:19:09it's the door knob um from the right
1:19:12door of the master bedroom double doors
1:19:19okay move for the admission of exhibit
1:19:21number 231
1:19:30objection none your honor is
1:19:50admitted take a look at this exhibit and
1:19:53describe
1:19:54and unlocking mechanisms of of this
1:19:58door
1:20:03Appliance the unlocking mechanism is a
1:20:07key hole okay the locking
1:20:12mechanism is a flat piece that's turned
1:20:16which one was on the inside and which
1:20:18one was on the outside of that door the
1:20:20inside was the locking mechanism which
1:20:23has the flat piece that turn turns and
1:20:25the exterior door knob was the one that
1:20:28has the unlocking key mechanism on it so
1:20:31in order to get into that room if if it
1:20:33had been locked from the inside would a
1:20:35person need a
1:20:36key yes and in order to lock it if you
1:20:40were inside would a person need a key or
1:20:43would they just need to turn the knob or
1:20:45the item
1:20:48there a key would not NE be necessary so
1:20:53does that mean that the person could
1:20:55just turn the little knob there or bump
1:20:58or whatever and close it from the inside
1:21:01and lock it
1:21:07[Applause]
1:21:10yes exhibit
1:21:13231 the item that we're looking here at
1:21:15here is that the inside or the outside
1:21:17it was the interior door knob and you
1:21:20were talking about turning this is what
1:21:21you would turn correct yes to lock it
1:21:24and this portion of it right here is
1:21:27that the inside or the outside that was
1:21:29the exterior side of the door knob and
1:21:31that's the one that would require the
1:21:32key correct
1:21:39yes exhibit number 60 is what what are
1:21:43we looking at there that is a closer
1:21:46view of that black bag from The Loft
1:21:48that was collected as item 31
1:21:50lb and exhibit 61
1:21:58what is that that's a view of the
1:22:00contents of that black
1:22:06bag take a look at exib
1:22:2323 you recognize it yes I do what is it
1:22:28this is the black camera bag that was
1:22:30collected as item 31 lb all
1:22:50right no objection to3 is admitted
1:22:55you want gloves for this or not I'd
1:22:57prefer gloves yes get them for you thank
1:22:59you
1:23:50there's a
1:23:52strap a lens attach
1:23:59sometimes that appears to be everything
1:24:05all let's take a look at
1:24:09exhibits
1:24:1062 through
1:24:1872 yes I do what are this these are
1:24:21photographs of the entry uh into the
1:24:23master bedroom the master bedroom itself
1:24:26the master bedroom closet and a portion
1:24:28of the bathroom in the master
1:24:31bedroom number 62 through
1:24:3673 Council exhibits 63 64 and 68 have
1:24:40already been admitted that's correct
1:24:43talk yes so no objections
1:24:47to those those photos previously not
1:24:49admitted being admitted all right 62
1:24:52through 72 will be
1:24:57Ed let's take a look
1:25:06at and what are we looking at
1:25:10here that is the view into the master
1:25:12bedroom from the the the doorway and
1:25:17we've taken a look at the lock or the
1:25:20the the door handle haven't we before
1:25:23yes we have
1:25:26exhibit
1:25:28number 65 shows us
1:25:33what a view of the bedroom the master
1:25:36bedroom specifically what the
1:25:39bed and one of the sides of the
1:25:42bedroom um in this one we see that the
1:25:46bedding if you will is crumpled up on
1:25:47the bed do you see that yes I do is that
1:25:51the way the bed was found when you were
1:25:54there
1:25:55it was that was how it appeared when I
1:25:56was there
1:26:00yes 66 shows us
1:26:03what that's another view of the bed from
1:26:06the opposite side and more of the
1:26:08bedroom
1:26:09itself and what is this right
1:26:12here that is a doorway leading one of
1:26:15the doorways um in the master bedroom
1:26:18closet so where does it lead to is there
1:26:21more than two doors from the bedroom
1:26:23going into the bedroom closet no that's
1:26:26the doorway from the bedroom to the
1:26:28closet all
1:26:34right exhibit 67 what are we looking at
1:26:37there that is a view from inside the
