Jodi Arias Trial - Day 21 - Part 1 (cross examination) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:12Please rise for the verdict.
- 0:43Please be seated. The record will show
- 0:44the presence of the jury, the defendant,
- 0:47and all counsel. Ms. Arias, you are
- 0:49still under oath, do you understand?
- 0:51Yes.
- 0:51Mr. Martinez, you may cross-examine the
- 0:53witness.
- 0:58Ma'am, take a look at exhibit 413.
- 1:03You recognize that exhibit, correct?
- 1:05Yes.
- 1:06And that's a picture of you, correct?
- 1:08Right here.
- 1:09And the other one is a picture of your
- 1:12dumb sister, Angela, correct?
- 1:17That's my sister. She's not dumb.
- 1:19Well, do you remember having a
- 1:20conversation with Travis Alexander back
- 1:22on May 10th of 2008?
- 1:25Yes.
- 1:26And do you remember that you tape
- 1:27recorded that conversation?
- 1:29Yes.
- 1:30And during that conversation, isn't it
- 1:31true that you said,
- 1:36"But I honestly think"
- 1:38talking about Angela,
- 1:40"she's a little bit dumb." You said
- 1:42that, right?
- 1:43Yes, I called her dumb and stupid.
- 1:46Did I ask you whether or not you called
- 1:47her stupid, ma'am?
- 1:48No.
- 1:49I asked you whether or not you called
- 1:50her dumb, right?
- 1:51Yes.
- 1:57Ma'am, take a look at uh exhibit 452.
- 2:11Do you recognize the two people there?
- 2:13Yes.
- 2:15And this photograph was taken by your
- 2:18camera, correct?
- 2:20It looks like it.
- 2:22Well,
- 2:23when you say it looks like it, isn't it
- 2:24part of the same photographs that are
- 2:26involved in exhibit 413?
- 2:30Um I think it is.
- 2:32Well, exhibit number 413, that was taken
- 2:35on
- 2:36May 10th. We'll bring it in.
- 2:39of 2008, right?
- 2:41Yes.
- 2:46And this photograph here,
- 2:49exhibit number 413, features the color
- 2:52of your hair, doesn't it?
- 2:53Yes.
- 2:54Exhibit 452 also features the color of
- 2:57your hair, doesn't it?
- 2:58Yes, a different part of my hair.
- 3:00And this was taken
- 3:02sometime in May of 2008, correct?
- 3:04This exhibit?
- 3:05No, exhibit number 452.
- 3:07I only remember it was the spring, I
- 3:08think.
- 3:09Of 2008?
- 3:10Yes.
- 3:12I move for the admission of exhibit 452.
- 3:15Objection, lack of foundation.
- 3:18Counsel, approach.
- 4:33452 is admitted.
- 4:48May I take a look at
- 4:50the back of exhibit 452? It contains a
- 4:52date on there.
- 4:57Does that date refresh your recollection
- 4:59as to when this photograph was taken?
- 5:01Yes.
- 5:02And what date was this photograph taken?
- 5:045 days later, the 15th of May, 2008.
- 5:09And with regard to this photograph,
- 5:14it also
- 5:16features
- 5:18you.
- 5:22And it also features your sister, the
- 5:24one that you
- 5:25also said was stupid, correct?
- 5:28Yes.
- 5:29Now, with regard to this name-calling,
- 5:33one of the things that
- 5:35we heard through a text message was that
- 5:37you were upset at some point because Mr.
- 5:39Alexander said that you were going to
- 5:43turn out like your mother, or you you
- 5:45acting like your mother. Do you remember
- 5:46that text message, ma'am?
- 5:47Yes.
- 5:48And in that text message, there was this
- 5:50indication that somehow he was saying
- 5:52something bad about your mother, right?
- 5:55Yes.
- 5:56And when you testified, you seemed to
- 5:57get pretty upset about that, right?
- 6:01I remember getting emotional.
- 6:03And you indicated that you loved your
- 6:05mother, right?
- 6:07I do love my mother, yes.
- 6:09Did you or did you not indicate that you
- 6:11loved your mother? I'm not asking you if
- 6:12you love your mother. I'm asking you if
- 6:13you indicated it.
- 6:15I don't remember.
- 6:17Do you have problems with your memory,
- 6:18ma'am?
- 6:19Sometimes.
- 6:20So, you can tell us, for example, what
- 6:22kind of coffee you brought at Starbucks
- 6:25back on June 3rd of 2008, but you can't
- 6:27tell us what you said yesterday or the
- 6:29day before?
- 6:30I always got the same drink at
- 6:31Starbucks.
- 6:32And you can tell us, for example, what
- 6:34type of sex you had with Mr. Alexander
- 6:36many years ago, but you're having
- 6:38trouble telling us what you said a
- 6:40couple of days ago?
- 6:42When I'm under stress, yeah, it affects
- 6:44my memory.
- 6:45I thought you said the relationship Mr.
- 6:47Alexander was very stressful.
- 6:49Some of the sex wasn't.
- 6:50Pardon?
- 6:51Some of the sex wasn't.
- 6:52So, you did enjoy the sex then, is that
- 6:54what you're telling me?
- 6:54At times I did.
- 7:11But you did indicate at some point that
- 7:18as part of your examination, also that
- 7:21Mr. Alexander at some point said
- 7:22something about your grandparents also.
- 7:24Do you remember telling us that?
- 7:26My grandfather.
- 7:26Right. Did he make some pejorative
- 7:28comment or some bad comment about him,
- 7:29right?
- 7:30Yes, his name.
- 7:31Right. And some of the
- 7:33one of the things that seems to be
- 7:35coming out here is that you seem to have
- 7:36a double standard here with regard to
- 7:38making comments about people, don't you?
- 7:40Yes, I do.
- 7:44I do.
- 7:45And in fact, it's okay for you to make
- 7:48comments about, for example, Angela and
- 7:50call her dumb and stupid, right?
- 7:52No.
- 7:53Well, but it's
- 7:55You said it, right?
- 7:56I did.
- 7:57And we heard on the telephone
- 7:58conversation that you were laughing when
- 8:00you said that, right?
- 8:02Yeah, it was sentimental kind of.
- 8:04You were laughing. You weren't upset
- 8:06when you said it, were you?
- 8:08No.
- 8:10And then, when Mr. Alexander says
- 8:12something like, "You're going to be like
- 8:14your mother," that's when you get
- 8:15emotional and upset, right?
- 8:21I did.
- 8:22And that's when you And you get upset
- 8:25when he says something about your
- 8:26grandfather, right?
- 8:29That night I was upset.
- 8:31And well, you did get upset, yes or no?
- 8:34Um no, because I was already upset.
- 8:36Well, you didn't get upset on the
- 8:37witness stand when you told us about
- 8:39that.
- 8:39the witness stand, certainly.
- 8:41And so, it just seems that it's okay
- 8:44unless it's Mr. It's okay to say these
- 8:46things unless it's Mr. Alexander that's
- 8:48saying them, right? So, you're applying
- 8:50a different standard to Mr. Alexander,
- 8:52correct? Yes or no?
- 8:53No.
- 8:54And ma'am, one of the other things that
- 8:56we know with regard to this standard
- 8:59applying and that sort of thing is
- 9:01back yesterday, as a matter of fact, you
- 9:03told us that
- 9:04back in August of 2007,
- 9:07you went over to Mr. Alexander's house.
- 9:08Do you remember telling us that?
- 9:10Yes.
- 9:11And you remember telling us that that
- 9:13that time you were broken up with Mr.
- 9:15Alexander, right?
- 9:17Yes, I had broken up with him.
