YouTube2Text

Jeff Bezos: Amazon and Blue Origin | Lex Fridman Podcast #405 — Transcript

by Lex Fridman · 21,560 words · 3,027 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00- The following is a conversation with Jeff Bezos,
  2. 0:03founder of Amazon and Blue Origin.
  3. 0:06This is his first time doing a conversation
  4. 0:09of this kind and of this length.
  5. 0:11And as he told me, it felt like we could have easily talked
  6. 0:14for many more hours, and I'm sure we will.
  7. 0:17This is the Lex Fridman podcast.
  8. 0:19And now, dear friends, here's Jeff Bezos.
  9. 0:24You spent a lot of your childhood with your grandfather
  10. 0:27on a ranch here in Texas,
  11. 0:30and I heard you had a lot of work to do around the ranch.
  12. 0:33So what's the coolest job you remember doing there?
  13. 0:35- Wow, coolest.
  14. 0:36- Most interesting.
  15. 0:38Most memorable.
  16. 0:39- Most memorable.
  17. 0:40Most impactful.
  18. 0:41- And it was a real working ranch.
  19. 0:43My grand, I spent all my summers on that ranch
  20. 0:46from age four to 16.
  21. 0:49And my grandfather was really taking me to those
  22. 0:52in the summers, in the early summers,
  23. 0:54he was letting me pretend to help on the ranch.
  24. 0:57'Cause of course, a 4-year-old is a burden,
  25. 0:59not a help in real life.
  26. 1:01He was really just watching me and taking care of me
  27. 1:04and be was doing that because my mom was so young.
  28. 1:08She had me when she was 17,
  29. 1:09and so he was sort of giving her a break.
  30. 1:12And my grandmother and my grandfather
  31. 1:13would take me for these summers.
  32. 1:15But as I got a little older,
  33. 1:16I actually was helpful on the ranch and I loved it.
  34. 1:18I was out there,
  35. 1:20like my grandfather had a huge influence on me,
  36. 1:23huge factor in my life.
  37. 1:25I did all the jobs you would do on a ranch.
  38. 1:28I've fixed windmills and laid fences
  39. 1:33and pipelines and you know, done all the things
  40. 1:36that any rancher would do,
  41. 1:38vaccinated, the animals, everything.
  42. 1:41But we had a you know, my grandfather,
  43. 1:44after my grandmother died, I was about 12
  44. 1:47and I kept coming to the ranch.
  45. 1:48So it was then, it was just him and me, just the two of us.
  46. 1:51And he was completely addicted to the soap opera,
  47. 1:55the Days of Our Lives.
  48. 1:57And we would go back to the ranch house every day
  49. 2:00around 1:00 PM or so to watch days of our lives
  50. 2:03like sands through an hourglass.
  51. 2:06So are the days of our lives.
  52. 2:07- Just the image of the two sitting there
  53. 2:11watching a soap opera as ranchers.
  54. 2:12- He had these big, crazy dogs.
  55. 2:14It was really a very formative experience for me.
  56. 2:16But the key thing about it for me,
  57. 2:18the great gift I got from it
  58. 2:21was that my grandfather was so resourceful, you know,
  59. 2:25he did everything himself.
  60. 2:26He made his own veterinary tools.
  61. 2:28He would make needles to suture the cattle up with,
  62. 2:32like he would find a little piece of wire and heat it up
  63. 2:34and pound it thin and drill a hole in it and sharpen it.
  64. 2:37So, you know, you learn different things
  65. 2:40on a ranch than you would learn
  66. 2:41you know, growing up in a city.
  67. 2:43- So self-reliance.
  68. 2:44- Yeah, like figuring out that you can solve problems
  69. 2:48with enough persistence and ingenuity.
  70. 2:52And my grandfather bought a D6 bulldozer,
  71. 2:55which is a big bulldozer, and he got it for like $5,000.
  72. 2:58'cause it was completely broken down.
  73. 3:00It was like a 1955 Caterpillar, D6 bulldozer
  74. 3:04knew it would've cost, I don't know,
  75. 3:06more than a $100,000.
  76. 3:08And we spent an entire summer fixing,
  77. 3:10like repairing that bulldozer.
  78. 3:13And we'd, you know, use mail order
  79. 3:15to buy big gears for the transmission.
  80. 3:17And they'd show up.
  81. 3:18They'd be too heavy to move,
  82. 3:19so we'd have to build a crane, you know,
  83. 3:21just that kind of, kinda that problem solving mentality.
  84. 3:26He had it so powerfully, you know,
  85. 3:30he did all of his own.
  86. 3:31He'd just, he didn't pick up the phone and call somebody.
  87. 3:35He would figure it out on his own.
  88. 3:37Doing his own veterinary work, you know.
  89. 3:39- But just the image of the two of you
  90. 3:41fixing a D6 bulldozer and then going in
  91. 3:43for a little break at 1:00 PM to watch a soap opera.
  92. 3:46- Laying on the floor.
  93. 3:48That's how he watched TV.
  94. 3:50- Yeah.
  95. 3:50- He was a really, really remarkable guy.
  96. 3:52- That's how I imagine Clint Eastwood also
  97. 3:55in all those westerns.
  98. 3:57When he's not doing what he is doing,
  99. 3:59he's just watching soap operas.
  100. 4:01All right, I read that you fell in love
  101. 4:04with the idea of space and space exploration
  102. 4:05when you were five watching Neil Armstrong
  103. 4:07walking on the moon.
  104. 4:10So let me ask you to look back at the historical context
  105. 4:14and impact of that.
  106. 4:16So the space race from 1957 to 1969
  107. 4:21between the Soviet Union and the US was in many ways epic.
  108. 4:25It was a rapid sequence of dramatic events
  109. 4:29for satellite to space, for a human to space,
  110. 4:32for a spacewalk, first uncrewed landing on the moon,
  111. 4:35then some failures, explosions,
  112. 4:38deaths on both sides actually,
  113. 4:40and then the first human walking on the moon.
  114. 4:43What are some of the more inspiring moments
  115. 4:46or insights you take away from that time,
  116. 4:47those few years, that just 12 years?
  117. 4:51- Well, I mean, there's so much inspiring there.
  118. 4:55You know, one of the great things to take away from that,
  119. 4:57one of the great von Braun quotes is
  120. 4:59"I have come to use the word impossible with great caution."
  121. 5:04- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
  122. 5:07- And so that's kind of the big story of Apollo
  123. 5:10is that things, you know, going to the moon
  124. 5:13was literally an analogy that people used
  125. 5:17for something that's impossible.
  126. 5:19You know, oh yeah, you'll do that when you know,
  127. 5:21men walk on the moon.
  128. 5:22- Yeah.
  129. 5:23- And of course it finally happened.
  130. 5:26So, you know, I think it was pulled forward in time
  131. 5:29because of the space race,
  132. 5:31I think you know, with the geopolitical implications
  133. 5:34and you know, how much resource was put into it,
  134. 5:37you know, at the peak, that program was spending,
  135. 5:39you know, two or 3% of GDP on the Apollo program.
  136. 5:43So much resource.
  137. 5:45I think it was pulled forward in time.
  138. 5:47You know, we kind of did it ahead
  139. 5:50of when we quote unquote should have done it.
  140. 5:52- Yeah.
  141. 5:53- And so in that way, it's also a technical marvel.
  142. 5:57I mean, it's truly incredible.
  143. 5:58It's, you know, it's the 20th century version
  144. 6:03of building the pyramids or something.
  145. 6:04It's you know, it's an achievement
  146. 6:07that because it was pulled forward in time
  147. 6:09and because it did something
  148. 6:10that had previously thought impossible,
  149. 6:12it rightly deserves its place, as you know,
  150. 6:14in the pantheon of great human achievements.
  151. 6:17- And of course, you named the projects The Rockets
  152. 6:21that Blue Origin is working on
  153. 6:22after some of the folks involved.
  154. 6:24- Yeah.
  155. 6:24- I don't understand why I didn't say New Gagarin.
  156. 6:26is that-
  157. 6:27- There's an American bias in the naming.
  158. 6:28I apologize.
  159. 6:29- It's very strange.
  160. 6:30- Lex.
  161. 6:31- Just asking for a friend.
  162. 6:33Clarify.
  163. 6:34- I'm a big fan of Gagarin though.
  164. 6:36And in fact, I think his first words in space,
  165. 6:41I think are incredible.
  166. 6:43He, you know, he purportedly said "my God, it's blue."
  167. 6:47And that really drives home.
  168. 6:49No one had seen the earth from space.
  169. 6:52No one knew that we were on this blue planet.
  170. 6:55- Yeah.
  171. 6:56- No one knew what it looked like from out there.
  172. 6:58And Gagarin was the first person to see it.
  173. 7:01- One of the things I think about is how dangerous
  174. 7:04those early days were for Gagarin,
  175. 7:06for Glen, for everybody involved.
  176. 7:08Like how big of a risk they were all taking.
  177. 7:11- They were taking huge risks.
  178. 7:12I'm not sure what the Soviets thought
  179. 7:14about Gagarin's flight,
  180. 7:16but I think that the Americans thought
  181. 7:19that the Alan Shephard flight,
  182. 7:20the flight that you know, New Shephard is named after,
  183. 7:22the first American in space.
  184. 7:24He went on his suborbital flight.
  185. 7:26They thought he had about a 75% chance of success.
  186. 7:31So, you know, that's a pretty big risk, a 25% risk.
  187. 7:36- It's kind of interesting that Alan Shephard
  188. 7:38is not quite as famous as John Glenn.
  189. 7:40So for people who don't know, Alan Shephard
  190. 7:42is the first astronaut-
  191. 7:44- The first American in space.
  192. 7:46- American in suborbital flight.
  193. 7:48- Correct.
  194. 7:49- And then the first orbital flight is-
  195. 7:51- John Glenn is the first American to orbit the earth.
  196. 7:54By the way, I have the most charming, sweet,
  197. 7:58incredible letter from John Glenn,
  198. 8:00which I have framed and hang on my office wall.
  199. 8:03- What did he say?
  200. 8:04- Where he tells me how grateful he is
  201. 8:07that we have named New Glenn after him.
  202. 8:10And he sent me that letter about a week before he died.
  203. 8:13And it's really an incredible,
  204. 8:15it's also a very funny letter.
  205. 8:17He's writing and he says you know,
  206. 8:20this is a letter about New Glenn from the original Glenn.
  207. 8:24And he's just, he's got a great sense of humor,
  208. 8:26and he's very happy about it and grateful.
  209. 8:29It's very sweet.
  210. 8:30- Does he say ps don't mess this up?
  211. 8:31Or is that-
  212. 8:34- No, he doesn't.
  213. 8:35- Make me look good.
  214. 8:36- He doesn't do that.
  215. 8:37- Okay.
  216. 8:37- But wait, but John, wherever you are,
  217. 8:38we got you covered.
  218. 8:39- All right, good.
  219. 8:41So back to maybe the big picture of space.
  220. 8:44When you look up at the stars and think big,
  221. 8:47what do you hope is the future of humanity?
  222. 8:49Hundreds, thousands of years from now out in space?
  223. 8:54- I would love to see, you know,
  224. 8:56a trillion humans living in the solar system.
  225. 9:01If we had a trillion humans,
  226. 9:03we would have at any given time a thousand Mozarts
  227. 9:06and a thousand Einsteins.
  228. 9:08That would, you know, our solar system would be full of life
  229. 9:11and intelligence and energy.
  230. 9:14And we can easily support a civilization that large
  231. 9:17with all of the resources in the solar system.
  232. 9:21- So what do you think that looks like?
  233. 9:23Giant space stations?
  234. 9:24- Yeah, the only way to get to that vision
  235. 9:26is with giant space stations.
  236. 9:28You know, the planetary surfaces are just way too small.
  237. 9:31So you can, I mean, unless you turn them
  238. 9:34into giant space stations or something.
  239. 9:36But, but yeah, we will take materials from the moon
  240. 9:40and from near earth objects and from the asteroid belt
  241. 9:44and so on, and we'll build giant O'Neill style colonies
  242. 9:49and people will live in those.
  243. 9:50And they have a lot of advantages over planetary surfaces.
  244. 9:54You can spin them to get normal earth gravity.
  245. 9:57You can put them where you want them.
  246. 9:59I think most people are gonna wanna live near Earth,
  247. 10:03not necessarily in earth orbit, but in you know, earth,
  248. 10:07but near earth vicinity orbits.
  249. 10:10And so they can move you know, relatively quickly
  250. 10:15back and forth between their station and Earth.
  251. 10:19So I think a lot of people,
  252. 10:20especially in the early stages,
  253. 10:21are not gonna want to give up Earth altogether.
  254. 10:24- They go to earth for vacation.
  255. 10:26- Yeah.
  256. 10:27Same way that you know, you might go
  257. 10:29to Yellowstone National Park for vacation.
  258. 10:31People will, and no one,
  259. 10:33and people will get to choose where they live on earth
  260. 10:35or whether they live in space,
  261. 10:37but they'll be able to use much more energy
  262. 10:40and much more material resource in space
  263. 10:42than they would be able to use on earth.
  264. 10:45- One of the interesting ideas you had
  265. 10:47is to move the heavy industry away from Earth.
  266. 10:49So people sometimes have this idea
  267. 10:52that somehow space exploration is in conflict
  268. 10:55with the celebration of the planet earth,
  269. 10:58that we should focus on preserving earth.
  270. 11:00And basically your ideas that space travel
  271. 11:04and space exploration is a way to preserve earth.
  272. 11:06- Exactly.
  273. 11:07This planet, we've sent robotic probes to all the planets.
  274. 11:13We know that this is the good one.
  275. 11:16- Yeah.
  276. 11:17Not to play favorites or anything.
  277. 11:19- But earth really is the good planet.
  278. 11:20It's amazing, the ecosystem we have here,
  279. 11:24all of the life and the lush, the plant life
  280. 11:28and you know, the water resources, everything.
  281. 11:30This planet is really extraordinary.
  282. 11:33And of course, we evolved on this planet,
  283. 11:35so of course it's perfect for us,
  284. 11:37but it's also perfect for all the advanced life forms
  285. 11:39on this planet, all the animals and so on.
  286. 11:42And so this is a gem.
  287. 11:43We do need to take care of it.
  288. 11:46And as we enter the Anthropocene,
  289. 11:48as we get, as we humans have gotten
  290. 11:51so sophisticated and large and impactful,
  291. 11:55as we stride across this planet, you know,
  292. 11:58that is going to, as we continue,
  293. 12:01we want to use a lot of energy.
  294. 12:03We want to use a lot of energy per capita.
  295. 12:04We've gotten amazing things.
  296. 12:07We don't want to go backwards.
  297. 12:09You know, if you think about the good old days,
  298. 12:15they're mostly an illusion.
  299. 12:17Like in almost every way,
  300. 12:19life is better for almost everyone today
  301. 12:21than it was say, 50 years ago or a hundred years.
  302. 12:25We live better lives by and large than our grandparents did,
  303. 12:29and their grandparents did, and so on.
  304. 12:31And you can see that in global illiteracy rates,
  305. 12:34global poverty rates, global infant mortality rates,
  306. 12:39like almost any metric you choose,
  307. 12:41we're better off than we used to be.
  308. 12:43And we get, you know, antibiotics
  309. 12:45and all kinds of lifesaving medical care
  310. 12:46and so on and so on.
  311. 12:49And there's one thing that is moving backwards,
  312. 12:52and it's the natural world.
  313. 12:54So it is a fact that 500 years ago, pre-industrial age,
  314. 12:59the natural world was pristine.
  315. 13:02It was incredible.
  316. 13:03And we have traded some of that pristine beauty
  317. 13:09for all of these other gifts that we have
  318. 13:11as an advanced society.
  319. 13:13And we can have both.
  320. 13:16But to do that, we have to go to space.
  321. 13:18And all of this, really,
  322. 13:20the most fundamental measure is energy usage per capita.
  323. 13:25And when you look at, you know,
  324. 13:27you do want to continue to use more and more energy,
  325. 13:30it is going to make your life better in so many ways.
  326. 13:33But that's not compatible ultimately
  327. 13:36with living on a finite planet.
  328. 13:38And so we have to go out into the solar system
  329. 13:40and really you could argue about when you have to do that,
  330. 13:44but you can't credibly argue
  331. 13:47about whether you have to do that.
  332. 13:49- Eventually, we have to do that.
  333. 13:51- Exactly.
  334. 13:52- Well, you don't often talk about it,
  335. 13:54but let me ask you on that topic about the Blue Ring
  336. 13:56and the orbital reef space infrastructure projects.
  337. 14:01What's your vision for these?
  338. 14:03- So Blue Ring is a very interesting spacecraft
  339. 14:07that is designed to take up to 3000 kilograms of payload
  340. 14:12up to geosynchronous orbit or in lunar vicinity.
  341. 14:17It has two different kinds of propulsion.
  342. 14:20It has chemical propulsion, and it has electric propulsion.
  343. 14:24And so it can,
  344. 14:25you can use blue ring in a couple different ways.
  345. 14:29You can slowly move, let's say up to geosynchronous orbit
  346. 14:32using electric propulsion
  347. 14:34that might take you know, a hundred days
  348. 14:36or 150 days depending on how much mass you're carrying.
  349. 14:40And then, and reserve your chemical propulsion
  350. 14:43so that you can change orbits quickly
  351. 14:44in geosynchronous orbit.
  352. 14:46Or you can use the chemical propulsion first
  353. 14:49to quickly get up to geosynchronous
  354. 14:51and then use your electrical propulsion
  355. 14:53to slowly change your geosynchronous orbit.
  356. 14:55Blue Ring has a couple of interesting features.
  357. 14:59It provides a lot of services
  358. 15:04to these payloads.
  359. 15:05So the payload, it could be one large payload,
  360. 15:07or it can be a number of small payloads,
  361. 15:10and it provides thermal management,
  362. 15:12it provides electric power, it provides compute,
  363. 15:16provides communications.
  364. 15:19And so when you design a payload for Blue Ring,
  365. 15:23you don't have,
  366. 15:24you don't have to figure out all of those things
  367. 15:27on your own.
  368. 15:28So kind of radiation tolerant compute
  369. 15:30is a complicated thing to do.
  370. 15:32And so we have an unusually large amount
  371. 15:36of radiation tolerant compute on board Blue Ring,
  372. 15:39and you can, your payload can just use that
  373. 15:41when it needs to.
  374. 15:42So it's sort of all these services,
  375. 15:46it's you know, it's like a set of APIs.
  376. 15:49It's a little bit like Amazon web services,
  377. 15:51but for space payloads that need to move about
  378. 15:55an earth vicinity or lunar vicinity.
  379. 15:57- AWSS space.
  380. 15:59Okay, so computing space.
  381. 16:02So you get a giant chemical rocket
  382. 16:04to get a payload out to orbit,
  383. 16:08and then you have these admins that show up,
  384. 16:11this Blue Ring thing that manages various things
  385. 16:13like compute.
  386. 16:14- Exactly.
  387. 16:15And it can also provide transportation
  388. 16:16and move you around to different orbits.
  389. 16:19- Including humans, you think?
  390. 16:20- No, but Blue Ring is not designed to move humans around.
  391. 16:23It's designed to move payloads around.
  392. 16:26- Okay.
  393. 16:27- So we're also building a lunar lander,
  394. 16:29which is of course designed to land humans
  395. 16:33on the surface of the moon.
  396. 16:34- I'm gonna ask you about that,
  397. 16:36but let me ask you to just step back to the old days.
  398. 16:40You were at Princeton
  399. 16:42with aspirations to be a theoretical physicist.
  400. 16:45- Yeah.
  401. 16:47- What attracted you to physics
  402. 16:49and why did you change your mind
  403. 16:51and not become, why you're not Jeff Bezos,
  404. 16:54the famous theoretical physicist?