1:26:41master bedroom of that doorway from the
1:26:43bedroom to the closet the entryway to
1:26:46the hallway that leads down to the
1:26:47bathroom and the door into the master
1:26:50bedroom
1:26:55exhibit 69 shows us
1:26:58what that is a view of the interior of
1:27:02the master bedroom closet from that
1:27:04doorway from the bedroom into the closet
1:27:08and what is this right
1:27:10here that is a doorway leading from the
1:27:12master bedroom closet into the master
1:27:14bathroom while you were there did you
1:27:16notice whether or not there was any
1:27:18blood in this area here in the master
1:27:21bedroom closet I did not any blood in
1:27:24that area or red staining and if it had
1:27:28been there and marked would you have
1:27:29photographed
1:27:32it what was the
1:27:35objection it's outside your scope overr
1:27:39you may answer can you please repeat the
1:27:41question if was if there was a stain
1:27:43that was marked there would you have
1:27:44photographed it yes and were you the
1:27:46person that actually actually look for
1:27:48these stains or
1:27:49not I was not okay but you would have
1:27:53photographed anything that was marked
1:27:55there correct
1:27:57yes number
1:28:0070 what do we see
1:28:03here that's a deeper view into the
1:28:05closet from that same Vantage Point um
1:28:08showing some of the contents and this
1:28:10right here that is the doorway leading
1:28:13into the master bathroom from the closet
1:28:16and if we look down here what is this
1:28:19area
1:28:20here carpeting inside the closet okay
1:28:24okay and that and this right
1:28:26here that's tile in the
1:28:32bathroom exhibit uh 71 if we start at
1:28:36the top what are we looking at
1:28:39here that is a view into the master
1:28:41bathroom from the doorway in the closet
1:28:44leading into the bathroom and this right
1:28:47here is what Carpeting and right here
1:28:51tile and then if we go back here what is
1:28:54this area
1:28:56here the vanity and sinks from within
1:28:59the master bathroom and this right here
1:29:01what is
1:29:02that a door for a linen closet inside
1:29:05the master
1:29:06bathroom and this hallway that we've
1:29:08been talking
1:29:12about take a look at exhibit number 67
1:29:15told us about this hallway
1:29:18here we take a look at the exhibit
1:29:21number
1:29:2271 where would the hallway
1:29:26be in relationship to this door sink
1:29:31it's to the right so it'll be right down
1:29:33this way that's
1:29:37correct exhibit 72 starting here what is
1:29:41this right
1:29:41here that is the door and doorway that
1:29:45is leading to the master bedroom closet
1:29:48and this right here is what a portion of
1:29:51that hallway we've
1:29:52discussed that what what I didn't hear
1:29:54you I didn't the hallway that we've
1:29:56discussed okay and this right here is
1:29:58what the door for the linen closet
1:30:01that's in the master bathroom where does
1:30:03this hallway
1:30:05lead to the master bedroom and if we
1:30:08take a look
1:30:12at exhibit number
1:30:1667 is this what you're talking about the
1:30:19hallway that we just discussed yes it is
1:30:27and this right here is the bathtub in
1:30:30the
1:30:31bathroom and right
1:30:34here that's the
1:30:36shower and this that's the victim inside
1:30:39of the
1:30:40shower and this greenish
1:30:44bluish I believe it's a robe
1:31:05through
1:31:0680 82
1:31:36what are they these are photographs of
1:31:38the victim additional photographs of the
1:31:41bathroom and some items from inside the
1:31:42bathroom and again were they as they
1:31:45existed back in June of 2008
1:31:49Yes move for the admission of exhibits
1:31:5177 through
1:31:5880
1:32:0482 through
1:32:0787 no objection exhibits 77 through 87
1:32:12are
1:32:15admitted these
1:32:24exhibit number
1:32:2676 what are we looking at there that's a
1:32:28photograph of the victim inside of the
1:32:30shower and a plastic cup that was found
1:32:32in the shower with the
1:32:40victim take a look at exhibit
1:32:48230 recognize
1:32:52it yes I do what is it this is that
