Jessup 2026 World Championship Round — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon.
- 0:07>> [applause]
- 0:11[applause]
- 0:14>> It's the same guy every time.
- 0:17Welcome to the White & Case Jessup Cup
- 0:21World Championship match.
- 0:24>> [applause]
- 0:30>> A very special hello to several
- 0:32ambassadors who've joined us this
- 0:34afternoon at the invitation of their
- 0:36Jessup teams. You honor us with your
- 0:38presence and I couldn't imagine a
- 0:41friendlier environment for you to come
- 0:42to for international diplomacy and
- 0:44international law. So, you are welcome.
- 0:48>> [applause]
- 0:55>> And to our remote teams and our friends
- 0:57watching around the world, you've
- 0:58already heard me talking about going
- 0:59live, so you you know we're live. I
- 1:02didn't know it was a hot mic.
- 1:12They said I was a hot mic.
- 1:17>> [applause]
- 1:23>> We have a fantastic championship round
- 1:25ahead of us with at you now know the
- 1:27identities three amazing judges and if I
- 1:30can say two amazing teams.
- 1:33Representing the applicant Representing
- 1:35the applicant today is the National
- 1:36University of Singapore.
- 1:42>> [applause]
- 1:50>> And representing the respondent from the
- 1:51Philippines, we have Ateneo de Manila
- 1:53University.
- 1:54>> [cheering]
- 1:55[applause]
- 2:01[applause]
- 2:03>> So, in a moment the bailiff will call
- 2:05all rise and the judges will come into
- 2:06the room. Before we do that, I want to
- 2:08ask everyone to turn off or set to
- 2:11silent mode any mobile phones, smart
- 2:14devices, beepers, holographic support
- 2:16animals, or anything else that might
- 2:18distract the round.
- 2:21Shut them down.
- 2:25Judges, would someone please add me to
- 2:27the WhatsApp group?
- 2:32Good luck to both teams.
- 2:34Have a great match.
- 2:37>> [applause]
- 2:41[applause]
- 3:12>> All rise.
- 3:14The International Court of Justice is
- 3:16now in session. President Anaya and
- 3:19honorable judges Muñoz and Akande
- 3:22presiding.
- 3:53The case before the court is the case
- 3:54concerning the Gordian Gorge. The
- 3:56parties are applicant, the Dominion of
- 3:57Alacostia, and versus respondent, the
- 4:00Republic of Rostovia.
- 4:02The applicant and respondent are each
- 4:04allocated 45 minutes to present their
- 4:05pleadings.
- 4:09Please be seated.
- 4:20Good afternoon, everybody.
- 4:22Counsel,
- 4:24looking forward to
- 4:26your presentations. We read your
- 4:27memorials with great interest.
- 4:30So, um
- 4:31applicant, please proceed.
- 4:53Please proceed.
- 4:55Mr. President, your excellencies, may it
- 4:58please the court.
- 4:59My name is Phoebe Chan and together with
- 5:02my co-agent, Miss Tan Kai Han, and our
- 5:05off counsel, Miss Lee Don Jean,
- 5:08we act on behalf of the applicant, the
- 5:11Dominion of Alacostia.
- 5:14For the first 22 minutes, I will address
- 5:16this court on the first two issues
- 5:19pertaining to Selenia's intervention and
- 5:22the consultation of the Piliman people.
- 5:25For the next 22 minutes, my co-agent
- 5:28will be addressing you on the issues
- 5:30concerning Miss Liss Scott's
- 5:32extradition, as well as the issue of
- 5:34state immunity. And we respectfully
- 5:37reserve 1 minute for rebuttals.
- 5:40To that end, we advance two main
- 5:42submissions.
- 5:44First, that Selenia should be permitted
- 5:46to intervene in these proceedings as a
- 5:49non-party pursuant to Article 62 of this
- 5:52court's statute.
- 5:54And second, that Rostovia has breached
- 5:57its obligations under both treaty and
- 6:00customary international law relating to
- 6:03the consultation of the Piliman people
- 6:05for the development of the Gordian
- 6:07Gorge. I turn to address your
- 6:09excellencies on the first issue on
- 6:11intervention.
- 6:15We note that under Article 62, a third
- 6:19state can intervene as a non-party if it
- 6:22fulfills three conditions. Namely, that
- 6:25it has a legal interest. Secondly, this
- 6:28interest may be affected by the
- 6:30proceedings. And lastly, that its object
- 6:33of intervention is proper.
- 6:35We note that this court most recently
- 6:37confirmed these conditions in its 2026
- 6:41judgment in the Sapodilla Cays
- 6:43concerning Belize and Honduras with
- 6:45Guatemala intervening.
- 6:48In this particular case, Selenia, in
- 6:51Alacostia's view, has two distinct legal
- 6:54interests.
- 6:55One, in customary international law as a
- 6:58result of its citizens' rights to the
- 7:01gorge.
- 7:02And second, in the Selenia-Rostovia
- 7:05Plateau agreement, which I will address
- 7:07in time.
- 7:11Firstly, on the customary international
- 7:14law interest,
- 7:15our position is that Selenia has a clear
- 7:18interest in this court's determination
- 7:21of the customary obligation on free,
- 7:24prior, and informed consent of the
- 7:26Piliman people.
- 7:28Your excellencies, we note that the
- 7:30respondent relies on the 1990 Gulf of
- 7:33Fonseca decision between El Salvador and
- 7:36Honduras, wherein this court stated that
- 7:39a general interest in the rules and
- 7:41principles of international law is
- 7:43insufficient for the purposes of Article
- 7:4662.
- 7:47But our argument in this case stretches
- 7:50beyond that. And that is because this
- 7:53court is specifically determining
- 7:56whether or not this obligation has been
- 7:58breached by Rostovia to the Piliman
- 8:00people.
- 8:02And we also note that this stems from
- 8:04the very recognition that indigenous
- 8:06peoples, as a collective, have the right
- 8:09to their traditional lands, here being
- 8:12the Piliman people.
- 8:13And therefore, our position Are the Are
- 8:16the Piliman people in Selenia
- 8:19clearly indigenous?
- 8:21And they're the majority in that
- 8:22country, is that correct? Your
- 8:24excellency, we note that they are a
- 8:26majority in the country, but that does
- 8:28not preclude them from being indigenous.
- 8:30What it means to be indigenous would be
- 8:32having a certain spiritual and
- 8:35connection to this land that they now
- 8:36refer to as the Tonga Plateau. And for
- 8:3940,000 years, the Piliman people across
- 8:42all three states have in fact venerated
- 8:44the Tonga Plateau and maintained their
- 8:46cultural connection to this land. And
- 8:48for that reason, we would consider
- 8:49Selenia's citizens to also be
- 8:51indigenous.
- 8:52>> Well, that would mean a lot of people in
- 8:54Europe would be indigenous, right? Who
- 8:55have long-standing connections with
- 8:57their
- 8:59their countries. Is that right?
- 9:01Well, your excellency, not quite. Our
- 9:04Our understanding of indigenous peoples
- 9:06would refer to the first nations of this
- 9:08land, and this being the indigenous
- 9:11people of Pilimo in this present case.
- 9:13And in the example of Europe, that would
- 9:15potentially be the Sami people that we
- 9:17note span across
- 9:18>> the Scots or the Irish?
- 9:20Well, your excellency, we certainly
- 9:22understand that those could also be
- 9:23understood as indigenous, and we would
- 9:25certainly be happy for your excellencies
- 9:27to acknowledge them as such. And in this
- 9:29>> Counsel, following on that, would you
- 9:31characterize the Pilimos as a
- 9:33transnational indigenous people? And
- 9:36what concrete legal consequences would
- 9:38follow from that, if so?
- 9:41Your excellency, would you be referring
- 9:43to the recognition that the Piliman
- 9:45people here are indigenous?
- 9:46No, I would like to know if, according
- 9:50to your understanding, the Pilimos is a
- 9:53transnational indigenous people. So,
- 9:56because they
- 9:57they live in three different countries.
- 10:00And they have they share characteristic
- 10:02of spiritual as you said. So.
- 10:05Yes, Your Excellency. The very fact that
- 10:08the Piliman people are straddled across
- 10:10these three borders does not preclude
- 10:12them from being considered as a
- 10:14collective indigenous to the Tunga
- 10:16Plateau. And this is because for
- 10:18instance at Article 26 of the UN
- 10:21Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous
- 10:22Peoples, it is noted that indigenous
- 10:25peoples have the right to their
- 10:26traditional lands. And there is no
- 10:28artificial distinction as to who whether
- 10:31or not disparaged between three states
- 10:34has the entitlement to this land. And
- 10:36therefore our position is that this
- 10:38court's determination on the scope and
- 10:40content of the FPIC obligation in
- 10:43relation to the Piliman people will
- 10:45necessarily implicate Selenia's
- 10:47interests in its own Piliman citizens'
- 10:50rights. And on that I turn to address
- 10:52Your Excellencies on the second interest
- 10:54which we understand Selenia to have.
- 10:56Just before you move on to the second
- 10:58interest. So, your argument is that this
- 11:01court in making a decision in this case
- 11:04will have to decide on
- 11:07legal interests of of Selenia.
- 11:10Does that then suggest that in the
- 11:12absence if we do not grant intervention
- 11:15that we would be precluded from deciding
- 11:17this case because of the monetary gold
- 11:19principle?
- 11:22To take Your Excellency's question in
- 11:24two parts. Firstly, we do submit that
- 11:27this claim in fact involves all Piliman
- 11:30people. And that is because Alacosta is
- 11:32invoking standing on the basis of an
- 11:35erga omnes obligation. That being the
- 11:37obligation to the right of
- 11:38self-determination which we understand
- 11:40the obligation to obtain free prior and
- 11:43informed consent stems from. And on your
- 11:45second question, we note that in the
- 11:48absence of Selenia this would not in
- 11:50fact trigger the monetary gold doctrine
- 11:52being applied. And that is because the
- 11:54original way in which the monetary gold
- 11:56principle was applied was concerning
- 11:59whether or not the court would have to
- 12:01make a predetermination
- 12:03of the international responsibility of
- 12:05an absent state. And this was for
- 12:07instance noted in the 1990 Gulf of
- 12:09Fonseca case where this court considered
- 12:12that Nicaragua's interests, though
- 12:14implicated, was not going to be a
- 12:16monetary gold party in that sense. And
- 12:18therefore our position is that Selenia,
- 12:20though it should have an interest and be
- 12:22allowed to intervene, would not preclude
- 12:24this court from exercising jurisdiction
- 12:26over the second issue.
- 12:27And on the Selenia and Restovia Plateau
- 12:29Agreement, I turn to address this
- 12:31interest.
- 12:34Now, we note that the respondent in
- 12:35their memorials attempt to draw analogy
- 12:38to this court's 2001 Pulau Ligitan
- 12:41decision arguing that Selenia's interest
- 12:45in the Sarpa is not sufficiently
- 12:47proximate to the proceedings.
- 12:50While we fully acknowledge that the
- 12:52Sarpa is not being put forth for this
- 12:54court's consideration,
- 12:56our position is that this does not
- 12:58preclude its interest from being
- 13:00affected nonetheless.
- 13:02And this is because it is acknowledged
- 13:04by the respondents themselves that the
- 13:06Articles 17 and 18 of both treaties are
- 13:10identical in text. Now, not only are
- 13:13they identical in text, but they also
- 13:15share overlapping object, purpose, and
- 13:18the circumstances surrounding this
- 13:20conclusion. And that's because in 1971
- 13:24Selenia was the very state who initiated
- 13:27the conference with the
- 13:29with the express objective of ensuring
- 13:31that the Pilimans would have lasting
- 13:32access to the plateau.
- 13:34And therefore our position is that this
- 13:36court in interpreting Article 18 of the
- 13:38Alacosta Restovia Plateau Agreement
- 13:41might therefore influence a future
- 13:43interpretation of the Selenia Restovia
- 13:45Plateau Agreement.
- 13:47But counsel, are there not other
- 13:49elements of treaty interpretation that
- 13:51might suggest that the two treaties
- 13:54could be interpreted differently?
- 13:57Absolutely, Your Excellency. We do note
- 13:59that the parties, being in fact
- 14:01signatories to the Vienna Convention on
- 14:02the Law of Treaties, would subscribe to
- 14:05the general principles of treaty
- 14:07interpretation which we understand to
- 14:08mean that the is each distinct bilateral
- 14:11treaty is to be interpreted differently.
- 14:14But that is not the standard for what an
- 14:16for when an interest may be affected
- 14:18under Article 62.
- 14:21Threshold for maybe affected is a low
- 14:23one and the very fact that they may be
- 14:25interpreted differently is not itself a
- 14:27precondition to allowing Selenia's
- 14:30intervention. What we are saying is that
- 14:32the overlapping circumstances, the
- 14:35identical text of the provisions, and
- 14:37the overarching purpose of both treaties
- 14:40may result in this court finding a
- 14:42similar interpretation and on that basis
- 14:44it should be permitted to intervene.
- 14:47I turn then to the proper object of
- 14:49intervention requirement.
- 14:51We note that the respondents have
- 14:53contested within their memorials that
- 14:55Selenia does not have a proper object of
- 14:58intervention
- 14:59because it has indicated its intention
- 15:02to pursue future litigation against
- 15:05Restovia.
- 15:06But we also note that this court in its
- 15:08recent decision of the Sarpa de Agua
- 15:10case has decided that having a
- 15:13having a separate claim is not itself a
- 15:16bar to
- 15:18to an application to intervene under
- 15:20Article 62.
- 15:21And for that reason, because in our view
- 15:24Selenia has clearly expressed its
- 15:26interest to protect the rights of its
- 15:28citizens, that should itself constitute
- 15:31a proper object of intervention and that
- 15:33its intervention should in fact be
- 15:35permitted by this court.
- 15:37But isn't there a difference though
- 15:38between those two case the case that you
- 15:41cite and and the present one? In the
- 15:43case that you cite there were already
- 15:45existing proceedings. In this case
- 15:48wouldn't the third party be using
- 15:50intervention as a way of actually
- 15:52bringing its own claims effectively into
- 15:55decision in this particular case?
- 16:01Absolutely, Your Excellency. Firstly, we
- 16:04do absolutely note that in the Sarpa de
- 16:06Agua case decision Guatemala had already
- 16:09submitted itself to the binding
- 16:10jurisdiction of the court in a separate
- 16:12proceeding. But in this particular case,
- 16:15what we are concerned with, although we
- 16:17do note that Selenia has also a
- 16:19potential avenue of claim, is balancing
- 16:22the interests of Selenia's interest in
- 16:24intervening and protecting its citizens
- 16:26and the interest of considering whether
- 16:28there is an abuse of process. And we
- 16:30note that nothing on the facts suggest
- 16:32that there is such an abuse of process
- 16:34and even if Selenia is allowed to
- 16:36intervene, it would not impermissibly
- 16:38broaden the scope of this dispute
- 16:40because fundamentally we are still
- 16:42concerned with what is in the prayer at
- 16:4459b and that is the interpretation of
- 16:47the Alacosta Restovia Plateau Agreement
- 16:50and the determination of FPIC at custom.
- 16:53Therefore,
- 16:54we ask this court to still consider
- 16:56Selenia's interest in intervening and I
- 16:58move to the second issue on
- 17:00consultation.
- 17:02We submit that Restovia has violated its
- 17:05obligations under both treaty and
- 17:08customary international law.
- 17:10And that is because Restovia has failed
- 17:13to consult the Piliman people with a
- 17:15view of obtaining their free, prior, and
- 17:18informed consent.
- 17:20We note this to be the position
- 17:21reflected in Article 32 subsection two
- 17:25of the UN Declaration on the Rights of
- 17:26Indigenous Peoples which was Your
- 17:29Excellency. Yes, please. I would like
- 17:31you explain the legal sources that
- 17:33support your definition of free, prior,
- 17:36and informed consent.
- 17:38Your Excellency, we note that this was
- 17:40not explicitly defined in the UN
- 17:42Declaration, but the elements of free,
- 17:45prior, and informed consent respectively
- 17:48free being free from coercion, prior
- 17:51being prior to any commencement of
- 17:53activities, informed meaning that the
- 17:56the indigenous community is sufficiently
- 17:58apprised of the consequences of the
- 18:00project, and consent being that the
- 18:02state should aspire to obtain the
- 18:04consent of the indigenous community.
- 18:06Agent, what what what is the the legal
- 18:08source for that standard you just laid
- 18:11out? Your Excellency.
- 18:12>> the declaration, but that's not a
- 18:14treaty, is it? Absolutely, it is not.
- 18:16>> then what is your legal source? We note
- 18:19that this has for instance been
- 18:21considered by the Inter-American Court
- 18:23in the decision of Agua and Colombia
- 18:252024 and is also noted by the UN expert
- 18:30UN Human Rights Mechanism in their
- 18:33report on the rights of indigenous
- 18:35peoples. And therefore that is our
- 18:36position Are there
- 18:38is is is is that expert report a source
- 18:41of international law? We we would
- 18:43absolutely support our conclusion that
- 18:45this court can have reference to these
- 18:48reports as a subsidiary means of
- 18:50international law or determining the
- 18:52scope and content of international law.
- 18:54And in fact we also support this
- 18:56obligation with the practice of states
- 18:58and opinion juris. For instance, we note
- 19:00that in 2007 the UN Declaration was
- 19:03adopted in overwhelming favor by 143
- 19:07states voting in favor. And this
- 19:10contemporaneously is also supported by
- 19:12the practice of at least 57 states who
- 19:15have consultation practices. We note
- 19:17that amongst amongst the countries of
- 19:20this world there are around 85 ethnic
- 19:22indigenous peoples. On opinion juris
- 19:25then, we note that states
- 19:27>> some states voted against and others
- 19:30abstained.
- 19:31Yes, Your Excellency. We note that the
- 19:33most famous objectors, including the
- 19:35Kansas states being Canada, Australia,
- 19:38New Zealand, and the United States, all
- 19:40subsequently later endorsed the
- 19:42declaration in fact because they
- 19:44believed it to, although be
- 19:46aspirational, reflective of the
- 19:48standards that states should aspire to
- 19:50achieve in their domestic legislations,
- 19:53and in fact, Canada, for instance, has
- 19:55in fact adopted the Injured Act, which
- 19:58customizes or which codifies this
- 20:00customary international law provision.
- 20:03But are you considering free prior prior
- 20:06informed consent as part of the
- 20:07customary law international customary
- 20:10law, and if so, why? Because until now I
- 20:13am not clear
- 20:15according to your arguments, please.
- 20:17Absolutely, Your Excellency. I
- 20:19understand in relation to your question,
- 20:21you might be referring to two distinct
- 20:23obligations, one being the obligation to
- 20:25consult with a view of obtaining
- 20:27consent, and one being the obligation to
- 20:30actually obtain free prior and informed
- 20:32consent. For the latter, we note that
- 20:34there are practices of states with which
- 20:36support this rule, including Bolivia,
- 20:39India, Nepal, but we also note that the
- 20:41practice of states is not yet fully
- 20:43consistent, and for that reason, our
- 20:45submission rests on the first, being
- 20:47that consultation should at least be
- 20:49done with a view of obtaining free prior
- 20:51and informed consent. This is supported
- 20:53by the opinion juris of states like
- 20:55Finland, Estonia, Peru, as well as
- 20:58Bolivia and Canada.
- 21:00Where's the opinion juris? What what
- 21:02what Where do we find the opinion juris?
- 21:04Yes, Your Excellency. These states have
- 21:07all articulated that the requirement of
- 21:10the participation of indigenous peoples
- 21:12in decision-making is, and I quote here,
- 21:15a legal requirement fundamental to the
- 21:18implementation of the rights enshrined
- 21:20in the Injured. And one such example was
- 21:22Saramaka, which stated before the
- 21:24Inter-American Court in 2015
- 21:27that free, prior, and informed consent
- 21:31is an international requirement that
- 21:33states should adhere to when consulting
- 21:36indigenous peoples.