  405. 16:57- So I loved physics and I studied physics
  406. 16:59and computer science,
  407. 17:01and I was proceeding along the physics path.
  408. 17:05I was planning to major in physics
  409. 17:06and I wanted to be a theoretical physicist.
  410. 17:08And the computer science
  411. 17:10was sort of something I was doing for fun.
  412. 17:12I really loved it.
  413. 17:14And I was very good at the programming
  414. 17:17and doing those things.
  415. 17:19And I enjoyed all my computer science classes immensely,
  416. 17:23but I really was determined to be a theoretical physicist.
  417. 17:26It's why I went to Princeton in the first place.
  418. 17:29It was definitely, and then I realized
  419. 17:32I was gonna be a mediocre theoretical physicist.
  420. 17:35And there were a few people in my classes,
  421. 17:39like in quantum mechanics and so on,
  422. 17:42who they could effortlessly do things
  423. 17:44that were so difficult for me.
  424. 17:46And I realized like you know, there are a thousand ways
  425. 17:49to be smart and to be a really, you know,
  426. 17:52theoretical physics is not one of those fields
  427. 17:56where only the top few percent
  428. 17:59actually move the state of the art forward.
  429. 18:02It's one of those things where you have to be
  430. 18:05really just, your brain has to be wired in a certain way.
  431. 18:09And there was a guy named,
  432. 18:10one of these people who convinced me.
  433. 18:14He didn't mean to convince me,
  434. 18:16but just by observing him, he convinced me
  435. 18:17that I should not try to be a theoretical physicist.
  436. 18:20His name was Yosanta.
  437. 18:22And Yosanta was from Sri Lanka.
  438. 18:26And he was one of the most brilliant people I'd ever met.
  439. 18:30My friend Joe and I were working on a very difficult
  440. 18:34partial differential equations problem set one night.
  441. 18:37And there was one problem that we worked on for three hours,
  442. 18:41and we made no headway whatsoever.
  443. 18:45And we looked up at each other at the same time
  444. 18:48and we said, Yosanta.
  445. 18:49So we went to Yosanta's dorm room.
  446. 18:51And he was there, he was almost always there.
  447. 18:54And we said Yosanta, we're having trouble solving
  448. 18:57this partial differential equation,
  449. 19:00would you mind taking a look?
  450. 19:02And he said of course.
  451. 19:03By the way, he was the most humble, most kind person.
  452. 19:07And so he took our,
  453. 19:08he looked at our problem and he stared at it
  454. 19:11for just a few seconds, maybe 10 seconds.
  455. 19:13And he said cosine.
  456. 19:15And I said, what do you mean Yosanta?
  457. 19:17What do you mean cosine?
  458. 19:18He said that's the answer.
  459. 19:19And I said no, no, no, come on.
  460. 19:21And he said let me show you.
  461. 19:22And he took out some paper
  462. 19:24and he wrote down three pages of equations,
  463. 19:27everything canceled out.
  464. 19:29And the answer was cosine.
  465. 19:30And I said Yosanta, did you do that in your head?
  466. 19:35And he said oh no, that would be impossible.
  467. 19:38A few years ago I solved a similar problem
  468. 19:40and I could map this problem onto that problem.
  469. 19:43And then it was immediately obvious
  470. 19:45that the answer was cosine.
  471. 19:47I had a few, you know, you have an experience like that,
  472. 19:50you realize maybe being a theoretical physicist
  473. 19:54isn't what your,
  474. 19:55isn't what the universe wants you to be.
  475. 19:59And so I switched to computer science and you know,
  476. 20:04that worked out really well for me.
  477. 20:05I enjoy it.
  478. 20:06I still enjoy it today.
  479. 20:07- Yeah, there's a particular kind of intuition you need
  480. 20:09to be a great physicist, applied to physics.
  481. 20:12- I think the mathematical skill required today is so high.
  482. 20:17You have to be a world-class mathematician
  483. 20:20to be a successful theoretical physicist today.
  484. 20:24And it's not you know,
  485. 20:26you probably need other skills too,
  486. 20:29intuition, lateral thinking, and so on.
  487. 20:32But without just top-notch math skills,
  488. 20:37you're unlikely to be successful.
  489. 20:39- And visualization skill,
  490. 20:40you have to be able to really kind of do
  491. 20:43these kinds of thought experiments.
  492. 20:45And if you want truly great creativity,
  493. 20:46actually Walter Isaacson writes about you.
  494. 20:49It puts you on the same level as Einstein.
  495. 20:52- Well, that's very kind.
  496. 20:56I'm an inventor.
  497. 20:57If you wanna boil down what I am,
  498. 21:00I'm really an inventor.
  499. 21:02And I look at things
  500. 21:03and I can come up with atypical solutions and you know,
  501. 21:08and then I can create a hundred such atypical solutions
  502. 21:11for something.
  503. 21:1399 of them may not survive, you know, scrutiny.
  504. 21:18But one of those 100 is like hmm, maybe there is,
  505. 21:21maybe that might work.
  506. 21:23And then you can keep going from there.
  507. 21:25So that kind of lateral thinking,
  508. 21:27that kind of inventiveness
  509. 21:29in a high dimensionality space where the search space
  510. 21:33is very large, that's where my inventive skills come.
  511. 21:37That's the thing is I self-identify
  512. 21:40as an inventor more than anything else.
  513. 21:43- Yeah, and he describes in all kinds of different ways,
  514. 21:45Walter Isaacson does that creativity
  515. 21:50combined with childlike wander that you've maintained
  516. 21:54still to this day, all of that combined together.
  517. 21:57Is there, like if you were to study
  518. 21:59your own brain introspect, how do you think,
  519. 22:02what's your thinking process like?
  520. 22:03We'll talk about the writing process
  521. 22:05of putting it down on paper,
  522. 22:07which is quite rigorous and famous at Amazon.
  523. 22:12But how do you, when you sit down, maybe alone,
  524. 22:15maybe with others,
  525. 22:17and thinking through this high dimensional space
  526. 22:19and looking for creative solutions, creative paths forward,
  527. 22:24is there something you could say about that process?
  528. 22:26- It's such a good question,
  529. 22:27and I honestly don't know how it works.
  530. 22:31If I did, I would try to explain it.
  531. 22:32I know it involves lots of wandering.
  532. 22:35- Yeah.
  533. 22:37- So I, you know, when I sit down to work on a problem,
  534. 22:40I know I don't know where I'm going.
  535. 22:43So to go in a straight line, to be efficient,
  536. 22:47efficiency and invention are sort of at odds
  537. 22:50because invention, real invention,
  538. 22:53not incremental improvement.
  539. 22:54Incremental improvement is so important
  540. 22:56in every endeavor, in everything you do.
  541. 22:58You have to work hard on also just making things
  542. 23:00a little bit better.
  543. 23:02But I'm talking about real invention,
  544. 23:04real lateral thinking, that requires wandering.
  545. 23:08And you have to give yourself permission to wander.
  546. 23:11I think a lot of people,
  547. 23:15they feel like wandering is inefficient.
  548. 23:20And you know, like when I sit down at a meeting,
  549. 23:26I don't know how long the meeting is gonna take
  550. 23:28if we're trying to solve a problem.
  551. 23:30Because if I did, then I'd already,
  552. 23:33I'd know there's some kind of straight line
  553. 23:35that we're drawing to the solution.
  554. 23:38The reality is we may have to wander for a long time.
  555. 23:42And I do like group invention.
  556. 23:43I think there's certainly nothing more fun
  557. 23:46than sitting at a whiteboard with you know,
  558. 23:49a group of smart people and spit balling
  559. 23:53and coming up with new ideas and objections to those ideas,
  560. 23:57and then solutions to the objections
  561. 24:00and going back and forth.
  562. 24:02So like you know, sometimes you wake up with an idea
  563. 24:06in the middle of the night
  564. 24:08and sometimes you sit down with a group of people
  565. 24:10and go back and forth
  566. 24:12and both things are really pleasurable.
  567. 24:14- And when you wander,
  568. 24:16I think one key thing is to notice a good idea
  569. 24:21and to maybe, to notice the kernel of a good idea.
  570. 24:25Maybe pull at that string.
  571. 24:28Because I don't think a good idea has come fully formed.
  572. 24:31- A hundred percent right.
  573. 24:33In fact, when I come up with what I think is a good idea
  574. 24:37and it survives kind of the first level of scrutiny,
  575. 24:40you know, that I do in my own head
  576. 24:42and I'm ready to tell somebody else about the idea,
  577. 24:45I will often say look,
  578. 24:47it is going to be really easy for you to find objections
  579. 24:50to this idea, but work with me.
  580. 24:53- There's something there.
  581. 24:54- There's something there.
  582. 24:55And that is intuition.
  583. 24:57- Yeah.
  584. 24:58- Because it's really easy to kill new ideas
  585. 25:01in the beginning.
  586. 25:02'Cause they do have so many,
  587. 25:04so many easy objections to them.
  588. 25:07So you need to,
  589. 25:08you need to kind of forewarn people
  590. 25:09and say look, I know it's gonna take a lot of work
  591. 25:12to get this to a fully formed idea.
  592. 25:14Let's get started on that.
  593. 25:16It'll be fun.
  594. 25:17- So you got that ability to say cosine
  595. 25:19in you somewhere after all.
  596. 25:22Maybe not on math, but-
  597. 25:23- In a different domain.
  598. 25:24- Yeah.
  599. 25:25- There are a thousand ways to be smart, by the way.
  600. 25:27- Yeah.
  601. 25:28- And that is a really, like when I go around, you know,
  602. 25:31and I meet people, I'm always looking
  603. 25:33for the way that they're smart.
  604. 25:35And you find it is,
  605. 25:37that's one of the things that makes the world so interesting
  606. 25:42and fun is that it is not,
  607. 25:43it's not like IQ is a single dimension.
  608. 25:48There are people who are smart in such unique ways.
  609. 25:52- Yeah, you just gave me a good response
  610. 25:54to when somebody calls me an idiot on the internet.
  611. 25:57You know, that's a thousand ways to be smart, sir.
  612. 26:01- Well, they might tell you,
  613. 26:02yeah, but there are a million to be ways to be dumb.
  614. 26:04- Yeah, right.
  615. 26:06I feel like that's a Mark Twain quote.
  616. 26:08Okay.
  617. 26:10All right, you gave me an amazing tour
  618. 26:12of Blue Origin Rocket Factory and Launch Complex
  619. 26:14in the historic Cape Canaveral.
  620. 26:17That's where New Glenn,
  621. 26:18the big rocket we talked about is being built
  622. 26:22and will launch.
  623. 26:24Can you explain what the New Glenn Rocket is
  624. 26:26and tell me some interesting technical aspects
  625. 26:28of how it works?
  626. 26:29- Sure.
  627. 26:31New Glenn is a very large,
  628. 26:35a heavy lift launch vehicle.
  629. 26:37It'll take about 45 metric tons to LEO,
  630. 26:41very, very large class.
  631. 26:44It's about half the thrust,
  632. 26:46a little more than half the thrust
  633. 26:48of the Saturn V Rocket.
  634. 26:50So it's about 3.9 million pounds of thrust on liftoff.
  635. 26:55The booster has seven BE-4 engines.
  636. 26:59Each engine generates a little more
  637. 27:02than 550,000 pounds of thrust.
  638. 27:05The engines are fueled by liquid natural gas,
  639. 27:09liquified natural gas, LNG as the fuel
  640. 27:12and LOX as the oxidizer.
  641. 27:15The cycle is an ox-riched stage combustion cycle.
  642. 27:19It's a cycle that was really pioneered by the Russians.
  643. 27:21It's a very good cycle.
  644. 27:23And that engine is also going to power the first stage
  645. 27:29of the Vulcan rocket,
  646. 27:30which is the United Launch Alliance rocket.
  647. 27:33Then the second stage of New Glenn
  648. 27:36is powered by two BE-3U engines,
  649. 27:39which is a upper stage variant
  650. 27:41of our New Shephard liquid hydrogen engine.
  651. 27:44So the BE-3U has 160,000 pounds of thrust.
  652. 27:47So two of those 320,000 pounds of thrust
  653. 27:51and hydrogen is a very good propellant
  654. 27:54for upper stages because it has very high ISP.
  655. 27:59It's not a great propellant in my view for booster stages
  656. 28:03because the stages then get physically so large.
  657. 28:06Hydrogen has very high ISP,
  658. 28:10but liquid hydrogen is very,
  659. 28:12is not dense at all.
  660. 28:14So to store liquid hydrogen, you know,
  661. 28:17if you need to store many thousands
  662. 28:19of pounds of liquid hydrogen,
  663. 28:20your tanks, your liquid hydrogen tank, it's very large.
  664. 28:23So you really, you get more benefit from the higher ISP,
  665. 28:27the specific impulse.
  666. 28:29You get more benefit from the higher specific impulse
  667. 28:31on the second stage.
  668. 28:33And that stage carries less propellant.
  669. 28:37So you don't get such geometrically gigantic tanks.
  670. 28:41The Delta IV is an example of a vehicle
  671. 28:44that is all hydrogen.
  672. 28:45The booster stage is also hydrogen.
  673. 28:47And I think that it's a very effective vehicle,
  674. 28:49but it never was very cost effective.
  675. 28:52So it's operationally very capable
  676. 28:55but not very cost effective.
  677. 28:56- So size is also costly.
  678. 28:58- Size is costly.
  679. 28:59So it's interesting.
  680. 29:01Rockets love to be big.
  681. 29:03Everything works better.
  682. 29:05- What do you mean by that?
  683. 29:06You've told me that before.
  684. 29:07It sounds epic, but what does it mean?
  685. 29:10- I mean, when you look at the,
  686. 29:12kind of the physics of rocket engines
  687. 29:15and also when you look at parasitic mass,
  688. 29:19it doesn't, if you have,
  689. 29:20let's say you have an avionic system,
  690. 29:22so you have a guidance and control system,
  691. 29:25that is gonna be about the same mass and size
  692. 29:29for a giant rocket as it is gonna be for a tiny rocket.
  693. 29:33And so that's just parasitic mass
  694. 29:37that is very consequential if you're building
  695. 29:40a very small rocket,
  696. 29:41but is trivial if you're building a very large rocket.
  697. 29:44So you have the parasitic mass thing.
  698. 29:46And then if you look at, for example,
  699. 29:48rocket engines have turbo pumps.
  700. 29:50They have to pressurize the fuel and the oxidizer
  701. 29:53up to a very high pressure level
  702. 29:55in order to inject it into the thrust chamber
  703. 29:58where it burns.
  704. 29:59And those pumps, all rotating machines, in fact
  705. 30:03get more efficient as they get larger.
  706. 30:06So really tiny turbo pumps
  707. 30:09are very challenging to manufacture.
  708. 30:13And any kind of gaps, you know,
  709. 30:15are like between the housing for example,
  710. 30:19and the rotating impeller that pressurizes the fuel,
  711. 30:22there has to be some gap there.
  712. 30:24You can't have those parts scraping against one another.
  713. 30:27And those gaps drive inefficiencies.
  714. 30:31And so, you know, if you have a very large turbo pump,
  715. 30:34those gaps in percentage terms end up being very small.
  716. 30:39And so there's a bunch of things
  717. 30:42that you end up loving about having a large rocket
  718. 30:46and that you end up hating for a small rocket.
  719. 30:48But there's a giant exception to this rule,
  720. 30:51and it is manufacturing.
  721. 30:53So manufacturing large structures is very, very challenging.
  722. 30:58It's a pain in the butt.
  723. 30:59And so, you know, it's just if you have,
  724. 31:01if you're making a small rocket engine,
  725. 31:03you can move all the pieces by hand,
  726. 31:04you could assemble it on a table, one person can do it,
  727. 31:08you know, you don't need cranes and heavy lift operations
  728. 31:12and tooling, and so on and so on.
  729. 31:14When you start building big objects, infrastructure,
  730. 31:19civil infrastructure, just like the launchpad
  731. 31:22and the you know, all this,
  732. 31:23we went and visited,
  733. 31:25I took you to the launchpad
  734. 31:26and you can see it's so monumental.
  735. 31:28- Yeah, it is.
  736. 31:29- And so just these things become major undertakings,
  737. 31:33both from an engineering point of view,
  738. 31:35but also from a construction and cost point of view.
  739. 31:37- And even the foundation of the launchpad,
  740. 31:39I mean, this is Florida,
  741. 31:42like isn't like swamp land?
  742. 31:43Like how deep do you have to go?
  743. 31:44- You have to at Cape Canaveral,
  744. 31:46in fact, at most ocean, you know, most launch pads
  745. 31:48are on beaches somewhere in the oceanside.
  746. 31:52'cause you wanna launch over water for safety reasons.
  747. 31:57The yes, you have to drive pilings,
  748. 32:01you know, dozens and dozens and dozens of pilings,
  749. 32:04you know, 50, a 100, 150 feet deep
  750. 32:07to get enough structural integrity
  751. 32:09for these very large, you know, it's yes,
  752. 32:11these turn into major civil engineering projects.
  753. 32:15- I just have to say everything about that factory
  754. 32:17is pretty badass.
  755. 32:18You said tooling, the bigger it gets,
  756. 32:21the more epic it is.
  757. 32:22- It does make it epic.
  758. 32:23- Yeah.
  759. 32:24- It's fun to look at.
  760. 32:25It's extraordinary.
  761. 32:26- It's humbling also,
  762. 32:27'cause you know, humans are so small compared to it.
  763. 32:29- We are building these enormous machines
  764. 32:33that are harnessing enormous amounts
  765. 32:35of chemical power, you know, in very, very compact packages.
  766. 32:43It's truly extraordinary.
  767. 32:44- But then there's all the different components
  768. 32:46and that you know, the materials involved.
  769. 32:50Is there something interesting
  770. 32:51that you can describe about the materials
  771. 32:54that's comprised the rockets?
  772. 32:57So it has to be as light as possible, I guess,
  773. 33:00whilst withstanding the heat and the harsh conditions?
  774. 33:03- Yeah, I play a little kind of game sometimes
  775. 33:06with other rocket people that I run into where
  776. 33:09say what are the things
  777. 33:10that would amaze the 1960s engineers?
  778. 33:13Like what's changed?
  779. 33:15'Cause surprisingly, some of rocketry greatest hits
  780. 33:18have not changed.
  781. 33:19They are still,
  782. 33:20they would recognize immediately a lot of what we do today.
  783. 33:24And it's exactly what they pioneered back in the '60s.
  784. 33:27But a few things have changed.
  785. 33:30You know, the use of carbon composites
  786. 33:34is very different today.
  787. 33:36You know, we can build very sophisticated,
  788. 33:39you saw our carbon tape laying machine
  789. 33:42that builds the giant fairings.
  790. 33:44And we can build these incredibly light,
  791. 33:48very stiff fairing structures
  792. 33:52out of carbon composite material
  793. 33:55that they could not have dreamed of.
  794. 33:57I mean the efficiency, the structural efficiency
  795. 34:00of that material is so high compared to any you know,
  796. 34:05metallic material you might use or anything else.
  797. 34:07So that's one.
  798. 34:12Aluminum lithium and the ability
  799. 34:15to friction stir weld aluminum lithium.
  800. 34:18Do you remember the friction stir welding that I showed you?
  801. 34:20- Yes, incredible.
  802. 34:21- This is a remarkable technology.
  803. 34:23This was invented decades ago,
  804. 34:25but has become very practical
  805. 34:26over just the last couple of decades.
  806. 34:29And instead of using heat to weld two pieces
  807. 34:32of metal together, it literally stirs the two pieces.
  808. 34:37There's a pin that rotates at a certain rate
  809. 34:40and you put that pin between the two plates of metal
  810. 34:44that you wanna weld together.
  811. 34:46And then you move it at a very precise speed.
  812. 34:50And instead of heating the material,
  813. 34:52it heats it a little bit because of friction,
  814. 34:54but not very much.