1:32:55plastic cup from inside the shower it
1:32:58looks kind of black or dark is that mold
1:33:00or what is that this item was processed
1:33:03in the laboratory for lat prints and you
1:33:06indicated that there was a couple of
1:33:08processes that could be used one of them
1:33:09being uh powder and and the other one
1:33:13being nuc Crystal W
1:33:16correct those were types of processing
1:33:19that we do at a scene right yes but in
1:33:21this one powder was used right
1:33:24this item was brought back to the
1:33:26laboratory and was processed with a
1:33:27variety of different things all right
1:33:30and we any results
1:33:33obtained refer to my reports
1:33:53no no Laten prints were developed on the
1:33:55plastic cut one of the things that you
1:33:57told us was that there were
1:33:58environmental factors that would affect
1:34:00whether or not not an individual leaves
1:34:02a lat and fingerprint do you remember we
1:34:04discussed that earlier yes I do with
1:34:06regard to water if water is run on an
1:34:08item is will that affect the ability to
1:34:10later obtain a latent fingerprint it can
1:34:13yes why in some cases if water is run
1:34:18over a surface it may obscure that
1:34:20latent impression that was left behind
1:34:22it could wash away the res res do or
1:34:25something of that
1:34:26nature and how about if the person is
1:34:28turning the cup as they're doing
1:34:31whatever it is they're doing with it
1:34:32would that also affect whether or not
1:34:34they might uh leave behind a usable
1:34:37Laten fingerprint how an item is handled
1:34:40will always affect how whether or not a
1:34:42latent print is is Left Behind or not I
1:34:45move for the admission
1:34:50of no objection 230 is admitted
1:34:55exhibit number
1:34:5977 what are we looking
1:35:05at it's a lower view of the victim
1:35:08inside of the shower
1:35:10stall and what is this right
1:35:13here is that the wall I guess is what
1:35:15I'm saying yes it's the wall of the
1:35:17shower stall
1:35:20and is his this is his right foot
1:35:22correct
1:35:24yes it is is that touching that wall yes
1:35:27it is how about the left knee is that
1:35:29also touching the wall yes and if we
1:35:32look over here to the right uh what
1:35:35portion of his Anatomy is that it's his
1:35:37right knee is that touching the wall
1:35:39also it looks like it is I don't know
1:35:42specifically if it is or not if we go
1:35:45back to exhibit number
1:35:4876 his head correct yes it is is that up
1:35:51against the um
1:35:54portion of the the shower there yes it
1:36:01is now exhibit 78 we're starting to see
1:36:05first of all the victim's body here
1:36:06correct that is the victim inside the
1:36:08shower stall yes and two three and four
1:36:11what what are we looking at there those
1:36:14were some hair and fiber like materials
1:36:16that were found around the shower stall
1:36:19that were designated to be collected as
1:36:20items of
1:36:21evidence and exhibit number 79 we're
1:36:25also looking at this area here right two
1:36:29is actually just indicating the hairs
1:36:31that you see here on the floor right but
1:36:34you can see the red staining in this
1:36:37Photograph and this is what is this the
1:36:39trim right here baseboard trim of some
1:36:42kind yes and there's also some staining
1:36:44up here correct yes and there's also
1:36:46staining here
1:36:49yes exhibit number 80 is
1:36:56what that's a fiberlike material that
1:36:59was found on the floor in the bathroom
1:37:01that was collected as item number three
1:37:05lb and exhibit number 82 we're now
1:37:08looking at what you can see a small
1:37:11portion of the shower stall with the
1:37:12victim inside the bathtub and a doorway
1:37:16leading into what I call the toilet room
1:37:18the toilets contained in that room
1:37:20there's a door and then a portion of the
1:37:23bathroom B um to the right side of the
1:37:25photograph what's this right here it's a
1:37:31towel take a look at exhibit number 228
1:37:35see if you recognize it yes I recognize
1:37:37it what is it this is that same towel