- 21:37>> was that? This was the decision of the
- 21:39Kaliña and Lokono people, Your
- 21:41Excellency.
- 21:41>> And and the what?
- 21:42So sorry, could you say that again? The
- 21:44Kaliña people, Your Excellency.
- 21:47But are they interpreting are they
- 21:49saying that's a rule of customary
- 21:50international law, or are they
- 21:51interpreting the American Convention on
- 21:53Human Rights?
- 21:54>> We do absolutely note that in the
- 21:56Inter-American context, there is that
- 21:58convention, but they also make explicit
- 22:00reference to the Injured and
- 22:01international standards of customary
- 22:03international law.
- 22:04>> referring to the declaration to to
- 22:07interpret the American Convention? Isn't
- 22:09that what they're doing
- 22:11in those cases? Well, yes, Your
- 22:13Excellency. That is part of their
- 22:15decision, but with respect to the
- 22:17reasoning of the judgment, we can also
- 22:18have reference to the fact that the
- 22:20Inter-American Court has on multiple
- 22:22occasions looked to the standard at
- 22:24customary international law. And what
- 22:27our position is is that this obligation
- 22:29is one of process.
- 22:31This requires that the state consult the
- 22:34indigenous community. Excuse me,
- 22:36Counsel. And how the
- 22:38Inter-American Court decision can be
- 22:40applicable
- 22:42for this court? And my second question
- 22:44is about
- 22:47because it's not clear to me if you are
- 22:49considering
- 22:50that they are an
- 22:52international obligation to consult or
- 22:55to consent. Mhm. And I would like to to
- 22:58listen more
- 23:00and justify because
- 23:02this is an important point for this
- 23:04court.
- 23:04>> Absolutely, Your Excellency. To firstly
- 23:06clear up the confusion, our obligation
- 23:09is one which requires the state to
- 23:10consult with a view of obtaining
- 23:12consent. This is not a right to an
- 23:15outcome, but one to a process. And on
- 23:18the judicial decisions of the
- 23:19Inter-American Court, we note that they
- 23:21are a subsidiary means of interpreting
- 23:24the law as noted by Article 38(1)(d) of
- 23:27this court's statute. And if I could
- 23:29provide some clarity on what exactly
- 23:31this obligation entails, it requires,
- 23:34firstly, that information be provided
- 23:37and made accessible to the indigenous
- 23:38community.
- 23:40Secondly, that genuine dialogues happen,
- 23:43and thirdly, the dialogues happen with
- 23:45an aim of obtaining free, prior, and
- 23:47informed consent. Counsel, I think we're
- 23:49fairly clear on on your argument about
- 23:51the content of the standard um but the
- 23:54source, where do we get a legal
- 23:56standard? You cite to jurisprudence of
- 23:59the Inter-American Court, they're
- 24:01interpreting the American Convention,
- 24:03aren't they? Are they interpreting a
- 24:04treaty?
- 24:05So where do we get a customary rule
- 24:08as as your
- 24:10your your arguing is
- 24:12the practice you're referring to simply
- 24:15the adoption of the declaration, is that
- 24:17the practice?
- 24:18No, Your Excellency. We're simply citing
- 24:20one case, but rather our position is
- 24:22that this is in fact a distillation of
- 24:25the principles that multiple courts have
- 24:27used in order to determine whether the
- 24:29state's obligation has been fulfilled.
- 24:31So we don't just rely on the
- 24:32Inter-American Court's practices, but
- 24:34also the African Court on Human and
- 24:36Peoples' Rights, which we also note is
- 24:39also interpreting a convention, but also
- 24:41the federal court decisions of Canada,
- 24:44as well as New Zealand and Australia.
- 24:46>> of Canada, right? Well, Canada does in
- 24:48fact have the Injured Act, which is
- 24:50meant to reflect the provisions of the
- 24:53the UN Declaration on the Rights of
- 24:54Indigenous Peoples, Your Excellency.
- 24:57And if I could perhaps refer this court
- 24:59to a decision by the Inter-American
- 25:01Court once again, in the 2024 decision
- 25:04of Uwa and Colombia, there the court had
- 25:07considered that although the state
- 25:09required that the company perform its
- 25:12obligations with respect to the
- 25:13community's integrity and access to the
- 25:16land, in that case, it had also set up
- 25:19opportunities for the dialogue between
- 25:20the state and the community, but
- 25:22nevertheless, the state was considered
- 25:25to be found in breach of its obligation.
- 25:28And that was because it had essentially
- 25:30been embarking on a predetermined plan
- 25:33to exploit the land, and therefore, it
- 25:35was not in fact a genuine dialogue aimed
- 25:38at obtaining the consent of the
- 25:40indigenous community. And we draw an
- 25:42analogy to this present case, where we
- 25:44say Restovia failed to do three things.
- 25:47It failed to provide information, making
- 25:49it sufficiently sufficiently accessible
- 25:51to the community. It failed to properly
- 25:53engage in meaningful dialogues, and
- 25:55finally, it failed to actually obtain or
- 25:59aim to obtain the consent of the
- 26:01community. And Your Excellencies, I
- 26:03point you to a few salient facts,
- 26:06being that yes, we do note that there
- 26:08were documents provided, but these were
- 26:11thousands of pages of technical
- 26:13>> Um state me in terms that Yes. in in
- 26:17better understand where to subtly human
- 26:20rights or people indigenous peoples'
- 26:22rights are affected by the consultation
- 26:25process
- 26:26according to the facts of the case.
- 26:29Are there only spiritual and cultural
- 26:31aspects, or there are also aspects
- 26:33related to environment, for instance, in
- 26:36the context of climate change,
- 26:38future generations? Could you explain
- 26:40more about this?
- 26:42Absolutely, Your Excellency. We note
- 26:44that the free, prior, and informed
- 26:45consent obligation is a procedural right
- 26:48aimed at guaranteeing the substantive
- 26:50right of indigenous peoples to, for
- 26:52instance, their right to culture, their
- 26:54right to use and enjoy land. I note my
- 26:56time, Your Excellency. If I could have
- 26:5830 seconds to conclude.
- 27:00>> Your Excellencies, including their right
- 27:02to determine what happens to their land.
- 27:04And if I may be allowed some time to
- 27:06conclude my my submissions on Restovia's
- 27:09obligation, our position is that because
- 27:11they overloaded the elders with
- 27:13technical information, failed to even
- 27:16allow more than 7 hours for a total of
- 27:19200 preliminary elders across five
- 27:21forums to actually meaningfully provide
- 27:23consent. Thank you, Your Excellency.
- 28:05Good afternoon. Please proceed. Thank
- 28:07you.
- 28:13Mr. President Anaya, honorable Judges
- 28:16Muñoyza and Aponte, may it please the
- 28:18court.
- 28:19As introduced by my co-counsel,
- 28:22my name is Tan Kai Han, and I appear as
- 28:25second agent for the Dominion of
- 28:27Lacustria.
- 28:29For the next 22 minutes, I will be
- 28:31covering the issues of Ms. Lisscott's
- 28:33extradition,
- 28:35as well as Nexca's claim to state
- 28:36immunity.
- 28:38Now, I make two submissions.
- 28:41Firstly, that Lacustria did not violate
- 28:44its extradition treaty with Restovia
- 28:47when it refused to surrender Ms.
- 28:49Lisscott.
- 28:51And secondly, that Restovia violated
- 28:53international law when it refused to
- 28:56grant state immunity to Nexca in the
- 28:59civil suit filed by the estate of the
- 29:01late Mr. Domingo Montoya.
- 29:03I turn first to the issue of
- 29:05extradition.
- 29:08Under the extradition treaty,
- 29:10Lacustria is entitled to refuse to
- 29:13surrender Ms. Scott if her extradition
- 29:16would be contrary to the general
- 29:18principles of law under Article 38(1)(c)
- 29:22of this court's statute.
- 29:24I make two points.
- 29:26Firstly, that ne bis in idem, or double
- 29:29jeopardy, is a general principle of law.
- 29:33And secondly, that Ms. Scott's
- 29:35extradition would place her in double
- 29:37jeopardy, contrary to the general
- 29:40principles of law.
- 29:42On the first point, Your Excellencies, a
- 29:44two-limbed test is applied to determine
- 29:48the content and existence of general
- 29:50principles of law.
- 29:52The first is that a principle must be
- 29:55identified across national legal
- 29:57systems, a common principle.
- 30:00And the second is that this principle
- 30:02must be transposable to the
- 30:03international legal system.
- 30:06This test
- 30:07>> would
- 30:08the double jeopardy principle also
- 30:10qualify as a norm of customary
- 30:13international law?
- 30:15No, your Excellency, our submission is
- 30:16only that it is a general principle of
- 30:18law and that that is what is required
- 30:20under the extradition treaty to bar Ms.
- 30:22Scott's extradition.
- 30:25And So, it does not constitute a
- 30:28No, Mr. President.
- 30:30Now, this test was articulated by the
- 30:33International Law Commission in its 2023
- 30:36conclusions on the identifications of
- 30:39general principles of law and it is
- 30:41reflective of this court's
- 30:42jurisprudence, for instance, in the 1949
- 30:45Corfu Channel case and the 1970
- 30:48Barcelona Traction case.
- 30:51Applying this this test to the present
- 30:54circumstances,
- 30:55double jeopardy refers to the principle
- 30:58that no man should be tried twice for
- 31:00the same criminal matter
- 31:02following a final trial producing a
- 31:05judicial decision on the merits.
- 31:08This principle, your Excellencies, is
- 31:11found in most, if not all, national
- 31:13legal systems in the world, including
- 31:16common law traditions such as the UK,
- 31:19US, India, and South Africa, as well as
- 31:21civil law traditions such as Russia,
- 31:23Japan, and Germany. So, when you say no
- 31:25person should be tried twice
- 31:28twice in the same country, twice in
- 31:32different countries, twice in the same
- 31:34jurisdiction, or does it not matter?
- 31:37We would say twice across different
- 31:40countries in this case is what we're
- 31:41arguing for, your Excellency, a
- 31:44transnational double jeopardy. But we
- 31:46note that what I've just cited are inter
- 31:48state rules of double jeopardy. On top
- 31:51of that, however, we would point to the
- 31:53extradition acts of various countries,
- 31:55including Malaysia, the UK, Estonia, and
- 31:58Ghana, all of which contain double
- 32:01jeopardy as a mandatory grounds of
- 32:03refusing an extradition of a person. And
- 32:05so, there is common principle across
- 32:07these states. So, you have a few states
- 32:10that explicitly provide for a
- 32:12transnational
- 32:14rule against double jeopardy. Does that
- 32:17suffice to make it a general principle
- 32:19of law if it's just a few states? Well,
- 32:21your Excellency, it's not just these
- 32:22states that we rely on, but also
- 32:24extradition treaties concluded between
- 32:26many, many other states, all of which,
- 32:28to our knowledge, contain such an
- 32:30exception to double jeopardy. But you
- 32:33said that for a general principle of
- 32:35law, you have to find a rule that's
- 32:36common to national legal systems.
- 32:39So, how can we What is the relevance of
- 32:42these extradition treaties for the
- 32:44purpose of finding a general principle
- 32:46of law?
- 32:47Well, the relevance of these extradition
- 32:49treaties becomes more apparent at the
- 32:50second stage of finding a general
- 32:52principle of law, namely the stage of
- 32:54transposability.
- 32:56That's because the stage of
- 32:58transposability requires that a
- 33:00principle that is common to various
- 33:02national legal systems can apply on the
- 33:05international plane without conflicting
- 33:08with the existing structures and
- 33:09principles of the international legal
- 33:11system.
- 33:12>> But can't can't the general principle
- 33:14also be generated a general principle of
- 33:16law?
- 33:17Can't Can't it also be generated by the
- 33:19international legal system and not just
- 33:22domestic legal systems?
- 33:24Certainly, Mr. President.
- 33:26>> these treaties would be relevant
- 33:28to the formation of a general principle
- 33:29of international law in this regard? Is
- 33:31that part of your argument as well?
- 33:33Yes, Mr. President. Our alternative
- 33:35argument would be that double jeopardy
- 33:37can be found as an intrinsic general
- 33:39principle, but our primary argument is
- 33:41that these treaties are proof of
- 33:43transposability of a principle that is
- 33:45generated in national legal systems. But
- 33:47on your first argument, sure, you argue
- 33:50that these treaties can be used for
- 33:51transposability, but first of all, you
- 33:54have to get over the hurdle, as you
- 33:56said, that it's a principle that's
- 33:58common to
- 34:00various national legal systems. So,
- 34:02that's the key question, isn't it? Is
- 34:04your trans is the transnational
- 34:06principle of double jeopardy, or against
- 34:09double jeopardy, is that common to
- 34:11various national legal systems?
- 34:13I understand that that was your
- 34:14Excellency's earlier concern as well
- 34:16regarding commonality specifically. Now,
- 34:19while a rule of transnational double
- 34:21jeopardy is certainly not as common as
- 34:24an inter state rule of double jeopardy,
- 34:26we submit that the exact same principle
- 34:28underlies all these different variations
- 34:30of double jeopardy, namely that no man
- 34:33should be tried twice for the same. And
- 34:35in any case, your Excellency, the very
- 34:38foundation of a general principle is the
- 34:40concept of a principle that is borrowed
- 34:43from national legal systems. So, it is
- 34:45fine if the principle that is common
- 34:47applies inter state because at the
- 34:49transposability stage is when we
- 34:51determine that this principle can also
- 34:54apply on an international level.
- 34:56Counsel, but what about the
- 34:57international law in this in this
- 35:01argument that you are trying to expose?
- 35:03Because I I miss references to the
- 35:07international law applicable. If so,
- 35:10could you please
- 35:11explain about it?
- 35:13Well, your Excellency, you're asking
- 35:14about how this general principle
- 35:16manifests as a rule of international
- 35:18law?
- 35:18>> Yes, please. It will only apply if I can
- 35:20establish the second stage of
- 35:21transposability, your Excellency, and I
- 35:23will proceed to do so.
- 35:25Now, we note that where a principle
- 35:27already exists on the international
- 35:29plane, for instance, as is reflected in
- 35:31treaty rules, this would be evidence
- 35:33that it is transposable, as was noted by
- 35:36the International Law Commission in its
- 35:382025 fourth report on general principles
- 35:41of law. Now, we say that double jeopardy
- 35:44is transposable to the international
- 35:46legal system, and we do note that the
- 35:49respondents have argued in their written
- 35:51memorials that double jeopardy conflicts
- 35:54with the principle of sovereign
- 35:55equality, but we would respectfully
- 35:58disagree with that.
- 35:59Per the 1970 Friendly Relations
- 36:01Declaration, sovereign equality merely
- 36:04requires that the same legal rules must
- 36:06apply to all states equally.
- 36:09Now, we acknowledge, your Excellencies,
- 36:12that an application of a transnational
- 36:14rule of double jeopardy would require
- 36:17states to refrain from exercising their
- 36:19own criminal jurisdiction when another
- 36:21state has already subjected an accused
- 36:23to a final judicial decision on the
- 36:25merits.
- 36:26However, your Excellencies, this rule
- 36:28applies equally to all states.
- 36:30>> How about How about to indigenous
- 36:32peoples? Does it apply to them?
- 36:34Say, so the Pilamon, does
- 36:37I assume they have their own
- 36:39jurisdiction, internal dispute
- 36:41resolution mechanism. What if Ms. Scott
- 36:43had been
- 36:44uh adjudicated by that and held
- 36:47not guilty or guilty?
- 36:50Does this rule apply to them as well?
- 36:52To their judicial systems?
- 36:54Mr. President, we do not go so far as to
- 36:56suggest that the Pilamons are a nation
- 36:59of their own. Their right to
- 37:00self-determination is an internal
- 37:02>> they they assume they have, like many
- 37:04indigenous peoples across the world,
- 37:06have their own jurisdiction, their own
- 37:08internal judicial
- 37:10or adjudicative dispute resolution
- 37:12system.
- 37:14They are certainly entitled to apply
- 37:16their own dispute resolution systems as
- 37:18long as it is with respect to the
- 37:21territorial sovereignty of the states in
- 37:22which they are contained.
- 37:23>> say they say they prosecuted Ms. Ms.
- 37:26Scott and found that she was
- 37:29uh not guilty or guilty, either one.
- 37:32Would that be subject to the double
- 37:34jeopardy?
- 37:35No, Mr. President, we would not say that
- 37:37because the Pilamons
- 37:39um cannot be said to be recognized as a
- 37:41sovereign state. And when we talk about
- 37:42transnational double jeopardy, we are
- 37:44talking about the principle as applied
- 37:47between recognized sovereign states.
- 37:50Now,
- 37:51on my earlier point regarding why it
- 37:53does not conflict with sovereign
- 37:54equality, we do note that any principle
- 37:57of double jeopardy would apply across
- 37:59all states equally. So, even if it were
- 38:01to produce a differentiated result in
- 38:04this case, that does not mean that the
- 38:05rule contradicts with sovereign
- 38:06equality. If, for instance, Westovia had
- 38:09prosecuted Ms. Lis Scott first, we
- 38:11certainly would not be trying to
- 38:13prosecute her again,
- 38:15which takes me to the facts of this very
- 38:16case, your Excellencies.
- 38:18Ms. Scott is being tried for the exact
- 38:21same conduct for which the Alacostrian
- 38:24Court of Appeal has already tried her.
- 38:26This can be seen at paragraphs 40 40 and
- 38:2944 of the copy.
- 38:30>> or the same crime?
- 38:32The same conduct is our primary
- 38:33submission, your Excellency, and the
- 38:35reason why the same conduct test should
- 38:38apply on an international level is
- 38:40because there is a lack of harmonization
- 38:43between national criminal legislation,
- 38:45as was noted, for instance, by the
- 38:47European Court of Justice in the 2006
- 38:49case of Van Esbreck. But even if we were
- 38:52to compare the crimes in Alacostria and
- 38:55Westovia, we submit that they are the
- 38:57substantially similar offenses that
- 38:59would place Ms. Scott in double
- 39:01jeopardy.
- 39:02We take guidance, for instance, from the
- 39:04test applied by the UK House of Lords in
- 39:06the 1964 case of Connelly and DPP, in
- 39:10which it states, "Where facts fulfill
- 39:13the legal elements of one offense
- 39:15fulfill the legal elements of the other,
- 39:17that can be considered the same
- 39:19offense." And that is the case in this
- 39:20situation.
- 39:22Now, the second inquiry for the court
- 39:24would therefore be whether Alacostrian
- 39:26Court of Appeal's decision was one that
- 39:28was on the merits.
- 39:31And we say that it was, your
- 39:32Excellencies, notwithstanding that she
- 39:34was acquitted for a breach of her right
- 39:36to silence.
- 39:37The reason for this is because fair
- 39:39trial rights are a of substance and not
- 39:42mere procedural technicality.
- 39:45This was noted, for instance, by the
- 39:47European Court of Human Rights in the
- 39:492023 case of Lalique and Poland.
- 39:52Now, this is because a breach of fair
- 39:54trial rights affects how the court
- 39:56assesses the evidence against the
- 39:58accused.
- 40:00For instance, it changes what kind of
- 40:03inferences can be made from the evidence
- 40:05that Ms. Scott has given.
- 40:07>> the court didn't get to that evidence,
- 40:08did it?