  815. 34:56You can literally immediately after welding
  816. 34:57with stir friction welding,
  817. 34:58you can touch the material and it's just barely warm.
  818. 35:01It literally stirs the molecules together.
  819. 35:05It's quite extraordinary.
  820. 35:06- Relatively low temperature.
  821. 35:07And I guess high temperature is what makes them,
  822. 35:09that makes it a weak point?
  823. 35:11- Exactly.
  824. 35:12So with traditional welding techniques, you may have
  825. 35:16whatever the underlying strength characteristics
  826. 35:19of the material are,
  827. 35:21you end up with weak regions where you weld.
  828. 35:24And with friction stir welding,
  829. 35:26the welds are just as strong as the bulk material.
  830. 35:29So it really allows you,
  831. 35:31and so, 'cause when you're,
  832. 35:32you know, let's say you're building a tank
  833. 35:34that you're gonna pressurize
  834. 35:36you know, a large liquid natural gas tank
  835. 35:38for our booster stage, for example.
  836. 35:41You know, if you are welding that with traditional methods,
  837. 35:44you have to size those weld lands,
  838. 35:46the thickness of those pieces
  839. 35:48with that knockdown for whatever damage you're doing
  840. 35:50with the weld.
  841. 35:51And that's gonna add a lot of weight to that tank.
  842. 35:53- I mean, even just the looking at the fairings,
  843. 35:56the result of that,
  844. 35:58the complex shape that it takes and-
  845. 36:01- Yeah.
  846. 36:02- And like what it's supposed to do is kind of incredible
  847. 36:05'cause so people don't know it's on top of the rocket,
  848. 36:06it's gonna fall apart.
  849. 36:08That's its task.
  850. 36:09But it has to stay strong sometimes.
  851. 36:11- Yes.
  852. 36:13- And then disappear when it needs to.
  853. 36:15- That's right.
  854. 36:16- Which is a very difficult task.
  855. 36:17- Yes.
  856. 36:18When you need something that needs to have 100% integrity
  857. 36:22until it needs to have 0% integrity.
  858. 36:24It needs to stay attached until it's ready to go away.
  859. 36:27And then when it goes away, it has to go away completely.
  860. 36:31You use explosive charges for that.
  861. 36:33And so it's a very robust way
  862. 36:36of separating structure
  863. 36:38when you need to.
  864. 36:40- Exploding
  865. 36:41- Yeah.
  866. 36:42Little tiny bits of explosive material
  867. 36:45and it just, it'll sever the whole connection.
  868. 36:49- So if you wanna go from 100% structural integrity
  869. 36:54to zero as fast as possible use explosives,
  870. 36:58- Use explosives.
  871. 36:59- The entirety of this thing is so badass.
  872. 37:02Okay, so we're back to the two stages.
  873. 37:04So the first stage is reusable.
  874. 37:06- Yeah.
  875. 37:06Second stage is expendable.
  876. 37:09Second stage is liquid hydrogen, liquid oxygen.
  877. 37:11So we could take advantage of the higher specific impulse.
  878. 37:14The the first stage lands downrange on a landing platform
  879. 37:20in the ocean, comes back for maintenance
  880. 37:24and get ready to do the next mission.
  881. 37:26- I mean there's a million questions,
  882. 37:29but also is there a path towards reusability
  883. 37:31for the second stage?
  884. 37:32- There is, and we know how to do that.
  885. 37:35Right now we're gonna work on manufacturing
  886. 37:39that second stage to make it as inexpensive as possible.
  887. 37:42Sort of two paths for a second stage,
  888. 37:45make it reusable,
  889. 37:47or work really hard to make it inexpensive
  890. 37:50so you can afford to expend it.
  891. 37:53And that trade is actually not obvious which one is better.
  892. 38:00- Even in terms of cost.
  893. 38:02Even like time cost?
  894. 38:03- I'm talking about cost is, you know,
  895. 38:05space flight, getting into orbit is a solved problem.
  896. 38:08We solved it back in you know, the '50s and '60s.
  897. 38:11- You're making it sound easy.
  898. 38:13- So the only thing that,
  899. 38:14the only interesting problem
  900. 38:15is dramatically reducing the cost of access to orbit,
  901. 38:19which is if you can do that,
  902. 38:21you open up a bunch of new, you know, endeavors
  903. 38:26that lots of startup companies, everybody else can do.
  904. 38:29So that's, we really,
  905. 38:30that's one of our missions
  906. 38:32is to you know, be part of this industry
  907. 38:36and lower the cost to orbit so that there can be
  908. 38:40you know, a kind of a renaissance, a golden age
  909. 38:43of people doing all kinds of interesting things in space.
  910. 38:47- I like how you said getting to orbit is a solved problem.
  911. 38:50It is just the only interesting thing is reducing the cost.
  912. 38:53You know, how you can describe every single problem
  913. 38:55facing human civilization that way.
  914. 38:57The physicist would say everything is a solved problem.
  915. 39:00We've solved everything.
  916. 39:01The rest is just well, Rutherford said that
  917. 39:04"it's just stamp collecting."
  918. 39:06It's just the details.
  919. 39:07It's some of the greatest innovations and inventions
  920. 39:10and you know, brilliance is in that cost reduction stage.
  921. 39:14Right, and you, you've had a long career of cost reduction.
  922. 39:18- For sure.
  923. 39:18And when you,
  924. 39:20what does cost reduction really mean?
  925. 39:22It means inventing a better way.
  926. 39:25- Yeah, exactly.
  927. 39:25- Right, and when you invent a better way,
  928. 39:27you make the whole world richer.
  929. 39:29So, you know, whatever it was,
  930. 39:30I don't know how many thousands of years ago,
  931. 39:32somebody invented the plow.
  932. 39:34And when they invented the plow,
  933. 39:35they made the whole world richer
  934. 39:37because they made farming less expensive.
  935. 39:40And so it is a big deal to invent better ways.
  936. 39:45That's how the world gets richer.
  937. 39:48- So what are some of the biggest challenges
  938. 39:52on the manufacturing side and the engineering side
  939. 39:54that you're facing in working
  940. 39:56to get to the first launch of New Glenn?
  941. 40:01- The first launch is one thing
  942. 40:03and we'll do that in 2024 coming up in this coming year.
  943. 40:07The real thing that's the bigger challenge
  944. 40:09is making sure that our factory
  945. 40:12is efficiently manufacturing at rate.
  946. 40:18So rate production.
  947. 40:19So consider if you wanna launch New Glenn
  948. 40:23you know, 24 times a year.
  949. 40:25You need to manufacture a upper stage
  950. 40:30since they're expendable every, you know, twice a month,
  951. 40:34you need to do one every two weeks.
  952. 40:36So you need to be,
  953. 40:37you need to have all of your manufacturing facilities
  954. 40:41and processes and inspection techniques
  955. 40:43and acceptance tests and everything operating at rate.
  956. 40:47And rate manufacturing is at least as difficult
  957. 40:51as designing the vehicle in the first place.
  958. 40:55And the same thing.
  959. 40:56So every upper stage has two BE-3U engines.
  960. 41:03So those engines you know, you need
  961. 41:05if you're gonna launch this the vehicle twice a month,
  962. 41:08you need four engines a month.
  963. 41:10So you need an engine every week.
  964. 41:11So you need to be,
  965. 41:13that engine needs to be being produced at rate.
  966. 41:16And that's a,
  967. 41:17and there's all of the things that you need to do that,
  968. 41:20all the right machine tools, all the right fixtures,
  969. 41:24the right people, process, et cetera.
  970. 41:26So it's one thing to build a first article, right.
  971. 41:30So that's you know, to launch New Glenn for the first time,
  972. 41:35you need to produce a first article.
  973. 41:37But that's not the hard part.
  974. 41:39The hard part is everything that's going on
  975. 41:42behind the scenes to build a factory
  976. 41:45that can produce New Glenn's at rate.
  977. 41:47- So the first one is produced in a way
  978. 41:49that enables the production of the second and third
  979. 41:52and the fourth and the fifth and sixth, and so on.
  980. 41:54- You could think of the first article
  981. 41:56as kind of pushing,
  982. 41:57it pushes all of the rate manufacturing technology along.
  983. 42:02You know, in other words, it's kind of the,
  984. 42:05it's the test article in a way
  985. 42:09that's testing out your manufacturing technologies.
  986. 42:13- The manufacturing is the big challenge.
  987. 42:15- Yes.
  988. 42:16I mean I don't want to make it sound like any of it is easy.
  989. 42:18I mean the people who are designing the engines
  990. 42:21and all this, all of it is hard for sure.
  991. 42:25But the challenge right now is driving really hard
  992. 42:29to get to rate manufacturing
  993. 42:32and to do that in an efficient way.
  994. 42:34Again, kind of back to our cost point.
  995. 42:36If you get to rate manufacturing in an inefficient way,
  996. 42:39you haven't really solved the cost problem
  997. 42:41and maybe you haven't really moved
  998. 42:43this state of the art forward.
  999. 42:45All this has to be
  1000. 42:46about moving the state-of-the art forward.
  1001. 42:48There are easier businesses to do.
  1002. 42:50I always tell people look, if you are trying to make money,
  1003. 42:53you know, like start a salty snack food company
  1004. 42:55or something, you know.
  1005. 42:57- I'm gonna write that idea down.
  1006. 43:01- Like make the Lex Fridman potato chips,
  1007. 43:03you know, this is-
  1008. 43:04- Don't say it, people are gonna steal it.
  1009. 43:08But yeah, it's hard.
  1010. 43:10- You see what I'm saying?
  1011. 43:11It's like there's nothing easy about this business
  1012. 43:14but it's its own reward.
  1013. 43:17It's fascinating, it's worthwhile, it's meaningful.
  1014. 43:22And so you know, not,
  1015. 43:23I don't wanna pick on salty snack food companies,
  1016. 43:25but I think it's less meaningful.
  1017. 43:26You know, at the end of the day,
  1018. 43:29you're not gonna have accomplished something amazing.
  1019. 43:33- Yeah, there's-
  1020. 43:34- Even if you do make a lot of money out of it.
  1021. 43:35- Yeah, there's something fundamentally different
  1022. 43:37about the quote unquote business of space exploration.
  1023. 43:41- Yeah, for sure.
  1024. 43:42- It's a grand project of humanity.
  1025. 43:44- Yes.
  1026. 43:45It's one of humanity's grand challenges.
  1027. 43:47And especially as you look at going to the moon
  1028. 43:51and going to Mars and building giant O'Neill colonies
  1029. 43:54and unlocking all the things.
  1030. 43:56You know, I won't live long enough
  1031. 43:58to see the fruits of this,
  1032. 44:01but the fruits of this come from building a road to space,
  1033. 44:06getting the infrastructure.
  1034. 44:08I'll give you an analogy.
  1035. 44:10When I started Amazon,
  1036. 44:12I didn't have to develop a payment system.
  1037. 44:15It already existed.
  1038. 44:16It was called the credit card.
  1039. 44:18I didn't have to develop a transportation system
  1040. 44:21to deliver the packages.
  1041. 44:22It already existed.
  1042. 44:23It was called the postal service
  1043. 44:25and Royal Mail and Deutsche Post.
  1044. 44:28And so all this heavy lifting infrastructure
  1045. 44:32was already in place.
  1046. 44:33And I could stand on its shoulders.
  1047. 44:36And that's why when you look at the internet,
  1048. 44:40you know, by the way, another giant piece of infrastructure
  1049. 44:43that was around in the early,
  1050. 44:44I'm taking you back to like 1994,
  1051. 44:46people were using dial up modems.
  1052. 44:49And it was piggybacking
  1053. 44:50on top of the long distance phone network.
  1054. 44:53That's how the internet,
  1055. 44:55that's you know, how people were accessing servers
  1056. 44:57and so on.
  1057. 44:58And that again, if that hadn't existed,
  1058. 45:02it would've been hundreds of billions of CapEx
  1059. 45:05to put that out there.
  1060. 45:06No startup company could have done that.
  1061. 45:09And so the problem you know, you see in,
  1062. 45:13if you look at the dynamism in the internet space
  1063. 45:16over the last 20 years,
  1064. 45:18it's because you know, you see like two kids in a dorm room
  1065. 45:22could start an internet company that could be successful
  1066. 45:24and do amazing things.
  1067. 45:26Beause they didn't have to build heavy infrastructure.
  1068. 45:28It was already there.
  1069. 45:30And that's what I wanna do.
  1070. 45:33I take you know, my Amazon winnings
  1071. 45:36and use that to build heavy infrastructure
  1072. 45:38so that the next generation you know,
  1073. 45:41the generation that's my children and their children,
  1074. 45:45these, you know, those generations
  1075. 45:47can then use that heavy infrastructure.
  1076. 45:50Then there'll be space entrepreneurs
  1077. 45:51who start in their dorm room.
  1078. 45:53- Yeah.
  1079. 45:54- Like that will be a marker of success.
  1080. 45:56When you can have a really valuable space company
  1081. 46:00started in a dorm room,
  1082. 46:01then we know that we've built enough infrastructure
  1083. 46:04so that ingenuity and imagination can really be unleashed.
  1084. 46:09I find that very exciting.
  1085. 46:10- As they will of course, as kids do,
  1086. 46:13take all of this hard infrastructurability for granted.
  1087. 46:15- Of course.
  1088. 46:17Which is-
  1089. 46:18- That's the entrepreneurial spirit.
  1090. 46:19- That's an inventors greatest dream.
  1091. 46:23- Yeah.
  1092. 46:24- Is that their inventions are so successful
  1093. 46:26that they are one day taken for granted.
  1094. 46:29You know, nobody thinks of Amazon as an invention anymore.
  1095. 46:31Nobody thinks of customer reviews as,
  1096. 46:33we pioneered customer reviews,
  1097. 46:35but now they're so commonplace.
  1098. 46:37Same thing with one click shopping and so on.
  1099. 46:39But that's a compliment.
  1100. 46:40That's how you know,
  1101. 46:41you invent something that's so used,
  1102. 46:45so beneficially used by so many people
  1103. 46:48that they take it for granted.
  1104. 46:49- I don't know about nobody.
  1105. 46:50That's every time I use Amazon,
  1106. 46:52I'm still amazed how does this work?
  1107. 46:53Logistics.
  1108. 46:54- Well, that proves you're very curious explorer.
  1109. 46:57- All right, all right, back to rockets.
  1110. 47:00Timeline.
  1111. 47:01You said 2024.
  1112. 47:04As it stands now,
  1113. 47:06are both the first test launch and the launch
  1114. 47:09of escapade explorers to Mars still possible?
  1115. 47:11- In 2024? - In 2024.
  1116. 47:13Yeah.
  1117. 47:13- Yeah, I think so.
  1118. 47:14For sure the first launch,
  1119. 47:16and then we'll see if escapade goes on that or not.
  1120. 47:19I think that the first launch for sure.
  1121. 47:21And I hope escapade too.
  1122. 47:23- Hope.
  1123. 47:24- Well, I just don't know which mission
  1124. 47:26it's actually gonna be slated on.
  1125. 47:28So we also have other things
  1126. 47:30that might go on that first mission.
  1127. 47:31- Oh, I got it.
  1128. 47:32But you're optimistic that the launches will still-
  1129. 47:35- Oh, the first launch,
  1130. 47:36I'm very optimistic that the first launch
  1131. 47:37of New Glenn will be in 2024.
  1132. 47:39And I'm just not a hundred percent certain
  1133. 47:43what payload will be on that first launch.
  1134. 47:44- Are you nervous about it?
  1135. 47:46- Are you kidding?
  1136. 47:47I'm extremely nervous about it.
  1137. 47:51- Oh man.
  1138. 47:52- A hundred percent.
  1139. 47:53I've, you know, every launch I go to,
  1140. 47:56you know, for New Shephard, for other vehicles too,
  1141. 47:59I'm always nervous for these launches.
  1142. 48:02But yes, for sure.
  1143. 48:03A first launch to have no nervousness about that
  1144. 48:06would be, you know, some sign of derangement,
  1145. 48:08I think so.
  1146. 48:09- Well, I got to visit the launchpad,
  1147. 48:11it's pretty, I mean, it's epic.
  1148. 48:14- You know, we have done a tremendous amount
  1149. 48:17of ground testing, a tremendous amount of simulation.
  1150. 48:21So, you know, a lot of the problems
  1151. 48:25that we might find in flight have been resolved,
  1152. 48:28but there are some problems you can only find in flight.
  1153. 48:31So, you know, cross your fingers.
  1154. 48:33I guarantee you, you'll have fun watching it
  1155. 48:36no matter what happens.
  1156. 48:37- 100% when the thing is fully assembled and comes up.
  1157. 48:40- Yeah, the transporter erector.
  1158. 48:44- The erector, yeah.
  1159. 48:45- Just the transporter erector for a rocket of this scale
  1160. 48:48- Yeah. - is extraordinary.
  1161. 48:49- That's an incredible machine.
  1162. 48:50- The vehicle travels out horizontally
  1163. 48:54and then kind of-
  1164. 48:55- Yeah.
  1165. 48:56- You know, comes up.
  1166. 48:57- Over a few hours?
  1167. 48:58- Yeah, it's a beautiful thing to watch.
  1168. 49:00- Speaking of which, if that makes you nervous,
  1169. 49:04I don't know if you remember,
  1170. 49:06but you were aboard a New Shephard
  1171. 49:11on its first crude flight.
  1172. 49:14How was that experience?
  1173. 49:17Were you terrified then?
  1174. 49:20- You know, strangely, I wasn't, you know.
  1175. 49:22- When you ride the rocket-
  1176. 49:23- It's true.
  1177. 49:24- less nerve wracking.
  1178. 49:25- Its true.
  1179. 49:26I've watched other people ride the rocket
  1180. 49:28and I'm more nervous
  1181. 49:29than when I was inside the rocket myself.
  1182. 49:31It was a difficult conversation to have with my mother
  1183. 49:35when I told her I was gonna go on the first one.
  1184. 49:38And not only was I gonna go,
  1185. 49:40but I was gonna bring my brother too.
  1186. 49:41This is a tough conversation to have with a mom.
  1187. 49:44- There's a long pause when you told her.
  1188. 49:46- She's like both of you?
  1189. 49:50And it was an incredible experience
  1190. 49:54and we were laughing inside the capsule
  1191. 49:59and you know, we're not nervous.
  1192. 50:01The people on the ground were very nervous for us.
  1193. 50:05It was actually one of the most emotionally powerful parts
  1194. 50:12of the experience was not happened even before the flight
  1195. 50:17at 4:30 in the morning, brother and I are getting ready
  1196. 50:21to go to the launch site
  1197. 50:23and Lauren is gonna take us there in her helicopter
  1198. 50:25and we're getting ready to leave.
  1199. 50:27And we go outside the ranch house there
  1200. 50:29in west Texas where the launch facility is.
  1201. 50:32And all of our family, my kids and my brother's kids
  1202. 50:38and our you know, our parents, and close friends
  1203. 50:44are assembled there.
  1204. 50:46And they're saying goodbye to us,
  1205. 50:48but they're kind of saying,
  1206. 50:50maybe they think they're saying goodbye to us forever.
  1207. 50:54And you know, we might not have felt that way.
  1208. 50:56But it was obvious from their faces
  1209. 50:57how nervous they were that they felt that way.
  1210. 51:00And it was sort of powerful
  1211. 51:01because it allowed us to see,
  1212. 51:03it was almost like attending your own memorial service
  1213. 51:06or something.
  1214. 51:07Like you could feel how loved you were in that moment.
  1215. 51:09And it was really amazing.
  1216. 51:12- Yeah, and I mean there's just a epic nature to it too.
  1217. 51:18- The accent, the floating and zero gravity.
  1218. 51:21I'll tell you something very interesting.
  1219. 51:22Zero gravity feels very natural.
  1220. 51:25I don't know if it's because we are,
  1221. 51:27you know, it's like return to the womb or what.