1:37:40from the master bathroom was there one
1:37:42or two towels
1:37:44there I believe there's only one when
1:37:47you say you believe it means you're not
1:37:48sure I why don't you go ahead and open
1:37:49it and take a look at it and make sure
1:37:51okay
1:37:55it's a single towel why don't you hold
1:37:57it up for
1:38:00us what's the exhibit number on it
1:38:03please it's the green
1:38:06tag 228 I move for the admission of
1:38:09exhibit
1:38:10228 228 is admitted
1:38:14you take a look at the label there on
1:38:17there
1:38:24it says Bianca b i a n CA concept
1:38:29by Mundo textile m u n d o t x t i l all
1:38:36one word
1:38:49[Applause]
1:39:12um this is the
1:39:14towel that you previously looked at and
1:39:17it's
1:39:19from exhibit number 216 from the washer
1:39:23do you remember talking about that yes I
1:39:25do why don't you read a label on this
1:39:28one for
1:39:33me it's labeled Bianca concept by Mundo
1:39:37textile do the at least the labels are
1:39:40they from do the labels match how about
1:39:43that yes they do
1:39:46right and if we hold these two up I'll
1:39:49hold this one here you hold the other
1:39:51one up
1:39:57they seem to be a little bit different
1:39:59in Shades correct yes they do and also
1:40:03one is spotted and one is not
1:40:06right that's correct
1:40:09okay exhibit 83 shows us first of all
1:40:12what is this right here that's the
1:40:14victim inside of the shower stall and
1:40:16this is the the bathrobe and this right
1:40:19here some staining or some material that
1:40:22was seen on the wall by by the B by the
1:40:24shower
1:40:27stall exhibit number 84 we're looking at
1:40:31what that is a view of the bathtub
1:40:33inside the master bath bathroom and this
1:40:35room was what again I called it the
1:40:37toilet room it's the room that contained
1:40:39of the toilet in the bathroom and what
1:40:40is this right
1:40:41here that is red staining reddish brown
1:40:44staining that was seen on the on the
1:40:46wall and or door jam I may have to show
1:40:48you the photograph because of the glare
1:40:50on this one you know what this is down
1:40:52here
1:40:54if you want I'll bring the photograph up
1:40:56there that's a a bath mat
1:41:01okay this right here that's the bath mat
1:41:05right yes it
1:41:11is number 85 what are we looking at
1:41:15there that's another view of the same
1:41:17bath mat that we discussed and this
1:41:19right here on the left what is that that
1:41:22is the door jam of the entry into the
1:41:25toilet room with the red staining that
1:41:26we saw in the previous photograph and
1:41:28this right here is what more staining
1:41:31and down here in the ground is more
1:41:33reddish brown substance and this right
1:41:36here it's also a reddish brown stain on
1:41:39the mat correct correct and this right
1:41:43here is what right there additional
1:41:47staining the the towels that we looked
1:41:49at are where are they in relationship to
1:41:51this staining right here where I'm
1:41:52pointing too the towel that is in front
1:41:55of me is directly above maybe slightly
1:41:58further back from that it's it's hanging
1:42:01from that wall in the
1:42:05photograph exhibit uh
1:42:0986
1:42:12um what are we looking at here that's a
1:42:15view of some of the staining on the
1:42:17walls and tile floor of the master
1:42:19bathroom showing the entry into the
1:42:21toilet room and you can see see more of
1:42:24the bathroom itself and this up here
1:42:27that's this towel
1:42:28here exhibit uh 87 is
1:42:35what that's a more mid-range close-up
1:42:38view of the reddish staining that's on
1:42:40the door jam and some of the floor
1:42:42leading into the toilet room you see
1:42:45that right back there yes I do what is
1:42:48that more reddish brown staining that
1:42:51was on the bottom bottom pedestal of the
1:42:54toilet
1:42:57okay show you
1:43:01exhibits
1:43:0688 through
1:43:10116 let's take a look at
1:43:13those do you recognize what's in what's
1:43:16in these photographs yes I do what uh
1:43:19what do they show those are photographs