- 9:19Well, you broken up with him or he
- 9:21broken up with you, one of the two,
- 9:22right?
- 9:23I broke up with him about a month later.
- 9:25he And he broke up with him on June 29th
- 9:27of 2007, right?
- 9:28Yes.
- 9:29But you felt that it was okay for you to
- 9:33go over to his house in August of 2007,
- 9:35didn't you?
- 9:36After he told me, yes.
- 9:37Yes or no, did you feel it was okay to
- 9:40go over to his house?
- 9:41I said yes.
- 9:42And when you went over to his house, you
- 9:44indicated that you knocked or you did
- 9:45something
- 9:47and that nobody came to the door, right?
- 9:51I don't I went to his house a lot in
- 9:53August, so it depends on the incident
- 9:54that happened.
- 9:55the incident that you told us about
- 9:56yesterday. Do you remember the one that
- 9:58you related that involved the killing?
- 10:00Do you remember telling us about that?
- 10:01I did not knock.
- 10:03And you did go over there and at some
- 10:05point you started to peep in to the
- 10:08house, didn't you?
- 10:09Yes.
- 10:10So, that means that you don't know if
- 10:12you knocked, though, right?
- 10:13I did not knock. I know I did not.
- 10:15So, you went around the back then to
- 10:16look, right?
- 10:18I went around the back to get in.
- 10:19You went around the back then, right?
- 10:21Yes.
- 10:22And when you went around the back,
- 10:23you're telling us you went around the
- 10:25back to get in, right?
- 10:26Yes.
- 10:27But when you got to the back to get in,
- 10:30you started to look at what was going
- 10:31on, right?
- 10:33I glanced in as I was walking to the
- 10:35sliding glass door.
- 10:36You did walk in and you were looking at
- 10:37what was going on, right?
- 10:39not walk in.
- 10:41Then you were from outside looking in,
- 10:43right?
- 10:43Yes.
- 10:44Never went in, right?
- 10:45No, I ran out of the backyard.
- 10:47You never went in, yes or no?
- 10:49I said no.
- 10:50And when you went and looked, you saw
- 10:52something that upset you, right?
- 10:54Yes.
- 10:55You saw Mr. Alexander, right?
- 10:59I didn't know it was him at first, but
- 11:00yes.
- 11:00did you see him during that encounter?
- 11:02Yes, she's she's answering the question.
- 11:04I don't know what you're talking
- 11:07Answer the question.
- 11:08I did. I said no.
- 11:10Pardon?
- 11:10I didn't know it was him at first.
- 11:12You didn't see him when you were there
- 11:13that night?
- 11:14I did afterwards, yes.
- 11:15That night, ma'am. Listen to my
- 11:17question. That night, did you see Mr.
- 11:19Alexander inside that house, yes or no?
- 11:21Yes.
- 11:22And inside that house, there was a
- 11:24female, right?
- 11:25Yes.
- 11:26What's the name of the female?
- 11:30He didn't tell me her name.
- 11:31I've asked that. did I ask you if he
- 11:33told you the name?
- 11:36No.
- 11:37So, did you recognize her?
- 11:40No, I did not.
- 11:42And he was there with the female though.
- 11:44You were able to see her face though,
- 11:45right?
- 11:46Yes, sort of.
- 11:48Well, yes or sort of means two different
- 11:50things. Yes or no, were you able to see
- 11:52her face or not?
- 11:53Part of it was shadowed from the TV
- 11:55behind her, so I saw part of it.
- 11:57Judge, she's not answering my question
- 11:58if you could instruct her.
- 12:00Witness, listen carefully to the
- 12:01question and answer only the question
- 12:03you are asked.
- 12:04Okay.
- 12:04You may continue.
- 12:06Could you see her face, yes or no?
- 12:09Part of it.
- 12:11And but you were able to see that they
- 12:13were making out, right?
- 12:15Oh, yeah, they were.
- 12:16And so, is that a yes?
- 12:18They were making out, right?
- 12:19Mhm.
- 12:20Is that a yes?
- 12:20Yes.
- 12:21And part of what you also saw was that
- 12:23her brassiere was off, right?
- 12:27I did not see that. I just saw her
- 12:28re-hook her bra.
- 12:29Pardon?
- 12:30I didn't see it all the way off. I just
- 12:31saw it.
- 12:32You indicated that you saw her
- 12:33re-hooking the brassiere back on, right?
- 12:35You told us that yesterday, yes?
- 12:36She was re-hooking it, yes.
- 12:38So, you did tell us that yesterday,
- 12:39right?
- 12:39Yes.
- 12:40So, that means that at least at the her
- 12:42bra was unhooked, right?
- 12:43It was unhooked.
- 12:44And you stood there and they stood up in
- 12:47reaction to something that you did. Is
- 12:48that what you're telling us?
- 12:49No.
- 12:50They didn't see you.
- 12:51They didn't see me.
- 12:52But you saw you So, the So, what
- 12:55happened then is you actually were
- 12:56watching what they were doing then,
- 12:57right?
- 12:58Briefly, yes.
- 13:00Did I ask you for how long, ma'am?
- 13:01No.
- 13:03I asked you if you stood there and
- 13:04watched them, right?
- 13:05No.
- 13:06You You didn't stand there and watch
- 13:08them?
- 13:08I didn't stand there. I saw it and then
- 13:10I turned and ran out of the backyard.
- 13:11But you saw enough to know that they
- 13:13were kissing, right?
- 13:15Um yes.
- 13:17You used the term making out, didn't you
- 13:18yesterday?
- 13:19Yes.
- 13:20You You were there long enough to see
- 13:21that one of the individuals was Mr.
- 13:23Alexander, not his roommate, right?
- 13:25Yes.
- 13:26You were able to see that it was a
- 13:27female, right?
- 13:29Yes.
- 13:29You were able to see that the bra was
- 13:31unhooked, right?
- 13:33Yes.
- 13:33And there weren't The lights weren't on,
- 13:36right?
- 13:37There was a light.
- 13:38Well, didn't you indicate that it was
- 13:39like a TV kind of light that was
- 13:41That light. Yes.
- 13:42Right? So, there wasn't a light, there
- 13:44was a television that was on, right?
- 13:46That's light.
- 13:47Ma'am,
- 13:49was it a light or was it a television
- 13:51that was on?
- 13:52It was light from a television screen.
- 13:54So, are you saying that it was a
- 13:55television that was on then?
- 13:57Yes.
- 13:58And from that light, you were able to
- 13:59make all of this out, correct?
- 14:02Yes.
- 14:03No other light was on, right?
- 14:06Not that I recall.
- 14:08And then you decided to leave, right?
- 14:10Yes.
- 14:11And this was at the point that you were
- 14:12living very close to Mr. Alexander,
- 14:14right?
- 14:15No.
- 14:16Well, you were living within 10 miles of
- 14:19him, weren't you?
- 14:20Um I was living by Greenfield and
- 14:21Broadway. I don't know the length.
- 14:23How long would it take you to drive
- 14:25there?
- 14:25About 15 minutes, depending on traffic.
- 14:28And
- 14:30after you saw this, one of the things
- 14:31that you did was that you took off,
- 14:33right?
- 14:34Yes.
- 14:35And
- 14:36then you thought about it, right?
- 14:39Of course.
- 14:41And you felt strongly enough about this
- 14:44that the next day you called your
- 14:46father, right?
- 14:48I called my parents' house and my dad
- 14:49Yes yes or no, you spoke to your father.
- 14:51I did speak to him.
- 14:52And you were crying, right?
- 14:54Yes.