  1222. 51:30- You just confirmed you're an alien.
  1223. 51:33But that's okay.
  1224. 51:35I think that's what you just said.
  1225. 51:37- It feels so natural to be in zero G.
  1226. 51:38It was really interesting.
  1227. 51:39And then what people talk about the overview effect
  1228. 51:42and seeing earth from space,
  1229. 51:44I had that feeling very powerfully.
  1230. 51:46I think everyone did.
  1231. 51:49You see how fragile the earth is.
  1232. 51:51If you're not an environmentalist, it will make you one.
  1233. 51:54The the great Jim Lovell quote, you know,
  1234. 51:57he looked back at the earth from space
  1235. 51:59and he said he realized "you don't go to heaven
  1236. 52:02when you die.
  1237. 52:03You go to heaven when you're born."
  1238. 52:05And it's just you know, that's the feeling
  1239. 52:08that people get when they're in space.
  1240. 52:09You see all this blackness, all this nothingness,
  1241. 52:12and there's one gem of life, and it's earth.
  1242. 52:15- It is a gem.
  1243. 52:16What, you know, you've talked a lot
  1244. 52:19about decision making throughout your time with Amazon.
  1245. 52:23What was that decision like to be the first
  1246. 52:27to ride New Shephard?
  1247. 52:29Like what, just be before you talked to your mom.
  1248. 52:31- Yeah.
  1249. 52:32- What, like the pros and cons,
  1250. 52:34like actually as one human being,
  1251. 52:37as a leader of a company on all fronts,
  1252. 52:41like what was that decision making like?
  1253. 52:43- I decided that, first of all,
  1254. 52:45I knew the vehicle extremely well.
  1255. 52:48I know the team who built it.
  1256. 52:49I know the vehicle.
  1257. 52:53I am very comfortable with like the escape system.
  1258. 52:58We put as much effort into the escape system on that vehicle
  1259. 53:03as we put into all the rest of the vehicle combined.
  1260. 53:05It's one of the hardest pieces of engineering
  1261. 53:08in the entire New Shephard architecture.
  1262. 53:10- Can you actually describe,
  1263. 53:11what do you mean by escape system?
  1264. 53:13What's involved?
  1265. 53:14- We have a solid rocket motor
  1266. 53:16in the base of the crew capsule
  1267. 53:18so that if anything goes wrong on ascent,
  1268. 53:23you know, while the main rocket engine is firing,
  1269. 53:26we can ignite this solid rocket motor
  1270. 53:30in the base of the crew capsule and escape from the booster.
  1271. 53:35It's a very challenging system to build, design, validate,
  1272. 53:39test, all of these things.
  1273. 53:42It is the reason that I am comfortable letting anyone
  1274. 53:46go on New Shephard.
  1275. 53:47So the booster is as safe and reliable as we can make it.
  1276. 53:53But we are harnessing,
  1277. 53:56whenever you're talking about rocket engines,
  1278. 53:59I don't care what rocket engine you're talking about,
  1279. 54:02you are harnessing such vast power
  1280. 54:06in such a small, compact, geometric space.
  1281. 54:10The power density is so enormous that it is impossible
  1282. 54:15to ever be sure that nothing will go wrong.
  1283. 54:18And so the only way to improve safety
  1284. 54:23is to have an escape system.
  1285. 54:24And you know, and historically rockets,
  1286. 54:27human rated rockets have had escape systems.
  1287. 54:29Only the space shuttle did not.
  1288. 54:32And, but Apollo had one,
  1289. 54:35you know, all of the previous, you know, Gemini, et cetera,
  1290. 54:39they all had escape systems.
  1291. 54:42And we have on New shephard of unusual escapes,
  1292. 54:46most escape systems are towers.
  1293. 54:48We have a pusher escape system.
  1294. 54:50So the solid rocket motor is actually embedded
  1295. 54:52in the base of the crew capsule.
  1296. 54:53And it pushes and it's reusable
  1297. 54:55in the sense that if we don't use it,
  1298. 54:58so if we have a nominal mission, we land with it.
  1299. 55:02The tower systems have to be ejected
  1300. 55:04at a certain point in the mission,
  1301. 55:06and so they get wasted even in a nominal mission.
  1302. 55:09And so again, you know, cost really matters on these things.
  1303. 55:12So we figured out how to have the escape system
  1304. 55:14be a reusable ,
  1305. 55:16in the event that it's not used, you can reuse it
  1306. 55:19and have it be a pusher system.
  1307. 55:21It's a very sophisticated thing.
  1308. 55:23So I knew these things.
  1309. 55:24You asked me about my decision to go
  1310. 55:26and so I know the vehicle very well.
  1311. 55:28I know the people who designed it.
  1312. 55:31I had great trust in them
  1313. 55:33and in the engineering that we did.
  1314. 55:35And I thought to myself look, if I am not ready to go,
  1315. 55:41then I wouldn't want anyone to go.
  1316. 55:43A tourism vehicle has to be designed in my view,
  1317. 55:47to have very, to be as safe as one can make it.
  1318. 55:50You can't make it perfectly safe.
  1319. 55:52It's impossible.
  1320. 55:54But you know, you just have to,
  1321. 55:56people will do things.
  1322. 55:58People take risks, you know, they climb mountains,
  1323. 56:00they skydive, they do deep underwater scuba diving,
  1324. 56:05and so on.
  1325. 56:05People are okay taking risk.
  1326. 56:08You can't eliminate the risk.
  1327. 56:10But it is something, because it's a tourism vehicle,
  1328. 56:13you have to do your utmost to eliminate those risks.
  1329. 56:16And I felt very good about the system.
  1330. 56:19I think it's one of the reasons I was so calm
  1331. 56:22inside and maybe others weren't just calm,
  1332. 56:24they didn't know as much about it as I did.
  1333. 56:26- Who was in charge of engaging the escape system?
  1334. 56:28Did you have-
  1335. 56:29- It's automated.
  1336. 56:30- Okay.
  1337. 56:30- The escape system is-
  1338. 56:31- I was visualizing deployment of that.
  1339. 56:33- is completely automated.
  1340. 56:34Automated is better because it can react so much faster.
  1341. 56:38- So yeah, for tourism rockets
  1342. 56:40safety is a huge, huge, huge priority for space exploration
  1343. 56:43also, but a tiny, you know, a delta less.
  1344. 56:46- Yes.
  1345. 56:47I mean I think for you know, if you're doing,
  1346. 56:49you know, there are human activities
  1347. 56:51where we tolerate more risk.
  1348. 56:52If you're saving somebody's life, you know,
  1349. 56:54if you are engaging in real exploration,
  1350. 56:59these are things where, you know,
  1351. 57:02I personally think we would accept more risk
  1352. 57:07in part because you have to.
  1353. 57:09- Is there a part of you that's frustrated
  1354. 57:12by the rate of progress in Blue Origin?
  1355. 57:16- Blue Origin needs to be much faster.
  1356. 57:18And it's one of the reasons that I left my role
  1357. 57:21as the CEO of Amazon a couple of years ago.
  1358. 57:25I needed, I wanted to come in
  1359. 57:27and Blue Origin needs me right now.
  1360. 57:30And so I had always, when I was the CEO of Amazon,
  1361. 57:33my point of view on this is if I'm the CEO
  1362. 57:35of a publicly traded company
  1363. 57:38it's going to get my full attention.
  1364. 57:39And I really, it's just how I think about things.
  1365. 57:44It was very important to me.
  1366. 57:46I felt I had an obligation to all the stakeholders
  1367. 57:49at Amazon to do that.
  1368. 57:52And so having, you know, turned the CEO,
  1369. 57:55I'm still the executive chair there,
  1370. 57:57but I've turned the CEO role over.
  1371. 57:59And the reason, the primary reason I did that
  1372. 58:02is so that I could spend time on Blue Origin
  1373. 58:06adding some you know, energy, some sense of urgency.
  1374. 58:09We need to move much faster and we're going to.
  1375. 58:13- What are the ways to speed it up?
  1376. 58:15So, I mean there's,
  1377. 58:18you've talked a lot of different ways to sort of at Amazon,
  1378. 58:23you know, removing barriers for progress or distributing,
  1379. 58:30making everybody autonomous and self reliant
  1380. 58:33in terms of all those kinds of things.
  1381. 58:34Is that apply at Blue Origin
  1382. 58:37or is the-
  1383. 58:38- It does apply.
  1384. 58:38You know, I'm leading this directly.
  1385. 58:41We are gonna become the world's most decisive company
  1386. 58:45across any industry.
  1387. 58:47And so you know, at Amazon ever since the beginning,
  1388. 58:53I said we are gonna become
  1389. 58:54the world's most customer obsessed company.
  1390. 58:59And no matter the industry, like people,
  1391. 59:01one day people are going to come to Amazon
  1392. 59:03from the healthcare industry and wanna know
  1393. 59:06how did you guys,
  1394. 59:07how are you so customer obsessed?
  1395. 59:08How do you actually not just pay lip service,
  1396. 59:10but actually do that?
  1397. 59:13And from you know,
  1398. 59:14all different industries should come on and study us
  1399. 59:16to see how we accomplish that.
  1400. 59:19And the analogous thing at Blue Origin
  1401. 59:21and it will help us move faster
  1402. 59:24is we are gonna become the world's most decisive company.
  1403. 59:28We're gonna get really good
  1404. 59:30at taking appropriate technology risk
  1405. 59:32and making those decisions quickly.
  1406. 59:34You know, being bold on those things.
  1407. 59:37That's what, and having the right culture
  1408. 59:39that supports that.
  1409. 59:40You need people to be ambitious, technically ambitious.
  1410. 59:44You know, if there are five ways to do something,
  1411. 59:47we'll study them.
  1412. 59:48But let's study them very quickly and make a decision.
  1413. 59:51We can always change our mind.
  1414. 59:53It doesn't you know, changing your mind is,
  1415. 59:55I took about one-way doors and two-way doors.
  1416. 59:59Most decisions are two-way doors.
  1417. 1:00:03- Can ou explain that?
  1418. 1:00:04'Cause I love that metaphor.
  1419. 1:00:06- If you make the wrong decision,
  1420. 1:00:10if it's a two-way door decision, you walk out the door,
  1421. 1:00:12you pick a door, you walk out,
  1422. 1:00:14and you spend a little time there.
  1423. 1:00:16It turns out to be the wrong decision,
  1424. 1:00:17you can come back in and pick another door.
  1425. 1:00:20Some decisions are so consequential
  1426. 1:00:23and so important and so hard to reverse
  1427. 1:00:27that they really are one-way door decisions.
  1428. 1:00:29You go in that door, you're not coming back.
  1429. 1:00:32And those decisions have to be made
  1430. 1:00:35very deliberately, very carefully.
  1431. 1:00:38If you can think of yet another way to analyze the decision,
  1432. 1:00:41you should slow down and do that.
  1433. 1:00:43So, you know, when I was the CEO of Amazon,
  1434. 1:00:48I often found myself in the position
  1435. 1:00:49of being the chief slowdown officer
  1436. 1:00:52because somebody would be bringing me
  1437. 1:00:54a one-way door decision.
  1438. 1:00:56And I would say okay, I can think of three more ways
  1439. 1:00:58to analyze that.
  1440. 1:00:59So let's go do that.
  1441. 1:01:00Because we ha we are not gonna be able
  1442. 1:01:02to reverse this one easily.
  1443. 1:01:03Maybe you can reverse it, but it's gonna be very costly
  1444. 1:01:06and very time consuming.
  1445. 1:01:07We really have to get this one right from the beginning.
  1446. 1:01:10And what happens, unfortunately in companies,
  1447. 1:01:16what can happen is that you have a one size fits all
  1448. 1:01:21decision making process
  1449. 1:01:24where you end up using the heavyweight process
  1450. 1:01:27on all decisions.
  1451. 1:01:29- For everything, yeah.
  1452. 1:01:29- Including the lightweight ones.
  1453. 1:01:31The two-way door decisions.
  1454. 1:01:33Two-way door decisions should mostly be made
  1455. 1:01:35by single individuals or by very small teams
  1456. 1:01:38deep in the organization.
  1457. 1:01:41And one-way door decisions are the ones
  1458. 1:01:43the irreversible ones,
  1459. 1:01:45those are the ones that should be elevated up
  1460. 1:01:47to you know, the senior most executives
  1461. 1:01:50who should slow them down and make sure
  1462. 1:01:53that the right thing is being done.
  1463. 1:01:55- Yeah, I mean, part of the skill here
  1464. 1:01:57is to know the difference in one-way and two-way,
  1465. 1:01:59I think you mentioned.
  1466. 1:02:00- Yes.
  1467. 1:02:01- I mean I think you mentioned Amazon Prime,
  1468. 1:02:03the decision to sort of create Amazon Prime
  1469. 1:02:06as a one-way door.
  1470. 1:02:08I mean, it's not, it's unclear if it is or not,
  1471. 1:02:10but it probably is, and it's a really big risk to go there.
  1472. 1:02:14- There are a bunch of decisions like that that are
  1473. 1:02:16you know, changing the decision
  1474. 1:02:20is gonna be very, very complicated.
  1475. 1:02:22Some of them are technical decisions too,
  1476. 1:02:24because some technical decisions
  1477. 1:02:26are like quick drying cement.
  1478. 1:02:28You know, if you're gonna, once you make 'em,
  1479. 1:02:29it gets really hard.
  1480. 1:02:30I mean, you know, choosing which propellants
  1481. 1:02:32to use in a vehicle.
  1482. 1:02:34You know, selecting LNG for the booster stage
  1483. 1:02:36and selecting hydrogen for the upper stage,
  1484. 1:02:40that has turned out to be a very good decision.
  1485. 1:02:43But if you changed your mind, that would be a very,
  1486. 1:02:48that would be a very big setback.
  1487. 1:02:50Do you see what I'm saying?
  1488. 1:02:52- Yeah.
  1489. 1:02:53- So that's the kind of decision
  1490. 1:02:54you scrutinize very, very carefully.
  1491. 1:02:57Other things just aren't like that.
  1492. 1:02:58Most decisions are not that way.
  1493. 1:03:01Most decisions should be made by single individuals,
  1494. 1:03:04but they need,
  1495. 1:03:05and done quickly in the full understanding
  1496. 1:03:08that you can always change your mind.
  1497. 1:03:10- Yeah, one of the things I really liked,
  1498. 1:03:12perhaps it's not a two-way door decision
  1499. 1:03:14is I disagree and commit phrase.
  1500. 1:03:19So don't,
  1501. 1:03:21so somebody brings up an idea to you.
  1502. 1:03:23If it's a two-way door,
  1503. 1:03:25you state that you don't understand enough to agree,
  1504. 1:03:29but you still back them.
  1505. 1:03:32I'd love for you to explain it.
  1506. 1:03:33- Yeah, disagree and commit is a really important principle
  1507. 1:03:36that saves a lot of arguing.
  1508. 1:03:38- Yeah.
  1509. 1:03:39- So-
  1510. 1:03:40- I'm gonna use that in my personal life.
  1511. 1:03:41I disagree, but commit.
  1512. 1:03:44- It's very common in any endeavor in life,
  1513. 1:03:47in business, and any you know,
  1514. 1:03:49anybody where you have teammates.
  1515. 1:03:51You have a teammate and the two of you disagree.
  1516. 1:03:54At some point you have to make a decision.
  1517. 1:03:57And you know, in companies
  1518. 1:03:59we tend to organize hierarchically.
  1519. 1:04:00So there's this you know, whoever's the more senior person
  1520. 1:04:04ultimately gets to make the decision.
  1521. 1:04:06So ultimately the CEO gets to make that decision.
  1522. 1:04:09And the CEO may not always make the decision
  1523. 1:04:11that they agree with.
  1524. 1:04:12So like you know, I would often
  1525. 1:04:15I would be the one who would disagree and commit.
  1526. 1:04:17One of my direct reports would very much wanna do it,
  1527. 1:04:22do something in a particular way.
  1528. 1:04:24I would think it was a bad idea.
  1529. 1:04:26I would explain my point of view.
  1530. 1:04:28They would say Jeff, I think you're wrong, and here's why.
  1531. 1:04:33And we would go back and forth
  1532. 1:04:34and I would often say you know what?
  1533. 1:04:38I don't think you're right,
  1534. 1:04:40but I'm gonna gamble with you
  1535. 1:04:43and you're closer to the ground truth than I am.
  1536. 1:04:48I had known you for 20 years, you have great judgment.
  1537. 1:04:52I don't know that I'm right either.
  1538. 1:04:53Not really, not for sure.
  1539. 1:04:55All these decisions are complicated.
  1540. 1:04:57Let's do it your way.
  1541. 1:04:59But at least then you've made a decision.
  1542. 1:05:01And I'm agreeing to commit to that decision.
  1543. 1:05:05So I'm not gonna be second guessing it.
  1544. 1:05:06I'm not gonna be sniping at it.
  1545. 1:05:08I'm not gonna be saying I told you so.
  1546. 1:05:10I'm gonna try actively to help make sure it works.
  1547. 1:05:14That's a really important teammate behavior.
  1548. 1:05:18There's so many ways that dispute resolution
  1549. 1:05:21is a really interesting thing on teams.
  1550. 1:05:25And there are so many ways when two people disagree
  1551. 1:05:28about something, even, I'm assuming in the case
  1552. 1:05:30where everybody's well intentioned,
  1553. 1:05:32they just have a very different opinion
  1554. 1:05:33about what the right decision is.
  1555. 1:05:36And we have, in our society and inside companies,
  1556. 1:05:40we have a bunch of mechanisms
  1557. 1:05:42that we use to resolve these kinds of disputes.
  1558. 1:05:46A lot of 'em are, I think really bad.
  1559. 1:05:50So, you know, an example of a really bad way
  1560. 1:05:53of coming to agreement is compromise.
  1561. 1:05:57So compromise, you know, look,
  1562. 1:05:58we're in a room here and I could say
  1563. 1:06:01Lex, how tall do you think this ceiling is?
  1564. 1:06:04And you'd be like I don't know, Jeff, maybe 12 feet tall.
  1565. 1:06:07And I would say I think it's 11 feet tall.
  1566. 1:06:11- Yeah.
  1567. 1:06:12- And then we'd say you know what?
  1568. 1:06:13Let's just call it 11 and a half feet.
  1569. 1:06:16That's compromise.
  1570. 1:06:17- Yeah.
  1571. 1:06:18- Instead of the right thing to do is you know,
  1572. 1:06:21to get a tape measure or figure out some way
  1573. 1:06:23of actually measuring,
  1574. 1:06:26but think getting that tape measure
  1575. 1:06:27and figure out how to get it to the top of the ceiling
  1576. 1:06:29and all these things that requires energy.
  1577. 1:06:31Compromise, the advantage of compromise
  1578. 1:06:34as a resolution mechanism is that it's low energy,
  1579. 1:06:38but it doesn't lead to truth.
  1580. 1:06:41And so in things like the height of the ceiling,
  1581. 1:06:44where truth is a noble thing,
  1582. 1:06:46you shouldn't allow compromise to be used
  1583. 1:06:48when you can know the truth.
  1584. 1:06:51Another really bad resolution mechanism
  1585. 1:06:54that happens all the time is just who's more stubborn.
  1586. 1:06:58- Yeah.
  1587. 1:06:58- This is also, let's say two executives who disagree
  1588. 1:07:03and they just have a war of attrition.
  1589. 1:07:05And whichever one gets exhausted first
  1590. 1:07:09capitulates to the other one.
  1591. 1:07:11Again, you haven't arrived at truth.
  1592. 1:07:13And this is very demoralizing.
  1593. 1:07:15So, you know, this is where escalation,
  1594. 1:07:18I try to ask people who you know, on my team
  1595. 1:07:23and say never get to a point
  1596. 1:07:25where you are resolving something by you know,
  1597. 1:07:28who gets exhausted first.
  1598. 1:07:31Escalate that.