- 40:09Well, it did, Mr. President, and we can
- 40:11say that because, as can be seen from
- 40:13paragraph 43 of the facts, the court did
- 40:16go through a full briefing of the
- 40:18information that was provided before the
- 40:20first court, as well as the arguments
- 40:22between the parties. And so, the court
- 40:24did have sight of all the evidence
- 40:26before them. And a breach of a right to
- 40:28silence would affect the way they
- 40:30considered the evidence, for instance,
- 40:32in the kind of inferences that can be
- 40:34drawn from evidence that was obtained in
- 40:36breach of a right to silence, and the
- 40:38consequences
- 40:40inferences and the conclusions that the
- 40:42court can reach based on such evidence.
- 40:44All of which, your excellencies, goes to
- 40:47the decision on the merits because it
- 40:49goes to consideration of Ms. Liz Scott's
- 40:52criminal responsibility for filling the
- 40:54elements of the charge.
- 40:56And therefore, we say Ms. Scott was
- 40:58subject to a final judicial decision on
- 41:00the merits in Alacostra,
- 41:02and her extradition would place her in
- 41:04double jeopardy contrary to the general
- 41:06principles of law.
- 41:09I turn now to my second submission on
- 41:11state immunity, your excellencies.
- 41:18Now, under Alacostra's fourth prayer,
- 41:22we submit that Restovia violated
- 41:24international law by refusing to grant
- 41:27the National Extraction Company of
- 41:29Alacostra, or Nexca, state immunity in
- 41:32the civil suit filed by the estate of
- 41:34the late Mr. Domingo Montoya.
- 41:37We make two points.
- 41:39Firstly, that Nexca was entitled to
- 41:41state immunity for its operation of the
- 41:47And secondly, that the personal
- 41:49>> Did you refer already the
- 41:50transpossibility question in the double
- 41:53double jeopardy
- 41:55principle in the non
- 41:56non bis in idem principle?
- 41:59I I missed the point about the the
- 42:01sources and international law that you
- 42:03used. Could you please summarize that?
- 42:05Yes, my summary of the ne bis in idem
- 42:07principle is that it is a general
- 42:09principle of law under Article 38 1C of
- 42:13this court's statute, and that is
- 42:15because upon applying the test of
- 42:16commonality and transposability, we can
- 42:19identify such a principle, which is then
- 42:21incorporated into Article 4 of
- 42:23Alacostra's and Restovia's extradition
- 42:25treaty as a preclusion to extradition.
- 42:29Now, on the issue of state immunity, our
- 42:31second point would be that the personal
- 42:34injury or loss exception,
- 42:36also known as the territorial tort
- 42:38exception, does not apply in this case.
- 42:42On my first point,
- 42:44acts that are an exercise of sovereign
- 42:46authority are cloaked with state
- 42:49immunity from the jurisdiction of
- 42:51foreign national courts.
- 42:53This is a well-recognized rule of
- 42:55customary international law, recognized
- 42:58by this court, for instance, in the 2012
- 43:01case of Jurisdictional Immunities.
- 43:03Immunity, we submit, extends to a
- 43:06separate entity that is authorized by a
- 43:09state to perform and is actually
- 43:12performing an act in the exercise of
- 43:14sovereign authority. And that is because
- 43:16these acts are attributable to the
- 43:19state.
- 43:20In this case, Nexca was indeed
- 43:23authorized under national law, as can be
- 43:25seen at paragraph 24 of the compromis
- 43:27and 26.
- 43:29It was authorized by Parliament and also
- 43:31the Minister of Foreign Affairs to bid
- 43:34in the Gordian Gorge project.
- 43:37The real question for this court, then,
- 43:39is whether or not the operation of the
- 43:41SARV to obtain cost estimates in
- 43:44furtherance of the Gordian Gorge bid was
- 43:47indeed an act in the exercise of
- 43:49sovereign authority. Before we get to
- 43:51the acts in the exercise of sovereign
- 43:53authority point, are you suggesting that
- 43:55merely because the state authorized the
- 43:58conduct, the conduct is attributable to
- 44:01the state? Is that the claim?
- 44:04Yes, authorization under international
- 44:06law would mean that the act is
- 44:09attributable to the state, but it does
- 44:11not instantly accord immunity for the
- 44:13act, your excellency.
- 44:16But your claim is that if it's
- 44:17attributable and it's
- 44:19something done in the exercise of
- 44:20sovereign authority, then there's
- 44:22immunity. On the attribution point,
- 44:25where can we find this principle that
- 44:27just because an act is authorized by the
- 44:29state,
- 44:31it's attributable to the state? Where do
- 44:32we find that?
- 44:33Now, one example of where you could find
- 44:35it would be the UN Convention on the
- 44:37Jurisdictional Immunities of States and
- 44:38Their Properties, which we note is not
- 44:41in force yet, but we say it is
- 44:42reflective of the possibility that
- 44:45separate entities can obtain immunity
- 44:48where they are authorized by a state to
- 44:49act. Now, this rule of attribution can
- 44:51also be found at Article 5 of the Draft
- 44:54Articles on the Responsibilities of
- 44:56States for Internationally Wrongful
- 44:57Acts. So, these two sources and state
- 45:00practice across various states, in
- 45:02particular in their state immunity acts,
- 45:05does show
- 45:06these acts attributable to separate
- 45:08entities
- 45:09>> so So, So, I'm clear.
- 45:11So,
- 45:12any act that's attributable to the state
- 45:14under the standard you just laid out is
- 45:17then
- 45:18shrouded by immunity.
- 45:20Not at all, Mr. President. Not at all.
- 45:22>> distinction between the two. Yes,
- 45:24attributability comes before
- 45:27ascertaining whether the act is cloaked
- 45:29with immunity.
- 45:29>> not sufficient to establish immunity.
- 45:31Absolutely not, Mr. President.
- 45:33>> is the What are the key elements
- 45:35to establish immunity?
- 45:37The key element is that the act must be
- 45:40an exercise of sovereign authority, and
- 45:42how we figure out whether that act is
- 45:44such an exercise is by looking at both
- 45:47the nature and the purpose of the act.
- 45:50Now, this nature and purpose test is
- 45:52well established by state practice
- 45:54across many states, including
- 45:55Philippines, Italy, the UK, Malaysia, et
- 45:58cetera. And so, it is this test that we
- 46:01rely on to establish that Nexca's
- 46:03operation of the SARV was an exercise of
- 46:05sovereign authority.
- 46:07So, you're saying nature and purpose.
- 46:10Nature and purpose, yes, your
- 46:12excellency. Can you give us an example
- 46:14of where we would find this nature and
- 46:16purpose test? Certainly, your
- 46:18excellency. Now, one example I can give
- 46:20you is the 1994 case of the Holy See and
- 46:24Aribas
- 46:25Rosario Jr., decided before the Supreme
- 46:28Court of the Philippines. In this case,
- 46:31the sale of land was in question, but it
- 46:33was not considered as a commercial act
- 46:36just because of its nature. The Supreme
- 46:38Court looked at the purpose of the act.
- 46:40The sale of land was for the purposes of
- 46:42building the official residence of the
- 46:45ambassador of the Holy See to the
- 46:46Philippines, and for this reason, it was
- 46:49considered to be a sovereign act. Now,
- 46:51this same trend is found across many
- 46:53states, for instance, in the 2005
- 46:55Italian Court of Cassation case of
- 46:57Borrian Argentina,
- 46:59the purpose test is also found in the UN
- 47:00Convention that I earlier cited, and it
- 47:03is established by state practice.
- 47:05>> the case that everything the state does
- 47:07is for the purposes of the state? So, if
- 47:09you're using the purpose, wouldn't all
- 47:11acts then attract immunity? Well, we
- 47:14would disagree with that, your
- 47:16excellency, and that's because the state
- 47:17can act for a purely commercial purpose
- 47:19as well, a profit-making purpose. And in
- 47:22fact, that was the case in the 2017 case
- 47:26of Beijing Urban Construction Group and
- 47:28Yemen, heard before the ICSID. In that
- 47:30case, the building of an airport was for
- 47:32purely profit-making purpose and was not
- 47:34a sovereign act.
- 47:36Now, in this case, however, at paragraph
- 47:3826 of the compromis, it is clear why
- 47:40Alacostra submitted the bid for the
- 47:42Gorge.
- 47:43Firstly, due to a lack of rare earth
- 47:45minerals within its own territory,
- 47:48and secondly, due to the importance of
- 47:50these rare earth minerals for the
- 47:52existing and emerging industries in
- 47:54Alacostra.
- 47:56On top of that, the bid in the Gorge was
- 47:58authorized as consistent with
- 48:00Alacostra's national security and
- 48:03foreign policy. And for all these
- 48:05reasons, we say it was done with a
- 48:06public purpose. But we don't just rely
- 48:09on purpose, your excellencies. We also
- 48:11rely on the nature of the act. Also
- 48:13found at paragraph 26 of the compromis
- 48:16is the fact that Parliament required
- 48:18Nexca to ensure that all activities were
- 48:21consistent with its obligations under
- 48:24the Alacostra-Restovia Plateau
- 48:25Agreement.
- 48:28Agent, at some instance, did you take
- 48:30into account the evolving standards,
- 48:34Inter-American, international, in
- 48:36relation to business and human rights,
- 48:38considering the obligations, evolving
- 48:41obligations the states has to control
- 48:45um
- 48:46business, especially when business is a
- 48:48national business?
- 48:51Could you please
- 48:52tell me something about that? Of course,
- 48:55your excellency. Now, there is a
- 48:56difference between a company that is
- 48:58required to act in accordance with
- 49:00interna- internal law, my apologies,
- 49:03domestic law imposed by the state which
- 49:06it belongs to, and a company which is
- 49:08itself subject to the international
- 49:10obligations that its home state has
- 49:12undertaken.
- 49:14In this case, Nexca Nexca falls within
- 49:17the latter category, as was also
- 49:19recognized by the Restovian Court itself
- 49:22at paragraph 52 of the compromis, in
- 49:24which it acknowledged that Nexca was,
- 49:26and I quote, "required to uphold
- 49:28Alacostra's international obligations."
- 49:31For these reasons, we say that the
- 49:33Gordian Gorge bid and the operation of
- 49:35the SARV was immune, which takes me to
- 49:38my final point on the territorial tort
- 49:40exception.
- 49:41Our primary submission in relation to
- 49:43that is that the territorial tort
- 49:45exception is not custom as there was no
- 49:47widespread state practice. But even if
- 49:50it was, taking the elements of the
- 49:51territorial tort exception as set forth
- 49:53by the respondent in their memorials,
- 49:56the requirements are not fulfilled here
- 49:58because although the harm to Mr. Montoya
- 50:00happened within Vestovian territory,
- 50:02the the negligence of Nexca happened
- 50:05solely within territory as can be seen
- 50:07at paragraph 38 of the compromis, which
- 50:10is why the territorial tort exception
- 50:12would not apply in this case.
- 50:14For these reasons,
- 50:17we humbly pray that Allecastra's prayers
- 50:19be granted. Thank you.
- 50:25Thank you very much. Uh respondent,
- 50:28agents for respondent,
- 50:42please continue or please start whenever
- 50:44you're ready.
- 50:49Mr. President, your excellencies, good
- 50:52day. And may it please the court.
- 50:55It is an honor to be before you today.
- 50:57I am Jose Andres Gonzalez. And together
- 51:01with my co-agent, Mr. Juan Gesmo Lema,
- 51:04and our of counsel, Ms. Jasmine Pandi,
- 51:07we respectfully enter our appearance as
- 51:09agents for the respondent, the Republic
- 51:12of Restovia.
- 51:13As first agent, I will speak for 21
- 51:15minutes on the first two prayers, while
- 51:18my co-agent will speak for 22 minutes on
- 51:20the final two prayers. And we
- 51:22respectfully reserve 2 minutes for
- 51:24surrebuttal if necessary.
- 51:26Thank you. And may it please the court.
- 51:30Now your excellencies, for respondent's
- 51:32submissions, we will address the first
- 51:34two prayers raised by the applicant.
- 51:37And in this manner, we will first
- 51:38discuss why Solania's request to
- 51:41intervene under this court's statute
- 51:43should respectfully be denied. And then
- 51:45second, we will proceed to discuss why
- 51:47respondent did not violate any treaty or
- 51:50customary rule on obtaining free, prior,
- 51:53and informed consent.
- 51:55Now if it pleases this court, I will
- 51:57begin with Solania's request to
- 51:58intervene.
- 52:00Now earlier, the agent for the applicant
- 52:02had correctly outlined the requisites
- 52:04under Article 62 of this court's
- 52:06statute,
- 52:07that first there be an interest of a
- 52:08legal nature, and that it may be
- 52:10affected by the decision of this court.
- 52:12Additionally, they mentioned the proper
- 52:15object of an intervention which was held
- 52:17in this court's most recent decision in
- 52:19Guatemala's intervention.
- 52:21Now your excellencies, while we don't
- 52:22contest these standards, what respondent
- 52:25does contest is the way the applicant
- 52:27has applied it with respect to Solania's
- 52:29interests because they mentioned two key
- 52:32interests here.
- 52:33First would be in the customary law of
- 52:36the Pilman people,
- 52:37as well as the parallel treaty of the
- 52:39Solania-Restovia Plateau Agreement as it
- 52:42regards to the Allecastra-Restovia
- 52:44Plateau Agreement which is in dispute
- 52:46before this honorable court today.
- 52:48And I shall address both in turn.
- 52:50>> [snorts]
- 52:50>> First with respect to Solania's claim as
- 52:52raised by the applicant, that the
- 52:54customary law of the Pilman people,
- 52:56especially those in Solania, will be
- 52:58affected by the decision of this court
- 53:00between the two parties because they
- 53:02have an interest in the formation of
- 53:04customary law, specifically that of
- 53:06obtaining free, prior, and informed
- 53:08consent, has already been rejected by
- 53:10this honorable court in its 1981
- 53:12decision of Italy's intervention between
- 53:15Tunisia versus Libya. In that case, your
- 53:17excellencies, we also dealt with the
- 53:19formation of a customary rule.
- 53:22The customary rule there was the the
- 53:24maritime rights granted by the
- 53:26continental shelves of peninsular
- 53:27states. And while Italy wanted to
- 53:30intervene to understand how the
- 53:32formation of that customary rule would
- 53:34affect its interests, this honorable
- 53:36court held
- 53:37that participating through intervention
- 53:40simply to understand how general rules
- 53:42are formed But counsel, at stake here is
- 53:44is is not just
- 53:47Solania's interest in uh
- 53:49uh how a customary rule is interpreted,
- 53:51is it? I mean, their interest is has to
- 53:53do with the people Solania who are the
- 53:55Pilman, right? And
- 53:58at stake in this very case is whether or
- 54:01not they were adequately consulted.
- 54:04And they are the same are the people I
- 54:06guess that's one question that I would
- 54:07have for you. Are the people of
- 54:09uh in in Solania the same people as the
- 54:13Pilman in in your country? And in
- 54:17Mr.
- 54:17>> And and and the applicant's
- 54:19Mr. President, we recognize that point.
- 54:21And to address your question, we
- 54:22recognize that the Pilman people do the
- 54:25people Pilman people in Solania do share
- 54:27cultural heritage with all the other
- 54:29Pilman states like the applicant and the
- 54:32and respondent. But they are different
- 54:34people considering they are different
- 54:35nationals protected by different state
- 54:37interests, which Solania is questioning
- 54:40here.
- 54:40>> But are they part of the same indigenous
- 54:41people?
- 54:43Yes, Mr. President.
- 54:44Or are they are they three different
- 54:46indigenous peoples that happen to go by
- 54:48the same name? No, Mr. President. We do
- 54:51agree that they are a transboundary
- 54:52indigenous people and part of the Pilman
- 54:54heritage. But if we take a step back and
- 54:57remember the requisites under Article
- 54:5962, we are dealing with state interests
- 55:02and the ability of that state to protect
- 55:03those interests. So while we recognize
- 55:05that Solania may have an interest in the
- 55:07formation of a customary rule, we must
- 55:10remember that in this case, we are
- 55:12dealing with the general obligation to
- 55:14obtain free, prior, and informed consent
- 55:17as it affects all indigenous communities
- 55:19around the world.
- 55:20>> Is that the claim of the other side that
- 55:23it's about that the in that the interest
- 55:25of Solania is about the formation of
- 55:28general customary international law or
- 55:30is the argument that the application in
- 55:34this case of customary international law
- 55:37will affect the rights of indigenous
- 55:39peoples that are nationals of Solania?
- 55:43Your excellencies, we recognize that the
- 55:44agent for the applicant raised an
- 55:46argument as regards to the latter, that
- 55:48the formation of this general rule will
- 55:50have specific implications to the Pilman
- 55:53indigenous people, especially those of
- 55:55Solania.
- 55:56But your excellencies, again, we go back
- 55:59to the standards of Article 62. And if
- 56:01we look at the cases such as the Gulf of
- 56:03Fonseca case decided in 1991, the
- 56:06interest of a legal nature, which is
- 56:08simply defined by this court as a real
- 56:10and concrete claim based in law, must be
- 56:13connected to the dispute. And while we
- 56:16recognize that Solania may have their
- 56:18own customary governing principles
- 56:20pursuant to Pilman spiritual tradition,
- 56:23what the interest in terms of an
- 56:25international rule is actually linking
- 56:27them to the dispute is that of a general
- 56:29obligation to obtain free, prior, and
- 56:31informed consent. So whatever decision
- 56:34this court will have on the obligations
- 56:36of respondent to obtain that consent, it
- 56:39may still not have an effect on on
- 56:42Solania's state considering that their
- 56:44Pilman people may govern themselves
- 56:46differently as regards to the
- 56:47applicant's nationals who have duly
- 56:50authorized Pilman representatives within
- 56:52their governance structures. So your
- 56:54excellencies, at least on a customary
- 56:56layer, we are still dealing with that
- 56:57general principle which was already
- 56:59rejected by this honorable court.
- 57:02And if it pleases this court, I move to
- 57:04the applicant's second
- 57:05>> Just before you move on, you say it may
- 57:07not affect the interest of the people in
- 57:10Solania, but it may affect their
- 57:12interest, may it not?
- 57:14Um your excellencies, to clarify the
- 57:16position, it will not affect Solania's
- 57:19interests in this case because whether
- 57:21or not this court will rule on the
- 57:23specific standards that exist within the
- 57:25obligation to obtain free, prior, and
- 57:27informed consent, that will not change
- 57:29any of the governing structures of
- 57:31Pilman customary law, especially with
- 57:33respect to Solania's state.
- 57:35Now if it pleases this court, I will
- 57:37move to address the prayer or the second
- 57:39submission of the applicant regarding
- 57:41the Solania-Restovia Plateau Agreement,
- 57:43and considering that it has identical
- 57:45treaty provisions in terms of Article 18
- 57:47of the ARPA, that this court's
- 57:49interpretation of that obligation on
- 57:52respondent will
- 57:54probably affect the identical treaty
- 57:56wording. But as this honorable panel
- 57:58already correctly pointed out earlier,
- 58:01the rules of the 1969 Vienna Convention
- 58:03on the Law of Treaties already tell us
- 58:05that we do not simply interpret treaty
- 58:08provisions simply by their text, but
- 58:10also by their context, object, and
- 58:12purpose, as well as subsequent practice
- 58:14of the states. And if we see in
- 58:16paragraph 17 of the compromis, when the
- 58:18respondent was concluding in the 1971
- 58:21negotiations, they were cautious to cede
- 58:23their sovereignty over to the Pilman
- 58:25people. So instead, they offered a
- 58:27purely consultation-based framework as a
- 58:30compromise. And the applicant state was
- 58:33fully satisfied with this outcome, which
- 58:35led to the ARPA, while Solania wanted
- 58:37further negotiations, which led to the
- 58:40SRPA. And we also see this in subsequent
- 58:42practice considering Solania has always
- 58:45objected this project in principle,
- 58:47while the applicant state and its
- 58:49nationals have participated and even
- 58:51entered a bid in our indigenous
- 58:53consultation mechanism.