- 14:55And you were upset
- 14:56about this, right?
- 14:57Yes.
- 14:57And you told him why you were upset,
- 14:59right?
- 14:59Yes.
- 15:00I thought you said before that you
- 15:01didn't discuss these issues involving
- 15:03you and Mr. Alexander.
- 15:04Not typically.
- 15:06Not typically. You said you didn't that
- 15:07yesterday and all the days before. You
- 15:10remember telling us that?
- 15:12The violence, yes.
- 15:13Oh, I see. So, but you did discuss the
- 15:15fact that you saw him kissing with
- 15:17somebody else with your father, right?
- 15:18Yes.
- 15:19And as a result of that, you decided to
- 15:22go talk to Mr. Alexander about it,
- 15:24right?
- 15:24Yes.
- 15:25What in the world
- 15:27gave you the right to go talk to an
- 15:30ex-boyfriend
- 15:32with who, according to you, you'd broken
- 15:34up with? What right do you have to do
- 15:36that?
- 15:36Objection, Your Honor. Sorry to
- 15:37interrupt.
- 15:38Sustained.
- 15:40Ma'am,
- 15:42did you feel
- 15:44that you could go and talk to him about
- 15:45that?
- 15:46Of course.
- 15:47Why? Weren't you broken up?
- 15:49Yes.
- 15:50You were being territorial about him,
- 15:52weren't you?
- 15:52No.
- 15:54Oh, you weren't? Then why in the world
- 15:56did you would you even care what he was
- 15:57doing?
- 15:59Because he was trying to court me back.
- 16:02That's you telling us that he was trying
- 16:04to court you back. If he's trying to
- 16:05court you back, you could have just
- 16:06walked away at that point, couldn't you?
- 16:09Yeah, I could have at any time, I guess.
- 16:11Well, you at that point you could have
- 16:13walked away, right?
- 16:14Yes.
- 16:15You didn't need him for his paycheck,
- 16:16right? Cuz he wasn't giving you money,
- 16:18right?
- 16:18He was giving me money.
- 16:19Well, that was for some work, but you
- 16:21could have gotten other work, right?
- 16:23I guess I could have looked.
- 16:24You guess?
- 16:25You worked at other places. You know you
- 16:27could have gotten other work, couldn't
- 16:28you?
- 16:28Not in August. It's very slow season for
- 16:30restaurants.
- 16:31So, you're saying that you were
- 16:33restricted in only getting work at
- 16:35restaurants, that there's no other kind
- 16:36of work that you could get?
- 16:39Restaurants is
- 16:40Yes or no?
- 16:42I guess that would be no, but I hadn't
- 16:43thought about it.
- 16:44So, then in addition to that, you were
- 16:47living in your own place, right?
- 16:50No.
- 16:51Well, you were living with Mr.
- 16:52Alexander?
- 16:53No.
- 16:54You were living elsewhere, weren't you?
- 16:56Yes.
- 16:56You were living in another place, right?
- 16:58Yes.
- 16:59Where you were paying rent, right?
- 17:01No.
- 17:02You weren't paying any rent at all?
- 17:03Not with Rachel.
- 17:04So, in other words, it was even better
- 17:06for you. You didn't even have to worry
- 17:07about having to pay the rent, right?
- 17:09Yes.
- 17:10And so,
- 17:12you could have just let that situation
- 17:14alone, but you decided to confront him
- 17:16anyway, right?
- 17:18Of course.
- 17:19And the reason that you did it is
- 17:21because you were jealous, right?
- 17:23No.
- 17:25And then you did talk to him about this
- 17:27issue, correct?
- 17:28Yes.
- 17:29And he got upset with you, right?
- 17:32No.
- 17:33He didn't get upset and scream and run
- 17:34upstairs, isn't that what you told us
- 17:36yesterday?
- 17:36Yes, he did.
- 17:39So,
- 17:40ma'am, to go back to this issue
- 17:42involving the text messages, one of the
- 17:45things that you told us was that there
- 17:46was a text message that you sent to
- 17:48somebody by the name of Steve, Steve
- 17:49Carroll, right?
- 17:51Yes.
- 17:51And that it was a two-part text message,
- 17:54right?
- 17:55Yes.
- 17:56And this two-part text message, one part
- 18:00ended up going to Mr. Alexander, right?
- 18:03Yes.
- 18:04And that he got upset about it, right?
- 18:08Very yes.
- 18:09And after he got upset about it, one of
- 18:12the things that he wanted was to see the
- 18:13second part of this text message, right?
- 18:15Yes.
- 18:16And so you lied to him at that point,
- 18:18right?
- 18:20No.
- 18:20Well, you fabricated a second text
- 18:23message, didn't you?
- 18:24After that point, yes.
- 18:25So,
- 18:27do you Are you telling me that
- 18:28fabricating a text message is not a lie?
- 18:31No, I'm not saying that.
- 18:33So, you did lie to him,
- 18:35Mr. Alexander, right?
- 18:36you and asked you and asked you.
- 18:40Um
- 18:42yes and no.
- 18:43So, you think that
- 18:45sending him
- 18:47that text message
- 18:49and telling him, "This is the second
- 18:51part of the text message," that that's
- 18:52not a lie even though you fabricated it.
- 18:54That part was the lie.
- 18:56And so,
- 18:59you then were asked the question, "Well,
- 19:01how did that make you feel?"
- 19:03when Mr. Alexander was sending you these
- 19:06text messages as involving Mr. Carroll.
- 19:09Do you remember those that line of
- 19:10questioning?
- 19:12Yes.
- 19:16We're applying a different standard
- 19:17here, then, right?
- 19:19Objection, argumentative.
- 19:21Sustained.
- 19:22With regard to this
- 19:24issue of how you feel,
- 19:28isn't that the same way that you felt
- 19:32when you were peeping in his window
- 19:35in August of 2007? Isn't that the same
- 19:37kind of feeling that you were having?
- 19:39The same as what?
- 19:40As the one involving Steve Carroll.
- 19:45I don't know.
- 19:46You were mad at Mr. Alexander both
- 19:47times, weren't you?
- 19:49I wasn't mad at Alexander.
- 19:51You weren't mad at him, or you were
- 19:52upset with him then, right?
- 19:54At what time?
- 19:56Either time.
- 19:58Steve Carroll, no. The girl from
- 20:00Phoenix, yes.
- 20:02And
- 20:03so it just seems that it's okay for you
- 20:06to lie to him about a guy,
- 20:08but when it comes to him
- 20:11being with some other girl,
- 20:13you decide to confront him, right?
- 20:17Yes.
- 20:18And one of the other things that you
- 20:19told us yesterday was that you were
- 20:21monogamous with Mr. Alexander, right?
- 20:24Sexually monogamous, yes.
- 20:26Ma'am, you
- 20:27you told us you were monogamous, and
- 20:29that's what monogamous means, sexually,
- 20:30doesn't it?
- 20:35I think it means more than that,
- 20:36sometimes.
- 20:37Well, in this case, monogamous means
- 20:39sexually, doesn't it?
- 20:40Objection, mischaracterizes the
- 20:41testimony.
- 20:43Re-state your question.
- 20:45When you say monogamous, it means
- 20:46sexually, doesn't it?
- 20:50Which time?
- 20:51What we're talking The time that we're
- 20:52talking about right now.
- 20:54Involving Mr. Alexander, no other time.
- 20:56Our relationship evolved, so
- 20:58I'm not asking you if it evolved. At the
- 21:00end, right when you killed him, you
- 21:01indicated that you were monogamous with
- 21:03him, right?
- 21:04Yes.