1:43:21of the master bathroom
1:43:23including staining shows the sink area
1:43:26and and the interior of the linen closet
1:43:28that's also in the bathroom are they
1:43:30true and accurate dep piics of the scene
1:43:31when you worked on it back in June of
1:43:332008 Yes they
1:43:42are8 objection exhibits 88 through 116
1:43:46are
1:43:48admitted start with 88 and we are
1:43:52looking at what here that's a view of
1:43:55the toilet inside of the room the toilet
1:44:00room 89 we're looking at what now that's
1:44:05showing the reddish staining that's on
1:44:07the pedestal of that toilet and that
1:44:09would be right there yes it yes it is
1:44:13number 90 is
1:44:15what a closer view of those those
1:44:19stains and these are at right here
1:44:21correct yes they are
1:44:2591
1:44:29is what is this here this is showing
1:44:32staining on both the tile floor and the
1:44:35wall um you can see the entry to the
1:44:37toilet room on the left side of the
1:44:39photograph and that's the wall that
1:44:42would be along the side of the toilet
1:44:44room that we've seen in other
1:44:45photographs and this is is this the wall
1:44:47where the towel is yes and this is the
1:44:50staining that you're talking about yes
1:44:52that's correct
1:44:55and is this also a stain here on the
1:44:56left yes it
1:45:00is 92 if we go to the upper right what
1:45:03do we see up here that's this towel and
1:45:11point 93 is what that is a view of one
1:45:15of the corners of the bathroom from
1:45:18around the area where the shower stall
1:45:20would be from that direction to the
1:45:22corner of bathroom and what is this
1:45:24right here the sinks within the
1:45:28bathroom 94 shows us what some of the
1:45:33floor in that master bathroom the walls
1:45:36the reddish staining and um two scales
1:45:39that were inside that
1:45:42bathroom
1:45:4495 that is a mid-range photograph of one
1:45:47of the scales with placard number 15
1:45:49because that item was collected as 15 lb
1:45:52by me
1:45:56and Number
1:45:5996 that uh depicts the the scale and
1:46:03also what was beyond the the the vanity
1:46:07in the bathroom containing the sink so
1:46:09you can see a a trash can and some
1:46:11staining near that scale and is this
1:46:13staining here too or not I don't
1:46:17recall 97
1:46:19is
1:46:21what that is view of the vanity and
1:46:24sinks in the master
1:46:25bathroom and you found this this was
1:46:28open when you were there
1:46:30correct to the best of my recollection
1:46:34yes 98 what are we looking at here that
1:46:39is reddish brown staining and reddish
1:46:41brown substance that was inside and on
1:46:43top of the sink in the master bathroom
1:46:5499 is what what are we looking at
1:46:59here that's another view of the right
1:47:02side sink in the master bathroom with
1:47:04staining there's also scales in the
1:47:07photograph that were placed in order to
1:47:10um do additional documentation
1:47:11photographs of that staining within the
1:47:14mirror and sink
1:47:19areas and 100 is what
1:47:24another view of of the same staining
1:47:27with the scales for reference and it
1:47:30also shows us the edge here doesn't it
1:47:33yes it does and it does have red does it
1:47:35have red staining on it yes it does
1:47:38there is something here on the upper
1:47:39left what is that that is a letter
1:47:43marker D to to indicate which
1:47:48area was photographed
1:47:53and exhibit 101 shows us
1:47:57what a closer view of the staining that
1:47:59would be within that D area or
1:48:08quadrant
1:48:10102 that's an overhead view of the sink
1:48:14on the right side and the staining
1:48:16within on top of the sink and countertop
1:48:19this looks like a wipe pattern are you
1:48:21familiar with like wiping or not I I
1:48:24don't do blood spatter okay
1:48:33interpretation
1:48:36103 shows us what
1:48:38now a closer view of some of the
1:48:41staining on the sink that's actually
1:48:43inside the sink with the outlet valve
1:48:46there right that's correct it was both
1:48:48inside the sink and on top of the sink