  1599. 1:07:32I'll help you make the decision.
  1600. 1:07:34Because that's so de-energized
  1601. 1:07:37and such a terrible, lousy way to make a decision.
  1602. 1:07:40- So you want to get to the resolution
  1603. 1:07:42as quickly as possible
  1604. 1:07:43because that ultimately leads to high velocity of decision.
  1605. 1:07:45- Yes.
  1606. 1:07:46And you wanna try to get as close to truth as possible.
  1607. 1:07:48So you want like you know, exhausting the other person
  1608. 1:07:52is not truth seeking.
  1609. 1:07:54- Yes.
  1610. 1:07:55- And compromise is not truth seeking.
  1611. 1:07:57So, you know, it doesn't mean,
  1612. 1:07:59now, and there are a lot of cases
  1613. 1:08:01where no one knows the real truth
  1614. 1:08:02and that's where disagreeing commit can come in.
  1615. 1:08:04But it's escalation is better than more of attrition.
  1616. 1:08:09Escalate to you know, to your boss
  1617. 1:08:13and say hey, we can't agree on this.
  1618. 1:08:14We like each other, we're respectful of each other,
  1619. 1:08:16but we strongly disagree with each other.
  1620. 1:08:18We need you to you know, make a decision here
  1621. 1:08:20so we can move forward.
  1622. 1:08:22But decisiveness, moving forward quickly on decisions
  1623. 1:08:27as quickly as you responsibly can
  1624. 1:08:30is how you increase velocity.
  1625. 1:08:32Most of what slows things down is taking too long
  1626. 1:08:35to make decisions at all scale levels.
  1627. 1:08:38You know, so it has to be part of the culture
  1628. 1:08:41to get high velocity.
  1629. 1:08:43You know, Amazon has a million and a half people
  1630. 1:08:45and the company is still fast.
  1631. 1:08:48We're still decisive, we're still quick.
  1632. 1:08:50And that's because the culture supports that.
  1633. 1:08:53- At every scale in a distributed way.
  1634. 1:08:55- Yes.
  1635. 1:08:56- Try to maximize the velocity of decisions.
  1636. 1:08:58- Exactly.
  1637. 1:08:59- You've mentioned the lunar program.
  1638. 1:09:01Let me ask you about that.
  1639. 1:09:03- Yeah.
  1640. 1:09:04- There's a lot going on there
  1641. 1:09:06and you haven't really talked about it much.
  1642. 1:09:08So in addition to the Artemis program with NASA,
  1643. 1:09:11Blue is doing its own lander program.
  1644. 1:09:13Can you describe it?
  1645. 1:09:15There's a sexy picture on Instagram with one of them.
  1646. 1:09:19Is it the MK1, I guess?
  1647. 1:09:20- Yeah,
  1648. 1:09:21The MK1.
  1649. 1:09:22The picture is me with Bill Nelson, the NASA administrator.
  1650. 1:09:26- Just to clarify, the Lander is the sexy thing
  1651. 1:09:29about the Instagram.
  1652. 1:09:30Really wanna clarify that.
  1653. 1:09:31- I know it's not me.
  1654. 1:09:32I know it was either the lander or Bill.
  1655. 1:09:34- Okay.
  1656. 1:09:36I love Bill, but-
  1657. 1:09:37- Thank you for clarifying.
  1658. 1:09:38- Okay.
  1659. 1:09:39- Yes, the MK1 Lander is designed to take 3000 kilograms
  1660. 1:09:47to the surface of the moon in a cargo, expendable cargo.
  1661. 1:09:50It's an expendable lander.
  1662. 1:09:52Lands on the moon, stays there,
  1663. 1:09:54take 3000 kilograms to the surface.
  1664. 1:09:56It can be launched on a single New Glenn flight,
  1665. 1:09:59which is very important.
  1666. 1:10:01So it's a relatively simple architecture,
  1667. 1:10:04just like the human landing system lander
  1668. 1:10:06that they called the MK2.
  1669. 1:10:08MK1 is also fueled with liquid hydrogen,
  1670. 1:10:14and which is for high energy emissions,
  1671. 1:10:18like landing on the surface of the moon,
  1672. 1:10:20the high specific impulse of hydrogen
  1673. 1:10:22is a very big advantage.
  1674. 1:10:24The disadvantage of hydrogen has always been
  1675. 1:10:28that it's, since it's such a deep cryogen,
  1676. 1:10:31it's not storable.
  1677. 1:10:33So it's constantly boiling off
  1678. 1:10:35and you're losing propellant because it's boiling off.
  1679. 1:10:39And so we're doing, as part of our lunar program,
  1680. 1:10:43it's developing solar powered cryo coolers
  1681. 1:10:46that can actually make hydrogen a storable propellant
  1682. 1:10:50for deep space.
  1683. 1:10:52And that's a real game changer.
  1684. 1:10:53It's a game changer for any high energy mission.
  1685. 1:10:56So to the moon, but to the outer planets,
  1686. 1:10:58to Mars, everywhere.
  1687. 1:11:00- So the idea with MK1, both MK1 and MK2
  1688. 1:11:03is the New Glenn can carry it from the surface of earth
  1689. 1:11:09to the surface of the moon.
  1690. 1:11:12- Exactly.
  1691. 1:11:13So the Mk1 is expendable.
  1692. 1:11:16The lunar lander we're developing for NASA,
  1693. 1:11:20the Mk2 lander, that's part of the Artemis program.
  1694. 1:11:24They call it the sustaining lander program.
  1695. 1:11:27So that lander is designed to be reusable.
  1696. 1:11:31It can land on the surface of the moon
  1697. 1:11:34in a single stage configuration and then take off.
  1698. 1:11:36So the whole you know,
  1699. 1:11:38if you look at the Apollo program,
  1700. 1:11:41the lunar lander and Apollo was really two stages.
  1701. 1:11:44It would land on the surface
  1702. 1:11:47and then it would leave the descent stage
  1703. 1:11:49on the surface of the moon,
  1704. 1:11:50and only the absent stage would go back up
  1705. 1:11:53into lunar orbit where it would rendezvous
  1706. 1:11:55with the command module.
  1707. 1:11:56Here what we're doing is we have a single stage lunar lander
  1708. 1:12:00that carries down enough propellant
  1709. 1:12:02so that it can bring the whole thing back up
  1710. 1:12:04so that it can be reused over and over.
  1711. 1:12:07And the point of doing that, of course,
  1712. 1:12:08is to reduce cost so that you can make lunar missions
  1713. 1:12:12more affordable over time,
  1714. 1:12:14which is, that's one of NASA's big objectives
  1715. 1:12:17because this time the whole point of Artemis
  1716. 1:12:21is go back to the moon, but this time to stay.
  1717. 1:12:25So, you know, back in the Apollo program,
  1718. 1:12:28we went to the moon six times and then ended the program
  1719. 1:12:31and it really was too expensive to continue.
  1720. 1:12:36- And so there's a few questions there,
  1721. 1:12:38but one is how do you stay on the moon?
  1722. 1:12:40What ideas do you have about-
  1723. 1:12:43- Yeah.
  1724. 1:12:44- Like sustaining life where a few folks can stay there
  1725. 1:12:49for prolonged periods of time?
  1726. 1:12:51- Well, one of the things we're working on
  1727. 1:12:55is using lunar resources like lunar regolith
  1728. 1:13:00to manufacture commodities and even solar cells
  1729. 1:13:05on the surface of the moon.
  1730. 1:13:06We've already built a solar cell
  1731. 1:13:09that is completely made from lunar regolith stimulant,
  1732. 1:13:13and this solar cell is only about 7% power efficient.
  1733. 1:13:19So it's very inefficient compared to you know,
  1734. 1:13:21the more advanced solar cells that we make here on earth.
  1735. 1:13:25But if you can figure out how
  1736. 1:13:27to make a practical solar cell factory
  1737. 1:13:31that you can land on the surface of the moon,
  1738. 1:13:33and then the raw material for those solar cells
  1739. 1:13:37is simply lunar regolith,
  1740. 1:13:39then you can just you know, continue
  1741. 1:13:41to churn out solar cells on the surface of the moon,
  1742. 1:13:45have lots of power on the surface of the moon.
  1743. 1:13:48That will make it easier for people to live on the moon.
  1744. 1:13:51Similarly, we're working on extracting
  1745. 1:13:55oxygen from lunar regolith.
  1746. 1:13:58So lunar regolith by weight has a lot of oxygen in it.
  1747. 1:14:02It's bound very tightly, you know,
  1748. 1:14:04as oxides with other elements.
  1749. 1:14:06And so you have to separate the oxygen,
  1750. 1:14:10which is very energy intensive.
  1751. 1:14:12So that also could work together with the solar cells.
  1752. 1:14:17But if you can,
  1753. 1:14:18and then ultimately we may be able
  1754. 1:14:22to find practical quantities of ice
  1755. 1:14:26in the permanently shadowed craters
  1756. 1:14:29on the poles of the moon.
  1757. 1:14:31And we know there is ice water
  1758. 1:14:35in those, or water ice in those craters.
  1759. 1:14:39And we know that we can break that down with electrolysis
  1760. 1:14:44into hydrogen and oxygen.
  1761. 1:14:46And then you'd not only have oxygen,
  1762. 1:14:48but you'd also have a very good high efficiency propellant
  1763. 1:14:54fuel in hydrogen.
  1764. 1:14:57So there's a lot we can do
  1765. 1:14:58to make the moon more sustainable over time.
  1766. 1:15:02But the very first step, the thing,
  1767. 1:15:04the kind of gate that all of that has to go through
  1768. 1:15:07is we need to be able to land cargo and humans
  1769. 1:15:13on the surface of the moon at an acceptable cost.
  1770. 1:15:16- To fast forward a little bit,
  1771. 1:15:18is there any chance Jeff Bezos steps foot
  1772. 1:15:21on the moon and on Mars?
  1773. 1:15:25One or the other, or both?
  1774. 1:15:27- It's very unlikely.
  1775. 1:15:29I think it's probably something that gets done
  1776. 1:15:33by future generations by the time it gets to me.
  1777. 1:15:34I think in my lifetime that's probably gonna be done
  1778. 1:15:38by professional astronauts.
  1779. 1:15:40Sadly, I would love to sign up for that mission.
  1780. 1:15:43So don't count me out yet, Lex, you know,
  1781. 1:15:46give me a fighting shot here maybe.
  1782. 1:15:50But I think if we are placing reasonable bets
  1783. 1:15:54on such a thing,
  1784. 1:15:56in my lifetime, that will continue to be done
  1785. 1:15:58by professional astronauts.
  1786. 1:15:59- Yeah, so these are risky, difficult missions.
  1787. 1:16:02- And probably missions that require a lot of training.
  1788. 1:16:05You know, you are going there for a very specific purpose
  1789. 1:16:08to do something.
  1790. 1:16:09We're gonna be able to do a lot on the moon too
  1791. 1:16:11with automation.
  1792. 1:16:13So, you know, in terms of setting up these factories
  1793. 1:16:15and doing all that, we are sophisticated enough now
  1794. 1:16:19with automation and we probably don't need humans
  1795. 1:16:21to tend those factories and machines.
  1796. 1:16:24So there's a lot that's gonna be done in both modes.
  1797. 1:16:28- So I have to ask the bigger picture question
  1798. 1:16:31about the two companies pushing humanity forward
  1799. 1:16:36out towards the stars, Blue Origin and SpaceX.
  1800. 1:16:39Are you competitors, collaborators?
  1801. 1:16:42Which, and to what degree?
  1802. 1:16:44- Well, I would say you know, just like the internet is big
  1803. 1:16:47and there are lots of winners at all scale levels.
  1804. 1:16:49I mean, there are half a dozen giant companies
  1805. 1:16:51that you know, the internet has made,
  1806. 1:16:54but they're a bunch of medium sized companies
  1807. 1:16:56and a bunch of small companies, all successful,
  1808. 1:16:58all with profits, dreams,
  1809. 1:17:00all driving great customer experiences.
  1810. 1:17:03That's what we wanna see in space.
  1811. 1:17:06That kind of dynamism and space is big.
  1812. 1:17:09There's room for a bunch of winners
  1813. 1:17:11and it's gonna happen at all skill levels.
  1814. 1:17:12And so you know, SpaceX is gonna be successful for sure.
  1815. 1:17:17I want Blue Origin to be successful
  1816. 1:17:20and I hope there are another you know,
  1817. 1:17:22five companies right behind us.
  1818. 1:17:25- But, you know, I spoke to Elon a few times recently
  1819. 1:17:28about you, about Blue Origin, and he was very positive
  1820. 1:17:32about you as a person and very supportive
  1821. 1:17:34of all the efforts you've been leading at Blue.
  1822. 1:17:37What's your thoughts?
  1823. 1:17:38You worked with a lot of leaders at Amazon, at Blue.
  1824. 1:17:42What's your thoughts about Elon as a human being
  1825. 1:17:44and a leader?
  1826. 1:17:46- Well, I don't really know Elon very well.
  1827. 1:17:49You know, I know his public persona,
  1828. 1:17:53but I also know you can't know anyone
  1829. 1:17:55by their public persona.
  1830. 1:17:57It's impossible.
  1831. 1:17:58I mean you may think you do,
  1832. 1:18:00but I guarantee you don't.
  1833. 1:18:02So I don't really know,
  1834. 1:18:03you know Elon way better than I do Lex,
  1835. 1:18:06but in terms of his, judging by the results,
  1836. 1:18:10he must be a very capable leader.
  1837. 1:18:13There's no way you could have you know, Tesla
  1838. 1:18:16and SpaceX without being a capable leader.
  1839. 1:18:19It's impossible.
  1840. 1:18:22- Yeah, I just, I hope you guys hang out sometimes,
  1841. 1:18:25shake hands, and sort of have a kind of friendship
  1842. 1:18:30that would inspire just the entirety of humanity.
  1843. 1:18:32'cause you, what you're doing
  1844. 1:18:34is like one of the big grand challenges ahead for humanity.
  1845. 1:18:40- Well, I agree with you
  1846. 1:18:41and I think in a lot of these endeavors,
  1847. 1:18:44we're very like-minded.
  1848. 1:18:45- Yeah.
  1849. 1:18:46- And so I think, you know,
  1850. 1:18:48I'm not saying we're identical,
  1851. 1:18:50but I think we're very like-minded.
  1852. 1:18:51And so I, you know, I love that idea.
  1853. 1:18:56- All right, going back to sexy pictures on your Instagram,
  1854. 1:18:58there's a video of you from the early days of Amazon
  1855. 1:19:03giving a tour of your quote sort of offices.
  1856. 1:19:06I think your dad is holding the camera.
  1857. 1:19:07- He is, yeah.
  1858. 1:19:08I know, right.
  1859. 1:19:10Yes.
  1860. 1:19:10This is what the giant orange extension cord and yeah.
  1861. 1:19:12- And you're like explaining the genius
  1862. 1:19:15of the extension cord and how this is a desk
  1863. 1:19:16and the CRT monitor and sort of
  1864. 1:19:21that's where all the magic happens.
  1865. 1:19:23I forget what your dad said,
  1866. 1:19:24but this is like the center of it all.
  1867. 1:19:27So what was it like,
  1868. 1:19:29what was going through your mind at that time?
  1869. 1:19:32You left a good job in New York and took this leap.
  1870. 1:19:36Were you excited?
  1871. 1:19:37Were you scared?
  1872. 1:19:38- So excited and scared.
  1873. 1:19:40Anxious, you know, thought the odds of success were low,
  1874. 1:19:43told all of our early investors
  1875. 1:19:45that I thought there was a 30% chance of success
  1876. 1:19:48by which I mean just be getting your money back.
  1877. 1:19:50Not like, not what actually happened.
  1878. 1:19:54Because that's the truth.
  1879. 1:19:55Every startup company is unlikely to work.
  1880. 1:19:58It's helpful to be in reality about that,
  1881. 1:20:02but that doesn't mean you can't be optimistic.
  1882. 1:20:05So you kind of have to have this duality in your head.
  1883. 1:20:07Like on the one hand,
  1884. 1:20:08you know what the baseline statistics say
  1885. 1:20:11about startup companies.
  1886. 1:20:14And the other hand you have to ignore all of that
  1887. 1:20:16and just be a hundred percent sure it's gonna work.
  1888. 1:20:19And you're doing both things at the same time.
  1889. 1:20:22You're holding that contradiction in your head.
  1890. 1:20:24But it was so, it was so exciting.
  1891. 1:20:26I love you know, every, from 1994
  1892. 1:20:30when the company was founded to 1995,
  1893. 1:20:33when we opened our doors
  1894. 1:20:35all the way until today, I find Amazon so exciting.
  1895. 1:20:40And that doesn't mean it's like full of pain,
  1896. 1:20:43full of problems, you know,
  1897. 1:20:45it's like there's so many things that need to be resolved
  1898. 1:20:49and worked and made better, and et cetera.
  1899. 1:20:52But on balance, it's so fun.
  1900. 1:20:55It's such a privilege.
  1901. 1:20:57It's been such a joy.
  1902. 1:20:58I feel so grateful that I've been part of that journey.
  1903. 1:21:03It's just been incredible.
  1904. 1:21:04- So in some sense, you don't want a single day of comfort.
  1905. 1:21:07You've written about this many times.
  1906. 1:21:10We'll talk about your writing,
  1907. 1:21:12which I would highly recommend people read
  1908. 1:21:14and just the letters to shareholders.
  1909. 1:21:17So you wrote up explaining the idea of day one thinking,
  1910. 1:21:21I think you first wrote about in 97 letters to shareholders.
  1911. 1:21:25Then you also, in a way wrote it about sad to say,
  1912. 1:21:30is your last letter to shareholders as CEO.
  1913. 1:21:35And you said that day two is stasis
  1914. 1:21:37followed by irrelevance,
  1915. 1:21:40followed by excruciating painful decline, followed by death.
  1916. 1:21:45And that is why it's always day one.
  1917. 1:21:49Can you explain this day one thing?
  1918. 1:21:52This is a really powerful way
  1919. 1:21:53to describe the beginning and the journey of Amazon.
  1920. 1:21:56- It's really a very simple,
  1921. 1:22:00and I think age old idea about renewal and rebirth.
  1922. 1:22:05And like every day is day one.
  1923. 1:22:08Every day you are deciding what you're gonna do.
  1924. 1:22:12And you are not trapped
  1925. 1:22:16by what you were or who you were,
  1926. 1:22:18or any self-consistency.
  1927. 1:22:20Self-consistency even can be a trap.
  1928. 1:22:23And so day one thinking is kind of,
  1929. 1:22:27we start fresh every day
  1930. 1:22:30and we get to make new decisions every day about invention,
  1931. 1:22:35about customers, about how we're going to operate,
  1932. 1:22:40what our, even as deeply as what our principles are.
  1933. 1:22:44We can go back to that.
  1934. 1:22:45It turns out we don't change those very often,
  1935. 1:22:48but we change them occasionally.
  1936. 1:22:50And when we work on programs at Amazon,
  1937. 1:22:56we often make a list of tenants.
  1938. 1:22:59And this, the tenants are kind of,
  1939. 1:23:02they're not principles.
  1940. 1:23:03They're a little more tactical than principles,
  1941. 1:23:05but it's kind of the main ideas
  1942. 1:23:08that we want this program to embody,
  1943. 1:23:10whatever those are.
  1944. 1:23:12And one of the things that we do
  1945. 1:23:15is we put, these are the tenets for this program.
  1946. 1:23:17And in parentheses we always put,
  1947. 1:23:19unless you know a better way.
  1948. 1:23:22And that idea, unless you know a better way,
  1949. 1:23:28is so important because you never want
  1950. 1:23:30to get trapped by dogma.
  1951. 1:23:33You never wanna get trapped by history.
  1952. 1:23:35It doesn't mean you discard history or ignore it.
  1953. 1:23:38There's so much value in what has worked in the past.