- 58:55Therefore, your excellencies, we clearly
- 58:57see that these two treaties are
- 58:58separate. And because we see that these
- 59:00treaties are separate, we go back to the
- 59:022001 decision of this court in the
- 59:05Philippines' intervention in the case
- 59:07concerning Pulau Ligitan and Pulau
- 59:09Sipadan Islands, where in that case, the
- 59:11Philippines also relied on a parallel
- 59:13treaty, the Sulu over back grant in its
- 59:15claim of sovereignty over in North
- 59:17Borneo.
- 59:18And in that case, your excellencies, the
- 59:20court recognized while there are similar
- 59:22circumstances
- 59:24to participate or intervene in a case
- 59:26merely out of concern that this court
- 59:28will have an interpretation on an
- 59:30international rule is improper for
- 59:32intervention.
- 59:34And to address the final point
- 59:35>> Could you better under
- 59:37explain why this is not proper
- 59:40participation and why they they do
- 59:44challenge the ability of this court to
- 59:47to to listen Solonia
- 59:49and
- 59:51and how this
- 59:53impossibility for this court could be
- 59:56against the interest of Pilinang people
- 59:58but also of the interest of the of the
- 1:00:01justice for this court.
- 1:00:05Certainly your excellencies, a clear
- 1:00:06standard for an improper intervention or
- 1:00:09an improper intervener would be again in
- 1:00:11the case of Philippines Pulau Ligitan
- 1:00:14Pulau Sepadan when the Philippines was
- 1:00:16rejected on terms of their intervention
- 1:00:18based on the Sulu over back grant. This
- 1:00:20honorable court held that it was simply
- 1:00:23not a real and concrete interest in the
- 1:00:25current dispute because to assume that
- 1:00:27this court would apply the same treaty
- 1:00:29interpretation would simply be too
- 1:00:30speculative and thus not concrete. And
- 1:00:33an additional point by this honorable
- 1:00:34court was it cautioned against granting
- 1:00:37the Philippines is intervention because
- 1:00:39since it was not a related subject
- 1:00:41matter, it would risk introducing a new
- 1:00:43dispute to the current dispute before
- 1:00:45this court. And this is exactly the
- 1:00:47prejudice that the respondent cautions
- 1:00:49this honorable court against. While we
- 1:00:51do not
- 1:00:52>> counsel
- 1:00:54that under article 63, I know this is
- 1:00:5662, under article 63 if it had been a
- 1:01:00common multilateral treaty
- 1:01:02any party to the treaty can intervene.
- 1:01:05In this case, it's not one multilateral
- 1:01:07treaty but it's two separate bilateral
- 1:01:10treaties but with common origins, common
- 1:01:13texts. So if it would have if it would
- 1:01:15be improper as you suggest under article
- 1:01:1762
- 1:01:19why would there be that provision in
- 1:01:21article 63 or if I could put it the
- 1:01:23other way around, if it's deemed to be
- 1:01:25proper under article 63 to have that
- 1:01:27kind of intervention
- 1:01:29why would it be improper under article
- 1:01:3262 to be able to intervene in the case
- 1:01:35of two separate but linked bilateral
- 1:01:38treaties? Your excellencies, it would be
- 1:01:41perhaps proper under article 63 if we
- 1:01:43did have a multilateral treaty. You are
- 1:01:46correct to point out that article 63 is
- 1:01:48also noted by this court as mandatory
- 1:01:51intervention where a state parties can
- 1:01:53intervene as a matter of right when it
- 1:01:55pertains to the interpretation of a
- 1:01:57multilateral treaty because again it is
- 1:01:59their right as But as you correctly
- 1:02:02pointed out your excellencies, we have
- 1:02:03two separate bilateral treaties here.
- 1:02:06And while we recognize the identical
- 1:02:07treaty provisions, respondent remains
- 1:02:09firm in its contention that they do not
- 1:02:11confer the same obligations because they
- 1:02:14were concluded under different
- 1:02:15circumstances with different state
- 1:02:17parties and in terms of subsequent
- 1:02:19practice of how those state parties
- 1:02:21acted, they had different intentions. So
- 1:02:24it would not be
- 1:02:25>> But isn't the purpose of the treaty both
- 1:02:26treaties essentially the same and the
- 1:02:28subject matter of both treaties
- 1:02:30essentially the same? And if I can add
- 1:02:32the text also as I say.
- 1:02:34Your excellencies, in terms of the text
- 1:02:37they are the same at least with respect
- 1:02:38to article 17 and 18. And Mr. President
- 1:02:41and I, we do recognize that in a sense
- 1:02:43the object of that treaty was to protect
- 1:02:46the Groyne Gorge and its access. But in
- 1:02:49terms of the standards raised by the
- 1:02:50applicant and Solania, they were
- 1:02:52different. So they may have different
- 1:02:55implications of how they want those
- 1:02:56consultation procedures contemplated
- 1:02:58under those treaties in a different way.
- 1:03:01And it makes sense here your
- 1:03:02excellencies because applicant is a
- 1:03:03developed state and wanted to further
- 1:03:05emerging industries by entering a bid
- 1:03:07through Nexca while Solania objected the
- 1:03:09project in principle. Therefore, they're
- 1:03:12clearly two different intervening
- 1:03:14interests with respect to the SRPA.
- 1:03:16And your excellencies,
- 1:03:18and if we look at the most recent
- 1:03:19decision of the Guatemala intervention
- 1:03:22we remember that in Judge Charlesworth's
- 1:03:24opinion that article 59 does not while
- 1:03:27he recognized that article 59 does not
- 1:03:29necessarily insulate or limit the
- 1:03:31decision of this court in every single
- 1:03:34case, it still can afford that
- 1:03:35protection when we are dealing with two
- 1:03:37separate bilateral treaties where this
- 1:03:39court can limit its its interpretation
- 1:03:42of one treaty and not apply it to the
- 1:03:44other. So if this court were to say in
- 1:03:47this case that the text of
- 1:03:50one of these treaties means something,
- 1:03:52the text in its ordinary meaning means
- 1:03:55something
- 1:03:56would that not have some effect on the
- 1:03:59interpretation of the other treaty?
- 1:04:02It may have some effect your
- 1:04:03excellencies but again, it wouldn't be
- 1:04:06proper because if we are to use that
- 1:04:07logic, perhaps the logic used in
- 1:04:09paragraph 66 of the Diallo decision
- 1:04:12where they held that similarly concluded
- 1:04:14treaties that have similar provisions
- 1:04:16such as the ICCPR and the African
- 1:04:18Charter on Human Rights could be
- 1:04:20interpreted consistently, it would not
- 1:04:22be proper when they do not have the same
- 1:04:24context or the same standards that they
- 1:04:26were concluded under. But your
- 1:04:28excellencies, even assuming this court
- 1:04:30finds that it is an interest of a legal
- 1:04:32nature, it simply would not be affected
- 1:04:34by the decision of this court because
- 1:04:36this court can limit its interpretation
- 1:04:39under article 59.
- 1:04:41Now if it pleases this court and if
- 1:04:42there are no further questions
- 1:04:44>> Just one more question.
- 1:04:45>> Certainly your excellency. Just on
- 1:04:46article No worries your excellency.
- 1:04:47>> Just on article 59 but if your argument
- 1:04:49was
- 1:04:50correct on article 59, would there be
- 1:04:53any case where the court would permit
- 1:04:55intervention? Certainly your
- 1:04:57excellencies and if I may point this
- 1:04:58honorable court to the most recent
- 1:05:00decision decided a few weeks ago in the
- 1:05:02Guatemala's intervention, the court
- 1:05:04discussed the probability of just using
- 1:05:06article 59 to protect the interests of
- 1:05:08Guatemala from the current case between
- 1:05:11Belize and Honduras. But the court found
- 1:05:13there that article 59 would still not be
- 1:05:16able to protect Guatemala because in
- 1:05:18that case, it was a case of sovereign
- 1:05:20ownership.
- 1:05:21And there, sovereign ownership even if
- 1:05:24limited to the decision between the
- 1:05:25parties already excludes other claims of
- 1:05:28ownership so it would practically defeat
- 1:05:31the case of Guatemala. But that's not
- 1:05:33the same interest here your excellencies
- 1:05:35because we have two separate treaties
- 1:05:36that are governed by two separate state
- 1:05:38parties. This court can still use
- 1:05:40article 59.
- 1:05:42At the end of the day your excellencies,
- 1:05:43Solania's rights will be what it was at
- 1:05:45the outset. Untouched in rights,
- 1:05:48unchanged in law fully preserved.
- 1:05:51Now if we move to the second prayer
- 1:05:52raised by the applicant on respondent's
- 1:05:55obligations to obtain free prior and
- 1:05:56informed consent. They mentioned that we
- 1:05:58have the duty to consult the duly
- 1:06:00authorized Pilinang representatives with
- 1:06:02the aim of achieving consent both under
- 1:06:04article 18 of the ARPA
- 1:06:06as well as in customary international
- 1:06:07law.
- 1:06:08Now Mr. President and your excellencies,
- 1:06:10respondent does not contest the
- 1:06:12standards raised by the applicant
- 1:06:14because your excellencies, respondent is
- 1:06:16also of the position that what we are
- 1:06:18dealing with here today is an obligation
- 1:06:20of conduct to consult in good faith. So
- 1:06:24in terms of establishing respondent's
- 1:06:26faithful compliance with its treaty and
- 1:06:28customary law obligations, allow me to
- 1:06:30walk this court through the pertinent
- 1:06:32facts of this case.
- 1:06:34Now your excellency So you agree with
- 1:06:37the
- 1:06:38with the applicants that there is a
- 1:06:39standard customary international law
- 1:06:42requiring free prior informed consent?
- 1:06:44Mr. President, we agree only to the
- 1:06:46extent that the standard raised by the
- 1:06:48applicant is free prior and informed
- 1:06:50consent as an obligation of conduct with
- 1:06:53the aim of achieving consent but not
- 1:06:55granting consent as a veto power over to
- 1:06:57indigenous communities.
- 1:06:59Therefore your excellencies, respondent
- 1:07:01is prepared
- 1:07:02>> You disagree with them cuz
- 1:07:04I apologize Mr. President. I'm your
- 1:07:06>> with them cuz they say that there should
- 1:07:07be a
- 1:07:08consent achieved. Okay, I apologize Mr.
- 1:07:10President. Then we do qualify that the
- 1:07:13object of the consultations in good
- 1:07:16faith should be
- 1:07:17>> Okay, all right. Yes Mr. President. And
- 1:07:19this is consistent actually with
- 1:07:21customary international law because if
- 1:07:22we look at the 90 specially affected
- 1:07:24states that host indigenous communities
- 1:07:27their domestic legislations of over 70
- 1:07:29states only reflect a good faith
- 1:07:32obligation of conduct. And in terms of
- 1:07:34opinion juris, we do recognize the point
- 1:07:37raised by the applicant that over 193
- 1:07:39states have voted in favor of the UN
- 1:07:41declaration of the rights of indigenous
- 1:07:42peoples. Many states like New Zealand or
- 1:07:45Canada for example have expressed the
- 1:07:47adopted the UN declaration of the rights
- 1:07:49of indigenous people but still do not
- 1:07:52reflect a consent veto over to the
- 1:07:54indigenous people. If we look at Canada
- 1:07:56your excellencies, they even have an
- 1:07:58express adoption through the UNDA that
- 1:08:00is the state's express adoption of the
- 1:08:02UN declaration of the rights of
- 1:08:03indigenous people but they have decided
- 1:08:05very recent jurisprudence in 2025 such
- 1:08:08as the Cabalic First Nation case versus
- 1:08:10Nuclear Laboratories as well as the
- 1:08:12Lumina Nation case versus the Supreme
- 1:08:14Court of Canada. Both cases ended with
- 1:08:17the decision that consent is not a veto
- 1:08:19power but only an interpretative lens in
- 1:08:22informing how we do our consultation
- 1:08:24obligations.
- 1:08:25Now this honorable court may be asking
- 1:08:27themselves, what are the standards of
- 1:08:29good faith consultations? And as pointed
- 1:08:32out in paragraph 167 of the most recent
- 1:08:34jurisprudence in Canada, the Lumina
- 1:08:36Nation case we see this principle is
- 1:08:39simply to put the indigenous communities
- 1:08:42in a place where they can influence the
- 1:08:43outcome. And more specifically, we see
- 1:08:45this in three badges. First would be
- 1:08:48notification. Second would be
- 1:08:49information sharing through public fora
- 1:08:51for example. And third would be the
- 1:08:53acceptance of the
- 1:08:54>> it matter what's being consulted?
- 1:08:57I mean
- 1:08:58isn't that relevant here? Is who's land
- 1:09:01is this?
- 1:09:02Mr. President
- 1:09:02>> Anyway,
- 1:09:03is it is it is this Pilinang land
- 1:09:06where the mining was to happen? Mr.
- 1:09:08President, respondent is of the position
- 1:09:09that it is within its territory and
- 1:09:11pursuant to the principle of permanent
- 1:09:13sovereignty over natural resources.
- 1:09:15>> But who who is the owner of the land?
- 1:09:17Mr. President, respondent submits that
- 1:09:19it is still the respondent state
- 1:09:21Restovia but it does recognize the
- 1:09:23cultural ties of the Pilinang people
- 1:09:25which is why it enacted the indigenous
- 1:09:27consultation mechanism to preserve the
- 1:09:30self-determination rights of the Pilman.
- 1:09:32>> so
- 1:09:33your position is
- 1:09:35that it is not owned by the Pilman, the
- 1:09:38land itself or the resources. Yes, Mr.
- 1:09:40President. Respondent is of the position
- 1:09:42that it owns its land, but it does
- 1:09:44recognize its international obligations
- 1:09:46to put the indigenous Pilman peoples at
- 1:09:48the forefront of those decisions. And
- 1:09:51respondent Sorry, Your Excellency.
- 1:09:52>> you define meaningful or effective
- 1:09:55participation
- 1:09:57regarding international law and
- 1:09:59regarding
- 1:10:00the the case? Your Excellencies,
- 1:10:03meaningful participation is most clearly
- 1:10:05defined in paragraph 167 of the Lumina
- 1:10:08Nation case versus Canada, where they
- 1:10:09are able to influence the outcome of the
- 1:10:11decisions of the state. And respondent
- 1:10:13submits, through the various facts that
- 1:10:15we have in this case, we were able to do
- 1:10:17that. As early as paragraph 20 of the
- 1:10:20compromi, even when we opened the
- 1:10:22bidding process, we ensured that any
- 1:10:24qualified bidder would
- 1:10:26make sure to follow the strict
- 1:10:28provisions of the ARPA and the SRPA.
- 1:10:31When we had the public forums, we
- 1:10:33ensured that there were technical
- 1:10:34special advisers, as well as experts on
- 1:10:37Pilman dialect to translate that
- 1:10:38information.
- 1:10:40And we see the success of this endeavor,
- 1:10:42Your Excellencies. Seeing a majority
- 1:10:45participation of over 200 elders, 120 of
- 1:10:48whom even gave their support to the
- 1:10:50project. And most importantly, Your
- 1:10:52Excellencies, we see this good faith in
- 1:10:55paragraph 31, where all of the
- 1:10:57recommendations of the Pilman elders,
- 1:10:59specifically avoiding the use of
- 1:11:01explosives and road constructions on the
- 1:11:03gorge, were incorporated. And we
- 1:11:05demanded that all finalist bidders
- 1:11:08incorporate those safeguards, just that
- 1:11:10anyone we choose would already reflect
- 1:11:12the interests of the Pilmans. But what
- 1:11:15about the low participation of Pilman
- 1:11:17people and and the kind of
- 1:11:21methods that you use to to provoke the
- 1:11:24participation given the the situation of
- 1:11:28Pilman people without access to internet
- 1:11:31and electricity, etc.?
- 1:11:33Your Excellencies, we ensured their
- 1:11:35accessibility and participation by
- 1:11:37hosting multiple forums, over 15, both
- 1:11:40public and online and on site, so that
- 1:11:42those without internet access could
- 1:11:44travel, even because it was over the
- 1:11:46span of several months. And we see that
- 1:11:48it was clearly successful because they
- 1:11:50were informed I know my time. May I
- 1:11:52simply address the question?
- 1:11:54So you can conclude quickly. Thank you.
- 1:11:57We see the success of that participation
- 1:11:59because they were even able to influence
- 1:12:01how the project would go forward with
- 1:12:03limitations such as the use of
- 1:12:05explosives and road access impediments.
- 1:12:08So thank you, Your Excellencies, and may
- 1:12:09it please this court. Thank you. Thank
- 1:12:11you, counsel.
- 1:12:17We'll now hear from your colleague, the
- 1:12:19second agent.
- 1:12:23For Restovia.
- 1:12:52Mr. President, Your Excellencies, good
- 1:12:54day. And may it please the court.
- 1:12:57My name is Juan Guzman Lema,
- 1:12:59respectfully appearing as second agent
- 1:13:02for the respondent.
- 1:13:03Over the course of the next 22 minutes,
- 1:13:05Your Excellencies, I will be arguing
- 1:13:07respondent's final two prayers in the
- 1:13:10way that the applicant has raised them.
- 1:13:12First, that Alacostia violated its
- 1:13:14obligations under the extradition treaty
- 1:13:17when it refused to surrender Ms. Scott.
- 1:13:19And second, that Restovia lawfully
- 1:13:22refused to grant state immunity to
- 1:13:24Nexta.
- 1:13:26Thank you. And may it please the court.
- 1:13:29Continuing then with our third prayer,
- 1:13:30Your Excellencies. Applicant earlier
- 1:13:32submitted that ne bis in idem is a
- 1:13:35general principle of law that would be
- 1:13:37violated by Ms. Scott's extradition and
- 1:13:40trial in Restovia.
- 1:13:42Allow me to show this bench why this is
- 1:13:44not the case.
- 1:13:46Now, as regards ne bis in idem's status
- 1:13:48as a general principle of law, we agree
- 1:13:51with the applicant's standards that the
- 1:13:53elements of a general principle of law
- 1:13:55are those of commonality and
- 1:13:57transposition.
- 1:13:58However, we submit that they have been
- 1:14:00misapplied in this case.
- 1:14:02As to the element of commonality, the
- 1:14:05applicant cited various legal systems
- 1:14:07and countries pointing to the principle
- 1:14:09existing in those jurisdictions, and
- 1:14:12this we do not contest. However, we
- 1:14:14simply point this court to the report,
- 1:14:17or rather the second report, of special
- 1:14:19rapporteur Marcelo Vázquez Bermúdez on
- 1:14:22general principles of law, where he
- 1:14:24stated that where a rule fundamentally
- 1:14:26differs across legal systems, then no
- 1:14:29general principle can arise.
- 1:14:31And we submit here that the fundamental
- 1:14:33difference is seen in the
- 1:14:35irreconcilability
- 1:14:37as to the constitutive elements of ne
- 1:14:38bis in idem across jurisdictions, which
- 1:14:42are the finality of the prior decision
- 1:14:44and the identity of the subject matter.