1:49:01104 what are we looking at there that's
1:49:04another overhead view of the staining on
1:49:06the sink and the the vanity top with
1:49:08some scales and a letter and number
1:49:12designators this bottle that's here do
1:49:15you see whether or not it has any
1:49:18staining on it can you
1:49:20tell I see staining around it I'm not
1:49:22sure if there's any on the bottle take a
1:49:24look at exhibit 104 the
1:49:27deer
1:49:32okay it appears that they're standing on
1:49:34the bottle
1:49:36yes the bottle is not knocked over right
1:49:39no it's
1:49:42not and
1:49:47105 we're looking at these patterns
1:49:50whatever they may be on a different
1:49:52portion of the sink right
1:49:56yes in terms of coloring these on the
1:49:59left look a lot darker than the ones on
1:50:01the right correct yes they
1:50:06do 106
1:50:09now over more to the right and we see
1:50:13that that staining there correct yes
1:50:25107 is
1:50:28what that's a photograph of the staining
1:50:31on the sink from a different Viewpoint
1:50:33shows the edge of the sink and some of
1:50:35the spatter inside of the sink running
1:50:37down right here what we're looking
1:50:44at 108
1:50:48is that is a photograph of the staining
1:50:53that I designated
1:50:55D1 that area was swapped and collected
1:50:58as a as a
1:51:03sample first and 109 we're what is this
1:51:06right
1:51:07here that is the linen closet or closet
1:51:10that's in the master
1:51:13bathroom and this right
1:51:16here see this right here that's red
1:51:19staining substance that's on the on the
1:51:21the tile in the bathroom I want you to
1:51:23look at this box and there you go can
1:51:26you see that box there yes I
1:51:30can do you see this right here on the
1:51:34bottom of that box yes I do I know we
1:51:37can look at it you were there can you
1:51:39describe it any better than what our
1:51:40eyes are looking
1:51:42at it was a light gradient of red
1:51:46staining running up the box what
1:51:48appeared to be running up the
1:51:49box and in front of it is this red
1:51:53larger stain yes and were these also
1:51:57stains
1:51:58here yes they
1:52:01are and while I have this this of course
1:52:08is what's this white thing here that's
1:52:12the door to that closet in the master
1:52:14bathroom do you know what this is right
1:52:17here yes I do I'm going to bring it in a
1:52:21little bit
1:52:23what is that that is a cartridge casing
1:52:26that was found on the floor in the
1:52:28master bathroom and did you seiz that
1:52:30yes I
1:52:46did want you to take a look at the
1:52:49exhibit number 260
1:53:12what is it that's the cartridge casing
1:53:14that I collected as number one
1:53:18lb I move for the admission of exhibit
1:53:20number 218 no OB
1:53:24216 18 is
1:53:36admitted when you packag it did you
1:53:38notice the caliber of it right now the
1:53:40caliber of it or not I documented what
1:53:43was written on the head stamp of the
1:53:45cartridge casing yes and what was
1:53:47written on the head stamp of this
1:53:48cartridge casing w n 25
1:53:53Auto uh do you know what wiin stands for
1:53:56it may not be your area it's not my area
1:53:59do you know what the 25 stands for I I
1:54:02believe it's the caliber but I don't
1:54:03work in fire that's not your area
1:54:06okay let's look a little bit at a wider
1:54:10view of this that's the
1:54:13casing and then we've looked at
1:54:17this area
1:54:19here I'm pan out a little bit
1:54:29more
1:54:31and what is this right
1:54:34here that's the cartridge casing and
1:54:37this up here
1:54:39is the right side
1:54:47sink exhibit number 110 shows us what
1:54:52that's a closer view of the cartridge
1:54:53casing on the bathroom floor and it also
1:54:56shows us that there's what you see this
1:54:58right up
1:54:59here there's red staining and red
1:55:01substance all over the floor as
1:55:05well and exhibit 111 shows us a closer
1:55:09view of the cartridge
1:55:11casing and this right here is just some
1:55:13red staining correct yes
1:55:22it may be stating the obvious but I'm