  1954. 1:23:42But you can't be blindly following what you've done.
  1955. 1:23:46And that's the heart of day one
  1956. 1:23:48is you're always starting fresh.
  1957. 1:23:51- And to the question of how to fend off day two,
  1958. 1:23:54you said such a question,
  1959. 1:23:55can't have a simple answer as you're saying,
  1960. 1:23:58there will be many elements, multiple paths, and many traps.
  1961. 1:24:01I don't know the whole answer,
  1962. 1:24:03but I may know bits of it.
  1963. 1:24:05Here's a starter pack of essentials.
  1964. 1:24:07Maybe others come to mind for day one, defense,
  1965. 1:24:10customer obsession, a skeptical view of proxies,
  1966. 1:24:14the eager adoption of external trends
  1967. 1:24:17and high velocity decision making.
  1968. 1:24:19So we talked about high velocity decision making,
  1969. 1:24:22that's more difficult than it sounds.
  1970. 1:24:24So maybe you can pick one that stands out to you
  1971. 1:24:28as you can comment on.
  1972. 1:24:29Eager adoption of external trends,
  1973. 1:24:32high velocity decision making,
  1974. 1:24:33skeptical view of proxies.
  1975. 1:24:35How do you fight off day two?
  1976. 1:24:36- Well, you know, I'll talk about,
  1977. 1:24:38because I think it's the one that is maybe in some ways
  1978. 1:24:41the hardest to understand is the skeptical view of proxies.
  1979. 1:24:49One of the things that happens in business,
  1980. 1:24:52probably anything that you're,
  1981. 1:24:54where you're you know, you have an ongoing program
  1982. 1:24:58and something is underway for a number of years,
  1983. 1:25:01is you develop certain things that you're managing to
  1984. 1:25:04like, let's say the typical case would be a metric.
  1985. 1:25:08And that metric isn't the real underlying thing.
  1986. 1:25:12And so you know, maybe the metric
  1987. 1:25:17is efficiency metric around customer contacts
  1988. 1:25:20per unit sold or something.
  1989. 1:25:22If you sell a million units,
  1990. 1:25:24how many customer contacts do you get?
  1991. 1:25:26Or how many returns do you get?
  1992. 1:25:28And so on and so on.
  1993. 1:25:29And so what happens is a little bit
  1994. 1:25:31of a kind of a inertia sets in
  1995. 1:25:36where somebody a long time ago invented that metric
  1996. 1:25:40and they invented that metric.
  1997. 1:25:42They decided we need to watch for you know,
  1998. 1:25:44customer returns per unit sold as an important metric.
  1999. 1:25:50But they had a reason why they chose that metric.
  2000. 1:25:53The person who invented that metric
  2001. 1:25:55and decided it was worth watching.
  2002. 1:25:57And then fast forward five years,
  2003. 1:25:59that metric is the proxy.
  2004. 1:26:01- The proxy for truth, I guess.
  2005. 1:26:03- The proxy for truth, the proxy for customer,
  2006. 1:26:06let's say in this case, it's a proxy for customer happiness.
  2007. 1:26:09And, but that metric is not actually customer happiness,
  2008. 1:26:12it's a proxy for customer happiness.
  2009. 1:26:15The person who invented the metric
  2010. 1:26:17understood that connection.
  2011. 1:26:20Five years later, a kind of inertia can set in
  2012. 1:26:25and you forget the truth
  2013. 1:26:29behind why you were watching that metric in the first place.
  2014. 1:26:32And the world shifts a little.
  2015. 1:26:34And now that proxy isn't as valuable as it used to be
  2016. 1:26:38or it's missing something.
  2017. 1:26:40And you have to be on alert for that.
  2018. 1:26:42You have to know, okay, this is,
  2019. 1:26:44I don't really care about this metric.
  2020. 1:26:46I care about customer happiness.
  2021. 1:26:49And this metric is worth putting energy into
  2022. 1:26:54and following and improving and scrutinizing
  2023. 1:26:58only in so much as it actually affects customer happiness.
  2024. 1:27:03And so you've gotta constantly be on guard.
  2025. 1:27:05And it's very, very common.
  2026. 1:27:07This is a nuanced problem.
  2027. 1:27:09It's very common, especially in large companies,
  2028. 1:27:12that they're managing to metrics
  2029. 1:27:14that they don't really understand.
  2030. 1:27:17They don't really know why they exist.
  2031. 1:27:19And the world may have shifted out from under them a little.
  2032. 1:27:22And the metrics are no longer as relevant as they were
  2033. 1:27:25when somebody 10 years earlier invented the metric.
  2034. 1:27:29- That is a nuance, but that's a big problem, right?
  2035. 1:27:33- It's a huge problem.
  2036. 1:27:34- That something so compelling
  2037. 1:27:36to have a nice metric to try to optimize.
  2038. 1:27:38- Yes.
  2039. 1:27:39And by the way, you do need metrics.
  2040. 1:27:41- Yes you do.
  2041. 1:27:42- You know, you can't ignore them, and want them,
  2042. 1:27:45but you just have to be constantly on guard.
  2043. 1:27:48This is, you know, a way to slip into day two thinking
  2044. 1:27:52would be to manage your business to metrics
  2045. 1:27:54that you don't really understand.
  2046. 1:27:56And you're not really sure why they were invented
  2047. 1:27:59in the first place,
  2048. 1:28:00and you're not sure they're still as relevant
  2049. 1:28:02as they used to be.
  2050. 1:28:03- What does it take to be the guy or gal
  2051. 1:28:05who brings up the point that this proxy might be outdated?
  2052. 1:28:09I guess what does it take to have a culture
  2053. 1:28:13that enables that in the meeting?
  2054. 1:28:14'Cause that's a very uncomfortable thing
  2055. 1:28:16to bring up at a meeting.
  2056. 1:28:18We all showed up here, it's a Friday.
  2057. 1:28:20- This is such,
  2058. 1:28:21you have just asked a million dollar question.
  2059. 1:28:25So this is what you're,
  2060. 1:28:27if I generalize what you're asking,
  2061. 1:28:31you are talking in general about truth telling.
  2062. 1:28:34- Yeah.
  2063. 1:28:36- And we humans are not really truth seeking animals.
  2064. 1:28:41We are social animals.
  2065. 1:28:43- Yeah, we are.
  2066. 1:28:44- And you know, take you back in time 10,000 years
  2067. 1:28:47and you're in a small village,
  2068. 1:28:49if you go along to get along, you can survive.
  2069. 1:28:53You can procreate.
  2070. 1:28:55If you're the village truth teller,
  2071. 1:28:58you might get clubbed to death in the middle of the night.
  2072. 1:29:01Truths are often, they don't want to be heard.
  2073. 1:29:05'Cause important truths can be uncomfortable,
  2074. 1:29:10they can be awkward, they can be exhausting.
  2075. 1:29:12- Impolite and all that kind of stuff.
  2076. 1:29:15- Yes, challenging.
  2077. 1:29:16They can make people defensive
  2078. 1:29:18even if that's not the intent.
  2079. 1:29:19But any high performing organization,
  2080. 1:29:22whether it's a sports team, a business, you know,
  2081. 1:29:24a political organization, an activist group,
  2082. 1:29:27I don't care what it is.
  2083. 1:29:29Any high performing organization
  2084. 1:29:32has to have mechanisms and a culture
  2085. 1:29:36that supports truth telling.
  2086. 1:29:38One of the things you have to do
  2087. 1:29:40is you have to talk about that.
  2088. 1:29:41And you have to talk about the fact
  2089. 1:29:42that it takes energy to do that.
  2090. 1:29:45And you have to talk to people,
  2091. 1:29:46you have to remind people it's okay that it's uncomfortable.
  2092. 1:29:50You have to literally tell people
  2093. 1:29:53it's not what we're designed to do as humans.
  2094. 1:29:56It's not really, it's kind of a side effect.
  2095. 1:29:59You know, we can do that,
  2096. 1:30:01but it's not how we survive.
  2097. 1:30:02We mostly survive by being social animals
  2098. 1:30:05and being cordial and cooperative.
  2099. 1:30:08And that's really important.
  2100. 1:30:10And so there's a, you know,
  2101. 1:30:12science is all about truth telling.
  2102. 1:30:14It's actually a very formal mechanism
  2103. 1:30:18for trying to tell the truth.
  2104. 1:30:22And even in science,
  2105. 1:30:24you find that it's hard to tell the truth.
  2106. 1:30:27Right.
  2107. 1:30:29Even, you know, you're supposed to have hypothesis
  2108. 1:30:31and test it and find data and reject the hypothesis,
  2109. 1:30:34and so on.
  2110. 1:30:36It's not easy.
  2111. 1:30:37- But even in science, there's like the senior scientists
  2112. 1:30:40and the junior scientists.
  2113. 1:30:41- Correct.
  2114. 1:30:42- And then there's a hierarchy of humans
  2115. 1:30:43where somehow seniority matters.
  2116. 1:30:46- Yes.
  2117. 1:30:47- In the scientific process, which is odd.
  2118. 1:30:49- And that's true inside companies too.
  2119. 1:30:52And so you wanna set up your culture
  2120. 1:30:55so that the most junior person
  2121. 1:30:58can overrule the most senior person if they have data.
  2122. 1:31:04And that really is about trying to you know,
  2123. 1:31:09there are little things you can do.
  2124. 1:31:10So for example, in every meeting that I attend,
  2125. 1:31:13I always speak last.
  2126. 1:31:16And I know from experience that,
  2127. 1:31:21you know, if I speak first,
  2128. 1:31:24even very strong-willed, highly intelligent,
  2129. 1:31:31high judgment participants in that meeting
  2130. 1:31:35will wonder, well if Jeff thinks that
  2131. 1:31:38I came in this meeting thinking one thing,
  2132. 1:31:41but maybe I'm not right.
  2133. 1:31:44And so you can do little things
  2134. 1:31:47like if you're the most senior person in the room, go last.
  2135. 1:31:52Let everybody else go first.
  2136. 1:31:53In fact, ideally let's try to have the most junior person
  2137. 1:31:57go first and the second and try to go in order
  2138. 1:32:00of seniority so that you can hear everyone's opinion
  2139. 1:32:05in a kind of unfiltered way.
  2140. 1:32:07Because we really do,
  2141. 1:32:09we actually literally change our opinions.
  2142. 1:32:11If somebody who you really respect says something,
  2143. 1:32:15it makes you change your mind a little.
  2144. 1:32:17- So you're saying implicitly or explicitly
  2145. 1:32:21give permission for people to have a strong opinion
  2146. 1:32:25as long as it's backed by data.
  2147. 1:32:27- Yes.
  2148. 1:32:28And sometimes it can even, by the way,
  2149. 1:32:30a lot of our most powerful truths turn out to be hunches.
  2150. 1:32:34They turn out to be based on anecdotes.
  2151. 1:32:36They're intuition based.
  2152. 1:32:38And sometimes you don't even have strong data,
  2153. 1:32:41but you may know the person well enough
  2154. 1:32:44to trust their judgment.
  2155. 1:32:45You may feel yourself leaning in.
  2156. 1:32:47It may resonate with a set of anecdotes you have.
  2157. 1:32:51And then you may be able to say you know,
  2158. 1:32:53something about that feels right.
  2159. 1:32:56Let's go collect some data on that.
  2160. 1:32:58Let's try to see if we can actually know whether it's right.
  2161. 1:33:02But for now, let's not disregard it
  2162. 1:33:05'cause it feels right.
  2163. 1:33:06You can also fight inherent bias.
  2164. 1:33:08There's an optimism bias.
  2165. 1:33:10Like if there are two interpretations of a new set of data
  2166. 1:33:14and one of them is happy and one of 'em is unhappy,
  2167. 1:33:18it's a little dangerous to jump to the conclusion
  2168. 1:33:20that the happy interpretation is right.
  2169. 1:33:23You may want to sort of compensate for that human bias
  2170. 1:33:27of looking for you know, trying to find the silver lining
  2171. 1:33:31and say look, that might be good,
  2172. 1:33:32but I'm gonna go with it's bad for now until we're sure.
  2173. 1:33:36- So speaking of happiness bias, data collection,
  2174. 1:33:40and anecdotes, you have to,
  2175. 1:33:42how's that for a transition?
  2176. 1:33:45You have to tell me the story of the call you made,
  2177. 1:33:51the customer service call you made
  2178. 1:33:53to demonstrate a point about wait times.
  2179. 1:33:57- Yeah, this is very early in the history of Amazon.
  2180. 1:34:00And we were going over a weekly business review
  2181. 1:34:05and a set of documents, and I have a saying,
  2182. 1:34:09which is when the data and the anecdotes disagree,
  2183. 1:34:12the anecdotes are usually right.
  2184. 1:34:14And it doesn't mean you just slavishly
  2185. 1:34:17go follow the anecdotes then.
  2186. 1:34:19It means you go examine the data.
  2187. 1:34:20'Cause the data,
  2188. 1:34:21and it's usually not that the data is being miscollected,
  2189. 1:34:26it's usually that you're not measuring the right thing.
  2190. 1:34:30And so, you know, if you have a bunch of customers
  2191. 1:34:32complaining about something,
  2192. 1:34:34and at the same time, you know,
  2193. 1:34:37your metrics look like why are,
  2194. 1:34:38they shouldn't be complaining.
  2195. 1:34:41You should doubt the metrics.
  2196. 1:34:43And an early example of this was we had metrics
  2197. 1:34:48that showed that our customers were waiting,
  2198. 1:34:51I think less than I don't know, 60 seconds
  2199. 1:34:54when they called a 1-800 number to get,
  2200. 1:34:57you know, phone customer service.
  2201. 1:34:59The wait time was supposed to be less than 60 seconds.
  2202. 1:35:02And, but we had a lot of complaints
  2203. 1:35:04that it was longer than that.
  2204. 1:35:06And anecdotally it seemed longer than that.
  2205. 1:35:09Like, you know, I would call customer service myself.
  2206. 1:35:12And so one day we're in a meeting, we're going
  2207. 1:35:14through the WBR and the weekly business review,
  2208. 1:35:17and we get to this metric in the deck,
  2209. 1:35:20and the guy who leads customer service
  2210. 1:35:23is to fit in the metric.
  2211. 1:35:24And I said, okay,
  2212. 1:35:25let's call picked up the phone.
  2213. 1:35:31And I dialed the 1-800 number and called customer service.
  2214. 1:35:34And we just waited in silence.
  2215. 1:35:38- What did it turn out to be, like a couple minutes?
  2216. 1:35:40- Oh, it was really long.
  2217. 1:35:41More than 10 minutes, I think.
  2218. 1:35:42- Oh wow.
  2219. 1:35:43- I mean it was many minutes.
  2220. 1:35:45And so, you know, it dramatically made the point
  2221. 1:35:47that something was wrong with the data collection.
  2222. 1:35:50We weren't measuring the right thing.
  2223. 1:35:52And that, you know, set off a whole chain of events
  2224. 1:35:54where we started measuring it right.
  2225. 1:35:56And that's an example by the way of truth telling,
  2226. 1:36:00is like that's an uncomfortable thing to do.
  2227. 1:36:03But you have to seek truth even when it's uncomfortable
  2228. 1:36:09and you have to get people's attention
  2229. 1:36:11and they have to buy into it,
  2230. 1:36:13and they have to get energized around really fixing things.
  2231. 1:36:16- So that speaks to the obsession
  2232. 1:36:19with the customer experience.
  2233. 1:36:19So one of the defining aspects of your approach
  2234. 1:36:22to Amazon is just being obsessed
  2235. 1:36:25with making customers happy.
  2236. 1:36:27I think companies sometimes say that,
  2237. 1:36:30but Amazon is really obsessed with that.
  2238. 1:36:34I think there's something really profound to that,
  2239. 1:36:37which is seeing the world through the eyes of the customer,
  2240. 1:36:39like the customer experience, truly like being,
  2241. 1:36:43that's using the product, that's enjoying the product.
  2242. 1:36:46They like the subtle little things
  2243. 1:36:50that make up their experience.
  2244. 1:36:52Like how do you optimize those?
  2245. 1:36:55- This is another really good
  2246. 1:37:00and kind of deep question
  2247. 1:37:02because there are big things
  2248. 1:37:04that are really important to manage.
  2249. 1:37:07And then there are small things internally in Amazon,
  2250. 1:37:11we call them paper cuts.
  2251. 1:37:13So we have, we're always working on the big things,
  2252. 1:37:16like if you ask me,
  2253. 1:37:17and most of the energy goes into the big things
  2254. 1:37:20as it should.
  2255. 1:37:21So, and you can identify the big things.
  2256. 1:37:23And and I would encourage anybody
  2257. 1:37:25if anybody listening to this as a entrepreneur,
  2258. 1:37:29has a small business, whatever,
  2259. 1:37:33you know, think about the things
  2260. 1:37:34that are not going to change over 10 years.
  2261. 1:37:37And those are probably the big things.
  2262. 1:37:38So like I know in our retail business at Amazon,
  2263. 1:37:4310 years from now,
  2264. 1:37:44customers are still gonna want low prices.
  2265. 1:37:45I know they're still gonna want fast delivery.
  2266. 1:37:47And I just know they're still gonna want big selection.
  2267. 1:37:50So it's impossible to imagine a scenario
  2268. 1:37:53where 10 years from now I say,
  2269. 1:37:55where a customer says, I love Amazon,
  2270. 1:37:57I just wish the prices were a little higher.
  2271. 1:37:59Or I love Amazon,
  2272. 1:38:00I just wish you delivered a little more slowly.
  2273. 1:38:02So when you identify the big things,
  2274. 1:38:05you can tell they're worth putting energy into
  2275. 1:38:08because they're stable in time.
  2276. 1:38:10Okay, but you're asking about something a little different,
  2277. 1:38:14which is in every customer experience,
  2278. 1:38:16there are those big things.
  2279. 1:38:18And by the way, it's astonishingly hard to focus
  2280. 1:38:20even on just the big things.
  2281. 1:38:22So even though they're obvious,
  2282. 1:38:24they're really hard to focus on.
  2283. 1:38:27But in addition to that,
  2284. 1:38:28there are all these little tiny
  2285. 1:38:30customer experience deficiencies.
  2286. 1:38:33And we call those paper cuts
  2287. 1:38:35and we make long lists of them.
  2288. 1:38:38And then we have dedicated teams that go fix paper cuts
  2289. 1:38:44because the teams working on the big issues
  2290. 1:38:47never get to the paper cuts
  2291. 1:38:49and they never work their way down the list to get to,
  2292. 1:38:52they're working on big things as they should
  2293. 1:38:56and as you want them to.
  2294. 1:38:58And so you need special teams
  2295. 1:39:01who are charged with fixing paper cuts.
  2296. 1:39:04- Well, where would you put, on the paper cuts spectrum,
  2297. 1:39:08the buy now with one click button,
  2298. 1:39:10which is I think pretty genius.
  2299. 1:39:12So to me like, okay,
  2300. 1:39:14my interaction with things I love on the internet,
  2301. 1:39:18there's things I do a lot.
  2302. 1:39:19I may be representing regular human,
  2303. 1:39:22I would love for those things to be frictionless.
  2304. 1:39:25For example, booking airline tickets.
  2305. 1:39:28Just saying, but you know, it's buying a thing
  2306. 1:39:35with one click, making that experience frictionless,
  2307. 1:39:38intuitive, all aspects of that.
  2308. 1:39:41Like that just fundamentally makes my life better.
  2309. 1:39:46Not just in terms of efficiency,
  2310. 1:39:47in terms of some kind of-
  2311. 1:39:49- Cognitive load.
  2312. 1:39:50- Yeah, cognitive load and inner peace and happiness.
  2313. 1:39:53First of all, buying stuff isn't a pleasant experience.
  2314. 1:39:58Having enough money to buy a thing
  2315. 1:40:01and then buying it is a pleasant experience.