- 21:05And at that time, you then left
- 21:08the
- 21:10killing scene, if you will, and you went
- 21:11up to Utah, right?
- 21:12Yes.
- 21:13And when you went up to Utah, ma'am, you
- 21:15ended up with somebody by the name of
- 21:16Ryan Burns, right?
- 21:18Yes.
- 21:18And you ended up in his bed, right?
- 21:22I think it was a love sack.
- 21:23Okay. And with regard to that at that
- 21:25point, according to you, Mr. Alexander
- 21:28still wasn't dead, was he?
- 21:32It wasn't discussed.
- 21:33Well, did I ask you whether or not you
- 21:35discussed it with Mr. Burns?
- 21:37I didn't, did I?
- 21:39I wasn't talking about Mr. Burns.
- 21:41I'm asking you at that time, didn't you
- 21:43tell us yesterday at the time that you
- 21:45went up to Utah, you weren't sure if he
- 21:47was dead. Do you remember telling us
- 21:48that?
- 21:52Not in Utah, from the Hoover Dam or
- 21:54right before the checkpoint.
- 21:56So, when did you know that he was dead?
- 21:58Tell me that.
- 22:04Well, I got confirmation of it on June
- 22:0610th, but
- 22:07So, okay, if you got confirmation on
- 22:09June 10th, you you met with Mr. Burns
- 22:11what? Before June 10th, didn't you?
- 22:13Yes.
- 22:14You met him on the 5th, right?
- 22:16Yes.
- 22:17And so, at that point, you didn't know,
- 22:19according to your own story, that Mr.
- 22:21Alexander was dead, right?
- 22:25I guess I knew
- 22:29I didn't wasn't accepting it.
- 22:31You either knew or you didn't. Which one
- 22:33is it, ma'am? Make up your mind, please.
- 22:35Objection, ask and answered.
- 22:38Ask another question.
- 22:40Did you know he was dead when you and
- 22:42Mr. Burns
- 22:45and he were kissing?
- 22:46Objection, ask and answered. Same
- 22:48question.
- 22:48Overruled.
- 22:50Um
- 22:51yeah, I think I did.
- 22:53You think you did, but you're not sure
- 22:54at that point.
- 22:58I don't It wasn't really in my own mind.
- 23:00I was out of my mind, sort of.
- 23:01So, if you didn't think he was dead, if
- 23:04that portion of you didn't think he was
- 23:05dead, then it's okay for you, at that
- 23:08point, if you didn't think he was dead,
- 23:10to sort of roll around with Mr.
- 23:12Alexander then, and with Mr. Byrd.
- 23:16And that was okay, right?
- 23:19I'm single.
- 23:21Right?
- 23:22Just like he was on August 7th of 2000
- 23:24and on August 8th of 2000 and August of
- 23:262007, right?
- 23:28Yes.
- 23:29So, it's okay for you, then it should be
- 23:30okay for him, right?
- 23:32It was okay.
- 23:33Then why did you confront him the next
- 23:34day if it was okay?
- 23:36Cuz he was still courting me. I wanted
- 23:37to know where I stood.
- 23:38And so, because of he was still
- 23:40your definition, courting you, you felt
- 23:42that you deserved an explanation, right?
- 23:44Yes.
- 23:45Didn't Didn't you just have intercourse
- 23:47with Mr. Alexander on the 4th of June?
- 23:50Yes.
- 23:51And if he was still alive, he would have
- 23:53deserved an explanation then for you
- 23:54being with Mr. Byrd, right?
- 23:56No.
- 23:57Well, no, is it Aren't we That's You're
- 23:59applying a different standard here,
- 24:00aren't you?
- 24:01No.
- 24:02You're saying one it's okay for you to
- 24:04confront him about the situation, but
- 24:06not okay for Mr. Alexander to confront
- 24:08you, right?
- 24:10If he wanted to confront me, it would
- 24:11have been okay.
- 24:12Ma'am, with regard to the exhibit number
- 24:154
- 24:1652
- 24:18it does show you, right?
- 24:21Correct?
- 24:21Yes.
- 24:22And it shows again
- 24:23Angela, correct?
- 24:25Yes.
- 24:25Show something else on there, though,
- 24:27doesn't it? Doesn't it show your hand?
- 24:29Yes.
- 24:30And in fact, let me show you another
- 24:32close-up of that hand.
- 24:54Here we're going objecting the
- 24:55foundation.
- 24:59Please approach.
- 25:43Now, take a look at exhibit number 453
- 25:46and then also take a look at exhibit
- 25:47452.
- 25:56Exhibit 453 is a close-up of your hand,
- 25:58right?
- 25:58Yes.
- 25:59And it's And then you would have also
- 26:01seen the jewelry around your sister's
- 26:02neck.
- 26:03Yes.
- 26:03Exhibit 453, correct?
- 26:05Yes.
- 26:07And you previously have I've told us
- 26:10about exhibit 452 and when it was taken
- 26:12and who's in that photograph, correct?
- 26:14Yes.
- 26:14I move for the admission of exhibit 453.
- 26:16No objection.
- 26:36And ma'am, this was also taken,
- 26:38according to your testimony, on May
- 26:3915th. Let's take a look at that.
- 26:41Of 2008.
- 26:47That's a picture of your left hand,
- 26:49isn't it?
- 26:49Yes.
- 26:50And that shows your ring finger, right?
- 26:52Yes.
- 26:52Do you remember that you testified that
- 26:54on January 22nd of 2008, you and Mr.
- 26:58Alexander were involved in some sort of
- 27:00violent encounter. Do you remember
- 27:01telling us about that?
- 27:02Yes.
- 27:03And you told us that during that
- 27:04encounter, he threw you down. Do you
- 27:06remember that?
- 27:07Yes.
- 27:08And while you were down, that he kicked
- 27:09you, right?
- 27:10Yes.
- 27:11And when he kicked you, ma'am, one of
- 27:12the things that happened was that you
- 27:14put up your left hand. Do you remember
- 27:15telling us that?
- 27:17Yes, both hands.
- 27:18Well, you told us specifically about
- 27:20your left hand, right?
- 27:21Yes.
- 27:22And when you went to put up your left
- 27:24hand, according to you, he kicked you
- 27:27and he damaged your
- 27:29ring finger on the left hand, correct?
- 27:30Yes.
- 27:31And in fact, you even held it up for us,
- 27:33didn't you?
- 27:34Yes.
- 27:34And it was crooked when you showed it to
- 27:36us, wasn't it?
- 27:38It's bent. Yes.
- 27:39It's bent. Show us how bent it is again,
- 27:41ma'am.
- 27:44Higher, so we can see it sideways.
- 27:47Ma'am,
- 27:48if he caused that damage
- 27:52on January
- 27:5322nd of 2008, that would have been
- 27:56before this picture that we have here,
- 27:58which is exhibit number
- 28:00453. It would have been about
- 28:025 months before that, right?
- 28:04It was before that.
- 28:065 months, right?
- 28:08Four.
- 28:09Four months then, right?
- 28:10Yes.
- 28:11You don't have a bent finger here in
- 28:13exhibit 453, do you?
- 28:15My finger is bent there.
- 28:17You're saying that your finger is bent
- 28:18there.
- 28:19Yes. Just the
- 28:20your finger again.
- 28:22Sideways, so we can also see it.
- 28:24But my fingers are straightened. This
- 28:26one stays
- 28:26And that's what it looks like, your
- 28:27finger.
- 28:28And you're saying that's what happened
- 28:30on January 22nd of 2008, right?
- 28:32Yes.
