Javiera Barandiaran | Climate Equity & Environmental Justice Search — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01I am reading the welcome introduction
- 0:04from Alistister.
- 0:07So welcome to a special environmental
- 0:09science policy and management department
- 0:11seminar. Today I'm delighted to present
- 0:14professor Javiera Baran
- 0:17>> to talk about living minerals a paradigm
- 0:20for advancing climate equity and
- 0:21justice. She's our ASPAM departmental
- 0:24candidate for the campus search for a
- 0:26new professor on climate equity and
- 0:28environmental justice. Javiera works as
- 0:31an associate professor in the global
- 0:33studies department at UC Santa Barbara.
- 0:36She received her PhD from ESPAM as well
- 0:38as a master's in public policy from the
- 0:41Goldman School here at Berkeley. So
- 0:43today is something of a homecoming
- 0:46for Javiera. Um, she's worked across a
- 0:49wide range of environmental issues in
- 0:51Chile and across Latin America as well
- 0:54as in California. More recently, she's
- 0:57been looking at the politics of critical
- 0:59minerals in energy transition,
- 1:02dissecting the push for a more radical
- 1:04environmentally rooted constitution in
- 1:06Chile and calling for scientists to be
- 1:09more actively engaged in climate
- 1:11struggles. Airaa has a new book coming
- 1:14out with MIT Press next month called
- 1:18Living Minerals: Nature, Trade, and
- 1:21Power in the Race for Lithium. And her
- 1:24talk today will cover some of her book
- 1:26themes. Javier is also the co-director
- 1:28of the UCwide Center for Climate Justice
- 1:32as well as the director of the Center
- 1:34for Restorative Environmental Work at UC
- 1:36Santa Barbara. So, please welcome
- 1:38Javier.
- 1:50put a timer on just to try to keep track
- 1:52of time. All right. Uh thank you
- 1:56everyone for being here. It's really
- 1:58such a pleasure uh to be back. As that
- 2:00said, a bit of a homecoming for me. Um,
- 2:03I want to give my really deepest thanks
- 2:05to Issha and Rachel for chairing this
- 2:08campuswide uh search and for inviting me
- 2:11and Seth uh for being the departmental
- 2:14chair who's been very gracious and and
- 2:16helping me uh come here and of course
- 2:19Kelly um I assume somewhere around here.
- 2:23Um Kelly who has been organizing behind
- 2:26all of the logistics. So thank you
- 2:28everyone for for the really kind
- 2:30invitation to be here. Um I also before
- 2:34I get started just want to give a quick
- 2:35word of thanks to everyone who has
- 2:37contributed to the research that I'm
- 2:38going to be sharing today. Uh the
- 2:40funding came primarily from the National
- 2:42Science Foundation and we live in times
- 2:44where it feels are very important to
- 2:46acknowledge that um that they were
- 2:48funding work abroad which I think is
- 2:51increasingly threatened and also work
- 2:53related to justice and equity issues. I
- 2:56also was lucky to have a writing
- 2:58residency sponsored by the Rockefeller
- 3:00Foundation and the American Academy of
- 3:02Berlin. Without that time to really
- 3:04focus on writing, it would have been
- 3:06very difficult to get this book done. Uh
- 3:08and of course all my collaborators um in
- 3:12academia, in law and activism who work
- 3:15in Chile, in Argentina, and in so many
- 3:17countries around the world.
- 3:20Uh so I'm going to start by
- 3:24sharing a little bit of how I got
- 3:26interested in the topic of lithium. Uh
- 3:29it was 2012 and I was finishing my
- 3:32fieldwork research for my PhD in Chile
- 3:36when I learned that Chile is actually a
- 3:38major producer of lithium. I had you
- 3:40know although Chile is a mining country
- 3:42I had never known that amongst all the
- 3:44minerals that Chile produces lithium was
- 3:46one of them. When I was back in the
- 3:48United States, news like this was
- 3:52beginning to pop up at the time and the
- 3:54by line of this New Yorker article
- 3:57caught my attention. Can Bolivia become
- 4:01the Saudi Arabia of the electric car
- 4:04era? Now, for me, you know, with deep
- 4:07roots in Chile and in Argentina, my
- 4:09family is originally from Argentina. Um,
- 4:13so neighboring countries that have also
- 4:15very large lithium deposits as does
- 4:17Bolivia. The idea of becoming like Saudi
- 4:21Arabia was completely alarming because
- 4:23it signaled more foreign intervention,
- 4:26more war, ecological destruction and
- 4:29grossly unequal development. So these
- 4:32were things very far from the hopes and
- 4:34dreams of the environmental movements
- 4:36and the communities that I had been
- 4:38working with while doing my PhD work.
- 4:41Um and so suddenly the prospect of the
- 4:44electric car era seemed like more of the
- 4:46same at the global level and more
- 4:48violence at the local level.
- 4:51Fast forward 12 year late 12 years later
- 4:54on the heels of a really frustrating top
- 4:57uh climate conference that just finished
- 4:59in Brazil as you all know. I think the
- 5:01possibility of defining even more
- 5:03territories primarily by their place in
- 5:06the global mineral production chain is
- 5:09even closer than than it was before.