- 1:14:47As regards the identity, we see in
- 1:14:49jurisdictions within the EU, South
- 1:14:51America, and African Union that a person
- 1:14:54cannot be prosecuted twice for the same
- 1:14:57act. But in jurisdictions like the US,
- 1:15:00Philippines, and India, a person can be
- 1:15:02prosecuted twice for the same act if
- 1:15:05they fall under different offenses. And
- 1:15:07thus to illustrate this
- 1:15:08irreconcilability,
- 1:15:10a person in the US can be tried twice
- 1:15:12for the same act of selling drugs. But
- 1:15:15if this very same person were in the
- 1:15:17Netherlands instead, then a second
- 1:15:19prosecution would actually be
- 1:15:20prohibited. Thus pointing to this lack
- 1:15:23of harmony across jurisdictions when it
- 1:15:25comes to ne bis in idem. And we see the
- 1:15:27same lack of harmony in the finality
- 1:15:29element, wherein common law
- 1:15:31jurisdictions treat child court
- 1:15:33acquittals as final. But in civil law
- 1:15:35jurisdictions, this can actually be
- 1:15:37appealed all the way to the highest
- 1:15:39court. So again, to illustrate, Your
- 1:15:41Excellencies, a person in the US is
- 1:15:44already protected by ne bis in idem
- 1:15:46after acquittal by a trial court. But if
- 1:15:48the same person were in the EU, then
- 1:15:51they would not actually be protected by
- 1:15:53this principle yet.
- 1:15:54>> You pointed to some differences
- 1:15:57as between different countries, but
- 1:15:58isn't it always the case that with
- 1:16:00general principles of law, what you're
- 1:16:01looking for is commonalities with regard
- 1:16:04to the essence of the principle? There
- 1:16:06will always be differences in domestic
- 1:16:09law, but that doesn't prevent one being
- 1:16:11able to find that there's a general
- 1:16:13principle of law.
- 1:16:14Yes, Your Excellencies, and we recognize
- 1:16:16this. However, when it comes to the
- 1:16:18principle of ne bis in idem, the
- 1:16:20applicant actually earlier correctly
- 1:16:22stated its essence, which is that a
- 1:16:24person should not be prosecuted twice
- 1:16:27for the same matter. And this exactly is
- 1:16:29the principle, Your Excellencies, that
- 1:16:31we come before this court for to say
- 1:16:33that it is not common because this
- 1:16:35essence shows us, rather, that
- 1:16:38when we talk about the same criminal
- 1:16:40matter, the question will always be what
- 1:16:42constitutes the same matter. Is it the
- 1:16:44conduct or is it the crime? And to
- 1:16:47borrow the words of Judge McNair in his
- 1:16:49separate opinion in the Southwest Africa
- 1:16:51case, the way that international law
- 1:16:53borrows from these municipal concepts is
- 1:16:56not by simply importing them lock,
- 1:16:58stock, and barrel, ready-made, and fully
- 1:17:00equipped with a set of rules, which is
- 1:17:02why we must account for these
- 1:17:03differences, especially when it comes to
- 1:17:05ne bis in idem, whose entire essence is
- 1:17:07hinged on what constitutes this very
- 1:17:10matter. But wasn't Judge McNair
- 1:17:12essentially saying we shouldn't actually
- 1:17:14be looking at all the details? We should
- 1:17:17be taking the essence of it.
- 1:17:19So isn't that the point that can we not
- 1:17:21take the essence of a principle that we
- 1:17:23find in every domestic legal system and
- 1:17:27then apply that in international law?
- 1:17:29Your Excellencies, yes, Judge McNair was
- 1:17:31referring to that as regards the
- 1:17:33mandatory system under the PCIJ. But
- 1:17:35what we come before this court to say is
- 1:17:37that the essence of ne bis in idem
- 1:17:39itself is tied to what constitutes this
- 1:17:41very matter, which is why we submit that
- 1:17:43it cannot be considered common because
- 1:17:45this is exactly the principle that ne
- 1:17:47bis in idem protects. Now, to quickly
- 1:17:49address the applicant's earlier point
- 1:17:51that ne bis in idem is considered
- 1:17:53intrinsic to the international system,
- 1:17:56we submit, Your Excellencies, that it is
- 1:17:57not, since as found by the ILC in its
- 1:18:01analytical work. But isn't isn't that
- 1:18:04that that requirement of it being
- 1:18:06intrinsic,
- 1:18:08according to the special rapporteur's
- 1:18:09report that you just read referred to?
- 1:18:12I could be mistaken, but I believe that
- 1:18:15that requirement is linked to
- 1:18:17norms, general principles that are
- 1:18:19generated not by domestic legal systems,
- 1:18:22but by the international legal system
- 1:18:24itself.
- 1:18:25Yes, Mr. President. And in doing so, the
- 1:18:28applicant earlier stated that even a
- 1:18:30transnational ne bis in idem is common,
- 1:18:32and they claim that this transnational
- 1:18:35ne bis in idem is intrinsic, to which we
- 1:18:37say, Your Excellencies, that it is not,
- 1:18:39since the ILC defined intrinsic as a
- 1:18:42principle specific to the international
- 1:18:44legal system and reflective of its basic
- 1:18:46features. Yet we submit, Your
- 1:18:48Excellencies, that rather than being
- 1:18:50intrinsic, ne bis in idem does not
- 1:18:52actually, or rather is not Yes, Mr.
- 1:18:55President.
- 1:18:56Is there any
- 1:18:57>> I
- 1:18:57apologize, Your Excellency.
- 1:18:58Apologies, Your Excellencies. I'm
- 1:19:00thinking. We submit, Your Excellencies,
- 1:19:01that You can ask me questions if you
- 1:19:03really want.
- 1:19:04>> [laughter]
- 1:19:06>> Maybe later on, Mr. President. Now, when
- 1:19:08it comes to transnational ne bis in
- 1:19:10idem, we submit that rather than being
- 1:19:12formed within the international legal
- 1:19:14system, it has purely domestic roots.
- 1:19:16And as to being reflective of its basic
- 1:19:18features, we submit that it is actually
- 1:19:21>> has purely domestic roots, but they say
- 1:19:23we see this reflected in a range of
- 1:19:25extradition treaties. So, that's not
- 1:19:27domestic. That is international, isn't
- 1:19:29it? Yes, Your Excellencies. And to this,
- 1:19:31we cite the third report of Special
- 1:19:33Rapporteur Vázquez Bermúdez. And
- 1:19:36assuming, without conceding, that
- 1:19:38transnational ne bis in idem is a
- 1:19:40principle formed in the international
- 1:19:41system, the Special Rapporteur stated
- 1:19:44that states must recognize the principle
- 1:19:46as generally applicable outside of any
- 1:19:49particular treaty regime or customary
- 1:19:51rule. And yes, the applicant cited
- 1:19:53various extradition treaties, which
- 1:19:55actually militates against their claim.
- 1:19:57As all this shows is that states do not
- 1:19:59recognize ne bis in idem in a
- 1:20:01transnational sense. But in the work of
- 1:20:03the ILC does accept that general
- 1:20:06principles of international law formed
- 1:20:08within the international legal system
- 1:20:11can be found in treaties. So, the fact
- 1:20:12that you see it in treaties doesn't
- 1:20:15necessarily mean that it is therefore
- 1:20:17not a general principle of law. But the
- 1:20:20ILC seems to say the opposite with
- 1:20:22regard to that that type of general
- 1:20:25principle. Precisely, Your Excellencies.
- 1:20:27And to this, we make two points.
- 1:20:29Firstly, we completely agree that
- 1:20:30presence in treaties can actually serve
- 1:20:32as evidence of being transposed to the
- 1:20:34international system. However, in citing
- 1:20:37the third report of the Special
- 1:20:38Rapporteur, we state that according to
- 1:20:41Mr. Vázquez Bermúdez, states must
- 1:20:43recognize it as being generally
- 1:20:45applicable even outside of a particular
- 1:20:47treaty regime. Yet here, Your
- 1:20:49Excellencies, we see that states do not
- 1:20:51recognize a transnational ne bis in idem
- 1:20:53outside of treaty since it explicitly
- 1:20:56requires consent, which is attained
- 1:20:59through the treaty negotiations entered
- 1:21:01into between the parties. But secondly,
- 1:21:03Your Excellencies, as to the point about
- 1:21:06presence in treaties proving
- 1:21:07transposability, we move on to this
- 1:21:10element of transposition. And Your
- 1:21:12Excellencies, to this we state that
- 1:21:14although the applicant earlier cited
- 1:21:15that this presence in multiple
- 1:21:17instruments is evidence of treaty or
- 1:21:19rather is evidence of ne bis in idem
- 1:21:22being transposed, we submit that this is
- 1:21:24merely evidence of it that doesn't
- 1:21:26necessarily conclude that it is actually
- 1:21:29transposed since the ILC itself found
- 1:21:32that for a principle to be transposed to
- 1:21:34the international system, it must be
- 1:21:36compatible with the fundamental
- 1:21:38principles of international law. And we
- 1:21:40note the applicant earlier attempted to
- 1:21:42preempt our position that it would be
- 1:21:44violative of sovereign equality. Yet in
- 1:21:46doing so, they failed to overcome or
- 1:21:48explain why it would actually violate
- 1:21:51this principle seeing that the Friendly
- 1:21:53Relations Declaration entails that
- 1:21:55states enjoy the rights inherent in full
- 1:21:57sovereignty. One of such rights being
- 1:21:59the right to uphold criminal
- 1:22:01jurisdiction. Yet if we were to accept
- 1:22:03the applicant's position, this
- 1:22:05transnational ne bis
- 1:24:46>> And so, we look to the actual offenses
- 1:24:47involved here, which clearly involve
- 1:24:49different elements. One requires a
- 1:24:51foreign nationality and an economic
- 1:24:53advantage, while the other does not. And
- 1:24:56clearly, these are different elements
- 1:24:58that are not
- 1:24:59sufficiently subsumed.
- 1:25:01Now, as to the more important point
- 1:25:03here, Your Excellencies, that we wish to
- 1:25:05bring up, there was no final
- 1:25:07determination on the merits to warrant a
- 1:25:09refusal of Ms. Scott's extradition.
- 1:25:12Your Excellencies, in the 2024 case
- 1:25:15ruled by the European Court of Justice
- 1:25:16in Pakitul de Pelanga, they found that a
- 1:25:19final determination on the merits is
- 1:25:22present when there is competent a
- 1:25:24competent authority assessing such
- 1:25:26evidence and decision is rendered on the
- 1:25:29basis of that evidence. Yet here, we
- 1:25:31clearly see in paragraph 43 that the
- 1:25:34decision of the Alikashian Court of
- 1:25:35Appeal was not rendered on the basis of
- 1:25:38the evidence pointing to her guilt or
- 1:25:40innocence, but on the mere procedural
- 1:25:43error of
- 1:25:44failing to read Ms. Scott her right to
- 1:25:46remain silent.
- 1:25:48But Your Excellencies, we are not so
- 1:25:50unreasonable as to presume that Ms.
- 1:25:53Scott's human right is
- 1:25:55not important in this case, which is why
- 1:25:57all that we seek is that there be a
- 1:25:59final determination on the merits that
- 1:26:01will ensure that both interests of Ms.
- 1:26:04Scott and our state are met. Seeing that
- 1:26:07if there is an actual determination as
- 1:26:09to her guilt or innocence, our state
- 1:26:11would be satisfied regardless of the
- 1:26:12result.
- 1:26:14That being said, ne bis in
- 1:26:16>> will the failure to read her her her
- 1:26:18rights, you know, be incorporated in the
- 1:26:21proceedings in your country?
- 1:26:23Your Excellencies, yes. And these are
- 1:26:25two different proceedings, the one that
- 1:26:27was conducted in Alikashia and the one
- 1:26:29to be conducted in our state. And we
- 1:26:31will ensure, Your Excellencies, if this
- 1:26:33extradition were to be granted that that
- 1:26:35failure would be rectified in the
- 1:26:37Restovia.
- 1:26:39Thus, ne bis in idem not meeting the
- 1:26:41elements of commonality and
- 1:26:42transposition is simply not a general
- 1:26:45principle of law. And in any case, it
- 1:26:47would not be violated here.
- 1:26:50To move on then to our fourth and final
- 1:26:52prayer, Your Excellencies, we submit
- 1:26:54that Restovia did not violate
- 1:26:56international law when it refused to
- 1:26:58grant state immunity to Nexca.
- 1:27:01Earlier, the applicant raised three
- 1:27:02points: that Nexca was entitled to
- 1:27:05perform sovereign acts, that they were
- 1:27:07actually performing sovereign acts, and
- 1:27:09that in any case, the territorial tort
- 1:27:11exception does not apply here. And I
- 1:27:13shall refute each of these points in
- 1:27:15turn.
- 1:27:16As to entitlement, we first point out
- 1:27:18that Nexca is a state-owned entity,
- 1:27:21which is defined by the UN Convention on
- 1:27:23State Immunities as an entity with
- 1:27:25independent legal personality shown by
- 1:27:27its capacity to sue or be sued and to
- 1:27:30acquire or dispose of property.
- 1:27:32All of these are met since Nexca was
- 1:27:34sued in its own name and acquires its
- 1:27:36own property such as the SARV. And since
- 1:27:39it is an it is a state-owned entity, the
- 1:27:42ILC in its commentary to the UN
- 1:27:44Convention stated that state-owned
- 1:27:46entities are presumed not entitled to
- 1:27:49perform sovereign acts precisely because
- 1:27:51they are typically put up to perform
- 1:27:53commercial functions. Now, we know that
- 1:27:55this we note that this is a rebuttable
- 1:27:57presumption.
- 1:27:58However, we submit that even though
- 1:28:00there are various facts in the compromis
- 1:28:02pointing to the fact that Nexca might be
- 1:28:05entitled to perform such sovereign
- 1:28:06functions like being created by an act
- 1:28:09of Parliament or being 100%
- 1:28:11government-owned, we submit that
- 1:28:12international decisions have already
- 1:28:14shown that these are not conclusive. We
- 1:28:17see, for instance, in the case of
- 1:28:18Trendtex versus Central Bank of Nigeria,
- 1:28:21wherein the Central Bank was also 100%
- 1:28:23government-owned and created by Nigerian
- 1:28:25statute, but the UK court found that
- 1:28:27since there was no showing that it was
- 1:28:29created or established precisely to
- 1:28:31perform sovereign functions, then it was
- 1:28:34not found entitled to perform sovereign
- 1:28:36acts. And we see the same thing here.
- 1:28:38Nexca, according to paragraph 24 of the
- 1:28:41compromis, was not necessarily
- 1:28:43established for sovereign functions, but
- 1:28:45to engage in mining operations both in
- 1:28:47Alikashia and abroad. And so, there's no
- 1:28:50particular showing that it was actually
- 1:28:52established for sovereign purposes.
- 1:28:55But to the more important issue here, as
- 1:28:57to whether Nexca was actually in the
- 1:28:58performance of such sovereign acts, we
- 1:29:01still maintain our position that they
- 1:29:03were not.
- 1:29:04Now, Your Excellencies, this court found
- 1:29:06in the Jurisdictional Immunities case
- 1:29:08that pursuant to the restrictive
- 1:29:10doctrine on state immunity, states are
- 1:29:12only entitled to immunity for their acts
- 1:29:14jure imperii and not their acts jure
- 1:29:16adjust runners precisely because as
- 1:29:19found by Lloyd will before in the
- 1:29:20Congress of the party to case today
- 1:29:23states in enter into more commercial
- 1:29:25engagements and private dealings with
- 1:29:27private individuals.
- 1:29:29>> acts here that you're pointing to that
- 1:29:31aren't sovereign acts?
- 1:29:33Your Excellency is to clarify how do the
- 1:29:34specific acts here point to
- 1:29:36commerciality?
- 1:29:37Is that you Mr. President's concern?
- 1:29:39>> say are not sovereign acts and Yes, your
- 1:29:41Excellency.
- 1:29:42We find that as the applicant rightly
- 1:29:45stated earlier the primary means for
- 1:29:47determining a character of an act is by
- 1:29:49looking at its nature and we see here
- 1:29:51that this venture by its very nature is
- 1:29:55commercial in every sense of the word.
- 1:29:57>> you recently talking about the robot,
- 1:29:58right?
- 1:29:59We are talking your Excellency about the
- 1:30:02mining activity in itself that was
- 1:30:04entered into by Nexa in our state. Is it
- 1:30:07just is it just the nature of the act or
- 1:30:10is it also looking at the context as
- 1:30:12they put it the purpose? So it's not
- 1:30:13just mining, it's mining of rare earth
- 1:30:16minerals which they want for particular
- 1:30:19defense and security needs. Isn't that
- 1:30:22the context? Your Excellency is we
- 1:30:24submit that context can be taken into
- 1:30:26consideration. However, context and
- 1:30:29purpose does not override the nature
- 1:30:31which as found by the ILC states
- 1:30:34actually preferred having the nature
- 1:30:35test as it served as a more objective
- 1:30:38standard in determining
- 1:30:40>> What is the what is the nature test?
- 1:30:42What does nature refer to in your view?
- 1:30:44The nature refers to this act this the
- 1:30:46entirety of this mining activity your
- 1:30:48Excellency is which clearly points to a
- 1:30:50commercial transaction especially when
- 1:30:52we take the context into consideration.
- 1:30:54Now we cite the case of BCG versus Yemen
- 1:30:57where in the exit stated that where a
- 1:30:59contractor enters into a competitive
- 1:31:01bidding process alongside other private
- 1:31:03companies and has their bid selected on
- 1:31:05commercial merits then these can point
- 1:31:08to commerciality. And so we look at the
- 1:31:09context here. Paragraphs 35 and 48 of
- 1:31:14the compromis show that Nexa was
- 1:31:15involved in the site survey to confirm
- 1:31:17cost estimates. All of this is true but
- 1:31:20couldn't one say that the context is the
- 1:31:23mining of rare earth
- 1:31:25you know minerals and that's a very
- 1:31:27particular type of thing which the state
- 1:31:30wanted for sovereign purposes.
- 1:31:33Well your Excellency is yes, we can say
- 1:31:35that the rare earth
- 1:31:37minerals were contemplated by Nexa here.
- 1:31:39However, we do not submit that it
- 1:31:41necessarily points to a sovereign
- 1:31:42purpose. The applicant earlier cited
- 1:31:45that paragraph 26 of the compromis was
- 1:31:47correctly stated that the Alacosta
- 1:31:49Minister of mining contemplated these
- 1:31:51minerals for existing and emerging
- 1:31:52industries without any particular
- 1:31:54showing to a particular sovereign
- 1:31:56purpose and your Excellency is these
- 1:31:58rare earth
- 1:31:59minerals can in fact be used for such
- 1:32:01sovereign purposes but at the same time
- 1:32:03they can also be used for technology
- 1:32:05such as cell phone screens which do not
- 1:32:07necessarily mean that in every instance
- 1:32:10these minerals are used for sovereign or
- 1:32:12national security purposes. And absent
- 1:32:15any showing in the compromis that this
- 1:32:16is precisely what Nexa contemplated, we
- 1:32:19cannot assume that this was the actual
- 1:32:21purpose engaged into by Alacosta into
- 1:32:24entering this project. And thus we
- 1:32:26submit that taking all of the context
- 1:32:28into consideration, we can still see
- 1:32:31that involved here was a commercial
- 1:32:33venture and therefore Nexa should not be
- 1:32:35entitled to immunity. However, on the
- 1:32:38final note that the territorial tort
- 1:32:39exception also does not apply in this
- 1:32:42case, we submit that it actually does
- 1:32:44because it is established as customary
- 1:32:46international law.
- 1:32:47>> Counsel, please.