- 28:33Ma'am, one of the other things involving
- 28:35this particular finger, it seems to have
- 28:37had its run, if you will, of bad things
- 28:41happen to it, right?
- 28:43This finger?
- 28:44Yes, the left ring finger.
- 28:49I don't know.
- 28:50Well, you talked to Ryan Burns about it,
- 28:53didn't you?
- 28:53Yes.
- 28:54And you told him that that finger, the
- 28:57left ring finger, had been damaged,
- 29:00right? Injured, didn't you?
- 29:04I don't know if it was the left.
- 29:07You don't remember telling him it was
- 29:08the left ring finger, ma'am?
- 29:09No.
- 29:11Do you Again, do you have a problem with
- 29:13memory?
- 29:14Occasionally.
- 29:16And so, some of the things that you told
- 29:18us, for example, then about
- 29:20other things in the past,
- 29:23you may have also had problems with your
- 29:24memory then, right?
- 29:26Yes.
- 29:27And so, whatever you told us in the past
- 29:30is somewhat suspect then because your
- 29:32memory may be lacking.
- 29:33Objection, argumentative.
- 29:36I only told things I remember clearly
- 29:38that are crystallized in my mind.
- 29:40With regard to Mr. Burns,
- 29:42you do remember who he was, right?
- 29:44Yes.
- 29:45And you do remember that you went over
- 29:47to West Jordan to meet him, right?
- 29:49Yes.
- 29:50And you do remember that you did meet
- 29:51him that Thursday, and it was sometime
- 29:53around 11:00 in the morning, right?
- 29:56I think so, yes.
- 29:58And when you met him, you guys decided
- 30:00to go somewhere to a restaurant for some
- 30:01sort of business meeting, right?
- 30:03Yes.
- 30:04And during that time, didn't you have a
- 30:06bandage on your finger?
- 30:08Yes.
- 30:09And it was your left finger, wasn't it?
- 30:12No.
- 30:13It was your right finger then, right?
- 30:15Is that what you're saying, it was your
- 30:16right finger?
- 30:17It was two right fingers.
- 30:18So, it was your right finger then,
- 30:19right?
- 30:21Um
- 30:22Are you sure that it was your right
- 30:24finger?
- 30:25It was two.
- 30:26Pardon?
- 30:27Two right fingers.
- 30:28Do you remember then that you had a
- 30:29conversation with Detective Flores about
- 30:32this issue involving the finger?
- 30:33Yes.
- 30:34And do you remember that that was on
- 30:35July 16th of 2008?
- 30:37Yes.
- 30:38And did you remember that you told him
- 30:41that on June 4th
- 30:44you had been over at Mr. Alexander's
- 30:46home, right?
- 30:47Yes.
- 30:48And you told him that you were over at
- 30:50Mr. Alexander's home and that some guy
- 30:53and some girl had come in, right?
- 30:55Yes.
- 30:56And during whatever happened on June
- 30:584th, you told Detective Flores that it
- 31:01was your left finger
- 31:04that had been damaged. Do you remember
- 31:05that?
- 31:06Yes.
- 31:07So, you did tell that to the detective
- 31:10that it happened on June 4th, right?
- 31:13Yes.
- 31:14Does that then
- 31:15Does that then refresh your
- 31:16recollection? And we'll play it so that
- 31:18we know what we're talking about.
- 31:23Okay.
- 31:25Objection. She's already admitted to
- 31:28I'm moving it in not for impeachment
- 31:29purposes, just for limited state versus
- 31:31Apple.
- 31:33Approach from counsel.
- 34:34Mhm.
- 35:13454 is admitted.
- 36:10Did you get hurt, though?
- 36:11You said you were fighting with her.
- 36:13Yeah.
- 36:14What happened to you?
- 36:16Um, she got me.
- 36:17Where?
- 36:18My hand.
- 36:19Let me see. Where at?
- 36:21You can't really see it. You can't see
- 36:22it. If you look at um
- 36:24My finger isn't the same, though.
- 36:26I was
- 36:28I was just
- 36:29Which Where's Where did I get cut?
- 36:32It was kind of It was conveniently it
- 36:34was right on the crease.
- 36:35Right there on the crease?
- 36:37Can you see?
- 36:38Well, it's kind of a purple-y color, I
- 36:40guess.
- 36:41And then there's this
- 36:42Yeah, right on the crease.
- 36:44Well, there's a vein on this one, maybe.
- 36:46I don't know.
- 36:47Is this one here?
- 36:49Yeah.
- 36:50It's a little slice there.
- 36:51Yeah.
- 36:52Just a small one?
- 36:54Um
- 36:55Was it pretty deep?
- 36:56I don't know how deep it was, but my
- 36:57finger hurt for a long for a while.
- 37:00Okay. So, like right in that crease that
- 37:02you
- 37:03Right. It crossed both of them?
- 37:05Uh not my middle finger. It cut this one
- 37:08a little, but not as much. This is where
- 37:09it really went in. I don't know how it
- 37:11happened that all these other fingers
- 37:13were missed, but this one Maybe that. I
- 37:15don't know.
- 37:16This one. Like I still can't close this
- 37:18finger all the way. This is close as it
- 37:20goes. Whereas this one goes like that.
- 37:22Mhm.
- 37:22Also, my CTR ring used to fit both
- 37:24fingers, and I can't get it on this
- 37:25finger anymore.
- 37:26So, it cut pretty deep then?
- 37:28I guess. If you feel it, squeeze it. It
- 37:30just feels like bone. Like there's
- 37:31nothing abnormal there.
- 37:33Mhm.
- 37:34But again, like my CTR ring slides right
- 37:36on this finger. It used to slide right
- 37:38on this finger, and I just can't fit a
- 37:40ring on here.
- 37:40Okay.
- 37:41It's a bigger size now.
- 37:44What about this here? What's that from?
- 37:46That's my cat.
- 37:48Okay.
- 37:48I'm pretty sure she scratches me a lot.
- 37:52That tape or that video tape, right?
- 37:55Yes.
- 37:56And that's you having the conversation
- 37:57discussing the left ring finger, right?
- 38:00Yes.
- 38:00And you demonstrated to Detective Flores
- 38:02that left ring finger, right?
- 38:05Yes.
- 38:05And you told him that this woman during
- 38:08this attack on June 4th of 2008 cut you
- 38:11right there, didn't you?
- 38:12Yes.
- 38:12And you showed him and the finger, if we
- 38:15look at it there,
- 38:16had the same aspect or had the same
- 38:19angle to it that your finger does now,
- 38:21doesn't it?
- 38:22Yes.
- 38:25Ma'am, the injury to your finger
- 38:28happened on June 4th, 2008, not January
- 38:3222nd of 2008, did it?
- 38:35That's not correct.
- 38:38Ma'am,
- 38:39with regard to the story involving this
- 38:41particular
- 38:42uh issue,
- 38:51you
- 38:53told us that it happened on January 22nd
- 38:57of 2008, right?
- 38:59Which issue?
- 39:01The left ring finger.
- 39:02Yes.
- 39:03You then
- 39:04discussed it or there was a this issue
- 39:07with Ryan Burns, right?
- 39:10Which issue?
- 39:12The cut finger.
- 39:13The cut finger, yes.
- 39:15And then
- 39:15fingers.
- 39:17on July 16th of 2008, you discussed it
- 39:21with Detective Flores, right?
- 39:22Yes.
- 39:23One of the things that you told
- 39:25Mr. Burns was that you cut it at
- 39:27Margaritaville while you were working
- 39:29there, right?
- 39:30No, I did not say that.
- 39:30You never told him that then, right?
- 39:32I said at work.