- 5:12So my goal is to inspire you and really
- 5:15everyone that that might read the book
- 5:17that I've just finished uh inspire you
- 5:19to think differently to think of lithium
- 5:22not as a strategic commodity but as an
- 5:24element of nature. um hopefully to think
- 5:27of not just lithium but any mineral and
- 5:30certainly not of any territory as
- 5:32strategic but to think of them as
- 5:34elements of nature to be used with
- 5:36humility and care in order to advance uh
- 5:39climate equity and environmental
- 5:41justice. So to meaningfully uh address
- 5:45climate equity and climate change, I
- 5:47argue that we need to shift from an old
- 5:50thinking of strategic minerals that has
- 5:52been with us from the 1950s if not
- 5:54longer to a paradigm of living minerals
- 5:58which emerges in partnership with a
- 6:00diverse set of voices. So, scientific
- 6:03voices, indigenous, uh, feminists, uh,
- 6:07many others, ecological practitioners
- 6:09and thinkers, uh, who have been working
- 6:12in these ways for a long time. And so,
- 6:15living minerals can deliver better and
- 6:18more equitable climate actions, but it
- 6:20does require that we reckon with some
- 6:22difficult subjects like environmental
- 6:25political memories. And so, the
- 6:26conjunction of those two things and
- 6:29structural inequalities
- 6:32Now, one reason that living minerals, I
- 6:35think, is a much better pathway to
- 6:38climate equity than strategic minerals
- 6:40is that strategic minerals puts its
- 6:42faith in technological fixes, primarily
- 6:46electric vehicles, which as you can see
- 6:48in this graph, they're just getting
- 6:50bigger and bigger and therefore more and
- 6:52more unsustainable. Not just here in the
- 6:55United States, you can see the big red
- 6:57line, but really everywhere around the
- 6:59world. um all for the profit of car
- 7:02companies, car manufacturers. And so
- 7:04there's been intense hype around lithium
- 7:07for a few reasons. So markets love it
- 7:10because it's really difficult to count
- 7:12and map and that makes it very easy to
- 7:15speculate with and it also leaves intact
- 7:18consumption as if this were a real
- 7:21solution to climate change problems. Um,
- 7:25I do think, you know, the reason that
- 7:26lithium is important to EVs is that it's
- 7:28the most lightweight metal and therefore
- 7:30it's really important for portable
- 7:32batteries of any kind. We're very likely
- 7:35to continue to to need lithium in in
- 7:38that sense. And I do want to be clear
- 7:40that EVs are still better than gas cars.
- 7:42That's uh I don't think that's very
- 7:45debatable, but it leaves intact the the
- 7:48inequities and the injustices of these
- 7:51markets. So what we see is that EVs are
- 7:54delivering sort of inequality and access
- 7:56these increasingly unaffordable cars and
- 7:59you know right now the news is all a
- 8:01buzz about the term affordability but
- 8:03these are really unaffordable cars in
- 8:05many ways. Um the mineral and fossil
- 8:09fuel needs and these two things are
- 8:10quite linked. We we really haven't seen
- 8:12that kind of decoupling yet. But in
- 8:14mineral and fossil fuel needs that are
- 8:16direct threat to people's lands and
- 8:18waters
- 8:20and all of it done with within a context
- 8:22of resource nationalism that pits the
- 8:26welfare of one country of one community
- 8:28against the welfare of another. So it
- 8:30creates this very zero sum dynamic. By
- 8:33resource nationalism, I mean that
- 8:36government efforts to control the
- 8:38production and trade of a natural
- 8:40resource to def to advance a national
- 8:42goal like military power uh and national
- 8:46development goals which may or may not
- 8:49be equitable but have a difficult you
- 8:52know complicated history.
- 8:54So resource nationalism, we can think of
- 8:56it as both a cause and a symptom of uh
- 8:59climate inequities and of global
- 9:01inequities. And it's really this that we
- 9:04see in that New Yorker by line, right?
- 9:07It's it's resource nationalism thinking
- 9:09that leads that kind of question. Can
- 9:12Bolivia become the Saudi Arabia of the
- 9:14electric car era? And really imposing
- 9:17that question, the journalist is saying
- 9:19a lot more about US anxieties than he is
- 9:23about Bolivian desires.
- 9:26Uh finally, all of this really helps to
- 9:29preserve the car the carbon economy
- 9:32because it creates this illusion that
- 9:35lithium replaces coal as EVs replace gas
- 9:39cars when in reality gas cars find new
- 9:43lives elsewhere. The oil industry is
- 9:45investing in lithium and all of us are
- 9:48spending a lot more time thinking about
- 9:50how to secure lithium supplies than we
- 9:53are thinking about how to phase out and
- 9:54close down oil production. And we see
- 9:57this at, you know, cop after cup. We've
- 9:59seen this here in California, recent
- 10:02policies, even the governor expanding
- 10:04oil licenses in Central Valley that we
- 10:06were mentioning earlier.
- 10:09Um,
- 10:11so that's basically the argument that
- 10:13I'm going to be making today in sections
- 10:152, three, and four of the talk. First, I
- 10:17wanted to say a little bit more about
- 10:19myself and my research and then my
- 10:21closing comments. I'll also talk about
- 10:23my uh next uh research projects.
- 10:30Yes. So, so as you know, I got my PhD
- 10:32here in ESPAM um in with training in
- 10:36science and technology studies or STS uh
- 10:39after having completed a master's just
- 10:41up the hill in the Goldman School. And
- 10:43ever since then, I've been at UCSB in
- 10:46the global studies department. I've just
- 10:49finished or in the process of finishing
- 10:51my very first quarter as chair of the
- 10:53department. Um so that's been that's
- 10:56been fun. Let's just say um my
- 11:00scholarship examines environmental
- 11:02politics and policy to understand the
- 11:05relationship between nature expertise
- 11:07and democratic governance and the
- 11:10consequences of all this for justice and
- 11:12equity. So some of my past projects have
- 11:15examined uh questions around trust in
- 11:18science uh and questions of whose voices
- 11:21are excluded or marginalized when we
- 11:24think of policy processes like
- 11:26environmental impact assessments. Um but
- 11:28also where science has been privatized
- 11:31is the case increasingly in Chile and
- 11:33where people have sort of compete in
- 11:35this marketplace of data and of
- 11:38scientific ideas. And I look at the
- 11:40consequences of this for accountability,
- 11:42for public trust, uh, fairness and
- 11:44environmental outcomes and how those are
- 11:46distributed.
- 11:48Um, I've also looked at how local
- 11:50knowledges are marginalized or
- 11:52misrepresented when they participate in
- 11:54global processes and public policies and
- 11:57including in courts of law. uh building
- 12:00on a 2018 Melan Sawyer seminar on energy
- 12:03justice I co-founded in 22 the Crew
- 12:06Center for Restorative Environmental
- 12:08Work. And this is a photo from a recent
- 12:11event we held uh with members of the
- 12:14Chumash Band of Santa Barbara uh and
- 12:16other indigenous allies from Hawaii and
- 12:19Northern California where we were
- 12:21discussing land rematriation practices.