- 1:32:49Um thinking in the death of Domingo
- 1:32:52Montoya
- 1:32:54I
- 1:32:55I wanted to know if in some point uh
- 1:32:59Restovia is not also has some kind of
- 1:33:02responsibility of culpa in vigilando
- 1:33:05because the facts
- 1:33:07uh happened in your in your states in
- 1:33:10your territory. So do you have something
- 1:33:13to tell about this possibility? Your
- 1:33:16Excellency is we submit that it is
- 1:33:18actually our duty and our obligation to
- 1:33:20ensure that the Montoya estate would be
- 1:33:22entitled to access to justice and as
- 1:33:25regards the actual event that occurred
- 1:33:27resulting in the death of Domingo
- 1:33:28Montoya, all these acts are clearly
- 1:33:30attributable to Nexa as the applicants
- 1:33:33themselves have cited. But here your
- 1:33:35Excellency is this is precisely why we
- 1:33:37invoke the territorial tort exception as
- 1:33:39doing so would allow greater access to
- 1:33:41justice for the estate of Domingo
- 1:33:43Montoya and as even found by the ILC by
- 1:33:47having these proceedings in another
- 1:33:48state it would result in a forum non
- 1:33:50conveniens.
- 1:33:51>> the legal source that you invoke to
- 1:33:55to apply the tort exception? The tort
- 1:33:58exception your Excellency is we cite
- 1:34:00various state practice and opinion juris
- 1:34:02which establishes the territorial tort
- 1:34:04exception as custom. We cite state
- 1:34:06practice in countries like the US, UK,
- 1:34:09Australia, South Africa, Argentina,
- 1:34:12Singapore, Israel and Australia and In
- 1:34:15the jurisdiction immunities case before
- 1:34:18this court, did the court accept did
- 1:34:20this court accept the territorial tort
- 1:34:22exception?
- 1:34:23Your Excellency is no but only in the
- 1:34:25context of armed conflicts or in the
- 1:34:27context of
- 1:34:29use cogans violations. However, your
- 1:34:31Excellency is the court did not make any
- 1:34:33particular pronouncement as to the
- 1:34:37rather existence of the principle in
- 1:34:38general outside of that context and we
- 1:34:41even cite the opinion of Judge Gaja in
- 1:34:43that case where in he stated that this
- 1:34:46territorial tort exception has existed
- 1:34:47since the 70s and and to date your
- 1:34:50Excellency is no state has objected to
- 1:34:52it being a rule of customary
- 1:34:54international law.
- 1:34:55Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:34:56>> counsel. Thank you Excellency is.
- 1:34:59Rebuttal?
- 1:35:10In relation to issue two, the first
- 1:35:13agent for the respondent contended that
- 1:35:15Restovia and I quote here put the Pilman
- 1:35:18people at the forefront. This was not
- 1:35:20true when elders from two states called
- 1:35:23for the tender process to be halted at
- 1:35:2522. This was not true when the remaining
- 1:35:28participating elders opposed the project
- 1:35:30in principle at 33 and this was not true
- 1:35:34when it unilaterally awarded the
- 1:35:35contract to Hyperion at 49. We
- 1:35:38fundamentally disagree with any
- 1:35:40discussion of the obligation as a veto
- 1:35:42right as it detracts from the
- 1:35:44conversation that should in fact be had.
- 1:35:47Indeed, this court should properly
- 1:35:49listen to the opposition of indigenous
- 1:35:51people and give recognition to the first
- 1:35:54nations of the land. Thank you your
- 1:35:55Excellency is.
- 1:35:57Thank you.
- 1:35:58For rebuttal?
- 1:36:12Mr. President, your Excellency is once
- 1:36:14again good day. Respondent has just one
- 1:36:16point for rebuttal in response to the
- 1:36:18applicant.
- 1:36:19The applicant rebutted that the
- 1:36:22respondent failed to put the Pilman
- 1:36:24people at the forefront of this project.
- 1:36:27And to support the rebuttal, the
- 1:36:29applicant mentioned the the core of it
- 1:36:32was the awarding of the contract to
- 1:36:33Hyperion and also failing to consider
- 1:36:36the calls for the moratorium by the
- 1:36:39applicant and the Salanian state. But
- 1:36:41your Excellency is the applicant fails
- 1:36:43to regard the consistent standard that
- 1:36:45is provided for us by international law.
- 1:36:48As mentioned by special rapporteur James
- 1:36:50Anaya in page nine of his report states
- 1:36:53can continue to develop their project so
- 1:36:56long as they enact good faith
- 1:36:57measurements that allow the bill allow
- 1:37:00indigenous communities to influence the
- 1:37:03outcome such that the state can proceed
- 1:37:05subject to those limitations. Across all
- 1:37:08three finalist bidders even Hyperion,
- 1:37:11they were included in the bidding
- 1:37:12process, they were included in the
- 1:37:14information sharing. Can I ask what is
- 1:37:16the status of that special rapporteur's
- 1:37:18report
- 1:37:20that you referred to? What why should
- 1:37:22this court take that into account? Your
- 1:37:24Excellency is pursuant to article 38
- 1:37:27paragraph 1D on the works of the most
- 1:37:29highly qualified publicist it is very
- 1:37:32highly
- 1:37:32>> question. It it it it is it is highly um
- 1:37:36probative on this court. But at the end
- 1:37:38of the day your Excellency is that
- 1:37:39consistent standard is clear and all
- 1:37:41respondent asks is to be evaluated based
- 1:37:44on what international law requires and
- 1:37:47not what applicant wants it to be. Thank
- 1:37:49you and it was an honor to speak before
- 1:37:51this court. Thank you. Thank you
- 1:37:53counsel.
- 1:37:54>> [applause]
- 1:38:01[applause]
- 1:38:10[applause]
- 1:38:17>> Thank you. We'll we'll now
- 1:38:20retreat [applause] to deliberate and
- 1:38:22we'll return soon with our decision.
- 1:38:27The honorable court is now adjourned.
- 1:38:28Counsel and spectators, please stay in
- 1:38:30the courtroom and the judges will leave
- 1:38:32to deliberate.
- 1:39:25>> Got it.
- 1:39:46Wow.
- 1:39:47Herman, crank me up.
- 1:39:51Check, check.
- 1:40:00>> [laughter]
- 1:40:01>> Check, check.
- 1:40:03Wow.
- 1:40:06Wow.
- 1:40:10Wow.
- 1:40:12Wow.
- 1:40:14Wow.
- 1:40:16That was That was amazing. I
- 1:40:21Good afternoon again.
- 1:40:25While the judges are deliberating, we
- 1:40:27have a couple things we need to get
- 1:40:28through, but before I do that,
- 1:40:31wow.
- 1:40:34>> [applause]
- 1:40:43[applause]
- 1:40:46>> I have the honor at this time to
- 1:40:48introduce the chair of the Board of
- 1:40:51Directors of the International Law
- 1:40:53Students Association, who is also the
- 1:40:55founding chair of
- 1:40:57the International Law Students
- 1:40:59Association, and who is um in less than
- 1:41:03a month um finishing his
- 1:41:06his tenure as
- 1:41:08chair of the International Law Students
- 1:41:09Association. Uh please welcome Steven
- 1:41:12Schneebaum.
- 1:41:14>> [applause]
- 1:41:19[applause]
- 1:41:21>> Thank you.
- 1:41:25Well, thank you, Michael.
- 1:41:26And
- 1:41:28my friends, as you all know,
- 1:41:30the Jessup competition, now in its 67th
- 1:41:34year,
- 1:41:36like other such venerable institutions,
- 1:41:38has generated an extensive network of
- 1:41:41customs,
- 1:41:43all of them, of course, established
- 1:41:45through uniform practice and opinio
- 1:41:47juris.
- 1:41:49This talk, given annually
- 1:41:51by the chair of the ILSA Board, is one
- 1:41:53of them.
- 1:41:55So, let me start with the obvious.
- 1:41:58On behalf of all Jessup competitors,
- 1:42:01their supporters, their teachers and
- 1:42:04coaches and judges around the world,
- 1:42:08let me offer our congratulations to the
- 1:42:10two best Jessup teams in the world in
- 1:42:132026,
- 1:42:14the National University of Singapore
- 1:42:17and Ateneo de Manila.
- 1:42:20>> [applause]
- 1:42:25[applause]
- 1:42:29>> They have just shown us that they richly
- 1:42:32deserve their places in the final round.
- 1:42:35Whichever of them takes home the Jessup
- 1:42:37Cup, they are both excellent, and we are
- 1:42:40in awe of their diligence, their skills,
- 1:42:43and their perseverance.
- 1:42:45I also want to remind everyone
- 1:42:48of the incredible work
- 1:42:51done by the men and women behind the
- 1:42:53curtain,
- 1:42:55the staff of the ILSA's Executive
- 1:42:57Office,
- 1:42:58and the volunteers who support them.
- 1:43:01This year's competition
- 1:43:03>> [applause]
- 1:43:10>> This year's competition posed
- 1:43:11difficulties that we had never had to
- 1:43:14confront before,
- 1:43:16but unless you have been watching
- 1:43:18closely,
- 1:43:19you may not even have noticed.
- 1:43:22It is such a cliché to say that people
- 1:43:25deserve credit for working tirelessly,
- 1:43:29but here that expression is literally
- 1:43:32applicable.
- 1:43:34These and International Rounds would not
- 1:43:36have been the phenomenal success that we
- 1:43:39have all enjoyed this week
- 1:43:41without the extraordinary
- 1:43:4324/7
- 1:43:45efforts
- 1:43:46of our superb Executive Director,
- 1:43:49Michael Pyle.
- 1:43:51>> [applause]
- 1:44:00[applause]
- 1:44:03>> And I I challenge those who follow me in
- 1:44:06this role to find more superlatives and
- 1:44:10more words of praise and more thanks to
- 1:44:13heap onto Michael
- 1:44:15and his incomparable deputies,
- 1:44:17Christopher Bernay and Roxana Nazari.
- 1:44:20>> [applause]
- 1:44:28>> And while thanks are being distributed,
- 1:44:30let me once again
- 1:44:32extend ILSA's deep gratitude to the law
- 1:44:35firm of White & Case,
- 1:44:38who
- 1:44:39>> [applause]
- 1:44:43>> The firm's chair, Heather McDevitt,
- 1:44:45unfortunately could not be with us
- 1:44:47today,
- 1:44:48but without her support and that of
- 1:44:50everyone at White & Case, this week
- 1:44:53would simply not have been possible.
- 1:44:56We thank Heather and her firm for
- 1:44:58believing in ILSA
- 1:45:00and for their singular dedication to the
- 1:45:02students for whom this organization
- 1:45:05exists.
- 1:45:09>> [applause]
- 1:45:14>> Now, the the next tradition to which I
- 1:45:17now turn
- 1:45:19is an important, but a sad, one.
- 1:45:21Since the Jessup community is worldwide
- 1:45:25and multi-generational,
- 1:45:27it is appropriate that each year we take
- 1:45:29a moment
- 1:45:30to remember the the members of our
- 1:45:32global family whom we have lost during
- 1:45:35this past year.
- 1:45:38Albi
- 1:45:40and his fiance
- 1:45:42were killed in an automobile accident in
- 1:45:44November.
- 1:45:46Albi joined the Jessup family in 2020 in
- 1:45:492014.
- 1:45:51He represented Albania in the
- 1:45:53International Rounds for four
- 1:45:55consecutive years,
- 1:45:57as well as in the European Friendly
- 1:45:59Rounds held in Hungary, Cyprus, and
- 1:46:02Austria.
- 1:46:04He was a true pioneer of the Albanian
- 1:46:07Jessup team,
- 1:46:09going above and beyond to ensure that
- 1:46:11the Albanian flag
- 1:46:13was always raised in Washington, D.C.
- 1:46:15throughout his years as a competitor.
- 1:46:19In 2019, Albi returned to coach the
- 1:46:23Albanian team,
- 1:46:24and in 2020 he served as a judge in the
- 1:46:27U.S. National Rounds
- 1:46:29after Regional Rounds, that is, after
- 1:46:32moving to the United States to pursue
- 1:46:33his LLM at Arizona State University.
- 1:46:37He continued his legal studies at
- 1:46:39Cleveland State University College of
- 1:46:41Law,
- 1:46:42and was on track to sit for the bar exam
- 1:46:45this coming July,
- 1:46:47when his life was taken from him and
- 1:46:49from us.
- 1:46:52Ivan Yuramchuk
- 1:46:55was also a pioneer of mooting,
- 1:46:57and was a member of the first-ever
- 1:46:59Jessup team
- 1:47:01from Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivetsky
- 1:47:05National University in Ukraine,
- 1:47:07as well as that country's first-ever
- 1:47:10Jessup Summer School.
- 1:47:13Following his participation in 2017 at
- 1:47:16the National Rounds,
- 1:47:17he remained actively involved in
- 1:47:19developing the university's moot court
- 1:47:21community by coaching teams,
- 1:47:25co-leading the the moot court society,
- 1:47:28and advocating for broader institutional
- 1:47:30support
- 1:47:31of student initiatives at Chernivtsi.
- 1:47:35Ivan was killed
- 1:47:37in combat
- 1:47:38while serving as an infantry medic,
- 1:47:41taking part in the defense of the city
- 1:47:44of Chasiv Yar
- 1:47:45in eastern Ukraine.
- 1:47:48I ask you all now, please, to rise
- 1:47:51and to honor the memories of Albi and of
- 1:47:53Ivan with a moment of silence.
- 1:48:12Thank you.
- 1:48:16And now,
- 1:48:18it is my pleasure
- 1:48:20to announce the topics of the Jessup
- 1:48:22Problem
- 1:48:23for 2027.
- 1:48:26Those of you who have been here before
- 1:48:28know that what I will now tell you
- 1:48:31will be the only clue you are going to
- 1:48:34get
- 1:48:35until September
- 1:48:37about the problem that will obsess
- 1:48:39students around the world until we next
- 1:48:43meet again in April of next year.
- 1:48:47Ready?
- 1:48:49The four questions posed in next year's
- 1:48:52Statement of Agreed Facts are the
- 1:48:54following.
- 1:48:55Number one,
- 1:48:57allegations of gender apartheid.
- 1:49:01Number two,
- 1:49:03state responses to a mass influx of
- 1:49:06migrants seeking asylum.
- 1:49:10Number three,
- 1:49:11sanction designations generated by
- 1:49:14artificial intelligence.
- 1:49:17And all of these in the wake of number
- 1:49:20four,
- 1:49:21a coup d'état resulting in a government
- 1:49:25whose status within the international
- 1:49:27community remains contested.
- 1:49:31That's it.
- 1:49:33>> [applause]
- 1:49:41[applause]
- 1:49:44>> Finally,
- 1:49:46I want to take advantage of your
- 1:49:47patience for just another few moments
- 1:49:51as I ask you to indulge me in some
- 1:49:53personal remarks.
- 1:49:56I have served as chair
- 1:49:58of this beloved organization for a total
- 1:50:01of 12 years
- 1:50:03since ILSA's founding as an independent
- 1:50:06entity in 1994.
- 1:50:08As Michael told you, I stepped down at
- 1:50:10the end of this month
- 1:50:12and I am delighted to let you know
- 1:50:15that my successor will be my friend,
- 1:50:18Judge Andrew Holmes.
- 1:50:20I cannot think
- 1:50:22>> [applause]
- 1:50:28[applause]
- 1:50:31>> You you You kind of got ahead of me
- 1:50:33there. I was about to ask Andrew to
- 1:50:35stand up. I cannot think of a person
- 1:50:37better suited to assume this role. I'm
- 1:50:40confident that the entire Jessup family
- 1:50:42will welcome Andrew as he assumes its
- 1:50:44leadership. Let me ask Andrew, please,
- 1:50:47to stand. I don't think you've done
- 1:50:49that.
- 1:50:52>> [applause]
- 1:50:57>> And we all
- 1:50:58>> [applause]
- 1:50:59>> we all join in wishing him good luck.
- 1:51:02This then is my last opportunity to
- 1:51:05address you.
- 1:51:07It comes at a uniquely difficult and
- 1:51:10trying time for international law
- 1:51:14and in a especially difficult moment for
- 1:51:16students
- 1:51:17wishing to become international lawyers.
- 1:51:21The evidence does not need to be
- 1:51:23belabored by me.
- 1:51:25The news media are daily doing a more
- 1:51:29than adequate job at presenting the sad
- 1:51:31facts.
- 1:51:33Suffice it simply to reiterate Article
- 1:51:3624 of the United Nations Charter.
- 1:51:40All members shall refrain in their
- 1:51:43international relations
- 1:51:45from the threat or use of force against
- 1:51:49the territorial sovereign territorial
- 1:51:51integrity or political independence of
- 1:51:54any state
- 1:51:56or in any other manner inconsistent with
- 1:51:59the purposes of the United Nations.
- 1:52:02Today,
- 1:52:03it seems almost quaint.
- 1:52:06Around the world,
- 1:52:08universities, probably including yours,
- 1:52:11are convening meetings and seminars and
- 1:52:14debates on the topic of whether
- 1:52:17international law still exists,
- 1:52:21whether it is worth studying,
- 1:52:23whether there still is or even whether
- 1:52:25there ever was
- 1:52:27a viable international legal regime.
- 1:52:31Whether the post-war era with the
- 1:52:33prominence it gave to the rule of law,
- 1:52:35even when legal norms were honored in
- 1:52:37the breach,
- 1:52:39has given way to a new age
- 1:52:42in which
- 1:52:43to quote the brilliant speech of
- 1:52:46Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney in
- 1:52:48Davos, channeling through Thucydides,
- 1:52:52the strong can do what they can
- 1:52:56and the weak must suffer what they must.
- 1:53:00How far we have come.
- 1:53:03Not so very long ago,
- 1:53:05President John F. Kennedy of this
- 1:53:07country spoke in his inaugural address
- 1:53:11of, quote, a new world of law where the
- 1:53:14strong are just
- 1:53:16and the weak secure
- 1:53:18and the peace preserved.
- 1:53:23In 2017,
- 1:53:25Michael's predecessor as ILSA's
- 1:53:27executive director, Lesley Benn,
- 1:53:30welcomed Jessup competitors to
- 1:53:32Washington
- 1:53:34by reminding them of the words of Sir
- 1:53:36Edward Grey,
- 1:53:38foreign minister of the United Kingdom
- 1:53:41at the outbreak of the First World War.
- 1:53:45"The lamps," he said, "are going out all
- 1:53:49over Europe
- 1:53:51and we shall not see them lit again in
- 1:53:54our lifetimes."
- 1:53:56Lesley cited those words to celebrate
- 1:53:59the progress the world had made.
- 1:54:02The lights had in fact been relit
- 1:54:06by international lawyers
- 1:54:08and it seemed as though they would
- 1:54:10remain lit forever.
- 1:54:14Resisting the winds of change
- 1:54:17fueled by international law.
- 1:54:20But to mix a metaphor,
- 1:54:23that bubble has burst.
- 1:54:25That enthusiasm is dissipated.
- 1:54:28That confidence is no longer
- 1:54:31sustainable.
- 1:54:32So, what do we do now?
- 1:54:34How do we how do you
- 1:54:37maintain the commitment to the rule of
- 1:54:40law that we see in this competition
- 1:54:43in the face of what we read or hear or
- 1:54:46see on our screens and in our
- 1:54:49communities every day?
- 1:54:52Or do we simply resign ourselves to
- 1:54:55despair?
- 1:54:57Every one of us will have to answer
- 1:54:59those questions for herself or himself.
- 1:55:03But let me offer a few suggestions.
- 1:55:06First,
- 1:55:08we must be confident and resolute in our
- 1:55:11belief in the rule of law.
- 1:55:13Only if the law is protected,
- 1:55:17honored, and observed,
- 1:55:20can humanity achieve a measure of
- 1:55:22justice and equity.
- 1:55:25The only way to engender hope for
- 1:55:27ourselves and for generations to to
- 1:55:30come.
- 1:55:31Lawyers are have always been and will
- 1:55:35always be on the front lines of this
- 1:55:39struggle.