- 39:34So, you never told him at Margaritaville
- 39:36then, right?
- 39:37No, he said that.
- 39:39Right, but you never told him that you
- 39:41cut it at Margaritaville, right?
- 39:43No.
- 39:44You told him that you cut it at work
- 39:46then, right?
- 39:47Yes.
- 39:48And then, when you spoke to Detective
- 39:50Flores, you gave him a different story.
- 39:51You didn't say that it was cut at work.
- 39:53You told him that it was cut some other
- 39:54way, right?
- 39:55Yes.
- 39:57And then, you testified about it in this
- 39:59court, right?
- 40:00Yes.
- 40:01And you gave us
- 40:03another story of how this happened,
- 40:05right?
- 40:05No.
- 40:06Well, do you remember that you testified
- 40:08that you were at Mr. Alexander's home on
- 40:10June 4th of 2008 at the sink? Do you
- 40:12remember telling us that?
- 40:13Yes.
- 40:14And do you remember telling us that that
- 40:16you dropped the glass in Mr. Alexander's
- 40:18house.
- 40:20June 4th.
- 40:22Whatever date you were there at Mr.
- 40:23Alexander's house.
- 40:26I broke more than one glass at his
- 40:27house.
- 40:28Ma'am, do you remember testifying
- 40:30yesterday about how you suffered this
- 40:32injury to your finger? Yes or no?
- 40:35Not this finger.
- 40:37No? Do you remember testifying that
- 40:40involving your finger, your left ring
- 40:42finger yesterday as a matter of fact,
- 40:44that
- 40:46that was cut
- 40:48when you dropped the glass when you were
- 40:49at Mr. Alexander's house
- 40:52on the day that you killed him.
- 40:54I did not indicate my left finger. I
- 40:56said my
- 40:56you were saying it was your right finger
- 40:58that you cut at Mr. Alexander's house
- 41:00then, right?
- 41:00It was my right finger, yes.
- 41:02So,
- 41:03throughout this whole thing,
- 41:05Mr. Burns, when he indicated what finger
- 41:07it was, he was mistaken Well, not he was
- 41:09mistaken. You're saying you never told
- 41:10Mr. Burns that it was the right finger
- 41:12that you cut, right?
- 41:16We didn't discuss which hand.
- 41:18Okay. So, you you're you never indicated
- 41:20to him in any way, shape, or form that
- 41:22it was the right finger.
- 41:24She actually asked me that.
- 41:26Mistake.
- 41:34Ma'am, this issue of the
- 41:3822nd of January 22nd
- 41:41when you injured when you say that you
- 41:43were injured.
- 41:44Um you kept a journal, didn't you?
- 41:49You You kept a journal, didn't you?
- 41:50Yes, I did.
- 41:51And you didn't write in it all the time,
- 41:54but you wrote in it some of the time,
- 41:55right?
- 41:56Frequently, yes.
- 41:57Frequently. And you were writing about
- 41:59what was going on in your life back in
- 42:01January of
- 42:032008, right?
- 42:04Yes.
- 42:05And you would write about things that
- 42:06were significant to you.
- 42:10Some things.
- 42:12Right. And in fact with regard to
- 42:14um
- 42:15this particular journal you knew that
- 42:17you could almost write anything that you
- 42:19wanted in it because it was going to
- 42:21stay private, right?
- 42:22No.
- 42:23Well,
- 42:24well, let me show you
- 42:27or let me mark that
- 42:28as an exhibit.
- 43:33Take a look at exhibit 242.001.
- 43:39Do you recognize it?
- 43:41Yes, I do.
- 43:42And that's your journal, right?
- 43:45Sure is.
- 43:51Take a look at
- 43:54the entry, just read it to yourself,
- 43:57on Sunday, August 26th of '07.
- 44:05The whole entry?
- 44:06Just read the
- 44:07first five lines.
- 44:12Six lines.
- 44:22Yes.
- 44:23You wrote that, right?
- 44:24Yes.
- 44:25Take a look at exhibit number 455.
- 44:28Is this a true and accurate copy of
- 44:30those
- 44:32five or six lines?
- 44:37Yes.
- 44:38And you wrote that back on August 26th
- 44:40of '07, right?
- 44:41Yes.
- 44:42Can I have that back, please?
- 44:52Move for the admission of exhibit number
- 44:54455.
- 46:17I don't
- 46:17You may.
- 51:29455 is admitted.
- 53:44Shh. this one entry?
- 53:46Yes, just that one entry of August 26th
- 53:49of '07.
- 53:49Okay.
- 53:50I know you have two entries, but the
- 53:51first entry is the one we're talking
- 53:52about.
- 53:53Yeah, it looks like I have three on that
- 53:54day.
- 53:56But have you read the first entry that
- 53:58involves this particular snippet?
- 53:59Yes.
- 54:00Thank you.
- 54:03Mr. Alexander, please read all entries
- 54:05before answering the questions for my
- 54:07position.
- 54:11Overall.
- 54:33This journal and your journals were
- 54:35meant to be private, right?
- 54:37Yes.
- 54:38And that's what it says there. Well, I
- 54:39guess it's a good thing that nobody else
- 54:41reads this because I write right now
- 54:44that I love Travis Victor Alexander so
- 54:46completely
- 54:47that I don't know any other way to be,
- 54:49correct? That's what it says.
- 54:50Yes.
- 54:51Do you remember when we started talking
- 54:53this morning that we talked about uh an
- 54:56incident where you went over to his
- 54:57house?
- 54:59Yes.
- 54:59And this was the incident that you
- 55:01referenced
- 55:02uh involving the killing, right? That it
- 55:04went through your head, right?
- 55:07Um you talking about the incident in
- 55:09August 2007?
- 55:10Right, exactly.
- 55:12And that incident in August of 2007
- 55:15where you went over and peeped inside of
- 55:17his house happened before this entry
- 55:19here of Sunday, August 26th of '07,
- 55:21right?
- 55:23Peep.
- 55:25What was the last thing you said?
- 55:26He said by saying peep.
- 55:29Re-state your question.
- 55:30When you looked inside the house.
- 55:34Yes, it did happen before this entry.
- 55:36Right. And so really the reason why you
- 55:39confronted Mr. Alexander was not because
- 55:41he owed you an explanation or anything
- 55:43like that. The reason you confronted him
- 55:46back in August of 2007
- 55:49was because you were in love with him
- 55:51and you didn't want to let him go,
- 55:52I'm not sure if that's argumentative.
- 55:55I don't know what to do.
- 55:57That's not right.
- 56:00But I was in love with him.
- 56:01Yes, you did write this though, didn't
- 56:03you?
- 56:03Yes.
- 56:05Now,
- 56:07you you kept more than one journal, you
- 56:09kept a number of journals, right?
- 56:13Um I kept one journal at a time.
- 56:16Okay.
- 56:17Let's uh take a look at the other
- 56:18journal.
- 56:56You definitely wrote this.
- 56:57Yes.
- 58:20You recognize it, right?
- 58:22Yes.
- 58:22Would you open it up and look through
- 58:23it?
- 58:35That's your writing in throughout that
- 58:37whole journal, right?
- 58:38Yes.
- 58:47There is an entry for
- 58:50Thursday, January 24th, 2008, right?
- 58:54Yes.
- 58:55Just take a look at it.
- 59:00See that?
- 59:01Yes.
- 59:02Let me mark another exhibit for you.
- 59:20Take a look at exhibit 456.
- 59:32The whole the exhibit that you have in
- 59:35front of you, that's the whole entry for
- 59:38January 24th
- 59:402008, correct?