- 12:23And so over the few years, CRU has
- 12:26become a hub on campus for this kind of
- 12:29work and also for graduate mentorship
- 12:31and and climate justice reading groups.
- 12:34Uh most of my work has focused on Chile.
- 12:37I also served for two years as the UC
- 12:39faculty director for study abroad
- 12:41programs there and in Argentina. That
- 12:43was arguably the funnest thing I have
- 12:45ever done. So I definitely always
- 12:47recommend study abroad. Um, but through
- 12:50through both the melon and the crew,
- 12:52I've also developed and maintained some
- 12:54California focused research.
- 12:58So, as Seth mentioned, uh, I'm really
- 13:01excited to share material today for my
- 13:03forthcoming book. Publication day is
- 13:05about a month away from today. Finally,
- 13:09um, it's called Living Minerals: Nature,
- 13:11Trade, and Power in the Race for
- 13:12Lithium. And what makes the book really
- 13:16novel from a methodological perspective
- 13:18is that I look at mining holistically,
- 13:21meaning I cut across both minerals and
- 13:24time. There's a lot of scholarship that
- 13:26will look at one mineral at a time. You
- 13:28know, there's books about tin and copper
- 13:30and all, you know, specific mineral and
- 13:34then other books will look at one
- 13:35country at a time. Instead, I focused on
- 13:38the trade in minerals between Chile and
- 13:41the United States. And I chose these two
- 13:43countries very strategically because
- 13:45these are friendly allied nations that
- 13:48have been trading minerals with each
- 13:49other for 150 years. Specifically, they
- 13:53have been buying and selling nitrate,
- 13:55copper, and now lithium. And each three
- 13:58of these has been at different times an
- 14:00emblematic global commodity where Chile
- 14:03has been the primary a leading global
- 14:05producer at different times. So in many
- 14:08ways we can think of this as a mineral
- 14:10trade that's in conditions of as good as
- 14:13it gets friendly nations emblematic
- 14:16commodities.
- 14:18So I analyzed um documents, reports,
- 14:21promotional materials, etc.
- 14:24correspondence produced by scientists
- 14:26and professionals working for industry
- 14:28and government in Chile and Argentina.
- 14:31and reflecting my training in STS, I
- 14:33looked at for scientific controversies
- 14:35and I scrutinized the methods used to
- 14:38map and count the desert landscapes
- 14:41where uh mineral hap uh mining was
- 14:43happening to understand the ways in
- 14:45which expertise shaped the mineral
- 14:48trade. Uh and so in a nutshell, the
- 14:50argument of the book is that we need to
- 14:53reckon with and understand past
- 14:55misrepresentations of nature in order to
- 14:59understand this unsustainable mineral
- 15:02trade and why we are sort of headed
- 15:05towards repeating those same patterns.
- 15:07uh and to advance equity we need to
- 15:10center um and think about how nature is
- 15:14um we need to center nature in how we
- 15:16explain things like trade and
- 15:18globalization. So we need to bring this
- 15:20into our explanations of the global
- 15:22economy.
- 15:25So first I'll say a little bit more
- 15:27about lithium
- 15:30first. As you can see, there's been a
- 15:32massive increase in the mining of
- 15:35lithium since 2016. U the key thing here
- 15:39is that there's a massive mining boom
- 15:41happening and it is only now getting
- 15:44started. By one estimate, the
- 15:46International Energy Agency is calling
- 15:48for a doubling of the tonnage of
- 15:51minerals extracted from underground in
- 15:53the next five years. So, to the end of
- 15:55this decade. So, it's a huge huge
- 15:57amount. We're talking about um the
- 16:00lithium supply chain is um complicated
- 16:04from a chemical point of view because
- 16:06the chemistry of lithium is really
- 16:08difficult and delicate and interesting.
- 16:10Um but from a geographic point of view,
- 16:12it's quite simple. Lithium is currently
- 16:15mined in just a few countries in North
- 16:17and South America and in Australia. And
- 16:19then nearly all of it goes to China for
- 16:22processing, which is what the USGS, I
- 16:25guess, was trying to capture in this
- 16:27slightly bizarre infographic where
- 16:29they've just taken China and planted it
- 16:31in the middle of the global map.
- 16:35>> Uh so to zoom in on the deposits, um
- 16:37this is the region of South America that
- 16:39concentrates the greatest number of
- 16:41lithium deposits.
- 16:43And here's a closeup of the high alitude
- 16:46deserts of Chile, Argentina, and
- 16:49Bolivia. Um, where the lithium happened.
- 16:52The white spots are the salt flats from
- 16:54where we extract the lithium. Uh, I've
- 16:57been focusing on two places. The first
- 16:59one here, the Salo Atakama or Atagama
- 17:02salt flat gets its name from the bigger
- 17:04Atagama desert where it's located. And
- 17:07it's the oldest and largest mine
- 17:09operating in this region. And here the
- 17:12silver peak mine in uh Nevada just very
- 17:16not far from here. Um and so brine
- 17:19mining was pioneered in California at
- 17:22Sals Lake in the 1930s. In the 1960s it
- 17:25moved to Silver Peak, Nevada. And then
- 17:26in the 1970s it moved to Chile Atakama.
- 17:30And so there are direct links between
- 17:32the US and the Chilean lithium mines
- 17:34that are mirrored in direct links
- 17:36between US and Chilean copper mines and
- 17:39US and Chilean fertilizer mines. And in
- 17:42the book I sort of discuss these
- 17:44different links across these different
- 17:45minerals. But today I'll focus on
- 17:48lithium.