1:55:26going to ask you to the naked eye your
1:55:30eye and you were
1:55:31there is there any
1:55:35staining on the top of this casing
1:55:39that's in this red
1:55:42stain not that I
1:55:47see see that it's a little blurry but I
1:55:51I still don't see any red standing on
1:55:52the
1:56:00top exhibit number
1:56:04112 now what are we looking at here
1:56:07starting with this corner here what is
1:56:09that that's the sink or a portion of the
1:56:11sink pedestal and this down here is
1:56:15that's the cartridge casing and it's
1:56:17photographed with evidence placard
1:56:18number one and up here that's a to
1:56:23and down here that's the hallway that
1:56:26leads from the master bedroom to the
1:56:27master bathroom or vice versa and right
1:56:30here that is the doorway leading from
1:56:33the bathroom into the
1:56:35closet exhibit uh 113 is the staining
1:56:40and what a view a mid-range view of item
1:56:44number one lb with placard one and it
1:56:47shows some staining there also right it
1:56:50does 114
1:56:53is the placard and a a closeup of the
1:56:56casing correct yes it
1:56:58is exhibit number
1:57:02115 shows us the box
1:57:06right correct and then it shows us the
1:57:10items in the closet uh number 11 what is
1:57:14number
1:57:1711 it's a USB thumb drive that was a
1:57:21Targus brand that was collected from
1:57:22inside that that closet a what now a
1:57:25thumb a USB storage device okay thumb
1:57:29drive um that was number what number was
1:57:32that that was 11 and what was number 10
1:57:35then it's a prepaid legal services
1:57:38business card
1:57:42okay and now 116 what are we looking at
1:57:49here that is red sub staining that's on
1:57:53the floor in
1:57:55the master bathroom and hallway to the
1:57:58master bathroom and now are we headed
1:58:00into the master bathroom bedroom now
1:58:02you're heading down the hallway towards
1:58:04the master bedroom and that to the right
1:58:07great thank
1:58:09you all right ladies and gentlemen we're
1:58:11going to take the weekend recess you may
1:58:14step down please return January 8 at
1:58:1810:30 all right ladies and gentlemen
1:58:20there will be no trial tomorrow Friday
1:58:22no trial Monday the 7th you should also
1:58:25return on Tuesday January 8th at
1:58:3010:30 I know every day I ask you to
1:58:35follow the
1:58:36admonition page 13 of your preliminary
1:58:39instructions contains that admonition
1:58:42since we are about to recess for the
1:58:43weekend I want to remind you of your
1:58:46obligations it is your duty not to speak
1:58:49with or permit yourselves to be
1:58:51addressed by any any person on any
1:58:53subject connected with this trial if
1:58:56someone should try to talk to you about
1:58:58the case stop him or her or walk away if
1:59:01you should overhear others talking about
1:59:03the case stop them or walk away if
1:59:07anything like this does happen report it
1:59:09to me or any member of my staff as soon
1:59:11as you
1:59:17can you may not discuss the evidence
1:59:19among yourselves until you retire to to
1:59:22deliberate on your verdict do not form
1:59:25any final opinions about any fact or
1:59:28about the outcome of the case until you
1:59:30have heard and considered all of the
1:59:31evidence the closing arguments and the
1:59:34rest of the instructions I will give you
1:59:35on the law keep an open mind during the
1:59:37trial form your final opinions only
1:59:40after you have had an opportunity to
1:59:42discuss the case with each other in the
1:59:44Jury Room at the end of the trial all
1:59:47right one more time has anyone had any
1:59:49exposure to the media regarding this
1:59:51case
1:59:52anyone at
1:59:54all I see no hands all right ladies and
1:59:57gentlemen thank you very much we will
1:59:58see you on Tuesday 10:30 a.m. have a
2:00:02nice weekend

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Jodi Aris Trial : Day 2 : 2 Of 2 : Evidence Reviewed (No Sidebars) by David Lohr, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,960 words across 2,191 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.