- 59:44I don't believe it is for this single
- 59:46one, yes.
- 59:47There are other entries, but that's the
- 59:48complete entry for that one, correct?
- 59:50Because it's written in blue ink, right?
- 59:53Yes.
- 59:53And the other ones are are written in
- 59:54black, right?
- 59:55Um yes, the one following.
- 59:57Okay.
- 1:00:07We move to the admission of exhibit
- 1:00:08number 456.
- 1:01:38Where are you from?
- 1:01:39Vietnam.
- 1:02:54And then can I take a look at
- 1:02:56this exhibit number 242-002?
- 1:03:00We talked about the entry of January
- 1:03:0324th of 2008.
- 1:03:05Take a look
- 1:03:07this journal.
- 1:03:09And isn't it true that the previous
- 1:03:13in terms of chronological time
- 1:03:16that the previous entry
- 1:03:18is on January 20th
- 1:03:21of 2008.
- 1:03:22Yes.
- 1:03:23So, there's a gap of
- 1:03:264 days between the time you wrote on
- 1:03:28January 20th and on January 24th of
- 1:03:312008, right?
- 1:03:32Yes.
- 1:03:32Nothing in between, correct?
- 1:03:35Not in the journal.
- 1:03:36I'm not I'm asking about the journal,
- 1:03:38ma'am.
- 1:03:39That's correct.
- 1:03:39anything else in front of you?
- 1:03:40Asked and answered, Your Honor, and I'm
- 1:03:42arguing that
- 1:03:43Sustained.
- 1:03:44In the journal, ma'am, there are no
- 1:03:46other entries between January
- 1:03:4920th 20th of 2008 and January 24th of
- 1:03:522008, right?
- 1:03:53Yes.
- 1:03:54If we then take a look at exhibit 456,
- 1:03:57let's see what you wrote
- 1:03:59on Thursday, January 24th of 2008.
- 1:04:06You wrote,
- 1:04:08"I haven't written because there has
- 1:04:10been nothing noteworthy to report."
- 1:04:13Correct?
- 1:04:13Yes.
- 1:04:14Didn't you tell us involving the finger
- 1:04:18that
- 1:04:19this injury to your left finger when Mr.
- 1:04:22Alexander went to kick you, that that
- 1:04:24happened on January 22nd of 2008?
- 1:04:27Yes, it did.
- 1:04:28And yet you write here that nothing
- 1:04:31noteworthy has happened, right?
- 1:04:34Yes.
- 1:04:35And then you also write that you turned
- 1:04:38down four offers for a date
- 1:04:40on Friday night, right?
- 1:04:42Yes.
- 1:04:43You were free to date and so was he,
- 1:04:44right?
- 1:04:45Yes.
- 1:04:47And
- 1:04:49then you finish it up by talking about
- 1:04:52going up to the snow, right?
- 1:04:55See that?
- 1:04:57Yes.
- 1:04:58You're going to go up there skiing, you
- 1:04:59crossed it out, and you just are going
- 1:05:00to go up to the snow, right?
- 1:05:02Yes.
- 1:05:03Did you go skiing?
- 1:05:04No, I don't ski.
- 1:05:05Pardon?
- 1:05:06I don't ski. No, I didn't go.
- 1:05:08All right.
- 1:05:26The entry of January 20th of 2008.
- 1:05:31Take a look at exhibit number
- 1:05:33242.02.
- 1:05:35Count the pages, please.
- 1:05:40The pages between the two?
- 1:05:43No, just the your entry of Sunday,
- 1:05:44January 20th of 2008.
- 1:05:47Do you want me to show you where it is
- 1:05:48here?
- 1:05:48I have it.
- 1:05:56Um, it's four and a few lines.
- 1:05:58And it starts on the lower left-hand
- 1:06:00corner with three lines in the calendar
- 1:06:03day,
- 1:06:04indicating January 20th January 20th of
- 1:06:062008, right?
- 1:06:07Yes, I'm sorry, misspoke. It's five
- 1:06:09pages and a few lines.
- 1:06:11And in it is one of the things that you
- 1:06:13talk about
- 1:06:15is this issue involving Lonnie's
- 1:06:17baptism, right?
- 1:06:19I haven't read it. Can I read it?
- 1:06:20Sure, go ahead.
- 1:08:54I moved away from Lonnie, so if you want
- 1:08:55me to finish it, if you're going to ask
- 1:08:56me about the rest of the entry, I can
- 1:08:58read that.
- 1:08:58I'm asking you about reading the whole
- 1:09:00entry of Sunday, June 20th, 2008. Go
- 1:09:02ahead and finish it.
- 1:10:11Yes.
- 1:10:14It does talk about Lonnie's baptism,
- 1:10:16right?
- 1:10:17Yes.
- 1:10:17And previously when you testified, you
- 1:10:19indicated that the reason you missed
- 1:10:21Lonnie's baptism is because you and Mr.
- 1:10:24Alexander were involved in a sexual
- 1:10:26liaison, right?
- 1:10:27Yes.
- 1:10:28And you And this was the sexual liaison
- 1:10:30where the Pop Rocks and the Tootsie Pops
- 1:10:34were involved, right?
- 1:10:36That's what you said, right?
- 1:10:37I'd have to reference dates.
- 1:10:39Well, why don't I show you a copy of the
- 1:10:41transcript then and see if that
- 1:10:42refreshes your recollection as to what
- 1:10:45you told us
- 1:10:50on February 12th.
- 1:10:52I would appreciate that.
- 1:10:53All right, I will.
- 1:11:19Starting on page five.
- 1:11:22Read that.
- 1:11:26Would you like me to read it out loud?
- 1:11:27To yourself.
- 1:11:35Just the highlighted portion?
- 1:11:37Nope, just keep reading it.
- 1:11:38Okay.
- 1:11:39Starting at the bottom, right?
- 1:11:41Right.
- 1:13:24You know, we would have answered any
- 1:13:25questions on the basis of the entire
- 1:13:27transcript.
- 1:13:34That's not legal.
- 1:13:35I can respond if you want. It's not a
- 1:13:37legal basis.
- 1:13:38Approach. Approach.
- 1:16:44Oh.
- 1:19:28Have you read the entire transcript that
- 1:19:30deals with the
- 1:19:32sexual encounter involving me
- 1:19:34uh
- 1:19:35Pop Rocks and Tootsie Pops?
- 1:19:38Yes, I started where you highlighted and
- 1:19:40finished it.
- 1:19:40Read Read it above it. Does that That
- 1:19:42have anything to do with the Tootsie
- 1:19:43Pops or the Rock Pops?
- 1:20:27Okay.
- 1:20:27Does the upper portion have anything to
- 1:20:28do with it or not?
- 1:20:29Yes.
- 1:20:30I want you to read the previous page
- 1:20:31just to make sure that we covered
- 1:20:32everything
- 1:20:34involving that particular encounter.
- 1:20:39Does she have any objection to dealing
- 1:20:41with the entire transcript?
- 1:20:46Granted.
- 1:21:12There's nothing about the Pop Rocks on
- 1:21:13this page.
- 1:21:14There is nothing before that, correct?
- 1:21:16Yes.
- 1:21:16Yes, Judge, I'm going to address the
- 1:21:17question of the entire transcript. I
- 1:21:19don't believe she has at this point.
- 1:21:21Read the entire transcript.
- 1:21:31I think that's the entire transcript.
- 1:21:33Granted.
- 1:21:34Irrespective of the date that we're
- 1:21:37talking about, whether it was January
- 1:21:4020th or January 21st or January 22nd,
- 1:21:44you do reference
- 1:21:46the Pop Rocks and Top Tootsie Pops
- 1:21:49sexual incident
- 1:21:51by reference to Lonnie's baptism, right?