- 17:49And so the very same people working for
- 17:53the very same company, the foot mineral
- 17:56company uh that built the silver peak
- 17:58mine then went to Chile to build the
- 18:01Atakama line. And so that's also part of
- 18:03the reason why it makes a lot of sense
- 18:05to look at them together. And we um
- 18:08published this book called Lithium
- 18:10Landscapes that pairs images of these
- 18:12two sites that gives you an idea of just
- 18:15how similar they appear uh when you when
- 18:17you're looking at them.
- 18:22So very quickly, brine lithium mining is
- 18:25very different from hard rock mining,
- 18:27which is the other major deposit of
- 18:29lithium. And as you can see from this
- 18:31photo, this is the largest hard rock
- 18:33mine in Australia. This is very similar
- 18:36to a gold or copper mine. So diesel
- 18:39trucks, explosives, tailings, uh large
- 18:42piles of um you know chemicals and toxic
- 18:45waste, etc.
- 18:47Brine mining is something else. Uh this
- 18:50is a the brine lithium mine in the at
- 18:54the salt flat just seen from a
- 18:56commercial flight.
- 18:58And the um important thing here is you
- 19:01know you see the the phase chemistry is
- 19:03what accounts for the different colors
- 19:05of the pools that you can see. And so
- 19:08this is basically the brine that's
- 19:10sitting there. Uh and each one of these
- 19:12brines and each one of these salt flats
- 19:14is absolutely unique. Um so the brine
- 19:18are salt water salts and elements
- 19:20including potassium, magnesium, calcium,
- 19:23boron, all kinds of things. Uh and it
- 19:26really is as if both the salt flat and
- 19:29the brine itself were rebelling against
- 19:31our efforts to commodify them because
- 19:33each one is unique and so the process
- 19:35has to be figured out again each time at
- 19:39each site. um and makes it complicated.
- 19:42This gives you a bit more detail about
- 19:44the process. Um and again, you know, the
- 19:47underground architecture or morphology
- 19:50of the salt flats is is unique each
- 19:52time. Um lithium is like all minerals
- 19:57not a renewable resource. It will run
- 19:59out. Um it is also um not particularly
- 20:04scarce. What is scarce is cheap lithium.
- 20:07And the Atakama lithium is the cheapest
- 20:09lithium out there.
- 20:12So there's many impacts that lithium
- 20:16has. It is destructive on the landscape.
- 20:18It creates piles of waste. But the
- 20:20number one concern for the communities
- 20:23who live in these areas is water loss.
- 20:25Um and this these two images from Silver
- 20:29Peak and the Atakama help to drive home
- 20:31that this is a massive water operation
- 20:34um in in both sites.
- 20:39And so
- 20:41the harms and burdens of lithium mining
- 20:43as is typical are unevenly distributed.
- 20:47And this is causing of course many
- 20:49climate injustices and inequities that
- 20:51are felt acutely by indigenous
- 20:53communities. From a climate equity
- 20:55perspective
- 20:57worldwide, indigenous communities are
- 20:59the ones that are feeling most acutely
- 21:02the impacts of this mining rush. of
- 21:04course they're the ones who have been
- 21:05most punished by colonialism and
- 21:07modernization and have contributed the
- 21:09very least to climate change and Nevada
- 21:12helps to illustrate this. So here you
- 21:15see in the map sort of pre-cont or
- 21:17ancestral Shosonyi lands um and then in
- 21:211863
- 21:22federal treaty effectively led to them
- 21:25being forced off their lands a year
- 21:27later the town of Silver Peak was
- 21:29founded by settler families. uh and in
- 21:32my research I didn't find much evidence
- 21:34of in Shosonyi living in Silver Peak but
- 21:37today uh Shosonyi peoples together with
- 21:39Paou and Banana peoples further north
- 21:42are um uh protesting resisting other
- 21:45lithium mining that's happening and they
- 21:47put up this sign life over lithium in
- 21:51the Fort McDermott uh soccer pass area.
- 21:55The situation in Chile is both similar
- 21:57and different and I'm happy to answer
- 21:59more questions about this in the Q&A.
- 22:01Um, there are 18 lani atakame
- 22:05communities uh that live here. Uh, this
- 22:08recent book by my friend and colleague
- 22:09Sally Babage provides a really deep
- 22:11ethnographic account of how one
- 22:14community b which is closest to the
- 22:16mines is coping with this onslaught of
- 22:19industrial projects. Um these are images
- 22:22of members of the Hooayu which is a
- 22:25little north of Bay. Uh and this is a
- 22:27project by a colleague at UC San Diego
- 22:29also doing uh sort of digital interviews
- 22:32that are accessible to everyone um on
- 22:34how communities are impacted.
- 22:37Now across the board there's a lot of
- 22:39conflict around the lithium mining in
- 22:42these communities but there's a shared
- 22:44sense of worry and frustration about the
- 22:48impacts that mining is having on the
- 22:50desert. So as the ecosystem becomes
- 22:52increasingly exhausted possibly to the
- 22:55point of extinction water you know as
- 22:58water disappears uh all life is
- 23:00suffering. This includes life like
- 23:02emblematic species like the flamingo on
- 23:05my book's cover. uh it includes also
- 23:08single-sellled microbes that live in the
- 23:11salt flat brine. Uh and these microbes
- 23:14were among the very first life forms to
- 23:16be producing ozone and oxygen and they
- 23:19made all subsequent life including our
- 23:22own possible on this planet.
- 23:26So from that perspective we might even
- 23:27call these microbes our oldest living
- 23:30ancestors. Uh and this is an image from
- 23:33a garden documentary that was published
- 23:36just last week. It's a really
- 23:37beautifully done documentary. Uh and
- 23:40here you have a sort of one of these
- 23:41microbes uh juxtaposed with flamingos on
- 23:45a salt flat to highlight the um richness
- 23:48of the microbial life in these places.
- 23:52So the ligani who live here they keep uh
- 23:55farms and uh animals and they know how
- 23:59to live with water scarcity. They're
- 24:02also complaining bitterly about the
- 24:05compounded effects of mining uh at the
- 24:07pace and scale that we see. So to
- 24:10understand how we got here and why the
- 24:12lithium trade promises to reproduce old
- 24:15patterns of inequity and injustice, I
- 24:18turned to examine the history of mineral
- 24:20trading between the US and Chile.