- 1:55:40We have been the sworn enemy of tyranny
- 1:55:43and those who seek it since time
- 1:55:45immemorial and for that reason
- 1:55:48we have been targeted throughout
- 1:55:50history.
- 1:55:52Welcome to the battlefield.
- 1:55:54You are the reinforcements
- 1:55:57and you are needed now more than ever.
- 1:56:01Second,
- 1:56:03advocating for the rule of law is a
- 1:56:05means to an end, not an end in itself.
- 1:56:09There are other avenues that some of you
- 1:56:11will explore in your careers and other
- 1:56:13opportunities that you may seize
- 1:56:16using your knowledge of the law and your
- 1:56:18skills in advocacy to promote peace,
- 1:56:22including the peaceful resolution of
- 1:56:24disputes between nations.
- 1:56:26You may become diplomats or elected
- 1:56:29leaders. You may be professors who will
- 1:56:31encourage and inspire the generations
- 1:56:34that succeed you.
- 1:56:36You may become judges
- 1:56:38who through wise decisions will
- 1:56:40demonstrate that the law is not a rigid
- 1:56:43set of strictures,
- 1:56:45but a formula for achieving justice
- 1:56:47tempered by mercy and compassion.
- 1:56:51Third,
- 1:56:52it is okay to be frustrated, to be
- 1:56:56depressed, and to be angry.
- 1:56:58Indeed, it might well be said that if
- 1:57:00you are not angry, you are not paying
- 1:57:02attention.
- 1:57:04But you have to pay attention
- 1:57:06when a world leader announces from his
- 1:57:09bully pulpit that, quote, I do not need
- 1:57:12international law,
- 1:57:14you have to pay attention.
- 1:57:17You have to focus when the head of a
- 1:57:18powerful nation's war-fighting
- 1:57:20operations declares that rules of
- 1:57:23engagement dictated by the Geneva
- 1:57:26Conventions are, in his word, stupid.
- 1:57:31And even closer to home, you cannot
- 1:57:33ignore the fact that nearly 30 nations
- 1:57:36Jessup teams,
- 1:57:38your colleagues, our friends, are not
- 1:57:41here with us in Washington.
- 1:57:44Their travel prevented by suspicion
- 1:57:46and mistrust
- 1:57:48and for some of them by war.
- 1:57:52And finally,
- 1:57:53it is not okay
- 1:57:55to remain silent.
- 1:57:58People, just like nations, will always
- 1:58:01disagree about the best course,
- 1:58:03sometimes deeply and for good reasons.
- 1:58:07But the rule of law will not survive if
- 1:58:09its defenders do not speak up.
- 1:58:13When the former president of the
- 1:58:15Republic of Liberia, Ellen Johnson
- 1:58:17Sirleaf,
- 1:58:18was awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace in
- 1:58:202011,
- 1:58:22she told all of those who love peace and
- 1:58:25justice, quote, "to find your voices and
- 1:58:30raise your voices."
- 1:58:32When you do speak up,
- 1:58:34no one can guarantee that you will
- 1:58:37prevail.
- 1:58:38But I can guarantee one thing.
- 1:58:41You will not be alone.
- 1:58:45Look around this room right now.
- 1:58:48These are your colleagues in the
- 1:58:50struggle.
- 1:58:52Old and young, from every tradition and
- 1:58:55in a hundred different languages, these
- 1:58:58are the people who will be by your side
- 1:59:00as you will be by theirs.
- 1:59:03The tests that lie ahead of you in your
- 1:59:05professional lives will be far more
- 1:59:08difficult than preparing for this
- 1:59:09competition.
- 1:59:11What we hope,
- 1:59:13what the International Law Students
- 1:59:14Association has attempted to show you,
- 1:59:17is that through this exercise,
- 1:59:20you can acquire the means, the tools,
- 1:59:23and the grit
- 1:59:25that you will need to carry the torch.
- 1:59:28Despair remains an option.
- 1:59:31Pessimism is omnipresent and with good
- 1:59:33reason.
- 1:59:35But it is hard
- 1:59:37to imagine how anyone,
- 1:59:39having seen your dedication,
- 1:59:42having heard your performances this
- 1:59:44week,
- 1:59:45having watched as you found common cause
- 1:59:47and friendship with colleagues from
- 1:59:50every corner of the planet,
- 1:59:52can fail to have hope.
- 1:59:55But whether that hope is justified, I'm
- 1:59:57afraid,
- 1:59:59is now up to you.
- 2:00:00And so, let me conclude with this
- 2:00:02challenge and with this wish.
- 2:00:05When days are dark
- 2:00:06and when it appears that the
- 2:00:08international order is crumbling,
- 2:00:10remember the time you spent in the
- 2:00:13Jessup competition.
- 2:00:15Remember the people you met here
- 2:00:17and the things you learned here.
- 2:00:20Even when it is most difficult to see
- 2:00:22the light of Lord Grey's lamps,
- 2:00:25remember,
- 2:00:26they were not extinguished in 1914.
- 2:00:30And if you have your way,
- 2:00:32if you deploy your commitment and
- 2:00:35dedication to peace and to the rule of
- 2:00:37law as you have done here,
- 2:00:40they will shine on despite everything in
- 2:00:442026
- 2:00:46and for decades to come.
- 2:00:48So, thank you.
- 2:00:50Good luck to you all.
- 2:00:51And let me now introduce
- 2:00:53Aditya Singh, a partner in the Singapore
- 2:00:56office of White & Case and a member of
- 2:00:59the ILSA Board of Directors. Good luck
- 2:01:01to you all.
- 2:01:03>> [applause]
- 2:01:11[applause]
- 2:01:19[applause]
- 2:01:22>> Thank you, Stephen. Ladies and
- 2:01:24gentlemen, we have just witnessed
- 2:01:26exceptional advocacy from our finalist
- 2:01:29teams. But I want to take a moment to
- 2:01:31recognize every student who participated
- 2:01:35in the Jessup this year.
- 2:01:37You committed months of your lives to
- 2:01:39this competition.
- 2:01:41The Jessup demands the very best of you,
- 2:01:44and you delivered it. Congratulations.
- 2:01:48>> [applause]
- 2:01:57>> This year marks the 19th year of White &
- 2:02:00Case's global partnership with the
- 2:02:02Jessup.
- 2:02:03Over nearly two decades of this
- 2:02:05partnership, we have sought to celebrate
- 2:02:08the values that the Jessup represents,
- 2:02:11international cooperation,
- 2:02:14excellence in advocacy,
- 2:02:16and a deep and enduring commitment to
- 2:02:19the rule of law.
- 2:02:21Six years ago,
- 2:02:23White & Case established an annual award
- 2:02:26to honor Jessup alumni who have made a
- 2:02:29profound impact on the legal profession
- 2:02:32and beyond.
- 2:02:34Now, Jessup alumni have gone on to
- 2:02:36become leading lawyers, judges,
- 2:02:39academics, government officials, and
- 2:02:41public servants, each playing a critical
- 2:02:44role in shaping a more just society.
- 2:02:49In selecting the award's recipient, we
- 2:02:51look for someone whose life and career
- 2:02:54embody those values. Someone who began,
- 2:02:57as you all did, as a law student trying
- 2:03:00to argue a difficult case and carried
- 2:03:03that experience into something
- 2:03:06extraordinary.
- 2:03:08It is my great pleasure to announce that
- 2:03:11the 2026
- 2:03:13White & Case Distinguished Jessup Alumni
- 2:03:15Award goes to Professor Ximena Fuentes.
- 2:03:20>> [applause]
- 2:03:30>> Professor Fuentes participated in the
- 2:03:32Jessup in 1990
- 2:03:35as a student at the Faculty of Law of
- 2:03:37the Universidad de Chile.
- 2:03:40Professor Fuentes exemplifies the very
- 2:03:43best of the Jessup tradition.
- 2:03:46She has distinguished herself not only
- 2:03:48as a scholar and an advocate, but also a
- 2:03:52public servant and a diplomat of
- 2:03:55exceptional accomplishment.
- 2:03:58Professor Fuentes has represented Chile
- 2:04:01multiple times before the ICJ, including
- 2:04:04as an advisor on the maritime dispute
- 2:04:06with Peru,
- 2:04:08in the Bolivia v. Chile proceedings on
- 2:04:10access to the Pacific Ocean, and as
- 2:04:13agent in the Silala case.
- 2:04:15She has also represented Chile in the
- 2:04:17ICJ climate change advisory proceedings
- 2:04:20last year.
- 2:04:21As a scholar, she has taught public
- 2:04:24international law at multiple
- 2:04:26universities in Chile and abroad and
- 2:04:29served as president of the Chilean
- 2:04:31Society of International Law.
- 2:04:34As a public servant and diplomat, she
- 2:04:37has served in a number of distinguished
- 2:04:39roles.
- 2:04:40As a deputy judge of the Second
- 2:04:43Environmental Tribunal,
- 2:04:45as Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs,
- 2:04:48and most recently as Ambassador to the
- 2:04:51United Kingdom.
- 2:04:53For everyone competing here this week,
- 2:04:56her example is a powerful reminder of
- 2:04:59what the Jessup can inspire.
- 2:05:03It is an honor to present the White &
- 2:05:05Case Distinguished Jessup Alumni Award
- 2:05:08to a member of the Jessup family whose
- 2:05:10career has brought distinction to our
- 2:05:14community.
- 2:05:16Professor Fuentes could not be with us
- 2:05:18in person to accept the award, but she
- 2:05:20has kindly shared a video message for us
- 2:05:23which will which will now be played.
- 2:05:25Thank you.
- 2:05:26I want to express my heartfelt gratitude
- 2:05:29for this award.
- 2:05:31On the 22nd of January, I received a
- 2:05:33mail from Elizabeth Black informing me
- 2:05:36that I have been selected as the 2026
- 2:05:41uh recipient of the White & Case
- 2:05:43Distinguished Jessup Alumni Award.
- 2:05:47This news came as a fantastic surprise.
- 2:05:52And it means a lot to me because the
- 2:05:54Philip Jessup competition occupies a
- 2:05:57very important place in my life.
- 2:06:01And for that reason,
- 2:06:03I am very, very sorry that I cannot be
- 2:06:05with you in person today.
- 2:06:09I was a participant in the Philip Jessup
- 2:06:12competition
- 2:06:14in the 1990s, way back 1990s.
- 2:06:19And it is not an exaggeration if I tell
- 2:06:21you
- 2:06:22that this experience had a great
- 2:06:24influence in my future career
- 2:06:27as a lawyer and as a professor of
- 2:06:29international law.
- 2:06:32This was the first time
- 2:06:34I had the opportunity
- 2:06:37to experience a moot court competition
- 2:06:42where knowledge of the law
- 2:06:44was only one aspect
- 2:06:47of the many skills that a good lawyer
- 2:06:48needs to display in court.
- 2:06:51The Jessup experience
- 2:06:53showed me
- 2:06:55that being a practitioner is an
- 2:06:57adventure,
- 2:06:59a real adventure into the complexities
- 2:07:02of real life problems.
- 2:07:05And it requires more more than knowledge
- 2:07:07about the law. It requires creativity,
- 2:07:10imagination,
- 2:07:13some actual skills, in fact, a lot of
- 2:07:15actual skills,
- 2:07:17intellectual curiosity,
- 2:07:20and an interest
- 2:07:25in the human condition.
- 2:07:28I enjoyed so much
- 2:07:30my experience in the Philip Jessup
- 2:07:32competition that I decided at that time
- 2:07:36that I wanted to work in the field of
- 2:07:38public international law.
- 2:07:41My first option at that time
- 2:07:43was to become an academic.
- 2:07:46And I was
- 2:07:48uh
- 2:07:49a privileged person because I wrote my
- 2:07:53thesis, my PhD thesis, at the University
- 2:07:57of Oxford under the supervision of
- 2:07:59Professor Ian Brown.
- 2:08:02I wrote about international
- 2:08:04watercourses.
- 2:08:06And when I went back to Chile to work as
- 2:08:09a professor of international law,
- 2:08:11I was lucky enough
- 2:08:13to work for my country
- 2:08:15with regard to a controversy regarding
- 2:08:18an international river.
- 2:08:20So, life is also made up of these lucky
- 2:08:23moments.
- 2:08:25I ended up working
- 2:08:28for the Republic of Chile in four cases
- 2:08:31before the International Court of
- 2:08:33Justice.
- 2:08:34And later,
- 2:08:35I became
- 2:08:37head of the International Boundaries
- 2:08:39Department at the Ministry of Foreign
- 2:08:41Affairs.
- 2:08:42Then, I became Under Secretary of
- 2:08:44Foreign Affairs.
- 2:08:46And most more recently, I was
- 2:08:50the Ambassador of Chile
- 2:08:52uh in the United Kingdom.
- 2:08:55Looking back,
- 2:08:57I think that the Jessup competition was
- 2:08:59indeed a life-changing
- 2:09:01experience for me.
- 2:09:03And for that reason, I continue to work
- 2:09:06in the preparation of the Chilean Jessup
- 2:09:10teams because I know
- 2:09:13that what you get to learn from this
- 2:09:15competition is much more than what you
- 2:09:18learn in the classroom.
- 2:09:22I'm sure most of you will become great
- 2:09:25lawyers.
- 2:09:27And let me tell you
- 2:09:29that I am convinced
- 2:09:31that today, more than ever,
- 2:09:34we need very good lawyers.
- 2:09:36Good, honest,
- 2:09:39knowledgeable practitioners.
- 2:09:41Because a rules-based order is our only
- 2:09:46opportunity to face
- 2:09:48global challenges today.
- 2:09:51Finally, I would like to express my
- 2:09:53gratitude
- 2:09:55to the International Students
- 2:09:57Association
- 2:09:58in the person of the Executive
- 2:10:01Director,
- 2:10:02Ilpa.
- 2:10:04You have made a great contribution to
- 2:10:08international law.
- 2:10:10And I'm sure that my experience is not
- 2:10:13unique.
- 2:10:14I'm sure that all former
- 2:10:17Jessup participants
- 2:10:19will share my view
- 2:10:21that this competition is a life-changing
- 2:10:24experience.
- 2:10:26So, I would like to end by wishing you
- 2:10:30the best of lucks in the competition.
- 2:10:33I'm sure that you will
- 2:10:35make great.
- 2:10:37And thank you very much. Good luck.
- 2:10:43>> [applause]
- 2:11:05>> So, while the judges are finishing up
- 2:11:07their deliberations, I have a number of
- 2:11:09people to thank. And Steven mentioned
- 2:11:11the traditions. One of those is that I
- 2:11:13get to
- 2:11:15thank a lot of people.
- 2:11:17None of this
- 2:11:19>> [clears throat]
- 2:11:19>> would have been possible without a
- 2:11:21literal cast of literal thousands.
- 2:11:24I want to thank a few of them now.
- 2:11:27The first are national administrators,
- 2:11:29national round judges, national
- 2:11:31memorials judges, and volunteers of all
- 2:11:33stripes
- 2:11:35who we don't we don't see here.
- 2:11:38Um some of them come as judges, but but
- 2:11:41the bulk of their work is organizing all
- 2:11:43of those national and friendly rounds
- 2:11:45around the world. I'd like a round of
- 2:11:46applause for our national
- 2:11:48administrators.
- 2:11:49>> [applause]
- 2:11:59[applause]
- 2:12:01>> I don't know what led me to believe
- 2:12:02there's a camera over there, but
- 2:12:04I'm that's for the camera.
- 2:12:08The Jessup and Xie Award
- 2:12:11is given by the Executive Office every
- 2:12:14year to the outstanding national
- 2:12:16administrator or national administrators
- 2:12:18in that year.
- 2:12:19Um it rotates around uh depending on how
- 2:12:23the world changes.
- 2:12:24This year um
- 2:12:27the Jessup Xie Award in part returns
- 2:12:30home. Dr. Jessup Xie was the founding
- 2:12:32national administrator of the Chinese
- 2:12:34national rounds
- 2:12:36and led the Chinese national rounds from
- 2:12:40a tiny start at the beginning of this
- 2:12:42century to one of our largest national
- 2:12:45rounds. And so, it is completely
- 2:12:47appropriate in the
- 2:12:51entering the third year after his
- 2:12:53retirement, a retirement that was well
- 2:12:57deserved, but but caused me a great deal
- 2:12:59of stress. How do you replace a legend
- 2:13:01who is is literally the institutional
- 2:13:03wisdom of such a large competition?
- 2:13:07It gives me great pleasure, and I'd like
- 2:13:09to invite his his school's Jessup team
- 2:13:11to come up and receive the award on
- 2:13:13behalf of our
- 2:13:15our second ever Chinese national
- 2:13:17administrator, now entering his third
- 2:13:18year, Dr. Zhu Lijang.
- 2:13:24>> [applause]
- 2:13:33>> China China University of Political
- 2:13:35Science and Law.
- 2:13:39>> [applause]
- 2:13:48[applause]
- 2:13:54>> I had a um
- 2:13:58Yes, I'm going to phrase it that way. I
- 2:13:59had a dream about 25 years ago, and yes,
- 2:14:01these are the kinds of things I dream
- 2:14:02about, that we would take all these tiny
- 2:14:04US regionals and combine them into one
- 2:14:08giant US national rounds.
- 2:14:11Uh
- 2:14:11you know, 150 teams all gathered in one
- 2:14:13place, rivaling even the size of the of
- 2:14:16the vaunted international rounds.
- 2:14:19The Board of Directors back in 2001 said
- 2:14:22that was insane. We had 12 regionals at
- 2:14:24the time. They each had about 12 teams.
- 2:14:27Um
- 2:14:27and then my predecessor, Amity Boy,
- 2:14:30tricked them into consolidating down to
- 2:14:32six super regionals, as we called them
- 2:14:34then.
- 2:14:35Um and then for financial and other
- 2:14:38trumped-up reasons, my other successor,
- 2:14:41um Wesley Ben, managed to sneak it down
- 2:14:44to five or four or three, and then I
- 2:14:46came back and said, "Well, wow, we're
- 2:14:48coming out of COVID. Why not have two
- 2:14:50semi-national rounds?"
- 2:14:52Um and then this year, for the first
- 2:14:53time ever, because, you know, what's the
- 2:14:55difference between two and one?
- 2:14:58You know, it's it's such a small
- 2:14:59difference and pay
- 2:15:01pay no attention to the slippery slope
- 2:15:04um Board of Directors,
- 2:15:06um all of whom were also Jessup judges,
- 2:15:08but
- 2:15:09but this year um the dream the the dream
- 2:15:12came true. We brought all the US teams
- 2:15:14into one competition in Atlanta,
- 2:15:16Georgia.
- 2:15:17Um and that Yay, Atlanta.
- 2:15:21It was it was awesome, especially in
- 2:15:23February.
- 2:15:24Um nice warm climate.
- 2:15:27Um but I want to congratulate and invite
- 2:15:29up here
- 2:15:30uh I want to congratulate both of them,
- 2:15:32and I want to invite up here the only
- 2:15:34one who was able to join us this week,
- 2:15:36uh our first ever
- 2:15:39um
- 2:15:39uh national administrators of the King &
- 2:15:41Spalding United States national rounds,
- 2:15:44Jeff Brooks and Jenny Anglender.
- 2:15:46>> [applause]
- 2:15:51[applause]
- 2:16:00[applause]
- 2:16:08>> Thank Thank you, Reem.
- 2:16:12We didn't have her plaque 4 days ago.
- 2:16:20But the the net is much broader than
- 2:16:21that, and the support network that ILSA
- 2:16:24and the Jessup competition have
- 2:16:27is much broader than that.
- 2:16:29I'd like to recognize at at this time a
- 2:16:32couple of groups that are
- 2:16:34central to the success of this
- 2:16:36organization. I'd like to ask them to
- 2:16:37stand in place uh and let us express our
- 2:16:40gratitude.