- 1:21:54Yes.
- 1:22:24The journal entry of January 20th of
- 1:22:262008 also references
- 1:22:29Lonnie's
- 1:22:30baptism, doesn't it? Take a look at
- 1:22:32exhibit 458.
- 1:22:35This is 458.
- 1:23:04Yes.
- 1:23:05And that's a true and accurate copy in
- 1:23:07front of you
- 1:23:08the excerpt of what's in your journal
- 1:23:11involving Lonnie's
- 1:23:13uh baptism
- 1:23:14and this sexual encounter, isn't it?
- 1:23:19Yeah, let me make sure I'm just
- 1:23:20referring to the same day in my journal.
- 1:23:21Well, let's take a look at it.
- 1:23:27Let me have that.
- 1:23:30The
- 1:23:31first entry is identical on the first
- 1:23:33page that indicates Sunday, January
- 1:23:3520th, 2008, correct?
- 1:23:36Yes, that's when I wrote the entry.
- 1:23:38Okay.
- 1:23:39Then, as we continue on
- 1:23:43there is the entry
- 1:23:45involving
- 1:23:47the baptism, right?
- 1:23:57Do you see that? Let's start that
- 1:24:00that entry is there involving Lonnie's
- 1:24:02baptism?
- 1:24:03Yes, I just don't know if I'm
- 1:24:03referencing the 20th on that part of the
- 1:24:06entry.
- 1:24:06Ma'am, is there any other intervening
- 1:24:08date between the January 20th of 2008
- 1:24:12where we started
- 1:24:15and the very end where you put J A? Is
- 1:24:18there any other date in there?
- 1:24:20In that day there
- 1:24:21Yes or no?
- 1:24:22There might be. I haven't
- 1:24:23Well, why don't you take a look? Let's
- 1:24:24take a look at the first page. First
- 1:24:26page starts Sunday, January 20th, 2008,
- 1:24:28doesn't it?
- 1:24:30When I wrote it, yes.
- 1:24:32Does it start out saying Sunday, January
- 1:24:3420th, 2008, yes or no?
- 1:24:36Yes.
- 1:24:37And isn't it true that it starts out in
- 1:24:38black ink, right?
- 1:24:40Yes.
- 1:24:40And then it continues on in blue ink,
- 1:24:42right?
- 1:24:43Yes.
- 1:24:44And it flows, doesn't it?
- 1:24:47Says it.
- 1:24:48The words flow from what's at the bottom
- 1:24:51there to the next page, don't they?
- 1:24:53Yes.
- 1:24:54So, then we go to the bottom of it. The
- 1:24:56next page is also in blue ink, right?
- 1:24:58In the next page, there is no other date
- 1:25:01reference, is there?
- 1:25:03Objection, she says she needs to review
- 1:25:05it before she can answer the question.
- 1:25:07at it.
- 1:25:07Overruled.
- 1:25:09May I
- 1:25:09Thank you.
- 1:25:15No, no, ma'am. Don't turn the page. I
- 1:25:17just want you to look at that next page
- 1:25:19to see if you see a date.
- 1:25:21Objection, your honor. She says she
- 1:25:22needs to review it.
- 1:25:24Oh, that's not the question. Overruled.
- 1:25:28I didn't write a date.
- 1:25:29No, there is no date on there, is there?
- 1:25:32No.
- 1:25:33Okay, let's turn the page.
- 1:25:36And that page is also in blue ink,
- 1:25:38right?
- 1:25:39Yes.
- 1:25:40And there is no date on that next page,
- 1:25:43is there?
- 1:25:44Yes, that's correct.
- 1:25:46Then let's look at the page following
- 1:25:48that. That page, where you have your
- 1:25:50left hand on, that's also in blue ink.
- 1:25:53No, no, no, you turned the page. Go
- 1:25:54back. That's also in blue ink, correct?
- 1:25:56Yes.
- 1:25:57And there is no date on there, either,
- 1:26:00is there?
- 1:26:01That's correct.
- 1:26:03Let's turn the page.
- 1:26:07And then on the next page
- 1:26:11that's also in blue ink, correct?
- 1:26:13Yes.
- 1:26:14And there's no date on that, either,
- 1:26:15right?
- 1:26:17That is correct.
- 1:26:18The next page after that contains the
- 1:26:21initials J.A., right?
- 1:26:22Yes.
- 1:26:23That's for Jodi Arias, correct?
- 1:26:25Yes.
- 1:26:26And that's also in blue ink, correct?
- 1:26:29Yes.
- 1:26:30And there's no date in that one, is
- 1:26:32there?
- 1:26:32There is not.
- 1:26:33And if you turn the page, go ahead.
- 1:26:37There's an entry for January 24th of
- 1:26:392008, right?
- 1:26:41Yes.
- 1:26:41We can then go back, turn the page once.
- 1:26:45We're looking at the entry that says
- 1:26:47J.A. on it, right?
- 1:26:48Yes.
- 1:26:49We go to the previous page, the one that
- 1:26:51you're pointing to.
- 1:26:53It does start
- 1:26:58If I may have it back?
- 1:27:00with a word that's in quotations, right?
- 1:27:04Yes.
- 1:27:05Exhibit number
- 1:27:07458 includes
- 1:27:11that particular portion
- 1:27:14of the entry in quotations, right?
- 1:27:17Yes.
- 1:27:18And if we go to the previous page,
- 1:27:23at the bottom of the page,
- 1:27:31it's also in blue ink, right?
- 1:27:32Yes.
- 1:27:34The entry that I'm showing you now
- 1:27:36includes that last paragraph, right?
- 1:27:40Second to last.
- 1:27:41Second to last paragraph.
- 1:27:43Well, if you take a look at the bottom,
- 1:27:46you see that there's a word that
- 1:27:47You're You're correct.
- 1:27:49Okay.
- 1:27:50So, in essence, what we're talking about
- 1:27:52is that
- 1:27:53the one with the word that's crossed out
- 1:27:55then travels onto the next page,
- 1:27:57and that's what's included in this
- 1:27:59entry, correct? We in exhibit 4
- 1:28:0258, right?
- 1:28:03Yes.
- 1:28:04Along with the first page that includes
- 1:28:06the date, right?
- 1:28:07Yes.
- 1:28:08And the
- 1:28:10entry or exhibit 458 references Lonnie's
- 1:28:14baptism, right?
- 1:28:15Yes.
- 1:28:19Move for the admission of exhibit 458.
- 1:28:37Are you going to need some additional
- 1:28:38time? All right, ladies and gentlemen,
- 1:28:39we are going to take the noon recess at
- 1:28:41this time. Please be back in the jury
- 1:28:43room at 1:25.
- 1:28:46Remember the admonition. Have a nice
- 1:28:48lunch. You are excused.
- 1:28:50All right.
- 1:29:25The record will show the jury has left
- 1:29:27the courtroom in recess. You may step
- 1:29:28down. Mr. Nurmi, do you need some
- 1:29:30additional time?
- 1:29:32You may be seated in the back of the
- 1:29:33courtroom.
- 1:29:37Do you need some additional time?
- 1:29:39Yes, Judge. This is several pages and
- 1:29:41and
- 1:29:42excerpts have been removed.
- 1:29:44Pick it up at 1:25.
- 1:29:48We're at recess.
- 1:30:12Mhm.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Jodi Arias Trial - Day 21 - Part 1 (cross examination) by croakerqueen123, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,851 words across 1,642 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.