- 24:25So since the 19th century, for over 150
- 24:28years, uh the Atakama desert has been
- 24:31central to global mineral markets. This
- 24:34is not a new phenomenon for this region.
- 24:37Um, it has provided most of the world's
- 24:40copper and most of the world's natural
- 24:42nitrates which are used as fertilizers
- 24:44and as explosives and now most of the
- 24:47world's lithium as well. And this
- 24:49painting celebrates life in one of these
- 24:52nitrate towns in its heyday in the
- 24:541940s.
- 24:57This is the same town today. Its
- 25:00refineries and processing plants are in
- 25:02ruins. homes and the town center are
- 25:04vacant. And across the Atakama desert,
- 25:07you will find the ruins of past
- 25:09industrial activity. And this includes
- 25:12both infrastructure that was valuable as
- 25:14well as waste piles of rock and toxic uh
- 25:19mine tailings.
- 25:22Ruins and waste are common also in
- 25:25Silver Peak. Um, and if you visit today,
- 25:27you will find intense poverty, a vacant
- 25:30village center, abandoned homes,
- 25:33abandoned and rusting trucks and cars.
- 25:36It's sort of where where cars seem to go
- 25:38to die really. Um, and and like in the
- 25:41Atakama, you can see in the distance the
- 25:44cake- like piles of mining waste.
- 25:49Now, this image provides uh the season
- 25:52greetings card provides a glimpse of a
- 25:54better time in Silver Peak a few decades
- 25:57ago. So, since its founding, Silver Peak
- 26:00has been a small village of familyrun
- 26:03mom and pop mining companies like this
- 26:06one, the leprechaun mining and chemical
- 26:10company. And this card captures a time
- 26:12when capitalism operated with a more
- 26:15human face. Uh, a face that was, you
- 26:18know, quite white, Christian, and middle
- 26:20class. Um, and what's funny about this
- 26:24is that Leprechaun was the really
- 26:26unlikely group that actually discovered
- 26:29the lithium and the Nevada rise. So at a
- 26:32time when the USGS and the footmineral
- 26:35company so this large multinational
- 26:38company were looking everywhere for the
- 26:40next big lithium deposit. It was this
- 26:43group of you know call so-called called
- 26:46themselves the we folk who actually uh
- 26:48discovered uh the lithium the lithium
- 26:51mines and and licensed it. And now my
- 26:54point here is not to glorify the past
- 26:58but to acknowledge what was achieved and
- 27:00what was lost. Uh because it is these
- 27:03memories that in the book I call mining
- 27:05memories that are animating today's uh
- 27:08resource nationalism in both countries.
- 27:12Uh, and so the both Silver Peak and the
- 27:15Nitro towns of the Atagama, they enjoyed
- 27:17relative prosperity, a sense of a
- 27:20tight-knit community, and a sense of
- 27:22pride in hard, honest work. And they
- 27:25lost these achievements even as new
- 27:28mines were built. The mining didn't
- 27:31close and disappear. New minds came and
- 27:33continued to come to these places. They
- 27:36lost these things for many reasons, but
- 27:38I argue that it has a lot to do with
- 27:40environmental mismanagement rooted in
- 27:43misrepresentations
- 27:44of nature. And this is an important
- 27:47point because we tend to explain loss of
- 27:50this kind by turning to explanations
- 27:53like globalization or poor governance,
- 27:56that this was bad policy, that these
- 27:58were incompetent or corrupt governments,
- 28:01that this was, you know, global trade
- 28:04taking things elsewhere.
- 28:05The important thing here is that it was
- 28:07rooted in an environmental mismanagement
- 28:10that therefore put climate inequities
- 28:14and into the very fabric of the mineral
- 28:17trade.
- 28:19Now, you may have noticed perhaps that
- 28:20these were very generically speaking
- 28:23mining memories. So, how does the
- 28:26lithium come back in? And this is where
- 28:28lithium adds a special twist to the
- 28:30story because it has a really
- 28:32interesting history of speculative
- 28:35future uses which helps to underscore
- 28:38the ways in which memories are also
- 28:40always also about what we thought the
- 28:43future would be like about aspirations
- 28:45for the future.
- 28:47So before World War II lithium was used
- 28:50very sparingly. It's with World War II
- 28:52that it comes into widespread use and um
- 28:56specifically right after the war because
- 28:59of its uses in the hydrogen or
- 29:01thermonuclear bomb. Uh so this popular
- 29:04science article uh calling lithium the
- 29:07Hbomb metal and promising that to usher
- 29:10in a mining boom to equal any gold rush
- 29:13in history. So like all nuclear
- 29:17materials, lithium nuclearity really
- 29:19changed its politics and its economics.
- 29:23At the time the US atomic energy agency
- 29:26was had a huge stockpile and you know
- 29:28stockpiles are now making a big
- 29:30comeback. They're again all over the
- 29:31news. Um it was the sole buyer and it uh
- 29:35bought it from just two producers, Foot
- 29:37Mineral and the Lithium Corporation of
- 29:39America or Litho. So with one buyer and
- 29:42two producers, there was really zero
- 29:44chance of lithium running out. There was
- 29:48no reason why there should be this kind
- 29:50of gold rush uh thinking. But still, the
- 29:54US government then was using every trick
- 29:56in the playbook to try to control uh
- 29:59global trade.
- 30:01Outside of the military, the lithium had
- 30:03a lot of potential. And I emphasize that
- 30:06it was all potential. And this uh cover
- 30:09from Lithto's annual report 1955 sort of
- 30:13helps to drive that home. It's very
- 30:14similar to the uses today pretty much
- 30:16all the same. So we have atomic energy
- 30:19in the form of nuclear fusion power,
- 30:21batteries, pharmaceuticals,
- 30:24etc.