  2316. 1:40:04And like having pain around that is somehow
  2317. 1:40:06just you're ruining a beautiful experience.
  2318. 1:40:10And I guess all I'm saying
  2319. 1:40:12as a person who loves good ideas, is that a paper cut,
  2320. 1:40:16a solution to a paper cut?
  2321. 1:40:17- Yes.
  2322. 1:40:18So it's probably, that particular thing
  2323. 1:40:20is probably a solution to a number of paper cuts.
  2324. 1:40:23So if you go back and look at our order pipeline
  2325. 1:40:25and how people shopped on Amazon,
  2326. 1:40:27before we invented 1-click shopping,
  2327. 1:40:30there were a whole, there was more friction.
  2328. 1:40:32There was a whole series of paper cuts
  2329. 1:40:36and that invention eliminated a bunch of paper cuts.
  2330. 1:40:40And I think you're absolutely right by the way,
  2331. 1:40:44that there, when you come up with something
  2332. 1:40:47like 1-click shopping,
  2333. 1:40:48again, this is like so ingrained in people now,
  2334. 1:40:51I'm impressed that you even notice it.
  2335. 1:40:54I mean, most people-
  2336. 1:40:55- Every time I click the button.
  2337. 1:40:56- I just, surge of happiness.
  2338. 1:41:00- This, there is in the perfect invention
  2339. 1:41:03for the perfect moment, in the perfect context,
  2340. 1:41:06there is real beauty.
  2341. 1:41:08- Yeah.
  2342. 1:41:10- It is actual beauty.
  2343. 1:41:11And it feels good.
  2344. 1:41:13It's emotional, it's emotional for the inventor,
  2345. 1:41:16it's emotional for the team that builds it.
  2346. 1:41:18It's emotional for the customer.
  2347. 1:41:20It's a big deal.
  2348. 1:41:21And you can feel those things.
  2349. 1:41:23- But to keep coming up with that idea,
  2350. 1:41:26with those kinds of ideas,
  2351. 1:41:27I guess is the the day one thinking effort.
  2352. 1:41:28- Yeah, and you need a big group of people
  2353. 1:41:32who feel that kind of satisfaction
  2354. 1:41:35with creating that kind of beauty.
  2355. 1:41:38- There's a lot of books written about you.
  2356. 1:41:41There's a book Invent and Wander
  2357. 1:41:43where Walter Isaacson does an intro.
  2358. 1:41:46It's mostly collective writings of yours.
  2359. 1:41:48I've read that.
  2360. 1:41:49I also recommend people check out the Founders Podcast.
  2361. 1:41:53That covers you a lot and it does different analysis
  2362. 1:41:56of different business advice you've given over the years.
  2363. 1:42:00I bring all that up because I saw that there,
  2364. 1:42:05I mentioned that you said that books are an antidote
  2365. 1:42:07for short attention spans.
  2366. 1:42:10And I forget how it was phrased,
  2367. 1:42:13but that when you were thinking about the Kindle,
  2368. 1:42:15that you are thinking about how technology changes us.
  2369. 1:42:21Yeah.
  2370. 1:42:22- We co-evolve with our tools.
  2371. 1:42:26So, you know, we invent new tools
  2372. 1:42:29and then our tools change us.
  2373. 1:42:30- Which is fascinating to think about.
  2374. 1:42:32- It goes in a circle.
  2375. 1:42:33- And there's some aspect, you know,
  2376. 1:42:35even just inside business
  2377. 1:42:37where you don't just make the customer happy,
  2378. 1:42:40but you also have to think about like
  2379. 1:42:41where is this going to take humanity
  2380. 1:42:44if you zoom out a bit.
  2381. 1:42:45- A hundred percent.
  2382. 1:42:47And you know, you can feel in your brain,
  2383. 1:42:53brains are plastic,
  2384. 1:42:55and you can feel your brain getting reprogrammed.
  2385. 1:42:57I remember the first time this happened to me
  2386. 1:43:00was when Tetris, it first came on the scene.
  2387. 1:43:04I'm sure you've had,
  2388. 1:43:06anybody who's been a game player has this experience
  2389. 1:43:09where you close your eyes to lay down to go to sleep
  2390. 1:43:12and you see all the little blocks moving.
  2391. 1:43:16And you can, you're kind of rotating them in your mind
  2392. 1:43:19and you can just tell as you walk around the world
  2393. 1:43:21that you have rewired your brain to play Tetris.
  2394. 1:43:25And, but that happens with everything.
  2395. 1:43:30And so, you know, one of the, I think we still
  2396. 1:43:34have yet to see the full repercussions of this, I fear.
  2397. 1:43:38But I think one of the things that we've done online,
  2398. 1:43:42you know, and largely because of social media
  2399. 1:43:44is we have trained our brains to be really good
  2400. 1:43:47at processing super short form content.
  2401. 1:43:51And, you know, your podcast flies in the face of this.
  2402. 1:43:55You know, you do these long format things
  2403. 1:43:58and reading books do too.
  2404. 1:44:00Reading books is a long format thing.
  2405. 1:44:03And we all do more of if you,
  2406. 1:44:05if something is convenient, we do more of it.
  2407. 1:44:09And so when you make tools,
  2408. 1:44:11you know that we carry around a little,
  2409. 1:44:15we carry around in our pocket a phone.
  2410. 1:44:17And one of the things that phone does
  2411. 1:44:19for the most part is it is an attention shortening device
  2412. 1:44:23because most of the things we do on our phone
  2413. 1:44:25shorten our attention spans.
  2414. 1:44:27And I'm not even gonna say we know for sure that that's bad,
  2415. 1:44:30but I do think it's happening.
  2416. 1:44:31That's one of the ways we're co-evolving with that tool.
  2417. 1:44:34But I think it's important to spend some of your time
  2418. 1:44:37and some of your life doing long attention span things.
  2419. 1:44:41- Yeah, I think you've spoken about the value
  2420. 1:44:45in your own life of focus,
  2421. 1:44:47of singular focus on a thing for prolonged periods of time.
  2422. 1:44:50And that's certainly what books do
  2423. 1:44:52and that's certainly what that piece of technology does.
  2424. 1:44:55But I bring all that up to ask you about another piece
  2425. 1:44:59of technology, AI that has the potential
  2426. 1:45:03to have a various trajectories
  2427. 1:45:07to have an impact on human civilization.
  2428. 1:45:10How do you think AI will change us?
  2429. 1:45:14- You're talking about you know, generative AI,
  2430. 1:45:17large language models, things like ChatGPT
  2431. 1:45:20and its soon successors,
  2432. 1:45:25and these are incredibly powerful technologies.
  2433. 1:45:29To believe otherwise is to bury her head in the sand,
  2434. 1:45:34soon to be even more powerful.
  2435. 1:45:41It's interesting to me that that large language models
  2436. 1:45:46in their current form are not inventions,
  2437. 1:45:49they're discoveries.
  2438. 1:45:52You know, the telescope was an invention,
  2439. 1:45:55but looking through it at Jupiter,
  2440. 1:45:59knowing that it had moons was a discovery.
  2441. 1:46:03My God, it has moons.
  2442. 1:46:06And that's what Galileo did.
  2443. 1:46:09And so this is closer on that spectrum of invention.
  2444. 1:46:13You know, we know exactly what happens with a 787.
  2445. 1:46:17It's an engineered object.
  2446. 1:46:19We designed it, we know how it behaves.
  2447. 1:46:22We don't want any surprises.
  2448. 1:46:24Large language models are much more like discoveries.
  2449. 1:46:28We're constantly getting surprised by their capabilities.
  2450. 1:46:31They're not really engineered objects.
  2451. 1:46:35Then you know, you have this debate
  2452. 1:46:39about whether they're gonna be good for humanity
  2453. 1:46:41or bad for humanity.
  2454. 1:46:45You know, even specialized AI
  2455. 1:46:49could be very bad for humanity.
  2456. 1:46:51I mean, you know, just regular machine learning models
  2457. 1:46:55that can make you know, certain weapons of war
  2458. 1:47:00that could be incredibly destructive are very powerful.
  2459. 1:47:04And they're not general AIs, they're just,
  2460. 1:47:07they could just be very smart weapons.
  2461. 1:47:12And so we have to think about all of those things.
  2462. 1:47:17I'm very optimistic about this.
  2463. 1:47:20So even in the face of all this uncertainty,
  2464. 1:47:24my own view is that these powerful tools
  2465. 1:47:30are much more likely to help us and save us even
  2466. 1:47:35than they are to unbalance, hurt us, and destroy us.
  2467. 1:47:39I think you know, we humans have a lot of ways of,
  2468. 1:47:42we can make ourselves go extinct.
  2469. 1:47:44You know, these things may help us not do that.
  2470. 1:47:47You know, so they may actually save us.
  2471. 1:47:50So the people who are you know, overly concerned,
  2472. 1:47:54in my view, overly concerned.
  2473. 1:47:55It's a valid debate.
  2474. 1:47:58I think that they may be missing part of the equation,
  2475. 1:48:01which is how helpful they could be
  2476. 1:48:03in making sure we don't destroy ourselves.
  2477. 1:48:07I don't know if you saw the movie Oppenheimer,
  2478. 1:48:11but to me, first of all, I loved the movie
  2479. 1:48:15and I thought the best part of the movie
  2480. 1:48:17is this bureaucrat played by Robert Downey Jr.
  2481. 1:48:22who you know, some of the people I've talked to
  2482. 1:48:24think that's the most boring part of the movie.
  2483. 1:48:26I thought it was the most fascinating
  2484. 1:48:28because what's going on here
  2485. 1:48:31is you realize we have invented these awesome, destructive,
  2486. 1:48:36powerful technologies called nuclear weapons
  2487. 1:48:40and they're managed and you know, we humans are,
  2488. 1:48:47we're not really capable of wielding those weapons.
  2489. 1:48:52We're, you know, that's what he represented
  2490. 1:48:54in that movie is here's this guy
  2491. 1:48:58who is just, he wrongly thinks, he's like being so petty.
  2492. 1:49:03He thinks that he said something,
  2493. 1:49:05that Oppenheimer said something bad to Einstein about him.
  2494. 1:49:08They didn't talk about him at all,
  2495. 1:49:09as you find out in the final scene of the movie.
  2496. 1:49:12And yet he spent his career trying to be vengeful
  2497. 1:49:17and petty.
  2498. 1:49:19And that's the problem.
  2499. 1:49:21We as a species are not really sophisticated enough
  2500. 1:49:29and mature enough to handle these technologies.
  2501. 1:49:32And so, and by the way, before you get to general AI
  2502. 1:49:36and the possibility of AI having agency
  2503. 1:49:39and there's a lot of things would have to happen,
  2504. 1:49:41but there's so much benefit that's gonna come
  2505. 1:49:44from these technologies in the meantime,
  2506. 1:49:46even before they're, you know, general AI
  2507. 1:49:49in terms of better medicines
  2508. 1:49:51and better tools to develop more technologies, and so on.
  2509. 1:49:55I think it's an incredible moment to be alive
  2510. 1:49:59and to witness the transformations that are gonna happen.
  2511. 1:50:02How quickly will happen no one knows.
  2512. 1:50:04But over the next 10 years and 20 years,
  2513. 1:50:06I think we're gonna see really remarkable advances.
  2514. 1:50:10And I personally am very excited about it.
  2515. 1:50:12- First of all, really interesting to say
  2516. 1:50:14that it's discoveries that it's true
  2517. 1:50:18that we don't know the limits of what's possible
  2518. 1:50:22with the current language models.
  2519. 1:50:24- We don't.
  2520. 1:50:24- And like it could be a few tricks and hacks
  2521. 1:50:27here and there that that open doors
  2522. 1:50:31to whole entire new possibilities.
  2523. 1:50:33- We do know that humans are doing something different
  2524. 1:50:37from these models in part because
  2525. 1:50:42you know, we're so power efficient.
  2526. 1:50:44You know, the human brain does remarkable things
  2527. 1:50:48and it does it on about 20 watts of power.
  2528. 1:50:51And you know, the AI techniques we use today
  2529. 1:50:56use many kilowatts of power to do equivalent tasks.
  2530. 1:50:59So there's something interesting
  2531. 1:51:00about the way the human brain does this
  2532. 1:51:02and also we don't need as much data.
  2533. 1:51:04So, you know, like self-driving cars are,
  2534. 1:51:08they have to drive billions and billions of miles
  2535. 1:51:11to try to learn how to drive.
  2536. 1:51:13And you know, your average 16-year-old
  2537. 1:51:15figures it out with many fewer miles.
  2538. 1:51:19So there are still some tricks I think
  2539. 1:51:21that we have yet to learn.
  2540. 1:51:23I don't think we've learned the last trick.
  2541. 1:51:26I don't think it's just a question of scaling things up,
  2542. 1:51:30but what's interesting is that just scaling things up,
  2543. 1:51:33and I put just in quotes because it's actually hard
  2544. 1:51:35to scale things up,
  2545. 1:51:36but just scaling things up also appears
  2546. 1:51:38to pay huge dividends.
  2547. 1:51:40- Yeah, and there's some more nuanced aspect
  2548. 1:51:43about human beings that's interesting.
  2549. 1:51:44If it's able to accomplish like being truly original
  2550. 1:51:48and novel to you know, large language models,
  2551. 1:51:51being able to come up with some truly new ideas.
  2552. 1:51:55That's one.
  2553. 1:51:56And the other one is truth.
  2554. 1:51:59It seems that large language models are very good
  2555. 1:52:02at sounding like they're saying a true thing,
  2556. 1:52:06but they don't require or often have a grounding
  2557. 1:52:11in sort of a mathematical truth.
  2558. 1:52:14It can just, it basically is a very good bullshitter.
  2559. 1:52:17So if there's not enough data,
  2560. 1:52:19if there's not enough sort of data
  2561. 1:52:22in the training data about a particular topic,
  2562. 1:52:25it's just going to concoct accurate sounding narratives,
  2563. 1:52:30which is a very fascinating problem to try to solve.
  2564. 1:52:35How do you get language models
  2565. 1:52:37to infer what is true and not to sort of introspect?
  2566. 1:52:41- Yeah, they need to be taught to say
  2567. 1:52:43I don't know more often.
  2568. 1:52:46- Yeah.
  2569. 1:52:47- And I know of several humans
  2570. 1:52:48who could be taught that as well.
  2571. 1:52:50- Sure.
  2572. 1:52:51- And then the other stuff,
  2573. 1:52:52because you're still a bit involved in the Amazon side
  2574. 1:52:55with the AI things,
  2575. 1:52:56the other open question is what kind of products
  2576. 1:52:59are created from this?
  2577. 1:53:01- Oh, so many.
  2578. 1:53:02- Yeah.
  2579. 1:53:03- I mean, you know, just to,
  2580. 1:53:05we have Alexa and Echo and Alexa has you know,
  2581. 1:53:10hundreds of millions of installed base, you know, inputs.
  2582. 1:53:15And so there's, you know, there's Alexa everywhere
  2583. 1:53:18and guess what Alexa is about to get a lot smarter.
  2584. 1:53:20- Yeah.
  2585. 1:53:21- And so that's really you know,
  2586. 1:53:24from a product point of view, that's super exciting.
  2587. 1:53:27- There's so many opportunities there.
  2588. 1:53:28- So many opportunities.
  2589. 1:53:30Shopping assistant, you know,
  2590. 1:53:32like all that stuff is amazing.
  2591. 1:53:33And AWS you know, we're building Titan,
  2592. 1:53:36which is our foundational model.
  2593. 1:53:38We're also building Bedrock,
  2594. 1:53:40which our corporate clients at AWS, our enterprise clients,
  2595. 1:53:47they want to be able to use these powerful models
  2596. 1:53:49with their own corporate data
  2597. 1:53:51Without accidentally contributing their corporate data
  2598. 1:53:55to that model.
  2599. 1:53:57And so those are the tools we're building
  2600. 1:53:59for them with Bedrock.
  2601. 1:54:00So there's tremendous opportunity here.
  2602. 1:54:02- Yeah, the security, the privacy,
  2603. 1:54:04all those things are fascinating of how to,
  2604. 1:54:06'cause so much value can be gained
  2605. 1:54:08by training on private data
  2606. 1:54:09that you want to keep the secure.
  2607. 1:54:11It's a fascinating technical problem.
  2608. 1:54:13- Yes.
  2609. 1:54:14This is a very challenging technical problem
  2610. 1:54:17and it's one that we're you know, making progress on
  2611. 1:54:18and dedicated to solving for our customers.
  2612. 1:54:20- Do you think there will be a day
  2613. 1:54:23when humans and robots maybe Alexa
  2614. 1:54:25have a romantic relationship?
  2615. 1:54:27Like in the movie Her.
  2616. 1:54:29- Well, I mean, I think-
  2617. 1:54:30- I'm just brainstorming products here.
  2618. 1:54:32- If you look at the spectrum of human variety
  2619. 1:54:35and what people like you know, sexual variety.
  2620. 1:54:37- Yes.
  2621. 1:54:39- You know, there are people who like everything.
  2622. 1:54:41So the answer to your question has to be yes.
  2623. 1:54:43- Okay.
  2624. 1:54:43- I don't know how-
  2625. 1:54:45- I guess I'm asking when?
  2626. 1:54:46- I don't know how widespread that will be.
  2627. 1:54:47- All right.
  2628. 1:54:48- But it will happen.
  2629. 1:54:49- I was just asking when for a friend, but it's all right.
  2630. 1:54:53Moving on.
  2631. 1:54:55Next question.
  2632. 1:54:56What's a perfectly productive day in the life of Jeff Bezos?
  2633. 1:55:01You're one of the most productive humans in the world.
  2634. 1:55:04- Well, I first of all,
  2635. 1:55:05I get up in the morning and I putter.
  2636. 1:55:07I like have a coffee.
  2637. 1:55:08- Can you define putter?
  2638. 1:55:11- Just like I slowly move around.
  2639. 1:55:14I'm not as productive as you might think I am.
  2640. 1:55:17I mean, 'cause I do believe in wandering
  2641. 1:55:19and I sort of I, you know, I read my phone for a while.
  2642. 1:55:23I read newspapers for a while.
  2643. 1:55:26I chat with Lauren, I drink my first coffee.
  2644. 1:55:30So I kind of, I move pretty slowly
  2645. 1:55:33in the first couple of hours.
  2646. 1:55:35I get up early just naturally.
  2647. 1:55:37And then, you know, I exercise most days
  2648. 1:55:42and most days it's not that hard for me.
  2649. 1:55:44Some days it's really hard and I do it anyway.
  2650. 1:55:47I don't want to you know, and it's painful.
  2651. 1:55:49And I'm like why am I here and I don't want to.
  2652. 1:55:51- Why am I here at the gym?
  2653. 1:55:53- Why am I here at the gym?
  2654. 1:55:54Why don't I do something else?
  2655. 1:55:56You know, it's not always easy.
  2656. 1:55:59- What's your social motivation in those moments?
  2657. 1:56:02- I know that I'll feel better later if I do it.
  2658. 1:56:05And so like the real source of motivation,
  2659. 1:56:08I can tell the days when I skip it,
  2660. 1:56:11I'm not quite as alert.
  2661. 1:56:12I don't feel as good.
  2662. 1:56:14And then there's harder motivations.
  2663. 1:56:17It's longer term, you want to be healthy as you age,
  2664. 1:56:19you know, you want health span, you want, ideally,
  2665. 1:56:23you know, you want to be healthy and moving around
  2666. 1:56:26when you're 80 years old, you know,
  2667. 1:56:27and so there's a lot of,
  2668. 1:56:29but that kind of motivation is so far in the future.
  2669. 1:56:33It can be very hard to work in the second.
  2670. 1:56:35So thinking about the fact I'll feel better
  2671. 1:56:38in about four hours if I do it now.
  2672. 1:56:39I'll have more energy for the rest of my day
  2673. 1:56:41and so on and so on.