- 2:16:41The first is my incredibly active
- 2:16:45um and um
- 2:16:47indispensable Board of Directors. Please
- 2:16:49stand.
- 2:16:52>> [applause]
- 2:17:01[applause]
- 2:17:06>> The second is the members of our All
- 2:17:08Rise Society, the donors that paid for
- 2:17:11so many hotel rooms and so many flights
- 2:17:13and so much of what we have around here.
- 2:17:15Um I we appreciate your cash, but it's
- 2:17:18no coincidence that many of you are also
- 2:17:21the the beating heart of our judging
- 2:17:22core, of our administrators. I'd like to
- 2:17:24ask the members of the All Rise Society
- 2:17:26to please rise.
- 2:17:28>> [applause]
- 2:17:37[applause]
- 2:17:44>> I have a number of other categories, but
- 2:17:46I would like at this point to do one of
- 2:17:48my favorite traditions. The it falls to
- 2:17:51the Executive Director every year in my
- 2:17:54sole discretion, sole and unfettered
- 2:17:57discretion,
- 2:17:58uh to
- 2:18:00uh
- 2:18:01indicate a volunteer
- 2:18:03either at these international rounds or
- 2:18:06or, you know, around the world or
- 2:18:07someplace else who has
- 2:18:10done extraordinary work on behalf of the
- 2:18:12Jessup competition. We call this the
- 2:18:14Pamela M. Young Award.
- 2:18:16Um as you've heard all week,
- 2:18:19uh the the drumbeat of there are teams
- 2:18:22who are competing from abroad.
- 2:18:24Uh there are teams that that can't be
- 2:18:26here, and how on, you know,
- 2:18:29and and one of them even advanced to the
- 2:18:31run-off rounds.
- 2:18:34A month ago, 2 months ago, when we were
- 2:18:35trying to figure out what we could do to
- 2:18:37recognize them,
- 2:18:40we had to figure out who would do that.
- 2:18:42And we figured, "Okay, there must be
- 2:18:43something like cameras out there, and we
- 2:18:45must have an FOJ who understands how
- 2:18:46those work. There must be something some
- 2:18:50web or net or something we could use to
- 2:18:53connect our camera to their camera
- 2:18:55and and we must know somebody who knows
- 2:18:57something about that and then we're
- 2:18:59going to have to babysit those cameras
- 2:19:00and those tubes
- 2:19:03so that we can actually hold these
- 2:19:05rounds
- 2:19:06and the recipient of this year's Pamela
- 2:19:09M. Young Award
- 2:19:11was the man who made all of that happen.
- 2:19:14You saw him on the second floor all
- 2:19:15week.
- 2:19:16He
- 2:19:19his job didn't exist in this competition
- 2:19:21a month ago and
- 2:19:23all of a sudden I I want to do it again
- 2:19:24next year Jeff.
- 2:19:28Come on up here Jeff. Jeff Blackwell.
- 2:19:32>> [applause]
- 2:19:40[applause]
- 2:19:49[applause]
- 2:19:53>> The song goes
- 2:19:56you don't know what you've got till it's
- 2:19:57gone. This year
- 2:19:59we
- 2:20:02almost this almost got a lot harder.
- 2:20:06Our our
- 2:20:09judges room
- 2:20:10our our judge administrator suddenly had
- 2:20:14a big case come up and he said I'm not
- 2:20:15going to be able to do it this year.
- 2:20:17So we cast about who else can can handle
- 2:20:20these huge grids of names and and
- 2:20:22everything else.
- 2:20:23And and you know, we've got a great
- 2:20:25team. You know, you'll hear about them
- 2:20:27in a moment but uh
- 2:20:29but then about a week and a half before
- 2:20:31the international rounds he said, "Okay,
- 2:20:32well, the case is gone now. I can come."
- 2:20:35And I know all of us our hearts leaped.
- 2:20:38But he's not just the judge
- 2:20:39administrator.
- 2:20:41Anytime I need judges anywhere in the
- 2:20:42world he keeps in touch with every
- 2:20:44judge. And so if I say I need to I need
- 2:20:47some judges experienced judges to do
- 2:20:50practice moot team in Botswana or I need
- 2:20:53107 judges in Atlanta or
- 2:20:58you know, eight in in Vietnam.
- 2:21:02There's one person I call and he's
- 2:21:04usually the last call I have to make and
- 2:21:06that's why there's no question in my
- 2:21:07mind that this year's Pamela M. Young
- 2:21:10laureate
- 2:21:11is also Derek Moore.
- 2:21:14>> [cheering]
- 2:21:15[applause]
- 2:21:24[applause]
- 2:21:32[applause]
- 2:21:35>> I told Derek to make sure that Jeff
- 2:21:37came. So Derek thought that he was here
- 2:21:39because he had to make sure Jeff was
- 2:21:41here.
- 2:21:45And just before the judges I gather that
- 2:21:47they are almost ready to come in. So I
- 2:21:49would like to thank
- 2:21:52the amazing bailiff crew we have
- 2:21:56led by Thais Nevis and Amity Boy. Thank
- 2:22:00you very much.
- 2:22:01>> [applause]
- 2:22:06[applause]
- 2:22:13>> Larissa Rabello and our student
- 2:22:14directors Tarazi Fang and Daniella who
- 2:22:17ran the information desk and pretty much
- 2:22:19were the glue that held the entire
- 2:22:20operation together this week. Thank you
- 2:22:22all very much.
- 2:22:23>> [applause]
- 2:22:31>> In the judges room this year in addition
- 2:22:33to Derek we had Anaya Palmer and Jenny
- 2:22:36Anglender and virtually Jeffrey Brooks.
- 2:22:40And yeah.
- 2:22:42>> [applause]
- 2:22:47[applause]
- 2:22:47>> I'm sure you guys could have done it
- 2:22:49without him. You were doing great but I
- 2:22:50do know there was a great sigh of relief
- 2:22:52when he came back.
- 2:22:55I'd like to thank all of our judges. I
- 2:22:58mean come on. Just that's all. That's
- 2:22:59our amazing. [applause]
- 2:23:09>> [applause]
- 2:23:11>> When you when you graduate to being a
- 2:23:12judge we put you in a cage.
- 2:23:16That's
- 2:23:17that's not to keep you out.
- 2:23:21I'd like to thank our incredible
- 2:23:22partners at White & Case.
- 2:23:24The the competition has transformed in
- 2:23:26the 25 years that I've been
- 2:23:29associated with it.
- 2:23:31And so much of that can be attributed to
- 2:23:34the involvement of
- 2:23:37the world's greatest law firm. Right?
- 2:23:38Come on. In in our world that that is
- 2:23:40what you are.
- 2:23:42I'd like yeah. Yes.
- 2:23:44>> [applause]
- 2:23:51[applause]
- 2:23:55>> Here with us today we have Jack Pace,
- 2:23:56New York antitrust partner and head of
- 2:23:58the pro bono practice at White & Case.
- 2:24:00Thanks Jack.
- 2:24:03>> [applause]
- 2:24:07>> We have Aditya Singh who you just heard
- 2:24:09from and so many other lawyers here with
- 2:24:11White & Case who judged this week.
- 2:24:14>> [applause]
- 2:24:20>> We have Madeleine George, manager of
- 2:24:22responsible business and the
- 2:24:24incomparable Elizabeth Black, global
- 2:24:26head of pro bono and responsible
- 2:24:28business.
- 2:24:29>> [applause]
- 2:24:37>> And then running around all week
- 2:24:41social media and with the photographs
- 2:24:42and the tubes and the webs and and the
- 2:24:45the
- 2:24:46muckety mucks and the nickety nacks and
- 2:24:48the tickety tocks.
- 2:24:49Ania Rizzi, Everton McLean, Mimsi Mejia,
- 2:24:52Richard Hogue, Tony Natoli, Vince Oliver
- 2:24:55and Doris Eliezer. Thank you guys very
- 2:24:58much.
- 2:24:59>> [applause]
- 2:25:06>> And finally they do not get enough
- 2:25:08thanks. I am grateful every
- 2:25:11day that I'm involved with ILSA that I
- 2:25:13have the world's greatest team. I mean
- 2:25:18you guys are good.
- 2:25:20Mine's better.
- 2:25:23Christopher Bonay and Roxana Nazari.
- 2:25:27>> [applause]
- 2:25:36[applause]
- 2:25:41>> Hi Chris. I know you can see me on the
- 2:25:43camera.
- 2:25:44He's outside.
- 2:25:46With that
- 2:25:48I'm told that the judges are now ready.
- 2:25:50So in a moment the bailiff will say all
- 2:25:51rise and we'll find out what they
- 2:25:53thought of that amazing round.
- 2:25:55Thank you all very much.
- 2:25:57>> [applause]
- 2:27:57>> All rise.
- 2:28:35Maybe seated.
- 2:28:43Good afternoon again.
- 2:28:44Congratulations to both teams.
- 2:28:47We're going to announce the results of
- 2:28:50our deliberations and but first I want
- 2:28:52to give my co-judges a chance to
- 2:28:54say just a couple of words about this
- 2:28:56experience.
- 2:28:59Good afternoon. Buenas tardes.
- 2:29:03How are you? Como están?
- 2:29:06>> [laughter]
- 2:29:06[gasps]
- 2:29:06>> It has been a real
- 2:29:08privilege to be here and of course
- 2:29:11firstly I want to congratulate [snorts]
- 2:29:13both teams
- 2:29:14for the extraordinary participation,
- 2:29:17performance and rigorousity. I don't
- 2:29:20have enough words to recognize your
- 2:29:23hard work and and your capacity not only
- 2:29:26to prepare the
- 2:29:27the the
- 2:29:30the speeches but also to
- 2:29:33to admit and to respond
- 2:29:36flexibly with flexibility to our
- 2:29:38interruptions, continuous interruption
- 2:29:41and and questions. So
- 2:29:44I really admire you both
- 2:29:46teams and I want to express not only my
- 2:29:50congratulations to the both teams but to
- 2:29:53all of us who are in this room at this
- 2:29:56moment because
- 2:29:58from my
- 2:30:01my very first moment coming to to to
- 2:30:04this hotel and feeling the energy
- 2:30:07around international law
- 2:30:10thanks to Jessup and the amazing people
- 2:30:13that organize the Jessup competition
- 2:30:17I felt hope, hope in the times
- 2:30:21where is not always the the feeling that
- 2:30:25that we have daily. So thank you, thank
- 2:30:30you so much. I hope this
- 2:30:33experience at
- 2:30:35it is in my case will enhance our love,
- 2:30:39our passion for international law
- 2:30:42because I think in these times of crisis
- 2:30:47of international law
- 2:30:49of crisis for human dignity, of crisis
- 2:30:53for
- 2:30:54nature rights. I also like to to talk
- 2:30:58about nature rights as the
- 2:31:00Inter-American Court has recently stated
- 2:31:03in the marvelous
- 2:31:05advisory opinion
- 2:31:09and the right to environment as jus
- 2:31:11cogens international. So we're
- 2:31:16times of crisis but we are also in times
- 2:31:19of moving forward for international law,
- 2:31:21moving forward for protection of human
- 2:31:24dignity and nature. So I really hope
- 2:31:29that all of us when we are back in our
- 2:31:32homes will be with this the same energy
- 2:31:36fighting if you allows me this
- 2:31:39>> [laughter]
- 2:31:39>> this war for
- 2:31:42be good lawyers
- 2:31:44taking into account and applying
- 2:31:47international law not because we like
- 2:31:50international law because it's our
- 2:31:52responsibility to know, to teach, to
- 2:31:56learn, to study and I think this has
- 2:31:59been an amazing opportunity to learn.
- 2:32:02Thanks to this to this
- 2:32:04problem but it was not a little problem
- 2:32:09but a huge, amazing, sophisticated
- 2:32:13and real really
- 2:32:17good problem to to to to learn and to
- 2:32:20think all together. Thank you, thank you
- 2:32:22so much. Muchísimas gracias.
- 2:32:26>> [applause]
- 2:32:34>> I also wanted to say congratulations to
- 2:32:37all of you who have been participating
- 2:32:40in in the Jessup. I was going to say
- 2:32:43participating for the last week but it's
- 2:32:45not been the last week, has it? It's
- 2:32:46been the last several months writing the
- 2:32:50memorials, taking part in the national
- 2:32:53rounds, probably hundreds of practice
- 2:32:56sessions and then coming here to DC for
- 2:32:59the international rounds. I'm sure it's
- 2:33:01an experience that will stay with all of
- 2:33:03you and one of the great things about
- 2:33:05the international rounds in in addition
- 2:33:06to everything that
- 2:33:08Judge said which I totally agree with
- 2:33:12but one of the things that I think is
- 2:33:13actually also really significant is
- 2:33:15coming in and seeing people from all
- 2:33:17across the world um discussing and
- 2:33:21debating these questions of
- 2:33:22international law. So that's fantastic
- 2:33:24and congratulations to all of you for
- 2:33:27getting here, for all the hard work um
- 2:33:30and I want to say a particular
- 2:33:31congratulations to the two teams that
- 2:33:34made it through to the to the
- 2:33:36championship round. Really impressive um
- 2:33:39advocacy from from everyone. What I can
- 2:33:42say is that what you have done is much
- 2:33:46more difficult than actually appearing
- 2:33:49before the International Court of
- 2:33:50Justice.
- 2:33:52It can only get easier.
- 2:33:55>> [laughter]
- 2:33:57>> You will not do this in front of as many
- 2:34:01people as you have done it. You will not
- 2:34:04have judges peppering you with
- 2:34:05questions. So this is as difficult as it
- 2:34:09gets and you all did a a fantastic job.
- 2:34:12So congratulations to all of you. Just
- 2:34:14to pick out a couple of things.
- 2:34:16>> [applause]
- 2:34:24>> Just to pick out a couple of things that
- 2:34:26I thought you all did really well and
- 2:34:28I'm sure that others in the competition
- 2:34:30would have done this well too but which
- 2:34:32I thought you did particularly well.
- 2:34:35It's always a real challenge
- 2:34:37navigating between answering the
- 2:34:39questions of the judges
- 2:34:42and then sticking to your structure and
- 2:34:44coming back to the points that you want
- 2:34:46to to make and I thought that you all
- 2:34:48did that really well. So you responded
- 2:34:51to questions, you actually took time to
- 2:34:53try and answer those questions but then
- 2:34:55moved as quickly as you could back to
- 2:34:57the arguments that you wanted to to make
- 2:35:00and I thought that that was was really
- 2:35:01good. And then secondly actually the
- 2:35:03responses to to the questions. Of course
- 2:35:05we've come in right at the very end.
- 2:35:08Maybe some of these questions you got
- 2:35:09before, maybe others you haven't got
- 2:35:11before but you know it's a real
- 2:35:14compliment to all of you to be able to
- 2:35:17take the various questions, use the
- 2:35:19knowledge that you have to be able to
- 2:35:21answer those questions. So
- 2:35:22congratulations to to all of you.
- 2:35:26>> [applause]
- 2:35:33>> So I'm going to announce the
- 2:35:35the results but before I do I want to
- 2:35:37talk for about 45 minutes. That's it.
- 2:35:39>> [laughter]
- 2:35:42>> No, I I just want to echo Mike and my
- 2:35:45colleagues gratitude for the opportunity
- 2:35:48to be here and and judge this
- 2:35:51championship round. It really genuinely
- 2:35:53is
- 2:35:54a privilege for me. I want to thank the
- 2:35:57organizer Michael, all the others, all
- 2:35:59everybody who's worked on the
- 2:36:00competition, those who
- 2:36:02the authors of the of the of the problem
- 2:36:05for the work in making Jessup happen. I
- 2:36:09was a when I was a law student I
- 2:36:11participated in Jessup I'm very proud to
- 2:36:13say but I did not make it to Washington.
- 2:36:15So
- 2:36:16>> [laughter]
- 2:36:17>> So I admire all of you who participated
- 2:36:19in these final international rounds of
- 2:36:23the
- 2:36:23of the competition and to the finalists,
- 2:36:27wonderful, wonderful job.
- 2:36:29I echo everything that's already already
- 2:36:31been said. What you have done,
- 2:36:35the way you performed and I mean this
- 2:36:36sincerely today
- 2:36:38is at all at a level that superior than
- 2:36:4195% of the lawyers in this world and I
- 2:36:43mean that sincerely
- 2:36:46in terms of oral advocacy
- 2:36:48and so you're well on your way to being
- 2:36:52outstanding lawyers. And to everybody
- 2:36:55else who participated in this
- 2:36:56conference, in this sorry, this
- 2:36:58competition,
- 2:36:59I'm sure you benefited enormously
- 2:37:02as have I and my colleagues I'm sure as
- 2:37:05well
- 2:37:06from the experience and so I want to
- 2:37:09congratulate
- 2:37:10all of you as well.
- 2:37:12Um
- 2:37:14just a
- 2:37:15just a little bit of reflection along
- 2:37:17the lines of what Soledad says, you
- 2:37:19know, these are really really trying
- 2:37:20times including for international law
- 2:37:23and I hear almost every day from many of
- 2:37:25my colleagues, law professors and
- 2:37:27certainly from a number of students that
- 2:37:29I interact with, is there still
- 2:37:31international law?
- 2:37:33Does it really matter? And I think what
- 2:37:37you all have shown is that yes, one,
- 2:37:40there is still international law and
- 2:37:41two, it yes, it does really matter and
- 2:37:44not just in a hypothetical sense, in the
- 2:37:46sense of a hypothetical problem
- 2:37:48but the kind of problems that really
- 2:37:50exist in the world that can be addressed
- 2:37:52by international law. And the problems
- 2:37:54that you were addressing in this in in
- 2:37:55this hypothetical reflect a lot of the
- 2:37:58problems and issues in the real world
- 2:38:00and so the kind of answers and
- 2:38:02approaches that you brought to these
- 2:38:04issues can contribute in a in a concrete
- 2:38:08way if not today
- 2:38:10down the road.
- 2:38:12So thanks for the optimism that you
- 2:38:14brought to this event for the hope that
- 2:38:19you displayed and that really emboldens
- 2:38:22all of us and I'm going to take that
- 2:38:24with me back to Boulder, Colorado. So
- 2:38:27thank you very much.
- 2:38:29And
- 2:38:30>> [applause]
- 2:38:37>> So with that it's my pleasure to first
- 2:38:40announce the best oralist in today's
- 2:38:44championship round.
- 2:38:46But before I do again, let me just
- 2:38:48emphasize how each one of you
- 2:38:50were outstanding and we had quite a
- 2:38:52debate in trying to
- 2:38:53uh decide which one was the best among
- 2:38:56such uh stellar oralists each of you.
- 2:39:00But we had to choose one and the one we
- 2:39:02did choose
- 2:39:03choose was uh Tonkai Han.
- 2:39:06>> [applause]
- 2:39:15[applause]
- 2:39:25>> And uh
- 2:39:27it's my pleasure now to announce the
- 2:39:29winners of the 2026
- 2:39:33uh Jessup competition.
- 2:39:36And the winners are the team
- 2:39:40uh for the applicants.
- 2:39:46>> [cheering]
- 2:39:48[screaming]
- 2:39:51[applause]
- 2:39:57[screaming]
- 2:39:59[cheering]
- 2:40:03[applause]
- 2:40:43>> Okay.
- 2:41:03>> [applause]
- 2:41:12[applause]
- 2:41:22[applause]
- 2:41:28[applause]
- 2:41:32>> I I declare the championship round
- 2:41:35closed. I will see you all this evening
- 2:41:37at the closing gala.
- 2:41:39Thank you all very much.
- 2:41:41>> [applause]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Jessup 2026 World Championship Round by Jessup Competition, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 21,337 words across 3,807 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.