- 30:26Um
- 30:28and so litho and foot through these
- 30:30years were building huge research
- 30:32research and development laboratories to
- 30:35develop new uses for lithium to find new
- 30:37buyers. But they needed not only a good
- 30:39product but also the promise of reliable
- 30:42and cheap future supplies, right? And so
- 30:46you take these two things together, US
- 30:49trade controls and this very speculative
- 30:53uh search for deposits and the priority
- 30:56was always more mining no matter what
- 30:59the equity or justice consequences might
- 31:01be for very speculative uses. Even
- 31:04though there was no actual market or
- 31:06need for this material, the solution was
- 31:09always more money.
- 31:13In the 1960s, electric cars with lithium
- 31:16ion batteries, they became the next big
- 31:19thing. And so, this is an image from
- 31:211967 from the Foot Minerals um magazine.
- 31:25And I love it because it's so similar to
- 31:27today. flying taxis, you know, in Orange
- 31:29County, they are now piloting flying
- 31:32taxis, um, electrified roads, which is
- 31:35something that periodically comes in and
- 31:37out of the news, and different kinds of
- 31:39car sharing ideas where the boundaries
- 31:42between private cars and public transit
- 31:45become really blurred. Um, you see a few
- 31:49years later, the Los Angeles Times in
- 31:511970 wrote, "Elect electric autos could
- 31:53revive Ghost Town in reference to Silver
- 31:55Peak," which as you now know was not
- 31:57revived on the terms that this
- 31:59journalist imagined. So, we see this
- 32:02real recurrence and of the same kinds of
- 32:05languages that we see today.
- 32:08So Foot wrote in this article, quote,
- 32:11"Faced with the urgent need to maintain
- 32:13an environment in which he can survive,
- 32:16man is virtually destined to eventually
- 32:18develop some kind of an electric car
- 32:21into a high into a highly efficient,
- 32:23lowcost mean of personal transportation.
- 32:26A lithium battery of some kind seems
- 32:29virtually assured."
- 32:32So to close this section of my talk,
- 32:35mining memories are a useful analytical
- 32:37tool for examining the aspirations
- 32:40different groups of pinned on minerals.
- 32:42These memories are affective and
- 32:44empirical, backward and forwardlooking.
- 32:47And lithium mining sheds a particularly
- 32:50bright light on the power of fears of
- 32:52mineral shortages and hopes for clean
- 32:55and infinite energy. Now the industrial
- 32:58scientists who built the lithium brine
- 33:01mines of Silver Peak and Atakagama, they
- 33:04were central to sustaining these hopes
- 33:06and fears through misrepresentations of
- 33:09nature that they authored. Um they
- 33:12articulated fictions about nature that
- 33:15enabled organizing extraction in these
- 33:18unsustainable and eventually very unjust
- 33:21and inequitable ways. So, these fictions
- 33:24included manufactured uncertainties over
- 33:27how to count lithium deposits, uh,
- 33:30selective ignorance about the effects of
- 33:32pumping on the brines and on the salt
- 33:35flats and of the behavior of the brines
- 33:37if they leaked or were reinjected and
- 33:40very narrow ideas about the water cycle.
- 33:43So in all these years, decades of
- 33:45correspondence between Leprechaun Foot,
- 33:48USGS and their Chilean partners, there's
- 33:51very rare mentions, if any, of the water
- 33:55in this landscape and the life forms
- 33:58that depended on this water cycle in the
- 34:00world's driest desert. And honestly, I
- 34:03found this surprising because as this
- 34:05photo from 1975
- 34:07really helps to drive home, this was a
- 34:10massive water operation. The geologist
- 34:13pictured here who really did a lot of
- 34:15this work, he described it at the time
- 34:18as a quote lake of lithium waiting to be
- 34:21tapped.
- 34:24Um, and he then went on after years of
- 34:28really this careful work of measuring
- 34:31this landscape and and studying these
- 34:33brines, he went on in the space of just
- 34:35a few hours to split this liquid mine in
- 34:39two. So in order for capital to work the
- 34:42way it did, he was told you must
- 34:45demarcate one investment from another uh
- 34:48as if the wells weren't all drawing from
- 34:51the exact same source. Right? So even
- 34:53though in nature this is one connected
- 34:55aquifer in law, in politics and in
- 34:59markets, it had to be demarcated in two.
- 35:02And so this is one example of many where
- 35:05separation was necessary for lithium
- 35:07production to succeed. So for the salt
- 35:10flex to become industrial work sites,
- 35:13lithium had to be separated from
- 35:14potassium,
- 35:16value had to be separated from waste and
- 35:19liquid mines had to be split in two. And
- 35:22these separations had to succeed in
- 35:24nature, in law, and in markets. Um, of
- 35:28course, this was no easy task and it
- 35:30mirrors the fragmentation of nature into
- 35:33its component parts in ways that are
- 35:36very uh emblematic of mechanistic
- 35:39science.
- 35:43So, I'm sure many of you know
- 35:44mechanistic science uh seeks to explain
- 35:47the whole by identifying its component
- 35:49parts and how they relate to each other.
- 35:52And I build on Carolyn Merchant's seinal
- 35:54critique of mechanistic science where
- 35:56she argued mechanistic science renders
- 35:59nature both dead um and quote as a
- 36:03female to be controlled and dissected
- 36:05through experiment uh so as to
- 36:08legitimate the exploitation of natural
- 36:11resources. Um I'm pretty sure that you
- 36:15know Caroline Merchant as professor
- 36:17probably addressed her students and
- 36:18colleagues in this room many times over
- 36:21many years. Um and it's really uh you
- 36:24know very special for me to be sharing
- 36:27with you uh that I got the title of
- 36:29living minerals from the death of nature
- 36:32in this edition. She talks in the
- 36:34preface about camping in the Utah desert
- 36:38and realizing that quote science viewed
- 36:40the desert rocks as dead and inert yet
- 36:43for much of human history those very
- 36:45rocks had been alive growing and
- 36:48reproducing like plants and animals.