  2674. 1:56:42- What's your exercise routine?
  2675. 1:56:44Just to linger on that.
  2676. 1:56:45How much do you curl?
  2677. 1:56:46I mean, what are we talking about here?
  2678. 1:56:49That's all I do at the gym.
  2679. 1:56:50So I just-
  2680. 1:56:51- My routine, you know, on a good day,
  2681. 1:56:55I do about half an hour of cardio
  2682. 1:56:58and I do about 45 minutes of weightlifting,
  2683. 1:57:01resistance training of some kind, mostly weights.
  2684. 1:57:04I have a trainer who you know, I love
  2685. 1:57:08who pushes me, which is really helpful.
  2686. 1:57:11You know, I'll be like,
  2687. 1:57:13he'll say Jeff, you think you could,
  2688. 1:57:17can we go up on that weight a little bit?
  2689. 1:57:18And I'll think about it?
  2690. 1:57:21And I'll be like no, I don't think so.
  2691. 1:57:23And he'll look at me and say yeah, I think you can.
  2692. 1:57:30And of course he's right.
  2693. 1:57:31- Yeah, of course, of course.
  2694. 1:57:32- So it's cool to have somebody push you a little bit.
  2695. 1:57:34- But almost every day you do that?
  2696. 1:57:37- I do, almost every day. I do a little bit of cardio
  2697. 1:57:40and a little bit of weightlifting
  2698. 1:57:42and I rotate.
  2699. 1:57:44I do a pulling day and a pushing day and a leg day.
  2700. 1:57:46It's all pretty standard stuff.
  2701. 1:57:48- So puttering, coffee, gym.
  2702. 1:57:49- Puttering, coffee, gym, and then work.
  2703. 1:57:52- Work.
  2704. 1:57:53What's work look like?
  2705. 1:57:54What are the productive hours look like for you?
  2706. 1:57:58- I, you know, so a couple years ago
  2707. 1:58:00I left as the CEO of Amazon.
  2708. 1:58:03And I have never worked harder in my life.
  2709. 1:58:08I am working so hard and I'm mostly enjoying it.
  2710. 1:58:11But there are also some very painful days.
  2711. 1:58:14Most of my time is spent on Blue Origin
  2712. 1:58:18and I've been, I'm so deeply involved here now
  2713. 1:58:21for the last couple of years.
  2714. 1:58:23And in the big, I love it
  2715. 1:58:24and the small, there's all the frustrations
  2716. 1:58:26that come along with everything.
  2717. 1:58:27You know, we're trying to get to rate manufacturing
  2718. 1:58:30as we talked about.
  2719. 1:58:31That's super important.
  2720. 1:58:32We'll get there.
  2721. 1:58:33We just hired a new CEO,
  2722. 1:58:35a guy I've known for close to 15 years now,
  2723. 1:58:37a guy named Dave Limp, who I love.
  2724. 1:58:39He's amazing.
  2725. 1:58:40You know, so we're super lucky to have Dave
  2726. 1:58:43and you know, we're going to,
  2727. 1:58:45you're gonna see us move faster there.
  2728. 1:58:47But, so my day of work, you know, reading documents,
  2729. 1:58:51having meetings, sometimes in person, sometimes over Zoom,
  2730. 1:58:55depends on where I am.
  2731. 1:58:56It's all about you know, the technology.
  2732. 1:58:59It's about the organization.
  2733. 1:59:01It's about you know, I'm very,
  2734. 1:59:04I have architecture and technology meetings
  2735. 1:59:08almost every day on various subsystems inside the vehicle,
  2736. 1:59:13inside the engines.
  2737. 1:59:14It's super fun for me.
  2738. 1:59:16My favorite part of it is the technology.
  2739. 1:59:19My least favorite part of it is
  2740. 1:59:23you know, building organizations and so on.
  2741. 1:59:25That's important, but it's also my least favorite part.
  2742. 1:59:28So, you know, that's why they call it work.
  2743. 1:59:30You don't always get to do what you wanna do.
  2744. 1:59:31- How do you achieve time where you can focus
  2745. 1:59:34and truly think through problems?
  2746. 1:59:36- I do little thinking retreats.
  2747. 1:59:38So for, this is not the only,
  2748. 1:59:41I can do that all day long.
  2749. 1:59:42I'm very good at focusing.
  2750. 1:59:44I'm very good at you know,
  2751. 1:59:47I don't keep to a strict schedule.
  2752. 1:59:50Like my meetings often go longer than I plan
  2753. 1:59:53for them to because I believe in wandering,
  2754. 1:59:55My perfect meeting starts with a crisp document.
  2755. 1:59:59So the document should be written with such clarity
  2756. 2:00:02that it's like angels singing from on high.
  2757. 2:00:04I like a crisp document and a messy meeting.
  2758. 2:00:08And so the meeting is about like asking questions
  2759. 2:00:13that nobody knows the answer to
  2760. 2:00:14and trying to like wander your way to a solution.
  2761. 2:00:20And because like when that happens just right,
  2762. 2:00:27it makes all the other meetings worthwhile.
  2763. 2:00:29It feels good.
  2764. 2:00:30It has a kind of beauty to it.
  2765. 2:00:32It has an aesthetic beauty to it.
  2766. 2:00:34And you get real breakthroughs in meetings like that.
  2767. 2:00:37- Can you actually describe the crisp document?
  2768. 2:00:39Like this is one of the legendary aspects of Amazon,
  2769. 2:00:42of the way you approach meetings?
  2770. 2:00:44Is this the six page memo?
  2771. 2:00:47Maybe first describe the process
  2772. 2:00:50of running a meeting with memos.
  2773. 2:00:51- Meetings at Amazon and at Blue Origin are unusual.
  2774. 2:00:55When we get new,
  2775. 2:00:57when new people come in, like a new executive joins,
  2776. 2:01:00they're a little taken aback sometimes
  2777. 2:01:02because a typical meeting,
  2778. 2:01:05we'll start with a six page narratively structured memo
  2779. 2:01:09and we do study hall.
  2780. 2:01:11For 30 minutes, we sit there silently together
  2781. 2:01:14in the meeting and read.
  2782. 2:01:16- I love this.
  2783. 2:01:17- Take notes in the margins.
  2784. 2:01:19And then we discuss.
  2785. 2:01:22And the reason, by the way we do study,
  2786. 2:01:25you could say I would like everybody to read these memos
  2787. 2:01:27in advance, but the problem is people don't have time
  2788. 2:01:31to do that.
  2789. 2:01:32And they end up coming to the meeting
  2790. 2:01:34having only skimmed the memo or maybe not read it at all.
  2791. 2:01:37And they're trying to catch up.
  2792. 2:01:38And they're also bluffing like they were in college
  2793. 2:01:41having pretended to do the reading.
  2794. 2:01:42- Yeah,
  2795. 2:01:43Exactly.
  2796. 2:01:44- It's better just to carve out the time for people
  2797. 2:01:46- And do it together.
  2798. 2:01:47- So now we're all on the same page.
  2799. 2:01:48We've all read the memo
  2800. 2:01:50and now we can have a really elevated discussion.
  2801. 2:01:53And this is so much better
  2802. 2:01:54from having a slideshow presentation, you know,
  2803. 2:01:57a PowerPoint presentation of some kind
  2804. 2:02:00where that has so many difficulties.
  2805. 2:02:02But one of the problems is PowerPoint
  2806. 2:02:04is really designed to persuade.
  2807. 2:02:05It's kind of a sales tool.
  2808. 2:02:07And internally the last thing you want to do is sell.
  2809. 2:02:12You want to, you're again, you're truth seeking.
  2810. 2:02:13You're trying to find truth.
  2811. 2:02:15And the other problem with PowerPoint
  2812. 2:02:17is it's easy for the author and hard for the audience.
  2813. 2:02:22And a memo is the opposite.
  2814. 2:02:24It's hard to write a six page memo.
  2815. 2:02:25A good six page memo might take two weeks to write.
  2816. 2:02:28You have to write it, you have to rewrite it,
  2817. 2:02:30you have to edit it, you have to talk to people about it.
  2818. 2:02:33They have to poke holes in it for you.
  2819. 2:02:35You write it again, it might take two weeks.
  2820. 2:02:37So the author, it's really a very difficult job,
  2821. 2:02:41but for the audience it's much better.
  2822. 2:02:45So you can read a half hour and you know,
  2823. 2:02:47there are little problems with PowerPoint presentations too.
  2824. 2:02:50You know, senior executives interrupt with questions
  2825. 2:02:52halfway through the presentation.
  2826. 2:02:54That question's gonna be answered on the next slide,
  2827. 2:02:56but you never got there.
  2828. 2:02:58If you read the whole memo in advance,
  2829. 2:03:00you know, I often write lots of questions
  2830. 2:03:01that I have in the margins of these memos,
  2831. 2:03:05and then I go cross them all out
  2832. 2:03:06because by the time I get to the end of the memo,
  2833. 2:03:08they've been answered.
  2834. 2:03:09That's why I save all that time.
  2835. 2:03:11You also get, you know,
  2836. 2:03:13if the person who's preparing the memo,
  2837. 2:03:15we talked earlier about you know, group think
  2838. 2:03:19and you know, the fact that I go last in meetings
  2839. 2:03:22and that you don't want you know, your ideas
  2840. 2:03:26to kind of pollute the meeting prematurely.
  2841. 2:03:29You know, the author of the memos
  2842. 2:03:32has kind of got to be very vulnerable.
  2843. 2:03:35They've gotta put all their thoughts out there.
  2844. 2:03:37And they've got to go first.
  2845. 2:03:39But that's great 'cause it makes 'em really good.
  2846. 2:03:42And so, and you get to see their real ideas
  2847. 2:03:45and you're not trampling on them accidentally in a big,
  2848. 2:03:48you know, PowerPoint presentation.
  2849. 2:03:50- What's that feel like when you've authored a thing
  2850. 2:03:52and then you're sitting there
  2851. 2:03:53and everybody's reading your thing,
  2852. 2:03:55you're like-
  2853. 2:03:56- I think it's mostly terrifying.
  2854. 2:03:57- Yeah.
  2855. 2:04:00Like maybe in a good way?
  2856. 2:04:02- I think it's-
  2857. 2:04:03- Like purifying.
  2858. 2:04:04- I think it's terrifying in a productive way.
  2859. 2:04:08- Yeah.
  2860. 2:04:09- But I think it's emotionally
  2861. 2:04:10a very nerve wracking experience.
  2862. 2:04:13- Is there a art science to the writing
  2863. 2:04:16of the six page memo or just writing in general to you?
  2864. 2:04:20- I mean, it's really got to be a real memo.
  2865. 2:04:23So it means you know, paragraphs have topic sentences,
  2866. 2:04:28like it's verbs and nouns.
  2867. 2:04:30You can't, that's the other problem with PowerPoints,
  2868. 2:04:31they're often just bullet points
  2869. 2:04:33and you can hide a lot of sloppy thinking
  2870. 2:04:36behind bullet points.
  2871. 2:04:38When you have to write in complete sentences
  2872. 2:04:40with narrative structure,
  2873. 2:04:41it's really hard to hide sloppy thinking.
  2874. 2:04:43So it does, it forces the author to be at their best.
  2875. 2:04:48And so you're getting somebody's,
  2876. 2:04:50they're getting somebody's really their best thinking.
  2877. 2:04:53And then you don't have to spend a lot of time
  2878. 2:04:55trying to tease that thinking out of the person.
  2879. 2:04:59And you've got it from the very beginning.
  2880. 2:05:00So it really saves you time in the long run.
  2881. 2:05:03- So that part is crisp and then the rest is messy,
  2882. 2:05:06crisp document.
  2883. 2:05:07- Yeah, so you don't wanna pretend
  2884. 2:05:09that the discussion should be crisp.
  2885. 2:05:11There's, you know, most meetings,
  2886. 2:05:13you're trying to solve a really hard problem.
  2887. 2:05:15There's a different kind of meeting,
  2888. 2:05:17which we call weekly business reviews
  2889. 2:05:19or business reviews that may be weekly or monthly
  2890. 2:05:21or daily, whatever they are.
  2891. 2:05:22But these business review meetings,
  2892. 2:05:24that's usually for incremental improvement.
  2893. 2:05:27And you're like looking at a series of metrics,
  2894. 2:05:28every time it's the same metrics.
  2895. 2:05:30Those meetings can be very efficient.
  2896. 2:05:32They can start on time and end on time.
  2897. 2:05:35- So we're about to run out of time,
  2898. 2:05:37which is a good time to ask about the 10,000 year clock.
  2899. 2:05:44That's what I'm known for, is the humor.
  2900. 2:05:48Okay.
  2901. 2:05:49Can you explain what the 10,000 year clock is?
  2902. 2:05:52- 10,000 year clock is a physical clock of monumental scale.
  2903. 2:05:56It's about 500 feet tall.
  2904. 2:05:58It's inside a mountain in west Texas
  2905. 2:06:00in a chamber that's about 12 feet in diameter
  2906. 2:06:03and 500 feet tall.
  2907. 2:06:0410,000 year clock is a idea conceived
  2908. 2:06:07by brilliant guy named Danny Hillis
  2909. 2:06:10way back in the '80s.
  2910. 2:06:13The idea is to build a clock as a symbol
  2911. 2:06:15for long-term thinking.
  2912. 2:06:17And you can kind of just very conceptually think
  2913. 2:06:21of the 10,000 year clock as it you know,
  2914. 2:06:24it ticks once a year.
  2915. 2:06:27It chimes once you know, every a hundred years.
  2916. 2:06:31And the cuckoo comes out once every a thousand years.
  2917. 2:06:33So it just sort of slows everything down.
  2918. 2:06:36And it's a completely mechanical clock.
  2919. 2:06:40It is designed to last 10,000 years
  2920. 2:06:43with no human intervention.
  2921. 2:06:45So the material choices and everything else.
  2922. 2:06:48It's in a remote location, both to protect it,
  2923. 2:06:51but also so that visitors have to kind of make a pilgrimage.
  2924. 2:06:57The idea is that over time,
  2925. 2:07:00this will take hundreds of years,
  2926. 2:07:02but over time it will take on the patina of age
  2927. 2:07:06and then it will become a symbol for long-term thinking
  2928. 2:07:11that will actually, hopefully get humans
  2929. 2:07:14to extend their thinking horizons.
  2930. 2:07:18And my view that's really important as we have become,
  2931. 2:07:23as a species, as a civilization more powerful,
  2932. 2:07:26you know, we're really affecting the planet now.
  2933. 2:07:29We're really affecting each other.
  2934. 2:07:30We have weapons of mass destruction,
  2935. 2:07:32we have all kinds of things
  2936. 2:07:35where we can really hurt ourselves.
  2937. 2:07:37And the problems we create can be so large.
  2938. 2:07:40You know, the unintended consequences
  2939. 2:07:43of some of our actions like climate change,
  2940. 2:07:45putting carbon in the atmosphere is a perfect example.
  2941. 2:07:47That's an unintended consequence
  2942. 2:07:49of the industrial revolution that a lot of benefits from it.
  2943. 2:07:52But we've also got this side effect
  2944. 2:07:55that is very detrimental.
  2945. 2:07:56We need to be, we need to start training ourselves
  2946. 2:08:00to think longer term.
  2947. 2:08:01Long-term thinking is a giant lever.
  2948. 2:08:02You can literally solve problems
  2949. 2:08:05if you think long-term
  2950. 2:08:06that are impossible to solve if you think short term.
  2951. 2:08:09And we aren't really good at thinking long-term
  2952. 2:08:11as you know, it's not really,
  2953. 2:08:13we're kind of, you know, five years is a tough timeframe
  2954. 2:08:18for most institutions to think past.
  2955. 2:08:22And we probably need to stretch that to 10 years
  2956. 2:08:25and 15 years and 20 years and 25 years.
  2957. 2:08:27And we do a better job for our children
  2958. 2:08:29or our grandchildren if we could stretch
  2959. 2:08:32those thinking horizons.
  2960. 2:08:34And so the clock is, in a way, it's an art project,
  2961. 2:08:38it's a symbol.
  2962. 2:08:40And if it ever has any power to influence people
  2963. 2:08:44to think longer term,
  2964. 2:08:45that won't happen for hundreds of years.
  2965. 2:08:47But we have to, you know, we're gonna build it now
  2966. 2:08:50and let it accrue the patina of age.
  2967. 2:08:52- Do you think humans will be here
  2968. 2:08:53when the clock runs out?
  2969. 2:08:55Here on earth?
  2970. 2:08:56- I think so.
  2971. 2:08:59But you know, the United States won't exist.
  2972. 2:09:01Like whole civilizations rise and fall.
  2973. 2:09:0310,000 years is so long.
  2974. 2:09:06Like no nation state has ever survived
  2975. 2:09:10for anywhere close to 10,000 years.
  2976. 2:09:12- And the increasing rate of progress
  2977. 2:09:14makes that even-
  2978. 2:09:15- Even less likely so.
  2979. 2:09:16Do I think humans will be here?
  2980. 2:09:18Yes.
  2981. 2:09:18What, you know, how will we have changed ourselves
  2982. 2:09:21and what will we be and so on and so on.
  2983. 2:09:23I don't know, but I think we'll be here.
  2984. 2:09:25- On that grand scale, a human life feels tiny.
  2985. 2:09:28Do you ponder your own mortality?
  2986. 2:09:31Are you afraid of death?
  2987. 2:09:32- No, I'm you know, I used to be afraid of death.
  2988. 2:09:36I did.
  2989. 2:09:37I like I remember as a young person
  2990. 2:09:40being kind of like very scared of mortality,
  2991. 2:09:45like didn't want to think about it and so on.
  2992. 2:09:47And always had a big, and as I've gotten older, I'm 59 now.
  2993. 2:09:51As I've gotten older, somehow that fear
  2994. 2:09:55has sort of gone away.
  2995. 2:09:58I don't, you know, I would like to stay alive
  2996. 2:10:01for as long as possible, but I'd like to be,
  2997. 2:10:02I'm really more focused on health span.
  2998. 2:10:05I want to be healthy.
  2999. 2:10:06I want that square wave.
  3000. 2:10:08I want to you know,
  3001. 2:10:09this I wanna be healthy, healthy, healthy, and then gone.
  3002. 2:10:12I don't want the long decay.
  3003. 2:10:15And I'm curious, I wanna see how things turn out.
  3004. 2:10:18You know, I'd like to be here.
  3005. 2:10:21I love my family and my close friends
  3006. 2:10:23and I want to,
  3007. 2:10:24I'm curious about them and I wanna see,
  3008. 2:10:25so I have a lot of reasons to stay around,
  3009. 2:10:28but it's mortality doesn't have have that effect
  3010. 2:10:34on me that it did you know, maybe when I was in my 20s.
  3011. 2:10:37- Well Jeff, thank you for creating Amazon,
  3012. 2:10:41one of the most incredible companies in history.
  3013. 2:10:43And thank you for trying your best to make humans
  3014. 2:10:46and multi-planetary species expanding out
  3015. 2:10:48into our solar system, maybe beyond,
  3016. 2:10:51to meet the aliens out there.
  3017. 2:10:53And thank you for talking today.
  3018. 2:10:55- Well, Lex, thank you for doing your part
  3019. 2:10:58to lengthen our attention spans.
  3020. 2:11:00Appreciate that very much.
  3021. 2:11:04- Thanks for listening to this conversation with Jeff Bezos.
  3022. 2:11:07To support this podcast, please check out our sponsors
  3023. 2:11:09in the description.
  3024. 2:11:10And now let me leave you with some words
  3025. 2:11:13from Jeff Bezos himself.
  3026. 2:11:15"Be stubborn on vision, but flexible on the details."
  3027. 2:11:20Thank you for listening and hope to see you next time.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Jeff Bezos: Amazon and Blue Origin | Lex Fridman Podcast #405 by Lex Fridman, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 21,560 words across 3,027 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.