- 36:52So how then to see nature differently
- 36:55not as dead inert appropriable and made
- 36:58of components that relate like clogs in
- 37:00a machine.
- 37:02The salt flats helped me see things
- 37:05differently and you know to go back to
- 37:07those uh our oldest living ancestors the
- 37:10microbial single cell forms in the salt
- 37:13flat. So the likenantai people they have
- 37:17a special name for these microbes. They
- 37:19call them living rocks because although
- 37:22they might look and feel like rocks and
- 37:24this is what you see here uh they are
- 37:26actually living and reproducing and if
- 37:29you look carefully enough you will see
- 37:32them grow over very very long periods of
- 37:34time.
- 37:36Uh and so as a paradigm, living minerals
- 37:40asks us to pay attention to both
- 37:42scientific representations of nature and
- 37:44also mining memories because as
- 37:47important as scientific representations
- 37:50have been, they remain rooted in
- 37:52cultural, political and economic
- 37:54commitments which have positioned
- 37:56scientific allies or even the vanguard
- 37:59of capital and colonialism over history.
- 38:02And this is illustrated particularly
- 38:04well by the history of mineral trading
- 38:06between the US and Chile.
- 38:09How we represent nature matters a great
- 38:12deal not just for understanding the past
- 38:15but also for new legal systems that
- 38:18recognize that humans are part of the
- 38:20earth's living systems and that
- 38:22challenge traditional legal models that
- 38:25treat nature as properties. And so this
- 38:27means includes rights of nature as part
- 38:29of this broader ecological
- 38:30juristprudence. So you can see this huge
- 38:33increase in ecological juristprudence.
- 38:36This is itself an achievement of many EJ
- 38:39movements around the world
- 38:41and it is also a reflection of the fact
- 38:43that we really face an existential
- 38:45threat uh because of human activities
- 38:48and mining is a a lead activity in this
- 38:51uh in this realm.
- 38:53Ecological juristprudence raises also a
- 38:56real challenge of who speaks for nature,
- 38:59for example, in courts of law. And a lot
- 39:02of scholars in the rights of nature
- 39:04world are increasingly turning to
- 39:06scientists as the privileged
- 39:07spokespeople of nature. In the book, I
- 39:11argue that this would really be a grave
- 39:13mistake to leave this to the scientists
- 39:15alone. And I hope that this history
- 39:17helps to show why that would be uh and
- 39:19the importance of leading towards a much
- 39:23more plural both science and plural set
- 39:25of voices um that are part of those
- 39:28conversations.
- 39:31So to tie this back to developments in
- 39:34Chile, in 2022, elected officials in
- 39:37Chile drafted a new proposed
- 39:38constitution which uh environmental
- 39:41organizations called an eco constitution
- 39:44and it contained many really progressive
- 39:47and forwardthinking ideas about what
- 39:50ecological jurisprudence might be. For
- 39:52example, it recognized minerals as
- 39:54finite and non-renewable and future
- 39:57generations rights to minerals. It
- 39:59introduced concepts of repair and
- 40:01natural common goods. Um, and it's not
- 40:05to redefine also science, replacing a
- 40:07singular science with a more plural
- 40:10systems of knowledges uh both in the
- 40:13plural and recognizing sort of the
- 40:15damages and the harms caused by uh
- 40:18epistemic injustices and and sort of
- 40:20legacies of colonialism.
- 40:22the constitution was rejected and sort
- 40:25of a lot of the environmental issues as
- 40:27often happen sort of drowned out by
- 40:28other salient electoral issues but it
- 40:31continues to be I think a really
- 40:33important experience and legal document
- 40:36that advanced ecological jurisdictions
- 40:38with a particularly cleareyed commitment
- 40:40to social justice uh and for that reason
- 40:43alone I think it deserves a lot more uh
- 40:46scrutiny uh and I think I see it as one
- 40:50more step in trying to implement a
- 40:52living minerals paradigm.
- 40:55So to close um I've described living
- 40:59minerals as a new paradigm that is draws
- 41:03on plural voices. So indigenous science,
- 41:06feminist approaches and moving away from
- 41:09mechanistic notions of science that's
- 41:11rooted in ecological juristprudence. And
- 41:14that really opens up how we talk about
- 41:16and represent nature to take into
- 41:19account people's lived experiences and
- 41:21also how our historical and
- 41:23environmental memories which as climate
- 41:26change accelerates become increasingly
- 41:28fragmented uh and and sort of fragile
- 41:31and at risk of being lost and forgotten
- 41:34in ways that cause further harm further
- 41:37social harm to communities. That's in
- 41:39contrast to strategic minerals which
- 41:42relies on mechanistic science which has
- 41:44often been a source of
- 41:45misrepresentations
- 41:47and uh this resource nationalism where
- 41:50it focused a lot more on the US brand of
- 41:52resource nationalism than the Chilean
- 41:54brand but I'm happy to talk more about
- 41:57that in the Q&A.
- 42:00So lithium mining brings into sharp
- 42:02relief climate inequity at the local and
- 42:05global level. At the local level, fence
- 42:08line communities are being forced to
- 42:10live with mining at a pace and scale
- 42:12that is really unprecedented and
- 42:14happening on top of already severely
- 42:17degraded and exhausted ecosystems. At
- 42:20the low at the global level, countries
- 42:23like Chile are really putting forward
- 42:25their entire territories towards this uh
- 42:28global extractive um regime. again at an
- 42:31unprecedented scale because of the sheer
- 42:34volume of capital available for
- 42:36investment, the efficiency of the
- 42:38machines available and at its disposal
- 42:41and also the voraciousness of consumer
- 42:44appetite. And I think this image helps
- 42:46to capture both of those scales of
- 42:49inequity. Um, so here we are driving
- 42:53south on Chile's Highway 5 through the
- 42:55desert and a police convoy asked us to
- 42:58pull over to make room for these mining
- 43:00trucks. So these are trucks that are
- 43:02used in today's open pit copper mines
- 43:05and they are so big it takes four loads
- 43:09like this one. This is just the chassis.
- 43:11Four loads like this one to make one
- 43:13mining truck. So it really begs the
- 43:15question, are we going to build bigger
- 43:17roads, bigger ports, and bigger oil
- 43:20infrastructure to keep this kind of
- 43:23economy going? Uh because for mining in
- 43:27Chile to increase any further, this is
- 43:29what we need. And at lunch we were
- 43:32talking about energy needs and whether
- 43:33they were predictable in this region.
- 43:36For example, coal fired power plants are
- 43:39increasingly being placed with solar
- 43:41power plants, which is great, especially
- 43:44for the people living really close to
- 43:45those coal fired power plants. But the
- 43:48scale of the solar is such that it is
- 43:50also dispossessing people of those lands
- 43:52and waters, but also um it's also
- 43:57requires sort of expanding the
- 43:59infrastructure in every which way. And
- 44:02so and and the energy consumption has
- 44:04doubled just over the last decade for
- 44:07the for the mining to make room for this
- 44:10more this increased pace of mining. So
- 44:12it becomes a really spiraling uh
- 44:16exponentially growing um situation.
- 44:20Um so I've also analyzed quickly also to
- 44:23just summarize why EVs are a false
- 44:26solution to climate change. um and what
- 44:29happens when we u marginalize voices
- 44:32that do not conform to mechanistic
- 44:35science. Um so I'm just going to go to
- 44:39talk more about my next project. So
- 44:42looking forward um I'm going to be
- 44:44continuing to write more about lithium
- 44:46now looking at new lithium extraction
- 44:48technologies and places where lithium
- 44:50mining isn't yet happening. I'm also
- 44:53writing more about the constitutional
- 44:55process and analyzing some of the ideas
- 44:58and the movements that went into that.
- 45:00Um, but my next big project is focused
- 45:02on what I'm calling increasingly
- 45:05urbanized glaciers. Uh so for a few
- 45:08years I've been working with Chilean
- 45:10colleagues um on several things related
- 45:12to glaciers, but we've put together this
- 45:14social inventory of glaciers that tries
- 45:17to capture the deep connection between
- 45:20people and these places that sort of
- 45:22seem kind of very far away uh very
- 45:25inaccessible to most. And there you can
- 45:28read about this conflict in particular
- 45:31which was involved a gold mining company
- 45:34that proposed to move uh some glaciers
- 45:37in order to protect them. And this idea
- 45:40was just so preposterous it led to a
- 45:43massive outcry and it actually led to
- 45:45quite a lot of policy change. But at the
- 45:48heart of it and I've written about it
- 45:49and elsewhere including in my
- 45:51dissertation that Nancy might remember
- 45:54um at the heart of the plan the
- 45:57company's plan was the idea of the
- 45:59glaciers as just inert ice. You know
- 46:02that these are just this is just inert
- 46:04dead nature there for the taking and the
- 46:06moving wherever we wanted to put it. We
- 46:09now have a much better appreciation of
- 46:12the ways in which glaciers are also
- 46:14living systems. They can't just be
- 46:16picked up and moved.
- 46:19So in the capital city, Santiago, place
- 46:21of 8 million people, we have increasing
- 46:24growing conflict between glaciers and
- 46:27mining as the mining is expanding and
- 46:29encroaching increasingly into glaciers.
- 46:32And we perhaps have also increasing
- 46:33problems with living glaciers as they
- 46:36are living more wildly and melting in
- 46:39more unpredictable ways and sort of
- 46:41causing all kinds of changes at the very
- 46:44top of our of our not just our watershed
- 46:47but our living scape. Right? The city is
- 46:49sort of directly below. So just above
- 46:51that snow beyond that snow line there's
- 46:54about 300 glaciers up there. Um
- 46:57hopefully many of these will very soon
- 47:00be protected in a brand new national
- 47:02park, Glaciers of Santiago National
- 47:05Park. Um, and so I'm interested in this
- 47:07park and as I think ESPAM faculty know
- 47:11very well from decades of research that
- 47:13has happened here, parks are
- 47:15particularly excellent privileged places
- 47:18that bring to light race and class
- 47:21differences, historical legacies of
- 47:23dispossession,
- 47:25um, and that really sort of pit, you
- 47:27know, different na views of nature
- 47:29against each other and sort of provide a
- 47:31very good place from where to study
- 47:33these. Um, and so at stake in this
- 47:35project are questions like who has a
- 47:38right to nature and a right to the city
- 47:40when the two are now understood to be
- 47:43sort of really inextricably linked to
- 47:45each other. Um, there's a I've been
- 47:48working with an NGO that's been behind
- 47:50the campaign to create this park and one
- 47:53of the concerns that they have is how do
- 47:55we make this park in the high mountains
- 47:57accessible to workingclass Chileans when
- 47:59we really don't know anything about them
- 48:01and where they go on holiday? what do
- 48:03they do for recreation? Um, and so
- 48:05that's one of the interesting questions
- 48:07that we've been we've been grappling
- 48:09with there. Um, and so the same
- 48:13environmental equity and justice
- 48:16concerns that motivated the lithium
- 48:18project are present also here. So now
- 48:21it's mining for copper, for the renewal,
- 48:24you know, for electrification that is
- 48:26putting intense pressure not just on out
- 48:28of the way communities but major urban
- 48:30centers. Um we have also the solution of
- 48:34parks that raises all kinds of questions
- 48:36around equity in access including equity
- 48:40and access to leisure and leisure being
- 48:42an important idea to think about when we
- 48:44think about degrowth or postgrowth
- 48:46thinking um and instead of the global
- 48:49trade this project is focused on climate
- 48:52adaptation policies um at the at the
- 48:56urban level and the glaciers already
- 48:59have raised question about around whose
- 49:02knowledge of nature counts uh when we're
- 49:04dealing with these big issues. Thank
- 49:07you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Javiera Barandiaran | Climate Equity & Environmental Justice Search by ESPM Berkeley, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,343 words across 1,130 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.